We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Committee on Budgetary Oversight

Post-Budget 2027 Engagement: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

IBEC welcomed Budget 2027’s investment in skills, innovation and jobs, while warning of reliance on corporation tax and calling for LPG to receive the same carbon-tax treatment as other heating fuels. It supported stronger spending controls and multi-year budgeting, and said third-level education remained underfunded. Voluntary-sector representatives welcomed additional service funding but sought fair pay, coverage of auto-enrolment and other costs, and sustainable multi-year agreements coordinated across Departments. They also highlighted gaps in homelessness prevention and disability supports, while witnesses and members called for better evidence of service outcomes and less duplication and waste in funding.

I ask everyone to turn off their phones and devices, or put them on silent mode. Before we proceed, I will explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the House as regards references witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. Witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of the presentations they make to the committee. This means that they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure that this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory regarding an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Members are advised of the constitutional requirement that a member must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex to participate in public meetings. In this regard, I ask any members participating via MS Teams to confirm that they are on the grounds of the Leinster House campus prior to making their contribution to the meeting. Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity either by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory regarding an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

Our post-budget 2027 engagement today is the committee's second post-budget engagement. This will lead into the committee's forthcoming post-budget report. For this session, I welcome from IBEC, Mr. Gerard Brady, head of national policy and chief economist, and Mr. Mourad Mejdi, economist. From the coalition and community of voluntary services, I welcome Ms Elaine Teague, CEO of the Disability Federation of Ireland; Mr. John Gallagher, chair of the coalition federation, The Wheel; Mr. David Carroll, CEO of Depaul Ireland; and Mr. Gordon Hill, senior manager of Crosscare. The committee welcomes the opportunity to engage with the witnesses. I thank them for being here today. I invite Mr. Brady to make his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

I thank the Cathaoirleach for the invitation to IBEC to appear before the committee. I thank members of the committee for their time. We are grateful for the opportunity to input into the committee's post-budget examination. IBEC welcomed budget 2027 for delivering a focus on driving innovation, protecting and creating jobs and increasing investment in critical skills. The measures demonstrate sensible ambition. There are several measures that we would like to acknowledge, including: unlocking €150 million of National Training Fund resources for AI training and a broader €360 million for further skills investment; increasing income tax bands and rates; cutting the rate of capital gains tax, CGT, from 33% to 31%; improvements in PRSI and the research and development tax credit; real-time reporting changes; and the introduction of a savings and investment scheme in 2027.

The budget took place against a strong economic backdrop. The Irish economy continues to expand, driven by consumer spending, which has so far proven robust despite inflation, and investment levels that have been buoyed by both the national development plan and AI-related spending. The recent budget will add further impetus to that growth.

Ireland is in a structurally different position than much of the rest of Europe. Relative to countries that have already produced a budget plan for 2027, Ireland’s budget is very expansionary. The most recent Irish budget package represents an expansion of about €1,600 per person in the country. This is compared to other countries that have published their 2027 budgets, like Finland and Netherlands, where the expansion is less than €100, and countries like Austria and, in particular, France, where we are seeing significant cuts in budgets as bond yields rise. This reflects Ireland’s unique position and is very strongly driven by corporation tax income.

The budget 2027 forecasts are that Ireland will collect €39 billion in corporation tax in 2027 following the implementation of Pillar 2 minimum tax rules. This means that we will collect more corporation tax alone in 2027 than we collected from all tax heads combined 13 years ago. This source of funding has obvious risks but our expectation, having talked to our members that pay the majority of that tax, is that it will continue, at least in the short run.

There are two issues that we will flag in respect of the forthcoming Revised Estimates in the Finance Bill and in the context of the budget just gone. Budget 2027 reduced carbon tax on heating, kerosene and natural gas to €48.50 per tonne. On the other hand, liquefied petroleum gas, LPG, for heating remains at €63.50 per tonne, with an increase retained to €100 per tonne by 2030. LPG is an important source of fuel for tens of thousands of households in rural areas but also rural businesses and other operations with production and cooking needs in parts of the country beyond the gas network. Our view is that the failure to include it on the same footing as similar fuels is an oversight that should be rectified during the passage of the Finance Bill.

We particularly welcome the strong emphasis on workforce transition in budget 2027 and praise the decision to unlock €150 million from the National Training Fund, NTF, and €360 million for wider training investments. Given the scale of workplace change driven by AI, the employer-funded NTF is an essential resource to ensure that workers and workplaces are adequately supported to meet both the challenges and opportunities of AI. It is critical that these funds be maximised in terms of their potential use, which is yet to be decided upon. They need to fund skills programmes that operate well and have been proven to work, like Skillnet Business Networks, Springboard+, microcredentials, microqualifications, and the SOLAS skills to advance programme. These investments in lifelong learning will be as important in the forthcoming period of technological change as investments in the broader education system were in decades past.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Brady and invite Ms Teague to make her opening statement.

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Teague

We appreciate the opportunity to return to talk to the committee as part of its post-budget sessions. I am the CEO of the Disability Federation of Ireland. I am appearing here today with my colleagues, Mr. Carroll, Mr. Hill and Mr. Gallagher, as part of the coalition of voluntary service providers.

Our coalition includes Tusla-funded grantees, the Dublin Homeless Network, family resource centres, Mental Health Reform, the National Community Care Network, the national voluntary drug and alcohol sector, the network of Cuan-funded organisations, and the Simon Communities of Ireland, and we are co-ordinated by Mr. Gallagher from The Wheel.

We have provided the committee, as part of our opening statement, with an analysis of budget 2027 from each of our coalition members. I will just focus on some of the common themes.

Our sector partners with the State to deliver essential services. We employ a combined total of over 40,000 staff who deliver services and supports countrywide. We are focused on delivering stable, reliable services, value for money and real outcomes for people in communities. Our message is simple. We want to work with the Government to drive efficiencies, effectiveness and innovation, and work to achieve the full cost of service delivery. To do that, we need co-ordinated Government action, adequate pay and non-pay funding, and sustainable multi-annual funding. We identified these three elements as priorities when we were here in April and they remain our priorities today.

We welcome budget 2027 and the additional funding for services. However, we have four key recommendations that we ask this committee to support. First, we seek effective cross-departmental co-ordination. We know that the people we support live in communities, not in Departments. Their needs span across housing, mental health, disability, addiction, domestic violence and family supports. Separate funding and duplicated reporting hinders joined-up thinking and services and diverts time away from front-line supports. We ask to be part of a Government-led working group that involves relevant Departments, funding agencies and sector representatives to reduce duplication, increase transparency, and improve efficiencies and value for money.

Second, we ask for a clear, fully funded approach to pay for staff in our organisations. The next public sector pay agreement will progress over time. Today, we ask that it applies in full to our staff who deliver equivalent services. Excluding our staff from any public sector pay agreement will deepen existing recruitment and retention challenges. The current Workplace Relations Commission, WRC, agreement provides for equivalent general round increases under successive public service pay agreements and to avoid the repeated need for catching up for staff in our sector. We need confirmation that all of our staff will be included in current discussions and avoid another cycle of uncertainty.

Third, we ask for the Government to fund pension auto-enrolment as a non-negotiable service cost. Contracts and service-level arrangements must cover employee contributions of 1.5%, including outstanding costs for 2026 and provision for 2027 and going forward.

Fourth, we ask for sustainable multi-annual funding that covers the full cost of agreed services. Costs like insurance, energy, premises maintenance, governance, IT, cybersecurity and training are not optional extras. They underpin safe, accountable services. We need funding to cover these costs, as it will give organisations certainty to plan and retain staff.

Investment in new services is welcome but it must go hand in hand with sustaining the services that people already depend on, and we ask the committee to seek a co-ordinated Government response with clear responsibilities, funding commitments and timelines for those four recommendations.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Teague. I will now open the discussion to the floor and call Deputy Farrell.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their attendance. I also thank them for their opening statements. It is always helpful to gain insight into how different people and organisations feel the impact of the budget. I try to engage with the different people I come across in my daily life to learn the impacts of the budget.

Two of the big issues are the cost of living and homelessness. They are interlinked. If a person cannot afford housing, then anything that increases other aspects of the cost of living will have a serious and detrimental impact on the ability to pay for things. I ask the witnesses for their views on the impact of the budget on those experiencing homelessness and, indeed, the impact of an increase in the number of people experiencing homelessness. I also want to know what impact this budget will have on lower income households that might be at risk of homelessness at the moment.

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Teague

I will ask Mr. Carroll to take that.

Comment on this
Mr. David Carroll

The Deputy is right to focus in on one of the most important issues of our times, particularly for those people who are in temporary accommodation. There is a lot to welcome in the overall budget,

There are a number of key issues we would like to highlight that we are seeking resolutions to. The ongoing issue of how we keep pace with the private rented situation and the absence of any financial target in terms of HAP or any improvement of HAP are the key areas we would want to focus on. One of the major initiatives from the Department of housing is the homeless prevention strategy. We need to move away from the focus on temporary accommodation to stop people coming into homelessness in the first place. We were disappointed not to see a specific budget against the homeless prevention framework, which is focused on providing community and local authority interventions to stop people coming into homelessness in the first place.

Mental Health Reform is represented here today in the Gallery. There is a general welcome around the budgetary commitment to mental health issues but there is a crisis at the moment within temporary accommodation for people with mental health and dual diagnoses. There is an absolute need to be able to specify in detail and focus on how interventions will be targeted within that. I would add that while there is a commitment to the drug and alcohol strategy, given the complexities of people who are in temporary accommodation, we would like to see more detail on how the additional funding is going to be distributed to the NGO sector to be able to intervene with people with complex drug and alcohol difficulties in the homeless system.

Comment on this

It is an interesting point. So many people are struggling when they are in emergency accommodation. I see all the time that there is no end in sight when people are in emergency accommodation. We have seen again today the lack of HAP properties. There is not enough housing coming onstream. There is a range of those issues, and it really does have a massive impact. When there is a lack of security in housing, it impacts on every single facet of a person's life, including their health, mental health and everything else. It just has that impact. Is there anything the witnesses feel should have been announced in this budget that would have assisted in turning the tide for those who experience going into homelessness or indeed moving out of homelessness and ending it?

Comment on this
Mr. David Carroll

I think we have over 5,000 children in temporary accommodation at the moment. There is an initiative coming from the Department of housing regarding family and child intervention. We in the Dublin Homeless Network want to see a specific target set against the movement of families and children out of temporary accommodation through the use of social housing and the private rented sector. While €1.2 million has been committed to that strategy, there is an absolute need to get it up and running immediately, and to set specific targets for 2027 to utilise the social housing stream that is coming, prioritising people who are in temporary accommodation, particularly families and children.

Comment on this

I also want to talk about the extra costs associated with having a disability. We see that all the time and there is an awful lot of talk about additional supports for people with a disability. I did not think the budget really dealt with it to the extent that it needed to. I would be interested to hear to what extent the budget has helped disabled people who live in consistent poverty. Was there anything targeted and, if not, what should have been targeted?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Teague

We are on record a couple of times as being critical of the approach that the Government took. We welcome that the cost of disability was established as a principle for the first time, and that there will be a payment going forward. A €500 once-off payment does not account for the challenges that people with disabilities experience every day with all the extras of living, including additional heating, lighting, food and transport. It was an opportunity for the Government to signpost its intention to improve, perhaps, and it did that by establishing that there would be a cost-of-disability payment in 2027. We heard from a lot of disabled people about how frustrated and annoyed they are that the amount is so low. The commitment now to co-design a payment is something on which we will be holding the Government to account. They have said very clearly that they will get into a design process whereby disabled people will help to figure out how to administer it in terms of prioritising those most in need, making sure it is targeted to those who have the most significant costs. A once-off payment helps right now but it will not be any help in January, February or March when there are more bills coming in. There were opportunities that were missed in this budget. They were labelled as administrative, for example the requirement to understand how to administer this payment. We accept that. Now our challenge is to make sure that in budget 2028 there are some very firm weekly and monthly payments that disabled people can rely on, irrespective of their personal circumstances. We hear a lot from people who are working who have a disability that they are excluded from this payment because it is social welfare-based. If someone is working, it does not mean they do not have additional costs of disability. It means they have a wage but it does not mean they have any less costs. How can that group be included in future payments? How can we make sure the payments are targeted so that people do not miss the opportunity to take up or stay in a job because they would lose a welfare payment?

Comment on this

That has come up quite a bit locally. People are afraid, even of voluntary work. There is this fear. This can very much isolate people further. I will ask IBEC the next question. I represent Connemara, where there are a lot of small and medium businesses. I think sometimes people in Dublin might not understand, but these businesses are providing the services and they are the hub of the community. They are providing jobs. It is so much more than a place to get a pint or a coffee, or go to the butcher's. It is the hub of a community. We saw how in Storm Éowyn some of them became designated community hubs. A lot of them are really struggling with the additional costs of energy and operating. What does IBEC feel may have addressed those issues in the budget?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

In the next number of weeks, we are going to see the national energy affordability task force, NEAT, report on the cost of electricity. It is due to come out. We will be watching that very closely to see what it proposes. It would have been ideal if that had come out before the budget and had led through to measures in the budget, but it did not. We will be looking very closely to see what is in that from a regulatory point of view, but also in respect of State support. On the two biggest costs we see for a lot of businesses, up to half and maybe north of 40% of their electricity bill is not the cost of the electricity itself; it is the network costs and fixed costs that are on the bill. How do we deal with those costs which are going to continue to increase as we need more capacity in the grid and so on? There is a big question there. We have put out a paper that suggests ways the State could subvent that rather than it coming off the user. The other issue, particularly in rural areas, as I mentioned in my opening statement, is that while carbon tax cuts will benefit kerosene or natural gas, most of the west and north west of the country is not on the gas grid. Most rural areas are beyond the gas grid but particularly in the west and north west there is no gas grid. Not doing the same for liquified petroleum gas, LPG, means that people with that kind of kitchen set-up will not see the benefit of what is there for other businesses. There is a big urban-rural divide in the use of LPG. It is a line in the Finance Bill; it is not a major cost. Our view is that it was an oversight not to include it as well.

Comment on this

Does IBEC think we are still too expansionary in the budgetary process?

Should we be putting away more of the corporation taxes windfall?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

We are in an unusual position whereby we do not have to choose, but that brings its own challenges. We could certainly be putting more away but it is very hard, in an inflationary context, to say what we are going to do less of in a budget. Do we do less on the tax side or what type of spending will we do less of?

Comment on this

At 6%, it is more than inflation, plus the population-----

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

It is but I do not think that the 6% was outrageous. We have seen 10% in recent years and one of the big challenges we have had is that we have not been sticking to budgets once we have set them. In the current environment, given that we have roughly 3.5% inflation and population increases, 6% is not far off what would be normal. The problem is that in-year, we tend to end up with Supplementary or Revised Estimates that bring that figure up closer to 10% every year. That is probably a bigger challenge.

Comment on this

An issue that I raise all of the time with the Minister, Deputy Chambers, is cost control. Does Mr. Brady have any ideas with regard to cost controls in the way we spend? I refer to both current and capital expenditure.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

We were very interested to see what was announced in the budget, namely a review of public spending. There was a move towards that in the post-crisis era when there were regular reviews. I am not sure what really came out of them-----

Comment on this

Is Mr. Brady referring to the public spending efficiency task force?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

Yes, the public spending efficiency task force. We are interested to see what that looks like. Our view is that it is important to maintain critical services and also a mix of spending. What we have seen in the past, when there have been spending cuts, is that the things that get cut are capital spending and things that are positive for the future but which do not hit people's pockets straight away. Things like research, for example, get cut very sharply. Our view is that we need to ensure that we have a strong mix of spending as well as a focus on the volume of spending. There is a challenge in those in-year spending overruns that needs to be looked at seriously. We need to determine whether it is, as some have suggested, because of under-budgeting at the outset and not recognising costs at the outset or whether it is a question of poor control of spending in individual parts of the system.

Comment on this

What I am interested in, which this committee may not have time to discuss today, are mechanisms of cost control like those in private companies, where each month one would review where one is vis-à-vis the budget, one would monitor overtime, consultancy costs and all of those kinds of nitty-gritty things that are often done at a very local level. They are the things I am interested in, rather than saying we should just cut expenditure here or there. Obviously, if one cuts expenditure it forces organisations to find ways of saving money but that is the area I am interested in. We do not have time to go through it now but that is the point in which I am interested.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

In other countries, like Switzerland for example, what is done - and we have seen it with these internal levies on Departments - is that if a Government Department runs over budget, it is claimed back off that Department in future years. The internal, in-year overruns-----

Comment on this

There are future consequences-----

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

Yes, there are future consequences.

Comment on this

They take a more long-term view than us. Our view is too short term.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

Yes. The system of levies that was introduced this year enforces the costs on other Departments rather than the Department that overran, which is a challenge. That brings its own political challenges. The other thing that countries do, which goes back to points made by colleagues earlier, is multi-year funding. They have multi-year plans.

Comment on this

That is something we discussed in our private meeting. I have asked that we as a committee have discussions on that and develop the idea of having more-than-one-year budgets.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

We are moving towards it under this new medium-term framework at an EU level but it is very high-level.

Comment on this

It is big numbers and percentages. It is not hard euro numbers, which is the only way to do it properly really.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

If we could bring that down to budget line level and Department level it would give that multi-year discipline so we would know where we were going and how to plan. The other thing is that for a lot of organisations, and we see this with our own membership, when they interact with the State, they find they are waiting until the budget happens and then they are waiting until they know what the Department is getting, what the line is getting and so on. It could be the middle of the year before something is finalised. We have seen this with colleagues in the education sector, for example, where it could be the middle of the year before they know their budget for the year because of how the budgeting system works. Multi-year budgeting would help.

Comment on this

Does IBEC have an ongoing role in the context of the action plan on competitiveness and productivity that was published in September last year? Does it have an ongoing role in monitoring progress on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

Yes, and there is the cost of business forum as well. We have been part of that too and we are following up all of the time with the Department on implementation.

Comment on this

Is there anything else that IBEC would have looked for in the budget that was not there? The opening statement is reasonably supportive of the main measures in the budget.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

Yes, it is but the one area that probably would have been most worrying for our members and more broadly for the economy would be third-level funding. Not much was done on third-level education. There was lots done on the skills side of things, including in-work skills which will be really useful but third-level is up against the wall in terms of funding and that is a big worry for employers.

Comment on this

I have some questions for the other witnesses. I join them in welcoming the increase in funding for mental health and addiction services although, obviously, we still have a fair bit to go on that. They referred to the extra costs of auto enrolment and said that they have not been funded for that. They should be funded for it because it is just going to be squeezed out of their overheads.

I am looking at the homeless figures and maybe this is a very simplistic way of working things out but there are 17,885 homeless people, which is obviously that many too many, and the cost is €543 million. When I divide one figure by the other, I get €30,000 per person. I know it is probably a lot more complex than that but-----

Comment on this
Mr. David Carroll

Yes, it is but I would argue that we are in a crisis at the moment in terms of temporary accommodation. We would agree with the Deputy that there has to be a reduction in that expenditure but that will only come through a reduction in the dependency on temporary accommodation. Temporary accommodation is expensive.

Comment on this

It is quite dear, yes.

Comment on this
Mr. David Carroll

Yes, absolutely, both within international protection and also within homelessness generally. I would go back to the call I made earlier regarding housing supply and a focus on that. We need a task-force type approach to reducing our reliance, on behalf of the public purse, on temporary accommodation. In the longer term, it has not only financial costs but human costs as well. From that perspective, I would share the Deputy's view on the absolute need for a reduction in that figure.

Comment on this

Related to that, on page six there is a proposal on the elimination of duplication which I welcome. We spoke about that on the last occasion the witnesses were before the committee, a few months ago. Has anything been done in that area? Are there any quick fixes that the witnesses could identify? This links back to the new public spending efficiency task force, which would have an important role to play in that.

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Hill

Our proposal is to be part of that committee, which we believe is led by the Department of public expenditure. There are different sections across our submission that it would cover. For example, there is no mention in the budget of an alternative care framework from the Department of children, which is going to be the new way of preventing young people from becoming homeless and looking after vulnerable young people in care. Linking up the services with the financial end is important. I was very interested in the Deputy's conversation with my colleague on future planning and being more efficient. Our care system is a good example of a system not working because we had short-term measures to make savings which has led to a long-term system that is now costing millions with unsatisfactory levels of care being provided. Having the likes of ourselves at those groups, focused on both the delivery of higher quality services and in a more efficient way, would be useful. We do not need eight different funders auditing the same piece-----

Comment on this

Are there any quick fixes on duplication that the witnesses can identify at this stage or is it premature to be asking that?

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Hill

It might be slightly premature but there are a couple of ideas.

Comment on this
Mr. John Gallagher

I do not think there is a quick fix. There is a process that we are going to have to enter into because if we look at addiction services, for example, they may be funded under mental health, homelessness-----

Comment on this

I understand that there are no quick fixes but even short-term, is there any low-hanging fruit?

Comment on this
Mr. John Gallagher

If Departments and agencies were to come together, we could begin to work towards it. We certainly would like a quick fix but the different agencies all need to get together to see-----

Comment on this

I know there is no quick fix. It is a process and it is time. That brings me to my last question. I have met with the likes of Sunbeam House Services and Cheshire Ireland which have outlined their costs model.

We then use private operators that are more expensive. From my years working in business, I know that, if you have experienced staff, you grow them, which leads to stability and a better service, rather than employing the quick fixes the witnesses spoke about. When their groups provide services at a better value than private operators, do they demonstrate that to Departments? I have met with the likes of Cheshire Ireland and Sunbeam House Services and they have shown that to me. It is very important that the groups show Government that, if it provides more funding, they can provide a given number of extra spaces or services when Government is paying millions of euro to private operators and that figure is expanding quickly. Do the groups sell their own efficiencies?

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Hill

As Mr. Carroll was saying, we are in crisis as regards homelessness and the care system. Our disability services have struggled over the years. Some of that has led to not having a long-term plan. We now have a framework for the prevention of homelessness. That needs to be funded and delivered. A framework for an alternative care system is now being developed. That needs to be funded on a long-term multi-annual basis. We need to move away from a crisis, where we spend too much money because things have built up, and towards a stable and functioning system. It is not a quick fix but it is exceptionally achievable.

Comment on this

It is a process. The main thing is that we see progress. I know there are no quick fixes to these things but I thought there might be some short-term improvements.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in today. It is good to hear an overview of what they are up to and what they forecast for the future. After the budget, RTÉ ran a headline about business groups being unhappy with the minimum wage increase. We hear that all the time. It makes my heart sink because I think of all the younger people who have become very disillusioned and do not see a future in this country. They are told that the minimum wage of €25,000 a year, give or take, is good enough for them but I do not think it is. They do not see a way to grapple their way out of that very low base. Today, the ESRI said that our reliance on lower-skilled migrants has doubled and that the number of such migrants has overtaken the number of higher-skilled migrants. Our young people are disillusioned and my heart sinks when I hear business groups saying that increases in the minimum wage should not be on the cards.

What could be done? Could the Government focus on tackling soaring fuel prices, the cost of running services and everything else that goes along with running a business, such as operational costs, energy bills and insurance rather than punishing the very low-paid, putting our young people off staying or progressing? Could it target those skyrocketing costs because they are significant for businesses? What benefits do the witnesses believe we could see from the National Training Fund? Could they answer that quickly? Have they seen businesses benefiting from the 9% VAT rate or has that reduction been eaten up by inflation? On hospitality, as we all know, the costs of purchasing food and materials have increased significantly. For business, it comes into one hand and goes out of the other. It is the same for households. Did setting the VAT rate to 9% make any significant difference? Have operational costs, the cost of living and business costs overtaken that in its entirety? To go back to the National Training Fund, will the witnesses tell me a little about that because it is important for the younger generation and future generations to see some progress in their lives.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

On the minimum wage and business costs, the challenge for business is not one measure on its own. It is the accumulation of measures. Auto-enrolment, minimum wage increases, changes in PRSI thresholds and lots of costs, including energy costs and other things, that are outside of the Government's direct control have all come at the same time. That is where we see the pressure, particularly on SMEs. The pressure comes from that accumulation. The cost of business forum has made lots of recommendations. The sooner we can progress those recommendations, which are not really about labour costs but about all the costs outside of those, the better. We saw some progress in the budget as regards the use of the PRSI system. To be fair, Sinn Féin was pretty early in supporting the idea of using the PRSI system to offset some of the increased labour costs we are seeing.

On the National Training Fund, it is very welcome that €360 million of that fund was unlocked in the budget. That has not yet been allocated. The €150 million AI element has not been allocated. There are schemes that really work. We talk to our members who engage in these schemes and who train their staff through them and they know what works for them. Money should be poured into those schemes. We should ensure this newly unlocked money is used in the right ways to get the maximum benefit. For both workers and businesses, that AI transition is going to be real and will come very quickly at all levels.

On the 9% VAT rate and costs, costs have gone up significantly. When we saw the reduction introduced, we did not expect the challenges that have arisen again in terms of energy costs. However, it has certainly helped with margins. Is it a solution that solves all of the challenges for the SME sector? The vast majority of SMEs are not in the hospitality sector. For hospitality sector SMEs, it has worked well. It has supported them. For those outside of that sector, the changes in the PRSI introduced in the budget were material and are welcome. We would like to see more of that in future budgets. We would like to see more of this recognition, which was included in the programme for Government, that the PRSI system could be used to help offset some costs. That would deal with some broader issues for business. Using the PRSI system to offset costs on the other side could result in a virtuous circle.

Comment on this

I will go back to the minimum wage increases and the vast majority of young people listening to these statements that employer groups are not happy. I know it is only a part of everything else but Mr. Brady is saying that the PRSI system can be helpful in encouraging the youth, the next generation, to ground themselves, to avail of training and to stick around and progress their careers. He is suggesting that we should concentrate on that rather than not giving them the rise.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

If we are going to see continued rises, offsetting these through decreases in PRSI on the other side would really help. In this budget, we have seen a start on that and a recognition of the principle. If we can do more of that in future budgets, it would ease the cost pressure that comes from rising wages.

Comment on this

Perhaps Mr. Brady could come back in nine months or a year, or provide a report, so that we can see how that PRSI change has made an impact. We can then see whether there is positivity about it and any forecasts regarding further measures.

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

We have some analysis. Mr. Mejdi might be able to share that analysis on the PRSI measures included in the budget.

Comment on this
Mr. Mourad Mejdi

As Mr. Brady mentioned, the adjustment in budget 2027 was welcomed. It offset approximately 40% of immediate costs to business as regards the minimum wage. A bit further up the line, we saw that employers who had employees being paid just above the minimum wage also saw a decrease in total labour costs. That is welcome in itself. The issue is not so much that the minimum wage is increasing but the ratchet effect. There are relativities there. As the minimum wage goes up, other workers also see their wages going up, which causes cost pressures to accumulate. It is not strictly targeted at one particular area.

As Mr. Brady mentioned, anything with regard to the PRSI mechanism that can be used to offset that and offset labour costs is welcome. As mentioned with regard to the National Training Fund and disillusionment among young people, I know from talking to my colleagues that one of the biggest sources of disillusionment is AI and what is coming down the tracks, and how that is going to affect the jobs of the future. We are in a unique place as regards really upskilling young people. We have the capital there to direct money to the relevant training programmes and funds. That was very much welcome in the National Training Fund. To see exactly how that is used on a broader basis would be welcome as well.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Mejdi very much. This question is for Ms Teague. Slieve League rhymes with Teague; that is a way of remembering it. I must confess that I am a former psychiatric nurse, so I like a lot of the stuff the witnesses said regarding mental health. Obviously, however, the 6% of the overall health budget, when we need to get to 10%, is a real bugbear. That has been the case for a long time. It used to be 14% in the 1980s and 1990s. We seemed to be more enlightened then than we are now. It was a different time and a different type of care was offered. It was more asylums than community care, but we will leave that.

On the assistant director of the HSE, it is about time. I have been asking about this for a long time through my union. The mother and baby mental health unit is needed as soon as possible.

I enjoy listening to the witnesses and seeing what it is that all the various voluntary and section 39 and 38 organisations do. I will ask some questions. Many section 39 organisations report that the core funding always falls short of inflation. We come across that constantly. They are just begging Peter to pay Paul or whatever. They will get a certain amount and are then told, "Off you go and find it for yourselves". Do the witnesses think this budget will provide a truly sustainable multi-annual funding model for the organisations they represent or does will their member bodies be left to face another year of instability? I think I know the answer to that.

Sinn Féin has consistently argued that staff in the community and voluntary sector deserve payment. The difference and why we lose people in the voluntary sector is that they are poached sometimes by the HSE. The HSE is so slow anyhow to employ people. Eventually, they do work their way in because the terms and conditions are so vastly different. If people had a brain in their heads, they would in all good conscience go to the HSE for pensions, holidays, sickness benefit and improved terms and conditions, even though it would leave an awful space and more struggle in services on which we absolutely rely. Are they still losing hand over fist - I know the answer to that as well - to the HSE and Tusla, although that may not be quite as significant as was the case previously? Given the allocation of the budget across the areas of disability, homeless and addiction services, do the representative organisations have the financial breathing room to expand capacity in order to meet rising local demand or will the current allocations result in a managed decline of existing services?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Teague

There were quite a few questions there that I think the Deputy already knows the answers to. There is absolutely a transfer of skills, knowledge and experience from our sector into State sector for all the reasons the Deputy mentioned in terms of pay and conditions. However, what we offer our staff members is a values-led way of working and that sometimes enough to attract people back. When they do a couple of years with a State entity, they might come back to a voluntary organisation and might have some different skills. We are all fishing in the same pond for the same staff and there are a limited number of staff. They go where the best terms and conditions are on offer. As the Deputy asked, who would blame them for doing that?

There is also an opportunity for us to work. If we worked collaboratively with our colleagues in State organisations, in circumstances where we have expertise, they could lean into us for that and where they have expertise and staff, we could lean into them. There is an absolutely siloed way of working that does not facilitate that kind of transfer of skills and knowledge. If there was a particular place in the country that needed some skills, would we be willing to talk to our counterparts in State organisations about how could we help to fill that? We absolutely would. However, that always comes at a price for voluntary organisations that do not often get the recognition or support then to either backfill posts or to fill certain posts by employing people with different skill sets. We are very willing to try to reach out. We are all in this to try to improve the lives of people in our communities. When we are here as a sector with this committee and other committees, one of the things we are trying to do is present the idea of intersectionality. What happens in drug and homelessness services impacts on disability services, mental health services and children's services. As a result, when we can co-ordinate ourselves and our work, we can then perhaps can encourage and guide our Government colleagues to maybe do the same thing and State agencies to be able to think a little more creatively about what they do and how they support better lives for people in our communities. If we bring it back to the people in our communities, we will be doing the right thing, whatever that is. At the moment, however, it is about budget lines, who owns the cost, how we can transfer the cost from here to there and who will pick up the tab. That is the conversation we are having, rather than asking what does a certain community need from a particular public service that has been funded? We really do want to drive the efficiency agenda and innovation. We can collaborate. We are hoping we can collaborate with our Government colleagues and with our funding agencies in order that we can really see some progress in some of the areas the Deputy identified.

Comment on this
Mr. David Carroll

The fact that the Deputy sees a national coalition of NGOs working together to advocate demonstrates the increased cohesion within the sector in the provision of services on behalf of the State. There probably have been a number of glimmers of hope for us in the past 18 months. One is the Workplace Relations Commission, WRC, and the pay awards that did come forward and that allowed us partially to keep pace. Obviously, we have the expectation that the public service awards will automatically award the uplift that the public service gets to the NGO sector.

The other key piece for us is the KOSI report, which demonstrates the differentiation between the NGO sector and the public sector in the context of terms and conditions. Our expectation is that this report will be published and that Government will take it forward into budget 2028 and will implement it. That will absolutely assist us in being able to maintain ourselves within the overall service provision market, because we do provide excellent services with high impact.

The third element is the talk about the annual awards that will drive efficiency. If I give the example of our organisation, we have 44 services and 80 service level agreements, SLAs, that have to be negotiated on an annual basis. If that was multi-annual and if there was cohesion between Departments, if we multiply that out across 1,000 organisations, we can automatically see the efficiencies that may come with a more efficient approach from Government as well. The WRC, the KOSI report and interdepartmental rationalisation of the SLA process will be hugely beneficial to us.

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Hill

I will give a couple of quick examples regarding the sustainability to build on that. There are set costs that the Government produces with each budget. Auto-enrolment is one. That is a known amount. We have minimum wage increases. We have staff who do sleepovers and get paid that at night. We had an extra bank holiday over the past couple of years. They were all set costs, but they are not being planned for in the budgets for the community and voluntary sector. That means for each individual service, we are estimating about €7,000 or €8,000 per year from just Government costs that have gone up. Then, we had the increases, obviously, in utilities that we have at the minute. The pressures on IT, as we laid out, are sufficient. They are easily calculated. Pre-recession, we would have had standard things like small cost-of-living increases; 1% or 2% per year would have been enough. It is only now that we have not done that for a number of years since the recession ended that it has meant that the bill involved is now a significant bump. If we get over that bump, however, we can get back to the simple plan within the budget to make sure that each Department is allowing for the community and voluntary sector to have the standard increases that all Departments are feeding themselves.

I am the chair of a primary school. We know that the cost of our heating has gone up. We have to try to manage that. There are simple things that can be put in place which will mean we will not end up in situations with large bumps that are required in budgets, which are straightforward sustainability pieces that would tie in nicely with multi-annual funding and those other pieces that we mentioned.

Comment on this

It is good housekeeping. I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this

I thank you all for coming in. I am a very practical person. I am a businessperson and I put that on the record. Deputy Devine was talking about the minimum wage. I will give an example. One company had part of its staff on minimum wage. It was also in receipt of the 9% VAT rate. When the minimum wage changed, it cost €400,000 that year because of all the different sectors, with everyone wanting the same bump to their wages. This meant that the cost of staying in that place rose as well, so we ended up paying for it ourselves anyway. The whole point of having a minimum wage increase - I am not against it - is for you to get more when you have more money, but when you add in the inflationary costs of everything else, then no matter what you raise your minimum wage to, it is only going to drive inflation in the situation we are in. That is what is frustrating for all of us, because we all want to keep our young people here and ensure that people and their jobs are valued. I mean everyone, regardless of what they do in the country. It is a wheel that we are turning and everyone, regardless of what their expertise is, from the lowest paid to the highest paid, has to get this wheel to go around. That is what I look at but the State is getting it wrong all of the time from the point of view of where it is targeting.

At the start of the meeting, Mr. Brady mentioned LPG and that it was like an urban-rural divide. I have been saying that since I got elected. Every decision being made by Departments shows the urban-rural divide because the people making the decisions forget about urban and rural. To me, urban and rural are the same; it is Ireland, so let us cover everyone. However, you have people making their budgets for this and they leave LPG out of it, so Calor Gas, Flogas and their gas bottles were left out. There are premises that do not have the facilities for natural gas. They do not have the space for tanks of natural gas, so they have to use small tank systems. They are left out. That is more than an oversight when the Department should recognise all areas in business. It is the SMEs that get kicked.

I am going to be brutally honest - I am an honest person - about the NGOs. In business terms, there are NGOs doing absolutely fantastic work but there are some that are getting massive funding and not delivering. The sectors the witnesses have talked about have been underfunded but are providing massive supports for people. I would love to see a business model put into the NGO sector whereby NGOs that are getting funding but not providing any services are audited against the NGOs that are providing services above and beyond their working hours. They should get the funding and it should be balanced, so I would like to see an audit of what some NGOs are providing in services. If they are not providing services, the funding should go to the NGOs that are providing those and need it. That is the business model. I have been in business all my life and that is the model I use. The way to help more people is to give the funding to the organisations that are helping people and to give the ones that are not doing that less because they are not providing a service. That is me calling a spade a spade and that is the way I work. The worst thing is NGOs getting the same name as politicians. It is said that we are all the same. You can have people doing great work but all are branded as the one sector. I would like to see it segregated and see the great work that some NGOs are doing while there are other NGOs that are getting massive funding but not providing any services at all to the people. That is me telling it straight out.

I am going to direct the first question to Mr. Brady. I am from a business sector and my turnover has gone up. My profits have not gone up. They have declined overall. If I put in that growth and based my profits on the same percentage model as I was using in other years, the inflationary costs would mean that people would be paying an awful lot more for my services to be delivered, so it is a balancing act. The PRSI may help a small bit but not an awful lot. The price of materials is huge. On the cost of getting people to work, carbon tax is huge. Then there is the auto-enrolment, which I do not have an issue with, but it has to be paid. If I pay it, though, it has to come from somebody else who has to pay me. It is all in the budgeting.

If the Department was a business, would it survive based on the system it is using at the moment, given that cannot forecast? With my business, I have to look at next year and try to forecast and stay within budget so that I can make myself as efficient as possible and also see if I can have growth and future-proof my company. It was rightly said that organisations did not know until quarter 1 or half way into quarter 2 what funding they were getting. The model needs to be changed, and it needs to be a business model. Come 31 December, people need to know on 1 January what they have to forecast for the full 12 months. How can the witnesses help with getting our Departments to be that way?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

Most of our members will be well into setting their budgets or will have already set their budgets, so they will know that they are doing next year. There are lots of things in the wider world, energy costs in particular, that can throw that in any given year, but they will know more or less, and the departments and divisions within those businesses will know exactly what they are doing, and they can plan on that basis.

A common theme we have heard about today is the challenge of multi-annual funding but also the way we fund within the year, whereby you might not know until quarter 2 what your budget is for the year. It does not allow organisations to plan and, furthermore, it leads to inefficiencies because if you cannot plan, then you cannot set up the most optimised way of running your organisation. That applies to the private sector, NGOs and anybody in between. There is a challenge in how we budget that is set up to be inefficient. It is set up to have the in-year overruns that I referenced earlier. Any organisation getting funding from any source should be budgeting now for next year and have a fair idea of what they are doing. We know at departmental level what people are getting but we will not know at organisational level as that feeds down until quarter 2.

We talked about the new efficiency body that was going to come out of the Department of public expenditure and reform. One of the biggest challenges for efficiency is the fact that how we budget does not really suit how organisations, which have to operate in contact with reality, have to run themselves and plan.

Comment on this

Turning to Mr. Gallagher and others, how do I get a model in place so that their organisations can get the rewards they need to help people? Could this year's model of funding be based on the number of people the groups helped last year? Is it a question of trying to audit from the point of view of the Government by saying that the groups helped 1,000 people this year and they got €1 million but they have to help 2,000 people next year? Is there a system that can be worked out that will show, year on year, the number of people the organisations are helping and how the services go above and beyond even the time limits of the organisations' days? Is there a way of putting that together so that I can come up with a system that will let me say that this is what a group has done and point to what it is able to do? In what way can we help the organisations' system to ensure it benefits everyone they are helping?

Comment on this
Mr. John Gallagher

I have a few points. Some of the individuals here might answer the Cathaoirleach's last question because there are variable costs. A body may have residential services to provide or it be just be providing drop-in services, so there may be some difficulty with having a uniform figure that would be allocated annually. Each of the areas like homelessness and health are probably making those figures available to their individual Departments. Maybe that can be improved.

The Cathaoirleach's idea about an audit is a good one. It is happening in a number of ways already. The KOSI report is effectively an audit of what is required to make the system effective.

It will show up disparities in funding and seek to correct them. We already know that the Cuan area, which deals with domestic and sexual violence, seems to be underfunded. The KOSI report will hopefully bring that out as factual data.

The proposals coming from the Government about an efficiency and effectiveness task force - I saw it described as a savings task force recently - are something we would like to contribute to. The inefficiencies that exist for us at the moment, from our side, are having to report to different agencies and different funders at different times with different stipulations, and being paid at different times, so staff and resources come in at different times. That is a clear waste of energy by the finance department, and that then carries over.

Comment on this

I have one question based on that for all the witnesses. The Department has set something up in the way it hands out its use-it-or-lose-it funding by the end of the year. It causes problems across each sector. It even impacts local authorities. They might have been able to save something for a project that had been put off for the last year or might be able to deliver something in the following year, but the funding is specified to be use-it-or-lose-it funding. Money is being wasted at the end of the year. If it was in the kitty, and money was needed for a project, it would be possible to forecast that it would be there for next year. There should be an allowance for this way of operating, because that is a business model. The funding saved in one year put together with the funding to be received in the next year might mean a service could be delivered. This use-it-or-lose-it approach is a thing that has to change.

Comment on this
Mr. David Carroll

The section 10 review conducted by the local authorities has provided a strong framework based on a clear delivery model, namely, getting people out of homelessness or preventing them from becoming homeless. There are very clear metrics. Another significant metric is improved health. Mr. Gallagher is correct that it is difficult to come up with a unit cost because there may be a set of accommodation-based services. For example, we have a service in Cork with 70 men in one building. We have another service with 42 people, but we need the same number of staff because of the on-site presence needed.

What the committee is probably hearing from us is in respect of the efficiency framework. The Cathaoirleach is absolutely right. We have a story to tell that we are not telling properly about the impact we have on the ground. Going forward, we have bought in fully to working with the Government to make sure there is the required cohesion across organisations in areas such as insurance, procurement - mass food procurement, for example - building maintenance and fuel purchasing. Things can be done better across organisations.

There is also the big question of the sector’s responsibility to look at the organisations themselves. Depaul took over six services from the Society of St. Vincent de Paul, SVP, five years ago because the society concluded it was more efficient for it to hand over those services. More of these types of discussions need to happen, and innovation funds need to exist to facilitate that. The approved housing body, AHB, sector is another example.

What the committee is hearing from us is that impact is very important to us. We want to engage with the efficiency task force and to be facilitated to have discussions ourselves about how we can do things better.

Comment on this

Would Mr. Gallagher like to come in on this point?

Comment on this
Mr. John Gallagher

I will make a final point about supporting organisations that deliver services and giving less to those that do not. There is some difficulty in classifying where services begin and end. I am aware, for example, of organisations that have done a great deal of advocacy on smoking controls, alcohol, sugary drinks and the need for greater cancer awareness. There is a role for the sector to come to the Government with ideas and say that we need to do better. It is not purely about delivering a readily available and clearly identifiable service. There is a role for the sector to work with the Government to make things better, whether in smoking regulations or whatever it might be.

Comment on this

At the end of the year, when we look at the budgets, it can be seen that there is a massive purse coming into the third quarter. Meanwhile, looking at the sector represented by the organisations here and other sectors, their purses may have been empty since the first quarter and they may be struggling. The large amount of remaining money that I mentioned is then put into a large project to get ready for the end of the year. That is where auditing should come in across the whole year. This is being done. The money is being got rid of at the end of the year. Even if the funding is to help a sector, it should have been forecast throughout the year on the basis of four quarters and not at the end of the year. If there is auditing across the different sectors, it will be possible to see that a lot of money is being spent in the fourth quarter that had not been spent in the first three quarters. It could have been sustained across the whole 12 months. That is where I want to get the balance right. I want to see that done over three quarters and results achieved, and the money gone by the end of quarter 4.

Comment on this
Mr. David Carroll

On that point, section 10 has introduced an in-year mechanism for reviewing budgets and also includes a clawback mechanism.

Comment on this
Mr. Gordon Hill

One of the issues I have discussed with some of my colleagues in the Child and Family Agency, Tusla, in recent years is that any money not spent is taken back. An organisation is not allowed to have a sinking fund. Organisations are trying to break even at the end of each year. If a building then requires work, the money is gone. It is the same if something more sustainable comes up, exactly as the Cathaoirleach described. Money has to be spent by year end or it is taken back. Organisations may then find themselves on the verge of problems because, for example, of a sudden increase in heating bills. There is no flexibility, particularly in the smaller projects, in budgets to support such an increase.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Brady want to comment?

Comment on this
Mr. Gerard Brady

That all makes perfect sense. I do not think there are many organisations, particularly larger, service-driven organisations, certainly in the private sector, which do not maintain some kind of reserve for the unexpected. We had many more unexpected events in recent years than we had in the past.

Comment on this

I turn to Mr. Mourad Mejdi at the end of the table. Does he have one suggestion that he thinks could make a difference? If people have five points to make, I often ask them if there is one difference they can see that could alter the trajectory, even a small bit, for people.

Comment on this
Mr. Mourad Mejdi

What would this be in terms of?

Comment on this

It could concern taxation or something else. Does Mr. Mejdi have one small change that he thinks could make a big difference if introduced?

Comment on this
Mr. Mourad Mejdi

It is a good question. My colleagues in IBEC take a long-term view on this. I made a point to Deputy Devine about the National Training Fund. Equipping people with skills is the key issue we see at the moment. The beauty of the fund’s design is in its simplicity, in the sense that the more people are at work, the more employers pay into it. A more productive workforce is needed because key skills gaps remain and there are not enough people to fill them.

Comment on this

When the fund was examined, it was seen that there was a massive amount of money in it that was not being used. The Government is now trying to divert it into something elsewhere. The money should instead go back into training to keep our younger people here and benefit Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Mourad Mejdi

Exactly. That is where the blockage is. The money is not transmitted back into the system and it does not recycle back into skills. I would say-----

Comment on this

If it is not being used as a training fund, why is the charge being paid in the first place? Many businesses are asking this question and wondering whether they should set up their own training funds within their own sectors. If they are putting money into a Government training fund that is not being used to train people, should this be something that is done internally instead? It is something to be looked at.

Comment on this
Mr. Mourad Mejdi

Yes.

Comment on this

That concludes the session. I am sorry. Does Deputy Devine want to come in again?

Comment on this

Yes. I have a question about Cuan. The organisations represented are members of agencies that Cuan is giving some funding to. Is that correct? It is a newly established agency and needs much more attention, given the violence against women and girls. Is it difficult for those agencies to obtain funding? I have not really engaged with Cuan. The committee, on my behalf, has invited its representatives to come before it within the next month or so. Has it proved difficult for the agencies seeking funding? Is the funding generous or should more be available?

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Teague

They would say that what is difficult is being able to understand the budget allocation, how it applies to them, where the funding is going to go, what that funding is for and how they can help to deliver it.

There is money in the budget for work and the agency has not really been clear about what the deliverables are and who is going to deliver these things. Everybody recognises the need for additional services and additional supports for people who are experiencing violence but what is not clear is the plan. A theme of some of the discussion today is the need for improved planning and being really clear about what we are looking for, how we are going to count achieving it and how we are going to assess the impact of these kinds of services.

I would say that from Cuan's perspective it would say it is absolutely underfunded. It welcomes the additional funding in the budget but it needs some transparency and clarity on how this money will be allocated to organisations in order to provide these services. It may be that over the next few weeks there will be clarity. We absolutely experience what has been described by my colleagues here from IBEC. There is a budget announcement, which goes through the mechanisms in the Departments and gets allocated to the State agencies that do their work. It takes us a number of weeks, if not longer, to really understand budget announcements. Then we have to go and pitch for the business. We have to ask for it and state we can deliver it, at which point we might be told that it is something else that is needed.

It is very unclear to us and perhaps it will be the second quarter of next year before we get deliverables. This would mean we had missed a whole lot of time and we would be playing catch-up, trying to recruit staff at very short notice and trying to put projects together. If we do not do this we will not deliver and then we will lose the money. We are in a cycle of trying to play catch-up all of the time. Improved planning for Cuan, for all of us and for all of our colleagues, and improved clarity on budget allocations and what is to be delivered, would really help to set us on a footing whereby we can get into a conversation about what is possible - not what is wanted but what is possible for us to deliver, where this would leave the gap and how could we work together to bridge it.

Comment on this

We do not have time, really, with 13 women dead so far this year. It is crazy. It was great that Cuan was going to help local organisations, and the emphasis was going to be on what can be delivered locally, with none of the BS around it. Absolutely there were going to be checks and balances, auditing and all of this sort of stuff, but we need ordinary people in ordinary communities to deliver to ordinary people who have all this shit happening to them. This was my vision of it, and maybe I was naïve. Now I am looking at all the hoops that we have to go through to get to people. I am delighted it is coming before the committee so I will be able to chat to it a little bit.

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Teague

There is this thought about care in the community and that this is where people should receive care. At the moment it feels like there is neither money for care nor communities that can pick up the pieces. We do have to do a bit of work in communities all over the country to make sure there are joined-up services. For example, a child experiencing homeless who has a mental health challenge does not get something for one element and something else for another element. Who actually takes care of this child and the family in a whole-of-society approach to these issues? We have a journey to go on but it does start with that-----

Comment on this

As long as we are not strangled by it all because often we are paralysed.

Comment on this
Ms Elaine Teague

The efficiencies task force is a very good place for us to start. We can start to speak about the inefficiencies we experience and ask how we can collaborate to break them down. We can get ourselves into a position where we are all focused on using taxpayers' money to deliver what people need in communities, and we are not going up, down and around the hills reporting 15 times on the same thing but instead we are all really clear on what we are here for and what we use State money and taxpayers' money for. We need everybody to be fighting on our side.

Comment on this

Something I will take from today's meeting, and I am using a business model for everything, is that our budget is done in October but I hear across the board that people do not know what is to be delivered until quarter 1 or quarter 2 of the following year. This means we lose quarter 4 of one year and quarter 1 and some of quarter 2 of the following year, or between six and nine months of a cycle. If the budget is decided in October, Departments have to decide in quarter 4 what the sector must deliver and the funding must be provided in quarter 1. If the funding does not arrive until quarter 2 to deliver a service, the Department is allowing only six months of the year to deliver a service that should take 12 months to deliver. This is not efficient funding. For the Departments to make sure the organisations get proper funding, they have to deliver in quarter 4 and have it ready for quarter 1 of the following year. If the Departments are not capable of doing this, those in the Department should be audited themselves and someone else should be put in their place who can deliver it for the organisations to provide a 12-month service rather than trying to push it into a six-month service to make their books look good. That is what I have come up with.

I thank all of the witnesses very much for coming in. The meeting has been very informative. This concludes the session and I thank everyone for attending the meeting today.

Comment on this