We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Chapter14.3 — Extra Remuneration.

Contributions 108–246 of 246. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Woods

There is no intention at this stage to establish another scheme. The requirement on us will be to quantify the amounts charged, which we believe will be significantly smaller. The scheme to which the Deputy referred is intended for making payments under the health repayment scheme, which is also operated from Tullamore with the involvement of an outside contractor. In the first instance, we will carry out an evaluation based on the available data of the potential quantum and we will use the information which has already been obtained through the repayment scheme to the extent it is possible to do so.

Comment on this

Is it the case that a high percentage of elderly or psychiatric patients in long-term care would not make use of the patient private property account schemes? What percentage would hand over their pensions to hospitals?

Comment on this
Mr. Woods

I do not have the figures to hand but I can tell the Deputy that approximately 15,000 patient private property accounts exist across 170 locations.

Comment on this

It is high. Many people opt for it. Does Mr. Woods know what the money earned on the interest on the private patients' accounts was used for? There were suggestions that it was used in various institutions for partial refurbishments, painting or extra curtains. Is that correct? That was the common understanding.

Comment on this
Mr. Woods

The guidelines issued make it clear that patient funds can be applied only for purposes directly relevant to the patient and not for the kind of matters to which Deputy Burton refers. I have not anecdotally come across instances such as the Deputy mentioned.

Comment on this

What was it spent on?

Comment on this
Mr. Woods

In the time of the health boards the main intention was to use the resource to fund the cost of administering the scheme across the 15,000 accounts in the 170 locations.

Comment on this

Was that accounted for in the accounts as an administration cost?

Comment on this
Mr. Woods

Yes, in the patient private property accounts, not in the accounts of the HSE.

Comment on this

Has Mr. Woods a timeframe for the contractors to arrange the repayments? We receive a number of complaints from people. Yesterday my colleague Deputy McManus raised a case of a lady who is happily celebrating her 101st birthday, but it is proving difficult to find out when she might get her refund. Is there any prioritisation of people who are entitled to refunds who are reaching a venerable age? We would like to see them receiving the funds while they are still able to use them. Is there any way to indicate to such people the timescale for repayment by the contractors?

Comment on this
Mr. Woods

There is a commitment in the scheme that payment to all valid applicants will be made within 28 days. The scheme commenced repayments in December 2006 and the guaranteed 28-day turnaround time is being adhered to.

Comment on this

I refer back to the issue of the additional remuneration paid. In the Comptroller and Auditor General's report I noticed that the extra remuneration was approximately 14.5% of the payroll payments by the HSE and that there was an analysis of the 22 top earners. The three highest earners worked an average overtime of 75, 68 and 51 hours per week on top of their ordinary standard working week of 39 hours. Do I understand that correctly? How could that possibly be safe? We have all heard horror stories of what unfortunately happens to some people in hospitals. Under health and safety risk assessment could those extraordinary numbers of overtime hours be safe?

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

Perhaps I should comment on that. The answer is no. We have to accept that there is a significant risk at all times if people work very long hours. As the Deputy knows this has been highly prevalent in the health services and therefore the European working time directive was a serious challenge to health services in Ireland and across the world. Although these hours breach the European working time directive, we accept that we must come within the directive and are working hard to do so. We are in an ironic situation where we also have to negotiate with the representative bodies for non-consultant hospital doctors to bring those hours down because a significant loss in income is potentially associated with a reduction in overtime.

Comment on this

What is the baseline rate for a non-consultant hospital doctor? What are their average gross earnings excluding overtime?

Comment on this
Mr. Woods

At a registrar level it is approximately €55,000. The house officer and intern would earn less. The specialist registrars would probably be in the range of €55,000 to €65,000. At the extreme end, figures indicate that some of these people could make €150,000 to €160,000 above this.

Comment on this

Would they not be in a complete state of exhaustion unless they were simply sitting in an ante-room waiting for a bell that never rings?

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

That is an interesting point because there is a significant difference in on-call work. Some people are on call at home, others are on call in busy specialties in hospitals, and they are paid the same.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

One could be on call for a specialty that has little call-in. Call-in rates are itemised in this jurisdiction and elsewhere. Deputy Bruton is pointing out an inequity in how we pay for that overtime. It raises the question how somebody could work those long hours and be working all the time.

Comment on this

Is the HSE doing anything about it? Is it part of the national negotiations?

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

Absolutely. There are several pilot projects under the auspices of the LRC. At nine pilot sites we are exploring how we can meet the extended working time directive. We are trying to see how new rosters can be put in place on these pilot sites, which include some of the biggest hospitals in the country, to see if the service can be run without affecting quality of service. As we run them on reduced overtime hours we continue to pay all the overtime we paid beforehand because those are the conditions under which the——

Comment on this

Can Professor Drumm explain that?

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

It is good that the Deputy has asked——

Comment on this

He is paying the same overtime although people's hours have been reduced. So somebody who used to earn €150,000 as a registrar with these extraordinary hours is guaranteed to retain those earnings although those hours have reduced dramatically.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

Absolutely, on those pilot sites. It was the only way agreement could be reached.

Comment on this

Could that be called a bribe or an inducement?

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

The representative organisation involved agreed to enter the pilot projects examining a reduction in hours. Deputy Burton will remember that for many years the cry was constantly in the public arena about the number of extra hours we had. We now have to pay for those hours to enter into a process that allows us to examine how they might be reduced. I have to accept that this agreement has been reached under the LRC and we have to work within it.

Comment on this

On the remuneration, Professor Drumm's statement also referred to the fact that some of the payments related to former senior staff in the old health boards who were, presumably, taking redundancy or retirement packages. Does Professor Drumm have an indication of the highest and lowest or the average package figures?

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

If we could refer to Mr. Woods on that we could give the Deputy that information.

Comment on this

One understands that a number of these people have been re-engaged as consultants. Is there a policy on that and to what extent are they re-engaged as consultants or contractors in part to their former jobs or areas?

Comment on this
Mr. Woods

The arrangement was common across all the former chief executives of the health boards. It included a normal lump sum pension, a severance element of 26 weeks pay and an ex gratia payment which equated to the same. The final element was a €10,000 retraining grant which was subject to being vouched. The lump sums ranged from €189,000 to €274,000. The pension elements are standard at approximately €60,000. The severance and ex gratia payments were approximately €60,000 each. For one person the total was approximately €380,000. For 2005——

Comment on this

Is that €380,000 the average payment?

Comment on this
Mr. Woods

It is not far from being the average, though arithmetically it is not quite so.

Comment on this

Could Mr. Woods give an indication of the highest amounts?

Comment on this
Mr. Woods

It is a fair enough average. The highest is approximately €385,000. I am adding a full-year pension but 2005 was a half year, the termination coming at the end of June 2005. In that context, the pension would only be €30,000, rather than €66,000. What was the Deputy's second question?

Comment on this

How many of those people would be engaged again as consultants or contractors or provide services, primarily to the HSE but also to the Department, through companies?

Comment on this
Mr. Woods

I am not aware of the figure. Pension abatement would normally apply if a person who had retired from the service returned to work. In that context earnings would be offset against any pension receivable to the extent that those earnings were from the health service.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Woods inquire as to the situation in that regard?

Comment on this
Mr. Woods

I will.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Scanlan clarify a point relating to discretionary medical cards, which were discussed earlier? I understand why they exist and have no difficulty with them but my concern is about their number. Is the figure of €10 million per annum, €50 million for the period examined by the Comptroller and Auditor General, negotiated rather than based on the number of discretionary medical cards allocated to individual doctors?

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

The figure of €10 million was negotiated with the IMO and was based on a suggestion by that body that there were 75,000 discretionary medical cards in existence. The Department carried out certain checks to validate that figure in general terms but there were no absolute figures. As the Comptroller and Auditor General stated, the money was paid pro rata through a doctor’s GMS list, as opposed to being tagged to each card.

Comment on this

So it was not tagged per discretionary medical card.

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

It was not.

Comment on this

The issue of medical cards has previously come before this committee. My specific concern is about the fact that, some years ago, we looked at the number of duplicate medical cards and those in circulation for people who were deceased. I am disappointed to learn that, several years on, the fundamental programme of monitoring and controlling the issue of medical cards has not been tightened so that we can see how many cards exist, irrespective of their category. Are the medical cards issued in the normal way monitored closely or could the problems experienced recur?

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

The Deputy is correct. The money is not tagged to particular cards, enabling the identification of the number, because it was an industrial relations concession and we never pretended it was based on an exact number of cards. My colleagues from the HSE may wish to comment but my understanding from a briefing I received some time ago was that the system for cross-checking medical cards with PPS numbers was now all but complete and far more robust. There were, however, some suggestions that caused me some concern, on which the HSE may comment.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

A much more robust system is now in place. Medical cards are reapplied for every year and we must wait for that process to be completed. In the coming year all medical cards will be accurately recorded on the new and very advanced IT system now in place, that allows a general practitioner to check in his or her surgery, the eligibility of a patient to have a new-born baby logged on to the system. Our PCRS people have developed very advanced systems, to the extent that they can even use their mobile telephones to deal with GPs. They may also remove a patient whom they know to be deceased so there will be no excuse for GPs not to do so, or for the HSE not to enter a patient. The system is much more comprehensive and will allow us, in a short period, to identify all discretionary medical cards.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Purcell to comment on this issue.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

I know what Mr. Scanlan is saying to the effect that this was part of a negotiated deal with the IMO at the time, in the context of broader negotiations relating to the extension of medical cards to the over-70s. We held a few sessions on the costings for that and the way it was implemented. In this case there was a condition, as Professor Drumm said in his opening statement, that a person had to be significantly in excess of the medical card guidelines and have a medical condition requiring more frequent attendance at a GP. Not all of the 64,000 discretionary medical cards, which is the latest figure, fit that condition. Effectively, the Department entered into an agreement but was unable to police it. The original intention, stated in the chapter, was for an analysis of the cards to be carried out to see what doctor provided what services to what people. The problem with entering into an agreement of that nature and undertaking to carry out the exercise presupposes that a body has the necessary records for obtaining the information. This agreement dates back to 2002 but we are not really any closer to that goal in 2007.

The HSE is trying to ascertain by how far people exceed the limit but events have overtaken it. As recently as last December the Department wrote to the HSE. One interpretation of a letter from the director of primary care in the Department to the assistant national director of contracts, primary, community and continuing care is that it suggested forgetting about determining the number of discretionary cards issued in the past. I have a real concern that GPs are being overpaid in this regard on the basis of the agreement entered into. Also, certain GPs are getting paid but have no discretionary medical card holders, because they are issued on an average basis by reference to their panel. That is why I was so upset about it.

Comment on this

The problem was identified four or five years ago. Initially there was supposed to have been an additional €2.5 million for 20,000 such cards. It subsequently emerged that the figure was 75,000 and for the past five years we have been paying approximately €10 million per year, €50 million in total. Is the problem still current? Are we still paying for 75,000 so-called discretionary cards when in reality there could be substantially fewer? Is it not time for a conclusion to be brought to the issue?

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

I will answer both questions together. I agree with all that the Comptroller and Auditor General said, with one caveat concerning the letter issuing from the Department suggesting we forget about the discretionary cards. I agree with Professor Drumm about the need for cards to be granted to individuals who have particular needs or expenses. I also agree with the Comptroller and Auditor General that events have overtaken this matter. Part of it relates to industrial relations peace, on which we are now back in discussions with the Irish Medical Organisation. Part of it relates to the introduction of the GP visit card which has added a whole new category.

There is a big issue relating to how non-discretionary medical cards are granted. I assume the information collected by the Comptroller and Auditor General related to the number of discretionary medical cards. I agree that a total of 66 indicates that not all of them fall into the category supposed to be covered by this payment. I wonder if ordinary medical cards are granted below the line, owing to higher medical outgoings, rather than purely on the basis of income. I previously said to the committee that the system of eligibility for medical cards should be examined to ensure it was fair, equitable and consistent across the country, while taking medical needs into account. There is a commitment in Towards 2016 to this effect. My point is that all of these factors have overtaken that commitment. For good or ill, a little like the case of the junior doctors, we did a deal which involved the payment of what initially was a sum of €2 million. A subsequent IR deal saw this amount rise to €10 million; it was not that someone had underestimated the number of medical cards.

Comment on this

It was alleged that there were 75,000 such medical cards and that was the basis of the deal.

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

I agree absolutely. If I had a choice, I would like to stop paying this money but I do not think the Health Service Executive is in a position to make that decision in the immediate future because it is still involved in an IR process. I told the committee previously that, given the issue of industrial relations with the highly unionised health service workforce, it was important peopled realise many of these deals imposed significant costs on the health service and, therefore, had an impact on the services delivered. Such matters are often portrayed in the light of the Government, or the Department, refusing to deal with a bunch of well meaning and caring people.

Comment on this

They say all politics are local and as Professor Drumm is present today, there is an issue I must raise with him. A plan for the use of an alternative site for the national children's hospital has been lodged. The Department painstakingly examined the McKinsey report and selected the Mater Hospital site as a result. What is the current situation regarding the planning application lodged today — this may be outside Professor Drumm's remit — and the delivery of a national children's hospital?

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

As Mr. John O'Brien is head of the transition group charged with initiating the process to deliver the national children's hospital, I will ask him to comment.

Comment on this
Mr. O’Brien

Where is the M50? Is the committee member referring to that big parking lot circling the city? An individual, identified in this morning's newspapers, made an application for planning permission, having previously made a submission to and been interviewed by the original task group regarding a similar project, in the vicinity of, although perhaps not on the same site. Contrary to newspaper reports, nothing new has been presented that was not, by and large, part of the considerations of the original task group.

Comment on this

Effectively, is the planning application that has become public knowledge today something the HSE has already evaluated?

Comment on this
Mr. O’Brien

It may not have been precisely what the individual had sought planning permission for but the same grouping made a submission to the task group that made the recommendation that the national children's hospital be built on the Mater Hospital site. This submission would have been considered within the framework of locating a hospital on a greenfield site in that general vicinity.

Regarding the site to be given to us by the Mater Hospital, this is not a Mater Hospital issue. The Mater Hospital will cede a site, free of charge, fully unencumbered to the HSE to build the new hospital. It will be independent of the Eccles Street site, straddling the site to the North Circular Road. The transition group is in the process of securing this site from the Mater Hospital. The critical issue concerns the development of what we call a framework brief — the description of the hospital. It will cover factors such as model of care and how the service will function and will take around three months to complete. This will form the blueprint for a development board which is to be established to develop the hospital on the site. It is difficult to put a precise timeframe on the development but it will probably take four to five years to complete.

Comment on this

Not everyone has been fully supportive of this idea and the co-location argument has also been made. Does Professor Drumm believe any of the other options make sense or is the matter closed?

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

I did not come to this saying I would build a co-located hospital. I said for many years that we needed an international review to get beyond the internal fighting between the children's hospitals which had paralysed progress. As a result, McKinsey was brought in and, despite the confusion, had a great deal of interaction with 19 centres across the world and came forward with a very clear recommendation that we needed one tertiary centre. It is amazing that we needed international agreement because it was self-evident to everyone with a knowledge of children's health care matters in dealing with complex diseases that what had gone on for 20 years was a disgrace.

The location of the hospital was the second issue and McKinsey stated that ideally it should be co-located with an adult facility. That did not provide me, or anyone else, with an à la carte menu to make decisions. My job was to say on behalf of the HSE what had been described. We had a meeting, which we thought might be fractious, with all interested parties, including the children’s hospitals and parents’ groups, in a local hotel and, remarkably, everyone thought the plan was wonderful. Reaching that point was considered a wonderful achievement but, lo and behold, not everyone thought it was so wonderful when we went to pick the site.

On the choosing of the site, there has been a great deal of emphasis on paediatric input and Dr. Berman, with his places in Florida, who contributed to the McKinsey review. As a site had to be picked by experts in the areas of infrastructure, transport and so on, the main part of the group was comprised of engineers and architects. The third group, critical to this, was comprised of population health doctors — those who plan for the services which will be required in the coming 20 or 30 years and determine what demographic changes will mean for services. I was a paediatrician; I have no expertise when it comes to population health matters and demography but it is funny how a remarkable level of expertise seemed to appear in these areas. Paediatric input is now needed at this stage of the process when, as Mr. O'Brien said, we are setting up the framework of what should go into the hospital. It is ironic that at the point where we needed engagement at this level, people suddenly decided not to engage. It is now that we need huge paediatric input.

Through having many experiences with them — I was part of the group for 15 years — I am hopeful and convinced that the people on the Crumlin site who have contributed so much to child health care in this country are absolutely committed to doing what is right. There will always be fear in a process of change, but I believe the people on that site will commit to this and they are central to getting it right.

Comment on this
Joe Higgins Deputy J. Higgins Socialist Party

Mr. Scanlan, I am seeking further clarification on the point on which the Cathaoirleach pressed you earlier, namely, the costs of the post mortem inquiry which is more accurately known among ordinary people as the inquiry into the scandal of organ retention. When the legal costs are laid in front of us, even for someone like me who has witnessed in this committee inordinate figures arising from legal costs to tribunals, it still shocks. How can the Department have agreed to circumstances where, from March 2001 to March 2005, €7.7 million in legal costs are spent? Not only that, €5.6 million of that sum is divided between three individuals. I thought it was a misprint. It was €2.5 million for the chair and two barristers got €1.65 million each, approximately €412,000 per year over four years.

When I read in the Comptroller's report that the inquiry team caused 54 bankers' boxes and materials to be furnished to the Department of Health and Children, it came to mind that perhaps the boxes were stuffed with returned fees from the barristers who had an outbreak of decency considering that after four years they had produced a mishmash. It was either that or the fork-lift on which the 54 boxes were brought must have been made of solid gold paid for by the barristers. It beggars belief. One can understand how these figures would cause outrage to the ordinary taxpayer.

Mr. Scanlan did not fully clarify the position to the Cathaoirleach. Before this inquiry was launched, did the Department of the Health and Children sign off and agree that these barristers would get €400,000 per year and the chairperson would get €2.5 million overall?

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

I can confirm that the figures the Deputy has are correct. The Chairman asked if agreement had been reached beforehand that people would be paid those amounts per annum or in total. This was not agreed. Brief fees and daily fees were agreed and approved at the outset by all the relevant parties. That was the nature of the remuneration system for legal people involved in this inquiry and, to the best of my knowledge, this was in line with the arrangements applicable to other tribunals.

Comment on this
Joe Higgins Deputy J. Higgins Socialist Party

Let us take the example of barrister X. Barrister X sent a paper to Mr. Scanlan's desk outlining how many days he worked and stating his fee. How much per day did the barristers get?

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

Broadly speaking, claims were certified by the chairman, submitted to the Department and paid on that basis. The Deputy is broadly correct in how he described the process. The documents I have are not dated, but the currency is punts so it must be back in the early days. The chairman had a brief fee of £30,000 and a daily fee of £1,500.

Comment on this

Is that in punts or euro?

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

That figure is the total in punts and I do not have it converted to euro.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Purcell have a converted figure?

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

Yes. The brief fee for the chairman was €38,092 and the daily rate was €1,902. The brief fee for the two senior counsel was €31,473 each and they got the same per diem rate of €1,902.

Comment on this

In the Comptroller and Auditor General's report, there is a record of a letter from the chairperson to the Minister dated February 2001. The chairperson sets out the terms under which the team were embarking on the inquiry. She indicated that it would take substantially longer than the six months envisaged. She also indicated that she would require at least one senior counsel on a full-time basis. She also indicated that she and two members of the legal team would be operating with flexibility and this would allow them to tend to legal work other than that of the inquiry. She felt this was necessary in order to maintain connection with the Law Library and their respective practices.

Therefore, the individuals in question were not full-time and were able to work with flexibility. When Mr. Scanlan completes his round of questioning with Deputy Higgins he might return to this point. How many days did they dedicate to private practice and the inquiry?

Comment on this
Joe Higgins Deputy J. Higgins Socialist Party

This is worse. We have three moonlighting lawyers holding the taxpayer to ransom. In view of what we are hearing today, the Law Library, or certain elements of it, should adopt an effigy of Dick Turpin as its mascot.

After seven or eight months had passed and the bills kept arriving, did bells not start howling around the Department of Health and Children saying that this could not continue? Why was not it stopped?

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

As recorded in the report, there was a point at which the chair of the inquiry told the Minister it was not envisaged that the work could be carried out within the six months. I understand an 18-month period was then agreed. When it became apparent, in the summer of 2002, that the deadline was unlikely to be met, alarm bells certainly rang. There was a great deal of discussion about this and the Minister again met the chair. Throughout the process it was becoming clear that a deadline would be missed. The Minister met the chair of the tribunal on several occasions. The difficulty is the Deputy's final question. He asked me if the thing should have been closed down. Ultimately, one could say — the facts are set out there — that on foot of the Attorney General's review a decision was taken that the inquiry's proceedings would be brought to a halt at a given date. As the Chairman has already said, that did not translate into what would be seen as a normal report of the type that other tribunals would have provided, but it was brought to a conclusion at that date.

Comment on this
Joe Higgins Deputy J. Higgins Socialist Party

The other question that arises is the nature of an inquiry. I may be simple-minded in ways and I probably am, but why could we not have a few people assigned on reasonable wages to go into the hospitals and ask them what their procedures were, what they did with the organs they retained, where they went and if were they sold to pharmaceutical companies for money? Why do we need to pay people millions to ask a few basic questions of the hospitals concerned, when others could come back with the information?

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

It is recorded in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report that the establishment of the terms of reference were approved by the Government.

Comment on this

We understand your position, Mr. Scanlan.

Comment on this
Joe Higgins Deputy J. Higgins Socialist Party

From the point of view of ordinary people, what amazes me about this is the dignity of Parents for Justice and the parents concerned who had been put through such trauma. This matter was sprung upon them, including the fact that children's pituitary glands had been sold to large pharmaceutical companies. The inquiry should have been able to bring information, closure and consolation, instead of which they got this. Up to 20 December, they were still seeking a meeting with the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Harney. Can Mr. Scanlan tell me if the Minister has agreed to meet them? Is any legislation being drafted arising from this situation with regard to organ donation? I reiterate that Parents for Justice have said how essential organ donation is. For the purposes of medical research, it is necessary for people to donate their remains. If the matter was approached in the right way there would be voluntary donations by bereaved parents. What is the current situation with regard to that?

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

The Deputy is absolutely right in terms of his final conclusions. My understanding is that this was the central recommendation aimed at the Department by the Madden report. It was all around the issue of "appropriately informed consent", or some similar language that was used. That is what caused people hurt — the sense that things had been done without their knowledge or consent. As the Deputy said, most people, if informed and given a chance to give their consent, will agree and would see the benefits of it. On the issue of legislation, the Department is now in the process of preparing proposals — it will go through the normal channels obviously — that would lead to legislation in this area. As regards the actual inquiry, the Chairman acknowledges that I can only repeat the facts as they are. In fairness to all concerned, this was only one of several tribunals.

On the question the Chairman asked me, I have some figures on days. They are only approximate and are only for the Chair as it happens. I am not sure if we have them for the other members. I can give them to you, Chairman. Perhaps we should also confirm them when we go back and write to you, if you like.

Comment on this

Mr. Scanlan should confirm them and write to the committee. We will circulate it in correspondence.

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

I will do that. I think the Deputy asked me another question.

Comment on this
Joe Higgins Deputy J. Higgins Socialist Party

Mr. Scanlon said that other legislation was being prepared arising from this. I have three brief questions for Professor Drumm, before I conclude. As regards overtime in hospitals, the Comptroller and Auditor General gave the example of 22 non-consultant doctors earning €100,000 each in overtime. Another 22 doctors could have been employed full-time on that pay scale. Does the service not have the flexibility to work out in advance what will be required? I know there is always a need for overtime at various times because unforeseen events arise and people get sick. Surely, however, given this example, it should be possible to make provision for that and hire extra staff.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

We agree fully with the Deputy. This is a huge investment of money. As I said earlier in response to Deputy Burton, the flexibility in terms of taking this money back out of the system that has been paid as overtime has not proved to be so simple. We have had to negotiate to take down the number of overtime hours. We are focused on trying to get the European working time directive in operation right across our system. At the moment, it applies to 30% of junior hospital doctors. We are currently in negotiations, under the auspices of the Labour Relations Commission, to get agreement on bringing in rosters that would allow those hours to decrease. As I said to Deputy Burton, we have pilot sites running at the moment whereby we can show how alternate rosters can work. However, we still have to pay the overall overtime while those pilot sites are in operation. It is a bigger issue than appointing more junior hospital doctors. It is an issue of skill mix because there are other grades of people. For instance, with the advancement in nursing we would argue that there is a huge amount of this type of work that can be done by nurses who remain within our system, who are not trainees and who are constantly building up their skills. Therefore, there is a whole skill mix issue about the work we are currently giving junior hospital doctors that could possibly be done extremely well on a consistent basis by other grades, as well. From our perspective, it could be done more consistently going forward because every 1 January and 1 July the system would not be challenged by skilled people leaving it. We are anxious to see a great deal of movement in this area but we need negotiated solutions at an IR level to achieve that. The Deputy's point is accepted absolutely by us.

Comment on this
Joe Higgins Deputy J. Higgins Socialist Party

I am sorry I had to leave for ten minutes for an appointment that I could not avoid, so I hope I am not repeating questions. My second last question refers to the €78 million surplus to have been returned in 2005. I take this to mean that the moneys were available but were not used. If that is the case, why is there not flexibility to look around the country to see where there are urgent requests for extra scanners and equipment, etc? Blanchardstown hospital, for example, has been seeking vital equipment for years, but it has not been provided. Ideally, there should be more funding to meet those requirements but, in the meantime, why can the current system not be flexible and the likes of this reallocation be done at the end of each year?

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

I will ask Mr. Woods to comment on the figure of €78 million in a moment. Deputy Higgins asked why we do not get the money back into the system, which seems like a reasonable approach. That has happened to some degree historically with capital moneys. The plan is to spend the money, but if projects get held up and it is not spent, the obvious solution is to suggest applying it to absolute need. The procurement industry, or the suppliers of equipment such as CAT scanners, have done well out of us doing this. They know we must spend the money by November or December so prices tend not to be competitively negotiated then. Therefore, there is a danger in taking that approach. I will ask Mr. Woods to comment on the overall situation in that regard.

Comment on this
Mr. Woods

On the €78 million, €25 million of that is represented by an excess in appropriations-in-aid, or to put it more simply, we collected more income than we thought. In Vote accounting terms and under normal rules, that excess is returned to the Exchequer. Some €36 million of the moneys was capital related and this has not been lost to the system. Under the multiannual nature of the capital programme, they can be carried forward into the following year and used for health projects. As Professor Drumm said, these moneys help us manage effective procurement of equipment for hospitals and community facilities. Therefore, the major elements are not lost to the system. The appropriations-in-aid are automatically returned and the capital can carry forward.

Comment on this
Joe Higgins Deputy J. Higgins Socialist Party

Perhaps Blanchardstown could be allocated some of the next surplus to be surrendered.

We must come back to discuss these matters again because we have hardly touched on the issue of mental health today. There are issues related to funding and outcomes for that area that we do not have the opportunity to deal with now.

I will finish for now with a question for Professor Drumm. The experience of many of the people who have dealings with the health service leaves them with the impression that it is at times an obtuse bureaucracy and that it is difficult to get a message through to it. In today's newspapers we read the story of a young woman from Waterford who died tragically. Her story has been in the public arena. She had been referred with a strong recommendation to the health service, including a recommendation from a Deputy. Notwithstanding that representations from public representatives may have been devalued by the activities of one or two people, I believe that when representations are made by professionals in the community or public representatives who have seriously examined a situation, made a judgment on it and requested urgent intervention, the intervention should be made. While I am not familiar with all the ins and outs of this tragic situation, I wish to ask whether there will be an inquiry into the case to see whether everything possible was done or what weaknesses existed in the system. It is too late for this family, but an inquiry could teach us some lessons for the service in general.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

That is right. We cannot speak on the specific details of this case, but automatically in a situation such as this we examine all the steps taken to see if there was an error in terms of a decision to do something not being implemented. I agree this is a tragic situation for the family, especially when the person involved is so young.

I would like to speak in more general terms about the issue of contact with our services. As the Deputy is aware, the mental health service can be a particularly difficult area in which to work. Often decisions are made to take a certain step or appropriate action, but these decisions are not like those made in the regular hospital service where a decision to remove a gall bladder is made and all that remains to be decided is the timeframe. In the mental health area, the original decision will often change over a few months. A worker in the field dealing with a person may decide residential care, which is something we want to avoid generally because it is the last choice anybody wants for a child, is no longer the best option. When this happens, the decision is made on the judgment of an individual committed to the care of the person is question.

Such situations are extraordinarily sad for families, but from the perspective of the HSE, they can also be traumatic for the people working with them and with young people who subsequently die by suicide. Often the professional in question has made a judgment decision not to recommend residential care for the young person so that he or she can stay with his or her family. That can turn out to be the wrong decision and be hugely traumatic for the care worker involved. We need to keep that in mind.

The Deputy raised an issue close to my heart, namely, how people interact with the health service. I am a fan of the idea of what we call "key workers". These "key workers" could be the porter in a primary care centre, a social worker or a physician, etc. We will constantly struggle with our complex system in terms of access and feedback if it depends on contact with the HSE as a bureaucracy or as a significant clinical provider. We must get to a situation — something that is happening in some areas of mental health already — across the organisation that facilitates access. Most of the people involved with us on a day to day basis have a chronic illness and this small portion of the population unfortunate enough to be afflicted with a chronic illness need access to a "key worker" so that when they face a problem or crisis, they can pick up the phone and get a response. The problem might not be in that person's direct area of service, but he or she would be responsible for making contacts for the patient within the organisation.

I believe the Deputy has touched on what is a critical need for the health service, namely, the need for a "key worker" within the structure who would link to the person in the community in need of a service. Time and again I remind people that the difficulties of the system are not within the system but in navigating one's way into it. Most people get a superb service once within the system. We must work hard to ensure this process is simplified.

The Deputy may not be aware of our transformation programme, but our ambition for the next five years is to reach a stage where we will have made access easier, people will have confidence in the service we provide and we can be proud of the way we provide it. That is our challenge, but we must start with access.

Comment on this

On the issue of contingencies and contingent liabilities for claims against the health service, what is the situation with regard to MRSA and similar related infections? I sent a letter on this matter, a copy of which I have with me, to Professor Drumm a few days ago. Catastrophic events happen to families within the health system from time to time.

The case raised in the letter I sent a few days ago concerned a woman having a baby who ended up with a serious infection as a consequence and became gravely ill. In the context of the discussion on discretionary medical cards, this woman and her family were amazed to find they got a bill for her emergency treatment because she had to be accommodated in one of the hospitals dealing with the infectious disease she had acquired. I understand bureaucracy, but can Professor Drumm understand the inability of the family to understand how this could happen? When such a devastating event happens in a family, the issues of income and whether the family has access to a medical card arise.

In the context of the earlier discussion of discretionary medical cards, where people acquire serious hospital-related illnesses such as MRSA and MSSA, is there some kind of protocol and path through this for the relatives? In terms of the contingencies, has the HSE a system to address this? The Minister suggests there has been an attempt to address the infection risk side by trying to improve cleansing. I am one of many who now go to hospitals and to visit people in nursing homes only if I carry wipes so that I can wipe my hands, their hands, the bed and the locker table, which is often not cleaned at all. This is a shattering state of affairs. If Professor Drumm undertook a small survey of the people in this room, many of us would be extremely nervous of ending up in surgery unless it was absolutely necessary because of the horror stories we are hearing and experiencing.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

Much of what Deputy Burton stated about MRSA is true, but the first point to make clear is that MRSA is a huge international problem. Everybody quotes a couple of countries in northern Europe that have a low incidence of MRSA. The bottom line is that most countries have misused antibiotics and used them for long periods, which is what has generated MRSA. The bug itself exists in its native form in all of us. Many of us in this room may have MRSA on our skin and transmit it by shaking hands today, and we need to realise that.

We, for instance, now have the figures from a recent study across the UK and Ireland, and Northern Ireland and England have significantly higher prevalence than we have. That is not to say we do not have a high prevalence. There seems to be a feeling out there that in some way this is something that has taken off in Ireland and not somewhere else. There is no reassurance in that except to say that it is not simple and it is not that somebody else has got it perfect.

Equally, in northern Europe, where they have lower levels of MRSA, they have as high a level as us or others of other hospital acquired infections. I stated at this committee previously that there are more devastating infections one can pick up in hospital that are antibiotic driven — clostridium difficile being the common one. They are even more devastating than MRSA. They have been with us for years.

There are several factors we need to take on board and Deputy Burton has hit on the major one. While we want our hospitals to be as hygienic as possible, the evidence is it does not have a massive effect on MRSA. What has the effect is what Deputy Burton is talking about — people washing their hands as they move from visitor to visitor or patient to patient — and there is no doubt that we have to get far more focused on that within our own structures to stop it spreading.

We also have to realise that it is a significant risk coming into hospital. We have to reduce the average length of stays in hospital, which by international standards are high, so that people spend as little time as possible there. We really have to make people aware that if they go in for surgery or they are debilitated in any way, they are specifically at risk.

After an earlier one of these meetings, I was accused of trying to hide the figures. Far from it, I was pointing out that giving the figures for MRSA in the oncology unit in St. James's Hospital on the same list as that giving the percentage figures for MRSA for a general hospital in the country has to be interpreted in the light of what the committee is speaking about because there are certain groups of patients who have been exposed to antibiotics in high-risk units that are much more likely to have them. That was portrayed as me saying that I would not give the members the figures. I was saying that one must give the figures in the context of relevance.

Can we take on this problem and succeed? Yes, but slowly. One will not wipe out MRSA until antibiotic prescribing pharmacists play the biggest part in it in terms of watching and controlling how physicians prescribe antibiotics and bring in a cautionary note to that. In terms of bringing down the overall existence of the organism, what we have to control is the spread of it. Hand washing, as simple as it is, is imperative and it does not cost money; it is what we do every day.

From the point of view of medical cards, nobody should be billed for any room in the system when they did not ask for a private room. Everybody is entitled to be treated free in the hospital system. At least, that is the way I would see it. It is a statutory right.

Comment on this

A healthy woman in her 30s acquired this infection but would not have been at risk otherwise. As a result of acquiring this illness, she then had to be treated in a hospital dealing with infections and was sent a bill for €600.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

In terms of statutory charges for bed days or whatever, whether we were going to levy charges or not would clearly be a decision for the Department. The same is the position in the case of medical cards — that is a decision for the Department. I would just caution that the existence of MRSA in the community and, as I stated, within this room is something of which we are not yet aware.

Comment on this

Perhaps I did not explain myself well. This person is now facing colossal medical bills for treatment that will take a significant period of time. I am confident the hardship fund will deal with that but the person's spouse must take her to and from hospital regularly to be treated. The person's life has changed. Six weeks ago this couple in their 30s were both working and paying a mortgage, and now one of them is gravely ill with a hospital acquired infection. The point is that when it happens it is a catastrophic event for people. Has the HSE got some kind of a system where people can relate to what they are going through and how they may deal with it? Obviously, the financial implications of becoming ill like this for young people with a mortgage are horrendous.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

Apart from hardship funds and being able to use discretionary funds at that level, we certainly are not in a position to make a policy decision about whether we will supply medical cards or whatever to people who acquire MRSA.

Comment on this

Does the HSE even have a central system for such a person, who six weeks ago knew nothing about this and for whom this will have grave implications for her life and family for quite a long period? I hope the person will recover. However, the person must learn all of this on her own and it is devastating when it happens. This person suffered heart failure as a consequence of this event. As I stated, I wrote to Professor Drumm earlier about it and I have a copy of the letter with me.

I am sure the Chairman is well used to this. When this trauma happens in a family, there does not seem to be a central contact point in trying to find one's way through the maze of what one must deal with in coming to terms with this. There was a reference when the HSE was set up to a concept called shared services, along with PPARS. Shared services seems to have gone by the board now. Is there, even in the HSE concept, some notion of a shared or common point at which people who are being devastated by this change in their circumstances can get access to uniform information?

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

In terms of somebody who has suffered a devastating event such as that of which Deputy Burton speaks, the primary source of that information has to come from the clinical team with which they are dealing. That is from where the HSE would have to get that information. As Deputy Burton described, this infection can affect a person in many different ways and there are a number of other really serious infections like this. The responsibility for dealing with people in a caring way and dealing with how this occurred has to rest with the local clinical team and with the wider support.

Comment on this

The clinical team does not deal with the costs that a couple in their 30s with a family who are paying a mortgage and working have to deal with.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

Our scope there is, as we discussed earlier, through issues like discretionary medical cards. We could issue a discretionary medical card in that situation and certainly we would be perfectly open to doing that.

Comment on this

I have the details and I will give them to Professor Drumm. I gave them to his office and to the Minister's office. I will give them again.

My final question is in the context of Professor Drumm's comment that the HSE is continuing with PPARS. Has the notion of shared services been abandoned? If so, with what will it be replaced? The Estimates for this year were cast in terms of the old health boards and not the new regional groupings. What accounting structure is in place? Have shared services been abandoned and, if so, what does this imply? I accept that more information may be forthcoming when the Revised Estimates emerge at the end of February. Will Professor Drumm indicate what is happening?

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

Absolutely. The process of introducing shared services into the HSE was examined by a group of people charged with considering the business case for bringing such services on board and how these could then be implemented. The first stage was carried out and we considered what would be required — in terms of the changes that would need to be introduced — to put in place shared services in the areas of finance, HR, procurement and ICT. Finance is probably the largest area in respect of which such services could be introduced. We then considered how shared services might be implemented. Our conclusion in this regard was that the new system would be best implemented through the individual directorates. Instead of moving large numbers of people out of the various areas and into new shared services, we will centralise shared services relating to finance, HR and procurement within those respective areas. Shared services are being implemented according to a model that we consider to be the best for us.

Comment on this

That is a completely different model from that which was originally advertised, particularly those on the political side. The original intention behind the HSE was to provide shared services, whether through PPARS or in respect of other functions——

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

No.

Comment on this

We are not concluding our deliberations on this matter today. The Deputy will, therefore, have a further opportunity to pursue that matter in greater detail.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

The original idea behind the HSE related mainly to the provision of clinical services on a consistent basis throughout the country. Many of the points raised at this meeting are relevant in that regard.

In terms of business functions, shared services represent one of the gains. Such services are still being implemented. The model we are using is employed by many major corporations. We examined the entire process and this is the model we have identified as being the best, from a business point of view, from our perspective. In three to four years time, we may have common financial and human resource systems. In such circumstances, we might alter the model at that point. However, this is the best way to proceed at present and our decision in this respect has been validated by expert input from outside the organisation as well as from within. We do not want to place ourselves in a straitjacket in respect of how to proceed. We have learned from past experience in this regard.

Comment on this

Professor Drumm conversed earlier with Deputy Dennehy regarding the controversy involving the IPU. Will he provide a succinct summary of the position and does he have suggestions regarding how the logjam might be broken?

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

No. The position as regards the Irish Pharmaceutical Union is that a joint approach was taken by the Department and the HSE to see how maximum value for money could be achieved in respect of our pharmaceutical spend, which, in terms of drugs and devices, is approximately €2 billion a year. This is an enormous figure even by international standards. It appeared to us that we should be able to obtain significant savings in respect of the spend. There are three legs to the negotiations that normally occur. One must first negotiate with the manufacturers, then with the wholesalers and distributors and then with the retailers. There are many links in terms of ownership across these three groups and, in particular, the final two. We dealt with the manufacturers and moved on to negotiate with the wholesalers and distributors. At that point, the retailers communicated to us in writing to the effect that, depending on the deals we achieved with the wholesalers, we would be affecting their businesses and that they were seeking legal opinion about our right to negotiate with the wholesalers independently of them. That might come as a surprise to members and it certainly did come as one to us.

We were obliged to seek legal opinion of our own, which indicated that not only were we not entitled to negotiate with the wholesalers but that we were prevented from doing so not in the context raised by the IPU but in view of the fact that it was anti-competitive. It emerged that we had no right to negotiate agreements with groups of wholesalers or retailers. Essentially, this means that we are obliged to deal with all pharmacies as individual providers to the system. Does this have knock-on effects outside the system in respect of dentists and general practitioners? The answer is more than likely "Yes".

Comment on this

Is this driven by the anti-competition or pro-competition EU directives? Is it from this standpoint that the legal advice emanates?

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

That is my understanding. I ask my colleagues from the Department who have been involved in dealing with this matter to comment.

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

I confirm everything Professor Drumm stated regarding the way this matter emerged. A joint team has been working on it at various levels of the supply chain. We have spent a great deal of time discussing a payment of €10 million to GPs. We approached this matter jointly in the interests of obtaining value for money for the health service. That is important to bear in mind when one comes into contact with groups that take certain views. My understanding is that the legal advice obtained by the HSE and the Department indicates that, under the law of the land and EU law, we have no choice in the matter. As Professor Drumm stated, it is a major change. We are trying to clarify——

Comment on this

I asked the question because almost every Member of the Oireachtas has received letters from his or her local pharmacist. We require accurate information to allow us to reply.

The second aspect of this matter is whether what Professor Drumm and Mr. Scanlan have said represents the end of the story or whether a way can be found to maintain some form of centralised system rather than being obliged to enter into contracts with individual pharmacies, which would be extremely onerous.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

I need to discover how best to do so but we would be happy to provide the Chairman with a summary of the current position. It would then be a question of whether we would discuss the matter further with this committee or whether we would do so with——

Comment on this

Our guests may return to this committee in the first instance. They may then make a decision as to whether the information should be circulated to every Member of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

Okay. We can also provide clarity. There is a process — it is, I understand, established in other areas — where if an organisation or agency is seen as being in a near-monopoly situation, as the health service clearly would be in respect of how it deals with many of its providers, it is necessary to place advertisements in the newspapers and obtain independent arbitration regarding the prices applied in respect of individual services. One then indicates the price one will pay for a service or commodity and it is the responsibility of individual providers to decide whether they wish to supply it at that price. That is a high-level, but not an expert, opinion. Those are the circumstances in which we currently operate. We can provide an update on the position that obtains.

Comment on this

That would be great.

An issue arises in respect of the provision of out-of-hours services by GPs and GP co-operatives in that financial provision appears to have been made in some parts of the country but not in others. I am particularly interested in the position relating to ShannonDoc because if the issue to which I refer were resolved, every GP in Limerick city would join with their colleagues throughout the county in respect of the provision of the services to which I refer. I understand that a statement of claim has been submitted which would, if approved, increase the grant-in-aid to the co-ops. If Mr. Healy is familiar with the matter, perhaps he might report on the progress that has been made.

Comment on this
Mr. Healy

Negotiations are taking place with the GPs in ShannonDoc. As I understand it, the GPs have agreed, in principle, to enter the co-op in Limerick. The discussions are at a sensitive stage and perhaps we might report to the committee in the coming weeks on the conclusions reached therein.

Comment on this

That is fair enough.

What is the position regarding the psychiatric unit at Limerick Regional Hospital? This project has been left hanging for many years and an inquiry took place in the aftermath of a suicide. The inquiry found that the physical structure of the facility made it impossible for staff to ensure that there will not be a repetition of the tragedy to which I refer.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

I will have to come back to the Chairman——

Comment on this

In effect, it is a refurbishment and reconstruction project.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

The Chairman asked whether it is progressing.

Comment on this

It was the subject of a parliamentary question last session and the Minister replied that it would shortly go to tender.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

It will take a few minutes to check that information.

Comment on this

Professor Drumm dealt with the issue of breast screening on a national basis. A pilot cervical screening programme was carried out in the mid-west region in 1997. At the time commitments were made to extend the programme nationally. We are all aware of the arguments relating to all cancers. However, if breast cancer is identified at the screening stage, a 100% success rate is achievable. A national screening programme would prevent between 75 and 80 deaths among women every year. I fail to see why the successful pilot project has not been rolled out nationally or what is holding it up.

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

The former breast screening board has been changed to a cancer screening board and will be tasked with rolling out the cervical screening programme on a national basis. There is no question from our perspective about the case for doing so but the key issue in a screening programme is that if we offer screening, we must be in a position to provide absolute assurance in terms of follow-up services that patients may need. All this must be put in place. The expansion of the programme is scheduled to commence late this year.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear it. This was decided when I introduced the first cancer strategy as Minister for Health in 1996. This was a given and there was no debate about its effectiveness at the time. There might be a debate about other screening programmes but this was regarded as absolutely effective all the way through. However, it still has not happened. It was always unfair but it is now recognised to be very unfair because if one is a private patient, an appointment for screening does not present a difficulty, whereas if one is a public patient, the position is different.

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

The Chairman is correct.

Comment on this

Inequities are built into the system which, apart from the issue of treating all citizens equally, leave the Department exposed.

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

I accept the points made by the Chairman. We are committed to expanding and rolling out the programme. It will happen later this year but we have to expand it on an affordable basis. That is important in terms of groups we will have to deal with.

Comment on this

Has progress been made in improving neurological services and deploying them on a national basis?

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

I understand that matter was discussed earlier at a meeting of the Joint Committee on Health and Children. Officials who are familiar with it were in attendance but I have not heard how it went.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Scanlan forward a letter to the committee on the matter?

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

Yes.

Comment on this

Will he do something similar regarding rheumatology services? In both cases, will he make particular reference to the mid-west region?

Comment on this
Mr. Scanlan

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

Much of what was contained in my report was the result of the diversity of the previous arrangements. They may have had their strengths but it was clear they also had weaknesses. Legacy systems were not joined up and we witnessed the consequences with PPARS and other issues raised earlier. Professor Drumm and Mr. Scanlan are correct to highlight an issue that does not come through in the chapter, that much of what needs to be done must be done in a difficult industrial relations environment. This means that while one knows what must be done and the way to do it, it is not possible to do so while going through the hoops with people who legitimately have vested interests in the delivery of medicine and medical services. Perhaps that did not come through in the report but it was emphasised by the two principal witnesses.

I am not sure whether the committee will have another session on the Vote.

Comment on this

I will be advised by the committee but I am disposed to closing the chapters and keeping the Vote open. I have indicated to both the Department and the HSE that Thursday, 1 March is available and if that date suits, we will meet again.

Comment on this
Mr. Purcell

I have stated that the Appropriation Account for the HSE, in particular, is not the most informative account, even for the cognoscenti of Vote accounting, because of the different systems that had to be amalgamated as a practical consideration, as Professor Drumm explained. However, the HSE's income and expenditure account could be placed on the agenda because it is much more meaningful and a richer source of potential questions for members, which could be a double edged sword for the witnesses.

Comment on this

We will not note Votes 39 and 40. They will be kept for our next meeting when the HSE income and expenditure account will be added to the agenda and circulated to members. Is it agreed to dispose of chapter 13.1 and chapters 14.1 to 14.3, inclusive? Agreed.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

We may have a difficulty. Our board meets on the first Thursday of the month. We may inform it about the meeting and see what can be done.

Comment on this

Every other meeting between now and April has been fixed.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

I will have to come back to the Chairman regarding the psychiatry unit on the Dooradoyle site. Perhaps he will furnish me with more details.

Comment on this

It is known locally as 5B.

Comment on this
Professor Drumm

We probably have it, now that we have the terminology.

Comment on this

I will speak to Professor Drumm afterwards.

The witnesses withdrew.

Comment on this