We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE of PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

2000 Annual Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General and Appropriation Accounts: ›

Vote 10 - Office of Public Works (Resumed).

Contributions 1–225 of 443. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The documentation before the committee - the Campus and Stadium Ireland report and the submission by the Office of Public Works - has only been furnished within the last hour to the members, some of whom have not yet seen it. In view of this, members consider that the sitting should be suspended until 4 p.m. They also request that officials attending the committee be given copies of the documentation. I presume the witnesses have all received a copy of the Attorney General's report.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

We have not, Chairman.

Comment on this

We have some spare copies which we will make available.

Comment on this

What about the papers from the Office of Public Works?

Comment on this

The papers from the Office of Public Works will be furnished to the other witnesses. Obviously, Mr. Murphy has them but the Department of the Taoiseach, the Department of Finance and Mr. Teahon may not.

Comment on this

Chairman, I respectfully suggest that you ask each of the witnesses whether they have the documents with which you propose to deal, so that there is a fair and equitable opportunity for everybody to have what you would wish them to have, that is, fair access to everything that may form the basis of questioning.

Comment on this

Attending are Mr. Teahon of Campus Stadium Ireland and representatives of the Departments of Finance and Tourism, Sport and Recreation and the Office of Public Works. I ask them to ensure that they receive from the clerk a copy of the submission from the Office of Public Works and a copy of the Attorney General's report. If they do not have them, they should ensure they obtain them from the clerk. We will suspend the meeting and resume at 4 p.m. in order to give witnesses a chance to deliberate on the contents of these documents.

Comment on this

In the interests of clarity, we should inquire as to who has the documentation already.

Comment on this

I felt that if witnesses did not have the documentation, they could request it.

Comment on this

My expectation, Chairman, was that they would be asked if they had it.

Comment on this

All right. Mr. Teahon, have you copies of the submission from the Office of Public Works?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I do not have a copy of the Office of Public Works document. I have just received a copy of the Attorney General's report and have not had the opportunity of reading it.

Comment on this

Okay. Margaret Hayes?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

Chairman, I have a copy of both reports.

Comment on this

What about the Department of the Taoiseach?

Comment on this

To follow up - I asked this question the last day - will it be possible for the witnesses to answer questions on the information available to them from those reports?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

You need to be aware of the reports, yes.

Comment on this

I asked that question the last day, Chairman.

Comment on this

What about the representatives of the Department of the Taoiseach?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

We have both documents. I have not had a chance to read the Office of Public Works material.

Comment on this

Mr. Murphy, do you require the Attorney General's report?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes.

Comment on this

That will be furnished to you. What about the Department of Finance?

Comment on this

We have just received a copy of both reports in the last hour but we need to study them.

Comment on this

Is it acceptable to the witnesses for the committee to resume at 4 p.m.? That is agreed. Thank you. The sitting is suspended.

Comment on this

Witnesses should be made aware that they do not enjoy absolute privilege. Members and witnesses' attention is drawn to the fact that, as and from 2 August 1998, section 10 of the Committees of the Houses of the Oireachtas (Compellability, Privileges and Immunities of Witnesses) Act, 1997, grants certain rights to persons identified in the course of the committee's proceedings. Notwithstanding this provision in the legislation, I remind members of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they shall not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the House or an official, either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members are also reminded of the provisions within Standing Order 149 that the committee shall refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policy or policies.

Members should note that the committee is concerned with the accounts specifically listed for examination and the administrative and operational control aspects related to same which are within the knowledge and competence of the witness being examined.

I call Deputy Durkan to resume questions.

Comment on this

First, can I ask as I did on Friday whether any of the witnesses have any objection to any questions being raised in any particular form?

Comment on this

Would the Chairman like to ask the witnesses, in the first instance, if they had time to read all the documentation to their satisfaction?

Comment on this

Chairman, I want to restate my position. When I opened questioning last Friday I asked a question in relation to, for example, the Attorney General's report and whether it was possible for witnesses to answer questions. Mr. Teahon mentioned at the time that that would be unfair to the Secretary General of the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation. From memory, that was the reply. Are there any questions arising from the Attorney General's report or the papers made available from the Office of Public Works about which any of the witnesses are concerned? In other words, are the witnesses happy to answer questions emanating from the discussions which took place on Thursday and Friday of last week and the subsequent reports they have compiled since then?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

In response to that, the papers on the Office of Public Works file are part of the deliberative process connected with seeking tenders for the stadium part of the Campus Stadium Ireland project. That process has not ended. It would be preferable, if there are any questions relating to companies in the tendering process, that the names of the companies would not be referred to.

Comment on this

We are in public session and I would like to have prior warning as to the companies about which witnesses do not wish to have questions raised, if that is possible.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

There are only three companies at most mentioned on the Office of Public Works papers and I would not wish the names of any of the three to be mentioned in connection with questions. It will still be possible to ask questions without naming the companies.

Comment on this

Excellent. I want to ask one other question before we move into the subject matter. Do any of the witnesses likely to be questioned have any concerns about opinions expressed by members of the committee, within or outside of the committee or in the public arena and, if so, on what basis?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

To clarify that, I had a concern during the earlier questioning but fully accept what Deputy Rabbitte said in response to it. I misunderstood what he was talking about when he referred to boxes of documents. Deputy Rabbitte clarified it and I accept that he was referring to a disappointed bidder rather than the successful bidder.

Comment on this

Fair enough. Has any other witness any concerns about the opinions expressed by any member of the committee in the public arena or in the committee?

Comment on this

Chairman, I am not a witness here. I have the role of putting questions but it would be as serious for the members of the committee——

Comment on this

No, no, Chairman.

Comment on this

——to express opinions outside the committee or within it when making inquiries. Opinions are the very matters we should avoid. I am not speaking on behalf of the witnesses before us but I would be surprised if they did not feel there were serious risks potentially to the reputation of any one or all of them in the context of any opinions given.

Comment on this

We will move on to questions.

Comment on this

I thank my colleague for that assistance. I know I can rely upon him at any time.

Comment on this

Do not send for me in three weeks.

Comment on this

Have there been any developments since the last meeting of the committee which any witness wishes to bring to our attention before we commence questions? No.

I will return to the matter we discussed on the last occasion. Mr. Teahon mentioned initially - and again I am quoting from memory - with regard to the appointment of the tendering process and the advice from PricewaterhouseCoopers, that a particular company was a shelf company. That information was made available to him. He conveyed that information according to evidence previously submitted to the board but not to the Government or to the Department of the Taoiseach by whom he was appointed. By what form did he convey the information he had received to the member of the board? Was it advice by way of letter or some other form?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I am not sure we are talking about the same issue but what I said in my statement was that there were three cases in point - the assessment panel, the board and the Department or Government. At the assessment panel I said - and it is reported in the documents before the committee - that there were funding issues, meaning the issue in relation to the Waterworld consortium, which needed to be dealt with. That was the assessment panel. I did not use the word "dormant" on that occasion. In relation to the board, I did not tell the board or the Department. They are the three situations.

Comment on this

You gave the reasons for not telling the assessment panel the information that you had on the last occasion. You felt that it was not relevant, that by virtue of delegated responsibility it was not necessary and that there was not sufficient time to further investigate any outstanding matters. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

That was what I said in relation to the different occasions. I saw myself acting on the basis of delegated authority from the board to implement a process that the board had agreed.

Comment on this

How was the information conveyed to you with regard to the status of the company which was referred to as a dormant company by you and PricewaterhouseCoopers?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

By way of a document produced by PricewaterhouseCoopers.

Comment on this

Have you a copy of the document?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes.

Comment on this

Can you——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Have I got it with me?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No.

Comment on this

I hope that at some stage the Committee might have sight of that document if you have no objection.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No, I have none.

Comment on this

With regard to the document from Pricewaterhouse which advised you regarding the status of the company - again I am careful here - I suggested, perhaps wrongly so, that you had withheld information from the assessment group or from the board. You said the information was not given, which was somewhat different. However, we will not get into debate on that issue. In any event the information which was relayed to you by way of the document from Pricewaterhouse regarding the status of the company was not conveyed to the assessment group which subsequently would have to make a decision. Is that true?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No, the assessment panel did not have the document but the assessment panel was not making a decision in relation to the economic and financial standing of the consortia. In other words, the decision of the assessment panel was a decision on who or which consortium would become the preferred bidder, i.e. the most economically advantageous project.

Comment on this

Who, in your opinion, should have that document or the information contained in that document from Pricewaterhouse since it would appear to be germane to the group?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I recognised when I saw the document that there was a clear issue in relation to the economic and financial standing of the consortium of which Waterworld UK was a member. Therefore, there was an issue which had to be dealt with. In effect I said to the assessment panel that there was a funding issue which had to be dealt with. Then I put in place, working with PricewaterhouseCoopers on the financial side and McCann Fitzgerald, a process whereby a letter issued on 19 December to the consortium which said we were prepared to make them the preferred bidder provided they could answer to our satisfaction a number of items. That letter was issued on 19 December.

Comment on this

Surely those items should have been answered prior to that. Those items would have been of normal concern in respect of a tender for any project, whether it be an outline or a full tender. I presume these guidelines and EU rules apply to the procurement process for State contracts? Is that true?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Exactly. The EC rules were followed at the three stages. Firstly, there was an expression of interest stage where the consortia put forward evidence to us. At that stage the assessment panel adjudged that the consortia that had put forward adequate evidence were the ones that went to the next stage, the outline bid stage. The outline bid stage did not involve questions on the economic and financial standing. Nor did the detailed bid stage involve such questions.

Comment on this

Under EU rules is it not a prerequisite before proceeding in that fashion that the relevant directive be referred to?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes.

Comment on this

What is the directive?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The issue is one of what you are entitled to judge at different stages. Our legal advice was that at the first stage you have to make a judgment and that was done.

Our legal advice was that at the outline bid stage and the detailed bid stage you were not entitled to make a further judgment on the economic and financial standing. That judgment then fell to be made in relation to taking the preferred bidder forward to heads of agreement and eventually to what is called a project agreement or a contract. What we did with Pricewaterhouse was we put in place a process such that we could make the judgment on economic and financial standing in pursuit of signing a contract.

Comment on this

But you could only make that on the basis of continued dialogue with one or all of those who submitted tenders.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

That is correct.

Comment on this

Dialogue was established with all of the people who submitted tenders and kept——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

At the detailed bid stage we informed the consortium that the assessment panel judged it to be the most economically advantageous, that we were to make them the preferred bidder, subject to their satisfying us on the issues we raised with them. We notified the other two bidders that we would ask them to keep their bids open. We did that because it was possible that the dialogue or negotiation with the consortium that would become the preferred bidder would not be satisfactory in which case we would have turned to the next bid.

Comment on this

But surely that would imply assisting a bidder. Why not assist all three bidders together?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No, it did not imply assisting anybody. It implied or it was a fact that the assessment panel judged that, for shorthand, the Waterworld consortium was the one that was clearly the best. Therefore, appropriately that consortium would become the preferred bidder provided they were able to satisfy the questions that arose. That is what happened. That is what took place over a series of months.

Comment on this

I must refer Mr. Teahon to EU Council Directive 93/37/EEC, Chapter 2, Articles 24 to 27, inclusive. I presume this particular directive must have been referred in the context of a tender of this size.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I do not have the directive that you are speaking about, but I take it that was the directive to which our legal advice related.

Comment on this

There is a whole series of qualifications. Article 25 in particular says:

Any contractor wishing to take part in a public works contract may be requested to prove his enrolment in the professional or trade register under the conditions laid down by the laws of the member state in which he is established [which is normal practice].

In the United Kingdom and Ireland, the contractor may be requested to provide a certificate from the Registrar of Companies or the Registrar of Friendly Societies or, if this is not the case, a certificate stating that the person concerned has declared on oath that he is engaged in the profession in question in the country in which he is established, in a specific place and under a given business name.

I presume this section was run past those involved in the assessment process or in any part of the process that involved recommendation or a decision being taken.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I am happy to pursue the issue further if you want me to, but at every stage of the process we took appropriate legal advice. I am not an expert on EU procurement law in terms of the type of detail to which you are referring. If you give me the document I will check with our legal adviser and say I was asked if reference was made to it.

Comment on this

I would be happy to furnish the relevant document and hopefully copies can be made available to you before the end of this discussion.

Can I ask another witness a question?

Comment on this

Can I ask the Secretary General of the Taoiseach's Department the procedure normally followed in regard to a project of considerable volume, scope and importance coming before Cabinet?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

It would be covered by the general guidelines of the Cabinet handbook. In other words, there would be an expectation that the decision sought of Government would be made clear, that the background to that decision would be set out, that the financial implications would be made clear and that the issues which the Government should take into account would be made clear. Those would be the norms within which a proposal coming before Government on such a project, or any other project, would be expected to be formulated. The question of the precise format in which it would come before Government depends clearly on the context and circumstances.

Comment on this

Your Department was the sponsoring one in this situation. Did you prepare any memoir for Cabinet on this subject?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

There was a memorandum prepared, based on material which was received from Campus & Stadium Ireland. It was prepared on 19 December and submitted to the Government meeting of the same date. It was prepared in the context of a meeting of the project steering group for having taken place the previous week at which it was reported that the appraisal process was coming towards a conclusion and would be finalised with a view to coming to the Government meeting of 19 December and that it would not therefore be possible to circulate the final text in advance of the meeting because of the requirement for planning permission to be sought by 22 December.

Comment on this

How big a document was the one which came from Stadium Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

It was effectively of the scale of the actual memorandum submitted to the Government, which is appended to the Attorney General's report before the Committee.

Comment on this

Another five minutes.

Comment on this

I know Chairman. I will do my best. May I just move it forward slightly? Did you put your imprimatur on, or did you have sufficient time to study the documentation which came to the Taoiseach's Department before submitting it to Cabinet?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

The material was read, studied, clarified with CSID, prepared for discussion with the Taoiseach and subsequently for submission to the meeting.

Comment on this

Who read and studied it with CSID?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

My colleague, Mr. Ryan.

Comment on this

He read and studied the document produced by CSID in preparation for Cabinet.

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

That is correct.

Comment on this

Was the question that arose previously about the status of a particular company mentioned in that brief at that stage?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

No, it was not.

Comment on this

Are you quite certain of that?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

Yes.

Comment on this

If it was, would the reference from Pricewaterhouse to the effect that a dormant company was involved have affected the summation you would have sent to Cabinet?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

It is difficult to speculate on a counter-factual issue. I think it would certainly have been regarded as a relevant matter to draw to the attention of Government, had it then been made known to the Department. I should indicate that the material did indicate that the matter of the recommendation from CSID was based on a clear assessment that this was the best of the three proposals considered under all of the relevant headings and that it was the lowest cost in terms of the Exchequer capital requirement. If, in addition, there had been a question raised in relation to further matters to be confirmed before heads of agreement were signed I am sure that would have been drawn to the Government's attention. In the event, the decision which emerged was for heads of agreement to be signed, but on the basis that some further negotiations would take place regarding a capital contribution and the provision of free swimming hours, which was——

Comment on this

If you were now - this is not necessarily a hypothetical question - preparing a brief for Cabinet would you include the information regarding the status of the company?

Comment on this
Mr. McCarthy

I believe that if I had such information I would include it.

Comment on this

Okay. One last question which my colleague, Deputy Rabbitte, raised on Friday. What is the valuation of the Abbotstown complex site? I know what the valuation was but I want confirmation from the relevant authority, be it Office of Public Works or whoever.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The Office of Public Works has not put a valuation on that site. There was a valuation put on it by Pricewaterhouse in its feasibility study.

Comment on this

Was a valuation done at any stage of the site at Abbotstown as it stood?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

When you are doing that kind of valuation it depends what the site is going to be used for. There may be a number of valuations. The fact remains that the Office of Public Works did not do a valuation under any heading.

Comment on this

Was a valuation done by anybody else? The value of the site could vary from its unchanged state, prior to any development, to its potential after development, in the course of development or after initial development. Could there be a vast difference between the valuations?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes, they would be vastly different.

Comment on this

Is it correct that there would be 500 acres of potential development land after the initial development proposal?

Comment on this
Mr Murphy

I am not quite sure that you can take 500 acres and multiply it by the value of intensively developed land. In that kind of area and with that size of site there are going to be tracts of it that will either not be capable of being put to full intensive development or tracts that will be retained as open space in parks and so on. I am not sure that it is quite a simple measure. The measure was not made, that is really the key element.

Comment on this

I realise that I have run out of time. I have a number of other questions which I hope to raise again.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Is Mr. Teahon aware that the Government statement in relation to his position with CSID has been issued and handed to me a few minutes ago?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes, I am.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Are the contents agreed? Do you have a response to that statement?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The Government asked Mr. Dermot McCarthy, Secretary to the Government, to contact me this morning. He put the terms of the statement to me. I responded to him, after thinking about it, that I agreed, in the interests of the project. I have stated that publicly.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

In net terms, you have agreed to this position put to you by Mr. Dermot McCarthy on behalf of the Government?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

You have agreed to step down as chairman and chief executive?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I have agreed to the terms of the statement.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The terms seem to indicate, as far as I read them, that you are no longer the chairman or chief executive of the project.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

That is correct.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Do you have any response to that, in the round, in terms of what you said earlier about not being prepared to resign because you feel you have done nothing wrong?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I remain of the view that I have done nothing wrong. The Government put a proposition to me and I said that I agreed, in the interests of the project. I stated publicly before coming here for the 2 o'clock meeting that when I said "the interests of the project" I believe that the pool for the Special Olympics and the entire sports campus is a development - and I think that it is referred to in the statement - of which Irish people will be proud when completed. It was in that interest that I agreed to the statement. I also said at that time that I have received what were for me a most surprising number of calls and letters of support and I said that I was most grateful to all of the people who gave me support.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

On that point, there have been statements in recent days that this project, namely the aquatic project for the Special Olympics, cannot be delivered on time if you are not part of the management team or if the management team is disrupted. Is it your view now that it can be delivered and if it cannot be delivered what are the consequences, financial or otherwise?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The project, the pool at Abbotstown, will be delivered on time and in budget. I believe that to be the position post the Government statement.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

So you believe it can be delivered on time. Rather than pondering or delaying on the negative, what is the Exchequer liability if this is not delivered on time, if the Special Olympics do not have a pool? What are the consequences? Presumably we have also contracted with them.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I am not aware of the terms of the contract to which Denis O'Brien referred the other day between the Government and the Special Olympics.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Perhaps someone else here can tell us the terms of the contract with the Special Olympics. This is germane, because clearly now the priority for everyone on the official side around this table must be to deliver on the project. If there is a delay, a problem or a financial cost to not delivering on time we ought to know it now as a committee rather than be asking why down the line. Who is from the sponsoring Department, Ms Hayes?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

We would be advising, in a worst case scenario, that the games organising committee look at the availability of perhaps a 25 metre pool. The commitment entered into by the organising committee when it made its bid for the games was that it would provide a 50 metre pool within 30 kilometres of Dublin. If that was not provided, the international committee had indicated that perhaps a 25 metre pool would be acceptable. We would have to look at the availability of a 25 metre pool. It would also be a great inconvenience to the participants. There is, as the committee is aware, a 50 metre pool in Limerick. It does not have the same level of spectator capacity and it is more than 30 kilometres from Dublin, which would defeat the purpose of the organising committee to provide a strong, family-campus style games in Dublin in 2003.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

What is the contingency plan in relation to a 25 metre pool or campus? What other venues are being looked at there?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

As of now the games organising committee does not have a contingency plan although I suggested to the chairman of the games organising committee in 1998 that it would be prudent to have a contingency plan. He was confident that a 50 metre pool would be provided so he did not look at that contingency.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

So there is no provision but there is no contractual financial liability to the State if this goes wrong, if we do not develop it? Many people around this table and outside this room have expressed concern about the management of this project. We should clear ourselves in advance and make sure that nothing else goes wrong.

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

To clarify, this is a commitment given by the games organising committee. It would be incumbent on the organising committee to look at an alternative if a 50 metre pool was not delivered on time.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

So it is incumbent on it and there is no cost. Are you saying that there is no cost to the State if this new chairman and chief executive do not deliver?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

My understanding is that there is not. However, there is the issue of image and we certainly would not like to fail to deliver on the promise that Ireland has held out for the games in 2003.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

So there is no financial contractual obligation?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

No. We would have to look at the contract again, but not that I am aware of, on the face of it.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The 25 metre option is one not for you but for the organising committee of the Special Olympics?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

So you have no responsibility in that regard. That is good news, I suppose, out of it all. Back to Mr. Teahon in relation to the issues raised by the Attorney General's analysis. Did you provide any information to rebut the Attorney General's analysis of the sequence of events in relation to this matter? It is pages 29 to 43 of his report to the Government.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I wrote to the Taoiseach in relation to the analysis in the draft report. I have only just seen the analysis in the finalised report.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Have you had time to fully consider the analysis in the final report?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Have any immediate changes leapt out to you as you scan this or glance through the draft, between the draft and the final report.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

It seemed to me in reading the report which I have done just once, although in some respects it is similar to the draft report, that the chronology, the facts set out in it are the facts as I know them to be. I have no issue with the facts. I felt, in relation to the draft report, I could not agree with some of the analysis.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Are you satisfied now that the changes which have been made from the draft to the final form make you happy with the analysis?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I would now be comfortable with the vast majority of the analysis, but because I have not had the opportunity of studying it in detail and referring back to issues which were raised, not just by me but by others who responded to the draft report I am not really in a position to say at this time that there is nothing in the analysis with which I would not take some issue.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

For the vast majority I would not have an issue.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Is there anything which strikes you from the small minority of things which you might dissent from or find a problem with? Can you identify anything immediately that springs to mind in relation to the analysis which might strike you as not being in accordance with your analysis or your view?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

On the positive side of this my judgment would be that the analysis essentially sets out what the board reported to the Minister, namely that EU procurement law was followed in full. To the extent that is the case I have no problem with it. The analysis also sets down that the consortium which was successful was clearly the consortium which should be preferred. I have no problem with that. Given that I have not had the opportunity to take what is now in the analysis section and cross-check it against the points that I and others made, I would prefer to wait until such time as I had done that to say that there was a piece of analysis with which I did not agree.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

You might communicate with us directly in relation to that if there are substantive issues which you question. Let me draw your attention to pages 41 and 42 of that analysis, which I regard as containing the most important conclusions. The statement on page 41 - and I am breaking the paragraph in two in a sense - starts with the statement "However embarrassing the failure of Waterworld UK Ltd as a contracting party may have been, . . . ". The second sentence reads "Failure to alert those politically accountable to the true situation seems to seriously call into question the existence of a proper relationship between the executive and the board and between the board and its State shareholders.". Does that strike you as being relatively accurate, given your statement that maybe you should have told? Is that something you can live with?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

One of the problems I had with the analysis in the original draft report - and as I said, I still have not found it in the finalised report - was that in answer to a questionnaire circulated by the office of the Attorney General to board members and assessment panel members I said that I was operating and saw myself operating on the basis of delegated authority from the board. I have not seen this in the analysis section, and I would have expected to see it in the analysis section because it seems a material consideration. In so far as there is in effect a criticism in the sentence "Failure to alert those politically accountable . . . seems to seriously call into question the existence of a proper relationship between the executive and the board and between the board and its State shareholders", I would have thought it would have been in order to set down what the board said to the Minister in its report of 8 March, which was referred to not just by me but by a series of board members in their response to the Attorney General's questionnaire.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

A series of board members?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Regarding the answers that board members gave to the questionnaire, I think virtually everybody referred to the fact that the board had sent to the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation a statement, after the board meeting of 8 March, which set down very clearly that the board had put a process in place with which the board was satisfied, and that the board had delegated to the executive the implementation of that process. I would have expected in an analysis section, and given that this was one of the questions in the questionnaire, that in making the statement that failure to alert seems to call seriously into question the existence of a proper relationship between the executive and the board - just taking that piece of it——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

That is the key point.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Apart from the relationship with the State, it seems - if I am not reading too much into it, and please correct me if I am, Mr. Teahon - that you had an improper relationship with your own board.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

This analysis is, I take it, an analysis by the Attorney General, so I am not the person who should answer, in some senses.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

To clarify, you are happy that you have had a proper relationship with your board and you cite the 8 March statements by your board members in response to the questionnaire as proof of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I would have expected, and said in response to the original draft report, that that would be conveyed. For the information of the committee, I have received a letter from Margaret Hayes, Secretary General of the Department, informing me that at the time the original draft report was given to the Government, the Government also had from the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation and apparently noted, the report from the board. I have a letter to that effect from Margaret Hayes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

What is the significance of having that?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I am simply trying to be as open as possible. I did raise this as a concern on my part and I have a response from Margaret Hayes in relation to raising that concern.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

What is that response in effect, Ms Hayes?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

Mr. Teahon's concern related to the issue of the delegated framework set out by the board for the procurement process, which delegated certain authorities to the executive chairperson and his executive team and was confirmed by the board in its report of 8 March to the Minister. Mr. Teahon was concerned that that fact might not have been brought to the attention of the Government. I simply confirmed that the Minister, Deputy McDaid, had included the full report from the board to him of 8 March, including that fact, and that it had been noted by Government for the record.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

On what occasion was it noted?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

When Government considered the draft report from the Attorney General last week.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The Government has noted——

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

——the full content of the report from the board of CSID to the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation, which contains the statement that the board had established parameters for a process in relation to the award of the contract for the aquatic centre and had delegated the implementation of that process to the executive. The board is satisfied that the process established was appropriate.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The board has established it.

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

What I am trying to get at here is that the Government, if I hear you correctly, has noted that the delegated authority under which Mr. Teahon acted was appropriate and correct and right. Is it usual for the Government to draw attention to this?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

He has noted the board's statement that it had established parameters for the process. I think Mr. Teahon's comment relates to the Attorney General's reference.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Is it usual for the Government to note that somebody had acted in accordance with their delegated authority? Is that normal?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

If a Minister presented or included in a submission to Government a particular report, it would be normal for the Minister to ask that Government note the report included in his memorandum, and that would be recorded.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The significance of noting, meaning that it is now acknowledged by the Government that whatever Mr. Teahon did in relation to his conduct of these matters——

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

No, that the board made a clear statement to him that it had established parameters for a process etc.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

There is no question, from the Government's point of view, that he was outside his parameters of delegated authority.

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

It has not disagreed with the board's statement because it has no grounds for disagreeing. The board has assured the Minister that it set out parameters.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

What I am trying to get to grips with here is that there is no question as far as you are concerned and the as far as the Government is concerned that he was outside the parameters set by his own board in relation to delegated authority. That is important because in our private session the issue of people's reputations was raised. It seems to be a very germane fact that in effect, in terms of the delegated authority under which he acted in relation to this competition, he was within the board's framework.

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

The Government's objective then is to get the framework set out?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

The Government made no further comment. It simply noted the content of the board's report to the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Mr. Teahon might provide clarity on that. Is it your understanding, therefore, that the Government has noted the fact that your company did set out an adequate framework of delegated authority for you?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

That is my understanding of what happened. The board had a board meeting, discussed all the issues, produced a statement which all the board members that attended accepted and agreed to on 8 March and sent that to the Minister. The Minister gave it to Government and Government noted it.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

As you understand it, that was the go-ahead for the framework or manner in which you conducted all of this?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

It was the Government noting a statement by the board of the company that it had put in place a process with which it, the board, in retrospect, having looked at it again, was satisfied, that the board had delegated to the executive the implementation of that. I saw myself, and said so to the board, as acting on the basis of that delegated authority. I should say, because I do not want to be partial in this, that in relation to the other issue I said in my statement to the committee on day one that my communication on the matter was inadequate. I am not trying to have it both ways.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

No. When you say your communication was not as good as it could have been, are you saying that you were outside the framework laid down and noted by the Government?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

No. When I said the communication was inadequate I said that I would not accept any suggestion from any source that my actions were designed with any dishonest or improper motivation in mind. In other words, I am very clear. I did nothing wrong. I acted on the basis of delegated authority and my communication was inadequate.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Yes, but you definitively were not outside the framework of delegated authority, as you saw it,——

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

That is very clear in the board's statement.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

As you understand it, does the sequence of delegated authority go from the Taoiseach to the Government to the company to the board?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

The company is what is known under EU procurement law as the awarding authority. Therefore it is the board of the company that has the entitlement to put a process in place. The board did that and I acted on the basis of that delegated authority.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

To return to the proper executive relationship, you have slight concerns about the reference in the Attorney General's report about the relationship between the company's executive and the board which presumably you will flesh out in detail at a later stage.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

Yes. If somebody was reading it without complete knowledge of all the different events, that page could benefit if it stated that the board had put the process in place as set down in its report. I feel that the sentence, "Failure to alert those politically accountable seems to call seriously into question the existence of a proper relationship between the executive and the board . . .", would benefit from saying that theboard had put this process in place and had delegated authority. The existence of a proper relationship between the board and its State shareholder seems to me to be a different issue.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

Ms Margaret Hayes, do you have an observation on that?

Comment on this
Ms Hayes

I would ask the Deputy to note that on page 40 of the Attorney General's report, under "Corporate governance", the Attorney General acknowledges that:

The board of CSID delegated to the Assessment Panel the function of deciding on the preferred bidder for the . . . .

Therefore there is an acknowledgement.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Yes, there is an acknowledgement but that is in relation to the assessment, not to the delegated authority. Mr. Teahon was not party to the assessment as such, is that not correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I was part of the assessment

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Party - part of it.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

It is a part issue. There is a wider issue which seems to be dealt with in the sentence, "Failure to alert . . . call . . . into question the existence of a proper relationship . . .", in other words, the relationship between the executive and the board is a broader issue than the issue of the board delegating "to the Assessment Panel the function of deciding on the preferred bidder . . .".

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

On page 41, the last paragraph——

Comment on this

Mr. Murphy wants to contribute.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

On a pure technicality, the board of CSID delegated these powers to Mr. Teahon, not to the assessment panel. The assessment panel were not delegated the power. That is mentioned on page 40. It is the executive that actually was delegated that power. The assessment panel was not delegated power.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Therefore is Mr. Murphy saying the Attorney General's report is inaccurate as far as he is concerned?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes, we have one or two small inaccuracies to note.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Let us read this back because it is important that we clarify this: "The board of CSID delegated——

Comment on this

Sorry, Deputy.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

This is very important.

Comment on this

When we are referring to pages, etc., in order to help the other people here I want to publish it each time because it is not coming up on the screens on the far side of the committee. In future, we will publish it automatically.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I apologise, Chairman. Mr. Murphy from the Office of Public Works is referring to the section headed "Corporate governance" on page 40. This is the statement, in order that we get it absolutely correct:

The board of CSID delegated to the Assessment Panel the function of deciding on the preferred bidder for the Aquatic and Leisure Centre.

It is the first statement under the section "Corporate governance". If I heard Mr. Murphy correctly, he is saying that that statement by the Attorney General is inaccurate,——

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

——that the assessment panel did not enjoy "the function of deciding on the preferred bidder for the Aquatic and Leisure Centre.". Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Yes. Chairman, I am saying that if you look at the very last printed page of the report, you will see there——

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

Can Mr. Murphy give us the page reference?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

There is no page number on it, I am afraid, but it is the very last printed page of the whole report, just before the hand-written notes. The committee will see it is headed "Report from the Board of CSID to the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation". Paragraph three states:

The Board had established parameters . . . [etc.] and had delegated the implementation of that process to the Executive.

not to the assessment panel.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

It states: "delegated the implementation of that process". Perhaps I am confused but I understand the words to mean that the executive is in charge of a process but that the assessment panel is in charge of the function of deciding on the preferred bidder. Maybe that is a silly distinction. If Mr. Murphy can clarify that, we would be a long way forward on that. It states "delegated the implementation of that process", that is, the award of the contract.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

It states "to the Executive" and all the assessment panel does is make a recommendation on which the executive acts.

Comment on this

Deputy, you have two minutes left.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I want to clarify that from Mr. Teahon's point of view because it is quite germane to other issues raised by the Attorney General in his report if we are not clear here who has made the decision. Is that in accordance with Mr. Teahon's view? Was it he, not the assessment panel, who made the decision in relation to the preferred bidder? Was it that he had delegated authority to make that decision?

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

I would say that one of the parameters that are referred to in the report of 8 March is that the assessment panel would have the function of making a recommendation, in other words, the assessment panel, in my opinion, was not making the decision as such; the assessment panel was reaching a judgment, and that that was one of the parameters.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

To the extent that the Attorney General has stated in his first sentence on page 40, under "Corporate governance", that the function of deciding on the preferred bidder was that of the assessment panel, would Mr. Teahon think, as Mr. Murphy does, that that is inaccurate? The panel does not make the decision.

Comment on this
Mr. Teahon

We are getting into issues that are not that material. In other words, I would not see myself, as the executive chairperson, under any circumstance refusing to accept a judgment of the assessment panel. In other words, everybody saw the assessment panel as making the judgment. Nobody would come along and say, "We have the recommendation from the assessment panel but we are not going to accept it". Therefore we are getting into an issue where if anybody said "We will not accept the assessment panel's view on this", I would think they are seriously wrong.

Comment on this

Deputy, your time is up but I want to exhaust this avenue.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I had one final question, Chairman.

Comment on this

I kept the other Deputies to 30 minutes as agreed.

Comment on this
Conor Lenihan Deputy C. Lenihan Fianna Fáil

I have one final question.

Comment on this

There is always one final question, Deputy. Mr. Murphy, did you want to say something?

Comment on this