COMMITTEE OF PROCEDURE AND PRIVILEGES. - TARIFF COMMISSION BILL, 1926—SECOND STAGE (RESUMED).
Contributions 133–281 of 281. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 30 of 1926 ›
In any case I think the inclusion of Deputy Magennis would only reinforce my point—it would only make it "curiouser and curiouser." You have an alliance between a man who proclaims on every possible opportunity that he is a free trader, and a man who, I do not think, has ever declared that he was by any means a whole-hog protectionist—if I may use Deputy Dalton's discarded phrase. It struck me, in view of the fact that the signatories to this alliance, so to speak, had such very distinct principles, that one should seek somewhat further than the principles on which they opened the discussion for the reason of their alliance. Of course, the reason of their alliance is perfectly obvious to anybody—a political reason.
Comment on this
It is a matter of political tactics. The Bill is introduced as an honest attempt——
Comment on this
As one who has been identified to some extent with the demand for protection, I support the Bill as an honest attempt to deal with the question. Deputy Heffernan's free trade views may be very wide and elaborate, but I know that there is one kind of free trade that Deputy Heffernan believes in, and that the majority of the Party to which he belongs believe in, that is free trade in the results of Government measures passed by the Dáil. I would be almost willing to prophesy, if the Bill is a success, that you will find Deputy Heffernan, and other members of his Party, who are opposed to this Bill—I cannot say anything to Deputy Gorey on this occasion because I am not quite sure whether he is supporting or opposing the Bill—but you will find Deputy Heffernan and those who joined with him in opposing the Bill, going down the country organising little industries and claiming protection, in friendly cooperation with the Farmers' Party, and claiming, also, that they above all the other Parties in the Dail, were the authors and sponsors of this Bill.
Comment on this
I wonder is the Deputy aware that members of his Party claim credit for things for which credit is not due to them?
Comment on this
I am afraid that is an argument, not an explanation.
Comment on this
I wonder if the Deputy has ever heard any claim in connection with the Waterford Meat Factory?
Comment on this
All human beings have a tendency to claim credit where it is not due, but in this particular matter of the benefits which flow from legislative measures passed by the Dáil the Farmers' Party have that tendency to a somewhat larger extent, perhaps, than any other Party. I should like, also, to make a reference to the attitude that Deputy Johnson has adopted on this measure. I have personally never heard Deputy Johnson make what I might call a clear-cut declaration, an unequivocal declaration for protection in this House, unaccompanied by reservations of different kinds. I think it is only fair that his attitude in regard to this measure should be adverted to in the light of his other utterances in regard to this question.
Comment on this
Deputy Johnson suggests, and tries to have it accepted, that he is a protectionist without making any definitely protectionist speeches. Now, when a measure like this for the solidification and definition of protection comes before this House, the support Deputy Johnson gives it is to try to damage the position of those who have been engaged sincerely and honestly in pushing the protectionist cause forward both inside and outside the House. I should like to say that I, for one, have a deeper belief and a stronger faith in the principles of protection than would induce me to descend to tactics of that kind. I do not think it is right, when a measure like this is introduced, which everybody agrees is of such vital importance to the industries of this country, that an attempt should be made to derive political capital out of it in such a way that the cause for which it is introduced may be damaged and may be retarded by such action.
Comment on this
For whatever reason, I cannot say, there seems to be a very antagonistic feeling against the farmers.
Comment on this
I venture to say the opposition coming from these benches, to this particular Bill, has been very fair and very mild and based upon sound principles as compared with the rhetoric of a speech lasting for two hours. Not one word has been said about that, while we have had to submit to the gibes and the jeers of youthful politicians who during the time that we were in stress and struggle were——
Comment on this
Yes, under the bed, or confined to the protection of a neighbouring country. They cannot see anything unfair in these attacks, considering the position which exists to-day, when the resources of this country depend upon the farming industry, without anything else or without any other industry in the country able and capable of sustaining itself in the foreign markets. No other industry in this country is able to stand up to competition. We have not asked for protection and we do not demand protection. We only demand what those able, as we are, to compete and sell in the world's markets might expect, namely, that the manufacturing arm in this country should also show a tendency in the same direction. I do not say that we stand against helping industry. It is well that the House should understand that our main reliance is on one industry, and that if your strong whole-hog protection policy is to be put in force, that industry will go like the rest, and you will go with it.
Professions of faith were made, but the professions of faith were not followed by any explanation. This is faith in an untried experiment. It is not a profession of faith: it is a profession of foolishness. Let us be candid. If the Bill means only an examination and thorough investigation into the problems of industry, then we have no notion of standing in the way. It is on the ground that this Bill brings with it the acceptance of the theory of protection for everything, and the Minister for Finance knows this, that we put forward our objection.
Adversity makes strange bedfellows and that is the reason you find us ranged with our colleagues on our left and on our right. We are standing against the wall. We are doing our best to live and we will not tolerate and cannot tolerate anything that will make it more difficult for us to carry on. Is that not a reasonable proposition? I agree that between extreme whole-hoggers, on the one side, and doctrinaire free traders on the other, there is a way by which we can help ourselves and help the country. Deputy Tierney is against unfair pressure on industry brought about by tariffs. Therefore he is in favour of our attitude.
Comment on this
You said you would like to see that any unfair pressure was brought to bear upon the Ministry that it should be rectified. But if the chief industry which is so large that you cannot see it is subject both to unfair competition and pressure it is not to be heard. Farming is not an industry nor a manufacture and, therefore, it is not to be heard. It is so great and immense that it is carrying the State upon its back but then we are told it is getting subsidies. The subsidies to farming in this country are nothing. Compared with other countries we are only in the halfpenny place in that connection. We never get anything but our rights and we have not got our rights yet. When we get our rights we will be in the position of giving ourselves what we demand and what we require. It is wrong to take credit for Bills passed in this House by the Government. It is wrong to say the Cumann na nGaedheal Party has done everything. The Farmers' Party has done its share in whatever beneficial legislation has taken place in connection with our farming industry and we do take credit for the fact that not only have we aided legislation passed here but we made the people who are behind us accept when it was even of a coercive nature and where it would not have been accepted but for us. I want the country and the House to understand, that our attitude is that of people bearing their burdens and facing the enemy, we have maintained our place in the foreign market on our merits which is more than can be said for other industries except, of course, Jacob's biscuits and Guinness's porter. If, however, the other industries in the country face facts in that way the farmers will not be behind time in giving them a helping hand.
Comment on this
I may say at the outset that I am very glad to know that the leaders of what I might call the hundred per cent. protectionist party—Professor Tierney and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs have become reconciled again with their Party. I was amazed when I heard Professor Tierney talking about the tacties of Deputy Johnson on this Bill. Deputy Tierney is a very good judge of what he describes as the low tacties of Deputy Johnson, but I do not think it is necessary to go into that matter any further.
Comment on this
The word was not used, because I was listening very carefully to that part of the debate.
Comment on this
I withdraw it, and with your permission, sir, I will substitute the word "high" if it suits the Deputy better.
Comment on this
It is not a question of what suits me, but Deputy Johnson.
Comment on this
I wonder how the Deputy reconciles his very halting apology for the Government on this Bill this evening, as compared with his one hundred per cent. protectionist speech last April. I suggest to Deputy Tierney that between now and the next reading of this Bill, if we are going to have another reading of this Bill, he might read the speech which he delivered on protection last April, to see how it fits in with what is contained in this Bill. Let us be frank about the matter. I am sure Deputy Tierney and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs could make 100 per cent. better speech against this Bill than they made in favour of it. I have no doubt whatever that were it not for the fact that Deputy Tierney, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and their colleagues who call themselves protectionists were afraid of an election they would speak and vote against the Bill. That is the position as I see it. I want to pay a tribute to the Government Party for their discipline and the way in which they have been able to wangle, if I might use the word——
Comment on this
If the Minister for Justice has any objection to the word I will substitute the word "handled"—the way in wmen they have handled the rebellious members of their Party. I am glad they have been able to dissipate all the fears of disruption which were foreshadowed in this morning's "Independent" by the political correspondent. I am glad to know that even if the division were taken last night there was no fear the Government would be beaten. I should like to know the real mind of the protectionists in the Government Party on this matter. It would be very interesting to hear the speeches made at the party meeting when they were discussing this Bill and to compare them with the speeches made in this House.
To get away for the moment from the Government Party and to come to a more popular object—the Farmers' Party—Deputy Gorey made a statement this evening which, I must say, surprised me, coming even from Deputy Gorey. I am surprised that none of the subsequent speakers referred to it. When speaking of the present tide of emigration from this country, Deputy Gorey made a statement, that that was in the natural order of things. It is the natural order of things that we should have 30,000 of the best of our young men and women clearing out of this country to try and earn a livelihood in other countries where protection is in force; it is in the natural order of things that these young men and women who are forced to clear out and who should be able to earn their money on the land——
Comment on this
I make a present of the fact to the Deputy that he is able to regulate the natural order of things.
Comment on this
If Deputy Gorey is not able to make an intelligent observation, he ought to remain silent. If the statement to the effect that the emigration that has taken place in the last three or four years is in the natural order of things gives the official outlook of the Farmers' Party in this country, there is very little hope in the country from the point of view of the Farmers' Party. The Deputy suggested it was necessary that there should be a reduction in the population and that this country was unable under any system that might be devised to maintain and find employment for a population greater than what we have at the moment.
Comment on this
I said nothing of the sort. I contrasted the population today with that at the peak point in '49 or '50 when we had eight millions and I said—I adhere to the statement— that this country would not be capable of carrying that population, even though all our industries were developed and protected.
Comment on this
I admit that it is not easy to quote the Deputy. We have heard here this evening, particularly from Deputy Wilson, that this country is absolutely dependent upon agriculture. That is all right, but Deputy Wilson and his party by their attitude on this matter are insisting that this country will be dependent on agriculture and are refusing to allow us to have any other industry in this country.
Comment on this
Yes, but for quite a different reason. Deputy Wilson and Deputy Gorey and some other Farmer Deputies and business men even on the Government Benches are prepared to vote against any suggestion of protection for industries in this country but they are prepared to vote in favour of protection for agriculture. What is the £600,000 of a double Agricultural Grant but a form of protection?
Comment on this
I would like to get an interjection made clear. Did I understand Deputy Heffernan to say that he did not ask for the beet subsidy?
Comment on this
I understand that the Farmers' Party were taking full credit for having got it. I am against the Bill, because I do not believe the Government are at all sincere in setting up this Commission. I believe it is just a dodge to shelve the whole question until after the election. I am convinced of that.
Comment on this
Why does not the Deputy vote for the Bill, if it is the right thing to do? The people who are sincerely in favour of the Bill—I do not include the people who are professing to be in favour of it—are out-and-out free traders. A number of 100-percent protectionists have been cajoled not only into voting for it but even trying to speak in favour of it. I am going to vote against it, because I believe it is an attempt to deceive the House and to deceive the country on this question of protection. Perhaps, on that ground, Deputy Tierney will find an explanation of what he spoke of as a "curious alliance." It is an alliance against the deception of the Government Party.
Comment on this
We have been listening to a succession of lectures on alleged family differences in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. Charges have been made that members of that Party have been brought to see the light, not because of their belief in the efficacy of this Bill for the purpose for which it was devised, but through fear of a General Election. I wonder does it occur to any member of the House who made charges of this kind that even in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party there are men who think more of the general interest of their country than of their own future at a General Election or of small matters arising out of a division of opinion as to the extent to which a measure will go. Nevertheless, it is possible that there are men of that type in this Party, much maligned as it is. I wonder sometimes, when I hear frequent rejoicings about the divisions that occur in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, if all the other Parties are quite a happy family, or if they are so devoid of independent thought that they never differ from one another.
The question of tariffs has exercised the minds of politicians and statesmen in every country. It is a very good thing it is exercising the minds of political parties in this country even to the extent of the excellent debate— interesting and sometimes amusing— that we have had during the last couple of days. Again, our Party is sometimes charged, as in the case of Deputy Magennis, with lack of independence of thought. We are told that in the Party there is no thought other than that inspired from the Ministerial benches. I think that somewhere between the two the truth may be found. Deputy Morrissey has spoken of those who are in favour of protection and who are being forced, by one means or other, to vote in favour of this Bill. I am in favour of protection and I am in favour of it not as a sentimentalist. I have been engaged in business all my life and I am convinced that if the future of this country is not to be entirely agricultural, a change can only be effected by a judicious application of tariffs. I confess that there are points in the Bill that I would like to see changed, but as it goes in the direction I desire, I am in favour of it and I propose to vote for it.
On one or two points I should like to comment. I object to the attitude that might be sought to be implied in this Bill, that commercial men and manufacturers consider only their own personal interest and profit when dealing with the creation of industry. I have been recently in touch with a body of men who put up £10,000 to re-establish an industry in this city. I can assure the Dáil that the majority of those men were not at all primarily concerned with the making of profits but that there was some little national impulse behind the effort. I should not like to think that the Minister for Finance or the Executive Council took that attitude towards manufacturers because it would not be a proper attitude. The Executive have always given generous and broad consideration to the claims of the agricultural community, as is right and proper, agriculture being at the moment the staple industry of this country. But there has always been a range of economic life in the nation and I think their attitude should be as generous in this case as in the case of the farming community. For that reason, I feel that the onus of having a tariff placed upon an industry should not lie entirely with those who are engaged in it or who propose to engage in it. I would like to see the functions of the Commission extended, so that it might initiate inquiries into certain industries either established in the country or suitable to the country's requirements. I should like to see the clause in the Bill referring to the payment of a certain sum of money, deleted, not so much for the sake of the few pounds involved as for the sake of the implication that an interested section only is concerned in this matter. My outlook is a broader one. I think the whole future of the country, the whole future of the population which agriculture cannot absorb, is dependent on this matter. It is a matter of broad national interest and not a matter of interest to sections only. There are other matters referred to by Deputies which I presume will be dealt with when the Bill is going through Committee. Speaking as a protectionist, convinced of the necessity and rightness of that policy for this country, I have no hesitation in saying I will vote for this Bill.
Comment on this
Nearly all those who have spoken in opposition to the Bill have been answered by others who spoke in opposition to the Bill. Deputy Johnson said he thought this Bill was going to do harm to both sides in the controversy. If he means that the results of the operation of the Bill will be agreeable neither to the whole-hog protectionists nor to the doctrinaire free trader, I am inclined to agree with him and I hope it will be so. When we get away from the political argument against the Bill—the argument arising from disappointment, because there is not a big split in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party—we find that the arguments are mostly based on the desire to have a different kind of Commission altogether, charged with different functions. Some people have said that this Commission should investigate the results of existing tariffs. It might be desirable that there should be a Commission even now to investigate the results of existing tariffs, but I do not quite agree. I think that the existing tariffs have been too short a time in operation and that any attempt to appraise their efficacy now would really give misleading results. For my part, I certainly think that until the existing tariffs have been a year or two years more in operation I should not attempt to say what the effect has been, because, for the first year of any tariff, it has practically no results. Sometimes big stocks have been laid in and the effect of the tariff does not begin to be felt at all. Even when big stocks have not been laid in or even when they have been exhausted, there are difficulties in getting going for the purpose of increased production. There are difficulties in erecting buildings, in installing plant and in getting capital, and it is very difficult to see how a tariff is going to operate for three or four years. I would not be inclined to conduct any very serious investigation into tariffs before some period like that. But in any case, that is entirely different from the problem that we wish to deal with. Something like a year ago I said that we did not propose to proceed further with tariffs on manufactured articles until after a general election. Before I made that statement we had had an enormous number of applications. We found that we were being pressed on all sides for additional tariffs and our general view was that the whole matter had not been sufficiently considered by the public at large, that we had not had sufficient experience of the tariffs that had been imposed and that in many cases employers were pressing for tariffs who would have been very much better engaged in attending to their business and carrying on their industries. We thought that on the whole the best thing for the country and for manufacturers themselves was to call a halt, to let the country see, at any rate to some extent, as the result of experience, how tariffs would operate, and to give us an opportunity of considering what was the best machinery to deal further with the tariff problem. But after we had made that declaration of policy, we were told, told with great vehemence, and, in certain cases, with a great deal of convincingness, that there were industries which could not wait for two years, which, if we did not do something, would go out of existence, and that if we waited until after a general election we, or our successors, would have to deal with a position in which the industries had gone, the plant had, perhaps, been scrapped and the workers had been scattered.
We did not want to let cases like that lie over. It might be that on full consideration of some such cases we would decide that the amount of protection that would be necessary to save the industry would not be justified and that we ought to let it go. On the other hand, an industry that was in danger might be such that it ought to be saved when it could be saved at comparatively small cost and when the cost would be very well worth while. It was when these arguments were put up to us, when we were convinced that not in all cases could we safely wait over the two years, that we began to elaborate the idea of a tariff commission, a commission which would not leave us in the position of yielding to or resisting the clamour and pressure of manufacturers, but which would enable us to examine the case that could be made, so that if there were industries that needed protection, that would benefit by protection, that would be in great danger of going out of existence if protection were not granted, we could deal with them on their merits. That feeling, that desire, is the real genesis of this Bill. The object of this Bill is not to inquire into the general merits of free trade or protection, or to get the theory discussed in any way; it is not to inquire into the effects of existing tariffs; it is not to enable people who want wholehog protection to come in and make cases for industries with which they are not concerned. It is a Bill to enable us to get a full examination of the cases of industries which claim protection, and particularly the industries which allege that they would be in grave danger of destruction within a brief period if protection were not granted to them.
I have indicated that proposals like the sugar beet proposal might arise which would be outside the scope of this Bill and of the ordinary operations of a commission such as that proposed, and I have said that I believe those proposals should be dealt with by some ad hoc body and by means of a special investigation. This proposed Commission is to make a thorough investigation of claims for tariffs such as have been made to the Ministry for the past year and a half or two years, such as in some cases we felt had not merits, such as those about which we could not make up our minds, such as those which we were rather inclined to accept, but still felt that there was substantial doubt about. It might be that if this Commission had been working for a year or two we would want to add other functions to it or we might set up other bodies or other machinery to discharge other functions. We have a special and an urgent reason for setting up this particular machinery to do the kind of work that I have indicated. Deputies have asked—Deputy Gorey has asked most clearly—whether all the evidence will be published in the Press. It would not be possible to have that. If you paid for it as an advertisement you would have too much of it in, and I do not think it would be read. Besides, it would be extremely costly.
Comment on this
Taking it broadly— I do not say that this always applies— the kind of news that a paper does not think worth inserting as news would not be read by many people if it were inserted otherwise. It might be read by a few, but the few who would read the kind of material that a newspaper would regard as not having much news value would read it if they got it in a White Paper. It is proposed that the proceedings of the Commission shall be published.
Comment on this
Will there be a selection of documents to be published, because the documents will be the evidence?
Comment on this
Yes. What I say about the publication of evidence applies to documents as well as to oral evidence. There is just one exception to that, what I mentioned yesterday, that where a firm gives confidential evidence which might show its position and damage its credit, that evidence will not be published.
Comment on this
No; there are things which a firm could not have published without running grave risks. If a firm were to show in evidence, for instance, that its stability was very doubtful, the result would be that immediately it became public it would ruin its credit and that it could not carry on— that would not be published. What we would have published would be a statement in general terms what the effect of the confidential evidence was. If a number of firms gave evidence showing that they had been incurring heavy losses, and were in a condition bordering on insolvency, the Commission would have to report that the evidence given in regard to certain firms showed that they had serious losses and that their condition was one of great difficulty. It would have to state in general terms the effect of the private evidence. Beyond that, all evidence would be published, both documents and oral evidence. The intention of the Government, and I am sure it will be carried out by the Commission, would be that, so far as possible, the evidence should be published, that is, that the confidential stamp should be put on as little evidence as possible, consistent with dealing fairly with firms whose proposals and whose affairs would come up for investigation. A Deputy stated that bodies like trade unions could not come before the Tariff Commission. As a matter of fact they could. There is no restriction against any bodies interested in giving evidence before the Commission.
Comment on this
"When considering any applications referred to it as aforesaid the Commission shall hear every person who desires so to be heard and appears to the Commission to be substantially representative of persons, trades, or interests who would or might reasonably be expected to be affected by the granting or refusing in whole or in part of the concession asked for in such application and shall receive and consider any evidence tendered by such persons." That would mean representatives of workers in an industry, or who had been in an industry, and perhaps even representatives of those who might be employed.
Comment on this
I think that the Minister will remember that the Deputy was referring to applications from trade unions.
Comment on this
The Deputy may have thought that he was referring to such applications. He was not. So far as evidence is concerned, anybody interested can give evidence if he has evidence to give, but applications must come from the people who are proposing to engage in the industry. I think we have hundreds, we certainly have scores, of such applications already, and it is primarily to deal with those applications, which we have, that the Commission is being set up. This Commission is not being set up to probe matters, to travel over the whole field, and to look out for things to inquire into. This Commission will act judicially in so far as the putting together of evidence and setting out the facts, are concerned. It is to hear a case that will be made that the Commission is being set up. The cases can be made only by those who are interested. You do not set up a court to go out and look for disputes among the people. Your court is established and people, with material to bring before it, go to it and present their case. We believe that the most satisfactory way of dealing with ordinary tariff proposals will be to have them made by those who are interested. Somebody must take responsibility for making the case. Otherwise you could not have the type of investigation which we desire, and which we think will be most satisfactory. If you have not the people who are actually engaged in the industry making a case for the protection of that industry, you are going to get into generalities and into a wide discussion on economic principles. We do not think that that would be fruitful. We do not think that such discussions would tend to put us in a position to deal intelligently and satisfactorily with the practical problems which will come up to us, the problem in the case of each industry, of imposing or refusing a tariff. I do not think that I need at all deal with the question of mandate. We certainly had as much mandate for the imposition of protective tariffs as for any other things we did.
Comment on this
Quite, but there has been no general election since that. That was a statement of policy. It was no pledge, but a statement of intention and policy. That was what we proposed to do, but we did not make any bargain with anybody.
Comment on this
It was a statement of policy, and if things arise which indicate that a policy must be modified, then it would be a most unintelligent and a most irresponsible thing to do to refuse to modify that policy because that had been stated already in clear terms.
Comment on this
This is very important. If on a discussion on the Budget proposals a case is put up, from any party, and a Minister gives an official reply, making a definite statement, is not attention to be given to that statement? Is not that a pledge, or what is it to be accepted as?
Comment on this
In the Budget debate a question arose as to tariffs, and in reply the Minister stated that there would be no more tariffs introduced pending an election. If that is not a pledge and an official statement of the Minister what is it?
Comment on this
Unfortunately there will be no more tariffs. There is no doubt the country wants them.
Comment on this
In any case Deputy Corish has given a reply. I do not know whether it will satisfy the Deputy or not.
Comment on this
The Deputy will be satisfied at the next election as to whether the people want protection or not.
Comment on this
The circumstances which lead us to feel that some modification of that policy might be necessary were those that I have already mentioned. In the case of some industries it was put to us with great force and vehemence and with some convincingness that if we waited for two years to consider and deal with their cases it might be too late. Investigation may prove that there are not such industries and investigation may prove that there are no industries which could not wait. In that case if there are no industries which are likely to collapse because protection is not granted, I certainly would hesitate very much before I would go any further with the policy of protection. I have no desire to go ahead of the feeling of the country. The country has not been able to express itself very clearly on the matter. Above all things, I have no desire to commit the country to a general tariff policy before the electors have had an opportunity of pronouncing on the matter. On the other hand, if there are industries which are going to collapse, or are going to be so seriously prejudiced that it is equivalent to collapse, by the conditions that exist if some help is not given within the next two years, then I am prepared to consider the cases of these industries on their merits.
Deputy Gorey said a thing with which I agree in part. He said we did not hear anything of these industries which were failing and which were in danger of collapsing before protection was first introduced, but that we have heard of them since. There is no doubt the introduction of protection and the hope that certain industrialists have of getting protection has led them to make a poor mouth.
Comment on this
On the other hand, the entire economic conditions in regard to industry, just as in regard to other matters, have been upset as a result of the European War and the catastrophic results of that war. Industries which could carry on quite well before the war and which seemed to have prospects of gradual expansion and increased prosperity, find that their markets are lost and that they are reduced to conditions of the greatest difficulty. The results of this upsetting of the economic conditions have been coming home only within the last two or three years, or at any rate, coming home to their full extent, and while it is true to say that there are industries which plead necessity simply because they believe they have something to get, there are also industries which are genuine in pleading exceptional difficulties and in pleading that the conditions under which they operated have so changed that it may be impossible for them to carry on without help. I am certainly convinced that in this matter of protection you have, as the Minister for Justice said, to let every herring hang by its own tail. You have to consider each case on its merits; you have to try to get at the facts with regard to an industry, and having got at the facts as fully as they can be got at, to come to a decision with regard to it.
It is certainly a short-sighted view to consider only one aspect of a question. It is a short-sighted view to say merely because agriculture is depressed that therefore nothing must be done for industry, that we must not weigh up the expenditure and the result, that we must consider simply and solely what it may cost without having any regard to the possible results of our action. I think that we cannot satisfactorily deal with our economic problems by taking a doctrinaire view from either side.
We feel very strongly that serious burdens must not be imposed on agriculture. We feel that it cannot bear the handicap of any appreciable additional burden, but we have to see what would be the results even to agriculture of a further industrial collapse. It would not be good. People engaged in agriculture would suffer, just as the people who are directly engaged in the industries would suffer. I submit that the information that will be made available to all parties and all citizens of the country as a result of the operations of this measure will enable us to deal with many questions that will come before us in relation to tariffs on the merits, free from propagandist influences and from any doctrinaire considerations.
Comment on this
I did not want to interrupt the Minister. I want this point to be made clear. Is the Minister withdrawing the statement of policy enunciated by him in his Budget speech in 1925 when he said that no further tariffs would be imposed pending a general election? Is he standing by that statement?
Comment on this
Will the Minister tell us if, in view of the discussion in regard to the constitution of the Commission, he will reconsider the question of endeavouring to secure the services of a business or professional man who has not been actively associated with the protection or free trade movements as a competent chairman?
Comment on this
With regard to Deputy Baxter's question, I will be able to answer that when some investigations have been made by this Commission.
Comment on this
Yes, until I see what information is forthcoming. With regard to Deputy Davin's statement, I am not of opinion that it is necessary to look for such a chairman. I do not preclude the possibility, and when we come to consider the personnel, who is available, and what the balance of the Commission will be from the point of view of experience and outlook, we will decide on the question of a chairman. I certainly would not propose that we should have a business chairman or regard a business chairman as at all superior to a Civil Service chairman.
Comment on this
I see no advantage that any of these people could have over a civil servant. It will be a matter of extreme difficulty to get a business man who will give the time and the energy, and who will be impartial and disinterested, to act on such a Commission. You could get interested people easily. Perhaps you could get people of leisure who would not give a great deal of service to the Commission. When the Bill has been passed the whole question of personnel will be considered, but I do not propose to give any pledges in regard to it.
Comment on this
Question put—"That the Bill be now read a second time."
Do you agree with this result?
If the Committee Stage is fixed for to-morrow, those who take the opposite view to that held by the Government will have very little opportunity of sending in amendments. I think it is not reasonable to expect Deputies to table amendments if the Committee Stage is fixed for to-morrow. No Party will have an opportunity of submitting amendments if that is done.
Comment on this
I think there certainly was a sort of agreement that if the Second Stage were put off to Wednesday the Committee Stage might be taken on Friday. When that was fixed it was indicated to Deputies that they might prepare and send in their amendments before the Second Reading was actually through.
Comment on this
What does the Minister mean by a sort of agreement? With whom was that agreement made?
Comment on this
As far as the Labour Party is concerned, it was made between myself and Deputy Johnson.
Comment on this
So far as the Farmers' Party are concerned, the Bill is against their principles and they do not care whether or not it is amended. It cannot be amended in any way that would suit their view.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider the advisability of postponing the Committee Stage until after the adjournment?
Comment on this
Oh, no. I would like to relieve the political correspondent of the "Independent," who is apparently in very bad form.
Comment on this
I have heard complaints that we would not hear any more about this until after the General Election. Who is trying to put it off now? The Minister wants to push it.
Comment on this
I regret that I was not here when the Minister made a statement in reference to the Committee Stage. I am told that he said that I agreed to the Committee Stage being taken to-morrow.
Comment on this
If the Minister will look at the Official Report of what occurred when this matter was being discussed—just about the last column of the report—he will see that inferentially, at least, I raised a very distinct objection.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce stated very definitely that Deputy Johnson agreed with him not to raise any objection whatever to taking the Committee Stage to-morrow.
Comment on this
I do not know what time the Minister is speaking of, but after the Bill had been circulated and we saw what was in it, we distinctly objected and raised the question of the shortness of time.
Comment on this
I am speaking of the day on which the Bill was put into the hands of Deputies. I think that was Thursday. I was speaking to Deputy Baxter, who had talked of the Second Reading and the date of the Second Reading. I then went over to see Deputy Johnson in his place, where he is now sitting, and put it to him that I had made a suggestion to Deputy Baxter that the Second Reading was really not the point that he might be aiming at, that it was the Committee Stage, and if the Committee Stage were aimed at and were set down for to-morrow, that there might be some consideration given then to a later date for Second Reading. I asked Deputy Johnson his opinion of that, and he said he would agree. That is my recollection. It was not that he did not object, but that he would agree. I will add that I think his further remarks were: "It is not a Bill to which, I think, we will be putting in any great number of amendments."
Comment on this
The Minister is referring to a conversation that he had immediately after the tea adjournment?
Comment on this
It was, I think. It was circulated from the Lobby outside at the time.
Comment on this
It was the reading of the Bill that astounded me and the Minister will remember and certainly will recognise, if he will get the official report of what occurred just before the adjournment—when I had a chance, more or less, of glancing over the terms of the Bill—that I raised objections at once as to the period that was going to be allowed.
Comment on this
I seem to recollect that Deputy Johnson indicated that very little time was given and that he objected to the lateness of the introduction of the Bill, but following the conversation of the Minister for Industry and Commerce with Deputy Baxter, Deputy Johnson sent me a note. As a result, when we came to fix the Second Reading Stage, I said that I thought that there had been an agreement— whether it was an agreement that would cover all the Parties in the House or not, I do not know—that if the Second Reading were taken on Wednesday, the Committee Stage might be taken on Friday. I do not remember if Deputy Johnson said anything in reply to that.
Comment on this
I cannot remember all the circumstances. I am not raising an objection to taking the Committee Stage to-morrow, so far as I am personally concerned, because all my amendments have been put in and, so far as I am concerned, the time does not matter, but there are later Stages than the Committee Stage.
Comment on this
I am prepared to agree, in view of the fact that a considerable number of amendments have been put in, that the Report Stage be taken next week, no attempt will be made to go further than the Committee Stage to-morrow.
Comment on this
I raised the matter publicly in the Dáil and intimated that we were not going to face the Second Reading on Tuesday without seeing the Bill and having given it consideration. The position we are confronted with— Deputy Wilson has represented our point of view—is that we cannot accept the principle contained in the Bill as stated by the Minister. Atleast, so far as we can see, no amendments could alter the principle contained in it and we are raising no objection to it on the Committee Stage. I recognise that Deputy Johnson is in an entirely different position, but if we are to be asked to-morrow to pass judgment on Deputy Johnson's amendments which we have not yet seen, is it fair? That is the point.
Comment on this
No; Deputy Johnson's amendments have been in my hands for some time and certain alterations have been made in some of them from the point of view of order. They were not circulated because the Bill had not passed its Second Reading, and it would have been somewhat irregular to circulate amendments for a Committee Stage which had not been fixed. These particular amendments of Deputy Johnson, and some amendments of the Minister which are also in can be circulated in the morning with the Order Paper. That is as far as I can go in the matter.
Comment on this
I think Deputy McCullough and Deputy Tierney would like to send in amendments and they would require time.
Comment on this
I think it is desirable for the proper consideration of the Bill that the Committee Stage should be taken to-morrow, so that there may be some little interval before the Report Stage. If we took the Committee Stage on Tuesday it would mean either taking the Report Stage on that day or the next, and so holding the Bill over with no other business. I am inclined to hold to the arrangement that the Committee Stage be taken to-morrow.
Comment on this
Could the Minister or the President say what are the intentions with regard to a meeting of the Dáil next week or the week after? We are not opposing the Committee Stage to-morrow, but I would like if he would be clear as to what are the intentions, if the Minister talks of taking this Bill next week.
Comment on this
That is, if the Committee Stage were finished to-morrow, there would be for next week's business the Fourth and Fifth Stages of this Bill, and the draft Rules of Court, in the way the Minister suggested to-day. Possibly, there may also be matters from the Seanad, but it is more likely that the matters from the Seanad will have to be considered the week after next rather than next week. We have already disposed of some amendments that came from the Seanad.
Comment on this
And the week after that. The Seanad will have to deal with this Bill if they agree to meet.
Comment on this
If we do not pass this Bill till next week we would have to come back the week after that. The idea is to get this Bill to the Seanad as quickly as possible.
Comment on this
What is the extreme urgency just now? Why was not the Bill introduced a fortnight ago?
Comment on this
Even though I was not here I think I know the reasons.