We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Derek McDowell

Follow

Former member, 1992–2007

Service

Seanad

Criminal Justice Bill 2007: Committee and Remaining Stages.

In the Hogan report, the majority, including former Minister for Justice, Nora Owen, and Professor David Gwynn Morgan, were of the view that the decision in the Kenny case should be revisited. However, the chairman, Dr. Gerard Hogan was of the view that the existing law was…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

Protection of Employment (Exceptional Collective Redundancies and Related Matters) Bill 2007: Committee and Remaining Stages.

I wish to be associated with Senator Coghlan's comments. This is important social protection legislation which has become necessary because of very changed circumstances in Ireland in recent years. We gave Committee Stage quick passage largely because the Minister of State's…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

Protection of Employment (Exceptional Collective Redundancies and Related Matters) Bill 2007: Second Stage.

Like others, I acknowledge the genesis of this Bill in the Irish Ferries dispute of a few months ago, the outcome of which was particularly galling on a number of levels. It was galling in the first instance because what most of us thought of as an Irish company effectively…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

National Climate Change Strategy 2000: Motion.

——seven years ago. The Government committed to incentivise a move away from coal and it has since reversed that decision. The plan refers to an expansion in renewable energy but it is still at 4%. There is a proposal to bring it up to 33% by 2020 but I wonder how this will be…

10 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Roads Bill 2007: Second Stage.

Senators are being much nicer to one another. The temperature has gone down, for some strange reason. It would be important to gain access to the registration database in Northern Ireland if possible. This may require intergovernmental agreement. I imagine it will be difficult to…

14 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Credit Union Savings Protection Bill 2007: Second Stage.

I am pleased to contribute to the debate. The legislation provides the opportunity for a useful discussion on an issue that demands early resolution. I join others in acknowledging the important and vibrant role of credit unions in our society over many decades. However, their…

1 contribution in this debate

SELECT COMMITTEE ON JUSTICE, EQUALITY, DEFENCE AND WOMEN'S RIGHTS

Prisons Bill 2006 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.

There is a need, under EU law, for a process that takes environmental impact into account. Developments in EU law would have forced me to amend Part 9. I would have had to use one of two processes to meet environmental requirements. I would have had to ask an independent body…

65 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Defamation Bill 2006: Committee Stage.

He might be much happier to have the Supreme Court state this was never worth more than €20,000 and that one should forget about the €500,000. I imagine if an individual were concerned rather than an institutional defendant, it could be very punitive to send the case back to the…

3 contributions in this debate

Seanad

National Development Plan: Motion.

The problem with the plan is that it includes much that we have heard before. One example is the provisions in regard to the health service, an area with which the Minister is particularly familiar. I have read the full section on health and find it deliberately dodges the two…

11 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Consumer Protection Bill 2007: Second Stage.

I broadly welcome the Bill. Members will forgive me for being a bit churlish at the beginning of my contribution but some of the rhetoric used by the Government side in welcoming the Bill was a bit over the top. The Bill, in effect, consolidates existing legislation and…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

European Communities Bill 2006: Second Stage.

If this and the other House have passed a Bill, why should a Minister acting on his or her own be entitled to amend it? If we have had a full debate and this House has taken a view, if the other House has taken the Bill and the President has signed it in the normal course, why…

2 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Prisons Bill 2006: Report Stage.

The judge has the decision in the matter. Clearly a prisoner cannot participate unless the prisoner is somehow involved. I want to avoid a person saying a testimony is invalid because a notice was not served on the prisoner and his legal representative when both were well aware…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

National Development Finance Agency (Amendment) Bill 2006: Second Stage.

We will debate that another time. The decision in principle to commission a building project is made by the Government. The NDFA decides the funding mechanism for the project. This is technical advice that calls on the agency's expertise on funding and putting together contracts…

3 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Tax Code: Motion.

I do not support wholesale across-the-board reductions in stamp duty. I am proud to be a tax-and-spend social democrat. In order to improve social services we need to spend public money. To pretend that we could greatly reduce the rates of stamp duty would be hypocrisy on my…

2 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Estimates for Public Services 2007: Statements.

The projections made by the Department of Finance in October suggest that we will enjoy economic growth of between 4% and 5% of GNP and GDP for each of the next three years. On the face of it, that is a rosy scenario that we all welcome. There are, however, worrying trends and…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

Prisons Bill 2006: Second Stage.

I am pleased to be before the House today to present the Prisons Bill 2006. This Bill deals with a number of issues relating to prisons and prisoners and its purpose is manifold. The Bill provides primarily for the following matters: video conferencing of certain non-trial court…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

Land and Conveyancing Law Reform Bill 2006: Committee Stage.

Section 65 abolishes the needs for words of limitation in conveyances of unregistered land. This is a drafting amendment to bring the wording of section 65 into line with section 123 of the Registry of Deeds Act 1964 which abolished the need for words of limitation for transfers…

9 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Address by the European Union Ambassador to the United States.

I join others in welcoming the ambassador, Mr. Bruton, to the House. It is an advantage of this House that it can occasionally take time for these kinds of reflective discussions and I thank Mr. Bruton for taking time out to facilitate us. I was struck by his comments about the…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

Patents (Amendment) Bill 1999: Second Stage.

It is the first refuge of an Opposition spokesperson on a Bill such as this one to complain about the delay in its introduction. However, even by the standards of this and the other House, the delay of seven or eights years in progressing the Bill to this stage requires some…

2 contributions in this debate

JOINT COMMITTEE ON EUROPEAN AFFAIRS

EU-US Relations: Presentation.

Can one divorce Guantanamo Bay from their status? None of us would have a problem if they had been properly tried and jailed in the US. Guantanamo Bay is synonymous with the fact that they have not been tried and there is no indication that they will be tried. That is the issue…

2 contributions in this debate