We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

2004 Annual Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General and Appropriation Accounts: Vote 34 — Enterprise, Trade and Employment.

Contributions 141–294 of 294. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Gorman

The Department has a specific role and can respond through the Labour Court to instances of complaint where workers are not being properly treated regarding the pension scheme. This is provided for in the registered employment agreement.

Deputy Joe Higgins referred to two subcontractors as current instances and if a complaint is made to the Labour Court, it will be followed up. The broader issue of pensions and subcontracting in the constructing industry is beyond the resolution of the narrow focus approach of the Labour Court in enforcing the registered employment agreement. This wider challenge, including subcontracting, compliance and taxation, is being articulated at the national partnership talks.

Comment on this
Joe Higgins Deputy J. Higgins Socialist Party

If one or two construction bosses found themselves on the wrong side of the walls of Mountjoy Prison, it might focus minds.

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

Perhaps.

Comment on this

I wish to ask Mr. Gorman about the numbers of people at work. Does Mr. Gorman have statistics and European comparisons for labour force participation between Ireland and Scandinavian countries? Ireland has a sizeable cohort of young people who leave school with few if any qualifications, specifically young men who attend schools in local authority housing areas. Thereafter, they have sporadic employment. What is the view of Mr. Gorman's Department?

My view is that our labour force participation rates are significantly below countries we aspire to be like, such as Scandinavian countries. One factor is this cohort of young men who do not have much chance in the Celtic Tiger era. Could Mr. Gorman provide information and geographical distribution on this matter?

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

I do not have information on comparative labour participation rates from member states throughout the European Union but can get it for the committee. I can, however, give it some broad indicators based on an average set of figures. The employment rate target for 2010 is 70% overall for the European Union. Within this, the female employment rate target is 60%. The target for older workers is 50%. Ireland's current rates are 68.8% overall, 59.3% for female participation and 50.7% for older workers. The last figure is not surprising as our traditional retirement age is somewhat higher than in other countries, particularly the older member states of the European Union.

In terms of the 2010 targets, we are doing well. The participation rate of females is higher in economies such as Sweden. I do not have a member state by member state comparison or breakdown but I can get the information for the committee as it is available. I do not happen to have it with me.

Comment on this

On the prospects of young men dropping out of school——

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

Activation of young people and measures to help them back into the labour market are high on the agenda of FÁS and the Department of Education and Science. FÁS operates and provides a range of programmes which address early school leaving by men and women on a non-discriminatory basis. It uses community training centres and community workshops to provide various programmes and courses specifically aimed at addressing the problem of early school leavers. I can give the committee an itemised list of the various programmes and their budgets for this year. The Department of Education and Science operates a suite of programmes and measures aimed at preventing school drop-out and picking up young people after they drop out.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Gorman concerned that completion rates to leaving certificate are falling rather than rising?

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

There is concern. Our colleagues in the Department of Education and Science specifically address that matter in the context of their mandate. All of the research and indications show that those who enter the labour market at a significant educational disadvantage are the first casualties. It is a priority and a suite of programmes are in place. I can give the committee the details.

Comment on this

Do social welfare and rent supplement feature in the Department's overview? In the Dublin West constituency rent supplement is approximately €1,200 per month for a family of two adults and two children. For someone to enter employment he or she must earn at least €300 per week to pay the rent because of the loss of benefit. Effectively, someone moving from welfare to work in the Irish system probably requires a salary of between €30,000 and €40,000 to make it worth his or her while to take up a job. Would much employment be available at that level for the individuals we are discussing? Eoin O'Driscoll once described the economy as "quite agile". However, it is not very agile at present. Does this concern the Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

Certainly, the Department is concerned about disincentives for those re-entering the labour market, whether they are taxation disincentives or the social welfare type of disincentive mentioned by the Deputy. I am not au fait with the specifics of the rent supplement problem. With our colleagues in various Departments such as the Departments of Finance and Social and Family Affairs, we constantly try to find a balance between providing reasonable supports for those in difficulty and suffering social disadvantage, while at the same time ensuring these supports are not an absolute barrier in moving from support to work.

The medical card is another classic example of a potential barrier in leaving welfare and moving back into the workforce. It is a difficult call. People must have somewhere to live. A balance must be struck between extremely difficult and immediate problems requiring social welfare support and the tension generated by the support in terms of the ability of the person concerned to move away from that level of support and take a job. We generally address this issue on an ongoing basis. Specifically, I do not have experience of rent supplement.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Gorman aware that approximately 61,000 persons or families receive rent supplement——

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

I am aware of the general figures.

Comment on this

——in respect of which the State pays approximately €400 million per year? Is Mr. Gorman also aware that it is probably the biggest barrier to employment for those who might otherwise be gainfully employed? We require more labour and are recruiting abroad. Can we look to people here and give them an opportunity?

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

On a general point, we do look to people in Ireland. Specifically, I do not have a solution for the issue of rent supplement. It is part of our ongoing dialogue on the various tensions in the welfare and taxation systems that we will examine.

Comment on this

I want to give some information. One of the value for money reports by the Comptroller and Auditor General, Mr. Purcell, is on rent supplement. He expects to sign the final report in approximately six weeks and we will have it as soon as the Department releases it. I am sure that, as always, it will cast light on the issue.

Comment on this

Has Mr. Dorgan set targets for growth in productivity and the labour force in terms of upskilling Irish workers?

Comment on this
Mr. Dorgan

The short answer is that we do not have explicit targets for either upskilling or productivity. However, we are extremely aware that our aim, particularly through inward investment, is to be at the leading edge in a number of areas. This will require extremely high level skills, deep expertise, further investment in fourth level education and, concomitant with this, a stepping up of skill levels in all areas attracting inward investment. From that point of view, what FÁS does through its One-Step-Up initiative supports not only the wide economy but also the particular areas attracting inward investment.

Comment on this

I asked a number of parliamentary questions during the year about Gama. I was advised that it was a particular example of a company which had obtained work permits and then applied for an exemption from PRSI. The company had received approximately 1,200 such PRSI exemptions. On foot of these exemptions, it was allowed to use the remittance base of taxation for their workers in Ireland. Traditionally, employers applied for a PRSI exemption when someone came from Germany to work in Ireland for a year or two and stayed within the German social welfare system. The arrangement for Gama exploited a legal loophole found by some bright spark in a solicitor's or accountant's office. When the Department issues work permits, is there any correlation between the officials of the Department and their colleagues in the Department of Social and Family Affairs on the issue of PRSI exemptions? Such exemptions effectively allowed Gama to fly below the radar of the Irish tax system.

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

Our experience of Gama and others has influenced the changes to the Finance Bill's provision on remittance basis. We continually improve our liaison arrangements with the Revenue Commissioners and the Departments of Social and Family Affairs and Justice, Equality and Law Reform in terms of how we grant work permits to companies. The general expectation is that when people come here to work, they are employed in the ordinary way, that is, they are paid and taxed here.

The Gama situation, if not unique, was unusual in terms of the numbers involved and the extent to which the company was able to avail of exemptions. We continue to work with the Departments of Social and Family Affairs and Finance to ensure that clarity exists with regard to the identity of employers. One of the complicating factors in the Gama case was that it was difficult to identify the actual employer because it was not an Irish company. In our further discussions with Gama in respect of its continued presence here and the extent to which it will require work permits, we will focus on determining the identity of the employer. Our ambition in the case of any company applying for a work permit is to ensure that it is an Irish company which employs people subject to normal terms and conditions in terms of PRSI and tax and that workers are covered by the full suite of employment rights and protections.

Comment on this

Subsequent to issuing work permits, does the Department check the PRSI status of the relevant workers?

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

We do not, as a matter of routine, follow up with specific checks on status. Our involvement ends when we establish the bona fides of the applicant and the status of the employer as a properly registered company. Therefore, the subsequent monitoring of tax or welfare compliance falls outside our remit. However, we have a database from which we share with various Departments the details, in real time, of the work permits issued. Other bodies, including the immigration unit and the Garda, have immediate access to that information.

Comment on this
Michael Smith Deputy M. Smith Fianna Fáil

Ireland is taking the route of developing new added value products and services. In terms of the budget for research, what proportion goes to foreign companies and what goes to indigenous interests? How much do indigenous companies invest in research relative to international standards?

In terms of not wasting the valuable financial assets invested in programmes on advanced technology, how successful are the efforts to develop more collaborative research efforts by linking with universities? Can we be sure that the funds allocated to the university sector and other research institutes are dedicated to producing the best results for the country as a whole?

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

With regard to the distribution of the funding, in 2004, the breakdown of the main schemes supported under the science and technology research and development programme was as follows: a total of €33 million was invested in industry for research and development capability; €37 million was allocated for collaboration between industries and universities; basic research grant schemes came to €15.5 million; and miscellaneous investments, including incubation centres, totalled €1.9 million.

I do not have detailed enough figures before me to provide the precise split between the sums allocated to industry, including indigenous industry, as compared to universities. My agency colleagues may have the relevant figures but, if not, I will revert to the Deputy on the matter.

Ensuring value for money in the area of science is a particular challenge, both because of the amount of money involved and also as a result of the way it is spread across a range of programmes, including those relating to advanced technology. We have monitoring arrangements in place to measure value for money in terms of the level of complementarity among programmes and the good use of money by recipients.

Comment on this
Mr. Dorgan

To add to that, enormous investments have been made in universities and public research efforts. The challenge for IDA Ireland and Enterprise Ireland is to encourage companies to respond to those investments. For IDA Ireland, it is a question of persuading companies based outside Ireland or already here to use the benefits of our investments in research. While we can set targets for spending on indigenous or overseas industries, universities and the public sector, the difference will be made if real companies are made interested in what we are now doing through public spending.

In the figures to which I referred, rather than using the term "spent", I should have said that we had approved €19 million in grants for investment by companies in research. Our approval of €40 million in 2004 and €80 million in 2005 demonstrates that we are using a great deal of public funds to persuade the best international companies to conduct research here. Some of the best names have come to Ireland, including IBM, HP, Bell Labs, GenSyn and Pfizer. Our challenge will be to attract more of the same. We will not do so simply by setting up a programme but will have to prove the benefits of those public investments to individual companies.

Comment on this
Michael Smith Deputy M. Smith Fianna Fáil

Has a competition been set for the universities to apply for funds and, if so, how is it being developed?

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

The funds are generally made available on a competitive basis and overseen by a panel of experts, a method which has helped to maintain the quality and standard of investments.

Comment on this
Michael Smith Deputy M. Smith Fianna Fáil

Has more collaborative research resulted?

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

It is specifically targeted at achieving collaboration between business and colleges. Collaboration has significantly increased over the lifetime of these programmes and continues to be a major objective.

Comment on this
Michael Smith Deputy M. Smith Fianna Fáil

Continuing on that theme, will Mr. Gorman address the embryonic units and the efforts to create an entrepreneurial dynamic in Shannon Development? Further to Deputy Fleming's question, what extent of spread is apparent in the region? Given that Shannon Development has €16 million in rental income, it might have money left to refurbish the old industrial site in Roscrea. Now that we have the motorway south of Portlaoise, Mr. Dorgan's people might be able to travel south from the midlands. There is no difficulty as regards the roads.

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

Shannon Development has put much effort into linking enterprise with the expertise and knowledge in the third level education sector. The first example of that is the National Technology Park in Limerick, which we developed with the University of Limerick. During that experiment, we found there was a greater propensity for investment in knowledge-based activity among Irish companies when measured by the level of patents generated, investment and numbers of staff in research and development, etc. The question was how to make that relevant throughout the rest of the region. We then identified towns with third level institutions throughout the region and applied the national technology park, NTP, model in those locations. Examples include Kerry Technology Park in Tralee, where we have developed a 53-acre site adjacent to the institute of technology, Tipperary Technology Park in Thurles, of which Deputy Michael Smith was very supportive during its development, construction and delivery, Birr Technology Centre in Offaly, which is linked to Athlone IT, and the latest addition, Information Age Park, Ennis. We have linked those together and branded them the "knowledge network". In each location, we have an incubator, an innovation works and an active programme of linking with the educational institutions, particularly building on the expertise that is being funded through the science and technology programmes the Deputy mentioned. I refer, for example, to the Irish Software and Engineering Research Centre supported by Science Foundation Ireland, SFI, at the University of Limerick.

The funding for that came from the property portfolio, essentially in the more developed parts of the region, carrying out joint ventures with the private sector and releasing capital that can be invested in sectors where the private sector will not go. That is working well, particularly with Irish-owned businesses. We have invested over €40 million in the knowledge network in recent years and there is a significant number of companies, mainly Irish-owned — although a number have been taken over by foreign companies — involved. This is a new dynamic in terms of generating inward investment.

Investment in Roscrea would come from our capital budget rather than our rental income. As Deputy Michael Smith knows, we recently acquired land in Roscrea for the development of a business park and have approved the business expansion scheme, BES, certification for the development of a new building there. As our capital budget for 2006 includes an allocation for investing in infrastructure to open that park, we expect to see development early in 2006.

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

Perhaps I could return to the question about expenditure on investment in research and development as I have two ballpark figures that might help. Gross expenditure on research and development in Ireland increased from €586 million in 1994 to €1.78 billion in 2004. The higher education element of the expenditure was €121.1 million in 1994 and €491.7 million in 2004. I will elaborate on those figures in a further reply to the committee.

Comment on this
Michael Smith Deputy M. Smith Fianna Fáil

Approximately 30 years ago there were between 18,000 or 19,000 students in four universities and there are now in the region of 135,000 students in what we call the conventional new universities, institutes of technology and colleges. In terms of entrepreneurial skills and the number of people who want to establish businesses, how are the latter developing within the educational sector in terms of outlining the direction that Ireland will take in the future? Are dramatic changes being seen?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Irish entrepreneurship rates are the highest in Europe on a per capita basis. County enterprise centres and incubation centres are important and aid economic development but the question is how many people inside them are contributing to economic activity. The occupancy rate for the community enterprise centres across the State is 86%, which is high and satisfactory. Enterprise Ireland has incubator units under construction in every university and institute of technology. A growing number of entrepreneurs is using those facilities. Last year we supported 75 such high potential, start-up companies and approximately 11% of those came from people in the academic research community who had successfully commercialised their research and converted it into projects.

The commercialisation of research is important. We have heavily supported near-to-market research and development of both processes and products and services. Process is often forgotten but is important because it contributes to productivity. Average productivity growth in Enterprise Ireland companies in 2004 was 7.4%, a respectable figure. Exports increased 5.6% in 2004 from 0.8% in 2003. The research and development funds being spent on process and products and services are having clear outputs in terms of increasing productivity and exports.

Comment on this

Mr. Purcell referred to an inquiry, with which members of Mr. Thompstone's staff took issue, into Shannon Development's property department. As Mr. Thompstone did not refer to that in his opening remarks, could he give us some insight into the report? Was it commissioned by the board and what is the current position?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

The Comptroller and Auditor General was referring to a report by external property consultants looking at the operation of the property department with a view to seeing how best we could implement our new property strategy and ensure that we have the right skills and approach. Tensions have arisen from that exercise. The response from the property department included a statement along the lines to which the Comptroller and Auditor General referred. There is a view that there would be common ground between board members and staff of Shannon Development on many of the issues identified. There is a desire to improve how we go about our business.

Comment on this

When did the consultants report?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

The consultants presented their report to the board in July 2005. The property department issued its response in November or December 2005.

Comment on this

Is it fair to say that the report was scathing in its criticism of the practices and procedures of the property department?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

As written, yes; it makes clear statements to that effect. However, the property department responded to the specific issues raised by the consultants. For example, it referred to the purchase of land in Roscrea for the development of a business park, an issue raised by Deputy Smith. A railway line crossed part of the land and it would have cost a lot of money to build a bridge. Everybody was aware of this at the time of purchase and the issue was highlighted during the approval stage. Arrangements were made to dispose of the land on one side of the railway. The board and executive are focused on what needs to be improved. In that context, an active programme is under way.

Comment on this

Will the report make recommendations?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

Yes.

Comment on this

Has it been sent to the board?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

Yes.

Comment on this

Has the board accepted the recommendations?

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

The thrust of many of the recommendations has been accepted by the board.

Comment on this

Have the specific recommendations been accepted as board policy?

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

Some ten or 11 have been accepted.

Comment on this

Does the property division have a problem with the recommendations?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

Its misgivings are centred more on the general approach adopted in the report and the way it was written. In its response it stated it agreed with many of the points the consultants had highlighted. For example, as part of the action programme arising from the report, we are in the process of recruiting a property director who will report directly to me as CEO. This was not the practice previously.

Comment on this

Did the manual to which Mr. Thompstone referred predate the recommendations made in the report and, if so, will the recommendations be incorporated into the manual?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

I do not fully understand the question.

Comment on this

In his replies to Deputy Fleming and other Deputies Mr. Thompstone gave an historical account of the difficulties and said they had been overtaken by events, that there was a manual which set out the practice to be followed in all property transactions and the management of property by Shannon Development. Did the manual incorporate the recommendations or predate the report?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

The preparation of the property procedures manual predated the consultant's report of July 2005.

Comment on this

Has the agency taken on board the nine or ten recommendations to which the chairman referred?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

Yes. The key recommendations concerned new skills, for which a recruitment process is under way, and the amount we spent on the maintenance of our property portfolio, which has been decreasing due to significant cost constraints. The consultants suggested we might spend more, which issue is being reviewed. Recommendations concerning our records management and information system were accepted and will lead to a work package that will contribute a second level of consultancy expertise to the company. As a result of the consultants' review, we will also benchmark the service charges regime we introduced on foot of a previous value for money report. The review also stated that the property procedures manual was inappropriate but that is not a matter on which the board and executive agree with the consultants.

Comment on this

Is it correct to say that when the agency finally decided to dispose of the Gillogue site on the open market, it did not do so through the property division, but engaged the services of an outside agency?

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

Yes, it was in line with a number of previous sales. It is not unusual to employ outside agents to prepare the offering for the market in sales of such a scale.

Comment on this

Does that reflect on the property division?

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

No.

Comment on this

Why have a property division with considerable expertise if it does not handle the acquisition and disposal of property?

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

In this sale the decision was taken to prepare an offering with one of the major property vendors in the country. It was vital to ensure national exposure for the specific property in question. It is similar to trying to sell a house oneself or employing an auctioneer to cast the net wider in seeking potential purchasers.

Comment on this

That would be reasonable if Shannon Development had not tried to sell property itself on four occasions, according to Appendix A of the report.

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

There were four interested parties, not four attempts to sell. The focus at the time was on securing an industrial undertaking arising from the closure and liquidation of the previous operation at the premises. Following the liquidation, a number of parties expressed an interest in acquiring the equipment and there was a significant foreign direct investment inquiry. The procedure in dealing with those expressions of interest involved treating them as industrial undertakings. This meant we had to rely on the Red Book valuation procedure to determine the value at which the property should be sold.

Comment on this

I will go through some aspects of the Gillogue sale for the witnesses. In July 2004, according to the appendix, Shannon Development wrote to the consortium of business people interested in acquiring the site. A letter from the executive at Shannon Development stated that board approval was being sought for the sale.

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

Part of the approval process requires that heads of terms be agreed with a proposed purchaser to ensure there will no be uncertainty.

Comment on this

The letter of July 2004 indicated a decision by the executive of Shannon Development to seek board approval for the sale. Does this mean the board had not given approval?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

No. The executive indicated that they were the agreed terms which were to be put to the board for approval. It is normal to do this to ensure a common understanding of the exact terms to be agreed during sale negotiations.

Comment on this

Did the board agree when it considered the submission from the executive in August 2004?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

No. The property sub-committee reviews board documentation with the help of the internal auditors who confirm compliance with public procurement guidelines. The document went before the board at its meeting in August 2004. While the board was generally supportive of the proposal, it decided to approve the sale of the buildings with less land. This amounted to 47 acres rather than 116 acres contained in the recommendation coming forward from the executive and the property sub-committee of the board.

Comment on this

Is the other 69 acres to be retained by Shannon Development because of potential in the future?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

Yes, that is what led to the decision. A concern was expressed when it came to the board that while we had treated the Gillogue facility and the adjoining land as one asset, some of the adjoining lands could have potentially been used for speculative purposes. For that reason, the 69 acres were withheld from sale and the proposed purchasers were so advised after the meeting.

Comment on this

A special meeting was held on 16 September 2004, and according to the appendix, it was attended by Mr. McElligott, two members on the board and two members of the executive. Was this a board meeting, an informal meeting or a sub-committee meeting? What was the status of the meeting?

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

It was a meeting of board members to discuss the issue on 16 September 2004.

Comment on this

Does that mean it was a board meeting?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

Technically, it was a meeting of board members. It would not have had the status of a full board meeting.

Comment on this

Two members of the board were present with the chairman.

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

Yes.

Comment on this

Were all board members invited?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

No.

Comment on this

Why were two particular members selected to go to the meeting? What was their role in the sale of property?

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

Dealing with the matter of property transactions, issues evolve as one proceeds. It would not be unusual for the chairman to seek the advice of available board members and members of the executive during the course of property or other issues that arise in the course of the company's activity.

Comment on this

These two members happened to be available.

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

The Chairman will appreciate that some of our board members live outside the region and are not immediately available.

Comment on this

I understand that. I am trying to establish if these two members were brought to the meeting because they had particular expertise or they were available on the day.

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

It was a combination of knowledge, expertise and availability.

Comment on this

Were other board members asked to come along?

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

They were not asked to the meeting of 16 September 2004.

Comment on this

Was Mr. Thompstone present with some of his personnel?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

Yes.

Comment on this

The appendix states that the chairman was present for the first part of the meeting while two executives attended the second part. Was this two meetings or one meeting?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

My recollection of the meeting is that I was present for the duration. There was a discussion between the chairman, the board members and me, during which the board members expressed a desire to explore a number of the issues with the executive. After a period I asked the two executives concerned to join the meeting. As I had advised them it was likely they would be required, they were available. These members joined at the latter point of the meeting. My recollection is that the chairman left just before the executive members joined.

Comment on this

Was a potential solution proposed in that the sale of the property including the 47 acres would go ahead and the ancillary lands would go on the market via public auction?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

Yes, that was a potential solution discussed at the meeting. The view expressed was to explore if that option would solve the issue at hand. At the time, the proposed purchasers expressed concern about the outcome of the decision not to sell the entire landbank with the building.

Comment on this

On 24 September there was a board meeting but the sale of the property was not on the agenda. It was discussed nonetheless, probably under the heading of "any other business".

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

It came up as a matter arising going through the minutes of the previous meeting.

Comment on this

Why did it come up again?

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

The issue was still live in terms of correspondence and interaction between the parties during that September.

Comment on this

What was the decision on the meeting of 24 September 2004?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

The board considered the issues raised and it was updated on the fact that the proposed purchasers, the packaging company, had expressed significant concerns about its ability to deliver the project if it did not have access to the full land bank. It argued that the financing package was secured on the whole land bank, and reducing it would cause a problem. The board decided to proceed with the sale, taking account of the potential impact of the industrial undertaking. It requested that a new red book valuation would be secured on the 69 acres.

Comment on this

Was a valuation done?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

There was a condition that the proposed purchasers would have to accept the outcome of the red book valuation.

Comment on this

Another letter dated 1 October was addressed to the consortium making the new offer. The board met on 29 October, and again there was no agreement. Is it correct that members again expressed concern?

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

That is correct. If I recall correctly, the offer was made to the prospective purchaser with restrictive covenant on the use of the additional lands.

Comment on this

The consortium then rejected the offer. Is that the sequence?

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

If I recall correctly, the consortium was in discussion with the company and was not in favour of the restrictive covenant. The issue was deadlined for close of business in December, at which point the consortium accepted the covenants.

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

To be factually accurate on the timing, the deadline was in early January.

Comment on this

On 25 February 2005 there was a board meeting where a firm decision was made to sell part of the Gillogue property, the building and its immediate land surround on the open market. Ownership was to be retained of the remaining lands.

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

That is correct.

Comment on this

That process is now ongoing.

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

To recap, in January of that year there was resistance initially from the proposed purchasers to the idea of the restrictive covenant on the lands. Ultimately, on the evening of the closing date for acceptance of the sale, the proposed purchasers decided to sign the contract documentation. The board met in January and decided, having considered all the information available, that it would not be in the best interest of the company to proceed with the sale. The company decided not to proceed.

Subsequent to that, at the February board meeting, the decision was taken — given the interest that had been expressed and the controversy generated around the sale transaction — to expose the property to the open market. In doing so, the decision taken was to expose to the market the building and as much land as needed to build and operate a business successfully. The Chairman is correct in stating that this process is ongoing and coming to a conclusion.

Comment on this

In the meantime a letter has been received from the liquidator looking for an explanation why the decision was taken not to proceed with the sale. It points out that Shannon Development had needlessly prolonged the liquidator's occupation of the premises, incurring all costs and expenses associated therewith. It states the liquidator would reserve his rights in this regard. Has the liquidator looked for money from Shannon Development to pay him compensation?

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

On what date was that letter sent? We have received many letters from the liquidator.

Comment on this

The letter, which is referred to in the appendix, is dated 26 January 2005.

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

The answer to the Chairman's question is no. The liquidator has not looked for any money from Shannon Development in that regard. I will give details of the company's current dealings with the liquidator. The liquidator has agreed terms for the sale of the equipment in the building. Shannon Development has agreed a method statement for the liquidator's exiting of the building and closing of the sale of the equipment to his preferred purchaser. I understand it will take place within 105 days of a date at the end of November 2005. That time period will expire shortly.

Comment on this

Do officials from Shannon Development visit its properties on a regular basis? Is a procedure in place to allow sites which are not used to be visited once, twice or four times a year? Are such sites visited at all?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

Such visits are facilitated through Shannon Development's property department and its regional offices. As the Chairman is aware, Shannon Development has offices throughout the region. Some other methods are also used. Caretakers are employed to keep an eye on sites in more remote locations, in particular, and to report back on any issues which might arise.

Comment on this

Is there a significant system of oversight of Shannon Development's property portfolio at management level? Are people in management positions involved in any physical supervision of the property portfolio on a regular basis?

Comment on this
Mr. Thompstone

Yes. One of the outcomes of Shannon Development's recent cost management and change management programme is that it no longer employs the same number of people in the clerk of works category as it did previously. Such people would have been involved in supervision and inspection in the past. I accept that Shannon Development needs to address this area.

Comment on this
Mr. McElligott

Shannon Development has employed an extensive management service charge regime to maintain the operational properties in its portfolio.

Comment on this

The Comptroller and Auditor General referred to an aspect of Mr. Dorgan's area of responsibility. He said €4 million of the overall figure of €30.9 million related to a property transaction. Can Mr. Dorgan throw any light on that by filling in some of the details?

Comment on this
Mr. Dorgan

IDA Ireland has disposed of many properties in recent years. It owned 650 buildings at the start of 1998, but that figure has since been reduced to 102 as a consequence of an organised programme of disposing of properties over an extensive period of time. A property was sold to an investment company in 2004 on the basis that a sitting tenant with a long lease was in place. IDA Ireland mistakenly omitted to mention that the tenant had a break clause, which it exercised in early 2005. It is clear the exercise of that break reduced the value to the investing company of the property it had purchased. IDA Ireland was at fault because it had not adverted to the clause when it was disclosing the details of the property and everything attaching to it. The break was mentioned in a side letter which was not associated with the file as it should have been. A mistake was made. IDA Ireland entered into negotiations with the investing company and subsequently reached a settlement with it. IDA Ireland has repurchased the property from the investing company at a cost. It is now in the process of putting the property and another property beside it back on the market. IDA Ireland believes it will achieve full value for the site, although that has yet to come to pass.

Comment on this

Was it originally sold for €4 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Dorgan

No. It was sold for a much larger sum. The provision IDA Ireland made in its accounts against the lesser value to the investing company was €4 million.

Comment on this

What is IDA Ireland's loss to date on foot of the two transactions? I know it hopes to recover that loss.

Comment on this
Mr. Dorgan

It is not possible to state what the loss is to date, because it depends on the outcome of the further sale.

Comment on this

Is it not the case that IDA Ireland bought back the property for more than it had paid for it?

Comment on this
Mr. Dorgan

That is correct. The increased price relates to the loss to the investing company for that period.

Comment on this

Did IDA Ireland have to pay substantially more than the company had paid for it?

Comment on this
Mr. Dorgan

It paid somewhat more for it. I will not give the exact sum, but I can confirm the price increased by between 10% and 20%. The exact figure is not immediately available to me.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Dorgan give the committee that figure by way of correspondence?

Comment on this
Mr. Dorgan

Yes.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Ryan tell me how many people are employed by Enterprise Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Some 940 people were employed by Enterprise Ireland in 2004. I think the final figure for 2005 is 931.

Comment on this

How many of the employees will be transferred to Shannon Airport?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

It has been designated that 300 posts will be relocated to Shannon Airport.

Comment on this

How many people have volunteered to take up the 300 positions at Shannon Airport?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Nineteen people have volunteered internally. A total of 49 people, including the 19 people in question, have expressed an interest through the central applications facility in being decentralised to Shannon Airport.

Comment on this

Are the rest of the Enterprise Ireland employees reluctant to leave Dublin or to go to Shannon?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

The scarcity of volunteers is a reflection of the fact that people will not have to relocate for a few years. People do not like to make decisions that far in advance. There is a human dimension to this matter as well. It is usually the case nowadays that both halves of a couple work. Some of Enterprise Ireland's staff are looking after elderly parents, for example. A number of human issues are taken into account as people make their final decisions

Comment on this

That is understandable. Can Mr. Ryan outline the timetable for Enterprise Ireland's relocation to Shannon? Can he give the committee details of the major deadlines, relating to buildings and offices, etc.?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Following the Government's original decision in December 2003, Enterprise Ireland identified the posts to be transferred, which were advertised on the central applications facility. Enterprise Ireland has developed an implementation plan and worked with Shannon Development on the identification of a site. I wish to express my appreciation to Shannon Development for its co-operation in that regard. Enterprise Ireland has worked with the Office of Public Works to ensure proper value for money in the acquisition of lands. The board of Enterprise Ireland has approved the purchase of a 13-acre site that has been identified and submitted an application to its parent Department, the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, for permission to proceed with the purchase of the site.

Comment on this

Representatives of the OPW, including Mr. Seán Benton, attended a meeting of this committee last week. Mr. Benton indicated that in many locations, the OPW has adopted a policy of putting advance parties of small numbers of people in leased accommodation. Does Enterprise Ireland intend to do that at Shannon, or is it waiting for the permanent move?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

We are actively investigating that possibility. The Minister, Deputy Martin, has decided that responsibility for the development of indigenous industry in the Shannon region will revert to Enterprise Ireland. As a result, it is quite likely a number of staff from Shannon Development will transfer to Enterprise Ireland. We look forward to those workers joining us.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Gorman give the equivalent figures for FÁS? Where are the workers in question supposed to be going? How many of them have volunteered to transfer?

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

The head office, in effect, of FÁS is scheduled to relocate to Birr, County Offaly. It is intended that some 383 staff will go to Birr. Some 11 persons from within FÁS and nine from external agencies have expressed an interest in going to Birr, with 58 persons from within the public sector system generally, giving a total of 78 expressions of interest. The target is 383.

Comment on this

What is the timeframe involved?

Comment on this
Mr. Gorman

The parties concerned are almost at the point of agreeing to the purchase of the site. Construction will certainly take a couple of years. I do not, therefore, have a precise target date for moving.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Dorgan state how many are employed in the IDA? How many staff are located in Ireland, especially in Dublin, and how many are located overseas? Where are they located overseas?

Comment on this
Mr. Dorgan

The IDA has 280 staff, of whom 40 are based overseas. Roughly 25 are to be found in five offices in North America, approximately ten in three offices in Europe and approximately five in the Asia-Pacific region. In Ireland there are 240 staff, of whom 140 are located in Dublin and 100 in offices in the regions, including 45 in our office in Athlone.

Comment on this

Obviously, the agency has to work closely with Mr. Ryan's staff. What structure is in place to formalise the relationship?

Comment on this
Mr. Dorgan

There are structures at various levels. The chief executives of all the agencies involved meet regularly, at the monthly formal Forfás board meetings and otherwise on at least a quarterly basis. There are various other tiers below this level. In many, but not all, areas, both in Ireland and overseas, Enterprise Ireland and the IDA are located together.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

We have had a very broad canvas today, involving four Accounting Officers. The site in Gillogue has been haunting more people than most during the years. I believe it was bought by Forfás for £5 million in 1994.

We referred to some of this material before in that an earlier value for money report in 1998 considered the provision and management of industrial property by all of the industrial development agencies. In that report we referred to the need to get a better return from property. At the time the IDA had undertaken a programme of selling excess property. The report found that the agencies involved the IDA, Shannon Development and Údarás na Gaeltachta, were holding onto property for too long, certainly in places where there was no real prospect of industrial development.

Getting back to the Gillogue site, Forfás paid the equivalent of over €6 million for it in 1994 and it was to be sold for €3.3 million ten years later. Intuitively, one feels there is something wrong with this. I do not understand why the market value of the surplus 69 acres involved was in the region of €295,000. It seems extraordinary that it was valued at only a little over €4,000 per acre. Perhaps some property expert can tell me why this is the case. There are certain difficulties with the site but, in the light of current developments, the valuation seems extraordinary. However, it must be said it was carried out in line with the Red Book which is the standard for valuing land set by the Society of Chartered Surveyors. Reference was made to betting. I would like to bet on getting a market value of more than €295,000 for 69 acres. That is just a layman's observation.

Comment on this

Is it agreed to dispose of Vote 34, the IDA Ireland Accounts 2004 and Enterprise Ireland Accounts 2004? Agreed. Is it agreed to note and dispose of value for money report No. 50? Agreed.

Our agenda for Thursday, 23 February is the 2004 annual report of the Comptroller and Auditor General and Appropriation Accounts, Vote 30 — Department of Communications, Marine and Natural Resources, chapter 11.2 — fishery harbour centres, and chapter 11.3 — foreshore leases and licences.

The witnesses withdrew.

The committee adjourned at 2.35 p.m. until11 a.m. on Thursday, 23 February 2006.

Comment on this