We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

APPROPRIATION BILL, 1928—SECOND STAGE.

Contributions 112–238 of 238. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Appropriation Bill, 1928
Enacted

No. 50 of 1928 ›

Is the Minister anxious to speak?

Comment on this
ACTING-CHAIRMAN

Let Deputy Moore proceed.

Comment on this

I do not think anybody could hold that I take up a lot of time. Perhaps I take up as much as I deserve. I do not make any claim in that respect, but I do not know what the Minister is driving at. It is a big surprise to me that it is not relevant on this Vote to consider who are bearing this taxation and whether they can afford to bear it or not. Before the Bill goes through, it is important to know whether the people who are going to pay this £7,000,000 are able to bear the impost or not.

Comment on this
ACTING-CHAIRMAN

The fact is that the money has to be raised somewhere. I do not think the question that the Deputy is discussing can be raised now.

Comment on this

I think that the question of the amount that should be raised and who is going to bear it is an important question. After all, we have to cut our cloth to the proper measure and the means of the people who will ultimately pay is, I submit, relevant to the debate. From that point of view, I say that we have no guidance whatever from the Government. We have three different accounts as to who ultimately bears this taxation. We have the statement of the President. He holds that the farmers of the country are escaping taxation.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Would the Deputy be a little more exact?

Comment on this

That was before the last Budget, I admit.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

When previously quoting me on that subject, the Deputy was a little more truthful.

Comment on this

When Deputy Clery complained that the farmers of the country were unable to bear the taxation that was being levied upon them, the President himself followed to show —I can give him the reference to the Official Report——

Comment on this

Better give the quotation.

Comment on this

The President went on to argue that if the farmer took care to buy Irish-made goods and did not deal in stocks and shares, he need pay no taxation.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

That is a very different story.

Comment on this

Not at all. Contrast that with the statement of the Vice-President, when introducing his Budget, that all taxation ultimately comes out of production. Contrast it again with the very extraordinary statement of the Minister for Agriculture, who asserted three weeks ago that practically all taxation is borne by the small farmers and the small traders. Why the small traders are singled out for mention is a thing I have never been able to ascertain. I suggest that it does look badly for the Executive Council that three such different statements regarding an important subject should be made officially from the Government Bench. I suggest that all the boosting that is going on, all this wonderful talk by the Government followers of our brilliant young Ministers is not entirely justified if these statements I have quoted are meant seriously. After all, the question of the basis of taxation and who is to bear it is a very fundamental thing, and one would expect that Government Ministers would be very exact in regard to it. One would expect that it would be one of the first things they would have made up their minds upon. Yet we find, after six years of experience that is unique in the world— the bringing of a new State into existence, the setting up of departments, and all that sort of thing—Ministers make these statements. When statements that are so divergent are made, it does suggest terrific carelessness, to say the least. I will not for a moment suggest that it indicates any lack of intelligence or anything of that kind. As a matter of fact, it is because we know that the Government Ministers are exceptionally brilliant men that we wonder all the more at these curiously loose statements.

Comment on this
ACTING-CHAIRMAN

I think that is a good stage at which to leave the taxation point.

Comment on this

I am still unconvinced, but you, Mr. Chairman, and I have had several arguments during the past few days on another matter. I am, however, still unconvinced that I am irrelevant. On the general question, I do not think this Bill has been proven. I do not think the House can be conscientiously satisfied that the Estimates we have discussed are the lowest possible that should be passed in the present circumstances of the country. I believe that very few who vote for the Bill will do so believing that it is a fair measure for the country and a suitable measure for the country. Instead of an "empty formula," I suggest that "empty formality" will be the phrase in the future, because the passing of this Bill will be simply an empty formality. It will represent no conviction of any kind. It will represent a disregard of duty rather than a regard for duty, and while that is a regrettable state of things from one point of view, from another point of view it is a happy state of things, because we all know that when a Government reaches the stage that its followers simply become automata then its hour of dissolution is near.

Comment on this

I did not intend to speak in this debate until the President entered in his usual chirping mood. I know it is not decent for us to carry on the debate at this length at all. Really it would be much decenter for us to vote against this Bill or, perhaps, for it, and allow it to go through. After all, we have got round so many corners in this country and improved so well, and the country is so satisfied with the Ministers and the Departments of Government as a whole, that we, if we were really decent fellows, would vote on every occasion to allow the Government to carry on in a grander way.

I know it is not a nice thing for us to have carried on a debate here, and to have disgusted the Ministers by saying such awfully foolish things. When you know that you are not heeded, and that you certainly will not be answered unless you make a very foolish statement, you can say anything you like. I know it is not decent to carry on the debate much longer. Of course, if we accept the suggestion of Deputy Davin for a political truce in order that the Economic Committee might bring forth some miracles, and at last bring us where President Cosgrave and his Ministers promised the Irish people they would get to two years after the Treaty was accepted, everything might be all right. I am surprised that Deputy Davin did not call for a political truce yesterday when the Government Party defeated, by a majority of four, the motion to provide pensions for widows and orphans proposed by one of his colleagues. Deputy Davin did insist on stating that he did come into the Lobby with us on several occasions in the last three weeks. We know he did. I think he wasted a lot of time in telling us that, by accident or otherwise, he came into the Lobby with us to vote against the Government. Deputy Davin need not feel at all uneasy. We know very well that he has good intentions sometimes. He has said he has, because he votes with us, and in order to prove to the Government Party that he has good intentions, as far as they are concerned, he gave us to understand that he will vote with them on this occasion. It is a very nice thing to be a jolly good fellow with both parties.

If we were to accept the suggestions of Deputy Anthony I do not think it would improve things to go ahead with this debate either. I do not want to go back to what Deputy Anthony stated. His moratorium is all right. I wonder if his colleagues of the Labour Party agree with the Government in accepting our political truce, and embracing President Cosgrave and saying the more we are together the more we will be satisfied——

Comment on this
Prof. William E. Thrift ACTING-CHAIRMAN (Professor Thrift) Independent

I wonder what this has to do with the Bill.

Comment on this

I was just saying that Deputy Anthony wasted a lot of time in telling us that we should agree to a political truce I think he called it a financial truce—in fact, he wanted us to go down the country and tell our supporters not to think of anything that could be objectionable to President Cosgrave. I think that contribution of the Deputy was a waste of time in two ways, first, because he held up the House while he was speaking, and then because he convinced me that I should speak afterwards. That is my reason for mentioning what Deputy Anthony said.

Then, after all the speakers on this side of the House had said, and all the suggestions they made as to how we might be better able to carry on in this country if the Government looked at things from a serious point of view, Deputy J.J. Byrne told us that we have not made a single concrete proposal. Perhaps there is some commonsense in that. Perhaps we realise that with such brains in the Government Party that J.J. Byrne and others possess, they ought to be able to put forward sufficient concrete proposals to carry on for a long time, and that concrete proposals should not be put forward from this side. We realise that very well from the way the Government are carrying on and the way the country is prospering, as a result of these concrete proposals put forward by Deputy J.J. Byrne or some other great men of the Government Party. In considering whether we should vote for or against the Government, however, I would like to follow the old motto of "charity begins at home." and look at the County Mayo and the West of Ireland. If I am to judge by the activities of governmental departments in County Mayo for the past two or three years. I can easily convince myself that the honest thing for me to do, representing that county, is to vote against the Government. I do not expect that the Cumann na eGaedheal Deputies from County Mayo will vote against the Government, because, of course, if they did, not one single social service, as Deputy Davin said, could be carried on in the country. You could not pay the old age pensioners, and you could not carry on in any way if you voted against the Government; that is their plea. But why should Deputies, representing the country and knowing the position in the country as it is to-day, by voting for the Government on this motion, pass a vote of confidence by that means in the Government considering the state the country is in.

There was a discussion here a few nights ago about the position in the West of Ireland. Notwithstanding the statement of Deputy Bourke about the Gaeltacht, and all that has been said about arterial drainage and afforestation when we go down the country we find that not one single promise has been put into action. Some time ago the Government took a lot of trouble and I suppose went to a good deal of expense and certainly raised many hopes by having one of the largest rivers in County Mayo examined by their engineers who made estimates for the drainage of the River Moy. In a very casual way we were told by the Parliamentary Secretary that the Government had decided in the last few months that it would not be economic for them to go ahead with that scheme. I wonder on what grounds they came to that decision. If they made a decent effort to carry out a scheme of that kind and lesser schemes, I would feel justified and would have sufficient moral courage to vote for them. But I cannot when I see the Gaeltacht as it is and the condition of the kelp industry in County Mayo about which the Minister for Industry and Commerce seems to know very little, because I had a communication with his office some time ago as to the attitude he would take up in regard to the kelp industry along the coast of Mayo where people try to eke out a livelihood by it and are suffering much because of obstacles they are trying to fight against, and I did not even get the courtesy of a reply from that Department.

Comment on this

When did you send the letter?

Comment on this

Within the last three months.

Comment on this

Have you any reference, because I would like to inquire into it.

Comment on this

I would be only too glad to give it to the Minister. I hope when I make certain suggestions to him that they will not be turned down in the way they were yesterday when we made some suggestions about the activities of his new legation or office that will be opened in Berlin. When he was asked if it would not be wise to have a new legation opened up in Soviet Russia he said our suggestion was that our ambassadors should go around selling fish through Russia. If he wants to deal in that cheap, chirping way with arguments that are put there is no use in putting them forward. I hope he will try to deal with the suggestion about the kelp industry in a decent manner.

Recently we had representatives of French and English firms testing the qualities of some class of clay in parts of Erris. They took samples away and it is strongly rumoured in Erris that it is their intention to purchase some of the area and to have the clay transferred to factories in England or France for manufacture. I know that they have been exploring in the area and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, after all the expenditure on his office, has not paid any heed whatsoever as far as I can find out from certain officials, to the exploration of that clay and what might result from it in the County Mayo. The County, as Mr. Bourke, the Parliamentary Secretary, said, is very poor; in fact they do not realise there is such a thing existing as a Department of Industry and Commerce. They know, of course, that there is a Department of Agriculture. It is very refreshing to the prosperous farmers in County Mayo to read in the newspapers now and again statements from the Minister for Agriculture that the one solution in Ireland for agriculture is one more cow, one more sow, and one more acre and to stick it out. Of course, that is of great assistance to us in County Mayo, and because of that and the road he leaves open to us and the great things we know our young Ministers are going to do we should be expected to vote for the Government. But I think we are not going to be fooled into that action. If we consider the attitude of the Minister for Justice in regard to certain happenings in County Mayo we feel that we will have the absolute support of the people in voting against this Bill. Although this debate has dragged out painfully and we have been very mean in saying certain things which the Ministers should not be told about we should not close our eyes to the situation in the country and do the nice fellows and vote for the Government. I think perhaps some of the suggestions we have made may not do any harm at all. If the Government would really face the situation and the facts as they are they would find a good deal more co-operation and sympathy in the task they have to perform in trying to help the country in some manner.

Comment on this

Some months ago Deputy Corry, in the course of one of his prosy speeches, described this House as a circus. He was pulled up by the Ceann Comhairle who, if I remember rightly, read him a small lecture on the dignity of this institution. Many of the members following referred to it in sneering terms. Nothing has convinced me more since this debate started that Deputy Corry was right, absolutely and definitely right, that this House is being turned into a circus by the Governmental Party opposite, than their frigid silence while this debate has been in progress. Not one Minister has attempted to participate in this important discussion. Since 3 o'clock only one member, if I remember rightly, of the Government Party has intervened to make a statement. Still, when criticisms are levelled at this House, and when members make remarks regarding its activities, Ministers are the first to declare that this is a solemn institution, a Parliament worthy of the name and as good as any in the world. Yet they themselves by their attitude in this debate, whether they have been mute of malice or by the visitation of the Lord, as their Judges say, I do not know, but whatever it is they certainly have attempted, and are still attempting, to turn this into merely what is described in certain periodicals as a talking-shop.

There has been no attempt to answer arguments, no attempt to make a case, and no attempt to meet suggestions put up from the Opposition Parties in this House. There has been nothing but sullen, frigid silence. Probably the Minister for Industry and Commerce will get up to end the debate. He will just intervene when the debate is concluding, when there is hardly any opportunity to reply, and he will indulge in a few sarcastic jeers. In any Parliament that I have read about the Government Party always attempt to make some answer to criticisms arising in the course of the debate. The debate is never a one-sided affair like it appears to be here.

I understand we can discuss the Government policy on this Bill. So many speakers have been ruled out of order to-night in referring to various items in the Bill, I do not know exactly what direction to take. There is one item that I should like to refer to in connection with Governmental policy. That is the item the Minister sneeringly dismissed last night by describing as red herrings. I am certain the House will agree with me when I state that there is no necessity for the Minister to discuss red herrings, because he provides most of them whenever there is a debate here. Remarks were made this evening regarding the Government's policy, or rather lack of policy, in the development of trade. Deputy Derrig criticised the Government for their failure to keep the promises they made in the debate on the Gaeltacht Commission with regard to certain portions of the report which they embodied in a White Paper. I come from a constituency where the fishing industry was at one time the premier industry over a great stretch of coastline from Crosshaven to Castletownbere. At the present time the struggling remnants of what was once a great industry in Kinsale. Baltimore and Schull, provide ample evidence of the fact that if proper encouragement were given by the authorities that industry could be quickly revived.

The Minister may sneer at the suggestion I made with regard to the export of fish, herrings in particular, to the Union of Soviet Republics. Some years ago in Kinsale an export trade was attempted with Russia and Germany. In the first eighteen months the business proved very successful, and it resulted in a considerable profit to the people who had the courage to initiate it. Owing to circumstances over which we had no control, that industry was a failure last year. Undoubtedly there is a market there for cured herrings, and last night, when I stated that eight million roubles' worth were imported over European frontiers, I was not stating a thing that the Minister could lightly waive aside. He attempted to side-track the issue by stating that I wanted our ambassadors to sell fish. Even if I did say so, or if it could be inferred from what I said, it would be one hundred and fifty times better if our so-called ambassadors did go around attempting to improve the fish market rather than be endeavouring to make out that this is a sovereign nation.

Deputy de Valera this evening made an appeal to face facts and several other speakers on these Benches stressed that point and asked the Government Party, when they did see fit to relieve themselves of the taint of being mute of malice or by the visitation of the Lord, to deal with the appeal put up to them. A statement was made by the versatile Minister for Agriculture with regard to the lack of sincerity and honesty that exists in some parts of the country, or amongst some people in the country. Nothing exemplifies that refusal to face facts more, and nothing indicates that there is a tremendous amount of truth in the few jocose remarks he made time and again with regard to that point more than the portion of this Appropriation Bill which relates to the so-called League of Nations. It appears to be Governmental policy to remain a member of that greatest illusion in history, as I consider it to be. It seems to be our Government's policy to attend the Conferences of the League of Nations and to continue the farce that we are a sovereign State. Being men of great brilliance and great intelligence, and being people who have had experience of diplomacy in connection with European countries during the last six years, they should know that the thing has been a barren failure and they should face the facts in that connection. I do not say that the money asked for that concern is tremendous, and I do not say that if it were to serve any useful purpose it would not be well to spend it; but it is a continuance of the policy that the Minister for Agriculture once described as a refusal to face facts and that is why I object to it.

The League of Nations, of which we are supposed to be a highly esteemed and honoured member, was started with the object of preventing war. It has failed to do it, and it has done nothing in the last ten years except arrive at conventions, most of which are never ratified by the constituent States that are members of the League. There was one convention with regard to poison gas and germ warfare. Only one civilised country has ratified that, and it is three years now since it was signed. Do the Government consider there is any useful purpose served by being a member of that institution? In this Bill we are asked to vote a sum for the League of Nations. I think some case should be made by the President, or by whoever is responsible for our activities there, to show what advantage this State is getting out of the money expended and in what way the whole thing can be explained to the people. The people are not fools all the time, and some day they will insist upon an explanation. Not alone will they be struck by this one-sided debate, this bringing of the House into disrepute and ridicule, but they will also be struck by those attempts on the Continent and in other countries to maintain a status which we have not got, and by this effort to make people believe that we have a certain status as a result of the 1921 Treaty. I believe that the Ministers realise the uselessness of that institution just as well as we do. I believe if they would face the facts we would not be members of that farce which the two biggest countries in the world, the United States and the Soviet Union, have refused to join.

The Department of External Affairs has been well dealt with, but the Minister glossed over a point I wanted him to reply to. I ask him to be good enough to deal with the points I have made now. Perhaps his intelligence is superior to the combined brains of other Deputies in the House, but at least he might give us some assurance that the suggestions made from these Benches will be considered in all seriousness. These suggestions have not been made for the purpose of scoring debating points. If the Minister cannot see his way to deal with our criticisms, then Deputy Corry's remark should be painted in big letters and put over the door of this building, and the name "Leinster House" should be obliterated.

Comment on this
Timothy Sheehy Mr. T. SHEEHY (Cork) Cumann na nGaedheal

I would not rise in this debate but for the fact that after the speech of Deputy Mullins, in which he took the Russian Soviet over and over again to his bosom, I must state that as far as West Cork is concerned, the people are not with him in his affliction. He stands up here and he brings the Minister for Industry and Commerce to book with regard to the sale of herrings in Russia. I may inform Deputy Mullins that there are plenty of markets for all our herrings, and the only difficulty in the Saorstát at this moment is that we are not getting enough of them. The Deputy stands up here and holds up the Russian Soviet as a model for this country, the Republic that has stamped on the soil of our Redemption, that has torn down churches and turned them into theatres, that has done away with the sanctity of marriage, and that has permitted free love, that has, in fact, broken every Commandment of the Almighty. I heard the Deputy to-night on three occasions calling for the assistance of the Almighty. The Deputy ought to make an Act of Contrition for what he has said. Never did I think that I would hear in the land of St. Patrick a man speaking of a Republic, of a country, that is keeping 160,000,000 people in slavery and that is starving the workers. I suggest to the Deputy that if he has such great love for that country, he and Deputy Corry should spend six months there. We will see how they come back. They will both come back starved, and indeed it would be a great improvement to the both of them, because they want to be reduced either mentally or physically, so that they will become a pair of sane men.

I desire to support this Bill. I have listened to the Deputies on the other side attacking every Minister who has responsibility for the government of the country. Each and every one of the Ministers came under the lash of the Deputies opposite. Where were those same Deputies when the Ministers took up the cudgels six years ago and built up this State that we are all proud of? Not alone are we proud of our Ministers, but those who come from foreign lands are proud of them. I had the privilege of meeting a clergyman in the Dáil to-day, a distinguished Dominican from the United States. He told me that he was here in 1922 and he came back again to find a new Ireland. "All you have to do," he said, "is to work the freedom and the liberty that you have, and you have more freedom than there is in the United States." There is no use in Deputies over there putting the President and Ministers into the pillory, because they claim they are not doing their duty. They are doing their duty and if the Estimates here are a little over in one part or another the Ministers are doing their level best to stabilise every Department. Are there seven men in Ireland or in any other country who are doing more work for their country or who have done more work during the past six years than our President and Ministers? What return do they get? Is there one word of thanks? They attacked my friend from Cork—Deputy Anthony—because he had the courage to give some credit to the Government. Deputy Anthony is an honest man, no matter what his feelings may be. He felt to-night that he was in duty bound to give justice and fair play to the Government for the good work they have done all along the line. He was not crying out for Russia. There is no use sneering at Ministers because they were endeavouring to carry out their work and carried it out successfully. I can tell them that before the Dáil expires, and it will not expire for four years more, the Deputies over there who are sneering and laughing will find that the Government will have advanced even further in the estimation of the people than they have hitherto.

Comment on this

I want to raise the case of the ex-R.I.C. men whom we say have been victimised. Their cases have not been dealt with. I am sorry the Minister for Finance is not here, because this matter has been raised with him several times, but no result has come from it. It is a considerable time since Deputy Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll raised this matter in the form of a question, and the answer of the Minister for Finance at that time was that in connection with the people who were excluded under Section 5 for some technical reason he was contemplating bringing in a Bill. On the 16th November last year Deputy de Valera raised the matter in the House by asking a question, and the Minister at that time replied:—

The applications for the grant of a pension under Sec. 5 of the Superannuation and Pensions Act, 1923, lodged in this and a small number of other similar cases have not been hitherto entertained because in each such case the applicant was known to be a member or a helper or active sympathiser with the organisation engaged in armed opposition to the late Provisional Government or the Government of Saorstát Eireann. In view of the improved conditions in the country, I am now prepared to have these cases considered.

That question arose out of the treatment that had been meted out to Mr. McElligott. Various suggestions have been made from time to time as to whether he deserved a pension or not, or as to whether he should come within the terms of this Bill. In connection with that reply of the Minister, Mr. McElligott wrote on the 20th November, 1927, to the Minister for Finance as follows:—

With reference to your reply to Mr. de Valera's question on the 16th instant, I wish to renew my application for a pension and treatment at least as favourable as that accorded to those who did not resign from the R.I.C.

I joined the Force on the 20th October, 1907, and resigned (under the conditions stated in the question) on the 20th May, 1919. I held the rank of sergeant after the first Service examination in 1913, and also Board of Trade Certificate as Inspector of Weights and Measures.

I desire to state that when the "resignation policy" was adopted, I was urged by Michael Collins (R.I.P.) to leave no stone unturned to get the men to resign, and Harry Boland (R.I.P.), who was then American envoy, came over specially to arrange for the emigration and care of the unemployed members. In the Munster Hotel both authorised me to assure those men that they would be treated justly and generously. I have a letter from Michael Collins—a guarantee that resigned men would be treated "not less generously than those who continued to serve." If necessary I can submit the guarantee of Michael Collins.

The R.I.C. were disbanded in January, 1922. Under these circumstances I claim the pension to which I am entitled from that date—1st January, 1922.

As I am practically responsible for the resignations and for giving those men authorised guarantees. I strongly urge their just claims for "equal treatment."

During the years 1918-21 the resigned men were paraded as "men of principle," who sacrificed their means of living for the cause of freedom. They served the National cause, and for doing so, I trust they will not be penalised.

There has been no reply so far as he is concerned or any Deputy is concerner to that letter, and no indication that anything has been done since with regard to dealing with that particular case, or the other cases that come under that head. I do not know, and I am sure no Deputy outside the Government, who may have some particular or special information with regard to this, knows why these cases have not been dealt with. It is only necessary to read the concluding paragraph of Mr. McElligott's resignation, dated the 20/5/1919, to show the reasons why he resigned. He gave a statement of the whole facts to the District Inspector when sending in his resignation, including the fact that the force should not be armed, and he concluded by saying:—

I am leaving the force with no regret—with a policeman's savings of £130 after 11 years' service—a single, temperate man, nearly half that time a sergeant. I am leaving rather with pride to serve the Union of which, you say, I am a member, the force, the men whose interests and whose welfare I have at heart and the country I love, and that I alone have the honour to represent.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

The Union?

Comment on this

Yes, the Police Union. The question of the Police Union certainly was not raised in reply to the question by Deputy de Valera. If it is a question of his being engaged in the Union, I may say that two other men similarly situated are in receipt of pensions.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

I have not read that letter for a long time, but I take it the reason of his resignation was for some purpose in connection with the Union and not for the purpose of disassociating himself from the activities of the R.I.C.

Comment on this

The President would be well aware of it if he inquired into the whole circumstances which preceded his resignation. I have a number of letters here, amongst others one from Mr. T.M. Healy, but I cannot lay my hand on it. Immediately before the anti-conscription campaign in this country, Mr. McElligott was in touch with the people concerned, and that is on record. The President can ascertain that, and the Minister for Finance, I am sure, is well aware that he submitted to that conference in the Mansion House a memorandum dealing with the best means of fighting conscription and that memorandum was adopted. Amongst the people who have already stated that in the Press is Mr. Thomas Johnson. Mr. Johnson wrote a letter to the Press setting out all these facts and stating that the memorandum was furnished at that time and set out all the circumstances in connection with it. I have also a letter from Mr. Nugent of the A.O.H. setting out some of the facts and stating that when he was in the British House of Commons information was conveyed to him through Mr. McElligott. I shall read portion of that letter which was written to Mr. McElligott and dated the 30th July, 1928:—

"As soon as the Ancient Order of Hibernians learned early in 1917 that it was the intention of the British Government to enforce Conscription in Ireland we proceeded to organise all the available forces to resist so gross a tyranny. Amongst these forces were the two great police organisations, the Royal Irish Constabulary and the Dublin Metropolitan Police. You were one of the first to respond and your action was wholly spontaneous. You immediately sent me an intimation that you were prepared and anxious to assist the Anti-Conscription Movement, your attitude being that you looked upon the threat of compulsory enlistment as an outrage on the Irish Nation so long as the majority of the Irish representatives were opposed to it.

"Inquiries made at the time satisfied me that there was no ulterior motive behind your action—that you were acting solely from the impulse of patriotism. In the first place, you were popular with your colleagues. Secondly, you had been successful in obtaining promotion as a sergeant, not through any services rendered to the enemies of Ireland, but because you had passed with flying colours in the examination for what was known as the "P" list. You not only assisted in the organisation of the police force in Meath, but you furnished me with valuable introductions, some of them even to members of the force who held positions on the Headquarters' Staff. I was then, and I am still, convinced that the organisation of the police force —both the R.I.C. and the D.M.P.— had a mighty influence in altering the decision of the Government, or rather the Ascendency, who were behind the Government and had been egging it on, and the Military junta in the control of the Army.

"Largely through your influence and by means of the wonderfully effective system of communications you had already established I was able to obtain copies at the very earliest moment of all the circulars and secret documents that were being sent to the Country and District Inspectors of the Constabulary. So effective indeed was your action, and so completely did it on many occasions defeat the purposes of the Government, that the then Chief Secretary, Mr. Shortt, declared in the British House of Commons that I had obtained circulars and utilised the information contained in them before there had been time for them to be communicated to the rank and file of the police force.

"The services rendered by Irishmen to their country and the sacrifices made by them for the national cause in the past often not only went unrewarded but were actually forgotten, or slurred over as of no account; but I can at least bear testimony to what you did, and pay tribute to the patriotic motives by which you and other members of the R.I.C. were inspired at a great crisis in the National movement when vital issues were at stake."

After Mr. Johnson's letter was published, there was a leading article in the "Irish Independent" which set out that the editor of the "Independent" himself could vouch, of his own personal knowledge, as to Mr. McElligott's activities at the time. This is the extract:

"As Mr. Thomas Johnson and others have testified, he gave valuable assistance to the National cause during the anti-conscription campaign. Through all that crisis he conveyed useful information to the leaders of the resistance movement; for several years he was in constant communication with the editor of the ‘Irish Independent'; and we have no hesitation in asserting that the movement inaugurated by him was one of the driving forces behind the subsequent resignations."

It can be proved by a number of witnesses and I am sure that the Deputy for Kerry—Mr. J. Crowley—will testify to the activities in the Kerry area of Mr. McElligott. I am sure he will admit that he was in communication with him and that he was in the conveyance of war material during the trouble. It will also be testified, I am sure, and admitted by many on the Government side, that it was on the instructions of the late Mr. Collins that that letter was prepared tendering the resignation, and that that letter set out the reasons why the members of the police force should resign. That letter was refused publication in this country at the time, as the papers were prohibited from publishing it, but it was published in England. If it was a case of some substantial grounds being put forward, or some question of that kind, it might be a matter for investigation, but I am quite sure that the Government are aware of all this and that they are conversant with the facts and why no investigation is necessary with regard to them. It is a peculiar fact that in November, 1922, when this committee of inquiry was being set up to inquire into these cases Mr. McElligott was appointed by these men to represent them, but for some reason that I do not understand, and that it is very difficult for anyone to understand, a letter was written to him from the Department of Justice inquiring who gave him the credentials and who appointed him.

Everybody in the country at that time recognised Mr. McElligott as the leader of that particular movement and the guiding force behind it both by his letters to the Press and the position he occupied in the Committees. While this controversy was going on in 1922 between the Department of Justice and Mr. McElligott he was arrested in the Park. The documents he had in his possession at that time, some of them very valuable documents in proving his case—but I am sure he has sufficient evidence to prove his case if the Minister for Finance will look into it—were seized and not given back to him. No charge was brought against him and in no way was it shown he was implicated in anything that happened at the time. Even if he were, I do not think it would alter it in any way.

Deputy Batt O'Connor, when I raised this question in 1927, said that there was no victimisation by that Committee. Surely, if there were ever a clear case of victimisation this was one. I would like to know did that Committee of Inquiry—I can hardly believe they did—turn down the application of Mr. McElligott. I would also like to know would the Deputy from Kerry, Deputy Crowley, deny or repudiate in any way the statement I made with regard to this man's activities or the reasons he resigned from the force, or would the Minister for Finance repudiate the fact that it was under the instructions of the late General Collins that McElligott acted during all the time up to his resignation and afterwards up to the Truce. It does seem an extraordinary thing that the Government will ignore not only the demands made from this side of the House but those made by Mr. Johnson of the Labour Party, Mr. Nugent of the Ancient Order of Hibernians, and even by the leading article in the "Irish Independent," all calling for justice to be done in the case. A little over twelve months ago we were informed in reply to a question that the matter would be reconsidered.

It is under consideration since then I suppose. It had been under consideration before that, and, if that is the speed with which the Department moves then those unfortunate men will be in a sorry plight for a long time.

There was another case raised concerning a man named Thomas Kearney, an active man during the Tan trouble. An assurance was given that his case would be considered also. Another matter was mentioned by Deputy Davin that by our policy in opposing this Bill we were holding up the old age pensions. That is too foolish. Deputy Davin knows quite well that if the Government wanted to reduce the Estimates they have a method of doing it. This does not mean throwing the whole of the administrative forces of the country into disorder or that the old age pensioners would be deprived of their pensions.

Comment on this

I would like to take advantage of this opportunity to ask the Government to reconsider the position in connection with the claim made by the Executive of the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union in connection with the bombardment of Liberty Hall in 1916. It is common knowledge that from 1913, when the Citizen Army was established at Liberty Hall as their headquarters up to 1916, and immediately prior to Easter, it was the military headquarters of the I.R.B. Final arrangements were made there for the insurrection and the Republican proclamation was printed there on the printing press owned by the Union. Liberty Hall was shelled on April the 26th, 1916. The front portion of the premises was entirely demolished. The rere portion was in the occupation of British troops for about a month, and all the furniture in it was burned or looted during that period. The Executive of the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union made an application to the Property Losses Commission set up, subsequent to the Rebellion, by the British and, of course, being implicated in the insurrection, they were turned down. One can understand that attitude of mind in so far as the British Government were concerned, but I cannot understand an Irish Government, the Executive of which is composed of men who were colleagues of those who issued the Proclamation from Liberty Hall in 1916, not being prepared to entertain and honour the application made by the Executive of the Irish Transport Union. I would like the President to say if he is prepared to re-consider the attitude of the Government in this connection. After the Insurrection General Collins wrote the following letter to the President of the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union, which shows that he recognised what had been done by the Union. He said:—

"Dear Sir,—Your appeal for financial help towards the loss you sustained during and after the Easter Rising, duly received. My Executive have considered the matter, and they instruct me to say that they regret they could not, owing to the constitution of the Irish National Aid and Volunteers' Dependents' Fund Association, vote you any money out of the funds at their disposal. At the same time they direct me to inform you that they are quite satisfied from the particulars you gave them in writing, and the further facts you placed before them, that you suffered very serious loss to your premises, furniture and other effects, and they believe, if your Union decided on issuing a public appeal to replace and restore your losses, that such appeal ought and would receive the warm consideration and support of the Irish people.—Yours faithfully, MICHAEL COLLINS."

Everyone knows that that was not an opportune time to make any appeal to the public for things of that kind. I suggest to the President it would be only common decency on the part of his Government to reconsider the claim of the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The Minister for Industry and Commerce to conclude.

Comment on this

If he wishes to speak we are quite willing to let him speak but not necessarily to conclude.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

Is there any other Deputy who wishes to speak?

Comment on this

I would like to ask a question. I understood that the Minister for Industry and Commerce desired to address the House. I would like to put this question. Having risen to speak, if he does not proceed to speak now, are we entitled to assume that he foregoes his right to speak in this debate or is this precedent going to be created, that when a Minister rises to speak he rises naturally to conclude the debate?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

I understand the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in the absence of the Minister for Finance, is to reply to the debate on behalf of the Government.

Comment on this

We are unaware that any such understanding was come to. As members of the Opposition we deny the right of the Government to enter into any such understanding with the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The Deputy must not misrepresent anything I said. There is no understanding entered into between the Government and the Chair, and the Deputy has no right to suggest it.

Comment on this

I apologise to the Chair if I misinterpreted what was said, but I think you did say that you understood the Minister for Industry and Commerce was to conclude the debate on behalf of the Minister for Finance. As we had no knowledge of that understanding, and as no such understanding was arrived at between the Opposition and the Government, I naturally concluded if there was such an understanding it must have been with the Chair. If I was wrong in that I retract what I said. At the same time we are entitled now to ask the Minister, since he has risen to speak, to proceed with his speech, but we do not think he has a right to conclude the debate as we have the right to reply to him.

Comment on this

He must have a very bad case.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

If the Minister for Industry and Commerce, or any other Minister, does not wish to speak at this particular moment, I have no power to compel him to do so, but if the Deputy foregoes his right to speak now. I do not think that he can speak afterwards.

Comment on this

I put it to you that, the Minister for Industry and Commerce having risen to speak and not having exercised his right to do so, you must call on him to speak, but I do not think you are entitled to call on him to conclude. He has risen and attracted your attention. You have named him. I think you ought to make him proceed and then give us the right to reply.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The practice on the Second Reading of Bills has been that when the debate, so far as the Chair can see, has concluded, when no Deputy rises to speak and when another Deputy has concluded his speech, the Chair should call on the particular Minister answering for the Government to conclude the debate. That has been the practice, and it has not been departed from in this particular instance.

Comment on this

In view of the fact that, so far, no member of the Government has risen to reply to the speeches delivered from this side and that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has been the first member on the Government Bench who rose to participate in this debate, I think we are entitled to hear what he has to say in reply to our speeches, and we are entitled, if we think fit, to reply to anything he says and then permit the Minister who moved the Vote to conclude the debate. I think it is a violation of the privileges of the Opposition if the Government are always going to put themselves in this position, namely, that they can sit on their benches while the whole policy of the Government is being criticised and then take advantage of their power to conclude the debate to go into a lot of scurrility, as they do, and in their reply make wholesale misrepresentations of the things which the Opposition have said.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The question whether the Minister for Industry and Commerce has spoken on this debate or not does not arise. If the Minister does not wish to speak I am not in a position to compel him. I may point out to the Deputy that the practice has been that some member of the Government concludes the debate on Second Reading of a Bill. It was intimated to me earlier in the evening that the Minister for Industry and Commerce would reply on behalf of the Government. That exactly is what I meant when I said that I understood that the Minister was to reply. When no member rose to speak when Deputy Corish had concluded I naturally, and in accordance with the practice of the House, called on the Minister for Industry and Commerce to conclude the debate. That is the position.

Comment on this

I take it that the rules of procedure are laid down in Standing Orders, and I do not think that any intimation given to you by a member of the Government would justify you in departing from the Standing Orders, which provide that the Deputy who moves the motion "That the Bill be now read a Second Time" alone has the right to speak again and conclude at the termination of the debate. I would like to hear from you what particular Standing Order empowers you to call on a Deputy other than the Deputy who moved the motion to speak and conclude the debate. I would also like your ruling on another point and it is this: The Minister for Industry and Commerce rose to address the House. He was named by you, but he sat down without saying anything. Does he not by doing so sacrifice his right to speak?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

Would the Deputy refer me to the particular Standing Order which he has in mind?

Comment on this

Standing Order 38. "No Deputy shall be entitled to speak twice upon the same motion except to close the debate upon a motion of which he was the proposer; but a Deputy is not precluded from speaking on an amendment by reason of having spoken upon the original motion or upon any other amendment." I will look the right one up in a minute.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

There are two points raised by Deputy Lemass. I take it that the Government are entitled to arrange their business, and, if the Minister for Finance is not present, I think he may depute any other member of the Executive to reply on his behalf. As I pointed out to the Deputy, the practice has been that some member of the Government concludes the debate on Second Reading. With regard to his point about calling on the Minister for Industry and Commerce when he stood up, I called on him to conclude the debate.

Comment on this

Your calling on the Minister for Industry and Commerce practically means the closure of the debate, without a single speech having been made from the Government Benches on this Bill, either to justify or answer the criticisms which we have made on their policy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The Deputy can put a point of order, but he cannot suggest that the Chair is trying to put on the closure.

Comment on this

I do not suggest that you are consciously trying to put on the closure, but I say that it is tantamount to the same thing if you call on a member of the Government who has not spoken to conclude the debate. There is no reason to assume that the debate will conclude after the Minister for Industry and Commerce has spoken, but there is every reason to believe that the debate might then become more real.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The Deputy must accept what I have said, namely, that the practice has always been that a Minister concludes the debate on Second Reading. I hesitated to call on the Minister when Deputy Corish concluded in order to see if any other Deputy wished to exercise his right to speak before the Minister concluded. If any Deputy wishes to speak before the Minister, he has a perfect right to do so. If the Minister does not desire to speak I cannot compel him.

Comment on this

I thought that Deputies were privileged to intervene at any portion of the debate they thought fit?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The debate must conclude at some stage.

Comment on this

We have until 10.30.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

It is not a question of time.

Comment on this

Then, why suggest that it must conclude now? Why not prolong it? Why should the Minister's speech conclude it now?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

Does the Deputy himself wish to speak now?

Comment on this

No. We wish to hear some member from the Government Benches on the matter. The Government are asking the House to vote a sum of over £7,000,000.

Comment on this

Would I be in order in moving to report progress and that the debate be adjourned until tomorrow?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Report progress? We are now in the Second Reading of a Bill.

Comment on this

We wish to extend to the Government Benches the courtesy of a hearing. We are anxious to hear them, but certainly if they do speak now, I think that we should have the right to reply. There has not been a single official spokesman from the Government Party who has spoken in support of this measure during the whole debate. I do not know whether it is that they are afraid or ashamed of their position.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

I wish to explain to the Deputy for the last time that, so far as the Chair is concerned, there is no power whatever to compel any member, Minister or otherwise, to speak if he does not wish to do so. This is my ruling on the matter, that if the Deputy does not wish to speak now, then the Chair must, in accordance with the practice and procedure of the House, call upon a member of the Government to conclude the debate.

Comment on this

I should like to point out that it is quite clear, I think, that it is not in accordance with the Standing Orders that a speech by a member of the Government concludes the debate.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Practice and the Chair—the two things together.

Comment on this

We know that the real explanation is that the Government is afraid to let their case be criticised.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

If the Deputy would restrict some of his speakers we could speak.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

We cannot have this cross-examination.

Comment on this

I must say that the exhibition of silence on the Ministerial benches is one of those things that bring discredit on Parliamentary institutions generally. We all want to see Parliament something which represents the earnest effort of all parties in trying to drag this country out of the terrible state in which it is. We have contributed to the best we know. Instead of taking us in that spirit in which we tackled the subjects that came before the House, we are met by indifference, a callous silence, and a cynicism which must re-act on those who are serious in the country in one way, and one way only, and that is that Parliamentary institutions are a farce and a fraud and a waste of time. The Appropriation Bill naturally afford an opportunity for an Opposition Party to sum up its criticisms of Government policy. One would at least expect to get intelligent criticism met with intelligent answers. Our criticism is that we find the Government wanting on all counts, that is, dividing the matter of government under two broad heads: one dealing with external affairs, and the other with internal affairs. On most counts we have severe criticism to make. So far as the judicial administration is concerned, that has been pretty fairly dealt with and fully gone into on the individual Estimates. On the economic side, the question of agricultural depression in the country and a lack of policy will be dealt with on another motion. But there is another side of the economic life of this country. The speeches from these benches have pretty fairly shown that there is very serious ground for very severe criticism of the Government. One has only to point to the conditions in the country in order to prove by the fruits that the tree such as it is, is not in a healthy condition, and that the Government has failed to do its duty.

Our criticism has not merely been of a destructive nature. We have departed from the usual policy in a great many countries of an Opposition making merely destructive criticism. There are very few Opposition parties which have gone so far as we have gone in making suggestions out of which the Government could have made political capital if they liked. We have in certain respects proved to have been right. Although motions put down and advocated by the Opposition Party were defeated in this House they have succeeded, and we may note as a victory the very establishment of this new Economic Committee which is about to come into existence. But we must make it perfectly clear that an Economic Committee will not be able to produce real results to the country. It is perfectly obvious that we are facing a winter with a paltry Vote for something like £30,000 for relief, a certain amount of which may be expended in subsidies in the building of houses. The sum of £250,000 has been allocated, but how much of that can be spent during the winter months when the weather and season are unfavourable for building? It will be a long time before that will produce results in the form of money in circulation.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

On a point of order, that £250,000 has not yet been voted.

Comment on this

I did not catch the President's remark.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The Deputy, I think, is merely mentioning that in passing. He is not dwelling on it.

Comment on this

I was even more generous than I ought.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

The Deputy can reserve that for a later time.

Comment on this

In any case, I take it in that matter that we are not going to have a case of broken faith. I am simply examining it and considering it from the point of view of how long it will be before there is any development in this matter, and before wages are circulating amongst the people as a result of this.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Some of it already.

Comment on this

Circulating amongst the people and reducing unemployment? I wish it were more. I am sure that the President does not suggest that the amount that is percolating is a really serious contribution to the reduction of unemployment.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Very serious.

Comment on this

We want at least 400 houses in Waterford, and there are 2,000 people unemployed there. We have criticised the Government because of its inaction and delay. If the Government last year had adopted this economic council it would now be in the position to know what it could do, and we would all now be in the position to make an advance to face the terrible winter the poor people are faced with. We have criticised their tariff policy. They have done nothing to build up the industries of the country, or very little, and the very things they have done have condemned them. The success which has been the result of their timid efforts, even in the matter of small things like furniture and the boot industry, is proof that if the same policy had been acted upon courageously and on a big scale this country would be in a different position to what it is. In connection with the building up of industries, we suggest there should be established a proper under-writing firm which would carry out the functions that well established under-writing firms do in London. A small firm has been established, but nothing has been done on a big scale which would go hand in hand with a policy of tariff protection. We suggested that a central bank should be established, but no knowledge has been shown by the Government of the attitude taken up by the authorities in England on the question of a central bank. It has come forward with no proposition to do what is taken as granted as commonplace by the authorities like Mr. Montague of the Bank of England.

If the policy which the Minister for Industry and Commerce mentioned is the policy adopted inside the British Commonwealth of Nations by Ireland, namely, the policy of sovereign and exclusive control, there is no indication that the Government has adopted the same policy in the matter of the economy of the country. If there were, the first thing he would do would be to establish a central bank. In a book, with the blessing as it were, of Mr. Montague of the Bank of England, one finds it stated as the ordinary accepted principles of guiding central banks the very principle we are looking for, namely, national safeguarding of the interests of the country as the source of the control of the credit of the other banks. So far from developing any policy on that question the Government has even failed to get the necessary information from the banks as to how much Irish capital is invested out of Ireland. After all, knowledge is the first step. We may get bank statistics, but we are groping blindly in the dark as to how much Irish money is from day to day deposited in the banks by the farmers and other people in the country how much of that is invested in Ireland, and how much invested in English bank undertakings? We are like a motor car the lights of which are gone out, and we are driving along at a good, hard speed and do not know what is in front of us. We want to get knowledge first before we can develop a scheme. What effort has been made to reduce prices in this country? We had a Commission upon the subject, but no effort has been made affecting the purchasing power of the people.

Turning to the other side of the Government policy, namely, as to external affairs, I would first like to say that Deputy Sheehy, with his usual eloquence, misunderstood the attitude of certain speakers on this side of the House. It would be a very serious charge indeed to make against anybody who spoke in favour of opening trade relations with Russia to suggest that they were in any way in sympathy with the irreligious activities in Russia, and it is a misapprehension which should not be allowed to pass without it being pointed out and contradicted. It need only be mentioned in order to make it clear, that it is perfectly obviously a gross and unfair comment on what has been said from this side of the House about opening trade relations with Russia.

As to the quotation by the Minister for Agriculture from Deputy Aiken's speech, I had myself an experience of what newspapers can do by making a mistake, and I mention it only in order that it may be put side by side with that alleged report of Deputy Aiken's speech. Yesterday evening I stated that it would be to the interest of England and of Ireland if Ireland were a neutral country, free and guaranteed. A certain daily paper in this country this morning reported me as saying exactly the opposite. I suppose if someone like the Minister for Agriculture were in America he might get the opportunity of attacking me under certain conditions, and building up a case against me under certain conditions, simply on the report of a newspaper like that. Anybody who has had any experience of propaganda must know that there comes a time when one gets tired of correcting misrepresentations.

I would like to return to the subject we were dealing with on the Estimates. In a general way we criticise the Government because it devotes almost its entire attention to its activities in the League of Nations and the Imperial Conference instead of adopting some big supreme principle which will actuate its policy, namely the declared policy of going for the complete unity and freedom of Ireland, and appealing rather to the public opinion of Europe and America, for the strength you will have inside any council, I do not care whether the League of Nations or anywhere else, will depend largely on the support you have generally from public opinion. Everyone knows the League of Nations is largely under the control of a few of the Great Powers, and the advance, even with the best intentions and best efforts, we may hope to make inside the League of Nations is small. Again, inside the Imperial Conference it is very difficult to see how we can get support and sympathy from most of the other colonies if we require it in this country.

We get a certain amount, but to look to it as a means of protecting us against any future attack from England is very futile. The other members of the Commonwealth are scattered; their sympathies are largely English. Australia is very nearly three-quarters English. South Africa—I am speaking of the white population—is something less than half English; and Canada must be, so far as effective public opinion is concerned, predominantly British. To depend upon these for protection or freedom is depending upon a broken reed, and is a very different thing from looking to those countries which will benefit by a neutral and free Ireland, and which will appreciate fully the difference between colonial autonomy and complete national independence.

We have very little security in this development of what is called coequality. In the past, England has adopted the policy of letting the Colonies have a free rein and pulling them up when it chooses to do so. The policy which preceded the conflict between England and America was such a policy. The colony of North America was left largely to itself, but with a change of Government there came a tightening up which was the beginning of war between America and England. It is a short-sighted policy to satisfy one's own mind that one is making any real, solid advance towards an independent Ireland so long as one has to rely purely on the atmosphere of Imperialism and the atmosphere of the colonial statehood. The advantage of adopting a policy like that is that it puts foreign affairs outside party politics. There is something in common for the whole country to look to, something that everyone feels is the right policy. I do not believe there is anyone in the Twenty-six Counties, and largely in the Six Counties, who does not, in some way or other, crave to have unity back again. It is extraordinary how one discovers in those who appear to be most opposed to the aspirations of Ireland how unconsciously they feel that the advance towards freedom would, to some extent, improve their own self-respect. In spite of what the Minister for Industry and Commerce said last night, guarantees of neutrality are valuable. The breaking of the guarantee of the neutrality of Belgium was perhaps the greatest weapon against Germany in the war.

Comment on this

It helped Belgium.

Comment on this

The breaking of the neutrality of Belgium helped another country, because when Germany was tempted to take the advantage of marching across Holland it had learned a terrible lesson through having attacked Belgium, and it did not do so. In Holland you get a lesson. Holland was there, and England or Germany could have got an enormous strategic advantage by landing there or marching across it. No country dared to do so, because they all saw that advantage in morale which had accrued to the Allies, owing to the fact that Germany broke the neutrality of Belgium. Ireland is in a stronger position than Holland because it is an island. Someone mentioned Denmark, but it is not an island, and has not got a Danish-America at its back to support and protect it; it has not a public opinion against which, if Ireland was once established as free, England would never dare to attack Ireland again. A policy put forward like that in a friendly manner to England might be more effective than if it were put forward in a hostile manner. It is true that men like Lloyd George, inspired with jingoism and opportunism, refused to entertain this claim because they do not want to lose the opportunity of using Ireland as a jumping-off ground in any war.

Again, one can look to European history and see what a short-sighted policy this is. Germany held Alsace-Lorraine for its own benefit and paid very heavily for it. Even Bismarck was not altogether in sympathy with that policy, and pointed out that by holding Alsace-Lorraine they were creating permanent grievances amongst their enemies, for which they would pay in the long run. The value of a common policy inspired by these ideas would be of enormous advantage to the country. It would lift the status of the country and would bring us closer to our real aspirations for freedom. I do not suppose it is likely that we are going to influence the Government in this matter. It is something which is outside their power, apparently, or else, is something to which they have become so hardened and indifferent that we might give up hope of getting such a common policy. On all these counts, both as to external affairs and in the internal government of this country, the present Government is found wanting; it is not merely found wanting by those who speak in this House, but it is found wanting by the farmers, the workers, and by the poor in the cities.

Comment on this

The courage of the Government in this debate, and the tribute which they have paid the Opposition, almost disarm criticism. Apparently they think that our replies to the speech which the Minister for Industry and Commerce is prepared to make on their behalf would be so trenchant, that he could not risk a reply. He feels that discretion in this case is the better course, and, so as to preclude any rejoinder to one of his usually polished speeches, he reserves to himself the right, the usual feminine right, of having the last word in the matter.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The PRESIDENT

Does the Deputy want it?

Comment on this

No, I do not want it. I am perfectly prepared, after having listened to the speech of a responsible person—if there is still a responsible person left on the Government Benches—to reply to that speech, and to leave to another spokesman of the Government the right to reply to anything that may be said from these benches. We protest, and we are entitled to protest, at the Government making, as Deputy Mullins said, a circus or a farce of what is supposed to be a deliberative assembly. So far the Government have not uttered one word in justification of this measure. This is the Government's child, but it is something which is of very great importance indeed to the taxpayers, of whose money the Government is the custodian. This Bill contains only five clauses, but it proposes to deal with over £7,000,000 of the people's money: over £7,000,000 to be voted away for certain Services; and the Government, so far, in reply to the criticisms which have been advanced from these benches, have not said a single word.

On this Vote we ought to have a balance of £22,438,000 for Supply Services, and to this sum is added £4,315,000, which are also to be expended for the Central Fund purposes, making a total expenditure in the current year of public money, £26,753,000. The point I think the House is entitled to consider before it votes for the Second Reading of this Bill is to ask where is that money to come from? It is quite easy to spend £7,000,000 of the country's money, but where is it going to come from? Where is the Government going to get that money? In March last the Minister expected that he would get some twenty and a half millions of it from taxation. Last year, however, he only got £20,396,000 out of taxation, and at that time some of the taxes which he had imposed in the preceding year had already begun to yield a diminishing return. That related then, I think, only to the Excise duties, but this year it has become manifest in respect of practically every single tax imposed by the Minister for Finance, on behalf of the Government. Here are the figures for some of those taxes: Customs duties last year in the first seven and a half months brought in £4,261,000. This year, during the corresponding period, they brought in £4,427,000, but included in this year's figures are the proceeds of two new taxes which the Minister for Finance imposed in March last. There is the Sugar tax, from which he hoped to get an additional £200,000. There is the extended duty on tyres and motor vehicles, from which he hoped to get another £200,000. Altogether he hoped to secure in the twelve months £400,000.

Seven and a half months of that twelve months have gone, and the Minister by this time ought to have secured from this tax something like £300,000. I would like to point out that I am not discussing the failure of the Minister's Budget policy. What I am endeavouring to show to the House is this, that in view of the fact that the premises from which the Government and the Minister proceeded being apparently about to fail, the House is not justified in voting this money. The House is not justified in voting for this expenditure, because it is not going to have at the end of this year the wherewithal to meet it. I have, therefore, to show that this decline in revenue which is manifesting itself is general and universal and is likely to continue. For that reason, however, I have got to take these taxes more or less in detail. If the Customs duties were coming in at the same rate as they were coming in last year, the amount collected in respect of them up to this period would be something like £4,550,000. As a matter of fact they are £4,261,000. So that there is in these figures and in regard to that tax an apparent deficit of something like £290,000. So much for the Customs duties. That is one of the principal sources of revenue. The next is the Excise. Last year the Excise brought £4,205,000. This year it has brought only £3,925,000 up to the present. Contrasting the revenue collected up to the present with the revenue collected in the corresponding period last year, there is already a deficiency on this tax of something like £280,000. But in his Budget the Minister adopted an expedient of shortening the brewers' credit from three to two months in the hope of collecting in twelve months of this financial year the revenue that would normally accrue in thirteen months. He hoped by that to secure an extra £300,000 of money in this year, and that £300,000 should have been secured and should have been made manifest in the Exchequer returns in the second or third month of the year at the very latest. What is the position? Here, after seven and a half months have elapsed, we find that the revenue derived from that tax is £280,000 below what was derived from it last year. In order to evaluate the real deficiency we have to add to the £280,000 this sum of £300,000 extra revenue which the Minister forestalled and anticipated, a revenue that properly belongs to next year, and which, as I said, the Minister has forestalled for this year. These two together make the deficiency up to something like £580,000.

Estate Duties last year brought in £779,000. This year up to the present they have only yielded £637,000. There is a deficiency under that head of £142,000. Last year, Property and Income Tax brought in £2,088,000. This year up to date it has only yielded £1,645,000, a deficiency of £443,000. Excess Profits tax last year brought in £111,000. This year it has brought in £64,000, a deficiency of £47,000.

Last March the Minister budgeted to collect from the taxpayers £1,51,000 more than he did in the twelve months of last year. Up to date, he has failed to collect even what he secured last year, and the proceeds from the several sources on which he relied, so far from yielding him that excess, £1,151,000, are at the present moment yielding him £1,000,000—what he got last year. The Minister, on behalf of the Government, in order to meet some portion of the cost of services—not the whole cost— that you are asked to vote in this Appropriation Bill, said that he wanted to collect from the taxpayers an extra £1,151,000. He has failed, not only to collect that extra £1,151,000, but has failed to collect another £1,000,000 as well, so that we can estimate that the total deficiency on the sum mentioned in the Minister's Budget statement for this year will be something like £2,151,000. If we vote, therefore, for this Appropriation Bill, if we vote this £22,438,000 for these supply services— and we are already compelled by statute to make provision out of the taxpayers' money for an additional £4,315,000—what will be the financial position of this State at the end of this year and at the beginning of the next?

The Minister, if you remember his Budget statement, took out certain items totalling, I think, £2,235,000, classified them as abnormal expenditure, and said that they were going to be met by borrowing. Therefore, so far as the Budget position is concerned, we have already started off with an acknowledged deficit of £2,235,000, and we are now faced with the almost certain prospect of having to add to that another £2,151,000. In his Budget statement, as I said, the Minister classified certain items as abnormal. He proposed to meet the expenditure in regard to them by borrowing, but so far as £24,000,000 of that Budget statement was concerned, the items which went to make it up were items which—notwithstanding the plight in which he found himself, notwithstanding the fact that he had to put the best face he could on the matter to the country—he was unable to justify as abnormal. He was unable to come to the Dáil and make a case by saying: "Look, we must regard this expenditure as abnormal. We cannot meet it out of taxation. We must meet it by borrowing."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

Is the Deputy not making a speech which he might make on the next Budget?

Comment on this

No. I am making a speech to show that we are not justified in passing this Appropriation Bill, and as we must take account for the future, we must visualise the result of our actions and the result of every vote which is cast in the Division lobbies, for this Bill——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

I would like the Deputy to pay a little more attention to the Bill and a little less to the next Budget.

Comment on this

The Appropriation Bill and the Estimates have been, to some extent, based on the last Budget, or the last Budget has been based on the Estimates, and I am endeavouring to show what the next Budget will be like if we pass this Bill.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

Might I suggest to the Deputy that everything we do has some relation to the Budget?

Comment on this

Exactly. Therefore, on every single legislative measure that is passed through this House we are entitled to ask ourselves what will be the general effect on the taxpayer.

Comment on this

The year after.

Comment on this

Certainly, the year after. I hope that by the time of next year's Budget there will be such a change of mind in the country that there will be a change of Government in this House.

Comment on this

And there is not much prospect for the successors of the present Government.

Comment on this

You will go back to Liverpool then.

Comment on this
A DEPUTY

And you will go back to the University.

Comment on this

We have got a word from the silent Deputy!

Comment on this

What about a word from the silent Ministers?

Comment on this

I was saying that to the deficiency of £2,235,000, which the Minister himself anticipated, there has to be added a further £2,151,000——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The Deputy ought to commence to deal with general policy.

Comment on this

I am.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The Deputy ought to deal with general policy.

Comment on this

I am dealing with general policy. I am dealing with the general policy of the Government, as expressed in this Appropriation Bill. I am going to show that the general policy of the Government will result in a deficiency at the end of this year of £4,386,000.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

The Deputy must deal with this matter according to the judgement of the Chair and not in accordance with his own judgement.

Comment on this

Oh, I beg your pardon. When I make a statement I wish to document it properly. I wish to produce to the House figures which I hope will convince any impartial Deputy that this Bill is not one for which he can conscientiously vote, and I wish to put before Deputies as plainly as I can the consequences of voting for this Bill. I do not want them to go into either the Tá Lobby or the Níl Lobby blindfolded. Let them know what they are doing. If they vote for this Bill they are voting to create a deficiency on the present year's Budget of £4,386,000, and I am entitled to ask them, before they cast their votes to create that deficiency, how they propose to meet it. That is the question that I am putting to the Deputies on the Government Benches. If they vote for this Appropriation Bill, how are they going to meet the expenditure which they sanction when they vote for it? It will have to be met. If there is a deficiency of £4,386,000 on this year's Budget, over and above what we will have in the Revenue, somehow or another that deficiency will have to be provided next year. How is that going to be done? So far as £2,235,000 of it is concerned, we know that the Minister has already classified it as abnormal expenditure, and that he proposes to meet it by borrowing. We do not think that that is a justifiable course, but we have at the present moment no power to prevent it. But what of the balance— what of the other £2,151,000? That expenditure cannot be classified as abnormal. The Minister and the Governmen have already excluded it from that category. It is expenditure which they themselves admit, in so far as it is not devoted to any unusual purpose, in so far as it is recurring expenditure, is not abnormal expenditure. They declare that it is indispensable expenditure. It is expenditure, which, therefore, ought to be met out of the proceeds of taxation. Are the Deputies who are going into the Lobby to vote for the Second Reading of this Appropriation Bill going to declare by their votes that they wish the taxpayers to have an additional £2,151,000 of taxation imposed upon them next year? Is that the fate to which the Government is leading the country? Is that the fate to which Deputy Timothy Sheehy, who so eloquently defended the Government, is going to consign his constituents in West Cork? Is Deputy John Daly going to vote in that manner also?

Comment on this

I am afraid I am.

Comment on this

And is Deputy Carey, whose heart was bleeding for the widows and orphans the other night——

Comment on this

For John Bull.

Comment on this

Is he going to give a vote the inevitable consequences of which will be that next year the Minister for Finance, in whatever Government he sits, has got to impose another £2,151,000 upon the unfortunate taxpayers of this country? Deputy Shaw believes, I think, that the Betting Tax ought to be remitted. What chance has the Government next year of remitting the Betting Tax if Deputy Shaw votes for this Appropriation Bill? Then there is Deputy Alfred Byrne, and there is, or should be, Deputy Vincent Rice. They believe that the Excise duties—the duties on beer and spirits—ought to be reduced. What chance is there next year of a reduction in the Excise duties if Deputy Rice and Deputy Alfred Byrne vote for this Appropriation Bill and give the Government the majority which will enforce it? Then there is Deputy Anthony. He was the first, I think, to spring into the breach when the Government feared to defend themselves in this debate. The main burden of his speech was the sins of omission and commission of Fianna Fail. Well, of course, we do not regard Deputy Anthony as a typical Labour member. We think that he sits on the Labour Benches more by accident than by design. Every time I hear him he reminds me of an old definition in my Catechism about Purgatory, and I always think of Deputy Anthony as one of those politicians who regard the Labour Benches as a place or state of punishment where some statesmen suffer for a time before they join a Coalition Government.

But Deputy Anthony was very anxious that the Government should make an increased grant for unemployment, so far as his attitude towards this measure was expressed by his speech. I admit that he devoted very little attention to the Bill. I take it that Deputy Anthony is going to vote for this measure. He is anxious that there should be an increased grant for relief schemes this year, and I am afraid that an increased grant will be needed also next year for the same purpose. Deputy Anthony is very anxious that adequate provision should be made for widows' and mothers' pensions. If Deputy Anthony votes for this Appropriation Bill and thereby ensures that next year an additional burden of £2,151,000 will be imposed upon the taxpayer, not for new services, but to recoup money that was wastefully expended this year, what chance has he of getting an increased grant next year for relief schemes? What chance has his Party, or any Party in this country, of seeing that adequate provision is made for widows' and mothers' pensions?

Comment on this

To all of which I say Amen.

Comment on this

I hope that Deputy Anthony's prayer is a sincere one. I hope it will not be a mere Pharisaical Amen; that instead of honouring these sentiments with his lips, with his heart being far from them, he will carry that Amen into practical action, and that he will come into the Division Lobby with us and vote against this Bill.

Comment on this

Not likely.

Comment on this

I have just one other point to make, and I ask every Deputy to consider it. Can you possibly, if you vote for this measure, avoid imposing increased taxation next year? If you vote for this Bill next year you will have to impose taxation amounting to an additional 10 per cent. of practically every tax that is at present current. Can the country stand that? Can industry stand it? Can the shopkeepers stand it? Can the farmers stand it? Can the labourers stand it? Unless you can answer these questions in the affirmative, unless every Deputy in this House, speaking for his own particular class, can answer them in the affirmative, then they are not justified in voting for this Bill, which will inevitably entail that increased taxation if you pass it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy PROINNSIAS O FATHAIGH Fianna Fáil

Is mo rádh a fhéadfainn a rádh mar fhreagra ar a bhfuil ráidhte ag Ristéard Anthony, Teachta Dála, acht nár bhfiú liom aon tsuim a chur i na chuid ráiméis. Chuir sé síos ar "phlúr cogaidh" nó "cáise cogaidh" nó adhbhar plaosctha éigin ar ar thug sé "geglinite," mianach nua éigin atá tagtha amach le goirid i gCorcaigh is dócha. Ar aon chuma, is iongantach an fonn troda atá ar mar fhear síothchána.

San mBille seo, tá cupla alt go mba mhaith liom tagairt do dhéanamh dóibh. Siad sin ailt a 45, 46, 47 agus 48. Baineann na h-uimhreacha so le Roinn an Oideachais. Nuair a bhí an meastachán fá choinne Roinn an Oideachais fá diosbóireacht annso, do labhair mé ar feadh tamaill fhada agus do chuir mé síos ar gach phointe. Do mhol mé an méid atá a dhéanamh ag an Roinn chun na scoileanna do Shaolú, agus táim ar aon tuairim agus ar aon intinn fós. Ach tá ranna eile nach bhfuil chó Gaedhealach agus nach bhfuil ag déanamh beirte dá réir. Tá sé maith go leor na páistí a bheith ag foghluinn na Gaedhilge sna scoileanna ach fhad agus nach ndeineann na ranna eile iarracht chun na daoine ag a bhfuil baint acu do Ghaolú is beag toradh atá air.

Taobh amuigh de cheist na teangan, is éigin an sprid ceart a bheith sna scoileanna. Ní shaoilim gur mar sin atá sé. Is eigin stair na tíre do mhuineadh do na páiste. Tá fhios agam gur éirigh cuid de na múinteoirí san bun-scoileanna as muineadh na staire ar fad. Agus ce'n fáth? Dubhairt múinteoir liom gur tháinig cigire isteach sa sgoil lá amháin agus gidh nár chuir sé i gcoinne múineadh na stáire ba léir a fhéiceáil nach rabh sé sásta leis na ceachta a bhí an múinteóir a thabhairt do na páistí. Ba cheart go dtuigfeadh gach páiste staid na tíre fá láthair agus go mbeadh sé in ánn ceisteanna a cuirtear air do fhreagairt mar—An bhfuil na condaethe uilig san Saorstát? Ce'n fá ná fuil? An náisiún Eire no bhfuil dhá náisiún inti ná "An b'fhuilían tír saor?" Tuigim go bhfuil deachrachtá ann ach ba cheart an sprid a bheith sna scoileanna chó maith leis an teangain. Is fíor é nach bhfuil na condaethe uile san Saorstát agus nach bhfuilimíd saor. Ba cheart go dtuigfeadh gach páiste an méid sin, i dtreó go ndéanfadh sé a dhícheall chun aontú do thabhairt chun críche sa tír agus í do shaorú. Ach níl cead ag an múinteorí ceacht mar sin do thabhairt. Tá fhios agam gur thug cigirí anuas ar múinteoir toisc go raibh a leithéid de cheacht a thabhairt acu. B'fhéidir go bhfuil athrú intinne tagtha ar an Aire le déanaí mar tá leabhar agam annso do scríobh M.J. McManus "Dublin Diversions" is teidiol do. Ar leathanach a 68 de'n leabhar san tá amhrán ina mínighthear cuid de stair na hÉireann. Deirtar ar bharr an leathanaigh sin go bhfuil an t-amhrán san molta i gcóir na mbun rang ins na scoileanna náisiúnta. Má's ag Aire an Oideachais atá sé, molaim an t-Aire, óir is ionmholta an t-amhrán é agus má's rud é nach ag Aire an Oideachais atá sé molta mholfainn dó é do mholadh. Tá líne nó dó ann a chuireanns amhras orm, mar ní dóigh liom go dtaithneochaidis leis an Aire.

Is iomadh Coimisiún agus Coiste do cuireadh ar bun chun ceist an Oideachais do scrúdú. Tá fhios agam go raibh dhá Chomhdháil ann chun cláracha i gcóir na mbun-scoileanna agus na meadhon-scoileanna do leagadh amach agus rinne siad obair mhaith, gan amhras. Cuireadh coiste ar bun mar gheall ar cheist na bpinsean agus thainig toradh maith asta. Ach tá a lán le déanamh fós.

Ba cheart cúinn a bheith soléir in ár n-intinn mar gheall ar an gcuspóir atá romhainn. Cad is Oideachais ann? Cad is minn linn na páistí d'fháil as Oideachais? Go mbeadh siad in ánn a saoghal do chaitheamh i gceart in a dtír féin. Ní shaoilim go bhfuil an ceacht san dhá mhúineadh sna scoileanna ar chor ar bith. Is minic a deirtear linn gur féidir linn a lán a fhoghluim ó'n Danmharc. Is fíor san. Tá "folk schools" annsin agus isé an rud atá scríobhtha ós comhair na ndoras acu na—ní chun dochtúirí níos fearr do dhéanamh no chun saor cloiche níos fearr do dhéanamh ach chun Danair níos fearr do dhéanamh. Ní dó go bhfuil an ceacht san a mhúineadh sna scoileanna annso. Ba cheart fosta do na múinteoirí a chur in a luighe ar an páistí chó tábhachtach agus atá sé an fhírinne d'innsint igcomhnuí—is cuma cad a thiocfas as. Is gá tréithe na ndaoine do neartú. Is minic a scríobheas duine atá ar lorg pinsin tsean-aoise chugam agus uaireannta cuireann sé chugam faisnéis fá mhionn agus ainmneacha beirte no triúr léi. Nuair a théidhim go dtí Oifig an Chustuim no oifig éigin eile, bíonn innsint eile ar an sgéal. Is minic a bhíonn dearg-bhréág fá mhionn sa bhfaisnéis. Is náireach an rud san. Ba chóir tréithe na bpáistí do láidriú agus do neartú.

Mar gheall ar Oideachas na gCéard, níl mórán déanta fós. Tuigim gur ceist mhór é agus nach féidir molta an Choimisiúin do chur í bhféidhm ar a bponnc. Isé an locht is mó atá ar an scéim oideachais seo nach bhfuil baint idir an teagasc agus saol na ndaoine. Is cuimhin liom uair a thainig cigire isteach i gColáiste in a raibh mé ag teagasc. D'fhiafruigh sé dhíom cadé an barramháil a bhí agam ar Oideachas na gCéard. Dubhairt mé leis gur beag é an meas a bhí agam air. D'fhiafruigh sé dhíom cé'n fáth. Dubhairt mé nach raibh aon bhaint idir an oideachas san agus saol na ndaoine, nach raibh mórán dul ar-aghaidh air ar feadh 25 bliana agus gur droch-chomharthe é beirt chigire as gach triúr a thagadh annsin a bheith as Alban no as Sasana—tar éis 25 bliana de'n Oideachas san. D'iarrfainn ar an Rialtas rud éigin do dhéanamh chun an cheist sin do shocrú —có-cheangailt do bheith idir na mbun-scoileanna agus na meadhnon-scoileanna agus scoileanna na gCéard—agus d'iarrfainn orra fosta socrú a dhéanamh chun stáir na tíre do mhúineadh sna sgoileanna, idtreo go dtuigfidh na páistí an fáth go bhfuiltear ag iarraidh orra an Ghaedhilg d'fhoghluimn. Má dintear san, dhéanfadh siad iarracht níos láidre chun an teanga d'fhoghluim ná mar tá siad a dhéanamh in aiteacha éigin fá láthair.

Comment on this

It certainly is not the £7,108,323 that would drive me into the Opposition Lobby to the Government when voting on this Bill. It is because I am convinced that the people from whom this money is extracted do not get the proportionate value that we in this House would expect them to get. If that money were definitely invested for the development of national industries and the progress of the ideals of the Irish people, as we were led to believe, and were educated into believing, those ideals were prior to 1916, and as approved after we had passed from 1916 to 1921, there would be no objection to this Bill, from these benches. If I could have at this moment a copy of a speech delivered to this House only a few days ago, I would echo it word for word, and ask the House to accept it as representing the primary objection that individuals on this side of the House, at any rate, have to this Bill. I refer to the speech delivered by the leader of this Party—the leader of the Opposition. It was delivered on the Vote for the upkeep of the establishment of the Governor-General. I would frankly say that the majority of this House were convinced privately in their hearts that in that speech was contained the principle that divides the two great parties in this House. It is that principle that will divide them when they enter the Lobby on this Bill. It is that principle that brought the assistance of representatives of the Party who occupy two benches on the seats on my immediate right—who brought their assistance in the times when it was necessary to establish that principle.

My objection to this Bill is not so much to the money, because I would be prepared to give an additional Vote to increase the amount of cash if I could see that money being expended towards giving the people who have always stood in this country for the best traditions of the Irish people a chance, and if it were even invested in industry to supply employment for the plain people of Ireland who have always stood for nationality. The money is certainly of no tremendous consequence to me. It is the value to a great extent that counts. It is because I think the money at the present time is not spent consistently with that principle that I am opposed to this Bill. In every Department of the Government the same expenditure continues in the same inconsistent manner and contrary to that principle.

Recently one or two questions were asked as to whether this House would have an opportunity of discussing the Report of the Commission on the Relief of the Sick and Destitute Poor. We will not have an opportunity of discussing that Report if we do not have it now. To my mind I am entitled, at any rate, to criticise it, not in detail, but from the general policy point of view, since its expenses come within the Vote on this Bill. The origin of amalgamation of unions dates back, probably, to somewhere about 1918, and at the first opportunity that any section of the movement which originated that idea had of doing anything practicable, we have it in the result of that Commission. If there is an individual in this House who can stand up and tell me that it is nothing but trying to make good on something that has been raised on a foundation which was definitely established in 1918 as rotten. I do not know exactly where I am standing, at any rate from the point of view that I was educated in from 1918. That Commission has been put under the authority of an individual who has been absolutely steeped—I do not say it in any insulting way——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

Before the Deputy goes any further, I wish to say that I do not think he would be at all in order in discussing the Report or the personnel of the Commission. The Deputy would be in order, I think, in criticising the Government for its action or inaction on that Report, but I do not think he should proceed to criticise the Report itself or any member of the Commission.

Comment on this

I will confine myself to saying that the Report has been influenced by an ideal that has been controlled by long association with the British Poor Law rule in Ireland. Beyond that I have nothing to say, except that all Ireland objects, I think, as much as the people of Cork objected, to a Deputy of the Government Party describing the poor who were treated at an hospital in Cork as paupers. As long as the Local Government Department or this Executive intends to administer the Poor Law in Ireland and still attempt to keep the British stigma on the poor by calling them paupers, you will find objection from these benches.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy is referring to me, and I would ask him what is the stigma in the word "pauper"? Is it not merely the Latin for a poor person or a desstitute person?

Comment on this

It was a slip anyhow, Doctor Hennessy.

Comment on this

Anyway, it was a British translation that they tried to inflict upon the poor of this country. It is to our credit that since the amalgamation, when there was a body elected by people who did not represent the majority opinion in this House we revolutionised what was once called Cork Workhouse, and is now the County Home Hospital and which is a credit not alone to Cork, but to Ireland. It is very hard to enter a general discussion like this without answering, at any rate, some of the references that have come from Deputies in this House who are defending the Bill.

I would like to say, just in passing, a word to my friend, and distinguished colleague from Cork. I was certainly very disappointed that he took on this Bill another opportunity to cast aspersions on this Party that I do not think came within the limit of the £7,401,000. I noticed with a certain amount of pleasure, however, that to-night he forgot the petrol tin. But I might take this opportunity of asking him—if every member of the Party on this side is a gunman—to throw his own memory back to a day when certain people in Cork had almost heart disease, when there were individuals who were in the last line of trenches in "the Retreat from Mons" and when people realised one fact, that the parapet of Brian Boru Bridge was very low and one of the gentlemen was very tall.

Going generally into the policy of the administration of the different Departments, I had occasion to make a reference by way of question to the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. I asked if a preference were given to a particular class of people in Cork over those who sell stock in the English markets. The Parliamentary Secretary answered me—I believe truthfully, because there is a considerable improvement since—that it was not the policy of the Department that that particular profession should get a preference. In passing, I would say that if he would make inquiries for say twelve months previously he would find out that there did exist in the General Post Office in Cork a preference for the profession I referred to.

There is at this moment an anxiety throughout countries in Europe with regard to the development of their harbours from the aerial transport point of view. I think anybody who will examine it will find that in Cork Harbour there are greater facilities for air transport than there is in any other harbour in the Saorstát, not alone from the aerial point of view, but for ordinary shipping.

With regard to the criticisms of Haulbowline, I would like to say that there is no objection to any money being spent, as far as I am concerned, on Haulbowline, provided we are convinced that there is value for it, or that at any future date there is likely to be value given to the nation for the money expended. Rightly or wrongly, it has been insinuated, and it has been mentioned on more than one occasion at meetings of the one or two public bodies that exist in Cork that there were people who negotiated with the appropriate Department of the Government for either a lease or a purchase of that property. There is a belief that not alone is the lease limited, but that there is some other condition as regards evacuation in time of necessity— say a war in which England might be concerned. That may be right or wrong, and it would be well, once and for all, to have a statement that such an agreement does not exist.

Comment on this

It does not exist. There is no such limit.

Comment on this

That has been stated more than once. I was very glad to hear the Minister contradict it. Another point of dissatisfaction is the method of contract in respect of public Boards. I am not denying that tenders are advertised for in the usual way, but there is a certain amount of suspicion. People tendering can get no information even as to the price of the lowest tender, and it is being insinuated in some cases that tenders are being accepted at greater prices than some of the lowest tenders sent in. I do not think there could be any legitimate objection to the publishing of three or four of the lowest tenders. It would give contractors the consolation, at any rate, that they were beaten fairly and squarely.

To my mind, in no Department of the Government is there demonstrated more clearly the lack of real charity, which the Irish people have always boasted of and have been credited with, than in the Department dealing with old age pensions. There was a period in Ireland, and it is not much more than seventy years ago, when there was no compulsory registration of births. You have a considerable number of people right throughout Ireland who cannot prove their birth. They can state that somebody else was born two years before them and that that person was over seventy years—they can supply sufficient information that to my mind would convince at any rate any sympathetic person, but it is of no use to them. For this work you must have men who understand the Irish poor. The Irish poor are not the same as the poor of other nations. They are poor not by lack of enterprise or of willingness to work. Take the position at the present moment. You have men who two or three years ago were in comfortable positions and who, if the present unemployment continues, will be very poor in the near future. There is no use in trying to introduce British old age pension methods in Ireland.

As regards the collection of revenue in respect of dutiable goods, whether by rail or sea, there is an extraordinary delay. There is no fixed rule. There may be a percentage fixed, but whether that is governed by quality, analysis or the opinion of the officer as to the actual value of the goods, I do not know.

I heard a most ridiculous case the other day of a child who got a present from her mother of a two-shilling box of chocolates. She got a notice from the Post Office, and when she went there she was asked to pay 4/-. She came back again and was asked to pay 3/-, and in the end she felt as if she would do anything to get the box of chocolates from her mother, purely from a sentimental point of view. The result of the whole thing was that she did not get the box at all. That is the position of most of the Departments.

Now we come to the Civic Guards. There is no justification for the actions quite recently of individuals who go around in plain clothes. I do not know what they call them, and I do not like to libel the Guards by calling them Civic Guards.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Labour Party

We had all that on the Gárda Síochána Estimate.

Comment on this

And now we are getting an estimate of the Gárda Síochána.

Comment on this

As regards the administration generally, from the local government point of view, we welcome the small attempt—we hope it will be a bigger attempt after the Report Stage of the Bill—to bring back popular representation instead of the principle of commissioners. The principle on which commissioners were appointed is certainly not a matter, I think, that you would allow me to debate. I will say, however, that grants are being continually given to public bodies at the present moment under the control of commissioners, while they are being kept from bodies on which there still are public representatives. Everywhere you will find that there is all the time a considered policy of paring down the individual who is attempting to live on a small salary. The policy of the Government in every Department is that the individual who has a big income should have that income increased, while as regards the man with the small wage, cut him down. That is not the policy that was anticipated when the people were making efforts to establish a National Government in Ireland. When we have a basis—and some people boast of this as a basis— on which we will get the complete independence of Ireland, then I hope to Heaven that when that day arrives there will be people here in power who will be sufficiently educated to realise that freedom in name counts as nothing; that it must be freedom with all the principles and all the traditions of the Irish people.

Comment on this

One notable absentee from the Dáil during this debate is the Minister for Finance—the Minister who is in charge of the finances of the country. Throughout the discussions on the Estimates the procedure adopted was that the Minister responsible for particular Estimates dealt personally with his own Department. The Ministers had at their disposal, and rightly so, the heads of each Department concerned, so that in the event of any criticism being offered or any question being asked which a Minister might not be in a position to reply to, the officials in attendance could provide him with the necessary information. To-day, when this Appropriation Bill was taken up, a Bill covering, as it does, all the Estimates, and in connection with which the Minister from previous experience must have known that the question of policy would likely be considered, we find that the Minister is not here, nor are any of the officials of his Department here. To me it is quite clear that either no discussion was expected, or, if it was, certainly no information was to be given to Deputies. As Deputies on these benches have already pointed out, possibly we will be treated to a speech from the Minister for Industry and Commerce dealing with matters introduced by various Deputies. I am sure it would not be fair to suggest that the Minister for Industry and Commerce should be made responsible for the Minister for Finance and should be asked to give explanations in regard to the numerous queries put forward by Deputies here.

In this Appropriation Bill there is an item referring to the Governor-General and the upkeep of his establishment. As far as I could understand the discussion on the Estimates, it was made fairly clear that the position of the Governor-General could be dispensed with if the Government so desired, or they could so alter it as to reduce considerably the expenditure in the upkeep of the establishment. It is interesting, if one takes the trouble to calculate, what this expenditure means. On the face of it, the expenditure of £32,000 per year for the upkeep of the establishment might not appear very much in comparison with a total expenditure of something like £24,000,000. I admit it seems almost negligible, and to some Deputies it may seem rather a small point to labour. On the other hand, we have a very serious position confronting us with regard to housing accommodation, not alone in the cities, but in the country generally.

Notwithstanding all the pressure from various parts of the House, the Government has not been able to provide more than £250,000 for the coming year to wind up housing schemes on foot. That amount of money covers the erection of a certain number of houses. Let us, for argument's sake, realise that where expenditure exceeds income you must of necessity borrow to make up your deficiency and keep your affairs straight. Each time you borrow it will cost you something in the nature of interest and sinking fund. Let us agree that 8 per cent. would be a fair amount on which one could borrow money, providing 3 per cent, for sinking fund and 5 per cent, for interest. The capital would be repaid in twenty-five years. I do not know whether the Minister will dispute that figure; it is merely for the purpose of illustration. It is reasonable to assume that could be done on that basis, £32,000 per year, representing sinking fund and the payment of interest over a period of twnety-five years, means that you would have repaid £400,000. I consider that would be a very healthy addition to the housing proposition. It would be a big step forward if we could add even another £100,000 to the £250,000 provided. Originally £200,000 was provided, and after great efforts in the House this was increased to £250,000.

One can realise the value of money in the country, especially at the present time, and one can see the ridiculous position of paying money which brings no real value to the country. It may be argued that the Governor-General is symbolical of something or other, but I consider that £32,000, which could be better utilised in the fashion that I have suggested—utilised usefully in the interests of the people—is a rather high figure to pay for any symbol. It is certainly a very dear symbol for the country to shoulder. As far as I can calculate, the £250,000 voted for housing would cover the building of something like 2,500 houses. If we had not the Governor-General's establishment we could have another 5,000 houses, and that would go a long way towards relieving the situation. The building of 5,000 houses would give much-needed employment. It would be reproductive work. The houses would be a great benefit to the area in which they would be built. Notwithstanding the possibilities in that direction, I do not suppose we will be given any explanation regarding the upkeep of this very expensive symbol which, if the present Government so desired, could be changed. It is not actually the sum of £32,000 that matters; it is the use to which that money could otherwise be put.

I believe if the Government faces the situation seriously and if they make an effort to realise what they are heading for, they will attempt to do what some Government succeeding them will have to do. Something drastic will have to be done to cut down expenditure, and efforts should first be directed to cutting down the expenditure that means nothing to the country. The £250,000 that is being spent on the building of 2,500 houses will mean, on the basis of a 3 per cent. sinking fund, 5 per cent. interest to the people who lend the money, that you would have, roughly, £20,000 per year to pay back. I do not say that my particular argument has any special value. What I say may be wrong, and if it is proved to me that I am wrong I will bow to superior wisdom.

We are considering now an Appropriation Bill which relates to the balance of an expenditure of £24,000,000. It has been definitely stated that in the spending of this money we are again heading for a position where we will exceed our revenue and where we will have to borrow. My point is that there are certain considerable sums of money being spent which serve no useful purpose to the country and are not of a reproductive nature. Large sums are being spent in a fashion that no one can find excuse for. It is not to relieve hardship, and it is not to save the country from any special scourge that has arisen which might necessitate some expenditure of money and which, because of its special nature, might not be reproductive.

The House, and the people who have to provide the money, are entitled to some explanation, and if they are going to get any explanation from the Minister for Finance it should be given at this stage, when this has been pointed out and has not been refuted so far. They are, at least, entitled to some expression from the Minister as to what his policy is going to be. I consider that we are entitled to know whether what we say is correct, and if it is correct, what is the Minister's attitude in connection with it. If our contentions are wrong, I consider that it would be very wrong for a Minister or the Government to allow the accusations to go forth and be taken by the people as true if they are not. On the other hand, if they are, and if no message of hope goes out from the Government as to what they intend doing to stop this state of affairs, I consider that not only will it mean hopelessness, but that it will bring about a feeling of depression and pessimism—that it will be hard to face a further financial year with any optimistic view whatever.

I do not wish to go through the items. I do not suppose I am considered of sufficient importance to be replied to by the Minister, but other Deputies have given more concrete cases and more important facts. All I say to the House is that there is a simple calculation for them, and let them think it over. I put this question to Deputy J. X. Murphy as a banker: Is it unreasonable to say that £32,000 per year paid to a bank would enable a person to get £400,000 to do whatever he likes with? That is the sum that we are paying every year for the upkeep of the Governor-General's establishment. If the Government cannot face the complete abolition of that establishment, at least, according to this, they can cut down a great deal of the expenditure, and if they got £200,000 for building houses out of the saving on that Department, I would say they were making an attempt to go in the right direction. If Deputies who are more capable of dealing with figures and matters of this kind would tackle other Estimates and save the country from the expenditure of money which means nothing to it in the shape of value, this discussion would be of some use.

It being now 10.30 p.m. the debate stood adjourned.

Comment on this