We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - The Flour-Milling Industry.

Contributions 166–342 of 342. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Griffith would have done the same. He would have listened to reason.

Comment on this

I do not know; he might have done the same, but there is nothing in the circumstances of the present time, and there is nothing in the arguments that have been advanced here against this proposal, to show that President Griffith would have been moved. This is a period of depression. It is a period when people want a lead from those in charge, a period when people all over the country have demanded that stronger and more vigorous steps should be taken to meet industrial conditions. Those steps are not being taken, and those members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party who feel they are carrying on a national tradition in economic matters ought to ask themselves now whether they are furthering that policy in voting against this motion. I beg to offer the House the suggestion that whether this proposal is accepted or not steps ought to be taken to improve the Tariff Commission, so that it would have power in future to examine and watch the course of prices in regard to tariffed articles, and that, in the second place, it shall be empowered to deal with the question of foreign combines coming in and taking over Irish industries. These are two vital defects in this respect in the Government's tariff policy at present, and everyone knows they are there. It is up to the Government to improve the constitution and basis of the Tariff Commission so that it will be able to deal with these things.

Comment on this

I listened to Deputy de Valera's speech on this motion, and I confess I was somewhat depressed by it, because I spent three or four months on the Economic Committee, with the aid of the Department of Agriculture, trying to teach the Deputy the elements of agriculture. On listening to him to-day I had to come to the conclusion that I had completely failed. Whether it is that I am a bad teacher, or he is a bad pupil, I leave to the House to decide. The fact is that there is a motion before the House, and also an amendment by Deputy O'Connell. The motion deals with flour and the amendment deals with flour and wheat, principally wheat.

Deputy Ryan has a motion also dealing with this question of encouraging the production of wheat in the country, but it seems to me, listening to the debate, that the enthusiasm for the production of wheat which used to exist amongst the Fianna Fáil supporters has completely disappeared. I take an interest in the Fianna Fáil policy, and even in some of the members of the Fianna Fáil Party. Out of the generosity of my heart, some time ago I told them to stick to the Land Commission annuities, to Document No. 2, to the Oath, and these sort of things. I want to repeat now for future record: While you may persuade the farmers of the country to repudiate the Land Commission annuities, and while you may persuade them to call themselves Republicans, you never will persuade them to grow 100,000 acres of wheat, for that is business. While Deputy de Valera has not learned the lessons which I with the greatest pains and conscientiousness have tried to teach him, he has learned that lesson. It is perfectly clear to me that so far as the Fianna Fáil Party are concerned they have not the slightest belief in this wheat programme. Deputy O'Connell, the leader of the Labour Party, has put forward his proposals and we will deal with them. In speaking to these proposals Deputy de Valera told us that we import £26,000,000 worth of agricultural produce which we might produce here. Roughly, he said, there are £7,000,000 worth out of the £26,000,000 worth for wheat and flour and about £7,000,000 worth for feeding stuffs. That is £14,000,000, and the balance is made up of all sorts of items— horses, beef, tomatoes and so forth; stock animals and so on. In the £26,000,000 are included Scotch whiskey, an agricultural product, beer and other drink that come into the country. He pointed out that apropos of this motion he had made a calculation. It is not the first time he has pointed out that if we produced this £26,000,000 worth of what he calls agricultural produce in this country, that from the production we would make a net profit of £6,000,000. I have read that statement three times, repeated exactly word for word. It may be that an efficient clerk put these figures into his hands, but I suggest to him to show how you make this £6,000,000 profit by producing this £26,000,000 worth of what he calls agricultural produce in the country.

He made the point that, of course, the production of £26,000,000 of agricultural produce is all gain, because it will be produced in the country, because it means labour employed in the country, and because it means indirect profit in the country to others than farmers. But, in addition to all this gain that will accrue to the trade balance, to labour, etc., there is to be a profit to the farmers of £6,000,000. How are we to produce this £26,000,000 worth in the country? Apparently, we are to put an import duty on those goods coming in—we are to tax them. We are to tax the £7,000,000 worth of cotton cake, maize, palmnut cake, pollard, etc., which form the raw material of agricultural production. That ought to be made clear to the farmers, especially the small farmers, who are rearing pigs and who purchase practically all the maize consumed in the country, practically all the linseed cake for their calves, and all the cotton cake for their young cattle. The big farmers purchase very little of these items. It is the small farmers who purchase them, and it should be made clear to them that by making cotton cake dearer, maize-meal dearer, and by taxing their linseed cake, they are going to make £6,000,000 more. That has been put forward three times already as a statesmanlike contribution to the solution of the evils from which agriculture is suffering, or is supposed to be suffering. The least we might get from the Leader of the Opposition is a little more detail, and I would ask him to explain, with the same lucidity which he displayed when he was dealing with the question of wheat, to farmers like myself, graziers like myself, who do about 50 acres of tillage, how we are going to make a bigger profit by buying cotton cake at an increased price, or, alternatively, by substituting for it a food which is not nearly as suitable for its particular purpose, such as oats or barley. I should like to know where the profit comes in.

Of course he went on to say also that we import £28,000,000 of nonagricultural products, and that there was to be an immense profit if we put an import duty on all these. Everybody is to be happy except the consumer—he is to pay through the nose—and the country is to be all right. However, that is not strictly relevant. I should like the Deputy to explain at some more length how the £6,000,000 is to come to the country as a result of taxing the raw materials of agricultural production. We ought to be self-sufficient, he says. We are, in a great many ways. We ought to be self-sufficient with regard to wheat. In the good old days, about 1918, 1919, 1920 or 1921, when I was a looker-on and saw most of the game, enthusiastic reformers used to come down to my part of the country and used to tell the County Galway farmers about growing wheat. Wheat is a sort of fetish. It is a patriotic crop. Oats and barley are Anglicised, so are turnips and mangolds, but there is something particularly Irish in our philosophy about wheat.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

And bran.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I do not know why it has become a fetish. The picture is painted to us of the condition this country would be in in the event of a stoppage of communication between Great Britain and the Free State. We were reminded that when the general strike took place some years ago there were about 27 days' supply of wheat and flour in the country, and we were invited to contemplate and to make our flesh creep at the prospect of what would happen if by any chance that strike had continued much longer. As a matter of fact, if that strike had continued much longer, if the communications between this country and Great Britain had been cut, not for a month, but three months, our flesh would creep, but not for the reason that Deputy de Valera has mentioned. We would find ourselves with so much food and with so little money in this country that after a short time we would be giving the food away.

If that had happened, the real problem would not be to get food into the country, but to get it out. If that happened the price of cattle —another British agricultural product—would have fallen £5 or £6 per head, if they could not get across to Great Britain; the price of butter would completely collapse, there would be no price for eggs, and even the enthusiastic Republicans who go to the fair of Ballinasloe with a basket of eggs on their arm, or a bullock in front of them, would be a little bit disappointed when they were told that there was no one there except the local butcher to buy from them. There would be quick conversions from the economic Republicanism of Deputy de Valera if that had happened. We would be in no difficulty from the point of view of starvation. We would starve, of course, in about two years, because we could not go on living by taking in each other's washing, but I doubt if this general dislocation would have lasted so long.

You can draw any moral you like from that. You can say, if you wish: "Give up producing cattle, give up exporting the surplus of cattle, pigs, bacon and eggs." But the one moral you cannot draw from it, in the event of a dislocation of trade between Great Britain and Ireland, is that there would be anything in the nature of starvation or any real shortage of wheat. We could get as much wheat as we wanted from Canada and the Argentine, provided we were prepared to pay for it. The real trouble would be to pay for it, because we could not get payments for our own goods from Great Britain. Wheat comes into Dublin, and into Cork and other ports, both from the Argentine and Canada every week as a matter of course. We could get as much wheat as we liked, and the mills of the country would be able to mill, I am told, 80 per cent. of the total requirements of the country, and we could eke out the other 20 per cent. while the struggle lasted with the best beef, bacon, eggs and butter in the world. We really ought to hear the end of this nonsense as to what would happen this country if we ran short of wheat for 27 days because of a dislocation of the transport services between Great Britain and Ireland.

They go further, because Fianna Fáil policy is based, as one would expect from heroes, upon the idea that the duty of statesmanship is to provide, not for normal times of peace, not to expect peace as the normal situation of the country, but war. In the event of war with Great Britain—which, of course, is bound to come!—if we have to fight her we will still get supplies from Canada and the Argentine. I am perfectly certain that we will have a considerable amount of unexpended heroism after walloping the Empire, and if we do take on the rest of the world we will be in a different position. A little extra heroism is nothing, and I put it to the Deputy that by the time we are ready to take on the whole world, to cut off communication between the rest of the world and ourselves; that by the time we build that brass wall effectually around the country, we ought to be prepared to make a little sacrifice, and I say that we will have to make a great many more sacrifices than by doing without supplies of wheat. That is so much for that particular article.

Deputy de Valera's contribution to this weighty problem is this—I took it down, and I think it should not be forgotten. I do say that it was really disappointing to me, after conscientiously taking considerable pains to put matters before Deputy de Valera, to find him making these statements. Deputy de Valera is not a farmer, and cannot be blamed for not knowing all about these things. Deputy Lemass is not a farmer, and could not be expected to know anything about these things. Deputy Ryan has not yet spoken, so that I leave him out for the present, but I took the greatest possible care to put the whole Department at their disposal and to give them some of the elementary facts that every illiterate farmer in the country knows about wheat——

Comment on this

Is the Minister a farmer?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I till more land than the whole Fianna Fáil Party put together.

Comment on this

You what—yourself, personally, is it?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Yes.

Comment on this

I would like to have a trial of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I made some inquiries and I would like the farmers to listen to this contribution as the serious contribution to this debate of Fianna Fáil. Deputy de Valera said: "We are told that wheat is a precarious crop. In our opinion, wheat is a less precarious crop than any other grain crop. We are told that wheat takes more out of the land than any other grain crop. In our opinion, it takes less out of the land than any other grain crop. We are told that wheat fouls the land more than any other crop. In our opinion, it fouls the land less." These are his exact words.

Comment on this

No, not the exact words.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We will not fight about adjectives, but that is the exact sense. He also said: "We believe, in addition, that wheat is a better nurse crop for grass seeds." As a farmer, I will not attempt to comment upon that. Comment would spoil it. Every farmer knows that the exact opposite of these four statements is exactly correct. Wheat is a more precarious crop; it is much more exhausting to the land; it is eleven months in the land, and it is more exhausting for other reasons. Wheat fouls the land more because weeds grow better if the land is not stirred and cleaned, and the land is not stirred under wheat from November till the following August. The weeds have the whole summer to go ahead. Wheat is not a better crop for grass seeds. I know the reason the Deputy stumbled into that mistake. An agricultural instructor mentioned, in his presence and in mine, that in some places they have heavy land where oats lodge and where it lodges grass does not do well. In some places, they sow wheat and they put in grass seed with it—presumably spring wheat—for it is almost out of the question to put in grass seed with autumn wheat, and ninety per cent. of the wheat grown in this country would be autumn wheat.

Comment on this

Does the Minister remember the evidence given by the instructor in the Agricultural College, Athenry? That man gave evidence of growing ten or twenty acres of wheat per year?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

On what point?

Comment on this

On the point of grass seeds being sown.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That is the very man I meant.

Comment on this

I remember cross-examining him very closely and asking if he possibly could state the difference between the grass grown following after wheat and that grown after oats, and he said he could not; I shall have an opportunity of dealing with the matter later on.

Comment on this

I could show the Deputy the difference.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Brennan going to speak?

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Is that point so?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Comment would spoil it. I assert as a farmer that the statement that wheat is a good nurse crop for grass seed is absolutely a foolish statement. That is Deputy de Valera's contribution to the wheat problem. Deputy O'Connell used somewhat the same argument but he got down to business to some extent. He said he realised that it was almost probable that we could not get anything like the total quantity of wheat required by this country grown in the country within any reasonable period, and he suggested we should aim at twenty per cent. When I asked him what subsidy he thought would get this twenty per cent., he answered £1 per ton as a guess. Take that figure. £1 per ton, as Deputy Gorey pointed out, is 2/6 per barrel. I assume what the Deputy has in mind is this: that the farmer who grows wheat under this scheme will take it to the miller and the miller will pay to him the world-price of wheat, plus 2/6, or an arrangement will be made by which he will receive the world-price, plus 2/6 per barrel. But it does not end there. The miller pays the world-price for Irish wheat but he has to get compensation also, because he is not getting a barrel of wheat which corresponds with a barrel of Pacific wheat though paying for it. He is getting a barrel of wheat, apart from quality or flavour, that contains seven per cent. more moisture, and he has to make allowance for the cost of taking out that moisture, which the Flour Millers' Association themselves computed will take three shillings per barrel. So that the real subsidy there is 5/6 per barrel.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

What about the thicker skin and more bran?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am leaving out all that. That has to be taken into account. It has, also, to be taken into account that people, rightly or wrongly, prefer the flavour of foreign wheat, but I am leaving out all that. The subsidy is 2/6 to the farmer, and the miller, in order to be put in the same position and to sell bread at the same price, must get an additional three shillings. It is suggested that there will be a way of taking out the moisture much more inexpensively, but that particular suggestion is quite out of the question, because it would mean that the farmers would have to deliver their wheat in regular lots at specified mills, in certain quantities, and it would be utterly impossible to get farmers to deliver in that way or to find the regular supplies needed in order to mix Pacific with Irish wheat so that the Pacific wheat would suck the moisture out of the Irish. So that in addition to the 2/6 paid to the farmer, the miller would have to get three shillings. When he gets three shillings compensation, he will have a certain amount of wheat that will make exactly the same amount of flour as a barrel of Pacific wheat. I think it would take about eleven million cwts. of wheat to supply the flour required in the country. It is 10,900,000, something less than 11,000,000, in round figures, 11,000,000. That amounts to 4,400,000 barrels, and at 5/-, not 5/6, it would require £1,100,000 of a subsidy to get all the wheat required for the country grown in the country.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

All the wheat?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We will come back to the other point later on. Now the first question you have got to ask yourself is what are the chances that farmers would grow for this 2/6 extra. We were debating this matter. I am not giving away any secrets; it has been referred to in debate and it is in the report of the Economic Committee. It was suggested that farmers would grow wheat if they got a guaranteed price of about 30/- a barrel for it. I give it as my view that farmers would not grow wheat in any additional quantities for 30/- a barrel, and I pointed out that the price in the year 1928 that could be got by the farmers for good milling wheat was between 30/- and 31/-.

Comment on this

Not in 1928.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Yes, it could be got then. Certainly they could get 30/-. Deputy Dr. Ryan, I think, pointed out that it was very fine, and made the point that if there were a definite guarantee of 30/- wheat could be got. I am still of the opinion that nothing like 10,000 acres extra could be got for 30/- a barrel. That was the figure suggested. What is the price of wheat at the present moment? It varies from 22/- or 23/- to 26/-. Australian wheat is 26/1. Manitoba is 21/3; a certain standard of Manitoba, good quality wheat is 21/3. Rossafidda 22/9, and No. 3 Manitoba would be about 23/-.

Comment on this

Does the Minister consider that those are the normal prices?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Is not that exceptional?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That is exceptional. The price of wheat has broken, and it is rather amusing in view of that to read the forecasts contained in the minority report signed by Deputy Lemass. We were told that there were indications from everywhere in the world that there would be a shortage of wheat, that the price of wheat would go up, and so on.

Comment on this

Does the Minister think it is this year's wheat that is being quoted at that price?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Yes. These are forward quotations. In fact, what has happened. The price of wheat has broken for reasons I am not aware of, for reasons which were very hard to measure, but there are certain considerations which are known to us all, and which we can take into account without placing too much reliance on them, and those are: luckily for us the Argentine is getting out of cattle raising to some extent. Their stock has dropped, I am delighted to say, by about 25 per cent. Canada is getting more and more out of cattle raising, and more and more into wheat. Wheat growing has gone into Alberta, the great cattle raising province, and is going further north every year. While nobody can prophesy, and while it is dangerous to draw deductions, there is one thing clear, and it is this: that there are no circumstances apparent at present which would lead anyone to prophesy that wheat would go up. Whatever indications are there point to the fact that wheat is going to come down. Take this year. The prices I quoted were 26/-, 23/- or 21/-. Take the highest price and make it 27/-, if you like, and for all you know, and for all any Deputy knows, the price of wheat may fall further next year. Twenty-six shillings plus 2/6 is 28/6. Last year, for good milling wheat in this country, you got 30/-. In the light of these facts does any Deputy in the House seriously think that you can get one acre of wheat extra for that 2/6 in view of the fact that last year and the year before farmers who had milling wheat to sell could get 30/- a barrel for it?

Comment on this

What do you mean by last year? Do you mean last autumn?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Yes.

Comment on this

Where did you get it?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I know cases.

Comment on this

You did.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Would the Deputy quote a figure?

Comment on this

I would like to know of anybody who got more than 27/- last year.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I do. I made inquiries about wheat which was delivered to the mill, and they got 29/- and 30/-last year.

Comment on this

Does the Minister read the statements issued by his own Department?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Yes. The year before it went up to 31/-.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

But did the area of wheat raised increase one iota? There are 31,000 acres, roughly, growing at present. That has been the acreage for the past two or three years. In spite of the fact, as Deputy Ryan admits, that, say, the year before last 30/- could be got for wheat—I put this to Deputy O'Connell, or anyone who likes, not from the agricultural point of view, but from the business position with the basic price round about 27/-, if he offers 2/6 more than 29/6 or 28/6, it may be lower or higher, in view of the fact that wheat was fetching between 30/- and 31/- the year before last, and that the area has remained absolutely constant and even with the price of 31/—does he think that there is the slightest chance of getting 10,000 acres extra? There is not the slightest possible chance of getting the difference between the present figure of 32,000 and 100,000 acres for a subsidy of 2/6 a barrel. I will put a ten pound note aside and buy all the wheat that would be grown by every member of the Dáil at the fixed price of 28/-, that would be brought genuinely in because of that price.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

That would not rob you.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

A ten-pound note would buy the lot of it. Deputy Lemass is not a farmer. I know he is a business man. I assume that Deputy Lemass, even though he is living in the heart of the city, has a rood of ground behind his house the same as everyone else has. He could sow as much in that rood as would be grown by the rest of the Party under the influence of that subsidy. So that he is in the competition. A ten-pound note would buy it all.

Comment on this

We have it sown already.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I tried to explain often to Deputy de Valera and Deputy Lemass at the meetings of the Economic Committee that a mere 2/6 a barrel extra would have no influence on the farmer who is not already growing wheat for sale.

Comment on this

An extra shilling on beet has had a big effect.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The subsidy on beet is over £20 an acre, and most of the beet is substituted beet.

Comment on this

A lot was made of the extra shilling.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

There is no analogy. It is not the extra shilling they were thinking of; it was the 43 shillings or the 44 shillings that were behind it. When a farmer is considering the question of whether he will sow wheat or not, he has to take into account very much more than the price he is going to get for it. If I was thinking of growing wheat on a large scale as a catch crop, the way I would approach it is this, not whether I would get 2/6 a barrel extra for the wheat, but whether I would have to change my economy to a considerable extent. If you want anything like 100,000 acres or 200,000 acres, a great many people in this country must sow three, four, five or six, and in some cases ten acres extra, and when I come to the question of growing ten acres there will be the question of other crops. I am sowing so much oats, so much roots, and so much barley for feeding. Yet I have to buy between £400 and £500 worth of feeding stuffs each year. The smaller, mixed farmer has to buy correspondingly less. The best mixed farmers are the men who are buying the most feeding stuffs and who are tilling most. I ask myself why have I to buy these foodstuffs? I could, if I wished, substitute additional oats, additional barley, which I could grow, but if I grow that I am short of hay for my stock in winter time, and I am short of a certain amount of grazing for my cows. That, of course, does not apply to every farmer. It applies to the best farmers, the people who are tilling most, the people who are likely to respond to any inducement for increased tillage. I have to ask myself is it worth my while to change my whole economy, to break up more land for the purpose of producing a catch-crop which, in the main, even with a subsidy, will hardly leave me a profit. These are the considerations I will take into account. You might possibly, by guaranteeing a price of 33/- or 34/- a barrel, get 60,000 or 70,000 additional acres, but if you want to look for 200,000 or 300,000 acres you must contemplate that the farmers whose lands are suitable for wheat-growing will put them under wheat and use them under wheat in big quantities, that they will go into tillage in a big way. To get them to do that, you will have to offer them an extravagant subsidy. An agricultural inspector put the thing in a nutshell, in answer to a question by Deputy de Valera. He asked him what he thought would induce farmers to grow 300,000 or 400,000 acres of wheat. His answer was "the gun." That is what it comes to.

Comment on this

A very cheap weapon.

Comment on this

An invention, of course, of the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Ask any of the other members.

Comment on this

I may say that I heard it a long time ago from another member of the Commission.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Does the Deputy seriously suggest that he did not hear that answer?

Comment on this

Yes. That happened.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Absolutely, in the presence of every member of the Commission. I thought it was the correct answer.

Comment on this

It is a good joke.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It is not a good joke; it is the truth. No money inducement that you could mention without being so extravagant that it would be laughed at, would get, in the circumstances of this country, 300,000 or 400,000 acres of wheat extra. Supposing you did, by offering an extravagant monetary inducement to farmers, get an increase from 31,000 to 100,000 you would pay for that, roughly speaking, in my opinion, £2 an acre. You would pay something like between £150,000 and £200,000 for that. What would you have got? In nine cases out of ten you would not have got an extra acre of tillage. You would have got substitution. We examined this question of substitution with great care at the Economic Committee and no one was able to suggest a practical way in which you could prevent substitution. If you are to prevent substitution you must hold, first, a survey of the crops of the country. You must know exactly what each farmer is sowing. You must re-inspect them every year and afterwards you must provide most intricate, elaborate and costly machinery to prevent farmers from dealing with each other and getting around it. We are paying a handsome subsidy for sugar beet, over £20 an acre. Yet it is very largely substituted. I should say that out of 10,000 acres of sugar beet there are between 7,000 and 8,000 acres substituted sugar beet. So, if you had spent between £150,000 and £200,000 to get about one-sixth of the wheat supplies of the country for the sake of saying we were growing wheat, you would have spent it largely not to bring about increased tillage but simply for the substitution of one crop for another. As well as the loss to the taxpayers of the country in spending £200,000 wastefully, you would have the cost of the administration and you would have a further and even heavier indirect loss; you would have persuaded farmers to get out of a permanent system which might have been quite sound, a system which, in my opinion, is a sound system, of raising crops on the farm for consumption on the farm, to give it up, temporarily, because it could only be temporarily, and to revert to another system which was bound to break down. You would have persuaded numbers of farmers to sow wheat on land that was unsuitable and, in my opinion, the direct loss due to that would be greater than the loss due to administration costs and the waste of the subsidy.

Comment on this

Has the sugar beet scheme been a failure?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Analogies should not be drawn by people—let farmers and industrialists draw analogies between themselves. I do not want to go into this.

Comment on this

It is an awkward query.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Frightfully awkward for a fellow who knows nothing about it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

So far as the subsidy is concerned it would get us nowhere. It would be immensely costly. It would be availed of by farmers to change the existing and better economy, the production of crops, both corn and roots, for consumption on the farm. In addition to that what would be happening would be that the subsidy would be paid, so far as it was paid at all, by farmers on the poor land in favour of the farmers on the rich land. You would have no wheat grown in the poorer districts. You would have no wheat grown in Leitrim. I did not hear much about wheat in the Sligo-Leitrim election. The Land Commission annuities are a lot better there. Stick to land annuities. In Sligo they grow very little wheat. In Galway or any of the Western counties or in any of the light land you have little wheat. So far as you can induce wheat growing at all, it would be on the better land, and so far as the farmers who were paying that subsidy as taxpayers—I know they would not be paying the whole of it—are concerned it would be the farmers on the poor land who would be paying the subsidy for the benefit of the farmers on the rich land.

What, therefore, are the arguments in favour of wheat-growing? The position about wheat-growing is this: it is an admitted fact that the trend of prices has been against wheat for a long period as against any other crop. By that I do not suggest simply that wheat has fallen. When I speak of the trend of prices I mean wheat has fallen and the price of other crops has risen. As between the two, taking an index figure, say, in 1848 or 1860, the trend of prices has been against wheat as compared with any other crop—barley, oats, mangolds or turnips. That establishes at least a prima facie case that wheat pays the farmer less than any other crop, and that prima facie case is absolutely confirmed when you look at the figures and find that there are three or four hundred thousand acres of oats, four or five hundred thousand acres of potatoes, two or three hundred thousand acres of turnips and mangolds, and only 31,000 acres of wheat. That is the position for a long number of years. When you take these circumstances together you are inevitably driven to the conclusion that wheat pays the farmer less than any other crop, and you can only get away from that conclusion on the assumption that the farmer is a fool and does not know his business. That is an assumption which I refuse to make. If it is once accepted, then another question arises. Nobody suggests that there should not be more tillage. There should be. There is plenty of room for an increase in oats, ample room for an increase in barley for feeding purposes, and ample room for an increase in turnips and mangolds. The position is that the best farmers in the country are mixed farmers, and they are the people who are tilling most. On the other hand, there are many farmers, almost a majority, who, while they are in exactly the same position as mixed farmers, are not tilling nearly as much, and the real problem is to get that majority up to the standard of the best mixed farmers. There is ample room for an increase in oats, mangolds, turnips and barley, and therefore if you are going to subsidise you have a choice of crops. We do not stand for subsidies for many reasons. We believe that they are wasteful in administration, that they will lead mainly to substitution, and that they are mainly paid by people who are subsidised, so that they result in nothing. If you are to subsidise, why not subsidise other crops? You would get better results.

It is absolutely certain that a bigger subsidy will be required to make an unprofitable crop profitable. It is absolutely certain that it will take a bigger subsidy to make wheat profitable than the subsidy required for oats, a crop which pays to some extent, at any rate. There is, however, no case for any subsidy, no matter how small, on wheat. There is no point in saying: "Let us make experiments." It would cost a tremendous amount of money to get all the wheat required in this country grown here. Let us say 20 per cent. What is the advantage of getting 20 per cent.? Why should we? If we have money to spare in order to get a 20 per cent. increase in tillage, why not apply it in other directions? What particular virtue has wheat? Wheat is a most precarious crop. It exhausts the soil, it fouls the land, and it fails often. It gives a lower profit; so far as the average farmer is concerned, he makes less profit out of it than any other crop. If you take the other side, and if a farmer can sow more oats, more barley, more turnips and mangolds, the conclusion is inevitable that instead of spending whatever money you have on wheat it could be spent on encouraging the production of crops which are already paying the farmer, but which he could still grow with twice as much profit. That disposes absolutely of the contention that while it may be impossible to get all the wheat required in the country produced here we could get portion of it. We do not believe in this policy, and we are not going to make experiments. If other parties believe that experiments should be made let them make them and let them take all the credit or all the blame attached to them. I have no faith in that policy. I do not believe in subsidies, particularly in regard to wheat, and we do not intend to subsidise wheat. As I have said before, I do not care what your protestations may be, there never will be a subsidy for wheat, except, perhaps, for one year. We may get away with it on political issues, but when we get down to hard, practical facts and try to get the farmer to do certain things we have to stop talking in generalities and we find that we are up against insuperable difficulties.

Now with regard to the flour-milling proposal, we are told that we are approaching this question with a prejudice against the flour millers, that we are always acting as devil's advocates, and that the normal and patriotic point of view should be to approach the question sympathetically and with a view to insuring, if at all possible, that the millers should get a tariff. I entirely deny that particular definition of patriotism. I believe in the good old maxim that the man who pays the piper should call the tune. I believe that the consumer is as good an Irishman as the producer. He is often the same person. I believe that the consumer, who pays for any tariff and whose point of view we represent, is absolutely entitled to make sure first that a tariff is necessary and, secondly, that if it is necessary only the very minimum tariff should be given. If I go into a shop to buy certain goods for £1 and if I am told by the producer that I will have to pay £1 5s. 0d., I am entitled to say that I can get them at £1 next door and that I earned that 5s. I am entitled to ask why he charges £1 5s. 0d., and, if he gives as his reason the cost of production, I am entitled to ask him whether he is sure that his business is organised on proper lines and whether changes in his business would not enable him to sell that article at the same price as other producers. I am entitled to go further and say: "Would changes in your business enable you to sell it at £1 2s. 6d.?" That point of view is forgotten by the Fianna Fáil Party. The idea is that anybody producing in this country has only to call himself a patriot, and protest that he is producing for the good of the country and not for his own profit, to ask for a tariff and, unless the consumer can prove that he does not want the tariff, the consumer must fork out his hard-earned money.

Comment on this

Could the Minister mention the emigration statistics for the last five years?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What have they got to do with it?

Comment on this

Everything.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Deputy's way to stop emigration is to force the consumer to pay an uneconomic and high price for everything. The moment you mention tariffs, make the slightest criticism of them and suggest that a certain manufacturer is not entitled to be constantly spoon-fed by the unfortunate agricultural labourer who is paid £1 or 25/- per week——

Comment on this

Until he gets his passage to America.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The moment you suggest that the unfortunate consumer, who may be an agricultural labourer trying to rear a family on 22/6 a week, or a small farmer, with whom the Deputy is in sympathy, making £50 a year, is entitled to examine with a microscope the amount of subsidy he should pay, you shout "Emigration."

I cannot see how this policy of increasing prices in general, increasing the price of cotton cake, woollens, flour, boots—all these necessaries of life—by tariffs is going to keep more people in Leitrim-Sligo or more people in the poorer areas of Donegal. I can see that there are advantages in tariffs both from the point of view of the industrialist and the nation as a whole, but I cannot see, from the point of view of the consumer, that the fact that he has to pay more for his necessaries of life or for the raw materials of production, is going to enable him to keep one son more at home.

Comment on this

Would the Minister comment on the fact that County Leitrim has the highest emigration statistics in Ireland?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I will. County Leitrim has the highest emigration statistics in Ireland because the people are paying 11/- per cwt. for Indian meal. They ought to be made pay 14/- and emigration would stop at once! They are paying, I should say, 15/- per cwt. for cotton cake. They ought to be made pay 20/-!

Comment on this

What would they do with cotton cake?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Feed calves occasionally. I do not know exactly what the present price is, but in any case the suggestion is they should be made to pay up to £1 per cwt. and emigration would stop immediately! Whatever else Deputy Lemass may be, he is not exactly stupid. There are ways in which he is not stupid, and when he puts it to me that there is more emigration in County Leitrim than in any other county in Ireland and asks me to explain why that is so in view of the fact that there are no industries and no tariffs in Leitrim, he knows he is entirely irrelevant. I am making a specific point in connection with tariffs. I admit that tariffs to a certain limited extent increase employment and increase wealth. I am pointing out that there is another side to it and that unless people who impose tariffs are very careful, the evils which tariffs bring in their train will more than counterbalance the advantages.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not want this to develop into a debate on tariffs generally.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

To come back to the question of flour, we are told that milling is disappearing. I see no evidence of that. As far as I can get any information, there is practically the same amount of flour milled in the country this year as last year or the year before. It is, roughly, the same. There are no indications that the mills are going to be closed immediately. We are told by Deputy Lemass that we ought to ignore the case made by the flour millers and, with his usual modesty, he goes on to inform us that he is prepared to make a much better case. I read carefully the case made by the flour millers and I listened very carefully to the case Deputy Lemass attempted to make for them. My view, for what it is worth, is that they made a very much better case for themselves than Deputy Lemass did, and their case was the worst I ever listened to or read. There is, in my opinion, no case whatever for a tariff on flour in this country. At the present moment, fifty per cent. of the flour consumed in the country is being produced in the country, very largely from imported wheat. At the present moment, the Irish flour millers have adequate protection. They have 12/- per ton on flour and 15/- per ton on offals. Wheat, except parcel wheat, can be bought at practically the same price here as in Birkenhead. The spot price is the same in Liverpool as in Dublin. If you take the case of a mill at Birkenhead and a mill here in Dublin, and say that the miller in Birkenhead buys ten tons of wheat and the miller in Dublin also buys ten tons. They buy it at the same price and they mill it into flour and offals. From the ten tons of wheat in each case there are got seven tons of flour and three tons of offals. You have got the seven tons of flour in Birkenhead, if you like, free on board, and the seven tons of flour in Dublin. You have got three tons of offals in Birkenhead and three tons of offals in Dublin.

Assume that the two consignments of flour and offals from Birkenhead are being sold here in Dublin in competition with the flour and offals produced here. The freights between Birkenhead and Dublin—they are less than the freights between Birkenhead and Galway, or Birkenhead and Limerick, so I am taking the figures that are least favourable to myself—are 12/- per ton for flour. It costs the miller in Birkenhead, therefore, 84/- to take over that seven tons of flour to Dublin. It costs him 15/- per ton to take over the three tons of offals—that is 45/-, or a total for the whole consignment of 129/-. In other words, by the time that the seven tons of flour and the three tons of offals are landed in Dublin to compete with the seven tons of flour and the three tons of offals produced here, the English miller has paid 129/-. The Irish miller can get exactly the same price for his offals as the English miller. Therefore he has that protection. It works out, roughly speaking, at 2/4 per sack. That is the protection as between Dublin and Birkenhead. These figures cannot be challenged except it is alleged that wheat can be purchased cheaper in Birkenhead than in Dublin. Wheat can be purchased cheaper in Birkenhead than in Dublin, but only to a very limited extent. As Deputy Lemass admitted when he was making his case, the amount of parcel wheat that is bought is only an infinitesimal portion of cargo wheat. The spot price is the same in Dublin as in Birkenhead. The cost of the raw material is the same, and the freight is not denied.

On these figures, which the flour millers admitted, and which were not denied in any evidence put before the Economic Committee, there is already a protection of over 2/- per sack on flour milled in this country in favour of the home millers. Is that protection not enough for them? Is there any reason why it should not be? Is there any reason why the consumer should be asked to pay them more? Is there any reason why the small farmer, the small shopkeeper, or the labourer in the poorer districts, should be asked to pay more? I cannot see it. We are told that Irish mills are suffering from one disadvantage, inasmuch as, for commercial reasons, they cannot make patent flour; they can only make straight-run flour. They do find it impossible for commercial reasons to make patent flour because they have no market for the low-grade flour left over. I should say that not more than 20 per cent. of the flour consumed in the country is patent flour, and until the millers are producing 80 per cent., between 70 per cent. and 80 per cent., of the flour consumed in the country, they are not under any disadvantage whatever by reason of the fact that they are not able to make patent flour. We are told, also, as an inducement, that the farmers will get the benefit of cheap offals. I would like to know why. Roughly speaking, if all the flour consumed in this country were milled in the country we would have 20 to 25 per cent. too much offals. Roughly speaking, if 75 per cent. of the flour consumed in this country were milled in the country we would have exactly the amount of offals required in the country. Now, until the mills reach that capacity, that is to say, 75 per cent., there will be no surplus, and there is no reason on earth why the price of offals should fall by one penny.

In my opinion, until the mills reach 80 per cent. of the total requirements of the country there will be no surplus offals that will make any difference to the price. The price of offals would not fall one penny. There is no use in saying they would. There are many people in business who could sell cheaper than they do. In business a man gets what he is able. He gets the maximum price. I get the highest price I can in business. Every other person says the same. Otherwise they would not be in business. There is no reason why there should be a fall of a single penny in the price of bran or pollard until 80 per cent. of the flour used in the country is milled in the country instead of as at present 50 per cent.

I am satisfied that patent flour will always be demanded in this country. I personally believe from the witnesses I have heard and from my reading of the Tariff Commission Report that the millers contemplate always importing patent flour. It is almost impossible to keep patent flour out, because you cannot get a test which can be operated at the ports. I am quite satisfied that they contemplate always importing patent flour. The position of the millers is this: "We would be very glad to get 80 per cent. of the flour business because a lot of us have bakeries. We would be very glad to import patent flours and we will then be in the happy position of being protected by a tariff. We will be able to sell our flour up to the hilt and we need not give a rebate of a single penny in the offals, because as long as patent flour comes in and offals up to that 20 per cent. are not brought in there will be no surplus of offals." Even if patent flour were stopped the first effect of the tariff, as almost admitted in the Minority Report, would be to bring in much more efficient and better equipped mills.

I am absolutely satisfied that the first effect of the tariff would be to wipe out the country mills. I do not believe there would be a small mill left in Cork. We will be asked, of course, to stop these millers from coming in and we will be asked to control prices. Do not ask us that again. We have some experience of controlling prices and we have some experience also of the waste and extravagance and inefficiency entailed in having prices controlled. It is practically impossible for a Government to control prices with any sort of satisfaction to the consumer. If a tariff is imposed there is no question about it efficient mills will come in, and come in immediately, and the smaller mills will be wiped out. The milling trade of this country, which at present is not in the hands of a very large number of people, will then be in the hands of a much smaller number, and I have sufficient confidence in the business instincts of these millers to believe that they will see to it that even if there is a seasonal surplus of offals that they would be kept off the market, that they would be put into compound cakes and sold here at world prices, and even if there is a slight rebate to the wholesaler, I know that by the time it comes down to me and to Deputy Gorey we will get very little of that rebate.

Comment on this

The resources of civilisation are not yet exhausted.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

From the point of view of the consumer there will be no rebate. It cannot be denied that until the home milling reaches 80 per cent. of the requirements there would be no surplus of offals and no reduction. The first effect of the tariff will be to reduce the number of mill owners in this country, and everybody knows that in the absence of Government control that is going to lead to an arrangement which will insure that the full prices would be charged for the flour, that full advantage would be taken of the tariff, and that full world prices will be received for the offals. Deputy Lemass took great care to show us that under certain circumstances— he quoted a lot of figures about the fluctuation of the prices of bread and the relation between bread and flour and showed to his own satisfaction that the millers could have sold their flour at cheaper prices in certain circumstances. Of course they could. That argument is positively childish. It is not a question of what a business man can sell an article at. It is not a question whether a business man could sell at a certain price and still take a profit. Every business man sells at the highest possible price he can get, and if a tariff is imposed business men will charge fully up to that tariff and the only thing that can stop them is internal competition. If the milling business falls into the hands of the Dublin Milling Company and the few millers connected with it, there will be no internal competition and they would be fools if there were. They would be a most incompetent body if there were internal competition.

Comment on this

Does the Minister imply that the milling industry is controlled by a few persons just as the bakers' industry is controlled by the Master Bakers' Association?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That will be in the control of three or four companies, and they would not be so foolish as to cut each other's throats.

Comment on this

Does not that apply in the case of bread just as in the case of flour?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am not in a position to answer that. I have not much knowledge of the costings in the bread industry but I do know this particular subject and I am dealing with it now. What are the reasons for the tariff? It has not been proved here that the milling industry is dying. The figures show that the industry is practically stationary. It has not been proved here that the millers made any suggestion to meet their difficulties in another way. Deputy Lemass asked what can be done for the millers. What can be done for people who have already protection to the extent of 2/- a sack? I tell you one thing that can be done—that is a good basis to start with. We are told that if they reach their maximum output, if they were working at their full capacity, that their cost of production would be reduced and they could compete with the British.

What is to stop them reaching their maximum output? Capital? We will give it to them. There is the Trade Loans (Guarantee) Act. Let them come forward and make application under the Trade Loans (Guarantee) Act. But why should they do that? As long as there is any hope that there is going to be a tariff imposed, and that the unfortunate consumer is going to be bled to the extent of 2/- or 3/- a sack for their benefit, why should they take the trouble of equipping their mills so as to work to their full capacity? As a matter of fact, the millers are solving their difficulties, and they would have solved them long ago only for all the nonsense that is talked about a tariff on flour. When we have definitely shown that we are not going to be humbugged on this issue you will find that the millers will do this, and they will be able to look after themselves, with the result that the output of their mills will be increased.

Comment on this

Could not that argument be used against every application for a tariff?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It could not. Every application must stand on its merits. I could put up an excellent case for a tariff on oats and margarine.

Comment on this

That would be something different from what you are doing now.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Deputy suffers from the delusion that tariff reform is a sort of dogma which applies generally and in all circumstances. When I pointed out that the consumer was entitled to ask whether a tariff was necessary and how much it should be, Deputy Lemass nodded approval. Now he goes back to his old position. One tariff is the same as another, and everything, in fact, should be tariffed. He sees no reason why the arguments I put forward in regard to this industry should not apply to every other industry as well. What the Deputy really means is that there should be a sound principle of economics setting out that every industry in every country should get whatever tariff it required. Of course that is absurd. I know that the millers have their special difficulties. The Minister for Industry and Commerce did not charge the millers with inefficiency. He pointed out that the mills were built at times when, perhaps, the economic conditions were different. Now, because of location and other causes, they were unsuitably placed, and in certain cases there was not the most efficient management.

If it is true that the mills will be on a paying basis immediately they reach their maximum production and when they are working full time, then why not reach that position in another way? What do they want? Do they want money? That is what the Trade Loans (Guarantee) Act was passed for. Let them prove their case and the money is there for them. They want a tariff instead, a tariff which will give them a permanent subsidy. The Deputy knows quite well that once a tariff is imposed it is next to impossible to take it off. Indiscriminate tariffs are a bad principle, but it would be worse if there was a Government in charge which would give a tariff one year and take it off the next year. There would be absolutely no security. It is no use suggesting that this tariff might be removed later on.

There was one other point which had relation to dumping. I think Deputy Lemass admitted in cross-examination that he had no case in regard to that. The Deputy started to prove what dumping meant. He pointed out that dumping meant selling below the cost of production. He asked us how could the millers have knowledge of it. Who would have better knowledge? The millers are in touch with their customers, and they know at what price their customers are able to get flour from other concerns. If they cannot get information with regard to dumping, no one can get it. They came forward on two occasions to deal with the question of dumping, and on both occasions when they attempted to prove it they failed lamentably. There was one attempt made to prove there was dumping and a start was made with the price of 45/- odd for wheat. The witness admitted in the course of examination that suitable wheat could be got at 44/6. The figures brought forward on that occasion proved that there was no dumping. When it is in the interests of an organisation to prove dumping, and when that organisation, which has all the requisite knowledge and the opportunities of getting full knowledge, fails to prove dumping, then it certainly ought not to lie with the Deputy to allege that there is dumping. There is no proof of dumping. It is a fact that competition is keen, that English millers are selling at very keen prices, and that England is over-milled and is competing with the Irish mills in a strenuous way. But when one remembers that the Irish millers have already ample protection in the way of freights and transit charges, then no case can be made for a tariff for that reason.

I would like to refer to page 16 of the Minority Report. I would like to take one example from the figures given there. We are told that a certain amount of flour was brought into this country and that it was sold at a certain figure. I find that it works out at 45/7 a sack. We are told that the wheat to produce it could be bought for a certain figure, which I work out at 31/6. I then applied 31/6 for wheat to the costings figure given in the Deputy's own report, and I find, on his own figures, that the flour cost 40/6 to produce. Mutatis mutandis—the the cost of producing the flour was 40/6. The position, on the Deputy's own figures, is that flour can be produced at 40/6 and sold at 45/7. In addition to that there are offals amounting to nearly £1,000,000. Apparently, on the Deputy's own figures, there is a fortune to be made in flour; that is, if these figures are correct. You would there have a profit of 5/- on the price of flour and, in addition, you would have the offals.

Comment on this

Where are these figures?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

On page 16 of the Minority Report the following appears: "During the twelve months, January-December, 1927, there were imported into the Free State 3,380,984 cwts. of wheaten flour, valued at £3,084,634." I calculate that that works out at 45/7 a sack.

Comment on this

And that includes patent flours?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Exactly. I calculate it is sold for 45/7. The Report goes on: "If there had been an effective import duty in operation during that period resulting in the complete exclusion of foreign flour, the quantity of wheat which should have been imported to produce the same quantity of flour... would have been 4,695,811 cwts. At the prices for wheat prevailing during that year these 4,695,811 cwts. would have been secured for £2,954,447, or £130,187 less than the amount paid for the corresponding quantity of flour." I calculate that that works out at 31/6 a sack.

Comment on this

A barrel.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It is the same thing— 20 stones. Now let us go back to the costings. I find on the Deputy's own costings that to turn the wheat into flour would work out at 40/6 per sack. That leaves us a profit of 5/1, plus all the offals.

Comment on this

I am satisfied that the Minister sees the flaw in that argument.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No.

Comment on this

Of course you do.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The figures here show a profit of 5/1 per sack of flour, together with the full cost of the offals. I do not believe that.

Comment on this

I knew you did not.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I merely quote it to show the Deputy that his figures are absurd. In the course of the debate I told him that we had too many statistics in this country. Seditious literature and statistics are the curse of this country. It should be made a penal offence to publish statistics. The amount of injury that the Statistics Branch of the Department of Industry and Commerce is doing to the Party opposite is almost unbelievable. They produce these figures, and they draw deductions from them showing how much we lose and by how much our trade balance is so adversely affected. But when I make a calculation from their figures I find a perfectly ludicrous result. The only lesson to be drawn from all this—and I have warned Deputies about it already—is that they should not use these figures without realising all the implications that may follow. The figures which have led to such results as I have quoted are about as valuable as the rest of the figures, and that means that they have no value at all.

Comment on this

The Minister should write another "Alice in Wonderland."

Comment on this

The Minister started his speech by saying that you are never going to persuade the farmers to grow 100,000 acres of wheat. I notice that in 1925 the Minister, speaking on the question of wheat, said that for the last two or three years the farmer was paying £1 0s. 6d. for a bag of flour that he could produce off his land at 12/- if that land were in good heart. When he stated that before, Deputy Gorey stood up and said that the land in this country would not produce wheat. Most of the land in the country has produced wheat. At that time the Minister was advocating the growing of wheat by the farmers in the country. Deputy Gorey was then, as now, opposed to the growing of wheat. The Minister, in his speech to-day, has made it out to be one of the biggest disasters that could befall a farmer to grow wheat on account of the injury it is going to do to his lands, and so on. During these last four years he must have found out his mistake, or if not, he is trying now to score a point against us as to the conditions under which wheat is grown, as he scored a point against the then Opposition, which was the Farmers' Party. The Minister said: "It was done practically all over the country." Mr. Gorey said: "It was done. When?" The Minister said: "It was done between 1840 and 1850.""It was when they had nothing else to eat," said Deputy Gorey.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What are you reading from?

Comment on this

One of your speeches.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I know, but I would like to re-read it.

Comment on this

The Dáil debates, 4th June, 1925. Later the Minister said: "They could, on the average, produce barley and oats 3/- or 4/- a cwt. cheaper than they can purchase. Indian meal. They can produce wheat for 7/- or 8/- per cwt. cheaper than they can purchase flour." Our economy has changed since then. If we were to do that now the whole economy of the farmer would be changed. The man who is tilling 15 acres out of 200 acres, and the small farmer proportionately, would have to grow more oats, more roots, would have to go into his meadow and have no hay for the winter. He would have to sell his live stock; in fact, farming would have to be changed so much that you would have to compensate the farmer, not only for growing wheat but for having his whole farm turned topsy-turvy, but in 1925 that was not the policy, when the Farmers' Party were in opposition. But now, when the Farmers' Party have joined the Government Party that is the wrong policy. "If I am wrong in that, I want to be shown where I am wrong. I want to be shown I am wrong when I say that you can produce a cwt. of barley for 8/-, and you can produce it on the average slightly less than one ton to the statute acre."

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Will the Deputy state what is he quoting from?

Comment on this

From the Minister's speech in 1925. "I will give you some figures which may be of interest"—the Minister was interested in statistics at that time—"He can produce barley at 8/-, yet he is giving 12/- for Indian meal. That man might have two or three sons who might not be working terribly hard. What has that man been giving for flour, for instance, for the last two or three years? He was paying £1 or £1 0s. 6d. for the bag. He could produce that for about 12/- off his own land if that land was in good heart. When I stated that before, Deputy Gorey said that very little land will produce wheat. Most of the land of this country has produced wheat."

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Of course.

Comment on this

And Mr. Conlon said "Of a sort." The Minister said, "It was done, practically over the whole country." Mr. Gorey said, "It was done. When?" The Minister said. "It was done between 1840 and 1850," and Deputy Gorey said, "It was when they had nothing else to eat."

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That is all right. I stand by every word of that.

Comment on this

He said later: "I am only pointing out that they could produce wheat, and did produce it." He said: "Wheat cannot be produced upon a good deal of the land in the country at present because the land has gone back and it is not in good heart," and the Minister made this very interesting observation: "I have seen the land myself and I know it." He knew from the look of the land that it could produce wheat. Now, what does the Minister know after four more years of experience? The Minister said that if there was a dislocation between Ireland and England some two years ago and if that dislocation had continued the serious thing we would be up against would not be to get food into Ireland but to get food out of Ireland. I heard him make that observation before. But I never quite understood it until he said why. He said the dislocation would be between England and Ireland only, that the rest of the world would be in communication with us to supply us with wheat, provided that we had the money to pay for it. He said that we could get it from Canada or the Argentine if we were able to pay for it. But we would not be able to pay for it because England would not take our produce. What is wrong with that, supposing we were in that position? It must be that we are wrong in having only one market for our produce or that we are wrong in bringing wheat from a foreign country, because we may be in a predicament some time. Therefore, until we get alternative markets for our produce or have other than the British market for our cattle, butter and eggs and other things, I think we are in a very precarious position, just as wheat is a precarious crop, if we do not produce more of our own foodstuffs. I read in the Majority Report a lot of things. It talks about the good time we could have by living on the best of beef, butter, bacon and everything else, and it actually goes so far as to say that if the thing were to last for a couple of years we could even begin to sow our own wheat. Where we are to get the seed from is a mystery. Even, if such a situation were to occur suddenly in the month of October, when we would have the largest amount of wheat available, we would not have half the amount necessary to sow the land to provide one year's supply. What would we do in the meantime?

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Stirabout.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Try bacon.

Comment on this

We have not enough bacon and stirabout. Presumably, the live stock of the country in such a case would be fed on the grain and the produce of the land, we would be fed on the live stock, and our dead bodies would be thrown out on the land for manure in order to make up the circuit. The Majority Report starts off by giving us an insight into the minds of the men who read and signed the Majority Report, and I suppose some of them did not read it before they signed it. On page 1 of that report it is stated: "Otherwise the millers would be subject to unfair competition inasmuch as flours manufactured from imported wheats, if sold without restriction, would appeal more strongly to public taste than flour made wholly or partially from native wheat." There you have the mind of people who, naturally and without question, will always take it for granted that anything made from Irish wheat or anything of Irish manufacture will be inferior to the foreign article until it is proved to be superior. The onus is always on the Irish article to prove itself superior. If they had gone to the trouble of looking up the application for a tariff on flour they would find there a proof that the native wheat was superior in flavour and colour. Messrs. Odlum and Odlum, on page 93 of the Tariff Commission Report, reporting on samples of Irish wheat submitted to them by the Department of Agriculture, said: "We are of opinion that wheat of the type reported on above can be incorporated in the average Irish miller's grist to great advantage, both in the matter of colour and of flavour." They did not say that there would be no disadvantage in incorporating it; they said that it could be incorporated with great advantage not only in the matter of flavour, but in the matter of colour, so that you could have your cream loaf of better flavour.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Read on.

Comment on this

I will read on if you wish.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Read your own Minority Report.

Comment on this

Paragraph 2.

Comment on this

I have very little time now, and I would like to get on to a few other points. That shows the prejudice of the men who started to write the Majority Report. In addition to their prejudice there was their ignorance. They say on page 9, paragraph 12: "Popular taste in the Saorstát at present demands bakers' bread of a kind which can be made only from flour milled from a grist composed wholly or almost wholly of strong wheat." I do not know who in particular was responsible for this report, but very likely it was the Minister for Agriculture who took responsibility for it. But I think that the Minister for Agriculture, surrounded by a competent staff, might have been advised that there is no bread made by a baker composed wholly or almost wholly of flour coming from a strong wheat. The ordinary mixture that the bakers make up contains 60 per cent. from a strong wheat and 40 per cent. from a weak wheat. That is neither the whole nor almost the whole. If it had been 10 per cent. from weak wheat and 90 per cent. from strong wheat that statement might have been justified, but certainly where it is a matter of 40 per cent. you could hardly use that expression. Then they speak of the difficulty of getting strong wheat grown in this country. I think they admit that a certain amount of weak wheat can be grown, but not strong wheat. We will assume for the moment that that is true. Of all the wheat imported into this country we find that two-thirds used for domestic purposes is weak wheat or flour, as the case may be, and of the other third, 40 per cent. is weak wheat or weak flour. So that, as a matter of fact, 80 per cent. of the flour used in this country comes from weak wheat and only 20 per cent. from strong wheat. Therefore, it would be years and years before we would be up against the question of producing strong wheat of our own. But supposing that we were asked to produce strong wheat, what do we find? In the Journal of the Department of Agriculture, which is doing a little work for wheat, in spite of the Minister's prejudice, it is stated about Red Stettin:—"A large propagation plot of Red Stettin wheat, comprising about three Irish acres, was grown on the farm of Mr. P. O'Connor, Knocklofty, Clonmel, Co. Tipperary. From this area 46 barrels, 4 stones, 115 cwts. and 4 stones of dressed grain were obtained. The grain was of exceptionally fine quality, equivalent, in the opinion of several millers, to Manitoba Wheat No. 2."

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

All that is admitted.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

What do you say the product was?

Comment on this

25 cwt. per acre of strong wheat, and they get only 9 in Canada. "A small scale baking test on samples of flour from this wheat showed that it was sufficiently strong for the making of loaves of high volume, and, moreover, in other respects, notably as regards flavour, it compared favourably with loaves made from an ordinary commercial mixture." That is from the Journal of the Department of Agriculture, the twenty-eighth year, No. 2, page 187.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Twenty-five cwts. was all right.

Comment on this

It was not too bad. The question has been raised by some speakers, including Deputy Gorey, as to some of the disadvantages of growing wheat, and these are tabulated, to a certain extent, on page 11 of the Majority Report — considerations which would naturally influence farmers in growing wheat; one is, "the extent to which wheat growing finds a place in the economy of the system under which his farm is worked. Wheat is regarded as a more exhausting crop on the soil than other cereals." We had experts before us at the Economic Committee, and that was not proved, at any rate to my recollection. It may have been stated by some of them, and others may have stated the opposite; but it certainly was not proved that it was a more exhausting crop on the soil than other cereals.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

What is your own experience?

Comment on this

I have not that experience. But surely Deputy Gorey did not grow wheat after what he said in 1925. He has no experience.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I always grow what I use myself.

Comment on this

"Wheat occupies the land for a longer period than other cereals, and, consequently, the land under wheat is likely to become more foul with weeds and to require more cleaning than after either oats or barley." As Deputy de Valera stated, that depends on the crop. If you have a poor crop of oats or barley you will have weeds, and if you have a good crop of either of them you will not have weeds. The same applies with regard to wheat. "The suitability of the cultivated portion of his land for the production of wheat, having regard to the fact that wheat will yield a full crop only on the heavier and more fertile soils"—that is, that wheat will be produced only on land that is suitable for wheat, just the same as oats will only grow on land that is suitable for oats, and that bullocks will fatten on lands that are suitable for bullocks, and that is all about it. "If corn is grown as a cash crop, the return likely to be derived from a wheat crop as compared with a crop of oats or barley." From the figures supplied by the Department of Agriculture, the following were the results over four years with regard to oats, barley, and wheat per acre: Oats, £7 10s. 7d.; barley, £9 6s. 11d.; and wheat, £12 4s. 2d.; so that wheat is well away on its own. "There is greater difficulty in obtaining a good ‘strike' of grass seeds and clover where these seeds are sown down as a ‘nurse' crop than when sown with either oats or barley." As I stated here before, the only witness who came before us who claimed to have grown wheat, and who grew wheat on a very big scale—the Director of the Agricultural College, Athenry—when questioned by me on this matter, said that he certainly could never see any difference whatsoever between meadows that came after oats, barley or wheat; that they were the same as far as he could see; and it was not spring wheat that was grown in Athenry. Of course that can be verified by any Deputy. Deputy Brennan claimed to have grown wheat. I do not know whether he gave any evidence on this question of grass seed.

The Minister for Agriculture did have wheat grown on his farm, but I do not know that he claims to have personal experience of it. I do not remember if he gave any opinion of his experience in regard to grass seed. The next point is—"Wheaten straw is less valuable as fodder than oaten straw or even barley straw." There is no farmer here and no farmer in any other country who lives under conditions similar to those here who does not require a certain amount of straw for bedding his cattle, so that the farmer who has a certain amount of wheaten straw can use it for bedding, and if he grows oats he will use oaten straw for bedding, so that I do not see any loss from that point of view. "There is, as yet, no really prolific variety of spring wheat suitable for cultivation in this country." It would be a great advantage to the country if a prolific variety of spring wheat could be got, and that is one of the matters to which the Department ought to direct its attention. Then there is the question of adverse weather conditions, but they can be used as an argument against any crop. The Minority Report mentions that if that argument were followed to its logical conclusion we should advise the farmers to get out of tillage altogether, because there are years when farmers have the same difficulty in sowing their oats, and the same difficulty in harvesting their oats, and there are years when the farmers have to sow their turnips twice, so that the only logical conclusion, if you lay too much stress on the weather, is that the farmer should get out of tillage altogether.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Winter sowing, anyhow.

Comment on this

"There is a greater risk of a total or partial failure of a crop under wheat than in the case of other tillage crops." There appears to be the impression that that is true, but I do not know that it really is. With regard to the turnip crop, it more frequently happens, I think, that there is a total or partial failure of it than of wheat. Partial failure may not happen so often in the case of oats and barley. There is no doubt whatever but that there is often a partial failure in the case of oats and barley. That happens very often, perhaps as often as in the case of a wheat crop. These are the disadvantages given in the Majority Report against the sowing of wheat. I will go on now to the end of paragraph 18:

It may, therefore, be taken as granted that the area of wheat sown each season must depend to to a considerable degree on the weather conditions in late autumn and early winter.

Pay attention to that for a moment. The contention of the Minister for Agriculture, when speaking this evening, was that the area under wheat had remained unchanged for the last four or five years in spite of high prices and everything else, so that according to the Minister's argument weather conditions must have had no influence on the area of land that was under wheat. In each of these years there were 32,000 acres of land under wheat in spite of weather conditions and everything else. The farmers who engaged in the sowing of wheat, must, therefore, have believed that they would have been able to cultivate wheat, no matter what the weather conditions were. If, as the Minister has suggested, weather conditions had anything to do with the matter, these farmers would have ceased growing wheat. Although they continued to sow it, we are still told that they are very much opposed to the idea of wheat growing.

We come on now to paragraph 19:—

The growing of wheat on lea land which it is possible to prepare for sowing a corn crop at a time when the state of the soil would not permit of working potato or root land is not attended with success, save in the case of land which has been under grass for one year only.

I would like to know where that information came from. That is a matter that was never mentioned before the Economic Committee and, as far as I know, it was never mentioned in any agricultural paper or anywhere else. It may, of course, be the idea of someone in the Department of Agriculture. I would like to know if there is any Deputy in the Dáil, or anywhere else, who ever heard that proposition put forward before: that you cannot grow wheat on lea land except in the case of land which has been under grass for one year only.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

You hardly ever attempt to grow wheat on lea.

Comment on this

Yes, you do.

Comment on this

I saw it fail on lea.

Comment on this

Then, I suppose we may take it that Deputy Brennan was responsible for that paragraph in the report.

Comment on this

That was the Deputy's contribution to the report.

Comment on this

Further down in that paragraph it is stated:—

On the other hand, the area of land capable of producing wheat satisfactorily as a second corn crop is limited, and, except under abnormal conditions, farmers do not and would not grow wheat immediately after another corn crop.

In regard to that, I might say that one of the agricultural instructors who came before us said it was quite a common practice in his part of the country to grow wheat on stubble.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

He did not say it was quite a common practice.

Comment on this

He used that argument. At least that was my impression. Now we come on to an interesting point in paragraph 20. where they say:—

The liability of newly-sown wheat and wheat brairds to depredations by birds is a further discouraging factor. Sown at a season when bird food is scarce and no other cereals are in the ground, serious damage to winter wheat crops is caused by the ravages of birds.

That is quite true, that serious damage is caused by the ravages of birds, but it is not any more true than it would be if applied to other crops such as oats and barley in the spring time. If anyone cares to come down to the district in which I live, they will see there two fields, one under a crop of wheat and the other under a crop of oats. They can see for themselves that the wheat crop is a splendid crop, while the oat crop is practically all gone as a result of damage by birds. Therefore, I submit that putting in a paragraph of that kind in the report, where it applies not to wheat only, but to every crop, is no argument whatever against wheat-growing, unless, of course, that you want to do away altogether with tillage. Lower down in the same paragraph they state:—

Precautionary measures are not always effective in preventing such injury.

I think that any farmer who has been in the habit of growing wheat would be able to give those who wrote that paragraph a recipe for the cure of that. I think that if they were to use a pint of tar and a pint of paraffin as a mixture to prevent the damage referred to, it would be successful. In paragraph 24 they say:—

The extent to which a guaranteed price would bring about an increase in the area of wheat is subject to definite limiting factors.

Of course it is. The report then goes on to talk about the limiting factors, and continues:—

The current market price of oats and barley in relation to the fixed price of wheat,

the price of cattle and other live stock products, and so on, and concludes in this fashion:—

Unless the price of live stock and of live stock commodities, to the production of which the country is beyond question admirably adapted, should fall considerably in relation to that of wheat, the provision of subsidy for wheat, save at a prohibitive cost, would be ineffective in securing any considerable extension of the area devoted to wheat cultivation.

I want to emphasise the words "to the production of which the country is beyond question admirably adapted." There is no doubt, but that this country is admirably adapted to the production of live stock commodities, and if it is a good policy for the country, as no doubt it is a good policy as far as it goes, to get all we possibly can for our export live stock, why then do we argue against tillage? If we look at page 13 of the trade statistics you will find there that Denmark is tilling 61.2 per cent. of the total arable land of the country, while the figure for the Free State is 12.4. Denmark's net exports over imports in the matter of agricultural products represent £42,000,000 as against our £17,000,000. It would be argued, perhaps, by the Minister for Agriculture, if one were not familiar with these figures, that if this country were to till 62 per cent. of its arable land the farmer would necessarily have to go into the meadows and sell his live stock, as he would have no way of keeping them, and that the result would be that the number of live stock in the country would go down.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Not at all. What you would have to do is to do what the Danes do, turn from summer to winter farming.

Comment on this

That might not be a bad idea at all if one looks at the prices that are paid for butter and beef in the winter as compared with the summer.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I just wanted to make that point clear.

Comment on this

In paragraph 25 the argument is used that if you till a few acres of wheat you must make up for that by putting a few acres of land under roots, and that, therefore, to make up for the loss of land that is brought under the plough you must put a few additional acres of land under grain for the amount of food that has been lost, and that all that would mean upsetting the farmers' existing economy. At all events, if it does that it is going to increase the acreage of land under tillage. It is going to have the effect of increasing tillage in the country. That is what we are told in that paragraph.

In another paragraph we hear about substitution, that you will not have an additional acre tilled in the country under this scheme. Well, one or the other must be wrong. We are told in this paragraph:—

On the ordinary mixed tillage farms in the Saorstát of the class on which additional wheat would be grown, the area under grain to that under roots would, under a system of good husbandry, be in the ratio of 2—1 respectively.

In 1928 the number of acres under grain in this country was 814,000, and the number of acres under roots was 700,000, so that, according to good husbandry, we have 586,000 to be brought under grain, and therefore there would be no upsetting whatever of a farmer's existing economy. In fact, you would not only be not upsetting his existing economy, but you would be getting better husbandry than you have at present by putting an additional 586,000 acres under wheat.

In paragraph 26 they go on to say: "Some districts are better suited to this crop than are others," which is hardly deserving of mention. Then it is stated: "That wheat production, as a cash crop, is and will continue to be localised is a matter of grave importance." In one paragraph they make an assertion without any proof that wheat will be grown more in some areas than in others, and having proved that by stating it, they go on to say "that wheat production, as a cash crop, is and will continue to be localised, is a matter of grave importance."

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

"If the price of wheat be guaranteed."

Comment on this

I am reading from paragraph 27.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Quite right, but the Deputy will see that the paragraph begins: "If the price of wheat be guaranteed."

Comment on this

What I am finding fault with is that they assert in one paragraph that wheat will be grown more in one place than in another, and having asserted it they go on to apply the argument as if it was proved.

Comment on this

Read the whole sentence.

Comment on this

Yes. "If the price of wheat be guaranteed and no measures be taken to subsidise the production of other crops which can be grown on land unsuited to wheat, the fact that wheat production, as a cash crop, is and will continue to be localised, is a matter of grave importance." In paragraph 29 they say: "Immediately upon the cessation of these measures, the area declined; and although the average price of wheat in the three years 1924, 1925, and 1926 exceeded 30/- per barrel, the average annual area of wheat grown in these years did not exceed 30,000 acres." That is the argument the Minister has used, that the area remained the same even though the price was higher. As I said before, if you use that argument in that connection we can at least use it also, and say that adverse weather conditions have no effect whatever on the growing of wheat. I might have added also that in the end of 1928 the price was under 30/- per barrel, and that at the end of 1927 it was over 30/- per barrel. The farmer has to sow his wheat every year before he knows what he will get for the crop. He has to make up his mind and have the ground ready for the 1928 crop, before he knows what he will get for the 1927 crop.

In paragraph 30 they state: "Moreover, we are satisfied that the additional wheat would be grown almost entirely in substitution for oats and barley on land suitable for producing wheat and that no considerable increase in the total area under tillage would result." We have been told already that additional barley and oats will be necessary, and that not only will it not be a substitute, but that really the whole difficulty with the farmer is this, that he not only will have to grow wheat, but more roots and grain to make up for the upset in his existing economy. In spite of that assertion we are told that it will be a substitute. In paragraph 33 there is reference to "a limited number of farmers who have land in temporary pasture of indifferent quality and who are not financially in a position to stock the land fully." I think, from our experience of the number of farmers in that category in the country, you would have no difficulty in getting your million acres. A big proportion of farmers in every county and district have land temporarily under pasture, and of indifferent quality, and they are not in a financial position to stock their land. If they are able to take advantage of a wheat subsidy we would have done a service to a very big part of the population.

Again, in paragraph 33 it is stated: "In certain of the best dairying districts where a relatively small proportion of land is tilled, it is most desirable that an increased area and variety of crops should be grown for feeding on the farm, but the production of wheat as a cash crop would not, we think, tend towards a better economy on such farms." According to figures supplied by the Department of Agriculture the profit on an acre of grass for milk was £3 8s. 9d.; for beef, £3 9s. 3d., and for wheat, £2 18s. 7d. The interesting point about these figures was the data on which they were based. For instance, we were told by the Department of Agriculture that a bullock would increase by 3 cwt. on an acre of grass in one year.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Where was the land?

Comment on this

We inquired but we could not find out. The figures given for wheat were 18 cwts. per acre. What I said at the time was that if they would give us that acre of grass that was producing 3 cwt. of beef we would certainly produce 35 cwt. of wheat on it, which would change the figure from £2 18s. 7d. to £6 10s. 0d. profit on wheat. Paragraph 34 says: "A very large number of farmers produce grain (oats and barley) for the purpose of feeding live stock on their own farms." Why are they doing it? Because it pays them, and if it pays them to do it—surely they will continue to do it unless the wheat is going to be made such an attractive matter to them that they will give it up, and, from what we hear from Deputy Gorey and the Minister for Agriculture, the wheat proposition will not be so attractive as that. Again, we have sympathy for the man growing wheat at present for his own use and who will not get the subsidy. The man who is growing an acre of wheat, and that is not much, would have to have a big family to eat the food that would be produced by it. It would take a good many people to use the whole of the product of that acre in a year. That type of man who grows an acre of wheat would probably grow three or four acres if there is a subsidy, and so he will benefit more by the subsidy. I think we need not have any great sympathy with him. If he thinks he is badly treated he can sell the whole lot to the miller and buy flour for himself and his family.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

resumed the Chair.

Comment on this

Paragraph 38 says: "The scheme would be of direct benefit only to those farmers who are in a position to grow wheat for sale and not to the agricultural community as a whole." Is not that a truism? You would not think it necessary to say that it is so obviously true, but when we come to analyse it, it is not true at all. Surely the benefits, as Deputy Derrig says, would flow on to the rest of the population? It is said that if we give a subsidy on wheat that nobody will get any benefit only the farmers who produce the wheat. Does not the same apply to beet and other things? Then at the end of paragraph 39 it says: "The fact that the average farmer does make a greater profit from oats than from wheat (whether the profits be direct or indirect) is demonstrated beyond all question by the general practice of farmers themselves, by the fact that the wheat area has shrunk to 31,350 acres, while there are 648,615 acres of oats in cultivation."

In other words, the same old argument, that the farmer knows what is best for himself. If the farmer is not growing wheat, it is because it is not good for the farmer to grow wheat. The peculiar thing is that when we come to the conclusion the farmers do get a little bit of a lecture about not doing the right thing. Evidently they do not know as much about what is good for them as those who signed the Majority Report, who state:

While there are many farmers who, because of exceptional conditions, are making more money out of grass farming than they could make out of mixed farming, nevertheless, it is demonstrable that the farmers who are making most money for themselves, and creating most wealth for the country as a whole are those who do mixed farming and who are tilling a much higher percentage of their land than the average. These farmers are the minority, but they work under conditions which are common to seventy-five per cent. of the farmers of the country, inasmuch as their holdings are small and they have considerable family labour.

So that the minority of the farmers, we are told by those who signed the Majority Report, are doing the right thing for themselves and for the country, but the big majority are not doing the right thing; there are cases where the Minister for Agriculture, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and the Minister for Finance are able to tell the farmers that they are doing the wrong thing. Of course, in other cases, if we suggest a thing should be done we are told that the farmer knows his own business best. The farmer knows his own business best except in a few exceptional cases where Ministers are able to tell him that he does not know his own business best.

Comment on this

I claim just a few minutes as a farmer who does grow wheat. There has been so much soft talk and sob stuff spoken by Deputies in favour of this motion and amendment that I really think it would be too bad if a farmer who grows wheat every year was not allowed to say a word. There are many things I want to say, but which I have not time to deal with. I should however, like to take up Deputy Ryan upon page 11 of the Majority Report. This matter has been mentioned by at least three or four speakers. On page 11, No. (2) states: "Wheat is regarded as a more exhausting crop on the soil than other cereals." Then No. (3) states: "Wheat occupies the land for a longer period than other cereals and, consequently, land under wheat is liable to become more foul with weeds and to require more cleaning than after either oats or barley." Then No. (6) states: "There is greater difficulty in obtaining a good ‘strike' of grass seeds and clover where these seeds are sown down with wheat as a ‘nurse' crop than when sown with either oats or barley." I have considerable experience of growing wheat—in fact, I have been growing it all my life. I take these three paragraphs together and they are true for the same reason. As to No. (2), wheat is naturally a most exhausting crop. It is in the ground for ten months of the year, as it is sown in October, and it is there until the following August or September.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What about spring wheat?

Comment on this

Spring wheat is considered of no use. I think the general impression is that only winter wheat is of any use for flour. If you sow any crop in October and the land is undisturbed all through the following winter, spring and summer, the land must naturally be more dirty and weedy than land that has been tilled in the spring. That goes without saying. If you have land undisturbed for ten months, it must naturally be weedy and in a worse condition than other land. If a crop is drawing out of the soil for ten months and is accompanied by a large amount of weeds as well as itself, it must naturally take more out of the soil in ten months than a crop which is only in the land for four months. Then as to No. (6), any farmer who knows what it is to till land can imagine the difference in putting in grass seed in the month of April with oats or putting it in at that time of the year upon ground that has already been covered with weeds and that has been lying there for five or six months during the winter. If any Deputy cares to see the difference between sowing grass seeds with oats and with wheat, I can show them a perfect illustration of it if they come down to Roscommon. I have a field there at present that I laid down last year with grass seeds in turnip soil, potato soil and mangold soil. One piece was sown in with wheat, and it got grass seed the same as the rest. The grass seed struck, but, owing to the amount of weeds and the exhausted condition in which the soil was after taking the wheat out, anybody who goes there and sees that will ask what happened that patch. That has been my experience all through, and I think it is only fair that that should be known.

Comment on this

You do not consider yourself a fool for going on growing wheat all your life?

Comment on this

I do not, but I would consider myself a fool if I grew wheat for other people besides myself. It is good policy for a farmer to grow some wheat for his own use, but I certainly would not grow wheat for sale for anyone. If I grew any more wheat than I do I would be interfering too much with my rotation crops and the economy of the farm. What is more, that wheat land, as happened this year, would occasionally have to be laid down in grass, and it would certainly have a very bad effect on the grass. I was certainly not struck by Deputy Ryan's analysis of the report—I think it was very weak. Some Deputy, I think it was Deputy Lemass, mentioned emigration. Does Deputy Lemass seriously believe that the growing of wheat, or rather, what is asked for in the motion here, a tariff on flour, would relieve, to any extent, the emigration problem?

Comment on this

What I say is that the existing system has made this country the only nation in the world, inhabited by white people, which has a declining population.

Comment on this

Quite right; but we are discussing proposals for a tariff on flour. Deputy Lemass said something to the effect that the present policy with regard to flour was responsible for emigration. The people who asked for a tariff on flour said that they had 1,700 people employed in the industry, and if they got a tariff they would be able to employ 153 people more. These are the figures given to the Economic Committee. and they speak for themselves. I can assure Deputy Lemass that he has made a mistake in assuming that I said at the Economic Committee that I was against tariffs on principle. I certainly am not, and never was.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce said he hoped that we had not heard the last of the protection of the milling industry or wheat question with this debate. I am quite certain we have not heard the last of it. It is rather fortunate that the House will have an opportunity of going more fully into the whole question of wheat on Deputy Ryan's motion, no matter what happens here, than it has been able to do to-day. The Minister for Industry and Commerce suggested that we should accept Deputy O'Connell's amendment, and that it was as a matter of jealousy, or something of that kind, that we were asking him not to press his amendment at present, and to let the question of a tariff be put as a simple question to the House. Of course, this suggestion of jealousy is nonsense, because long ago, immediately after the tariff debate, we put down this motion, as we were anxious that the House should take a decision upon the matter. As regards the Labour Party, we know that some of the principles contained in Deputy O'Connell's motion are of long standing. We have seen, from previous reports, the Labour Party point of view. At the same time we know our point of view, and it has been stated; there is no question whatever of jealousy. The unfortunate part is that there is urgency about this question of a flour tariff. If the inland mills and others go out of existence, it would be doubly difficult for any object, which has wheat promotion as its policy, to be put into effect.

For one, I agree, very largely, with Deputy Anthony's view and the view also expressed by Deputy Derrig, that there is something wider in this whole question than the narrow economic view. But we hold that even from the narrow economic view, our view is right. I do not know whether any of the speakers have given all the figures that we had at the Economic Committee on the relative values of land —land under grass and land under different crops. If Deputies look at these figures, they will see that an acre of land under wheat is worth to the community something like £1 7s. per acre over and above what the same land would be worth to the community if it was used as pasture, either for producing milk or for producing beef. Therefore we say there is that amount of extra wealth available for the community, if some of the land at present being used for the production of beef and milk were used for the production of wheat. We say that even if, with the individual farmer, in order to bring up his profits to the point in which he would prefer using his land for the growing of wheat than for the production of beef or milk, it were necessary to divide a portion of that £1 7s., we believe portion of it could very well go to the individual farmer, and it would be good national economy that it should.

The relative values of land under various crops have been stated, I think, in our Minority Report. These figures have been taken from experts, who considered the question and went into it in detail, and these figures are their expert opinion. One hundred acres of land under potatoes would support 418 persons for a year; under wheat 208 persons; under oats 172 persons; under mangolds used for feeding cows for milk, 117 persons; and so on down the list, until you come to the average for pasture for beef and mutton, where 100 acres would only maintain nine persons. It is obvious, when you look at these figures, that, next to potatoes, the most valuable crop from the point of view of human food that can be put upon the land is wheat. This is borne out by the figures showing the food values of the crops also; they run parallel and they are partially based upon them. But the fact that you can show, at present prices, an acre of land produces £1 7s. more than the average acre of the same land under pasture producing milk or beef, shows that you have an opportunity of creating £1 7s. extra per acre for the community. If a subsidy is to be given to the individual farmer in order to induce him to produce that extra wealth for the community, I say it is only fair to give, and the community could afford to give, portion of that £1 7s. to that individual farmer and still benefit.

That is an argument on the narrow, economic side; but, as I indicated at the start, it has a very much wider consideration than that. The question for us is: are we going to continue the economy that exists? The individual farmer has to adapt himself to the present conditions. We are anxious, and our policy is, that the State should do whatever lies in its power in the interest of the community as a whole to change these conditions to such an extent that it will be in the best interests of the individual, as well as the community, that the crops that are of the most value to the community as a whole should be grown. There is no use arguing that in the conditions as they exist such and such is the case. What you must examine is what will be the conditions when the changes proposed take place. We hold, if you take that view, there is not the slightest doubt that the figures are convincing, and they are there. When I say there is not the slightest doubt I know that doctors differ, and that different people take different views. Are we satisfied to be exporting our people, as we are exporting them? Is the present system so good that we should always attend to the argument for maintaining it as it is and never pay any attention to the argument for changing it?

The Minister for Agriculture has been called the "devil's advocate" in this matter. He suggested that he has been trying to teach us in the Economic Committee something about agriculture and that we are too dense to understand. What is wrong is that we are not going to be bluffed by the Minister for Agriculture. We know him too well to be bluffed now, and we know perfectly well that he has sufficient audacity to make any statements, no matter how contradictory they may be to other statements that he previously made; he will still make them without qualification when necessary to assist his case. We are not people who have been reared in bandboxes in cities. Most Deputies in this House have a fair general knowledge of the agricultural conditions of the country—those brought up in the country have, anyhow. There are very few of us who, after sixteen years of age, spent most of our time in cities who did not spend the first part of our lives in touch with agricultural occupations in the country. I remember that in the national schools when we were taught agriculture in those days there was a book which Deputy Gorey may remember or not, got out by a man named Baldwin and a very good little book it was. I remember my disappointment with the first part of it, which dealt too much with the Norfolk five-acre rotation and things of that kind. It was only when we came to Part V that we got things that really mattered for Irish conditions. I remember well it was stated that there were four million acres under poor pasture in Ireland, which if put under tillage would be much more profitable. I remember, too, it was stated that under the poor pasture this land was able to produce something like twice the fair rent, whereas under grain crop and tillage it would produce two and a half times that. He estimated, if I remember rightly, what was the national loss through the fact that this land was kept under pasture instead of being put under grain. We all know that. As I say, even those of us not connected with agriculture have sufficient knowledge of the general conditions of things to know when the Minister for Agriculture is bluffing and when he is not, and to be able to sift the evidence given by experts and to know whether it is a question, as it is very often, of pure individual judgment or whether there are some facts behind it.

When we have something in the form of catch-cries repeated again and again, and when we recognise that in these catch-cries there is a good deal of the element of prejudice we naturally discount them. Instead of being convinced, in any way, by any of the arguments of the Minister for Agriculture, any members of our Party that I have been speaking to were convinced that there was no hope for the country as long as there is a Government in power whose attitude towards national affairs is the attitude that has been indicated by the speech of the Minister for Agriculture. That is our position. We believe that they are simply going to continue the old policy by which this country will be simply a farmyard for feeding English operatives cheaply, and a dumping ground for English manufactures. That is what we want to change. We are prepared, anyhow, to take whatever risks there are in furthering this policy, in trying to secure here in this country as much agricultural produce as possible.

The Minister, of course, questioned some of our figures. He talked about cotton cake. Cotton cake is a very small fraction of the total, but it is a considerable item, and the country would be served if some of the experts were able to suggest substitutes for it. It would be good policy to have our experts looking out for substitutes for all these imported articles. Even though it is only half a million in something like twenty-six millions, it is a substantial item, I will admit. We have done our best to sift the expert evidence that has been put before us, and to read carefully the reports and lectures that have been given by responsible people, such as those who are in charge of the Agricultural College at Glasnevin, and elsewhere. We are convinced that at the back of this antagonism to the growing of wheat, apart from the conditions which have been imposed, and which will have to be changed, there is a good deal of prejudice. The Minister for Agriculture was much nearer to the truth when it served his purpose to make a case four or five years ago than he was to-day, when it served his purpose to make a case in the opposite direction. We know that it is the business of lawyers to make a case on whichever side they are briefed.

Comment on this

There are lawyers on both sides.

Comment on this

I, for one, am very glad that this debate is not going to end here. I will make a last moment appeal to Deputy O'Connell not to put back the whole attempt. The question involved in his amendment is a very much bigger one than the one involved in our motion. There will be need to be a much closer and more detailed examination of it than there is in the question of the imported flour. There will be greater need for going into detail to convince individual members of this House. What is he going to do by putting this amendment forward and pressing it at this stage? He is going to prevent a thing that is urgent and necessary for his particular proposals as well as ours. Of course, his is wider, but by the time the Executive Council will have taken the opinion of the Dáil and by the time you get anything out of the mentality that is evidenced here with respect to the wheat proposals there will be several more of your mills closed down.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Where is the difference in the matter of urgency if our amendment is passed?

Comment on this

What I believe is that your amendment will not be passed by the House as a whole.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

It may have a better chance than yours.

Comment on this

The more is going to include the less—the Deputy said his proposal is wider and it includes ours. Therefore, if the House votes for the bigger proposition it votes for the less inclusively. If there is a majority in favour of Deputy O'Connell's general proposal they will vote for this proposal as part of the general proposal. The converse would not necessarily hold. My view is Deputy O'Connell's amendment is going to be used by the Executive Council, who are delighted to have it, as a red herring across the trail of our proposal, for their purposes. I do not see Deputy O'Connell's point.

Comment on this

Has not Deputy de Valera made the best speech of the night in favour of Deputy O'Connell's amendment?

Comment on this

I have. I have given evidence of the fact. There is no question of jealousy. We will be delighted to have Deputy O'Connell's amendment. So far as we are concerned, we have indicated the whole scheme much more fully in the Economic Report. But there will be a question between those two. What is going to happen, of course, is obvious. First of all, Deputy O'Connell's amendment will be defeated and then our motion will be defeated.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Why? They will be put separately.

Comment on this

We know how the people on the other side are going to deal with it. We are long enough watching this sort of thing to know what is going to happen in this particular case. There is one chance, and that is to get a straight vote on this question of protection.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

You will get it if my amendment is defeated.

Comment on this

If Deputy O'Connell's amendment, for instance, is passed it is the end of our motion, and when Deputy O'Connell's amendment comes before the House as a substantive motion it is going to be defeated. Those of us who want this policy put through are simply playing into the hands of our opponents.

Comment on this

Do not tell them how you are going to vote. We will bring you together.

Comment on this

We, at any rate, in this case are going to vote definitely for our own motion. Although, in the main, we agree with the amendment, we are going to vote against it, because there is no other way in which we can deal with the urgent matter of the protection of the milling industry. It is a simple problem. There is no other way for us to deal with it.

As far as the arguments in favour of it are concerned, I will mention them in general terms. I will just summarise the main arguments for the tariff on flour. I forgot to mention to-day another factor in favour of the British mills, and that is derating. They are going to have a further advantage over the mills here inasmuch as they are going to be de-rated to the extent of 75 per cent. The effects of protection would be these:—It would enable the existing mills to work to their full capacity. It would spread the overhead charges over nearly twice the present output. It has been estimated by one of the experts who came before the Committee that that would result in an economy of about 1/2 per sack. It would encourage the erection of new mills and the improvement of existing ones as well as the re-opening of those that have closed down in recent years. We have got from the Minister a picture of what would happen if protection was there and if we had a monopoly or a combine here. But he has taken very good care not to give you a picture of what will happen if you are wiped out here by a cross-Channel monopoly.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 13
·
Níl 113
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Division

Motion put.

Tá 59
·
Níl 68
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?