Central Fund Bill, 1929—Second Stage.
Contributions 1–177 of 332. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 1929 ›
I understand that it is the general wish that the discussion on this Bill should not range over the whole field of Government policy and activity, but should be concentrated upon the activities of particular Departments or special points of policy. In accordance with that opinion I intend to devote my remarks exclusively to the administration—a better description I think would be the mal-administration—of the Department of Justice with special reference to the recent activities of members of the Detective Division of the police force in and around the city and neighbourhood of Dublin. During the last two or three weeks a large number of individuals have been arrested and re-arrested, held for periods in police stations and imprisoned, and some of them assaulted by members of the Civic Guard, in whose custody they were. All of them were threatened, and all of them released without at any time having been charged with any offence or brought to trial in a public court. No official explanation or apology has been offered by any Minister for this activity. An attempt made to get from the Minister for Justice information as to the identity of persons arrested, met with a straight, downright refusal. The only information which we could secure or have been able to secure concerning the motives behind the sudden outburst of activity was the statements which appeared in the daily Press, and which, I admit, appear to have been inspired by some governmental authority, and also the references to various matters which were made by various Ministers in election speeches at meetings held in support of a particular candidate. On Monday, 4th March, the President, at a meeting in the Rotunda, said: "A deliberate and organised attack has been launched against the foundations of ordered society." He referred to the murder of a young man named Armstrong, which had occurred a fortnight previously, and the attempted murder of a man named White, which had taken place two months before he made his statement. He denounced and deplored them, and rightly so.
It seems to us to be a very extraordinary thing that the President of the Executive Council should, as Deputy de Valera stated, have kept his denunciation of these crimes in cold storage, and kept the police force inactive and quiescent until the election campaign was in progress. By doing so he has, in my opinion, left himself fairly open to a charge of being concerned less with the safety of individual citizens and the punishment of criminals than with the return of the candidate nominated in the North City by-election by the party of which he is a member. It is the opinion, not merely of members of this party, but of many responsible citizens of every party, that the machinery of the Department of Justice has been operated to make political propaganda for one party in this State, and they hold that the responsible Minister, who either directed its use in that manner or permitted it to be used, has placed himself in a position which very few decent men would like to occupy.
In the same speech to which I have already referred the President said: "If you are to have government you must have law. If you are to have law you must have instruments of law. You must have means of finding out whether a person charged with an offence is guilty or not." He will not, however, put his theory into practice or, at least, he has not done so during the last few weeks. He, the Government and the Department of Justice have been engaged on a campaign to make law and justice the prerogative of the adherents of one party only. Men accused of any crime, no matter how odious it may be, have the right to be faced by their accusers and to be tried in open court. The Government have ignored and abolished that right with respect to the men they are now harassing. We do not know who these men are. We have heard that an individual here and an individual there has been amongst those arrested, but no information has been given to us of an authoritative nature to indicate who exactly are the victims of this campaign. We do not know what they are suspected of. Does the Government know? Does the Minister for Justice know? I do not think so. I believe that they just instructed their police force to show activity, to arrest somebody, to do anything so that they could scare voters by such a campaign into giving their candidate support which they could not get on their policy.
Certain information has been placed in my hands concerning a number of these arrests. There is operating in Dublin City an omnibus company, amongst the directors of which are some men who took an active part against the Government forces during the Civil War period. During that period they incurred the personal enmity of certain individuals now holding high and responsible positions in the police force. Those high and responsible officials of the police force have been, in my opinion, using the power conferred on them as police officers in order to put that particular company out of business. The method they have adopted is the arrest of the inspectors, the conductors and the drivers of its buses, frequently, two or three times a day, stopping buses on the street and taking the drivers and the conductors off them, driving them to prison and releasing them a few hours later. It is quite obvious that these methods will be effective in destroying the business of that company if they are not stopped. I have just secured information concerning the number of times during the last few weeks that certain employees of this company have been interfered with in that way. I select three cases as being indicative of them all. The first is that of an inspector. He was arrested on February 17, while on duty, held for two hours and released. He was re-arrested on February 21, and released at 8 p.m. the following day. He was again arrested on March 4, at 8.30, and released at the same hour the following day. He was re-arrested on March 6, while on duty, and released on March 7. He was again arrested on March 11, while on duty, at 12.30, and released at 6.30 on the same day. During the entire period while he was in captivity he was never charged with any crime whatsoever. The second is the case of a conductor in the same company. He was arrested on February 17, detained for two hours and then released. He was again arrested on February 21, and released on the 22nd. He was re-arrested on March 4, and released next day. He was re-arrested again, I understand, this morning.
Another conductor in the same company was arrested on March 7, released on March 8, re-arrested on March 8, released on March 9, and re-arrested on March 11. Other employees of the same company have been interfered with in the same way. It is the opinion of directors of the company, and of all others who know the facts, and it is certainly my conviction, that the activities of the police force in that connection are not designed to assist in the suppression of crime, but to victimise the political opponents of the Government and to vent the spleen of individual police officers who are abusing the powers conferred on them by the State. Numbers of other young men have been repeatedly arrested in the same way, and on each occasion on which they were released, members of the detective division informed them—and these are the words used in every case: "We will arrest you every time we see you on the streets of Dublin." I want to know from the Minister for Justice, the President, or any member of the Executive Council, what right a member of the police force has to make a threat of that kind to people against whom they have no charge? Are these detectives acting on their own responsibility? Have they, in fact, got out of the control of the Minister for Justice, or are they working in accordance with some definite plan and definite instructions issued from the Minister's Department? If these men are criminals—as I say, as regards the majority I do not know even who they are—and if the Government have any evidence to prove them so, why do they not bring them into court and give them a chance of answering any charge that may be brought against them? Are they even suspected of any crime? I am not yet aware that it is the law of this State that it is a crime to be suspected by a police officer, but even if we could be informed that there were reasonable grounds for suspicion that these men were criminals, then we could understand the motives in part, at any rate, of the Government's action. I do strongly suspect, however, that these men who are being treated in this manner are just opponents of the Government—men who are being branded as criminals in order to make political capital for the Government's Party candidate at a by-election.
I noticed in the evening Press last night an advertisement issued on behalf of the candidate, and there was published in that advertisement a rather fantastic extract from a document alleged to have been found on one of these persons arrested. I want the Minister for Justice to tell us how that document got into the hands of the election agent of the Cumann na nGaedheal candidate in the North City. That document was never officially published. Are we to understand that the officials of Cumann na nGaedheal have the right to go down to police headquarters, examine the files there, and extract from the files any document which they think they can use for the benefit of their Party? If that document was not given to the members of Cumann na nGaedheal in that way, how was it given? Is there some member of the police force who is surreptitiously extracting these documents from the police files and giving them to Cumann na nGaedheal headquarters? The extract that I saw was so fantastic that it was possibly written in the Cumann na nGaedheal headquarters. But whether that is so or not, we have it definitely stated on behalf of the Government candidate that such a document was found on a person arrested on January 30 last. We want to know from somebody who is in a position to tell us how that document got into his hands? If this document was found on some person, why was that person not charged concerning it? The Government will, no doubt, avoid all these straight questions, if they intervene in this debate at all, and they will tell us in very vehement language that crime must be suppressed and criminals brought to justice. We agree. They will be talking to the converted if they talk in that strain. Murder is, of course, a crime, and there is no Party in this State which possesses the same desire to see murderers, all murderers, brought to justice as the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
If the Government held, and always had held, the same attitude to crime which Fianna Fáil holds, there would be much less of it in the country to-day. What is their attitude? Last week in the Dáil a member of the Labour Party. Deputy Hogan, put down a question to the Minister for Justice with respect to certain alleged assaults on individuals by members of the Civic Guard in Co. Clare. He asked: "If I furnish the Minister for Justice with affidavits made before a Commissioner for Oaths in which these men allege that they have been assaulted, will the Minister, with a view to maintaining the status and reputation of the detective division, have an investigation carried out?" and the Minister replied: "I am quite weary of these groundless charges against the Civic Guard." I think the Minister's answer to Deputy Hogan is indicative of his attitude to similar questions on all occasions. Many murders were committed during the civil war period. I do not want to refer to them for the purpose of raising old issues, but we have to face the fact that to-day quite a number of those who were engaged in the commission of these murders are, I believe, holding responsible positions in the police force. The Minister for Agriculture said in a speech recently that Fianna Fáil were afraid of criminals. I make the assertion that the Government are afraid of the criminals whom they were forced to place in responsible positions in the Civic Guards and in the detective division, and that that is, in fact, the true explanation of the Minister's attitude whenever an inquiry is asked for into some particularly brutal piece of conduct in which these individuals engage. It will be remembered that early in 1927 members of the Civic Guard in Co. Waterford broke loose and committed a number of assaults upon well-known Republicans in various parts of the county. I understand that an inquiry was held and that certain well-known detectives were censured, and some cashiered I think—I am not sure if that is correct, but I have been informed that it is so—as a result of the inquiry. Some months later the Minister's predecessor was murdered.
Deputies can connect these two facts if they like. It is remarkable, however, that the Minister for Justice scorns and repudiates and refuses any further demands for inquiries into Civic Guards' conduct. I wonder is he determined that he will not meet with the same fate as his predecessor. When the late Mr. Kevin O'Higgins was murdered a number of well-known Republicans were arrested, charged with the crime, brought into court, not one shred of evidence produced against them, and they were released. No one has been arrested since. The purpose which the Government had in taking that line of action is, I think, obvious. In the public mind they fastened responsibility for that crime upon Republicans in general. But it is an extraordinary thing that, despite the fact that we have been paying 1½ million pounds every year since to maintain a police force, they have been unable to link up anyone definitely with it, and apparently at present all activity in that connection has stopped.
The Minister made a statement some time ago to the effect that Fianna Fáil had never at any time expressed the wish that the murderers of the late Minister for Justice should be brought to justice. I personally believe very strongly that those responsible for that crime were men who were at one time in Government pay, and I would very much like to see them on trial, if for no other reason than to throw a strong searchlight upon the real significance of the Government's boasted courage in the face of criminal activities. The Minister will ask why those people throughout the country who have been assaulted by members of the Civic Guard do not take action in the courts to recover damages. He knows as well as I do the main reason why they do not take such action. In the first place, they are mainly poor men, and it is our experience that whenever action is taken against a Civic Guard officer the case is appealed from court to court, up and down, until it is quite obvious that only somebody with a strong bank balance could ever hope to get a final decision. In other cases, he knows that the reason they do not take such actions is because of fear of the consequences to themselves selves. No matter what damages they get they will have to go back and live in the same area, in which the same Civic Guard, or some other Civic Guard, will still exercise the same measure of power over their lives and fortunes. In the majority of cases, of course, it is due to the fact that the individuals have an outlook not expressed in this House, and would not, no matter how strong their claim, bring an action in the courts established by the Free State Government. But it is an extraordinary thing that in every case I know of, in Kerry, Tipperary and other centres, in which such actions were taken, the judges and juries awarded damages and costs against the Civic Guard officers. I want to know if, in any such case, where a judge and jury gave such a verdict, the Civic Guard officer concerned was made to account for the action which he took.
There was a case in Newport, Co. Tipperary, which was referred to here some time ago. On Christmas Eve members of the Civic Guard, having drunk not wisely but too well, embarked upon a general rampage through the town and assaulted quite a number of individuals. A number of those individuals took action against the officers of the Civic Guards concerned. In some cases the actions were dismissed for insufficiency of evidence. In other cases in the Circuit Court they got decrees for various amounts against Civic Guard officers. There were appeals up to the higher court. Some of the cases were returned for retrial and went down again to the Circuit Court. The case is, in fact, still in the public courts, and has been in progress for the last twelve months. The fact remains that, when the facts were placed before a jury, the jury on two occasions gave a verdict against the members of the Civic Guard. I want to know why the responsible officer, who was a Superintendent of the Civic Guard, and who has thus been convicted by a jury of having carried out an illegal assault upon a civilian, was not dismissed from the force; why he was left in that responsible position, and continues to exercise power and authority over the lives and fortunes of our people.
Other cases have come to our notice where members of the Civic Guard have engaged in the political victimisation of Republicans. Licensed traders have been approached and told that if certain individuals employed by them were not dismissed they would lose their licence. Other employers have been told that certain men were bad characters and should not be employed. But the only thing they had against their characters was that they were political opponents of the Government.
This speech I am making will not, I know, help to secure that co-operation between all parties which is, I think, necessary for the solution of the various economic and political problems in front of our people, but the responsibility for that, however, is with the Government. They went into the North Dublin by-election campaign with a muck-rake, and they cannot complain now if there is a stench which offends their nostrils. Let anyone read the speech of the Minister for Agriculture delivered last Monday. In that speech, he sneers and derides Padraic O Maille, who had been at one time Vice-Chairman of this House, because he is not filled with hate against the individuals who wounded him when they were on opposite sides in the civil war in 1922.
Comment on this
Padraic O Maille was big enough to let no personal animosity guide or direct his conduct. It would be a good thing for this country if some more men in it were as big as Padraic O Maille. I suggest to the Minister for Agriculture, and I suggest to other Ministers, that they should take some lessons in elementary Christianity before they come into public and speak in that manner again. I wonder did the President take into consideration the effect his sensational speech is likely to have upon business credit and trade in general. If the situation existing is one-half or one-quarter as serious as he represented it to be, does he not think that the place to make that speech was not at an election meeting, and was not from a party platform, but was here in this House? If he thinks that is so, but still deliberately chose to make it in such a place and in such a manner as would help the candidate of his party, regardless of the effect upon the general welfare of the community, then both he and the party that stands for these tactics are deserving of repudiation by all decent self-respecting Irishmen.
If they wanted to ensure the co-operation of the citizens of this country, irrespective of their party affiliations, in the suppression of crime, the place to ask for it was not in the heat of an election campaign off a party platform. The President knows that, but he does not want anything at all except to maintain his Government in office and to win a panic vote at a by-election. That is the whole thing. This activity on the part of the police, these sensational speeches, have all been devised for that purpose and for that purpose only. The welfare of the community, the maintenance of law and order, or the preservation of open trial were never considered. Quite the reverse. As long as Cumann na nGaedheal are able to secure the return of their candidate, let all the fundamental rights of the citizens, the welfare of the business community, all attempts to wipe out the bitterness of the past and to secure a better spirit in the future, be thrown to the winds. I hope, now that the by-election is almost over, the Minister for Justice will cease these forms of activity. There is no longer any necessity for them. There is no immediate prospect of a by-election in the next couple of months. If the Government has evidence against any men that would prove they are criminals let them arrest them, and let a judge and jury decide. If you have no evidence, however, then leave them alone until you have. That is their right. In taking that right from them, you are abusing the power the people gave you.
Comment on this
The speech made by the Deputy who has just sat down is a speech that, unfortunately, in this place, I cannot categorise as I should like to. The Deputy complained, I think, primarily that certain people had been arrested. He suggested that that was done to assist in the by-election. He gave the dates of the arrest of certain individuals. I think his first date was the 17th February, next the 21st, then the 4th, 6th, 7th, 8th and 11th March. Now, on the 20th February a man named Armstrong was brutally murdered. He was murdered, as the Deputy is morally certain, as the result of an organisation, and he was murdered because he gave evidence in court. There was an organisation behind that. I do not know what information the Minister for Justice may have. I am morally certain that that organisation has its messengers going about the city. I have reason to believe, independent of police knowledge, that part of the means of communication is by employees of 'bus companies, railway companies, etc.
Our experience in the last seven years is that amongst those people who blandly call themselves "Republicans," there is an entire failure to realise what I may call the ethical side of citizenship. We have seen it in the Fianna Fáil Party within the last year. I refer to an occasion of 28th March, when I asked Deputies on the other side should they at any time get any information that would be useful to get the murderers of Kevin O'Higgins would they put that information at the disposal of the police? What was the reaction of that Party? Deputy Little said it was absurd to ask such a thing; it would bring odium upon them. Deputy Cooney said it would mean becoming police informers. Deputy Fahy implied that he recognised that it was a duty on them to give such information.
In a public speech last Sunday, I said that as far as I could judge it seemed to me that the attitude of Deputy Little and Deputy Cooney was the attitude approved by the other side, and that the attitude of Deputy Fahy was not the attitude approved of. It may be that the proprietors of a certain bus company are supporters of the party opposite. My observations in the last seven years have been that amongst those people who believe they have a right to keep their tongues silent when by speaking they could bring a murderer to justice—and if Deputy Cooney and Deputy Little speak for the Opposition, then that party is amongst such people—there has been a complete failure to recognise the duty that rests upon them as citizens and as human beings subject to the moral law. Such people are prone to give employment by preference to men associated with illegal organisations. I do not know, but I think that, seeing that an attempt was made to murder a juryman a couple of months ago, those dates—17th February, 21st February, March 4th, 6th, 7th, 8th, 11th, etc.—formed a period during which, in a country where things are as they are in this country, it was very natural that there should be a number of arrests.
Comment on this
The Deputy says: "If you have a charge and have evidence against people bring them into the court and let them face the charge." The Deputy knows as well as I know, and every Deputy opposite knows perfectly well that when you have an organisation working one can have a moral certainty that certain people have been associated with criminal acts without being able to prove it. For instance, suppose Deputy Lemass's legitimate successor in the office of Minister for Defence, which I believe he occupied until the end of November, 1925, utilising the authority that Deputy Lemass claimed when he occupied that office up to 1925, the power of life and death, decides that Mr. A or Mr. B should be executed. He wishes to convey that to Mr. Aiken's successor as Chief of Staff, who happens to be at the other side of the city. He may send a message verbally or in writing. Suppose the police, knowing there is an organisation operating to murder citizens in this State, have very good reasons to believe that messages of such a nature are being carried, are they to stand by and let these things occur and say, "We must not do anything, we must not raise our hands until we have complete evidence that can convict a man in the court"? I said here years ago that the well-being of the State is the supreme law. The State exists primarily and fundamentally for the maintenance of social order. Murder is the greatest crime against social order. Everybody in this House knows perfectly well that when an organisation is operating it is possible to know that people are morally implicated, morally parties to crime. They have their messengers and agents going about. The Deputies say these people must not be touched. Murder may happen, but the Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party, if they had information, would not dream of giving it. Still it is the right of the gentle murderer or his friend to be untouched until such moment as the police have, by a miracle, got complete evidence against them that will convict them in the court.
Comment on this
Everyone knows that at a given point a truce was made on July 11th, 1921. The Treaty was signed on December 6th, 1921. That was the turning point. It was a change from alien government here to a native government.
Comment on this
For practical purposes, yes. What I would like to know from the Deputy is this: The Deputy right into 1925, and calling himself President of the Irish Republic, had his Ministers who were calling themselves the Government. They had their staff and their army, meaning that they claimed powers of life and death. I would like to know at what moment that power they claimed, ceased to exist in people outside this Dáil, at what moment was it that the authority of this Dáil became legitimate and ceased to be illegitimate? I quite agree that there was a period of civil war. Then there was a "down arms" in April, 1923. I understand the situation changed after that moment, but after that moment the arms were not surrendered. People claimed to be a Government. That is, they claimed a power over life and death. They were fired out of that position. Other people have taken that place. What is the moral line of the Deputies opposite? They say they do not condone murder. I do not say they do. I have no doubt that they very much regret those two recent murders as being politically inconvenient for them.
Comment on this
Let us give the Minister as good a hearing as Deputy Lemass has got. This debate cannot continue unless one side gets as good a hearing as the other. There is no other basis. Otherwise it cannot be continued.
Comment on this
I assure you I thought I was saying something almost complimentary to the other side. I am quite prepared to agree that the Deputies do not condone—
Comment on this
If we are to get the same opportunity as the Minister for Defence is getting we are quite prepared for it, but what I want to know is, if this debate is going to be continued as you suggested, is it in order for a Minister to say that we regret certain deeds simply because they were politically inconvenient for us?
Comment on this
I did not exactly say that. I did not say they condemned them "simply because," but I cannot help thinking that that element of inconvenience may have given an additional objection. I am quite ready to believe that the Deputies opposite are far from condoning murder but I want more. The Party opposite are the second largest Party in the country. They are almost asking us to believe that they are to be the next Government. A little over a year ago I tried to get from the Party opposite—not for Party purposes but because I think it is very important to get it in this State and I would be very glad if they came out and said it—two things, one, not merely that they condemned murder. They are the second largest Party and they believe that they are going to be the next Government. Two Deputies got up and in reply to a question of mine said that even though they knew exactly who was the murderer of Mr. O'Higgins—to quote a phrase I used before, "the nine ways of sharing the guilt of another's sin," which I was taught as a child—they would share in the guilt of that sin by silence and concealment. I tried to give them an opportunity on Sunday last but the papers did not report me fully. I said I was anxious for the Party opposite to go out and tell me that they condemned murder. It is the duty of every citizen but pre-eminently the duty of those who say they are the largest Party and are to be the Government next, to do all that in them lies to bring the murderers to justice and if the Deputies can do that and give an assurance to this House and through this House to the country that the whole force that the Party commands and the whole information it may have that may be useful for bringing murderers to justice, are to be placed at the disposal of the State nobody will be more glad than I.
Comment on this
I am anxious for the Party opposite to make its position clear. If they get up and state that clearly I will not question it. I would like also another thing. I would like them to say exactly how it was and what the circumstances were which made it a perfectly moral and legitimate thing for Deputy de Valera to call himself President, Deputy Lemass to call himself Minister for Defence, and Deputy Aiken to call himself the Chief of Staff, and to have a body of men under them calling themselves an army. I would like them, not for my own sake, but for the country's sake, to show us how they removed from themselves what I considered to be a moral handicap. I would like them to show how it was that the authority they claimed then was right then, but not right for the other people outside now who claim it. I would like them to say when it was and how it happened. Apparently, it did not happen in April, 1923. It was some time after that. It was some time, presumably, earlier than November, 1925. Even if they have to admit that they were doing a considerable amount of humbug when they were posturing in these positions, I would like to see it clear. Even in the speech of Deputy Lemass here, he suggested clearly that the late Minister for Justice was murdered by people who had been in the Government service, and that the murder was a result of justice being meted out to them in the Government service. I do not believe that Deputy Lemass believes that. He knows perfectly well that there is a moral certainty amongst the whole people of this country that the late Minister for Justice was murdered by people who belonged to an illegal organisation, that he was murdered because he was Minister for Justice in this State, and as Minister for Justice he had done his duty while he occupied that position. Is there anyone but Deputy Lemass who does not know that that is the fact?
Comment on this
I say I am morally certain of it. I do not believe any Deputy in this House doubts it.
Comment on this
We want to get to a position where the police do not require extraordinary powers and do not require to use them. How are we going to get to it? An attempt was made to murder a man named Harling by a would-be murderer named Coughlan. Obviously, this was an occasion for the co-operation of every Party, but here in the Dáil allegations were made and there was a judicial inquiry into the matter. Before that judicial inquiry had brought in its findings, the Party opposite had a Fianna Fáil club called the Seán Coughlan Club. The results of the inquiry came out showing that this man called Coughlan was a would-be murderer, but, without waiting for the result of the judicial inquiry, the Party opposite called one of their clubs after the would-be murderer. The Deputy has suggested that nobody more than the people opposite deprecate things that have been happening recently. There is an organ called "The Nation." It is edited by Seán T. O'Kelly, a Fianna Fáil Deputy. It is actually, if not nominally, the official organ of the Party opposite. There was an attempt to murder Mr. White. As a result of that, we gave protection to certain jurymen. On the 20th February Mr. Armstrong was murdered, and in that paper, in effect the official organ of the Party opposite, and edited by a member of the Party opposite, of the 23rd February, three days after the murder of Armstrong, what do we read: "Prisoners notes are usually gloomy reading, but we are glad this week to be able to give some cheering items." Then it goes on to say that the jurymen who were misguided and cowardly enough to sentence the gunman Healy on the 3rd December have to be protected by police. That is the cheering item. Jurymen who swore to bring in a finding they considered proper and who failed to commit perjury were misguided and cowardly. We are told that it is cheering news to know that they have to be pro tected by the police, and that that protection is injuring them in earning their livelihood.
Comment on this
No, sir; it is under the column headed "Prisoner's Notes" which appear more or less weekly.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy suggest that the editor of a paper, as a responsible man, has the right to put in his organ, to circulate in this country, a document calling upon the people to rejoice that jurymen have to be protected against murderers, and that jurymen who refuse to commit perjury at the behest of the gun-bully are to be injured in earning their livelihood because they have to have police protection? Are the Deputies opposite running away from it? Are they prepared to say that it should not have been published? Does the Fianna Fáil Party disown that document and the paper that published it?
Comment on this
Does the Minister disown the advertisement appearing in this morning's paper, regarding the North Dublin election?
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy is referring to. Do they disown this organ which is practically the official organ of the Fianna Fáil Party, rejoicing that as a result of the murder of one juryman and the attempted murder of another, jurymen are to be injured in earning their livelihood because they have to be protected against men who claim in 1929 the powers that the Party opposite claimed up to the end of 1925? Then Deputy Lemass told us that there is no Party in this country in a supererogatory position and that nobody more than they condemned murder. I suggest the publication of that paragraph, in that paper, edited by that man, associated with that Party, associates everybody associated with that publication, with the murder of Armstrong and the attempted murder of White. Then we are told that we are trying to make Party capital out of this.
Here is a very serious situation in this country. Here is a great party, the second greatest party in the country, handicapped morally because other people are only claiming the authority they claimed previously, and they have not told us up to the moment in what way the authority they claimed ceased to come to their successors in the organisation that they were associated with. Let us have it clearly once and for all. They told us that they condemned murder but if they know who the murderers are, they are not going to tell anybody. I am not wanting to put this in the form of charges. I am most sincerely anxious that the whole Fianna Fáil Party should get up, like Deputy Fahy, and tell us that they intend, in office or out of office, to do all that in them lies to bring these murderers and members of these associations to justice. I do not believe that the speech of Deputy Lemass complaining that people associated with or suspected of being associated with these things, are being arrested and kept for two hours takes in anybody in this House. We all know about that; we belonged to organisations. We went about and took good care that there would be as little evidence as possible against us, unless we were actually caught in the act. Everybody knows that there is this organisation, and that members of it are about the town. The job of the police is to try to get these people, and it is the job of the Deputies in this House to do nothing to handicap them in doing that work.
With regard to the men the police are harassing, men who are in an organisation plotting to commit murder in this country cannot be too harassed. I am not satisfied that there is personal enmity on the part of police who are in high and responsible positions against the proprietors of a bus company. Is the Deputy opposite prepared to get up and assure us that nobody employed by this bus company, whoever he may be, is in any way associated with any illegal organisation? Can he get up and assure us of that?
Comment on this
I do not say they are, but I am prepared to believe, seeing that the police have arrested certain men, that there is very good ground for believing that some of them are.
Comment on this
This is more important than any cliché or anything else that the Deputy learned from British Liberalism in the nineteenth century. Are they suspected? he asks. I am prepared to believe that they are, and I am prepared to believe that there is reasonable ground for suspecting them.
Comment on this
Why do you let them out, then? It will not frighten them if you keep them in, because they are used to it.
Comment on this
"There is no Party in this State that possesses the same desire to bring all murderers to justice." Well, the Deputy says that to-day. Why did he not get up and say it on the 28th March last when I put the thing clearly before the House? The Minister for Industry and Commerce came back on it again and again, but we could not get anything from the opposite benches. All we did get was a statement from Deputy Cooney and Deputy Little that to do such a thing would make them informers. If the Deputies opposite ever become a Government would they, in cases of murder, give the police information?
Comment on this
Will the Minister give us the names of the gun bullies who are all over the country at the present time?
Comment on this
There was a necessity to have an amnesty resolution in 1923 which covered all that. Apart from that, the Deputy can rest assured that I stand for bringing every murderer to justice, and, as an ordinary citizen, apart from being a member of the Government, if I had any information that I thought would be useful to the police in bringing murderers to justice I would give it to them. I would feel it my duty as a human being, bound by the moral law, to give that information. The Deputies opposite seem to think that the Fianna Fáil Party can make or unmake the eternal laws just as it suits their convenience. I cannot say what I would like to say about the suggestion that the late Minister for Justice was murdered by members of the police forces. I am satisfied that no Deputy in this House believes any such thing.
Comment on this
I, for one, have heard it suggested in practically every place where the matter was spoken of. It has been commonly suggested.
Comment on this
Will the Minister assure us there was an attempt to find the guilty people in political spheres other than the Fianna Fáil and the Republican Parties? Was there any attempt made to find out who murdered the late Minister for Justice amongst the Cumann na nGaedheal people or the police, or was all the attention confined to those people who are Republicans? I would like a straight answer to that question.
Comment on this
The police went out on every track that they considered likely to lead them to the murderers. I can quite believe that the people associated with that murder are most anxious to put it on to the police. Deputy de Valera has now told us that everyone he met who discussed the matter thought so.
Comment on this
Was any attempt made to discover the murderers in circles other than Republican circles? I would like a straight answer to that question.
Comment on this
Every possible attempt was made to find them. If the police had confined themselves entirely to Republican circles they would have saved themselves extra trouble and would be more likely to get their men. Much time was wasted in looking up other circles for them.
Comment on this
Does time make any difference in murder? That question has been brought up. Is there going to be a time limit put to it?
Comment on this
Only in case of war where you bring in an amnesty. There was an amnesty brought in in 1923.
Comment on this
I do not believe the Minister or anyone on those benches opposite. In connection with the murder of the late Minister for Justice no attempt was made to find the murderers in circles other than Republican circles. I say that as a responsible Deputy.
Comment on this
I am satisfied that I and my colleagues gave every possible encouragement to get after the murderers, whoever they were.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass is much concerned that employers were told that Republicans in their service were bad characters. But the Deputy's organ rejoices that employers are almost driven to discharge employees who did their duty as jurymen, because the murder gang have made it necessary to protect them. The Deputy talks about co-operation between all Parties. I know that Deputies opposite do not believe me, but I can assure those Deputies that I have time and again come on to those things because I feel it is necessary in the interests of social order. Where social order is concerned, all other matters are only secondary in governmental and State affairs. The all-important thing is the maintenance of social law and order. On that fundamental point all decent citizens and all lawabiding people can be united. I think it is important that the Party opposite should make it perfectly clear that far from wanting to curry support from the enemies of the State, they stand for cutting down rigidly any attempt to overthrow social order here, and that they stand for bringing to justice every enemy of social order in this country whether he be a murderer, the associate of murderers, or merely associated with an illegal organisation.
Deputy Lemass, filled with Christian charity, is horrified that the Minister for Agriculture referred to what might be called an obscene statement by a Mr. O'Maille. I think the Minister for Agriculture was not exactly reported in the Press. I on Sunday, and he on Monday, referred to Mr. O'Maille's pride in shaking hands with the man who murdered Seán Hales. I went further, and said that no doubt when Fianna Fáil came into power they would make him a judge, and when the murderer of Kevin O'Higgins would be brought before him, tears of appreciation would come into his eyes as he came from the Bench to ask permission to clutch the murderer's hands, and he would shake those hands, saying that he was sure the man thought he was doing right when he committed the murder. No doubt, when the murderer of Mr. Armstrong would be brought before him he would come down again and ask permission to shake hands with the murderer, and with tears in his eyes, he would say he was sure the murderer thought he was right in what he did.
Here we have the Party opposite saying they are to be a Government at any minute, and as far as murderers are concerned, they are prepared to shake hands with them. provided that the gentlemen who committed the murders thought they they were doing right. How can one maintain social order in a country where you have that hypocritical humbug preached under the cloak of Christian charity?
Comment on this
I do, quite, but I would not be a party to any amnesty that sentenced me to be proud when I shook hands with the murderer of my friends.
Comment on this
The Minister is quite confident that the Minister for Agriculture was misreported. But the "Independent" and the other papers are so favourable to us that we were quite accurately reported.
Comment on this
I know that happened in my own case, anyway, and I understand it happened in the case of Mr. Hogan's reference to Mr. O'Maille and the murderer of Seán Hales. I do not pretend to be a lawyer, but as the Deputy refers to the amnesty, I presume that but for the amnesty Mr. O'Maille would be at this moment in jail as an accessory after the fact. Mr. O'Maille is getting the benefit of the amnesty all right.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass said it would make more for stability if the President's statement was made not in an election campaign, but in the Dáil. Personally I feel the election campaign was the more appropriate place.
Comment on this
I most carefully dealt with these matters on Sunday last. People in elections are electing Governments. The Government exists for the maintenance of social order. The people's first duty is to consider the matter of social order. If the two parties are agreed on that, then we can give the subsidiary matter, such as whole-hog protection or protective tariffs, a secondary place.
On the 28th March last, I asked the Deputies opposite to give information. They said "No." Three days after the murder of Mr. Armstrong, the semi-official organ of the party opposite comes out with the "good news" that jurymen have to be protected. They make assertions with regard to jurors who refuse to commit perjury. There was the case of a man who was at one time associated with the Deputies opposite. When jurors refuse to commit perjury and refuse to find a man innocent when he is guilty, they say they are misguided and cowardly. It seems to me that the party opposite has not come out clearly on the question of the maintenance of social order. They say that they, less than anybody, condone murder, and they condemn the murder of Kevin O'Higgins. From a party that says it is going to be the Government we need more than that. We need them not to be morally handicapped, and we need them to be able to get up and say, "We will put this thing down." When a man says, "You did this in 1923," or anything like that, they can say, "We were wrong, then," or "Owing to circumstances, what was right then is not right any longer. The authority we had then is not possessed by you. We are going to treat all cases of assassination by you as murder, and you are going to pay the penalty for it." I feel that this thing must be met clearly, and as long as we have this element in the country, the murder organisation will continue. The Deputy casts doubt on the documents that are found on prisoners when arrested. The Deputy can rest assured that horrifying statements are found on people arrested.
Comment on this
I know nothing about that. We have the murder gang about, and we have the Party opposite who have not, as far as I know, made it clear that they are going to give any information that they have in their possession to bring murderers to justice and to put down plots that are existing against the State. Once we have the position clear from them, I think it will be good not only for them and for us but for the whole country. I ask them, before they demand that the police be very careful to make sure that they have complete evidence against persons before they interrogate them or examine them, to make it clear that we must have a condition in this country that would justify such a line. I do not think that you have that condition in any country in which you have an association plotting against the State. These nice phrases that Deputy Lemass rolls off like a Mr. Gladstone do not really apply. The first condition is that life be safeguarded and social order maintained. If there is a moral certainty amongst the police that a man is in any way associated with murder or associated with crime I feel that the police ought to arrest him. But I do think the position will be better when we have the Party opposite saying, as we say to the murder gang, that any information they have is going to be used to bring those men to the gallows when they commit murder. They do not need to say that here. They can do it in some public place. Let them tell us exactly when the position changed. It was not in 1923 when the order to "down arms" was given. How are we to have proper stability when only about one week ago, Deputy O'Kelly got up and referred to me as the "so-called Minister for Defence"? I do not mind that personally, but it seems to me that that remark meant that he challenged the authority of this Government. It meant that every time this Government sanctions the execution of a criminal, that as we have not the authority of a Government, we are thereby committing murder.
How does Deputy Lemass explain that remark of Deputy O'Kelly? Does Deputy O'Kelly recognise or does he not recognise the authority of this Dáil? I am only Minister for Defence because I was made so by the Dáil. The Deputy said "so-called Minister for Defence." What did that remark mean? The only thing I understand from it is that he denies the authority of the Government set up by the Dáil. If he denies that, it is conceivable, especially reading what I read in his paper, that he recognises that the power of life and death lies in some body of people outside the Dáil. Therefore, when some ordinary criminal is executed, we are murderers. When somebody outside the Dáil, belonging to some organisation that Deputy O'Kelly thinks has authority that we do not possess, assassinates a man, then that is merely an execution. If they murder a juryman that is an execution. I would like to have these things cleared up.
I feel that Deputy O'Kelly's remarks last week were dangerous remarks for this State and for the people of this State. I think it is time that the Deputies opposite would make clear what is meant when Deputy O'Kelly speaks of a "so-called Minister for Defence." I would like if they would make it clear what is meant when he says the Free State is dying and that it cannot die too quickly for him. This Deputy publishes in his paper a statement about "cowardly and misguided jurymen," one of whom was almost murdered. As long as there is an organisation outside operating for murder the police must not halt in getting after it in any way they think feasible. Remember that the position is made worse when we have a Party like Fianna Fáil in this House, I will not say flirting with the people outside, but which has failed so far to make clear what is their attitude towards the authority of the Government in the Dáil and towards the people outside who claim the power of life and death. I am ready to believe Deputy Lemass that when they gave the "down arms" order in 1923 they considered all that had ended, and it was only amateur theatricals when Deputy de Valera called himself President of the Republic and when we had talk about the Army, the Chief of Staff, the Minister for Defence, and the rest of it.
Comment on this
We are asked to state clearly what our attitude towards this House is. I have on more than one occasion said exactly what our attitude was. I still hold that our right to be regarded as the legitimate Government of this country is faulty, that this House itself is faulty. You have secured a de facto position. Very well. There must be some body in charge to keep order in the community and by virtue of your de facto position you are the only people who are in a position to do it. But as to whether you have come by that position legitimately or not, I say you have not come by that position legitimately. You brought off a coup d'état in the summer of 1922. We heard the President of the Executive Council talking about the independence of the Judiciary the other day. Here I see members of the Cabinet of the Government of the Republic but when a matter was brought before the Supreme Court of the Republic—a Habeas Corpus action—what was the result? The answer to that was to suppress the Republican Courts. You are in favour of the independence of the Judiciary when it suits your purpose, not otherwise. And if you are not getting the support from all sections of the community that is necessary for any Executive if it is going to dispense with a large police force, it is because there is a moral handicap in your case. We are all morally handicapped because of the circumstances in which the whole thing came about. The setting up of this State put a moral handicap on every one of us here. We came in here because we thought that a practical rule could be evolved in which order could be maintained; and we said that it was necessary to have some assembly in which the representatives of the people by a majority vote should be able to decide national policy. As we were not able to get a majority to meet outside this House, we had to come here if there was to be a majority at all of the people's representatives in any one assembly.
As far as I am concerned the only Constitution I give "that" for, the only thing that I think I am morally bound to obey in this House, is a majority vote, because you are all elected by the Irish people. As a practical rule, and not because there is anything sacred in it, I am prepared to accept majority rule as settling matters of national policy, and therefore as deciding who it is that shall be in charge of order. When the change came about, the Ministers on the opposite side were very anxious to try and keep, and have been anxious in the past to try and keep, this House from going back on the circumstances of 1921. They think that their propaganda— they have had two or three years of it, to say the least—has had such an effect on the minds of the people, and that the public memory is so short, that their view of it is going to hold. Their view does not hold with us. Some of us know the circumstances quite well.
We know that when the Four Courts were attacked, they were attacked despite the Truce, that the ordinary means that could have been taken to avert that disaster—the bringing of the House together— were not taken, and that we were involved in civil war. I for one, when the flag of the Republic was run up against an Executive that was bringing off a coup d'état, stood by the flag of the Republic, and I will do it again. As long as there was a hope of maintaining that Republic, either by force against those who were bringing off that coup d'état or afterwards, as long as there was an opportunity of getting the people of this country to vote again for the Republic, I stood for it.
My proposition that the representatives of the people should come in here and unify control so that we would have one Government and one Army was defeated, and for that reason I resigned. Those who continued on in that organisation which we have left can claim exactly the same continuity that we claimed up to 1925. They can do it. I differed with them because, as I have said, I had to recognise there was some body who would have to keep order, that there was a de facto position created, and that for the good of the community generally, and with the hope of restarting, it was necessary to try and get a unified assembly.
When I was listening to what I certainly felt was hypocrisy on the part of the Minister for Defence, I could not help thinking of the Gospel scene when the hypocrites asked that a certain crime should be punished. The answer, I think, was, "Let those without sin cast the first stone." When you have an Executive in this country whose hands will be clean, and who will not be murderers themselves, then you will have the Irish people standing up for them. The Ministers opposite laugh. They come here and they taunt us because we say that we will not pursue and use every means in our power to bring to justice those who have been exasperated by their action. They are simply repeating what every British Minister who had to do with Ireland in the past repeated. There is not a single statement made by one of them that cannot be paralleled from Irish history during the 19th century.
The Ministers talk about murder and the moral law, and apparently the Minister for Defence thinks that if an amnesty is passed here that it is going to abrogate the moral law. That is not my opinion in any case. Those Ministers who talk and expect that the whole of the citizens here should be outraged in their sentiments the moment that they speak of murder forget that they themselves, before they put to death Erskine Childers, executed four young boys at Kilmainham.
Here is what was said by the Minister for Justice on the occasion on which he said that this was going to be done. He said:
If this were merely an average case, it may perhaps have been because it was better at first to take the average case, to take cases which had nothing particular, no particular facts about them to distinguish them from the cases of thousands all over the country who are leading the nation to death. If you took as your first case some man who was outstandingly active or outstandingly wicked in his activities, the unfortunate dupes through the country might say, "Oh, he was killed because he was a leader," or "he was killed because he was an Englishman," or "he was killed because he combined with others to commit——
I think "crime" is the word. Now this was the excuse——
Comment on this
I will have the reference copied. That was on the occasion on which it was announced that there were four boys going to be executed in Kilmainham before Erskine Childers was executed. There was no execuse for putting these four boys to death except to pave the way for the execution of the man who had been blackened by propaganda and whom they wanted to get rid of. Shortly afterwards, in Mountjoy, four other men were taken out and put to death. If the killing of these four men on that morning was not murder, I do not know nor does anybody else know what murder is. When an Executive comes along whose hands are clean of murder, then perhaps you will get from the people general co-operation. But I doubt very much if the appeals that have been made by the Minister for Defence and others are going to have much weight with the people, or that the people will think that there is any sincerity behind them when they come from men who themselves are not in a position to throw the first stone.
Reference has already been made to the case in Clare. Perhaps before I come to that I should say that those who are the agents of the Ministry were not long learning their lesson. The example which the Ministry set was quickly taken up by their agents. We had in one week men who were taken out and blown up by a mine at Countess Bridge, Ballyseedy, Ballyhar, and near Cahirciveen. Not one of these men has ever been brought to justice. They were maintained and kept in their positions. They were openly defended by the Ministry, and there has never been any attempt by the Ministry to bring these people to justice. When we ask here of the Minister for Defence to protect the individual citizens against the outrages that are committed against them by the C.I.D., and when we ask him to use his power of discipline over them to keep them right, we are told that the ordinary civil proceedings are open to the individual citizen. I think it was Deputy Lemass who pointed out that you might as well say there is no redress, because we know full well, as we have pointed out, that these cases are appealed and appealed. They have no funds by which they could bring these people to justice, and they feel that if they were convicted in some way or other the Executive would protect or compensate them. The feeling generally is that the Executive are afraid, are absolutely afraid, of the tools they had in the past, and that they cannot exercise over them the powers of discipline that would be effective. If we are going to have here these questions of co-operation discussed, we will have to have them discussed in quite a different tone from that adopted by the Minister for Defence.
We are anxious to spare the country any further trouble. We came in here in order to assist in doing that. We have pointed out time after time that the way to do it is to remove any barriers that would prevent the representatives of all sections of the people coming here. It can be done. There is not a single member of this House who thinks for a moment there would be any difficulty about it, and you will achieve more in doing that in the securing of public order than you will with all your appeals and denunciations. You have achieved a certain de facto position, and the proper thing for you to do with those who do not agree that this State was established legitimately, and who believe that as a matter of fact there was a definite betrayal of everything that was aimed at from 1916 to 1922, is to give those people the opportunity of working, and without in any way forswearing their views, to get the Irish people as a whole again behind them. They have the right to it. You have no right to debar them from going to the Irish people and asking them to support the re-establishment, or if they so wish to put it, to support the continuance of the Republic.
They have the right to demand, if they are able to convert the Irish people into a majority in favour of the maintenance of the Republic or the re-establishment of the Republic as the de facto institution, that they should be given that opportunity. If you deny them that, if you are going to continue the methods that have been adopted of harassing them constantly, you are going to have repeated against you what was done against the British Government in the past. There is no use in your blinding yourselves to the fact that you are regarded here as simply continuing in another form British authority, that you are the agents of British authority in this country, and any other Executive that get into your position will have the same moral handicap, except they are able to get the acceptance of some common assembly.
Comment on this
The Deputy should make personal references in the third person. It is less exciting.
Comment on this
I meant them in the third person sense. The Executive have been trying to use force, and have been using it all the time. If they are going to meet force by force then they cannot expect the co-operation of citizens who wish that there should not be force. I know perfectly well that any Executive carrying on must have some final sanction. Surely the existence of that final sanction does not mean that it is to be used before common sense is used? One would imagine that the present Executive had never been anything but British Ministers. That is exactly the attitude they are taking up. They say, "Our position is quite different. We are the Irish people's Government," but if they are so certain of that why should they bring off a coup d'état? Why then do they not go in the ordinary way and establish it properly and get a proper vote on it? It was agreed that the register that had been in existence since 1921 was out of date, and instead of giving the opportunity for a proper register they again came along and said, "It is our policy to change and everybody else must change with us." Well, they found it very difficult to get certain people to change, and they are only thinking of force as the remedy for it. We say that force is not the remedy for it, and that there is no use whatever in appealing to anybody to help the present Executive unless the Executive take up a line which will be morally supported by the people as a whole.
Comment on this
I suppose it was in the nature of things that some day and that some time despite your valiant efforts to the contrary, A Chinn Comhairle, we would have a debate of this kind in the House. Perhaps it is as well that we should have it. Personally, as one who had nothing to do with these unhappy events which are being debated here to-day, and as the Chairman for the time being of a Party who were not involved in these unhappy events, I had made up my mind not to intervene at this stage of the debate and on this particular subject. There are other things of more interest to us and the people we speak for— matters of social concern which we had hoped to speak about on this Central Fund Bill—but I feel I would not be doing my duty as a representative in this House if I did not give my views on the points which have been raised in the rather extraordinary speech of the leader of the chief Opposition Party in this House. Before I go into that, I want to mention a few points with regard to the two main issues which were raised by the first two speakers.
There can be no question, there must be no question, that the very basis of social order in this country is the right to the jury system and the preservation of the jury system. Interference with that right, anything that would sap that system or hinder its proper working, is something that must be condemned by every right-thinking person, something that all right-thinking people must co-operate in putting down, and putting down as strongly as it is possible to put it down. Everyone of us stands for that, and is prepared to give the fullest co-operation with any Government or any party that will stand for putting down that. I want to make that quite plain. I want to know where we stand here. I want to know from the Leader of the chief Opposition Party, who may be the President of the Executive Council of this State in a very short time, and who might possibly look to receive support from our Party to put him into that position, where we stand? Have we a Government in this country? Who is the Government of this country if those people who have been voted in by the majority of this House are not the Government of the country? I do not agree with the policy of the present Government; I am in opposition to the present Government; but I am forced to recognise that while they are there they are the custodians of law and order in this country until we put somebody else in their place, and it is the duty of all right-thinking men to obey the laws while those laws are there. It is our duty to make the laws; it is our duty to see that, in so far as we can—we may not always be able to do it—the laws are equitable. But as responsible citizens it is also our duty, once the law is made, to obey that law and to do our best to see that it is obeyed until it is changed in this House. That is a fundamental principle that must be, I think, accepted by everybody—by any of us who has any respect for law.
Now, who is the Government of this country? Where are they if they are not the Party that is sitting there? If they are not, who is the legitimate Government of this State? Deputy de Valera made what to me sounded as an extraordinary statement when he said that those who now claim to be what I took him to mean the legitimate Government of the country are people who are outside this House, who are not represented in this House. That was the conclusion I drew from what he said —I may be wrong—but that was the clear inference when he said that they could claim the same continuity and authority as they themselves claimed when they were in that position, and we know what they claimed when they were in that position. And he has come in here, has taken part in the work of this Assembly, taken part in the making of laws for this Assembly, while he now says that this is not a legitimate Assembly, that the legitimate authority and Government of this country reside in some body outside this House. That to me is certainly a most extraordinary statement, and I think it is a statement that will not serve the interests of this country and will not serve the interests of the community as a whole. I thought, and I had hopes, that we were getting away from that. I was looking with confidence to the building up of political parties here who would be prepared to fight out their political differences in a constitutional way. No one will deny—I certainly will not deny, and I do not think that anyone denies—the right of any citizen in the State to go out on a public platform to-morrow and say that the proper form of government in this country ought to be a Republican form of government.
Comment on this
Might I ask Deputy O'Connell if he thinks you have a constitutional way of settlement as long as a section of the people are definitely debarred by a test oath from coming in here?
Comment on this
I am prepared, as the Deputy knows—I went into the Lobby with his Party—to get away from those tests. I do not want those tests; we never stood for those tests, and if the Deputy gets into office as President of the Executive Council in a Government which he declares and admits is a legitimate Government, I am prepared to help him in every way I can to get rid of these tests if I am here at the time. That is the attitude of this Party. But we must get back to fundamental principles. One cannot come here, take part in making laws, do everything that an Assembly like this ought to do, and at the same time say: "This is not the Government at all." We must have it either one way or the other. I said I had hoped that we were nearing the time when all this would be forgotten, when we would have got away from this, when we could meet here and discuss matters of great importance to the community, social matters such as have been discussed and very ably put forward from those benches and supported by us on practically all occasions. That is what the people want, in any case. The people are fed up with and sick of this kind of talk that goes on here on occasions of this kind. They do not want to go back to 1921; they do not want to know what happened in 1921; they want to forget it; it is the one thing in their history that they do not want to have raked up in their faces in this country or in other countries, and it will do them no good. It may not be, of course, right that that should be so, but it is so, and I believe that in saying that I am more truly voicing the views of the ordinary common people of the country than anybody is who says that the people are thinking, and continually thinking, of the things that happened in 1921 or 1922. And the reason why I think that Deputy de Valera was on the wrong track in the line that he took to-day rather than when he and his Party advocate social reforms, industrial development and the betterment of the country from that point of view, is this, that it encourages that attitude of mind out of which disrespect for the law grows and has grown, that attitude of mind which leads to the terrible things that he, no doubt, as much as we, is prepared to condemn.
But it is that attitude of mind that I object to, that statement by a responsible Deputy who may be head of the Government any day, that statement that there is no legitimate Government, and ipso facto, that any Government formed by this House will not be a legitimate Government—because it must mean that. If this body of individuals, elected by the members of this House, are not a legitimate Government, then no body of individuals elected by this House will be a legitimate Government; therefore they will have no right to enforce law and order, and therefore the men who stand up against them, break and abuse their laws, commit what we call a crime and what they say is a legitimate act, will have no respect for the law, and they will claim as their justification the statement that was made by the Deputy to-day. That is the thing that I see wrong about it, and I regret very sincerely that it should be so. But I think this is really not a Party matter; it is a matter that I think ought to be faced in a way other than a purely Party way. There were things done in 1921, 1922 and 1923—terrible things—and no one regrets them more than I do; perhaps no one protested more strongly against them than I did. But we want to forget them, and in the name of God let us forget them. There was one point that was raised to which I would like to refer. I thoroughly agreed with Deputy Lemass when he stated that the speech that the President made on a political platform in the Rotunda ought to have been made in this House, if it was necessary to make it. If the President found it necessary to make this statement and to give this information, here was the place to do so, not on a political platform, because it was a matter that concerned, not his own particular Party, but every Party in the House.
There is another matter to which I want to refer. Reference was made to an advertisement which appeared in the papers yesterday, and again I support the point made by Deputy Lemass, and very strongly support it. I will quote from the advertisement. "Here are extracts from a document captured from one of the election workers on the 30th January last"—"election workers" is in inverted commas:
We must devote all energies towards destroying Ministers' persons and property. Train all members in use of firearms, bombs, laying of mines, etc. Concentrate activities on houses of Ministers and public officials. Blow up theatres, cinemas and places of amusement.
That is what is issued by the election agent for a particular candidate. With Deputy Lemass, I want to know where was that document found? By whom was it found? Was it found by the police? If it was, was it quoted in public court, and if not quoted in any public court, how did the writer of the advertisement get hold of it? Has the person on whom that document was found been brought to trial?
Comment on this
Has he been brought to trial? If found in possession of that document, I take it, he should be brought to trial. Has he been brought to trial? We want some explanation. The Minister for Defence deliberately avoided giving any explanation or said he did not know. I say that it is the business of someone on the Government Benches to know how a document that was in the possession of the police apparently got into the hands of the advertisement writer of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. The House is entitled to an explanation on a matter of that kind, which deliberately associates a Party in this House with people who are found in possession of documents of that kind.
There is just one other matter that I will mention with regard to the action of the police. I do not agree with the action, or the line of policy, taken up by the Minister for Justice in regard to irregularities committed by the police. His line is, as I understand it, that if they break the ordinary law let them be prosecuted. That is as far as I understand his attitude. That is not the usual attitude in the case of Government servants and of servants of other Departments. There are departmental regulations to be observed, as well as questions of ordinary law, and I have no hesitation whatever in saying that if a policeman is convicted of assault, or of any crime that makes him unworthy of being a policeman, then he should be no longer a policeman.
Comment on this
Does the Minister admit that there is no person in the police to-day who was convicted of conduct of that kind?
Comment on this
I say there is no person in the police to-day who was found guilty of conduct justifying his dismissal from the force.
Comment on this
It is a plain answer, but who is to be the judge?
Comment on this
I am only expressing my own view when I say that a person who was found guilty by the Court of things which members of the police force—the Waterford incident was referred to—were found guilty of, in my humble opinion, and I speak as an ordinary citizen—a man in the street if you like— ought not to be a member of the police force if we are going to have that respect for our police force that we ought to have. I know, and the Minister for Education knows, that people engaged in his Department who may break the law, are not only punished for it, but the Department will hold an investigation afterwards, and I say rightly. Whether the law says a man is to be convicted or not the Department will act, and the Minister for Education knows a case where a court found a man innocent of the charges brought against him, but the Department had its own regulations, and had its own investigation and dismissed the man, because it thought he was not worthy to hold the position, and, in my opinion, quite rightly dismissed him, because he was not worthy to hold the position. But the Minister for Justice takes a different attitude. He says: "Let the law take its course." There is more reason for such a course in this case, because they are the instruments of the law, and there should be strict regulations in regard to them.
It is not good for the police themselves, it is not good for the force, and it will not engender that respect that I say all citizens ought to have for the police if that attitude is taken up, if on all occasions the Minister for Justice feels himself bound to defend the police? We had a case in another country not very long ago where quite a different attitude was adopted, and we must not take it for granted that, though the police as a body may be very good in carrying out their duties, there is not a black sheep in every flock, and the flock will be all the better for getting rid of the black sheep.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will not take up the attitude he seems to be taking, that if charges are brought they will not be investigated in his own Department, but that if people are found guilty in the way some have been found guilty they will be brought to justice, and not only that but dismissed the force, because they are not people who ought to hold a position which should command the respect of the whole community, no matter to what party they belong.
Comment on this
I have had notice from Deputy O'Connell of at least one other matter that is to be raised to-day on the Central Fund Bill. Deputy Lemass expressed very admirably at the beginning of his speech what the views of the Chair are with regard to the debates on the Central Fund Bill, and this debate, although one might not imagine it, purports to be on the Ministry of Justice and on certain recent actions taken by the police. I want to indicate to the House that that matter must be concluded at some particular moment so that other matters might be taken up. I do not want the debate to continue on more than one subject at the same time.
Comment on this
Before I come to deal with the speech—a very extraordinary speech, in my judgment—which Deputy Lemass delivered to-day I will shortly deal with what Deputy O'Connell has just said, that is, the question as to how my Department deals with irregularities in the conduct of the police. If one were to take Deputy O'Connell's words, knowing nothing about the facts, one would come to the conclusion that no men were ever dismissed from the force; one would come to the conclusion that no inquiries were ever held into the conduct of men in the force; one would come to the conclusion that the force was a force in which discipline was lax. The very opposite is the case. Whenever the conduct of a man comes under suspicion it becomes the duty of his authorities to investigate his conduct. That investigation is always and under all circumstances carried out. Men are dismissed. Very frequently there are complaints against Guards against whom no charges are promulgated in the courts or in this House. In every case inquiry is held by the officials responsible for the maintenance of discipline in the Guards, and upon these reports action is taken and the Guard is appropriately dealt with. Deputy O'Connell said that men are dismissed from the Department of Education—National Teachers and the like, I suppose, who have been acquitted of charges in the courts. It is exactly the same with the Guards. A man who was recently acquitted by a jury in the South of Ireland was discharged from the force. On the other hand, when there are rather trivial cases of assault it is considered by the authorities that dismissal is not necessary—cases in which assault arose under tremendous provocation and in which the juries have found that the assault was not serious.
We come back now to the old Waterford case which is always brought up in this House. What are the facts of the Waterford case? Guards, young men, unarmed, were foully murdered when doing their duty. I have heard denunciations of the Guards for attacking people, but I have never yet heard denunciations of the men who murdered the Guards. On that occasion the Guards did use a certain amount of violence which they were not justified in using towards persons in their custody. These cases were made the subject not only of an ordinary inquiry by the police force, but of an inquiry by a special tribunal set up by the then Minister for Justice, and certain sums were awarded to the persons who were attacked. These cases were subsequently brought into court, and verdicts were awarded by a jury, but they were very small verdicts. I did not anticipate this debate or the turn it would take, so I cannot at the moment give particulars of the amounts awarded, but, unless my memory is very wrong, the largest sum awarded was something like £30, and the smallest, I think, either £5 or £6. That is to the best of my recollection. In these cases disciplinary action was taken, but, considering all the circumstances and the provocation under which these men acted, it was not considered that dismissal was necessary in any case. That brings me to the statement, the terrible statement, which was contained in the speech of Deputy Lemass, who said that as a result of the inquiry in the Waterford case one officer was dismissed, and the Deputy went on to say that following close on that event the then Minister for Justice, Mr. Kevin O'Higgins, was murdered by the Guards. That is a terrible statement to make.
Comment on this
Did the Deputy not say that Mr. O'Higgins was murdered by the Guards? What were his words?
Comment on this
What did Deputy de Valera say? Did he not say that he heard it repeated again and again?
Comment on this
That is a different point. This is a specific point about the Waterford case. The Minister says that Deputy Lemass stated that the late Minister for Justice was murdered by the Guards. I think we should give Deputy Lemass an opportunity of stating what he did say.
Comment on this
I said that it was my personal belief that he was murdered by men who were at one time in the Government pay.
Comment on this
It is contrary to my practice, and I do not like doing it now, to make clear what Deputies have said. The particular case at issue is the Waterford case, and the Waterford inquiry was connected specifically this evening in this House with the murder of the late Minister for Justice. I think we should go no further in regard to that and leave it there.
Comment on this
That was the impression left on my mind. If Deputy Lemass did not wish to convery that impression. I would like to know what impression he did wish to convey.
Comment on this
The impression I wished to convey was that the Minister for Justice had enemies outside the Republican movement, men who knew how to use a gun.
Comment on this
Then am I to take it that the Deputy did not make the statement connecting that murder with the Waterford incident?
Comment on this
The Deputy says there is a possibility. I like plain, frank, open statements, but I do not like hedging.
Comment on this
We will not all run away. I have a word to say. I do not say that Deputy Lemass is running away.
Comment on this
We have heard from Deputy Boland and Deputy de Valera the statement that they have heard, at any rate, that members of the Guards were associated with that foul murder. There is no contradiction there. Deputy de Valera does not run away. He stands his ground on this occasion. Am I to take it so?
Comment on this
There is no possibility of conducting any debate in this House if Deputies will not listen to their opponents. I suggest to Deputies who are interrupting that if Deputy de Valera's speech had been received with one-hundredth part of the heat displayed towards the Minister for Justice the place would be in an uproar. Deputies should listen to the arguments of their opponents.
Comment on this
Here is this charge from Deputy de Valera, backed up by Deputy Boland, that the late Minister for Justice was murdered by members of the Guards. I have heard in this House again and again groundless charges made against the Guards, but I did not think that any Deputy in this House, without the slightest shadow of evidence, without the possibility of producing one shred of evidence, would degrade himself to the position to which Deputy de Valera and Deputy Boland have degraded themselves to-day.
Comment on this
Why were charges made against Republicans without evidence? That is what I want to know.
Comment on this
I am perfectly ready and willing to deal with that. I say that there are persons here who, without a shred of evidence or shadow of foundation, without being able to produce the slightest bit of evidence, even suspicion, are bringing charges against a force like the Civic Guards, persons who are not fit to black the boots of the youngest recruit in the Guards.
Comment on this
Too much, to his bitter cost. You have the chief murderer in this country in your employment. If you want his name we will throw it across.
Comment on this
You may. Any statements that come from Deputy Boland after his statement to-day would be treated with the contempt it deserves.
Comment on this
It is flung up to the Civic Guard that the murderers of Mr. O'Higgins have not been found. I admit that there is no evidence, no conclusive proof, at the present moment, that could be brought into court as to the murder of Mr. O'Higgins. If you get this association, the same association, I believe and I have reason to believe, that has murdered young Mr. Armstrong and tried to murder Mr. White, you get an association in which members plan secretly. There are five or six men, they have relays of motor cars to get away, and it is very hard to obtain convictions in those cases. In the case of the late Mr. O'Higgins it was harder still, because the murder was done at a time when there were only one or two persons who could possibly identify the murderers. I myself, and I am speaking deliberately, have far from abandoned hopes that those men who so foully murdered the late Mr. O'Higgins will yet expiate their crime on the scaffold. Of course the idea of Deputy de Valera and Deputy Lemass is to cut down the Guards by half; let crime flourish, let us have only half enough Guards.
Comment on this
They have stopped it. Deputy Lemass does not want them to stop crime. Deputy Lemass does not want them to prevent crime being committed. He does not want them to search for documents persons who they know are engaged in a criminal conspiracy.
Comment on this
Why do they not charge them with it? Because there is a great deal of difference between knowledge and complete legal proof.
Comment on this
To be suspected by a detective is a very good reason why you should be searched and a very good reason why you should be prevented from committing crime. Deputy Lemass said that these searches were carried out because there happened to be an election campaign in progress. Was it because there was an election coming on that there was an attempt made to murder poor Mr. White? Was it because there was an election coming on that poor young Armstrong was murdered? Is that the point?
Comment on this
No, they followed quick and hard on an attempted murder in one case and a successful murder in the other. That is the explanation of the timing, and when the election is over I can tell the Deputy that exactly the same steps will be taken to prevent a recurrence of crime of this particular nature. Deputy Lemass for the first time to-day seemed to denounce, not by name, but rather by a generality, this murder and this attempted murder. It is the first time I have heard crimes of that nature denounced in this House by Opposition Deputies. I have again and again asked in the House that they should denounce this class of crime. Again and again I asked the Opposition whether they considered that perjury by jurymen was lawful, and I could get no answer. Again and again I have charged the Deputies with moral cowardice in being afraid to express opinions which, at any rate, I hoped they held. To-day Deputies seem to have got a little more courage. To-day Deputies, though rather tentatively, as far as Deputy de Valera was concerned— he comes along with his excuses and palliatives and all the rest of it—have specifically denounced, though not so specifically as I would wish, that particular class of crime. If Deputies would get up in this House or on platforms and would deliberately say that every man, who murders a juryman or murders a witness, is guilty of wilful murder, they would certainly raise themselves in the estimation of most persons and they would cease to be regarded as potential sources of strength by the persons who commit those crimes.
Comment on this
We will stop murder; do not be in the least afraid. We will stop it very successfully. We are told that these speeches frighten people, upset confidence and all that sort of thing, and that that was the result of the President's speech the other day. It is not by shutting your eyes to what happens that you master conspiracies of this nature. It is by recognising that those conspiracies are in existence and taking every necessary means of crushing them. It is not a widespread conspiracy. It has not got a tremendous number of men in it. It is a conspiracy which is losing ground day by day. It is a conspiracy, the members of which are already losing heart. It is a conspiracy, the members of which know that every single person in this country, who values the name of this country, and who believes in the Ten Commandments, is against them, and, outside their own wretched little circle, the only bit of exhortation or the only bit of encouragement they get is from speeches like that which Deputy de Valera made here to-day.
Comment on this
I want to say as definitely as I possibly can that at no time did I stand for murder. I am prepared to denounce the murder of prisoners, jurymen or witnesses, as strongly as any member of this House. The Minister who has just sat down has taken good care to mention only the Guards. I have had some complaints against the ordinary Guards in the way of doing electioneering work, working for the Cumann na nGaedheal, and batoning people at odd times, but I never charged them with murder. The Minister supplied the very sentence I wanted in making my case against a particular section of his police force, the C.I.D., when he said that knowledge is a different thing from complete legal proof. That is the position some of us are in. There is a gentleman, who is going to be nameless—I can tell the Minister privately his name, but he knows it probably as well as I do—and who was associated with shocking murders in 1922 and 1923, at present employed in the C.I.D. If that is information for the Minister he must be living with his head in the sand. It is commonly believed in this city that the gentleman who was involved in the Waterford murders knows more about the murder of the late Minister for Justice than any other man in this country.
Comment on this
I am glad the Minister corrected me if I said murder. I meant the Waterford beatings. I am going to say this to the credit of the late Minister—he took a firm hand against people of that sort. I know he cleared them out of the Army as far as he could. I did not love the Minister, but I am going to be just to him. He cleared as many of these people as he could out of the Army, but some of them stopped in the police; he could not clear them out of the police. He ordered an investigation—so the story goes, and there is a circumstantial case for it—a complete investigation into these Waterford beatings, and was satisfied that certain things were done which should not have been done, and these men were ordered to be dismissed. The Minister may laugh, but I am telling him what is believed by all responsible people in the country and in the city.
He ordered these men to be dismissed and those whose hands were stained with murder in the old days and who were involved in these beatings. I say that there was at least a prima facie case for investigation, and I have almost certain knowledge that there was never any investigation in that direction. If the Minister likes to put that down to a charge against the Civic Guards he can do so. I want to be as definite as I can. I say that in a case of a murder of that kind he should always insist, where there are reasonable grounds for suspicion, that the police should act. They have not to have definite proof; the judge and jury have to decide that. I defy him to say that those people who were involved in that inquiry were hauled up and an investigation held. I am sure they were not interrogated in the way people on our side were, with the muzzles of revolvers stuck into their ribs. I have almost certain knowledge that these people were completely ignored. The Minister for Defence referred to the coming time when these murderers would be brought to justice. As everybody knows that this Government is going out soon, he has the idea that the Government which will succeed them will not be afraid to get after these people. I must pay him that tribute anyhow. I suppose the tribute he paid us was unconscious; whether it was or not, I shall give him the benefit of the doubt. He certainly did say that the murderers of Kevin O'Higgins would be put on trial.
Comment on this
I said I had not given up hope that the murderers of Kevin O'Higgins would reach the scaffold.
Comment on this
I was referring to the Minister for Defence—the Minister for War. Reference has been made to last March. It was pointed out last March from these benches that these criminals attached to the C.I.D. were deliberately stirring up strife in the country, and an appeal was made to the Government to call them off, but nothing has been done. Instead of that, terrorism by them has been intensified—everybody knows it —with the inevitable result that there is trouble still in the country. There is no necessity for C.I.D.—at least for that particular section; there is certainly for a detective force which will investigate criminal conduct and look after robbers, thieves, murderers, and people like that. There is no justification for keeping people like the gentleman I, spoke about and his associates still in the pay of the Government.
I am going to repeat what Deputy Lemass said, that there is only one explanation for the evasive way in which the Minister replied to the charges of misconduct against these people, and that is a regard for his own skin. That is all I have to say on the subject, except that the sooner you call off these political C.I.D. men, these survivors of the murderers of 1922, the better for everybody, both in this House and in the country in general.
Comment on this
I wish to deal with a few matters, and I regret that the Minister for Justice has left the House. There is in existence in my constituency amongst the C.I.D. a definite conspiracy to drive certain young men out of the country and to incite others to commit crime. A fortnight ago a list of these cases was sent to the Minister for Justice by one of my colleagues, and the Minister has not had the decency to send a reply. These were cases where young men were held up constantly on their way to work. A few days ago one young man going to work in Ford's factory was held up by C.I.D. men, taken away for the day, and released that night, without any charge being made against him or any questions being asked of him. On three separate occasions recently one of the checkers on the Great Southern Railways has been taken from his train at Limerick Junction and Mallow and searched by C.I.D. men. What is at the back of it all? It is a deliberate attempt to have these young men driven from their employment. I have another case of a young man from Cobh who, within the past six months, has been searched at least seven times every week, sometimes four times in the one day. On Christmas Eve that young man and a comrade were arrested and charged with housebreaking and kept in jail for three weeks. When they were brought before the District Justice one of the C.I.D. men who were bringing the charge was being cross-examined when the District Justice stopped the case and dismissed the charge without even hearing any evidence for the defence. That is a deliberate attempt to drive certain young men out of the country on account of their political opinions. Ministers talk of murder. Recently a Peace Commissioner was shot in Cork by a C.I.D. man.