ESTIMATES—VOTE ON ACCOUNT (RESUMED).
Contributions 203–417 of 417. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Certainly, one thing at a time, please. The judges, we are told, cost less to-day than they did when the Free State came into being. Well, I should hope that they would, because the country to-day is not the same, in area, wealth and population, as it was at that time. But we are not told how much less they cost. We are told that there are certain judges now only drawing so much per annum, but, on the other hand, we are not told what it cost us to dismiss the other judges. I want to know what is the net figure, at what cost did we dismiss judges and replace them by others, and whether in regard to that cost it was worth the difference.
Comment on this
I do not think I can find it there. If the Minister can find it I will be very pleased.
Comment on this
It is not your job, but if you cannot sustain interruptions you had better refrain from making them.
Comment on this
I want to get them from the Minister. The point is that the judges were dismissed. The actual sitting judges may be costing us less to-day, but the point that is put up on the other side of the account is: What did it cost us to dismiss the other judges? I was asked to talk about R.M.'s. The R.M.'s were very few in numbers, and for political reasons, we were told to-day, they had to be dismissed. Well, I am not quarrelling with the dismissal of the R.M.'s, but the R.M.'s used to be known as removable magistrates; they were sometimes known as resident magistrates, but mostly as removable magistrates. But what I do object to is the dismissal of one form of removable magistrate and replacing him with another; what I do object to is dismissing one removable magistrate who was dismissable at the will of one Government and replacing him by a quasi judge who may be removed at the will of this Government.
Comment on this
The District Justice is, of course, removable only on the joint certificate of the Chief Justice and the Attorney-General.
Comment on this
Their salaries come up on the Estimates. They are not in the same position, as regards removal, as judges. Judges cannot be removed except by a resolution——
Comment on this
Will the Deputy allow me? They can be dismissed only on the joint certificate of the Chief Justice and the Attorney-General that they have been guilty of such impropriety in office as would warrant their discharge.
Comment on this
Well, my point is that the District Justices are not in the same position as judges. The District Justices were called judges during the debate on the Courts of Justice Act, but they are not now judges. They are not in the same position as the judges, because their salaries come up every year on the Estimates. They are removable by other means.
Comment on this
I said by the Government. If I am wrong in that statement I withdraw it, but my objection is as to the character. They are still removable.
Comment on this
I am sure some people would like to remove them. I do not say that I would. I did not catch what the Minister for Finance said. Perhaps he would like to make a fourth speech. The attitude is: "There is the Estimate; the Government cannot help it; we have been landed with this baby; we had nothing to do with its production"—an argument with which I entirely disagree—and "There it has got to be." In fact, the attitude of the Minister for Finance is that any reduction in this Estimate would be nothing less than a reductio ad absurdum. That is practically what he has said in regard to the proposed inquiry. That is what he has said in regard to suggestions made by Deputies for reductions here and there. There is not one scintilla of chance, according to Ministerial utterances, of any possible reduction in any item of this expenditure. The Minister did say that one of the reasons for the swelling of this estimate was that they had to get rid of old prejudices. I would suggest that one of the means of reducing this expenditure would be to get rid of new prejudices. I would suggest that, in the future, not as in the past, they should be less hasty in regard to their legislative proposals, in regard to the creation of new services, and in regard to the discharging of men who had done their duty well. In regard to that point, I certainly would like once more to state that I have no quarrel with the salaries as paid to civil servants. I have no quarrel with the amount that is paid to the higher civil servants, and certainly I have no quarrel with the amounts paid to those on a lower scale. But I have a quarrel with salaries paid to people that I think the State could do without. I think that there are certain offices——
Comment on this
A few Parliamentary secretaries, for instance, are not, I think, indispensable. In regard to the Civil Service itself, I desire to join with what has been said by other speakers—because I do not think it is fair to state that there has been any attack upon civil servants themselves—and to express my admiration and regard for the Civil Service and for the work it is rendering. I also desire to place upon record my view that the Civil Service would be costing us less to-day if we had not dismissed some of the competent men who were in it and replaced them by others, and if we had not had, perhaps, to swell the numbers by introducing fresh legislation. These are what I shall be told, and what I stand for, as my criticisms at this stage on this Vote on Account. I take it that if this amendment is passed it will not mean that the Estimates will be reduced by one iota. What we are virtually asked to do by this amendment is to say whether we are in favour of the Government policy in regard to this expenditure or whether we are not. If the amendment is carried and if the Government chooses, at a future date, to bring forward another Vote on Account, and to amend their hand in the meantime—they need not provide for the same amount; they might alter it; they might modify it, they might do various things—it will not prevent the country from going on. It has been suggested that if this amendment is carried it will prevent the country from being carried on for the next few months.
I say it will do nothing of the kind. This is only a Vote on Account. Those who vote in favour of the amendment will only be voting to show, not that they believe there can be a great reduction in expenditure, but that there could be reduction in it. They will also be voting for the purpose of asking for something in the nature of an inquiry into the administration of the services. I must confess that going down through the list before us it is very difficult to discover where reductions can be made. I say that candidly. I see many things there that must be provided for. There are pensions of various sorts and descriptions, as well as legacies left to us from the Treaty under Article X. I see in the list a hundred and one things that we cannot touch, but, even so, I ask, are we at rock-bottom in these Estimates? That is the question that we have to ask ourselves to-night, whether we cannot by some means reduce these Estimates somewhat. If we can do that, then this debate will have done this service, that it will have focussed public opinion upon the necessity of going thoroughly into our whole system of revenue and expenditure and of seeing whether we cannot in the future do somewhat better than we have been doing, and carry on this country as it should be carried on according to its taxable capacity.
Comment on this
I move the adjournment of the House to 8.15 so as to enable Deputies to get their tea. I think the President's idea is to carry on to 10.30. It is only right then, I think, that we should have an adjournment until 8.15.
Comment on this
I am sorry to have to disagree with Deputy Johnson in his speech yesterday backing up the Minister for Finance with regard to this Estimate and to the amount of money that the citizens of the Saorstát have to provide. He backed him up to the extent that the only thing he found fault with was that there was not a sufficient amount for the unemployed.
Comment on this
I would like to tell the Deputy that is why I am going to vote against the motion and for the amendment because there is not provision made for the unemployed.
Comment on this
Because there is, you mean? Well, then, the Press report you wrongly. To my mind, great retrenchments could be made in the Government services. We are asked to provide, approximately, a sum of twenty-five and three-quarter millions for the upkeep of this State. Some of us who were out in the fight for freedom—it is all right for Deputies to laugh who were not out—advocated that a sum of eight millions would be quite sufficient to run this country. In 1903, when the late Mr. Arthur Griffith introduced Sinn Féin, he advocated the same thing. It is estimated that for twenty-six counties it will take approximately twenty-five millions to run them. The Ulster Government costs about seven and a half millions. When the citizens of Ireland made sacrifices for a free sovereign, independent country, they did so with the best intentions in order to allow the citizens to live cheaper. A free country, to my mind, is one where you have education for your children. I hold that you can have great retrenchment in the Government Departments, and if you want to reduce taxation you must start at the head. The Minister for Local Government has succeeded in getting every local authority in the Saorstát to reduce the wages of the workers down to starvation point for the sake of economy. But while he did that, he did not reduce the wages of his own staff. We have ten Ministers, and every Minister has two or three secretaries. There is a huge staff of private secretaries. One is paid £1,200 a year; the assistant private secretary is paid £1,000, and then you have an assistant to the assistant at £100 a year, and so on down along. The majority of these could be done without. The time has come when we should call for economy.
The taxation in the Saorstát amounts to £8 per head of the population. In the olden times the people were completely against taxation. I think it is time that the present rate of taxation was reduced. The Governor-General's establishment costs over £26,000 a year, while Deputies and Senators, with the officials, cost £141,850 or so. We have a large number of Deputies, as well as Senators, whose election did not cost them as much as a 2d. stamp, as they were nominated by the Government in 1922, who could show good example to the people of the country by forfeiting their salaries. Some of the Senators are drawing pensions from the British Government, which we have to pay. I think it would be a patriotic thing on the part of these representatives if they were to forfeit their salaries. Their doing so would help to bring down the high cost of living and they would be acting as patriots.
There are many ways in which retrenchment could be made. The Minister for Finance has three or four secretaries. I think he could do with a less number than that. The President has £500 a year for the use of his own motor car. Well, a poor county surveyor is lucky if he gets £100 a year. The President has a salary of £2,500 a year. I believe he is entitled to £5,000 a year because he succeeded in making the Saorstát after the death of President Griffith. We must bear in mind, however, that we are out for economy. Every Deputy must realise that you cannot expect the sprats and the smaller fry to pay for the luxuries of the bigger fish, and by the bigger fish I mean the higher officials in the Government offices.
We are the common people. At least I am one of the common people, and I am not ashamed to be associated with them. But if the people are overtaxed how can they live in this Free State? We are supposed to be free. We fought for freedom but we have got slavery and high taxation in every county in Ireland. There is not a county council in Ireland that has not mortgaged the rates for years to come. Why did they do that? To enable the Free State to function. Now we have got a Free State Government, and I ask Deputies if they are going to listen to the cry of the people and get the burden of taxation reduced. If the taxation is not reduced then the best thing that can be done is to give a subsidy to the emigrants going to foreign countries. It would be better to give £50 to every young man and woman between 18 and 21 years of age, to pay their passage to a foreign country and tell them that you have no room for them in this State, than to keep up the taxation as it is at present. I do not agree with the views expressed by Deputy McCullough. His idea was that the Government had done everything in its power to facilitate the people. I do not agree with that. I think that every Minister in the Government could make retrenchments in his Department. What do we want a Department of External Affairs for? What are we gaining by it? What do we gain by the Minister for Fisheries or his Department? The Boards of Fishery Conservators control the Department of Fisheries, and the foreign representatives control the Department of External Affairs. I think it is about time we realised that we are gaining nothing by these Departments.
On this Vote I wish to raise a question concerning the distress prevailing not only in my own constituency, but all over the Saorstát. We have numbers of people who have to go without food and numbers of children who cannot go to a place of worship for want of clothes. Women cannot do their marketing owing to their impoverished condition. These people are citizens of this State who sent Deputies to this Dáil. They are in a more impoverished state to-day than they were when England ruled in this country. It is our duty to try and relieve these people and place them in a position to earn a livelihood so that they can provide food and clothes for themselves and their children. We have a Catholic Government, and yet they allow their fellow-Catholics to live under such conditions that they cannot go to a place of worship for want of clothing. What do the Government do? They levy taxation to the extent of eight pounds per head on individuals who are trying to exist under these conditions.
I should also like to say something with regard to the friends of Ministers getting jobs. Ministers may probably take offence at that. I can prove that there are numbers of friends of Ministers in high positions who are not qualified to occupy these positions. I make that accusation, and I can prove it. If they are qualified now, they only qualified within the last six months. What do the people of the Saorstát think?
Comment on this
Are they going to be represented by a Government who say they will not do this or that? The Minister for Finance has declared that no retrenchment can be made in any Department. He has declared in effect: "This is the Estimate put forward by me and I am going to stand by it; and the Deputies behind me, when I press the button, must vote for it." That is his attitude. He forgets that the people are out for economy, that they want lower taxes and lower rates, and that they want the cost of living reduced. The cost of living cannot be reduced, unless the example is shown by the Government. The example must come from the top. They should do away with the secretaries to Ministers and save money in that way. The position of Governor-General should also be done away with. The Treaty has been amended in regard to the boundary in order that the present boundary should be the boundary for ever. If the Treaty can be amended in that way, why can it not be amended in order to do away once and for all with the position of Governor-General and thus save £26,706 per year? We have ten Ministers, each of whom has two or three secretaries. Why not abolish one secretary in each case and save ten thousand pounds per year? That would be £36,706 saved. We are told these things cannot be done—that they are only small things.
Then we have Senators who were nominated by members of the Dáil and who are drawing £360 per year. It did not cost them a penny to become Senators and I think it is good enough to give them the honour of the title without paying them. There are also Deputies belonging to the Government Party and the Farmers' Party who could live without drawing the £360 per year. Let them forfeit that in the interests of the people. Let them come down to realities and show they are genuine patriots. As the President said in 1919, if we want to be free everyone must be a patriot and fight for Ireland. Let these Deputies follow that advice. Let Senators and Deputies who can afford it forfeit their salaries in the interests of the State. Let the President appeal to his Ministers to do without one of their secretaries and thus save £10,000.
Deputy McCullough criticised the Press for publishing the actual facts concerning expenditure. I think the Press should be congratulated for letting the people know the true facts and letting the people see how the inner circle is worked. In the Parliament at Westminster there was a ring, and nobody knew anything only those who were in the ring. Deputy Byrne is not here now to bear me out in that. He knew the ring was there. We want to show that there is no ring in the Saorstát Government. Every Deputy is as much responsible for anything that is done as the Ministers and must hear the burden of responsibility as much as the Ministers. There is no ring as far as the Saorstát Government is concerned. It is time that the President should look to the real interests of the people and cater not for the classes, but for the masses of the people, including the working-classes.
Comment on this
I did not intend to intervene in this discussion, but Deputy Gorey wanted to know what my opinion was in connection with salaries, whether it coincided with that of Deputy Johnson or not. At the moment, I am not concerned with the question of salaries. I am going to vote for the amendment as a protest against the financial policy of the Government. For the past few years the Government has had no consideration for the poor, or the needy, or the working-classes. They reduced the old age pension by ten per cent. and the Farmers' Party and a large majority of the Independent Party supported that reduction.
Comment on this
All our ills are not going to be removed by a reduction in taxation. We are all in favour of a reduction in taxation. The Government may not have done what they should have done, but what have the farmers done for the country? What have the independent business men done for the country? Deputy Gorey says the workers will not work. I say the workers will work, but they cannot get it. Take the case of the Carlow Beet Factory. I have been canvassing people to get them to grow beet in that district. We find that the farmers in County Carlow, and probably in Deputy Gorey's constituency, are not sufficiently interested in their own business, from the financial point of view, to say nothing of the patriotic point of view, to grow beet for which they could secure about £50 per Irish acre. That is the whole trouble. The farmers say, "Everything is wrong. The Government is doing this, the Republicans are doing that, and the business men are swelling their profits at our expense; we are paying all debts and all rates; we are paying everything." Yet that is the condition of affairs in the County Carlow. Experiments in beet-growing in my own locality have shown that a return of £50 per Irish acre can be got from growing beet. The sugar content of that beet was shown to be 18.3 per cent. That was three points above the minimum for which they would receive fifty-four shillings per ton, and they would get two-and-sixpence for each point over fifteen.
Comment on this
They got exactly ten points to the statute acre, 54/- a ton, and then the farmers say that they want a guaranteed price from the Government. I am not standing up for the Government. I am going to vote against their policy in connection with the draining of the Barrow, the Shannon scheme, and several other schemes. The farmers ought to be more interested in their own business—the development of agriculture—because the only solution of the problem in this country is increased productivity. That is the way to reduce taxation. There is no other means of doing it. What is the position of the country? Our small and large farmers are making a doctor out of one son, a clergyman out of another, a solicitor out of another, and they leave the poor Paddy or Biddy at home to work the land. There is only one policy that will bring about the upliftment of the people, and that is the cultivation of the land. There are sixteen million acres in the Saorstát, and out of that one and a half million acres are under the plough. Then we talk about farming.
Comment on this
I want to make a remark that I have made very frequently, and that, I think, everybody must have heard. If Deputy Doyle has anything to say for or against the Government, I would be glad to hear it. I do not think we are here to criticise the farmers in general. What is before us is, the policy of the Minister for Finance, and anything said against him will be in order.
Comment on this
I am sorry I had been out of order, but I think most of the speaking in connection with this business was almost out of order, too. The financial policy of the present Government certainly is in no way in accordance with the wishes of the people of this country. There is no question at all about that. The Press and the people are against taxation: they want the reduction of taxation. I have no consideration for the Press, no more than anybody else, because the price of the "Irish Independent" is 400 per cent. above the pre-war price. Let them first put their house in order and then they can ask the Government to put their house in order.
Your policy in the past has been a damnable one for the poor of this country. You have reduced the old age pensions. You fixed a wage of 32/- a week for the Shannon scheme, while we pay salaries of from £1,000 to £2,000 a year to officials. If the old age pensioners and the men working on the Shannon scheme have to live on a miserable pittance, I fail to see why the well-paid, well-groomed, and well-fed officials in Government Buildings cannot submit to a reduction of 10 per cent. I intend to vote for the amendment.
Comment on this
I am not going to vote for the amendment, because I consider if this amendment were passed we would take too much money from the Government. I consider that they have asked for just sufficient to enable them to carry on the functions of Government during the next financial year. It has been suggested to me that I should vote for the amendment in order to show my dissatisfaction with the policy of the Government. I am dissatisfied with the policy of the Government, but I think it is the usual practice in Parliamentary matters to move a small reduction in order to show your dissatisfaction and I do not think that I would be true to myself or to my constituents if I were to vote for this amendment, because the sum involved is too large. There has been a great deal of talk during the past three or four days in connection with the salaries of civil servants. A great deal has been said about civil servants and their work which I think is unworthy of this House. Any civil servants I have come in contact with are very hardworking men. Some of them I know intimately, especially in the Local Government Department, and I know that there are men there who have to bring their work home at night in order to finish it. In so far as offices being overstaffed are concerned, to my mind, in many offices there are not sufficient men to carry on. My dissatisfaction with the Government lies in the fact that there is no provision, good, bad, or indifferent made in the Estimates this year for the relief of unemployment. The position is very little better than it was last year, if it is better at all, and I cannot understand for a moment how the Government could adopt such a callous attitude as to bring in an estimate, without making any provision, good, bad, or indifferent for the unemployed. That is my principal objection to the Estimates as presented, and I am not going to say any more on them as the debate has gone on long enough.
I understand that during my absence on Tuesday night Deputy O'Mara, in his new-found zeal for his constituents and the country in general, made an attack on me. He told the Dáil that I was not in my place. It is very seldom that I am out of my place and my record of attendance here will compare very favourably with that of any member of this House. I happen to be twelfth in the Divisions in the last session and Deputy O'Mara had nought after his name. Deputy O'Mara stated that since I became Mayor of Wexford seven years ago, a record that I am proud of, that Wexford decayed. It is quite easy for anybody who does not know what he is talking about to get up in this Dáil and make such a statement, and Deputy O'Mara evidently does not know what he is talking about. He talked about shipping in Wexford. Shipping in Wexford, unfortunately, is on the decay for a considerable number of years, and since the amalgamation of railways a great deal of the shipping that was coming into Wexford has been diverted to Rosslare. I have been endeavouring to get the Minister for Industry and Commerce to make some adjustments that will enable Wexford to get a fair share of its shipping. So far as the foundries in Wexford are concerned, I helped the proprietors there in every way possible to secure trade. I am waiting for proof from Deputy O'Mara—and I defy him to give it—that any action of mine, at any time, is responsible for the decay in the trade of the Wexford foundries. Deputy O'Mara has been out of this House for a considerable time. He taunted me with being out of it on Tuesday evening.
Comment on this
I did not, sir. I said I was sorry that the Deputy was not present.
Comment on this
You would have been sorrier if I had been here. As I said, Deputy O'Mara has found new zeal and energy, but I have an idea that he did not find them until an "Independent" reporter called upon him and asked him for his views on the bacon industry. Then his head swelled sufficiently to bring him to this House to put down an economy motion. He taunted me with having no interest in his motion. Neither had I, because I realised, and I have realised it more since he dropped his motion, that it was simply window-dressing and eye-wash. He certainly must not have had much interest in it himself, or he would not have withdrawn it yesterday evening when his time came to move it. Deputy O'Mara was out of this House for practically twelve months, like a sulky child, I understand, against his party. I would suggest to him that if he drew his salary for that twelve months he ought to pay it back to the Exchequer.
Comment on this
I want to explain, for the information of Deputy Corish, that his understanding of what the reduction in the Vote would be is not in accordance with my intention. Efforts were made in the usual clever way by members on the Ministerial Benches, to inveigle me into a statement with regard to the actual proportion of the proposed reduction of this Vote and the total of the Estimates. I wish to say that in putting down the motion for the reduction I had no intention to fix any exact figure. The Vote as it stands is really a token vote, and I am asking the Dáil to vote on it as a token vote and as a vote of disapproval of the financial policy of the Minister, as expressed in his Estimates and in his statements here yesterday and to-day. I intended at one time to traverse the arguments made by the Minister and others, but now I only intend to deal with a few headings or with the main points we have tried to bring out. I maintain that the Minister has evaded the real issue in regard to this Vote. The real issue that we are putting up is the capacity of the country to pay. We on the Farmers' Benches are convinced that the present taxation is really greater than the people are able to meet. We say that from personal knowledge and because of our information with regard to the main industry of the country and with regard to the financial and economic condition of the people engaged in that industry. Attempts have been made to show that we have endeavoured to prove that the whole economic depression existing in the country, with particular reference to agricultural economic depression, is due to overtaxation.
I have never said, nor have I ever heard it said on these Benches, that the taxation of the country is the only reason for the economic depression existing in the country. Nor do I maintain that taxation is the reason, or the main reason, for the economic depression in the country. I recognise that economic depression is caused by conditions apart largely from taxation, and on account of the conditions prevailing throughout the world, and that the conditions are not unique in Ireland. But we do maintain that expenditure, and consequent taxation, is an important factor in the present depression. We do maintain that the position of the farmer, and, through the farmer, the position of industry and commerce and trade and the condition of employment is influenced to a large extent by taxation. We are of opinion, and we think that the Minister might deal with it, that taxation must be reduced if the agricultural industry is to go ahead.
The Minister, as is usual with him when he is caught, so to speak, in a tight corner, and when he is in an unpleasant situation, and has to meet criticism that touches, apparently, rather raw spots in his make-up, resorts, as usual, to a rather insolent type of address to Deputies in this House. I submit that the Minister has not made his case stronger by throwing insults and taunts across the House, and I call the attention of the House to the fact that this is not the first time that we have had insolence of this kind from the Minister. Deputies will remember a very unpleasant scene that arose in this House before owing to what I may call a very ill-mannered remark which fell from the Minister for Finance. We are taunted with futility. Futility is not a crime, but I maintain that glaring indiscretion on the part of the Minister is a crime, and we have had several instances of glaring indiscretion on the part of the Minister and most flagrant breaches of good taste.
We could call the attention of the House to the statement made by the Minister on the occasion of the breakdown of the Boundary Commission. The House is cognisant of the statement made on that occasion by the Minister in reference to Mr. Justice Feetham, acknowledged by every man of good feeling and good sense to be altogether beyond the bounds of good taste and altogether beyond the type of criticism that should be used by a Minister towards a responsible judge who came to this country to do his duty honestly, as we think, on behalf of the Boundary Commission. We know that the Minister made a statement that he was going to split the Cabinet from top to bottom.
Comment on this
May I say, just as this is mentioned, that that statement is entirely untrue and entirely false. I never said any such thing. I never made any such statement in my life.
Comment on this
The statement the Deputy said I made, the statement that you have just attributed to me.
Comment on this
I do not contradict statements made about me in the Press. I have more respect for myself.
Comment on this
I say no more about the Minister's action. I leave it to the House. The Minister knows what I refer to.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy is referring to, but it is improper for him to say that he knows I made a statement when he really knows nothing about it or whether I did or not; but it is typical of Deputy Heffernan. He constantly makes statements here and when challenged and asked for his authority he is found to have none.
Comment on this
That statement was made in the Press and was not contradicted, and I consider that is reasonable authority.
Comment on this
In any event a statement made by the Minister for Finance on any matter relating to the Boundary Commission has no relevance to the Vote on Account.
Comment on this
Ministers who make statements of that kind are not competent to carry on the business of this House properly.
Comment on this
The Minister thinks that he is meeting the argument with regard to the Geddes Committee by saying that it is silly and futile. He is fond of making statements of that kind. I wonder if such statements are argument? In the opinion of the Minister the suggestion is silly and futile, but in the opinion of the House is it silly and futile? When the British Government set up the Geddes Commission did they regard the suggestion for that Commission as silly and futile? I am taunted with being a man of one idea, because I happen to be consistent. That is a crime we cannot accuse the Minister of. I am a man of one idea because I cannot do as the Minister suggests. He can go down the country and make speeches and say one thing, and come up here and say another thing in this House. Consistency, apparently, is not one of the virtues of the Ministry. We are not imputing anything to the Civil Service. We accept the Minister's statement that the civil servants are all they ought to be, but we are faced with the problem that we are taxed up to a capacity beyond the power of the country to meet, and if such is the case we maintain that we will have to face the facts. Now we are told that we will not face the facts and will not make suggestions, that we will not deal with matters of policy, and that we are lacking in moral courage on the Farmers' Benches. We are prepared at any time to make suggestions with regard to matters of policy and with regard to cutting portion of the services. We have no hesitation in making such suggestions, but we do not think that this is the time to make them, and we know that when we are asked to make such suggestions we are asked to make them on the spot so that we may make hasty, ill-considered suggestions that can be torn to pieces by the Ministry. We have made suggestions with regard to the reduction of Votes. We have put them to the House more than once, We have proposed that the salaries of the Parliamentary Secretaries should be reduced. We have put that to the House and we have been beaten. We have supported the suggestion of Deputy Johnson that the salary of the Governor-General should be reduced and we were beaten, and if we propose any further reductions they will be put to a vote of the House and Ministers will be supported by the loyal party behind them and our suggestions will be defeated. Now a great deal of play has been made with the question of policy, and that the House is to be over-ridden in matters of policy and in matters of this kind. I read twice the terms of reference of the Geddes Commission, and I suggest that similar terms of reference would satisfy us.
They were not accepted by the Minister or the other Ministers arguing on behalf of the Government, and they were not prepared to give this Commission powers to deal with matters of policy. We know that a committee of this kind, if set up, would deal with the details of departmental organisation and personnel and would find itself inevitably up against matters of policy before it could achieve any economies worth talking about, but there was no intention, and well the Minister knew it, that it should override or be superior to the House in these matters. It would simply report to the House, and the House would then, sitting in session, and having full knowledge of its responsibilities, deal with the question of policy. We know that a reduction in salaries will not involve any great reduction in taxes, but I am not personally satisfied that a thorough overhauling of the services and departments of State by an independent committee would not effect economies, that re-organisations could not be brought about, that changes in the personnel and departmental methods could not be made, and economies thereby effected. In addition, we think that the committee, viewing things in proper perspective, and not from the point of view of those on Farmers' benches or the Labour benches, but in an independent manner, would be able to tell us that it would be possible and advisable in the circumstances with which we are faced to make cuts in particular services. They could suggest that such a service is redundant. They might say "You need not wipe out the whole service but a portion of it; you can cheese-pare in certain directions." As a result of its recommendations we would be able to achieve something in the way of economy. If that committee is set up we on the Farmers' benches would have no hesitation in going to it and stating what services we are prepared to jettison—what services must in the financial conditions of the country be jettisoned. We have got no hope from the Minister. We are faced with the problem that we have a prospect of taxation for the coming year as high as in the past year, and we have Estimates which are really over £2,000,000 higher than payments out of revenue in 1924-25. We are faced with the problem of asking the taxpayer to meet these Estimates in the year of the greatest depression that has fallen on this country for a very long time. We do not believe the depression in agriculture is a thing of a year. It is probably a thing of many years. We will be faced with that possibility for many years, and with the probability that the agriculturists and the taxpayers, owing to the depression, will not be able to meet the demands made on them. The Minister for Agriculture, as a matter of good tactics, was put up to talk to us. When he gets up to talk one is always in doubt as to whether we are going to have a cooing turtle dove or a petty sessions lawyer. Yesterday we had the cooing dove. He was as mild as mother's milk. Everything Deputy Baxter and I said was more or less right. We had agreement on the fundamentals and on the premises of our argument. The farming industry is being greatly hampered by high taxation; it was advisable taxation should be reduced and the farming community would be helped if taxation could be reduced. We started with that premise. We were then asked if we would advise a reduction in the Agricultural Vote. That was a clever move. We were taunted with insincerity. Why was not the Minister for Defence put up to defend the Army Vote; the Minister for External Affairs to defend the Vote for External Affairs; the Minister for Fisheries to defend the Fishery Vote?
Comment on this
We want you to do it now. It is suitable tactics to put up the Minister for Agriculture to ask us what reductions we would accept in the agricultural vote. The farmers would be floored then. We want to say this in answer to the taunts that we are avoiding responsibility, that we are actuated by unworthy motives. We tell the Minister we are prepared to face the country on this question. Let the President dissolve Parliament and face the country at a general election on his financial policy, and we will face him.
Comment on this
It was not on this issue. We are told the people are not thinking. We tell the President that the people are thinking, and not thinking favourably of the Government. The people do not approve of the financial policy of the Government, as the President may find to his detriment if he puts it to the people. If he goes to the people they will show him and the Minister for Finance that they do not approve of their financial policy. We had a speech from Deputy Egan. I notice he is very likely to come along as a kind of supernumerary supporter of the Ministers when things are beginning to look shaky. He is a very excellent apologist for the Government. I do not take Deputy Egan's support of the financial arrangements of the Government in any great seriousness. I do not think that Deputies who are personally interested in subsidies, which subsidies have to come from the pockets of the taxpayers, can be very interested in the reduction of taxation.
Comment on this
I think when Deputy Heffernan reconsiders that remark he will withdraw it. That remark conveys to me a very plain implication, which I think no good purpose would be served by explaining. Deputy Heffernan might reconsider it.
Comment on this
If the Ceann Comhairle will convey to me what my remark conveys to him, and if it conveys anything which is unparliamentary and that should not be used in this House, I will withdraw it. I must state by way of explanation that I did not mean to impute anything dishonest or dishonourable to Deputy Egan What I intended to convey was that Deputy Egan is a director of a factory which is receiving subsidies or interested in subsidies. Now, subsidies are part of the Government expenditure, and help to swell our Estimates. The Deputy is in such a position that his defence of the Ministerial position with regard to finance can hardly be taken as very effective.
Comment on this
Might I be allowed to explain that the matter of a subsidy for the sugar-beet industry had been arranged by this House long before I had any financial interest in the matter. I might also explain that though the farmers of the country had the opportunity of investing their money they did not invest one single penny in this industry. I make no apology to Deputy Heffernan or anyone else for investing my money in an Irish industry.
Comment on this
I put it to Deputy Heffernan that the plain meaning is that the Deputy is personally interested in the expenditure of Government money and therefore cannot exercise his rights properly in the Dáil in defending Government expenditure. I think the suggestion wholly unwarrantable, and I think if it was allowed to be made in the Dáil it would render debate impossible.
Comment on this
I do not like to make any statements in the Dáil which I would not be prepared to make outside. If the statement conveys that idea to you, or to the Dáil, I think the honourable and the honest thing is to withdraw the statement and I withdraw it. In winding up I want to point out that we put forward an amendment to the Vote on Account as a protest against the whole policy of the Government with regard to finance as indicated by the Estimates placed in our hands. The refusal of the Government to meet our demand for a Geddes Committee deals with only one portion of the demand we are making. I may say that the amendment can be looked at from different angles. This is our angle. There may be other angles, but from our angle I am going to ask the Dáil to support us. I am asking Deputies on the Independent Benches who, in different places—the Chambers of Commerce—are constantly harping on the necessity for economy, to support us. It is up to them now to support the assertions and the statements they have made. They can do so by their votes.
Comment on this
I have already explained about the amount. I am dealing with it as a matter of principle. I am putting it to the Deputies on the Labour Benches, if they are satisfied that the provision made in the Estimates meets with their requirements, and if they are satisfied to have £26,000 for the Governor-General while the Minister for Local Government has reduced the wages of road workers.
Comment on this
I did, but I did not approve of the Governor-General's salary. I ask these Deputies if they are satisfied with the provision made for the relief of distress, which is £20,000 under that of last year. If they are satisfied with the Estimates placed in their hands they can give additional support to the financial policy of the Ministry by voting with the Ministry.
Comment on this
I intervene in view of the concluding sentences that have fallen from the Deputy who has moved the amendment, and in view of the statements that were made by Deputy Hewat and Deputy Redmond. The concluding words from Deputy Heffernan make a case for concentration against the Government forces on the part of one Deputy who thinks that the expenditure could be reduced slightly. An appeal is made to another section to vote against it, because there is not enough given, and to his own party simply to follow up the ramp there is about economy. After two days' ramp I have heard from Deputy Redmond a suggestion that the Ministry of Fisheries is an expensive institution and the proposal, if his recommendations were to be taken, is that the expenses of that Department should be reduced. By taking off £1,700, and I presume by including £1,000 or £1,200 for a Parliamentary Secretary, he is to make a saving of £700. I make him a present of the sum saved in respect to the Minister for External Affairs. £1,400 of a saving! I am afraid even the saving that Deputy Redmond contemplates would be discounted by a charge that would fall on the funds by reason of a claim one of the two gentlemen I have mentioned has under the Military Service (Pensions) Act. The total sum saved by reason of Deputy Redmond's economies would be £1,000 per annum.
Deputy Sir J. Craig's statements attracted me in connection with the expensive nature of the medical services in the Army. They are expensive, and I think the reason of that expensive incidence was explained here last year. It is not fair to say that the cost of that service should be compared to the real strength of the Army, because other work besides that of attendance on the soldiers and officers of the Army has to be done by the medical officers. When I was Minister for Defence, I know that there were at least three Boards, each one of which would require one or two medical officers in almost constant attendance to deal with claims in respect to the Wounds (Pensions) Act. Much the same thing can be stated in respect to a number of civil servants whose names are included in the return and who would appear to be doing no other work than acting as secretary to a Minister. One of those in my own case has acted on three Committees, and there have been many occasions on which I required his services that I was not able to avail of them by reason of his attendance at one of these particular Committees. If we were to pay attention to this ramp that has been started on economy, this brainless, useless, nonconstructive portrayal of the country's infirmities—it is nothing short of it— we would come to the conclusion that this country was bankrupt. Is it bankrupt?
Comment on this
I am prepared to make that speech again, to parse it sentence by sentence, and go over every word of it. This is poor country, yes; bankrupt, no, certainly not, no sign of bankruptcy. It would be bankrupt if all the people of the country were the same as the Deputy who has just spoken—bankrupt in intelligence, bankrupt in initiative, bankrupt in everything of use to the country. The other evening when I taxed a Deputy about comparing the Civil Service here with other countries, he said that was not his business. He said: "It is your business." That is the critic! "If you can prove to me that our Civil Service is not more expensive than that of Germany, France or Denmark I am satisfied." The Deputy seeks to get a majority by a combination that could not possibly maintain a Government. If the three Parties he has invited to effect this particular economy were to succeed and were to remove the present Government from office, will they form a Government?
Comment on this
I challenge any Minister on the Government Benches to resign his seat and I will resign mine. I represent two counties. That is a fair test to put this issue to the people in order to see whether the Government have the people at their back. There is no use living in a fool's paradise.
Comment on this
I congratulate the Deputy on his return from the wilderness. I am glad to see he is in good health. He has been a long time absent from the House. He has been occupying some of the platforms in the country in connection with his condemnation of the policy and the expense of the Government.
Comment on this
That is the point. Like the Duke of Plazza Toro, he has led on his army from behind.
Comment on this
The Duke of Plazza Toro was a general who was famous for his military achievements, but he preferred to lead his army from behind. This is the place for the criticism.
Comment on this
I never observed the Deputy's contribution to these criticisms last year during the two or three months the Estimates were under discussion here.
Comment on this
The proposal now is that on the head of this ramp we are to have a general election. Is that not the proposal?
Comment on this
Now we know. It is office we want, not an economic Government. It is office we want when the work is done, when the risks have been taken. I will cite one or two economies there are here——
Comment on this
The Deputy should go out of the House or occupy some other seat if he cannot conduct himself.
Comment on this
I do not think there is any necessity to say anything. Deputies know what I was going to say. Perhaps on that basis we could get along.
Comment on this
Deputy Hewat's contribution was to the effect that we were probably exceeding the taxable capacity of the country. I failed to gather from Deputy Connor Hogan or Deputy Heffernan what tax they wish to reduce. I heard two speeches. One lasted over an hour and the other might have been prolonged. It was capable of considerable elasticity. I did not hear either of them mention a tax that was hurting or a tax that was grinding. There is no tax on tea. There is a small tax on sugar. There is a tariff imposed with a view to rehabilitating the industrial activity of the country. It was put on for that purpose. It brings in revenue, but revenue was not the purpose for which it was intended. The tax on motors, I am sure, does not affect the people for whom Deputy Connor Hogan or Deputy Heffernan speaks. I am sure that the tax on beer and spirits does not hurt them. I am positive that it is not the case either with the Corporation Profit Tax. I am sure it is not the case with regard to the four shillings in the pound income tax. Then we come back to the one thing.
Comment on this
These are not the taxes that grind and hurt, that hurt the back or the saddle, as the Germans used to say. I want to see what it is.
Comment on this
In that case it means all the super-tax, and the death duties, the cost incidental to changes that might take place on our Stock Exchange. I presume that all these things are included, but if it is put to us here that there is one particular tax that affects the principal industry in the country, that is restricting its advance, that is impeding its progress, and that its removal is going to make matters easier, it is up to the Deputies to tell us what it is.
Comment on this
The Minister for Lands and Agriculture himself acknowledged that all taxation is passed on to the man on the land. The amount for central taxation is £7 6s. 10d. and for local taxation £1 13s. 8d. We have it on the unequivocal authority of the Minister for Lands and Agriculture that it is all passed on to the man on the land in one form or another and therefore affects the cost of production.
Comment on this
We do not like the bayonet. The point of the bayonet hurts when it is driven home. There is no particular tax to which exception is taken. Let us eliminate the beer tax entirely. That will satisfy us. Is that the tax to which exception is taken?
Comment on this
Of course, I listened to a lot of nonsense for the last week and the most of it came from the Deputy and Deputy Connor Hogan.
Comment on this
I deny that. The Minister's was the most futile and abject confession of failure that this House ever listened to, only surpassed by that of the President.
Comment on this
If I am not mistaken the Deputy who has just sat down put himself forward for election at the last County Council elections in Clare.
Comment on this
He contested a seat at the last elections in County Clare for the county council and failed.
Comment on this
That was two years before. At any time I went to Clare I do not think I ever said anything against the Deputy.
Comment on this
There are two points to be considered. The real point which we have not been considering, and which is to a very large extent inseparable from the Estimates, is the means by which we are to discharge the obligations in the Estimates. It is perfectly permissible to go into the second point, because it has been urged that taxation is heavy. There is a particular item, I take it, in the Estimates that was not there last year. I think it will be admitted by Deputy Connor Hogan and Deputy Heffernan that when last year's Budget was announced here they were perfectly satisfied. They might not have expressed themselves as being perfectly satisfied, but it was better than they anticipated, much better. The Deputy shakes his head.
Comment on this
Both; one is inseparable from the other. Deputy Hewat when he made his statement did not really go into the Estimates. He touched on them lightly, and the main point that he made was whether the weight of the Estimates was not too much and if we were getting beyond our taxable capacity. In that connection we are told that agriculture is in a depressed condition. We are told that the railways are in a depressed condition and I think at least one Deputy mentioned that there was a remarkable drop in the deposits in the banks last year. These things getting out will, of course, not increase the confidence or the buoyancy which is almost inseparable from an improvement in business. Since I came into the Dáil this evening I have taken the trouble to look over the Stock Exchange quotations for the banks. I find that in one case a bank's stock was quoted in 1922 between £6 and £7, while the present price is £7. Another bank's stock ran from £16 to £19.
Comment on this
The present quotation of that bank is £20. The quotation for a third bank was between £10 and £12, while the present quotation is £13 10s. Another bank ran from £195 to £238, and at present the price is £275. Another bank was from £4 2s. 5d. to £6 10s., the present price being £7 7s. 6d.
I will not put in the case of the largest reserve, but I will indicate in a moment or two what it amounts to. The total reserves amounted in the case of the four banks to two and a half millions, and the reserves now amount to £3,300,000. The fourth bank put £230,000 to reserve last year and the same amount the previous year. The other figures are slightly complicated by reason of certain adjustments that had to be made, and in order not to mislead anybody, or to take advantage of what Deputy Hewat and Deputy Good know happened in the case of the particular bank in question, I simply put it down at an average of £250,000 a year in the case of that last bank. That is £1,300,000 of an increase in reserves since 1923. There is another well-known firm whose quotations in 1922 were somewhere about 40 and now the equivalent figure is 110.
Comment on this
Will the President tell us about the decrease in deposits and investments in England?
Comment on this
I refer the Deputy to Deputy O'Mara who gave that figure yesterday evening. As the Deputy occupied a very considerable time in addressing the Dáil on two occasions, when he gave those figures, it is really asking me too much to provide Deputy Heffernan with figures that he ought to have heard if he were here when they were given. The case I am putting up is, if there is depression in particular cases, there is also evidence of an increase in the value of the capital of very important institutions in this country.
Comment on this
The drapery trade dividends were a little different; they were a little better in 1922 than now, but this year they are much better than last year.
Comment on this
Deputy Heffernan wants to know about the increase in the value of land. I will tell him about the value of land. There were twenty-five acres of land and a house sold out just beside me. The price at the auction was £2,250; that, with auctioneers' fees and the cost of title, brings the land up to £100 an acre.
Comment on this
I was not aware of that, but I must say this, that it was too much for me. £100 per statute acre is too much for me. When you talk to me about the depressed condition of agriculture that is what puzzles me.
Comment on this
If I were to go round the country asking everybody his opinion about everything I would have no time to do my work here.
Comment on this
Well, bring it up here and sell it here. You will get any price you like for it here.
Comment on this
I need not go to the country to see what particular activity there has been in house building. During the last twelve months something like 1,500 houses have been built by the farmers who have received the Government grant. These are the farmers who, according to Deputy Heffernan, are not able to pay their way, yet they are able to build houses.
Comment on this
We have collected a lot more than the Deputy thought we would. When I look around and compare the roads with the condition they were in in 1922 and 1923, I see a vast improvement; when I look at the returns of motor cars coming into this country and see the numbers rising, then look at Deputy Heffernan, take an occasional look at Deputy McKenna when he visits us here after his long periods of depression, and at Deputy Connor Hogan, I am amazed where the money comes from to buy these cars.
Comment on this
Does the President challenge the statement that depression in agriculture is the worst in the country perhaps in the memory of any man in the House?
Comment on this
I do not believe it. I am perfectly satisfied about one thing. It was often more prosperous, but I do not believe it was never more depressed. If it were the case I would have heard it from Deputy Wilson and Deputy Gorey, the first of the two members of the Farmers' Party who would say it, and they have not said that.
Comment on this
They may say it now when it is too late. Looking at the increase in the building activities —then looking at the huge factories built since the fiscal policy of the country changed, and, viewing those things, I have come to the conclusion that if agriculture were in a really prosperous condition then the success of this country would be almost greater than that of Florida.
Comment on this
Deputy Heffernan will agree that there is not much to be got by keeping his eyes cast down and feeling depressed. There are better times coming. They must come, and they will not come from shirking our responsibilities. We should rather seek to do ourselves the work we were sent here to do and not to look to someone else to do better for us. On that I am perfectly prepared to face the people of this country at any moment.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
On the main motion now before the House, I want to raise a matter which involves a question of Government policy and, as such, is a matter of some importance. I propose to call the attention of the Dáil to a certain number of public servants who were removed from their positions because of complicity, or alleged complicity, in the troubles of 1922 and 1923 and whose cases have been before the Executive Council for almost two years. There has been no decision so far by the Executive Council. I will delay the Dáil for a few moments to give a brief history of the case. We know that during the pre-Truce period, when there was trouble with the British, there were many public servants, among them several teachers, who took an active part one way or another in the fight against the British. They were employed, either actively as Volunteers, or as Intelligence Officers, or in other ways. At the time of the Treaty, not all of them, unlike the bulk of the people, went in a certain way. Some of them took up an attitude of opposition to the Treaty and got involved in the trouble that took place afterwards. Some took an active part against the Government after the Treaty in the civil war. Some got involved, although they did not take an active part, and were arrested or charged, rightly or wrongly, for taking such part. In any case they were interned, and at the general release in 1923 they came out and went back to their schools. They took up the positions they had before the trouble began and continued in them. I raised this matter two or three times during the latter part of 1923 and eventually, about January, 1924, a special Advisory Committee was set up by the Government to call these people before them, to examine into their cases and to see whether or not they should be continued in the public service. For one reason or another, which it is unnecessary to go into now, the Committee did not get to work until August, 1924. They were then called before this Committee. As a result, a certain number of them were allowed back and a certain number were not allowed back.
When it became known in October, 1924, that about twenty of these persons were not to be reinstated, deputations from the organisation which I represent met the Executive Council and met individually several members of the Council, and written communications were sent to them. On one occasion Deputy Johnson accompanied me to see the President on this matter. Representations were made in many directions. On the 9th April last year, a letter was addressed to me saying that the decision, which had been come to, did not preclude the reconsideration of any individual case upon personal application. I want to lay special stress on that point because it is of more importance than appears on the face of it. This personal application for a reconsideration of the case was insisted upon by the Government, and indeed I was rather led to believe that it was insisted on because such personal application by the individuals concerned would indicate that they were prepared personally to submit their cases to the Government and that they would, therefore, be acknowledging the right of the Government either to reinstate or dismiss them. At that time, certain supporters of these people took up the attitude that the ordinary procedure with regard to collective bargaining should be insisted upon, and that the organisation which took up the case of these individuals should take up their case collectively and not individually. That organisation took the view that, seeing that what had occurred and considering the circumstances in which it occurred, it was not unreasonable for the Government to insist that personal application would be made by each individual for reconsideration of his or her particular case and that if any one of them refused to do that, we would not support their case. They took our advice and every one of them made application personally to have their cases reconsidered. I believe they all did so. At any rate, I am only speaking for those who did, and if anyone refused to do so, that is his own concern. I believe they all made that personal application. That was in May or June last year. Some who did not appear before the Committee previously were called before it and three or four of them have since been reinstated.
Up to this moment, however, in spite of repeated representations on our part, no decision has been communicated to either those who are making representations on their behalf, or to the individual teachers as to whether or not their individual applications for reinstatement have been considered. I quite agree that there were many reasons for the delay, and I would hope that the final decision has not suffered by that delay, because we know that the further we get away from the unfortunate incidents of 1922 and 1923 the more likely are we to have a favourable decision on the matter. That is briefly the history of the case. So far as I know, there are some ten or twelve individuals now concerned. Some of them have despaired of any settlement being made in their case and a few have left the country. Some of these men and women are actually working all this time in their schools. They are not in the same position as civil servants. If the Government dismisses a civil servant he leaves his office and goes out of work. That is not their position. They are in their schools and are working there with the approval and consent of their managers, and with the approval of the people in the district. No objections have been made; indeed, a request has been made that they should be reinstated. The Government have refused to recognise them and have refused to pay their salaries.
This is what happened: One of these men was arrested in the autumn of 1922. It was supposed he was arrested because of certain correspondence which he had written. I do not know, and I have no means of knowing, why he was arrested. He was brought to Sligo jail. I put down a question on the matter and I got a communication from the Department of Defence in which it was definitely stated that as they had no evidence to show he was actively engaged in assisting the Irregulars, and as he had signed the usual form which we all know prisoners had to sign, he was released. That communication is on record and the Department have it on their files, because I sent them a copy. He came back to his school, continued teaching and was paid his salary. He got a summons; a summons went out to anybody who happened to be interned or caught in the mesh. He had been paid his salary all along and he did not go before the Advisory Committee. He told me the reason he did not go before the Advisory Committee was that he did not believe he was implicated, inasmuch as he was getting his salary. He was then dismissed. That was on 30th April last, and he has not been paid one penny since. He is continuing his work in the school.
He made personal application for a reconsideration of his case and all this time he is awaiting a decision. There was a case of a man in Dublin, a very active Volunteer in the old days, whose company took a certain attitude in regard to the Treaty, and he went into the Four Courts. At the fall of the Four Courts he was lodged in Mountjoy and was kept there until the general release in 1923. He went straight back to his school and has been working there ever since. The Department have the means of finding out whether or not that man has been engaged in any illegal activities since. So far as I or anyone in any way connected with him can discover, he has not been. He may have made—and possibly did make—a mistake in adopting a certain attitude, but when he was released he went back to the school. The general attitude of the Government may be summed up by a letter which I received from the Minister for Finance early last year. I would ask Deputies to note this letter especially because I believe it states the attitude of the Government fairly. This is an extract from the letter:—
We are really most anxious to overlook past complicity in the Irregular movement wherever there are reasonable grounds for anticipating proper behaviour in the future. That this is our policy is manifest from our action in reinstating men who were actually sentenced to death by courtmartial and had their sentences commuted only by the merest good fortune. On the whole you may take it as certain that the Government in making its decision, although dealing with past offences, was guided no more by the former activities of the teachers concerned than by their present attitude and behaviour. We felt that we could undertake the responsibility of overlooking the complicity of teachers with Irregulars only when their present good dispositions justified us in anticipating proper conduct for the future.
That sums up the Government attitude and it was affirmed on several occasions by the President in the course of interviews. The Government were not concerned with what men had done in the past—they were willing to wipe the slate so far as that was concerned —but they were not satisfied with regard to the future. That is quite an understandable attitude. I will now instance how they judged what the future conduct should be. This man appeared before the Advisory Committee. No indication was given as to the procedure that would be adopted, or whether the men would be tried. Some men regarded it as a kind of trial and they got legal advice as to how they should proceed. The lawyer advised them: "Do not answer any questions which will incriminate you. You are not bound to answer any such questions." I understand some of these men took up the attitude before the Advisory Committee of saying nothing with regard to questions which they thought would incriminate them. It was afterwards held against them that they were not straight with the Committee because they did not answer such questions. Allowance should be made for the fact that these men were going there not knowing what they were expected to do, or what the Government attitude towards them was.
It has been said in some quarters that these men refused to sign an undertaking. My information is that no undertaking was ever put before them; they were never asked to sign an undertaking. These men, since they were released, have been carrying on their work. More than two years have elapsed in some cases. Have any charges been made against them since? Are they guilty of any further illegalities? Is it not now clear to the Government, if it is the future rather than the past they are concerned with, that these men have proved they are quite willing to obey the law and give good service in their positions in future? The managers of the schools—the parish priest in most cases—have approved of the teachers being there, and the people of the district have also approved. No matter what the decision of the Government may be, that state of affairs may go on. The teacher will remain there because it is a matter for the manager and not for the Government or the Department to put him out of the school. Is it better that that man would be under the authority of the Department and the Government, bound to obey the rules and regulations of the Department under the supervision of inspectors, or that he should carry on without any responsibility to the Government, the Department or the inspectors, and have full liberty to do as he likes in the matter of instilling doctrines that he should not instil into the minds of his pupils? Undoubtedly a man will feel he has a grievance if he asks the Government to put him back into his job and the Government reply: "No, we will keep you out; we will not reinstate you." I think it would be a better proposition for the State if the Government were to say: "We will treat you magnanimously. We will put you back into your place and recognise you." That would create a better impression in every way and it would be a surer way of making the man a better citizen than leaving him, as he is now, with a sense of grievance and with a feeling that after all old scores might be forgotten. It was, perhaps, merely by the toss of a button that he was on one side or the other. Fate was, perhaps, too much for him.
There are all these considerations and, in view of the length of time that has elapsed, in view of the advisability of healing old sores and closing old wounds, and in view of the spirit of peace that exists between people who were enemies in 1921-22, I hold it is wrong not to recognise those men who are anxious to come into the service of the State. I hold that teachers are different, in this way, from civil servants. The civil servant, if he is inclined to anti-State activity, is in a position to do a good deal of harm. The teacher is not so directly concerned. I have nothing to say for any teacher who would use his position in the school to do what he should not do. So far as I am concerned, or anybody for whom I speak, the Government is free to take any action that it considers right in connection with any such teacher who so uses his position in the school. I have no sympathy whatever with action of that kind. What I am putting to the Government is that by recognising these men and paying them they will be in a position to control their activities. The claim is made now by practically every member of the organisation with which I am connected that these old sores should be closed, but while that claim is made now, I promise the Government that if it were found that these men offended after reinstatement and recognition, they would have no sympathy whatever among the general body of teachers. The teachers would have regard to the fact that the Government, having the right to dismiss and dispense with the services of these people—a right which I do not deny—would have done the big thing and the right thing in putting these teachers back. If, in those circumstances, they betrayed their trust in any way, I can assure the Ministry that neither the general body of teachers nor I personally would have any sympathy whatsoever with them. The Executive Council has let this matter drag on for quite a long time. No decision has been taken. Perhaps, in one way, that has been an advantage, because the farther away we get from those things the less important do they appear and the less is the desire for punishment. They have been punished severely already. They are now almost three years without recognition of their service. Many of them have suffered great hardships in that time. I do put it to the Government that the time has come when they might deal in a proper way with this rankling sore in the organisation of teachers. There is no question of danger because there are only ten or twelve teachers concerned altogether, and, of these, three are women. Possibly, this matter counts for more than it really should amongst teachers. This demand has been made by every branch of the teachers' organisation, and the Government knows that the vast majority of the teachers are supporters of the State, if not of the present Government Party. I do not want to go into individual cases, but I indicated a couple of cases in which there is grave doubt as to whether or not there was real activity on the part of these men. I do not know what took place before the Advisory Committee or what evidence the Government have in regard to them, but there has been no public trial. In one case I quoted, the man actually signed the form, was let out and got back to his work.
There were other cases where the men were very active, indeed, against the Government while the fight was on. But the Government have reinstated a man who was found in arms in an ambush against Government troops. He, as was indicated in the letter of the Minister for Finance, was actually sentenced to death. On the other hand, a man who used foolish language in answer to a heckler at a public meeting on the occasion of an election has not been reinstated. If we were all answerable for the statements we use on platforms at election times, especially in reply to hecklers, few, I am afraid, would escape. To say that the greater number of these men were foolish, would probably be to describe their conduct accurately. But what I plead for is a wiping of the slate and the putting of these men back in their jobs. No good purpose will be served, but a good deal of rankling discontent will be engendered, by leaving them in the position they are in. Comparatively, it is a small question, but it means a good deal to the individuals concerned. It may be said that these men made no move themselves in the matter, but the position is as I explained. They made a personal application for reconsideration of their cases on the advice of their organisation. Having done that they thought that they had done all that they were asked to do. They have never been asked to do anything else. They have had no communication whatsoever from the Government since they made their personal application, except merely an acknowledgement. I do hope that the Ministry will see their way to accede to the request that has been made to them by the whole body of teachers, and by people on this side of the House on more than one occasion.
Comment on this
I want to add one word to what Deputy O'Connell has said. My interest in this matter is through the manager of a school where one of these teachers is at present working. The teacher is perfectly satisfactory. His conduct, from the point of view of the manager, who is a very strong supporter of the State, is quite satisfactory. As a teacher he stands high. The manager does not desire that he should be removed, but the difficulty that he is in at present is that, while the teacher is not being paid, and while there is no indication of the policy of the Ministry, if there was to be a change the manager would be in a very difficult position in trying to remove a man who has given satisfaction, both to the manager and to the parents. In a rural district, as we know, it is not very difficult to stir up considerable strife as to who the teacher is to be, and I believe that while the conditions at the moment are such as to give no cause for alarm, the attitude of the Ministry should be to adopt what the manager in each case would be prepared to state to the Ministry. I think it is nearly true in every case that the manager is prepared to accept the teacher and I think the policy of the Ministry should be to wipe the slate and leave things as they are.
Comment on this
I want to support the plea made by Deputy O'Connell and Deputy Baxter. As Deputy O'Connell said, I attended with him as one of a deputation to the President on this point. Therefore I have a little knowledge of the case that was made, and some knowledge, perhaps, of the attitude of the Ministry with regard to it. But that is, I suppose, twelve months ago, and quite a number of things have happened since that, I would hope, would affect the minds of the Government. It is not necessary to re-state the position, following Deputy O'Connell, except to emphasise the point he made, that the teachers concerned are, in fact, teaching in schools. It was urged that the Government should not accept liability, in the way of payments, for men or women who, they had reason to think, were not loyal citizens, that their effect upon, shall I say, the growth of civic morality was such that they could not be trusted. That argument is never used in respect of teachers as a whole. Its weakness lies in the fact that these teachers are in a position, and have been for some time, to do all the evil things that may be charged as possibilities against them, that the evil effects, if there are such, of their reinstatement remain as they have been for the last two or three years, and that the children are being infected.
Comment on this
That is not the Government's responsibility, true. But whosoever responsibility it is, the Government are parties, in a way, by the very fact that there are teachers in daily contact with these suspects and they are being recognised and paid. I do not know what the actual point of distinction is between the people who are still unrecognised and others who were not active in their particular districts in the actual leading of the opposition.
A Deputy from Clare who has been speaking a good deal on another subject is familiar with the actions of a teacher who was most active in that part of the country and who has been reinstated. I am very doubtful where the line of distinction can be drawn. I am afraid that it is an arbitrary line which cannot be fairly defended. But supposing it can, I am going to ask the House to remember the incident that happened here two days ago. You had the entry into the House of Deputy Sean MacCurtain. He had been imprisoned for several years, with a number of other men arrested by the Northern Government, in circumstances similar to his own. As a result of representations made, amongst others by the Ministry, of pressure brought to bear on Ministers in the North and Ministers in London, and the demand by the public for reasonable consideration of their cases, these men were released, and it was proclaimed that this was an evidence of a new spirit which was intended to wipe the slate clean, so that life could go on free from those grievances which had been in the minds of many for quite a long time. I ask that that same idea should be given effect to in the case of the teachers. Taking into account the statement made by Deputy O'Connell, the assumption underlying this plea is that these teachers are willing to enter into and to undertake to give loyal service. If that is the assumption, the answer must be that you will not accept their promise. I think it will be difficult to distinguish between the promises made under these circumstances by any of these teachers and the promises made by hundreds of others who have been reinstated in one position or another whose past conduct was at least as reprehensible in the minds of the Government as that of the teachers concerned, and I cannot, on the logic of the case, see what reason the Government can have for refusing to reinstate at this stage.
But, apart from that, I would ask them to give expression in these cases to the same spirit as was shown when a plea was made and a response given by the Northern Government and the British Government in respect to Deputy Sean MacCurtain and a number of others. Supposing these men are not reinstated, what is going to be the position? As sure as anything in politics there will, some time in the future, be a change, at least, in the personnel of the Government, and also, as sure as anything in politics, these men, staying on at their schools, will eventually be reinstated by some Government at some time in the future. If that is admitted, what, then, will be the value of maintaining this sense of grievance in their minds until that day comes? Is it that you desire to punish? If it is punishment, then one can understand it, but if it is not a desire to punish, and if it is admitted as a likely thing, as almost a certain thing, that if these men remain on at their schools as they are to-day that eventually they will be reinstated, is it not better, in every interest, that they should be reinstated now than to have a sense of grievance carrying on and a temptation, at least, to convey those grievance to the children and the people round about them? I think that every consideration should be given to the plea that is made now publicly on behalf of these men and women, and I hope the Government will accede to the representations that have been made.
Comment on this
I would like to know from the Minister if the Compulsory School Attendance Bill, when it becomes an Act, will be enforced in those schools, or will schools, where the teacher is not recognised by the Government, be outside the Act?
Comment on this
The position that has arisen ought to be cleared up. You have either to recognise or to dismiss the teacher irrespective of whether the manager is agreeable or not—that is, if the School Attendance Act is going to apply. You are going to enforce the Act in a school where you do not recognise the teacher. Is that so?
Comment on this
And even if the teacher is an objectionable character, from your point of view, you are going to force children to go into that school.
Comment on this
Unless the individual is very objectionable, I think the slate ought to be wiped clean. I say further that in the case of any one of these teachers who is objectionable and who wants to force his opinions down the throats of the children, he ought to be removed.
Comment on this
Yes. I say that where political opinions are given expression to by a teacher in a school he ought to be removed.
Comment on this
I have stated more than once in the House, and would like to say it again, that I have no sympathy whatever with anything such as Deputy Gorey complains of, either in the case of these teachers or any other teachers. If such a thing does occur—I do not say that it does— then the people and the manager have their remedy. The Department is there to deal with cases of that kind.
Comment on this
The Department ought to be above the manager, and ought to have the power, under an Act of Parliament, to remove a teacher who is objectionable.
Comment on this
What a teacher is paid to do is to teach the children the subjects that are on the school programme and not to ventilate his own private sentiments.
Comment on this
If they have not been offenders in that direction, and if their conduct otherwise has been good, perhaps it would be as well to wipe the slate clean. I do not know what the Minister thinks.
Comment on this
I will deal first with the point raised by Deputy Gorey. He says that if a teacher uses his position in a school to teach objectionable matters that he ought to be removed.
Comment on this
Teaching politics. I do not think it is his business to teach politics of any description.
Comment on this
I would like to say to the Deputy that we would be in exactly the same position with regard to that teacher that we are in now with regard to these men. The same dilemma would be created if the manager wanted to keep him there.
Comment on this
I am sure the Minister recognises that these are special cases that do not occur more than once in a century.
Comment on this
I was addressing myself to Deputy Gorey's argument and was showing him where it led to. Deputy O'Connell has raised this question and has put it very strongly before the Government again and again. He pleaded the cause of these teachers in interviews with different Ministers, and in writing he put different considerations up to the Government. During the last twelve months, and even longer, the matter has been again and again considered by the Government. The Executive Council weighed all the circumstances of the case for and against. So far as leniency to the teachers who were guilty of complicity in armed resistance to the State is concerned, the Government feels that it has gone to the limit. It is not a question of amnesty. I would ask Deputies in the different parts of the House to understand that. The question is whether men who were guilty of complicity in armed resistance against the State should have their conduct overlooked. Their conduct was the subject of a careful investigation by a committee of men who served the old Dáil. At least two of the members of the committee were in the old Dáil, and all were in the old movement before the split. These men carefully considered all the evidence that was put up in these cases. They decided that in a number of cases the Government had no reasonable grounds —I might say no shadow of ground— for believing that the future conduct of these teachers, so far as unconstitutional action against the State was concerned, would be better than it was in the past. Hence it is that the Government, having weighed and fully considered the arguments in favour of wiping the slate clean, are compelled to come to the decision that what I may call the final findings of this committee on the matter must stand, and that in, I think, fourteen or seventeen cases—I am not certain of the number —the complicity cannot be overlooked.
The first batch were interviewed by the Committee some time in the summer of 1924. About a year after three more were interviewed. I wish to make it quite clear decision was based on opinions that these men held—even the voicing of those opinions. It was only if they were concerned in armed resistance or in the organisation of armed resistance, or helping, promoting or inciting to armed resistance. So far as reinstatement was concerned, complicity even was not regarded as a bar—again, I say, not to amnesty, but even to being received back and receiving their salaries from the State that they had been trying to overthrow. Complicity was not regarded as a bar unless it was complicated by other circumstances, especially the circumstance I have now to mention, that having fully considered the case the Government came to the conclusion that the future attitude of those individuals could not be depended upon. I want to make that quite clear.
Comment on this
Will the Minister explain what steps were taken to find out what their future attitude would be, because it is not quite clear to me?
Comment on this
They were hypothetically asked by the Committee would they sign and they said "No." Then they were asked: "Will you conduct yourself in future?" and in the majority of cases they would give no guarantee whatsoever as to their future conduct.
Comment on this
In view of the time that has elapsed, is the Minister prepared to offer an opportunity now of making such a declaration?
Comment on this
The Government is not prepared. Everything has to be taken into account. It is not only a question of their making a declaration, but the Government has to be convinced that they have some ground for believing that declaration. I ask the Deputy to look at it from that point of view.
Comment on this
Have representations been made by managers of any of these schools that these teachers should be reinstated?
Comment on this
As far as I know, only in one case, and in that case I think the Advisory Committee agreed to advise that it should be overlooked.
Comment on this
As I said, Deputy O'Connell in the interests of those teachers put up the case, and in a memorandum which he submitted he stressed portion of a reply from the Minister for Finance that "the Government was most anxious to overlook past complicity in the Irregular movement wherever there were reasonable grounds for anticipating proper behaviour in future." I may say that so far as the teachers are concerned the Government consider that much greater leniency was shown in their case than in the case of any of the ordinary public servants. There were in all some 55 cases considered. In a number of these cases, say about 20, complicity was not established, and when I say "not established" very often the phrase used is "not fully established." In a number of cases—some 18 altogether—complicity was found, and it was determined that the circumstances were such that the Government might exercise leniency, and the Government determined to exercise leniency. There were two cases in which there had been sentences of death which had been commuted to penal servitude and then an amnesty. In these cases the Government believed their protestations of good conduct in future. In another case a man was sentenced to 15 years penal servitude. These cases were overlooked and the teachers were allowed to go back, because there did seem to be a chance that they would turn over a new leaf. In at least one of those cases evidence has since come to light that that promise has not been kept—that one at least of the individuals is still a member of an illegal military organisation.
Comment on this
Is there any evidence that the teachers at present teaching and who are not paid by the Government are associating in any conspiracy against the State?
Comment on this
Deputy O'Connell said the Government has information. There are various kinds of information.
Comment on this
No. Some of the cases I can tell of are not malicious. It is quite true that a number—I think 18 or so out of 20—did apply to have the cases re-examined. They were re-examined, and even after that I think about three or four were reinstated and it was agreed that they should get their salaries. It is said that a lot of allowance should be made for the circumstances. I think I have shown that the Government did make a good deal of allowance and, as far as the Government can see the matter, they could not reasonably, having regard to their sense of duty to the country, make more allowance.
Deputy Johnson raised the question as to what any future Government will do in those particular cases. This particular Government can hardly be expected to answer that or be responsible for that. They have quite enough to be responsible for at the moment. They have to use the lights they have in considering the conduct of these particular, shall I call them, semi-public servants. That is to say, the Government have weighed all the arguments for restoration and against restoration and wherever they considered there was any reason for tilting the scale in favour of leniency, that is the course that they have followed. It is not a question as to whether a person may be perfectly satisfactory as a teacher. He may be.
Comment on this
I put it as satisfactory from the managers' point of view. The Minister can understand that.
Comment on this
He may be satisfactory even from that point of view and still there may be no good reason for believing that he would be satisfactory from the State's point of view. I will say that all along the assumption underlying Deputy O'Connell's plea was that the teachers were willing to give loyal service. That is one of the principal differences between Deputy O'Connell and the Government. The Government feel that in these particular cases they cannot rely on anything which by any stretch of the imagination could be called a reasonable likelihood of loyal service from those individuals.
Comment on this
There was more than one application by a manager, but I cannot say whether more than one was agreed to.
Comment on this
I would like to say, in regard to what the Minister for Education has just announced, if this is the final word on behalf of the Government, that I regret it exceedingly. With regard to the guilt or complicity of these people, the manner in which that guilt was established, if it had been established, was not satisfactory. It was never established in any regular court in any public way. An Advisory Committee was set up, and the teachers were called before it, but they got no opportunity whatsoever of seeing any charge made against them until they came before the Committee. There is nothing on record except the report of the Committee, which none of us have seen, as to what took place. We have varying accounts of what took place. The Minister himself says that they were asked hypothetical questions.
Now a man after coming out from prison is not always in the best position to answer hypothetical questions at an inquiry of this kind. I want to stress this: the manner in which their guilt, if they were guilty, was established was rather peculiar. It was certainly not established in open court where they could have had the help of a legal adviser if necessary.
I take the man Flynn; he was imprisoned for some foolish letters that he wrote, and was afterwards released because he signed a form and went back to his school. There has been no charge against him since, so far as I know. The Minister says he was not satisfied with any assurances that they gave or could give as to what their conduct would be in the future. I put it this way: Two and a half years have elapsed and these men are teaching in their schools, and it is not said, and I do not think the Minister can say in the case of those on whose behalf I am pleading, that they have done anything otherwise than shown their inclination to obey the law and carry on their work in accordance with the rules and regulations of the Department, although, in effect, they are not under the jurisdiction of the Department.
Now, what method has been taken by the Government to find out whether or not they are prepared to give assurances? What method has been taken to find out whether or not they are prepared to give those assurances that they are asked for? It is not satisfactory to ask hypothetical questions.
Comment on this
They were also asked definitely if they would give an oral promise and they refused. The hypothetical questions had reference to written declarations put before them.
Comment on this
As far as I can gather, in no case did they get any satisfactory explanation of what was being asked of them. They said they would do as any other teacher would do, namely, carry out the rules and obey the Department. They understood that was what was being asked of them, and they gave that assurance. One wrote in afterwards, and said he quite misunderstood what was being asked of him, and that he was quite prepared to give any assurance necessary upon his side. As Deputy Norton has said, two and a half years have elapsed since that time, and they know perhaps better to-day. That period of probation, if you like, has been served by those teachers. I do not see why the Government are adopting this attitude. There is no danger to the State and I make a plea again that the Government should reconsider their attitude to these teachers. I put this to the President and the Minister for Education, that if these teachers should make personal application again for the reconsideration of their cases they should get the opportunity of appearing before the Committee, or before some committee, in order to re-state their position and attitude. They never got such an opportunity. They were never again invited to appear before the Committee in any way. I think it is hardly fair that they should be judged entirely by their attitude before that Committee.
They were brought into a private room before three members of the Advisory Committee; they did not know what was to take place; some of them were legally advised not to answer any questions that would incriminate themselves in any way. Now their whole career is being judged by what took place before that Committee. I do not think, in all the circumstances, that that could be regarded as fair, and I strongly urge the Minister for Education and the Executive Council to review the cases and to give these men an opportunity of stating their position and their attitude towards the Government and towards the State. I believe if that is done they will satisfy the Government that they are prepared to give loyal service, and to give any assurances that may be necessary to that effect. If they are concerned with any illegally organised body, or are not prepared to say that they will not be concerned with any such body, I have nothing to say for them, but I think they would give any assurances in that direction.
Comment on this
Is it your intention, a Chinn Comhairle, to put the resolution of the Minister for Finance, or to put separately the Votes for which they are asking credit on account?
Comment on this
There is only one motion, and I intend to put that motion.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy going to discuss some details in connection with the Estimates? They will be before us in the usual way. Is the Deputy going to prevent me putting this motion to-night—that is the point?