We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. - FINANCIAL RESOLUTIONS (RESUMED).

Contributions 109–227 of 227. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Deputy Johnson says so.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Gorey deny that he is in favour of a tax on imported bacon?

Comment on this

I will not answer the Deputy. The question does not arise.

Comment on this

We will see the Official Report in a day or two. If the Deputy does not support that, then I am sorry for the farmer-producers of bacon. The import of bacon—chiefly American—is valued at £2,000,000. I suppose the greater portion of that is bought by farmers, who sell their own bacon and their own pigs to curers to send away. I think that is bad business. It is certainly bad national economy. I would suggest to the Minister that one way of increasing the pig-population and steadying the industry is to have something like a stabilisation of prices—something more of stabilisation than has existed for quite a long time. I believe that that could be accomplished if an attempt were made. The bacon-curing industry is fairly compactly organised, and there can be much more regularity in the prices of bacon if an attempt be made in that direction, in the interests of the industry. I refer to the pig-rearing industry, and not merely to the bacon-selling industry. With organisation and determination, agreement between producers of pigs and curers of bacon, and, perhaps, the assistance of the Department of Agriculture, there could be a regularisation for a period say, of six or twelve months, of bacon prices within smaller variations than exist at present. That would go a long way towards assisting the growth of the pig-population in the country.

Comment on this

Can Deputy Johnson tell us the total value of the bacon imported from the United States last year? It appears in the returns as £6,000.

Comment on this

The total value is £1,800,000.

Comment on this

The figure Deputy Cooper has given refers, I think, to direct importation.

Comment on this

I see by the return, that imported pig products, bacon and a few sundries, amount to £1,805,000 from January to December.

Comment on this

That includes Danish bacon, as well.

Comment on this

It is all imported bacon. I do not mind whether it comes from America or not.

Comment on this

When Deputy Johnson asked me a question about an import duty on bacon a few minutes ago, I did not answer him directly. The reason is that we have not discussed this question in our organisation. I would not like, therefore, to confine myself to a cut and dry policy, because it might be only my own policy. That is the reason I did not answer the Deputy directly.

Comment on this

It is well to hear, at any rate, that the farmers have not made up their minds against the possibility of an import duty on bacon.

Comment on this

Or any one item. They could not single out any one item.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey, after all, must bear in mind that three or four of the representatives of the farmers who have spoken here are not now resolutely opposed to the idea of protective tariffs. It is now a question of choosing which article may be taxed and which may not be taxed. The principle has been conceded, so that we may now discriminate—

Comment on this

It has not been conceded.

Comment on this

Did not Deputy Gorey state he was opposed on principle to protective tariffs?

Comment on this

On a proportion of articles. This is a sort of conditional tariff so far as we are concerned. What is coming in is protected. What we are producing and sending out is not protected at all. Until you are in a position to protect that and are able and willing to protect it, we must oppose the other tariffs.

Comment on this

I propose to repeat an argument which I have already used here—that is, that the farmers, through their organisation and through their spokesmen, quite frequently expressed the view that they should find additional markets abroad, apart from England. On the question of industrial tariffs, I am suggesting to Deputy Gorey—

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy where we have expressed the view that additional markets for our produce can be found abroad?

Comment on this

I think if Deputy Gorey will read up some of the speeches during last year's Budget debates, he will find that Deputy Heffernan expressed the hope that the Ministry would spend some of the money expended on the Ministry of Foreign Affairs looking for markets abroad for Irish agricultural produce.

Comment on this

Perhaps he meant poteen or whiskey or something like that.

Comment on this

I do not want to get Deputy Gorey and Deputy Heffernan at each other's wool. Therefore, I will not pursue that matter. It is undoubtedly believed by many people, even amongst the farmers, that there should be alternative markets found for agricultural produce, if possible.

Comment on this

If possible.

Comment on this

I am going to show to Deputy Gorey that it is possible to find a new market for Irish agricultural produce.

Comment on this

That is what we want.

Comment on this

You have a million people in the towns of the Saorstát, and you have two hundred thousand of those certainly not eating enough. If they were employed with anything like regularity, or at anything like fair wages, there would be a new market for Irish agricultural produce. I would like to see that million people working and earning in the towns obliged, by virtue, shall I say, of an economic inducement, even through a tariff upon imported foreign food stuffs, to purchase Irish bacon, Irish butter and Irish eggs in preference to American or Canadian bacon, Danish butter or Siberian eggs. There you get your market: you get it at home by stimulating, even by tariffs, the employment of Irish labour in Irish towns. Then there is a reciprocal duty imposed upon these townsmen to do what I have said, to consume Irish agricultural produce. Those two forces working together will mean, undoubtedly, a very great increase in the gross production of wealth in this country. I believe that all our energies should be directed to stimulating that production, whether of manufactured articles or of agricultural produce. If we take advantage, as we must, of all the new methods, of the improvements in the method of production and of marketing, to get the highest prices for the produce that must be exported, that, incidentally, will have a very beneficial effect upon even that portion of the produce which is sold in this country. But there is nothing, except the proposal regarding beet root, in this Budget to show that there is any desire or any intention to stimulate that kind of productivity. You will, I think, by virtue of the tariff upon apparel, create new wealth through the employment of new labour in the towns. But you must move directly and swiftly towards increasing the amount of production from the land, and I do not think we ought to be content to wait for increased prices in the English markets through a general rise in prices that may possibly come, but is not likely, or through increased prices due to improved methods of production and of marketing. That, I am afraid, is going to be too slow. I would like to see a direct attempt, by subsidy or by a guarantee of prices or by tariffs upon imported agricultural produce, to stimulate the production of that kind of produce concurrently with the stimulation of the production of manufactured goods. In that respect, I think, the Budget is not going far enough towards remedying the grievances from which the country is suffering and will continue to suffer.

On the whole, I must say that the Budget is better than I anticipated. I feared there would have been a refusal to reduce the taxes upon breakfast-table commodities, that there would have been a greater reduction in the income tax, and that we would have been obliged to wait for another year before we had a further development in tariffs of a protective kind. It has been said occasionally that my business here, and the business of our Party, has been to oppose anything which the Government introduces. Of course, anybody who knows anything knows that that is not true. We have tried to discriminate between what we thought was good, and what we thought was bad; to support that which was good, and to oppose that which was bad, even though it came from the Government. We do not think that the duty of an Opposition is simply to oppose. In this case, I am glad to support the general propositions in the Budget. I would like to have seen a greater discrimination in respect of the income tax. There are two or three small points that will certainly be raised later regarding the incidence of taxation, and some other small matters that I need not deal with now. I think the country will be delighted to find that it is possible to reduce taxation, and particularly the taxation upon people who will take sugar and tea even if they can get very little else. It goes some way, perhaps, to relieve even the old age pensioners, because they are very large consumers of tea and sugar. I hope that we shall get to the ideal of an absolutely free breakfast table before many years are over. We are nearer to that ideal now than this country has been within certainly sixty years, and for that we have to be thankful.

Comment on this

Deputy Johnson, by the policy he has just enunciated, seems as if he were speaking for those who go by the name of workers. I would like to point out to him that a certain Union, known as the Distributive Workers' Union, some short time ago passed a resolution in opposition to the very tenets of which he is such an able exponent. Furthermore, when he twits us here with not having formulated a policy which would meet with the views of every man, I may say that we labour, on our side, under the same disadvantages that he, perhaps, labours under on his side. What is the policy of the Farmers' Union? The Farmers' Union protests against the imposition of tariffs. On two or three occasions, through our advocacy here, the Farmers' Union has spoken against them. Seeing that the Government is determined to pursue the policy which it has thought out on tariffs, the Farmers' Union demands, through us, that the policy of tariffs should be applied to the products by which we live.

Comment on this

Will Deputy Wilson state what particular articles he is demanding a tariff for?

Comment on this

I will—on what we produce. Now, we hear a good deal of the neglect of this country to avail itself of its natural fertility, and although we have been passing through a period of political unrest here, yet on the comparative table I find set forth the productivity of this country as compared with Denmark, and while the Dane has got an exchange which amounts to practically one-third in his favour, yet, working on that basis, his exports in agricultural products is £48,000,000 in his own money, which would really only amount to some one-third less. Our exports, based on the pound here as equal to the pound in London, amounts to £32,000,000, so that as a matter of fact we are producing in Ireland equivalent to what the Danes produce in Denmark. How is that done? It is done, as you know, by cattle. I demand an examination of this matter, and I deny that anyone can say that we can be reckoned as not doing the work which we are supposed to do. How can we get greater productivity? That is what we are all anxious for. Will a tariff on oats enable us to produce more oats? Oats imported into the country and oat-products amount to about £700,000. It is a positive fact that it is nearly impossible to sell oats in Dublin to-day at a reasonable price. When you come in to sell you are shown a sample of Canadian oats 2/- more than they will offer us. It is of a better quality, I admit, but that is the position. Our price is not sufficient to admit of the production of that particular grain, and the means we have to use up that product is by feeding it to cattle and exporting the cattle. Take bacon: £1,806,000 worth has been imported. The question arises, if you put a tariff on bacon will people use the bacon here, or will we get higher prices for the local consumption which would stimulate production to some extent? Similarly, with butter. We imported last year £739,000 worth of butter. I believe myself that a tariff on butter would stimulate winter dairying and in that case increase the productivity of the land. I will come on to barley. Barley is an old friend in this House, but it is the smallest import of the lot. Only £188,000 worth was imported, plus £205,000 worth of malt. Yet we hear of barley night, noon and morning; whether it is the product of the barley that makes some people speak of it so often or not I do not know.

Comment on this

What about maize?

Comment on this

That is tremendous.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy say how many resolutions he received from branches of the Farmers' Union on the question of the importation of barley, and what is the result of these resolutions on the Farmers' Party?

Comment on this

I do not represent a barley constituency, thank God, and have nothing to do with it, but taking it all, whether it is by a subsidy to the production of a certain number of barrels, or a certain number of acres of corn, or whether it is by the imposition of a tariff, we demand that you give us the same protection as you are giving people who live in the cities. That is a fair proposition; it is dragged out of us, and I am explaining it to you as I have been directed to explain it, and I speak with the authority of the Farmers' Union.

Comment on this

Are we to understand that the Deputy is now asking definitely for a tariff on imported barley and malt?

Comment on this

On everything.

Comment on this
A DEPUTY

On bacon?

Comment on this

Exactly, on everything.

Comment on this

The Deputy has changed his mind since the last meeting of the Farmers' Union.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

That is no trouble to him.

Comment on this

We are here, I take it, to express our views and it is our responsibility whether we express the views of any organisation behind us or not. We are not asked here to express the views of any organisation behind us. We are rather responsible to the organisation. If I am prepared to take the responsibility of expressing any definite views to the House I am responsible to the House so far as my relations to the House are concerned, and any other organisation I am responsible to can call me over the coals if they desire. I wish Deputy Wilson to avow the same thing, otherwise we are at sea.

Comment on this

Exactly, because while you might be repudiated by people behind you, people here would not understand you were speaking for a dummy. We have made our position perfectly clear. We say we would produce more if certains things were not imported. We say we desire to get all we can out of the land and to produce more, and we look to the removal of everything that is a barrier to our production.

On that I want to point out to the Minister that in this country a tax of £25,000,000 is certainly a barrier upon production and if he would stimulate production and enable us to get in front of the Dane or anyone else, let him see that the taxes levied in this country, both local and central, are reduced, and let him apply to the management of the Government that principle which each individual has to apply to the management of his own affairs. That is the protection that is neglected. We know, and I readily admit, that we are inheritors of a system of Government which was extravagant in the extreme. We were the junior partners in a joint concern where money was looked on as of very little value; but we are in a different position to-day. It has been stated that there are difficulties in the reduction of the staffs in Government departments, but it is in the reduction of these staffs the salvation of the farming industry lies, quite as much as in the retention of tariffs which are put on as a counterpoise to other tariffs. There are several other industries that were quite as well entitled to a tariff as those upon which a tariff has been put. One is the flour industry. I am not advocating a tariff on it. It is said that tariffs are put on to stimulate industry, and I wonder why the Government refused to put a tariff on flour. There are sufficient mills in this country to supply Ireland, or at all events the Free State. We are losing the offals from the importation of flour, and we have to import offals to the extent of £370,000. If the wheat were milled in Ireland we would have these offals at a much cheaper rate, which would incidentally help us in our industry. I am not advocating a tariff on flour, but I am showing the inconsistency with which tariffs have been set up. We import flour to the value of £3,260,000 and because the cry would go up that you were taxing food, the Government had not the pluck to put a tariff on imported flour and aid agriculture incidentally.

Comment on this

There seems to be great productivity about this Budget.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

Of new views.

Comment on this

It would be impossible for me now to go back on all the suggestions which have been put forward with a view to this country being lifted up. I will just speak for a moment on the question of sugar beet. It looks a very entrancing and flourishing proposition, but when you begin to examine it closely, the whole idea seems foolish. Why do I say those things? I know that you can produce sugar in Africa and buy it on the farms a thousand miles from Natal at 14/- a cwt. You are giving here a tariff or a subsidy of 23/- for an article that is produced there at 14/- per cwt. I am not speaking through my hat. I am speaking commonsense. If you look at the price of Tate's cubes in Liverpool, you will find that the highest quality of sugar is selling at 31/-.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

Is it beet sugar?

Comment on this

I do not care what sugar it is, whether it is sugar-cane or anything else. I know anyhow that you can get unrefined sugar at 17/- in Liverpool. Here you are going to give it a subsidy for a period of ten years. It may be the right policy, perhaps, but those are all considerations which the general taxpayers in the country ought to look to. As a farmers' representative, I am delighted that we are going to have a new industry. I hope it will succeed, and I hope that in the course of a few years, when it is self-supporting, we will get other industries to follow suit. But there are considerations which I am surprised the business-men have not taken up; I am surprised they have not informed the Dáil what these subsidies mean in essence. I think I have said sufficient to make clear the position of the farmers. We hope, and I am quite satisfied in believing, that no better Budget could have been brought out in the circumstances. A remission of one shilling in income tax, a subsidy of £600,000 for local rates, and then this question of a sugar-beet industry, is a sufficiently broad gesture on the part of the Government, and an indication that it is doing something to help us. I agree that, under the circumstances, what has been done is very good. But the real thing to be tackled is the overhauling of the expenses of the Government, and the reduction of these barriers which, in their operation, are so antagonistic to progress on the land.

Comment on this

There was a time during the speech of the last, Deputy when I though I would start by congratulating Deputy Johnson on having got a new convert. Candidly, I do not know now whether I can congratulate him. Candidly, I do not know whether Deputy Wilson is of the opinion and is glad that the Government is undertaking a foolish project by starting the beet industry or not. I do not know whether he is undertaking that attitude on his own behalf or on behalf of the Farmers' Party. I do not know whether he is in favour of free trade. There, again, I do not know whether he is speaking for himself or the Farmers' Party, or whether he is such a complete convert to the views that Deputy Johnson expressed that he is in favour of a tax on oats, flour, bacon, butter, barley or, as he succinctly expressed it, everything.

Comment on this

Yes, everything.

Comment on this

That is undoubtedly a great conversion on the part of the Farmers' Party from the attitude that they took up last year.

Comment on this

And to-day.

Comment on this

Yes, last year and to-day. I am not sure whether it really represents the views of the Farmers' Party. It is a rather difficult thing, I must confess, to follow Deputy Wilson's—I was going to say line of argument—setting-forth of his policy, or what he calls his policy. I believe it was the policy of the Farmers' Union. Taking the Budget, however, as a whole, it is interesting to see that the only, I will not say effective, but pronounced opposition that has come from any distinct part of the House to the Budget and its proposals has been from—I was going to say farmers' representatives— the representatives of the Farmers' Union. I would suggest to the representatives of the Farmers' Union that they cannot have the thing both ways. They cannot, for instance, expect remissions from taxation along certain lines and then seek to attack other taxes, the imposition of which, apart from any other consideration, would be needed to make up the necessary sum to allow of the remissions. If you look at the figures you will see there is available £1,800,000. That is effectively available as a surplus. The remissions amount to £2,400,000. In new taxes, therefore, there ought to be made up £600,000. The question of whether you should make up that in a way that would help industry, or simply in a way that would be no good to the country, naturally arises. What the Government did was to find that money in a way that, while doing good, and promoting industry, would ultimately help everybody, the farmers as well as everybody else. Supposing you do away with the revenue that you get from the £600,000, which will be derived mainly from wearing materials and on furniture, what portion of the remission are the Farmers' Party prepared to drop? If you look hastily at the list, you may suggest there is one sum that comes remarkably near the £600,000. I wonder whether it is necessary to mention that particular sum?

If it is said the Government have done nothing for the Farmers' Party, I do not know that that can be borne out. Some members of the Farmers' Party referred to the industrialists of the towns. As regards the Budget, I see £600,000 for the new protective tariffs; I also see that there is £600,000 placed as an addition to the agricultural grant. Supposing you do not suggest the dropping of this £600,000, what about the duty on sugar, tea or income tax? The Farmers' Party protest this year that the income tax does not interest them; but last year the one amendment to the income tax proposal, proposing its reduction, came from the Farmers' Party. Deputy Connor Hogan proposed it, and Deputy Heffernan spoke second in support of it. It was then pointed out that ultimately all these taxes came down on the farmer, because he could not pass it on to anybody else. It was quite clear that the attitude was that the income tax, as well as every other tax, pressed heavily on the farmer. If the urging of that last year had any weight—I do not say it has—it should have a certain amount of weight this year, too. Even now, the Government are benefiting the farmers. I would be very slow to apply some of the criticisms that Deputy Gorey urged against trade and the manufacturers in the town, to our principal industry. He went back to the good old cave-man rule of the survival of the fittest. The theory of what is fittest in an industry was its ability to pay. On that ground he condemned Irish manufacturers in the towns. I have a vague idea in regard to having heard here in the Dáil that a certain other industry, the great industry in our country, also wanted help. Is that a proof of the inefficiency of the people in it?

Comment on this

If the Deputy would cast about and see what other countries are doing for agriculture, perhaps he might be more acquainted with the world position.

Comment on this

And if the Deputy cast about and saw what other countries are doing for their industries, perhaps he, too, would become acquainted with world matters. I have no objection to agriculture; I think everything should be done for agriculture. But the idea that nothing should be done for any other industry is an extraordinary position for the representatives on the opposite Benches to take up. That is why, especially in the last month or two, the representatives of the Farmers' Party would insist in making a distinction between the people they represent and the nation. In a couple of debates recently, when it was urged that the nation was getting the benefit in certain matters, the question came from the Farmers' Benches: "What are we getting out of it?" Why is the distinction made?

Comment on this

Where has it been made?

Comment on this

In recent debates.

Comment on this

I challenge the Deputy on the matter.

Comment on this

I remember recently, when a certain policy was put forward for the benefit of the nation as a whole, a member of the Farmers' Party interrupted: "What has the agricultural community got out of it?"

Comment on this

Take the Shannon scheme as an instance.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

resumed the Chair.

Comment on this

The Shannon scheme was one instance, but there were several instances recently. Within the last couple of months I have noticed that it was more prevalent than before. I would suggest that the Farmers' Party must realise that with the material at the disposal of the Government they have tried as well as they could to help, not merely manufacturers, but to help the principal industry in the country, namely, agriculture. They have done so by their policy all through, and have done so even in this Budget. Last year, when there was a question of a tax on boots, people in this Dáil were given the impression that there was only one particular class in the community who wore boots. I suggest that in the same way now people are given the impression that the only people who sleep in beds were that particular portion of the community; but when Deputy Johnson was urging the question of the amount of the remission given in the way of the tea and sugar duty, I think I heard the gentle voice of Deputy Wilson saying: "Oh, that is not all for the farmers," the suggestion being that the remission of tax did not benefit the farmers, but that it fell in the form of a remission spread over the nation. That is precisely the attitude that the Farmers' Union representatives on the opposite benches take up. All the burdens of the Budget fall upon them, but the benefits go to everyone else. I think that is not an unfair summing-up of the general trend of the speeches. I cannot understand what their attitude is, whether they want protection or not. Deputy Wilson is wholly in favour of it, but I understood the other Deputies were convinced free traders. Deputy Gorey interrupted Deputy Johnson on several occasions. Until Deputy Wilson got up, I was under the impression that the Farmers' Union had not a policy as to what they want taxed. As to whether they want protection or not, I do not know, but if there was any meaning in Deputy Gorey's interruption of Deputy Johnson, that was the meaning I got.

Comment on this

The meaning was, that we say that you are not in a position to protect our Irish agriculture. Even though you put a tax on foreign bacon you are not able to protect our bacon. Even if you put a tax on foreign butter you are not able to protect our butter. You are only able to protect a small proportion as compared with other exports, and you are not able to increase the price of Irish bacon, because at the present time it is selling at a higher figure than the imported article. Therefore you are not able to protect any article of that kind by putting a tax on it.

Comment on this

Whether Deputy Gorey speaks for the Farmers' Party, or Deputy Wilson, I do not know. Deputy Wilson said that he wants tariffs on barley, flour, oats and everything, but Deputy Gorey thinks that our circumstances are such that the imposition of tariffs will not help or protect our industries. Apparently because the Farmers' Party have not a policy, therefore the Government is to go on and have no policy, as far as the general industries of the country are concerned.

Comment on this

I gladly join in the general chorus of approval of that portion of the Minister's Budget which confers such a measure of relief upon the general body of the taxpayers, particularly on the poorer section. Listening to the discussion from the Farmers' benches, I have been unable to discover, although I have been trying to do it by listening carefully to the distinguished representatives, what the policy of that Party was in regard to Protection. I assumed that in a country like Ireland, having secured its freedom by the action of its own people, and realising that Ireland is very largely, if not altogether, an undeveloped country, that we would be naturally called upon as a result of that measure of freedom to think out for ourselves the policy that would develop our country and make it as self-supporting as possible. I think that Deputy Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll dealt with the Farmers' position in a practical way, so far as I could follow her. I would like to know from the Farmers' leaders whether they are in favour of an increase in the number of bullocks, cattle, sheep and pigs which are exported from this country or whether they are prepared to tolerate the continuance of export of our young men and women from this country.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy mean?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know himself what it means?

Comment on this

I know what Deputy Gorey said. I am just going to quote Deputy Gorey. I took a note of what he said. He stated quite emphatically that he opposed the retention of the existing duty on boots on principle, and also objected to the making of any new duties as a result of the Minister's Budget. Deputy Wilson, who in today's Irish Times and for the first time to my knowledge, has been designated Chairman of the Farmers' Party in the Dáil, said he was prepared to swallow an unconditional protectionist policy. It is very difficult to find out where we are, when I find Deputy Gorey, whom I have always understood up to now to be the leader of the Party, saying one thing, and Deputy Wilson, who is reported as being the new leader, saying another.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Does the Deputy depend on newspaper reports for his information?

Comment on this

I am not to be accountable for the statement appearing in the Times. I have nothing to do with that. He should not put the sins of others on my head.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Why sins?

Comment on this

Everybody, I am sure, realised that, as a result of the reaction following the European War, the market for emigration from any country, but particularly from this country, to America, and to other places where young Irishmen and women have hitherto gone, has been very much restricted. For that reason, and owing to the fact that we have freedom which we ought to make use of, we are bound as a consequence of these things to discover for ourselves the best possible method of a living in our own country for our own people. If we are to do that we must provide, as Deputy Mrs. Collins O'Driscoll said, for the new industries that we hope to start and develop, for the sons of the small farmers particularly. I speak here not as a representative of the farmers, naturally, but as a farmer's son, who worked myself on the land before I was forced to leave to make a living elsewhere.

Comment on this

Before you escaped from it.

Comment on this

No, sir. I worked, I am glad to say, from the time I was ten years of age until I had to leave home to get a living, because I was the eldest son of a family of ten who could not be all accommodated on a farm of 50 or 60 acres. I speak from that experience and I thoroughly agree with the point of view put forward by Deputy Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll. I think if you have the nation, and the Government particularly, prepared to put forward a policy calculated to find greater room for our growing population, which must be provided for at home, that room must be found for the industries to be developed in the towns, as well as by splitting up all the land through the Land Act and so creating more economic holders in the country. I have always tried to subscribe to the view that a good living could be found at home for the thousands of young men and women who emigrate annually. If they would only settle down and work half as hard here in Ireland as they have to work in foreign lands, I say Ireland would be a much better country to-day.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that Deputy Gorey says "hear, hear," because if he agrees with that particular statement, it is up to him as the distinguished leader of the Farmers' Party to find room for people at home.

Comment on this

He could not get them to work.

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy Davin could emigrate the lot we have got, and bring back the lot who have emigrated.

Comment on this

I agree that an exchange of population would be useful because the outlook in this country is too parochial, and a little bit of travelling and the experience which is got by going abroad are valuable, and when people come back, they come back better Irishmen than when they left. I subscribe to the protectionist policy only on the ground that, wherever protection is given to a particular industry, it should be on a carefully considered basis, and that protection should only be given to a particular industry when there is an assurance of a definite nature that the cost of living will not be increased if the measures which are going to be taken by the Government give the benefit that is expected. Everybody who spoke in opposition to the protectionist policy of the Government has assumed, and wrongly assumed, that the only result would be an increase in the price of particular articles. I was glad to hear from the Minister that in regard to boots there was no increase in price as a result of the tariff of 15 per cent. I have met many people who stated that there has been a considerable increase in the price of boots manufactured at home, but I am glad to learn from the Minister that there has not been any such increase.

Comment on this

I referred only to Irish boots.

Comment on this

That only applies to boots manufactured at home. Imported boots have gone up in price, and they are fourteen-fifteenths of the trade.

Comment on this

The tax was not on a week when the price of boots went up.

Comment on this

I hope that Deputy Baxter will give evidence of that.

Comment on this

I have evidence. I went into the shops myself.

Comment on this

I take it that the Minister and his advisers can give more reliable information than Deputies can. I am glad also to hear the Minister say that the number of people employed in the manufacture of boots in Cork and elsewhere has increased by about 80 per cent. That, to a certain extent, justifies the duty imposed last year. I had considerable doubt at the time that it would be of any benefit, because I do not care definitely to commit myself to the imposition of a duty on any particular article where there is not a possibility of manufacturing in the country, as a result of the duty, boots, or other articles that get the benefit of the tariff, that will supply the internal needs of the poulation. I believe that a tariff, as such, should, in the ordinary course of events, be an inducement to many Irish capitalists, who invested large sums out of their savings outside this country, to bring their money home and invest it in industry in this country, and thereby help to increase its prosperity. There are, I know, many people who support what is known as a high-wall tariff policy. So far as I am concerned, I am in agreement with the attitude of the Government in taking steps, after careful consideration has been given to the demands put up to them, to impose a tariff on this, that, and the other article. It is rather strange to find that during the last eight or ten years we have people in this country who supported the protectionist policy when Ireland sent its representatives to the British House of Commons and who, to-day, as a result of the setting up of the Free State Government, are opposing a protection policy for Ireland. If a protection policy was good for Ireland when Ireland was part of the United Kingdom, surely it is more beneficial for Ireland now, when we have freedom and have power to make use of it. I am not altogether in agreement with the Minister in the attitude he has adopted in closing the door definitely on any further tariff being given to industry, and I do not like his attitude in that particular matter, because circumstances may so change as a result of a change of policy on the part of the British Government that would force us to adopt a different attitude and, perhaps, force the Minister to take a different view of the situation. I have never supported a protectionist policy or a tariff on any particular article on the ground that any firm in my constituency would be likely to benefit thereby. I support it on general grounds, as it is the best means I can see at the moment in helping to produce the articles we need, and thus keep as much money as possible in circulation internally, and also provide much more employment. Deputy Wilson, the new leader of the Farmers' Party, and I congratulate him upon his promotion——

Comment on this

Deputy Davin is making a mistake. The "Irish Times," I believe, is now the leader of the Farmers' Party. Deputy Davin is quoting from the "Irish Times," and if you settle up between Deputy Davin and the "Irish Times" we will be satisfied.

Comment on this

I am quoting from the "Irish Times" and from an interview given by Deputy Wilson to the "Irish Times" which I assume to be correct. Usually I do not take the "Irish Times" as being a medium that is good for everybody.

Comment on this

On a point of personal explanation, the interview in question was given at the request of Deputy Gorey.

Comment on this

Deputy Wilson was good enough to say, and he said he was speaking on behalf of his party, that the Farmers' Party had now changed their policy and were prepared to support a tariff on imported barley and malt. I am glad that he has been converted to that point of view, but I am sorry that Deputy Gorey, realising that that is the policy of the Farmers' Party, did not make it known to the Minister for Agriculture. Deputy Gorey admitted that he did not approach the Minister for Agriculture and represent to him, as the Minister responsible for agricultural policy, the views of the Farmers' Union in regard to tariffs and what tariffs would be likely to suit them. I have received a number of resolutions from Farmers' Union branches, from one county council, and from a number of district councils in my own area, definitely and unanimously demanding a tariff on imported barley and malt. I know that these resolutions have found their way to 37 Fitzwilliam Street, and I know that they have been given careful consideration. I assume that the farmers have, at least, discussed that question and have, perhaps, decided in accordance with the view of Deputy Wilson, but they should have made their decision known to the Minister for Agriculture as their considered policy now. Deputy Conlan, speaking at a meeting in his own area, said: "To my mind, this question will have to be forced on the Farmers' Union." Deputy Conlan will, perhaps, give us the benefit of his views at a later stage.

Comment on this

My views are not changed.

Comment on this

We see how far his persuasive powers prevailed at that meeting of the Farmers' Union, where the matter was discussed. It is hard to understand the policy of the Farmers' Union, when, at their Congress, they definitely protested against a tariff of any kind as it would not be beneficial to the farmers, and they come along to-day and express different points of view and leave us in doubt as to what their views are.

Comment on this

I think that Deputy Davin is misquoting the policy outlined at the Farmers' Congress.

Comment on this

Deliberately.

Comment on this

I would not say deliberately. It is a natural tendency with him.

Comment on this

I quoted with due deliberation, but not for deliberate misrepresentation purposes. Deputy Wilson complained that the tariffs imposed are too small. Does he believe that a tariff of 33 1/3rd per cent. on furniture and bedsteads is too small? I am glad he has corrected his view with regard to that one particular matter at any rate, and I presume he takes the same view with regard to other articles that have the same duty as a result of this Budget, and as a result of the Budget of last year. Deputy Gorey made the alarming statement that our taxable capacity could be very easily reduced by five million pounds or ten million pounds. I think it would be very useful information, particularly to the Minister for Finance, if Deputy Gorey as the prospective President, or Minister for Finance, could give some indication as to how that reduction could be brought about. He referred to the over-staffing of Government offices, but surely it would not be possible to effect such a reduction in the different Government departments, which he has alleged are over-staffed, as to bring about a reduction of five million pounds or ten million pounds. However, I will be glad to hear from any of his distinguished colleagues who will follow in the debate how that figure could be arrived at, without, of course, imposing any undue hardship on the people he himself represents. The Minister for Finance indicated that exemption from entertainment tax would be given to the Gaelic Athletic Association in future, although he admitted that the duty had never been collected. I would be glad to know if that exemption would also apply to the National Cycling and Athletic Association.

Comment on this

Why not Rugby?

Comment on this

No. I would not support Rugby. There is one other question which I regret the Minister has not seen his way to deal definitely with, and that is the Government policy in regard to taxation on motor vehicles. The Minister said: "I shall deal briefly with two matters of importance outstanding. The first is the road tax on motor vehicles. Various suggestions have been put forward for a new basis. We have not yet been able to arrive at any conclusions. If it is decided to propose any change from the horse-power basis, a Finance Bill No. 2 will be introduced. In view of the fact that road-tax year ends on the 31st December, nothing will be lost by two or three months' delay."

I am not sure if the Minister for Finance is acquainted with the bad condition of most of the main roads to-day, due to a large extent, and perhaps rightly due, to the fact that the ratepayers are not prepared to pay for the breaking up of the roads by the heavy motor lorries. Last year in one county in my constituency a provision of £28,000 was made for the repair and maintenance of roads. The roads in that area are in a disgraceful condition. I went over them with the chief roads' engineer a fortnight ago, and he, no doubt, has expressed the view to the Government which he expressed to me as a result of that inspection.

Comment on this

Perhaps that has something to do with the main roads to Cork.

Comment on this

For Deputy Gorey's information I was not concerned with that aspect of the case at all, but I understand that the Deputy's constituents in the last couple of days have expressed their views very forcibly on that question. This year, in the same county that provided £28,000 last year, the County Council have agreed to provide only £25,000. I am sure, if the Minister will only consult the Minister for Local Government and his advisers in this matter, he will be rightly informed that it is impossible to repair and maintain the roads in that county on a figure of £25,000. I know, and Deputy Gorey knows, judging from statements he made in Cavan during the recent elections, that this matter has been given long and careful consideration, and perhaps he knows more about the consideration the subject has got than I do.

I think it would be very hard to find anyone who has given consideration to this question of road maintenance who would oppose the tax on petrol as being the only way out of the difficulty. Ratepayers, of whom, of course, the farmers are a very important section, should not be called on to pay for the tearing up of the roads by the heavy motor lorries. If the main roads are to be made, repaired, and maintained, out of the taxpayers' money, then every form of transport is entitled to the same consideration. The Railway Act passed some months ago guaranteed a certain revenue to the shareholders of the new Company, and it is being seriously hit as a result of this preferential treatment as regards roads. I refer to it only because I know that the result of that preferential treatment of roads as against railways has been that a large number of railwaymen have been thrown out of employment. The question does not brook further delay, and having been carefully considered for the past six or twelve months by experts advising the Government they should by this time be in a position to announce a definite policy. I hope I am correct in reading into the language used by the Minister that the Government are not satisfied with the present system of taxation on motor vehicles, and that the people who use and abuse the roads so largely should pay for using and abusing them. Deputy Wilson, I think, referred to a resolution which was passed by the Distributive Workers' Union protesting against this protectionist policy. The Distributive Workers' Union are quite as much within their rights in passing a resolution on this or on any other question as is any branch of the Farmers' Union. I am only referring to the matter for this reason: the Distributive Workers' Union have been passing resolutions for the past fifteen or twenty years advising the members of their Association, who sell goods in the drapery establishments, to do all they possibly can to sell and advance the sale of Irish manufactured articles. There is no member of that Trade Union who can come forward to-day and say that they have been effective in their advocacy of that particular method of advancing the sale of Irish manufactured goods. Therefore, I say that having failed in that direction, protection has now to be fallen back upon as a means of increasing the sale of Irish manufactured articles, and that is the remedy which has been adopted by the Minister for Finance.

There are one or two small matters which I would like to mention, but which I think could be more properly referred to and dealt with when the Finance Bill comes along. I can only say that the matter of closing the door to future tariffs on any particular industry might, owing to exceptional circumstances, require reconsideration. I think with that exception, I can heartily support the Minister both in the relief that he has given by the reduction of taxation and in his general attitude upon the protectionist policy of the Government.

Comment on this

I wish also to join in the general expression of congratulation to the Minister for Finance on the satisfactory endeavour he has made to effect an equitable distribution of the concessions offered to the taxpayers in the Budget proposals which he submitted yesterday. He said that he had had a multitude of appeals to afford protection to all kinds of industries and that these suggestions had been considered by his Department during the year. He further stated that the Government did not believe it would be for the benefit of this country to establish a general tariff, or anything like it. That is a policy that I, at any rate, agree with. I am satisfied that it is the wisest and best course to be taken under existing circumstances, that is, the gradual introduction of a protection system.

I would like to go a little further by saying that I am sorry he did not respond to a few more of the appeals that were made to him during the year, particularly with regard to tanning, brush-making, and printing. I will confine myself, at the moment, to one of these industries which gives considerable employment in the country. That is the printing industry. I might include the other industries. They are all suffering from the great depression of trade. There is considerable unemployment and what I want, principally, to point out is that most of this unemployment is brought about through the activities of foreign manufacturers' agents in this country. My attention has been drawn to a very large order for printing that has been given away by a South of Ireland firm to a London printer. Those who might be inclined to sample the "Paddy Flaherty" brand might ask that firm where their work is produced. A very large order from that firm was given away, and a considerable amount of money has left the country as a consequence. This is only one of many. There are numerous others. It is not necessary to refer further to them at the moment.

I might suggest to the Minister, when considering any further proposals, that he would consider the question of licensing the representatives or agents of foreign manufacturers in this country. This system, I understand, is in operation in South Africa. In the Cape Province of South Africa, manufacturers' representatives must be licensed. Representatives of foreign manufacturers and merchants are obliged to pay a £50 licence per annum for first agencies, and £2 10s. for additional agencies. Similar provisions are in operation in the other three Provinces, although the systems and the amounts vary. Such provisions, if applied to Ireland, would yield a pretty handsome sum of money to the State, without being any burden whatsoever on the taxpayer, even indirectly. If this system of carrying orders out of the country could be stopped by such an imposition, it would do a great deal towards giving that fillip that the proposals embodied in the Budget are intended to give. At the same time, it would be an encouragement to the people, who, I hope, will take advantage of the opportunity that is now given by the protection that is afforded. This would give a fillip and a support to Irish industries more than was ever given to them in the past. I believe the time is ripe for another industrial revival. I earnestly hope that the new tariffs will be a stimulus to the protected industries.

Comment on this
Michael Egan Mr. MICHAEL EGAN Independent

I do not rise for a general criticism of the Budget. I rise rather to join in the congratulations that have been showered upon the Minister with reference to the Budget which, I believe, will be a popular one throughout the country, except perhaps in the constituency that I have the honour to represent. In that constituency there is a factory that is giving employment to about sixteen hundred hands and paying, in wages, about £10,000 a week. It was expected in the City of Cork for some weeks past, and statements were made by people in authority, that the tax on the Ford car would have been reduced. But the people of that city are now greatly disappointed. We also find that here, in the Dáil, efforts are being made by subsidy, by forms of protection, to help industry, to give what every Deputy wants to see given—more work. Here is an opportunity of having, at least, five or six hundred more men employed. I am not speaking of the Ford car, mind, from the luxury point of view; I speak of it more from the commercial point of view, because the Ford car is generally used commercially throughout the country. That being so, it would be an incentive to the purchase of a tremendous number of these cars if this tax were removed. The idea of paying £18 a year on a Ford car, which, let me remark, was put on by the British Government for the specific purpose of killing the sale of Ford cars, is ridiculous. It is a most extraordinary thing that the Free State should propose to continue that tax on a car, the manufacture of which is giving so much employment in the State. The Minister for Finance has stated that a Finance Bill No. 2 is to be introduced. Let us hope that if that is so he will introduce it at once, because now, when trade is about to open up, is the correct time to deal with this matter, and I sincerely hope that the Ford tax will be reduced, not merely by half but by considerably more, in order to increase employment. Naturally, the more people who are employed the greater will be the reduction of the dole, and the amount of unemployment in Cork at present warrants the removal of this tax. I sincerely hope that the Minister will immediately introduce the Bill for that purpose.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The intention is, I think, to continue the debate to-morrow, but the Minister desires to intervene now, without concluding the debate.

Comment on this

The intention is to continue to-morrow?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Yes.

Comment on this

I just want to say one thing. Since I spoke, introducing the Budget, various appeals have come in that the date for the reduction and abolition of the taxes on sugar and other articles should be advanced. On the other hand, representations have come that no change should be made. During the day we have given careful consideration to the whole matter and to the representations that have been received, and we have come to the conclusion that the date announced should stand.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Would the Minister accept a proposal to report progress now?

Comment on this

I would like the Deputy to look at to-morrow's Order Paper. There is a considerable amount of business, and if we were to adjourn the whole discussion until to-morrow I would like to know how many speakers are going to address themselves to this subject, and what length of time they would occupy.

Comment on this

We have three or four.

Comment on this

Is the Farmers' Party the only one that can form fours in this respect?

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I suppose there has fallen to my lot the melancholy duty of continuing the debate. Although this subject has been and will be extensively debated, I do not suppose there will be any division on the resolution before the House, which has been more or less forgotten: "That it is expedient to amend the law relating to Customs and Inland Revenue, including Excise, and to make further provision in connection with finance." As I say, I do not believe that it is the objective of any group or of any Deputy to challenge a division on that; there is, at least, that degree of uniformity. But the resolution itself has afforded an opportunity of reviewing the whole system of administration, of revenue and of income, or of the means of raising money, and it is well in that respect then to take some cognisance of some of the main items of expenditure. Any Deputy who turns up the Abstract of Accounts of Public Services for the year 1925-6 will see that under several heads there are very large increases. In the office of the Ministry of Finance, for instance, there is an increase of £10,000, in the Revenue Department there is an increase of £61,000, in the Gárda Síochána there is an increase of no less than £90,719, and under the heading of Army Pensions there is the very alarming increase of £108,000. These are very large increases, and while I admit that there is a substantial reduction under other headings, yet I submit that these increases will require, when the Estimates come up, very careful consideration, particularly Vote 58— Army Pensions. Deputies will notice that pensions granted under Section 4 of the Military Service Pensions Act, 1924, amount to no less than £224,000. When you come to examine the details of that you find that ex-Non-Commissioned Officers and Men are to receive only £82,700, ex-Second-Lieutenants, Lieutenants and Captains £110,070, ex-Commandants and Majors £22,080, ex-Colonels and Major-Generals £7,400——

Comment on this

Might I ask if this is in order on the resolution?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

It is possible that eventually the Deputy will have a point to make that will put him in order.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

To find this money to pay these large pensions this State and the citizens thereof must pay certain taxes. I submit, then, that I am perfectly in order, inasmuch as we are raising money, to question the expenditure of that money. I would put that view-point expressly before Deputy Egan. When this matter comes up for consideration we will have something more to say to it, but I do object to having a tax, even at this stage, to pay these pensions. I have expressed elsewhere, and I am prepared to repeat it here, and to stand over it, that this thing is not so much a case of pensions for men who were demobilised in the ordinary way owing to a reduction in the service, but that it is in a special manner to make provision for mutineers. I have to take that view-point and express it——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Deputy should have expressed that on the Bill. These are statutory pensions. The Deputy really cannot discuss, on these Financial Motions, expenditure made under a Statute, regularly passed and having the force of law. That should be clear to him.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

With all respect, I remember the Statute, and it said that the money must be provided by the Oireachtas—"out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas," were the words.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think that we were going to get it by robbing banks?

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Well, to turn away from this and to discuss the whole incidence of taxation, I am afraid that we are spending on a scale that the country cannot afford. We are an agricultural State; the greater part of our income accrues to us from agriculture. Industry is only subsidiary; it only produces a relatively small portion of the national income and the national wealth. In addition, we are at the end of a great war period when agriculture all over the world is depressed. In particular, we are at the end of a revolutionary era which has had very great and perhaps disastrous reactions upon our whole economic situation. I submit that at this juncture especially, there is need to have a committee set up to deal with the problem, prepared to go into every office and deal with this question, to see to what extent the expenditure in the various offices is justified, and to what extent they should be staffed, so that the service may give some adequate return, having regard to the capacity to pay it. It must be remembered that this is a pastoral State and our public services must be based on our capacity to pay. We cannot afford to maintain services at the same rate or pay the same salaries as are paid in Great Britain. It is out of the question, because agriculture is one of the least remunerative of industries.

I protested last night and I protest again against the basis of assessment for income tax of farmers. Pre-war it was only one-third of the valuation. To-day it is on the basis of the full valuation, so that it is trebled. It may be said that, in a sense, very few farmers pay income tax, but I know that demand notes by the hundred are being sent out to farmers whose valuation is only £60 or £70. The Department also have got out a form which makes it so difficult to furnish farm accounts that the evident intention is to compel farmers to pay under a certain Schedule, in other words, to deprive them of the legal right to have the assessment based on the net profits.

As to the Corporation Tax, I have been informed that firms registered in Great Britain, who are doing business in the Saorstát, by the operations of some agreements, or by putting obstacles in the way of the Department of Finance, are evading the Corporation Tax. That is manifestly unjust to the companies registered in the Saorstát. In the past, as a matter of fact, these foreign registered companies have had a manifest advantage, because income tax here has been higher than in Great Britain, and they are only assessed at half the British rate. The very least the Finance Department can do is to insist on the payment of the Corporation Tax in all cases.

I have several times pointed out the need for a reduction in income tax, not merely to the British level, but below it. We want infiltration of capital into this country. One of the great needs of the situation is to get foreign capital to come in, and the only way to do that is to make a return on the investment pretty certain by having a low rate of taxation.

Comment on this

What about the 150 or 160 millions of Irish capital at present invested abroad?

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

The Minister can deal with that question. It is extraneous to the subject which we are debating. Of course, before the Minister cooks his hare he must catch it. I have no doubt that with that perverse ingenuity which he is said to be capable of exercising, he can deal adequately either now or at some subsequent period with the dividends accruing on the 160 millions invested abroad.

Our great objection is to the proposed tax on wearing apparel. It seems to me that for many years to come we are throwing a very heavy burden on the bulk of the community. For what end? The Minister will deny that he will get much revenue out of it. He will say that whatever revenue accrues is more or less accidental, that it is not the primary intention of the Government to secure revenue, but that it is directly a tariff. How many people will this tariff benefit? Deputy Johnson gave figures to the effect that something like 12,000 are at present out of work in these trades.

Comment on this

No. I said that about 12,000 persons were registered as engaged in the trades normally when they are employed. The expectation is that there will be an increase in the actual number employed in those industries.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Twelve thousand people normally employed in the turning out of ready-to-wear clothing? Even with 12,000 affected, I submit it is scarcely fair to put the very heavy tax of 15 per cent on the whole community. Deputy Wilson gave some figures last night showing that the imports of wearing apparel exceeded over £7,000,000 in value yearly. A fifteen per cent. tax would amount to considerably over £1,000,000 annually. That is a very big amount for the people to pay so that 12,000 persons may benefit. It is possible that factories may be established here but it will be some time before they are set up. After a while we may become more or less self-supporting but, at the present juncture, when people have to cut down every item of expenditure in their homes, it is hardly fair to impose a tax of fifteen per cent. on clothing.

Farmers have a particular objection to this Budget, in respect of tariffs, as they have to buy in protected markets and sell in markets where open competition prevails. I do not think that can be justified. As far as I can see, the present position is particularly ruinous for agriculturists particularly, in view of the fact that agricultural prospect are bad, prices low, and that it is scarcely possible to make ends meet.

Deputy Wilson was twitted some time ago on putting forward a demand for a quid pro quo. Rightly or wrongly we think that it is a dangerous thing to interfere with the fiscal system. Whether we like it or not, the thing is now an accomplished fact. I am prepared to stand over it and make no scruples about doing so. Inasmuch as we cannot continue to buy in a protected market and to pay relatively higher prices for necessaries in justice to ourselves we must demand a share of protection. We do not want protection as a principle or a policy, but if it is given to some sections of the community, farmers have a right to protection and will put forward demands for it. As the Ministry has embarked on a protectionist policy, protection must be given to farmers also, and they are going to insist upon tariffs being placed on articles of food that are dumped here, while at the same time they are produced by the agriculturists of this country. We must demand an adequate tax on these foreign importations. I am prepared to go to that extent, and while I do not look upon such proposals as an ideal solution of our economic troubles, at least they will be some help and agriculture will not be as depressed as it is. Undoubtedly, we have been defeated on the principle of free trade. We have then to take up a second position and to determine what will be best for ourselves. There are four or five articles that protective duties should be placed upon, such as bacon, butter, eggs, barley, oats, and flour—perhaps a very small duty on the latter. All these things are being imported in very large quantities and are pulling down the prices for the agricultural producer. That is a matter of common knowledge. There is no need to conceal the fact.

We are then faced with this position: will the cost of production of other articles which we require go up? I am afraid it will. I am afraid wages will advance. But what are we to do? We are, speaking figuratively, between the devil and the deep sea. We cannot continue to produce at the present unremunerative prices. We are forced by the inevitable necessities of the case, inasmuch as tariffs have been imposed for the benefit of one section, to demand that they be applied all round and applied fairly generously. We have to face a risk. But, rather than continue the present situation, I for one, am prepared to face it. Give me free trade all round and I am satisfied, but once you embark on tariffs for certain selected articles, creating sheltered trades as it were, particularly in regard to wearing apparel, including boots and shoes, the position is that we must get an adequate quid pro quo.

Comment on this