Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland - 2009 Accounts
Contributions 140–291 of 291. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
There could be a royalty, but at the moment there is no provision for a royalty.
Comment on this
If a lease is being signed on a certain basis-----
Comment on this
I am trying to make the point that while a 40% tax rate might seem high, if there is a gas or oil field in the Atlantic Ocean the size of those in Dubai, effectively the only yield we get is the taxation. There is no yield to the State via a royalty route.
Comment on this
That is quite a high tax rate by international standards.
Comment on this
There is a provision for €3.5 million for the national seabed survey. Excuse my ignorance, but what is the national seabed survey?
Comment on this
The national seabed survey is being undertaken in co-operation with the Marine Institute under the auspices of the Geological Survey of Ireland. It is basically to try to explore the sea bed in terms of issues such as exposure to pollution, hazards to shipping and marine traffic, and potential for fisheries. It incorporates all that as well as being important in the geological sense and giving early indications as to the prospects for offshore exploration. It is a long-term project.
Comment on this
I would welcome Mr. Dunning's view on the retrofitting of the homes of the working poor under the warmer homes scheme. There is competition for funds. Some people get nothing. If one is working one gets practically nothing from the State. Is there a proposal in 2011 to expand the schemes? Has this point been covered in my absence?
Comment on this
It is a fair point. We are all operating within the constraints on capital resources but will operate the scheme with the available resources. This issue will be covered in the energy affordability strategy. I must underline the point that we are in a constrained situation on the capital budget.
Comment on this
Chairman, I apologise if I raise areas that have been covered. I wish to question the new name of the organisation that we knew as Sustainable Energy Ireland, SEI.
Comment on this
I will turn to the 2009 income and expenditure figure of SEAI on page 7. Has the energy performance buildings directive been discussed? The figure of 4,367-----
Comment on this
Is the Deputy referring to the €4.36 million?
Comment on this
I might ask my colleagues from SEAI to comment on that.
Comment on this
That is the fee income relating to the building energy rating certificates. When an assessor lodges a certificate on the national database, we charge an administration fee. The growth in the fee relates to the growth in the scheme. In 2008 it was starting and 2009 was the first year when many thousands of BER certificates were lodged and therefore the income went up.
Comment on this
It is typically €25 to lodge a certificate on the database.
Comment on this
That is the same scheme. The income pays for the operation of the BER scheme.
Comment on this
Yes, but to the degree there are fluctuations each year, the balance is not always struck. SI 666 of 2007 sets out that the income generated from the registration fees is directly linked to the operation and promotion of the scheme. Each year there is slight fluctuation in terms of how much money was spent on systems and promotion and such things.
Comment on this
BER is a measurement tool to determine the energy efficiency of a building. Is Dr. Motherway satisfied the cost of €4 million or thereabouts for the measurement of the energy efficiency of buildings is good value for money? As well as the cost of measuring the energy efficiency, one has the cost of insulating the building.
Comment on this
As the Deputy mentioned, this is driven by the energy performance of buildings directive. It is our view that it works very well as an information tool for driving behaviour change and, in particular, in the grants we offer to people to upgrade their insulation. It is typically the case that people use the BER as a tool for understanding the state of their home today, the savings opportunity and the financial savings they will make if they invest in insulation. We believe this is working well.
Comment on this
No, the Department. I am assuming the numbers within the Department have reduced between 2008 and 2009.
Comment on this
As I said in my original statement, we have seen a very significant reduction of 21% in numbers in the Department since the end of 2007. We have gone from 340 staff to 270. We have also seen the administrative budget reduced by 36%.
Comment on this
Over that period, there would have been some increases in salary because there was some carryover in 2007. Our salary will be held at the same level next year as this year.
Comment on this
I am perplexed. If the numbers are being reduced and if we assume the Department has lost some lower grade administrative staff along with some higher grade staff, then why have the salaries-----
Comment on this
The salaries have reduced as well over that period. In 2008, salaries were estimated at €17.3 million whereas in 2010 the estimate is €16.2 million. In 2008, the outturn figures came to €18.3 million, €18 million in 2009 and €16.25 million in 2010. I would argue that these are reasonably significant reductions.
Comment on this
No. It was from 2009 onwards that we really saw significant reductions. The figures I have given reflect the reality of the situation.
Comment on this
What is Mr. Dunning's view on payments towards semi-State bodies under the remit of his Department, such as the ESB, Bord Gáis and others? It is a real slap in the face for people who are on very small incomes and seeing their wages being reduced to see people earning hundreds of thousands, a multiple of what the Taoiseach and the Secretary General of the Department earn. What is Mr. Dunning's view on that?
Comment on this
This has arisen tangentially. All I can do is refer to what the Minister for Finance said in his Budget Statement which indicated it was his policy from now on that a cap of €250,000 would be put in place in the public sector. He acknowledged that there were contractual issues that needed to be examined for existing incumbents. I cannot really say any more than that at this stage.
Comment on this
Has Mr. Dunning been given an instruction from the Department of Finance, following the Minister's speech, to the effect that this cap is immediate? There may be contracts currently being negotiated. Has the axe fallen on them? Has it come down that this is the price and that is the end of the discussion?
Comment on this
We have not received any formal instructions at this stage from the Department of Finance in respect of the implementation of that. In fairness, the Minister did signal that further consideration of existing contracts would be required. However, he signalled strongly his determination to do that. Clearly, the Department will implement it.
Comment on this
I appreciate what Mr. Dunning is saying about existing contracts. It is quite possible that there are agencies or semi-States under his remit that are in the process of negotiating contracts. I do not know if there are, but there could be.
Comment on this
That is a fair point. Any contract must be approved by our Minister and by the Minister for Finance. I expect that would reflect the new policy.
Comment on this
I do not want to labour the point too much, but was the Department in negotiations before the Minister's speech with people in employment in the semi-State companies who were looking for more than €250,000? The ground has changed since the Minister's speech.
Comment on this
There are no vacancies at chief executive level, apart from the position of director general of RTE who has indicated he is retiring soon. There will be negotiation on that vacancy.
Comment on this
Deputy D'Arcy is asking a question that could be asked a different way. Was there anyone monitoring the madness that went on whereby people were getting a salary of more than €500,000? Did anyone ever express a concern that this was getting out of control? We are trying to come to grips with costs at the moment. We asked Mr. McDonagh from NAMA last week the salary scales of people within his organisation. He told us that they would be in the annual report and we said we were entitled to get that information. We got a letter this week which we are publishing today and which effectively told us to get stuffed. We were not going to be made aware of the salaries. We do not want to personalise things but we should be in a position to get the range of salaries from NAMA and other organisations whose employees are being paid from the public purse. We do not expect to be told that Mr. Murphy or whoever is receiving €400,000, but at least we should be given the range of salaries being paid from the taxpayers' purse. We are taking legal advice at the moment on our rights to get this information. We are not accepting the type of letter we got from Mr. McDonagh in recent days.
Comment on this
It was correctly stated that there are many commercial State bodies under the aegis of our Department. The full remuneration of the chief executive is set out in the annual account. There was a particular system of pay determination that had been approved and put in place in respect of chief executives of the commercial State bodies which depended on the particular category of the organisation and was based on a particular range. That primarily came from an independent study which was then considered by the Department of Finance and was then sent on through us to the individual State bodies. The contract would then have been negotiated between the board and the individual in question, but it would have been subject to the approval of the Minister and of the Minister for Finance. That is the history of the situation.
Apart from basic pay, these contracts provided for other things such as performance related pay and other pension benefits that were within the norms that were accepted. Perhaps we can argue about the amounts but they were allowed within the overall template that was in operation at the time. This template arose from an independent study. Department of Finance officials may wish to add to what I have had to say on this. It was within those parameters that the pay of chief executives was decided.
Comment on this
I know what Mr. Dunning is saying. In the case of NAMA, however, we are being told it is sensitive, commercial, and a contract between the individual and the organisation. However, we have heard all this before with the banks and the madness that went on there. Someone must come to grips with it. The committee is endeavouring to do so and has taken a very poor review of the type of letter we received from NAMA. It appears as though no lessons have been learned from people who are there to do a job on behalf of the taxpayer. While Mr. Dunning cannot comment on that matter, my point is that the committee will not accept the type of answers it has been getting from other people.
Comment on this
As I stated, chief executive officer pay in each case is set out in detail in the annual report.
Comment on this
Contracts below that are negotiated within the company.
Comment on this
I am a former member of the Joint Committee on Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, whose members have been told that details regarding the top earners in RTE are commercially sensitive. Everything is commercially sensitive if one wishes to throw out that line. Who drew up the independent report mentioned by Mr. Dunning?
Comment on this
It would not have been conducted under the aegis of my Department.
Comment on this
As I recall, it would have been independent consultants.
Comment on this
Those banding arrangements are known as the Hay scales.
Comment on this
Yes, they were called the Hay scales.
Comment on this
I do not know. While it is not my area of expertise, it was some years ago. It is a system of pay determination informed by an independent report.
Comment on this
I cannot commit to anything in particular. I think it was more than five years ago.
Comment on this
The point I am trying to make is that I assume the aforementioned report was drawn up in a different era. We have entered an era that is different to that in which I assume the report was requested.
I will turn to more bread and butter issues. What analysis has there been of the three programmes for the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland, SEAI? I refer to the warmer homes and greener homes programmes. Has there been independent analysis?
Comment on this
If Deputy D'Arcy has concluded, I wish to ask a question regarding the Department's decentralisation programme. Was Cavan to be the Department's destination?
Comment on this
Yes, Cavan was our destination. As the Chairman is aware, that was put on hold in 2008. There is to be a review next year and as matters stand, we have an advance office in Cavan with 50 employees based there who perform various functions. That was set up not long after the decision was taken.
Comment on this
They are in leased accommodation in Cavan. Did the Chairman mean their physical location?
Comment on this
They are in leased accommodation, which is being leased by the Office of Public Works, OPW, on our behalf.
Comment on this
It is not hugely expensive. I apologise that I do not have the precise figure to hand.
Comment on this
They share the building with other enterprises. There may be some other local authority offices or something like that there.
Comment on this
Yes, it is. Some important functions are located there, such as our salaries, finance and corporate services functions. We find that we have excellent communications with them and video-conferencing works quite well. Obviously there are times when one can be a bit frustrated that one cannot meet in person but that is part and parcel of it. With due respect, the core policy functions, namely, energy, communications, broadcasting and natural resources, remain in Dublin.
Comment on this
Looking at the accounts, under heading 6.2 on commissions and inquiries, it is stated "€458,147 was paid in respect of various expenses arising out of the Department's involvement in the Moriarty Tribunal." Is it possible to get a cumulative figure on the costs paid to date by the Department? Is there a liability in respect of legal fees? Is the Department awaiting a decision from the tribunal as to what fees might be payable by it?
Comment on this
The Deputy is correct. The figure to which he refers relates to 2009. If the Deputy will bear with me, I have to hand another figure. The total legal cost of this module of the tribunal, which deals with the GSM licence that was awarded in 1996, to the Department to date has been €2,511,283.
Comment on this
Yes. Other costs of €434,000 have arisen.
Comment on this
So the figure of €458,000 includes legal and-----
Comment on this
It has cost the Department approximately €3 million to date.
Comment on this
Are other liabilities coming down the track of which Mr. Dunning is aware?
Comment on this
We obviously still are involved in the tribunal. We have a legal team and its costs must be met.
Comment on this
Is the Department's legal team paid up to date?
Comment on this
No huge shock to the system awaits the Department.
Comment on this
No. Clearly, the issues are important from the Department's point of view and from those of the witnesses who are involved in the tribunal in respect of its final outcome. Consequently, it has been incumbent on us to ensure that we are legally represented at it and put forward a position. Obviously, I am reluctant to discuss the tribunal because it still is sitting.
Comment on this
I understand that and we will stick to the figures.
Comment on this
I will be a little parochial in respect of my final question. I refer to the flooding of parts of Cork city that occurred just over 12 months ago, which happened as a result of the release of water by the ESB. Mr. Dunning might set out what the Department of Communications, Energy and Natural Resources has done to satisfy itself that the ESB acted properly with regard to water management at the dam. What steps has the Department taken to ensure that in future, the ESB will have adequate or satisfactory water level management at the dam to avoid a recurrence of the problem?
Comment on this
We have relied very much on the advice we received from the ESB in that regard. We are not in a position to second-guess the ESB technically in respect of what actions it felt it was obliged to take on that occasion. I understand that more recently, it has been in discussions with the OPW and the local authority regarding the management of that dam. Moreover, although I am not fully familiar with this matter, I understand there are issues regarding work that must be carried out within the city itself by the OPW. Although I am not exactly sure what is involved, I believe it relates to the river and drainage works. In any discussions it has had with the local authorities and perhaps before Oireachtas joint committees, the ESB has strongly asserted that the action it took on that occasion was proportionate and correct. If action had not been taken, the situation might have been worse. This is very much a-----
Comment on this
The Secretary General has stated he did not want to second guess it, but it is not exactly an independent body in this affair.
Comment on this
No, but this is primarily an engineering issue.
Comment on this
One must take the advice of engineers. My Department does not comprise technical personnel. I have one technical adviser on the energy side who deals with a wider range of issues.
Comment on this
The Department did not examine the matter to a point where it could be satisfied that the ESB had acted properly at all times.
Comment on this
Did the Department appoint an expert or consultant to satisfy it that everything had been done properly?
Comment on this
We did not see that as being within our remit. Our understanding was that, had these actions not been taken, circumstances might have been worse. The ESB has been in continuous contact with the local authority and other relevant bodies on the matter. It was an unfortunate incident at a time when there was heavy flooding and bad weather. The Department's main concern was to ensure we were aware of what was happening.
Comment on this
The issue was not one of flooding but the management of water levels ahead of the rainy season.
Comment on this
I am amazed that the Department did nothing to check to ensure the ESB had acted properly and that it accepted the ESB's word on everything.
Comment on this
We were not in a position to check. To do as the Chairman suggests, we would have needed to engage external consultants.
Comment on this
The strong opinion of the ESB which has a track record in this regard was that it had acted in a responsible way.
Comment on this
I understand some work was done recently to lower the level of water as a contingency measure.
Comment on this
That is the point. The ESB could have done that last year. The committee won the battle, but I am disappointed that the ESB's word about there being adequate and proper water level management prior to the incident had been accepted. I am also disappointed that the Department, the ESB's parent Department, has done nothing to deal with the issue.
Comment on this
The Department is not responsible for flood relief or flood management programmes. We liaised with and were kept informed by the ESB on the issue and were aware of the work being done by the local authority and the OPW. We did not have the competence to indicate at what level the water should have been. It was an engineering matter.
Comment on this
I can appreciate how bad the situation on the ground must have been.
Comment on this
In trying to get answers it seems no Department is grasping the nettle and there is a need for an independent inquiry into what occurred.
Comment on this
I understand the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government instituted an inquiry. I might have seen something about it, although I was not a party to it.
Comment on this
There has been no independent inquiry. The issue is being passed around Departments and Government agencies and people are still waiting for some action to be taken. However, we will leave it there.
Comment on this
It has been reported in the newspapers that €40 million is being paid to AIB staff in bonuses.
Comment on this
There are two points I wish to clarify. First, the main costs of the Moriarty tribunal will be borne by Roinn an Taoisigh, a separate Department. Second, we remarked on the need for an evaluation. Clearly, as with everything else in the public service, an evaluation must be cost justified. The issue that arose in the report had to do with the extent to which an external evaluation should be carried out. The important factor is that the evaluation should be external to the scheme function, not necessarily to the organisation. From the point of view of achieving value for money and ensuring organisations have systems and procedures in place and practices that enable them to evaluate their operations, we need to see a rigorous review process, culminating in a public report that will be sufficient to demonstrate the effectiveness of the measures taken by reference to their objectives and results and to position the Department for the next round of policy formation. That is what we had in mind when we made the remarks.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Buckley. I also thank all of the witnesses, including Mr. Dunning and his staff, Professor Lewis and the officials from the Department of Finance, for their attendance. Is it agreed that we should note Vote 30? Agreed. Is it agreed that we should dispose of chapter 26? Agreed.
Next week we will resume our consideration of chapter 37 on the SKILL programme. The committee has agreed to invite Mr. William Atlee, chairman of SIPTU's management committee, to the meeting.
The witnesses withdrew.