1998 Annual Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General and Appropriation Accounts. ›
Vote 3 - Department of the Taoiseach
Contributions 1–171 of 347. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
We are resuming under the Department of Foreign Affairs. It is relevant to the Department of the Taoiseach and the Ombudsman. We will dispose of the Department of Foreign Affairs first.
Columba Peoples, who has been with us for the past six months is leaving the committee tomorrow. We thank him for his excellent work and wish him good luck in the future.
Comment on this
Hear, hear.
Mr. P. Mac Kernan (Secretary General, Department of Foreign Affairs), Mr. D Gallagher (Secretary General, Department of the Taoiseach) and Mr. P Whelan (Director, Office of the Ombudsman) called and examined.
Comment on this
We are dealing with the 1988 Annual Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General and Appropriation Accounts - Vote 38, Department of Foreign Affairs (resumed). We will later take the Department of the Taoiseach and the Office of the Ombudsman. We open formally Vote 17 - Office of the Ombudsman and Vote 3 - the Department of the Taoiseach.
Witnesses' attention is drawn to the fact that as and from the 2 August 1998, section 10 of the Committees of the Houses of the Oireachtas (Compellability, Privileges and Immunities of Witnesses) Act, 1997, grants certain rights to persons who are identified in the course of the proceedings. The other provisions of that section are drawn to the attention of witnesses.
I welcome Mr. Dermot Gallagher, Secretary General of the Department of the Taoiseach. It is your first time to attend the PAC. Congratulations on your promotion. We will talk to you later.
Comment on this
That is correct, dealing with Northern Ireland. Previous to that I was in Washington for six years.
Comment on this
Your former Secretary General is also in attendance. He can act as your guardian angel today.
Comment on this
I wish to be associated with those comments. It is great to see Leitrim doing so well at present.
Comment on this
It is all happening for Leitrim recently. Perhaps, Mr. Gallagher, you would introduce your accompanying colleagues.
Comment on this
I am accompanied by Mr. Peter Ryan, assistant secretary; Mr. Martin Fraser and Ms Elaine Kelly.
Comment on this
Mr. MacKernan, you are welcome back. Perhaps you would introduce your accompanying colleagues.
Comment on this
I am accompanied by Mr. Frank Cogan and Mr. Derek Feely.
Comment on this
You are both welcome. I also welcome Mr. Pat Whelan, Director, Office of the Ombudsman.
Comment on this
Thank you, Chairman. I am accompanied by Maureen Behan and Tom Morgan.
Comment on this
You are welcome. From the Department of Finance we have Mr. Niall McSweeney, Mr. Lorcan Nolan, Mr. Terry Walsh, Mr. Tony Gallagher and Mr. John White. You are all welcome. We are dealing first with an outstanding issue from the Department of Foreign Affairs which I will ask the Comptroller and Auditor General to introduce.
Paragraph 5 of the Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General reads:
5. Referendum Commissions
In March and April 1998 the Minister for the Environment and Local Government set up two Referendum Commissions, under the Referendum Act, 1998 to provide information to the electorate in respect of the referenda on the Amsterdam Treaty and on the Northern Ireland Agreements. The Commissions were chaired by a former Chief Justice of the Supreme Court and the four ordinary members were the Clerk of Dáil Éireann, the Clerk of Seanad Éireann, the Ombudsman and the Comptroller and Auditor General. The Commissioners were independent in the performance of their functions. Not later than six months after the completion of the performance of their functions the Commissions shall submit a report to the Minister for Environment and Local Government in relation to the performance by them of their functions and the Minister shall lay the report before the Houses of the Oireachtas. The Commissions stand dissolved one month after the submission of the report. In November 1998 the report was submitted and accordingly the Commissions dissolved in December 1998.
As the referenda were held on the same day there was a considerable amount of commonality in the work of the two Commissions. The Secretariat of the Commissions was drawn from the Office of the Ombudsman and the expenses incurred by the Commissions in undertaking their statutory duties were borne on the Vote for the Department of the Taoiseach in respect of the Northern Ireland Agreements Referendum (£2.137m) and on the Vote for the Department of Foreign Affairs in respect of the Amsterdam Treaty Referendum (£2.197m).
The total expenditure on both referenda of £4,334,861 can be analysed as follows:
AmsterdamTreaty | Northern Ireland Agreements | Total
£ | £ | £
Sub-contractor/supplier expenditure via media consultants | 1,852,971 | 1,752,619 | 3,605,590
Media consultants management fees | 199,423 | 111,622 | 311,045
Paid to media consultants | 2,052,394 | 1,864,241 | 3,916,635
Direct expenditure through Referendum Commissions | 145,053 | 273,173 | 418,226*
Total | 2,197,447 | 2,137,414 | 4,334,861
*Comprises | £
Advertising | 194,000
Postal Costs | 177,000
Printing and Design | 20,000
Legal Fees | 14,000
Miscellaneous | 13,000
As I was a member of the Commissions I decided in the interest of transparency to engage the services of the auditor who audits the Appropriation Account of my Office, on my behalf, to also carry out an audit of the expenses incurred by the Commissions. His report was brought to the attention of the Accounting Officers of the Department of the Taoiseach, the Department of Foreign Affairs and the Office of the Ombudsman and their observations were sought.
The auditor prefaces his findings with the statement that it should be borne in mind that the Commission and the staff assigned to it were working under significant time pressure and had a heavy workload. This is due in part to the fact that the Commission was under-resourced from a staffing perspective. Accordingly, a number of the problems noted, in our opinion, arise from these matters.
The main audit findings were:
In the appointment of the media consultants public procurement procedures were not adhered to as:
For the Amsterdam Treaty Referendum campaign the lowest tender was not considered suitable and Government Contracts Committee approval was not sought or obtained for the award of the contract to a higher tenderer. Guidance was not sought from the Department of Finance as to whether, due to the urgency of engaging a media consultant, the publication of the tender in the Official Journal of the European Union was not necessary. The successful tenderer however, had got legal advice that there was no requirement to so advertise. As there was no time for a separate tendering process in respect of the Northern Ireland Agreements referendum the Commission sought proposals from the consultants then engaged on the Amsterdam Treaty referendum. The proposal was acceptable to the Commission and the contract was awarded accordingly. However, the approval of the Government Contracts Committee was not sought or obtained for this extension of the contract. A tax clearance certificate must be provided by the consultants before a contract is awarded. Whilst the requirement was specified in the invitation to tender, this was subsequently not provided to the Commissions. Contract documents should be signed in duplicate by authorised persons and copies retained by both parties. Draft contracts/project management agreements were prepared but were not apparently finalised and signed, due to time constraints. There was a letter of 1 April 1998 from the consultants outlining budgeted costs for the Amsterdam Treaty referendum as it was anticipated by them that it would take some time to prepare and agree a detailed contract. The consultants organised sub-contracts with expenditure totalling £3.6m. Apart from the printing element (£611,000), a tender process was not arranged by the consultants. There were deficiencies in the system of internal control for authorising and approving invoices.
I was informed that:
The Commission had to carry out a broad range of statutory functions within a predetermined time scale which was not of its own making and had to do so under the added pressure of a high level of public, media and political attention. The campaigns in respect of the referenda on the Amsterdam Treaty and the Northern Ireland Agreements, were the first such campaigns run by the Referendum Commission and as such were very much a learning experience for the Commission.
The difficulties encountered by the Commission included:
Because two important referendums were held on the same date, the time scale available to the Commission to carry out its functions was particularly tight. Furthermore, the subject matter of the Amsterdam Treaty referendum was particularly complex and presented the Commission with very formidable challenges.
While the staff resources requested by the Commission were approved by the Government without delay, there was considerable delay in filling the approved posts because of the absence of any panels of qualified people. The Commission had, therefore, to draw from the staff of the Ombudsmans Office, who had no previous experience in or expert knowledge of the Amsterdam Treaty or the Northern Ireland Agreements, with the resulting vacancies being filled later on, when staff became available from service-wide panels.
The Commission obviously had to spend considerable time initially in putting staff and an office in place, setting up payment mechanisms and other logistical arrangements as well as engaging consultants and planning a comprehensive information campaign. Almost immediately work had to start on the preparation of the initial publications on the Amsterdam Treaty and on setting up the Website, Press Office and Information Line. In respect of the Amsterdam Treaty, a period of twelve weeks was available to the Commission to carry out its functions from the date of its establishment to the date of the referendum. In the case of the referendum on Northern Ireland, the time available was four weeks and during this period the Commission was running two separate information campaigns. As a result, the work pressures on the seconded staff, especially the Secretary to the Commission, were constant and intense and quite a number of logistical difficulties arose. A series of deadlines arose in quick succession.
The Commission in its report to the Minister for Environment and Local Government agreed that it was desirable that any future Commission should have the maximum amount of time possible under the terms of the Constitution to fulfil its remit properly. Indeed some advance logistical and other work, including the putting into place of staff should be made possible even before the proposals for the referendum are settled by the two Houses of the Oireachtas, for example, as soon as the Government has publicly announced an intention to initiate the Bill concerned.
Arising from the difficulties encountered the Commission also recommended that where it is decided to establish a Commission under the Act of 1998, the minimum period to elapse between the passing of the Bill or the making of an order under Section 12 of the Referendum Act, 1994 and the polling date should be 90 days.
The matters raised on audit in relation to internal controls and procedures have been noted and appropriate measures will in future be put in place to deal with these matters. All the points raised relating to contract procedure are noted for future reference. The severe staffing and time constraints were again relevant in this regard.
The Commission had less than one month to prepare and implement a multi-faceted information campaign in relation to the Northern Ireland referendum. It would have been impossible to do this except through the consultant as it was necessary to utilise the campaign framework already put in place in respect of the Amsterdam Treaty campaign e.g. press office, production company, printers, advertising company, media monitoring etc. The fact that these were already in place meant that the Northern Ireland campaign could be managed and run at a much reduced cost than would otherwise have been the case.
When the consultants decided to submit a tender bid for the project management of the information campaign it formed a consortium to handle the advertising elements and to handle the broadcast production elements of the campaign. While it might have been more appropriate to ensure a tender process for all major elements of the services provided to the Commission these were on board from the outset as part of the consortium. The consultants did not engage in a tender process for these services. When a subsequent need for printing arose a tender process was followed at the request of the Commission. Due to the severe time constraints which the Commission operated under it was a distinct advantage in planning and implementing the campaign to have a number of service providers available at the outset. However, in future and assuming adequate notice is given of its establishment as outlined in its recommendations on these two campaigns, the Commission will seek to ensure that separate major services are contracted following a tender process.
Work has already commenced on a Referendum Commission Procedures Manual which will put in place a series of procedures for expenditure controls, internal controls and strict compliance with public procurement and tendering procedures etc. for future referendum campaigns, where such proves practicable.
Comment on this
Thank you, Chairman. We have a distinguished gathering today because of the unusual arrangements for the financing of the Referendum Commissions. There were two commissions. The first, the referendum on the Amsterdam Treaty, was financed from the Vote for Foreign Affairs. The second, on the Northern Ireland agreements, was funded from the Vote for the Department of the Taoiseach. The administration of the referendum commissions' activities was undertaken by the Office of the Ombudsman. That is why the three are here today.
Paragraph five, which refers to the Referendum Commission, draws attention to the results of an audit of expenditure by the referendum commissions established to provide information on the referenda concerning the Amsterdam Treaty and the Northern Ireland agreements. A total of £4.3 million was expended. Before going into the substance of the paragraph I wish to advise the committee that I was a member of both commissions and for that reason I directed that private sector auditors be engaged to carry out the audit on my behalf in the interests of transparency and to avoid any possible perception of a conflict of interest. The fact that I was aware that short cuts had to be taken by the commissions to fulfil statutory mandates made it all the more important that my office's contact with the audit should be at arm's length. I am stating my interest in this matter.
The main deficiencies in the procedures operated by the commissions identified in the reports of the auditors are summarised in the paragraph. Most of them centre around the contracting arrangements, which did not comply with public procurement procedures. There was a failure to obtain the approval of the Government's contracts committee where appropriate, there was no competitive tendering for most of the sub-contracts organised by the consultants and there was also non-completion of contract documents.
The reports also drew attention to shortcomings in the system of internal control for authorising and approving invoices, although the auditors say there is no evidence that incorrect payments were made. The accounting officer for the Office of the Ombudsman points out the difficulties which the commissions had to overcome, particularly the time frame in which they had to operate, effectively with two staff commandeered from the Office of the Ombudsman. He states that appropriate measures will be put in place for future referenda to address the shortcomings. In that context he instigated work on the preparation of a procedures manual to facilitate management and control overall financial aspects of the commission's operations in the future.
Since then there has been a referendum on local government but that did not involve expenditure or activity of anything like the scale of the two previous referenda, and I am not aware that there were significant problems regarding the operation of that particular referendum, but that would be something which would be looked at in due course.
Comment on this
The Office of the Ombudsman was responsible for the administration of the Referendum Commission and the secretariat and the staff, such as they were, were drawn from the Office of the Ombudsman. The moneys were provided from the Vote of the Department of Foreign Affairs in the case of the Amsterdam Treaty referendum and from the Vote of the Department of the Taoiseach in the case of the referendum on the Northern Ireland Agreement.
Comment on this
Perhaps I should allow each of the Accounting Officers to make a brief statement first. Mr. Mac Kernan, would you like to make a brief statement?
Comment on this
Yes. Thank you, Chairman. First, I wish to express my gratitude to the Comptroller and Auditor General for explaining the basis of the problem which has arisen. Essentially he touched on one central aspect of the problem, and there is another one to which I will come. The central problem for the sponsoring Departments and the administering Department, if one is to describe the Ombudsman's office in that way, was the time constraints under which the whole operation had to be carried out. It was a very tight schedule and with a very small number of personnel capable of being deployed to do the job.
A second problem, which arose and which I expect will have to be put right for the future, is the fact that there are certain ambiguities and a want of precision as to the role of the sponsoring Departments or Department vis-à-vis the commission when it comes to carrying out the duties of accounting, tendering, etc. This was specifically highlighted when the issue of retention tax or withholding tax arose, and the Department of Foreign Affairs ultimately sought the advice of the Attorney General’s office in regard to this. That advice showed that there is an ambiguity in the legislation in the sense that it is not precisely clear as to the respective roles of the sponsoring Department and the commission in regard to accounting responsibilities.
There is also a paradox in that the Act setting up the commission stipulates that this is an independent body. Therefore, there is an inherent problem in a sponsoring Department micro-managing the day to day operations of a body which is, by law, independent. In any event, the view of the Attorney General's office was that if a matter like this were to be contested, it would be likely that the courts would find that the commission is the body, given its independence, etc., which has the duty of following the accounting rules.
What happened as far as the Amsterdam Treaty commission was concerned, and indeed the other one, was that the Department was supposed to advance funds, in effect, in consultation with the Department of Finance. Funds were not advanced as such but it was undertaken that the Department would pay the bills, duly checked, as they were submitted and this is in fact what happened.
Then, as the Comptroller and Auditor General has explained, when he submitted the material for checking in the private sector because of possible conflict of interest, etc., a certain number of deficiencies came to light and failures to follow proper tendering procedures. That is how the whole issue arose. It is of course regrettable that, between one thing and another, these procedures were not fully complied with although the audit indicates that everything was kosher as far as the bills, etc., are concerned.
The net situation, as far as my Department is concerned, and indeed for the future, is that on this issue it is necessary to be clear about the precise role of the commission or commissions, given their independence and given the need, of course, to have proper accounting procedures and proper tendering procedures. How that will be done is a matter for consideration and no doubt at the end of today's deliberations the Committee of Public Accounts will have a view on that.
Comment on this
Yes. I wish to express appreciation again to you, Chairman, and the members for their warm welcome.
In relation to the 1998 accounts, I have carefully read and studied paragraph 5 of the Comptroller and Auditor General's report and in my view it is a very fair statement of the situation. For my part, having just taken over my position in the Department of the Taoiseach, I found it very helpful, including of course its recommendation.
As regards the detail, the general position with regard to payments was that payments were made once they were duly authorised by the Referendum Commission. Clearly it was essential to the fulfilment of its remit that the commission retained its independence from the sponsoring Department and it goes without saying that the Department of the Taoiseach was anxious to respect that independence.
I should also make the point that the audit report confirms that the amounts expended from our Vote conform to authority and that moneys received by the commission were in respect of properly authorised payments. I think it was the first time the Referendum Commission had operated.
In the case of the Good Friday Agreement, I was involved in the negotiation of that Agreement and we did not know until that Good Friday, as the Deputies and the Chairman will be aware, whether it was going to be approved by the Unionist Party or not. Therefore, there was only literally four weeks and it was very important that a referendum be held on the same day in both parts of the island. It was the first occasion in over 70 years that the people of Ireland had voted on the same issue on the same day and that was a very important message to be able to convey to any organisation which opposed the Good Friday Agreement.
Given the time constraints and the staff constraints, I would like to pay tribute to the excellent work of the commission in carrying through its mandate in such difficult circumstances. There is a lesson in the report to be learnt by all us and certainly I would take it fully on board.
Comment on this
I wish to point out at the outset my role in these matters. I am the Accounting Officer for Vote 17, the Office of the Ombudsman, which covers the Ombudsman, the Information Commissioner and the Public Offices Commission.
The Referendum Commission is an unusual organisation or body in the sense that the funds which are given to it in respect of any particular information campaign regarding a referendum come from the Department sponsoring that particular referendum. Having said that, the day to day expenditure of moneys in connection with both of the campaigns concerned, the Amsterdam Treaty and the Northern Ireland Agreement, was organised and administered by my office. In that respect, I acknowledge that, although I was not the Accounting Officer for moneys expended on the Referendum Commissioner's behalf, my office did have a role in ensuring the propriety of that expenditure.
There are two problems which have been touched on already which I would like to draw to the attention of the committee. The first was the extremely short timescale available to the Referendum Commission in carrying out its information campaign on these two referenda. The establishment order for the commission was signed by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government, Deputy Dempsey, on 2 March 1998, and the referendum took place on 22 May. Therefore, there was a very short timescale for the Amsterdam Treaty campaign, but of course it was even shorter in the case of the Northern Ireland campaign because, in that case, the establishment order was not signed until 22 April, leaving just one month to organise and administer a campaign.
The second difficulty was in relation to the staffing of the secretariat of the Referendum Commission. Although staff were approved by the Department of Finance on 6 March 1998, it did not prove possible to put staff in situ because there were no staff available from panels set up by the Civil Service Commission. We were faced with a crisis and our answer to that crisis was to redeploy some existing staff from the Ombudsman’s Office, to whom I would like to pay tribute in terms of the excellent job they did. It was the first time an exercise of this scale had been undertaken by the office and had circumstances been different, we probably would have sought either people with expertise in this area or to have had the time to train people in the particular skills necessary. That was not possible at the time.
I want to draw attention to another issue at this stage, which is the withholding tax issue, as raised by Mr. Mac Kernan. This was a problem at the time but it was actually sorted out later on. I do not want to go into the details of it at this stage, simply to say that there was some confusion about whether payments made to the consultants to the Referendum Commission should have been made net of withholding tax or not. The net issue here was that nowhere was the Referendum Commission specified as a body which had statutory authority to withhold tax on payments. However, that problem was sorted out to everybody's satisfaction after a period so it was not central to the issues.
Comment on this
Who in the Department of Finance looks after this sort of issue? Is it Mr. McSweeney or Mr. White?
Comment on this
We deal with different Departments. I deal with the Department of Foreign Affairs, some of the other people here are responsible for the Ombudsman's Vote and others for the Taoiseach's Vote - it depends on the issue. The staffing issues, for example, were handled by the people dealing with the Ombudsman's Office.
Comment on this
Clearly we have a problem here that may arise again and we do not know what Department might be involved in future referenda. Who can we talk to in the Department of Finance in order to get something sorted out for the future so this problem is anticipated and there is as much forward planning as possible?
Comment on this
Could I interject to clarify an issue for you on this point?
Comment on this
We did of course eventually get the staff we were looking for. We now have an arrangement with the Department of Finance that these staff will be kept in situ in the Ombudsman’s Office and they can be immediately deployed in the event that another Referendum Commission is established.
Comment on this
I know but if something is urgent, as happened in the Good Friday Agreement, the normal procedures must be short-circuited. We need a way in which permission is available or processed in advance. Will somebody in the Department of Finance think about that and I will come back to you?
Comment on this
Just a pragmatic suggestion, if I may. Because of this, a procedures manual is being drawn up by the Ombudsman's Office and that may be the vehicle which would highlight any deficiencies and suggest a remedy, a process——
Comment on this
A mechanism to deal with this even if had to be fast forwarded. I think that may be a way of handling it.
Comment on this
It is reasonable to assume that the commissions were brought into action urgently and that many complexities were involved. There are issues of time, staff, skills and the complexities involved. We need to establish something along the lines of what Mr. Gallagher referred to in the context of the Ombudsman's proposed manual. The commission is dissolved within one month after its obligation to report within six months. On that basis, an organisation that is dissolved is non-existent and consequently it is difficult to understand how it can be re-established with the expertise and contacts normally associated with another organisation. How do we overcome this? How do we deal with an organisation which is only put in place when it is required? In the meantime, there is the question of staff being redeployed and returning to other duties in the Ombudsman's Office. It is not something to which one can easily give an answer.
I am not too concerned about the fact that some of the obligations in relation to guidelines, procurement, etc., were not adhered to. This matter has been adequately addressed by the Comptroller and Auditor General. However, we need to find a more suitable structure. Greater continuity needs to be maintained within an organisation which does not exist. Are there any suggestions as to how we could make it more concrete and constructive? Does Mr. Mac Kernan have any particular views on this?
Comment on this
Deputy Doherty and Mr. Gallagher have raised two very cogent points. It may well be that the handbook or manual which is being devised by the Ombudsman's Office would be sufficient for ensuring that tendering and the usual accounting procedures are strictly followed in each case. However, the point made by Deputy Doherty is very cogent in the sense that if this body dissolves itself, it still leaves open the question of who, at the end of the day, is the Accounting Officer and who should be sitting here addressing you and your colleagues, Chairman, and responding to your queries. As I pointed out initially - I know it was a relatively minor point in terms of the substance - the query put to the Attorney General's office brought out the fact that it is not clear, there is an ambiguity, as to who is the Accounting Officer, and a problem posed by virtue of the fact that the commission is, by definition, independent and should, therefore, not be presumably interfered with it in its day to day procedures.
Perhaps it is necessary either to designate one Department - I am not trying to shove work in anybody's direction but the basic Act here comes, I think, from the Department of Local Government. It is certainly important that the issue raised by Deputy Doherty should be clarified for the future, given the fact that these commissions are set up on an ad hoc basis and dissolve themselves subsequently. If another problem arises in the future, we shall have the same difficulty about who will be responsible. Will it be the sponsoring Department, as is the case today, and, if so, which sponsoring Department? Will it be precisely the Department that has to do with the substance of the commission’s business or what? That problem is there and perhaps legal advice and legislative drafting is needed.
Comment on this
That very accurately highlights the difficulty. The independence of the office and the public perception of its independence cannot be fully subscribed to in the form in which it is now constituted. Public perception is important and it is not only about adhering to this but about being seen to be doing so. Regarding staffing and funding, people may wrongly conclude but rightly suspect that it is not independent. It is independent in its function but it does not have any continuity of independence. Mr. Mac Kernan is right that somebody must be in situ permanently. That person, commission or whatever must have financial independence.
There must be a Vote for which they are accountable and answerable to the committee and the Comptroller and Auditor General. It would be wise if we were to conclude that the circumstances in which we find ourselves are a worthwhile learning experience. However, if the situation is not to be repeated, something more substantial and thought provoking must be undertaken in the meantime to ensure independence, continuity and some accountability in the form of one person rather than it being subjected to the influence of three Departments. This has already shown itself to be unwieldy and it is not possible to be independent as a result nor can it be perceived to be such. I am sure it is but it cannot be perceived to be such.
Comment on this
My comments are not a criticism of the commission or its activities. It must work within the confines and exigencies of its directions. The problem arises from the need for a referendum commission. I cannot see the purpose of the exercise. It arises from a court case where it was deemed that the Government did not have the right to spend money promoting its own issue——
Comment on this
——and that the counterpoint had to be made. I would have presumed and thought that, in a democratic society, the counterpoint was put by the opposition to Government. I do not understand why that was set aside. It is a waste of public money to have a commission doing a job which is already being done and for which procedures exist to do it.
This is not a criticism of the commission. It is doing the job it was given to do. I do not understand how anyone can claim that the opposition or the opposing view in the country, which exists in almost every situation, is not capable of putting the point itself. Someone decided there was an apolitical way and thinking converged in such a way as to produce an apolitical way to do the job. There is not an apolitical way to do the job. There is a view and a counterview and those views are entitled to be put to the people by the people who hold those views. If a majority exists on one side or the other, so be it. That is democracy. That is the way it works. I cannot——
Comment on this
Everyone disagrees with me. There is a political and democratic process and legislation should be introduced to change the need for a referendum commission. The procedures exist and referenda have been held before without such procedures.
Comment on this
I am interested as to the views of Mr. Whelan and others regarding this commission being a permanently established body within, for example, the Public Offices Commission, which seems to be the logical place for a body of this nature to reside.
The other issue on which I wanted to take Mr. Whelan to task is that there is a long standing practice established by myself and the Chairman that if any outside consultants are hired by a State body, it should be published with the accounts when coming before the committee. The Ombudsman's accounts do not list the outside media consultants used by the referendum commission for its work. It is important information which we would require.
It is important on a number of levels. Some of the information pumped out to the public was inaccurate, exaggerated and wrong, and that was the case on both sides of the fence. I must question the validity of what the consultants and the commission were doing as regards the presentation of the arguments in the referendum. They appear to have adopted an excessively academic approach where it might have been better to divide the arguments between the political parties as opposed to the Government and the Opposition. I would be interested to see the consultants' report on this referendum and the arguments presented. I find it odd that a public body charged with presenting information in a neutral way should, for the sake of presenting opposition to the referendum on the European issue, for example, be forced into telling untruths, which appears to be the very negation of an independent public commission charged with informing public debate. It appears odd that it could hire barristers to draw up arguments about the position on certain referenda which would end up being direct untruths. I do not say that in a political way. I thought the information was bizarre.
Comment on this
No, and I have a difficulty in speaking on behalf of the commission. I was not a member of it so I have a difficulty on that score. To be helpful, I wish to make the following observations. The commission, in its report, when it completed its task, drew attention to the need for research and information on possible developments in the area of holding referendums to be undertaken in the period between the appointment of referendum commissions so, to that extent, there would be a degree of continuity, shall we say. Although a commission would dissolve, there would be work going on in the meantime. The type of thing I think the commission had in mind was that, were another referendum to be in the offing, as it were, but not fully decided upon, it would be an opportunity for people to carry out research on the commission's behalf around that issue so that, when the commission was established, it could get up and running reasonably quickly.
As regards the actual output from the commission and Deputy Lenihan's comments about the unsatisfactory nature of it, there are debates going on in practically every democracy in the world about how to actually organise and conduct this type of information campaign. Different countries have adopted different approaches. The Danes, for instance, have a very sophisticated system that involves funding, not only of political parties in proportion to their strengths, but also of specific lobby and interest groups. I know for a fact that the Danes are not happy with that system. I do not know to what extent one can satisfy everyone on these issues.
The third point I wished to make was to pick up on some of the debate which went on earlier around the question of the systems manual we are producing. I fully accept that this will be of great assistance within our own organisation in terms of identifying proper procedures for the future. In this respect, the auditor's report has been very useful to us. Equally, I take the point about the role of the Accounting Officer and who should be the Accounting Officer. There is a great deal of ambiguity and unanswered questions around that.
These questions are somewhat peripheral to the main issue, which has to be that a commission must be given adequate notice and time to carry out its functions as currently prescribed by law. One can have an Accounting Officer in place and one can have the most wonderful systems and procedures but, if one does not have enough time to go through the contracting procedures——
Comment on this
Situations may arise where the national interest demands urgent action, as in the case of the Good Friday Agreement. That could occur again in some circumstances. We must have arrangements in place which can facilitate urgent action by the State where the national interest demands it. In the normal course, there should be sufficient notice for the commission to be able to organise matters, but there may be occasions similar to what occurred. How do you propose to deal with that?
Comment on this
You are right, Chairman, there could be, but I would have thought that those situations would be few and far between. How many referenda of that nature have we had that required such urgent action?
I draw to your attention the recommendations which the commission made in its report. One was that the Act should be amended to enable a commission to be set up at an earlier date relative to polling date than is possible at present; the second was that the minimum period allowed between the passing of a referendum Bill or the establishment of a referendum commission could be extended. That would go a long way towards easing the commission's difficulties in relation to the majority referendums.
Comment on this
On a couple of fundamental things, we are talking about the main issue and from my position the main issue relates to who has the ultimate responsibility. There is an irony in several issues here. I am hearing that there were breaches of regulation and there were breaches in terms of the guidance from the Department of Finance; there was no tax clearance certificate supplied and there were also deficiencies in contract documents. Here are three people in the highest positions in various Departments, were they aware they were breaching the regulations? Did they take conscious decisions to go down that road? It is extraordinary to me that while there were breaches of regulations, considering the first sentence here regarding the Amsterdam Treaty referendum, someone along the line decided that the lowest tender was not considered suitable. Who did not consider it suitable? Here were people willing to take a particular decision in relation to a contract on the referendum campaign itself, but there was nobody willing to comply with the regulations as set down by them. For us the fundamental question is how that was allowed to happen in this instance.
Comment on this
With respect, it is quite clear that Deputies here, those of us who have contributed and the Comptroller and Auditor General have pointed to the problems that arose, partly because of timing, but also because of the fact that the commission, under the pressures of the day, did not comply fully with accounting regulations. It was not so much the case that the sponsoring Departments failed to comply, it was a problem with the commission and when the matter came to light, as I pointed out in regard to withholding tax and this matter was discussed with the Revenue Commissioners and the Department of Finance as well as the Attorney General's office, the ambiguity at the heart of the problem came to light, namely, there is no clarity as to who, ultimately, is the accounting officer. This is the issue I pointed out in my initial intervention at the invitation of the Chairman. It remains the case that this ambiguity requires to be resolved.
The generic referendum Act is an Act brought into being, put into place or sponsored by the Department of the Environment and Local Government. They are in the referendum business, so to speak. It has happened in individual cases, for a variety of reasons, the sponsoring body in the case of the Amsterdam Treaty was the Department of Foreign Affairs. The sponsoring body of the Northern Ireland Agreement was the Department of the Taoiseach. The body with executive responsibility for providing the personnel was the Ombudsman's Office. Ultimately the accounting officer issue must be resolved, it seems to me, and it might be done best by ensuring the body which first brought in the Act, namely, the Department of the Environment and Local Government and its Minister would have responsibility there. There is a franchise section in that Department that is in the business of enabling elections and so forth to be carried out. It is certainly clear for a variety of reasons, some coming out here and some coming out of Deputy Doherty's cogent points, that the fact that a referendum commission is set up and then dissolved means that the permanent problem remains - of continuity plus the problem of who is to be the accounting officer.
That needs to be clarified in legislation, it seems to me, by amendment or otherwise. It is not for me to say how that is done as I am not in the business of legislation, but it is clear this problem may arise again. Deputy O'Keeffe's quite valid concerns about a lack of proper procedures being followed may yet arise again. The manual being talked about will make sure commission officials will be able to do their job properly.
Comment on this
Further to Mr. Mac Kernan's contribution, while I understand where he is coming from, the responsibility still rests with people where there are regulations and procedures to be followed. As I see it, the respective Departments had responsibilities and those responsibilities, as far as I can see, were not being taken on board and regulations were not adhered to. I spoke of the irony of refusing to accept a particular contract, which begs the question as to who was able to be responsible for the decision that that tender was unsuitable while ignoring all the other regulations that have been in place over the years?
Comment on this
As I said, I am in an unusual situation here in that I am reporting on accountability that in some ways would relate to me, though as an ex officio member of the Public Offices Commission I would not be involved in the administration. I can throw some light on the point raised by Deputy O’Keeffe.
Because there were no staff available to the referendum commission and because of the need to discharge their functions under the Referendum Act, the tenders were sought from seven companies - I know this - and three responded and came in to be interviewed. Because there were no staff, both the Ombudsman and myself, with the secretary to the referendum commission, who was the one member of the Ombudsman's staff at that stage assigned to the commission, interviewed and were given a presentation by each of the three groups of communications consultants. As a result of that, we decided on a particular firm, Drury Communications, which is recorded in the referendum commission report. The fact that that was not recorded or the formal evaluation that was carried out of those bids was not recorded and there was no evidence of why a particular tender was not accepted is of course a serious oversight, but I understand the circumstances in which that happened. The one member of staff who was available to the commission was being pulled in all directions at the time and clearly things like this were overlooked. That is not to excuse them. They should not happen and I am not trying to excuse them. I can reassure the committee that the evaluation of the bids was carried out in a serious way. Neither the Ombudsman nor myself should have been put in a position where we would have to discharge a quasi-administrative function in relation to this whole business and I suppose the only real answer is to say this is the first time it happened, people were not geared up and there are several reasons that was so. The important thing is to learn from the process.
If I could make a suggestion in relation to the point made by Deputy Doherty, we are not, hopefully, going to have a referendum a year, but if there is a need for a referendum commission it could be set up as a separate Vote. The accounting officer for that Vote could be the Accounting Officer for the Office of the Ombudsman. There you have a direct responsibility on the people who discharge the expenditure; there is direct accountability rather than having it at one remove with the Departments of Foreign Affairs or of the Taoiseach. There are plenty of precedents for this. It is like having a Vote for flood relief which is dealt with by the Office of Public Works, where the Accounting Officer for the Vote is the same Accounting Officer for the Office of Public Works. That seems to be a straightforward way of proceeding in future. That did not happen on this occasion and there were these ensuing problems.
I also recommend to members of the committee, and particularly Deputies Lenihan and Durkan, to read a copy of the Referendum Commission's report where some of the issues they raised in relation to putting negative and spurious arguments are addressed by the commission but I better not try to wear too many hats.
Comment on this
One question was omitted. I refer to Vote 17 - Office of the Ombudsman. Why have the consultancy contracts awarded by Mr. Whelan's office not been published together with the Vote?
Comment on this
There is an answer to that. We are discontinuing that practice. We tried for a year and we found it was not necessary to continue it. We did not ask for it in this case.
Comment on this
Yes, we ask for details of the consultancy. If Mr. Whelan does not have them now, he can let us have them by note as soon as he can.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy mean contracts awarded by the Referendum Commission?
Comment on this
I refer to the Office of the Ombudsman, the Public Offices Commission and the Information Commissioner. The cost totals approximately £90,000, including administration in the Ombudsman's Office. The Public Offices Commission has dispersed £25,000. Does consultancy fee come under general administration consultancy for the Referendum Commission?
Comment on this
No. This is the point we made earlier that the moneys expended by the Referendum Commission do not appear under the Vote for the Office of the Ombudsman. Ultimately, they were a charge on the Vote for the Department of Foreign Affairs or the Department of the Taoiseach, as the case may be.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Accounting Officer of the Department of Foreign Affairs will outline the cost of external consultancy in regard to the Referendum Commission.
Comment on this
It is in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report, precise answers to that.
Comment on this
Can Mr. Whelan make any recommendation based on Deputy Durkan's proposal, which I support, regarding the discontinuation of commissions entirely? Referendums should not be promoted by any side. A referendum involves an amendment to the Constitution, which is a matter for the people. A campaign which involves the distribution of literature to households only adds to the litter problem and does not solve it. The electorate should be given more credit for making up its mind on a referendum. The electorate is the most sophisticated group one could meet in any scenario and it should be given more credit.
I am also concerned that consultants organise subcontracts with expenditure of £3.6 million, apart from printing, which gives a total of £4.3 million. The tender process was not arranged by the consultants. Did the consultants issue subcontracts to whomever they liked? I am concerned that the Office of the Ombudsman was involved in this. We depend on that Office to be the watchdog for the public yet it stood idly by when all this was happening. How did that happen?
Comment on this
On the Deputy's first point, I do not feel I can deal with that here today. That is a matter the Referendum Commission addressed to some extent in its report.
Comment on this
In relation to the Deputy's second point about the Referendum Commission's consultants and the subcontracts, the PR consultants to whom the commission awarded the contract acted as a consortium for a number of other contractors as well. I accept that was not desirable in the circumstances but again I have to draw the Deputy's attention to the very short timescale under which the commission was operating. It would have been impossible for the commission within the timescale it had to subtender for these additional contracts. That was done in one particular case, namely, in relation to the printing contracts.
If time had been available it would have been done in relation to the other contracts as well but there was also - I am not making excuses on this - a certain efficiency available to the commission to the extent that dealing with one consultant meant that all these other issues could be put in place and taken care of by those consultants without the need for the commission itself to run around and deal with these other consultants on a separate basis. However, that is something we have taken on board from the auditor's report and if time allows that practice will not be followed again.
Comment on this
I do not accept that regulations can be breached because of pressure of time. It would be better not to do the job than to breach regulations and do a job in the manner in which it is presented to us here. Somebody should have called a halt and said it was impossible for the commission to carry out this function in the time available rather than breaching regulations as evidenced in very line of this paragraph. It would have been better if somebody in management said he was sorry but the Office could not complete its function according to regulations and law.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy McCormack. At different times there will always be pressurised situations where people must work under fixed, short-time constraints. If it is a case of ignoring all regulations at such a time it sets a bad precedent. I have a question for the Comptroller and Auditor General. During the interview process three companies tendered for this. I find it hard to understand if the vetting procedure was so detailed - I accept the Comptroller and Auditor General's word that it was - that the tax clearance certificate was not obtained. One could not build a £5,000 extension to a local authority house without obtaining a tax clearance certificate. How could that arise in regard to a contract of this size?
Comment on this
Certainly in the request for tenders the requirement to produce a tax clearance certificate was one of the conditions of the tenders. As I said the failure to obtain that is an administrative matter but the requirement was there in the request for specification.
Comment on this
It does not have to be satisfied at the interview stage. It is a condition on the granting of a contract that a current tax clearance certificate is available. That requirement was not checked when the contract was granted, as I understand it.
Comment on this
I would rather let the Accounting Officer account for that. The one administrative function that I carried out in relation to this whole activity was to evaluate the tenders and hear the presentations by the various PR companies.
Comment on this
On the question of the tax certificate, it was specified in the application to tender that went out. I assure the committee that the consultants who were chosen, Drury's, had a tax certificate. It was simply an administrative oversight in omitting to ask them to furnish that. We are quite satisfied they had it. My basis for saying that is that at the time they were involved in a major contract with the Department of the Taoiseach, for which they would have had a tax certificate.
Comment on this
The auditor's report quite rightly pointed out that the tax certificate had not been furnished, but we are quite satisfied that it was there.
Comment on this
You say they were working as consultants for the Department of the Taoiseach. Are you sure they had presented it in that particular case or was there an assumption made there also that perhaps someone else had got it previously?
Comment on this
No, we are happy that they supplied it in that case.
Comment on this
I am just reading the figures and I want to get it clear in my mind. In relation to the Amsterdam Treaty, is it correct that in excess of £2 million was channelled through Drury Communications for the purposes of the referendum? Was the figure of £2,052,394 paid to a PR company for a period of 12 or 14 weeks' work?
Comment on this
Why is the media cost so high? Was everything from mainstream media to press handling, advertising, posters and leaflets done through the PR agency?
Comment on this
Does the fee of £199,000 for media consultants management apply to the fee they charged? Are we to assume this is all Drury Media Consultants made in terms of pure fee income out of the total of £2 million channelled through their accounts? Would their fee income in profit terms have made just £199,423?
Comment on this
Is it because of the short-term argument there was a vast difference between the cost of the Good Friday Agreement and the Amsterdam Treaty referenda? Why is the cost less given that the issue is far more important and there was arguably less warning? You have advanced the argument that there was a lack of warning for your work in relation to the Amsterdam Treaty. However, there appears to have been less warning about the Northern Ireland Agreement which happened on Good Friday. Given that no one anticipated an agreement would be brokered, there was a more punishing deadline to achieve that particular result by way of referenda, North and South. Why are the costs for the Good Friday Agreement lower than for the Amsterdam Treaty given your argument about the difficulties posed by the timespan and lack of readiness of the commission? Why were the costs for the Good Friday Agreement referendum, which was much more important, cheaper? I do not understand the time argument in that context because you had less time to prepare for the referendum on Northern Ireland than for the referendum on the Amsterdam Treaty which was signalled at European Union level well in advance.
Comment on this
The infrastructure was in place at that stage and we had the consultants on board. The timescale was shorter, therefore, there was not the time to undertake the same type of publicity campaign as was possible in relation to the Amsterdam Treaty. There was more publicity carried out at different intervals in relation to the Amsterdam Treaty than was possible in the case of the Good Friday Agreement referendum.
Comment on this
Your argument for the high cost of the Amsterdam Treaty referendum is that you did not have time to prepare. You are now saying you had even less time to prepare for the Good Friday Agreement referendum. Are you saying there is a kind of an efficiency gain in the work of your office and consultants between the two referenda?
Comment on this
No, I am not saying time was a factor in pushing up the cost. The auditors picked up that the procedures were not properly followed because there was not sufficient time to go through the normal channels on tendering and contracting generally.
Comment on this
What is the time difference between the two referenda? What years are we talking about?
Comment on this
Both referenda were held on the same day and both were running together as joint campaigns, so to speak. The order for the Amsterdam Treaty referendum was signed by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government, Deputy Dempsey, on 2 March 1998, and for the Good Friday Agreement on 22 April 1998. This latter date was one month before polling date.
Comment on this
Part of the expenses incurred in relation to the Amsterdam Treaty included designing a lot of leaflets. Three different leaflets at different times during the campaign were sent through An Post to each household. That simply was not possible in the case of the Good Friday Agreement campaign where there was just one postal delivery. There is a breakdown in the referendum commission's report of each of these. I am sure the Office of the Ombudsman can make that available. The detail of the expenditure is set out in that report. For instance, on Amsterdam printing and design of publications amounted to over £400,000, whereas in the case of the Good Friday Agreement the same category of expenditure was merely £229,000. Radio and television broadcasts in the case of the Amsterdam Treaty amounted to almost £200,000, whereas it amounted to £158,000 in the case of the Good Friday Agreement. Ultimately the cost for the Amsterdam Treaty campaign was £2.2 million and £2.13 million for the Good Friday Agreement. There was a different emphasis on the different categories of expenditure. There were heavier advertising costs in the case of the Good Friday Agreement to compensate for not having had the time to send out leaflets to every home.
Comment on this
What was the percentage turnout for the Amsterdam Treaty referendum? I want to determine if we got value for money because people were more confused after they received all the literature than they were before that.
Comment on this
The participation rate was lower than for the Good Friday Agreement referendum.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy talking about the turnout or the vote?
Comment on this
My argument is that the confusing outpourings from the commission were one of the reasons for the low turnout.
Comment on this
One cannot make that connection. We will try to obtain that information for the Deputy. There is obviously a lacuna which needs to be addressed.
Comment on this
I understand the Oireachtas All-Party Committee on the Constitution is looking at the conduct of referenda, including the McKenna and Coughlan judgments. Clearly this is the right vehicle and they may be producing a report.
Comment on this
As this is a constitutional matter, it is appropriate that the Department of the Taoiseach take the lead. It should also clearly involve the Office of the Ombudsman, the Department of Finance and the Department of the Environment and Local Government. A working group should be established to address the questions that have arisen today - the desirability of having a separate Vote established so that all moneys spent on future referenda will be accounted for by the Accounting Officer of the Ombudsman's office rather than accounting officers having to provide the money and not having control over its expenditure; contingency provisions should be made to deal with urgent situations in the future and whether it is necessary for the commission to spend money in a referendum such as the recognition of local government where there is no significant opposition and only invented arguments. Can provision be made whereby a judgment can be made that it is not necessary to make arguments because there is no opposition? They do not need to spend money in this area. Obviously they have to have regard to the Supreme Court ruling but there may be flexibility within the perimeters of that ruling so that expenditure on unnecessary extraneous arguments can be avoided.
Comment on this
There is likely to be a referendum early next year on the international criminal court. It is important that we take that into account when undertaking the work you, Chairman, have stipulated should take place.
Comment on this
We always put a timescale in place. I suggest the report should be with this committee by 15 November.
Comment on this
There is also the question of preparing estimates depending on which Government Department, local government or Ombudsman's office is the lucky recipient of the task.
Comment on this
As we are coming up to the holiday period we will extend the normal three month period to four months within which the report on those issues - the Comptroller and Auditor General should also be consulted - and any other issues which the group and Comptroller and Auditor General consider need to be addressed including any changes in the law that may be necessary.
Comment on this
What scope do we have, notwithstanding the Supreme Court ruling, to make a recommendation that we should reconsider referendum commissions?
Comment on this
The Deputy is going outside the scope of the committee. We have to be sure that public moneys are not being unnecessarily spent and, where they are spent, that they are being spent with due regard to value for money, efficiency and effectiveness. That is the duty of this committee. We cannot get involved in policy issues.
Comment on this
We would not have that problem if we did not spend the money; we would not have to decide whether it should be spent. The money should not be spent in the first instance.
Comment on this
A decision has been made by Government and the commission, as appropriate, as to whether expenditure is warranted. Looking at the subheads of expenditure in the two referenda I wonder why we spent £1 million on television and radio programmes and £2 million in advertising. We must question whether we are getting value for money. We must address that issue. Perhaps we should have a retrospective look at those referenda to see if the expenditure was warranted and to see if we can learn anything about getting better value for money.
Comment on this
It is entirely open to this committee to make suggestions to the committee looking at the Constitution. We should put forward the suggestion that there be no requirement for a referendum in non-contentious issues and that it be weighted by majority voting in the Dáil or the combined Houses of the Oireachtas. That would represent a significant saving to the public. We are talking about genuinely non-confrontational referenda involving two changes to the Constitution, one of which could be an act of Parliament by a majority vote——
Comment on this
The committee has no role in deciding whether a referendum should be held. That is a decision that has to be taken elsewhere. We have to ensure that when a referendum is held the money spent is used in an efficient and effective way and in accordance with due procedure. That is our job.
Comment on this
The spending of money and the purpose for which it was spent is a matter which comes within the ambit of this committee. I propose - I hope the Chairman will agree - that we make contact with the Committee on the Constitution with a view to ascertaining the optimum method of dealing with these situations having regard to the fact that it is the putting of the counterpoint that has brought this about. That is what it is all about, putting the opposite view. I reiterate what has been said. One of the complaints made by the general public was that they could not understand the information. There was a greater volume of voting in the Northern Ireland referendum which was held simultaneously. The reason for that was that people complained they could not understand what the referendum was about.
I find it difficult to understand what one can do to explain the situation. It is obviously complex. One can explain it forever and spend all the money one wishes trying to explain complex issues and people will still not understand. That is not the fault of the commission or the people. We simply put the points of views and let the people make up their minds.
Comment on this
We are looking at that too. I suggest we make contact with the Committee on the Constitution.
Comment on this
Perhaps we could invite the Chairman of that committee to come and talk to us in the autumn.
Comment on this
We will invite Deputy Brian Lenihan to come and talk to the committee about the costs involved.
Comment on this
We will ask Mr. Mac Kernan to take responsibility for reporting back to us by 15 November. If you require any further clarification you may contact me.
Comment on this
I think the official was preparing the figures on the percentage of voting in the Amsterdam referendum.
Comment on this
No, that is not the figure I am looking for. I am looking at the number of people who voted in the Amsterdam referendum compared to the number of voted on the Good Friday Agreement. The figure is different because many people did not vote in the Amsterdam referendum.
Comment on this
They did not cast their votes at all. We were able to research it in the newspapers ourselves.
Comment on this
We are not, Chairman. I resent that remark. We are not getting flippant. If we spend £4.3 million promoting referendum I am quite entitled to know what success that expenditure had in making people clear about how they wanted to vote. I do not think it had the success desired because a large number of people did not vote in the Amsterdam referendum. Despite all the publicity and literature they received they were more confused. I have heard that from voters in my own house.
Comment on this
It is not a point for this committee. We have made a decision in that respect. We will note paragraph 5 and Vote 38, Department of Foreign Affairs.
Before we proceed I should like to state that I received an e-mail yesterday from your Department telling us that there are 2,768,653 Irish passport holders, worldwide, of whom only 2,023,926 live in the State. That means there are 745,000 living outside the State. Does Northern Ireland represent a very big part of that?
Comment on this
I would say Britain and the United States and various places like that. It would include Northern Ireland, I am sure.
Comment on this
It is a very big number, 740,000. I suspect it is bigger than any other European Union state. Is it bigger?
Comment on this
I could not answer that. Many people in Europe do not need passports to travel so it might not necessarily be the same.
Comment on this
What emerges from this is that a very large number of Irish people hold passports, by comparison with citizens of other countries. For example, probably fewer than 10% of Americans have passports. It is a big country and they do not travel outside it. The number is very high for Ireland and many people who are entitled to Irish nationality, whether they are living in England or in Northern Ireland, want to have Irish passports although they are entitled to both. People in the United States who have Irish nationality have for some time been permitted by American law to travel on Irish passports when travelling abroad, but not for returning to the United States. Many of them hold Irish passports. It is a matter of sentimental attachment.
Comment on this
The Office of the Ombudsman includes the Public Offices Commission and the Office of the Information Commissioner. Mr. Whelan, did you want to make some opening remarks?
Comment on this
No, Chairman, I have nothing to say at this stage.
Comment on this
A report is published every year. We have become familiar with the number of reports published by various commissions and bodies which are now a way of life. From where does the greatest number of questions come to the Ombudsman's office?
Comment on this
Until recently our major client was the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs but that is no longer the case. The number of complaints against that Department is declining, for all sorts of obvious reasons.
The local authorities are now our single biggest client. We group all local authorities together. We get more complaints about local authorities than any other area.
Comment on this
About half the people who come to us are better off as a result of coming to us, which means we either fully or partially resolve their difficulties.
Comment on this
What about Government Departments? I recall the Departments of Agriculture, Food and Rural Development and the Environment and Local Government featuring heavily in queries?
Comment on this
The number of complaints against the Department of Agriculture, Food and Rural Development has increased in recent years. The number of complaints against the Department of the Environment and Local Government is quite small. We do not have more than 20 or so every year.
Comment on this
In the main they are from private citizens but complaints are also referred to us by public representatives.
Comment on this
I have, on occasion, referred to the Ombudsman's office and I cannot recall any query being resolved to my satisfaction. That does not mean my point of view was correct, nor does it mean the Ombudsman's view was correct. Is there a bias towards or against the categories of people who make referrals?
Comment on this
Absolutely not. The Ombudsman's function is to see if any maladministration is involved. It is not his role to get things for people. He is there to ensure that public bodies have acted correctly and to see if there is substance in the complaint made by an individual.