We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Committee on Budgetary Oversight

Post-Budget 2027 Engagement: Discussion

Summary

ESRI said Budget 2027 brings modest income gains overall, with the lowest-income households benefiting most, but is likely to leave child poverty broadly unchanged; it welcomed the new disability payment while noting it is limited, and warned that broad carbon-tax cuts are poorly targeted. Social Justice Ireland and NERI criticised inadequate welfare increases, insufficient investment in housing and services, and tax cuts that weaken the revenue base, calling for stronger disability and child supports and a broader, more sustainable tax system. In questioning, witnesses also highlighted the need to expand social housing and childcare, while the Chair pointed to Ireland’s progressive income tax system and rising minimum wage.

Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I ask everyone to turn off their mobile phones and devices or put them in silent mode.

I wish to explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards references witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. Witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the presentation they make to the committee. This means they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Chair to ensure this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if witnesses' statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Some of today's witnesses are giving evidence remotely from a place outside the parliamentary precincts. As such, they may not benefit from the same level of immunity from legal proceedings as a witness who is physically present does. Such witnesses have already been advised that they may think it appropriate to take legal advice on the matter.

I advise members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex to participate in public meetings. In this regard, I ask any members participating via MS Teams that, prior to making their contribution to the meeting, they confirm they are on the grounds of the Leinster House campus.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, I will direct them to discontinue your remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Today marks the committee's first post-budget engagement. This will lead into the committee's forthcoming post-budget report. For the first session, I welcome, from the Economic and Social Research Institute, ESRI, Dr. Karina Doorley, co-ordinator of tax and welfare research; Dr. Claire Keane, associate research professor; and Dr. Rachel Slaymaker, research officer. From Social Justice Ireland, I welcome Mr. John McGeady, chief executive officer; Ms Susanne Rogers, research and policy analyst; Ms Michelle Murphy, research and policy analyst; and Ms Mansi Rawat, economic and social analyst. From the Nevin Economic Research Institute, NERI, I welcome Dr. Tom McDonnell, co-director, and Mr. Ciarán Nugent, economist.

The committee welcomes the opportunity to engage with the witnesses and I thank them for being here today. I now invite Dr. Doorley to make her opening statement.

Comment on this
Dr. Karina Doorley

I thank the committee for the invitation to appear before it. I am joined by my colleagues, Claire Keane and Rachel Slaymaker. We are very grateful for the opportunity to appear before the committee to provide our assessment of budget 2027.

Every year, the ESRI carries out a distributional impact assessment of the budget, using SWITCH, the ESRI's tax benefit model. This work is possible thanks to core funding provided to the ESRI by the Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation and funding for the SWITCH work programme provided by the Departments of Health, Finance, Social Protection and Children, Disability and Equality.

We compare the effect of the budgetary reforms to a scenario in which policy reform keeps the distribution of income, or purchasing power, constant. In practice, this implies comparing changes in the parameters of the tax and welfare systems to an index baseline in which these parameters change in line with forecast income or price growth. Changes to direct tax and welfare measures and childcare supports announced as part of budget 2027 are, on average, ahead of forecast price growth of 3%, and broadly in line with forecast wage growth of 4.1% for 2027. This means that at the household level, direct tax and welfare measures announced as part of budget 2027 will result in small income gains, compared with a budget pegged to price growth, and almost no average change compared with a budget pegged to wage growth.

There is variation in how budget 2027 will affect households of different income levels, with the lowest income households gaining, compared with both price and wage index policies, and higher income households experiencing smaller changes or no change in their disposable income.

Some of the protective effect of budget 2027 for the lowest income tenth of the population is due to the new €500 per year cost-of-disability payment for recipients of some long-term disability payments. This has been introduced to help households with disabled members to meet their extra consumption needs, which previous ESRI research has shown can reach half of disposable income.

There are some budgetary measures targeted specifically at children. The increase to the child support payment is above forecast price and wage growth for 2027, while the increase to the working family payment is above price growth, but below wage growth.

The increase to universal childcare subsidies for children up to senior infants and the extension of the income-assessed subsidy and fee cap will reduce childcare costs for families who use formal childcare. However, the overall effect of the budget package, including these measures, is to hold child poverty relatively constant compared to a wage- or price-indexed baseline. Although the increased support for childcare costs may indirectly reduce child poverty through increased parental labour supply, this will require the supply of formal childcare to expand. Many more measures directed at children will be necessary to achieve the Government target for child consistent poverty of 3% or below. A second tier of child benefit remains the most effective way of meaningfully reducing the number of children experiencing poverty and deprivation.

The reduction in carbon tax on home heating oil and gas is untargeted to the extent that it benefits all households who use heating oil and gas, whether they can afford the recent price increases or not. This makes the measure expensive and reduces the incentive for households who can afford to decarbonise to do so. Targeted measures to support low-income households would maintain this incentive while protecting the most vulnerable groups. The cumulative package of indirect tax measures for 2027, including the reduction of carbon tax on home heating oil and gas, the phased reinstatement of fuel excises and the increases to carbon tax on goods other than home heating oil and gas, will result in aggregate income losses across the income distribution next year, averaging 0.5% of disposable income.

Although there is no formal policy of indexation of tax and welfare parameters in Ireland, in practice, historically, the tax and welfare system has tended to keep up with both price and wage inflation. Taking the last seven budgets together, we find that compared to a scenario of wage-indexed budgets since before the pandemic, households are slightly worse off, by around 0.3% of disposable income on average, as a result of direct tax and welfare measures and childcare supports. However, those in the lowest income group have seen substantial, policy-driven income gains which persist up to the middle of the income distribution. As a result, policy changes have been nudging poverty rates down since 2020 for all groups. Compared to a series of wage-indexed budgets, the overall at-risk-of-poverty rate is down by around two percentage points since 2020. We thank the committee members for their time and the opportunity to discuss budget 2027 and we look forward to answering related questions.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

A Chathaoirligh agus a choiste, go raibh maith agaibh as an gcuireadh. Social Justice Ireland advocated that budget 2027 should do four things: protect the most vulnerable; promote a more equitable distribution of resources; invest in our social infrastructure and services; and future-proof the public finances. It is therefore disappointing that the budget only provided an additional €10 per week in core welfare payments. Such an inadequate increase condemns vulnerable households to a winter of prolonged hardship with high food and energy prices. We also regret that a system of benchmarking was not introduced. Tracking earnings is crucial if inequalities are not to widen further between earners and households reliant on social welfare.

The increase to the child support payments and the working family payment threshold and the reduction in childcare costs are welcome. However, if we are to eliminate child poverty, the Government must improve core welfare payments. The introduction of a cost-of-disability payment is welcome and long overdue. While the annual €500 payment is a first step, making this a weekly payment and increasing it sufficiently to meet need is crucial going forward. Social Justice Ireland welcomes the increase in the personal and employee tax credits. This is especially valuable for low-income workers. However, we regret these tax credits were not made refundable, which would have seen the lowest earners benefit from the increases.

In terms of income tax changes, the budget is skewed to provide larger gains to those on higher incomes. Families below the standard rate threshold gain least from the income tax choices across budgets 2026 and 2027. Single-earning couples on an income of €30,000 have seen their weekly income decrease under this Government, the only group to do so and one on the lowest incomes. The rich-poor gap will increase marginally by 90 cent per week. While this is only a small increase, it represents a move in the wrong direction, widening rather than narrowing this gap. As a result of policy choices, next year’s gap will be the second highest we have recorded since 2014.

Despite an allocation of €29.1 billion for healthcare in this budget, this will not fund the existing level of service, ELS. While current spending was given a €1.6 billion boost, this headline figure completely fails to absorb the health sector's massive €1 billion overspend. In respect of education, we welcome the additional special education posts and the additional special needs assistants. However, clarity is required as to whether this will only meet current demand or lead to an increase in overall provision. We regret the Government did not allocate sufficient resources to reduce the pupil-teacher ratio by 1.5 points. No detail has been given as to how the Department plans to meet current demand and cater for future demographic pressures.

We welcome the €3 billion investment to deliver 11,250 social homes. However, social housing targets remain inadequate given the ongoing need for housing of around 134,000 households. The allocation also fails to make up for the shortfall of 4,955 units in the Government's own targets between 2022 and 2025 targets. Around €2.2 billion of current funding will continue to meet the social housing needs of over 110,000 households through HAP, RAS and the social housing current expenditure programme, SHCEP. Investing in social housing would have lowered these long-term costs and provided secure, affordable homes for those most in need. Meanwhile, analysis shows that subsidies like the help-to-buy scheme disproportionately support higher-income earners to purchase higher-priced properties and maintain high house prices, rather than boost supply.

We welcome the €170 million allocation to climate action and environment. While we note the commitment to continue to fund SEAI upgrade schemes, there is no clarity as to the impact cuts to the carbon tax will have on schemes funded by this revenue. We regret this budget did not contain the long-term strategic investment required to deliver the services and infrastructure needed for a just transition.

Removing expected windfall revenues, there will be an underlying budget deficit of €12 billion in 2026 and €13.4 billion in 2027. The unsustainability of this position is of major concern. A worrying aspect of this budget was the scale of tax expenditures or tax breaks. The absence of detailed documentation to justify the cost and rationale for these measures undermines fiscal stability and long-term resilience. An increase in Ireland’s overall level of taxation is unavoidable to even maintain present levels of public services and supports in the context of demographic change, never mind to provide the resources to build a better society. As a policy objective, Ireland can remain a low-tax economy, but not one incapable of adequately supporting necessary economic, social and infrastructural requirements. We welcome questions from the committee members.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

I thank the Cathaoirleach, members and staff of the committee for the invitation to appear before it today. We value the opportunity to give our views on budget 2027. Budget 2027 was close to €9 billion. Public spending will increase by roughly 6% and this increase was accompanied by a further narrowing of the tax base with a package of around €2 billion in measures. The Government’s total fiscal package exceeds the potential growth rate of the economy, which we estimate at circa 5%. There have, in practice, been consistent overruns in recent years so we should consider the budget numbers as a floor.

The recent half decade has been characterised by record-setting employment growth and levels of employment. From an output perspective, whether modified domestic demand, MDD, GNI* or GDP, the economy has also been growing exceptionally fast in recent years and we now have a positive output gap. We therefore observe that the budget is modestly procyclical.

The budget will be mildly inflationary though it should have been deflationary. This is not the same thing as saying that public spending is growing too quickly. A fast rate of growth in public spending is needed merely to address infrastructure gaps; the growing demand for public services; population and age pressures; and price inflation. Indeed, the vast bulk of the increase in public spending is required simply to finance existing levels of service adjusted for population and price pressures. The Government was correct to continue expanding investment although the relatively small allocation for public sector pay will inevitably need to be increased.

Crucially, the outlay for public spending needed to be accompanied by a tax package that actually broadened the tax base rather than narrowing it. The annual hollowing out of the tax base has become a major problem now. The public finances fall into significant deficit once we exclude potentially transitory corporation tax receipts. The Government has, in effect, created a situation whereby the health of the public finances has become dependent on the health of a tiny number of US multinationals and their tax planning decisions. The government should be saving as much of these volatile receipts as possible and an economy operating close to capacity should be running a fiscal surplus. As it happens, the Government is projecting headline surpluses of €6.7 billion in 2026 and €9.5 billion in 2027, though these translate into deficits of €12.1 billion and €13.5 billion once windfall corporation taxes are excluded. The underlying budgetary position is clearly unsustainable.

Leaving aside whether it is a good idea or not, an indexation of the tax system should not be considered a tax cut. Ireland has a progressive income tax system and this means that, as people's wages increase each year, their effective tax rate will also increase unless wage indexation is deployed to counter this effect. Put differently, full indexation amounts to a standstill position in the effective tax rate.

Wages are projected to grow by circa 4% in 2027 meaning that full indexation is also close to 4%. This was broadly achieved in budget 2027, albeit not uniformly across different aspects of the taxation system. Notably, the failure to index in budget 2026 means that workers are net losers over the lifetime of this Government, in the sense that they are paying higher effective tax rates. Indexation over the two years will be circa 2.5% behind price inflation and circa 4% behind wage growth.

The problem is that the income tax indexation was accompanied by a swathe of actual tax cuts. These tax cuts mainly related to capital taxation and they benefited businesses, inheritors, investors, savers, pubs and farmers. In addition, there were a range of environmentally damaging tax cuts including deferrals and reductions in carbon tax and temporary reductions in fuel excise. There was little economic justification for most if not all of these measures. Most of the tax cuts were either highly regressive or environmentally damaging.

Given the long-run fragility of the public finances and the current strong position of the economy, it would have been much better to have increased taxes in budget 2027. A range of plausible options, mainly focusing on capital taxation and tax expenditures, have been proposed by the Commission on Taxation and supported by, for example, the Irish Congress of Trade Unions. The Government’s ongoing programme of tax cuts is making us increasingly vulnerable to a fiscal shock and future austerity.

A number of the budgetary measures will impact on the cost of living in 2027. The Government estimates that HICP inflation will average 3.3% in 2026 and 3% in 2027. It should be said that the Government’s 2027 projection is on the lower end of inflation estimates, which tend to be marginally above 3%.

The most important cost-of-living lever by far is the welfare budget. The logical approach would have been to index the welfare budget to the higher of expected price and wage inflation. Instead, the Government adopted its traditional approach of increasing payments by X euro, in this case mainly €10. This translates to a 3.3% increase in the State contributory pension with slightly higher percentages for many other benefits. If price inflation comes in higher than the Government forecast, we can expect deprivation rates to increase next year. A €15 increase would have been more appropriate.

Notably, the Government once again failed to introduce a second tier of child benefit to take thousands of children out of poverty, instead favouring tax cuts for certain interest groups. It is deeply regrettable that child poverty was not a priority in the budget. The Government also failed to put in place an adequate cost-of-disability payment.

There was potential relief for some groups with a cap placed on childcare costs though the details here are not fully clear. In the longer term we need to move to a model of childcare where it is delivered as a public service.

The cuts to fuel excise will disproportionately benefit higher income households. Universal energy credits, for example, would have been more progressive and deadweight could have been ameliorated by treating the credits as taxable income. Some workers will obviously benefit from the cut in fuel excise. On the other hand, commuters relying on public transport will pay larger fares in 2027. This represents another anti-environment measure in the budget. The minimum wage was increased by 79 cent which will comfortably exceed inflation. However, the Government has again broken its promise to achieve its own standard of a living wage, with the timeline for reaching 60% of median hourly earnings now abandoned.

The Government has actively made things worse with regard to the environment and we seem to have lost focus on climate issues. In addition, the Government’s profligate pro-cyclical budgeting increases the probability of a fiscal shock and pushes fiscal costs on to future generations. It is not clear what vision the Government has for the economy. Policy making needs to shift from a tactical approach to a strategic one. We are happy to take questions.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in today. At a time of record corporation tax windfalls, why does Social Justice Ireland believe the Government continues to rely so heavily on HAP, RAS and other subsidies rather than building the social homes that would reduce long-term costs and provide security for people?

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

The Government is in the best position to answer why it chooses to do something. It is very clear to us that the huge sums of money that are being spent on these subsidies to keep social housing within the private rental market is really money being poured down the drain when that money could be spent on investing in social housing. The Government budgeted for 11,250 new social homes in 2027. Its own target is 12,000 meaning the budget did not provide enough funding for its own target, let alone the fact that target is too low for the actual housing need. Not alone that, but it does not take account of the shortfalls in previous years' social housing targets. It is not clear as to why the Government does not do it at a time when we have these huge resources. We need to prepare for the future. Part of preparing for the future is ensuring that we are in a strong fiscal position but part of it is ensuring that we have adequate infrastructure. This is clearly a significant failing of this Government.

Comment on this

Social Justice Ireland argued that schemes such as help to buy disproportionately benefit higher income buyers, inflate prices and do little for supply. Given the evidence Mr. McGeady cites, why does he believe the Government persists with these measures?

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

We are not clear as to why. Obviously, there is a political imperative there. Individuals who are buying houses will see this as a welcome measure but ultimately in the long run it is a damaging measure. It supports an economy whereby housing prices remain high. That money would be better spent on building more homes and building social homes. Building more social homes takes pressure off the private rental sector. Taking pressure off the private rental sector will result in perhaps not a reduction but certainly not an increase in rents, which would allow people to begin to save money to purchase houses, those who are in a position to do so.

Comment on this

Mr. McGeady welcomed the new €500 annual cost-of-disability payment as a first step but argued it should be a weekly payment at a higher rate. Given the research the Department already has on the extra cost of disabilities, why does he believe the Government opted for the least ambitious version possible for people with disability?

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

Before the budget was announced, there was a lot of a rhetoric about the need to bring public spending under control and maybe that fed into that. In his opening statement, Dr. McDonnell from NERI said that the challenge here is not bringing public spending under control per se but having a stable fiscal position going forward, including the need to invest. Part of that investment would be investment in people and in communities. Particularly for people with disabilities who face significant costs, a cost-of-disability payment was absolutely essential. We really welcome that it has been brought in, but €500 is far below what was required. Research into this by the ESRI showed the level of additional costs borne by people with disabilities and €500 is nowhere near enough. We strongly encourage the Government over the coming budgets to increase that payment substantially and to turn it into a weekly payment so that people are able to make decisions on a week-to-week basis and deal with costs as they come rather than having a lump-sum payment at the end of the year when they have already borne costs throughout the year.

Comment on this

Representatives of disability groups appeared before the committee a couple of weeks ago. For them, getting services for the children is as big a problem as weekly payments. Is Social Justice Ireland happy with the additional money, if any, the Government has put into disability services for children?

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

Ms Murphy might wish to come in on that point more broadly.

Comment on this
Ms Michelle Murphy

I thank the Deputy for the questions. We would have expected a higher investment in disability services. We all know the payment and the cost of services go hand in hand. In conjunction with a payment, sufficient investment in services is required. It is unclear whether the announced investment will cover existing shortfalls and waiting lists in services and also provide for additional places. Demographic change gives rise to additional needs. Regarding the payment, there is substantial research as to the rate at which the cost-of-disability payment should be set.

We urge the Government to look at the research on a cost-of-disability payment in Ireland and use it to inform a weekly payment going forward now that the principle of the payment has been delivered. In terms of the service itself, there is still no clarity as to whether it will just cover existing demand as opposed to future demand or if services can be provided to the people who need them across the country.

Comment on this
Mr. Johnny Guirke

How many of the four tests Social Justice Ireland set before the budget - protecting the vulnerable, equity, investment in services and infrastructure, and future-proofing - does it believe budget 2027 passed? Where did it fall furthest short?

Comment on this
Ms Susanne Rogers

The Parliamentary Budgetary Office, PBO, on budget night had a forecast for what it thinks the poverty line will be next year. It has forecast that it will go up for those aged 65 and over, in particular. This is crystal ball stuff, obviously. The current rate for such people is 14.8% and the PBO has forecast 23.5%. The current rate overall is 12.6% and the PBO has forecast 15%. For children under 18, the current rate is 16.9% and the forecast is 18.4%. That is from the PBO looking to see what budget 2027 is doing, where it is going and what the at-risk-of-poverty rate is. When we see the survey on income and living conditions from the CSO probably next March, I hope the figures will not be at this level but this is where the PBO sees them going. It is quite worrying in a country, as the Deputy said, with full employment and a budget surplus. We have all of the resources. We do not even know what to do with them and we still seem to have this problem. I walk around Dublin and I keep wondering whether it is 1986, but no, it is 2026. There are a lot of similarities such as dereliction, homelessness and open addiction. These really high levels of poverty are very worrying.

Comment on this
Mr. Johnny Guirke

I have a few questions for the ESRI. What does the ESRI's analysis tell us about children in households just above the poverty threshold? Can a budget that holds the overall poverty rate relatively constant still leave a significant number of families unable to afford essentials? For households in rural Ireland that rely on home heating oil because alternatives are unavailable or impractical, how should the Government balance affordability, the availability of alternatives and the transition to lower carbon heating? If the Government's objective is to reduce child poverty to 3% or less, but the ESRI's analysis shows the current budget will hold child poverty relatively constant, what policy changes does the ESRI think should have been prioritised in this budget?

Comment on this
Dr. Karina Doorley

I will take the child poverty question. The poverty line is just an income line. If you are below the poverty line, you are deemed to be at risk of poverty and if you are above it, you are not. Many children and indeed adults who are living above the poverty line are still at risk of deprivation. That means they cannot afford essentials. That usually comes about because their income is not enough to meet their consumption needs because they have extra consumption needs. For example, there might be a person with a disability in the household, or it might be a lone parent household and the income has to stretch a bit further. Children in households above the poverty line can still experience deprivation. The at-risk-of-poverty rate, which refers to the poverty line, is not the only income measure or poverty measure we should look at when we are considering whether reform is targeting these children adequately.

In our post-budget analysis, we looked at the effect of the entire package of budgetary measures on the at-risk-of-poverty rate of children because it is directly linked to income. We found no change, more or less, in the at-risk-of-poverty rate of children as a result of budget 2027 and no change in the poverty gap which measures how far below the poverty line children are. We do not see either of those metrics moving much as a result of this.

On the second tier of child benefit, euro for euro, if you introduce a second tier of child benefit, it will result in a larger poverty decline than making changes to existing payments because existing payments miss some of the groups that are at risk of poverty. This is either because they are not eligible for social welfare, they are living in households that are not eligible for the working family payment or they are not claiming either of those because they do not know they are eligible. There is a group of children being missed by these payments that a second tier of child benefit would adequately capture. Does Dr. Keane want to come in?

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Keane

I will speak about home heating oil. As Mr. McGeady mentioned, while the carbon tax cuts provide some short-term relief, they also reduce the funds available to try to target people. Research by Trinity College has shown that the uptake of things like heat pumps, electric vehicles and solar panels - things that can really help to cushion the impact of the fuel crisis - is really targeted towards higher income households and higher income areas. There are people on lower incomes who will really struggle, even with grants in place, to pay any upfront costs for those schemes. One worry we have with carbon taxes being rolled back in some areas is that it might reduce funding for SEAI grants, for example. A new scheme was announced at the end of September. We will have to watch that to see if it does anything to increase take-up and target lower-income households that will need a lot more support to move away from fossil fuel dependency.

Comment on this
Mr. Johnny Guirke

I always feel after budgets that people will be left behind. If we are any kind of a society at all, we should not be leaving people with disabilities and mental health issues behind. There is a certain section of people whom we as a State should not be leaving behind. We are not doing a very good job of it at the moment.

I have some questions for Dr. McDonnell. In his view, why has the Government not put in place an adequate cost-of-disability payment? What financial pressure does the current approach place on people with disabilities and their families?

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

I cannot answer as to why the Government did not bring in a more comprehensive reform. I suppose the assumption would be that it had not put in place the details from a bureaucratic perspective and it felt it was simply easier to do it this way. At least the principle is in place now and it can be increased in future years. Presumably the Government's goal is to reduce poverty for groups experiencing disability. Clearly, it got lost in the shuffle in terms of its adequacy. I agree with the point that it is not simply about the payment but also the services and all that is in place to ensure people experiencing disability can participate fully in society. Other labour market reforms, such as working from home and flexible work, are important too. It is broader than just the payment but clearly the payment itself is inadequate at this stage.

Comment on this
Mr. Johnny Guirke

Dr. McDonnell also criticised the failure to introduce a second tier of child benefit. How many children could be lifted out of poverty through such a measure?

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Dr. Doorley is here so I would defer to the ESRI on those details.

Comment on this
Mr. Johnny Guirke

That is all right.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

I know the ESRI did that research.

Comment on this
Dr. Karina Doorley

We estimated a couple of years ago, in 2023 I think, that a second tier of child benefit that combined the working family payment and child support payments could lift 40,000 children out of poverty at a cost of about €700 million per annum.

Comment on this

I thank each of the contributors for the presentation and overview. From time to time, the witnesses will have heard criticisms of the middle four deciles getting left behind in different budgets and suggestions that budget measures would benefit those on lower or high incomes more. I am trying to get a handle on that. For example, the ESRI feels this current budget benefits lower income households more than middle income households. Why does the ESRI feel that is the case? Is it at odds perhaps with Social Justice Ireland's argument that it was higher income earners rather than middle and low income earners who gained?

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Keane

I am looking at the results. We looked at just budget 2027. What we see is that relative to prices everybody is gaining slightly. The Deputy is right in that relative to wage growth, the bottom income decile has a small rise and there is actually a decline in the income of people in the second and third deciles.

As Social Justice Ireland touched on, it can be hard to target this group. They may not be paying enough to benefit from tax credits and standard bands increasing. One way to target them is something like a refundable tax credit or to have a more generous working family payment scheme. One issue with that scheme is this-----

Comment on this

Is Dr. Keane referring to the lower decile income group?

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Keane

No, I am talking about people in the second or third decile. The bottom decile is being protected but it is about trying to get those people who are not in the very lowest decile but not in the middle income bracket. The people in the second or third lowest decile may not be benefiting from any of those tax changes and credits increasing because they do not have enough income to pay tax. One of the issues with the working family scheme is that half of the people who are entitled to it do not actually take it up. We also know it is only for people with children. There are people who might be in work and on low incomes but if they do not have children, there is no scheme to help them.

Looking back, we looked at the impact of all of the budgets from 2020 until now. One favourable thing there is we see the bottom income decile in particular being very well protected compared with wage and price growth. It is a positive that welfare rates have been growing ahead of both price and wage growth. It is roughly flat among the other income groups. Not the very lowest income but not the higher income groups can be difficult to target. We have some work done on in-work poverty and how it might be addressed.

Comment on this

To stay with my original question about those four deciles in the middle, Dr. Keane spoke about the third and fourth decile. What about the fifth, sixth and those in the middle?

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Keane

Those middle income groups will have gained from the standard rate band increasing and the tax credits increasing but higher income earners tend to benefit from that more because they are more likely to be paying 40% tax. It can be hard to target those groups. Last year, there was no increase in tax credits and bands. Over the longer term, we are just playing catch-up with the tax credits and bands increasing for that group. It is really only the tax system. We must bear in mind as well that child benefit, which is received across the income distribution, is frozen in nominal terms this year. It has not grown in line with wage or price growth.

Comment on this

On the refundable tax credit Dr. Keane referred to, is that applied in different jurisdictions?

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Keane

We have an in-work support that is done through the welfare system in Ireland, the working family payment. That is one way to support people who are in work but might be on lower incomes. In some countries, they choose to have a refundable tax credit. If you have a tax credit of €2,000 or €3,000 but you do not pay that much tax, you essentially get a refund. It is done in different ways and it is an in-work support that is in place in other countries.

Comment on this

Dr. Keane might send on one or two examples of the refundable credit so we can take a closer look.

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Keane

Sure, yes. We can have a look at that.

Comment on this

The Nevin Economic Research Institute feels the Government should have raised taxes rather than reduce them. I know Dr. McDonnell referred to the recommendations of the Commission on Taxation and Welfare. Why does he believe the Government should have raised tax and were there particular measures from the commission he feels could be applied? Are there particular ones he is eyeing up and what sorts of figures would Dr. McDonnell see related to those?

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

I thank the Deputy. It is a great question. On the issue of the middle four deciles, we really only have three big levers, namely, welfare, tax and public services. There was tax indexation for those groups. They do not tend to benefit much from welfare payments generally. The third lever is the cost of using public services, which is another area where you can help those groups, but of course, we are increasing public transport costs. They will also have benefited from fuel excise cuts, which is worth noting.

In terms of overall tax policy, yes-----

Comment on this

On the increase in public transport costs, many of the people I represent do not enjoy the benefit of public transport. We would like to see a greater roll-out of public transport if there was funding available to see the bus coming from large towns like Bantry to Macroom or others like it. On the public transport point, we want to see an increase in services in communities I represent.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Absolutely. That is the third lever I was talking about: public service expansion, cost, availability and all of these things. It could be making childcare services available in every region within the State at an affordable level or reducing the cost of education, healthcare and all of these things. Moving to a tapered model in terms of medical cards and things like that could help the middle deciles too. There are many levers available, but I will address the Deputy's core point about tax policy.

Comment on this

The taxation point, yes.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

The economy is in a position where it is operating close to its capacity, if not at an unsustainable level. We have high inflation for sure, which obviously sees cost-of-living pressures, but we also have a very high and historically high employment rate and fast economic growth. It would seem we are on the upward swing of the economic cycle. When the economy is performing strongly like that, we should be operating with either a very low deficit, excluding windfall receipts, or indeed a surplus. By not doing so, we are putting the cost of higher taxes onto future generations. We know from the Government's own Future Forty report that we are looking at very significant deficits in the decades to come. It is better to have a sustainable tax system before we get to the danger point. By making small increases in taxation and broadening the tax base each year, that would be a better approach.

What the Government in fact did, leaving aside the indexation, was broadly to cut taxes, whereas we should be going in the opposite direction. As to what types of taxes specifically, the Commission on Taxation and Welfare provided a long menu for policymakers to choose from, but obvious ones include things like the local property tax, LPT, or reducing the use of tax expenditures which tend to be distortionary, regressive and have very little to recommend them. Broadly speaking, the emphasis within the Commission on Taxation and Welfare's report was on tax expenditures and various types of capital taxation. Those are the areas to go for. On the middle income groups, by gradually transitioning the composition of the tax base away from labour income and towards capital income, that would be beneficial to the four middle deciles as well.

Comment on this

To come back to those examples Dr. McDonnell referred to, such as LPT and the capital expenditures, what kinds of figures should we be looking at trying to raise out of that?

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

I do not think we would have to do too much each year because we would take a multidecade approach to take us out to the 2040s. The Commission on Taxation and Welfare identified a menu of measures which would be in the region of €15 billion or so, but we certainly would not do anything like that in a single year. In fact, we may not need to do all of that at all. It could be something in the range of €500 million to €1 billion per year.

Comment on this

The LPT is a local authority competency. It is not funding that central government would raise.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Ultimately, however, it is all going to public services and broader Government revenue. As much as we like to draw these distinctions, particularly when it comes to social security contributions and PRSI, we like to pretend they are separate when in fact-----

Comment on this

I mean the ability to change the LPT rate would be decided at council level. It is not done as part of a budget measure.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Yes, but the Government can increase what the minimum rate allowable would be. There is scope there.

Comment on this

Dr. McDonnell is talking about changing the system itself.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Potentially. If we want stronger local government, then the local property tax will be one of the biggest levers there. The Commission on Taxation and Welfare also pointed to a site valuation tax potentially replacing one or both of commercial rates and local property tax to create a new system, which would probably be economically preferable. That would be one possibility in terms of local government reform. There are other areas too. The elephant in the room in how Ireland is different from most other European countries relates to PRSI, particularly on the employer and self-employed side.

Again, those are labour taxes. You would not necessarily want to be going for damaging types of taxes that are labour taxes. Capital taxation and tax expenditures are really where you can make the most positive reform without doing damage to the economy. These would also have the advantage of being broadly progressive.

Comment on this

Those are my two main questions. I thank each of the contributors.

Comment on this

Apologies for being delayed in coming in. I had another meeting, and it seems a lot of things tend to clash on a Tuesday. I have questions for everyone, so I will see how much I can get through.

I might start with NERI. In their opening statement, the witnesses acknowledged that the Government could simultaneously increase the rate of growth in public spending and drive down the cost of living. That is something I think is lost an awful lot of the time in media debates around budget time. I am interested in whether the witnesses could elaborate on that a little more, as well as on what kinds of tax measures they feel would support or would be necessary for a deflationary budget with a fast rate of growth in public spending.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

It is a very good question. The general assumption is that when you increase public spending, naturally, it is going into the economy and the likelihood is if you increase incomes, this will push up inflation. Of course, one of the things the Government can do is decrease the cost of using public services. By decreasing the cost, you are effectively giving households a virtual income. It could push down prices in that one area, but could potentially push up prices in other areas. However, it would probably not be on a one-for-one basis. That would be one way to do things. From a Government perspective, if we simply reduce the cost we charge people to use our services, such as public transport-----

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

-----and so on, we can reduce the cost of living while having an expansionary or strong spending budget.

Comment on this

That is a very strong point, and it is one I have tried to make during many interviews after the budget. It something that is very often lost in the media debate. That is maybe as a result of misinterpretation or misunderstanding of some of the things other organisations have said, such as IFAC and others that have often warned against a high rate of growth in public spending on account of it being inflationary. We have had IFAC in this committee many times, and when we delve into it, that is not exactly what it is saying but that is the way it is constantly interpreted and perceived in media.

What would be NERI's response to that? Is it that when you cut costs, you are not increasing them?

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Again, it comes down to the composition. It is about what you are doing and whether you are targeting what you can target from a Government point of view, because you are effectively selling a lot of services. If you can reduce the cost that way, it reduces pressure on necessary wage growth to stay ahead of inflation, if you are generally doing things in that way.

This is one of the things with fuel excise. Although reducing it is damaging from an environmental perspective, it would for sure have put down the cost of living. It reduced inflation.

Comment on this

Does Mr. McDonnell have a view on the effectiveness of the annual percentage spending targets - not that the Government sticks with them?

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

The percentage increase is something to look at, and it is good to have rules. Obviously, you are going to have a different impact if it is a 20% increase versus a 5% increase. To say there is no difference at all would be incorrect.

However, to simply stand still in many of these areas, it effectively uses up the entire 5% - maybe closer to 4% - just to do all that. Prices are increasing by over 3%.

Comment on this

That is a very good point.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

If you also take into account demographic pressures, which obviously mean there is going to be a greater demand for the use of healthcare, pensions and long-term care, then suddenly you get to 4%. What is your 5% increase in spending then for? Most of it is basically standing still. If you want to do anything new at all, your 5% is effectively gone.

The issue for us is that the expansionary nature of the budget could have been reduced by looking at the taxation system and increasing Government revenue in that way. Of course, there are a million different ways you can increase revenue, and they will all have different effects, some being inflationary and others deflationary and so on. Income tax cuts generally tend to put money in people's pockets and will tend to increase inflation, but there are other things you can also do. It can be complicated. People also have less money to spend, so the income and substitution effects could be different there. The analysis can be complex.

Comment on this

That is a good point.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Certainly, to the Deputy's point, you can have an expansionary budget and reduce pressures on the cost of living.

Comment on this

That is a very good point, and I wish it was agreed on more, especially in the media debates.

The end of NERI's opening statement is quite damning where it says this Government has no vision and that budget 2027 pushes fiscal costs onto future generations. That is interesting because, obviously, we have the saving funds. Would investing public money into public transport, climate adaptation and social care today be a more effective way of creating a better economy for future generations than exclusively storing money in these savings funds? Obviously, you need a bit of both but it would seem we are just creating disaster for future generations.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

It is a very interesting question, and I do not think there is any right answer for what is the specific amount you should put into your savings fund versus the amount you should put into infrastructure.

Comment on this

We are basically standing still, and we have seen the horrific impacts of the lack of an equal economy on people. At every single clinic I have, someone will come to me who is in homelessness. It is just horrendous. I always think of one woman who is 22 and has a two-year-old. For the last year, she has been in bed and breakfast accommodation with black mould. We are financing that as a State instead of providing housing for her.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

I agree. One of the constraints is our lack of construction workers, which means there is a real cap on what we are able to do in practical terms.

Comment on this

To be fair, we have construction workers building offices and hotels; we see them. If we had an apprenticeship system whereby we tell people it is four years and it is actually four years, then people will not go to the US. It is a weak argument on the Government's side, but that is my strong view on things.

Did Mr. Nugent want to come in there?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Nugent

We have just touched on housing there, which has been the elephant in the room with the cost of living. Wage and income increases are below the increases in house prices again this year. When we talk about real incomes and real wages, the headline CPI indicators might obscure different costs facing different families, such as young people who are increasingly living at home, or are increasingly in deprivation if they are renting, and are getting further away from family formation because of that.

Bringing down the cost of living is obviously the biggest one. It is the biggest issue in every opinion poll. As Dr. McDonnell pointed out, there is no revision in that budget for what we are going to do about it. Sometimes the impression is it is not really considered the crisis that it is.

Comment on this

I do not think it is in any way, shape or form. It is what I want to talk to the ESRI about. It has done great work on child poverty and taking housing into account when looking at how many children are living in poverty, but the long-term impact we are going to have in that regard is terrifying and I feel they do not care. Otherwise, something would have been done about it. I have been an elected representative for the last 12 years and it is only getting worse, not better. Obviously, there is a mismatch here in terms of want, but I do not expect the witnesses to comment on that.

The ESRI's opening statement points out that the overall effect of this budget is basically to hold child poverty relatively constant, which is a disaster and really should have been the talking point of this budget. Instead, we talked about people in the higher tax band getting a bit extra. I know the ESRI has done a lot of work in that area. Is it the institute's view that Government has all the tools at its disposal to reduce child poverty and chooses not to? What role does housing have in child poverty? Does the ESRI consider cash transfers the most effective way to reduce child poverty? That might specifically relate to single mams, because I have done a huge amount of work with them. I have watched that programme "Maid" on Netflix, and it is exactly that.

Comment on this
Dr. Karina Doorley

With child poverty, the sort of multifaceted approach is always going to be there.

We need a combination of cash transfers and free or subsidised services. We then need to reduce the barriers to work so that, for example, single parents can go and put in a day's work, if they want to earn, and are able to because there is available and affordable good quality childcare.

Comment on this

It is so difficult to get any kind of childcare before a child is a year old. Is that something the ESRI has noticed in any of its analysis? Has it looked at how that impacts people as it is hard to a crèche place for a baby?

Comment on this
Dr. Karina Doorley

We have not done any research on that per se, but I think there is data on waiting lists. It is difficult to look at the waiting list data because children are on multiple waiting lists, so we cannot really tell how many children are waiting on a childcare place. There is certainly a lack of supply of formal childcare. The measures introduced in the budget are to reduce the cost of formal childcare for children up to senior infants at least and then an increased subsidy for those over that age. That will reduce costs and comes into the category of the free or subsidised services. It will be great for people who are using formal childcare, but if there is no extra supply, it will be very difficult for new children to access that or for parents to choose to work because this new subsidy is now available.

Comment on this

On that point, if we are talking about children who are in poverty, is the cost of childcare low enough for those parents to access it? All parents obviously need support, but I am talking about that most at risk group in general. I do not like the term "vulnerable".

Comment on this
Dr. Karina Doorley

There is an income assessed subsidy that is higher than the universal one. That probably covers the cost of formal childcare for most children in that group. If people are earning under a certain amount, there is a much more generous subsidy available. Access is probably the issue and actually being able to find a place to use the subsidy. I am not sure if there is any data on that-----

Comment on this

It is just interesting.

Comment on this
Dr. Karina Doorley

-----and how that subsidy is taken up, and whether everyone who is eligible for that generous subsidy actually takes it up or gets the universal one. That is an interesting question.

Comment on this

I am basically out of time, but I have one last question for Social Justice Ireland, just to be equal. In his opening statement, Mr. McGeady said that, as a policy objective, Ireland should remain a low tax economy while also acknowledging that increasing tax revenues is unavoidable to maintain public services. Will he clarify what kind of long-term tax policy Social Justice Ireland considers necessary to reduce inequality and to build strong public services? I may have misunderstood it. That part was a bit confusing to me.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

What we were basically saying was-----

Comment on this

Was Social Justice Ireland referring to corporation tax or all taxes?

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

We were referring to overall taxes. Looking to the future, we know we have demographic change and a growing population. We know we will have an old age dependency ratio that is increasing. Therefore, we know that we are going to have raise and collect more revenue to pay for more services and infrastructure into the future. Our basic contention is that there are lots of different ways that the Government can achieve that. It is possible to do so while, broadly speaking, remaining a relatively low tax economy compared to other European countries and other countries around the world. However, we should not be prioritising that over and above meeting the basic needs that we have to meet to provide those services and infrastructure into the future.

We are recommending that, over the long term, there should be a tax take target for the overall tax that we should be gathering as a country and that it should be on a per capita basis. By linking it to the size of the population, if we have a per capita tax take target then we know that if we add a quarter of a million people to the population, the tax take target needs to go up in tandem with that because they are people who are going to be drawing on services and infrastructure. That can be achieved in the context of still remaining a relatively low tax economy. Dr. McDonnell of NERI, in answer to another question, spoke about various recommendations in the report of the Commission on Taxation and Welfare. There is low hanging fruit for the Government to extract more revenue from our economy.

Comment on this

I thought it was a different thing. Social Justice Ireland is not recommending lowering tax by taxing the banks more or that kind of thing. That is how it reads but I understand that is not what was meant.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

No.

Comment on this

That is okay. I thought that it was unusual perspective from Social Justice Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

That would be an unusual perspective from Social Justice Ireland given that we have consistently called for an adequate tax take.

Comment on this

Sometimes when reading a document, something in it stands out. I get what Social Justice Ireland means now.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

That is a fair point. I will be more cautious of that in the future.

Comment on this

It had to be asked in case there was a big shift.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

No. There certainly has not been.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I will give a slightly different perspective. The witnesses have heard me before. I thank them for their contributions.

I am especially struck by the contributions from Social Justice Ireland and NERI. They paint a picture that the less well-off are doing badly and the Government could have done a lot more. There is no recognition of how progressive our income tax system is. Is it one of the most progressive in the world? I am guessing that it is up there, certainly among OECD countries. I think people have to be earning €21,500 before they pay any income tax at all, with the extra bands, although I looked for a little bit extra on the credits, rather than the €300 increase. People get €21,500 tax free, but I know they will pay a little USC on that.

The minimum wage was referred to. We have the second highest minimum wage in Europe, after Luxembourg. I know the Nordic countries have a slightly different system. The minimum wage went up by 5.8%, which comfortably exceeds inflation. There was very little recognition of those facts.

Social Justice Ireland talks about a windfall corporation tax and an underlying budget deficit. That is music to my ears, and I totally agree with it, but it is largely looking for more spending. Dr. McDonnell referred to the Commission on Taxation and Welfare and the different types of taxes, including property tax. That is fairly incremental and it comes from the Government, as he knows. It increased by 12% last year, although it has been behind inflation since it was first introduced five years ago.

The witnesses also mentioned payroll taxes. We are very precious about keeping payroll taxes low to protect employment, which is the strong point of this economy. I do not know if that was recognised either. We have full employment. We actually have a shortage of employment, with thousands of people coming in on work permits to fill the gaps.

Ms Rogers mentioned 1986. I lived in Dublin as a young man in 1986. I could not get a job and there was no money. I emigrated in the 1980s. Walk along the streets and there are issues, although there was a lot of dereliction along the quays in Dublin back in 1986. I remember I used to walk into college. Of course, we still have problems but regarding young people and employment, the landscape is completely different from what we had 40 years ago.

I am glad Social Justice Ireland and Dr. McDonnell pointed out the underlying deficit, but that is a difficult circle to square. Controlling spending is the easiest part of it in some respects. Dr. McDonnell talked about getting it back to around 4%. I get that inflation, at 3%, is at a standstill, and that population growth has been running at 2% and will probably drop a little bit closer to 1% over the next couple of years. Dr. McDonnell used the figure of 4%, and I agree with him that it would be a nice target to go for. However, getting value for money, improving the value we get, controlling costs or adopting 0% budgeting, where every cost has to be justified rather than thinking it is going to automatically increase. It does not automatically have to increase. That is the psychology we have. The Department of justice is reducing the international protection accommodation services, IPAS, budget and its expenditure on Ukrainians next year.

If we examine each area, we will see possibilities of reducing expenditure. Overall, we should maybe match inflation and population growth, but there are probably, to use Mr. McGeady's phrase, low hanging fruit all over the place that we are not looking at.

That is what I regularly tell the Minister, Deputy Chambers. I am interested in hearing the witnesses' view on how to square that circle by getting the underlying deficit back to evens rather than potentially 3% or 4% of GDP and, at the same time, implement the wish list Social Justice Ireland has set out, which is quite extensive.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

On the question about the progressive tax take and whether we acknowledge positives in the budget, we sought the increases to the tax credits and strongly welcomed them when they were brought in. We recognise that. However, if a worker does not earn enough to pay enough tax to get the full value of his or her tax credit, he or she does not get that full benefit, and is among the lowest earning workers. Therefore, a further reform we suggest that would really benefit a worker in that bracket would be to introduce refundable tax credits. If we look at the gain to higher income earners from the increase in the threshold compared with the gain that all workers received, including higher income earners from the tax credits, it is substantially larger. There is a question around progressivity, purely in terms of the income tax decision.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

There was an element of correcting last year's non-increase in the threshold for the top bracket.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

That depends on one's assumption of what is correct in the first place and where you start as a baseline.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The starting point is what is correct and indexation matching inflation.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

We argue that the Government should always prioritise those on lowest incomes first, where there is money available. That is the first point, on the progressive aspect. On the second point, the Leas-Chathaoirleach made a point about getting value for money in expenditure. I do not think anybody in this room disagrees with the need to get value for money in expenditure. We 100% agree with all of that reform.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is the problem that not enough of us are coming up with proposals?

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

Reform is a key part of the Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation but that reform needs to be not just about where we cut spending, but how we gain value for money and productivity. We need to ask what kinds of changes and innovations can be brought in to get the best value for money possible. Notwithstanding all of the reforms and innovations that could be could be done, we are still going to be dealing with the reality of massive demographic change over the next 40 years. That has been recognised by the Department of Finance in the Future 40 report, which was debated in this Chamber. We have to have a certain element of realism about the level of cost coming down the line and the level of revenue we need to meet those needs and retain the current level of service provision. If we can get more value for money, 100%-----

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We only do one-year budgets, unfortunately.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

There is a further reform that we would welcome.

Regarding the question of wanting spending while also pointing to deficits, getting the deficit down has to be a real priority for this Government but it needs to be done in the right way. If there are cuts to key services or incomes, all that happens is that those costs get moved somewhere else in the system. While we may make a saving in one area by cutting things for people living in poverty who face deprivation, we are going to drive up costs that relate to their experience elsewhere in the system.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We have to be smart about how we do it and it has to be thought through. I am not talking about bluntness. Sometimes we have to force people to look at their cost base.

Mr. McGeady referred to the rich-poor gap going up by 90 cent a week or more than €40 a year, but he is being been selective and picking an absolute figure. He is not picking percentages. Indexation means any increase in bands will increase the gap in euro or cent terms.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

It is important to look at the euros because that is what people have in their pocket to spend.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Euros devalue over time because of indexation. That is my point.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

Regardless, the rich-poor gap that we point out is the gap that grows between those on the highest incomes or those whom we regard as a rich person, which would be an individual earner-----

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

How big is the gap in euros? If the increase is 90 cent, what is the total gap?

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

The cumulative rich-poor gap will stand at €1,209 per week, or €63,000 per annum in 2027.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Does that mean that 90 cent is less than 0.1%?

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

The point is that it is a widening of the rich-poor cap, rather than a narrowing of the rich-poor gap. We recognise-----

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

However, in real terms, it is reducing.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

No, in real terms, it continues to grow.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

In real terms, adjusting for inflation, it is reducing. It only went up €90 cent from €1,000 to €1,000.90. That is a pretty small increase.

Comment on this
Mr. John McGeady

We will have a look at that but certainly, what we see in euro terms is that gap growing year on year.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I agree with a lot of what Dr. McDonnell said. In its statement, NERI refers to narrowing the tax base and used a figure of €2 billion. Later in the statement, it recognises that the indexation elements do not really add up to €2 billion. I do not know what the income tax indexation value is, but let us say it is about €1 billion, which is roughly what it should have been this year, not to mention last year. It is a bit misleading to talk about tax breaks of €2 billion. In fairness, NERI recognises that elsewhere in its statement.

Dr. McDonnell spoke of the annual hollowing out of the tax base. I do not agree with that. Last year, we did nothing on indexation on income tax or inheritance tax, which was referred to as well. Inheritors are one of the groups listed. The main inheritance tax threshold went up by 5% from €400,000 to €420,000. It went up last year by approximately €50,000. It is lower now than it was 20 years ago, when incomes were one third, or certainly less than half, of what they are today. I would not describe that as hollowing out the tax base.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Some of the points the Leas-Chathaoirleach made are valid, including perhaps describing it as €2 billion. Anything in excess of the indexation would be the narrowing, and that is probably in the hundreds of millions rather than billions. The point is that when the economy is booming, let us be honest, from an employment, income and wealth perspective, that is when we should be taking away the punch bowl. We should be trying to deflate the economy.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

There is a cost-of-living crisis in the background-----

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

There is, absolutely.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

-----that we are reminded of every day.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

There is a cost-of-living crisis.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is political.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Household wealth is at a record level

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

You cannot spend household wealth.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

If we break households down into three groups, for the bottom third, for sure, there is absolutely a cost-of-living crisis, and for many in the second group, there is some element of that. However, to say that people on €120,000 or even €90,000, or often a lot of two-income households, are experiencing a cost-of-living crisis, is not quite fair. Some in society are doing very well and have never had it better. However, at the bottom, there is, and that implies that what we should do is focus on adequacy. The budget needed to be targeted, which is why we said the welfare budget is where to start.

We have also talked in the past about how we need to reform the system, so it becomes tapered. That would allow the Government to give benefits to the middle deciles, if needs be. There are a lot of mechanisms it can use. To say there is a cost-of-living crisis affecting everybody is not something I would necessarily agree with per se. My colleague Mr. Nugent wants to respond because the Leas-Chathaoirleach mentioned the minimum wage, and obviously the increase there is the second highest. I suspect he has more to add.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Nugent

I will throw in a few comments. The latest Eurobarometer poll comparing us with our European colleagues shows that, out of 27 EU members, the country with the highest share of people who answer that they are struggling with bills with great difficulty is Ireland.

It is higher than in Greece, at 17%. That is the latest data.

The Leas-Chathaoirleach said we have the second highest minimum wage in Europe, which is about true, but we also have the highest cost of living in Europe. As to what has happened there, again, I will bring it back to housing, which is the main issue here. We have had a collapse in home ownership among under-40s since 2011. It has halved. We have doubled the share of adult children aged 25 to 34 years who are living at home. These are the most educated group of adults in the history of civilisation, almost. I think we have outpassed Korea and Finland, which used to be at the top of the table. In addition, we talk about employment but we have high rates of overqualification in Ireland compared with other countries. The rate is about 30%. It is about 35% for that group I mentioned, those aged 25 to 34 years. The European Trade Union Institute, ETUI, did some research on rent over minimum wage. Even with the high nominal rate in Ireland, which the Leas-Chathaoirleach mentioned, we are still the joint most expensive for rent. How far does that minimum wage go when rent is the most expensive? I looked at this because I am on the living wage technical group, and we looked at the cost of living and at-risk-of-poverty rates, in-work poverty rates and so on. The cost of renting a one-bedroom apartment in Galway in 2007 took about 40 hours' work at the minimum wage, and today it is more like 70, so-----

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I made the point before that that is not relevant to most people on the minimum wage. People on the minimum wage qualify for social housing. If people cannot get a social house, they qualify for the housing assistance payment, so they do not pay the rents Mr. Nugent is talking about.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Nugent

Yes, because they cannot pay them. They cannot live independently. They have to get the house in the first place, which they cannot do, to be able to get those supports, so it does not exist. We see these-----

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

No, but they are renting. I deal with them all the time. They are in social housing or they are on HAP.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Nugent

They are absolutely not. Mostly, they are living at home or they are migrant labourers who are not able to get that support. We do not have to talk just about the minimum wage; we can talk about the next 5% and 10% of the wage distribution as well, which most of those issues count towards as well. That is why that is reflected in the housing deprivation for a generation that is locked out of housing. They have to wait for their inheritance or whatever. Earnings cannot get people through now. People cannot get out of bed early enough in the morning, or at least in what most people would consider a reasonable amount of time, to be able to afford a house or to "get on the property ladder" or whatever by the time they are in their late 20s or early 30s. They need an inheritance, a gift. The Leas-Chathaoirleach said-----

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I agree with the point about housing. Maybe this is a discussion for another day, but one issue I have looked at a bit and want to do more work on - maybe the witnesses can help me - is the cost of building a house. It has become much more expensive. When I bought my first house 30 years ago, my and my wife's earnings amounted to double the price of the house. Our joint earnings doubled equalled the house price. That multiple is between three and four times for someone on a similar income today. Are there areas we could focus on to reduce the cost of building a house? Development levies did not exist until, perhaps, 25 years ago. There is obviously VAT on the sale of a house, at 13.5%. There are lots of costs. Obviously, there is the Ukraine war and concrete costs are going up. The guy sweeping the floor is on €800 to €1,000 a week now, the builders tell me. I do not know if anyone is doing work to see how we can reduce the cost of actually building a house. I am talking about building, not people who can get a free site. It is still expensive to build a house. It is not that developers are making it, no more than they ever were. It is the cost of building a house. That is a huge challenge for Ireland. I know it is the same in other countries, but I think this country could do work on reducing the cost of building housing.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

A lot of those materials are imported, and what we can do directly is limited. We need to attract more construction workers, so reducing wages in that sector will not be helpful in terms of adding to supply. There are things that can be done on productivity, for example, using modern methods of construction and those types of schemes in the longer term, and moving to a factory model of building houses and then essentially constructing them on site.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Also, the quality of housing now is higher than it was 30 or 40 years ago-----

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

It is.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

-----and people's expectations are higher. There is nothing wrong with higher expectations, but that is-----

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Living standards are higher generally, and higher quality housing is a positive thing. The Leas-Chathaoirleach is right that the cost of housing is a major problem. I do not think there are any easy solutions in the shorter term. We have seen a full 25 years of market failure now, if we count the period of the second Celtic tiger in the 2000s as a failure as well.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

What is the solution?

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Maybe the solution is actually more radical than we are preparing for. We are increasing housing supply year on year. That is in fact happening, but not nearly fast enough. That suggests there needs to be a more direct response. The Government needs to become more directly involved. There are arguments for sustainable construction companies, for example.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are spending more than we ever did. We are spending €3 billion. Are we not spending enough?

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Maybe we need to rethink how we are spending. Are we spending enough? Perhaps not. We need to find ways to get more construction workers in. That means making construction an extremely attractive sector. It will probably mean, in the short term, having to bring people in from abroad because we do not necessarily have the skill base in the short term. Over the medium term, we need to make construction a more attractive profession and less volatile. We lost five of every eight construction workers in 2008-09 when a lot of them left the country, so we have that shortage there. It is very difficult to convince people to go into construction because we have close to full employment. Obviously, we do not want not to have full employment. That creates a situation where we will have to bring people in from abroad over the short term, as is likely to happen for metro north and those types of projects. We will have to have conversations about how we do that, where those people will live and, fundamentally, whether there will be a guaranteed income that will encourage people to stay in construction for 20 or 30 years. That means having a State option. Of course, it is not just housing but infrastructure as well. Infrastructure is really what is holding back the country generally, although housing is an aspect of that.

The only thing that will bring down the cost of housing in the long term is something entering the market that en masse adds to supply. That does not necessarily help with materials costs but if we want those costs to come down, it will probably involve State subsidies. Only the State itself would be willing to do that, not necessarily-----

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I agree with Mr. Nugent's point about house prices and the multiple. I get that completely. The cost of building a house, the fact that people cannot afford a house and the housing shortage are probably the biggest issues in the country. How do we address that?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Nugent

On top of that, there are a bunch of levers other than the State building housing, which is the biggest issue and should be the focus. As regards short-term lets, there are 23,000 Airbnb properties in the country. There was an announcement a few years ago on regulating and taxing that sector. I tried to report my neighbour but I could not do so. People were in and out making terrible noise in the apartment complex.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is in cities. I think it is more a city or big town problem. I am supportive of short-term lets in rural areas because they will not go into-----

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Nugent

It is also ruining the Gaeltachtaí. I was reading about this just recently. It is pricing people out and taking over supply for weekenders, even affecting the summer schools and so on. There is a balance to be struck there and a balance as regards regulation. Not every one of those 23,000 has to be regulated out, but a lot of them could be.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Those 23,000 properties would not solve our problem either. It is only-----

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Nugent

It would be a pretty good start. There is also the vacant site levy. There are a bunch of things. There are signals that are at least on the menu and not really being implemented.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The residential zone land tax, RZLT, has been implemented.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Mechanisms like a proper site valuation tax would help to bring down the value of land, which would-----

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The RZLT is in place. It is being applied.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

Yes, but what we need to see is probably a site valuation tax that covers the entire country in order that it would be attractive to use that land to prevent land hoarding and the like and to create a financial disincentive for doing so. The tax system is an important model.

As regards Airbnb, again, it is a matter of using the stick to free up supply, primarily in the urban areas, for sure. Obviously, having the State do it means you do not have to worry about profits.

That can also help reduce the price of purchase, which means it is not as hard for people to save up money. There is no silver bullet here but there are a lot of small things to be done. The lack of construction workers at a time when we also have an infrastructure problem means it will be a decade or so before we are properly on top of this.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

As the population slows a little bit, it will bring us more into line and help resolve the problem of supply.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

It will, but it will probably be the 2040s or afterwards before we start to see the population decline at a fast enough pace to really matter in that regard. However, supply is going up every year so-----

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I think the population increase has flatlined. It is probably going to drop a little bit.

Comment on this
Dr. Tom McDonnell

We will get there in about a decade but the problem is that we also have pent-up demand.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes, there is the unwinding of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Nugent

A lot of resources have gone into data centre construction. The economic case for those is much weaker than the case for providing affordable housing. That puts pressure on the minimum wage and wages and makes us less competitive in general across firms and households. It is the same for office space and things like that.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Does the ESRI want to comment? Dr. Doorley mentioned grants and so on. I hope the reduction in the carbon tax on home heating oil and gas will not adversely impact the pot of money. The grant system will still be in place so people can apply and get the grant. I do not think it was fully drawn down. Does Dr. Doorley have any comments to make?

Comment on this
Dr. Karina Doorley

I will address the Leas-Chathaoirleach's point about the tension between everyone in this room saying we need to spend more in certain areas, while also being very mindful of the bottom line and the underlying fiscal deficit. When we are talking about increasing spending it is net spending. We need targeted approaches to managing the cost-of-living crisis, increasing our supply of housing and dealing with climate change and an ageing population and so on. However, we need to do that in a targeted way and raise money elsewhere to do that so that the whole thing does not become inflationary. Deputy Farrell made the point that the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council is often in this committee saying we need to keep spending to a certain level, but that is also net spending. If spending needs to happen in certain areas, for example, infrastructure, which I think we would all agree is very necessary at the moment, in order to keep things manageable and to keep the economy at a sustainable pace, it is net spending that needs to be controlled. You can increase spending but you must also increase taxes and raise revenue elsewhere.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes, but that is the whole problem - that you are raising taxes. No one likes that. The witnesses are always very shy about making proposals on that, although in fairness to Dr. McDonnell, he threw out a few there. It is a question I often ask but I usually do not get a detailed answer. Dr. McDonnell probably gave one of the most complete that I have heard.

Comment on this
Dr. Karina Doorley

We need to think in the longer term as well. Because of the way the budget is set up, we do our analysis on a year-by-year basis but-----

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I could not agree more. I worked for companies and we did five-year budgets. A state should do 30-year or generational budgets. I am also more inclined to put numbers into those budgets. Maybe that is the accountant in me. Rather than an economist putting in little percentages and graphs, we should put in hard numbers. In that way, we can see that our health budget will be €50 billion in five years' time and we can build it around demographics. Putting in hard numbers is a more sobering exercise than putting in figures for percentage growth. We could then ask how we are going to plug the growth in ten years' time when the health budget is €60 billion or €70 billion. Of course it is a complete guessing game and the figures would have to be revised all the time. However, when we start thinking on paper and putting in numbers, it gets us to focus on which problems are coming down the tracks. We might say, for example, that people will work longer and we can get more productivity out of them because their health is improving. People will work into their 70s and 80s, by choice maybe. There will be benefits from things like AI, which could help to deal with the health budget. There is a raft of things. However, thinking in numbers and putting numbers down focuses the mind. We should be doing long-term budgets. What we have is one budget, with all the hoo-ha around it, and then there is next year's budget and what will be in that. It is like what is coming out of a Christmas box. It is a bit juvenile in ways.

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Keane

I think we need to think about future pay-offs as well. One thing we noted about this budget is that we do not expect it to increase childcare supply. Looking back 30 years ago, we were in a similar situation. We know that if people have childcare, they are more likely to work and pay tax and that over their lifetime they will have higher incomes, so it is about spending on that now. Similarly, with child poverty, recent research by the ESRI showed that the negative impacts of growing up in poverty follow a person through their lifetime. They will be less likely to work, more likely to be unemployed and more likely to have lower earnings, so tackling things at a younger age can-----

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The witnesses are looking at how we can maximise the economy and the income of the country. It is about getting a maximum number of people working. Charlie McCreevy brought in individualisation. A lot of people had a problem with that. Some partners, more often women, might want to stay at home and the tax system does not provide them with many benefits. That is a more philosophical way of looking at things, rather than just looking at the issue through an economic lens.

Comment on this
Dr. Claire Keane

I will not mention the State pension age. I have been here before talking about that. It is an issue that resurfaces every now and then. Having people work longer and pay taxes longer will probably be necessary in the future if we are to tackle that. We would be here until midnight at least talking about that one.

Comment on this
Edward Timmins An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank the witnesses for their indulgence, especially with me, and for attending today’s meeting.

Comment on this