Irish Universities and the FETAC 2008 Accounts and the Royal Irish Academy of Music 2009 Accounts.
Contributions 153–313 of 313. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
From the reputational point of view, the Committee of Public Accounts does not have any inclination to cast aspersions on the huge reputation enjoyed by Dr. O'Conor and the credit he has brought to the country. At the same time, I presume Dr. O'Conor understands that the questions that are being raised are in the context of the need for full transparency where public funds are involved.
Comment on this
Dr. O'Conor is still a part-time teacher of the academy. His contract comes to an end next year. He is paid more than other teachers in the academy and we have to address that issue. As soon as news broke that he was no longer director of the academy, he was promptly recruited to a part-time teaching job in America. Dr. O'Conor has a very high reputation and we were very glad to have him. He is one of the most recognised interpreters of Beethoven in the world and is recognised in that particular category. He will not have any position which will put him in any areas of this context. We have the issue again in 2012, which we will have to address at that time, but we will do so with our Department.
Comment on this
The academy will address the issue in the context of the need for compliance with public sector rules and regulations.
Comment on this
Any steps taken by the academy or Dr. O'Conor will not be taken in a way that would reflect in any way on his reputation but would be related solely to the requirement for transparency and full compliance with public sector arrangements.
Comment on this
I have already stated that we will stand behind Dr. O'Conor. The errors made, if any, were made by the academy. As far as we are concerned, Dr. O'Conor's reputation is intact. If we have to address the issue, the normal way is that we would do so in the context that the people who are giving us money are telling us we have to-----
Comment on this
Under Dr. O'Conor's stewardship, did the academy increase its income from private sources?
Comment on this
Did private income increase as a percentage of the overall budget? That figure would be a good indicator. We cannot be negative about the matter.
Comment on this
Overall in his stewardship, Dr. O'Conor raised €3.4 million. We have a breakdown which we can submit to the committee if it likes.
Comment on this
We have a confidentiality issue, however, as some of our donors would prefer not to be known. We will submit the document after the meeting, perhaps some time this afternoon.
Comment on this
As one would expect, Dr. O'Conor has been a major plus to the academy and country. The committee accepts that.
Comment on this
If I may, I will make one further point on Dr. O'Conor's work for the academy because it comes up in the various expense issues and things like that. In 2008, the academy orchestra toured Seoul, Beijing and Tokyo. The tour was possible for a number of reasons. Dr. O'Conor raised funds from various sources, including some State funding. However, it was his contacts in Seoul, Beijing and Tokyo which enabled the tour to happen. Unfortunately, none of my children are good enough to have attended the academy but, as a parent, when one sees the pictures of the academy students on bus stops in Seoul, Korea, and emblazoned across the national concert hall, it is almost worth paying him anything. I accept that is a bit over the top. He established a worldwide reputation in the academy and that is of benefit to it.
Comment on this
We recognise and appreciate that. We are pleased to have it on the record but we still have a duty to raise issues.
Comment on this
As I do. Sometimes the matters raised are not nice.
Comment on this
If I can turn to FETAC, those responsible put their hands up to say a mistake had been made. In legal terms the situation with recovery has been examined. Is it the case that there are serious problems in terms of the reimbursement of overpayments?
Comment on this
I am sorry; I am not sure what the Deputy's question is.
Comment on this
Overpayments or unauthorised payments were made. Has the reimbursement of those payments been examined?
Comment on this
Yes, it has been looked at. We have been advised by the Department that the pension payments need to be adjusted. We are now looking at the implications of that with the Department. I need to talk to the council about it as well to see what precisely needs to be done in that regard.
Comment on this
Are we talking about pension payments for the future or reimbursement of what might be considered overpayments in the past?
Comment on this
The emphasis has been on pension payments for the future. However, all is still under consideration.
Comment on this
There is a relatively small number of staff. We are talking about four people who were relatively senior who as far as I can gather were essentially surplus to requirements. The organisation is a relatively young one of ten years standing. The question arises as to how such a relatively young organisation could have four senior staff, in such a relatively small staff complement, surplus to requirements. How did that happen?
Comment on this
I would not have looked at them as surplus to requirements up to then. As I indicated, we were restructuring, we had spent a considerable amount of time on it and three out of four people were involved in policy development. Once those policies were developed then the operation moved over to encouraging and working with providers to implement those policies. While they are FETAC policies they are implemented in the broadest sense by all of the providers. Therefore, the need for policy development was considerably reduced. That is what we are talking about in that regard. Looking to the future there was less of a need for the precise skill set that those people had. We were also looking forward to the amalgamation.
Comment on this
What is the up to date position on the amalgamation? I am not sure to whom to pose my question.
Comment on this
The question is probably best addressed to me. All three bodies involved in the amalgamation - HETAC, FETAC and the National Qualifications Authority - are statutory bodies that were established under the Qualifications (Education and Training) Act 1999. Therefore, legislation is required to bring about their full amalgamation. The general scheme of the legislation was approved in January 2010 by Government and we are very close to completing the drafting of the legislation. We expect to publish it, notwithstanding some of the uncertainty around the current Oireachtas term, in the current term with a view to establishing the body on a full statutory basis in the second half of 2011.
To some extent the amalgamation perhaps addresses some of the comments of the Comptroller and Auditor General. That is the legislative track. There is also an administrative planning side to the matter. Last year the Minister appointed an interim board of the new body essentially comprising the chairs of each of the existing bodies and also appointed the new chief executive officer of the National Qualifications Authority of Ireland as the CEO designate. He will be the new chief executive officer of the new organisation. Under his auspices there is a process of administrative planning to cover the bringing together of the functions of the various agencies, the resource issues involved, accommodation for the new agency and other such matters. The intention is that when the legislation permits the statutory establishment of the authority that it can hit the ground running because it will have done the work of administrative planning in large part before the legislation is passed.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Flaherty mentioned that he expects the legislation to be circulated "in the current term". Does he mean in the term of the current Government?
Comment on this
I shall choose my words carefully. Assuming the term is as has been expected we would hope to have it completed for publication by the end of February.
Comment on this
The end of term appears to be a moveable feast. We await developments in that regard. I will turn to the previous comments on the strategic innovation fund. The amount of money involved in that is considerable and is worthy of a little more detailed examination. In broad terms, is Mr. Boland satisfied with the outcomes to date?
Comment on this
Unhesitatingly, I would say "Yes". The Comptroller and Auditor General's report highlights issues, as did our own review, but overall it has been a successful project which in broad terms has helped the higher education system to do two things, one, to cope better with the economic downturn and the difficulties placed on their budgets and, second, it puts the sector in a good position to hit the ground running now that the Government has published a national strategy for higher education. It was a new project in this country and inevitably there were some difficulties. It was not perfect but it has been a sound programme overall.
Comment on this
My recollection is that an bord snip nua suggested that the continuation of the fund was a luxury we could not afford. Do I take it from Mr. Boland's comments that he would not be in total agreement with Dr. McCarthy?
Comment on this
I would not be in total agreement with him at all. It is a minor point but I thought the Comptroller and Auditor General's report made reference to the funding for the strategic investment fund, SIF, being cut on foot of the report of that group. I do not think the two were necessarily directly connected in that way. The cut in funding for SIF arose from the general budgetary difficulties rather than necessarily the recommendations or the views of the so-called McCarthy group or an bord snip.
Comment on this
I do not want to get into too much debate on the work of that particular group but in fairness, significant and detailed analysis and reviews of the fund have now been done, both independently commissioned by the HEA and by the Comptroller and Auditor General.
Comment on this
In fairness, I do not think any reasonable person would reach the conclusion from either of those reviews that this was a totally worthless programme that should be stopped immediately.
Comment on this
In fairness to Mr. O'Connor, the conclusion was that it was a luxury we could no longer afford. I do not think he condemned it as being entirely useless.
Comment on this
We will hear from Mr. O'Connor in a moment. Far from being a luxury we could ill afford, it represented much better targeting of needed funding. There were two options available to the Government regarding the funding of higher education, one of which was to make a broad across-the-board increase in so far as that was possible, and the other of which was to make a very targeted increase in areas of particular national importance, as was decided.
Comment on this
The collaboration supported by SIF has created efficiencies that are actually quality enhancing. There has been a huge impact owing to universities and institutes of technology working together on different things. A good example is the flexible learning platform now established across all the institutes of technology. There is a web portal to host the content of all Irish research. Access programmes are now run nationally through the CAO.
For a rather modest investment in the grand scheme of investments by this State in universities and higher education institutions, the SIF has had a huge impact and has leveraged very significant change that is very relevant as we adopt a new national strategy for higher education.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Boland situate the fund in the context of the international status of our universities? It has always been a concern of mine to see the international and national status of our universities enhanced. I take it Mr. Boland shares that view. Has the approach adopted in respect of the fund helped in any way to improve the status?
Comment on this
First, the Irish higher education system has a very high status internationally. Various reports - from the OECD, the Lisbon group and so on - demonstrate that. In addition, some of our universities are in the top 100 in the world. The status is good. To the extent that I am convinced that it makes for a more efficient system and helps create a system of higher education as opposed to stand-alone institutions, I believe the programme can only have a positive impact on the higher education sector. The programme is still fairly new and its full impact has yet to be felt. Sometimes it is very difficult to be precise as to the outcomes of programmes like this; that is one of the criticisms of the Comptroller and Auditor General. Overall, I would be optimistic that the programme cannot but help make a better higher education system for Irish people, which in itself should improve the standing of our system internationally.
Comment on this
I want to add to that. We share the view that the SIF has had a very positive impact on the higher education system generally. On the specific question raised on the standing of universities and institutions and international rankings, one can create a direct linear relationship between one of the projects that Mr. O'Connor just cited, the open portal for research, and the visibility of Irish research internationally and the citation rates for Irish research internationally, which have an impact on the rankings of Irish institutions. The more important question is not related to how many of our universities feature in the top 100, although that is important from an inward investment point of view, but to how the whole system operates and to the quality across the entire system. One of the important dimensions of the SIF was that it encouraged a system approach to the development of higher education, building on what the programme for research in third level institutions had encouraged in terms of greater inter-institutional collaboration. The SIF brought that a step further in regard to the organisation and delivery of teaching at an undergraduate level and some of the other projects on the access front. All in all, it has had a number of very positive impacts.
Let me revert for a moment to the question of funding. The Deputy asked why it has been wound down. I will address that directly because it is an issue for the Department in the first instance. Clearly, the budgetary context changed quite dramatically from mid-2008 onwards. When the SIF was first conceived in 2006, funding for higher education was on an upward trajectory. This was seen as a better means of targeting any additionality for the direct achievement of desired policy outcomes in the system. It gave us a mechanism to identify the kinds of strategic objectives that we wanted to see delivered at system level, to ensure there was a funding mechanism to incentivise behaviour in support of those objectives, to support innovative ways of delivering on those objectives, to encourage collaboration across the system to deepen the system approach, and to encourage a redirection of existing resources within the system through the matching resources requirement. It was a very significant vehicle. As Mr. Boland outlined in regard to the mid-term review, it was identified as almost revolutionary in some ways in attempting to achieve the objectives.
All in all, the story is very positive. We have been constrained by very significant budgetary issues in the past couple of years. As a result, the programme is being wound down. The mid-term evaluation and the Comptroller and Auditor General's report point to the very positive outcomes of a significant number of projects. The HEA has been building on the outcomes of that mid-term evaluation, looking at means of ensuring that the projects that have succeeded and are delivering can be sustained through mainstream funding. It is important that we do not lose the benefits of the projects under this investment.
Comment on this
I understand there have been two cycles so far. The second cycle planned to take on board some lessons learned from the first. Is there a third cycle planned?
Comment on this
Unfortunately, there is not because that would require funding. There are no specific proposals. Mr. Boland, in his opening remarks, pointed to the value of a strategic approach to the allocation of available higher education funding. The higher education strategy sets out an agenda for the development of the system over the next 20 years. The strategy identifies the need to ensure that funding for the sector is aligned to strategic objectives. We must find ways and means of ensuring that the allocation of funding follows the delivery of strategic objectives, however we achieve that. SIF was one mechanism, and there are other ways. That is a challenge for us now in terms of how we use the available resources in the system. There are no direct immediate proposals on a SIF cycle.
Comment on this
In clarifying, could Mr. Boland give me a handle on the figures? My understanding is that the original figure was approximately €500 million for the period to 2013. How much has been allocated and spent?
Comment on this
Mr. O'Connor will give the Deputy chapter and verse on that in a moment. On a specific point with regard to the continuation of the SIF - it would be my view that we should be prepared to put our money where our mouths are if we consider SIF to have been such a success, which we do - the HEA needs to consider how, even with limited resources, one can build into the funding model an element of funding for real innovation in the system. Funding does grease the wheels of innovation. That is something I would like to explore with my colleagues in the executive and the authority when the SIF programme is ultimately terminated.
Comment on this
SIF 1, when announced, allocated €41 million. To the end of 2010, €38.57 million was released in the SIF funding.
Comment on this
Some €38.57 million of €41 million.
SIF 2, at the point of announcement, anticipated the investment of €101 million. So far, we have released €38.3 million to SIF 2. It is highly unlikely that we will be honouring the full allocations announced under SIF 2. The management of the SIF has involved pruning the fund as we have taken cuts, but we have been guided in the management of resources by the rankings assigned to projects in the mid-term evaluation and, more recently, by the insights emerging from the Comptroller and Auditor General's review. We have always monitored closely — the universities argue too closely — quarterly financial reports and biannual statements of progress. We keep a close eye on them and have routinely withheld moneys in cases in which an institution held, say, one and a half times a typical quarterly payment. This has helped us to focus on the projects that show most promise. The Comptroller and Auditor General and the external evaluation observed that the projects that had displayed the most ambition, the best collaboration and clear objectives had been the most successful.
Comment on this
The Comptroller and Auditor General raised issues concerning the requirement for the production and quality of matched funding. Has this issue been addressed?
Comment on this
The term "matched funding" creates the impression that there is cash on the table which was never anticipated by the Higher Education Authority. Most of the matched funding has been taken in the form of staff time. We welcome this as part of the thinking behind the strategic innovation fund which involves a relatively modest amount of investment in the grand scheme of things. The idea behind matched funding is that it will leverage a commitment from what we are investing in through the use of core funds. The Higher Education Authority does not have a difficulty with the fact that most of the matched funding is in the form of human resources. It has, however, created difficulties for institutions, of which the Comptroller and Auditor General is aware, in that a large amount of bureaucracy is generated in quantifying and recording the inputs and participation of the various individuals involved in the institutions. However, it has been very valuable. In some cases we have also encouraged the provision of matched funding from outside the higher education sector in projects involving better engagement with business and communities. The Higher Education Authority recognises and considers valid inputs by external partners as matched funding also.
Comment on this
I am not at liberty to give full details, but I understand an announcement is due shortly from one university on its strategic innovation fund project which will receive a substantial philanthropic donation to allow the project to continue. That is an example of where cash is following the project.
Comment on this
The matched funding mechanism which involves a heavy commitment of core staff time to the strategic innovation fund project, helps to achieve the objectives of sustainable change in how an institution does it business.
Comment on this
Were there many examples of universities or institutes of technology re-tailoring existing courses to draw down funds as extra funding for themselves? If so, was funding refused in such cases?
Comment on this
The strategic innovation fund is not so much about the production of new courses, as that is a core business and institutions always revise the content of their academic programmes. We did keep a close eye on the fund to ensure it was producing something additional over and above what could be legitimately expected. There were instances where, if we thought the strategic innovation fund was being used, say, to fund the payment of salaries that could not be credibly regarded as additionality, we terminated the projects or withheld payments.
Comment on this
The discussion has centred mainly on universities, but the fund also applies to institutes of technology. What is the breakdown in participation between the two?
Comment on this
The Comptroller and Auditor General's report which focused mainly on the first tranche of funding observed that 70% of awards went to universities and 30% to institutes of technology. In the second tranche, the figure was 56% for universities and 44% for institutes of technology, which showed a substantial improvement in the draw-down from the fund for the institutes. I was impressed by the way the institutes of technology sector engaged with the fund. It undertook co-ordinated and ambitious initiatives. The 14 institutes can now upload and provide information on their flexible learning and part-time programmes and there is an application facility on their portal website www.bluebrick.ie. The business intelligence information available to senior management in the institutes has also been greatly improved by the strategic innovation fund.
Comment on this
Some projects have generally resulted in collaboration between third level institutions. Is there a Chinese wall between the institutes of technology and the universities? Has there been a crossover between the two sectors?
Comment on this
There are no Chinese walls. We heartily encourage collaboration across the two parts of the sector. A good example of this which is still at a relatively early developmental stage is the Dublin regional higher education alliance which takes all of the higher education institutions in the Dublin region under a single umbrella with the view to creating a dynamic higher education system. We very much encourage cross-collaboration between the sectors so long as they stick to their mission and it does not lead to mission drift.
Comment on this
There are many examples of universities and institutes of technology collaborating on a regional basis. That provides a blueprint for the regional cluster concept coming through the national strategy. For example, the Shannon consortium involves the University of Limerick, Limerick Institute of Technology, Mary Immaculate College, Limerick, and the Institute of Technology, Tralee. They have developed a very impressive multi-agency approach to educational disadvantage in the area and are connected with the broader Limerick regeneration project. The strategic innovation fund is not about going off on a new tangent but that the institutions plug into the range of higher education agencies in their area.
Comment on this
I want to inform the meeting that correspondence, dated 20 January 2011, was received from Hugh R. Brady, president of University College Dublin and addressed to me as Chairman. It reads:
Dear Chairman,
It has come to UCD's attention that as a follow-up to Report 75 of the Comptroller and Auditor General, Irish Universities Resource Management and performance, the issue of allowances will be considered at today's meeting of the Committee of Public Accounts. UCD thought it appropriate that its position on the matter, as communicated to the HEA and the Department of Education and Skills in early December 2010, should be available to the committee.
The letter refers us to the one discussed earlier from Professor Hugh R. Brady to Mr. Tom Boland, chief executive of the Higher Education Authority, and Ms Brigid McManus, Secretary General of the Department of Education and Skills. There is nothing in the letter that would have changed the discussion we had.
Regarding FETAC's relationship with Empower Learning Limited, the Kilkenny-based company which went out of business, is it correct that in February 2010 FETAC was contacted by Skillnets to highlight problems with the company? The communication included a preliminary investigation which concluded that the trainer, Empower, was issuing false certifications. Would that be correct?
Comment on this
In other words, FETAC got a communication from Skillnets in February last year informing it that it had carried out a preliminary investigation into Empower and concluded that the trainer was issuing false certifications.
Comment on this
We were informed by Skillnets that there were issues with the Empower organisation. At that stage it was simply informing us that it was investigating issues. I do not have the detail of that with me but as far as we were concerned when we were informed that Skillnets had issues, we instigated a monitoring arrangement with Empower. Our monitors went to Empower to look at what it was doing in respect of its responsibilities to us. That happened in July.
On foot of that monitoring visit, certain recommendations were made. We then followed up in September with a further visit to see what the situation was in respect of the recommendations, and it was then that the situation became clear to us as regards Empower itself. Other issues had come to the surface. For example, Empower had sent a cheque to us which had bounced for payment of fees in respect of certification. We drew these matters to the attention of Empower and said we would be withdrawing all certification from them until the issues were resolved. Within a week a notice went on our website, and we then formally suspended from the certification service.
Comment on this
We informed it that we were in the process of suspending it. I do not have the date here.
Comment on this
We actually held a meeting with the managing director of Empower on 20 September.
Comment on this
That was 13 September. I just have it here, as regards its access to FETAC certification until it fully complied.
Comment on this
That was the question, as regards 13 September. On what specific date did FETAC put on its website the fact that this company was suspended?
Comment on this
Not deliberately, Chairman. I would not have done that.
Comment on this
I would have known it at the time. I apologise for that.
Comment on this
Why did it take from 13 September to 7 October to inform the public, and more importantly the students, of this issue?
Comment on this
We were dealing with the issues. Our responsibility is, through quality assurance, to ensure that providers are improving their quality assurance arrangements, so when we-----
Comment on this
The fact is FETAC made a decision to suspend on 13 September and did not inform the public, and more importantly the students, until 7 October.
Comment on this
In the first instance, we took legal advice as to how this should be done. Once we had informed Empower, the intention was that we would announce this publicly as soon as possible. It took some time. This was new territory for us, and it had not happened before. A considerable number of private providers are registered with us, it had not happened before and the circumstances were particularly difficult because, as I said, it was new territory.
Comment on this
As a result of the gap between suspension and informing the public and students, substantial fees were lost by how many students?
Comment on this
The relationship surrounding fees was between the students, the learners and Empower. Our role was to ensure that-----
Comment on this
FETAC's responsibility was to inform the public and students that Empower was suspended since 13 September, surely.
Comment on this
Our responsibility in this is also to ensure that the learners are protected in terms of completing their courses. We have put considerable time and effort into ensuring that those learners have access to programmes of a similar standard. The arrangement with regard to protection for learners allows us to work with other providers to ensure that these learners are not let down. In terms of that, there were 1,164 learners in total on the register, with Empower. Given that the owners had left the country we had to take exceptional steps to get that information in the first place, which we did. Of that number, 528 were certified reasonably quickly, arising from assessments that took place in August, and we are still in the process of arranging and managing assessments for 161, so that they can obtain the relevant certification. Some 444 are on programmes with other providers through the protection for learners process, and we are still working with a further 31 in terms of finding providers for them.
Comment on this
Yes, we were aware that there were issues, in the broad sense.
Comment on this
This would have been earlier in the year, around February or March.
Comment on this
Our remit is around the courses. We were very careful to stay within our remit. That is our responsibility.
Comment on this
What does Mr. McHugh mean by "around the courses"? Surely accreditation is the most important thing.
Comment on this
Yes, and that was what we looked at when we visited Empower. We looked at the assessments and the various courses. There is a report on our website regarding earlier initiatives we had visited upon Empower. What we found afterwards was that there were not issues in relation to courses. The vast majority of learners found that the courses were very good. That was the general feedback we got. We spoke to tutors and they were very respectful of FETAC's requirements. The issue, I believe, was something that had to do with the ownership and management of the organisation.
Comment on this
My opinion for what it is worth is that FETAC's credibility is not great. When the question of accreditation arose, it suspended the company but did not tell the students, the staff or the public.
Comment on this
With respect, I think we told them as quickly as we could. As I indicated to the Chairman, this was new territory for everybody involved. The learners who have come through the process and who have been in touch with us on a regular basis have expressed gratitude to FETAC for sorting out the situation.
Comment on this
Many have expressed dissatisfaction, namely, the people who have lost fees and have been left high and dry because of FETAC's delay of six days short of one month, from 13 September to 7 October.
Comment on this
With respect, there were difficulties around that time but those issues have been resolved.
Comment on this
Not to the satisfaction of the students because they have been left high and dry because of their fees. There is also the question of accreditation.
Comment on this
I have to disagree with the Chairman. The students have been placed on other programmes. The numbers I have provided to the committee relate to what the students were entitled to at the time. Some 528 students were certified as they had completed their assessments and we ensured they got their certificates. That was part of our role to ensure they were looked after. We are also looking after students who were due to be assessed but had not been assessed. Those students who had enlisted on programmes and lost money have been offered other opportunities to complete their programmes. We acknowledge that it was not a perfect situation. I accept that, but we have done what was required of us under the legislation and within our remit. We may not have proceeded at the pace that some learners would have wished but we have given this issue significant time resources to do what we could in respect of the issue.
Comment on this
I beg to disagree with Mr. McHugh. On the broader issue what is the FETAC position on all FÁS courses that it has been examining? Is Mr. McHugh in a position to satisfy himself that all FÁS courses are bona fide?
Comment on this
We are going through a process relating to certification. FÁS is obliged under its quality assurance agreement to bring certain issues to our attention and in November 2010 it did what was required under that agreement. We talked to them and said we would look at their internal quality assurance in respect of assessments and requests for certification. We visited four particular centres and on foot of the visits to those four centres we found issues that needed to be resolved. We were not sure whether this was reflected in the particular four centres or whether it was across all 17 centres. We continued our examination of their procedures and went to all 17 centres across the country where they request certification from us. We will publish a report in February when the whole issue is resolved. We found some systemic issues and we then requested FÁS to put in place certain measures that would allow us to proceed with certification. FÁS is in the process of doing that but in advance of that, there were a number of areas where we were able to say there were no issues and we could proceed with certification. There were no issues in relation to apprenticeships, CSCS courses or single certificate awards, known as minor awards where there is a single component. The delay that occurred because FETAC decided not to issue certificates was resolved in relation to those. What remains outstanding relates to certification requests on foot of completion of courses. There are two areas where FÁS is co-operating with FETAC on major awards and special purpose awards which have more than one component. The issue that we found was that the computation of the requirements needed double and treble checks and FÁS is now carrying out that process and we would expect to be able to resolve the matter in the near future.
Comment on this
Is what Mr. McHugh described a reaction by FETAC to an invitation from FÁS to examine the courses?
Comment on this
Yes, that is right. That is its responsibility. Under the quality assurance agreement that we have with all providers, if there are issues relating to any certification, providers are obliged to bring this to our attention and we address it. There are other ways of looking at this which FETAC has in place. I mentioned earlier that FETAC monitors private providers. We have a risk assessment of areas where issues might come up and we focus our monitoring on those areas. We have a programme of monitoring that is now in place. As I would have said, in the first instance, we concentrated on private providers, the second step which is starting shortly is to monitor FÁS and to detail the degree to which it has implemented its quality assurance approval. We will then be following that with a monitoring of the VECs.
Comment on this
Would I be unfair if I said that the FETAC monitoring programme seems to be deficient in that in the case of Empower it took the Skillnets State agency to inform FETAC about its reservation about that company's courses? In the case of the deficiencies in a broad range of FÁS courses, it took FÁS to alert FETAC to the issues relating to its courses. How can FETAC have confidence in its monitoring programme?
Comment on this
It is not quite accurate to say that FETAC relied on Skillnets to tell us that there were issues with Empower.
Comment on this
That is what Mr McHugh said earlier. He agreed with me when I said that Skillnets brought it to his attention in February 2010.
Comment on this
It brought certain matters to our attention, but it did not bring matters that were -----
Comment on this
If FETAC was aware of it before Skillnets brought it to its attention, will Mr. McHugh tell us what he did before Skillnets brought it to his attention?
Comment on this
There are two reports on our website relating to monitoring businesses that we were looking at and we had brought to the attention of Empower. We were already aware of Empower and its operations.
Comment on this
Mr. McHugh states that FETAC was aware of Empower and its operations? Was it aware of deficiencies in its training courses?
Comment on this
There were no major deficiencies in its procedures. The issues that were arising related to matters outside our remit, which related to funding. These items are on record. We were aware of what was happening in relation to our responsibilities. We did not get involved and we did not follow through on funding issues, because that is not within our remit.
Comment on this
As I am not responsible for it, I cannot say-----
Comment on this
Yes, we also had discussions with FÁS. However, I would not like to state on oath who precisely has responsibility for the funding of our funding-related issues that arose in Empower Training because that is not my-----
Comment on this
When Mr. McHugh became aware of funding deficiencies, did he take the trouble to establish who was responsible and did he tell them?
Comment on this
No, they told us that they had funding issues.
Comment on this
FÁS did, as did Skillnets. It was through Skillnets and it stated there were funding issues. We decided that we had better ascertain-----
Comment on this
In the letter the Chairman mentioned earlier in February or March of-----
Comment on this
No, I refer to funding issues. We are getting confused here between what are funding-----
Comment on this
I am getting confused because I cannot add up what Mr. McHugh is telling members. He has stated that he was aware of deficiencies prior to Skillnets informing FETAC of this in February 2010.
Comment on this
What was Mr. McHugh aware of, who told him and when he became aware of it, who did he tell?
Comment on this
I am stating what are our responsibilities. Our responsibilities do not relate to funding and consequently, we did not follow through on funding. That was not our responsibility.
Comment on this
We looked at that for which we were responsible, namely, the procedures it was required to carry out under its quality assurance agreement with us. Other bodies were responsible for the funding. We simply were keeping each other informed of the various steps that were being taken. However, we do not have any responsibility in respect of funding.
Comment on this
FETAC has a responsibility to pass on information to those who have such responsibility, if it is aware of deficiencies in funding.
Comment on this
The question I asked earlier was whether Mr. McHugh passed on that information to the responsible bodies.
Comment on this
They informed us and not the other way around.
Comment on this
I revert to my original question. Is Mr. McHugh satisfied as of now with the monitoring mechanism that FETAC has in place?
Comment on this
We have in place a monitoring system that addresses the key risks that face us. That said, we examine it continually because the situation is evolving all the time. We are satisfied with what we have but endeavour continually to strengthen the approaches we take. Last year, for instance, we introduced a different focus on monitoring and how it might be done, which is being implemented at present.
Comment on this
It has been reported that when Mr. McHugh was asked the reason the students, that is, the customers or consumers, were not informed about the situation with Empower Training, he replied that it was the college's responsibility to inform its students. Was that a fair comment? FETAC was aware that Empower Training was suspended but did not inform the public or the students and left it to the company or college to inform its students that it had been suspended.
Comment on this
I appreciate there was a time lapse there and I said that earlier. We were in new territory and had to be sure to be careful about following due process. Were this to happen again, we would be in a much better position to address these issues faster in order that the sort of things that happened would not happen again.
Comment on this
Mr. McHugh has been quoted as stating, "When Empower was told about the suspension, it was the college's responsibility to inform its students." Is this quotation correct?
Comment on this
As part of their quality assurance agreements, all providers are required to keep all their learners up to date with all the current situations. I agree with the Chairman that this does not absolve FETAC from making statements if matters are drawn to our attention. As I mentioned, having learned from that situation, we would be in a much better position to address such issues. It was a most unusual situation in that the owners left the country.
Comment on this
However, FETAC left it to them to inform the students. Surely that constituted the washing of one's hands and responsibilities to the students that FETAC was meant to protect.
Comment on this
It was not our intention not to carry out our responsibilities.
Comment on this
I wish to clarify one or two things. In respect of the split between the university sector and the institutes of technology, I think the figure quoted by Mr. O'Connor was for one category only. There actually are four categories and the details may be found in paragraphs 1.16 to 1.18 of Special Report 74. Second, we do not really have issues with regard to using staffing as matched funding and so on. Our issues there pertained to the consistency of calculation, which again was set out in the report at paragraph 1.71. In addition, some notional amounts were used as matching funding in one institution we visited.
As for the Royal Irish Academy of Music, it is of course true that this issue was first raised in 2008. The context here is that I have been in this job for approximately two and a half years and after the first year, I changed the audit policy and introduced a new probity checklist. At that time, we also began to consider the wider implications for pay policy downstream, especially in the health and various other sectors in which the same staff-type resources are used both in the course of direct delivery and delivery by in grant-aided bodies. When we began to look more deeply and in a more systematic way, those two changes in audit policy threw up this issue. I acknowledge it did not come to our attention in any structured way through sampling before that or if it did, in the case of the Royal Irish Academy of Music it was not an issue because of its institutional independence and because of the actual funding environment that existed in the past.
Finally, I wish to consider the three broad points that might arise out of what has been discussed today. Basically, it is better to summarise them at systems level. Obviously, there is a need for boards in particular to ensure there is regularity in the commitment and payment of funds. In particular, scarce resources should only be committed by the correct governing organ of the entity and in accordance with any approval mechanisms set by law. This is the general principle that would arise out of looking at the FETAC situation. The principle that we were applying in the case of the Royal Irish Academy of Music would be that to manage the wider delivery system, whether in education or in any other sector, it is desirable that the broad pay and expenses norms applicable to State agencies be mirrored in the case of the other delivery entities and while they may not be constituted as State bodies since they rely on the taxpayer for a substantial proportion of their funding. In conclusion, I note that the detail contained in both Special Reports 74 and 75 indicates a high level of innovation in universities covering all the areas such as access, participation, teaching and learning and restructuring. The crucial point is that the results of the SIF projects and the various other innovative approaches that can be found in Special Report 75 should be mainstreamed and, where appropriate, identified opportunities for better practice should be shared widely throughout the system.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Buckley. Is it agreed to dispose of chapters 1, 4 and 5 of Special Report 74? Agreed. Is it agreed to dispose of Special Report 75, to note the 2008 FETAC accounts and to note the 2009 Royal Irish Academy of Music accounts? Agreed.
I thank all the witnesses for their attendance and apologise for the absence of some members who have other business at present outside this room. We must agree next Thursday's agenda, which is Votes 39 and 41 and chapter 36 of the 2009 annual report. We will also be considering the latest accounts of the National Treatment Purchase Fund, NTPF.
The witnesses withdrew.