We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Vote 64—Army.

Contributions 92–204 of 204. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The Minister has given an estimate of £10 as a token Vote. What is the estimate really?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think we can conduct this debate by way of question and answer across the House. We should conduct the debate in the ordinary way.

Comment on this

That is what I am objecting to.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is the usual practice and procedure.

Comment on this

I am suggesting that it is a bad practice and procedure, and that it is wasting the time of the House and the Minister, and preventing us from getting on with the job.

Comment on this

As far as my calculations go, I estimate that the service given as indicated by this Vote of £10 will cost nothing. A man gives half an hour of his time to the service—you know how it works out in any big establishment—you cannot map out five minutes here and five minutes there and say that is worth so much. But the whole assistance that will go to those people will undoubtedly be worth more than £10, and the actual extra cost to us I calculate is nil.

Comment on this

It is included in the £10?

Comment on this

The extra actual cost to us will be nil. I may be wrong, but that is what I think.

Comment on this

You may be wrong. I am suggesting that you may be a hundred per cent. wrong or ten thousand per cent. wrong, and anything that you have just said has shown that the figure was founded upon nothing but pure guessing. That is all I am suggesting. And the fact that such a query was raised by Deputy Derrig in relation to previous irregularities——

Comment on this

The Deputy might be right when he says I might be ten thousand per cent. wrong. We have more ground than is used at any one moment We have hangar accommodation there for more planes than we want. Therefore I do not calculate that it will really cost us anything, with repairs at cost, plus 7½ per cent. overhead charges. Even if men possibly having a few spare moments threw them in, that would be a gain. There is free use of an office in a hangar, not otherwise used. Of course there are periodical improvements. The place would require to be repaired and this office would be repaired as well as the rest. Even if these people were not there it would be repaired all the same. The Deputy can assess a certain amount of cost for general maintenance of the hangar, and we really would have to maintain it even if these few planes were not here.

Comment on this

Are we to assume that the labour given to the Irish Aero Club voluntarily or charged for would be included in the £10? What is the total amount of assistance that is given at Baldonnel to the Aero Club? What I am driving at is: surely the garrison assist the club in other matters besides the one the Minister mentioned. Surely they help to get off the planes and so on. Is there not a certain amount of manual labour connected with the landing and the getting away of the planes in which the garrison assist?

Comment on this

The officials at Baldonnel never assist. There is no compulsory labour on the part of any soldier at Baldonnel to assist anybody unless he wishes to take part.

Comment on this

Are any payments made by members of the Club to army ranks in Baldonnel? Are any payments made to certain soldiers by members of this club in Baldonnel?

Comment on this

I presume not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps the Deputy will address the Chair.

Comment on this

This brings us back to the whole question as to why this aerodrome is there, what is it there for, what it accommodates and what it does. What is the £6,000 for extra lighting charged this year?

Comment on this

That is for Customs purposes.

Comment on this

£6,000 for Customs purposes. How much do we expect out of the Customs by aeroplanes?

Comment on this

I would like to know if I am to answer each question in this way?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the Minister should not interrupt the Deputy. Let Deputy Flinn make his speech.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister is interrupting me at all.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not a matter of what the Deputy thinks. It is a matter of what the Chair thinks.

Comment on this

The Minister is, for once in his life, serving the House in trying to give a Deputy information. I want to know what this £6,000 is for, and to have that afterwards definitely correlated against some revenue that is coming from it. The Minister will recognise that this is the first intimation to the ordinary member of this House that £6,000 for lighting is charged for Customs purposes. Certainly if in the Army Estimates £6,000 is to be put down for that entirely extraneous purpose of Customs we ought not to have it dragged out merely by cross-examination. It is perfectly new to me.

Comment on this

It is not a separate sub-head. It is down in our barrack maintenance and minor works. Baldonnel is a recognised aviation station. As such it has to fall in. There may be 10,000 planes there next year, or there may not be any. It is an internationally recognised aviation station, and has to have accommodation ready at night. Its value is not solely on that ground. Men must be trained for night flying, and if it is an internationally recognised aviation station it must fulfil the required conditions.

Comment on this

We have an internationally recognised aviation station, but for the spending of £6,000 we must get some definite revenue, and we must get that co-ordinated and put up against some value we are receiving. Why should we not have ten recognised aviation stations and spend £6,000 a year on each for maintenance? I want to know what the aviation branch of this Army is doing for the country? How many aeroplanes have we? The Minister would not like to tell us that, or to tell us what they are doing. With the exception of carrying the President to an election meeting, and with the exception of going out during the Cleggan disaster, a very brave and a very meritorious effort to attempt to find people lost, and as a jumping-off ground——

Comment on this

On a matter of information, is it not a fact that the 'plane that carried the President was private property?

Comment on this

You are wrong. I shall bet you £100 on it. Will you take it?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps the Deputy would address the Chair.

Comment on this

Then through you, sir, I will offer to bet the Deputy £100. The publicly known work of the aviation branch up to the present is restricted to three or, according to Deputy Byrne, to two efforts of that kind. What else have they done? What is to be put upon the other side of the expenditure made upon that branch except to ask for trouble; except to say that this country, which cannot put into the field an Army of more than six thousand men, is deliberately saying to every air fleet in the world: "We are capable of military attack and defence in the air and we are prepared to take the consequences." What else have we to show for it? If ever there was folly, if ever there was criminal folly, committed by a fool in relation to a weakly circumstanced country, such as this, which was greater than for us to start a sort of anaemic toy air service in the name of military service and ask for all the risks of an effective air service by so doing, I would like to know what it was. If there is any other folly as great as that I am sure it would have to be matched out of the military record of the Minister for Defence.

It is time that this House asked itself whether it is getting one single penny of value, or ever has got one single penny of value from that air service. I can understand that air service being now transferred into a civil service; I can understand it never having existed, but I cannot understand the pretence that it ever was to this country anything but a military danger. As at present constituted and run, it can never be of any value in war or peace to a country circumstanced as ours. It is time the Minister gave up fooling or pretending that he has got an Army or has made it an Army.

The Minister's memory has been recalled to-night to a disgraceful scene in this House when, after he had read a carefully-prepared manuscript in relation to the Army, and when he had gone through all the flapdoodle of pretending that he had organised the service and divided into units an organised military force, a colleague of his in the Cabinet, a Minister of some importance, came into this House and kicked him into the corner, laughed at him and his Army and told us that it was not worth a damn. The Minister remembers it. He remembers the Minister for Agriculture telling this House— because he ignored the Minister—that everything said by the Minister for Defence was pure flapdoodle, that the Army was not an army. One or the other of the Ministers was deliberately lying or ignorantly stating what was untrue. Either the Minister for Defence was right and was dealing with an army, or the Minister for Agriculture had some justification for his statement; but if the Minister for Defence was right, then he should not be upon that bench now, having heard the Army actually called useless rubbish. If the Minister for Defence were sincere in defending this as an army, he should not be in the same Cabinet with the man who said it was not an army, that the one and a half millions spent upon it as an army was a fraud and a farce and that, in fact, our Army was only an adjunct to the C.I.D.

The Minister for Agriculture may be right in saying that this is an Army of no military value, that it could not last a minute in the actual test of military conditions, that it is an armed C.I.D., and that it is a gunman's gang akin to what the Chicago police keep in reserve and put out when the ordinary police are gone. If the Minister for Agriculture is right in saying that, then he ought not to be in the same Cabinet with the man who deliberately attempted to fool this House into the idea that we were spending one-and-a-half millions on an Army. If either of these men was right, and if this House had any respect for itself, the Cabinet that contained them should not be here or in any other Parliament. Now, it was lying——

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Is that a Parliamentary expression?

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Does it really matter very much?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think that Deputy Flinn all through his speech could be a little more moderate in his expressions. He has accused either the Minister for Defence or the Minister for Agriculture of deliberately lying and of deliberately deceiving this House. These are expressions that should not be used.

Comment on this

Or, in ignorance, saying what he did not know to be true —that is what I said.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy said that either the Minister for Defence or the Minister for Agriculture was deliberately lying ——

Comment on this

Or——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy said deliberately lying.

Comment on this

Or——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not dealing with the Deputy's alternatives, but with what he actually said, and his expressions ought not to be used.

Comment on this

Either the Minister for Agriculture was culpably and privatively ignorant of what the Army existed for, or the Minister for Defence was culpably and privatively ignorant of what the Army existed for. The Minister for Agriculture, in effect, said that the Minister for Defence was privatively ignorant of what the Army was for, and the Minister for Defence, before the Minister for Agriculture spoke, said, in effect, that what the Minister for Agriculture said was the truth was not the truth and that he had an Army.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy ought to get away from that and get away from it at once.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

That is the issue that the country will ask to have decided. What is the Army for? Is it a military police force or is it an adjunct? We would like the Minister to tell us what is going to be done with the Army. Frankly, I do not know. I incline to the belief that when the Minister for Agriculture laughed to scorn the definition by the Minister for Defence of the functions of the Army, that the Minister for Agriculture was telling the truth, that it was not an army, and that reasonable men on that Bench knew it was not an army which was masquerading under the title. Now, if it is not an army, are we prepared to pay £1,500,000 for an armed adjunct to the Civic Guard and the C.I.D.? If we do want an armed adjunct to the C.I.D. and the Civic Guard, is this the best armed adjunct? Is that a proper way in which to organise it? Is this a proper price to pay for it? Here is one Minister who said it was not an army. And the other Minister has now gone out and left it undefended as far as he is concerned—

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

He is not done yet, go ahead.

Comment on this

I do not know whether we are in order in proceeding with the discussion of the Army Estimates without any representative of the Minister present?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is quite in order.

Comment on this

To me this is a problem and it is not a problem which is being made any more easy of solution when that bold, unbiddable child, the Minister for Agriculture. contradicts in his own Department the responsible Minister's definition as to the functions of that Army. My difficulty, and I think there is a real difficulty, is that there is no logical basis upon which you can erect such an Army. The Ministers know it, and that is why they are playing about between one definition and another. They know they cannot stand on either of these definitions. They have got to play about between them.

What logical basis can you have in a divided Ireland for an army in the South? The suggestion is that this is a sovereign State. There is no man more anxious to exaggerate the status of this State in relation to the authority from which it drew its existence than I. The more you can exaggerate, the higher you can put the status of the Free State as against the English Parliament the better. But if you do accept it as a fact that this State could, from that origin, attain sovereignty, you must accept it as a fact that another State inside this country can obtain sovereignty in exactly the same way. One of the functions of a sovereign State, unfortunately, is to have an army. Exactly upon the same logical basis you can build up in this country another sovereign State with another army—two sovereign States within these boundaries, two States that have the right and the power to instruct their armies to kill the army of the other portion of Ireland. There is no logical basis upon which that can be defended. You have to take the right of this State as against the rest of Ireland to be a sovereign State in the sense of having the power of life and death over members within and outside her borders.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is now travelling a long way altogether from the Vote.

Comment on this

The real difficulty is to find what this Army is for. I am formulating the question again. It cannot resist outside aggression of any important kind. It is cumbersome, expensive and inefficient as a backing to the civic force. It is playing about between two functions which are utterly irreconcilable. It is not a good Army. It is not a bad Army. It is an irrelevant force which has no relation to any actual existing problem which is or can be in this State as a permanent entity. Which is right and which is wrong? Which Minister did show privative ignorance of the function of the Army?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy ought not to go back on that again. He has used that phrase already half a dozen times.

Comment on this

I sincerely hope now that it will be in the recollection of this House that, speaking officially in relation to the Department for which he was responsible, and defining the functions of the Army which he was supposed to control, that the Minister was contradicted in every particular and detail as to the functions of that Army by the Minister for Agriculture when he said that it was not an army——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must——

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture said what was a police force ——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I must ask the Deputy to discontinue. There are two things that Deputy Flinn will have to realise. First he must give way to the Chair——

Comment on this

I sat down and gave way to the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Not very graciously. When the Deputy has been told that he must not indulge in such repetition then he must not do so.

Comment on this

In speaking on this debate on various occasions I dealt with what seems to me to be the overstaffing of the Army Medical Service. I am glad that some reduction has been made since last year. But when that reduction is examined it is not a real reduction. I say that because if the number of medical officers in the Army has been reduced by nineteen, the total strength of the Army has been reduced also and the relative strength remains pretty much as it was. At the present time you have one qualified medical or dental practitioner for every 218 men. That ratio to my mind is far too high. In the poor law service in the country everybody knows that on an average there is one doctor to every 5,000 people. In that service the doctor has to deal with children, the old and infirm and with both sexes. He has to travel long distances between dispensaries and he is exposed to getting far more calls than a doctor in the Army. The doctor in the Army is dealing with people who, ordinarily, should never be ill. He is dealing with a young Army which I take it is in the very best condition physically because they were subjected to examination on entrance. Therefore, I maintain that in a country like this which already is overtaxed, one doctor to every 218 men is altogether out of proportion.

Deputy Sir James Craig spoke about hospital accommodation. He said that we could very easily close one of the large military hospitals. On a former occasion I asked the Minister the number of beds occupied in the various hospitals and the cost and the number occupied in St. Bricin's and the Curragh combined. That number was 189 per day last year. If the Army is smaller this year than last, if there is a reduction in its strength then we naturally expect that there should be a reduction in the number of patients, and it is plain as the noonday sun, notwithstanding the defence made by Deputy O'Higgins, that one hospital would easily accommodate all the patients in the Dublin-Curragh area.

Not alone that, but you have, in addition to this hospital, an hospital in Athlone, an auxiliary hospital at the Curragh, and you have hospitals in Cork. Athlone is within easy reach by ambulance from Dublin, and so is the Curragh, and the Curragh is within easy reach of Dublin. I would have expected that Deputy Dr. O'Higgins, as an ex-Director of Army Medical Services, would have made a better defence for that section. Neither he nor any other speaker on the other side of the House even ventured to suggest that there was any justification for the cost of this service. The Minister for Defence will, no doubt, give us figures as regards costings and so forth, but the fact remains that you can send patients to any civilian hospital—and I say this without fear of contradiction—for two guineas a week, either to fever hospitals or to surgical and medical wards. If a military patient, however, goes to St. Bricin's he will cost 11s. a day, as compared with 6s. in a civilian hospital. The cost per day at the Curragh is 9/8; in Athlone 11/10, and in one hospital in Cork last year I know that the cost was 15/- a day. Fifteen shillings a day amounts to five guineas a week. There is no justification for treating military patients at five guineas a week when civilians can be treated for two guineas a week. I expect that the Minister will at least show us how the cost is so high, and also how it is that patients in one military hospital can be treated at 9/8 per day. In one case at Portobello the cost was 7/-. Perhaps the Minister will tell us why the cost varies from 7/- to 15/-.

I submit that in this particular service, not alone in the number of medical and dental practitioners, but in the cost per patient per day, there is room for a big reduction. Looking through the reports of some of the debates in former years, I noticed that Deputy Cooper moved a reduction of the Estimate by some thousands of pounds.

If he were in the House this evening he could move the same amendment in regard to this particular service because, owing to the reduction in the total strength of the Army, there is a case to be made for a reduction of the number of medical officers. Even if we were to allow that the Army is not overstaffed, there is no justification for the present hospital costs. It is time that the question of closing down some of these hospitals was considered seriously. There is no use in keeping a hospital in Athlone with ten patients and three nurses, at the Curragh with fourteen or fifteen patients, and at a time when neither of the large hospitals in Dublin or Cork is taxed to thirty per cent. of its accommodation. The total number of patients in Dublin and the Curragh at any time, owing to the reduction in the strength of the Army, would not tax the capacity to the extent of fifty per cent. of the combined hospitals. There is no justification for keeping two of these hospitals open.

Comment on this

I have carefully searched the Estimate in the hope that I would find a certain new departure. Coming from a constituency which has very important fisheries along its coast, I hoped to see some steps taken towards providing us with a navy. I must say that this deficiency on the part of the Minister is not very creditable, especially when we remember the number of foreign trawlers which are sailing around our coast

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is on the wrong Estimate. He has made a mistake.

Comment on this

Very well. We will take that as a deficiency. None of the members opposite seems to know what the Army is for. In regard to sub-head A 2, "Resignations, retirements and discharges," I must say that the ordinary private soldier leaving the Army is being very unfairly treated while the amounts given to officers are outrageous. When an officer leaves the Army he gets anything from £500 to £1,400 with a pension to boot. I know several cases of private soldiers who served in the Black-and-Tan war and who retired during the past few years but who got no pension whatever. That is grossly unfair especially when such large sums are paid to officers, young men full of health and strength. Considering the present position of those who have to find the money, namely, the farming community, such amounts are outrageous. Deputy Dr. O'Dowd referred to the medical service and I know that the pay of officers in that service amounts to £24,650 for 6,000 men. As a member of the South Cork Board of Assistance, I know that we had complaints from dispensary doctors about having to attend the wives and children of soldiers. I think that with a medical man for every 180 soldiers they ought to be able to look after the wives and children of these soldiers instead of having to put them as a charge on the rates. I know that £2,550 is put down for the cost of the horse show circus which is travelling Europe. When the unfortunate farmers read the cold statement in the Budget some days ago that they were to get no money, no de-rating scheme, at a time when they have to meet in their own markets men who have to pay no rates I wonder what they will think of this item of expenditure.

I notice a contribution of £700 to the Dublin hospitals for the treatment of the wives and families of soldiers in the Dublin area. I have examined the whole Estimate unavailingly to see if I could discover anything like a similar contribution in the case of Cork area. Are the wives and families of soldiers in the Dublin area specially susceptible to disease or is the expense of treating the wives and families of soldiers in the Cork area being charged to the ratepayers? The letter which I saw from the dispensary doctor in Cork would suggest that certainly. If this item of £700 is being contributed to the Dublin hospitals for this purpose, why should there not be at least an equal contribution to the hospitals in Cork? With regard to sub-head A (3), the expenses of those gentlemen who are travelling Europe as a kind of circus, I notice that the horses were purchased for them out of public funds. The Minister for Defence must expect that this House has a lot of patience, or he must be definitely sure that his Party, which is in a majority in this House, will put up with any kind of nonsense which he proposes when he quietly put down a sum of £1,000 for the purchase of horses for the travelling circus in Europe.

In regard to the item for warlike stores, amounting to £72,145, while I am glad to see that the amount has gone up by £25,000, I still think that out of a Vote of £1,400,000 the amount devoted to Army stores is entirely too little. Now that we are starting a reserve force, I would like to see a decent lot of arms in the country. One never knows who will use them. If this country is ever threatened with invasion, I would like that there would be some army, even though we had to depend on the plain people, to meet it, and that there would be ammunition for that army. The amount provided for warlike stores is absolutely insufficient.

I think the item under that sub-head could have been doubled quite easily, and we could then hope for some results. I would like to know what is the number of rifles and arms under the control of the Department of Defence and to see some definite statement on that head. If this country was ever threatened with invasion I would like to feel that there was a supply of arms for the civilian population. Anybody who has any knowledge of history in this country will admit that it is on the civilian population we will have to rely ultimately.

Other Deputies have dealt with the use of the Army. Personally, I must say that I do not think the Army is of much use as a military force. I know very well that if this country were invaded in the morning it would have to depend absolutely on the young men of the country and on the patriotism of the young men of the country. I am sure if this country were invaded, we could definitely rely on the patriotism of the young men of the country. If this Vote were reduced to one million pounds, and if the greater portion of the one million pounds were spent in providing arms and ammunition, I think it would be making a better preparation and a better defence against invasion than the nonsense which we see provided for here.

Comment on this

It is with a certain amount of diffidence that I rise to support the Estimate. Of course I intend to vote for it. Having listened to the opinions of the various Napoleons and the Marshal Neys, or, should I say, le dernier des braves, and having heard them deal with guerilla warfare and guerilla tactics. I feel my position rather acutely. I feel myself that instead of cutting down the Army Estimates we should be increasing them some what. My opinion of our Army is that it has proved itself in the past, unhappily if you like, in internal strife. I hope we will not have any more internal strife, and I do believe that, if the Army was called upon to repel invasion to-morrow, our Army, small as it is, would render a very good account of itself. After all, every Government in the world is ultimately backed by force, and if you had not a Government backed by the forces of the nation, by an army, by a navy if they have one, or by what I believe is going to be the great force of the future, an air force, you would, I am afraid, have no country. You would have chaos and strife and no progress whatever. I have heard about light mountain howitzers; I have heard about guerilla warfare, but I believe that if you want to get at the bedrock of putting things in order you must begin in the schools and you must begin to teach the children of this country to abhor war. I think if any progress is to be made in the world at all, as far as peace is concerned, you must begin in the schools.

The League of Nations and the disarmament conferences may be of some avail, but still whilst these are sitting what do you find? You find the first-class Powers, instead of curtailing their armaments, are actually increasing them. I must confess that I am somewhat puzzled. Members on the opposite side to-day said our Army was of no avail, and if I understood them aright some of them suggested that you should have a defence force. You cannot have it both ways. You must either have an army or you must not have an army. I believe in our Army. What nation to-day is without an army? I do not think there is any. Anyway I believe that this country, for some years to come at any rate, must maintain an army. I do not look upon our Army as a costly, wasteful machine that some of the members of the Opposition seem to think it. After all, what does military training do for the young men of Ireland? It renders them spruce; it teaches them how to be men if nothing else; it teaches them how to obey, a very necessary thing with regard to the youth of any nation. Furthermore, where does the food come from that feeds our troops? Where does the clothing come from that clothes our troops? Are not the boots and uniforms to a great extent made in Ireland? I think they are. Consider the employment given in our factories. In my opinion the Army gives employment to various sections of the nation. I am not going to touch on the medical services. I prefer to take the word of the late director, Deputy Doctor O'Higgins, to any medical Deputy in the Dáil. One would imagine, hearing some of the Fianna Fáil Party talk, that everything in Ireland was couleur de rose, but unhappily I am afraid it is not. The only safeguard, or, to take the term used to-day, the great national insurance this nation has is an efficient Army.

I think it was Deputy Corry who referred to the army horses which took part in foreign equestrian shows. The horses of Ireland are famous the world over and, I think, require very little advertisement. But we are, if you like, a new-born nation and, to my mind, it is very important that we should bring ourselves to the forefront and let the rest of the world see—the world has forgotten, perhaps, in some cases anyway—that such a nation as Ireland exists. Furthermore, I look on these military officers who took part in these equestrian demonstrations as envoys, or, if you like, as business men advertising this nation. I make no apologies for them, but I think sending those horses abroad, bought, as Deputy Corry says, at public expense, a splendid idea.

As to the Air Force, I think that the Air Force will be the fighting arm of all nations in the future. Going back to 1921, I recollect, when we were discussing the Treaty, someone spoke about Ireland being the Heligoland of the Atlantic. So it is. I think it was Deputy Lemass to-day who mentioned that Ireland was an island, and somebody said: "Surrounded by water." Anyway, certainly Ireland is the key to the Atlantic. Ireland is the Heligoland, if you like, of the Atlantic, and Ireland, perhaps, is the key to international peace.

Comment on this

The "hell-ye-go-land."

Comment on this

I would like to see this aerial arm of the nation further developed. I do not think I heard Deputy Carney saying anything about bombs to-day. I certainly expected him to say something. The fact remains that I make no apologies for supporting this Vote to-night, and I regret very much that instead of a curtailment of the Estimate there has not been an increase.

Comment on this

I certainly would not intervene in this debate were it not for the fact that I have witnessed, what I consider to be the greatest demonstration of muddled thinking that anyone has ever witnessed in this House during the past couple of hours. I wish to comment briefly on the peculiar outlook as demonstrated by two or three of the various speakers supporting the Vote. Deputy Dr. White prefaced his remarks by stating that we should endeavour to teach the people of this country to abhor war, and he proceeded to tell us how we were to do that by increasing the Army and teaching the people to become efficient soldiers. I fail, for the life of me, to see how we are going to secure the idea of abhorrence of war by increasing the Army and training men, mentally and physically, in the military profession. Another ardent advocate of this Vote in the person of Deputy Anthony, who is reputed to be a member of the Labour Party, told us, on the one hand, that no reduction of the Army or police forces was possible. We cannot afford to reduce those forces by even one man so long as we have the present state of affairs obtaining in this country. We have, he says, a mythical army underneath the surface, and consequently he believes it is necessary to maintain the armed forces of the State at their present strength. He goes on to tell us in very frank language that he has no illusions whatever as to the effectiveness of this armed force as a defensive force against external aggression. He makes a statement that in the event of external aggression or interference in any form whatever this Army would be of no avail. Are we to take it then that this Army is being maintained for the sole purpose of dealing with what is termed by Deputy Anthony as a mythical army which is said to exist underneath the surface? I should like if the Minister would make that clear. Is that what we are asked to Vote £1,400,000 for? Does he believe that the people of the Twenty-six Counties would support that viewpoint?

Comment on this

I will not ask the Minister to make it clear at all. I will make it perfectly clear myself, I said whilst there was in this country a movement directed against ordered and settled government, a Government elected by the people, and whilst we have an institution, acquiesced in by the people, to carry on a legislative assembly, and so long as there was, in this country, an armed force which is said to exist to overthrow the Government of the people, so long will an army be necessary. I said also that we could afford to reduce the Army and the police force if and when we know where the dumps are, and when the dumps are given up and scrapped by what I term the mythical army. I will not ask the Minister to reply. I am able to defend myself.

Comment on this

I did not suggest for a moment that I was speaking on Deputy Anthony's behalf when I said I would like if the Minister would give a reply to that question. I am interested to have the Minister's reply to that question, not that of Deputy Anthony. According to Deputy Anthony—he has perhaps blundered into the truth—we are in reality paying out this sum of money to maintain an army for the purpose of perpetuating British Imperialism in this country. If we are to think clearly we must face that fact. Perhaps it is because I have not developed that finer sense of——

Comment on this

Brain power.

Comment on this

—rhetoric, or brain power, if you like, which enables Deputies to get up here and say one thing whilst thinking another.

Comment on this

Did you not say that wars were necessary?

Comment on this

I will come to that in a moment.

Comment on this

Do not withdraw it.

Comment on this

I will not withdraw it. Wars are necessary in certain circumstances.

Comment on this

And should be held periodically and without arms.

Comment on this

And we are asked, as responsible Deputies representing the people of this State, to vote this sum of money. For what? For an army that is admittedly incapable of defending these shores against invasion, admittedly according to the advocates who have spoken in support of this Vote. We are to take it, then, that the maintenance of this Army at its present strength and of the police force is for the purpose of maintaining British power in this country. When we speak of external aggression or invasion, again we are losing sight of fundamental facts. This country is still held by enemy forces. There will be no necessity whatever for invasion on the part of the British Empire. She holds the key positions in this country at the present time, and within twenty-four hours, if she so decided, she could overrun all this territory with her armed forces. There can be no denying that fact. Therefore, this game of make-believe should cease, and we should recognise that the only effective force in this country, if we are desirous of defending the nation's dignity, that we can ever organise will be the mass of the people, standing for the fundamental principles which all the people suffered and fought for from 1916 until December, 1921. There was no Army Vote during those years, except for the money which was raised by voluntary contributions from the people.

Comment on this

And the banks.

Comment on this

As I have said, this is, to my mind, a horrible game of make-believe, this whole attitude which we are displaying on this and various other questions. Yesterday I got an invitation to attend a certain function under the auspices of the Department of Defence. This function was to be held in honour of the men who died in 1916. I presume that the expenses in connection with that are being borne out of public funds. A further proof of the inconsistency of our position lies in the fact that this function is being held in honour of men who fought in 1916 and gave their lives in defence of the Proclamation of the Irish Republic, and is sponsored by men who executed others who followed on the lines of those men some years after.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must keep to the Vote.

Comment on this

I am trying to.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is not.

Comment on this

I am endeavouring to clear the air——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is not clearing it at all.

Comment on this

In so far as bringing every Deputy in this House to a realisation of our true position. Deputy Davin I think it was who suggested that I advocated war. Some months ago this House passed a motion in favour of the Kellogg Pact, which was said to be the method by which all wars were to be abolished. Those who supported that Pact in favour of the abolition of war are standing up this evening and advocating the maintenance and the increasing of our present armed forces, a further proof of our inconsistency.

Comment on this

Are you withdrawing what you said?

Comment on this

I said then that it was an ignoble thing for an unfree people to preach the abolition of war. What are we maintaining this present armed force for? Is it in defence of the free will of the people? Is it in defence of the common rights of the people of this country? If so, I, for one, would be glad to say that we should increase it a thousand-fold. If it is out to secure the full rights of the people of Ireland, I would be the last person in this House to suggest that it be reduced. I face the fact that it is being maintained for the sole purpose of maintaining and defending British interests in this country, and that it is not a free agent. If, to-morrow, America and England were to go to war, the Minister tells us that this House could decide whether this country would remain neutral or whether we should take sides with either of these countries.

That is a deliberate misrepresentation of our position. Before this House could meet we would be presented with a fait accompli, and the Minister knows that well. The forces of Empire who intend to remain in control of the key positions in this country will decide that question. Our Army would be shown up in its true colours as a mere unit of imperial forces. That is why I feel it incumbent upon me to get up and suggest to those who want to face facts that you may fool some of the people all the time but you cannot fool all the people all the time. Those who speak here in favour of this Vote are simply deluding themselves when they think the people will swallow the doctrine which they are preaching. The people are not such fools—they know the position perfectly well. I hope the amendment which has been moved from this side, to refer the Vote back, will be passed by this House.

Comment on this
Timothy Sheehy Mr. T. Sheehy (Cork) Cumann na nGaedheal

I rise with great pleasure to support this Estimate. I have been here all day, like the Deputy opposite, listening to a great number of speeches. He called them muddled, and I endorse that. There were a good many of them so muddled that when the speakers got into them they did not know how to get out. We are here in this Dáil to stand by the Minister for Defence, because it is our bounden duty. We were elected by the people to sustain the Army; that is to sustain the Constitution and the State. If we were by any vote of ours to reduce the Army, or lessen the Estimate which the Minister has presented, we would be betraying the trust that we undertook when we were elected. Deputy Kerlin, who was one of the first Deputies to address the House, commenced by warmly congratulating the Minister on the admirable manner in which he managed his Department during the year. I thought that was a very favourable gesture, and I thought the next gesture would be to ask why should we not follow the example of Denmark, which has disbanded its army.

Denmark is a small nation that knows how futile it is to be standing up against all the mighty nations around her, and she has therefore disbanded her army. I thought that was what I was going to hear, and that it would be an encouragement to us to go in for further economies. However, I have to say that I would not face back to the South of Ireland if I thought for one moment a vote of this House would reduce the ranks of the Army by one soldier. We want them all; we want them not for aggression or to attack any Irishman on his own soil, but to sustain and support the honour of the State This State has only been seven years in existence, but, short as has been its existence, it has won the admiration of the world. Irishmen in other countries have shown that we are capable of governing ourselves. In the Parliaments of America, Canada and Australia, and all over the world our distinguished fellow-countrymen have shown what they can do in the administration of nations. Here we have had a grand chance and the State is functioning. This wretched, pettyfogging policy of trying to knock it down will be spurned by the Irish nation.

Comment on this

I think it will be agreed that this Estimate will meet with general approval throughout the country in comparison with previous ones, and I am sure that, with the advance of order in the country, it will be possible for the Minister still further to reduce it in future. As regards the functions of the Army as at present constituted, the less said about that the better. It would be well if both the great Parties would show a little more toleration in this House to each other, and let us get on with the business of the country that we were sent here to do. We all know that if this country is to make any progress there must be some sort of agreement between the two great Parties. As one who does not belong to either of them, I am frankly rather pained at times when I hear some of the speeches delivered from both sides of the House. It almost tempts me at times to remind Deputies of what transpired in this country before the Treaty, but that would do no good. I want, if possible, to forget the past because I am painfully conscious of the state of the country at present, with thousands unemployed. I hope and trust that as far as the Army is concerned the debates in future will be carried on with a little more toleration and forbearance on the part of the two great Parties.

In connection with the distribution of the Army, I would appeal to the Minister to consider the claims or Dundalk as a centre where a portion of the Army should be stationed. Some Deputies may not be aware of the position as far as the people there are concerned. Owing to its close proximity to the Border, the trade and industry of Dundalk suffered very much during the past few years, and anything that the Government can do to mitigate that state of affairs should be done. It would be only fair to the people there that the Minister, when he comes to introduce the final Bill dealing with the Army in general, should consider the advisability of at least stationing portion of the Army in Dundalk, more especially as I may call it the frontier outpost. In addition to the claims of Dundalk itself, I may say that the barrack there is supposed to be one of the healthiest in the country, and the district around has the most beautiful scenery.

In the event of the Minister not seeing his way to fall in with my suggestion, he should as soon as possible be in a position to transfer to the local authority the married quarters attached to the barrack. There are a large number of well-built houses there which would be very useful in meeting the housing shortage which is very acute there at present. I hope the Minister will give this matter his serious and earnest attention. In conclusion, I wish to express the hope that when the Minister presents his next Estimate he will be in the happy position of showing a still further reduction. We must bear in mind that this is a very small country which does not possess vast resources, and the less we spend on services of an unproductive nature the better for all concerned. I hope that with good-will prevailing among the different sections of the people it will be possible for the Minister to show a considerable reduction when he comes to present his next Estimate

Comment on this

This has been a very long and somewhat rambling debate, mostly repetition of what was said last year. Although a great many Deputies seem to take great pleasure in saying again what they said before, I must say it is not a function very pleasing to me. Deputy Lemass and Deputy Kerlin brought up the usual things. They said that reductions in the Army were only carried out because of the criticism so ably levelled at the Government from the Benches opposite. I might clear the minds of Deputies upon that point. I became Minister for Defence in June, 1926, before Deputies opposite came into this House. And I became Minister for Defence to carry out exactly the policy that has been carried out. This year we have a reduction of £360,000 odd following upon a reduction of £380,000 odd last year. If I made any mistake I made it in proceeding too rapidly and drastically in making my financial reductions. Anybody with any intelligence who knows anything about the Army knows that that is a fact, and that any attempt to go faster than I have gone would be a mistake and not a beneficial thing.

I have not much patience when it comes to: "We advise that the Army should be composed of volunteers." We had a certain amount of experience of the gentlemen known as volunteers in 1922. As fighters they did not count for very much, and they were beaten by a very inadequate Army of our own.

Comment on this

In 1920 and 1921?

Comment on this

I am talking of 1922.

Comment on this

But what about 1920 and 1921?

Comment on this

I shall come to that now. In 1920 and 1921 they were fighting in very peculiar circumstances. They were fighting against a Government that was handicapped by pretending that it was not carrying on a military but a police work. It would have been a very different thing if the mask was off and that it had been frankly military work it was carrying on. In 1922 and 1923 these men tried to carry out the same kind of thing and made a very poor show against a very inexperienced Army. A number of conditions are made; that such an economic army of volunteers can only be made successful by what is called a national Government, and then we are told that a national government must be supported by all the people of this country. But the one Party in this country which has the support of the biggest body of people in the country is the existing Government, and if we are going to wait until such time as Deputies opposite change their mind and their view of what they would like to consider a national government which will also have the unanimous support of the people of this country we will have to put things off until Tibb's Eve. We know well that this is merely talk for talk's sake and that the people who say that do not believe in it at all.

Any army to be anything other than a danger to the State must be carefully disciplined and carefully trained. I am satisfied you cannot have a trained and disciplined body of men in this country bearing arms unless you have a proportion of them permanently employed, and having the advantage of being permanently so occupied in order to get a high degree of training and becoming thoroughly amenable to discipline. Discipline cannot be inculcated casually. Deputies on the benches opposite who are opposed to the present system of the Army have an innate and inherent objection to discipline and order which has been shown in every manifestation on their part in recent years. We want order in this country, and we want order in the Army. I do not know of any serious thinker who thinks you can have in this country an efficient disciplined army organisation without any permanent body. My own idea of a permanent body is such as I indicated last year, roughly in the neighbourhood of 5,000, to deal with every branch of army work. Then as the men pass through that we put them into what is called the "A" reserve. Men who have two or three or five years' army service who have become thoroughly trained are kept in touch with the training that they had before by an annual period of training. Apart from that there are the lesser trained men who come in the first instance only for three months, and after that one month per annum. These men will necessarily not be as well trained as the others, but with the more highly-trained body of men leavening the whole body, I think, by such an arrangement as I have indicated, we can have a body which, acting as a body, will be a highly-disciplined one, but it will not be such a highly-disciplined body unless we have the leaven of a good percentage of permanent men who have had their training by membership of the permanent Army.

Deputy Lemass says this is an island, and he goes on to talk about possible attack. He says that for any country other than Great Britain to attack us would mean that that country would first of all have to destroy the British navy. As I said last year, that type of argument would mean that no country should maintain an army or a navy unless its strength was equal to the aggregate strength of all other countries. You might just as well say to Great Britain: "If all the other countries in the world organise against you you will be beaten." The British answer to that would be: "It is so improbable as to be practically impossible that every other country in the world will organise against us and beat us. We maintain our Army to meet what we consider possible contingency." In the same way here our business is to maintain such a force as will be able to resist or, at the worst, retard any such attack as we see any possibility of occurring to us. If a country was so powerful as to beat the British fleet what could we do? I presume that country would have beaten the British fleet with a view to breaking British power and, in so far as they proposed to invade, their first function would be to invade Great Britain. They would not proceed to beat the British fleet for the sole purpose of invading the Free State. I presume their first function would be to invade Great Britain, and therefore it is not to meet that power that we should have an Army but to meet such residuary portion of that power as would be sent over here—for what purpose I do not know.

I presume that once they have crushed Great Britain in the very centre—that is, in Great Britain itself—it would not be worth their while to concentrate a considerable portion of their forces here. We have at the present time 14,000 men available, with the country behind them. We would have at such a time of invasion a considerably greater number than that.

I would like to have something more definite to argue upon than what has been presented in the course of this debate. One must always presume a certain amount of intelligence in one's military antagonists, if not in one's political antagonists. We must presume a certain amount of intelligence in our potential enemies. One would first want to consider the aims and possibilities of any evil-minded Power with regard to our country, what value they will place upon achieving their object, and to what extent they will consider the advisability of detaching large numbers of men for whatever work they may have to achieve in our land. They would have to consider, of course, the number of men they would be obliged to leave elsewhere and how advisable it would or would not be to add to their opponents such a body of men as we could put into the field. We have people here who have talked about another round with England. They now assure us that this country is incapable of resisting any other country in the world, and is pre-eminently incapable of resisting England.

I think that this country is able to maintain a body of men which will create such opposition as to make it worth while for any Power that considers attacking us, presumably for a military object, seriously to weigh the advisability of such a project. We can maintain here a body of men capable of making such resistance as to make any attacking Power seriously consider whether it would be worth while to detach a section of forces in order to achieve here whatever military object it might have in mind. I say that the best and the most economical way in which to do that is along the lines that I have detailed. Every intelligent man in this country is well aware that we must have a standing Army for the purpose of training our whole armed forces. We, possibly more than any other country in Europe, have reason to know the cost of a volunteer force on a territorial basis inspired, as some Deputy said, by national ardour to do all the work for nothing. We found that they were too expensive to maintain in this country. I said that last year, and I repeat that this country cannot afford it. We prefer to cut down Army expenditure in accordance with the needs of any Army we think we should maintain rather than increase expenditure along the lines of the Army maintained a few years ago.

I was asked time and again did the Army exist solely for police purposes or to resist invasion. The Army exists to protect the Irish people from any enemies, whether they come from outside or inside. It is quite conceivable, not only in this country but in other countries, that the first duty of the Army would be to resist internal aggression. That was undoubtedly the first duty of our Army in 1922-23. I am very glad to say they carried out their duty splendidly. I do not foresee that the Army will be called upon on anything like the same scale or for the same work in the future, but we must be prepared. This country, the same as every other country, must maintain an armed force. During the last two years my work has been to create a position where we would maintain an armed force to meet the needs of the country and actually to do it at the cost of a lesser proportion of the country's revenue than is spent in any other country that I know of for the same purpose.

A great many questions have been put to me. Deputy Kerlin loves getting up and telling us about his 60,000 men. He calculates at so much per head and quotes us plenty of figures. He does this regularly and more or less automatically. He reminds me of a story—I think it was written by Balzac. I do not remember the story, but I know that there-is a scene in a prison where there is a dilapidated Communist prisoner. This prisoner is writing on a sheet of paper and someone asks him: "What are you writing?" His reply is: "I am making out a list of my Cabinet Ministers." Deputy Kerlin is something after that fashion. He has some form of graphomania. He repeatedly writes out figures about his Army and then he gives us 60,000 men at so much a man. All that sort of thing may amuse the Deputy. It really does not do anybody any harm, but it is very remote from reality. We on this side have to be closely associated with and, in fact, wedded to reality, and consequently that reduces our capacity for appreciating the gymnastics performed on paper by Deputy Kerlin, though I must say they are deserving of praise.

Questions were asked about surplus rifles. We have a great many surplus rifles. We may destroy them. There is difficulty in selling rifles. There are international conventions which make it necessary for us to see that anybody who wants to buy our rifles wants them for a good purpose. When a country possesses such a large number of rifles as we have, it usually transpires that people who come to buy them may not want them for a good purpose. We have a great many stores and most of them are for sale. We have stores not only since 1922, but stores which we took over from the British, and we are putting all these up for sale.

I was asked if the officers on the reserve will be called up this year. Roughly, one may say—and this is not to be taken too strictly literally, but it is roughly an indication—that officers not called up this year will not remain on the reserve.

A number of Deputies spoke about the hardships of the rank and file going out of the Army. That is a thing I cannot deny and I cannot contest. Unfortunately, I am not able by law to include them in unemployment insurance. That is a thing I would very much like to do. We have improved the position so far by a certain gratuity. There is nothing to boast about in that gratuity, I quite agree. I think that it may be possible for us to do more in the way of gratuity. I think also that we should be able to make arrangements so that men due for discharge would be in a position to get employment that would be suitable for them. Another thing is that as we get Army organisation tightened up we may be able to take steps towards getting the men Deputy Anthony said belonged mostly to the unskilled class into the semiskilled class, and improve the chances of employment. I can assure Deputies that no one here is more concerned about that position than I am, and I am considering a number of matters to ease that position.

Deputy Wolfe asked about a military college for officers. Deputy Colohan also asked about it. I hope it will be in operation this year, but I do hope also that it will be able to operate without too large an expenditure on reconstruction work in the Curragh, much as I sympathise with Deputy Colohan in that matter.

Comment on this

It is for a good purpose.

Comment on this

Even the better the purpose the more economically it can be achieved. Deputy Lemass was worried that he did not think the Army would be able to resist Great Britain. If he does not think that the Army, or any army that he will be able to put up if he were in the Government, will be able to do that, then I would recommend him to bear that in mind when his Government are considering their policy towards Great Britain. Deputy Briscoe asked what was the total cost to the State of the competitions. It seems to me that Deputy Briscoe wanted a complete rearrangement of the sub-heads in this Estimate. One could rearrange, practically to infinity minus one, all the sub-heads, but this is the form of sub-head which has been found most convenient for Government accountancy. One could take the cost of a soldier and work out what percentage of barrack accommodation he occupies, and what that cost is, but the actual way of working it out under these sub-heads is as it has been presented, and I think these sub-heads are sufficiently clear to enable people to form a pretty accurate idea of the cost of most things in the Army.

As to the cost to the State of the competitions, you have two headings here under which you can form an idea of that. There are certain reductions from that due to the fact that certain prize money has to be deducted. But just as in the case of the aerodrome and the conveniences we allow to the Aero Club, we have a certain number of stables and a certain number of grooms and horses in the Army. If you take the whole cost and divide that by the number of horses then you have the cost per horse. But we have a certain number there. Sometimes it happens that by adding a certain extra number you add nothing whatever to the cost. I think the Deputy will have to take the Estimates as they are and the details he gets there. Adding these together, he will form a rough idea as to the cost. He can add a certain amount of that for the general use of the barracks, and so on.

If it comes to going into a detailed analysis I do not think I can do it, because one can say one figure and another may say another figure. Both are equally right and equally wrong. Competitions are gone into largely because this is a horse-producing country. This country does a big business in horse breeding. Other countries come and compete and buy horses here. We have to take our part as an ordinary adult person amongst other nations that are competing. When they come here it is for the advantage of the horse-breeding industry. Our men going abroad are acting as commercial travellers for our horses.

Comment on this

Bad samples.

Comment on this

I did not hear what the Deputy said.

Comment on this

I said they were bad samples they had on the last occasion.

Comment on this

No, not at all.

Comment on this

Oh, no; very good samples. Quite the contrary. It was very good business. On sub-head G Deputy Briscoe presumed that the Headquarters Staff, when going on inspection, except under exceptional circumstances, stay in the barracks. That is not so. I do not allow the Inspection Staff to stay in the barracks when they go to inspect. I would consider that thoroughly bad for their work. As to the matter of clothing, Deputies spoke of a reduction in the Army and pointed out that there was no reduction in the clothing. There is an actual increase in the number of men in the Army. There is a decrease in the standing Army, but in the Army as a whole there is an increase. This is the form in which, financially, it is most convenient to present the accounts. I explained the matter of the new sub-heads which intrigued Deputy Derrig so considerably and seemed to have upset the digestive organs of another Deputy. There is an increase in the matter of rifles. In the same way as we buy a new set of clothes in one month we buy rifles in one year. You buy a suit of clothes in one month, and you do not buy it in another month, and one does not ask why did you buy the suit of clothes this month and not last month. That is why it happens that a great number of our rifles were replenished. They were replenished this year because they did not require to be replenished last year, or the year before that, and so on. In the same way, next year we will require certain things that we have not this year. Under general sub-heads certain things get worn out. Everything does not happen to get a life of one year. Some things bought run to three years, and some have a life of fifteen years. If certain things have not appeared in last year's Estimate and appear now, that is simply due to the fact that it was down last year, and that it is up this year.

As to the increases in the matter of aviation, there are a number of reasons for these. The first is because I do not feel justified in standing for a man going up into the air in any machine that I do not consider gives reasonable assurances of safety. I propose that the general mechanical side shall be increased in efficiency; also that a fair number of machines, whose lifetime is drawing to an end, require to be replenished. I think it was Deputy Briscoe, or perhaps some other Deputy, who asked what was the expenditure on the Reserves last year. The figure was £27,475.

As to the cost of ammunition, this does not necessarily go down with the decrease in the Army because, as I have already explained, the decrease in the cost of the Army is coincident with an increase in the number of the Army. Ammunition is required for the training of both the Regular Army and the Reserves.

There was a question about the great number of surplus and unserviceable stores that have to be sold, and the implication was that we bought wildly, and, having bought things that we did not need, that we had to sell them. I do not know if that happened in the past, but if it did it will happen much less frequently in the future. We have a great many things in our possession since this State came into being. We are closing down Gormanstown. That leads to a considerable saving. We are improving transport, though decreasing the number of vehicles. That leads to a considerable saving. Then there is the question of clothing. The implication is that we bought it and did not need it. But the clothing was bought and used, and its utility has ceased; it is due to be sold. There are huts that we inherited and we propose selling them. We inherited things that are useless to us. We propose selling them. There are various stores in barracks that have been evacuated and these things will be sold. We took over, amongst other things, old motor cars, from the British Government.

There is a question as to why the cost of the civilian administration did not diminish in the same proportion as the general cost of the Army. Well the civilian administration has taken over a great deal of the work done by the Army. It does not follow that as the cost of the Army has been reduced that the cost of the civilian administration should be reduced in the same proportion. I think it was Deputy Derrig who quoted the report of the Comptroller and Auditor-General. Well, as a matter of fact, in our general reorganisation of the whole Department, in our determination to diminish the possibility of such irregularities as he referred to, a great deal of the work that has hitherto been done by the various Army Departments has now been transferred to the Civilian Department. I may say at the same time that the same somewhat rigid attitude of mind that has so far been brought to bear on the military side is also brought to bear on the civil side.

I have no more use for waste on the civil side than I have on the military side. I think that about seventy per cent. of the officers on Reserve would be in receipt of military pensions. A Deputy asked that question and I give that figure as an approximate one. Deputy Sir James Craig and Deputy Dr. O'Dowd talked about the Army Medical Service. I think it may be possible to reduce the hospital accommodation. I do not think that it will mean a discontinuance of St. Bricin's. Deputy O'Dowd loves to talk about the cost of patients in civilian hospitals, and so on. I do not want to go over the explanation already given to the effect that there are probationer nurses in civilian hospitals who pay fees and that there are operating surgeons who are not paid. These are elements which come into the case, but I say that, even though military hospitals cost twice as much as regards patients, the actual cost of illness is less. If a man goes to an ordinary hospital we pay his wages while he is there. If he is in our own hospital, if he has any given disease, say, hydrophobia, the time taken to cure him and get him back to his unit is considerably less than it would be if he were in an outside hospital. He is much more closely under our eye and the period of recuperation seems, somehow or other, to curtail itself. Although it may cost so much per day, even if it cost twice as much, if he stays in a military hospital only one-fourth of the time which he would spend in a civilian hospital, I consider that that is a net gain.

There was a question about the cost of Reserves. It costs about £10 per annum in one case and about £16 10s. in the other. Even in the most ideal force, which is likely to exist only in Deputy Kerlin's brain, I think that the cost would be, at least, £6 per man per annum. I would prefer one of our men at £10 to four of Deputy Kerlin's men at £6. Deputy Dr. O'Dowd was rather wrong in his figures about the Medical Service. Deputy Colohan referred to civilian employees being discharged at the Curragh to make room for ex-soldiers. I am not aware that that is happening. Although it may have happened I am not aware of it, but I quite admit that I am very anxious, if I hear of a job, near or far, to secure it for a man demobilised from the Army.

Deputy Anthony spoke about deferred pay. A soldier can at his own request have a certain amount of his pay held back each week to be kept over for him, but we cannot insist on that if he does not agree. I already referred to the fact that I was endeavouring to see what I can do to improve the position of soldiers when the time comes for their demobilisation. Deputy Lemass still insists on misunderstanding the Minister for Finance when he gave his estimated figure for a normal Army cost. The Minister was dealing with the point that the cost of administration in this country should be met out of current revenue. Quite properly, and very conservatively, knowing that it would react against the financial credit of this State if it could be demonstrated that our ordinary living expenses were being met out of capital expenditure, he came to the point that the cost of the Army was considerably more than two millions, and he said that he considered that it was a safe thing to assume that the normal cost of the Army would not exceed two millions a year. Quite rightly he preferred to pay a certain amount of abnormal cost out of current revenue rather than run the risk of being in the position of meeting current costs out of capital expenditure. As the position improved he moved on to the definite position of one-and-a-half millions.

If I remember rightly, the Deputies opposite went round the country at that time saying that he was trying to fake his Budget and that he would never get down to one-and-a half millions. I do not think that Deputies opposite should allow us to dictate their policy. If we say two millions they will say one million and a-half, and if we say one million and a-half, they will say one million. As adult people, they should insist on having a policy of their own and not allow us to dictate it to them. Deputy Lemass said that our defence forces should depend on a spirit of loyalty, that they must be local units and have elected officers. I love that touch about elected officers. I always felt that the Party opposite were reactionaries against order, but I think that the system of elected officers is the last thing in the way of organised anarchy in this country. The Deputy told us that elected officers give a sense of confidence and make the men have confidence in their officers. I do not know if, in 1922-23, the officers were elected in Deputy Lemass's army, but if they were, the confidence that they inspired in their men does not seem to have been the kind of confidence that leads one very far. I think it leads only to a "Down Arms" order.

Comment on this

In 1920-21.

Comment on this

After 1920-21 came 1922-23.

Comment on this

But before that came 1920-21.

Comment on this

Before Adam fell he was in a state of innocence.

Comment on this

You never had that distinction in 1920-21.

Comment on this

A question was asked as to why we were spending £25,000 more on warlike stores this year than last year. It just happens that the figure goes up this year. We are asked why are we buying anti-gas machines and buying anti-gas instruments. Part of the military training is anti-gas training and certain equipment is needed for that. It happens that we are buying large amounts during the current year. In a few years' time we will probably be buying some again. Deputy Lemass will probably get up in five or ten years' time and ask again how is it that this thing is being done this year which had not been done last year. The explanation is that such expenditure has to be incurred at intervals of every few years.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not anticipate that the Government representative at the Conference on Disarmament will be able to carry his point?

Comment on this

As far as I remember, the Anti-Gas Convention applies only in regard to countries which are parties to it. We cannot sit down and state what we have made up our minds that we are only to be attacked by parties to the Anti-Gas Convention. Apart from the possibility that any of the parties may break away from the Convention, there are other countries who are not parties to the Convention, and there is no harm in having the Army instructed in this matter. I think I have dealt with the majority of points raised. Deputies opposite seemed to be largely talking for the purpose of keeping the debate going until somebody else arrived so that I may have lost track of some of their points.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister to give us some indication of the policy that brought about the introduction of the Token Vote for the Aero Club, and if there were any arrangements made by which the State would benefit by the advance to that particular Club.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy was not here when I dealt with that matter.

Comment on this

I did not anticipate that the Minister would deal with it so soon.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not anticipate that I would deal with it so early, whereas Deputy Derrig had an enormous grievance because I did not deal with it earlier. I dealt with it, presumably, before Deputy Briscoe wished that I should, and after Deputy Derrig wanted me to. I said that the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who is the Minister relevantly interested in civil aviation, considers that the Aero Club should be encouraged. They asked him for certain facilities. The Minister for Industry and Commerce advised me to give them such facilities as I could. I read out the facilities which we are giving and which were roughly these: the use of a hangar, running repairs at cost plus 7½ per cent. overhead charges, the use of an office in the hangar. That actually represents to them much more than £10, but to us, roughly speaking, we might say it means nothing. We have more hangar space than we are using, and it does not deteriorate the hangar to use it for housing additional planes. The office there is not necessarily used by us. We have merely put down a sum of £10 because we are not allowed to give such facilities to private individuals without giving some indication in the Vote here that they are being given. The sum of £10 is put down, but I do not think it will cost the State anything, while the Club will get more value than the £10 represents. As to the benefits which the State may receive, I am told by my confrere, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that he desires to encourage civil aviation. I do not know whether his desire goes to the extent that he will provide any money out of his own Vote, but I know he is anxious to encourage the Club, and has expressed the desire that we should encourage it if possible without cost to the State. He has a benevolent and god-fatherly attitude towards it.

Comment on this

Will the Minister state that he does not anticipate that the expenditure will be increased as contact between the Army and the Aero Club become more familiar?

Comment on this

I think the Deputy can judge for himself. He knows what we are giving—use of the hangar, running repairs at cost, plus 7½ per cent. for overhead charges, and the use of an office. No matter how cordial the relations of the Army and the Club may become. I do not think that it will mean that we will have to ask for more expenditure because the members of the Club have worn more of the floors or because the office requires to be painted as a result of their having worn off the paint of the walls.

Comment on this

If they get ten aeroplanes——

Comment on this

I regard it as static and not dynamic.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration."

Tá 63
·
Níl 72
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?