We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Special Report 76 of the Comptroller and Auditor General: National Asset Management Agency - Acquisition of Bank Assets (Resumed)

Contributions 186–379 of 379. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

In that case, is he guaranteeing to the committee that such transfers must be fully reversed before NAMA will agree the business plan?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Absolutely. Once the memorandum of understanding is signed, the process moves to what we call the heads of terms and legal agreements. If, at any time until we sign the legal agreement, facts emerge which indicate that the borrower has not been acting in good faith or providing information to us, all bets are off.

Comment on this

Are the sworn statements signed at the point of the memorandum of understanding?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

The sworn statements are signed before we engage with the borrower on the memorandum of understanding. We require sworn statements to be independently verified by solicitors.

Comment on this

How can NAMA deal with assets that were transferred prior to the agency's establishment?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

It depends on the timing. The kernel of this issue is whether the person who was transferring the assets was solvent at the time of transfer. If the transfer took place prior to the establishment of NAMA - effectively before 21 December 2009 - one has section 74 of the land and conveyancing Act of 2009 which applies only from 1 December. That is not a long period. For transfers that took place prior to that, one has the Conveyancing Act of 1634. If NAMA or anybody else goes to court, it will have to prove intention to defraud on the part of the debtor.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

In that case, the courts can infer an intention to defraud from the circumstances of the case. For example, if it is quite clear that a person has significant debts to pay and he transfers some of his assets to a relative or a connected person at an under-value, the courts might presume that he intended to defraud his creditors as this would seem to be the obvious consequence of the transfers. In those cases, under the land and conveyancing Act, the person does not have to be insolvent at the time he transfers the property. Showing an intention to defraud future creditors can sometimes be enough to set the transfer aside.

Comment on this

How far back can one go?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

There are two Acts, the Land and Conveyancing Law Reform Act of 2009, which applies from 1 December 2009. There is also a similar provision in the Conveyancing Act (Ireland) 1634. The second Act will probably take us back far enough.

Comment on this

How far back can one go in practice under the legislation?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

I am not a legal expert but I am not aware that there is any particular limitation. The period we are all interested in is probably the period when it was quite obvious that the bubble was bursting and something like NAMA was on the horizon. That probably takes us back only half a dozen years or thereabout. I believe it would be well within the compass of the legislation.

Comment on this

What powers does NAMA have to deal with assets that have been moved offshore?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

Again, we are dealing with the debtor, as such. That is the issue rather than where the asset is located. In the first place and to return to the consensual approach, if we are trying to persuade somebody to transfer assets back into NAMA as part of the business plan process, it does not matter to us where the assets are, they have to come back. To go down the legal route - I am open to correction on this - I do not know that the location of the assets is a particular barrier.

Comment on this

Is there anything NAMA can do if a developer has moved assets to the Cayman Islands, for example?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

If the developer still owns the assets, we have a hold over the developer. If the developer has transferred assets - I am presuming the transfer will be to a family member, a spouse or somebody like that, as is usually the case - the issue again is one of using the legislation.

Comment on this

In such circumstances, can NAMA investigate the spouse, son or daughter?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

We can certainly make every attempt to do so. We are engaged with the debtor and we can certainly do that through the debtor.

Comment on this

Mr. Daly used the term "consensual". This type of approach did not work terribly well in the area of tax evasion. NAMA should not depend on the people in question volunteering information.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

No. As I said earlier, the term "volunteering" is probably a bit of a misnomer because a question arises as to whether the individuals in question would volunteer the information if we were not engaged with them in a rigorous business plan process. They need us to help work out their debts to NAMA. For this reason, we have quite extensive leverage over them. When I say voluntarily transfer assets back, I am really talking about them probably being forced into a corner as part of that process.

Comment on this

I am not convinced about that. This country's record of pursuing people is not very good. Is Mr. Daly satisfied that the penalties are adequate should NAMA decide to take the vigorous approach we would all like it to take? The agency can only operate on the basis that people will volunteer information and co-operate if non-disclosure or defrauding the organisation carries major penalties and it is not worth the person's while to take such a risk. Is Mr. Daly satisfied that the legislation is sufficiently robust to achieve this outcome?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

It has not been necessary to go down the road of using the legislation as yet. All I can say to the Deputy is that we are using the whole process with rigour. I assure her that the process of engagement with the debtors is not easy for them. We are pursuing that with every possible rigour. The proof of the pudding is in the eating. The reality is that the process is working in the engagement with the top 30 to date. As Mr. McDonagh said, 13 or 14 memorandums of understanding have been signed. In each of these cases we are satisfied with the disclosure that has been made and in relation to the transfer of assets back in. While the process takes a bit of time and considerable persuasion, argument and toing and froing, it is working. As to whether the penalties in the Act are adequate, at this stage we have not had any reason to test them so we do not have any reason to say they are not adequate.

Comment on this

Progress is slow and the kind of stuff that we saw on the "Prime Time Investigates" programme does not inspire confidence.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

The Deputy must understand the position NAMA is in. Everybody would like to go in, close these people down and deal with them. For a start, we are a State body so we must have a responsible approach. More importantly, if we do not do due process we will end up being judicially reviewed. We will end up down in the courts and the whole process will slow down and collapse. I can understand the frustration that exists. I assure Deputy Shortall on behalf of the board and executives of NAMA that we are fully aware of our responsibilities.

Comment on this

I wish to make two very quick points. First, this committee has expressed concern in the past about shortcomings in company law. Has Mr. Daly come to the view that there are gaps in company law in terms of trying to pin down a number of these issues?

To return to the point made by Deputy McGrath previously on where NAMA might become aware of a situation where there was an attempt to defraud, where tax evasion was involved or reckless trading, are there clear guidelines on reporting that to the relevant authority even though it may not come within the direct responsibility of NAMA?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

On the Deputy's question on the adequacy of company law, it is not an issue we would have actively thought through. As we go through this process if we become aware of any defects in company legislation we would not alone be quite happy but off our own bat we would draw attention to them in the relevant Department. As to reporting offences, we have an obligation to pass information to various law enforcement authorities under section 203 of the Act. That is where NAMA has reason to suspect that the participating institution may have committed a criminal offence. It extends to anything else as well. We would be aware of that and alive to it.

Comment on this

Does NAMA have guidelines on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

Does Deputy Shortall mean written guidelines?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

I am not sure we do, but everybody would be aware of the fact that this is the approach that we would want to take.

Comment on this

How would they be aware of that? It is a big undertaking to deal with business plans and many different aspects have to be considered. When one becomes aware of reckless trading, tax evasion or other infringements, surely one should have guidelines for staff in terms of highlighting and reporting it to the relevant authorities?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

I will let Mr. McDonagh deal with the detail. NAMA is a relatively small organisation and the approach of the board and senior management is one that is very well passed down in terms of message to all the staff in the organisation. Mr. McDonagh might wish to add something.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

The Deputy has raised a very good point. That is something of which I am very conscious. When people join NAMA we make them aware of the provisions within the Act. We also make them aware that as a State authority we have reporting obligations and if anyone comes across any matter they are to report it to their head of function. The heads of function report to me and I report to the board. A process is in place in the case of someone coming across anything. Every single business plan is read by the case management team. It is read by me and the senior executive team. It is read and reviewed by the NAMA credit committee which includes two non-executive directors and is chaired by a non-executive director. If it is the case that it falls within the board's remit - most of the major borrowers do fall within the board's remit - then effectively it is reviewed by the board. Many sets of eyes have read the review of the business plan and we are aware of anything that arises in any of the reports. If it turns out that a matter needs to be reported to a relevant authority it is reported.

Comment on this

There may be many sets of eyes, but they are looking at different aspects of the business plan. It would be sensible to have clear guidelines in terms of other issues that would arise of which persons should be made aware which might not come within the direct responsibly of NAMA but need to be reported to the authorities. There should be clear guidelines on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

All I can say is that we take the compliance obligations of NAMA very seriously. There is a compliance officer and a legal team. When any matter arises which needs to be considered we go through the correct process on that and report it if we have to report it.

Comment on this

NAMA did not do that because in the case of the inaccurate information given by the banks, NAMA did not feel obliged to pass on information. There was a failure in that regard.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

That information was made available prior to the establishment of NAMA.

Comment on this

That is exactly what I am talking about. If, in the course of examining the proposed business plan, one of the staff of NAMA discovers a situation where there was clear tax evasion, reckless trading or attempts to defraud at some point before the existence of NAMA, are there not guidelines to ensure that it is reported to the relevant authority?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

That is picked up as part of the business plan process and the business plan review process. No matter when an issue arises if it is a reporting offence the issue is reported.

Comment on this

Okay, but based on the example that arose earlier which is why NAMA is back before the committee today-----

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

That concerns the institutions providing information before NAMA was established. It did not concern a debtor's business plan or whether a debtor had engaged in-----

Comment on this

The point has been made effectively that there should be guidelines. If such were in place NAMA would have felt obliged to report to the Financial Regulator but it did not. That is the point we made.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Okay.

Comment on this

A member of staff examining a business plan may discover something untoward happened three years ago and might say that does not come within NAMA's remit because it occurred before NAMA was set up. The staff of NAMA should be mindful of their responsibility to ensure that where they find any breach of legislation prior to the establishment of NAMA there should be a clear requirement on them to report it on.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

I fully accept that.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I welcome the representatives of NAMA on their second visit since 18 November. We are surprised to get this kind of exposure a second time at the committee. At what stage is NAMA at? The original estimate was €80 billion. How far has NAMA gone in that respect? I was very impressed to hear Mr. Daly talk about the 1634 Act. No man is more familiar with such legislation as he. Revenue legislation, excise and capital tax legislation all date back to the 1800s. Is the 1634 Act still relevant in law in the Irish context? Is NAMA at 50%, 40%, 30% or where is it in real terms?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

In real terms, by the end of 2010 we had acquired €71.2 billion worth of assets. We had not acquired approximately €3 billion worth of assets by year end. The majority of that €3 billion related to a case which is still in the Supreme Court that has not been concluded yet. In the case of some other transfers the participating institutions, PIs, are contesting the eligibility of assets and invoking their rights under the Act to refer the assets for eligibility to the expert reviewer. He is to review their objections during this month. If he decides that they are not eligible assets they will stay with the institutions. If he decides they are eligible assets then NAMA will acquire them. That is where we are. There was potentially €74 billion coming to NAMA. We have acquired €71 billion of that to date. The other €3 billion is-----

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

So NAMA has nearly reached its prescribed target figure.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Absolutely.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

If the average loss to the State is 58% do I take it that that much will be written down?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

That amount is written down by the various institutions depending on their various discounts.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

So that erodes their capital base.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Yes.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Is it correct that my tax money is going to put that capital back into the bank?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Yes, if the State is putting in the capital.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

On the last occasion Mr. McDonagh made a statement that resulted in his coming back here today, uproar throughout the country and the issuing of press reports by various people, for example, Mr. Alan Dukes. What made Mr. McDonagh make that statement? What was running through his mind at the time he made it?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

I spoke about the loan-to-value ratios not being at an average figure of 77%. Deputy Michael McGrath asked whether the information provided was correct in respect of 2009 before NAMA and said it was a matter that might be worthy of investigation. I did not disagree with him on whether the matter was worthy of investigation.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Deputy Michael McGrath questioned Mr. McDonagh as a politician, just as we questioned bank board members. Mr. McDonagh answered that there was possibly mischief in the information he was receiving from the banks and that it was erroneous, misleading and a cause for concern.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

I set out in my opening statement which actually included the transcript of what was said-----

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I was here.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

What I did say was that I did not believe the loan-to-value ratios averaged 77%, as originally presented, and that the figure was closer to 100%. As I said, I stand over this.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

When a developer receives a loan from a bank, be it €4 million, €5 million, €10 million, €100 million or €100 billion, is that the value in the book on the day the advance is made to the customer?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Yes; that was the information requested by the banks.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Is Mr. McDonagh saying that, based on that valuation, it was a misleading value.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

I said I had requested from each of the institutions their original loan-to-value ratios. They provided me with estimations of what their original loan-to-value ratios were. I have said that when I look at the outcomes of the individual loan-by-loan evaluations, effectively I do not believe the loan-to-value ratios presented to me averaged 77%.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I shall make it simpler. Mr. McDonagh probably has much more power than I do; I am just a public representative. If I go into the building society and borrow €75,000 to build a new house and it is given to me on day one, that is the value in the building society's book in respect of payments. Is Mr. McDonagh saying the values in the books listing the loans the banks gave to customers were not true and fair?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

To break it down, if a bank has a policy of lending at a loan-to-value ratio of 75%, for an asset that will be worth €100,000 it will give someone a loan of €75,000. We all have mortgages and one has to put up the equity oneself for a certain part. I asked the banks to estimate, based on looking at their land and development books and loans that could potentially be transferred to NAMA, the figures for the original loan-to-value ratios. They provided figures for me to show what the ratios were. If they only had one asset-----

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Were they the values on the days on which the loans were taken out?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Yes; that was the information I requested from them.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

What is the problem now?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

When I look at the valuations in terms of the discounts NAMA has applied to loans and try to work out, by reverse engineering, the original loan-to-value ratio compared to the discount given today, it does not appear the loan-to-value ratios averaged 77%; it appears that they must have been much higher.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

That was the book value they gave NAMA and there was nothing erroneous or misleading about it. It is NAMA's job to apply a discount and put a value on the loans thereafter.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Absolutely. All I am saying is that it does not appear the loan-to-value ratios given to me were what the banks said they were. It appears the loan-to-value ratios they advised me of must have been higher. Whether they are is for someone else to determine.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I take it Mr. McDonagh has access to the files and all of the agreements reached between the borrower and lender. The borrower is the developer and the lender is the bank. I suspect the banks gave NAMA the files. If they did not, there is a problem. Based on the amount borrowed, be it €10 billion, €4 billion, €70,000 or €4,000, it was NAMA's job to assess and value the loans and write down the discount. What is NAMA's crib with the bank?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

My view is that the average discounts being applied are in the order of 58%.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Is NAMA receiving the co-operation of the banks on the discount applied? Are they arguing that their values are more correct than those of NAMA?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Yes, that is what they are arguing. The valuation process is set out in the legislation and as agreed with the European Commission. It has been approved for tranches 1 and 2 because they have altered all of the individual loan valuations for tranches 1 and 2. If the loan-to-value ratios held true at 77%, I do not believe the NAMA discount would have been 58%. That is what is at issue. It would be substantially less than that; that is the fact.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

The market is dead; there is no market. The bank manager's problem is that the discount was false also because one cannot sell or give anything away. NAMA is working in accordance with an Act of Parliament, which I accept and recognise. I was present for the passage of the legislation and offered a certain amount of support to it. I would have had strong reservations shortly afterwards. All I have to do is look at what happened in Berlin after German reunification and in London after Mrs. Thatcher's boost to the economy. All that came right and the discounts were at a level such that the banks lived with the situation. NAMA may be overdoing it. The Minister for Finance made a statement that the discount would be only 30%. I have said at this forum that when the developers met the Department of Finance before the Bill was drafted and finalised, the figure of 28% was put forward as the discount, or haircut, by a principal officer in the Department. The developers did not agree with this and have told me so. Those to whom I spoke are respectable people. The principal officer answered that there was already an effort to exploit circumstances. If the Minister says the figure should be 30%, I do not understand why NAMA can make the statement it has made. I am very concerned about the matter because a figure of 30% was acceptable to the general public, the Government parties and, by and large, the Opposition. When we go beyond it, we have a crisis on our hands. It is a real economic crisis in that we have no bank on the high street today as a result of the haircut figure applied. That is taking out capital. NAMA is taking capital out through the front door and the taxpayer is putting it in through the back door. It is not Mr. McDonagh's fault, but I must make this point.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

The Deputy acknowledges the position and I can understand from where he is coming, but we have to apply the valuation methodology in accordance with the legislation and European Commission approval. It has produced a 58% discount. Do I personally wish that, in respect of everybody in the country, the discounts were much less? I certainly do, but the discounts have been established in accordance with a very thorough process.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Mr. McDonagh stated in a press report contained in the Irish Examiner that he was concerned about what the banks had told the Stock Exchange. I can read it for him.

Comment on this

We have dealt with that matter.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Hold on. The newspaper article states, "However, it [NAMA] does believe misleading information may have been issued by the banks elsewhere prior to the legislation's introduction". Of all the sacred bodies in this country and across the world, none is more sacred than the Stock Exchange. We have seen people being given long sentences in jail, dating back to the Guinness debacle many years ago in London. There have been other examples since. How did NAMA arrive at the view that the banks had misled the Stock Exchange? That is extremely serious. It is much more serious than telling me or Deputy Michael McGrath anything.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

I said in my letter to the Financial Regulator:

As you may be aware, particular issues referred to at a public accounts committee related to the provision of aggregate information by the financial institutions prior to the introduction of the NAMA Bill. Based on that information, the Minister for Finance, in his announcement of 16 September 2009, proffered a view that the average NAMA discount would be 30%. Both AIB and Bank of Ireland issued Stock Exchange statements after this in September 2009 indicating that they both expected their respective discounts to be less than 30% based on substantial analytical work they had undertaken with their respective advisers.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Does Mr. McDonagh believe they misled the Stock Exchange?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

I cannot determine that matter. All I am doing is pointing to what is factual.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Mr. McDonagh must have a view on it seeing that he mentioned it. This is undermining the financial system. We are already in bad shape, but we will be in much worse shape as a result of the PR. If the Stock Exchange, a very small part of business on this island, is to be undermined because somebody misled it or told it something, I fear for the economy.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

I made a statement of fact.

Comment on this

The Financial Regulator has to deal with it now.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Why is Mr. McDonagh making these statements? He works under an Act of Parliament. Is he moving outside his brief? I am not giving out to him. As a public representative, I represent ordinary people. I am looking at what is happening throughout the world and at the IMF and the European Union being involved here, which I totally oppose. I am very concerned about our sovereignty and so forth. This is a small economy with a small stock market.

Comment on this

Okay.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

I responded to a query raised by Deputy Michael McGrath at the meeting on 18 November. As a statement of fact, I said both banks had issued Stock Exchange statements indicating the discount would be 30%. The discount applied turned out to be higher. That is what I said and that was the matter referred to in my letter to the Financial Regulator.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I will quote from the Irish Examiner, an authoritative newspaper: “As a result, questions are now likely to be raised about the statements provided to the stock exchange”. Were the statements raised with Mr. McDonagh with regard to the statement he made?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

No.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Is Mr. McDonagh satisfied they are accurate?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

What I have said - I stand over it - is that their discounts turned out to be much higher than what they had advised the Stock Exchange. It is for others to determine whether these statements were correct; it is not for me to determine.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I have a few more questions. With regard to NTMA salaries, where is the impediment to giving us accurate details about these salaries?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

Chairman, perhaps-----

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I addressed my question to Mr. McDonagh.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

We are representing NAMA. As all NAMA personnel are employees of the NTMA, the question is probably better addressed to the NTMA rather than NAMA. The difficulty in giving the committee a greater breakdown was explained in the two letters from the NTMA to the committee on 16 December and 7 January. The letter of 16 December explained why individual salaries could not be advised to the committee and referred to the remuneration structure in the NTMA. There are no general grades and no pay scales. All staff are employed on an individually negotiated contract. The rationale for this dates back to the foundation of the NTMA, when it was agreed - this seems to have been accepted during the years by all parties in government - that it needed to be positioned outside the wider public service with operational freedom to set its own competitive market rate salaries in order that it would attract the best people and have the flexibility to recruit specialists in mid-career. That was the rationale from the beginning. On a personal basis and speaking about NAMA personnel, we still need that flexibility. We are in the market and the people up against us are the highly skilled professionals or first team. We cannot afford, on behalf of the taxpayer, to have a second team. We must, therefore, match the first team from the other side with the first team from NAMA. To do this we must have the right people and pay them the market rate.

The second letter on 7 January explained that if one were to go into greater detail on the salary bands, it would, in effect, identify individuals which would be in contravention of data protection legislation. That is the background.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I cannot agree with Mr. Daly. We are in a crisis. The world knows Mr. Daly's salary as chairman, which is €150,000. It is very good value for money, to be fair to him. When I talk to other public servants about reductions in salaries, how can I justify the different process in terms of salary? I do not accept for one moment that there is no one in this country who would work for a lower figure and do the same job. I believe I am correct in stating a person has been recruited recently in the United Kingdom who was made redundant at a salary of £65,000 and who has been given a job in the agency on a salary of €250,000. That is true.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

The Deputy knows I cannot talk about such cases, but I am not aware of that case. I accept the difficulty we are all in. However, it goes back to wishing to do the best for taxpayers in the work NAMA and the NTMA do. The reality, regardless of whether one likes it, is that one must have the best people and retain them. To get the right people to come into NAMA which, incidentally, has an expected lifespan of seven to ten years, one must pay them the market rate. Unfortunately, the market rate is not the Civil Service rate. We are competing against financial professionals and will be dealing with asset management companies, venture capitalists and the like. We need the best people to deal with them.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Our brightest and best are now unemployed. They are highly skilled and educated. It is not the bottom layer who are unemployed but the middle layer. Mr. Daly is telling us that the people concerned are not qualified enough, that he cannot accept them-----

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

No.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

-----and that he doubts they could do the job.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

I am not.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

The other issue is that an increasing number of jobs are being lost in the sector Mr. Daly mentioned. Every day we hear of them being lost and there is the threat that thousands of jobs will be lost in the future.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

I am not by any means saying there are no people out there with the right skills. We have an open recruitment process. We advertise, interview and subject people to psychometric testing. It is a very rigorous selection process. Anyone is free to apply for a job in NAMA and, I presume, the NTMA, although I am not here to speak on its behalf. The reality is that when one interviews and assesses people, one wants to get the best people because they are the ones one must put out against those from the financial institutions and the venture capitalists with whom we will be dealing. Unfortunately, to pay them, to get them to work for the organisation and come away from where they are to an organisation where they will be told from the first day that if they are really effective, they will work themselves out of a job in seven years-----

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

With respect to Mr. Daly and all he has done and achieved as a public and civil servant, the State was able to recruit him for €150,000. There are many people who are his equivalent and as good who could do the job for less. How can he justify a figure of €480,000 and a promise of a bonus of 80%?

We have 400,000 people unemployed and wage packets last week suffered enormously. I take the view that Mr. McDonagh should be taking a voluntary reduction in his salary. We have all done it and we will have to do more if this country is to get back on its knees, gets its exports up and get the country moving. The witnesses have to lead by example. They are part of an organisation that is chastising developers and the banks. Horrendous things are happening that we have never seen before on this island, yet Mr. McDonagh rides on with a salary of €480,000. It is absurd. It is shameful and I am going to say that in this climate. I advise Mr. McDonagh to have a rethink about that salary.

Comment on this

In fairness, Mr. McDonagh does not set his own salary.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

He can take a voluntary reduction.

Comment on this

I am not saying that I disagree with you, but I do not think you should personalise it.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I am not personalising it.

Comment on this

The National Treasury Management Agency sets the salaries and bonuses in conjunction with the Department of Finance. I do not agree with it, but I do not think the Deputy should personalise it.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I can put it another way. It is a crime that people are on that salary. It is absurd. It is a shame on our society and it should not be tolerated. It cannot be tolerated because we in Dáil Éireann are being questioned more. It is now a discussion across the British Isles - I do not like to use that term but I must - and we can do these things voluntarily. Do not try to tell me today that the National Treasury Management Agency and its board fix the salaries. I do not have to take such a salary, I can give it back. We gave back our ministerial pensions without being forced to give them back. Let us be straight about it. Let us be honest and fair. Let us have some respect for our citizens and our society.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

I would like to make two brief points. Mr. McDonagh's salary is set by the NTMA advisory board and not by himself. The salary level for Mr. McDonagh that has been advised to the committee is €430,000, plus a maximum of 60% and not 80%.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Sixty per cent of what?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

Sixty per cent of salary.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

So he could earn about €700,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

That is a maximum bonus. The reality is that the process of bonuses is a matter for the NTMA.

Comment on this

Was a bonus paid this year?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

There has not been any consideration of that yet by the NTMA advisory board, but I cannot speak for that board.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

This is serious business and I do not want to personalise it, but at a time when this country is facing a liability of €200 billion and a repayment on interest alone of €10 billion, the public service is drawing this kind of money. If this was in the private sector, it would be seen as a disgrace. This matter must be taken in hand. As one of the most respectable people in the land, Mr. Daly should provide leadership in this area and advise the board of NAMA to reduce those salaries. He is involved in fixing those salaries because he is chairman and a member of the board.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

All NAMA employees are employees of the NTMA and it is the NTMA advisory board that sets the salaries. I am not a member of that board.

Comment on this

Like in all organisations, there should be transparency in NAMA. We found it very difficult to get information from NAMA, something that I find to be completely wrong.

Is there an arrangement whereby pension credit is given of two years for every year's service in the NTMA?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

I do not know.

Comment on this

Would you be familiar with the arrangement in NAMA?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

No.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Effectively, the scheme is based on one eightieth for every year of service. If somebody works for seven years, they get seven eightieths.

Comment on this

We ask that of all organisations.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I understand that Mr. McDonagh was employed with the NTMA. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Yes.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

What level of salary is his equivalent being paid after Mr. McDonagh was seconded to NAMA?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

Chairman, I think we will again be getting into revealing the salary of an individual.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

The witnesses are public servants. They are employed by the taxpayer. The taxpayer is under extreme pressure and the public service is under extreme pressure. We are entitled to know the information. The world has changed and we have more transparency today.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

I accept that, but I am not here today representing the NTMA. The salaries in the NTMA are set through individual contracts with individuals in the organisation, and it has not been the practice to reveal their salaries. That is an NTMA position. The NTMA and all of its bodies, including NAMA, have now adopted the code of practice for State bodies. In accordance with that code, the salaries of the chief executives are published in the annual report. That will be done for NAMA in the next few months and we will advise the committee in advance of that.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

The National Treasury Management Agency had those guidelines in place at a different time in the history of our economy. Things have changed since 2007 and we have been on the slippery slope since March 2008. The rules were different then and people are doing voluntary things now that they would not have done then. That is my point.

Comment on this

We came across an obstacle today when Mr. Daly quoted the Data Protection Act. As a committee, we have encountered ongoing difficulties in getting information due to that Act. We have sought extra powers for the committee to override the provisions of the Data Protection Act, because this would eliminate some of the difficulties we have had with NAMA in getting information about salaries and bonuses. That is all I will say.

Comment on this

I will be brief at this hour of the day. I want to concentrate briefly on the major question before the committee today, but I would like to go back to where Deputy O'Keeffe came in. NAMA has acquired €71.2 billion in assets to underpin the loans at year end, and there is €3 billion pending. Is that it?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

No. There is a potential, as part of the EU and IMF plan, of loans worth less than €20 million in AIB and Bank of Ireland, which in total amount of €16 billion, that could be transferred to NAMA.

Comment on this

Has a decision been made to take in at any stage loans worth €5 million or less, performing or otherwise?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

As part of the restructuring of those banks, all loans from zero to €20 million in AIB and Bank of Ireland will be transferred to NAMA as part of the EU and IMF package. The announcement said that it was up to about €16 billion. The figures that are emerging - Mr. Carrigan can probably confirm this because he is dealing directly with the two institutions on the issue - means that the total amount is probably around €13 billion.

Comment on this

Does Mr. McDonagh say that it was all loans from zero to €20 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

All loans from zero to €20 million that are in the land and development category and that are sitting in the balance sheets of AIB and Bank of Ireland will be transferred to NAMA in the form of a bulk transfer from each institution.

Comment on this

Therefore, loans worth less than €5 million, performing or otherwise, will be taken in at some stage.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Yes. That is part of the conditionality attached to the EU and IMF agreement.

Comment on this

I would like to clarify something. After the meeting of 18 November, it would have appeared to the taxpayer in the street that the exchanges that took place here were contradicted, or certainly not assented to, by the regulator, the Garda Síochána, NAMA, and the chairman of one of the banks. They all seemed to dispute it. That is what was left in the ether, and I think Mr. McDonagh said as much in his opening statement. As a result of the exchanges at the earlier part of today's meeting, the impression has been left that if NAMA had proceeded on the basis of the information presented to it in the months before it was created, let us say in July or August 2009, then it would have been tantamount to a swindle of the taxpayer to the tune of €20 billion. Is any of that unfair?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

What I said - and Deputy McGrath made the point first - was that, yes, we could have potentially overpaid for the assets to the tune of €20 billion.

Comment on this

Okay. Is it fair to say that as a result of the depth of the haircut, refurbishment on the other side of the balance sheet was necessary, as a result of which considerable State investment or public money went in?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

The Deputy is completely right. It is a question of smaller haircuts meaning less capital would have to go into the banks. This came down to the European Commission oversight of NAMA, that it wanted a very rigorous process in terms of establishing what the valuations were. We have done that and the outcome is that the banks need additional capital to cover those losses.

Comment on this

It is a long time since anyone started a sentence in Ireland with the term "in fairness to the banks". However, one of the merits of this committee is that one gets different points of view, which is very valuable. What can we say in mitigation of what the banks did? Is Mr. Daly saying that the systems were so dysfunctional and the paperwork so defective that it was an innocent misrepresentation?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

I believe I used the term "in fairness to the banks" myself recently and, like Deputy Rabbitte's intervention, it was greeted with laughter. What I was saying is that there are a number of factors that could have contributed to those figures, but the essence of the discussion the last day and today is that the only way to determine the exact drivers of those figures is if they are inquired into further. That seemed to be the direction in which the committee was going earlier, and is possibly also signalled by the letter to which Mr. McDonagh referred which we received from the regulator last evening indicating that he is going to inquire into this further.

Comment on this

Would Mr. Daly dismiss any suggestion that the misrepresentation that occurred was because the banks' own paperwork was so defective that they did not know the true situation?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

If I am reading the Deputy right, I think it is possible that this is one of the things that might emerge from this, that maybe they did not have adequate systems, maybe the paperwork was inadequate, maybe there was wrong estimation or something like that. All I am saying is that these are possibilities. In the absence of somebody actually inquiring into that, I cannot be definitive about the cause.

Comment on this

On the other hand, it could have been deliberate on the part of the banks in terms of protecting their own balance sheet, protecting their capacity to raise money in the marketplace and so on, that they made the presentations or estimates they did.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

However, I am not saying that. I am saying the same thing, that until somebody looks into the entrails of this it is not possible to come to a definitive conclusion.

Comment on this

Have we established today that nobody was minded to look into it until the controversy happened on 18 November at this committee?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

That is probably not an unreasonable conclusion.

Comment on this

Considering all that we have been through, is that not remarkable? One of the reasons people are so angry is that they do not believe that, at the end of the day, anybody will be held to account for what has happened to our country. They do not believe that we, the legislators, have made laws that are capable of holding people to account. They believe there are loopholes in laws as they affect white collar misbehaviour as distinct from other kinds of misbehaviour. We are still at the stage where the regulator and NAMA are swapping letters. The regulator seemed to ask NAMA for the information and so on. It is not a very reassuring picture. I am not saying it was Mr. Daly's job, but we must consider what has emerged from today's hearings.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

From NAMA's point of view, all we can say - and Mr. McDonagh has already said it - is that we put the facts on the table on 18 November. We will fully co-operate with whoever is going to inquire into this and we will make any information we have available to them, including the information the committee suggested earlier that we should make available, whether it is asked for or not. NAMA has been concentrating and totally focused on doing what we have to do over the last year and it is not an inconsiderable challenge. There was no apparent breach of NAMA legislation here, so from that point of view I do not think NAMA had a locus standi in inquiring into this. It has emerged on the table as a consequence of these two meetings and I presume it will go further.

Comment on this

Mr. McDonagh said earlier that there was €1 billion in assets. I presume that was from the combined covered institutions in respect of which the paperwork was so defective that if they had not come to the tape NAMA would have had to write down the entire amount. Will Mr. McDonagh briefly describe that dereliction of duty?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

When the loans were extended there were issues, incorrect mortgages being one instance. Another issue was that title was not perfected and security was not correctly charged and was not registered. If NAMA had acquired those loans and the borrowers then turned around and decided not to co-operate and we had to go off and enforce against them in court, the judge would have pointed out that we had an incorrect mortgage, incorrect security or incorrect title. Therefore, we said to the institutions that because of those issues we would take the loans but at a 100% haircut. They then said they would go off and sort it out, which they did, and it took them a number of months. If we had not looked at the paperwork correctly and done proper due diligence we could have acquired those loans and ended up in that scenario.

Comment on this

Is it the staff in the bank who do that? For example, if a developer bought a site in Kinnegad with a loan of €100 million in 2003, does one of Mr. McDonagh's staff actually see the file on that or is NAMA reliant on the information being furnished by the bank?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

We have a legal template which we send to the banks and on which they have to fill in the information. We get that legal template reviewed and then we do asset searches to see whether the title is correct and the security is registered. Sometimes institutions will say to us that they do not have correct title and seek time to remedy it. Other times we will find that out ourselves. Because there was so much business being written, when people were following through on the documentation they might not have got their charge registered. For example, they might have had the first charge initially but because they did not register it on time the second charge became the first charge.

Comment on this

Are there no circumstances in which NAMA staff would go in on any type of random audit of any of these files?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Under section 80 of the Act, we can request any book or record from the institutions as part of the process and, yes, we have done that.

Comment on this

Does NAMA have in-house legal expertise?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Yes.

Comment on this

To what extent must the agency resort outside of that?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

We must resort outside of it because at present, we have a very small legal team that only comprises approximately six people and we must build it up. Effectively, however, in respect of the legal due diligence, we were obliged to make use of a panel of legal firms to review the due diligence that was submitted by the institutions.

Comment on this

There are a couple of other areas that it is too late in the day to open up. There is an opportunity to get back to what may be a stupid question, namely, does this mean that in some cases, the loan-to-value ratios were higher than 100%?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

I would think so.

Comment on this

In other words, were I to go in seeking €100 million for the aforementioned site in Kinnegad, I might have been given €110 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

There could have been instances of that, yes.

Comment on this

I have a few questions on which to follow up. Mr. McDonagh stated previously that 14 of the top 30 developers had agreed and signed memorandums of understanding. How many of the top ten have signed and agreed?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

I do not have to hand the break-out of the top ten but I can revert to the Chairman on that if he wishes.

Comment on this

Have the majority of them done so?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Yes, the majority of them have moved towards the memorandum of understanding stage.

Comment on this

They have moved towards it.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

Yes. This is a complicated process but effectively what happens is that the developer submits the business plan and we get the business plan reviewed. It is reviewed through the process by NAMA through the credit committee or the board, as necessary. One then starts the engagement with the borrower whereby one states the outcome of NAMA's review, whether it be by board or credit committee. One states it is as follows, this is what NAMA thinks of the borrower's business plan and these are the lines along which it believes it should be restructured or whatever. That starts the discussion with the borrower, which can be to and fro for a number of weeks because these are highly complex connections and a huge amount of assets are involved. Thereafter, once we get through this process with the borrower, we state our intention to issue the borrower with a draft memorandum of understanding at a point where we think we have got to an agreement. Again, once this is finalised, one moves to a signed memorandum of understanding and one then starts the legal documentation on the back of that.

Comment on this

That clarifies this issue for me.

I asked about bonuses for this year earlier. Were bonuses given out or awarded last year?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

Does the Chairman mean in respect of 2010?

Comment on this

Yes, for NAMA staff.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

No, no bonuses have been considered.

Comment on this

Ever?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

As I understand it, this has not yet been considered by the NTMA advisory board.

Comment on this

Yes. Is this also the case for last year?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

For 2009?

Comment on this

Were bonuses given out to NAMA staff at any stage?

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

No.

Comment on this

All right. On the last day, I spoke to the witnesses about a Mr. Emmet Oliver and his comments that NAMA should be a liquidation company rather than one that dealt with developers individually and asked for business plans. Mr. Daly may remember that he stated he would clarify this and revert to members but he never did. I hope I have the correct name. No, I apologise, I refer to Mr. Graham Emmett, who wrote in Property Week in the United Kingdom and The Sunday Tribune subsequently carried the story. He stated that NAMA should be following liquidation plans rather than looking for business plans. Mr. Daly stated he would clarify that position but the committee did not hear from him subsequently in this regard.

Comment on this
Mr. Frank Daly

My apologies for not reverting to the committee on this matter. I did go back and look at the presentation that Mr. Emmett made to that property conference and certainly there was no reference in that presentation to that type of comment.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan McDonagh

I followed up with Mr. Emmett on that matter. He made a presentation at that conference. There was a question and answer session after the conference and while he stated that he did make those remarks, this was not representing in any way either my view or that of the board of NAMA.

Comment on this

That clarifies this point. I believe the committee has gone as far as it can go.

Comment on this

It has exhausted the committee anyway, whatever about the loans.

Comment on this

The subject matter is sufficiently clarified. Before we dispose of it, I think the committee should pass on the transcripts of today's evidence to the Financial Regulator. Subsequently, when the latter has had an opportunity to consider the evidence given today, members of the committee, if we are still around, will pursue the matter further with the Financial Regulator. Members must be proactive in dealing with this matter as some of today's evidence is deeply disturbing and must be pursued by the committee. Is it agreed to dispose of Special Report 76? Agreed. That is great.

I again thank the witnesses for their attendance. The committee must agree the agenda for next week's meeting. It concerns Special Reports 74 and 75 of the Comptroller and Auditor General, as well as the FETAC accounts.

The witnesses withdrew.

Comment on this