We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Cathal O'Shannon

Follow

Former member, 1922–1923

Service

Dáil

INTOXICATING LIQUOR BILL. - SECOND STAGE.

I quite agree with the Deputy that that is probably so, and that elsewhere, outside the English speaking countries, these things are done much better. But that cannot be brought about by legislation. There is general agreement in the Dáil that the Bill should not be rushed, and…

2 contributions in this debate

Dáil

DAIL IN COMMITTEE. - INDEMNITY BILL, 1923—FOURTH STAGE.

I have another amendment to that section. It is: In line 58 to substitute for the word "two" the word "three." The sub-section as it stands provides that the reviewing body shall consist of not less than two, and the object of the amendment is that these bodies shall consist of…

4 contributions in this debate

Dáil

DAIL IN COMMITTEE. - [ THE DAIL RESUMES. ]

On a point of order, I submit you will have to go on to the next item on the Orders of the day.

2 contributions in this debate

Dáil

DAIL IN COMMITTEE. - INDEMNITY BILL, 1923. THIRD STAGE RESUMED.

I beg to move Amendment No. 3:—To add to Sub-section (4) of Section 3, the words, "provided that such rules shall not prevent such Board of Commissioners from holding any of its sittings in public, and that nothing in this Act shall permit such Board to sit and hear in secret…

8 contributions in this debate

Dáil

CEISTEANNA—QUESTIONS. [ORAL ANSWERS.] - ARREST AND COURTMARTIAL TRIAL.

asked the Minister for Defence whether he can state the reasons, if any, why James Lynch, Trim, who was arrested and tried by Court-martial recently in company with the prisoner Crieghton, released on July 18th, has not yet been released; and whether the Minister will now cause…

2 contributions in this debate

Dáil

THE INDEMNITY BILL, 1923. - DÁIL IN COMMITTEE

We have been about ten or eleven months here now, and nothing, I think, has been more striking, even up to this last week, than the capacity of the Ministers to make false analogies, to see only one-half of a position, or, if they see the other half, to ignore it. The President…

8 contributions in this debate

Dáil

PUBLIC SAFETY (EMERGENCY POWERS) BILL, 1923. - INTOXICATING LIQUOR BILL.

It is not the Bill, or the provisions, that are objected to at all. That could not be in question, because we do not know what the provisions of the Bill may be. The question raised by Deputy Johnson is the question of procedure in the Dáil. Deputy Johnson's objection is not at…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

PUBLIC SAFETY (EMERGENCY POWERS) BILL, 1923. - DAIL IN COMMITTEE.

Neither three nor five is the maximum. The fact of the matter is that if the man is poor and cannot get £100 to pay the fine, another year's imprisonment, making a possible six, is to be added. When we were debating this Bill before, the Ministerial side and this side differed on…

4 contributions in this debate

Dáil

DAIL IN COMMITTEE. - CIVIC GUARD BILL, 1923.

Surely the Minister can see that the extent to which the term "political" can be stressed is so wide that the Civic Guard would be deprived of a great number of not only the ordinary citizen's rights, but even an ordinary person's rights. The term could be applied to cultural…

3 contributions in this debate

Dáil

CIVIC GUARD BILL, 1923. - SECOND STAGE.

Strong as was the case for a temporary Bill for the Army, the case for a temporary Bill for the Civic Guard is much stronger. Deputy Johnson has shown quite conclusively that the measure before us is a controversial measure; at least, in several of the sections it raises issues…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. - THE SCHEDULES.

To return to the matters which we were discussing before Deputy Gavan Duffy spoke, I think I might say that the issue is pretty well knit, and the issue is whether the main arteries of the country, apart from the railways, are purely a local concern, a local interest and a local…

2 contributions in this debate

Dáil

COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. - [DAIL IN COMMITTEE.]

I think it would be well if the President would look into the matter raised by Deputy Johnson, because there is a certain amount of feeling in the Tirconaill part of the district over the matter, not that there would be any great objection, so far as I understand, to reciprocal…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

DAIL IN COMMITTEE.

The President, I think, forgets that a certain number of these men have not, on account of their previous association with this particular Force, been able to get employment, and numbers of them are still unemployed, and probably will be unemployed for a very considerable length…

8 contributions in this debate

Dáil

APPROPRIATION BILL, 1923. - REPORT ON ACCOMMODATION FOR OIREACHTAS.

As one who is not a member of the Committee I would like to support Deputy Johnson's suggestion. Unless we are to read something into the report other than the face value of the words in the report, and no one would make a suggestion like that, considering the signature at the…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

CEISTEANNA—QUESTIONS. [ ORAL ANSWERS. ] - AN ATHBOY ARREST.

asked the Minister for Defence if he can state the reasons for the arrest, some three weeks ago, of John McCormack, Derrylangan, Athboy, Co. Meath; what charge, if any, has been preferred against him; and whether the Minister can now authorise his release.

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

DEFENCE FORCES (TEMPORARY PROVISIONS) BILL, 1923. - SECOND STAGE.

Dubhairt mé an lá fé dheire go raibh gádh le Bille den tsord seo, ach nuair do léigh mê an Bille mar atá sé os ár gcomhair indiu annso, b'é mo thuairim nár cheart glacadh leis in aonchor. Nílim ag trácht anois ar na puintí do chuir Tomás Mac Eoin agus na Teachtaí eile os cómhair…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. - OIREACHTAS.

With reference to the explanation in regard to the Librarian and the Assistant Librarian I am perfectly well satisfied, but I think it well that the statement that the President has made with reference to these two gentlemen should have been made. So far as I know from their…

3 contributions in this debate

Dáil

CEISTEANNA—QUESTIONS. ORAL ANSWERS. - A KELLS PRISONER.

asked the Minister for Defence to state the result of the further consideration, promised in an answer on July 12th, of the case of Michael McInerney, Carnaross, Kells; to ask whether the Minister is aware of, and has considered the grounds for his release set forth in a…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

QUESTION ON THE ADJOURNMENT. - UNTRIED PRISONERS AND THE FRANCHISE.

Aontuighim le Teachta Ó Dúbhghaill. Is dóigh liom go mba mhaith leis an chuid is mó de na daoiníbh san tír an guth a thabhairt do na daoiní ata i bpriosúin. Is í mo thuairim-sa go ndéanfadh sé maitheas do'n Togha, agus nach ndéanfadh sé aon dochair do'n Stát, da mbeadh cead ag na…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

DAIL EIREANN COURTS (WINDING UP) BILL, 1923.—SECOND STAGE.

It would be illegal to produce them.

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

DEFENCE FORCES (TEMPORARY PROVISIONS) BILL, 1923—FIRST STAGE.

I do not rise to oppose the introduction of the Bill, as I am one of those who, right from the beginning of the sitting of this Dáil, urged that some such Bill should be brought in, as it was absolutely necessary, and because the Army required something that would regularise its…

3 contributions in this debate