DEPRESSION IN AGRICULTURE—MOTION OF CENSURE.
Contributions 114–235 of 235. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I have always said that increased production in itself was not the remedy for the depression in agriculture. It is an old saying and a true one, that high farming is no remedy for low prices. Increased production undoubtedly would be an advantage to the farming community if production could be increased on a paying basis. The problem for those who are endeavouring to work out the economic salvation of the farmer is to see how production can be increased as a paying proposition. I maintain that, in so far as the endeavour on the part of the State has been to see that agricultural products are produced in such a manner, and of such quality, as to secure the highest possible price in competition with the other agricultural countries, the State has done its part, and that although the results have not yet become very definitely clear, and very fully shown, there is no doubt that the action which the State has taken in stimulating the production of high-quality agricultural produce has resulted, to a certain extent, in increasing the prices which we have got in the outside market, and undoubtedly will, when followed up, result eventually in placing them very close to the level of other competing countries who share that market with us.
But we have to advance slowly in that connection. It seems to me that everybody who wants to see something done wants to see it done immediately— he wants to see immediate results, and results in regard to agricultural products cannot be immediate. The education and training of the people and the necessary Government control which must follow, are a slow process and one cannot expect to have immediate results. Having done our part to see that the farmers produce the best agricultural products, the best of their kind, if we find that producing those products, with the overhead charges which the farmer has to pay, is not paying as well as it ought to pay, our next step is to endeavour to reduce the cost of production on the farmer. That is the line which we will have to follow in future, and the efforts which we may make in this House should be along the line of endeavouring in so far as it lies in our power, to reduce the cost of production to the farmer, that is to reduce the cost of the articles which the farmer must buy to live and to produce.
It has been already pointed out that there is one way open to the farmer to reduce these costs, and that is by co-operation and buying in bulk. I accept it that that is one of the principal ways open to the farmer. But there is another way which will have to be availed of, and which is outside the powers of the organised farmers, working as an organised unit—that is a reduction in the cost of production. When one starts to talk about reducing the cost of production on the farmer one finds that one is opening up a most intricate and involved subject—that there are so many factors which go to make up the cost of production that one cannot by one stroke of the pen, or by one simple Act of legislation, provide the means by which the cost of production and the cost of living can be reduced to the farmer. We all know what the cost of living means and the advantage it is to reduce it. We all know that every reasonable effort is being made to reduce it. We all know the various factors involved. The same thing applies to the cost of production —the articles which the farmer must use in order to produce—his agricultural machinery, his seeds, manures and feeding stuffs. If we can by any action of ours reduce the cost of these articles for the farmer, we will be helping him and taking a step which may help to place his industry on an economic basis.
The vote of censure which has been moved has not been proved. The charge has not been proved. The endeavour is to show that by neglect of the obvious remedies for the agricultural depression the Government has failed to meet the contingency and the depression which have arisen. I maintain that in so far as the actual positive stimulation of agriculture is possible by means of legislation, the Government has more than done its part. I maintain that the causes of depression in agriculture are causes which are, to a large extent, outside the control of any Government—that they are due to world-wide causes and that the remedy will depend eventually, to a large extent, on world-wide conditions.
The contribution by the Deputy who moved the motion, though a very interesting one and one which opened up avenues of discussion as to the possible future development of agriculture, was not one which brought home to the Government of the day the fact that they had failed to do their part. I believe that in so far as the stimulation of agriculture is concerned the Government have done their part. The other side of the story, which has to do with reduction of the cost of production, involves a great many factors, including the factor referred to by the Deputy— high taxation. I have expressed the view several times, and I still hold the view, that high taxation is a factor in keeping up the cost of production on the farm. It is an important factor, though I do not say it is the only factor. If that is so, surely the remedy is for the Deputy and his colleagues on the same benches to show how taxation on the farmer can be reduced. When we were talking about the effect of high taxation we endeavoured, at least, to show how taxation could be reduced. We faced up to our problems and we worked along the lines of solving those problems. We are still working along the lines of solving these problems, but I have listened to Deputies on the opposite benches for a considerable time and I have not yet heard one concrete, practical suggestion which, followed out, would result in the reduction of taxation and in easing the burden which the farmer has to bear.
The Deputy ascribed other failures to the Government—failure to reduce rates, for instance. I am as anxious to see rates reduced as the Deputy is, but surely the reduction of rates does not lie with the Government. Surely, it lies, to a very considerable extent, with the local bodies. The question involves de-rating, which is a complex and difficult problem which will probably have to be discussed at some other stage. The scheme of tillage put forward by the Deputy I have already dealt with. Allusion has been made to the vesting of land in the tenants by the Land Commission. As has been already pointed out, the Government has endeavoured to do its part in this matter. I would ask those who are interested in the matter on the Government side to endeavour to expedite in every way the vesting in the tenants. A burden is cast on the tenants which would not be cast upon them if vesting were effected. I am satisfied that the Government are doing their best and are expediting the completion of land purchase as much as possible. Generally, I feel that the Deputy has not made his case. The alternative scheme of agricultural development put forward by the Deputy would, in my opinion, be a retrograde step, instead of a step in advance. If I have to choose between the policy of agricultural development suggested by the Deputy and that which has been pursued by the existing Government, I have no hesitation in saying that my support will go with the existing policy.
Comment on this
I rise in an atmosphere of profound inspiration. I am occupying one of the seats that were occupied for a number of years by the erstwhile Farmers' Party. For the last few minutes, I have been endeavouring to conjure up from the misty past the shades of the wise, powerful and well-meaning Farmers' Party and to recall some of the burning words of wisdom that they poured upon the Minister for Agriculture from these very benches. I remember in 1925 when these benches were made resound with the thunder of the Farmers' Party in denunciation of the policy of the present Minister for Agriculture—or rather the want of policy— in meeting what was then described as "a devastating epidemic of fluke." I myself was quite prepared to join in that denunciation, as I am to-day willing, and perhaps anxious, to join in that denunciation. If I endeavour to strip this discussion of a good deal of its theory and bring it down to the realities that a farmer might understand, I hope it will be believed that I do so in the interests of the farmer and with the understanding that I will endeavour to get from the Minister his opinion and his policy on a few of the main features and on a few of the main difficulties that face the farming community to-day. This motion, to my mind, resolves itself into two parts. Is there agricultural depression at the present moment and has there been a reaction during the years since 1925 as a result of the losses that took place in that year? The other question naturally arises: What has the Government done to deal effectively with that depression? These, to my mind, stripped of all the theory and stripped of all the more or less highbrow economics we heard from every side, are the two propositions before us. Deputy Heffernan told us that one cannot estimate from the statements made by Deputy Ryan what actually has been the loss. He stated that he was dealing with values rather than with the actual loss that had been suffered. Representing an agricultural constituency, as I do, I have endeavoured to find out what, in the main, has been the loss to the farming community. I looked up what is described as the cattle population in the census——
Comment on this
I refer the Minister to his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce. He has a better opinion of the value of words than I have and that is the term he gives us. I find in regard to cattle that there is a reduction between 1923 and 1925 of 286,278. Lest it might be contended that we exported more, I find that between 1924 and 1925 there was a reduction in the export of cattle of 249,205, representing an approximate value of £4,279,521.
Comment on this
It is between 1924 and 1925. Between 1924 and 1926 there was an actual reduction in the export of cattle of 307,002, representing an approximate value of £5,121,462. In the sheep export between 1924 and 1925, I find a reduction of 524,468. I find also, in the matter of tillage, that between 1923 and 1924 there has been a reduction of 33,413 acres. Between 1924 and 1925 there was a reduction of 39,012 acres. Between 1922 and 1925 there was a reduction of 21,043 acres. As regards butter exports, between 1924 and 1925 there was a reduction of 55,465 cwts., representing an approximate value of £387,897. How this matter presents itself to me is this: there has been a loss to the farming community. There has been a very specific loss. The cattle have not been exported and the cattle are not in the country. Something must have happened to the majority of the cattle in that period. I have endeavoured in my own constituency to ascertain if there has been any change upwards in the position of the farmer. I have endeavoured to find out amongst the farming community whether there has been any effective method of dealing with these losses from 1925 up to the present time— whether there has been any movement by the Government to re-establish the economic position that the farmer found himself in before this epidemic occurred. I find in my examination of the position that there is no upward curve in that position. You might demonstrate by figures that there is a slight inclination upwards, but I find that, in actual practice, the reaction since 1925 has been such that the farmer to-day finds himself in the position that he is not able to meet the actual demands upon him. Therefore, there has been no real facing up to the situation on the part of the Government. I want to make whatever contribution I make to this debate brief and clear. I do not want to score any points whatever, even if I could—possibly I could not—off the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
Deputy Byrne is so unaccustomed to scoring any point off anybody that he cannot imagine how I could score off even the Minister for Agriculture. Perhaps I might give a local turn to the matter, that is, really, what we have got to do; we have to go back and examine the position as we find it locally; we have to take our own counties and constituencies as standards by which we will measure the other counties and arrive at a conclusion as to the country as a whole. I have a document which I think I made use of in this House before but it is of such importance that I think I could claim the privilege of the House in again quoting it. When this cattle mortality occurred and when there was so much distress consequent upon it, the Clare County Council asked that some definite statement should be made so that those in authority would have an opportunity of realising the extent of that cattle mortality. I thought myself, at the time, that the Minister for Agriculture was not sufficiently well informed on the matter. I do still believe that the Minister for Agriculture was not sufficiently well informed on the matter. I believe that the information in his offices and the statistics supplied to him were not such as could be relied upon, and, in order to get some kind of a stamp of authority, the Clare County Council asked the rate collectors to examine the position in the different rate collecting areas and to find out what was the cattle mortality in these areas and to say what was the reason, and how much that cattle mortality interfered with their collection of the dues to the County Council.
The questions put to each rate collector were:—
"What was the extent of live stock mortality in your district between September, 1923, and April, 1925?
"To what extent is the shortage of money due to that cause in your district?"
In the Ballyvaughan district we find that in the two rate collecting areas the extent of live stock mortality was 20 per cent. and 33 per cent.; in the two areas in Corofin it was 10 per cent. and 20 per cent.; Ennis, 30 per cent., 40 per cent., 15 per cent., 25 per cent. and 20 per cent.; Ennistymon Rural District from 20 per cent. to 33 per cent.; Kildysart district, 40 per cent. to 80 per cent.; Kilrush Rural District (four rate collectors' districts), 20 per cent., 30 per cent., 50 per cent. and 70 per cent.; Meelick, 10 per cent., 20 per cent., 25 per cent., and 50 per cent.; Scariff rate collecting districts, 40 per cent., 20 per cent. and 10 per cent.; Tulla rate collecting districts, 70 per cent., 10 per cent. and 10 per cent. That represents a position that was calamitous at the time. It was something that presented a serious condition that should be faced up to by the Government. The reaction of that upon the farming community is still having its effect. The reaction is such that the amount of money put down does not represent the actual losses. What has to be considered is that the farmer had not alone the loss of his cattle to contend with, but that he had to sell his hay and crops at a sacrifice because he could not purchase cattle to consume them, and, consequently, he could not meet the demands made upon him; he could not meet the local demands nor the national demands. I do not want to be taken as saying that there is undue pressure brought upon him for land annuities, but I do suggest that there is pressure brought upon him to the extent that his cattle are seized, taken to Dublin, and sold, with the result that the Land Commission perhaps gets £1 or £2 out of the decree and the tenant gets nothing. The amount is spent in various ways, in transport and other ways. Very little goes to the Land Commission, and nothing at all goes to the annuitant. I put that to the Minister as something that has not been dealt with, or that no attempt has been made to deal with in what one might call a satisfactory fashion.
I do not propose to put forward remedies. I do not propose to say what course the Government should have taken. The thing is so obvious, the Government itself ought to have seen to the methods it ought to have employed to meet this difficulty. I am making the case as mild as I possibly can. I live in an agricultural district. I know the condition of the people in that district. I know perfectly well what their difficulties are, what their troubles are, and the strain that is put on their resources to meet the demands upon them. I know that there are many of them in very dire distress, and in the unfortunate position that they cannot do what they are willing to do and what they would like to do.
I would ask that the Government consider the position not in any spirit of partisanship, and I would ask the House to deal with it not in a spirit of partisanship, but as something that is of national importance, something that demands the strength of every party in the country to try and find the remedy for.
There are other matters that possibly enter into the question, and which caused some amount of economic distress amongst the farming community. We do know that there are farms to-day throughout the country which are not of the same value as they were when the valuation was made. We do know that there are people paying rates to-day on valuations that are entirely excessive. We do know that there were certain things which gave a certain value years ago that they have not to-day. They are paying on these valuations, and probably will continue to pay on them. These are matters that probably are not so theoretical; they are very practical. They are not so theoretical as some of the things we heard in this debate. I would put them to the Minister as being practical propositions. The propositions that this motion resolves itself into are these: Is there economic distress amongst the farming community? Was there economic distress amongst them in 1925? Has that been relieved? Has it been removed? My contention is that it can be readily proved that there is economic distress, and the reaction of 1925 and the reactions from other reasons have not been met by the Government. The Government at the present time is asked, and asked very forcibly, to introduce some means by which economic distress amongst the farming community should be remedied, at least, if not entirely removed.
Comment on this
When Deputy Hogan asks whether there is economic distress amongst the farmers I suggest he is taking the question of economic distress as a comparative term. There is, of course, economic distress amongst the farmers, comparatively speaking. There is equal economic distress amongst the shopkeepers. There is economic distress amongst the farmers in England and there is economic distress amongst the shopkeepers. Not only is there economic distress, comparatively speaking, in this country and in England, but there is economic distress all over the world. There has been economic distress all over the world as compared with the conditions either pre-Truce or during the war, and when I am asked is there economic distress I cannot answer the question.
Deputy Hogan's rate collectors went around Clare and said to the farmers: "The Government is going to pay for all the live stock that died; how many cattle, how many sheep and how many pigs belonging to you died." The answer was, 80%, 40% and 30%. Deputy Ryan, on the contrary, told some of his farming friends that he had a vote of censure on the Government down; that he was going to charge the Government with failing to deal with agricultural distress in the country and that he wanted to prove his case. He asked his farming friends were they in a bad way and they said they could not be worse. He then went to two or three shopkeepers and told the same story. I am sure he picked a Cumann na nGaedheal shopkeeper.
Comment on this
I deny it vehemently. We will have to agree to differ on that. He asked him did he hear that the farmers were in a bad way, that they were very short of money with which to pay their debts, and he said they are in a shocking way; they could not be worse. That is no good. Neither Deputy Hogan's statistics, obtained in that way, nor Deputy Ryan's statistics, obtained in that way, have any value whatsoever. To come back to the debate, Deputy Ryan was of opinion that the President was wrong in stating that we had turned the corner. I think the President was right. I will give my reasons. The farmers now are not nearly as well off as they were in 1913. Neither are the farmers in England, nor the farmers all over Europe. There was not the same money as there was during the war, but they were in an extremely sound position. They were going ahead, increasing their stocks. There was less money and credit, but there were more cash transactions.
The world was a happy place, if we only knew it, in 1913. Everyone was fairly well off, everyone was working hard. The farmers in 1925, 1926 and 1927 were not nearly as well off as they were in 1913, nor as they were in 1916, 1917 and 1918. During the war all food producers had a great time; they did extremely well. But that is not the question. Every Deputy who thinks over it knows that after the war, when food was no longer so valuable, when prices collapsed, farmers all over the world began to suffer bad times. So did industrialists. I think there is no doubt that the farmers had worse times than even the industrialists. From 1921 to 1925 there was a collapse in prices. A collapse in prices is always accompanied by a collapse in production. There was a steady decline in production up to the year 1925, in England Scotland, France, Germany and all over the world. That steady decline was caused by a fall in prices. I will not go into the reasons; that is too big a subject. Deputy Maguire mentioned one, he said our financial policy was wrong. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle said that that was a subject which should not be debated here, that there should be some limitation. The Deputy attempted to point out that it was due to a policy of deflation that followed the European war. I will not go into that. I will only say that I do not know anything about deflation or inflation. I do not believe that there are any Deputies in this House who have any real knowledge on the subject. It is a most intricate subject and there are only five or six people in Europe who have any detailed knowledge of that question. I do not know anything about it, but I do know that the English financial system is as sound a system as there is in the world. I do not think we can do very much better. That may be or it may not be the case, but the fact is that in 1925 prices collapsed and production collapsed. The collapse in prices was steep, it was particularly steep in 1921, but it continued and is continuing still. The decline in production was particularly steep from 1921 to 1925. The fact of the matter is that in 1925 that tendency was arrested, undoubtedly the figures show that. Deputy Ryan quoted figures for cows, in-calf heifers, pigs, sheep and so on. He made the point, a genuine point, that there was a decrease in the number of cows and in-calf heifers as compared with 1927. He did not make the point, which he should have made, that there was an increase in the number of cows and in-calf heifers this year as compared with 1925. Here are the figures for cattle. Before I read these figures I want Deputies to realise that there was a steady decline in the numbers of cattle down to 1925. The total cattle in 1925 was 3,991, 358.
For 1927 the figures are:—Milch cows, 1,234,242; heifers in calf, 97,098; total, 4,047,013. The figures for 1928 are:—Milch cows, 1,230,506; heifers in calf, 83,931; total, 4,125,145.
What really happened was this. You had a steady decline in production up to 1925, a stoppage, an arrest, of that tendency in 1925, and a very slight increase from 1925 onwards, taking one year with another. I do not like to compare one year with the year immediately following. Such comparisons are always illusory, in agriculture especially. Deputy Hogan compared the figures for 1924 and 1925. I am not sure whether I am right, but I believe I am relatively right. I think in 1923 or 1924 there was the biggest export of cattle in living memory. If you examine the exports of cattle for ten years, you will always find that immediately after the year in which there has been a very big export of cattle there is a small export. The reasons are perfectly obvious. Those are the figures from 1925 and 1927. Taking pigs, there is an immense increase. I did not bother to get the actual figures, because there have been too much statistics in this debate and too much misleading statistics. There has been a tremendous increase in regard to pigs. There has been equally an increase in sheep—a tremendous increase between 1925 and 1927. I will leave out the word tremendous, and I will say there was a considerable increase. There was also an increase in the production of butter, milk and cream. I have not any figures before me with regard to pigs and bacon; we can take the two of them together. I agree with Deputy Ryan that it is not quite a satisfactory tendency to have an increase in live pigs as against bacon, but that is a detailed question which I do not want to go into on a debate like this. I have given you figures relating to cattle, sheep, pigs, butter and eggs. I think there was an increase in eggs since 1925, but I am not sure; I think there was an increase from 1925 to 1927. That followed a steep decline in the production of these articles. In 1925 that was arrested, and not only have we stabilised the position but there is a slight decrease. I put it to any Deputy, was the President's statement that we are turning the corner a fair description of that? I certainly think so. Irish agriculture consists of cattle, sheep, beef, mutton, pigs, bacon, eggs, and poultry. That is Irish agriculture. That has been Irish agriculture within living memory, and it will continue to be Irish agriculture.
I find it very difficult to intervene in this debate because a multitude of points have been raised. Deputy Ryan made, if I may say so, a very well-informed speech, but it was really a technical lecture. He probably knows a considerable amount of the practical side of farming and, if I am to answer, my speech must be not an economic exposition but another technical lecture, and that will lead us nowhere. I do welcome one statement he made, and it was that the only hope for tillage in this country is to substitute imported food for home-grown food, and increase tillage for the feeding of livestock and livestock products. That is my theory of agriculture. That is the doctrine I have been advocating for the last five or six years. I believe the only hope for increased tillage in this country is an increase in tillage for consumption on the farm, and for the feeding of livestock and of livestock products. Deputy Ryan, in opening the case for his Party, made that point. I congratulate him. He has come a long distance. We have got a long way from the time when we were to produce barley for all the breweries and all the distilleries in Europe, when we were to have a great export trade. I have read a lot written by the economic theorists in that Party. We were to have wheat for export, possibly to Canada. We have got a long way from the time even of compulsory tillage. It is at last admitted that the only hope for increased tillage is to substitute imported food for the home-grown food, and increased tillage for consumption on the farm, for the production of livestock, and as the raw materials for livestock products. I hope Deputies will stick to that. That is sound and absolutely right. I hope they will not desert that position and go back again to the perfectly absurd views they had on this question about a year ago.
The Deputy suggested also that not only should we produce all that we need in the way of meals, cereals, roots, etc. for live stock and the products of live stock, but that there should be some attempt made to prevent the importation of foreign foodstuffs. Why do Deputies tack on that point to a perfectly sound proposition? I make this statement without fear of contradiction. There is not a farmer in the Dáil who knows anything about agriculture, who has ever fattened cattle, who has ever produced milk in winter, who has ever fed pigs, but must know that the more cereals he produces, the more tillage he has, the more foodstuffs he will import and purchase. Practically no foodstuffs go into Deputy O'Reilly's county, Meath. That is summer farming pure and simple. There is very little tillage there as compared with West Cork. The small farmer of West Cork, County Galway, North Tipperary, who tills quite a big percentage, comparatively, of his holding, buys far and away more foodstuffs than the County Meath farmer who, perhaps, owns four or five hundred acres of land and has only two acres of tillage. Denmark produces far more butter and eggs than we do, and far more bacon, but no beef We purchase £4,000,000 worth of meals; they purchase £8,000,000 worth, notwithstanding the fact that more than half of their land is in tillage. Why Deputy Ryan, who knows something about the practical side of farming, should tack on to a perfectly sound argument in connection with home-grown food an absolutely unsound argument against the importation of more food, I do not know.
Comment on this
I would like to know what exactly the Minister is charging me with, because I think I am being charged in the wrong.
Comment on this
I will tell the Deputy what I am charging him with. The Deputy made it quite clear he was entirely in favour of more tillage for the purpose of producing food as the raw material for live stock products and as food for live stock. His whole speech was deprecating the importation of foodstuffs such as maize, cotton-cake and so on. He went to great trouble to show that maize could be substituted by oats or barley. Half his speech was dealing with this point, that it was absurd in an agricultural country like this to be importing £4,000,000 worth of meals. That is the stock-in-trade argument of the Party to which the Deputy belongs. It is absolutely an unsound argument. How anyone who has ever farmed land, fattened cattle, produced milk in winter, or who has ever fed pigs, could use such an argument honestly, I could not understand.
Deputies must remember that when it comes to the realm of commercialism propaganda is no good. A small thing makes all the difference in the world. There is no doubt that we could produce all the protein food we want in this country. There is a certain percentage of protein even in roots, not to speak of barley at all, and there is protein in oats. But can you produce the protein foods which are absolutely essential? Can you produce them economically? The answer is there, if you want to look around you. If the farmers of the country could produce protein food economically from barley or oats, they would not be importing cotton-cake. I am told that maize meal is exactly the same as barley. So it is to a point, but there is a slight difference. There is a little more indigestible matter in barley than in maize meal. There are other matters. The ordinary farmer has not sufficient buildings to store barley, and he finds it convenient to buy maize meal. All these are commercial considerations— advantages, conveniences, which the shopkeeper, the manufacturer, the factory owner take into account, and which the farmer also takes into account. If the Deputy will agree that increased tillage is desirable for the purposes of feeding live stock on the farm, and will agree also that the more imported foodstuffs we get into the country, provided they are coupled with tillage, the better, then we would be at one in our agricultural policy. I interrupted the Deputy while he was speaking and I asked him a very simple question. If I am to produce all the meals I require to feed my cows, I must produce more roots, and I must farm my land properly. These are some of the considerations.
I advise Deputies not to lie awake at nights thinking too much of the amount of foodstuffs we import. They should concentrate their attention on the sound point that Deputy Ryan made. That is, that it would be sound economics to have an increase in the area under tillage in this country in order to feed the live stock, and in order to provide raw materials for live stock products. The Deputy made certain other points in that connection which I do not propose to dwell too much on. He asked himself the rhetorical question—how can the Government help in bringing about this increase in tillage? He answered it after a bit. Perhaps the Government could buy up oats at 9/- per cwt. and sell it at 11/- or 12/-. Perhaps the Government could buy barley at 8/- per cwt.—the figures are only relative—and sell it at 10/-. I do not know. I pay the Deputy this compliment—that I doubt if he believed in that. If there are oats on the market at 9/-, why do the farmers not buy them? If the farmer cannot get more than 9/-, how will the Government do it? If the Department of Agriculture takes a big mill in the County Cork and buys a couple of thousand tons of oats at 9/-, who will give them 12/- for it? If 12/- can be got for that, then surely the farmer who owns it can get it? Possibly 11/- per cwt. can be got in the early spring from the people who own horses in Dublin. I know the ordinary cab or car-driver pays 1/6 a stone for his oats and for his bran. I do not want the Deputy to quote those figures for me. That would absorb only a very small quantity of the oats in the country. But when the Deputy suggests that the Government should go into business, buy up mills, purchase the oats and barley of the country and re-sell it, surely he must know that he is advocating a proposition which will only land everybody in expense and loss. If the barley is stored in the granaries that some Deputies have spoken of, will that make Guinness give more for it? It would not affect the price by one penny.
Comment on this
It would not. It might be, for instance, that occasionally the Government would buy in a rising market. That would be a gamble, and it would only come off occasionally. But, speaking generally, it would not affect the price by one penny. The only effect would be that the cost of the administration of such a scheme would have to come out of the pockets of the farmers who sold the oats and barley. But here is the real point. What is the occasion for all this? The Deputy should be logical. Having once admitted that correct economy for the farmer is to produce more cereals and roots for feeding on his own farm, why advocate that he should sell them to another farmer and buy another farmer's produce? That is what it comes to. Instead of selling it let him feed it himself, and save all the expense of taking it to the mill, of dealing with a Government inspector, of paying cartage and storing to save the risk of a lower price. Let him keep it in his farm and feed it himself. Undoubtedly there should be more tillage. This is a country of small farmers. Seventy or eighty per cent. of the land is owned by farmers whose valuations are less than £30. They may have three or four acres of tillage each. A little more would cost them nothing. It would mean that instead of farmers of £16, £18 and £20 valuations sending their sons to work on the roads in the spring-time—this may be an unpopular thing to say in some quarters—they should keep them at home and put their work into the land, into draining land, into working land, into a little more tillage, that they should leave roadwork to the people who need it more, and in that way everybody would be increasing the national wealth. The farmer in this country who sells grain is going against the times. The farmer who is attempting to market grain, whether it be oats or barley; the farmer who is attempting to market any tillage crops to any great extent—of course there may be minor transactions to which this would not apply—who makes a practice of marketing grains and roots, or any of the products of his farm, as a cash crop, is going against the times and is not going to make money out of them. It would pay the farmers, and pay them well, to keep their sons and daughters at home and working, to till a little more and to produce more home-grown food, and for every pound of meal they produced, and for every extra cow and every extra sow they kept, they would import an extra quantity of maize, cotton-cake, and protein foods of that sort.
I think I have dealt with this question of increased tillage and the methods by which increased tillage would be brought about. Deputies will note that I have deliberately omitted any reference to wheat. I will deal with that separately. I want Deputies to note that the only suggestion made by any Deputy who spoke in favour of the motion that the Government has failed in its duty was a suggestion like that—that increased tillage could be brought about if the Government bought up the grain, put it into granaries and resold it. Leaving out the suggestion with regard to a subsidy for wheat, the sole contribution from the Opposition benches on this question as to how to bring about increased tillage consisted of a suggestion by Deputy Ryan that the Government might buy up the oats and barley of the country, employ graders and inspectors, and sell it back to the farmers themselves.
Comment on this
Buy—purchase. I do not see the Deputy's point. That has been the only suggestion made up to the present for increased tillage. They have all run away from compulsion. Perhaps it may come now. But the only suggestion——
Comment on this
The only argument of yours in regard to increased tillage is the feeding of pigs and cattle.
Comment on this
Deputies will have an opportunity of comparing my suggestions with the suggestions that are put up from the opposite benches, and they can make up their minds about them. I am only concerned now to point out that, though this debate has lasted more than four hours, the only suggestion made from the Opposition Benches directed towards increasing the area under tillage has been the suggestion by Deputy Ryan that the Government should purchase cereals in the way of oats and barley from the farmers and resell them to other farmers. Another point was made by the Deputy, that not only should we have no importations of feeding stuffs, but that, so far as possible, we should first supply the full home market, and only after that think of exports. He suggested that I stated on some occasion that I am not concerned with imports. I do not remember making such a statement, and such a statement would have no meaning. I am concerned with imports, but in quite a different way from the Deputy. However, his point of view, apparently, is to supply the home market first and afterwards think of exports. Such simplifications of that sort mean nothing. You do not think of these two things in watertight compartments. You think of production generally and then you think of selling a thing the way you think best. That is the way the business man and the farmer thinks. I think, in fact, that it has been admitted that the agriculture of this country in the future must be the production of livestock and livestock products. I think that that admission has come, by implication, from Deputy Ryan's speech. I again omit this question of wheat, which I can deal with later; that would perhaps upset to some slight extent, my generalisation, and I propose to leave that point to the end. I think I am right in stating that it has been admitted almost directly that the agriculture of this country has been the production of livestock and livestock products, and that there has also been the admission that that must continue to be so. If that is so, it is another long step in advance, and we could then agree that we should all concentrate on increasing the production of these articles and on making them more profitable.
What are these articles? Cattle, sheep, pigs, beef, mutton, bacon, butter and eggs. Do we supply the home market with these articles? In fact we do. No beef is coming into this country. I hope that no Deputy will tell me that there is £10,000 or £5,000 worth of chilled meat coming in. In a production of about £20,000,000 that is of no importance. Commerce is a complex thing, and there are obligements between people. So far as beef is concerned, we are supplying our whole home market. The same practically applies to mutton. There are very small quantities of Canterbury lamb coming in at special times of the year. The same applies to butter. The same, I suggest, applies to bacon. That is the only item that can be challenged. Deputy Ryan dealt with that himself. He said that we export £4,000,000 worth of bacon and import £3,000,000 worth. Let us examine that, and apply Deputy Ryan's own principle to it. Apparently, instead of exporting £4,000,000 worth and importing £3,000,000 worth—I have taken round figures—the Deputy thinks that we should keep the £3,000,000 worth at home and export £1,000,000 worth. What advantage would that be? I cannot see it.
Comment on this
I may not have made it very plain, but I did not mean to stop there. Could you not capture the home market as well?
Comment on this
The Deputy asks why not capture the home market as well?
Comment on this
I am on the point at the moment that we are in fact doing what the Deputy said we ought to do, namely, that before exporting anything we are supplying the whole home market. Of course, I admit that this is another point altogether—that if we could capture the £3,000,000 and export £4,000,000 we would have achieved a big thing. But I am on a different point. That so far as we do produce agricultural products we do supply the whole home market. There is only one item on which I can be successfully challenged, and that is bacon.
Comment on this
I have already stated that I will deal with that separately. Take that one item. Would we be any better off if in fact instead of exporting £4,000,000 worth of bacon we exported only £1,000,000, and substituted for the £3,000,000 which we import the other £3,000,000 that we produce? We would be worse off. The farmer buys American bacon, which he likes better; it is fatter, and some farmers who live in the open air and want a good deal of fat meat buy it at X per cwt., and sell their own at X plus Y per cwt. If we did that there would be a national loss. The same consideration applies to the £400,000 worth of butter. We do, in fact, produce about £800,000 worth of butter, including what we use at home and what we export, and we import £400,000 worth. The very same principle applies there. It is a matter for the creamery owners to say whether it would pay them during the winter to put £400,000 worth in cold store and pay for keeping it there, or export it at a good price. So that it comes to this, so far as agricultural products are concerned, that we supply the whole home market, and the Deputy can possess his soul in patience on that point. Our aim should be to increase production so far as possible of these products and afterwards to sell them in whatever market suits. I will take another point that Deputy Ryan and Deputy O'Reilly made. After painting a most depressing picture of the state of agriculture at present, Deputy Ryan asked himself what was the cause of it. He said that he heard people stating that it was the fall in prices since the European War, the bad years, and so on, but that was not the first reason. The first reason was high taxation.
Comment on this
The real reason was high taxation. Apparently it has been high taxation in Ireland that has brought cattle down from 60/- per cwt. to about 38/- or 39/-.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Reilly stated most specifically, and so did Deputy Ryan, that the main reason for the depression in agriculture was the high taxation.
It was, he stated, a more important reason than the fall in prices, than the reactions of the European War. It was a more potent reason than the bad seasons. Does Deputy Ryan deny that? Every speaker on the opposite benches made that point.
Comment on this
Very well. I will make you a present of that. The depression in agriculture is a question of falling prices.
Comment on this
Very well. We will not dispute it. The main reason for depression in agriculture, according to the opposite benches, is high taxation. That opinion was so unanimous it must have been agreed on beforehand. Every speaker on the opposite benches mentioned it. It is good politics. That is all. None of us came down in the last shower. We all know that when Deputies in Dublin, the Capital City, say a thing it gets into the papers and some Deputies take great care to get their pronouncements into the local papers. The unfortunate small farmers read them, and then, of course, the wish becomes father to the thought. It is good politics, but that is all, and Deputies know that. When Deputies say that the main reason for the depression in agriculture is high taxation, that it is a more potent reason than the reactions of the European War or bad harvests, they know that they are talking nonsense, but nonsense which is very good political propaganda. Let us examine it. I ask Deputy Dr. Ryan and Deputy O'Reilly is it high taxation that caused cattle to fall from 60/- to 39/- a cwt.? Is it high taxation that caused the live price of pigs to fall, from—I forget what it was in 1920—something over 100/- to 50/- to-day? Is it the same high taxation that caused a relative drop in the price of eggs and butter? Has that got nothing to do with the causes of depression? Is it not really the cause of depression and do not Deputies know it?
Comment on this
Unlike the Deputy, I am unable to deal with more than one point at once. Deputy Ryan has quoted figures showing that taxation was so much in 1913 for the Free State and so much to-day, and proved that taxation now was 200 per cent. over that of 1914. The Deputy has the advantage of me. I could not tell you what the taxation was in the Free State area in 1913. Nobody could. I could give plausible figures, but the percentages might be out by 60 or 70 per cent. Taxation has increased, but what has increased it? New services. Sugar beet costs £400,000 a year. I know, of course, that the economists opposite could get the same factory for £100,000, which is only £300,000 less than what England could get it for. You must make allowances for our gross inefficiency. The increase in the agricultural grant was 100 per cent. The increase in educational services was over 100 per cent. The increase in live stock —and Deputy Ryan will admit that all these animals are good value—which the Department is putting out throughout the country is more than 100 per cent. The Dairy Produce Act did good work by saving Irish butter on the English market.
Comment on this
All right. The Eggs Act cost money. The Live Stock Breeding Act cost money. All these new services demanded by the country, and which have been invaluable to the country, have cost money. Grants for cow-testing purposes have been increased by a very big percentage. Will the Deputy tell me which of these services he would forego? I would like to see myself coming here and suggesting that the Dairy Produce Act be no longer in force, and that the officers administering it be dismissed. If I suggested that we should no longer give an increase of 100 per cent. in the Agricultural Grant what would Deputies say? If I suggested that we should no longer continue, as we are continuing, to double the number of stock, cattle, sheep, pigs and rams, and go back to 1921, what would the Deputy say? I would be denounced by every Deputy except tillage experts, like Deputy Corry, who might take my part on that occasion. Which of these services do you want dropped? It is easy for Deputies to talk glibly about increased taxation. Which of these services do you want dropped? We are told that, as a result of increased taxation. Irish farmers are in a worse position than English farmers. Let us examine that. In what respects is the Irish farmer in a worse position than the English? How do the Irish and English rents for agricultural land compare? Again, we have had some statistics gone mad from Deputy O'Reilly—£4 an acre for rates on some of the champion Meath lands, out of which the Deputy is making a fortune, or, at least, he ought to. What is the average annuity which a farmer, say, in the Midlands here, has to pay? £1 per Irish acre is the outside. I know that that is a bit too high, but I would put it at that. What is the corresponding amount in England? About £3. That is very direct taxation. If we had the English farmer paying £1 and the Irish farmer paying £3 per acre, there would be a serious revolution in this country.
Comment on this
I want to see the derating scheme worked out. It may not all be cakes and ale. What are the rates? They are far and away higher than ours. I admit that the rates on Irish land are far too high. I am not saying that they are not. I am making a comparison between English and Irish land because England was mentioned. There are two items of taxation to which I draw Deputy O'Reilly's attention. He practically wept when he talked about the shocking state of the Irish farmer compared with the British. Take these two heavy items, rates and rent. The English farmer pays 200 per cent. more. He has some advantages which the Irish farmer has not. Does the Irish farmer pay more income tax? Does he pay more for his tea? Is there a bigger tax on tea there? I think there is. Does the Irish farmer pay more for sugar?
Comment on this
Last year it was less. Where is the Irish farmer at a disadvantage compared with the English? In one way he is at a disadvantage, because he pays more for his boots and clothes, and when Deputies opposite get their way and put a tariff, not only on blankets but every piece of woollen that comes in, every piece of cloth and paper, and when we carry out Deputy Dr. Ryan's suggestion that there should be a tax on imported agricultural machinery, then the Irish farmer will be in a happy position.
Comment on this
Exactly. According to the President, if he buys Irish manufactured goods, he does not pay any taxes.
Comment on this
I am trying to meet the points that were put up. The case was deliberately made by every speaker on the opposite benches that the real reason for depression, so far as there was depression, amongst farmers was high taxation. The cost of an Irish farm was compared with that of an English farm. I suggest that every argument that I have used is relevant to those points. Taxation is too high. It should be reduced. I do not pretend that the farmer does not bear his full share of the taxes. I do not pretend that it would not be a great benefit to the farmer if we could reduce taxes and rates and the taxation of the country generally. I admit that the crying need is to keep things as economically cheap as possible in this country. I think that that should be the aim of all Governments from this on, but I cannot understand the attitude of Deputies opposite, the point of view which amounts to this, namely, that high taxation is the real cause of depression in agriculture when, in fact, the only aspects of taxation in which the Irish farmer compares unfavourably with the English farmer, with whom he has been specifically compared, are those aspects which all Deputies opposite are praising highly and of which they want more. There have been constant demands for tariffs on woollen goods, on clothes, on agricultural machinery, on paper, and a higher tariff on boots. I say that it does not lie in the mouths of people who ask for all that extra taxation on the farmer to make the case that all depression in agriculture since 1921 has been due to high taxation. Take another aspect of the matter. Deputy Dr. Ryan said that it would be necessary for him to show how taxation could be reduced. Of course, I could have written them all down beforehand. Abolish the Army. Abolish the police.
Comment on this
Am I expected to answer that? There have been tremendous economies made in the Army. There has been no service so definitely, deliberately and gradually cut since 1921 as the Army. I do not want to go into the question as to what economies could be made in the police, but if I liked I could put up quite a good argument tending to show that the Deputies on the opposite benches are the last people who should talk about reductions in the Army and in the police. I want to discuss these questions—do not pay any pensions to judges; cut down all salaries to £1,000 per annum; keep the land annuities in the country, and pay no pensions to civil servants or to the ex-R.I.C.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, I took down that. The Deputy did say it, but I came to the conclusion that he was not exactly saying what he meant, judging by its place and its context. I took it he meant that we should not pay pensions to civil servants who resigned after 1921, or something like that. Anyway, leave out the civil servants. Then it comes to this—pay no pensions to ex-judges and ex-R.I.C.; keep the land annuities in the country, and cut down all salaries to £1,000. The only respectable one is, cut down all salaries to £1,000. The Deputy knows that that would not save £100,000 per year. He knows well that the proportion of highly-paid civil servants to civil servants whose salaries vary from £200 to £400 is negligible; that the amount of money that goes to pay civil servants between, say, £800 and £1,200 is negligible as compared with the amount that goes to pay the lower grades. The Deputy knows well that no cuts in the Civil Service will yield any big sum of money, any sum of money which is any way adequate to deal with any of the problems in which he is interested, unless you apply that cut to the big number in the lower grades. Deputies opposite would talk about oppression, and unfairness to the poor and to the weak, to people who cannot protect themselves, if we attempted to touch the salaries of the junior grades in the Civil Service. I agree that on the merits there is absolutely no case for it. The salaries in the junior grades are extremely low for men with the education that they must get. We have a large number of civil servants, but, if we have, we have a large number of social services.
You cannot have less civil servants unless we are prepared to do with less social services. In any event, it is not worth arguing about. When we compare the grandiose schemes put up here and hear of the amount of money that is required to re-establish prosperity here, and when we consider, on the other side, the suggestion that we should cut down all salaries to £1,000 a year, it is absurd. Of course, it is excellent politics—I admit that. Deputies opposite know that perfectly well. I will get a cheer off any platform if I can say there is no man worth more than £1,000 per year. No one will cheer louder than the dispensary doctor or the solicitor who is in the crowd and is making about £1,500 or £1,700 for half the work.
We are to keep the land annuities at home; we are to refuse to pay the pensions of the ex-judges and ex-R.I.C. I can only make one answer to that: We are not in a position to do that. We accepted the Treaty; we persuaded the country, if you like, to accept it, and you have to wait for the Republic, to wait until Deputies get a majority, and until they repudiate the Treaty; or wait until they get the British to agree to leave them the annuities and alter the financial settlement in that respect, and then they can consider the question. When they do that, they can use this £3,000,000 of annuities and the pensions of the judges and the R.I.C., which are, I suppose, negligible, for this development. I put it to them that that is also politics—nothing else. As far as I am concerned, I do not believe it is possible to repudiate these liabilities. I believe that a national policy directed towards repudiating these liabilities is going to rot this country. I believe that firmly. I believe it cannot succeed. If you do, I believe you will be no better off. This £3,000,000 would go like water. You know that when people get rich quickly like that they lose their heads. I have not the slightest doubt that there will be other political exigencies then, that after, say, two or three years, the farmers might find they were not absolutely millionaires because they happened to pay 15/- or 16/- or 17/- per acre for their land. I believe the new situation created would create new political exigencies and I believe more money would be wanted. I believe that this money which you had got in that way in the long run would give nothing extra for distribution. The question is too big, and I am not going into it. I do not think the Deputy should have brought it in now—it is too big a question to discuss. We will be discussing the whole Treaty position, the whole political position of the country, and a very big financial question connected with the financial settlement, if you try to discuss the merits of the case. Hence I do not think the Deputy should have introduced that here.
Let me say a word about wheat. I want to repeat that apparently we are getting nearer to each other on this question of an agricultural policy. I make the Deputy a present of the point that it was only recently I discovered that we had not a substitute market. We need not debate that—I think it was always obvious. But we do appear to get nearer to agreement in regard to the whole agricultural economy. It is agreed now that the products we are producing, namely, cattle, sheep, pigs, bacon, eggs and butter, are what we should continue to produce and that it is good business to produce more. Apparently it is agreed now that extra tillage. While desirable, should be directed towards producing raw materials for these finished products. If we can get agreement on that point, we go a long way towards agreement on agricultural policy; we go a long way to kill, once and for all, a lot of the nonsense that has been talked on this question for the last five years. But Deputies will insist in tacking on to that perfectly sound point of view some special consideration in regard to wheat. I have never said that farmers should not grow wheat. I have never yet seen a bad farmer growing wheat. If you see a good patch of wheat in a small farmer's garden you may be sure that he is a good farmer. That is a lot to say for him. It is a pity that there is not more wheat grown. There are only 30,000 acres. In a great many parts of the country the land is suitable and the farmer's economy suits it. There are certain parts of the country, such as Meath, where there is very rich land and, in my opinion, when that land is tilled, wheat is a more suitable crop than oats—it will stand up better. I want to see an increase of wheat in the country. What I do protest against is the idea that there is some special virtue in it—that it is the panacea for all agricultural ills. My view is that you would be doing twice as much for the country if you could find a breed of oats that will stand up, than you can possibly do by any suggestions we have heard as to wheat growing. That is probably a point that will only appeal to farmers. The Deputy suggests for some reason that we should aim at a production of wheat equal to the production which we had, say, in 1840— that we should aim at growing sufficient wheat to feed the country. I think that is a fair statement of the Deputy's case. He admits that it will take a long time to bring about that, and I should like to see it and shall be glad to see it. What I do protest against is paying very large sums of farmers' and shopkeepers' and other people's money. In other words, I draw Deputy O'Reilly's attention to the increase in taxation out of all bounds which would be required for that purpose. We grow at present 30,000 acres of wheat; we grew something like 500,000 long ago.
What is the cause of the decline? Why have farmers dropped from 500,000 to 30,000? For only one reason: that prices went against them. The price of wheat for the last sixty or seventy years has almost invariably been lower than the general index of prices. In that respect it is unlike other crops. Practically all other crops have gone up. The Corn Laws did not affect that—any of the other considerations did not affect it. The price of wheat has been lower than the general index prices. That is the reason why farmers are not growing it. It is as clear as daylight that if farmers are to grow anything like 500,000 acres of wheat again they must be paid for it by the taxpayers of the country, and in six cases out of eight the taxpayer is the farmer himself. I cannot see any way out of that dilemma. It seems to me to be absolutely clear that if we are to aim at 500,000 acres in this country, having regard to the fact that we have at present only 30,000, and that that state of affairs in which we have only 30,000 acres has continued for a long period and seems to be permanent, it must be done by paying the farmer to grow it in some shape or form. It is a question of what he is to be paid. I do not know what the price of wheat is this year, but the farmers were getting 11/- per cwt. last year for wheat fit for milling purposes. There was a slight increase in the acreage, but only 32,000 or 33,000 acres were grown. Would any Deputy say what price per cwt., without complicating this by subsidies to mills and to middlemen, as it all comes back to what price the farmer will get for it, the farmer should get for wheat in order to induce him to grow, say, 300,000 acres?
Comment on this
I will take the Deputy's word. That is about 4/- extra, and somebody has to find that; it has to be guaranteed by somebody and has to come from somebody. It is not a commercial price—it is 4/- over it.
That would amount to about £1,500,000. Is it worth it?
Comment on this
That is another question. That may be all wrong. If it is, abolish it. We must treat the subject separately. I will take the Deputy's own figure. To produce 300,000 acres of wheat would take £1,500,000, coming from someone, and there is only one place for it to come from—that is the taxpayer. Is it worth it?
Comment on this
That is another question. This must be treated on its merits. Abolish the army afterwards, when you have done that. Of course, I must say I do not agree with Deputy Corry that 15/- per cwt. would get an increase of from 30,000 to 300,000 acres. Nothing like it. You will get no wheat grown in the Gaeltacht, very little in Galway, and very little in other parts of the country. It is only in suitable land it would be grown. You cannot get 300,000 acres of wheat grown at even the 15/-. Accepting that it would take £1,500,000, why should that be spent? What is the national advantage? There is no reason urged why there should be 300,000 extra acres of tillage. 100,000 acres would be the outside. If an increase were brought about by artificial methods those methods would have to be applied every year, otherwise they would revert; secondly, that increase is only an increase in a specific crop, and there would be a corresponding, or an almost corresponding, diminution in some other crop.
Comment on this
I will come to that in a moment. What is the advantage? I would like Deputy Ryan, who knows something about farming, to tell me. Give me £1,500,000 for ten years and there will not be in the country any shorthorn but a pedigree one. Look at what you would do with that as regards the shorthorn cattle. You would make the livestock in this country the best in the world, and have a situation like Jersey Island, having nothing but the best pedigree cattle.
Comment on this
I hope I will not hear that an argument for breeding livestock and producing livestock produce is grass. We have got past that in the Dáil. If Deputies will consider they will find there are other means of spending £1,500,000. I put it to Deputies in all seriousness, is this £1,500,000—which is a gross underestimate, as it would be nearer to £2,000,000—worth it? What is the advantage? It is beginning at the wrong end. Any increase in tillage will be only temporary and will last only while the subsidies last. The moment the subsidies go the area under tillage will go for certain. You can only bring about an increase in tillage by an increase in all your profits. An increase can only be brought about by a realisation on the part of the farmers that tillage pays, that it pays the small farmer, and even the big farmer, up to a point. In my opinion one of the real difficulties about persuading the farmers to increase their tillage is the fact that people talk so much nonsense about it. I suggest, having regard to the fact that seventy-five per cent. of the farmers are under £30 valuation, that you do the best for the farmers if you persuade them to keep one extra cow, one extra sow, and to till an extra acre of land. There is hardly a farmer in this country under £30 valuation it would not pay to do that, provided he did more drainage on his land, and provided he and his family worked harder. It would be all money coming in sometime. We cannot bank on the increased difference between production and the final prices.
We must bank on increased production, and we cannot have that unless the farmers realise there must be a little more tillage and that a little more tillage would afford them a little more live stock. If you could in ten years bring about that state of affairs it could be done for a negligible cost, and it would do one hundred times as much good and bring one hundred times as much prosperity to the country as all your subsidies for wheat schemes. We have been told we have neglected agriculture. I want to know where. I know the farmers are very hard hit, and that there is depression in agriculture. I know that the farmers for the last five or six years have had a hard time to make out. I know there are as good farmers in this country as in any other country, but unfortunately these are the farmers who never write a letter to the papers, and who have too much to do to go into the county councils to blather about Land Commission annuities, and so on. I know the big majority of them have made a real attempt to stand up to the adverse conditions of the last few years. They have done that consciously in their own interests and in the interests of the country. I claim we have done everything we could for them.
We have undoubtedly done a considerable amount for the dairying industry. The Dairy Produce Act was a great success. Irish butter was selling at low prices, and the price is still too low, and it was being undoubtedly driven off the market in England. It was in a disgraceful position in 1923 and 1924. It was being driven off the market. We put it in an impregnable position with the co-operation of the farmers. We have done the same with eggs. We have undoubtedly brought about an immense improvement in the live stock in the last few years, and we have been copied by Northern Ireland, by bringing in large numbers of first class animals. We have done a great deal for the improvement of the live stock, but the results have yet to be seen in the working of the Live Stock Act. We have made an experiment that has been received generously by all the parties when we bought over the Condensed Milk Company and announced our policy and handed over the dairying industry to the farmers themselves. That was a very big and dangerous project for the Government to embark upon. We have done that. Where have we failed? That is what I want to know. In addition we have established faculpan ties on agriculture in the University colleges, and we have organised them so as to make them so far as material advantages are concerned of an equality with any faculties in the world. We have attempted to find a new crop for the farmers in sugar beet. I could go down the line talking over our agricultural economy, and on what our projects are and what we could do for the farmers.
In regard to agricultural projects, I would like to know where have we failed? I repeat that the farmers of this country had a very hard struggle. It would be an optimist who would say that the bad times are completely over, but undoubtedly things have become stabilised. The farmer who has stuck it for the last three or four years should not be depressed and defeated now. It is not patriotic. I do not care what your views are on Land Commission annuities. I do not care what your political views are, it is nothing but unpatriotic to preach a gospel of pessimism to the farmer. Deputy Ryan knows, and every Deputy who knows anything about agriculture knows, apart from the merits of the case, that you are not going to save the farmer by talking about not paying his annuities. I suggest that we ought to have an agricultural truce, that the farmer should be left alone, and that the Deputies of all Parties should realise that if the farmer gets to be a defeatist, if he loses heart, this country is beaten. I do not care what the political structure of the country may be whether Free State, a Republic or a Monarchy, if the farmer loses heart and becomes a defeatist, this country goes down. I suggest that is the problem which is much more important than any political problem in connection with any particular form of government. I suggest that the right course for Deputies is to let the farmer alone, to give the farmer a chance. I agree that it is the business of the Government, so far as possible, to reduce the farmer's burden, whether of rates or of taxes, direct or indirect, that he has to bear.
Comment on this
I must say that I have been greatly disappointed at this debate. We have travelled from the Argentine to Canada, round by China and Peru. We have heard read a list of statistics which were quoted about all sorts of questions—what is a balanced ration for a calf; or whether they should eat crushed oats or decorticated cotton cake. This debate reminds me of the fact that on all occasions when the farmers' interests are being discussed in this House or on political platforms, the farmers interests are always overshadowed by political propaganda, and that fact was abundantly evident on both sides of the House to-day.
I must say that I was grievously disappointed with Deputy Dr. Ryan's opening. His statistics were all right, but he could not resist bringing in his Party's political propaganda into the question into which it should not have been introduced, good, bad or indifferent. The question under consideration is: has a serious economic situation arisen as a result of depression in agriculture, and has the Government failed to take the necessary steps to remedy that? Now, another remarkable factor in this debate is the Minister's reply. The Minister talked on every subject in this debate but on the one subject that hit the spot. That was the speech of Deputy Hogan, of Clare.
Comment on this
What is the farmer faced with? Agriculture has neither capital nor credit. Over 75 per cent. of the productive workers of the State are engaged in agriculture, and the balance of the productive workers are engaged in industries largely dependent upon agriculture. It is the farmers who are the consumers of the products of the industrialists. Hence it is not agriculture alone that suffers from the depression. Every citizen in this State feels the pinch, and the depression on agriculture reacts everywhere. That, in a nutshell, is the economic situation in the Saorstát to-day. That was the position of affairs when Deputy Ryan put down his motion six months ago. The main industry of the country has been allowed to lie in the condition in which it was six months ago or six years ago, because nobody takes an interest in it. The discussion on this motion has been delayed for six months. The motion has appeared on every Order Paper that has been issued in that period. Nothing has been done or attempted by the Government in the meantime to relieve the depression, and that depression was admitted. I must, therefore, assume that the Government was going to suggest and do suggest that there is no such thing as depression in agriculture at the moment. We have heard all about the various Acts which were passed for a number of years back. We were told about the Egg and Dairy Acts. The Egg and Dairy Acts were no doubt palliatives to a degree, just a little nourishment to keep the vital spark in the agricultural body. As for the Live Stock Improvement Act, this has added nothing to the farmers' incomes so far. Therefore it must be admitted that none of these Acts has improved the condition of the farmers so far as these two great needs are concerned. And what are these two great needs? What is the cause of the depression in agriculture? The cause is that the farmers have neither capital nor credit.
Comment on this
That is the whole point. The Minister for Agriculture has a panacea. That panacea is that the small farmer should get another cow, another sow and an extra acre of tillage. Let him go down to the country and tell the small farmer who cannot pay his land annuities where he is going to get the capital for that. What about the Credit Corporation? Well what about it. Does anybody here know anything about it? There has not been a word about the Credit Corporation in this Debate and for information sake I would like to know something about it, because I know nothing about it myself. I have heard nothing about it in this House and my constituents know nothing about it. The Minister for Agriculture stated that he knew nothing about deflation and that there was only five or six people in the world who knew anything about it. I must congratulate the Minister upon having brought one of them to Ireland. I will quote you a statement from one of those gentlemen. It is a statement made by the Chairman of the Credit Corporation, a gentleman who was brought over from England to be made chairman of this body at a salary of £1,500 a year. Here is what he said about deflation, speaking the other day:—
"Many people look towards the Agricultural Credit Corporation as if it were some Lourdes Grotto of finance, with miraculous power of healing all the cripples of deflation." The cripples of deflation to whom he refers are of course the Irish farmers whose cause we try to plead to-day, and unfortunately we find many of them. The chairman of the Credit Corporation with his salary of £1,500 a year for talking platitudes like that to the Irish farmers, is certainly not a cripple of deflation, and, in my opinion, the Agricultural Credit Corporation has been, through its chairman, directors, secretary, chief clerk, staff clerks and all the minor financial experts a veritable Lourdes Grotto so far as finance is concerned. The chairman of the Credit Corporation has made another statement in which he says:—"I wish to emphasise that the Corporation is not merely a financial investigating and marketing body, such as an Issuing House; it is a borrowing institution. In fact its primary function is a borrowing rather than a lending one. Now the basis of the appeal which the Corporation will make to the investor later on is twofold; first the credit of the State, and, secondly, the land mortgages and other securities that it will accumulate as it expands. Some people appear to think that the Corporation should not trouble much about the second, since the credit of the State will in any event be the prime security for its borrowings. But after all the resources of the State are limited; its credit would be very seriously damaged if it embarked on unwise borrowing. Besides the collateral land mortgages will be a very real security for the investor. It should be obvious that the more the Corporation enhances the value of the collateral security the cheaper it can borrow, and consequently the cheaper it can lend in the long run. On all counts it would be folly for the Corporation to pursue any but a sound and conservative lending policy."
A most remarkable statement from the Chairman of the Credit Corporation. The farmers have discovered that the Credit Corporation is a borrowing rather than a lending body, and that it must pursue a sound and conservative lending policy. This is breaking the news gently to the farmers, and it is news that will cheer them this Christmas time. Why were they not told this two years ago at the inception of this Agricultural Credit Corporation? The Agricultural Credit Corporation became law in the spring of 1927. During two subsequent general elections enormous benefits were, the farmers were assured from political platforms, to be showered upon the agricultural community by this Act. The fullest hopes that were raised amongst the farmers have done incalculable injury to the Government, the farmers and the State.
Be it remembered that this Act was passed in the spring, at a time when there was very serious depression in agriculture. The Act was not implemented for twelve months after. Might I ask the Government the question: Why was the implementing of this Act, passed to meet agricultural depression and to provide capital for the farmers, delayed for twelve months? I have my own views about it, and so have the public outside, but I would like to know from the Government why that was so. Was it held over for a general election, or were there other considerations of the Lady of Lourdes Grotto idea behind the delay in financing the Corporation? Let me remind the House that the original Act was practically unworkable. The Minister for Agriculture introduced an amending Act which he assured us himself would remove all the difficulties in the way of granting loans to farmers. I can see no improvement in the working of these Acts since the amending Act was brought in. I do not think any Deputy can say that the Agricultural Credit Corporation, as it is working at present, is of any assistance whatever to the farming community. The hopes which this enactment fostered have now practically brought people to a state of despair, and that is the condition in the country at the moment. It was absolutely cruel to tell the farmers two years ago that an Act was being passed to provide credit for agriculture, and to tell them now that the Agricultural Credit Corporation is more of a borrowing than a lending institution.
The Chairman of the Agricultural Credit Corporation told us that we cannot go on giving credit to farmers until such time as the second security referred to is provided; that is, not until the land of the comfortably off farmer is put into pawn. It follows that the farmer who has got no credit at the moment can get no help. In other words, down the country that conservative lending policy, which he refers to, would be called "live horse and you will get grass," and that is the policy of the Agricultural Credit Corporation at the moment. I will not go so far as to say that the Government inspired that policy in the Credit Corporation. I do not think so. But at any rate, the Credit Corporation is outside the control of this House. No Minister will answer a question as regards its work. Another peculiar aspect in reference to this attitude to agriculture is: where exactly does agriculture rank? The Government themselves have graded the Departments of State. Since the Provisional Government was established, I believe the Minister for Agriculture, up to the year 1927, was not included in the Executive Council. He was not important enough to be included in it. The representative of our principal industry was not included in the Executive Council, but when a change was made in June, after the General Election of 1927, the Minister for Agriculture was included. But he was not included because the Government recognised the importance of agriculture, but because every other Minister was included at that time, and the Minister for Agriculture just walked in with the crowd. That is so, and he is in the Ministry now. Agriculture is recognised in the Executive Council, and I daresay the Minister for Agriculture may have something to say in the shaping of agricultural policy now. I am glad to see that the Minister for Agriculture is sitting in the second Government Bench at the moment. At the same time, he is not in his proper place according to the way he is graded by the Government. How have they been graded since all the Ministers were put into the Executive Council? Agriculture, Land and Fisheries, are the two lowest graded Ministries in the Government. How then can we get, or can we expect, from the Executive the interest in agriculture which agriculture should get? I do not say that is the view of the Minister himself.
Comment on this
The Minister, in the course of his reply, I am glad to say, took off the little wrapping of tariffs that the Government wears at times, and became a whole-hog Free Trader. He challenged the Opposition on free trade lines for political purposes. As regards the Minister himself, I do not really know what he is, but he has to play the game of the half-boiled Tariff Reformer and the half-boiled Free Trader, and until he is able to convince the Government that tariffs are wrong, and they are very wrong, then the Minister, I would say, is not pulling his weight on the Executive Council.
Now let us see how this important industry of agriculture is dealt with by the Government. This motion has been on the Order Paper for eight months. During all that time we have had discussions about the Civic Guards, the Army, the Civil War and who was responsible for it. We gave hours, days and weeks to these discussions, but once agriculture, the principal thing that should be discussed in this House, is put on the Order Paper, it has first of all to remain on the Order Paper for eight months, and after that is confined to one solitary day's discussion in this House at the tail end of a session. Have the Government got an agricultural policy? I do not believe they have. Do the Government believe that there is depression in agriculture? Evidently, from the Minister's speech, although I will excuse him this far to say that the point was not put up to him up to the present, but the question still remains: is there depression in agriculture? I say that there is very serious depression in it, arising principally from the cause referred to by Deputy Hogan, of Clare, who said that it was a reaction from the time in 1925 when the whole country was ravaged by fluke. The small farmers of the country never recovered from that, and there is undoubtedly at the present moment a want of capital and of credit amongst the agricultural community. I say that is a question that must be settled before next spring. Of course, if the Government take another view before this motion is decided upon, or even after that has been done, they can do a lot between this and next spring, but they will have to do something.
I do not want to go into too many matters outside this question of want of capital, or to elaborate the other causes for the depression in agriculture, but what are the burdens that are on agriculture at the moment? These rather touch on the question of marketing. Somebody stated in the course of the debate that a cow bought at £16 was sold at £24. I think it was Deputy Ryan mentioned that. He wanted to know what happened to that £8. I do not know whether that figure is correct or not, but it is a wide margin. That applies to everything the farmers sell. What happens to the price as between the producer and the consumer? The margin is so big that in many cases five or six people scoop the profit that should go to the farmer. How can we talk about agriculture under these conditions being in a prosperous state? These are matters which, quite apart from present depression, the Government must tackle sooner or later. The farmer has to deal with what I would call parasitical vampires who are sucking the profits out of his production. I do not like the word bankruptcy. The country is not bankrupt; it has plenty of resources and all it wants is to develop these resources. Take bankruptcy and take the farmer in respect to any other citizen in the State in regard to it. It is a peculiar thing, but it is a fact that the privilege which the professional man, or the business man, or any other citizen, enjoys is denied to the farmer when depression comes on his industry or when from some misfortune or other, he is not able to pay all his debts. In such circumstances the others take the protection of the bankruptcy court and liquidate their liabilities for a 1/- or 2/6 or 5/- in the £ and get a fresh start in life.
Comment on this
I have known many men to whom that happened. But what I want to illustrate is this: that when the unfortunate farmer cannot meet his liabilities, before he has gone too far, you find the Land Commission selling his farm or some other creditor to whom he is bound to offer 20/- in the £, and the farmer and his family are sent out on the roadside. These things are not taken into consideration by people in Dublin who think little of the farmer and forget that he is the man who is keeping the bread and butter in their mouths.
Comment on this
Where is he to be found? A few weeks ago I asked the President:
"Whether the Executive Council has under consideration any measure for the purpose of assisting farmers in the present depressed condition of agriculture and consequent depreciation in the value of land ... and if he will state when proposals for legislation for the extension of agricultural credit will be introduced."
The Minister for Finance replied that:
"The Government has continuously under consideration proposals for the purpose of assisting farmers in the present depressed condition of agriculture,"... and that "the experience of the working of the Agricultural Credit Act, 1927, is not yet sufficient to enable a sound judgment to be formed as to what extension, if any, is necessary in the provision of agricultural credit."
I say the place for the Government to find out the working of the Agricultural Credit Corporation, of which they say they have not sufficient knowledge, at the moment, is to ask the representatives of the people in this House exactly how it is working in the various counties, and they will very soon find the answer that there is pressing necessity for the further extension of agricultural credit to the farmers. They have it under "continuous consideration." Now "continuous consideration" of agricultural credit will not pay land annuities and debts and rates and taxes, and will not purchase seeds next spring. It will not buy stock, not even a cow or a sow, or the extra acre of tillage, and financial assistance is urgently wanted. Only yesterday I was speaking to one of the best farmers in my county, one of the most practical men in the county, and, strange to say, a very strong supporter of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. I have seen him on platforms against myself on many occasions. He told me—and he comes from one of the most prosperous parishes of the county—that four of his neighbours who hitherto had been in a prosperous condition had abandoned their farms, which were now derelict. If they were put up for sale they would not get a shilling for them. Yet we are told by the Government that they have continually under consideration the question of extension of agricultural credit, and that the experience they have at present does not justify extension. These are the things the Government should be considering. No matter what may be said to the contrary, if there was an investigation made, if the Government consulted their own Party, they must be convinced that the extension of agricultural credit is absolutely necessary. I say if they do not realise that fact, and if men on their own back benches, sitting behind them, do not bring pressure to bear upon them, then a very serious state of affairs will arise next spring, bad for the Government, bad for the State, and disastrous for agriculture.
When people talk about agricultural matters there is a feeling, especially in the city, that agriculture runs on while we play. People in Dublin go to the theatres, anywhere you like, the farmer does not count. It is my opinion, and I expressed it before, that, in reality, we are a nation of snobs. Snobbery of the highest degree is to be got in this City of Dublin. The greatest snobs in the City of Dublin and it is a snobby town, are the men who have just stepped off the farm into a profession, into business, into officialdom in Dublin. They are the people who sneer at farming and everything connected with it. Some of them, if they met their fathers and mothers in Grafton Street, would go to the other side for fear they would have to recognise them in public. And when that atmosphere is here in the city, at the seat of Government, I am afraid that that snobocracy in those who have just come off the land, has destroyed the Government influence in favour of agriculture. These people have done harm, and, God knows, the Irish farmer has produced more worthless things than scrub bulls.
I am not a pessimist. I have been an optimist all my life, and if I were not an optimist I would not be here trying to do something for the farmer, because I tell you any man who comes here to do anything for the farmers is a Mark Tapley of the first degree, an optimist first, last, and all the time. Thank God I never was a politician, and never will be. I am convinced that this country can be made prosperous and financially independent. We will leave the political side of it out of this debate. Everyone has his own ideas on that. If we go about it unbiassed by Party considerations or personal prejudices, the road to prosperity runs through the farmers. If we travel that road, helping and encouraging, we shall open for those who follow an enduring prospect of happiness and prosperity which will be reflected in our villages, towns and cities. Let us get back to the plough.
Comment on this
I would like to hear Deputy Davin if he is prepared to speak only for five minutes. After that I think it is for Deputy Ryan himself to say what he will do for the remainder of the time.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Hanlon has, in my opinion, put his finger on the real point when he states that the cause of agricultural depression is solely due to the shortage of working capital. I realise it is a very difficult job for any organisation like a Government to act in a way which a Government should act towards an unorganised producing community. The difficulty which the Government of to-day are confronted with, or which the Government of tomorrow will be confronted with, is that they have to deal with a body of agriculturists who are unorganised.
I will deal briefly with the point the Minister mentioned in his speech. He poured a certain amount of ridicule on a suggestion, which was not gone into in detail by Deputy Ryan, that the Government should purchase the grain crops for the purpose of guaranteeing grain-growers an economic price and disposing of them afterwards to the best advantage. I believe what Deputy Ryan suggested is the same suggestion that Deputy Aird put forward by inference in a question which he addressed to the Minister on the 25th October last. Therefore, if Deputy Ryan's suggestion is ridiculous, Deputy Aird's is equally ridiculous. Strange as it may appear, I agree with Deputy Aird's and Deputy Ryan's suggestion, and it would be interesting to see whether Deputy Aird is prepared to back his opinion in this matter by voting in favour of the motion.
Comment on this
The suggestion which the Minister previously made in a speech he delivered at the Chamber of Commerce is that the acreage of land under tillage should be increased. How does he expect grain-growers to increase their tillage, grow grain and give a good deal of employment if they are to be confronted with a price of 12/- to 14/- per barrel for barley? The acreage under barley this year, as given in the official statistics, is 129,092. That gives a great deal of employment to agricultural labourers throughout the grain-growing counties. I foreshadow, if the prices to be given in the years to come are the same as the pawnbroking prices given to growers this year, that the acreage under tillage, as far as barley is concerned, will be decreased rather than increased. The suggestion I put forward is that put forward by Deputy Ryan and privately backed by Deputy Aird, which amounts to this: that the Government should come in at a particular period of the year and reconstruct the derelict mills all over the country, store in them the grain for the farmers, advance to them by way of short-term credits, or some other method such as the Agricultural Credit Corporation, a certain minimum figure for their grain, then hold the grain until those who want it are willing to pay a decent price, and then hand over the difference to the growers. That is an easy method of dealing with the grain situation, and it is the only method of dealing with it, as the Minister knows. The average grain-grower cannot afford to hold his grain in bad barns, because if he does it will deteriorate. If he holds it in sacks he will have to pay 2d. a week for sack hire.
The only way to deal with the situation is for the Government to come in and store the grain until those who want it will pay a decent price. We know that the Government have roughly set aside three million pounds for the encouragement of the beet growing industry. What is the position? The beet factory in Carlow which has been making good profits for the last few years offers 44/- a ton for next year's beet crop. Will that tend to increase or decrease the acreage of land under beet? I think it will help to decrease it. We will hear very few more demands from Wexford, Buttevant and Limerick for beet factories. What does that show to me and others who speak for the Labour Party? It means that as you are decreasing the acreage under tillage you add to the list of unemployed in this country and so far as the party is concerned we are prepared to support any Government or party in this House which will force the hand of the Government to provide working capital to enable farmers to till more land with advantage to themselves and to help to reduce the abnormal number of unemployed mainly due to the depression in the agricultural industry.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Fisheries said that we had definitely turned the corner; that the President's pronouncement was right, and my figures wrong. In order to prove his contention the Parliamentary Secretary said the price of pigs had gone up. I have looked up the prices in to-day's newspapers and I find that pigs have gone up for the last few weeks. For instance, the price of a 4 stone pig is 76/- but if we go back to September 1st the price was 82/-. A pig under 6 stone is quoted at 76/- but on the 1st September last the price was 80/-. It was higher still last April. A pig of 12 stone is quoted at 70/- to-day but it was 80/- in June, and 82/- early in that month. I hope it is not a mere fluctuation in prices. That is no reason for saying that we have turned the corner. The Parliamentary Secretary said it was unfair to make a comparison between agricultural prices in 1913 and in the present year. He said that conditions had been changed by the war. There is no doubt about that. I think when I was quoting the figures I made a contrast between the exports of Denmark to the British market and the exports from the Irish Free State. I showed that last year the exports from the Free State to the British markets were 99.3 of the 1913 exports whereas the exports from Denmark were 164.5 as compared with the exports in 1911-13. That does not fit in very well with the contention of Deputy Gorey that, owing to the Great War, Denmark got markets elsewhere across her border, in Germany, and that that was why Denmark was not now sending her full complement of butter to the British markets. If Deputy Gorey is right in his contention that Denmark had found other markets as a result of the Great War then the increased exports of Denmark are far and away greater than 164 per cent. whereas our exports are not in the position they occupied in 1913.
Deputy Gorey's principal point was that I advocated compulsion. Well, I suppose if a Government is asked to do anything that would be advocating compulsion. It is very difficult to suggest that the Government should do a thing voluntarily, because it would have little value. I am quite sure that Deputy Gorey did not object to the various Acts that were passed for the benefit of agriculture because there was a certain amount of compulsion in them. He did not object to the Dairy Produce Act; he did not object to the Livestock Act or to the Agricultural Produce (Eggs) Act. There was a good deal of compulsion in every one of these Acts; still there was no objection to compulsion there. If I have advocated certain things here, as Deputy Gorey says, the logical conclusion to be drawn is that they will extend as far as the housewife. I do not think they will extend without compulsion. It is hard to foresee. At any rate, if it is going to have a good effect in the country there is no reason why the housewife should not be compelled to make bread from Irish wheat just the same as the baker.
The Parliamentary Secretary for Posts and Telegraphs offered a good deal of criticism to some of our suggestions. His first contention was that the Government was not responsible for falling prices. That view is also held by the Minister for Agriculture. I do not believe they are responsible for falling prices at all, but I do not think that falling prices should excuse the Government for leaving the farmers in the position they are in. If the farmers are getting less now than they got in 1913 it is the business of the Government to reduce taxation in order to give them a chance of living. I know that the Government cannot compel anybody to give a better price to farmers than they are getting now. There might be some exceptions in the case of oats and barley. Take the case of beef on the British market. The Government cannot interfere there and cannot compel Britain to give a better price. Farmers when getting big prices during the war were able to pay twice as much in taxation as they can pay now.
It is not that the Irish Government are responsible for the fall in prices, but I say they are responsible for not bringing down the cost of government, seeing that the farmers' prices have come down. As I said in introducing the motion, if the farmers can only get 30 per cent. more for their produce now than they got in 1913, and if against that taxation per head is 160 per cent. higher, surely there must be something wrong. What is wrong is that the farmer is getting too little and that he has to pay too much for government. The fact that he is getting too little cannot be remedied. The fact that he is paying too much for government can be remedied. That is the point I want the Government to direct their attention to, and not to side-track the issue by saying they are not responsible for the fall in prices.
The Parliamentary Secretary for Posts and Telegraphs said that if farmers had barley to sell for 16/- a barrel, and if it were good value for feeding, why did not some other farmers buy it at that price. That is not my point. My point is this: that 16/- is not the price at which the farmer was selling his barley. The price quoted, 16/-, was the price at which the buyers were selling barley to the maltsters. If farmers were selling barley at 14/- or 16/- a barrel, it was not my idea to get other farmers to buy it from them. My point is that they should get, at any rate, something near the value of the barley in order to encourage them to remain in tillage, and, if possible, to till more. What I am concerned about is that, as in the case of maize, it should, if possible, be regulated that people buying barley should buy it at what it is value for in order that the growers may till more.
The Minister for Agriculture said that a man could feed his barley to his own stock. That is not always possible. I know real tillage farmers in certain districts in County Wexford who keep practically no stock, except horses for working the land and perhaps a cow or two for the use of the household. They have practically no stock for winter feeding. They make tillage their business and they would grow grain still if they could sell it at a decent price. On the other hand, there would be certain people who, as the Minister for Agriculture mentioned, till a certain amount to sell, and who are prepared to buy more feeding stuffs along with what they till. That is what should be regulated. Some regulations should be made whereby the grain can pass from one person to another and that the person who is producing the grain would get a price that would induce him to grow more. The Parliamentary Secretary for Posts and Telegraphs said that the farmer will always produce what pays him best, and that it is an economic impossibility to make him do otherwise by State action. I think that is fairly evident. That is a very wise saying, and if the State were to intervene—not to try to make him produce something that does not pay him—but to try and regulate things so that it would pay him best to produce certain crops that would, perhaps, be doing what I have advocated.
I have never advocated that you should try to compel any man to produce what does not pay him to produce, but I have advocated that you should make it pay a man to produce what you want produced. The solution of the difficulty, according to the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, is more production, if possible on a paying basis. "On a paying basis." In fact, according to his previous statement, you will not get it unless it is on a paying basis.
The Minister for Agriculture commenced by telling us that he know absolutely nothing about inflation and deflation. I suppose a man would not really be a finished financier except he knew something about inflation and deflation. Still the Minister says that he does know that the British financial system is the best in the world. Has he taken that on hearsay?
Comment on this
Or does it follow that as Britain is good in other ways she must have a good financial system? At any rate, he has not gone into this matter for himself. I suppose he has taken it second-hand in some way or other. The Minister has proved to us that the number of animals in the country has gone up from 1925, and I must say I am very glad to hear that. I do not know whether the Minister exactly accused me of trying to evade that question. I do not think he did. In any event, I did not try to evade it. The sheet which I have in my hand only contains figures for 1927-28, and the trade and shipping statistics from which I quoted do not contain figures as to the number of animals in the country at all. The Minister made an attempt to congratulate us on changing our policy since this time last year. I think it would be very interesting to go back and read up the debate we had here in October of 1927, and then read the debate which we have had to-day. It would be very interesting to learn whether the Minister has not changed more than we did. On that occasion, when I was advocating increased tillage, the Minister asked was I sure whether or not there would be any grass left in the country if this scheme of increased tillage was carried out. I think he deprecated the whole thing, and told us that dairy farming was the best form of agriculture—the most profitable form—at the time in this country. He pointed out that the farmers had discovered from their own experience that summer dairy farming was the best, that they left their cows out on grass from 1st May to 1st January, that they were dry during four months of winter and did not require very much feeding while housed—in fact, that no tillage was required. I think the Minister did not see very much wrong with that policy at that time. I am certain that at that time he did not go so far as to advocate that a man under fifteen acres should till another acre.
I do not think it is fair to accuse me of advocating a stoppage of imports. I did suggest that we should grow our own grain in order to replace that £4,000,000 worth of feeding stuffs coming into the country. If we were producing that £4,000,000 worth of feeding stuffs, and if it were found that we could use more in the country, we might then advocate further tillage, or we might, perhaps, say, "Well, now we are tilling as much as we can afford, taking into account the rotation of crops and the number of years you can allow land to remain in grass before bringing it into tillage again." If, taking all these things into consideration, we were tilling as much as we could till, and we wanted more feeding stuffs, we would have to import them and I would have no objection. I would have no objection as long as we were tilling as much as we possibly could and thereby trying to relieve unemployment in the country, and trying to give cheaper feeding stuffs to the farmers than they are getting by means of importation at present.
The Minister said that my suggestion as to the storing of corn was a commercial proposition and not for the Government. It is very easy to get over an argument like that by saying that it is a commercial proposition. We could very well say, two or three years ago, that the production of butter was a commercial proposition. We could very well say that proprietary creameries and co-operative creameries were a commercial proposition. All those matters are commercial propositions, but the Government finds it convenient sometimes to intervene in commercial propositions. Sometimes they are very drastic, as, for instance, in the case of the electricity concerns, when they think it is good policy. If they do not think it is good policy, it is another matter. To say that the matter is a commercial proposition is not to deal with the question. The Minister asks also if oats are worth 9/- a cwt. why does the farmer not get that price —that it is his business to get it and not the business of the Government to look for it for him. If we said three or four years ago: "The Danish farmer is getting 182/- a cwt. for butter in the British market; why does the Irish farmer not go and get it?" We would have been told it was good policy for the Government to try and get it for him, to make regulations and laws to give him a chance to get that price. If it is not interfering with commercial activities to do that in the case of butter, why should it be wrong to interfere in the case of oats? I do not see why there should be a distinction made as regards the country generally. If the Minister says that it is good policy for an individual farmer to produce more feeding stuffs, to till another acre, and to feed it to his own stock, I do not see how it can be disputed that it would be good policy for the country as a whole to produce its own feeding stuffs rather than import them. In that way, there should be more profit on the feeding.
On the question of bacon, if there is £3,000,000 worth of bacon coming into the country, there is a market there which we should have no trouble in capturing if we set out to capture it. In the meantime we might lose a certain amount of our foreign market, but that is a matter that could be regulated. Even if we did lose temporarily a portion of the foreign market, there would appear to me to be a certain advantage in capturing the home market. There would appear to be some fallacy in keeping transport companies and wholesale buyers on the other side occupied in the distribution of our bacon and in keeping transport companies from China or America and a number of agents occupied in supplying our wants in that respect. There must be a certain loss in that. Surely, if we produce our own bacon and use it at home, it ought to be better value than the bacon which has already contributed a certain amount to those transport companies.
We heard the same old story again— that if we intended to reduce taxation we would have to reduce the Agricultural Grant or drop the Agricultural Produce Act, or do something of that kind. We are told, too, that we would have to cut down the salaries of teachers by another 10 per cent.
Comment on this
The three Acts that have been passed for the benefit of agriculture, the Live Stock Breeding Act, the Agricultural Produce Act, and the Dairy Produce Act, are costing, according to the Estimate, £28,243. In addition to that there are Appropriations-in-Aid amounting to £19,684, making a total of practically £48,000. I said that taxation had increased—we will take it per head—by £4 from 1913 to 1928. By dropping these three Acts we would save in taxation 5d. per head. Five-pence in £4 is not going far. I do not think the dropping of those Acts would save very much as compared with some of the other big things I mentioned. To say that the farmers of this country are paying the very same taxation as the farmers in England is perhaps at first sight true. The farmers in England are paying the same duty on tea and other things; practically all the things they buy cost the same as they cost the farmers here. Income tax does not come into it very much, at least as far as the farmers in Ireland are concerned.
The point is that if the taxation per head in England is the same as the taxation per head here a big amount of the taxation in England is contributed by income tax and corporation tax by commercial and industrial concerns. We have not got the same big industrial concerns here. As a matter of fact, the Minister for Finance told us in the Dáil a few weeks ago that the total valuation on land in England is only 2½ per cent. of the whole, and it is 65 per cent. here. That will give us an idea of the number of big industrial and commercial concerns in England as compared with here. Those people are often taxed very heavily in income tax and corporation tax, but no matter who pays income tax or corporation tax it eventually comes back to the producer. I think the Minister for Agriculture admitted that here on a former occasion. The producer here is, unfortunately, principally the farmer, and therefore the farmer here has to contribute most to the taxes of the country. In England it is quite different. You have production there from many other sources. For instance, there are mines, which we have not got here to any extent at all. There are also big industries turning raw materials into manufactured materials. They are producing, and therefore are contributing a certain amount to taxation. But in this country the farmer is the principal producer, and eventually he has to pay all the taxation. Therefore it is not altogether true to say that, although the taxes on commodities are practically the same in England as they are here, the farmer in England is taxed to the same extent as the farmer here.
With regard to the question of land annuities, the Minister for Agriculture said that that is politics. I will not go into that question. If it is politics we will have a political debate on it some other day. At the opening of the debate I said, in reply to the Minister for Agriculture, that the general price of wheat this year was about 24/- per barrel. I said that, in my opinion—I do not know if I was right—30/- per barrel would induce the farmer to grow wheat. I believe it would, but that is a thing that will have to be found out.
Comment on this
Generally speaking, it was 30/- per barrel last year. I do not know if it were that all over the country, but it was that in Dublin. If 30/- was not sufficient I suppose it would have to be inquired into. It would have to be decided eventually as to what would be the minimum price that would induce farmers to grow wheat to a larger extent than they are growing it at present. I do not believe that it would cost much more than 6/- per barrel to make up the difference. As I said in moving the motion, if the £280,000, roughly, that is given for the sugar beet industry were spent on wheat it would be responsible for the production here of the one and a half million pounds' worth of wheat which is at present being imported, and that it would mean about 100,000 acres of land under wheat. It is quite possible that what the Minister says is true, that it would not increase tillage, that instead of sowing oats or barley the farmer would sow wheat; but if we worked the two schemes together we would eventually make him sow oats, wheat and barley. We would have to keep as much as we possibly could under tillage in order to give increased employment and to get farming established on a more economic basis. The Minister accused me of making only one contribution to the debate. I think the Minister made only one contribution, and that was, that the farmer with fifteen acres would put another acre under tillage and get another cow and another sow. As Deputy O'Hanlon asked, where is he going to get them? That is the trouble. I think Deputy O'Hanlon made a very good suggestion. I believe if the Minister goes down to his own constituency in Galway and calls the small farmers with the fifteen acres into conference——
Comment on this
Fifteen pounds valuation. If he puts that proposition to them I am perfectly certain he will have a very big percentage of them telling him that they are only too willing to adopt that policy, to put another acre under tillage, get another cow. I am not sure about the sow.
Comment on this
Supposing he started with a sow, what would it cost him?
Comment on this
He would get a young one. He would have to wait for three months, of course. It is not a financial question, anyway.
Comment on this
A question arose here about creameries. Surely it should be just as easy for the Government to legislate for the sale of grain on the Irish market as it is to legislate for the sale of butter on the English market. The Minister, speaking on the 26th January, 1927, when introducing a Supplementary Vote, said:—
I need not now go into the question of the sale of Irish butter and indicate the weakness which was inherent in past methods...
and then lower down he says:
Before any new creamery gets the benefit of these credits it must agree to come into that federation and join up with the rest of the creameries in selling its butter in that way.
If that is not compulsion, I do not know what is. If compulsion is being used in that way, why is it—and I believe this is a fact—that the largest producer of food in this country, the Dairy Disposals Board, has not come into this federation?
Comment on this
I think it was published that they did not sell their butter through the I.A.O.S. They do.
Comment on this
I see. I have nothing more to say except to express the wish that my motion will be successful. It would be the best thing that could happen to the farmer.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?