NRA - Annual Financial Statements (resumed) and Annual Report.
Contributions 179–375 of 375. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Because we were not aware of it at the time. Again I can only guess - perhaps the county manager can help - but my suspicion is that at the time the contract was advertised the necessary funds were not available for the sanitary area.
Comment on this
If, in building a house, I have a surface water problem, surely the surface water provision would be included in the contract to build.
Comment on this
There is a misunderstanding. They were laying pipes as part of a main water supply scheme.
Comment on this
What did that have to do with the road project? I am entirely open to being persuaded that it is economic, efficient and desirable that it should be done at the same time, but why was it not included in the tender specifications?
Comment on this
I suspect - perhaps the county manager will elucidate on this - that at the time the tender documents for the road project were being put together and advertised they did not have the necessary sanction to progress the water scheme. I can only surmise.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Ó Ceallaigh confirm if that is correct?
Comment on this
The reality is that the road project was envisaged prior to 1998. In the meantime, various considerations were being given to how best to upgrade the water supply for Limerick city and the environs. Many options were considered and by late 1999 it seemed the most favourable option was to bring the supply along the new road that is being built, which is a totally new road in a green situation. Indeed, I recognise the strength of the Department of the Environment and Local Government in helping us to make that decision because it was a unique opportunity to do a job very cheaply. It would have cost a lot more at a later stage to lay it in the new road. It would have been folly of the first order, and I am sure Deputy Rabbitte would accept that point. It was not envisaged, however, at the time the contract was prepared because that knowledge was not available at that point in time.
Comment on this
That is perfectly sensible but, until we get to the bottom of Deputy Lenihan's question about whether favoured status was conferred here, it adds to the confusion surrounding this matter. You get the tender for £33 million and end up with a job for £43 million, even though you should not have got it in the first place. It is confusing.
Can we go back to the tendering process and to Deputy McCormack's questions? Would Mr. Tobin agree that the tendering process seems to be critical to the Committee being able to understand this?
Comment on this
If we look at Mr. Tobin's page - whatever it is, he wrote it in such a hurry last night that he forgot to number them but it is on the second page. It states:
Tenders for major road projects are submitted to the client local authority. There are a variety of procedures in place ...... for opening the tenders ..... for example, a full meeting of the elected council.
Will Mr. Tobin tell me again what the process actually adopted here was?
Comment on this
Again I hope I am not repeating what the manager said. By way of background, each local authority, at its first meeting following a local election, is required to draw up regulations or by-laws on how tenders are to be opened. In this case my understanding is that a member of the council and some staff of the council were present on that occasion. The tenders were opened and obviously the bottom line price for each tender would have been noted.
Comment on this
Yes. Mr. Tobin agrees that it is critical but he said earlier, in reply to a question from Deputy McCormack, that it was opened before the entire elected council.
Comment on this
Of course, and we all make mistakes but the interesting thing is that Mr. Tobin investigated this and formed the judgment that it was human error but he does not actually know how the tenders were opened. Is that not right?
Comment on this
Clearly in this case I misled myself in thinking that in the case of Limerick, this was the procedure when in fact it was not.
Comment on this
On the point in the report that details of the tender prices come into the public domain, Mr. Tobin states that regardless of the procedure used, there is a tendency for details of the tender prices to come into the public domain. Interested parties get the nod from somewhere or other. The grapevine works, is that what Mr. Tobin is saying to the committee?
Comment on this
In general that is the case. In this specific case, again as part of the requirements or regulations in Limerick County Council, each member was notified of the names and amounts of the tenders submitted but leaving that aside - I would not make an issue of that - there is a grapevine system that operates and people become aware.
Comment on this
I can understand that. The second paragraph states that the tender document is then sent for checking. Four or five were singled out and one was dismissed, presumably for reasons of capacity of performance, so Mr. Tobin was dealing with four or five - I cannot recall the number. Why is the checking not done before they are opened and the word goes around that A, B or C company got it?
Comment on this
Please excuse me. I do not wish in any way appear to be giving the Deputy a smart answer but how can we check the tender until we open the envelope, which is the first process of which we spoke? At a meeting which was attended by an elected member and an official, the envelopes were literally opened revealing within a tender document and a bottom line price.
Comment on this
On the amount of checking, in the context of somebody wishing that this were done on the spot, we are talking about, in each case, an 899 page document with 5,200 calculations in it.
Comment on this
In practical terms, to contemplate that exercise being done, while everybody is locked in before anybody moves, would be unrealistic.
Comment on this
I agree with what Deputy McCormack said. In my own local authority it is done differently as well. I just want to understand this. Is Mr. Tobin saying that all that actually happens at this stage of the process is that the envelopes are opened, the bottom line is looked at and it is assumed by someone around the table who sees the bottom line that the bottom line is successful?
Comment on this
No, I do not necessarily think so, Deputy. To take this a step forward, the Deputy has accepted that, be it the grapevine or whatever, people would be aware, first, of their own bid. They then get knowledge of the other bids and realise that on the basis of the bids made they are now - if you are SIAC at that point - in second place. Word then emanates that a tenderer is no longer in the running because of this issue of previous experience or whatever. They now know that the bid, as submitted by them, is the lowest in the race on the basis of an uncorrected amount. This is how one finds that——
Comment on this
There are quite a number of projects in Mr. Tobin's recent reports that we are considering. Does this problem of the bottom line being inaccurately calculated happen from time to time?
Comment on this
And in this case the officials of the local authority, or Mungret, take it upon themselves when they are doing the checking process to point out that on page 69 it is calculated improperly?
Comment on this
No. They point out to nobody. They are required to undertake this exercise without any reference to the tenderers. They simply go through them line by line, page by page. Has the tenderer multiplied the thousand units by the £1.50 price per unit they put in and have they got the right answer?
Comment on this
That would form part of the eventual report that goes through the various lines of command, finds its way eventually to the manager to sign off a formal order accepting the tender and in turn requesting approval from the NRA.
Comment on this
I presume it would come to him through the county engineer.
Comment on this
The report would go to the project engineer, to the county engineer and to me.
Comment on this
That happened in this case. Could I help the members in relation to the earlier question that Deputy Rabbitte raised? Since 1985, Limerick County Council has a very open policy regarding tenders and the regulations, which have been sanctioned by the Minister for the Environment, state that they have to be opened in the presence of the secretary and a member of the council for very obvious reasons - so that there is no element of collusion. Subsequent to that being done and all the information being opened, and bearing in mind that there were 899 pages in eight bills of quantity so one can imagine the mass of paper that had to be carefully opened, they were initialled by the secretary and by the member of the council who was present, chairman of the——
Comment on this
Tenders are often urgent in the context of getting major works done; anybody would appreciate that. Their practice is, and has been, that they would be opened in that way. In another local authority I worked for they were opened in the presence of all the urban councillors on a given night. It varies, and the reality——
Comment on this
I can get back to you on that point, Chairman, but I cannot recall off-hand. I was not present. It is a point of information that would be available on checking. There is no question about that.
Comment on this
I would not be at it. I would not be obliged to be there.
Comment on this
The county secretary would be the senior person, or his deputy if he was not available, who would be deputy/secretary on the day.
Comment on this
Did the county secretary get a copy of the report when it ultimately came as corrected?
Comment on this
It is not a function of the county secretary. The county secretary's function is to discharge the opening of the tenders in accordance with the tender regulations. They were passed on to the engineering section.
Comment on this
I am just curious in the sense that he was the senior person present when the tenders were opened and——
Comment on this
There is no capacity there for anybody to process or assess that volume of tenders in any moment of time. It would take many days, if not weeks in some cases, of assessment and checking.
Comment on this
Right. If there were questions of capacity to perform in terms of the lowest tender, he probably went away thinking that SIAC was the lowest tender.
Comment on this
I do not know if the county secretary went away thinking anything but I should point out that we are obliged under the tender regulations to notify the councillors, all 28 on the council, that the tenders are in, the name of the tenderer and the amount. They may have made assumptions or other people who got copies of that document.
Comment on this
How soon were the councillors advised that an error had been made and that the result was different?
Comment on this
As I pointed out, there are two errors. The first error was adjusted in the context of the normal processing or assessing in accordance with the instructions for tenders. Subsequently, or a year later when the error——
Comment on this
Let us stay with the first error. We did not know about the second error until court action had been initiated. Mr. Ó Ceallaigh will have to learn to be patient with those of us who do not know as much as him. We have a long way to go on this yet, so relax. Let us return to the first error. When were the elected members told about the first error?
Comment on this
To answer your question honestly, it would not be practice or necessary for the councillors to be informed because it is a confidential process. The technical officials are assessing tenders and they are precluded from conveying that confidential information to anybody. As Mr. Tobin said, they make the appropriate adjustments to the tenders where corrections are needed in accordance with the rules.
Comment on this
However, you had already informed the councillors in writing that you had received X tenders and the amount was on the other side of the page. Is that not right?
Comment on this
When it turned out that those figures were calculated wrongly, at least in one case known to you then, were they advised of that?
Comment on this
It is not as simple as that; it never is. There were five tenders, five bills of quantities looked at. There were many corrections made. As I said to the committee, Limerick County Council did not see the mistake made in this case by the tender. We spotted a lot of others, some worth only perhaps a shilling or 5p in current money.
Comment on this
I presume that normally this would not make any difference. Why it makes a difference here is that they were within an ass's roar of each other. Presumably, the councillors went away thinking that the Adare section would be built and that SIAC appeared to be getting the job. When did you disabuse the councillors of that and tell them that they had got it wrong?
Comment on this
There is a caveat in the letter which goes to the councillors. It says that the figures are uncorrected and will be subject to change and corrections on assessment of the tender.
Comment on this
They got an update when the tender was signed by the manager accepting the contract.
Comment on this
You managed to find the error in Mulcair's tender documents but the error in the SIAC documents did not come to light until court action was initiated.
Comment on this
I think you are wrong. Perhaps the best way to express what happened would be to say that errors were found both in the SIAC tender and in the Mulcair tender. In the case of the Mulcair tender, one error in the tender was not discovered. Others were but one was not.
Comment on this
No, it was approximately £40,000. Let me check my figures.
Comment on this
SIAC was initially £26,000 below Mulcair but the £40,000 error brought Mulcair below SIAC.
Comment on this
I did not know there was an error in the SIAC documents uncovered at this time. Was there?
Comment on this
There were some corrections made to the tender submitted by SIAC before we reached bottom line status, yes.
Comment on this
We are talking here in figures as corrected, if you like.
Comment on this
So when everything was reconciled - your document could be read as saying that these were the only two errors - the figure changed and Mulcair was bottom.
Comment on this
That is correct. We are dealing now with where all the corrections had been made in the SIAC document. We are talking about one significant error that was discovered in the Mulcair document which had the effect of taking their bid from being somewhat higher than the SIAC bid to being below the SIAC bid.
Comment on this
The corrected amount of the SIAC document was £33,161,503.26 and the uncorrected amount was £33,160,710.84. It was very little, a few hundred pounds in the overall amount, without knowing if there were some ups and downs. The overall impact was about £800.
Comment on this
It was. The final corrected version was £33,161,503.
Comment on this
After you were threatened with legal action you found an error in the Mulcair tender. How big was the error?
Comment on this
Yes, quite unrelated but, by coincidence, not unduly different an amount.
Comment on this
Can I add that a similar error was made in the correction of the tender that subsequently was dismissed in terms of not having adequate previous experience.
Comment on this
Whatever about the original error being made, is it not a little unusual that after going through the checking process and it being the subject of contention in the ether and so forth, it was not until legal action was initiated that you discovered the Mulcair error?
Comment on this
You could say that. One point that must be made, however, is that once the contract had been signed - the date was 21 September - the line had been drawn, in effect. There was no way back. There was an issue where we had a tenderer who should have got the work but did not. At that point we were exposed or the public purse was exposed.
Comment on this
Who made the ultimate call, Mr. Ó Ceallaigh? Who said, "That is it; it is Mulcair's job. Bring me the fountain pen"?
Comment on this
This point was alluded to by Mr. Tobin earlier. I also pointed out that as manager for a local authority, I have the statutory responsibility for dealing with any issue that is actionable in any way, whether because of discipline or otherwise, so I must be very careful. I am not trying to avoid the question but in this process there are a number of people involved in checking and reporting ultimately to the county manager. There is a partnership between ourselves and the NRA. As the NRA has said they did not and probably do not have the capacity to get involved in checking every contract in the country in mathematical terms. There were a number of people involved in the checking and our technical people——
Comment on this
I understand that. The checkers had done their work for good or ill, accurately or otherwise, at this stage. It had left the realm of mere checkers. I am trying to find out who said, "That looks okay to me, we will sign on the dotted line".
Comment on this
In the interest of accuracy, I would like to correct a point which I am sure was not meant to be wrong. The people who were checking were not mere checkers. They were either engineers or civil engineering technicians with a competency in assessing the rates in the process and in working out the figures we have talked about. They would report in a normal instance to a senior executive engineer who would report to and tell the project engineer that the process of checking was done.
As I said, there was a mistake; there was human error. There is no question about that. That process would be taken in good faith by the county engineer of the day and handed to me and I would accept the process. I will stand over that process. There is no way that a county manager or county engineer could indulge or be able to do all the checks. There is a process for it. I am sure the Deputy appreciates that.
Comment on this
Of course. We would not have county managers doing that. The people who compiled the report sent it up the line.
Comment on this
They did not call the shots after that. Mr. Ó Ceallaigh was back from holidays at this stage and the county secretary had washed his hands off it. The county engineer was, perhaps, in Brittany. Where did it go when it went up the line? Who made the decision?
Comment on this
The decision was made on the basis of correcting the mistakes. We thought we had found all the errors made by the contractors, leading to Mulcair being the most economically advantageous tender. As the meeting has already learned, there was a lower tender. I do not want to go into the fact why that person was not considered. Mr. Tobin has answered that and it is a sensitive issue for any tenderer at that point in time in their development. The process evaluates itself against the rules which are there and are required to be public. We followed those rules and they were the lowest. Having regard to the tenderer being competent, available for the job and his background, all things being equal, he was the lowest in price by a mistake.
Comment on this
We want to finish at a reasonable time tonight. I am not interested in the person who was discounted or in the basis on which the decision was made; one presumes the best. I am trying to find out who made the decision. Did the county engineer go to Mr. Ó Ceallaigh and say, "The Adare job is finished"? Did Mr. Ó Ceallaigh call the shots or did a senior executive engineer decide it? Who made the decision?
Comment on this
In the interest of safeguarding public money, there are a number of checks and balances in the system.
Comment on this
Ultimately they worked because we admitted the mistake when we found it. I want to bear that in mind.
Comment on this
Some questions have been raised here to which I must return on behalf of the staff of Limerick County Council and the council at a later date.
Comment on this
I reassure you we will return to this issue as well.
Comment on this
Approximately £3 million of taxpayers' money is involved and has been given away. I do not want any rows.
Comment on this
On a point of information, I have not received an answer to the questions I addressed to the council. I got answers from Mr. Tobin but I did not get any answers from the county manager to the substantial issues I raised. He is only responding now because Deputy Rabbitte raised them. I would like an answer.
Comment on this
I want to be fair to Mr. Ó Ceallaigh who has come before us for the first time and is trying to answer questions. Perhaps he is not used to being interrupted in the middle of trying to give answers. We will take one question at a time.
Comment on this
Deputy Rabbitte is in possession and he is getting some answers. Deputy Conor Lenihan can come back in later.
Comment on this
We will try to get them later but not in the middle of Deputy Rabbitte's questioning.
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt but perhaps you, Chairman, could indicate how long this meeting will last. We have already been here for four hours.
Comment on this
It should be obvious that the final speaker is in possession. I may speak for two or three minutes and then we will decide what to do. Deputy Rabbitte is in possession and he should be allowed to finish. We may not be satisfied with the answers but Mr. Ó Ceallaigh must be allowed to answer uninterrupted.
Comment on this
Thank you, Chairman. The questions are not unreasonable and I do not have a problem with them. There is a process by which checking is done and an assessment and evaluation is carried out of tenders, irrespective of whether it is this tender or another one. The final process is that the county engineer, as the council's chief technical officer, makes a recommendation to the county manager, who will have knowledge of the process and will be aware that an evaluation is going on, and he will accept or reject the county engineer's recommendation. The process is open. There are people at various levels checking that process and signing off on it. I cannot fly in the face of the reality of the tender in this case being the lowest economic tender. However, it is on a report from the county engineer. When I accept that, I forward it to the NRA or other Departments for their approval or sanction as required. That is the process.
Comment on this
I am not asking Mr. Ó Ceallaigh to fly in the face of anything. I am only trying to find out who made the decision. Mr. Ó Ceallaigh is telling me the county engineer recommended to him that he should go for the lowest tender as he in good faith thought it was. Is that the position for the record?
Comment on this
It may be of help to repeat a couple of sentences from the remarks I made at the early part of this debate. Based on the outcome of the checking process, the Mungret office prepared a tender assessment report, signed by senior office personnel and senior officials in Limerick County Council, as the project would be constructed in County Limerick, recommending the award of the contract to Mulcair. The report constituted the basis for the Limerick county manager's decision to award the contract to Mulcair and to seek NRA approval in that regard. I hope that is of some assistance to the process.
Comment on this
The second error was discovered during the process - I have alluded to it already, if I did not say it directly - of preparing the council's defence against the claim made by SIAC in the initial tender assessment. The bills of quantities and the rates were inserted at that stage on a spreadsheet for the purpose of putting them in electronic form and checking them. The error showed up during that process many months later.
Comment on this
Can Mr. Ó Ceallaigh help the committee in explaining why that error was not uncovered in the earlier checking?
Comment on this
I will help the committee as always to the best of my ability. The mistake was made by the contractor. I am not trying to push blame on anyone; I am only stating a fact. The form of rates, approximately 900 pages, was filled in by the contractor. A mistake was made when a total at the end of a page which should have been carried forward, as set out accurately by Mr. Tobin, was not carried forward to the summary page. It was not seen by the contractor, by our staff or by the lowest tenderer who was excluded. As already pointed out by Mr. Tobin, he made a mistake. The form is circulated in some of the documentation. Section 05 - drainage and service ducts - the £42,000 should have been carried forward but someone misread it as a title head as distinct from being a summary of another page. It was as simple and unbelievable as that, but that is what happened. As the county engineer has reminded me, it happened in two tenders and it was not seen by us in the checking process.
Comment on this
The lowest tenderer made the same mistake. It did not enter into his equation as there were other issues which had be to dealt with.
Comment on this
When the council was confronted with SIAC threatening legal action, it went through all the documents with a fine comb in order to be able to defend its position.
Comment on this
Yes, and as Mr. Tobin's report stated, I was informed of that problem. I vividly remember the day, it was 25 January, and I informed the NRA some two weeks later. As it happened, I was leaving on a personal holiday that week and I asked for the legal people to advise me of the issues before I contacted the NRA to know if I really did have a problem. I accept that I did have a problem.
Comment on this
Has the contractor in question done other work for Limerick County Council or Limerick Corporation?
Comment on this
I have no clue about Limerick Corporation. I presume he has. I have been there four years and I would not remember all the contractors before that.
Comment on this
He did one other contract, the Douradoyle link road which, essentially, was part of the overall framework. We had to advance that process because of the Dell contract - there was a major extension at Dell coming on-stream. I will say this much about Limerick County Council, we delivered that before time for Dell. It is no harm to say that on the record on a day like today.
Comment on this
No, it was an element brought forward from the contract.
Comment on this
Is it correct that the officers employed at Mungret are, in the main, professional technical people seconded from the local authority?
Comment on this
In the region, yes. There is a shared responsibility having regard to doing work on various——
Comment on this
He reports to me, technically. I am not an engineer, as the Chairman will appreciate, so he reports to the county engineer. Ultimately, through the process of the managerial system, he reports to the county manager of the day.
Comment on this
It is a very efficient way that has been in place for 11 years in County Limerick. As I already pointed out, Limerick County Council piloted this arrangement when, perhaps, there was not as much money available to do work, only planned work, and it has been quite successful. It has been copied, as I understand it, at 11 or 14 centres throughout the country.
Comment on this
The idea was that a corpus of professional technical people would be brought together. Does a hands-off arrangement exist or do these people work with the local authority? Do they consult senior executive engineers in the local authority?
Comment on this
In practical terms, there are five segments, as it were, each responsible for the work in a particular county. In other words, there are engineers almost dedicated to Limerick County Council, Clare County Council, Limerick Corporation or Tipperary North Riding County Council. They are divided among the responsibilities there. The county engineer of each county maintains a very close and direct relationship with the project engineer and with the senior engineering staff carrying out work in his county. As Mr. Tobin mentioned in his document - I appreciate people have not had an opportunity to read it - there are project teams, including the county manager, involved in each major project to consider the issues, monitor progress and achieve the desired effect which is these public utilities.
Comment on this
So they do not merely monitor and control, they actually do the design work. If the local authority states that works on an eight kilometre stretch of road must be carried out, the design work is farmed out to the design office. Is that correct?
Comment on this
We wish we could. Historically, however, we had to obtain approval from the NRA before any section of the design team commenced work on these projects because there was a financial liability attached to planning work. The principal function has been to design road works but, in recent times - again this is alluded to clearly by Mr. Tobin in his document - more and more road works are being done in major tranches as part of projects costing £200 million plus. Consultants are being utilised to deal with those projects and the council, through the regional design office, will monitor and supervise the outcome of the work of these consultants.
To some extent, the Limerick regional design office at Mungret has been the consultancy for these road jobs up to now. However, its role is changing and evolving to meet the challenge set down by the national plan at present.
Comment on this
Presumably if we were going to seek outside experts to carry out the engineering and building work it would be far more sensible to have a major contract rather than itsy bitsy contracts crossing counties here and there.
Comment on this
Absolutely. To put it in context, if this mistake was made by a consultant checking tenders, which would be his function, he would have the problem that you and I have today.
Comment on this
I was not clear about the answer to Deputy Lenihan's query - this is probably proper to Mr. Tobin - that it is normal for in-house staff to make corrections to the tender documents of private builders who submitted them in the first instance. Do the staff make such corrections without informing a tenderer that they made a real cock-up and that a massive error has been corrected?
Comment on this
What would happen is that arithmetical errors are corrected without reference to the tenderer. At that point, if a tenderer is perceived to be in contention, they are advised of what has happened to their tender and their bottom line price, etc., and they are asked if they wish to allow their tender to be further considered for the work.
Comment on this
When Mr. Tobin refers to a mistake, do I understand he is referring to an arithmetical mistake and that an estimation of cubic feet might be changed from seven to six?
Comment on this
No. Purely arithmetical errors are changed, nothing else. We check if that contractor or tenderer multiplied his £5 by the 1,000 units and wrote down £5,000 in the right spot and whether he did that in respect of all 5,200 calculations and carried forward the sub-totals from each page. That is the only check, nothing else is changed.
Comment on this
Does the investigation Mr. Ó Ceallaigh is carrying out refer to the staff at Mungret or to these people and the staff of his local authority?
Comment on this
The staff at Mungret are employed by Limerick County Council in so far as they are employed on Limerick County Council jobs. There are other people there who are staff of other local authorities, working together collectively as a team, to deliver these projects. The NRA raised the issue of disciplinary or other action that might be required on my part in regard to this particular mistake. That process relates solely to the officers in Mungret who are employed by Limerick County Council. There were no officers of any other local authority involved in the process. I am the responsible officer in that regard.
Having regard to the legal advice - of which I am aware and in respect of which the House is concerned - I must ensure that no injustice is done to anybody and protect people's rights. That process is ongoing. As already stated, I am optimistic that I will be able, by late October, to make a quasi-judicial but honest decision on the issues of concern here.
Comment on this
Before we make a decision on what further action to take in this area, I wish to put forward a number of observations, one request and a proposal. To use political terminology, I find it amazing, given that a court case of such magnitude was pending, that a full recount was not carried out and that people waited to find the second error until the case was due to come to court. However, I have no wish to return to the old system of local government where every housing scheme was checked three or four times by a local authority.
In light of the fact that it now appears commonplace to find and not find errors, allowing for the billions of extra pounds of expenditure, bearing in mind the changes being brought about by EU regulations and in respect of tendering practice, I will be asking if there is a need for a change in the procedures adopted. Mr. Tobin referred to a number of such changes earlier.
As a result of previous problems highlighted by the committee, changes have taken place, particularly within the Department of the Environment and Local Government. If we accept that there will always be errors in tenders and, in this instance, that human error has cost the Exchequer so much money, it is obvious that change is needed, particularly in view of the fact that a compensation culture has come into existence.
Those are my observations. My request is that I would ask Mr. Tobin and Mr. Farrelly to supply the committee with a list of the changes that have taken place to avoid any repetition of this totally unacceptable situation. Mr. Tobin referred to some of these earlier but I would like to obtain them in writing in order that we can consider them with the C omptroller and Aauditor General to see if they will remove the possibility of a repetition of this problem.
What has been spelled out clearly is that errors happen repeatedly, tenders are leaked and publicised to members and they are freely available. Mistakes happen and it now appears that, in the case of human error, the Exchequer can be liable for massive amounts of money. The EU introduced regulations of which some were aware and others were not. Perhaps we could have that list within two to three weeks when we will consider and work on this.
As I said at the outset following Mr. Tobin's contribution, given the serious nature of the matters raised separate to the four annual reports, it is obvious the committee cannot conclude its business. We will adjourn the issue and consider any further action we need to take within our terms of reference at the private session of our next meeting if that is acceptable to members. Is that acceptable, Deputy Lenihan?
Comment on this
I would have thought that any request for an answer or documentation made by a member of the committee would be either answered verbally or responded to in writing.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy would repeat the question.
Comment on this
I requested various pieces of information about the number of contracts the Pat Mulcair building contractor, sole trader, company or whatever, has won not just in Limerick but also outside it in the area covered by the famous Mungret based multidenominational group or whatever one wishes to call it. I want information on that specifically.
I would also like a specific reassurance from either Mr. Tobin or Mr. Ó Ceallaigh or both that there is no suggestion of corrupt procedures. The suspicions raised by the SIAC executive suggested there was malfeasance.
I also asked a question, which received no answer, if there were other instances involving Mulcair in previous awards of contracts by Limerick County Council where it was not the lowest but was the successful tender.
Comment on this
We will ask for a written response to those as far as it is possible. At 9.15 p.m. hunger, thirst and fatigue have set in.
Comment on this
I wish to make one point, lest it is not on the record, that Limerick County Council shares the same concern that everyone here does vis-à-vis this mistake. I assure the committee that there is not a scintilla of evidence of corrupt procedures. I do not want to leave that on the record. If I did not answer that question from the Deputy, I apologise for that. On the mid-west, I will get that information. I do not have it, obviously.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Ó Ceallaigh for that. Mr. Tobin dealt extensively with the question of corruption as he saw it. He was asked why he bothered going through that procedure. He certainly outlined it in that case and I accept Mr. Ó Ceallaigh's point about not leaving it on the record. I ask that the information on the contracts requested be supplied. It may emerge that there are one or two other questions which were overlooked, but we will have the transcript and I am sure Mr. Tobin will as well.
Comment on this
I seek clarification. My remit is quite limited in that it deals only with national roads. The Mulcair company works not only on national roads. It may well be involved in contracts on non-national roads. It is certainly involved from time to time on the sanitary services side. I can certainly undertake to seek out the information and have no difficulty in doing so as far as national roads are concerned. Is Deputy clear about what precisely he seeks? Is it national road contracts?
Comment on this
I ask for Mr. Farrelly to say something because he would have contact with all other schemes, infrastructure and spending. Does the Mungret office only deal with roads?
Comment on this
I think Deputy Lenihan is seeking any contract for national roads which came from the Mungret office. Would it be possible, Mr. Farrelly, to obtain a list of other contracts with which this contractor was involved?
Comment on this
Deputy Lenihan mentioned the Mungret office but that only deals with roads.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Chairman can interpret what I say and set himself up as being my interpreter. I will make it clear. I want to know what contracts the company won from Mr. Tobin in his role in the NRA and the county manager who is responsible for the non-national roads in his area, and also the contracts for non-national roads that perhaps have been drawn up by the design team but cover other counties in the region.
Comment on this
Mr. Ó Ceallaigh has offered to supply that information and Mr. Tobin will cover the NRA aspect. Do I have the agreement of the committee on the adjournment of this item? Agreed.
The next meeting of the Committee of Public Accounts will be held on Thursday, 5 October 2000 at 10 a.m. in room G2 in Kildare House. In the public session we will deal with the reports on the value for money examination of local development initiatives and on the value for money examination on the driver testing service which is the responsibility of the Department of the Environment and Local Government.
I thank all the witnesses on behalf of my colleagues and myself. It has been a long session. I trust they will accept that few people could stand over what has happened and say it should not be fully investigated. We must do everything we possibly can to avoid a recurrence. If it takes another five hours the next time, please God we will arrive at a satisfactory conclusion.
The witnesses withdrew.