We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE of PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Tallaght Institute of Technology: Annual Financial Statements 1994-97.

Contributions 1–230 of 461. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

We are dealing with the Comptroller and Auditor General's report on the annual financial statements for 1994, 1995, 1996 and 1997 of the Carlow Institute of Technology, the Dundalk Institute of Technology, the Letterkenny Institute of Technology and the Tallaght Institute of Technology and the Comptroller and Auditor General's general report on the education sector.

Witnesses' attention is drawn to the fact that as and from 2 August 1998, section 10 of the Committees of the Houses of the Oireachtas (Compellability, Privileges and Immunities of Witnesses) Act, 1997, grants certain rights to person identified in the course of proceedings. Witnesses are asked to take full account of the provisions of the Act. I now call on the Comptroller and Auditor General, Mr. John Purcell, to introduce his report into the Carlow Institute of Technology, followed by the Dundalk Institute of Technology, the Letterkenny Institute of Technology and the Tallaght Institute of Technology and then we will take general questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

Four years' accounts of the Carlow Institute of Technology are before the Committee.

Comment on this

I must interrupt to introduce the witnesses. From the Carlow Institute of Technology, we have the director, Mr. John Gallagher. I welcome you, is this your first time here?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Will you please introduce your colleagues?

Comment on this

I am accompanied by Mr. Brian Bennett, the college registrar; Mr. Cormac O'Toole, the college secretary and Ms Eleanor Rea, the college finance officer.

Comment on this

You are all welcome. From the Dundalk Institute we have the director Mr. Gerry Carroll. You are welcome and perhaps you will introduce your colleagues. It is your first time here too. We are going to have fun today.

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

I am accompanied by Mr. Stephen McManus, the institute's registrar; Mr. Peter McGrath, secretary and financial controller and Mr. Brendan Keane, finance officer.

Comment on this

You are all welcome. From Letterkenny, I welcome Mr. Paul Hannigan, director and accounting officer. Will you introduce our colleagues?

Comment on this
Mr. Hannigan

I am accompanied by Mr. Danny Brennan, registrar of the institute and Mr. Colin Morrow, secretary and financial controller.

Comment on this

Finally, from Tallaght, Mr. Columb Collins.

Comment on this

I am accompanied by Mr. Paul Caffrey, secretary and financial controller and Mr. Pat McLoughlin who is the head of the school of engineering.

Comment on this

You are welcome. From the Department of Education and Science, I welcome Mr. Paddy McDonagh, Assistant Secretary General. Have you been here before?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Perhaps you will introduce your officials.

Comment on this

I am accompanied by Ms Anne Killian, the principal officer in the third level planning and building unit, Ms Teresa Griffin, the assistant principal officer in that area, and Ms Mary Murray, the higher executive officer in the third level colleges section.

Comment on this

You are all welcome. I interrupted Mr. Purcell on the Carlow Institute of Technology.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

Four years' accounts of the institute, up to August 1997, the end of the academic year, are before the committee. I have given a clear report on each of those years because nothing came to light in the audit which, in my opinion, merited public accountability. That is not to say issues did not arise over the period. However, I am glad to say they were satisfactorily resolved by way of management letter, which is the normal channel of communication between my office and the institutes and clients after the completion of an audit.

I have recently certified the accounts for the academic year ended 31 August 1998 and there is no critical reference in that audit report either.As a general point, there were initial delays in finalising the accounts for the regional technical colleges, as they were then known, due to teething problems with the transfer of responsibilities from the vocational education committees to the new governing bodies. Practically all of these problems have since been resolved and the Committee will note the accounts of all the institutes are in a standard format which facilitates comparison and analysis. This also took some time to put in place but in the long run, it was well worth the effort. In relation to Carlow, we are not talking about any critical comments.

Comment on this

Mr. Gallagher, you will be relieved at that. Do you have an opening statement?

Comment on this

I did have an opening statement but I am not sure how relevant it is given we are taking all the colleges together. I wished to indicate the colleges were established in 1970, of which I am sure the committee is aware. The most recent change was the introduction of the Regional Technical College Act in 1992. This changed the structure of the colleges as it established the governing body, director and academic council, a framework for the operation of the colleges within an annual budget with the Department and for the participation of the colleges in R&D. There are characteristics which would apply to Carlow, although I do not know if I should go into them given this is a group session.

The colleges, having been established in 1970, have a 30 year history of development and change. The 1992 Act was just one landmark in that. The next one we are expecting to be implemented fairly soon is the national qualifications Act which will be a change for the colleges. I might leave it at that, if that is all right.

Comment on this

How many students do you have?

Comment on this

At the moment we have approximately 2,500 full-time students and about 1,200 part-time students.

Comment on this

What staff do you have?

Comment on this

We have 303.

Comment on this

Are they all full-time?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

How many degree courses do you have?

Comment on this

At the moment we have 11. A 12th was established last week and has to formally go through the NCEA but we understand there is a positive recommendation for that.

Comment on this

Regarding page 5 and the 1997 accounts, which are the most up-to-date available, I wish to ascertain any benchmarks relating to the pupil-teacher ratio, the cost per student, the cost per teacher etc. Is Mr. Gallagher aware of any benchmark regarding these measurements?

Comment on this

Not specifically. The Department of Education and Science allocates a grant but it is not specific in relation to any benchmarking. Locally, we would be conscious of the cost per student benchmark. We would look on that as an overall measure of effectiveness.

Comment on this

How much is the cost per student in Carlow?

Comment on this

The cost per student in the last set of accounts was about £3,700 per full-time student. That is simple division. It is a very simple benchmark.

Comment on this

I realise that.

Comment on this

That is the gross expenditure divided by the number of pupils.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

Are the courses offered similar to those offered in the other institutes of technology? Is there an equivalent number of people doing science, technology or business subjects? Would it be fair to say that the students in Carlow and the subjects they are taking are representative of the institutes as a whole?

Comment on this

I would think so. Generally speaking, that would be correct.

Comment on this

The amount of the State grant actually fell from 1996 to 1997. Is there a reason for that?

Comment on this

There is no reason I am specifically aware of, unless some of my colleagues wish to——

Comment on this

Did the number of students decrease?

Comment on this

No, the number of students increased.

Comment on this

From what figure?

Comment on this

In 1995-6 we had approximately 2,500 students and the following year we had an increase of approximately 200 students, bringing the figure to 2,700.

Comment on this

How did the institute compensate for the decrease in the State grant while there was an increase in numbers?

Comment on this

It is not possible for us to compensate in the general sense of compensation - we have to manage with the funds we receive.

Comment on this

The cashflow statement on page 7 shows the amount of cash received by the institute increased from £6.3 million to £7 million. Perhaps the financial officer would know how the initial income figure is calculated. How was that arrived at and why does it differ from the cash received?

Comment on this

I am sorry if I appear hesitant, I am seeking clarification on the point.

Comment on this

Perhaps, with no disrespect, the Comptroller and Auditor General might be able to assist us on that point. The cash figures on page 7 of the Comptroller and Auditor General's report are different. Why has there been asignificant increase in the amount of cash received?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

A conflict arises when dealing with universities and institutes of technology in that their accounting year is based on their academic year and the State's accounting year is based on the calendar year. The allocation for an institute such as Carlow would be put at roughly two-thirds of the annual allocation in the Estimates for that institute. As I understand it, perhaps Mr. McDonagh will go into more detail regarding the calculations because it can be quite complex, a certain amount of money which relates to the academic year may be allocated in the final quarter of that year. The amount shown as "incoming State grant" represents the amount allocated for that year. The cash figure represents what they have as of 31 August. There would always be a difference between the cashflow statement and that shown as income. That explains the matter in general terms but I am sure Mr. McDonagh can give fuller details on it.

Comment on this

The colleges receive funding from the State by way of grants. The bulk of tuition fee income also comes from the State. The fees listed under ESF funding are supplied to the institutes of technology for certificate and diploma programmes which predates the introduction of the free fees system throughout third level education. A significant element of that income is also paid through the Vote under a separate subhead. Subhead A4 provides for fees and maintenance grants in respect of students attending programmes in institutes of technology. One needs to add those two items to get the whole picture regarding State grants.

A difficulty exists, as the Comptroller and Auditor General said, in that the Department allocates funding on the basis of the Exchequer financial year, January to December, which tends to cut across two academic years in an institution. We ask the institutions, when they have been allocated their grant, to indicate the breakdown of that grant from January to August and from September to December. We then monitor the situation on that basis. The institutions have indicated they would like to undertake a reallocation of the funds. We would like to move to a position of sticking rigidly to allocations. We have, however, conceded to reallocation in justifiable cases.

Comment on this

If you do not operate a certain amount of rigidity with allocations it is difficult to make comparisons from year to year.

Comment on this

We accept that. The Department has operated with some flexibility to date but we are moving towards getting valid year on year comparisons. There is no problem with the Exchequer calendar year because the Appropriation Accounts illustrate what the year on year comparisons are on a cash basis. We are anxious to commit the institutions, when they make their breakdown, to adhering to their allocations. If the allocation is not precise it can result in a significant deficit or surplus arising at the end of August which would be rectified by the end of the calendar year. One will almost always find that a surplus shown at the end of the academic financial year may have been rectified by the end of December.

Comment on this

Accounts are often window dressed. Is it possible figures from 1996, when the accounts were submitted to the VEC, may have been restated for 1997?

Comment on this

Accounts for 1996-7 are the most recent available. The last set of VEC accounts was in 1992-3. We are four to five years into institute accounts now.

Comment on this

When were the accounts signed off for 1993-4, 1994-5, 1995-6?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

The 1993-4 and 1994-5 accounts were signed off on 27 February 1997. The 1995-6 accounts were signed off on 18 December 1997 and the 1996-7 accounts were signed off on 15 October 1999.

Comment on this

Page 7 of the Comptroller and Auditor General's report refers to "other income generating activities" and shows figures of £615,000 in 1997 and £284,000 in 1996. What do those figures represent and why the increase?

Comment on this

I refer the Deputy to page 8, item 5, which contains a breakdown of the figures.

Comment on this

The total at the bottom of page 8 is £710,000 and £790,000 but on page 7 the figures are £615,000 and £284,000. Is Mr. Gallagher saying there was a huge timing difference in when the cash was received? The accounts are done on an accrual basis.

Comment on this

What is the answer to that question?

Comment on this

It is a timing difference.

Comment on this

I do not know what banking institution you do business with but the figure listed under "interest received on short-term deposits" is a huge amount of money. What amount of money was held on deposit throughout 1997? What was the monthly cash balance figure held on deposit which generated that interest?

Comment on this

The average figure is about £1.5 million.

Comment on this

So you are getting in excess of 6%?

Comment on this

On average, whatever the interest rate was at the time.

Comment on this

With whom did you have it on deposit in that you were getting 6% interest?

Comment on this

We normally used treasury management arrangements through our banks. We used the Bank of Ireland but we were also with the EBS, the money market and money was usually deposited for a period to maximise the interest available. It was on deposit for approximately three months.

Comment on this

Was DIRT deducted in arriving at that interest?

Comment on this

The position of all the colleges is that we have charitable status.

Comment on this

So there is no DIRT. Were you getting approximately 6%? At the end of the financial year you had £1.5 million. Is that always the case?

Comment on this

In the early stages we had a considerable amount on deposit but that has diminished over the years.

Comment on this

How much do you have on deposit at present?

Comment on this

I am informed it is approximately £2 million. A considerable proportion of that is restricted reserve.

Comment on this

Restricted reserve - tell us more.

Comment on this

We have an agreement with our students that a certain amount of capitation fees would be reserved for building student facilities.

Comment on this

Do the capitation fees come directly from the students or the State?

Comment on this

Some are from students, some from the State.

Comment on this

When do you intend spending this money on student facilities?

Comment on this

As soon as possible. We are in the process of reviewing our master plan which will be presented, with costings, to the Department next Wednesday. I hope that shortly afterwards we will have a favourable decision from the Department in proceeding with the expenditure of that money.

Comment on this

When would you see it being expended?

Comment on this

I think the money should be expended inside a building period of approximately a year and a half to two years.

Comment on this

What type of student accommodation are you talking about?

Comment on this

Student facilities as opposed to student accommodation. Student accommodation is normally sleeping accommodation, residential facilities. These will be recreational and sports facilities. They are the facilities which were not constructed originally with the regional technical colleges and have been absent from the colleges. They are badly needed. In reality, it is a catching up process.

Comment on this

On the sports and student facilities, including swimming pools and tennis courts in Carlow, what is the position regarding acreage and how do you stack up vis-à-vis the other institutions and universities?

Comment on this

On the stacking up vis-à-vis the other institutes, we are probably reasonably okay with the exception that we are fairly landlocked at present in Carlow. We have a site of approximately 11 hectares and the surrounding region is zoned for housing. In terms of future expansion and potential we are landlocked. On the other hand, I am not really competent to comment on the universities in that I am not familiar with them but, generally speaking, we consider ourselves as the poor relation.

Comment on this

In relation to Carlow - I know it well from driving down regularly - will other lands be purchased outside the campus for recreational facilities?

Comment on this

We anticipate doing that at any opportunity. One or two opportunities have arisen but we have been unable to purchase land adjacent to the college to date largely because the zoning is for housing and residential estates. It has driven up the price of land.

Comment on this

The houses seem to be mushrooming around the college. It must be a desirable location now that there is a higher education facility nearby. Returning to the academic facilities - it would be very difficult to delineate between recreational, dining facilities and so on - but what is the total square footage of the college?

Comment on this

Until relatively recently there were 14,000 sq. m. and in the past month or so we have taken possession of a central services building which is an additional 3,000 sq. m. This provides some general social and dining facilities. We are in the process of taking over an additional 6,000 sq. m. which is a learning resource centre and it is effectively future proofing us from the IT point of view. The new learning resource centre will contain library, multimedia, computing and IT facilities. That will add 9,000 sq. m. to the 14,000 sq. m., giving a total of 23,000 sq. m.

Comment on this

What increase in full-time students do you envisage as a result of the increased facilities?

Comment on this

In the near future, we hope to increase our student numbers by approximately 200. Just in case there is ambiguity, the facilities we have obtained we did not have. The central services building is an increased dining facility, of which we were short. We had literally no social areas outside the classroom space. It is a completion of an organic college. The same comments would apply to our library facilities, of which we were short, but we now have an extremely good facility. Our computing facilities, which have been under tremendous strain, and our multimedia and video facilities will again benefit from the increased space. We are bringing the college into line with the numbers that we have.

Comment on this

Do you think Carlow will be a more attractive location academically and there will be greater competition for places at the institute as a result of these improvements?

Comment on this

It is attractive already.

Comment on this

The objective of the exercise is to bring the institute up to international standards in terms of facilities for students and to make Carlow, with deference to my colleagues, one of the more attractive institutes of technology. The Deputy mentioned a swimming pool and part of our plans is to have one incorporated. Carlow is an inland town 50 miles from the sea. Swimming is a most healthy exercise and recreational facility. We have ambitious plans in the development of student facilities and in many ways the completion of our master plan is to bring the institute up to good standards.

Comment on this

It was not exactly an accounts question, it was an opportunity for you to make a sales pitch, which you have done well.

What research and development facilities are there in Carlow? How successful have you been in that area? Is there staff involvement? Do the staff and students publish papers? What are your plans in this area?

Comment on this

We can be proud of the record of the institute in that area. We encourage research and development and I see it as vital support for the degree courses we run. We have been particularly successful on the international stage.

Regarding funds allocated by the Higher Education Authority and validated by an international review body, we have been successful in the last two sessions in obtaining research money against competition throughout the third level sector. The most recent grant we received was about £1 million. With that we established one new research laboratory and are in the process of establishing another, together with some staff facilities. These are most welcome as originally the Regional Technical Colleges as such had no specific facilities of that nature. We were given more scope under the 1992 Act, but the possibilities for expanding the range of activities were extremely restricted. With the development of buildings and success in getting funding we are beginning to establish a very solid core for research and development.

In relation to publishing papers, our staff and students both publish papers as part of our postgraduate programme. So far we have graduated two PhD students. We also have a number of other research grants and have links with industry. Research, in many ways, has the connotation of pure research, but we also do what we can in terms of the skills requirements of industry in the region and in relation to consultancy testing and related work.

Comment on this

What are the main areas of research?

Comment on this

The main areas of research to date have been in microbiology and food. We are beginning to open the computing area which is becoming a very strong specialisation in Carlow. We have a number of degrees in computing networking and software engineering.

Comment on this

Is microbiology tied into biotechnology?

Comment on this

I suppose I am a bit old fashioned and I use the term microbiology in place of the modern word which is biotechnology or bio-engineering.

Comment on this

What is the average gross pay per teacher in Carlow?

Comment on this

I am not prepared for that question. The quickest way is to take the gross pay and divide it by the number of staff which is roughly 300.

Comment on this

Can you tell me, Mr. Gallagher, of the financial control mechanisms in the institution? What are the structures and audit provisions?

Comment on this

Referring to the previous question, I am advised that £35,000 is a rough average salary.

Comment on this

About the same as a Deputy.

Comment on this

The structure for financial control which has been established in the Institute of Technology, Carlow, is that there is a senior post of college secretary/financial controller who is supported by a financial officer. Both are qualified accountants. Below this there is a substructure of a number of staff concerned in general with payroll and purchasing. Therefore, there is a fairly firm structure, but it has taken a number of years to put in place because all these were additional posts introduced subsequent to the 1992 Act and formed part of the expansion and change of structure programme introduced by the Department subsequent to that Act. In general I think we are in a firm and strong position.

Comment on this

How are you sure you are getting value for money and protecting the assets of the institute?

Comment on this

There are a number of ways of doing that. The strongest way currently is through internal audit. We have just completed the first cycle of the three year internal audits. The intention is that over the three year period every aspect of our financial controls will be scrutinised by an independent authority. Those reports will be returned to the governing body, the Comptroller and Auditor General and the Department.

Comment on this

So there is a separate internal auditor?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Who does he or she report to?

Comment on this

The external auditor reports to the audit committee of the governing body - effectively the governing body.

Comment on this

That is the external auditor?

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

Is there an internal auditor?

Comment on this

Just to clarify, the external auditor is the Comptroller and Auditor General who reports to the committee. The internal auditor reports to the governing body through a subcommittee. This concerns the three year cycle to which I referred.

Comment on this

Is that function or person completely independent of the financial function?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

What role or interest do you take as a director in the reports of the internal audit? Does the internal audit have free access to you? Does it have free access to all papers at all times in each section?

Comment on this

The internal audit has free access to everyone and everything in the institute. At the initial setting up of the audit I met the auditors. Subsequently, they were introduced to all heads of function in the college, about 19 people. Their function was clarified and they were introduced to the staff concerned. It was left open to them who they would choose to meet. Again, I refer to the three year cycle over which period they will have met everybody and have assessed all our internal systems.

Comment on this

We will move onto the Dundalk Institute of Technology.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

Again four years accounts up to 31 August 1997 are before the committee for its consideration and again there are no critical comments in my audit reports. However, I have a serious criticism regarding the timeliness of the accounts finalisation. It will be noted that the 1997 accounts were only certified by me last month which is clearly unsatisfactory. The audit of the 1997 accounts was contracted by me to a private firm of auditors and their audit commenced in August 1998. However, they were unable to complete the audit to their satisfaction due to delays in obtaining responses from the institute to their queries and they had some harsh words to say about the provision of information by the institute. They discontinued their involvement in March 1999 and my staff eventually finalised the audit.

The difficulties continued on the audit of the accounts for the academic year to 31 August 1998 which was undertaken directly by my staff. The audit field work was completed last August but I am still not in a position to issue an audit report. According to the acting director, serious staff shortages in the finance office are the root cause of the delays in clearing audit queries and providing information requested.

Comment on this

Mr. Carroll has submitted a written statement and may wish to summarise it.

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

I wish to refer to some of the points in the statement - I do not propose going through it in detail. As was the case in Carlow, the institute was established as an autonomous institution on 1 January 1993. We have about 2,800 students in total and approximately 300 staff. In general we serve the north-east region, namely, Louth, Meath, Cavan, Monaghan and, increasingly, north County Dublin. Like other institutes of technology we have courses which range from craft or apprentice level through technician and higher technician, degree and post-graduate level. The areas of specialisation include engineering, design, food science, building surveying, humanities, applied cultural studies and community development. Therefore, we have the standard courses found in any institute, but in our region we find we have adapted our courses to suit particular requirements.

We were probably one of first institutes to get involved in supporting start-up technology based businesses on campus. That would include new company incubation facilities which we started in 1989 prior to the Act and expanded in 1992 and 1997. That scheme supported about 20 new start-up companies and employed about 200 people.

Back in the late 1980s and early 1990s the job creation aspect was extremely important and we felt that this was something positive we could contribute to in the region. More recently we have been involved with other partners and other institutes of technology in supporting the development of the new Objective One area.

We have been involved quite extensively in research and development. Our particular focus has been in the applied research area, particularly with existing SMEs and indigenous SMEs. As was the case in Carlow and possibly other institutes, we have been involved in fairly significant campus development and building works in an effort to catch up on deficiencies that existed in the early 1990s. We hope to continue this process.

Comment on this

I welcome Mr. Carroll and his colleagues. I was not aware that he was a temporary director. When will the post be filled?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

I have been temporary director since 1 March because the previous director, Dr. Seán McDonagh, who held the post for almost 30 years, has gone to head up a new unit called the skills initiative unit. It is proposed to fill the position within the next number of months. But until such time, under the relevant section of the Act, I have been asked by the Minister for Education and Science to fill the position in a temporary capacity.

Comment on this

The Comptroller and Auditor General commented on the timing of these accounts. It seems to be a problem throughout the public sector, particularly in the regional colleges and educational institutions. We are examining accounts for 1994 to 1997, inclusive, and most of them are totally irrelevant. Many changes, additional courses and buildings have been initiated in Dundalk since then. I know this because I was in direct contact with the Minister at that time. It seems to me that we are examining a situation that is way out of date. For example, the governing body in Dundalk approved the 1997 accounts on 15 February 2000. According to the date stamp this committee received its accounts on 30 March 2000. We do not know what happened in 1998 and 1999. I am not criticising Dundalk but it is something we must deal with. We should gear ourselves up and insist that educational establishments submit accounts for the previous year. We should be examining the 1999 accounts now. We should consider this matter further. Neither my colleagues nor I approve of dealing with accounts that date back to 1994. This is ridiculous.

On page 11 of the 1997 accounts there is a heading "Sports and Recreation". In 1996 the cost of sports and recreation was £33,000 and in 1997 it was £38,000. Can Mr. Carroll explain this? That seems a very small amount of money from the overall budget. Perhaps funding has been incorporated under other headings. Can Mr. Carroll tell us what the Dundalk institute could do with just £38,000?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

That amount of funding is quite small. It is used to support coaching services for various student activities, predominantly field sports but that also includes indoor sports. That sum would pay for part-time coaches. It would not include any facility costs. Like other institutes we have been trying to gear up and update our sports facilities. We have some outdoor pitches but we are proposing quite an extensive improvement in this area. We are also improving indoor sports facilities with the assistance of capitation funding.

There is a need to increase funding. We try to use the funding that we have as judiciously as possible and we try to spread it across as many areas as possible. We are always trying to increase that level of activity. We are planning to increase our sports facilities in the coming years. We hope that the use of them will help to bring in additional funding on a self-funding basis and that will help increase the sort of services that we should be offering to students.

Comment on this

Is that a normal departmental allocation and is there no allocation for sports and recreation? The governing body decides on the funding on a yearly basis.

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

It is and we take that out of our capitation. Each students pays an annual capitation fee of £278 and that is used to fund a number of ancillary activities. They include sports and recreation, clubs and societies, the students' union and other social and recreational facilities and services. The funding does not come directly out of the Department's allocation.

Comment on this

Dundalk is one of the newest Regional Technical Colleges in the Border area. Its building programme has been fairly extensive. The initial cost was supposed to be £3.5 million but the final cost will probably be more than that. I know emphasis was to be placed on the tourism, catering and hotel industries. Can Mr. Carroll tell us what is the current state of that programme? It could not be included in the 1997 accounts?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

The tourism, recreational and, in our case, the hospitality studies, which are predominantly courses certified by CERT, are new to us. We had not been involved in those courses up to 1998 when the particular facility Deputy Bell referred to was completed. That particular activity supports almost 300 students at present. It is a whole new discipline area. It also means that the region's tourism infrastructure is being supported by a whole new cohort of students and that is to be welcomed.

In relation to the Border area, Members will be aware that Dundalk suffered quite a lot from adverse publicity over the past 30 years. It was not easy to attract students to the college. Thankfully, the situation is improving now. The inclusion of programmes in our institute to support tourism must be a positive step for the development of tourism in the Border region. We offer formal full-time courses. We also have specialist staff on board within that discipline. They are beginning to work with the region's tourism industry and they will help develop that industry through a range of activities such as part-time and updating courses.

Comment on this

Letterkenny Regional Technical College and Dundalk Regional Technical College are closest to the North. Is there any interaction between Dundalk Regional Technical College and the Northern Ireland Administration? If that is happening has that Administration made special arrangements to fund or part fund courses?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

We have been involved in cross-Border activities almost from the start. We were involved in quite an innovative programme called the masters of business administration programme. For that programme we co-operated with the University of Ulster for many years. That course supported the development of owner managers in small businesses. Since then we have been funded under a number of cross-Border funds, including the Interreg programme and the new peace and reconciliation programme. Those funding packages have supported the development predominantly of programmes in enterprise and entrepreneurship, where we have co-operated with a range of organisations such as Newry and Mourne, Omagh and Enniskillen enterprise agencies, in developing programmes to support the development of new small enterprises in the Border region. There we are using the expertise of our business and engineering schools in co-operation with the expertise of those cross-Border bodies to develop courses and programmes. These are not merely courses. They are actually support programmes which involve the expertise of all the institutes assisting the set-up of new enterprises. That is predominantly where we have concentrated our efforts on a cross-Border basis.

Comment on this

I noted on page 13 of the 1997 accounts that there seems to be a big shift in the trade credited and other creditors from 1996 to 1997, to the tune of more than £500,000. What is meant by trade creditors and other creditors? Who are the other creditors? What is the financial arrangement in relation to that activity?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

In relation to the increase in the other creditors, I mentioned earlier that we are funding the provision of new facilities for students. This was referred to earlier in the Carlow presentation. We are doing a similar thing in Dundalk. We are accumulating some capitation funding as a development fund for new student services facilities. A new building will come on stream next September which was funded over a period of a number of years by accumulating capitation funds and matching that with other funds, including some Interreg funds. That is why that is increasing. It is a reserve fund which has been put in place for that purpose. That fund will be exhausted by the end of this year or early next year because the building payment will have been taken out by that stage.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Carroll. I hope we will both be back next time.

Comment on this

What is the total number of students?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

We have 2,840 whole-time equivalent students. This is made up of approximately 2,600 full-time and about 800 part-time and apprentices.

Comment on this

What is the equivalence for a part-time student? Is it one third?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

No, it can vary. Some are attending one evening a week and some are attending en bloc. It really varies. Apprentices, specifically, are one third.

Comment on this

That is 2,840 equivalent full-time students.

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

Correct.

Comment on this

What is the equivalent full-time student population in Carlow? It was given as 2,500 full-time and 1,200 part-time. Does Carlow have a full-time equivalence?

Comment on this

Again, it is a figure that is mainly composed of part-time students. As has been mentioned, the equivalence depends on whether students attend one or two evenings per week. We have 1,200 part-time students and on average, we divide that figure by eight or ten. The figure is approximately 150.

Comment on this

What is the number of degree courses offered at the moment?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

We offer six degree courses.

Comment on this

Is it intended to increase that number?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

There are four additional degree programmes under development within the various schools of the institute.

Comment on this

What is the square footage or square metreage?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

At the moment it is about 29,000 square metres. That is a considerable increase. I qualify that by saying that it includes buildings currently under construction. By early next year the area will be around 29,000 square metres. We started in 1994 at around 18,000 square metres. If one divided the student numbers in 1994-95 by the area available and did the same exercise now, one would find that we are just keeping up, with regard to square metres per student. The building programme is just about keeping pace with the increase.

Comment on this

How successful has Dundalk been with regard to research? What fields of research are undertaken, how many people are directly involved in it, have any staff become involved in research and have papers been published?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

Carlow mentioned earlier that some of their activities fall into the basic and some into the applied area. Our focus in Dundalk has been on the applied research area - by applied research I mean contract research with existing companies. Some basic research is ongoing but it is quite small and has not reached a critical mass yet which would enable comparisons to be drawn on the publication of papers. Some academic staff have been pursuing further degree programmes and have published. Our main focus has been in applied research with industry. The discipline areas in which that has occurred are symptomatic of the way the economy has been developing. Research has been mainly in software development and also in engineering design. We regard ourselves as being quite strong in those areas, from the research point of view.

We have been involved in quite a number of European programmes in the area of academic and student entrepreneurship where we have been working since the mid-1980s, and certainly since 1989, in supporting new enterprise development. That has involved quite an input from across the college departments and schools, in particular from the business school.

We have not carried out a census of the number of staff involved but I guess that more than 30% of our academic cohort are actively involved in a range of activities. I would include in that research, enterprise development support, consultancy and customised training programmes. By customised training I mean programmes specifically offered to meet a particular company's needs, as opposed to the part-time suite of programmes we offer to the general public.

Comment on this

May I return to what the Comptroller and Auditor General said at the outset? If what he said about the Dundalk Institute of Technology had occurred in a private industry, the company would have gone wallop. It was an awful indictment of the management system in Dundalk.

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

I agree and it is very difficult to put a defence on that. We are trying to rectify the situation. It was caused by two main factors. One was significant staff changes over the last number of years whereby the director was seconded for a period of time to head up the new unit I mentioned earlier and to which he has now gone permanently. That left a number of acting-up positions. The secretary/financial controller was acting as director and the finance officer was acting as secretary/financial controller. The staff complement in the accounts area was not what it should have been.

A more serious problem was that our payroll system, which has to be taken into account when producing an accumulated set of accounts where we are putting the pay and non-pay together on a more regular basis, was inherited from the VEC and had not been updated. Steps have been taken to rectify the matter and it will not happen again.

Luckily, we are also in the situation where we have a full staff complement in the accounts area. We will always need more but, at least, we have senior staff there now who are addressing these problems. We have had to take in some external accountancy experts from the private sector to support us in the interim to get to the point where we are bringing the information more up to date but, unlike other years, for this year's accountswe expect to have sets of accounts available by the end of the year. Traditionally, they would have been available the following year. We hope to rectify the situation and get back on par this year.

There is no excuse for taking one year to answer queries, other than the ones I have offered. Unfortunately, that did occur. We have been addressing these and hope to catch up on that basis. I agree with the Deputy that it is a serious indictment. All I can say is that we are trying to rectify the situation.

Comment on this

You speak very well and knowledgeably. What is your background?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

I am one of those creatures known as an engineer. I am not an accountant. I am a mechanical engineer by background. I was head of development at the institute prior to becoming temporary director in the last few months.

Comment on this

Did you have financial responsibility?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

I did, mainly on the capital side, but not on the operational side. You will have to excuse my ignorance, therefore, on some of the technical questions relating to the accounts. I was also responsible for the research and development side.

Comment on this

What is the cost per student?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

If we divide total expenditure by the equivalent number of students, the cost per student is about £3,600.

Comment on this

How much, on average, does Dundalk Institute of Technology have on deposit?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

I am advised that currently we have about £200,000 on deposit but it varies somewhat. It can be as high as £1 million, typically about £500,000.

Comment on this

Are you happy that that money is invested at the highest possible rate of interest?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

We have a system known as chary cash through Allied Irish Bank under which the money is invested on our behalf with our bankers. We review the situation. In fact there is a review taking place of banking arrangements which will include a review of chary cash rates and bank charges generally. At this point in time we are confident that we are getting a good return.

Comment on this

On public-private partnerships, how have you developed with industries in the area in relation to partnerships that would benefit the college, community and partner?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

The public-private partnerships in which we have been involved essentially have been contractual research arrangements. Outside of that we have not been involved in the type of PPPs that have occurred in other agencies such as construction projects or student residences which are particularly popular. There is a working group under the council of directors of institutes of technology examining PPP arrangements on a number of fronts but it has not come up with any models as such. I am aware of one other institute in the sector which is involved in one of the pilot projects under the PPP arrangements for the construction of a particular faculty but in Dundalk we have not had that experience. The nearest that we have come is the partnership that I described on contract research with industry.

Comment on this

Is Rank Xerox establishing——

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

It is.

Comment on this

It is projected that the numbers employed will be very substantial.

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

The projections are that in excess of 2,000 jobs will be created in Dundalk in five individual plants which are in extensive recruitment mode. This is one of the areas in which we have co-operated closely with the company. We have accelerated technician programmes in which we are attempting to provide the skill base required. For a region such as the north east and a town such as Dundalk providing the skill set needed - I estimate that up to half of the 2,000 will have third level qualifications - is a daunting task, even from the graduate body in the region. We are working closely with the company to develop customised programmes to meet its needs. These would include upskilling programmes for people in employment. Like other industries, the company is very conscious of the need to upskill its workforce whereby technicians can pursue diplomas and those with diplomas can pursue degrees. This requires a partnership, which is ongoing. We have set up a liaison group to deal specifically with the company because of its size and skill base.

Comment on this

At what level is the relationship between the institute and Rank Xerox? It is an ideal opportunity for the institute to take a proactive approach and for the director to become involved. There are substantial benefits to be derived for the local and national economy.

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

I regularly meet the managing director of the company. We are both involved in a number of chamber of commerce initiatives but we meet formally to discuss interaction. There is also a subgroup. The company has a range of discipline needs, of which engineering is one. A liaison group has been set up between our engineering school and its engineering managers which liaises specifically on engineering matters. Another group has been set up on training specifically between our industrial liaison office and its training unit. It is happening, therefore, at many levels as one can imagine - I almost had forgotten - our careers office is in regular contact with the company and the company with us.

Comment on this

Have you managed to get any funding from it?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

We are in the process of negotiating a number of packages. When it arrived in Dundalk the company was very quick to enter into an arrangement whereby it supported a number of student bursaries. That was very popular.

Comment on this

Tell me about internal audit arrangements in the institute.

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

We are in the same position as Carlow. We do not have a specific internal audit person but, like all other institutes, we have engaged the services of an external consultancy which will provide internal audit services. The arrangement is that the internal audit service will deal specifically with a subcommittee of the governing body known as the finance and audit subcommittee and report to the governing body. We are programmed to have our first internal audit on 15 May.

Comment on this

What land does the college own?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

We have approximately 20 acres in total - I cannot convert this to hectares - approximately half of which has been developed. We are in a position where we have enough land for future development.

Comment on this

What about sporting facilities?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

A new range of sports facilities are planned. Unfortunately, because of the situation we were in over the last number of years the existing pitch areas were taken over and used as building, car parking and entrance space. They now have to be replaced. This will be done over the next number of years.

Comment on this

Does this involve the acquisition of more land?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

No, this will be done on the property that we already own.

Comment on this

What about the zoning of the land?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

In the urban council development plan it is zoned for educational use.

Comment on this

How many students do you have from the North?

Comment on this
Mr. Carroll

Very few. The figure is about 2%. The problem is that there is a mismatch at qualification level, either at O or A level, in matching our requirements. We would have to deal with students on an individual basis. Obviously, anyone who meets the entry requirements is taken. This is one of the things we recognise in a Border college, that we are going to have to, if you like, focus more on attracting students from Northern Ireland.

Comment on this

I suppose this applies to Letterkenny and Sligo as well. Has the Department of Education and Science any thoughts on the developing political situation - that the hinterland for these colleges might be expanding to the North?

Comment on this

There is an intention and consideration is being given to doing a study or even dual studies in cross-Border areas - Dundalk, Newry, possibly Letterkenny and Derry - to look at how cross-Border co-operation between the colleges might be nurtured and developed and also how one might develop synergies in relation to the whole area of further and higher education in that regard. In general, Letterkenny in the past has drawn to our attention that there is one difficulty in that regard in terms of the flows across the Border in that students from the Republic who wish to attend the equivalent of institutes, let us say colleges of further and higher education in Northern Ireland, are eligible, in many instances, for grant aid. In other words, they can carry a maintenance grant. There is not a reciprocal arrangement under the British system. There is no grant aid available to students coming from the North to study in certificate diploma type programmes in the republic. That can be a constraint on cross-Border movement.

Comment on this

To be clear, students going from the Republic to the North would be subvented by the Department of Education and Science here?

Comment on this

Yes. Students, for instance, from Letterkenny. In certain parts of Donegal the transport arrangements make it easier for a student to go into Derry to the further and higher education college in Derry.

Comment on this

Or Coleraine.

Comment on this

That student from Donegal, for a range of courses in the equivalent in Derry of the institute of technology, can get a maintenance grant for attending the course.

Comment on this

From our Department?

Comment on this

From our Department of Education and Science, whereas, as I understand it, if a student from, let us say, Newry or Derry, wanted to go to Letterkenny or Dundalk, they do not have the same maintenance grant arrangements.

Comment on this

Is that something that we are discussing with the education authorities?

Comment on this

It is something that we have raised on a number of occasions. It links into the national arrangements that apply in Great Britain generally that they tend to grant aid on the basis of degree provision rather than diploma provision.

Comment on this

In relation to degree provision, what is the situation?

Comment on this

In degree provision, students from Northern Ireland can carry maintenance grants and loans to the South. That is my understanding.

Comment on this

And vice versa?

Comment on this

And vice versa.

Comment on this

But not at certificate/diploma level?

Comment on this

At certificate/diploma level we do encounter some difficulties in that area.

Comment on this

Extraordinary. We will pause and go on to the Letterkenny Institute of Technology.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

There are two references to the Letterkenny Institute of Technology in my general report on the education sector which was presented to Dáil Éireann in January 1998. The first draws attention to inadequacies in the management of the institute after it was set up as an autonomous body which led the Minister for Education to appoint an inspector to report on its administration. The inspector's report, published in October 1994, was critical of a number of aspects of the institute's management and, as a result, a commission in the form of a sole member was appointed to run the affairs of the institute for two years.

The institute has since reverted to normal governance mode but I would think that the early difficulties contributed to the drop in enrolments in the years 1995-7 over the 1994 levels. Thankfully, the institute seems to have put those problems behind it and enrolments of full-time students in 1998 and 1999 have shown an appreciable increase.

The second reference in the report is to the fraudulent payment of student maintenance grants which was brought to light by my staff in the audit of the 1994 accounts. They identified two irregular payments to a value of £1,299 and it was eventually established by the institute, with the help of the Garda, that nearly £12,000 was involved. The £1,299 was recovered and I understand that the balance is to be taken out of the superannuation entitlements of the officer involved who, again I understand, has since tendered his resignation. I should say that the system for paying the grants was changed and a much stricter control regime was put in place.

As to the accounts themselves, there is the familiar problem with timeliness. The private sector audit firm which I engaged to perform the 1997 audit was unable to complete its work because of delays in the furnishing of information. So, there is a similar problem here to that which occurred in Dundalk. As a result, I was unable to issue my audit report for that year, the academic year ending August 1997, until October 1999 - over two years later. I am still awaiting adjustments to be put through on the accounts for the academic year ending 31 August 1998 so there is a common problem.

Comment on this

Mr. Hannigan, do you want to make a brief statement?

Comment on this
Mr. Hannigan

Yes, I would like to say a few words, Chairman, thank you very much. In relation to the comments made by the Comptroller and Auditor General, it is necessary to go back a little over some of the things which happened in the past. The college became autonomous in 1993 and had some difficulties in the transition period at that time. The Comptroller and Auditor General has made reference to some of the issues that arose and, from having student enrolments of around 1,500 in the 1993-4 academic year, the numbers reduced to just over 1,200 for the three subsequent years. As was also pointed out, the numbers have recovered dramatically in the past three years where we now have around 1,900 full-time students in the college. It has gone up from 1,550 in 1997-8 to over 1,700 last year and up to 1,900 this year, so we have recovered very well in that respect.

As to the contributing factors to that turnaround, the commission was put in place for two years and then as director for his final year in Letterkenny and the return of the governing body. We had investment of up to £12 million by the Department of Education and Science in the college's infrastructure and capital developments. We have also expanded our course provision from an institute where we would have primarily had certificate and diploma programmes. In September of this year we will have on offer eight degree programmes within the institute, one of which will be an ab initio degree programme which, hopefully, will be able to attract some students from Northern Ireland, an issue which has already been brought up this morning.

Our continuing education programme has also expanded with over 500 students at present. Again we are involved in relating to the skills shortage programmes brought forward by the skills initiative unit, particularly the national certificate in information technology for which we have had very good enrolments over the last while.

The employment of graduates locally is also an issue of which we are very proud. Traditionally there has been a migration of students or graduates from the Donegal area to other parts of the country. Our figures show that, in the last two years, the county has retained up to 40% of our graduates who have found employment. We would see this as a very important development from our point of view.

Also, in terms of our own enrolment, we are taking a large percentage of our students from the county. Up to 70% of our students are from County Donegal. Over 70% of them are first preference students so we would see that we have regained the confidence of our region and we are addressing that at the moment.

We have also made strides in terms of research and development and in developing the local economy. It is a well-known fact that Donegal has gone through more difficulties than others recently and has an unemployment rate of around 22% compared to the national average of about 5% to 6%. The institute sees itself as a major player in terms of turning the economy around and has participated in the recent Donegal employment initiative task force. We are looking at initiatives in which we can improve the attraction of foreign direct investment into County Donegal and also that we can provide further employment in the county for our graduates.

Comment on this

Mr. Hannigan, could you respond to the delay outlined by the Comptroller and Auditor General in relation to the 1998 accounts? As you are aware, our primary function is to see that funds are spent and are accounted for on a timely basis. We take it seriously and we take seriously comments by the Comptroller and Auditor General that these delays have occurred and are still occurring. What is your response to that?

Comment on this
Mr. Hannigan

The institute takes the delays very seriously as well. There are two issues to which I would draw attention. One is the staffing issue. Earlier Mr. Gallagher from Carlow outlined the structure in terms of financial controller, finance officer and support staff. We have had a position where we have had turnover in the position of finance officer over the last three or four years. We have actually just appointed a full-time person last week. Previous to that we had three incumbents in the job who left for various reasons so we have had some difficulties there, but we now believe we have sorted that one out.

As a result of one of the earlier reports from the Comptroller and Auditor General, there was a question over whether the accounting system we were using was 2000 compliant. We had to make a change in that regard and we were introducing a new system, which again caused some delays in getting the accounts prepared. We believe we have addressed the issues that were causing the delays and that we will not be falling into that situation from now on.

Comment on this

When will the 1998 accounts be finalised?

Comment on this
Mr. Hannigan

The 1998 accounts are almost completed. There were a few queries and they are being addressed.

Comment on this
Michael Bell Acting Chairman (Deputy Bell) Labour Party

Does the Comptroller and Auditor General agree with those sentiments?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

Earlier the Chairman, Deputy Mitchell, suggested that this is a topic the committee might take when all of the institutes have been reviewed. Perhaps I would hold my fire until then.

Comment on this

What are the specific items of the accounts with which there is still a problem? Is it to do with salaries, PAYE or something else?

Comment on this
Mr. Hannigan

They are just minor issues with respect to journal entries as to the year in which the money was spent.

Comment on this

Is it to do with the allocation of cash?

Comment on this
Mr. Hannigan

Yes.

Comment on this

Are decisions to be made in this regard? Must people think about it?

Comment on this
Mr. Hannigan

The issues were being addressed while the new accounting system was being put in place and the delay was caused by introducing this system. The queries were put forward by the Comptroller and Auditor General. They have been addressed by the college but the actual physical response must be prepared on the new system. That is the current position.

Comment on this

Would Mr. Hannigan let the committee have a written note to explain the particular problems in this regard, how he will resolve them and when they will be resolved?

Comment on this
Mr. Hannigan

Yes.

Comment on this

How many full-time students were there in the college for the 1996/7 year, the last year for which there are accounts?

Comment on this
Mr. Hannigan

The number of full-time students for 1996/7 was 1,290. I am not sure how many part-time students attended that year. There were probably about 400 or 500 part-time students.

Comment on this

One could account for a part-time student as 20% of a full-time student or the equivalent of 90 full-time students in this case.

Comment on this
Mr. Hannigan

Yes.

Comment on this

Therefore, 1,290 plus the equivalent of 90 full-time students equals 1,380 or, approximately, 1,400 full-time students. What was the cost per student?

Comment on this
Mr. Hannigan

The cost per student at that time was £4,200.

Comment on this

How many different disciplines are covered? How many degree courses does the Letterkenny institute offer?

Comment on this
Mr. Hannigan

To break it down into disciplines, we provide courses in business studies, science, engineering, nursing, graphic design and computing. We provide the following degree courses, which are a progression from our diploma courses: a Bachelor of business studies degree; a BSc in applied computing; a BSc in nursing, which is a part-time programme at present; a Bachelor of legal studies, which is in the business studies area and a Bachelor of food science.

There are a number of new degree programmes which are coming on stream in September, one of which is a BSc in an analytical science. The new degree in computing is in data communications and networking. The difference in this and other programmes which the institute has had on offer to date is that it is an ab initio degree programme - it is a four year programme from day one. It is an important one from our point of view. It is the first degree in Letterkenny Institute of Technology which has that structure. Relating to the issues which were brought forward about trying to attract students from Northern Ireland, that might be a course which will be able to stand on its own in that regard. A BSc in digital media will be coming on stream in September also.

Those courses are in place. There are other proposals on-going also. Our aim is to give any student who comes into Letterkenny Institute of Technology the opportunity to complete a degree programme with us. In the past there has been a fair migration of students either from certificate or diploma programmes to other colleges in other areas to complete their studies. We feel we have an obligation to try and offer the provision within County Donegal for the people who are attending the institute.

Comment on this

Of all the courses, where is the niche of Letterkenny Institute of Technology? Where is its selling point?

Comment on this