We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joe O'Toole

Follow

Former member, 1987–2011

Service

  • 2007–2011 Seanad National University of Ireland Independent
  • 2002–2007 Seanad National University of Ireland Independent
  • 1997–2002 Seanad National University of Ireland Independent
  • 1993–1997 Seanad National University of Ireland Independent
  • 1989–1992 Seanad National University of Ireland Independent
  • 1987–1989 Seanad National University of Ireland Independent
Seanad

Economic Situation: Statements

It is my great pleasure to welcome the Minister of State, Deputy Brian Hayes, to the House and congratulate him on his elevation to office. I wish him well, not just in his career but also in his ministry, in these difficult times. Last week, there was a classic example of which…

2 contributions in this debate

Seanad

European Directives: Motion

I welcome the Minister back to the Seanad. He is adorning the House with his presence and he could be the reason for its retention. I would like to hear his response on two issues. First, Senator Leyden raised a question in respect of the Data Protection Commissioner. Has the…

6 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Order of Business

I thought that; "Ditto to that". I thank the Leader of the House as I spoke to him on a number of occasions over the weekend with regard to including the extra debate today on the economic situation. I appreciate its inclusion and on this basis I will support the Order of…

3 contributions in this debate

Seanad

EU Regulation on Judgments in Civil and Commercial Matters: Motion

The House will applaud her appointment and elevation. She did trojan work as Leader of the Opposition in the House for the past four or five years. I wish her well. We have the utmost confidence in her. This is the type of change in Europe we need to welcome. It is a tidying up…

4 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Order of Business

In dealing with the banks, as many on both sides of the House have stated in the past few months, €50 billion, €60 billion or €70 billion of the money we are paying back is going to German and French banks. Of course, they do not want us to default or see a rescheduling, as it…

7 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Mental Health (Involuntary Procedures) (Amendment) Bill 2008: Committee Stage (Resumed)

While this is an imperfect argument that we are putting forward, I could come up with the perfect result. I will explain it shortly. We must deal with the issue raised by Senator Harris when we reach a situation that the best thing for a person is a particular treatment and the…

11 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Programme for Government: Motion

I am also attracted to the NewERA document. The Minister will be met with cynicism on this issue, which he will have to ride out. The document refers to important issues, some of which the previous Government was also considering, including a smart grid combining EirGrid and the…

5 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Construction Contracts Bill 2010: Committee and Remaining Stages

In support of the points made by Senator Quinn, I take on board what others said earlier. The Irish are very litigious by nature and we tend to go right up the line if there is another option. If arbitration or court proceedings are options, we will go to the limit, but that is…

5 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Death of Former Member: Expressions of Sympathy

I am privileged to add to what has been said and offer from the Independent benches our condolences and sympathy to the family of the late Willie Farrell and Fianna Fáil. I remember Willie for his argumentative nature and because he was always willing to take up a challenge. He…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

Order of Business

I support the points offered in congratulating our colleagues elected to the other House. People often speak about Senators being elected to the Dáil. The vast majority of the people elected to the Dáil from this House are people who would have worked diligently as Senators in…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

Finance Bill 2011 [Certified Money Bill]: Committee Stage (Resumed)

Let me talk about abolishing it. That is a little like the Minister's response to the last recommendation. Nobody is saying all property tax reliefs are bad. Bonus schemes are good, but badly implemented bonus schemes are bad. That is the problem. It is not just the bonus scheme…

4 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Finance Bill 2011 [Certified Money Bill]: Committee Stage (Resumed)

On a point of order. I do not wish to be unmannerly but I am conscious of time. The proposer has responded so the recommendation should be put now.

2 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Business of Seanad

I suggest the Leader propose a change to the Order of Business whereby the business that was supposed to be concluded at 11.30 a.m. be allowed to continue through the next section in order that all discussion is encompassed at 12.30 p.m. The only change would be that we do not…

5 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Finance Bill 2011 [Certified Money Bill]: Report and Final Stages

I second the recommendation. We have had a long debate on the civil partnership issue over several years. Finally, we took the step which we all welcomed and provided for it legislatively. I do not propose to rehearse all the arguments from that stage. The implementation of that…

3 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Finance Bill 2011 [Certified Money Bill]: Committee Stage

I do not know how people can manage to turn logic on its head to such a degree but having listened to the two speakers on the Government side, and Senator Cassidy in particular, I agree with everything they said but I thought they were making the argument in favour of the…

3 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Finance Bill 2011 [Certified Money Bill]: Committee Stage (Resumed)

I recognise that the Minister of State has given us several dates. I trust he will correct me if my understanding of the matter is wrong. However, I understood that last year or the year before we changed the date of the return of capital acquisitions tax to a date in October as…

6 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Finance Bill 2011: Second Stage

One of the great things from the boom has been the infrastructure in this country. Metro north would create 4,000 jobs plus a further 2,000 were it to be put in place. This is the gain which could result from moving the project forward immediately. Another issue of importance is…

5 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Order of Business

The professional way in which they go about their work and their constant availability to deal with tricky issues, solve problems and manage the affairs of the House should certainly be recorded. It is important, as we head into the general election campaign, to recognise that…

2 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Death of Former Member: Expressions of Sympathy

Cuirfidh mé fáilte roimh Bhríd agus roimh an chlann ar fad atá anseo linn inniu, agus roimh a chomhghleacaithe dáilcheantair, an Teachta Ruairí O'Hanlon, an tAire, an Teachta Brenda Smith agus an Teachta Margaret Conlon. Táimid anseo chun slán a fhágáil agus raiteas a chur ar an…

2 contributions in this debate

Seanad

Order of Business

I wish to pick up on some of the points made by Senator Fitzgerald. Also, it is fair to make reference to the biased and cynical comments made about elected Independent Members in the news media this morning, comments which have been well supported by many parties. The reality is…

3 contributions in this debate