PRIVATE BUSINESS. - TREATY (CONFIRMATION OF AMENDING AGREEMENT) BILL, 1925—SECOND STAGE (Resumed).
Contributions 213–435 of 435. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 51 of 1925 ›
All those things are to be accepted as judgments. That is the view taken of these things. Deputy Johnson stated, with regard to Article V., that if we cannot put up a counterclaim to balance the British claim of some £170,000,000, or if we believe that our claim will not work out in the event of the matter coming before an arbitrator, then he would have to make comments upon our veracity in the past. Our veracity in regard to what? Statements have been hurled by people in this country with regard to the amount of money likely to be paid under Article V., and the Minister for Finance denied them. If I were of the opinion that my words would have carried any weight in the matter, I should have denied those statements too. Is it a likely or a reasonable thing to expect that, simply for the sake of newspaper controversy, whoever was approaching this Article finally should go in tied hand and foot to a statement that we certainly owed at least three, four, or X millions to Britain?
There is no question of truthfulness or untruthfulness about these things. It would be as easy to question the truthfulness or the untruthfulness of barristers pleading in any case in which they are engaged. A man puts up his case and makes a contention. If we held that the Boundary Commission, dealing with the matter according to the terms of reference and the evidence presented to them, were likely to produce a certain result, and if that result does not come about, it does not weaken our contention and it is in no way any reflection upon the veracity of our statements.
There is another fallacy about this whole situation. People imagine that Deputy Dr. MacNeill could himself have decided the Boundary result, or that the Minister for Finance could have decided Article V. We are told what the Minister said; we are told about his contentions, and then it is assumed that because something else is signed now the Minister for Finance must have been untruthful or else he had not a proper case when he said something else. Deputy Johnson has stated that he will not concede that the Executive Council's inability to produce a counterclaim to the claim for £170,000,000 made by the British should excuse any payment under this Agreement that we are discussing. Who said that the Executive Council were not able to produce a counterclaim? I will receive offers of counterclaims now and those claims can be built up as high as you like. A sum of £3,000,000,000 has been mentioned. I will take that. But remember that what matters in the end is the result and not the counter-claim that any Executive Council, or any Minister, thinks is sufficient; the counter-claim will have to go before the arbitrator who finally will settle the matter. It does not entirely depend on what any Minister for Finance says, or what any Executive Council can put up by way of a counter-claim.
Deputy Johnson touched on some minor matters with regard to the Council of Ireland. He did not put this as a definite statement, but he suggested that what has been done in this Agreement might dispose of the contention which we have long been holding to with regard to the waters around the coast. He suggested that if this Agreement be passed that contention that the waters around the coast are ours goes by the board. I cannot see it in the Agreement. The Agreement states that the area of Northern Ireland shall for the future be the area set out in a particular section and sub-section of the Government of Ireland Act, 1920. This section has reference to six Parliamentary Counties only. That contention of ours may be right or wrong, but it is in no way weakened by the disappearance of the Council of Ireland.
Then there is the other contention that what we have done with regard to the Council of Ireland disposes of our claim that their powers cannot be added to, that the powers of the Northern Government cannot be added to without the consent of the Saorstát. In a sense there is a very definite recognition of that claim. Here are certain powers given, and given with our consent and only after our consent had been obtained. There may be weakness or there may be strength in our contention with regard to future powers; there may be restricted lines or specious lines of policy to be followed with regard to powers that are to be given. The contention that that was the case is not weakened by the handing over of certain powers to the Council of Ireland functioning through the Northern Government.
Comment on this
Will the Minister deal with one point? Is there any change consequent upon this Agreement in the status of the Northern Government and the Northern Parliament?
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister when he is on the point whether the powers that have been handed over to the Northern Government now are powers that were partially in possession of the Government of the Saorstát? What would be the difference in the handing over of powers in the possession of the Government of Britain and Northern Ireland?
Comment on this
That, I think, is an answer to Deputy Johnson; would the powers that are now reserved to Westminster, if handed over to Northern Ireland, imply a change of status. There is question of a restricted right to deal with three matters, and the suggestion that the giving of these three matters over would imply a change of status I deny.
Comment on this
There are more than three powers in question. There are the reserved powers. Under the Act of 1920 there were very definitely restricted and certain reserved powers. Will the Minister say whether the acceptance of this Agreement is a renunciation of any authority from the Saorstát in respect to the North, or alters in any degree the status of Northern Ireland?
Comment on this
I cannot say that I have completely caught that question, but may I put this as an answer?—All reserved powers are still reserved.
Comment on this
Would the Minister explain whether the Northern Parliament would have powers to make a Treaty? There were powers reserved under the Council of Ireland. Have they the right to make a Treaty or to sign a document?
Comment on this
The right to sign a document and the power to make a Treaty are quite different things. This document has not to be confirmed by the legislature of Northern Ireland. That is the main thing and that is what shows the powers. Deputy Baxter last night contended that we were throwing back certain people into the Six Counties, casting off certain people whom we rescued, and that we were turning the eyes of these people to Belfast and Westminster. He said that, having said in a sentence previously that no doubt there would emerge in ten or fifteen years' time a completely new political unit, the unit of Northern Ireland as a Dominion. The contradiction I see is this. The Deputy objects to turning people's eyes to Westminster— that is, the eyes of Belfast—and at the same time he objects to the political unit, Northern Ireland, becoming a Dominion. You cannot have it both ways. I, for one, would prefer to see Northern Ireland a Dominion with her eyes turned homewards, and away from Westminster.
Comment on this
Decidedly. Is that a thing to be regarded with surprise, particularly by a Deputy who objects to people's eyes being turned towards Westminster?
Comment on this
I suggest that that is just the time when two fiscal policies are going to be resolved and when we might easily have one fiscal policy for the whole country.
Comment on this
It is a hope. Nobody can express anything else but a hope with regard to that particular area. Deputy Johnson finished by referring to a message which he had received from Newry in which certain people there complained that they had been sold. I object to the metaphor, but since it has been used, may I put it this way: We never had the people of Newry to sell. Newry was never within our jurisdiction. Newry and the people there had certain rights reserved to them under Article XII., and these rights under Article XII. are now exhausted, with the exception perhaps of the only concrete suggestion put forward by any member of this House as an alternative, and that is the suggestion made by Deputy Murphy last night, followed by that of Deputy Esmonde to-night, that there may be a right of appeal to the League of Nations. So far as the bearings of Article XII. in regard to the Six Counties are concerned its powers were exhausted, with the exception of a possible right to appeal to the League of Nations, so that when people in Newry, or Deputies here, talk about casting off and selling people let them be very accurate as to the people to whom they refer. Let them be quite clear as to where the sale could possibly take place. We had no jurisdiction over the people of the Six Counties. We had hoped to get certain things from a certain article, but these hopes were disappointed, and the alternative was that means, if not of rescuing, at least of easing their situation had to be found, and we believe that we have found it here.
Deputy Professor Magennis spoke for a couple of hours the other night and displayed a most extraordinary facility in vituperation. As one member of the Executive Council I found myself accused of "incapacity,""blundering,""sinning grievously against the light,""frightened and panic-stricken,""adopting the methods of the cuttlefish,""supine, careless and negligent,""scuttling the ship,""having wool pulled over my (apparently collective) eyes,""inspired with colossal egotism,""making use of cunning stratagems,""having an egotism equal to my previous arrogance and audacity,""having no special experience of affairs and no special capacity in default of that experience," and—this coming from a democrat—"not being a person having any tradition of governing subject peoples," and, finally, in a last outburst of frenetical fury, I was "suffering from chronic ineptitude."
For a long time I wondered where this vocabulary could have been acquired. I believe I know now. I believe it is the fruits of Deputy Professor Magennis's communion with himself about himself—summarising all the comments which he himself would make and which he has heard a great many people make about his own career—a career void of any successful endeavour, not marked by any achievement, and only variegated by a very extreme blunder outside his ordinary blunders. I think the Dáil the other evening had an opportunity of seeing why this life of his has been spent so futilely, as it has been. They saw displayed considerable talent mixed up with a certain taint, a malady, a disorder, of egotism, which has certainly rendered all that the Professor set out to do ineffectual. I have known him for a long time. I have known him all the time as a vain man, and have known him most of the time as a futile man, but just how monumental his vanity was and how far-reaching his futility I did not know until the other evening.
Boil down his two hours' oration and it comes to this: the Executive Council made a grievous blunder, "sinned against the light"—the light shed by the Deputy himself. He wanted a certain resolution to be added to the Treaty (Confirmation of Supplemental Agreement) Bill, but that resolution of his was not accepted. That, he described as the first blunder of the Executive Council in this matter. Up to that point, he said, everything had gone well. There was no disputing that the Executive Council's handling of the matter up to that point was sound. They committed that blunder, and, strange as it may appear, Deputy Magennis voted for the Treaty (Confirmation of Supplemental Agreement) Bill. He voted for the first blunder committed by the Executive Council in this matter. That, with regard to one matter. A second point emerges from his speech. Deputy Professor Magennis was challenged to give any alternative to what is before the Dáil. He purported to give an alternative. I think he meant to give an alternative. He described himself as a professor of philosophy, used to exact thinking and precise language, and I think we might take his language as indicating what he intended, but the contradiciton of his last night showed that that was not the case. I can only reconcile that with his other statement to the effect that he is only a professor in his working hours, and that, consequently, exact thinking and precise language disappear when his working hours are over. The Deputy's only alternative was a Coalition Government, and he accurately envisaged the only circumstances in which he could see himself becoming a member of a Government —when a blindfolded man at the bottom of the stairs would grip the first persons who came within his grasp. The Professor would, I think, not be the person to elude that grip. What is this alternative Government to do? We have been recently challenged that we had no policy in this matter. That policy has been tabled; the position is clearly before us. I hope to recite later on, what Deputy Baxter calls the collective wisdom of the Dáil in regard to this alternative. Deputy Professor Magennis gave his alternative as another Government and counter-proposals. He said "They would have handled the Boundary situation and carried on until a General Election was possible." That is the alternative—a Coalition Government. That is offered to you seriously by a precisian in thought and language as the alternative to what we have before us.
Deputy Baxter dealt at some length with the situation. I often fail to understand the Deputy. He has a certain impassivity of demeanour, and it is very hard to discover what lies behind it, but last night it was obvious what was below the surface. His mind was tortured and his heart had plumbed pretty well the deepest depth of human suffering because the unfortunate people of the North whom we were casting off were to be committed to excesses beside which the worst records of the Black and Tans was a bright page.
Comment on this
We had cast these people off and it was our fault that they were to be hewers of wood and drawers of water.
Comment on this
I did not raise my voice against it. That is the situation put up by Deputy Baxter—that is the kernel of his speech. You must imagine we had them in our power first before we could cast them off, and throw them back to these excesses and allow them to be bludgeoned and beaten. The Deputy also was conscious he had to put forward an alternative. The unfortunate state of the people in the North caused him anguish and worry. How are we to get them out of that state? Surely he says statesmanship is not so bankrupt that there is not some way of doing it. Later on he says: "Is it for one single Deputy to put forward counter proposals?"
Comment on this
I asked did you get any guarantees, and if you did get them I asked why you did not get them in writing and embodied in the Bill.
Comment on this
A very pertinent question that could be put to Deputy Baxter as one Deputy throwing out proposals, is: How would you get the guarantees?
Comment on this
Therefore if you are dealing with the people who have things in their power, you can get everything.
Comment on this
It is admitted that they have not been got, and nothing has been signed with regard to them. As to a reduction of the armed forces in the Six Counties, or a review of sentences on prisoners, if we were asked had we anything in writing about that we could not say that we had. But we did speak about a spirit of concord, and when I used these words last night the Deputy objected to them.
Comment on this
You objected to them coming from the mouth of the Minister in Belfast.
Comment on this
You said: "Mark the words ‘peace and concord.'" There is something horrible, I take it, about these two words. There is a spirit of concord that we founded on, and that spirit of concord has been seen in things that have happened in the last couple of days, things that were not mentioned in the Agreement.
Comment on this
That is the only way. I think if you were to wait another month you would not see any signatures with regard to an agreement on these things, but that they are coming I have no doubt.
Comment on this
The Deputy asked us to go before our Northern people and say to them: "Will you accept this?" That is not what we would have to say to them but, "Do you accept this, and if you do not what do you think should be done for you?" and the Deputy himself in speaking on behalf of these people, and certainly having their cause very much at heart was asked the alternative to this, and all he could say was that it was not for a Deputy to put forward counter proposals, but that statesmanship was not so bankrupt that it could not be done.
Comment on this
I would not have to make the apology that you and your co-Ministers have to make for the promise you made to these people and failed to carry out.
Comment on this
I have already dealt with that. I made no statement or promise with regard to what would happen when the Boundary Commission functioned. If I had been impelled to make any statement on the Boundary Commission I should certainly have spoken on the same lines as others, that in setting up a Boundary Commission we agreed to do so owing to deputations from the North urging that it should be set up, and that we helped to set it up in the belief it was going to produce a verdict in accordance with the facts.
But if any person in the course of the proceedings said anything else, that they were not going to produce a verdict according to the facts, he would have been subject to criticism in this House for an attitude prejudicial to the findings. It must be remembered that Ministers and Deputies often speak here with a certain thing in prospect. They cannot make statements which would prejudice their case. They must always speak putting the best side of their case forward, and if any Deputy did otherwise he would not deserve to be returned to any deliberative assembly. Deputy Hogan dealt with the question of the moral taint resulting from the payment of this compensation money. That point has been very well explained, but it might bear repetition. The British Government cleared out of the 26 Counties. They took their forces with them, and passed the Treaty. An agreement was made with regard to how certain payments for damages were to be made, and they agreed to shoulder a certain liability in consideration of Article V. being in the Treaty. The other day we came to the revision of the Treaty in so far as it affected these two things. It had to be reviewed, and was under review, and being under review, this new consideration emerged, that Article V. was going to be abolished and the British said, and said quite naturally and legitimately, "If that be so, and if we are to continue to shoulder the responsibility we did shoulder in view of Article V. being of some benefit to us, the position will be that we will have left your country and paid you an indemnity for leaving it." That does not seem reasonable under the circumstances, and I doubt if it would seem reasonable to any Deputy here that that should be the case. Hence we agreed to pay for certain damages.
Comment on this
Can I go back to the Franco-Prussian war to answer the Deputy?
Comment on this
Now we have an agreement here the terms of which have been completely discussed. I do not want to deal with it any more than I have done. A vote is to be taken to-night for or against this, and that vote cannot be cast blindly or irrespective of what is coming after this. A certain number of people have spoken in opposition to this Agreement, and Deputy Baxter was annoyed because we did not take the collective wisdom of the House. We have got a certain amount of the collective wisdom of the House since we came home; a certain number of people have spoken. I have been at some pains to find out their alternatives. Deputy Magennis suggested a Coalition Government. Deputy O'Connell made no contribution by way of alternative. Neither did Deputy Morrissey.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish said it was very hard to suggest an alternative.
Comment on this
Not being in possession of the facts that the Executive Council had before they arrived at the Agreement in London, and we are not in possession of them yet——
Comment on this
It is very hard for the Deputy to put up an alternative under these circumstances, but he is going to vote in a certain way. Deputy Davin wanted us to go back to the Craig-Collins Agreement, and he read out one term that seemed to be very material to him, that both Governments were to meet to devise means of coming together.
Comment on this
No; but for maintaining the unity of Ireland. That is not exactly correct—for devising means for dealing with matters covering the whole of Ireland.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin is coming to his place—I shall ask him later. Deputy Lyons made no contribution. Deputy Hogan, of Clare, made no contribution as to an alternative. Deputy Davin, I say again, referred to the Craig-Collins Agreement, and insisted upon a particular part of it which stated that the two Governments should meet to devise means for something. What was it?
Comment on this
Well, I will take the trouble to read it for you—"to endeavour to devise a more suitable system than the Council of Ireland for dealing with problems affecting all Ireland."
Comment on this
"To endeavour to devise a more suitable system." That is the important part of it.
Comment on this
To endeavour to devise a more suitable means of dealing with all Ireland. And that is a concrete, serious suggestion, put up as better than what is here.
Comment on this
What is here is: "The two Governments are to meet from time to time to consider matters of common interest." Well, I fail to see the great significance of the other formula. If that is all that Deputy Davin is voting on, that that is his main alternative to this, this and Article V. wiped out, with the present Boundary line stabilised, instead of the Feetham line, if we are to throw all that overboard simply because there is in the Craig-Collins pact something about Governments endeavouring to devise——
Comment on this
Deputy McCullough thought that statesmanship was not so bankrupt that an alternative solution could not be found. He believed that there were other alternatives which would have provided a solution, and he approached a little bit nearer the concrete when he said that "it would have been possible for the British Government to induce Sir James Craig to call the minority into a conference so as to ensure the minority's rights." Deputy O'Maille and certain other Deputies vaguely sought to remove the Article in the Treaty which keeps certain Deputies out of this House. That, as an alternative, has no appeal to me. A certain situation was created by the failure of the Boundary Commission, by the failure of Article XII. to bring the assistance that we thought it would have brought to certain people in the North. That threw into glaring relief the uncertainty under another Article, and that uncertainty had to be met and disposed of. Now, if anything was to be brought home when a certain amount of Treaty revision was on, I hold it should be something the benefit of which would accrue to the whole community and not to that limited section which refused to acknowledge the wishes of the people. This financial consideration does come home to everybody in the country, and the taking out of the oath would have come home to a very limited section, and to a section that deserves no consideration at our hands. Deputy Johnson practically avoided saying anything. He said: "If we adopted the President's suggestion we might say ‘the Treaty, the whole Treaty, and nothing but the Treaty'"—no contribution on his own, a hypothetical contribution which, if we were to accept it, would be, to follow the President's statement, that we were to say, "the Treaty, the whole Treaty, and nothing but the Treaty." What would that give you? Article XII., representing the Feetham line——
Comment on this
Will the Minister tell us what the Feetham line is? Is he trying to suggest that the Feetham line would give us 20,000 inhabitants and would take six or seven thousand from us?
Comment on this
The Deputy has stated it as well as I know it. Does he accept that line? Would he accept it in that form? Deputy Corish refused to accept it when it was put up to him in an interruption. Deputy Baxter is silent.
Comment on this
The Deputy will accept a line which gives us a certain number of inhabitants and which takes away 7,000 from us. The Deputy is not fully conscious of the situation on the Boundary, much as he talked of it yesterday. The handling over of people who were under an unarmed police force so as to bring them under an armed police force would create a situation around the whole Border area that no one can see the end of.
Comment on this
The Minister tried to deny that statement yesterday when I made it. That is the position on the other side. The cat is out of the bag now.
Comment on this
The Deputy described a certain state of affairs, and I denied it, and deny it still as being a correct description of what is happening all over the Six County area. He gave certain examples from the North, but was corrected afterwards, and asked did he mean the Border area. I denied nothing about the Border area, but whatever the situation in the Border area it would certainly be aggravated by the Feetham line, and the Treaty would give you Article XII. and an award that undoubtedly would be legal but that possibly could be contested in other ways.
Comment on this
Will the Minister deal with this point? Time after time, at the time of the proposition about the Boundary, and since, Ministers—the Minister for Justice, for one—have spoken of a transfer from the Free State to Northern Ireland (notwithstanding the most recent development of Ministerial policy, the development before the last), that there had been contemplated in Ministerial circles a transfer of persons from the Free State into the North. Was that the case or was it not? And if it was the case has the Minister considered that they would have been in any better or in any worse position than these people that he is now speaking of, under the Feetham award?
Comment on this
Could the Deputy put that in disjointed questions? I cannot follow it.
Comment on this
Was the Minister always against the transfer of any citizens from the Free State into Northern Ireland?
Comment on this
I always contended that if the Terms of Reference of the Boundary Commission had been attended to none of our citizens could have been transferred. That was my contention.
Comment on this
I do not know what exactly the Deputy is driving at. When did I make any other contention?
Comment on this
I am asking the Minister did he always contend that it was not possible under the terms of the Treaty in Article XII. to transfer citizens from the Saorstát into Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
I have always said that if the interpretation we hoped for and believed in were given as terms of reference the question could never arise, apart entirely from its technical legality.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Vice-President when the Supplementary Bill was going through that he did not want to keep people contiguous to the border if they wanted to go?
Comment on this
I did not. I said we did not want to bring in unwilling and reluctant citizens within our jurisdiction.
Comment on this
Not having "Hansard" available I will not flatly contradict the Deputy, but I think the point I was making was that our claim was not a claim for territory as such, but that it was a claim that communities homogeneously or predominantly Nationalist would not be kept outside the jurisdiction of their choice.
Comment on this
In the discussion of claims the legitimate claim of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to address the Dáil is being neglected.
Comment on this
The Treaty, the whole Treaty, and nothing but the Treaty. Some boundary result by the Boundary Commission—this or some other. Article V. to be threshed out later on and the Council of Ireland to be preserved. That is Deputy Johnson's alternative to this—that is, outside the one good contribution made by Deputy Murphy and followed by Deputy Esmonde, the next best thing to an alternative we have. It is a matter for simple calculation and for a balance of results. You see what now you can get under this if the Dáil likes to pass it. You have the contingencies of a boundary award under some form of a Boundary Commission, the contingency under Article V. and the safe keeping of Deputy Johnson's pet, the Council of Ireland and votes can be cast upon that. One result we have got from this debate is that we have got a peculiar lining up of forces. I see the whole Labour Party animated by the desire to fight out the Shannon Scheme on the Boundary question.
Comment on this
The Shannon Scheme is being fought out on the Boundary question and the Labour Party are going in on that. I do not say there are not other considerations, but that certainly is a consideration, and that is what is going to be voted on in part by members of the Labour Party——
Comment on this
A member or two of the Farmers' Party, and an ex-member or two of the Government Party.
Comment on this
I have failed to discover any reason from Deputy Baxter. I have discovered emotion and tears, but neither emotion nor tears are going to do the people inside the boundary any good. But we have the strange spectacle of the three new political bed-fellows, Deputy Magennis, Deputy Baxter and Deputy Johnson.
Comment on this
I wonder how they are going to dispose themselves for comfortable slumber in the near future? It is the old problem of the fox, the geese and the cabbages that have to be taken across the river. I cannot see Deputy Johnson and Deputy Baxter side by side, passing the night in comfort. I cannot even see Deputy Baxter sandwiched between Deputy Magennis and Deputy Johnson having a comfortable period. I will throw out a suggestion that may ensure them a good night. Let them put the Deputy Professor between, and when those on the outside get irritated with each other they can take it out of the Professor. I was going to suggest, as a final impropriety, that they might make up their camp in the Shelbourne Hotel, and that the lady to whom Deputy Esmonde referred to to-night might come along to tuck them in. That suggestion I have to withdraw.
Comment on this
The lady to whom Deputy Esmonde referred is anxious, not to tuck them in, but to get them out.
Comment on this
I am satisfied that the House is very tired listening to speeches and I am not going to delay the House very long. I had hoped that I would be able to cast a vote without making any statement, but as a result of a vitriolic attack on two of my former colleagues of the Irish Party, made by a Deputy from Cork, misrepresenting the position, I find myself standing here to try and put right that Deputy and one or two others as to the position of the Irish Party in 1914. I was asked that question, and I say the position of the Irish Parliamentary Party, of which I was proud to be a loyal and faithful supporter, was that, in 1914, Mr. John Redmond and Mr. John Dillon refused partition in any shape or form for this country.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy confess that the reason why the negotiations I referred to broke down was because it was a question of whether it was four or six counties?
Comment on this
I will answer that, and I am glad the Deputy has given me an opportunity of referring to four counties. Before I go further, I wish to prove my statement, and I will take no less a person than the Prime Minister of England. Speaking on the Government of Ireland (Amending) Bill, in the House of Commons on the 20th July, 1914, the Prime Minister said:—
"By the indulgence of the House, before we proceed to the Orders of the Day, I should like to be permitted to make a very brief statement. I am authorised by the King to announce to the House that, in view of the grave situation which has arisen, he has thought it right to summon representatives of parties, both British and Irish, to a conference at Buckingham Palace, with the object of discussing outstanding issues in relation to the problem of Irish Government. Invitations have been issued by his Majesty to, and have been accepted by, two representatives of the Opposition, two representatives of the Ulster Unionist Party, two representatives of the Irish Nationalist Party, and two of His Majesty's Government. I am glad to add that at the King's suggestion, Mr. Speaker has consented to preside over the conference which, I hope, may begin its proceedings tomorrow. In the meantime, we shall not proceed to-day with the Second Reading of the Irish (Amending) Bill, but shall ask the House to deal with other Orders which appear upon the Paper."
Mr. John Redmond stood up and said:—
"Perhaps I may be allowed just to say one word. I would like to say that my colleagues and myself have no responsibility for the policy of the calling of this Convention, and I do not think that I am called upon to express any opinion as to whether in the result it will prove useful or the contrary. The invitations to attend this conference came to my honourable friend the member for East Mayo and myself in the form of a command of the King, and as such, of course, we at once accepted it."
That was on the 20th July. On the 24th July, under the title "The Government of Ireland Bill," the Prime Minister, in the House of Commons, stood up and said:—
"I have to inform the House that the conference summoned by his Majesty the King held four meetings—on the 21st, 22nd, 23rd, and 24th July—and the possibility of defining an area for exclusion from the operations of the Government of Ireland Bill was considered, and the conference being unable to agree either in principle or in detail upon such an area it brought its meetings to a conclusion."
Neither in Principle nor in detail did the Buckingham Palace Conference agree to the partition of this country.
Comment on this
I must ask for some indulgence for my colleague, Deputy Byrne. I understand that last night Deputy Murphy addressed the House at considerable length, and I do not think he was interrupted. I think Deputy Byrne is entitled to some indulgence in this respect.
Comment on this
I unhesitatingly say that had the country accepted Redmond's advice and allowed the constitutional policy to proceed that we would not be here to-night deciding on the partition of our country.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy says we would be all dead in Flanders.
Comment on this
In proof of John Redmond's attitude and the attitude of the Irish Party, Deputy Davin has already made a statement from no less a person than the Governor-General of Ireland. At that time he was Mr. Timothy Healy, M.P., and Mr. Timothy Healy, writing his cool, deliberate judgment on the issue, wrote a letter to the "Irish Independent" on October 19th, 1921, in which he stated:—
"In 1914 Mr. Redmond and Mr. Dillon, at the Buckingham Palace conference with Messrs. Carson and Craig on the eve of the war, refused to purchase Home Rule by any such surrender. Yet, seven years later, Sinn Feiners are expected to crawl down to a tamer position than that of the dethroned Parliamentarians, and go forth to history as signatories to a Pact in Downing street which Mr. Redmond refused to make in a Royal Palace."
In case someone might think that the Governor-General's opinion—I think it will be admitted it was an unbiased opinion because he had not the record of being very friendly with the Irish Party—counted for nothing, in February, 1921, the late Cardinal Lougue wrote:—
"Had there been a strong militant Irish Party of seventy or eighty members in the House of Commons. with the assistance they might get from other parties, Mr. Lloyd George and his colleagues could never have reduced this country to the lamentable condition in which we find it at present."
What was responsible for the condition of the country? The men who raised that bogus catch-cry "Abstention"— General Mulcahy and a few others who said, "Abstain from Westminster and we will go to the Peace Conference with heads erect and bring back an Irish Republic." What did they bring back? What did General Mulcahy bring back?
Comment on this
We brought back Deputy Byrne sitting in an Irish Parliament, representing an Irish constituency.
Comment on this
You brought back a divided Ireland—two Parliaments in a small island such as this, the country rent asunder, your industries crushed, and thousands of unemployed at our doors to-day.
Comment on this
If Deputy Byrne would address me he would be less interrupted because I will not interrupt him.
Comment on this
John Redmond's policy was defeated and Sinn Feiners succeeded, and it is these people who have cursed and scarred Ireland with the canker of partition. They do not like to hear the truth of the past ten years' torture of this country. They applaud a man when he stands up and abuses the memory of John Redmond and attacks Joe Devlin.
Comment on this
On that I wish to say that I was present in the Chair when Deputy Murphy spoke. Deputy Murphy did not abuse the memory of John Redmond.
Comment on this
No Deputy in this House abused the memory of John Redmond, and as long as I have the honour to preside over this Dáil, I shall not allow anybody to abuse the memory of any dead man, and more particularly of any man who was a beloved leader of the Irish people. That did not happen. I did not like to interrupt Deputy Byrne when he began and said that a vitriolic attack was made yesterday evening on two of his former colleagues.
Comment on this
No vitriolic attack was made on the memory of Mr. John Redmond in my hearing. An allusion was made to Mr. Devlin, who is a member of the Northern Parliament. It was a passing allusion. I did not stop the Deputy who made it, but I take this opportunity of saying that I do not approve of any allusion to a member of the Northern Parliament. I want to have that made absolutely clear. Speaking as the custodian of the honour of this Dáil, and representing every member of the Dáil, I repeat that no attack was made on the memory of Mr. Redmond—no attack whatever, and I would not have tolerated any such attack had it been attempted. I feel confident that no one would have attempted it.
Comment on this
Except in the way of personal explanation, I do not think that the Deputy will make things any better.
Comment on this
I did not complain yesterday when Deputy Byrne interrupted me. I never said anything in this House, or outside it, that I did not mean, and I hope Deputy Byrne can say the same.
Comment on this
On a matter of personal explanation, may I say that this is exceedingly personal to me, and most disagreeable. I thank you, sir, for what you have said, and not only do I thank you, but I believe, sincerely, that you carried out, and always will carry out, the expressions that you have just mentioned, and as far as I am personally concerned, I have no complaint to make.
Comment on this
I personally am grateful, sir, for your announcement, and I am satisfied that no member of the House, unless in the heat of the moment, or probably to gain some Party advantage, would insult the memory of that former beloved leader of the Irish people.
Comment on this
I want to say that that is a most unworthy sentence. I have been placed in this Chair as the custodian of the privileges of this House, and of the honour of its members. I appreciate what Deputy Redmond has said. We all do, but it is most unworthy of Deputy Byrne to say, after what I have said, that any Deputy would insult a dead man's memory for a party advantage, or in a moment of passion.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not improve matters by these interruptions. The memory of John Redmond was not insulted, and there is no danger of any Deputy in this House in a moment of passion or for any other reason insulting it. That is a matter on which I cannot let Deputy Byrne proceed. I want that made absolutely clear, and it is most unworthy, and Deputy Byrne should withdraw the insinuation, that any Deputy would be guilty of such a thing.
Comment on this
I withdraw any statement that might mean that you were not watching, and protecting, the interests of those inside, but I am so used to listening to those slanders outside that I may have fallen into the statement that the slander was made inside—that is, the attack. I am satisfied to accept the explanation that no attack was made.
Comment on this
Or that any attack would be made here. I do not like to continue this. As Deputy Redmond has said, it is most disagreeable. Deputy Byrne said nothing about me. He did say something about attacks by Deputies here. I am not responsible for Deputies outside, but I am responsible for Deputies inside. That Deputies here would insult a dead man's memory is a thing that should not be said.
Comment on this
I withdraw the statement that the attacks were made here, I withdraw it unreservedly. I know my duty to the Chair, and there is no man in this House would obey the Chair more readily than I would. Last night I heard the words "Pontius Pilate" used, and in connection with these words, two names were mentioned.
Comment on this
What names were used in that connection? Let us hear them now?
Comment on this
Deputy Murphy, speaking last night, used in the one sentence the words "Pontius Pilate" in connection with the names of John Redmond and Joe Devlin.
Comment on this
I was in the Chair, and I was listening, with the greatest possible attention, to Deputy Murphy, more particularly when he was verging on the topic Deputy Byrne speaks of. What has Deputy Murphy to say?
Comment on this
I deny absolutely I made any comparison between the late Mr. John Redmond, whom I certainly did not want to insult, even if I did differ from his policy in some respects, or used the name of Pontius Pilate in connection with John Redmond.
Comment on this
I do not like to intrude in this matter, and I feel it much, and I appeal to Deputy Byrne and to my friend above the gangway, Deputy Murphy, to let the matter drop, and so far as I am concerned, with all respect to either of the Deputies, I do not think it will affect John Redmond's career or what was thought of him in the country. That is all I have to say about the matter.
Comment on this
It is not a question of Deputy Byrne or Deputy Murphy. It is a question of what this House allowed to be said. I want to be clear that no statement that could by any manner of means be interpreted to be an insult to the memory of a dead man was made use of in this House. I want that made clear.
Comment on this
I accept the statement of the Deputy, and I also bow to your ruling, and I withdraw unreservedly. I was asked about the Irish Party's position and their policy in 1914 and again in 1916. I have given the announcement by the Prime Minister of England in 1914 to show that the Irish Party at no time agreed to partition. Deputy McCullough said that partition was born in Buckingham Palace and baptised in Belfast. Now, what are the facts? It is not a matter for face-saving, and we all ought to recognise the position we are in to-day. It is not a matter for face-saving for any Deputy in this House. There is a Boundary, and has been a Boundary since 1920, and every man who came into this House accepted the position that there was a Boundary. That Boundary was created, and the Orange Parliament was set up during the absence from Westminster of the Irish Parliamentary Party. When the abstention policy succeeded in 1918 Sir James Craig and his friends sought that golden opportunity, when there was no opposition, to establish a Parliament, and they succeeded in establishing the Parliament of the Six Counties in 1920 when the Irish Party had been removed from Westminster.
If anybody is to blame for the Boundary situation arising in this country, it is those who subscribed to and supported the agitation in 1918 to abstain from Westminster. When the Minister for Finance was making his speech I only had to shut my eyes to imagine I was back in Westminster hearing my friends asking the Opposition to give us a chance of proving to Ulster by good-will and good government that one Parliament for Ireland was a desirable thing. All the speeches made here during the last three days were almost copies of the speeches contained in the books before me made by John Redmond, but John Redmond was howled at for making those speeches, and Ministers have no right to come back from London posing as triumphant gladiators when they are just getting what John Redmond and his Party could have got without the shedding of a drop of blood, without the damage to property, without the loss of life. I do not find fault with the Government for taking it in the circumstances, but that is the feeling I have when I think of the destruction of the past ten years. What has it brought us? Nothing better than could have been got in 1914. Certainly it has given us our own Army. What does that mean only an expenditure of a couple of millions yearly.
Comment on this
I do not find fault with the Minister for thinking so in the circumstances.
Comment on this
Deputy Byrne thinks that the only place for an Irish army is on the battlefields of Europe.
Comment on this
I do not. I never subscribed to that doctrine, and I think the Deputy knows it well.
Comment on this
Somebody is finding fault, and saying that it was the doctrine of that Party. I think I remember some of the Free State Ministers joining in congratulations to America for the part they played in the war, and also referring in glowing terms to the work done by our own. You cannot have it one way to-day and another way the next day when it suits you. You would like to have it both ways, I am satisfied. Many good Irishmen went out in the Great War, believing that they were doing the right thing for Ireland, and are you going to find fault with them because they followed their belief as you followed yours and made yours a failure?
Comment on this
The Deputy is not addressing Deputy Mulcahy surely?
Comment on this
He continues to interrupt me, to try to make little points that do not arise, and I think it is only right that I should reply to him and draw attention to his part in Irish affairs for the past ten years.
Comment on this
I believe in the appeal made by the Minister for Finance. I believe that it is by good-will, brotherly love, and by being good neighbours, as referred to by Deputy Cooper, that we can yet bring about peace in this country. It is only by good-will and brotherly love that we can do so. The same appeal was made by John Redmond and his followers in the Irish Party, and Deputies here lent themselves to a political campaign that eventually destroyed the friendly feeling which John Redmond was endeavouring to create in Ulster. The same cries of "No surrender," and "Not an inch," were made ten years ago. It was only this week that Ministers recognised the difficulties that responsible leaders in the past had to face. Our Government to-day is in the same position that the Irish Party were ten years ago. I think the appeal made by the Minister for Finance for good-will and brotherly love ought to get a chance. I would have supported the same appeal in Westminster had an opportunity arisen. In 1914 discussions were going on for the establishment of Home Rule in Ireland when the Great War broke out and shattered all our hopes. An agitation was raised by the lords and the gentry of England. Some very vicious speeches were made and letters written which I will not quote from.
Some form of guarantee is necessary in order that our people in the North may get fair play. Only a few weeks ago they were refused representation in the Senate when the election took place. The Government may have got some information which they have not made public. It is quite possible that the Government have some form of guarantee or some information that things will change in the North of Ireland. I hope they will change. Judging by the tone of the speeches made from the Government Benches it appears we have not got all the information. I did not leave my seat in this House for five minutes at a time since this debate started last Monday, and from the speeches made by the Ministers I would be led to believe that there was something kept back from the House. If it is good news, I do not see why the Government should keep it back. It would make the passage of this measure much easier.
I will give one further quotation that I forgot to mention. It shows the position of the Irish Party in 1914. The Prime Minister, speaking in March on a Resolution that was before the House, said:
"The principle is this: That to allay the apprehensions felt in Ulster there should be given to that province local option by areas, voted, it may be by a bare majority for exclusion, and if, and when that option is exercised, areas so excluded are to come in at the expiration of a defined term of years, a term so fixed that during its currency the electors of the United Kingdom will at least have twice the opportunity of determining whether or not that automatic exclusion is to stand."
Again, I may be asked what happened in 1916.
Comment on this
Really, this is hardly fair. The Deputy has told us what happened in 1914, and has spent much longer on this matter than anyone else. He could really afford to come to the Bill now.
Comment on this
Perhaps I could throw some oil on the troubled waters.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is not Deputy Byrne as much entitled to speak for two and a half hours as other Deputies?
Comment on this
I will not delay the House very much longer. I do not think that I ever kept the House for more than a quarter of an hour before. I may be busy at Question time as you, sir, stated, but I can assure Deputies that I seldom speak for more than a quarter of an hour. I do so to-night because of misrepresentation of the situation in the past. I have marked out a little paragraph dealing with the discussion on the Home Rule Bill— the Government of Ireland measure of 1914—to show the difficulties the Irish Party had to contend with:
"In consequence of information received by His Majesty's Government, it was decided to make certain movements of troops."
That refers to the Curragh revolt. In spite of all that the Constitutional Party was still carrying on, as I claim, with success at Westminster. As far as partition is concerned I hope I have made it clear that the Irish Party were not responsible for it. The only thing they did agree to was exclusion of the Ulster counties for a period of six years, Ulster to remain under the British Parliament, the Irish people having full representation in that Parliament to see that no injustice would be done. At the end of six years Ulster was automatically to come into the Irish Parliament. Then the rebellion broke out in Dublin in 1916 and altered the whole position.
Comment on this
You have heard it for the last four days and you applauded it.
Comment on this
I did not applaud it. I want to say that we accept everything that Deputy Byrne has said, and everything he is going to say.
Comment on this
It is not a point of order. I am not sure how far history is relevant to this debate. A certain amount of history is.
Comment on this
One Deputy went back as far as Fionn Mac Cumhaill yesterday.
Comment on this
I feel that I, at least, am entitled to be heard without interruption. I think Deputy Byrne might now come to the Bill. I am not referring to the question of time and I am not limiting the Deputy in that respect. I do think that the Deputy might now come to something which would appear to be relevant to the Bill.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I am now going to raise a point of order, and it is this: on a Second Reading debate of a particular measure is the Deputy entitled to any time he chooses to discuss that measure, what has led up to that measure, the antecedents of that measure, and everything in and about that measure? Is there any rule whereby you, sir, acting in your capacity as Ceann Comhairle, can call him to order or curtail his discussion of that measure?
Comment on this
There are really two points of order in that question. I have answered one already. There is no time limit to a discussion on the Second Reading. There is considerable latitude allowed on Second Reading, but I am the judge of relevancy. There can be only one judge, and Deputy Byrne has exhausted his relevancy on one particular topic. I hope that is clear as a matter of order.
Comment on this
I can assure the Dáil it will not take me more than five minutes to conclude. I did not think I was going to speak so long, and but for the interruptions I would have concluded long ago. When the rebellion broke out in 1916 it upset all our hopes, and there was a hasty recall to Ireland. The late Cardinal Logue and the Ulster Bishops met in an hotel in Parnell Square to discuss the matter to see how exactly the position in which their people in Northern Ireland stood. That meeting decided that they would call a conference, and they selected delegates to the meeting, which was called for Belfast. The question was discussed there. John Redmond himself had agreed to accept whatever the Nationalists of the North thought best for themselves. By a majority of about 2 to 1—there were about six or seven hundred people at the conference—the people of Belfast, through these delegates, decided to remain out of the Home Rule Bill. That partition was not the making of the Irish Parliamentary Party. I am glad that I got the opportunity of putting myself and my colleagues, who served in another Parliament in the past, in the right position on this question. I am satisfied that the public will understand that I have only done that right thing to those of my colleagues who remained, to put the position plainly and to prevent their getting any further abuse in the country. I hope now that nobody in this House will attempt, for some face-saving purpose, to put the blame for partition on my former colleagues. I would not have been a friend and supporter of the late John Redmond if I did not express those views. We heard a good deal about the Locarno Pact recently and the Irish Pact, but the Locarno Pact and the Irish Pact would always have been the policy of the late John Redmond.
Comment on this
On this question of partition we have heard a good deal from Deputies on the responsibility of the Irish Parliamentary Party. I think that matter has been cleared up by the straightforward and clear manner in which Deputy Mulcahy dealt with the question, when he said that England, and England alone, is responsible for partition in Ireland, and will be responsible for it.
Comment on this
Táim cinnte go bhfuilimíd uilig buidheach don Teachta atá tar éis labhairt, mar gheall ar an mhéid staire do thug sé dhúinn. Bhíomar ag déanamh dearmaid ar na míorbhailte a rinne an sean Pháirtí agus ar stáir na trioblóide atá i gceist anocht. Dubhairt an Teachta go raibh lucht an Pháirtí in aghaidh roinn na tíre seo——
Comment on this
Is dóigh liom gur feárr gan dul isteach 'san gceist sin arís.
Comment on this
B'fhéidir gur feárr í a fhágailt mar tá sí. Is é mo thuairim go dtuigeann lucht na Dála an cheist seo—ceist an teorann— agus go dtuigeann na daoiní taobh amuigh den Tigh seo an cheist chó maith. Táimíd ag cur síos ar an gceist seo agus shaoilfeá ón chainnt nach rabh aon teora ann go dtí anois. Bhí an teora ann sar a n-deárnadh an Connradh idir muinntir na hEireann agus muinntir Shasana breis agus cúig bliana ó shoin. Ní híad na daoine atá annseo anocht a rinne an teora. Bhí sí ann agus tá sí ann agus bheadh sí ann, is cuma faoi thoradh an Chomisiúin.
Rinneadh socrú ar an gceist seo seachtmhain ó shoin. Níor thaithn an socrú san liom agus is é mo bharramhail nár thaithn sé le lucht an Rialtais ach oiread. Tá a lán daoine taobh istigh den teorainn agus is beag atá siad-san sásta leis, acht caidé an bealach eile atá acu? Tá bealach amháin —bealach an tsocruighthe seo—againn agus má tá bealach níos feárr ag aoinne, níl le déanamh againn ach glacadh leis. Ins an Chonnradh a rinneadh cúig bliana ó shoin, bhí a lán nidhthe nar thaithn liom-sa. Bhíomar ag cur síos ar an gceist sin ar feadh tamaill fhada agus nuair nach rabh aon rogha againn do ghlacamar leis. Dá mba rud é go rabh socrú ní b'fheárr ar fagháil an t-am san, ghlacfainn leis, agus bhéinn in aghaidh an Chonnartha. Má tá aon Teachta san Dáil in-ánn bealach níos feárr ná an socrú so a theasbáint dom, beidh mé ar son an bhealaigh sin. Dubhairt Teachta éigin—ní chuimhin liom i gceart cé hé —go rabhamar uilig ar thaoibh an rúin ar an taobh so den Tigh, toise go rabh bainnt againn le Cumann-na-nGaedheal. Is cuma liom faoi'n gCumann sin. Tá bainnt ag gach Teachta le Cumann éigin chó maith linne. Má tá Teachta ar bith in ánn bealach níos feárr as an gcruadh-chás so a theasbáint dom, béad ar thaoibh an bhealaigh sin acht, muna bhfuil, cuideochaidh mé leis an rún so.
Comment on this
I have been asking myself whether I should continue this debate for the next hour and five minutes, but as members of the Government Party have informed you that they were getting tired of this repetition of argument, I have decided not to do so. Inside and outside the Dáil I have been asked what I was going to do in connection with this important question. I said outside on the Lobby what I am going to tell you now, that I have carefully studied the debate and that it is my intention to support the measure.
Comment on this
I desire to record the reasons why I object to the ratification of the Treaty. I observed from the Press that the President stated that it has sown the seeds of peace. I believe that you cannot sow the seeds of peace by this Agreement either in the North or in the South of Ireland. I will be charitable to the Government representatives, and I am not going to suggest that they sold the country. I am sorry that members from another Party suggested that they were traitors in the Labour Party, because they objected to this Agreement.
Comment on this
I do not think that was said; I do not remember it.
Comment on this
I believe if we had unity in the South we would have had a better agreement and General Collins' prophecy would have come true. I think that if the President and his colleagues had come back and pointed out to the people in this Chamber that the arbitrators had gone outside their Terms of Reference, there would have been a possibility of uniting the people of the South and uniting with the friends we have thrown to the wolves in the North. We would have got back the unity that prevailed in 1918, and we would have been able to defy the power and the might of England. I notice that the Minister for Justice stated on September 9th: "We will not agree and never would have agreed to the compulsory exclusion from our State of a large mass of the Nationalist population who desire to be included." In December, a couple of months afterwards, the Minister for Justice stated:
Comment on this
It is an interview given by the Minister for Justice to the correspondent of the "Daily Express."
Comment on this
During the week the Minister stated: "I will not stand for a repudiation of the Treaty and throw the people of the South into the melting pot." He is prepared to throw the people in the North of Ireland into the melting pot, to be at the mercy of the Orangemen and the Freemason gang in the North of Ireland. The Minister for Industry and Commerce twitted us here on the people we have supporting us. Let him look at the support he is receiving and where it is coming from. It is coming from the men who denounced the Sinn Fein movement in 1916 and until the Free State was established. Now they are its most loyal supporters. I am not possessed of the slave mind. I take my teaching from the late General Collins when he stated that an Irishman's interpretation of the Treaty, from an Irishman's point of view, was superior to the Englishman's interpretation. I suggest that in Article V. there is a certain amount of vagueness. Deputy Professor O'Sullivan and another Minister stated that they were agreeing to pay £15,000,000 and £150,000 for the abolition of Article V. What is Article V.? I take this extract from a paper that supports the Government, "The Wexford People":—
It is well to point out a fact which has been overlooked in regard to Article V. It provides that the financial relations between the Free State and Great Britain shall be decided by arbitrators who must be citizens of the British Commonwealth. Here the Free State holds the trump card. There is no provision made for the appointment of such arbitrators or for the method of delivering judgment if the arbitrators disagree. There is, therefore, nothing to prevent the Free State insisting that it should appoint the Chairman of the Arbitration Board and even insisting that all the arbitrators should be Irishmen.
Of course, England would not agree. That is where the point comes in. The Free State would then not be bound by that Commission. This Article V., as Lord Carson said, is eye-wash. There should be no necessity to come back and tell us that we would have to reduce the old age pension by 10 per cent. and refuse to give to people unemployed in the South the same donation that they were getting in the North, if we are in the position of giving £15,000,000 for the permanent dismemberment of our country. I think our friend, Deputy Major Myles, in speaking for the Treaty, advanced an argument as to why we should vote against this Agreement. To put it in a nutshell—take away the last remaining clause which the Treaty of 1921 gave by abolishing the Customs barrier. It was painful to listen to Deputy Mulcahy. He gave over our whole ideal of Irish Nationality when he suggested lock, stock and barrel the position of British Unionism and Ulster Carsonism. He stated that the whole idea was to get in British wealth and British capital.
Comment on this
I think if the Deputy will get the Official Reports he will see that he made a suggestion that has never been made by any conceivable Irish Nationalist leader—that we were practically enslaved, that we were depending upon British capitalists and British industry.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, I want to say that I was drawing attention to the explanation given yesterday in the British House of Lords by one of the signatories of the Treaty of 1921 as to why he and his fellow-signatories to that Treaty insisted upon Article V. being put into the Treaty at that time, and the explanation was lest taxation in Ireland should be found to be at such a low level that it might tempt British capital and British industry to come into Ireland to the detriment of British Commerce, they would have that Article to squeeze money from us for the purpose of raising our taxation here and stopping that danger from the British point of view. The British objected to the possibility of Ireland being in the position financially that British capital and British factories might be tempted to flow into Ireland. It is not an idea of mine at all.
Comment on this
I accepted the Treaty believing it was a steppingstone to complete freedom for Ireland. I understood that under Article XII. we were to get two more counties. I admit that we have, as I pointed out, been divided. At the same time, I am sorry that in the Dáil we hear Deputies speak who may believe they are doing right by voting for the permanent dismemberment of our country. I speak for myself on this matter. I would prefer to see us back again where we were previous to 1921, even if the last shilling was to go and the last man was to give up his life, rather than agree to the permanent dismemberment of our country and to leave our fellow-Catholics in the North at the mercy of the Orange Government. I would prefer to see Ireland poor but free than to see Ireland rich and enslaved.
Comment on this
I am not going to detain the Dáil very long, but I am something of the same mind as Deputy Everett on this matter. Having regard to all the sacrifices that have been made for the establishment of the present Treaty—that is not the Treaty that we are discussing at the moment, but the Treaty under which this Dáil is functioning—I think it is too bad that we are now about to dismantle ourselves of any honour and dignity that we possessed when we entered into the conflict with Great Britain in the years 1919, 1920 and 1921, that is, after the elections in 1918. Some of us, at all events, in the Dáil, if not all of us, have taken a certain amount of responsibility in that campaign. We shouldered that responsibility in the endeavour to bring about what was long sought by the Irish people, the complete independence of Ireland, and to have an Ireland one and indivisible.
At one stage in the history of our country, we found it necessary to agree to a truce with the former authority that controlled or endeavoured to control the destinies of our people. From that truce came the Treaty negotiations, sometimes carried on by an individual, and finally came the negotiations by a number of individuals. Then came the Treaty and its ratification by the Dáil. I had a certain amount of responsibility for the ratification of the Treaty and I exercised that responsibility to the best of my ability. I advised the men at that time who were hostile to the Articles of Agreement brought from London, to accept the statement made by our responsible leaders here, that it was freedom to acheive freedom and that the settlement then arrived at would ultimately lead to the complete union of Ireland, and that it would be disastrous for these men to take responsibility for civil war, or to assist in any way those who disagreed with the majority at that time. It took some considerable length of time to convince these men with whom I was associated and who were soldiers of the Irish Republican Army, that the policy I preached to them was the best for the country. With the exception of one battalion that was under my command at that time, all the men took my word. They showed that they believed that I conveyed to them the facts and that I conveyed to them what would be the ultimate results of the acceptance of the Treaty. But, sad to say, that view is not borne out by the facts before us now.
The Treaty, which was so much objected to by some of those men at that time, is now going to be brought down to that state that it is going to become more objectionable. Instead of this Treaty going to bring unity amongst Irishmen and going to establish a new state of stability and citizenship within the State, it is my considered opinion that it will drive very many men who have made sacrifices and suffered much in the past before the ratification of the Treaty of 1921 into the hands of other people who have been referred to here to-night by Deputy Esmonde. I do not know what the policy of those people is, or if they have any policy. I do not know if they ever had a policy or ever intend to have a policy. However, they could throw out a bait to men who made sacrifices in accepting the promises of the late respected General Collins and others. The danger is that these baits may force them away from the straight line of decent citizenship into the ranks of the Irregular campaign, a campaign that may be started in the near future. The responsibility in the matter of the passing of this Bill that is before us now, or at least the passing of its Second Reading, or the responsibility for finding an alternative for it is not, to my mind, our responsibility. It is the responsibility of the Executive Council. They are the makers, they are the fathers, as I might say, of the situation. It is the duty of the father of the child to rear it up to decent manhood, and it is the Executive Council's duty to prove to us that the child they have brought home from London, and that was given birth to in Downing Street, will grow up sound and healthy and that it will establish the unity long sought for in this country.
We are told there are circumstances and consequences that make it imperative on this House to pass this Bill. I do not know what the circumstances are; I do not know what the consequences are. Like many other Deputies. I have not had the facts placed before me. The Government have failed, and failed hopelessly, to put the facts before me and before the House. What are the facts that created the circumstances that so much reference has been made to here within the past three or four days? There has been talk about the Feetham line and about terrible and immediate war. Some Deputies were good enough to suggest that this should be accepted in preference to war. Has any Deputy gone to the trouble of finding out if there will be war should the Bill not pass? Is there going to be war? They are all full of war.
The people who are in opposition to this House and who are outside to-day, in discussing the Treaty of 1921, suggested that it was by a threat of war that the Irish signatories were forced to sign. Deputies here adopt the same attitude. They stand up in the House and practically point a revolver at the heads of those in opposition to the Bill, and they say: "If you do not pass it, it means terrible war and bloodshed." Ridiculous nonsense. They have no proof for what they are saying. We heard the Minister for Industry and Commerce this evening giving a theatrical rehearsal that I did not think it possible for even Harry Lauder to venture upon. It was one of those manoeuvring rehearsals with which we are familiar from the Ministerial Benches. We heard the evasions, the theatrical evasions, due to quickness of mind brought about by high education and accompanied by a call to the Bar. A good deal of attention was paid to this, theatrical rehearsal by every Deputy, but all the time when I looked around the Chamber I observed the pleasant and amusing faces all laughing and smiling at the performance on the Ministerial Benches.
Comment on this
Yes; they started really in this House. Not once did the Minister for Industry and Commerce endeavour to make the position clear. When any question was put to him here he was like a barrister in the High Court trying to quibble and give quibbling answers. Several Deputies, including Deputies Baxter, Johnson and Davin, asked questions, and they all got a theatrical reply that one would only expect from a man like Harry Lauder. I do not intend to say very much more. I am aware that another Minister has to address the House before the debate comes to a conclusion.
Comment on this
The President has to address the House again, and I am sure he will not be disappointed. No doubt we will have another theatrical rehearsal. It may be more exciting than that given by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I suppose there will be a little bit of venom in it and, possibly, some of the vinegar that Deputy Esmonde suggests Miss MacSwiney is steeped in will be attached to his tongue. There is one thing I want to make plain: I, as one Deputy, hold no responsibility for the action of the Ministry that did not do its duty to the State in accordance with Article XII. It had its powers to force the Commission established in London to take a plebiscite of the people and find out their wishes. Luckily enough, they were enabled to discover what the Commission was doing through the pen of the political reporter of the "Morning Post."
They had another remedy. They could appeal to the League of Nations. They could have brought there the Feetham Report and along with it the terms of reference; they could place them side by side and have them interpreted by international lawyers. We are led to believe that this State is a member of the League of Nations, yet they made no application to be heard there. They have decided that it would be a better policy on their part to keep friendly with Great Britain and make friends with Sir James Craig. They came back with a document that is a disgrace and a dishonour to the State. Deputies who vote for this Bill, even though it may bring serious consequences to the State, are selling the honour and dignity of their country.
Comment on this
We have now listened for four days to a criticism of this particular instrument that has been placed before the Dáil. Many people have ransacked historical works in order to see how they could employ some of the information contained there in connection with this discussion. As far as I can learn, this particular trouble started in 1886. It occurred again in 1893, and the next incident occurred in 1912. Then we had it again in 1913, 1914, and 1916. In 1916 it was complicated to some extent by a letter from the Rev. Father O'Flanagan and by a meeting that was held in Belfast.
In 1917 an attempt was made to find a solution. In 1920 the British Parliament passed what is called the Partition Act, and the legal term of which is the Government of Ireland Act. We come down then to the one big gesture from Sir James Craig when he came here in 1921 to meet the then President of Dáil Eireann. In my view there was an opportunity at that time to do some business, but the same record has to be made in relation to that interview as concerns every other date I have mentioned. Failure marked every attempt to find a solution of this question. We may get apologists who will get up and say: "We ought to have had another chance; a longer time ought to have been given." The fact is that the solution fell to us and that is what has us here. Now, it would not be out of place to repeat what the late General Collins said in connection with the North-East, when speaking on the Treaty debate. He said:—"I would like to treat the question of the North-East corner in a similar manner. There have been many references that we would never accept partition." Again: "We must look facts in the face; we must examine statements that have been made in the light of their implications. In our correspondence with the British Premier we made it clear that we did not intend to coerce the North-East." Numbers of us have reiterated that one way or another since. That has been the policy of responsible political leaders in this country for four years. It is not the policy of the Opposition to this measure. They want coercion, but they do not want to call it that. Not a single person who has spoken against this instrument here for the last four days has said that if it passes it will have his good-will and support even though he disagrees with it.
Comment on this
Very well. I am glad to hear that there are two who are going to make it a success. Are there any others willing to make a success of this last effort of ours to bring peace, concord and goodwill to this country?
Comment on this
I think the President can rely that every person in this House will be pleased if all the President expects will come from this measure will be realised.
Comment on this
If the feelings of fraternity, brotherhood and concord, which the President expects, come from this I am sure that every person in this House and in the country will be delighted.
Comment on this
That is good, very good. It would have been much easier for us to come to an accommodation had we been able to say the same of the efforts made three or four years ago by General Collins and Sir James Craig. They having made a pact of peace, other people made it their business to see that it was not going to succeed. What is the contribution now of those people outside this House, neglecting their duties and responsibilities and trying to place every obstacle in the way of the prosperity of the country? What is their contribution towards a solution of this matter? In Document No. 2, on which they stand at present, with the exception of the term "British" before the words "Government of Ireland Act," their method of solving this question is exactly the same as ours; and if a Commission had been set up, and if the Northern Government had not appointed a representative on that Commission, they would have had to take the same means to ensure that that Commissioner would have been appointed as we have taken. The potentialities of partition were in the Treaty, and we were committed to them from the very commencement. Only one thing could have avoided partition once the Treaty was accepted, and that was that the Northern Government would not have opted out. Article XIV. provided for that; it provided the same machinery, the same words—everything except the explanatory clause— that are in our policy of the Treaty are in Document No. 2. What were the inducements for the Northern Government to exercise their option in favour of union in this country? They were invited by the anti-Treaty Party to warm their hands and their hearts at the fires they were kindling throughout the country. That was a nice invitation. When we called off the boycott with Belfast, goods were destroyed, goods were taken out of railway waggons and burned. When we attack Sir James Craig and the Northern Government for their bigotry let us remember that we cannot place our hands on our hearts and say that they did not get an invitation to do it.
After a very long delay the Boundary Commission was set up, and I notice that in January, 1924, even Deputy Baxter put a question to me on the point as to when it was going to function, and grave doubts were expressed whether the Government really meant business in that connection. From the commencement no expense was spared and no opportunity lost. Every precaution was taken. The best Civil Servants that could be got were employed to make the case. In fact, no Department of State functioned with greater vigour or energy or had within its ranks persons better qualified to make a case for those for whom we were acting as trustees. One of those employed was the winner of the £1,000 Filene Prize. That will give some indication of the wish and determination of the Government to discharge their obligations as trustees. When the speeches which have been quoted against us here are read it will be plain and distinct to anyone, no matter how prejudiced he is against the Executive Council, that their whole hearts and souls and minds and strength were brought into play in order that the best issues that could be got out of the Boundary Commission would be got. Now, when we hear learned professors talking about ineptitude, incompetency, inefficiency, and so on, and when we ask them for an alternative, the only one that can be suggested is a coalition. I hope the baby is doing well. I believe it is crowing to-night.
Comment on this
Evidently the President is not aware of it, but I have already corrected that mistake when made by the Minister for Finance and he accepted the correction.
Comment on this
I never proposed as an alternative, to the present agreement, a Coalition Government. I spoke of what constitutional course should have been followed before this Agreement was ever dreamt of.
Comment on this
Well, sir, he was two hours getting out what he thought would have been better than what the Executive Council was recommending, and now neither himself, I think, nor the Dáil is any wiser as to the solution he was proposing. The circumstances since the 7th November are within the minds of every member of the Dáil. We were within one month of the publication of the report by the Commission. Our representative on the Commission resigned somewhere in the month of November, and we were faced with a very serious problem. It was a matter of doubt with some people as to whether two Commissioners could issue a report. A perusal of cases of that kind—practically parallel cases— led one to believe that it was more than possible that the Commission was legally entitled to publish the Award. I have not seen the Award.
I heard Dr. MacNeill here in the House give an indication as to what it was like. Sir James Craig has not seen it. I was informed by the Prime Minister of Great Britain that the award was somewhat better—much better I believe he said—than the published forecast. On the balance, I should say, speaking now from recollection of what he told me, we should get something like a couple of hundred square miles and some twenty odd thousands of people. We would have lost a considerable portion of the County Donegal. When Deputy O'Maille is shedding tears about the loss of Tyrone I hope he will not forget to shed a few for the danger that might have happened in O'Donnell's county.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Maille's tears were not known to the Prime Minister, but if he means information I am giving the House as regards the balance and so forth, yes. He had seen the report. I see Deputy O'Maille smiling. I hope he is not smiling at the sufferings of the people in the North. We were in this position: we had four possible decisions to make. There was the Boundary Commission Report and the question of taking such steps as we deemed advisable to test its legality, or, as my learned friend said a few moments ago, of bringing it to the League of Nations, or retaining the old line as an agreed line. I could see no other way of dealing with the problem than by one or other of these alternatives. I would like to say here that in view of the representations that had been made to us, and in view of the information at our disposal, and bearing in mind that while we were the trustees for some, we had more than the responsibility of trustees for the citizens we were in danger of losing. I must say that I was satisfied in my own mind that it would take a very considerable amount of persuasion to make me look with any degree of favour upon the Boundary Commission Report, and those were the four possible alternatives which would have faced Deputy Professor Magennis's baby if it came into existence. As regards the first, I have already dealt with it; and as regards the second, I am putting my own view to the House.
The question to be solved was a difference between Irishmen. Already a non-Irishman had been brought in to endeavour to effect a solution. In my opening speech I said that a Divine solution was asked from human agency, and it was impossible. Bringing the question to the League of Nations would be raising false hopes— and perhaps succeeding—but I want to make it perfectly clear that while we have to suffer from expressions of opinion from other people, if we leave office to-morrow no one can say we have damaged any one of those four cases, or have done anything to prevent them being taken up by our successors and put through. All the arguments that could be used before the League of Nations stand good. The statement I make that as an Irishman I object to other people drawing a line is a perfectly legitimate one, and it does not affect the issue in this case. There is either the old line or an agreed line. I should like Deputy Davin, when recognising the agreed line, to picture himself for a moment standing in my position and recommending to the Dáil a line which would involve a surrender of other people or territory. Then there is the question of the old line. The old line had the advantage, at any rate, that it has been in existence for four years. It was, and had been for a long time, the wish of the Northern Government to have it, and it afforded a more stable basis for peace, understanding and good-will than a line which would be drawn by people whose responsibility in connection with the matter ceased when the line was drawn.
We came to the conclusion that if there was to be a line, that if we were unable to secure for the people for whom we were acting as trustees every ounce out of the Treaty, if we were unable to secure that they would be brought into the Free State, then it was a matter upon which judgment had to be brought to bear as to whether the old line, with all the advantages of it, or a new line with its many complications and disadvantages, ought not to be taken. Now I want to tear the mask off the political humbugs in this country, a mask which shrouds their hypocrisy. I want to expose to the Irish people those gentlemen who are endeavouring to deceive them by saying that we are, for the first time, definitely and permanently making partition in this country. Partition is there, settled and determined by the Treaty, and by its disinherited foster-brother, Document No. 2, which says: "For the purposes of the British Government (Ireland) Act, 1920, and of this instrument, the boundary of Northern Ireland shall be such as may be determined by such Commission." What is that?
Comment on this
Certainly it is, and I suppose we will read it in the Press to-morrow that they were always against Partition. I would like that the Leas Cheann Comhairle in his spare time would look up the last volume of Dáil debates, and he will find on page 579 where he voted for the second reading of the Constitution. The Constitution is an instrument of peace, and the foundation of the liberties of this country, and attached to it is the Treaty, and attached to the Treaty is the sentence I have read out. Is that partition? Partition, as I said, in a certain eventuality, and that is a thing that the Leas Cheann Comhairle has taken up and about which he shed tears last night when he thought of Tyrone and Fermanagh being lost to us though he was utterly indifferent as to whether or not Tirconaill was going. Now, if we have arrived at the conclusion that the best interests of peace would be served by getting agreement, getting accommodation, getting peace and goodwill on the old lines, what was the next alternative? How can we make the Irish Free State so attractive that it will be unnecessary to make political speeches in order to get our Northern fellow-countrymen to join us? How can we manage to make this country sound commercially, sound economically, sound politically and otherwise? Apparently by securing as far as possible that its credit will be on a sound foundation, and one drawback that we saw, in so far as any relations we had with the British Government were concerned, was Article V. If there are people here who think that in our negotiations with the British we damaged a case that might be made by our successors if this is not taken, I would like to relieve their minds. In our negotiations we went on one issue alone, and that was our ability to pay. Not a single penny of a counter-claim did we put up. We cited the condition of affairs in this country—250,000 occupiers of uneconomic holdings, the holdings of such a valuation as did not permit of a decent livelihood for the owners; 212,000 labourers, with a maximum rate of wages of 26s. a week: with our railways in a bad condition, with our Old Age Pensions on an average, I suppose, of 1s. 6d. a week less than is paid in England or in Northern Ireland, with our inability to fund the Unemployment Fund, with a tax on beer of 20s. a barrel more than they, with a heavier postage rate. That was our case. I do not think that there was much wrong with it. And if this great Coalition Government were to come along to-morrow I think that they would find that, notwithstanding the fact that we were an inept, an inefficient, an incompetent, and an egotistical Government, that they would not want to withdraw, that they would not want to defend, anything we have said. We have prejudiced nothing, we have lost nothing, and we have secured something that was never before secured, and that is the goodwill of Northern Ireland.
We explained also that our imports for the first seven months of 1924 were twenty-eight millions odd; for the first seven months of 1925, thirty-five millions. For the first seven months of 1924 our exports and re-exports were twenty-six millions, and for the first seven months of 1925 twenty-two millions, and I am glad to say, I am proud to say, and let whoever likes make political capital out of it, that we met honest, just, and generous people to make a case to. The Irregulars can go out now if they like and sound that throughout the country. I am going to tell the truth in connection with these negotiations—the whole truth. We explained that we were paying out three and a quarter millions a year for land held by our people, more than half of them occupying uneconomic holdings. We explained that we were sending out of the country a million and a quarter in pensions, and we told the British Ministers: "You can, if you like, assess us for ten, twenty, thirty millions; we will not be able to pay. Is it any advantage to your country to make us bankrupt? We are not standing for repudiation. We are prepared to bear our burden; we are bearing at present, and will be bearing for a long time, an undue burden, and we are not honestly able to pay a single penny." It was accepted in good faith, and that finished Article V.
I have been reading many books on finance. I have been reading about John Dunne in the 'sixties, about Sir Jos. Neill McKenna in 1888, and Mr. John Blake-Dillon in either the 'fifties or the 'sixties, and I have been reading about the Childers Commission, about all the claims and all the statements that have been made regarding over-taxation. It is stopped now, definitely stopped now, once and for all. And what have we agreed to pay? Five million pounds odd, not fifteen millions.
Comment on this
Five. Get me five millions now and I will clear the debt. I am a trifle hard at bargains, as I once told Mr. de Valera, and when this money was offered to me at 4¾ per cent. interest, sinking fund and all, I must say that I was astonished at the generous treatment given. We are borrowing money here at present at more than 5¼ per cent., and if we were to borrow this we would put a tax upon our credit. That tax is not on your pockets. I remember three or four years ago when the Minister for Justice first went over to arrange about compensation he put it to the British Ministers that they should pay a share of it, and he was met with the reply: "Great Britain never paid an indemnity." In the course of the bargain I offered to accept our liability in that respect. And why should we not? Are we strong enough to make the British Government pay an indemnity on leaving this country? This is a back-to-back arrangement, with no bad feeling over it, with good feeling and a better spirit between the two countries, a better spirit with our Northern fellow-countrymen, and the first evidence of it appeared in the papers yesterday. We have been taxed with not having made accommodation for our friends in the North who have suffered. How was accommodation made here? There are four Parties in the House. Is there any Party that will say that if they did not get all that they wanted and all that they made a claim for, they did not get fair play when they put up a case to us? If the Nationalists of the North attend that Parliament in the same spirit as that in which you have come here, if they make their case and if they do not receive justice, then it is time enough for you to say to me that there has been no success in this, that there was no good feeling and good-will. But until that time comes, every good Irishman who loves this country, every man who wishes to see this country placed on a sound foundation, everyone who looks to the nation instead of to the individual or party, must, if he is an honest man, support this as the best thing that could be done under the circumstances.