Vote 10 - Office of Public Works
Contributions 221–450 of 450. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I am trying to ascertain the reason the question of a car park to service the centre was excluded. That was the response given to Deputy Collins.
Comment on this
To follow on from what the chairman of the Office of Public Works said, it is customary that people are brought to conference centres in buses as international delegates would not arrive in cars. This was the basis for the decision.
Comment on this
I refer to paragraph 20.35 of the report of the Comptroller and Auditor General. It relates to the steering group agreeing the allocation of 20% of overall marks to the financial elements of the bid. A comparable project in size and complexity referred to in the report is the Criminal Courts of Justice complex which had a mark of 27% available for the financial considerations of the bid. The Department of Finance expressed concern when the financial criteria was lowered from 25% to 20% and the design and construction weightings increased to 40%. I ask Mr. Nolan to explain the Department's concerns.
Comment on this
I will answer that question. We began with a certain distribution of marks. It was proposed that the distribution be altered slightly. We expressed a concern about cost. A detailed discussion took place at the project steering group and having listened to all the advices, the decision was that the move to 20% was acceptable to the steering group. It took account of the concern that, given the scale of the facility and its vital central role in the generation of the conference business, it was very important to get this right and it was also vital to get the front end of the operation right, in other words, the capacity of the operators to pre-market the facility to international conference organisers. When all these factors are right, the potential to generate the conference business and reap the economic benefit - which is the central rationale of the project - is clearly enhanced. The steering group concluded that overall, it could live with the marking scheme and I think the outcome has borne this out as being the correct conclusion.
Comment on this
We do not know that because we do not know what the other bidder would have done had he been given the opportunity.
Comment on this
If one were to inquire into the detail of the comparison of the technical assessments of both bids, one would see that the successful bidder was a far more developed bid. It is not surprising, seeing as those people had been involved in the preparation of a conference centre for quite a number of years before this particular conference competition. Anyone who was involved in the assessment is completely satisfied that the right outcome was achieved.
Comment on this
We need to be mindful of the fact that the difference is €180 million. One can do a lot of marketing and maintenance for €180 million.
Comment on this
I will point out that the figure of €180 million was a figure put forward as a bid at a point in time. It was not a contracted figure. From what we know of the detail of the technical and operational development of the bid and from what we saw of the presentations, there is a very serious question. I can put it much stronger than that and my colleague on the NDFA, who is very familiar with the bid, might be able to comment. There is a very serious question as to whether that facility could have been delivered at the price and if so, whether it would have provided any value. There is very little point in the public sector procuring a facility which is simply not up to standard.
Comment on this
The chairman was Mr. Phil Furlong, the former Secretary General of the Department of Tourism, Culture and Sport. The members were Mr. Aidan Dunning of the Department of Finance, Mr. Seán Quinn, the chief executive officer of Fáilte Ireland and the then chairman of the Office of Public Works, Mr. Seán Benton.
Comment on this
The marking went from 25% to 20%. However, the percentage used in the Criminal Courts of Justice building project was 27%. Hypothetically, if the ratings had gone from 25% to 27%, who would have won the bid?
Comment on this
I cannot answer that question. The most important point regarding the distinction between those two projects is that there is no operational marketing, third-party revenue element in the Criminal Courts of Justice project. The conference centre is a-----
Comment on this
My question is that if the marking went to 27%, who would have been the successful bidder?
Comment on this
We would be happy to take that question away and write back to the committee setting out the basis of the calculations. In terms of our recollection, that was approximately where the cross-over was. In relation to that, it obviously makes a number of assumptions in terms of changing the weighting. The bidders would obviously have potentially responded differently. Second, they could have resubmitted the same bids. Third, in relation to where they want to go to it, they will have taken slightly different approaches.
I want to add to the earlier reply given to the committee on to the overall weighting of the financial marks, whose importance we were not fully aware of when speaking here as the financial adviser. We would obviously be very careful now in advising anybody on the importance of price and value for money for the taxpayer. The second and third components we now recognise are very important. First is the financial robustness and the financial strength of the entity, which I admit we did not fully understand at the time. I was also working on the criminal courts complex at the same time with the OPW. The third one, which has obviously picked up a lot of what we call the financial marks, is the whole area of commercial sustainability. When the NDFA wants to advise anybody on entering into a contract, we would obviously seek to ensure: it is good value for money; it is financially robust and can do what it is says it is meant to do; and it is financially sustainable and will last the length of the contract. Otherwise we just end up in a very difficult situation for my colleagues in the Department of Finance, given where they currently are in terms of other areas.
Comment on this
If some of the concerns related to operation and maintenance, why did the operation and maintenance marks remain at 30% rather than the design and construction?
Comment on this
Perhaps I can answer that question. We had an initial proposal, which was balanced in relation to where the major costs were expected to arise, which gave due weighting to the fact that the technical element was covering the design and construction of the facility. That was expected to cost in excess of €200 million. Therefore, that had to be given due weight. The operation and maintenance got fairly significant weighting in the marking scheme and a reasonable balance was achieved in the marking scheme, which was obviously available to the bidders when they bid.
Comment on this
My next question is for Mr. Dermot Nolan of the Department of Finance. What guidelines does the Department of Finance have on the treatment of public private contract proposals?
Comment on this
There is a whole suite of guidelines issued by the Department of Finance with regard to public private partnerships. They were developed in a series over two or three years between 2004 and 2007. They cover the various aspects that would arise in public private partnerships: risk attribution; taxation issues; how one composes the public sector benchmark; and how one determines value for money - the various tests for value for money for that. It is fairly substantial; several hundred pages of documentation have been issued and the most recent version went out in 2007.
Comment on this
I do not think the final version we have at the moment would have been out because they would have gone out-----
Comment on this
There were guidelines. There have been various bits of guidance. The most comprehensive version went out in 2007 but there would have been guidelines out before that as well, but not to the same detail or-----
Comment on this
Was that the final Government decision to enter into the contract?
Comment on this
Does the Chairman mean the recommendation to the Government to enter into the contract?
Comment on this
I definitely think the bulk of the guidelines would have been available by then. Yes.
Comment on this
Three or four different suites of guidelines have gone out. The most comprehensive and detailed version went out, I think, sometime in 2007; I am not sure of the exact date.
Comment on this
Perhaps I can answer that question for my colleagues in the Department of Finance. On the guidance, that was in issue at that time. Either in draft or in final form as I recall it, there was the February 2005 Capital Appraisal Guidelines as set out at www.ppp.gov.ie. Second, there was the guidance on the discount rate and how that would be determined. There was guidance on the public sector benchmark. There was also in existence guidance in terms of value for money, test 1, 2, 3 and 4. I can give reassurance that we have followed all that guidance. It is set out in all the reports agreed, adopted and approved because that must happen before my organisation will allow the Accounting Officer to issue a letter signing off on the process and all those reports are available.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Golden telling us that he is happy that the guidelines in existence at the time of the contract were as robust as they are now?
Comment on this
Absolutely, Chairman, and I can give you an undertaking that my colleague who runs this in the organisation, our deputy director, was absolutely assured that all the guidance was followed, step by step.
Comment on this
My final question is on development levies. What development levies were paid by the project?
Comment on this
Perhaps I might come back to the committee on that. I do not know that I cannot find that information just now.
Comment on this
Apologies, I will revert to the committee on whether they were and what they were.
Comment on this
No, I am not. I will revert to the committee with whether they had to be paid and what they were.
Comment on this
I welcome the delegations, especially the chairman of the Office of Public Works. I am glad to see Mr. Tony Smyth, with whom I had some arguments about flooding and such matters. I would appreciate help in the Blackwater valley in Mallow and Fermoy. I see that €95 million has been spent on maintenance and arterial drainage schemes. I ask for an update on the Mallow and Fermoy developments. I also compliment him on the way he has co-operated with the residents in the area. There have been very few hitches, other than perhaps looking for a bit of extra work to be done. The phrase is that we will cross the bridge when we come to it.
Comment on this
The second phase at Mallow is under way and the second phase of Fermoy is due to go to tender after Christmas.
Comment on this
I beg the Deputy's pardon. I will check that detail.
Comment on this
Just one. In Mallow the construction is ongoing and in Fermoy the procurement of the contractors is under way.
Comment on this
I would say the first quarter in 2011, but if the Deputy wants something more specific I will revert to him.
Comment on this
They are on site with 18-month or two-year contracts.
Comment on this
The last page of chapter 21 of public works decentralisation states:
Following the deferral of elements of the decentralisation programme, pending a review in 2011, the movement of approximately 6,600 staff from Dublin to locations across the country has been deferred. 3,148 staff had moved by April 2010 and current arrangements allow for the decentralisation of a further 1,191 staff.
Therefore, the programme of decentralisation is not yet complete. Where will the approximately 1,100 staff be placed?
Comment on this
Examples of the additional locations decided on after the Comptroller and Auditor General compiled his report are Roscommon, Wexford, Tipperary and Newbridge.
Comment on this
They would be the places we would provide in those locations and in one or two others.
Comment on this
The OPW does not have any use for a number of sites. How does it propose to dispose of those sites?
Comment on this
At the moment, the decision on decentralisation is that progress on permanent solutions at any of those locations has been deferred pending the 2011 review. We would not proceed to do something else with them. There is a Government decision on them. It is pending review in 2011.
Comment on this
No. The review of the Government decision that they are required for decentralisation has been deferred until 2011. We will not-----
Comment on this
I would like to ask a few detailed questions on the expenditure side. Page 127 of Vote 10, which relates to the OPW, states that the President's household staff, wages and allowances cost €941,000. How many staff does the President have?
Comment on this
Funding for the President's household staff is provided through the Vote of the Office of the Public Works. That has always been the situation. Is the Deputy asking about the composition of the Vote?
Comment on this
It comprises 26 people - a chef, catering and services staff, a cook, a cook's assistant, full-time and part-time household assistants and some on-call assistants who are needed for certain events.
Comment on this
That is fine. There is reference three lines down to grants for certain refurbishments costing €1.5 million. What were the refurbishments in question?
Comment on this
In that year, the grants in question would have related to such projects as the Mariners Church in Dún Laoghaire, the Irish College in Paris, the Irish College in Rome and Glasnevin Cemetery.
Comment on this
There is a separate reference to a grant that was given to the Leuven Institute for Ireland in Europe. Is that in Belgium?
Comment on this
That accounting treatment was identified when it was created within the Vote as an individual grant. They were subsequently grouped.
Comment on this
The institute there runs educational programmes that are funded on a North-South basis. The construction is complete. The job is finished. The Irish college there offers residential and training courses and other seminars in a European context.
Comment on this
The institute is an independent body. I will revert to the committee with the details. It is a trust.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy asking if it is registered in Ireland?
Comment on this
I will revert to the committee in that regard.
Comment on this
I would also like to ask about the reference to a drainage maintenance project that has cost €18 million.
Comment on this
It involves the maintenance of 11,500 km of drainage channels and 650 flood defence embankments. The maintenance of structures, sluices, pump stations and bridges, and so on, forms part of the OPW's draining maintenance responsibilities. When we do capital works, we subsequently maintain those works.
Comment on this
Page 133 deals with prison projects. On what projects was the amount of money in question spent?
Comment on this
The funds in question were not expended from the Vote of the Office of Public Works. The office acted as an agent for the Irish Prison Service and the Department of Justice and Law Reform in this regard. I will give the committee details of the locations in question. We would have been acting as agents for the Irish Prison Service.
Comment on this
Has the OPW made progress with the new proposed prison for Cork? Is it involved in that project?
Comment on this
The question of what is happening is a matter for the Irish Prison Service in the first instance. We act as agents in procuring properties or arranging construction. Decisions on what might progress are matters for the Irish Prison Service.
Comment on this
Agreement on a site has been reached between the Departments of Defence and Justice and Law Reform. It is now a matter for the OPW to develop it as funding becomes available.
Comment on this
I will revert to the Deputy on that because what he suggests in relation to our involvement might not yet be the situation.
Comment on this
This would have related to prisons such as that in Portlaoise. We were undertaking works on behalf of the Department in locations where it wished us to place contracts. I will revert to the committee with the specific details. I apologise. As this item is not borne on our own Vote, I do not have the specific details.
Comment on this
It relates to funding that came from the Department of Justice and Law Reform for the prisons. I suggest that it more than likely relates to block C in Portlaoise. That was largely where the funding was expended.
Comment on this
I note that €87,000 in compensation and associated legal and miscellaneous costs was paid in four cases of personal injury claims. What exactly does that refer to?
Comment on this
Yes. In the event of injuries, the State Claims Agency acts on our behalf. If the instance occurred on OPW property, the funds needed in the case of a settlement come from our Vote. I can give the committee some examples if it wishes. To which note does the Deputy refer?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy refer to a particular heading? If so, I can give him details.
Comment on this
Yes. Compensation payments totalling €87,000 were made in respect of four cases of personal injury by employees. I will give some examples. Somebody was injured in a lifting incident. One of our employees was involved in an incident with a digger. An employee slipped and was injured at one of our heritage sites. These are individual cases involving employees.
Comment on this
Does the OPW have any plans to put a coffee shop in place at Doneraile Park, which comes under its aegis? The park is very successful. Hundreds of people go there to walk. There is no facility there for refreshments.
Comment on this
I would not say we have any such plans at present. Although we primarily have a heritage remit that focuses on the conservation and protection of our heritage properties, we are conscious at all times that we also have a tourism remit that involves the presentation of these sites. We are anxious to avail of whatever advantage that can be got from sites in the area of tourism. However, as we have funding restrictions, we will seek to prioritise as between-----
Comment on this
Could the OPW not secure a substantial payback from having facilities at sites? I receive complaints from people in Dublin and elsewhere who are unable to purchase refreshments, including simple things such as a cup of coffee, at heritage sites. These are ideal locations for selling souvenirs and a margin would be available. The Office of Public Works is a commercial as well as helping organisation. Is that not the case?
Comment on this
Our remit is around the preservation and protection of the sites. However, we have done a playground and car park which have engendered demand. We are prioritising funding for facilities at heritage sites but there are competing and increasing demands. I take what the Deputy says.
Comment on this
If I thought I could get the advantage from the revenue into the Vote, I would be very happy.
Comment on this
If I am returned next year, I will come before the committee again to meet Ms McGrath.
Comment on this
I thank Ms McGrath and other officials for attending. I have a few questions on decentralisation. I ask Ms McGrath to talk me through the Comptroller and Auditor General's report which states that 3,148 staff were in place in the decentralised locations, of whom 2,403 were in locations where arrangements for permanent accommodation had been progressed. What does the word "progressed" mean in this context? Does it mean finalised or could it also mean that the arrangements are still at the initial stages? Of the 3,148 staff who have been decentralised, how many have moved into permanent accommodation?
Comment on this
The Office of Public Works speaks from the point of view of the provision of places. The persons who occupy positions would be a matter for the parent Department of the decentralising location. We provide the places.
Comment on this
Which of the witnesses present can answer my question? Perhaps the Comptroller and Auditor General can answer it given that I cited his report or perhaps officials from the Department of Finance can reply. The report states that 2,403 of the decentralised staff are in locations where arrangements for permanent accommodation have been progressed. How many of this number are housed in what will be their final accommodation? Perhaps the Chairman will suggest which witness should reply.
Comment on this
I cannot give the Deputy an exact answer but, from my recollection of providing draft figures at the time, it would be a mixture of those sites where, for argument's sake, the permanent accommodation was open and occupied at the time and a number of sites where the permanent accommodation would have been under construction. It would have included some advance parties, in other words, it would not be complete.
Comment on this
Of the 3,148 staff who have decentralised, how many have come from locations other than Dublin to the new locations? I understood decentralisation could also result in staff moving from Cork to Limerick and so forth. Did the programme include this?
Comment on this
The programme has included many things. As pointed out by the Deputy, people can move around the country. Ultimately, the policy is that if 3,000 people have moved to decentralised locations, the OPW's remit is that it will close 3,000 desks in Dublin. That would be a fair presentation of the position. Also, while I came into this in the later stages, quite often all of the posts would have moved from Dublin while the people who filled the posts may have moved from elsewhere. Ultimately, however, there would have been a vacancy left in Dublin.
Comment on this
I understood somebody could move from Cork back home to Killarney or Limerick under the decentralisation programme. If someone moves from Cork to Killarney or Limerick to Waterford, how would a vacancy arise in Dublin? Will Mr. Keane explain?
Comment on this
Yes, I can explain that very simply. For example, if my job was moved to Tullamore, as I do not want to move to Tullamore the job would be advertised Civil Service wide and somebody would volunteer to move to Tullamore. For argument's sake, let us say it is somebody from the Central Statistics Office in Cork. If I wanted to go to Cork, that would be fine and if I do not want to go to Cork, I would stay in the Department of Finance and we would find somebody else to go to Cork. Ultimately, the Department of Finance will either export me to a Department and I have seen-----
Comment on this
The post and the work move and my job in Dublin is ultimately suppressed. Either I retire or I move, let us say for argument's sake to the Department of Transport which somebody else had left to take up another post. Sometimes it is a direct one-for-one replacement in that my job goes or somebody comes into my job in preparation for decentralisation and moves on. Other times, we have had chains of up to seven moves, resulting ultimately in a desk being left empty in Dublin.
Comment on this
It is a little like a game of musical chairs or spin the bottle in terms of where one ends up. In other words, as many as seven people may have to move to accommodate a single decentralised post. A person may move from Cork to Killarney, someone else may move from Killarney to Tralee, someone else from Cork to Waterford and so on to create one vacancy in Dublin. I am a bit lost.
Comment on this
Yes, ultimately that is the case but normally it is much simpler than that and one or two people are involved. If it were a new job and no one else was available, one could recruit for the post. In the days when we were recruiting if the numbers permitted one could have recruited for Portlaoise or Tullamore or whatever. As I stated, if there were people on the list waiting to go, they got first offer and someone who did not want to go moved across into their job if that job was staying in Dublin.
Comment on this
I am becoming more confused the longer the discussion continues. Is it correct that having the 3,148 people move from Dublin to decentralised positions may have conceivably involved 7,000 or 8,000 staff transfers? In other words, multiple staff may move to have one decentralised post filled in Athlone or elsewhere. How many people transferred to deliver 3,148 decentralised posts? From what I gather, one net transfer from Dublin to a decentralised location often involves up to seven staff moving. How does the public service cope with this level of movement?
Comment on this
There are two sets of statistics. About 50% are moving between regions.
Comment on this
Yes, that would be the initial filling of a job. In the last programme, an average of three moves were required to fill every job.
Comment on this
These things have operated on a very planned and risk managed approach. People who wanted to participate in decentralisation were moved into the Departments in Dublin in advance of decentralisation, trained up and moved out when office accommodation became available. In some cases, people were able to move directly to units that were in advance offices. The process moved in phases. As people were ready to go, they left and the staff turnover was managed. There is a normal staff turnover, even without decentralisation, through promotion and interdepartmental transfers.
Comment on this
To achieve 3,148 decentralised posts, approximately 9,500 staff moved. This means that, on average, three persons moved position for every decentralised post. That is the figure Mr. Keane used a moment ago.
Comment on this
That figure was based on the previous decentralisation programme which was a bit smaller. From what I can establish, the actual turnover would have been a little less.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Comptroller and Auditor General might be able to assist me on the matter. What did he mean when he wrote in his report that 2,430 of the staff were in locations where arrangements on permanent accommodation had been progressed? Nobody else seems to be able answer the question.
Comment on this
It is easier if one starts with the bullet point below that, which states that 718 staff have moved to locations where advance offices have been established but the full decentralisation programme has now been deferred. They are in offices where the decentralisation programme will not go ahead. Deputy Fleming should bear in mind that the 2,430 staff are in locations we were considering from the point of view of accommodation. They are in locations where the permanent accommodation is being put in place.
Comment on this
It is either in place or it was in the course of being put in place.
Comment on this
For example, what is the position with the 300 staff who were decentralised to Portlaoise? They have moved, but they are all in temporary offices in 11 different leased locations around the town. Where do they fit into the situation?
Comment on this
I think they are included in the figure of 2,430.
Comment on this
What is emerging is that 718 staff are in advance offices, not their final offices. Half of that entire tranche is in Portlaoise.
Comment on this
That is a significant figure. Half of the entire tranche of people decentralised are currently in temporary offices in Portlaoise. The witnesses will understand me inquiring about that.
Comment on this
We are coming to that. I was leading up to that question. Before I deal with that issue, which is the one big PPP bundle that is in the system to which extensive reference is made, I wish to clear up a few points. What was the average price paid per acre in all those locations?
Comment on this
I have that figure in the briefing material. I will locate it.
Comment on this
The average price per acre is a figure to which people can relate in terms of sites. Perhaps it is there and I missed it.
Page 295 refers to the value for money aspect under various different categories - satellite commuter town to Dublin city, provincial cities, large provincial towns and small towns. There are 34 locations. Which are the towns and cities in each of those locations? There is disagreement between the OPW and the Comptroller and Auditor General in that regard. The OPW considers Newbridge to be a commuter town but the Comptroller and Auditor General said the opposite. Why do two State bodies have different opinions on the matter?
Comment on this
We used property consultants. Clearly, they are professionals. They used a classification process on the lines that have just been described. Since I engaged them as experts I did not consider that I should second guess them. We went along with the advice of the property consultants on the classification of towns. I have no doubt that another property consultant might classify it somewhat differently but I do not have any reason to depart from the classification process as set out.
In terms of looking at the outcome of it, look-back exercises have been done by the OPW itself and in a small number of cases it has come up with situations where the outlay exceeded the benchmarks which its own people set. Many of them were more favourable. The results were similar. The case that was raised was of Newbridge. It is somewhat academic in the sense that the money was moving from the State to another arm of Government, namely, Kildare County Council. Even if it was somewhat over the odds, as long as it is applied by the council for good and useful purposes it is not necessarily money that is wasted. Our classification system was devised by property consultants so that we could bring in to the office the expertise we needed to get a benchmark for those purposes.
Comment on this
The classification determines the conclusions as to whether something provided value for money because it was based on whether it was a Dublin or provincial town issue. That is what happens in the committee every day. People draw conclusions. The taxpayer, through the office of the Comptroller and Auditor General, paid one property consultant to come up with a definition of town categories for this purpose and the OPW, through the taxpayer, has a different set of conclusions as to which towns should be in each category. Did the two organisations not agree they were talking about the same thing before drafting the reports?
I am impressed that the OPW is contradicting the Comptroller and Auditor General's point of view. I always give out about Secretaries General who lie down under the Comptroller and Auditor General. They come before the committee week after week and are afraid to upset him. I am always impressed when someone disagrees with him. I do not say the Comptroller and Auditor General is wrong but I admire people holding their ground if they believe what they are saying.
What are the two satellite commuter towns of Dublin city? What are the five provincial cities? What are the 15 provincial towns and what are the 12 small towns? I did not see that outlined in the appendix. Where does Portlaoise come in that system? There are 35 trains in and out of Portlaoise every day. One could almost call it a commuter town. Portarlington has probably 50 trains in and out per day. Some would call it a commuter town. The definition of the categories has a fundamental impact on the way the report was carried out in terms of value for money based on the original categorisation.
Comment on this
Portlaoise was classified by the consultants as a large provincial town.
Comment on this
Mr. Buckley should just tell us the top two. What are the two satellite commuter towns?
Comment on this
On balance it would be better for us to give the detail subsequently because it is quite involved and substantial.
Comment on this
Two locations are listed on the chart on page 114 as satellite commuter towns to Dublin city. That report is in front of me. The OPW disagrees with the definition. I just want to know the two locations in that category in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report. I did not write the report. I would like to know.
Comment on this
If Drogheda is considered a satellite commuter town to Dublin and Newbridge is not it would suggest, at its mildest, that there is a very subjective basis to the report. I am just trying to understand what is in that category.
Comment on this
Drogheda and Navan are the two satellite towns.
Comment on this
The large provincial towns include Newbridge. It is as close to Dublin as Drogheda or Navan. I can sympathise with the OPW coming to a different view to that outlined in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report. A report will go out from this meeting suggesting that something was under the benchmark or provided value for money based on assumptions on whether a town should be considered a satellite town of Dublin or a large provincial town. I am probably labouring the point too much. I need to see the list of the 34 locations and how it was worked out because the OPW has picked one example and while I do not say it is right, I understand the point it is making. Drogheda and Navan are in one category for assessment by the Comptroller and Auditor General but Newbridge is not in that category. I am sure the Comptroller and Auditor General will forward a note on the matter to the committee.
Comment on this
We can certainly provide a note on the detail behind the actual figures in the report. However, I would stress-----
Comment on this
I understand from where the Deputy is coming. Normally when we carry out assessments, we operate on the basis of our own work. Here, however, we are dealing with an area of expertise that is outside our comfort zone. As a result, we employed consultants. Having received their report and discussed it with them, it would be wrong of me to second guess them because, as the Deputy correctly pointed out, my office, as part of the State, paid for the report. Why should I substitute my view for theirs subsequently? I would not have done that, I would have accepted their view.
Equally, the OPW would have had a similar benchmarking exercise carried out. What I would like to stress about this matter is that it is not an exact science. It is purely a set of professional opinions on both sides. The classification system that each would use would be crucial. Obviously, we could all have quibbles with regard to that classification system. However, if it is their professional judgment, I do not see how I could depart from it. What I set out is a yardstick, based on the opinion and professional advice I received from the consultants.
Comment on this
In such circumstances, the Comptroller and Auditor General will not object if I put to him the question we pose to witnesses each week, namely, which consultants carried out this exercise and how much were they paid? That is a fair question.
Comment on this
We will provide that information to the Deputy. I do not have it in my possession but I will include it with the note I have already committed to supply to the committee.
Comment on this
Would the Comptroller and Auditor General not have consulted the OPW in respect of its view on the definition rather than hiring external consultants?
Comment on this
The difficulty is that when one is examining the performance of the OPW, there is no point in using the way it operates as a yardstick to judge that performance. If there is going to be any meaningful challenge within the system, it must come from some professional who is outside that system. That is why we employed the consultants.
Comment on this
However, 90% of the audit work carried out by the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General is reliant on information supplied by the organisation that is being audited. I do not understand-----
Comment on this
Obviously, there are independent judgments. The entire point of auditing is that one makes such judgments. The first point the Deputy made is that we rely on information supplied. However, we rely on it after engaging and challenging. In order, therefore, to do the latter, one must use the appropriate mechanism to discuss the issue and engage with the relevant organisation.
Comment on this
I am seeking to tease this matter out because I am of the view that there is a conflict. People tend to take what the Comptroller and Auditor General says as gospel. It is certainly printed as if that were the case. Now we have discovered that it is subjective in nature and that consultants are supplying opinions which may be in conflict with each other. The OPW is the organisation in the State which possesses the greatest level of knowledge relating to property and it has a different opinion. I cannot glean from what has been provided that this is just a subjective view.
Comment on this
Okay. Will Ms McGrath provide information on the total cash outturn to date in respect of decentralisation, I am referring to the sale of offices in Dublin or wherever, the sale of land banks, etc., and on the total costs that have been incurred?
Comment on this
To the end of November, the figure for expenditure is approximately €354 million. The figure for disposals is €356 million.
Comment on this
-----there are projects which have yet to be completed. We are completing the projects relating to Roscommon and Tipperary Town and there is a traditional procurement process relating to Portlaoise which must also be completed. These projects will give rise to a number of outgoings. The figures I provided largely relate to capital. I should reflect that, as a result of decentralisation, we have ongoing leases and these are reducing. We are surrendering certain leased properties as we provide permanent accommodation.
In the context of the portfolio in Dublin, earlier I provided the example of surrendering annual lease rent of €1.6 million in respect of one building. This was possible because, as a result of decentralisation, we were in a position to accommodate staff in an owned estate in Dublin. That process is continuing and we will be releasing and surrendering in respect of properties in Dublin that are leased. That is an overall factor. If one considers the position just in respect of capital, it is €354 million in costs against €356 million in disposals.
Comment on this
Has Ms McGrath had any luck in obtaining information relating to the average price per acre or will she forward that at a later date?
Comment on this
If the Deputy does not object, I will send the information on later.
Comment on this
That is fine.
The final issue to which I wish to refer is the extremely large public private partnership, PPP, bundle relating to the offices in Carlow, Portlaoise and Mullingar and the fact that there was a preferred tenderer involved. I have been in contact with Mr. McMahon in respect of this matter on a number of occasions. Work on the Carlow and Mullingar offices has been postponed and the Government has made a decision to the effect that the office for Portlaoise should proceed as a stand-alone project. I understand NAMA recently placed the preferred bidder into receivership or examinership. Would the OPW consider contacting NAMA to discover whether it can obtain the property rights from it at a good price, particularly in view of the fact that all of the work relating to design, planning, etc., has been completed? I suggest that, in the interests of taxpayers, the OPW should contact NAMA in respect of this matter.
I understand there has already been a write-off of €600,000 in fees in respect of this project. Will Ms McGrath indicate the costs to which this write-off relates? I am not referring to site costs in this regard because the site in Portlaoise is owned by IDA Ireland and, therefore, remains in the ownership of the State. In light of the fact that there is an opportunity to acquire the intellectual property rights relating to the planning work done in respect of a building the OPW wanted to construct there is - I hate to say this in these recessionary times - an outstanding opportunity for the taxpayer to obtain those rights at a very good price.
Comment on this
To be clear, the preferred tenderer is not in NAMA. The preferred tenderer-----
Comment on this
No, the Deputy is referring to the construction element of the consortium which was to provide-----
Comment on this
Therefore, the intellectual property rights remain with the consortium as distinct from the construction element.
Comment on this
The Deputy is correct in stating that a decision has been made to proceed with the project for Portlaoise on traditional procurement lines. The OPW is awaiting confirmation in respect of the overall numbers from the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food and the decentralisation implementation group. This confirmation will enable us to have certainty with regard to what we are procuring. However, I take the Deputy's point. Should the building be what was originally intended-----
Comment on this
The detailed design has been done, planning permission has been acquired and the specifications relating to the construction tender work are in place. Why is Ms McGrath referring to the size of the office and the number of people who will work there? It is a matter of public record that the planning permission was granted. In such circumstances, is the OPW not in a position to acquire the rights to which I refer?
Comment on this
In acquiring those rights, I need to have confirmed that the operational requirements which obtained when the planning permission was granted remain the same.
Comment on this
If the project had proceeded under the traditional method, the OPW would not be obliged to ask that question at this stage. Why is the question being posed now?
Comment on this
No, the times have moved and changed for all Departments in respect of numbers, staffing and employment control frameworks. Departments are contracting-----
Comment on this
So the OPW has introduced a new element in respect of the remaining parts of the decentralisation programme, some of which have been deferred. With regard to the projects that are proceeding, it is going to try to discover whether what was being planned last year remains valid. That is a new aspect about which I have never heard before.
Comment on this
This relates to proceeding to acquire the intellectual property rights and I need to receive confirmation that the office, as originally envisaged, is what is required to be built.
Comment on this
How many properties are leased temporarily? Out of the approximately 600 staff in Portlaoise, half are still in the old building. There are 11 different leases costing more than €1 million per annum.
Comment on this
There are 11 private leases. What is paid on these? The Comptroller and Auditor General's report states 718 staff moved to locations in advanced temporary offices, half of whom are in Portlaoise.
Comment on this
The Deputy is correct. The leasing is in the order of upwards of €1 million. I understand it is nine buildings but it maybe 11 leases.
Comment on this
We will supply the information we undertook to supply in the course of this meeting.
The issue of whether the all-in cost of accommodation is a fair way of assessing the Office of Public Work's outlay on leasehold premises was raised. I believe it is. It brings all the leasehold acquisitions to a common measure for annual accommodation costs and identifies the true rental paid for offices of a modern and immediate-use standard. It is also in line with the Office of Public Work's cost-per-job calculation which takes account of fit-out costs. It aligns with the accounting treatment for depreciating leasehold enhancements, as set out in the accounting standards. That amortises the cost over the useful life of the asset which in this case would be the term of the lease. I stress that the benchmark we set was in terms of provision of modern office accommodation and not just premises in which the shell or core had been constructed.
As the Accounting Officer said in her comments recorded within the report, a full spectrum of conditions applies when one rents a property. To put it in simple terms, it is like having two pockets, taking the rent out of one and the enhancement – fit-out costs – out of the other. One has to find a common yardstick by which one can merge the two to get the true all-in annual cost of accommodation. That was the perspective we used when we did these calculations.
Comment on this
Thank you, Mr. Buckley. Does the committee agree to note Vote 10 and dispose of chapters 20 and 21 of the Comptroller and Auditor General's 2009 annual report? Agreed.
I thank the witnesses for attending today's meeting.
The witnesses withdrew.