We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Chapter 13 - The Development of Eircode, the National Postcode System

Contributions 1–213 of 425. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I welcome the witnesses. Before we begin, I ask members, witnesses and those in the Public Gallery to please turn off their mobile phones, because they interfere with the sound quality of the transmission of the meeting.

I advise witnesses that they are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the evidence they are to give this committee. If they are directed by the committee to cease giving evidence in respect of a particular matter and they continue to do so, they are entitled thereafter only to a qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given and they are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise nor make charges against a member of either House, a person outside the House or an official by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members are reminded of the provisions within Standing Order No. 163 that the committee should also refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policies.

I welcome Mr. Mark Griffin, Secretary General of the Department of Communications, Energy and Natural Resources and ask him to introduce his officials.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I am joined this morning by Mr. Martin Finucane, Ms Patricia Cronin, Mr. Brian Carroll, Mr. Brian Walsh and Ms Justina Corcoran.

Comment on this

I welcome Ms Austin from the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform. I ask Mr. McCarthy to make his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

The appropriation account for Vote 29, Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, had total gross expenditure of just under €425 million in 2014. Figure 1, in the presentation, indicates how that expenditure was divided between the various Vote programmes.

The largest programme was in regard to broadcasting. Just under €240 million, or 56% of the total expenditure, was on that programme. The bulk of the expenditure was in the form of grants paid to broadcasters. RTE received just under €179 million, while Teilifís na Gaeilge received €34.3 million, and €14.2 million was paid into the Broadcasting Fund. That expenditure on broadcasting was substantially funded by television licence fee receipts collected by An Post and paid to the Department. In 2014, a total of just over €213 million in broadcast licence fees was received by the Vote, accounting for the bulk of the appropriations in aid of the Vote. Some €11.1 million was paid to An Post in respect of the costs of collecting broadcasting licence fees.

The net expenditure on the Vote in 2014 was around €9 million less than was provided for in the Estimate. The Department got the agreement of the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform to carry over €4.6 million in unspent capital funding to 2015. The balance of the surplus was due for surrender.

Turning to Chapter 13 of the report in the accounts of public services, until July of last year, Ireland was the only developed country that did not operate a system of postcodes. The Eircode system has now been in operation for six to seven months, providing postcodes for both residential and business premises, related to individual postal delivery locations. This differs from the kind of postcode long used in many other states, where the postal services typically operate systems based on individual post codes that may be shared by a number of premises in a defined locality – often a street or road, or a cluster of buildings.

At the end of 2013, the Department entered into a contract with Capita Business Support Services Ireland Limited to develop and implement a postcode system, and to maintain it for ten years. There is an option to extend the contract for a further five years.

The report before the committee this morning sets out the results of an examination of how the costs and benefits of the project were assessed, how the project was managed, the costs to date and the various procurements associated with the project. Members will recall that the postcode project evolved over a long period, commencing in 2005. Initially, the proposal was for a locality-based postcode system, to be operated under licence by a private service provider. This was assessed as not being economically viable, and a Government decision was made in 2006 not to proceed at that time. Work continued on the project, and a Government decision to proceed was taken in 2009. Progress thereafter was slow, due mainly to a combination of a protracted competition to procure a service provider; difficulties in agreeing terms for access to a comprehensive State-owned property and address database owned by Geodirectory; and changes in data protection legislation.

The Department had identified the database access and data protection issues as important at an early stage in the development of the project. Geodirectory is a company established by An Post and Ordnance Survey Ireland, and it was considered to hold the most complete data source for addresses. Discussions relating to its use by a potential postcode licence holder began in 2010 but were not finally resolved until February 2015. Data protection issues arising from an address-specific postcode were identified in 2006, and resulted in a locality-based postcode originally being proposed. While the proposal changed to an address-specific system in 2012, legislation to address the data protection issue only came into operation in July 2015.

Given the likely public expenditure involved, the Department was obliged to undertake a detailed cost-benefit analysis of the proposal and to update it as the project evolved. The cost benefit analysis originally prepared in 2006 identified a net present cost for the project of €96 million. This means that taking account of the timing of cash flows, the costs were expected to exceed the benefits by a net €96 million. A revised analysis in 2008 had a very different result. This projected that the project would generate benefits that would exceed the costs by a net €6 million. This was further revised upwards in 2010 when a €20 million net present value was projected for the project.

The main projected public sector benefit was identified as improved data matching by Revenue, valued at just under €4 million a year. Revenue have since indicated that by the time the Eircode system was launched, it had already largely achieved improved data matching through other address-related developments, such as the establishment of a local property tax register and better data matching techniques. Overall, I concluded that it was not clear that benefits to the value projected in the cost benefit analysis will be achieved as a result of the implementation of Eircode.

The examination also identified a number of shortcomings in the cost-benefit analyses undertaken for the project. In particular, each round of analysis was based on a locality-based model only rather than the address-specific model that was ultimately introduced; the full project costs, including departmental staff and payments to consultants, were not included, and the shadow cost of public funds was not applied to the projected Exchequer-funded maintenance costs; the documentation available from the Department did not fully support some of the values used in the analysis; and different discount factors than those recommended for public sector projects were used.

Estimates of the cost have increased substantially over the life of the project. When first approved by the then Government in 2009, the project was projected to cost the Exchequer €18 million over an 18 month development phase, with no recurrent Exchequer payments to the operator. In 2013, the estimate provided to Government was for a cost of €31 million over a ten year licence period, including recurrent Exchequer payments of the order of €1 million a year. Departmental staff costs or the cost of consultants were not included in that estimate. The examination reviewed the costs incurred to date as well as outstanding contract obligations and estimated that the cost over ten years will be about €38 million. This includes some €686,000 arising from contract changes agreed after the contract was signed.

The procurement of the licence holder proved to be a protracted process. The process began in January 2011 with the publication of a tender pre-qualification questionnaire. The contract was signed almost three years later in December 2013. Issues in regard to procurement included EU concerns around the qualifying criteria for the licence holder tender, and a pattern of non-competitive procurement for consultants engaged to assist the Department with various aspects of the project.

The chapter makes a number of recommendations in regard to future projects of this kind which emphasise the importance of ensuring that adequate project governance structures are in place, with sufficiently broad membership; including all relevant costs in project estimates and in cost benefit calculations; revising and updating the cost benefit analysis where there are material changes or delays, and ensuring documentary evidence is available to support all elements of the analysis and assumptions made; and adhering to national and EU procurement rules when planning and implementing projects.

I am glad to say that the Department has accepted all the recommendations included in the report.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I am here this morning to discuss two issues: the Eircode projects and the 2014 audited accounts of the Department.

The Government approved the award of a contract to Capita Business Support Services in 2013 to develop, roll out and operate the national postcode system, Eircode, under licence for an initial ten-year period. Eircode was launched in July 2015 and a unique seven-digit postcode was provided to each of the 2.2 million residential and business addresses in Ireland. A national information campaign was completed over the summer of 2015 to inform the public about Eircodes.

Public sector bodies are supporting the introduction of Eircode, and since the launch several of them have started using Eircodes in customer engagement and service provision. This process will continue over the coming months. Capita has also signed up more than 20 value-added resellers who provide a broad spectrum of Eircode specialist services to businesses. Since last July there have been almost 3.7 million look-ups on the online Eircode finder, with average daily hits running at 20,000, which shows a high level of customer and commercial awareness of the new system. Some of the committee may have noticed in The Irish Times this morning that the National Ambulance Service, NAS, has committed to the use of Eircodes from the middle of next month. I think that is a very important and useful development, not just from the point of Eircode visibility, but also in terms of the critical service that the NAS provides.

With regard to the 2014 appropriation account, total gross spend under the Vote in 2014 was just less than €425 million, some €15 million below the budget allocation of €440 million. The underspend was primarily due to slower-than-expected expenditure on the trading online voucher scheme, energy research programmes and broadcasting expenditure due to lower-than-forecast TV licence receipts.

I will briefly set out some of the key projects supported from the Vote in 2014. There was expenditure of nearly €46 million on communications, multimedia developments and the information society. This expenditure was primarily on the postcodes project, the national broadband scheme and the second level schools broadband programme. Another milestone was met in 2014 when 269 schools in Counties Carlow, Cork, Kerry, Kilkenny, Limerick, Tipperary, Waterford, Wexford and Wicklow were provided with 100 Mbps broadband connectivity, bringing high-speed broadband connectivity to all 800 post-primary schools under the three phases of the national roll-out programme.

Some €86 million was spent in the energy sector in 2014, of which €64 million was by way of the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland on the delivery of energy efficiency upgrades. The schemes funded include residential grants, grants to low-income energy consumers through the warmer homes scheme, and group community projects. During the year, more than 22,000 buildings, including 12,000 low-income homes, benefitted from an energy efficiency upgrade. Government investment in these schemes supports 3,500 jobs on average, highlighting the importance of the State’s involvement in this area.

Expenditure in 2014 in the broadcasting area amounted to just less than €240 million. Of this, €179 million was paid in grant aid to RTE in respect of revenue from the sale of television licences. A total of €25 million of Exchequer funding and €9.2 million of licence fee funding was provided to TG4 to deliver on programme commitments. A total of €14.1 million in licence fee funding was provided to the Broadcasting Authority of Ireland to support the audio and audiovisual media sector in the production of new television and radio programmes of all genres on Irish culture, heritage and experience, as well as programmes in the Irish language.

Just over €28 million was paid to meet the administration and operational costs of Inland Fisheries Ireland, IFI, and the Loughs Agency. This funding enabled IFI to undertake more than 180,000 patrol hours and more than 7,500 environmental inspections. Some €7.4 million was spent on various geoscience projects, including the mapping of Lough Swilly, Mulroy Bay, Broadhaven Bay, Blacksod Bay, Killary Harbour and Tralee Bay, as well as offshore west Clare, Cork and outer Galway Bay under Integrated Mapping for the Sustainable Development of Ireland's Marine Resource, INFOMAR, the national seabed survey project.

The Department’s administrative budget has been significantly reduced from €40 million in 2007 to just over €21 million in 2014. Notwithstanding this, the Department has continued to oversee and implement a wide range of new and existing programmes, undertake regulatory functions and provide policy advice across its wide brief. I have separately provided the committee with the Vote outturn figures for 2015. These indicate gross expenditure of €400 million in 2015, compared to €424 million in the 2014 outturn. A breakdown of the 2015 outturn by subhead has also been provided. I look forward to assisting the Committee with questions it has on the matters under consideration today.

Comment on this

Thank you, Mr. Griffin. May we publish your statement, please?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Yes.

Comment on this

You mentioned this morning's The Irish Times in your opening statement. I see that Martin Dunne, the director of the NAS, is quoted as saying that the process involved updating emergency service systems to adapt to Eircode, and so on. In 2014, Mr. Dunne wrote: "At no stage has the NAS or myself outlined that this system is the answer to all our needs in relation to rapid access to patients etc, however it is a mechanism that will assist and fill the void that exists at the moment." That is at variance with the statement this morning. What has happened in the meantime and how much was spent to make Eircode compatible with the NAS, or vice versa?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

As I understand it, the NAS was engaged, in any event, in an upgrade of its dispatch facility and information systems. We have been in contact with the NAS since the Eircode design was put in place, discussing with them the utility of Eircode in providing an additional mechanism by which the ambulance service could identify a property and dispatch an ambulance to that location. What we are looking at here is the use of Eircodes, primarily, I would imagine, in rural areas. In terms of the centralisation of ambulance services on a regional or sub regional basis in some parts of the country, it makes eminent sense to me that being able to integrate a code that can identify each and every individual property in the State into the computer-aided dispatch system of the NAS adds potentially significant value to the service and their ability to respond quickly to incidents in a residence or a property.

Comment on this

I accept that, but I understood from the comment made in correspondence in 2014 that that was not the case. The NAS seems to be coming to this after the event, and it would seem, from what Mr. Dunne said in 2014, that they were not included in the process of developing Eircode. That is the point I am making. Is the NAS bringing its systems up to speed to be compatible with Eircode and, if so, how much did that cost?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

How much did it cost?

Comment on this

Yes. We have to add all of these costs - extra add-on costs - to the cost of providing Eircode in order to establish what the real expenditure of taxpayers' money is. Perhaps you could come back to that later on.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

We are quite happy to talk to the NAS and determine a figure, but I expect that the figure is quite minimal. There is-----

Comment on this

You do not know that.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

No, but my expectation would be that the figure is quite minimal. While the engagement-----

Comment on this

What is minimal?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I do not have a figure. The NAS would have to buy a licence from-----

Comment on this

But then you do not know, to be fair.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

No, I do not, but I am giving a view on it. We will find out what the cost was for the NAS specifically for the integration of Eircode. The point I wish to make is that we would expect to see public sector bodies integrate Eircode into their operations as part of the normal business and upgrade cycle that they have in place for their systems, and that is what we are seeing happen in the other bodies that are engaged in upgrades across the public sector at the moment.

While the National Ambulance Service would not necessarily have been consulted as part of the consultation processes that occurred as the design of the postcode system evolved between 2006 and 2013, when a contract was awarded, there were extensive consultations with both the HSE and the Department of Health at various stages, including on the design of Eircode or the postcode itself. While the view in 2006, as referred to by Mr. McCarthy, was that we should land on a non-unique postal address-type block-face postcode, certainly the view that emerged in discussion in the later stages with the HSE, the Department of Health and a range of bodies in the public and private sectors was that a unique postcode was the type of postcode that should be put in place. To use the National Ambulance Service as an example, if one used the postal sector model, which might identify anything between ten and 50 addresses as part of a block, it would be absolutely useless in rural Ireland, where 35% of the addresses are non-unique. We will come back to the committee on that specific point.

Comment on this

We will talk later about it. I call Deputy O'Donovan.

Comment on this

I welcome the representatives of the Department. In 2009, when this whole project started, Mr. Griffin's Department estimated that the cost was €18 million over 18 months. In 2013, the cost rose to €31 million, and then, in 2015, it rose to €38 million. Can Mr. Griffin tell me the actual cost of this project to date?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Let me go back to the sequence of events that the Deputy has described. He is right in saying the 2009 memorandum for Government included an estimate of €14.8 million, which, including VAT, was €18 million. One should bear in mind that was at the pre-tender stage. As one will find with a lot of contracts, whether they are in the public or private sector, it is difficult to determine precisely what the cost of a project is likely to be. The 2013 memorandum for Government included a cost of €25 million, again excluding VAT. That included the €9.5 million for encoding public sector body databases, which the 2010 consultation we undertook highlighted as important in terms of gaining traction, visibility and utility around the Eircode, and it also included costs for geodirectories. Including VAT, the €25 million cost was €31 million. It did not include, as a Comptroller and Auditor General has pointed out, our own internal staffing costs and some additional consultancy costs. The estimated cost, as set out in the Comptroller and Auditor General's report, which we would not dispute based on his use of the methodology he used and which included staffing costs dating back to 2005 when the bulk of the work on this commenced, is about €38 billion, including VAT. To date, or at the end of December 2015, we have spent just short of €21.2 million.

Comment on this

Consider the figures outlined by the Department for the period 2009 to 2013. I presume the 2009 figure was arrived at during the period 2005 to 2010, when this system was being designed. How did the Department get the 2009 estimate so wrong, considering the figure that was actually forecast in 2013? How could the Department's forecast have been so wrong given that it spent the previous five years considering this?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

One of the big changes that occurred, in terms of cost additions that would have arisen in the period from 2009 to 2013, was related to the inclusion of the cost of encoding public sector body databases. That-----

Comment on this

Surely that should have been known. What was going on?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

We did not actually provide for that in the 2009 estimate. There was an analysis done in 2010 following a consultation process. As part of further evaluation in 2012, when the view was expressed that it would be useful and, in fact, essential for the public sector body databases to be included in the-----

Comment on this

I am somewhat lost here. How could the postcode system have been developed, over five years from 2005 to 2010, without the basic information and without having sorted the GeoDirectory issue from the start? How did the Department arrive at an estimated cost without knowing the basic details on the locations of the houses in the country?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I suppose what I am trying to say to the Deputy is that-----

Comment on this

It seems the Department arrived at a cost without having agreed with GeoDirectory as to how much it would require for its database. Is that fair?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

No. I suppose what I am trying to say is that when one considers the evolution of this project, one realises it was first studied in substantial detail in 2006 as part of the report of the National Postcode Project Board, which settled, for a variety of reasons, on a postal sector model. We carried out a very substantial cost-benefit analysis in 2006 and brought the result to the Government in 2007. The decision taken at that stage was not to proceed on the basis that the cost-benefit analysis did not stack up. We went back to the Government in 2009 for further consideration of the matter. The best estimate at that stage, as we have said, was based on a project that would cost €18 million, including VAT. We did not provide for two substantial components at that stage, the biggest one being the encoding of public sector databases. In the intervening period, it was made clear from further evaluation-----

Comment on this

On that point, the Department arrived at a cost without including the public service databases so it went to the Government with a cost for a national postcode system that would have required, as a matter of basic necessity, that level of information.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

No. The decision had not been taken at that time that, as part of the project, we needed to encode public sector databases. That is why the cost was €18 million rather than €18 million plus an additional quantum.

Comment on this

How could the Department have been developing a postcode system at the time given that it was being changed from a locality-based system to an address-based system in 2012? How could the Department have been developing that kind of project without the databases that were required and, at the same time, arriving at a sum for the Government that was €20 million less than what it was in 2015?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

At the risk of repeating myself, it is not unusual in the evolution of projects for the estimated project costs identified before tender to be different from the costs that are part of the outcome of a tender process. In the case of projects across the public and private sectors, it is not unusual at all for that to happen. Let me mention the 2010 consultation process that we undertook with over 60 stakeholders. It included ten to 15 public sector organisations, half a dozen postal delivery and courier service organisations, including An Post, DHL, FedEx, UPS and Nightline, and other representative bodies, such as the Irish Exporters Association, IBEC and the Communications Workers Union. What clearly came out at that stage, and not earlier, was that pan-Government support and early implementation shall provide a major positive stimulus for the dissemination and uptake of the postcode. It was the outcome of that analysis that drove the decision to provide for the update of public sector databases as part of the implementation of the project. That, in itself, added €9.5 million net of that.

Comment on this

I ask the question because there was a large differential over the period in question. In the same vein, there have been significant procurement issues with the project since 2006 and procurement rules seem to have gone out the window. I presume Mr. Griffin accepts the findings of the Comptroller and Auditor General on procurement.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

There are two issues that the Comptroller and Auditor General has raised in relation to procurement.

Comment on this

There are a number of issues.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I will group them into two. The first one was the EU pilot case where a complaint was taken by an individual with the European Commission in relation to the procurement process itself. That complaint was concerned with the structure of the postcode request for tenders, which required a minimum of turnover of €40 million for each member of a bidding consortium, and a potential conflict of interest involving members of the project board. The first thing-----

Comment on this

Will Mr. Griffin elaborate on the potential conflicts of interest involving people on the project board?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Yes. There were two individuals who had been on the national public procurement project board set up in 2006, one a representative from An Post and one a representative of a private company.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

A company called GO Code.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

They were part of the national postcode project board team that assessed the implementation of postcodes back in 2006. The important thing to point out on this is that it was not a formal infringement under the EU treaties. It was what is termed a pilot complaint. The European Commission found in favour of the approach adopted by us in relation to the procurement process. It did ask that a number of adjustments be made to future procurement processes. This involved the subsequent issuing of a circular by the Office of Government Procurement, OGP, on initiatives to assist small and medium enterprises in public procurement. In April 2015, the European Commission notified the Department that the circular, of itself, did not fully address the concerns. We reverted with further information provided to us by the Office of Government Procurement, which has taken a number of steps to support SMEs in the procurement process. The OGP published a suite of model tendering and contract documents to make it easier for contracting authorities to comply with the rules and to drive consistency in how procurement functions are carried out across the entire public sector. The office has also engaged with SME stakeholders who have raised matters in relation to possible barriers for SMEs competing for tender opportunities and, in order to address these issues, has developed a new tendering authority service designed to give an informal outlet for potential suppliers to raise their concerns about a particular live tender process.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

The crucial bit is that the European Commission wrote to the Department on 14 October last and confirmed that there are no grounds to open an investigation into the matter.

Comment on this

I presume Mr. Griffin accepts what the Comptroller and Auditor General said in this regard. Is it not the case that the European Commission also stated that the Irish authorities were requested to adopt measures to avoid similar errors in future and to inform the Commission of those measures?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

We have done that.

Comment on this

In that case, everything was not hunky-dory.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

The Deputy may be familiar with the system within the European Union. If a jurisdiction is in serious trouble, what the Commission will do is launch a formal infringement process. This case never reached that stage - it did not get anywhere near that stage. A complaint was issued and comprehensively dealt with by the Department and the Office of Government Procurement. The Commission has written to the Department accepting what we have said, welcoming the changes that have been introduced by the Office of Government Procurement and stating that there is no basis to further the investigation. We are-----

Comment on this

The Office of Government Procurement also has requirements in respect of contracts awarded without a competitive process where the value exceeds €25,000. In this case, seven of the consultancy contracts met criteria for inclusion in the Department’s statements for 2008, 2013 and 2014 but only two of them were included. Why?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I cannot give the Deputy a full answer.

Comment on this

It must be borne in mind that the issue with the European Commission, which Mr. Griffin stated was sorted out subsequently, arose prior to some of these issues, yet the Department had seven issues with the Office of Government Procurement and only notified it of two of them.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

What the Deputy is talking about is the obligation on Government Departments to provide in a return, under circular 40/02, where consultants have not been engaged by way of a competitive tender process and the value of the contract is in excess of €25,000.

Comment on this

I know what I am talking about because I can see it here. Why did the Department not report that?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Let me deal with some of the-----

Comment on this

We will deal with them individually because the Comptroller and Auditor General outlined them. Consultant A was a retired public servant. For which Department or agency did he work?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I believe, though I cannot say with absolute certainty, that the retired public servant was a former employee of the ESB.

Comment on this

At what level of the organisation was this individual employed?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

In the ESB?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I do not know but I suspect it was quite a senior level. I would have thought it was at a management level, given the experience, capability and expertise he brought to the contract.

Comment on this

According to this information, consultant A was paid €137,000 up to 2014. How much has he been paid since this matter was reported?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

The total payment to consultant A is €146,000.

Comment on this

He was paid €146,000 without competitive tendering.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I suppose, with regard to both consultant A and consultant B, it is not unusual for Government Departments to-----

Comment on this

Can we stick to the question? Consultant A has been paid €146,000 without competitive tendering. Is that the case?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

That is correct, yes.

Comment on this

Consultant B is a retired civil servant. Where did that person work?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Consultant B was a former senior member of staff of the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Assistant Secretary level.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Yes.

Comment on this

This person received €145,000. Who appointed him?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

He was appointed by the Department. The figure is €158,000.

Comment on this

He was paid €158,000 without competitive tendering.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Yes. I suppose it is important for me-----

Comment on this

This is important and I want to stick to-----

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

It is important, and the Deputy will get all the information.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Donovan should proceed.

Comment on this

Consultant C is a retired civil servant. From what Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I believe the Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation was the final Government Department that he was employed by.

Comment on this

Did consultant A, B or C work for the Department of Communications, Energy and Natural Resources at any stage?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Consultant A would have done some work on an earlier project but he was not an employee of the Department.

Comment on this

What is the full payment to consultant C until now?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

The payment to consultant C is €44,000.

Comment on this

Without competitive tendering.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Yes.

Comment on this

All of these figures are in excess of the €25,000 threshold. What is the total amount paid to consultant D to date?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Payment to consultant D, which is a private sector company, is €53,000.

Comment on this

On consultant E-----

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Consultant E is a legal company that was employed by way of an open tender in 2011. Five tenders were received and the final value of that contract was €109,000.

Comment on this

The last contract was consultant F, who was engaged by Ervia.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

That consultant was seconded from Ervia. It is not unusual for the Department to second in from our agencies or commercial semi-State companies. The final amount paid was €201,000.

Comment on this

One of these consultants, PA Consulting, was expected to be paid on the basis of milestones reached, but instead was just paid monthly. It has received €399,000. Is that not so?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

PA Consulting has done work for the Department on the postcodes projects for a number of years now.

Comment on this

It was awarded without a competitive tender.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

No it was awarded by way of competitive tender, the first one in 2005. There were six bidders for that contract. PA Consulting was the successful tenderer. In the second one in 2010, there were 11 bidders for that contract.

Comment on this

Was another contract in 2008 for €54,000 awarded without a competitive process?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Correct.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

That was because the view was taken at that stage that PA Consulting was familiar with the project. As I understand it, the rules on public procurement allow an extension of the contract in certain circumstances up to a value not exceeding 50% of the original tender.

Comment on this

The Comptroller and Auditor General has reported that the contract was awarded to PA Consulting on the basis that payment would be made on receipt of monthly invoices for the support provided in the previous month rather than on the basis of milestones, as was requested under the tender. While the Department engaged in a tendering process, it did not adhere to it and that firm has been paid €399,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

When one looks at 2013 consultancy the Deputy is talking about, the PA consultancy, there were four bidders with the contract awarded to PA on the basis of a certain approach the Comptroller and Auditor General has mentioned in his report. The way the payment system operated subsequently, we believe we got better value for money from that.

Comment on this

That is not the question I asked. Based on what the Comptroller and Auditor General has reported, the tender awarded by the Department stated that specific milestones would have to be reached. Instead, payments were issued monthly. We do not know now if the milestones that were supposed to have been reached were reached or whether it was just payment pro forma based on time. If the tendering process that Mr. Griffin says the Department followed was robust enough, why was it deviated from? Rather than basing the payment on milestones the Department based it on time. Why did that happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I can only give the Deputy a high-level answer in response to this particular question. The view taken in the Department was that notwithstanding the approach that had been outlined in the tender documentation, we would have achieved better value for money, and in fact have achieved better value for money, by applying the type of approach that has now been applied. I assure the Deputy that in relation to the services provided by PA Consulting-----

Comment on this

If that is the case, why was it put into the tender in the first place? PA Consulting has been in since 2006 and obviously knew a lot about this by the time the tenders were received in 2014. What was the point of asking that specific milestones would need to be reached if the Department had no intention of paying it on the specific milestones?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

As things transpired, we expect the actual cost will be less than the amount actually tendered by PA Consulting.

Comment on this

That is not the question I am asking. I asked a very simple question. In the tender, the Department specified that specific milestones would need to be reached before payment would issue, but it did not do that. I am just asking why.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

There are times when the Department has consultants working for it that the approach is adopted that will provide best value for the Department notwithstanding the identified working arrangements that have been set out in the tender documentation. When we have people in and we are working through a complex project like this and we come across an issue, we can decide that it may work better for us at that stage if we re-engineer the approach, the working arrangement, between the Department and the consultant with a view to maximising to the greatest extent possible the value from what we will get from the tender competition.

Comment on this

Was PA Consulting always paid monthly?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

No.

Comment on this

Was it paid on a milestone basis at some stage?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

It was paid on milestones.

Comment on this

When was it decided to change from a milestone basis to a monthly basis?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

In this particular contract, I cannot give the Deputy a straight answer for that.

Comment on this

So we do not know when that happened.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

No, I will get the committee a note on it.

Comment on this

The Comptroller and Auditor General has outlined a catalogue of serious issues relating to procurement. At this stage the official from the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform might enlighten us as to its views of this.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Maybe before-----

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

The Deputy has not really given me a chance to answer.

Comment on this

Based on the questions I have asked.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I understand that. The Deputy has asked me a very specific question on PA Consulting, but I want to say a bit more about the employment of the other consultants he has outlined. This was a very large public private IT project. The history of the Civil Service and public service in delivering large public private IT projects is not great. I recall being before the committee six or seven months ago where the Department was accused - rightly at the time - of not applying the right number or the right level of resources to deal with the Bytel project. We were engaged in a project that was much more complicated than Bytel. It was essential, once the contract was awarded by Government, that we were in a position to deploy the right resources.

Comment on this

I accept that, but-----

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

There is a practice in Departments of using, where necessary, retired public servants and retired-----

Comment on this

I accept that, but my question relates to procurement and my question comes from the report of the Comptroller and Auditor General that I read last night. Regarding consultancy, and assuming I were to accept what Mr. Griffin said at face value, I will outline what is reported about consultant C. Consultant C was employed at a daily rate of €1,230. Further work was contracted for in March 2012 with the approval of the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform for a so-called all-inclusive fee of €2,000. However, payments totalled €38,000. I would like to hear from the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform at this stage because I am a bit at sea as to how we end up with these daily rates of €600, €800, €1,200, open-ended contracts and no tendering process.

Before Ms Austin comes in, I have a further question for Mr. Griffin. Are consultants A, B, C, D, E and F still working on this project?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

No.

Comment on this

When did they terminate?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

They would have terminated during the course of 2015. Shortly after the launch in July, we started to run down the use of these external consultants.

Comment on this

Will the official from the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform comment on the procurement issues? What is happening here seems outrageous.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Austin

The Secretary General has said the way the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform would operate. There are circulars. There are procurements. The Secretary General mentioned circular 40/2002. There is the office of public procurement and various things like that. The Department of Public Expenditure and Reform will give sanction for various things. It will list out requirements. The operation of a procurement procedure will be a matter for the Department concerned and the Accounting Officer. Failures in those systems do occur. There can be human error and things like that. These things will come to attention through the Department's own work, through internal audit or through external audit. The-----

Comment on this

When did the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform become aware of the issues with consultants A, B, C, D, E and F?

Comment on this
Ms Mary Austin

I would have to come back to the Deputy on that. I have only been in the section for a number of months; I have not been there for a year. It would have predated me. I am open to correction on this but it may have been through the Comptroller and Auditor General's report or leading up to the Comptroller and Auditor General's report. I can come back to the Deputy on specifics if he likes.

Comment on this

I presume officials from the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform read the report of the Comptroller and Auditor General.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Austin

Yes.

Comment on this

The Department of Public Expenditure and Reform became aware that seven of the consultancy contracts met criteria for inclusion in the Department's statements to the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform in the years 2008, 2013 and 2014, but only two of them were included. Therefore, during the intervening period, nothing happened.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Austin

As the Deputy will appreciate, if a return is made, the person receiving it will not know whether an error of admission or so on has occurred. The Department would have followed up on the matter with the Department of Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, but we would recognise that the Secretary General had agreed all of the Comptroller and Auditor General's-----

Comment on this

Is it not fair to say that, if the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform followed up, not much notice was taken of it? Consultants A to F only finished last July, but they never went through procurement processes. It is like they won the lotto. Not one of them went through a competitive tendering process, yet there are figures of €146,000, €38,000, €145,000, €137,000 and €37,000. Nothing happened.

Comment on this
Ms Mary Austin

Obviously, that happened before we became aware of an issue in the reporting of-----

Comment on this

The Department of Public Expenditure and Reform was aware of it. I asked whether the Comptroller and Auditor General's report was read, and it was. These people only finished in July when the process concluded. The Department should have been made aware of seven, but the other Department only told it about two. Obviously, no action was taken because the other five seemed to have continued as they had been and they all finished when Eircode was launched. The Department was told of two, given that they were mentioned in the document. That should have been enough reason to start examining whether there were others, but it obviously did not. In the intervening period, these "taxi meters" were out of control. It is a scandal.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I am sorry, but may I pick up on that? Describing this situation and the people involved as "taxi meters" is totally and utterly unacceptable.

Comment on this

It is totally and utterly unacceptable-----

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

No, bear with me.

Comment on this

Mr. Griffin has made an assertion about something that I just said. For me, it is totally and utterly unacceptable for the Secretary General of the Department of Communications, Energy and Natural Resources to tell this committee that consultants who were retired public servants, in some cases with a connection to the Department, received payments in the order of €146,000 without going through a competitive process. If Mr. Griffin takes issue with the fact that I might refer to that as a "taxi meter" or winning the lotto, I am sorry for any offence caused, but it does not in any way conceal the fact that the process has not been adhered to under the rules set down by the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I would accept that in part. By the way, the Deputy has not offended me. He would have to do a lot to offend me.

Comment on this

The taxpayer is offended by this report.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Yes, but it is important to understand the value that these people have provided to the Department. Secondly,-----

Comment on this

Then why did the Department not tender out the process?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

When the contract was awarded to Capita in 2013, we had to move quickly to implement a very complex-----

Comment on this

This issue had been knocking around since 2005-----

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

If the Deputy gives me a chance to explain-----

Comment on this

-----but the Department was in a hurry in 2013.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Will the Deputy give me a chance to explain?

Comment on this

These people remained in situ with renewed contracts. For example, consultant A had contracts dated October 2013, February 2014, September 2014 and January 2015. This person's four contracts' daily rates ranged from €362 per day to €604 per day at a total cost of €146,000. The Department had from 2005 to 2013 to get its act together, but no procurement process was followed in respect of this individual. That is totally unacceptable. That Mr. Griffin is now saying that the Department was in a hurry is not good enough for me as a public representative. The Department of Public Expenditure and Reform also failed the public in this, as it was aware of the situation. The Department of Communications, Energy and Natural Resources made it aware, as did the Comptroller and Auditor General, yet nothing happened. Nothing ever happens as regards procurement.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Let me try to deal with some of the issues that the Deputy raised. For the benefit of the committee and others who are watching, this is a large-scale, complex, public-private ICT project. We simply had to ensure that it was resourced quickly and with the right skill sets. I am referring to people with experience of stakeholder management, outreach, complex communication projects and management of complex public-private IT projects. The issue that we discussed a few minutes ago related to the encoding of public sector databases. Some 80 million records across approximately 20 bodies were to be encoded. It was important that we had someone in place who had experience of operating at a senior level with Departments and the networking capacity to get the job completed within a relatively short period.

Comment on this

And it just so happened to be a retired public servant.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

It is not unusual for-----

Comment on this

We know it is not unusual. We see that here week in, week out.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

There is provision for that. It is allowed under the-----

Comment on this

What is not allowed is the lack of competitive tendering.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I know, and I am trying to-----

Comment on this

How were the individuals selected?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

The two consultants-----

Comment on this

Just call them consultants A, B, C or whichever they are.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Consultant A-----

Comment on this

What attracted the Department to each one of them? What outstanding skills had they to cause the Department to-----

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

The Department had worked with consultant B on the digital switchover.

Comment on this

Which consultant was that?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Consultant B.

Comment on this

Start at the beginning for whoever it is.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Consultant A was involved in the public sector body, PSB, encoding. He would have been well recognised as someone who had extensive, senior-level IT experience within the public sector and, crucially, a network within the public sector system in terms of contacts at a high level.

Comment on this

What was the largest project that consultant A managed?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

He managed the public sector database encoding and worked with public sector bodies on ironing out any issue that arose in the application of Eircode within their systems.

Comment on this

What of consultant B?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Consultant B was what we would have termed the communications lead. He successfully managed the national digital switchover for the Department. Given the effect of the outreach campaign undertaken in the summer of 2015, the number of people supported through that campaign and the lack of concern regarding a project that some among the target group may have considered intrusive, the output was extraordinary.

Comment on this

What of consultant C?

Comment on this

Was consultant B working for the Department of Communications, Energy and Natural Resources? Mr. Griffin stated that he managed the digital switchover.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

No, he was not an employee of the Department.

Comment on this

But he was a retired civil servant.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Yes.

Comment on this

From which Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I am sorry, but he was a retired public servant from the ESB.

Comment on this

No, that is consultant A.

Comment on this

I am asking about consultant B.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I am sorry. Consultant A is the individual who dealt with the PSB encoding and consultant B is the individual who dealt with the communication aspects of-----

Comment on this

From which Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Consultant A was-----

Comment on this

No. Consultant B.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Consultant B was with the ESB.

Comment on this

No. Mr. Griffin told me a while ago that consultant A had been with the ESB-----

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Sorry.

Comment on this

-----and that consultant B had managed the digital switchover.

Comment on this

If the Deputy bears with us for a moment, we will tease this out. Mr. Griffin stated that consultant A had been with the ESB, given his senior-level ICT experience and management of public sector projects.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I beg the committee's pardon. Consultant A was with the ESB. He did the-----

Comment on this

He retired from the ESB.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Yes. He was the communications lead. Consultant B was retired from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine.

Comment on this

What did he bring to the table?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

He was the individual who had the substantial public sector ICT experience.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Griffin referring to the digital switchover?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

No. That was consultant A.

Comment on this

Consultant B was from the Department of Agriculture, Food and Marine.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

A retired official at assistant secretary level from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine who would have operated for the bulk of his career in the IT sector.

Comment on this

Was there anything in particular in the IT sector that he was experienced with or was it general IT?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

He was responsible for the IT network and systems in the Department, which is a very large operation, as the Chairman knows.

Comment on this

He was responsible for the IT sector within the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, but he had no specific expertise of coding for postcodes and so on. He came from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine and had no connection to Mr. Griffin's Department.

Obviously that was a skill set that was available. If one went down to Sir John Rogerson's Quay, one would probably find thousands of people with that skill set, yet the position was still not advertised.

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

No, I do not accept that for a second.

Comment on this

I will allow the Deputy back in in a moment but I wish to clarify the matter. What about consultant C?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

Consultant C was employed as the process auditor on the procurement process.

Comment on this

For where?

Comment on this
Mr. Mark Griffin

I beg your pardon. He was a retired civil servant.

Comment on this