We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

IN COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. - VOTE 32—GARDA SIOCHANA.

Contributions 129–259 of 259. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

It was not my intention to intervene in this debate, because I had very little hope that I would be able to convince the Minister of the error of his ways and the falsity of his arguments, but now that one whom I can regard as an ally has entered the House I can attempt to do so. That ally is the Minister for Agriculture. It appears that the Minister for Justice is under the impression that the police force consists of 7,210 men. It is to be regretted that he was not present when the Minister for Agriculture was speaking on the Army Estimate a few days ago and when he informed the House that in addition to the 7,210 men in the Civic Guards we had 12,500 policemen in the Army. If the Minister for Agriculture is correct we, therefore, have 20,000 policemen in the country, and it must be remembered that the functions of the Civic Guard, as defined by the Minister for Justice, do not differ one iota from the functions of the Army, as defined by the Minister for Agriculture. We have both forces serving the same functions and both costing the State several millions between them. The Government from time to time professes its anxiety for economy, and Deputies frequently emphasise the need for economy. Surely there is here an avenue along which it is possible to achieve economy. We have two forces performing the same functions.

I am trying to quote the Minister's exact words: "Both established for the purpose of ensuring that the people of the country will have the right to do wrong." 12,500 men in the Army, established for the purpose of ensuring that the people of the country will have the right to do wrong and 7,210 men in the Civic Guards established—I hope the Minister will agree—for the same purpose of ensuring that the people of the country will have the right to do wrong. If, as Deputy after Deputy repeatedly assured us, this is one of the most crimeless countries in the world; and if, as Minister after Minister assured us, any abnormal conditions which heretofore existed are now rapidly disappearing, it is possible to combine the functions of these forces, thus to reduce their numbers, and incidentally reduce the cost of both. The Minister for Justice is apparently very definitely of the opinion that the functions of the Civic Guard are not what are normally regarded as police functions in other countries. He compared the number of Civic Guards now in the Twenty-six Counties with the number of members of the R.I.C. in the Twenty-six Counties in 1914. He also compared the number of Civic Guard stations now in the Twenty-six Counties with the number of R.I.C. barracks in 1914, and by doing so and claiming credit for that argument, he has undoubtedly conveyed the impression that the functions of the Civic Guard are identical with those of the R.I.C. in 1914. The functions of the R.I.C., as stated by Sir Hamar Greenwood or somebody of that ilk, were identical with the functions of the National Army as stated by the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Or Balfour.

Comment on this

Any of them. They all talked much the same. The Minister has probably studied the various replies they gave to identical questions asked of the British Government. Certainly he has all the phraseology.

Comment on this

What is bred in the greenwood comes out in the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

We know, and some Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies know, that the R.I.C. was not a police force as such. It was the active service unit of the British army of occupation in this country. Their function was not merely to ensure that people had lights on their carts, drove on the left-hand side of the road, and did not beat their wives. They had a definite function, namely, to ensure that the authority of the British Parliament would be maintained in this country against the wishes of the Irish people, and when the Minister compared the relative strength of the R.I.C. with that of the Civic Guard, he gives the impression that the Civic Guard should have the same functions and perform the same duties in the Free State as the R.I.C. performed here some years ago. I would like if the Minister would correct that impression, and if he modifies his statement in concluding the debate and asserts, as I believe he will, that the Civic Guard have no other duties to perform except the normal duties of a police force, he will, perhaps, find that he has much difficulty in justifying the actual number of the Civic Guards. The number of police in this country, in proportion to the number of the people, is higher than in the majority of countries. It is much higher than in England or Scotland or Wales, and yet we know that the conduct of our people is much better than that of the people in those countries. Our people are not as addicted to crimes as the people in the large towns in England and Scotland. Deputy J.J. Byrne tried to maintain that that was due to the fact that the Civic Guards are here in such numbers.

It is not the case, as Deputy Hennessy by way of interruption pointed out, that there is a very decided difference between the attitude of the English people towards their police and the attitude of the Irish people to the Civic Guard. Deputy Hennessy said that every man in England is a policeman and is anxious and willing to assist the police forces in the detection of crime. That attitude does not exist so strongly in Ireland for the reason that there are too many policemen here. Take the average Irish village with half a dozen public houses, a few cottages and a police station with five or six Civic Guards. If anything occurs in that village—two men fighting at a street corner or a man runs away with another man's chickens—everybody says "Oh, there is something for the police to do at last, thank God, it will prevent them getting too fat." That is the attitude. They see the policemen have nothing to do but hanging round the barrack door or strolling up and down the village street and they are rather glad that anything should happen which makes them feel that they are getting value for the money they are spending on the police. In England, where there is only one policeman to every five or six thousand of the population, the instinct of self-preservation makes everybody anxious to help the police and makes everybody try to do what in them lies to prevent any crime. It is because we have too many policemen that we have not got the right attitude towards the detection and suppression of crime here. We do not object to the adequate payment of members of the police force and I think if Deputy Byrne—I am sorry he is not here—compares the average rate of payment in Britain to the English police force with the rate of payment here he will find that we pay our police force much more.

Comment on this

Oh no, far less.

Comment on this

I am sorry that I am not able to produce the figures now but I got a report issued by the British Government concerning the various rates of pay in the numerous police forces in England, and I found that on the average, rank for rank, the pay is much less in England. If the Minister can correct me I will be glad. Personally I think the police are adequately paid. A man in barracks provided with his clothes, his food and housing accommodation and with £3 or £3 10s. per week, pocket money, is not badly paid. As a matter of fact I was reading a newspaper article last Sunday by a well-known journalist who asserted that no member of the Civic Guard considers himself properly equipped unless he has a dress suit and a kit bag.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Lemass read the English Sunday papers?

Comment on this

I read that one and I have never objected to anybody else reading it. Certainly I was rather interested to hear that item of news, because we do not get that type of news in an Irish paper. No member of the Civic Guard considers himself properly equipped unless he has a dress suit and a kit bag. You can imagine what happens in Rosmuck, the Glenties or the Rosses—members of the Civic Guard parading down to the dance hall in their dress suits, and they are under the impression that they are badly paid! They can afford to go around regularly in dress suits when they are not in uniform. We are rather glad that we have got 7,210 people in this country who can go about in dress suits. Five or six years ago we could not parade that number of people in dress suits. We have them scattered throughout the country to give a tone to the social life of our towns and villages. That is rather satisfactory, but, unfortunately, the members of the Civic Guard do very little else except to give tone to the social life of our towns and villages. The purpose for which we want them is not to parade at village dances in dress suits, but to ensure that any person who wants to disobey the laws enacted by this Assembly will get what is coming to him. Mind you, that can be ensured. The Civic Guard in the detection and the suppression of minor crime, at any rate, have been remarkably successful. They have been remarkably unsuccessful in solving the bigger sensational crimes that have occurred in the last few years, but that is possibly due to circumstances not in their control.

The fact is that they have been reasonably efficient as a police force, but unfortunately we have to come to the conclusion that there is not enough work to justify such a number of them, or to prevent a number of them from becoming ineffective through sheer idleness. These remarks are with reference to the normal police force provided for in the estimate alone. They do not cover the 571 who cannot be described as policemen in the ordinary sense. They consist of 235 Gárdaí on detective duties and 336 in plain clothes. I hope the Minister will tell us the exact difference between a Gárda engaged in detective duties and a Gárda in plain clothes. There seems to be a distinction, because the Gárda detective on duty gets 7/- per week extra, while the Gárda in plain clothes only gets 5/- a week extra. Apparently there must be a distinction and a difference in the amount of work to be done. Unfortunately, in connection with those 571 people I cannot say any word of praise. Deputy Davin seems to think that it is a dangerous doctrine to preach that the Civic Guard is a political or a semi-political force. It is a dangerous doctrine, but it is much more dangerous to suppress the fact when we know that it is so. I can prove to any committee or to any court, or to any person who wants it proved, that the Civic Guards did act as an election machine for Cumann na nGaedheal last September. I can produce men who saw them in the barracks in Leixlip, in County Kildare, with a series of Cumann na nGaedheal posters in the day-room posting them up on boards to display them round the town.

I can produce hundreds of men all over the country who can declare that they have seen Civic Guards defacing and tearing down the posters of other political parties. I have seen them doing it myself. I can produce several hundred witnesses who will prove that the Civic Guards have interfered, without any justification whatever, in the political activities of members of this Party. I never yet travelled down the country for the purpose of addressing meetings, and I was not in the hotel until every Civic Guard or detective in the county was hanging round the street corners watching the people who were coming in and going out to see who was meeting me. That happens to the members of this Party everywhere they go. You may placard the hoardings for weeks before the meeting, and announce it in the local papers that you are coming, but they do not believe it until they see you are there, and they are always there to make sure you arrive.

It may be that they are protecting us, but I do not think that is so; in view of the several other types of cases, in which we could produce rather startling evidence, I have definitely come to the conclusion that it is not so. These cases—cases of assault by members of the Civic Guard—have occurred, and are regularly occurring, throughout the country. The Minister used some phrase in connection with them when the matter was raised by a question. I think "technical assault" was the phrase he used when the Civic Guards took a man into a barracks, hit him a few punches, and turned him out again.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon. The words I used were "trivial assault," that being the verdict found by the jury in the Cork case.

Comment on this

A trivial case?

Comment on this

The jury found that the assault was trivial.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin thinks it is rather a dangerous practice to refer to these cases of assault in the House. He considers that they should be dealt with privately between any person having information and the Minister, but, unfortunately, we have found that drawing attention to the fact that these assaults have taken place are not preventing them from taking place. I am not insinuating that every Civic Guard, or even every member of the detective division, steals around his district every night looking for someone to devour, or something of that kind, but reputable information comes into our possession that people have been stopped in the streets, conducted into the police barracks, assaulted in the barracks in order to get information out of them, and then turned out again. Deputy Little referred to one case of which I have given notice in a question. I want to give the Minister every facility to get all the information he can about that, because there can be no doubt about the facts. If the Minister thinks there can be any doubt about the facts, I assure him that I can produce in this House the names of sixty witnesses who saw the individual concerned before he was taken into the barracks and after he came out, and who can vouch for his condition when he came out. That happened only a few weeks ago, and the particular individual was a man who was an elected Deputy of this House, and a prominent man in his part of the country.

There have been other cases brought to our notice, and some of them have been re-echoed in the police courts and in other courts. It appears to us that there is amongst this particular section of the police force, at any rate, a tendency which is not corrected by the attitude which the Minister adopts in this House, when, instead of saying that he is going to do everything in his power to suppress any development of that tendency, he takes it upon himself to justify and defend these men against whom charges are made, if they happen to be members of the Civic Guard. The attitude of the Government has not tended to achieve what they themselves profess they want to achieve—that is, the establishment of a non-political force, that will not feel itself bound in any way to a particular political party. Their attitude all the time towards the Civic Guards in general, and to these detective and plain-clothes policemen in particular, has been that of one section of a particular army to another section —people serving the same cause, fighting the same enemies, and hoping for the same reward—and as a result of that there is established in the minds of these people the idea that their duty at all times is to assist members of Cumann na nGaedheal in any matter in which members of Cumann na nGaedheal may be engaged, whether it is in their normal work as Deputies or at a general election. There is not a member of Cumann na nGaedheal—at least I think there are very few—who could honestly stand up and say that he did not receive substantial assistance in his constituency from the members of the Civic Guard either in the June or September elections. Certainly the Minister for Justice or the Minister for Agriculture cannot say that.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon.

Comment on this

If they do I will produce evidence to show that they got assistance. Do not commit yourself.

Comment on this

I received no assistance, in the way of canvassing or otherwise, from any Guards.

Comment on this

I did not say canvassing. After all, a Civic Guard who goes canvassing is asking for it.

Comment on this

What do you mean then?

Comment on this

A Guard who goes out at night with a bundle of posters under one arm and a paste-pot, who proceeds to cover up the posters of another party.

Comment on this

I never heard of that down in my constituency.

Comment on this

Of course not. The Civic Guard who would inform the Minister that he did that would be foolish.

Comment on this

I do not believe it was done. I am certain it was not.

Comment on this

I challenge Deputy Lemass to prove that I got any more assistance as a Cumann na nGaedheal candidate from the Civic Guards in September than I did in June. The only assistance I got in either case was the fact that they were present at meetings in every case to keep order, but they did not need to keep order.

Comment on this

Then I think Deputy Cooper has a legitimate grievance. I think I have covered most of the points that I wanted to make in connection with this Estimate. I hope that the members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party will participate in the discussion on it much more freely than they have done heretofore. I would also like to suggest that the Minister should not wait until the conclusion of the debate to make any remarks he has to make, or to reply to any of the arguments that have been put forward. It is, no doubt, good tactics for the Minister to wait until he has all the arguments and all the statements marshalled in front of him so that he can attack them and then finish the debate by sitting down. The Government have been rather successful in the way in which they have got a tactical advantage of that kind during the debates on these Estimates. The Minister is not entitled to conclude the debate. The Minister for Finance, who has moved the motion, is entitled to do that. I would ask the Minister for Justice not to try to seize on a tactical advantage, but to give us his views on the various arguments that have been put forward, to answer the various questions that have been asked, and thus to enable Deputies on these benches to put further questions to him, if necessary, in order to clear up any doubts they have in their minds, either as to the purpose of the Civic Guard, their efficiency, or the manner in which they have been controlled.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for AGRICULTURE (Mr. Hogan) Cumann na nGaedheal

I have to make an admission to Deputy Lemass: I got most valuable assistance from the Civic Guards in the last election and in the June election.

Comment on this

You did.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I will tell you what it was. At a great number of meetings I would not have been allowed to speak but for the fact that the Civic Guards were there. The Deputy should not listen to so many stories. He is long enough in politics to know perfectly well that both sides exaggerate. As a Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy, if I am looking at a row I am inclined to think that the people on my side are not the aggressors, and I am perfectly certain that when a Fianna Fáil Deputy is looking at a row he thinks that we are entirely the aggressors, and that is with the best intentions in the world. Some of the stories that come up about the Civic Guards are entirely exaggerated or entirely wrong. I repeat that I got most valuable assistance from the Civic Guards in the last election and in the previous one. I addressed meetings all over my constituency and in other places, and I know perfectly well that I would not have been allowed to open my mouth but for the fact that there were Guards present.

Comment on this

Surely it is not the fault of the Fianna Fáil Party if the Minister is so unpopular.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

It does not matter whose fault it is. I was absolutely entitled to get up and speak.

Comment on this

Even if the people did not want to hear you?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The Deputy knows that that is a quibble. I was entitled to get up and speak and say what I thought, and I know that in a great many places, as far as I and other Deputies were concerned, there were deliberate attempts, not to assault us, but to prevent us from speaking by various devious methods which the Deputy and I know perfectly well. The right of free speech is a very valuable right, and I do say that that right has not been infringed by this Party. I do not believe that there is a Deputy opposite, either on the front or the back benches, who can say that he was ever prevented from getting up and putting his point of view before the country. I have never read of that. Of course there may be exceptions due to special cases; but, speaking generally, I do not know at the present moment, and I have never read in the papers, of any place or of any occasion where a member of the Party opposite was prevented from saying what he had to say, and I wonder if the Deputy does. I never heard of such a case at any time. I have stood in the crowd at a great many Fianna Fáil meetings.

Comment on this
A DEPUTY

It is a wonder you are so ignorant then.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

You will be surprised to hear that, but I like to be a spectator. The place I like to stand in at a political meeting is at the back of the crowd, looking at and sympathising with the unfortunate man who is on the platform. I never yet listened to a Fianna Fáil meeting that was interrupted.

Comment on this

There was no evil literature there.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I have seen meetings of different Parties—Labour, Fianna Fáil and Independents—and I have seen my own supporters there, but I never saw any of these meetings interrupted. Everyone was allowed to get up and say what he wanted to say— and certain very objectionable things were said at times—but there was not a single interruption. I have seen at meeting after meeting in the country concerted attempts steadily to interrupt Government supporters, attempts consistent and persistent, so persistent that really the right of free speech was denied to them. Now, surely it is the duty of the Civic Guard, of any police force in any country, to see that a man, unarmed, going on a platform can say his say at an election meeting. That is the only assistance I have ever got from the Civic Guards, and if they did not give me that assistance they would not be doing their duty as a police force. That is the only assistance I have ever seen Labour getting from the Civic Guards, that is the only assistance I have ever seen any Party getting from the Civic Guards, and it really does not lie in the mouth of any Deputy on the opposite benches to charge the Civic Guards with partiality. Deputies know perfectly well that there was a certain policy—it may not have been headquarters policy; it may have been confined to certain counties; it may have been directed against certain people—which was a definite attempt to prevent certain people from saying what they wanted to say. Now, it is the duty of whatever force is there, police or other, to see that every man in this country has the right to say his say and has the right to address the men and women who are before his platform. I have never seen a Civic Guard going any further than that.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that a certain superintendent in the Midlands spent a fortnight before the last two elections addressing envelopes in the Cumann na nGaedheal headquarters and that his car was at the disposal of the Cumann na nGaedheal organisation on election day?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am not aware of it.

Comment on this

Well, I am aware of it.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

If it is worth anything I will make this admission. I am not aware of it. Certainly they did not do it for me. I am speaking of my own experiences. I never heard of such a case, and I find it extremely hard to believe that there was such a case as that—that a superintendent of the Civic Guard spent the fortnight previous to the election addressing envelopes, or doing active political work for the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. You are bound to find in any country, and especially in a country with a recent history like ours, zealots on both sides. I think it is absolutely inevitable that men who leave the Free State Army and go into the Civic Guards, will be strongly in favour of a certain Party— just as the same thing happens in England, even though there is not the same reason for it—and possibly make fools of themselves. There may be, for all I know, exceptions. But I say deliberately that as far anyhow as my experience is concerned, I did get most valuable assistance from the Civic Guards, but the assistance was confined and limited to this, that they enabled me to go to any town in Galway or Roscommon and say what I wanted to say. That is all the assistance I ever got; that is all the assistance I ever wanted, and if Deputies opposite did not want that assistance it was simply because of a civic sense amongst their supporters. Personally I have never seen, at meetings of the Fianna Fáil Party, or at meetings of other Parties, the sort of organised attempt I have seen at meetings of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party to prevent members of the Party to which I belong from speaking. Deputy Lemass commented on another point. He tried to draw the inference from a statement of mine that there were two police forces, the Army and the Civic Guard. I will put it to him this way: Let me define their functions?

Comment on this

Will the Minister state definitely, before he goes on, that he is not joking? He will remember that that was the defence that the Minister for Defence put up for him—that he was joking the other day.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Oh, no, it was not.

Comment on this

You are not joking now?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Oh, no. I never joke on a serious subject like that, and the Minister did not make that defence. I hope he did not make any defence for me.

Comment on this

He said that you were joking.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I think the Deputy's point was that there was really no difference between the functions of the Civic Guard and those of the Army. I will put it this way: one of the functions of the Army is to see that the people have a right to do wrong; one of the functions, and the most important function, of the police is to see that the people have a right to do right. There is the distinction. It is all summed up in that. So that we have one force in the country to see that the people have an absolute right to do right, and we have another force in the country, one of the functions of which is to see that the people have a right to do wrong. You may not agree with me on this.

Comment on this

It is as clear as mud.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I want to make another point, in view of what the Deputy said. He quoted my views as to what the functions of the Army were. I did not so much give my views as to what the functions of the Army should be; I merely accepted the views of the military experts sitting on the benches opposite on the question of what the Army was capable of achieving. I listened to various military men—Deputy Flinn. Deputy Little and other Deputies on the benches opposite—and they told me that our Army was quite incapable of attacking and defeating the British or the Germans. I did not know whether it is or not, being a mere civilian, but I accepted the views of these high military authorities, and I pointed out that if they were incapable of defeating the British or the Germans, at least they were capable of seeing that the people had a right to do wrong.

Comment on this

I would point out that the Minister for Defence also tried to put that interpretation on your remarks, but I read him the exact words. You did not say that the Army was able or unable to defend the country against invasion; you said that it was not the purpose of the Army to defend the country against invasion.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Do you mean to say that you have read my speech?

Comment on this

I read your speech, strange to say.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I did not intend to go into this matter, but as the Deputy put it to me to define the functions of the police and the Army I gave him that definition, that the police exist to see that the people have a right to do right, and at least one of the functions of the Army is to see that the people have a right to do wrong.

Comment on this

There are some places in this country where the duty of compiling the Parliamentary Register devolves on the Civic Guards. Kerry is one of these places. My experience is that they work in a very partial manner. They disfranchised hundreds of Fianna Fáil voters in Kerry at the last election and they went so far as to tear down Fianna Fáil posters from the gates at some of the polling booths. I can only come to the conclusion that they are a semi-political body, and I leave it at that.

Comment on this

I see by the Estimates that the present cost of the Gárda Síochána is a total sum of £1,912,958. I consider this amount is excessive and unjustifiable. The number of officers and men and women police is 7,213. This figure is out of all proportion to the needs and requirements of this country. In the Estimate for 1918-19 the cost of the R.I.C. for all Ireland, and also the D.M.P. force, was £1,200,339. The number of officers and men for the thirty-two counties, including 1,254 officers and men of the D.M.P., was 11,121. We have, therefore, a comparison between 1918-19 and the present year. We had then for all Ireland 11,121 officers and men, costing £1,200,339, and now for the Twenty-six Counties we have 7,213 officers, women and men, costing £1,912,958. If we except the Minister for Justice, how many Deputies on the Government benches would not have told us in 1918, and did tell us then, that this country was over-policed? How many Deputies opposite who were then on the Sinn Fein platform were not of the opinion that the force should be reduced? I think every Deputy on the Government benches at that time advocated the reduction of the police force; they told us that this country was over-policed. People were told to vote Sinn Fein and the minute Sinn Fein would get into power the police force would be reduced. They said then that they did not require 11,121 officers and men, costing the country £1,200,339. Have these promises been carried out? Has the police force been reduced, have the expenses been reduced, and are the people able to pay for the present cost of these forces? I submit that that has not been done and there is no effort being made by the Government Party to do it.

We will be told from the opposite benches that a big police force like the Civic Guards is a necessity in this country. It is, of course, a necessity, a necessity to give the hangers-on of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party jobs—to provide jobs for them. That is the only necessity I see. In this force we have five commissioners, in receipt of £5,300; we have 159 superintendents, receiving £77,003; we have 55 inspectors, receiving £16,693. That is a total of 219 officers, receiving £98,996 in salaries, and they have allowances to the tune of £15,165. That makes a total for officers, combining salaries and allowances, of £114,161. We have 1,287 sergeants receiving £323,228; 5,703 guards and four women police receiving, in all, £1,013,257. That is, the rank and file, numbering 6,994, receive between them £1,336,435 per annum in salaries. We have a further charge for rent and accommodation allowances, amounting to £29,188; boot allowances, £27,425; allowances for casual expenses for officers and men employed on detective duty, £4,000; allowances for members employed on duty in plain clothes—officers and men —£4,415; allowances for men engaged on transport work, £1,008; subsistence allowances payable to officers and men absent on duties from their stations, £4,750; locomotion expenses, £56,500; clothing and equipment, £25,370; furniture, barrack bedding and bedsteads, £1,450; barrack maintenance, £760; transport and carriage, £9,710; fuel, light and water, £18,050; law expenses, £384; medical expenses, £7,840; telegrams and telephones, £14,600.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

Is the Deputy reading out the Estimate?

Comment on this

It is as well that the Estimate should be read out.

Comment on this

I think the people should be told what we are paying for. Here are some further items: Compensation to members of the force for property maliciously damaged or destroyed, £50; incidental expenses, £1,460; and the Appropriations-in-Aid total £43,320. At headquarters we have a clerical staff composed of 25 employees, and the housekeeper, cleaners, labourers, etc., total 55. The total salaries for the headquarters staff, including a bonus of £2,322, comes to £8,060. That makes a full total of £1,631,693 in salaries, wages and allowances. We have in other Votes sums properly chargeable to this Vote. In Vote 17 there is a sum included of £4,000 for rates, and we have £165,008 for office accommodation, buildings, fuel and light. That is in addition to the fuel, water and light mentioned in the estimate amounting to £18,050. I would like to know the particulars of the sums included in this estimate of £165,008. We have as well superannuation and retired allowances in Vote 16 amounting to £136,495. To whom are these superannuation allowances paid? In the Department of Justice we have a staff employed there on the Gárda Síochána account, and that staff is costing £8,067. This is in addition to the sum of £3,711 and £204 included in the Estimate proper, and it means, in other words, a total of £11,982 for clerical services, with £2,322 paid in bonuses as well.

In all these Votes we have a capital expenditure of £1,957,328. That is what the Civic Guards are costing the twenty-six counties. If you deduct the Appropriations-in-Aid, a sum of £44,370 we leave a net sum of £1,912,958 representing what the service is costing the country. That is the full sum for police services, and it works out at £265 4s. 2d. per man, and I have further calculated that we have one policeman for every 412 of the population. I ask the House, and particularly Deputies on the Government Benches, do they really believe that this charge is not excessive and exorbitant? In connection with this Vote it is mentioned in the appropriation account that there is a balance from previous years standing to the credit of this fund. It is a sum of £4,837 7s. 3d. That stands to the credit of the Reward Fund. The receipts for the year ended 31st March, 1927, reached £7,207 10s. 11d. Some of that money was made up through registration work performed by the police in County Kerry and County Sligo. The payments out of the account for the same period total £2,506 19s. 6d., leaving a balance of £9,537 13s. 8d., standing to the credit of this account.

We would like to know who gets this money, and why it is necessary, instead of paying it into the Exchequer, to treat those sums earned in Sligo and Kerry in this way? Why should they be given into this fund instead of being credited to the Exchequer? What law did the Government pass authorising them to devote this money to the reward fund? We also want to know the amounts that are paid out of this fund and to whom they are paid and what they are paid for. We want these particulars.

In Leitrim we have reason to complain of the treatment meeted out to the civilian population. I drew attention in this House a short time ago to a visit of C.I.D. to a farmer named McLoughlin in Drumsna; they went to his outhouse and threw out all his turf into the rain and left it there. That turf became useless to the man and no compensation whatever was paid to him. That is very unjust. I do not see why the police or the Government should go and damage any man's property. Their case was that it was necessary to damage it in order to search for arms. Was it necessary to damage it to search for those arms? There were no arms there. I think the Government would be justified in giving that man some compensation for the damage they did. It is unjust for any police force or any government to do any such thing to any person. It is not right.

Quite recently I had to draw attention to another case, that of a returned American who could not go up and down the streets of Carrick-on-Shannon without being followed by the Gárda. One night they molested him and attempted to shoot him. These things are not fair. Down at Arigna recently a man named Cull was arrested and charged, I believe, with having caused the Portumna fire. That man was living a hundred miles from Portumna and the Garda knew very well that he was not there. He was brought to the barracks and detained for a considerable time.

Then there is the case of ex-Deputy Seán O'Farrell, mentioned by Deputy Lemass and Deputy Little. I think these things are a scandal and it is a scandal that we are paying men for doing these things. I think it is very unfair. I certainly say in respect to the number of the Garda and the cost that it is excessive. In every little town in the country there are Garda barracks and in them there are four or five men. In Carrick-on-Shannon there are ten or eleven men. I do not know what use they are. I do not see them do any work. As far as we are concerned, I think the sexton of the chapel would be quite competent to do the police work and if he wanted assistance all he need to do was to ring the bell. I cannot understand why there should be ten or eleven men kept there. As well as that, there are two or three C.I.D. officers going about the country arresting men like Seán O'Farrell and Cull and throwing men's turf out on the mud and the rain. Why have that large number of them? Why is this tremendous sum asked of the taxpayers of the country? We cannot afford it and the sooner we get it into our heads and the sooner the Government gets it into their heads, to cut down that force to a figure that we can be expected to pay, the better.

Comment on this

In opposing this Vote, I do so on two grounds. First, that the amount of money being spent on the maintenance of the Gárda force is entirely in excess of the actual requirements of the State; and, secondly, because I believe from actual experience that that force is being maintained for the purpose of propagating the doctrines of one political party in the State. There is not the smallest doubt about it. While listening to the statements made by the Minister, we on the opposite side were told of the services of the Gárda Síochána. We were told that their services were for the general good, and that their services were at the disposal of all parties on all occasions, including specifically the last two elections. The Minister may have made that statement in good faith. I know I am not an exception, but I have to take exception to certain experiences, and I am sorry that I have to make this statement. I am sorry because we realise that a police force is necessary in this, just as it is in any other State, and I realise that in the police force of the Gárda Síochána we have good, honest and sincere young men, men who would be a credit to any service to which they would be asked to give their services. But when I find that the experience of these young men who have joined up that force is that the officer immediately in charge of them, their superior officer immediately in charge, has taken a certain definite action in regard to politics in this country, and that that action has been extended to the extent of actually assaulting the citizens of this State, and that that immediate superior officer's conduct has been condoned by the higher authorities in charge of his Department, and that the entire conduct and misconduct of that man and other officers is condoned by the Minister responsible in this House; when on various occasions acts of violence on the part of this man have been questioned here the Minister gets up and condones it, and the only extenuation or excuse he offers is that these acts should be brought into the law courts and the cases tried there, then we understand the position. When you find a responsible Minister in this House taking up that attitude you can only come to the conclusion that he condones these acts and that he knows that these acts are going on. He knows how impossible it is for a civilian living under the terrorism of a force such as the Gárda Síochána, how impossible it is to expect him to bring forward evidence in these circumstances to prove his case in court. In the last June and September elections I had experience of the Civic Guards acting under the control of their sergeant and their superintendent also. They were actually standing by when the tri-colour, the flag of this State, was torn down by opponents of ours in that fight, and for that act no arrest was made, although the superintendent of the Gárda was standing on the street and actually watched the transaction.

That action was reported to headquarters in Dublin, but no report ever came back as to what the findings on it were. The fact remains, at any rate as far as we can see, that the officers concerned were left in their positions and are still in them. I am informed that the sergeant in charge, in addition to the salary he draws as a sergeant in the police force, has since been awarded a pension for military services, which are a rather doubtful commodity as far as he is concerned. As to the statement made by the Minister for Agriculture that members on this side of the House were given assistance and that he had never heard of them being prevented from holding public meetings—I have no experience myself of being prevented from holding a public meeting—I have the experience that supporters of mine and of our Party who attended meetings at which I spoke were assaulted in the presence of Civic Guards, and no action was taken. I was not present in the House when reference was made to an assault recently on a man in my county —Seán O'Farrell, ex-T.D. I have heard the particulars of that case. This man attended a committee meeting of the Gaelic League. At the conclusion of the classes he was taken from that meeting, and the condition in which he came back from the Civic Guard station after being there for two hours, was visible to everyone who met him. His own statement is that he was grievously assaulted by the person who arrested him—a C.I.D. man. He states that while he was being assaulted in the barracks he called in the assistance of some Guards. The sergeant in charge came into the room in which he was being beaten by the C.I.D. man, and stood there watching the proceedings. He was beaten into a battered and bruised condition in the presence of the sergeant, who stood there watching the proceedings.

There is no use in the Minister getting up and stating, as he did on a previous occasion, that the courts are open to these men. There is no use in the Minister denying these charges, or in trying to minimise them, for, if evidence is required, ample evidence can be brought forward to prove the facts as stated. If the Minister is going to endeavour to maintain a service in this country the members of which act in such a way as I have outlined, he certainly cannot maintain that that is a service that is essential to the well-being of this State. If, as I stated at the opening, a Vote was asked for the service of a police force that was doing real essential service, one that would be impartial and that would engage in the detection of crime, one that would see that there was fair play for every citizen of the State who wanted to live an honest life, then such a Vote would receive from me, and from everyone on this side of the House, our full support and be passed without any discussion whatever. We realise that this force is used for a distinct purpose. The main purpose for which it is used is to keep the Cumann na nGaedheal Party in existence. For that purpose they use different methods. One is bribery to the extent of showing patronage to those who support them, but to those who do not agree with them they are prepared to use violence and terrorism. If it is for that purpose that this House is being asked to vote a sum amounting to about £2,000,000—it amounts to that when all the items are taken into account—then I say that the House is being asked to give its assent to an impossible proposition. I say, too, that this country is being fooled to the extent that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party is using the police force in this country for the purpose of maintaining that Party in office through methods, as I have stated, of bribery and terrorism.

Comment on this

The principal argument that I have heard in the criticism in regard to this Vote is the suggestion that the members at present in the Gárda Síochána force are too numerous. Assuming for the moment that the force is larger than those of us with economic tendencies would wish, I desire for a moment that every party in this House, and every member of every party and group would ask himself this question; who is responsible for that? Who is responsible for the state of affairs that has existed between 1922 and 1928 that has made it necessary for this country, for its freedom and its safety, to have in the Free State to-day a larger number of Civic Guards than we would wish for if the choice lay with us? I think, so far as the occupants of the Government Benches are concerned, that they can say without fear of contradiction "We are not responsible for the condition of affairs which have prevailed in this country from 1922 to 1928 and that has made that force necessary as regards the numbers constituting it to-day." I think that my friends in the Labour Party and my colleagues in the Independent group can say the same.

There remains then but one party, and I would ask every one of them to stop all this rameis. Who has been feeding the Civic Guards from 1922 down to the present time? Whose followers have been giving them work to do? Who has made it necessary for them to be there? Is it from that same party that the appeal now goes out to-night "Ah, do away with them. Put us back into where we were in 1922 and in 1923 and give us the same freedom that we had then plus the absence of the Civic Guards"? I think it was Deputy Lemass who made a second charge against them. Other Deputies spoke on the same question including the last Deputy. They charged the Civic Guard with bias. I wondered where all those stories were coming from until I heard from Deputy Lemass the standard argument that I heard against the Censorship Bill which the Minister for Justice is responsible for. He said that he had got it all out of the Sunday newspapers. When he read the English Sunday newspapers he found there the suggestion that all the Civic Guards wore dress suits. Did one ever hear anything more horrible than that, and "there can be no question about it for I got it out of the Sunday newspapers."

The Deputy told us a lot of stories about assaults alleged to have been committed by members of the Civic Guard force. I hope I am not unfair to him, particularly as he is absent from the House, but I do suggest to him that these fairy tales came from the same source and ought to be treated with the respect with which fairy tales are treated that come from a doubtful source of that sort. We had an extraordinary statement from Deputy Holt, and I take it from him as a confession that the party to which he belongs has turned over a new leaf. He said that the only necessity at present for the Civic Guards is this: that they give hangers-on of the Cumann na nGaedheal party necessary jobs.

Might I suggest that the force has served another and more useful purpose, namely, to give the hangers-on of the Fianna Fáil Party, and all criminals wherever they are situated, a very comfortable end? I would suggest to the Minister for Justice that the time has not come when the Civic Guards barracks can be depleted by one member—not until the day comes when the people can live without fear of interruption either at meetings or outside meetings. I regret very much to hear the suggestion that in some places somebody was engaged in interrupting some meetings. I am glad to have the admission from the Fianna Fáil Party that they disapproved of these interruptions at the meetings. I will take it from that admission that never again will they be any parties to allowing either a meeting of a Government candidate or of an Independent candidate to be in any way interfered with. I will take that admission, that promise, that never again will they sin.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

I would not have intervened in this dispute but for the statement we have heard from Deputy Maguire. Frankly, I do not think Deputy Maguire is a very responsible Deputy, but the statement he has made is of such a character that I think it should be replied to by a Deputy who lives in a rural district. He said that people lived in terror of a force such as the Civic Guards. He talked about terrorism, assaults, bribery, corruption and everything else. Now I come from a county somewhat similar to Leitrim, and during all those years since the Civic Guards have been recruited I have never heard of one instance, not even a trifling instance, of where people live in terror of the Civic Guards. It may be said that I am of a certain political tinge. I am, but there are other Deputies from my constituency who are not of the same political tinge as I am, or of the political tinge of the Party on the opposite benches. There are Labour members here from my constituency, and I appeal to them to state what they know. Deputy Maguire's speech can be dealt with only by an answer or an explanation. The answer would be a short one, that it was absolutely false, absolutely untrue, and if that is not so, then the only explanation is that the people living in his constituency must be peculiar, extraordinary individuals, individuals we do not know down our counties, and who deserve what they get. But I do not believe they get a lot of what the Deputy says. They must be a peculiar type, unknown in any other county. It is an extraordinary state of affairs if such a thing as the Deputy has spoken of could be possible for a moment. The Deputy seems to me to be advertising what I do not believe to be a fact, that they are a colony of savages in Leitrim.

Comment on this

There is a member for Leitrim on your own benches.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

I do not believe what Deputy Maguire asserted in his speech is a fact. Nobody for a moment believes such wild and extravagant statements.

Comment on this

When the Deputy makes a statement equivalent to saying my statements as to misdeeds are untrue, I wonder would he advise the Minister responsible to hold an inquiry to see whether they are true or not?

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

The Minister will act on and reply to these matters himself. Deputy Holt made a speech about the cost of the Civic Guards. He made a general attack, but as far as I could follow his speech he refused to come down to particulars on any one item. Deputy Lemass when speaking thought that £3 10s. a week for a Civic Guard was a fair wage. A front bench representative of the Fianna Fáil Party, one of its leaders, Deputy Little, thought it was a sufficient, not an excessive, wage. I hope I am not misrepresenting him. Why did not Deputy Holt say what he thinks as regards the wage that should be paid to any rank? Why did not he say that the wage of the rank-and-file was too much, that £3 10s. was too much, and that it ought to be such a figure; that the wage of the sergeants was too much and ought to be such a figure? Why did not he go through the ranks and say who was getting too much and how much they should get. Let us come down to these things if we want to be honest. Deputy Ruttledge, I understand, commented on speeches I made in this House. The frame of mind I was in when I made those speeches I am in now. I believe the Civic Guards are paid a wage in excess of what the average citizen can afford. That applies to the force from top to bottom. I made those statements two years ago, and I am in the same frame of mind to-day. There was a reply given to me then by the then Minister for Justice which answered all my points. His reply was that the police in the North of Ireland and the police in England were in receipt of a higher wage than the police in the Free State, and that was true of the different ranks.

There the difficulty arose. My speech is on record, and so is the speech of the Minister for Justice. Men could be trained here for six or twelve months, resign after training, and go to countries where they would get better pay. In addition to getting better pay policemen in the North of Ireland and in England have the assistance of the citizens when needed in carrying out their duties. I cannot give a more pointed instance of that than the action that was taken by the ordinary carters, the labouring men, in the streets of London when the late Sir Henry Wilson was shot down. We read in the papers then that the men who were driving carts jumped off and attacked men with guns and captured them. That is a lesson in citizenship. Even if I approved, and I did not approve, of the shooting of Sir Henry Wilson, what struck me as something to be aimed at was the sense of citizenship of the poor men who jumped off their carts to see that the law was upheld.

We have to have for the Gárda men of a respectable type with a fair education. We had to induce men like that to come into the force at a very critical time when they had to take their lives in their hands. Eight or ten—I do not know the exact number—lost their lives in the service—they were shot down. Such a thing as that would be impossible in England or the North of Ireland. Deputies should remember what led up to that. There is no use in Deputies opposite, with innocent faces, pretending that they never heard of these things—that they knew nothing about them—and comparing the Gárda with police forces in neighbouring countries.

It has been said that there are people able to prove this and that. I do not doubt that, I am sorry to say. Anybody who reads the newspapers or visits our courts knows that you can get people in this country to prove anything. So much so, that the heads of the Church to which I belong have displayed a certain amount of alarm at the moral condition of the country—I am not referring now to sexual morality. What did Deputy Little mean when he spoke about the detection of civic crime—a force that would only deal with civic crime? He went on to draw a distinction, but he did not say political crime. I should like to know exactly what Deputies opposite mean when they talk about civic crime, as distinct from other classes of crime. Is the assassination of a politician something that does not come under the head of civic crime— something that should be put on a different basis and treated differently? Are the Gárda to shut their eyes to the assassination of a politician or the preparations that lead up to it— drilling, dumps and all the rest of it? Do Deputies object to these things? Let them come down to the particular and tell us exactly what they do mean —when a crime is a civic crime and when it is not.

Deputy Goulding, who very seldom exaggerates matters, spoke about building barracks for the Gárda in his district in the neighbourhood of other houses belonging to poor people. What is the suggestion? If a barrack is needed and a house has to be built, it will be a new house. If a house has to be built, let it be a good one, which will be of some use afterwards. I defy any person to build a new house that will look like an old one. I am sorry Deputy Davin was not listening to the speech of Deputy Maguire, who charged the Gárda with being a source of terror to the people. His words were: "A terrorising force, such as the Civic Guards." If Deputy Davin has any knowledge of such a force as that being in his constituency, or if any offence has been committed by the Civic Guard against the citizens, I think he ought to tell us. I know that Deputy Davin knows everything that happens in his constituency, and that I need not appeal to him a second time to tell the truth of the matter.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy is not going to hold me responsible for what Deputy Maguire said?

Comment on this

On a point of order. Deputy Maguire made no such statement. He opened his speech by paying a tribute to the Gárda.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

I will quote his exact words. He said: "People were living in terror of a force such as the Civic Guard is." Will the Deputy contradict that?

Comment on this

He was referring to individuals.

Comment on this
Prof. John Marcus O'Sullivan MINISTER for EDUCATION (Professor O'Sullivan) Cumann na nGaedheal

Did he use these words?

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

He instanced a case in support of that. I hope I am not doing him an injustice, because I do not want to—if he wishes to correct me, I am satisfied. In reply to that I say that I never heard of any such thing. Nothing has occurred in my constituency in connection with the Gárda as to which a charge of that description could be made.

Comment on this

I cannot say at the moment whether the words quoted by the Deputy are correct or not. What I did wish to convey was that there are people in County Leitrim who, if they are not living in terror of the Civic Guards, have a jolly good right to be living in terror of them.

Comment on this

Criminals everywhere are afraid.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

I think the Deputy has proved exactly what I have said, although Deputy Moore wanted to apologise for him. Comparisons have been made between this force and the force that it replaced. Deputies have given figures and have gone back to 1911 and 1914. A good many things have happened since 1911. The traffic conditions of the country have changed very much. No one will admit that more readily than Deputy Moore. I would like to know how many members of the Civic Guard force are now employed in the cities and generally in the country in connection with our traffic conditions. The Minister will be able to answer that. It is also a fact that the war intervened; that the cost of living has gone up; that the value of money is on a different plane altogether from what it was. Is there anybody except the unfortunate agriculturist in the country receiving only the wages and salaries they received in 1911? I am prepared to argue that the conditions amongst the agricultural community to-day are not so secure and do not admit of so much profit as in 1911. But that does not alter the fact that we have grown into a system by which officials and people engaged in different classes of labour have very different wages from what they had in 1911.

I am not making any comment whether that is right or wrong but such is the fact and comparisons between the figures now and then are absolutely ridiculous. These figures are put forward in the hope that the people who read them, know nothing else. That is all I have got to say and I did not think I would have quite so much to say. I was brought to my feet by the speech of Deputy Maguire. I appeal to members for my own constituency and members of the Labour Party, who are generally considered to be neutral in those things to give their experience as distinct from members of political parties whom we know are absolutely unscrupulous as to what they say on these matters.

Comment on this

We have not been waiting until Deputy Gorey tells us what we ought to say. We have said it already and much better than Deputy Gorey.

Comment on this

I do not propose to debate the general question as to whether the Civic Guards are saints or sinners, but I ask the Minister for some information as to who is responsible for the activities of the Gárdaí under the Licensing Act of 1927. Very extraordinary cases have appeared in the Courts in reference to this Act. The evidence given in support of Reference Orders is very extraordinary in many instances. I do not suppose Deputies will believe this story but I refer them for confirmation of it to the "Wicklow People" of a month or six weeks ago. The Gárdaí applied for a Reference Order against a lady who keeps a public house in Rathdrum. The grounds of the application were not that she was guilty of any breaches of the Licensing Act. It was admitted that she was a model as a trader and that she was never charged with any offence. Now what was her offence in the eyes of the Gárdaí? That she did not keep Bass's ale. That is a very extraordinary thing that it should be an offence for an Irish trader not to keep English beer. There are a great many people in Rathdrum who do not admit that Bass's ale is necessary for health. Neither of the two doctors there had ever been known to recommend it to their patients. A great many people in this House, and in the country generally, have gone on fairly well through life without Bass's ale. It shows a curious irresponsibility, and I hope it does not show a certain vindictiveness on the part of the Gárdaí with reference to certain traders. I am at a loss to know what would be the cause of such vindictiveness, but there must be some reason for taking this prosecution in this way.

Comment on this

Was there a prosecution?

Comment on this

There was an application for a reference order. That is a new phrase which has come into the law, and the House must excuse a non-lawyer from not being familiar with legal language and procedure, but I think I have made clear what I am referring to. There were other cases where the Gárdaí were not able to support their applications with anything like reasonable evidence that an offence had been committed. There is a great deal of waste both of time and of money in connection with these applications. A considerable number of them have been refused by the justices on the ground that there was no satisfactory reason given for wanting to abolish the licences. I think it is a matter to which the Minister might well give a little attention. I hope, in replying, he will be able to explain how it came about that such a statement could be made by a person acting for the Government in a public court that it was an offence not to keep English beer, and that the lady was to be deprived of her means of living because of that deficiency.

Comment on this

I listened with great attention to the speech of Deputy Gorey. I believe he is an evil that must be endured.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

You have not the cure anyhow.

Comment on this

You never know. I also heard Deputy Jasper Wolfe objecting to a statement that the Civic Guards were finding employment for the hangers on of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. No doubt a large amount of employment is found for some gentlemen in the legal profession by the Civic Guards. These particular jobs seem to be the looking up of old Acts of Parliament about stopping horses on the bridges and things like that. On the question of the Vote before us, I do not wish to act in this matter in any partial spirit whatsoever. What I have to say is this: I was arrested by the Civic Guards at the time of the barrack raids——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

How long ago is that?

Comment on this

In 1926.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Too far back. The expense of the Deputy's arrest is not in this Estimate.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey was allowed to go back to the time people were shot before the Truce, and the Ceann Comhairle agreed with me when I said that it was an evil that had to be endured. What I wish to say is, that I was well treated by these gentlemen while in their charge, at least, by one side of the Gárdaí, at any rate, that is the uniformed force. My treatment by the so-called detective force was very different. But when we examine the speech of the gentlemen that we will have to call in future the joker of the pack, I mean the Minister for Agriculture, we find the price paid for the police force amounts to £3,793,000. The Minister for Agriculture says that what this force is for is to see to it that the people of this country have a right to do wrong.

He amplified that speech now by saying that the Army is there to see that the people have the right to do wrong. As I say, he amplified that by saying that one force is there to see that the people have the right to do wrong and that the other force is there to see that the people have the right to do right. I suggest that he is acting very unfairly to the Civic Guard in not providing them with arms like the Army, so that when two forces clash in their different duties they may have a fair fight. According to one member of the Executive Council, the policing of a piece of an island like this costs £3,793,000 between the Army and the Civic Guards, and the same Minister maintained that both forces were there to do the same duties. There are five Civic Guards stationed in my little parish, and they cost about £1,200 a year. Their salaries cost nearly £1,000 a year, but their duties are very light.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy inform us where he gets the £3,000,000?

Comment on this

That is the bother of having babies in the House. I have already stated that a member of the Executive Council has given it as his definite opinion that the Army is there as a police force, while the Civic Guard are there for the same purpose. If the Deputy had intelligence enough, or if he went to the Minister for Education, he would be able to add the two sums together.

Comment on this

Are we dealing with £3,000,000 or £1,000,000 in this Estimate? Have commonsense, lad.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

We were dealing with Deputy Corry's parish.

Comment on this

I consider that an expenditure of £988 in salaries and £200 in allowances for Civic Guards in one country parish is too much, and I think it is time that there was a change in that respect. I remember in the old days it was urged by Sinn Fein that we could do with half the police force, and I think that in the present state of transport we could have police stations a little further away than a couple of miles. To have five Civic Guards in a small parish is, in my opinion, too thick, especially when they live in a mansion which costs £1,550. In my constituency some time ago the C.I.D. made a special set on one individual. That was about two years ago.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Keep to the present date.

Comment on this

I will bring it down to the present date. Seven policemen were more or less permanently employed on the job of chasing him for nearly two years, and, if their statements are to be believed, he was chasing them for about the same period up and down the country until a month ago when they succeeded in capturing him. It was then decided that the charges in respect of which they wanted him were to be dropped, although it cost £6,092, because that was the salary paid to these gentlemen during their two years' chase.

Comment on this

Does that include travelling allowances?

Comment on this

Might I ask Deputy Corry the name of that particular individual?

Comment on this

Cornelius Healy, better known as "The One-Eyed Gunner." After chasing him for two years they captured him, and then dropped the charges on which they were chasing him. They said that they wanted him first for a raid on a police barracks, and then there was a case of a shot being fired into a dance hall.

Comment on this

What has he been charged with?

Comment on this

With attempting to escape.

Comment on this

Was he not charged with attempting to kill?

Comment on this

No; with attempting to escape. The capture of this terrible individual by a force of seven men has cost the taxpayers £6,092. I am very anxious to make clear the distinction between the C.I.D. and the Gárda, but it is rather surprising when we hear about the confidence which the people have in the police force to find that one individual can be in a parish for two years without being captured, although seven men have been constantly after him. Now I come to the question of persecution. There is one young man in Cobh whose house has been raided about eighty times during the past four months. The police go up at seven o'clock in the morning and search his house for documents, but, finding none, they come back again at 10.30 a.m., and return again at dinner hour for another search for documents. I put it to any sensibly-minded Deputy, is there any individual who would be idiot enough to keep documents in his house after it had been raided in the morning, knowing that it would be raided again later on? That is a system of persecution which is being brought against certain individuals for the purpose of driving them out of the country. It is a system which the Minister should look into and put an end to. This constant raiding of houses by any force of men is unjust to any citizen. Deputy Gorey was good enough to allude to salaries, and to say that the farming community were the only people whose salaries were back to the pre-war rate. I seriously suggest that the farming community, who apparently are to be the beast of burden for everything in this country, cannot afford to pay over £3,000,000 for policing a piece of an island. If the Executive Council are going to continue that game, they will find that they will turn even Deputy Gorey's late party against them, and then it will be all up.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey invited members of this part of the House to make a contribution to the debate. Our attitude to the Vote under discussion and the Gárdaí as a force has been clearly stated by Deputy Davin this evening. So far as I personally am concerned, I would like to avail of this opportunity to say that in my opinion the work of the Guards is done as well as it could be done under the circumstances. I had not the advantage of hearing many of the speeches this evening, but I gathered from those that I did hear that there was a suggestion that the wages of the Guards should be reduced. I think that would be undesirable, in view of the fact that members of that force suffered a reduction in wages not so long ago. I think Deputy Gorey was wrong in saying that the wages of a Guard is £3 10s. a week. I think it is £3 as a result of a reduction made some time ago.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Somebody referred to the action of the Guards in connection with elections. I would like to say that, so far as I know it, the attitude of the Guards at election times has been scrupulously impartial, and I never had an experience other than that of courtesy and kindness from them anywhere any time I had occasion to meet them. I have a recollection, however, of an experience not so pleasant when, on behalf of a candidate in 1922, I took part in the elections, and I remember that we had at that election a police force, and from the conversations I had with men alleged to be on police duty on that occasion, I learned that their particular duty was to vote for particular candidates. The people who were supposed to be police officers at that election told me that they had voted 27 or 28 times during the election. That is an experience which we should get rid of.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

I saw them at it, too.

Comment on this

There should be a force that would be strictly impartial and prepared to serve under any Government set up by the people in this country. A plea has been made for amalgamation or closing down of certain police stations. I can only give my own experience in that connection, and say that whenever the authorities signified their intention of closing certain stations in my constituency, I found that when the news of that intention got abroad I and other Deputies in the area were handed very extensively-signed petitions against the proposal. The Minister had his way, however, on nearly every occasion when stations were closed. There was an extensive local feeling against the closing of the stations on the ground that it would not be desirable. I must say that I have never experienced any display of bias on the part of the Guards, and I never saw any sign of terrorism attempted to be exercised over any section of the community. I think it only right that that should be stated.

Comment on this

In order to correct, perhaps, a wrong impression in the House about the position in Leitrim I think it well as a representative who has always received the votes of the majority of the people in that county at every election since 1918 that I should assure the House that there are law-abiding citizens in that county. I would remind Deputies also that Seán MacDermott was a native of County Leitrim and that the people there are very proud of that fact. Leitrim is ordinarily a law-abiding county and the majority of the people are glad that certain wrong-doers in our midst are afraid of the Civic Guard. Deputy Maguire has endeavoured to create an impression in this House that the people there are living in terror of the Guards and that the position there is that no law-abiding citizen has any respect for them. I think it is a tribute to the Guards that every person of any responsibility who stands for decent Government recognises that in the difficult circumstances under which the Guards were recruited and during the transition period over which they had to operate a wonderful transformation has taken place in that county. I daresay we would not like to go back on the history of the last few years, but we know that Leitrim being rather a backward county became a hiding ground for many people who went on the run from other counties. Leitrim being a hilly county was naturally a safe hiding place and there were portions of that county where trains could not pass safely and where it was not safe for banks to transfer money from one portion to another. There were a good many bank robberies.

Comment on this

And embezzlements.

Comment on this

We had hold-ups at fairs, but the impartial administration in the county has made the position such that there are now no hold-ups at fairs, the ordinary business of the county is being carried on and it is all due to the careful administration of the law in the county. The fact that so much money is being spent on our Guards, on the administration of the law and enforcing order in every part of the Saorstát is a deplorable fact, but we cannot dissociate it from the big fact that that is due to the will of the majority of the people being challenged persistently up to recently and for that reason there had to be an abnormal number of Civic Guards in the country. That is the true position and it is ridiculous for any Deputy to stand up and pretend that he does not know the reason for such a state of affairs.

I can imagine when I go back to Manorhamilton or Carrick-on-Shannon the broad smile that will meet me, and people will say: "Was not that outrageous conduct on the part of Deputy Holt and Deputy Maguire," and I can imagine people saying that they are glad that a certain element in County Leitrim is afraid of the police.

Comment on this
AN CEAN COMHAIRLE

The Minister for Justice, to conclude.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Does Deputy MacEntee desire to speak?

Comment on this

I understand that the House is now in Committee, and I submit to you that, as the Minister for Justice did not move the Vote, he is not entitled to conclude the debate. We feel that we have the right to follow the Minister after he has answered the criticisms which have already been passed on his administration, and then that the Minister who has made himself responsible for the motion in the House should conclude the debate.

Comment on this

One thing is that a man can bring a horse to the water, but it requires much more than one man to make him drink, so that I think that in that respect whether I speak now or subsequently is rather a matter in my own discretion. Now, this has been in some respects a very interesting debate. I do not use the word "interesting" in the sense that there was a complete absence of dullness in the criticisms——

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

On a point of order. The point of order that was raised by Deputy MacEntee has not been decided. If the debate is to go on after the Minister for Justice has replied we had better know it now.

Comment on this

There is no necessity.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. GOREY

I ask you to rule on the point.

Comment on this

I would put it to you this way, as a point of order: Under what rule of the House has any Minister a right to conclude? In the Standing Orders, as far as I understand, there is a proper procedure, and one single procedure only, for closing a debate, and unless and until that procedure is invoked I suggest that there is no machinery whatever to enable the Minister to get up and conclude a debate, except with the consent of the House.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

I understand Deputy MacEntee's suggestion is that the Minister should speak and that the debate should continue. Up to what point?

Comment on this

Until the Minister for Finance closes it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

The practice in Committee on the Estimates is, of course, that the Minister for Finance, or some other Minister not being the Minister in charge of the Estimate, moves the motion. The Minister in charge of the Estimate in this case is the Minister for Justice. The debate goes on, and usually, as a matter of practice, the Minister in charge concludes the debate. The suggestion that the Minister in charge of the Estimate should intervene now to restart the debate would, I think, introduce a practice that would be very undesirable. There is nothing in the Standing Orders about this matter, but as a matter of practice, a debate on a particular Estimate of this kind, particularly when the debate has been going on general lines, must be concluded at some particular point, and that has always been taken to be the point at which the Minister in charge of the Estimate replies. Now the Minister may intervene at this point, and if Deputies assert the right to speak after the Minister, of course they may do so. That would leave us in this position, that there is no way after that of saying, "Now the debate is going to conclude," until nobody wants to offer any further remarks on the subject, and then, of sheer weariness, the debate ends. That has not been hitherto followed.

Comment on this

On a point or order, I suggest that when the definite procedure for a certain purpose is laid down in the rules it is assumed that no other procedure will be used. There is one procedure in this House for bringing a debate to a close against the will of the minority, and that is the closure.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

The statement that because the closure is provided for in the Standing Orders, no other method of concluding a debate can be used, needs no comment. But in any event, if the Minister for Justice decides to speak now he may. It has to be remembered by Deputies on both sides of the House that the Minister is now defending the Estimate, that some other Minister at some other time will be defending this or some other Estimate, and as a matter of practice for the Minister, whoever he may be at the time, and for the House, the practice that has been followed has been satisfactory. If there is no consent for the Minister to conclude now, I assume the position is that Deputy MacEntee desires to speak, and desires to speak after the Minister. In other words, he desires to have the last word.

Comment on this

No. As the discussion is in Committee, if the Minister desires to have the last word he can reply to the speeches which are made from these benches after he has made his speech now.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

I understand the suggestion perfectly. It is a kind of recurring decimal suggestion.

Comment on this

With all possible respect, the Standing Order says that it is not a recurring decimal. The recurring decimal can only recur three times.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

The Deputy has not read the Standing Order.

Comment on this

I have.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

Will the Deputy quote the Standing Order about the three times?

Comment on this

I understand that a Deputy can speak for ten minutes in Committee, and more than once. Is that not so?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Fine Gael

I think the Deputy has got the wrong book. He has the first edition.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

It is out of date. I will intervene for one moment to say that we have spent something like sixty hours on the Estimates this year. The Estimates, with the Appropriation Bill, will require to be passed by the 1st December if we are to have money to carry on these services, and that is a consideration that Deputies ought to bear in mind, in view of the fact that something like forty more Estimates have got to be considered.

Comment on this

If it would convenience the Minister I am prepared to go on now. At the same time I would like to say, with all due respect to my friend Deputy Flinn, that we would not like the Minister to be a recurring decimal in more than two places. I move to report progress.

Progress ordered to be reported.

Comment on this