ORDUITHE AN LAE—ORDERS OF THE DAY. - TOWN TENANTS BILL, 1926—SECOND STAGE (RESUMED).
Contributions 120–246 of 246. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 42 of 1926 ›
Was it not stated by the Minister for Justice, on behalf of the Executive Council, when introducing the Rent Restriction Bill in 1926, that the Government were satisfied the time had come when rent control in this country should cease and they were providing for the gradual decontrol of rents?
Comment on this
That is very different to the other statements the Deputy made. If the Deputy would like to make his case clearer, I am quite willing to give way.
Comment on this
I want to get at the grievances. I have listened carefully to half-a-dozen or more speeches. I waited for a particular case of abuse, a particular case of hardship or a particular example of the infirmity of the law as it exists. If there are such, we are entitled to get them.
Comment on this
If the President thinks there is no infirmity in the law as it exists, why are the terms of reference given to the Commission so worded?
Comment on this
Even if the President said that the town tenants have no grievances, he is entitled to be allowed to mention that.
Comment on this
I would like to mention that I never did say that. I admit that they have grievances.
Comment on this
But their spokesmen here in the Dáil are very poor in their explanations of the grievances.
Comment on this
It is exploded on two grounds. I am waiting for further information in regard to the Cappoquin case which will enable me to show the weakness of the Deputy's argument when he was mentioning it. We have definitely exploded the Cappoquin case.
Comment on this
The Deputy's case in regard to the houses at Cappoquin was that the landlord asked that £200 should be expended in repairs. That would amount to £66 13s. 4d. per house and that sum was asked by the landlord to be expended on three houses which were built sixty-six years ago. I happen to have had some experience in connection with the expenditure of money on houses, new and old.
Comment on this
I have had experience of houses, some built many years ago and others more recently, and I submit that the expenditure of £66 13s. 4d. on any house is a negligible sum.
Comment on this
It does not matter by whom they were built. If the Deputy will go further and divide the amount involved over 66 years he will find that it amounts to £1 per annum for the purpose of carrying out serious structural repairs or alterations, and I submit that that is a negligible sum. If we were to go still further and take the capital value of it, it would amount —not on the Deputy Redmond basis of £12 per annum, but on the correct sum, 8 per cent.—to £16 per annum. I am putting it for the consideration of Deputies that the fixing of a fair rent in that case would, in the circumstances as described by the Deputy, be against the tenant.
I would like to say in that connection that Senator Sir John Keane is not a political friend of mine. If my information is correct, he occupies the same position as the late Deputy Figgis did in being the Dublin correspondent of the "Sunday Times," and anybody who reads his views on the Government there will realise that he is the political bed-fellow of the Deputy in his attacks upon the Government. One of the infirmities of this case is that while all the rapacity of a landlord was pictured before our minds, if the case were brought to court, on the evidence that has been set out, the court would most probably fix a higher rent than what the Deputy complains of.
Comment on this
Does that apply in the case of the Land Act of 1923, with the Judicial Commissioner?
Comment on this
The Deputy has slightly anticipated me. I was going to say in connection with the Land Act of 1881 that was what happened in quite a number of cases. The Land Act of 1881 is the parent of this Bill. This Bill is, apparently, taken almost body and soul from that measure, and rather badly at that, if the Deputy will not mind me mentioning it.
I explained a few moments ago what would happen if a case were taken into court. I will go further, and say that the town tenants, as a class, have not got the wealth, or are not reputed to be as wealthy, as the landlords, and when one goes to court the balance is always, as in war, with the big battalions. The heavier purse has the better chance.
Comment on this
Not at all. It is not the judiciary, but rather the persons one can employ in order to deal with the case. The Deputy knows that if he were taking an action himself the question of getting the best professional advice he could would be his first consideration. The Deputy does not deny that. I would like to know if the Deputy maintains that this particular Bill is not actually loaded against the poor tenant?
Comment on this
The President has asked me if I think that this Bill is loaded against the tenant, especially in regard to appealing to a judicial tribunal. I say that if this Bill was passed the town tenant of the future would have as good a chance as the agricultural tenant had in the past in the tribunal set up by the Land Act of 1881.
Comment on this
The land tenant in 1881 had rather a useful organisation behind him. The town tenants may have perhaps a greater number of organisations, but I hesitate to say that any of them have the punch or the purse or the ability that there was behind the land organisation.
Comment on this
And give them the money to enter it. We have got several cases of the poor tenant paying £20 a year. You offer him courts with fees for solicitors and barristers and the possibility of his rent being increased. I am sure that in cases like that there will be a great march towards the courts.
Comment on this
I desire to ask the President one question. Have the tenants taken advantage of the Rent Restriction Act?
Comment on this
As far as I know they have. It is alleged that some have not, and that they have settled rather than incur the court expenses. I do not know whether the Deputy's information is contrary to that: that some tenants have settled without going into court at a higher price than they could have settled if they had gone to court.
Comment on this
I certainly will not deny that cases were settled out of court, but I will deny this, that the tenant had not every opportunity to go to court under the Rent Restriction Act just as land tenants had under the Land Act; and that they did go to court and made use of the court.
Comment on this
Certainly not, you cannot say all. The Deputy knows perfectly well that this is an expensive Bill for the tenant.
Comment on this
And that if there was not an organization behind them that the courts, the Circuit Court in the first instance, and the High Court in the second instance, are beyond the means of the ordinary town tenant.
Comment on this
Will the President introduce an amendment providing the tenants with a cheaper method?
Comment on this
We are putting up a Commission to ascertain what infirmities or anomalies there are that might be corrected.
Comment on this
For many reasons. We had many things to do during the last two years. We would like to have been able to do many more things than we have done and I expect that when we come back, as I have no doubt we will, we will attend to every one of them. There was an express provision in the Town Tenants Act of 1906, and also in the Rent Restriction Act against contracting out of provisions. Now a landlord and tenant, if this Bill passes into law, may contract out notwithstanding what the Deputy said yesterday evening. If the tenant is a single week in arrears the landlord may get possession or become entitled to possession and he can refuse to re-let. One breach and out goes the tenant, and the house may not be let except the incoming tenant will contract out of the Act. There is one infirmity in the Bill.
Comment on this
Of course. The Deputy hastily wrote out a Town Tenants Bill, or got somebody to do it, and now everything that is wrong with that we are asked to settle in Committee.
Comment on this
There were a great many Bills introduced by the Government that had to be altered in Committee.
Comment on this
Certainly, and some were withdrawn, but during our period we have produced a considerable number.
Comment on this
Yes, quite a number. I think one was withdrawn and did not even get a Second Reading. The Minister for Defence asked, I think, to have one Bill withdrawn and produced another Bill.
Comment on this
The description of ground rent under this Act is very indeterminate. The Deputy made no explanation of what it meant, and none of those who spoke in favour of the measure enlightened us further as to what it meant. Deputy Davin smiles as if he had in mind some rapacious landlords.
Comment on this
Then there is the owner in fee simple. He lets to another and the thing goes up. We have landlords in Dublin five and six deep. Anyone who has had experience in the matter of the acquisition of land for the purpose of the Housing Acts knows to what extent there are interests in holdings. Anyone who has had experience knows what enormous costs are incurred in proving title. In one case which came under my notice the site value was fixed at £9 17s. 6d. The costs of proving title were £59. I was just thinking of that little experience in connection with this Bill: that if a tenant had spent £50 or £60 or £70 in getting his rent reduced one shilling a week whether it was a good bargain for him. As regards the ten per cent., where does it begin and where does it end? Does it begin with the ground rent, which is anything from £2 up to £20, and does it go from layer to layer up to the very top? A tenant may get a fair rent fixed under this Bill. He may then let the house in furnished lodgings at any price and make a considerable profit at the expense of the landlord. Under this Bill, if it became law, he is entitled to sub-let once the fair rent is fixed. He is in for a statutory term. Agricultural tenants were not allowed to sub-let without consent. The Increase of Rent Act or, rather, the Rent Restrictions Act——
Comment on this
No, I have the right to speak a second time. The Rent Restrictions Act is the correct title. There is no Act on our books called the Increase of Rent Act. The Rent Restrictions Act aimed at the stopping of bonuses and succeeded in doing it. Where is the provision in this Act to do it? The Deputy mentioned yesterday evening that there was a provision, but I have failed to find it. He said there would be no such competition "as was mentioned on the last occasion for key money."
Comment on this
Perhaps I could explain that. The only tenant that would have the right to sell his interest would be the tenant of business premises or partly business premises. That is in Section 4.
Comment on this
There is nothing to prevent a landlord demanding key money and getting it under this Act— nothing whatever. If the Deputy has a provision in the Bill to prevent it, I would like to see where it is. The position on the passing of this Bill is that a landlord could agree with an in-coming tenant for a bonus, fine, key money, or any other consideration, in respect of a vacant house.
Comment on this
It is the principles of this measure we are considering. If we give our consent to them we may or may not get anything in Committee. This Bill has not been brought into relation with the Rent Restrictions Act. The position is bound to be obscure and will lead to costly litigation. A great deal of play was made about fixity of tenure. If a man gets fixity of tenure under this Bill and has a house in Merrion Square he can turn it into a shop. It was not let to him for that purpose. He can go further and use it for bad purposes and the landlord cannot turn him out.
Comment on this
I would like to correct the President in that respect. Under Section 1 it is provided that the tenant shall not, without the consent of the landlord in writing, sub-divide his holding or alter the character of his holding, so that I think the President is not quite accurate when he states that if a house is let in Merrion Square the tenant could turn it into a shop.
Comment on this
He may not alter the character of the holding in the slightest, and still it can be turned into a shop. It could be used for bad purposes, and as there is fixity of tenure the landlord could not put out the tenant.
Comment on this
He can, because you are giving him something that he has not got. He could make it into a hospital for infectious diseases if he wished.
Comment on this
Once he gets fixity of tenure, the character of the holding has not changed by structural alterations. We will see now what the cost likely to be incurred would be in connection with these. A tenant having a fair rent fixed can become a landlord under this Bill. What is the position of the middleman? Deputy Morrissey mentioned one middleman, or middle woman, as the case might be. There are many interests in some holdings in a place like the city of Dublin, and I suppose in Cork and other places. You may have the position where a fair rent would be fixed less than what one of the intermediate middlemen would be paying. The last middleman might be getting £200 a year, or the second last, and the person in possession might have a fair rent fixed and have it arranged at £160. That is an immediate loss of £40. What is the way out? It is for the man paying the £200 to surrender his lease and out goes the tenant at once. It seems to me that the position of the tenant is much worse than before the Bill was brought in to provide for an improvement of the position of tenants "in certain houses, shops and other buildings."
I have dealt, I hope, with practically all phases of the measure. I come now to comment slightly on the manner in which this Bill has been dealt with here. I wondered for a considerable time whether it was the forthcoming election we had in our minds in this particular measure. Just before passing on, Section 8 of this Bill makes provision for landlords being liable for rates on houses up to £5 valuation. The Local Government Department has had under consideration for a considerable time and, in fact, a Bill may be introduced shortly, fixing the valuation for which landlords will be responsible at £6 while making other changes in connection with that particular matter. I am not satisfied at all that this measure deals in a fair and satisfactory way with the present position of tenant and landlord. I am not satisfied that the passing of this measure would be any relief to tenants. It is a hastily conceived measure badly drafted, and amendments, even to suit Deputy Morrissey or Deputy Davin, would be very considerable, and would fail to achieve the purpose which is portrayed. I submit, in all decency and honesty, that matters like this are too serious to be made the sport of political play, or political playacting, and that we have set up a Commission, in good faith, of persons well qualified to consider the question.
Comment on this
There are many other Commissions that have to be brought into being and that will have to wait still longer. If the Deputy would occasionally allow political considerations to escape from him, and not be thinking of what people in his constituency might say about him, and exercised his own commonsense on questions, he would bring a much saner and able judgment to bear on the questions he has to decide.
Comment on this
Certainly not. We have had the setting up of this Commission under consideration for two years.
Comment on this
How many Commissions have been set up by the Government since they assumed office, and how many reports or recommendations of these Commissions have been put into operation?
Comment on this
I will accept a statement from the Deputy as to how many have not been put into operation.
Comment on this
The report of the Canal Commission, which was one of the first, has been ignored and not been put into operation, and the recommendations of the Old Age Pensions Committee are another instance.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would make a list of all these before the General Election he will have the opportunity of explaining to the people what a different administration there would be if he were over here on these Benches. The complaint is that this Commission has been set up too late. It is better late than never. It is a better attempt to deal with the town tenants problem than this Bill—much better. If Deputy Heffernan had four years to go instead of only six months, he would back the Commission for all he would be worth, but the six months period is too short. It is much better to tell the people straight what you are satisfied you can do than to say "I always want to do the popular thing." We have not tried to do that. We have always tried to do the right thing. If a Bill was brought in to make it illegal to collect land annuities it would probably be received in certain parts of the country with considerable eclat.
Comment on this
I cannot allow this to pass. I do not like the President to suggest that I always like to do the popular thing.
Comment on this
During the few years I happened to be a member of the Corporation, the administration of the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act was one of the most successful of all the Acts administered by that body and the one which cost the municipality least. There was a real genuine effort made on the part of those who borrowed money under that Act to meet their obligations, and the losses in connection with its administration were negligible. It is not so easily worked now owing to the increase in the cost of money. At that time it was possible to lend £300 on a house that cost £400 at 4 per cent., and the actual outgoings on the part of anybody partaking of the provisions of that Act were the same as the rent that would be charged on a house of that kind. Our efforts during the last three or four years in connection with any houses that were built were to let those who could afford to buy the houses do so. Even with all the assistance we have given to housing the number of houses built under the various Acts that have been passed is something like 13,000 or 14,000. It is a considerable number, but all forces had to be brought into play in order to do it. I must admit here plainly and distinctly that in connection with this Bill there was present in the minds of the mover and supporters of it only one side of the case. I think I have shown some of the infirmities in connection with the consideration even of that side of the case.
There is another side and there is no voice here to represent that side. I am not in the position of a landlord. I know very few of them but I know they are needed to deal with the extraordinary shortage of houses. I know it is not safe or wise to make any attempts to limit them. I know they would be limited if a measure such as this were passed without bringing them into conference or consideration. They ought to be allowed to make their case if they have a case to make. It is a serious step to decide this matter from the evidence on one side. I must admit I have been appalled with the small number of cases in connection with the relations of landlord and tenant that have been mentioned here. There are many cases one hears of in which the landlord is quite a good citizen and in which his efforts are necessary. I mean the landlord of houses let to working-class people. His efforts are required to provide more houses.
Comment on this
Perhaps he makes a decent sum of money, but from what I have learned I may say it is by no means as remunerative an investment as it was. In one particular case in Dublin there is a company which has been at this work for something like 40 years. The profits that are made are not colossal. If you look at quotations on the Stock Exchange you will find that their shares are quoted at £7, whereas many people paid £12 for those shares. That company has the reputation of being well run and I am sorry that it stopped its operations. It is alleged that it stopped some of its operations by reason of the objection of tenants to pay any increase in rent during the time when certain increases of rent were permitted. I think very good work could be done if bodies such as that, which were at one time seriously interested in housing, could be brought back to the work. I believe the passing of the Second Reading of this Bill would stop activities of that sort definitely, and that if we were to find a solution it should be found through a Commission, and if not from this Commission let whatever Government is here after us set up one to find it out. The Government set up this Commission in good faith. It got a Commission to serve from which, I believe, we shall have a good report. Personally, I would be satisfied to adopt that report in legislation when it is furnished.
Comment on this
Frequently, lately, I have read, and heard more frequently still, of the number of young men who originally started life with one view but have turned their course and are going into the law. I have not heard that yet of the President, but if that had been his decision I could imagine him achieving particular success in a particular sphere of action in the law courts. There are lawyers who shine exceedingly in trying to appeal to a jury by getting hold of all the little details of a case, magnifying them and trying to convince the jury that here is the issue, and to leave out the real matter in question. That may succeed, and as soon as the lawyer has sat down the jury's minds are utterly befogged. They are convinced that the small details matter. The judge then brings back realities to the mind of the jury, and, unfortunately for the lawyer who has tried to confuse the issue, the judge brings the real facts before the jury. I think in this case the country will say that all the President's feelings about details do not affect the issue in question. The issue in question here, as far as I understand it, is the same issue as was raised in the previous Bill. Is this House prepared to say that the tenants of houses and business houses have a right to security of tenure as long as they pay the agreed rental and have protection against rack-renting by landlords?
There are several questions raised by certain provisions of this Bill, but those are the two main principles involved. The House has been persuaded to declare itself against those principles once, and now it is asked to declare itself in favour of them, to give them a second chance. The Second Reading of a Bill is intended to give the House an opportunity of saying whether they are in favour of the general principles of Bills brought to the House. The Minister for Justice has, quite legitimately, and very reasonably, told the country that it is the country that decides what shall be the course of legislation, and it appoints the Dáil to carry out its wishes in that matter.
The Dáil is a representative body. Here is a question of principle affecting security of tenure and protection against rack rents. Is this House prepared to say that it believes it is necessary for the good government of this country that house tenants and business-premises tenants shall be protected in this respect? If the House says "Yes," then your Commission can go to work to find how best to apply those principles with the least harm to the country and with the greatest amount of practical value, but give the Commission the will of this Chamber as to the main principles. There has been a good deal of talk about setting up the Commission. I am asking Deputies on all sides of the House whether they realise that the assumption in setting up this Commission is that the whole question in doubt is whether there are any grievances in connection with town tenants. Do Deputies say that they are satisfied that there are no grievances or that they have any doubts on the question?
To my knowledge for twenty-five years at least questions of town tenants and their grievances have been discussed. People talk about noisy agitations. I do not think that they have been very noisy. I think many agitations have been badly conducted, but the grievances are undoubtedly there. The President asks the Dáil to bring forward, for his edification, instances, as though there were not in the mind of every Deputy many grievances, and as though there was any necessity to bring forward detailed evidence regarding grievances and anomalies.
Comment on this
The President's method of judgment, his standard of equity, is at fault. A case was brought forward in connection with three houses which were built by the grandfather of the present occupant. A lease of sixty years had expired, and the owner of the ground, who had legal rights over the house, when the lease fell in demanded an increase of rentals and endeavoured to impose on the tenant an obligation to spend a certain sum of money before he would renew the lease. The President says that that is very reasonable.
Comment on this
No. I said if that went to court, only on the facts as outlined by Deputy Morrissey, it is possible that under all the circumstances, as mentioned in the Bill, the sum fixed for the fair rent might be more. I did not express any opinion on it.
Comment on this
The President believes that there is a risk that the court might take into account the present market value and the local demand for that particular house in fixing the value. There is the grievance. The law is that the landlord may use his legal authority to screw out of that tenant, when renewing the lease, whatever the can obtain and take advantage of that tenant's business ability, the local circumstances, the fact that he has established himself in business in that house, and that he will be reluctant to leave those premises. Therefore, the landlord exploits that value to raise the rentals. There is a sentimental value attached to a house in which a man lives and brings up his family. The President supports the landlord, and Deputy Hewat applauds him and says that the landlord is entitled to turn into money value the sentimental value attached to such house.
Comment on this
The President supports the proposition, and Deputy Hewat applauds it, that the law should be altered to enable a landlord to turn into cash the sentiment which each family has for its own home.
Comment on this
I do not think it is fair for the President or anybody else to assume that these are three separate dwelling houses, occupied by three families. I have not the details. Two of the houses may be business premises and, as a matter of fact, that, I think, is the position.
Comment on this
I want to know whether Deputy Morrissey's statement is correct, that they are three dwelling-houses.
Comment on this
The terms of reference to the Commission have been mentioned, and a phrase or two from these terms is worth quoting to a House that knows the grievances of town tenants, and, time after time, Deputies have been asked for support by town tenants with a view to removing their grievances. This Commission is "to ascertain what hardships or anomalies, if any, arise under the law." Deputies are asked by the Minister to withhold judgment as to whether there are hardships. Ministers say: "We do not know. There may be. The landlords may have hardships. The tenants may have hardships. We do not know. We will set up a commission to inquire and then we will consider what kind of legislation ought to be introduced." I am saying to the Dail: "Here is a proposition. There are, in fact, grievances of town tenants, whether householders or holders of business premises, and we require that legislation should be enacted which will give security of tenure to town tenants as long as they pay the agreed rental and observe the terms of letting, and they shall be protected against rack-renting. Give adhesion to these principles and then consider how they can best be applied." If Deputies are voting against the Second Reading of the Bill they are voting against these two principles. They have already voted against the principles because of the pleadings of Ministers. Again I say, the opportunity is offered and, as has been pointed out by Deputy O'Connell, they need not fear any criticism of Party disloyalty, because the President has assured us that there is perfect freedom of action in respect of his Party as there is in respect of our Party. I invite, publicly, every Deputy on our benches, if he wishes, to vote against the Second Reading.
Comment on this
I ask the President to invite his Party, if they think the principles embodied in this Bill are right, to vote for the Second Reading. Bear in mind, in view of that assurance to the Dáil by the President, you can not hide behind the contention that you are bound by Party discipline. You will be judged by your own actions and you will deserve to be condemned. It seems to me that the arguments that have been brought forward in opposition to the principles that I have put forth as the principles of this Bill are the arguments, differently stated, a little softened, a little involved, of Deputy Hewat—the arguments that the owner of the house is entitled to whatever he can consider the market value of that house to be.
If it is profitable for the owner of the house to get rid of one tenant and extract a higher rent from another, then it is perfectly justifiable, perfectly legal, and the right should be continued to the landlord, to evict one and take a rack-rent out of another. That is the proposition, clearly stated by Deputy Hewat, stated, not so clearly but undoubtedly with equal effect, by the President and the Minister for Justice. That is the issue, in my opinion, and I think that when reference is made to the effect of the Increase of Rent and Mortgage Interest (Restriction) Act it might be well to remember what the purpose of that Act was. If Deputy Hennessy had been thoroughly acquainted with the effect of that Act I think he would have had a different story to tell here to-day. The purpose of that Act was to bring into disuse any legislation restricting rentals on house property, and the position that Deputy Hewat looks forward to will, in fact, by the operation of that Act, introduced by the Government and passed by a majority of the House, become effective in 1929. Landlords will then be able to extract the last halfpenny out of any tenant, so far as the law goes. One effect of this Bill undoubtedly would be to make permanent the intentions of those Acts which have restricted the powers of landlords to screw rents out of their tenants in a time of shortage.
It is not true to say, as was suggested by Deputy Cooper, Deputy Hewat and others, by inference, that houses are identical in fact with every other marketable commodity. They are not. They may be increasable, but it takes a considerable time to increase the number of houses. Articles of ordinary commerce are, in the main, producible and are consumed within a very short period, but a house is something that is semi-permanent. There is attachment to a house; personal qualities enter into the occupation of a house. A house becomes part of a family heritage. It is suggested that there is no difference between a house in which a family has grown up and where the personal touch is clearly discernable, that it is the same as a watch or pair of boots, or a suit of clothes.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy consider that there is any obligation on a person to provide houses for sentimental reasons?
Comment on this
No, I do not consider that there is any obligation, but I consider that when a person has thought it a good investment at any stated period to put his money into house property, believing that he can obtain a certain rate of interest on his investment in that house property at the time, if he is secured by a fair rent court, by the law or by any other means in that rental, that he is well served in having a security and that he should not have the right to take advantage of the tenant's necessity to screw out a rent——
Comment on this
The tenant under this Bill would bind himself to pay a rental that is agreed upon or that may be fixed by the court.
Comment on this
A rent that is agreed upon or fixed by the court, according to the statutory term of his tenancy.
Comment on this
The law at present observes that, because if a man takes a house for a period of years he will be a tenant during the period of his lease.
Comment on this
The issue is clearly knit. The issue is whether Deputies are going, with Deputy Hewat, to say that the owner of a house or the owner of a business premises, when the lease, the term of agreement, has expired, is entitled to take advantage of the necessity or of the business needs of the tenant, or of the fact that that tenant will be bound to pay an increase if he wants to retain his business connection, or whether we are to consider that the tenant, having agreed to pay a certain rental, will continue to pay that rental and so long as he pays that rental will be secured in his tenancy, or, if there is any disagreement as to what is a fair rental, that he shall have the right to go to a tribunal which is impartial as between the two parties. That is the issue, and if Deputies are in favour of giving that security to tenants, whether as to tenancy or as to rentals, they will at least vote for the principles that are embodied in this Bill. If they are against the tenant in these matters, if they are for Deputy Hewat and the President and the landlords, they will do as they did before and vote against the Second Reading, and they are not in favour of the principles of fair rentals and security of tenure.
Comment on this
I wonder if Deputy Johnson would carry his argument beyond the tenants of houses, into all commercial agreements of every kind, and tell us what the difference is?
Comment on this
I do not desire to detain the House at any very great length, especially after Deputy Johnson's speech. He has, to my mind, put very clearly before the House what the real issue is which they will be called on to decide in the Division Lobbies. I never proposed this Bill, as some Deputies would seem to imagine, to be the final and the complete settlement of all the grievances of tenants in towns in Ireland. Such a proposition, coming from anyone, even from the head of a Government, much more from a private Deputy, would be nothing short of colossal egotism, in my opinion. I was distinctly amused by the suggestion which has come from some quarters, notably from Deputy Gorey, that because this Bill did not purport fully and finally to settle the question of the town tenants it should, therefore, not be considered in Committee. If that had been the attitude, may I say with respect to him, adopted by the leaders of the land movement in days gone by, what would have happened? Supposing that Mr. Parnell and others had at that time taken up the attitude that because the Land Bill of 1881 did not go as far as they thought was right and was not what they considered a final, full and satisfactory settlement of the land question, it should not be considered even upon Second Reading and the Second Reading allowed to pass, I think that the farmers of Ireland would not have progressed very far since that time.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation—will the Deputy say if a Commission were offered by the British Government at the time to treat the whole matter fully and fairly, not to tinker with the subject, but to deal with the question as a whole? In 1881, or at any other period, was a Commission offered by any Government to deal with the whole question?
Comment on this
I cannot go back to 1881. What I will surmise would have happened is this— that if Parnell and his colleagues had been offered a Commission, and if the terms of reference of that Commission had stated that the principles which they sought to establish, namely, fixity of tenure and fair rent, were admitted and agreed upon, I do believe that Parnell and his colleagues would have accepted that Commission and would have been glad to receive the offer of that Commission. But this is an entirely different state of affairs. The President, in his very amusing and lengthy speech, dealing, as he usually does, in his cheap, sneering way with paltry details, mentioned, amongst other details, that I myself had been the cause of the delay in having this Bill in the hands of Deputies. As a matter of personal explanation, I would like to point out that when I introduced this Bill, the Bill, as the Ceann Comhairle has already said, was actually in his hands, but that on that occasion the Second Reading of the Bill had, against my wishes, been postponed until the 19th January.
The complaint is now that owing to the Ceann Comhairle having raised points of procedure on certain sections in the Bill, I was not able to have it in Deputies' hands for three weeks after its introduction, in spite of the fact that it was not to receive its Second Reading until the 19th January. I do not think that that point carries much weight. I am not going into arguments with either the President or any Deputy on matters of mere detail in regard to this measure. The fact that it would entail considerable cost to the State, the fact that the tenants would undoubtedly not be in as good a position as the landlords to go to the courts, and various other questions, are entirely matters for discussion upon the Committee Stage, and nobody knows that better than the President himself. The only thing that I would like to make clear in regard to the remarks of the Vice-President is this: that I do not consider the question of the fixity of tenure or fair rent matters of detail. Those, to my mind, are the bed-rock principles of the Bill, and given those and admitting those, then the question of the means whereby those principles can be carried out and put into effect are matters for the Dáil in Committee. I have drafted the Bill based upon those principles, and I have done my best in that respect. I have been told by the President, who, I am sure, is a good judge, that this is a badly drafted Bill. Well, I am not in the position that he is. I have not got a host of able draftsmen at my back nor Parliamentary Secretaries to depend upon. I am merely introducing this as a Private Member in Private Members' time, and I make a present to the President of his opinion as to the quality of the draftsmanship.
One argument has been used which I think deserves mention. It was rather strongly stressed by the Minister for Finance. The purport of his speech was "Leave the existing law alone as it is in regard to the existing houses, but the real solution is to build more houses." Yes. There is a great deal to be said for that. But is it his contention and that of the Government that before the necessary number of houses are built—some say it is 40,000, others say it is 60,000 that are required in the Saorstát—that during that period the tenants under existing conditions should be allowed to remain where they are and have none of their grievances remedied?
It has been questioned whether it was advisable to limit this measure to houses erected before the year 1919. One of the principal reasons why I made that limitation was in the hope that new houses would be built and that when a sufficient number of houses were built that there would be no necessity to apply these principles to those new houses. But to suggest that we should wait until 40,000 have been built before anything is done for any of the tenants under the existing circumstances. I say does not meet the case as it presents itself, or should present itself, to every Deputy at the moment.
Comment on this
When the 40,000 houses are built would the Deputy repeal this Bill or extend it to the 40,000 houses? Clearly there would be a distinction between the houses built prior to 1919 and the houses built subsequently. Now, when and if the 40,000 houses which the Deputy mentioned were built, what would be the Deputy's idea then—would it be to maintain the distinction or to abolish it, by, either (a) to repeal this Bill, or (b) the extension of this Bill to the new houses?
Comment on this
Yes, perfectly entitled to put it. I am only pointing out that it is a hypothetical question; that if 40,000 houses would have been built the circumstances would have been altered to a considerable extent, and according to the Minister and his friends that would be the solution of the existing grievances of the town tenants, and if that was the solution of the grievances that exist to-day, there certainly would be no reason for applying the principles of this Bill. But if it was not the case, and if these grievances did exist, after a sufficient number of houses had come into being, then it would, of course, present a different picture.
The various speakers have thought fit to dwell considerably upon the effect of this proposal on the forthcoming election. We have heard it suggested that those who vote for this measure will vote for it entirely for election purposes. I dealt with that point in my opening statement, but I should like to say this—I do not think I will be accused of undue egotism when I say it, because it is a mere fact—that were it not for the production of the previous Bill and this Bill, there never would have been any Commission set up at all.
Comment on this
If that is not so, why was there not a Commission set up before the introduction of my second Bill? Why was it that, even in replying to my demand that the Second Reading of this Bill should be taken up earlier than the Government chose, the Government never even suggested to any of their spokesmen that they had the slightest idea of setting up a Commission? It was not until two or three days afterwards that the President went to the country and there announced to a deputation that it was the Government's intention to set up a Commission. I say that these facts prove conclusively—if there be such a thing as proof—that the only reason this Commission has been set up is because I have introduced this Bill.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy allow me to say that I was looking for a personnel for this Commission six weeks before the introduction of the Deputy's Bill? I could—I do not like to mention names in the Dáil—give the Deputy, personally, the names of people whom I asked to act on this Commission six weeks prior to the introduction of his Bill.
Comment on this
I must accept the Minister's assurance that he was seeking for people prior to the introduction of my Bill to act upon this Commission. Still, I am entitled to comment upon the extraordinary reticence shown by the Government when they were asking for postponement of the Second Reading of this Bill in the House. They never mentioned then that there was to be a Commission. Surely, if they were searching the highways and by-ways and the rotary clubs last year for members of a Commission, they could have stated so in this House. The only reason the Government offered for postponing the Second Reading of this Bill was that the time of the House was so occupied that it would not be possible to take the Bill before the 19th January. That is all I have to say on that point.
The President has said "Better late than never." I agree with him in that. It was suggested by the Vice-President that if I were in a similar position to him or his colleagues I would not introduce a Bill such as this without setting up a Commission such as the Government has set up. I am inclined to agree with him in that. But I am not in that position. I have no power to set up a Commission. I am only a private member of the Dáil. If I had been in his position, I would have had the power to set up a Commission and I would have set up the Commission. By now, I should have had legislation passed and in operation in the country. The effect of the introduction of this measure is that the Government has set up a Commission. The terms of reference of the Commission have been published. We now know that the Government are going to reject a measure the main principles of which are that no tenant shall be disturbed or evicted from his holding provided he pays his rent and complies with other reasonable conditions, and that he should be entitled to go before a tribunal and get a fair rent fixed. I am not going into the question the President was so anxious about as to what is a tribunal. I heard of an adult who asked the question: "Who is Charlie Chaplin?" I think that is on a par with the President's questions: "What is a tribunal?"; "what is a fair rent?" In the Bill are set out the rules the Court is to follow in order to determine what a fair rent is. They are there in plain terms, and I do not think it requires a great intellect to be able to comprehend the meaning of these terms. Deputies will be called upon to vote for or against the Second Reading of this Bill. If the Government could give me an assurance that they would amend the terms of reference of the Commission, which the passage of the Second Reading of this Bill would tend to bring about, and that they would inform the Commission that it was their opinion, and the opinion of the House, that the report should be based on the principles of fixity of tenure and fair rents for all tenants in Ireland, subject to the necessary conditions and exclusions, certainly I would be satisfied. But that is not their intention. Up to this, we have been told that the principles contained in the Bill, as well as the details, are wrong. If the Second Reading of this Bill were to be carried, it would in no way interfere with the Commission beyond giving them an expression of what the view of the House is, in regard to the basis on which they should make their report. If the House rejects the Second Reading, it comes to this: that the Commission will enter on the consideration of this question knowing that the present Government, at any rate—the Government which set it up—are not in favour of the principle of fixity of tenure or fair rents. Certainly that should and must influence their decision. In view of the attitude taken up by the Government, in view of the pressing demands—I make no secret of it—made every day on Deputies by tenants in towns all over the Saorstát, and in view of the manner in which the Government has dealt with the matter up to this, I can do nothing but ask the House to pass the Second Reading of the Bill. If the Second Reading of the Bill were passed I would not proceed any further if I got an assurance that the Commission would consider the question on the basis and principles I have enunciated. But in the light of the debate that has taken place and the attitude adopted by the Government and its spokesmen, I feel that I must ask Deputies to record their opinion on the question whether the tenants in towns in the Saorstát are to be allowed to remain in their holdings, provided they pay their rent, and have fair rents fixed. If the House decides in that manner it will do no harm to the Commission. It will only be guidance for it. If they decide in the other direction, it will intimate to the Commission that the lines on which it is to go are to be exceedingly restricted and limited.