Local Government (Dublin) Bill, 1929—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 118–258 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 51 of 1929 ›
In all the long discussion that has gone on about this Bill, I failed to notice that any attention was paid to the fact that in this Bill the Minister for Local Government has at least the credit of having adopted a new and more satisfactory method of procedure for dealing with the government of Dublin City. In the old days, if it was thought desirable to extend the boundaries of Dublin City, such an action could only be carried out by introducing a Private Bill into the Legislature, and the expenses in connection with a Private Bill of that kind would run to many thousands of pounds. There is no doubt whatever that sooner or later, apart from other aspects of the present Bill, it will be found necessary to include within the boundaries of Dublin City the districts of Rathmines and Pembroke. An effort to do that was made many years ago. The effort, as the Minister for Local Government pointed out, was a failure, but it cost £50,000 to bring about that failure. There is a tendency on the part of public representatives in these areas at the present time to object to the unification of Rathmines and Pembroke with Dublin, which it is contemplated to bring about in this Bill. I think it is pertinent to point out that the alternative to this Bill for these areas is the production of another Private Bill, which, whether or not it gets through the Dáil and the Seanad, will, at any rate, cost a considerable amount of money and which ultimately will probably prove much less favourable to the people of these districts than the present Bill is.
I think, in taking on this responsibility of rearranging the government of Dublin City, whatever opinions may be held about the characteristics of the Bill which he has produced, everyone must admit that the Minister for Local Government has performed a great service to the people of Dublin. I think that credit should be given to him and to the Government for taking on what is, after all, and what has proved to be in many ways, a rather thankless responsibility. You have had opposition to this Bill from all sides. No two elements agree in the precise direction that their opposition took.
We have the Fianna Fáil Party objecting to this Bill because, while in larger national affairs they are anything but democratic, in municipal affairs and the government of cities they profess to be the most ultra democratic party in the country. We have the Labour Party objecting to this Bill because they always insist on going a little beyond democracy, and becoming doctrinaire, and because they object to certain provisions in the Bill for giving special representation to special classes. We have the representatives of Rathmines and Pembroke passing resolutions because they are afraid that the rates in Rathmines and Pembroke will be raised. We have the "Irish Times" thundering denunciation against this Bill because they object to compulsory Irish. We have all kinds of denunciations from all sides, and if you go through the wearisome task of reading or listening to these denunciations and comparing them, you will find that hardly any two of the numerous parties that come forward to denounce this Bill agree on any one particular point on which they denounce it. Deputy Lemass was very robust yesterday evening in his denunciations of this Bill. He denounced the Government for interfering with the creation of a great City of Dublin stretching across Dublin Bay. One would imagine that Deputy Lemass had only flown suddenly into the Dáil yesterday evening from a cloud cuckoo land where there already existed this glorious city on Dublin Bay which contained every village and every dwelling house within twenty miles of the mouth of the Liffey and encumbered by no interference from the pressure of Cumann na nGaedheal or the various elements which are always ready to support Cumann na nGaedheal. The fact about this Bill is that it is not a Bill for the dismemberment or partition of Dublin City, but a Bill which takes a considerable step towards its final unification. One aspect of the Bill which the Dáil has to consider is whether such unification has proceeded far enough under it. That would be a fair way of looking at the Bill, but it is not fair to say that Dublin has been dismembered and disunited. There existed in Dublin up to the present many conflicting jurisdictions, many overlapping staffs, and there have existed many cases in which the work could be done more efficiently by one authority. The time has now come to bring about unification. It would be fair to say that we believe that unification could go further than it is proposed to bring it in this Bill. That would be fair criticism, but it is not fair criticism, and it would hardly be honest criticism of the Bill to throw in phrases about partition, and to try and clog its progress with all sorts of irrelevant allusions to political matters which have nothing to do with the Bill. The Bill is one for the unification of Dublin. That is made a big difficulty in the case of Dublin because of certain recent circumstances.
Deputy O'Kelly admitted yesterday evening that, whatever else might or might not be said about the old Corporation of Dublin, it was not characterised by the most thorough efficiency. In actual fact, everyone knows that for many years before the old Corporation disappeared the citizens were growing more and more tired of its inefficiency, and it was becoming more and more widely recognised that the Corporation was no longer a type of body capable of carrying out the complicated business of a large modern capital. The Corporation was done away with, and in place of it an experiment was tried which brought the government of the city to the opposite extreme. The democratic element was done away with and a body of autocrats was set up. That experiment was tried for a number of years, but it was admitted from the beginning that it was only a temporary experiment, and no one expected that it would be permanent. Now the time has come, having before us the experience of these two attempts—the attempt at democracy and the attempt at autocracy—to get some system of government for the city which will combine the advantages of those two systems for the good of the citizens of Dublin. It seems to me that while, of course, this is a type of Bill upon which it is easy for people to have different opinions—it contains a large number of provisions, and embraces a large number of questions— taking the Bill as a whole, it gives evidence not only of hard work on the part of the Minister and his Department but also shows that a highly ereditable attempt is made to combine these two elements, and to produce from the combination of them something that will redound to the good of the citizens.
I do not admit, in the first place, the right of the Fianna Fáil Party, or any member of it, to spring on the democratic horse in this Assembly and to ride away on it. The democratic horse is a very dangerous horse for the Fianna Fáil Party to ride in this Assembly. Apart from that, however, and leaving out the qualification of the witnesses, I think that very few citizens would go so far as to agree with the extremely democratic, or so-called democratic, doctrines to which Deputy Flinn has treated the House. I think that few citizens will admit the unlimited and uncontrolled right of Dublin, or any other city, to decide its own destiny for itself without interference or control from the people or any other authority in this State. It is a principle which, if carried to the fullest extent, would lead to complete anarchy, as extreme democracy is often liable to do if carried too far. It is proposed by this Bill to set up, in addition to the enlarged City of Dublin, a borough to be known as the Borough of Dun Laoghaire. The reasons for that step are somewhat subtle.
Comment on this
This is a Bill the rights or wrongs of which cannot be decided by sledge-hammer methods. You cannot settle the government of a city merely by shouting democracy or painting pictures of a rose-red city stretching across the Liffey from sea to sea. All these matters require careful consideration and involve a good deal of subtlety in their consideration and decision. The reasons for setting up the Borough of Dun Laoghaire are, as I say, reasons which cannot be made obvious by sledge-hammer methods alone. The position, in fact, is that Dublin up to the present consisted of a municipality with two large outlying urban districts which should belong to the municipality, as is admitted by everybody, and a string of smaller urban districts stretching along the sea-coast with no connection between the various administrations, and in spite of what Deputy Lemass has said, having problems of their own, problems peculiar to themselves which could only be settled by themselves. Dun Laoghaire and Blackrock have been struggling along for a number of years with separate Councils, separate staffs, but all the time with problems which are very similar and which could be settled more efficiently by a single organisation. At the same time there are problems in Blackrock and Dun Laoghaire, such as the housing problem, the drainage problem, and various other problems of that kind, which are peculiar to Blackrock and Dun Laoghaire and which could best be settled by those two districts acting in harmony with each other if that harmony could be brought about.
People who criticise this Bill always fail to notice the good effects which it involves. When criticising the setting up of the Dublin coastal borough they talk about partition but they forget that in the case of that borough there is an effort at the unification of that large area which, so far, has been scattered and disunited and which it is proposed to bring together under one government. It is not uncommon or anomalous that there should exist a large city side by side with a smaller area governed by a different municipality. You meet that over and over again in cities all over the world. These two areas have, as I say, problems which differentiate them in many cases sharply from one another and when the growth of neither of them is likely to be impeded by the existence of the other there is a good case for taking the course which the Minister has taken in this Bill. Reference has been made to the future of districts like Stillorgan, Foxrock and Cabinteely, and attempts have been made to show that under the Bill their fate is completely left in the air, undecided. It only needs a cursory reading of the Bill to show that ample provision is made, as soon as the necessity for the incorporation of these two areas into Dublin can be proved after careful and full examination, for their incorporation into the city. I know that the city is extending in the direction of Stillorgan. The Mount Merrion Estate was mentioned here last night. That is a very recent project and it is in its very early stages. One attempt to carry out that project has been a failure and it is still very much of a question whether the urbanisation of that area has proceeded, or is likely to proceed, far enough to make it necessary to incorporate it into Dublin. If, and when, that necessity arises ample provision is made in the Bill to secure that that area shall be incorporated easily and rapidly, without the machinery of Private Bills or expensive private legislation that was always involved in matters of that kind. That is another aspect of the Bill. It sets out to do away with the cumbrous machinery for extending the boundaries of the City of Dublin and its sets up machinery by which these boundaries can be readily and easily extended after a careful consideration of the various problems that arise from the extension.
Deputy Lemass, in the usual Fianna Fáil fashion, talked about setting up the Borough of Dun Laoghaire as something that was being done under the influence of some secret cabal. He tried to make it appear that the urban districts of Dun Laoghaire and Blackrock, which returned Deputy Brady amongst others to the Dáil, are districts which are monopolised by certain reactionary elements, and that the Government in setting up a new borough in that area was dictated to by these reactionary elements. I do not know what the ratepayers of Blackrock and Dun Laoghaire will think of the opinion that has been expressed of them by the chief spokesman of the Fianna Fáil Party in this House in trying to set up some secret bogey in this respect, but I think Deputy Lemass is making a very unfortunate attempt, and one to which very little attention will be paid.
We have heard a great deal of criticism, particularly from Cork, with regard to the institution of a City Manager in Dublin, and that criticism has taken most peculiarly vague lines. It is assumed by the speakers that the ideal system, and the system that should be set up under this Bill, is a system of complete democracy, a system in which full powers would be given to the council, and the manager would be placed in the position of being a servant of the council. That is to say, the manager would be in the position in which the Town Clerk used to be under the old Corporation. That is the form this criticism has taken. The whole genesis of the Bill has lain in the fact that that system of municipal government has been tried for many years in the country, and has been proved to be a complete failure. The case for the institution of a City Manager is written large across the streets of Dublin. The case has been tried and proved over and over again, and all this talk about reactionary methods, about the desertion of democracy, and so on, is in itself reactionary. It is an attempt to throw back the government of Dublin to the bad old period when Dublin was not governed at all, when there was nothing but a series of vague committees which interfered with one another's work, and the general result of whose operations was that nothing was done.
This whole principle that the legislative and the executive functions of the municipality should be divided is a principle that should need no justification in the Dáil. It is a principle that has been proved to be a proper principle over and over again. If we are to take that principle and if we are to divide the legislative and the executive functions of the city, how are we to set about it? I suggest that the method adopted in the Bill is about as good a method as any that could be devised to accomplish that object. As Deputy O'Higgins pointed out, the control of the purse, the control of all expenditure, whether by way of rates or by way of loan, is vested absolutely in the council, and a council which, having that control in its hands, having that power of checking and overhauling expenditure, of supervising the budget of the Manager, even before he attempts any expenditure, does not use and exercise that control over the Manager is going to be a very poor council indeed. I suggest that if that happens the failure in that case will rest, not on the shoulders of the Manager, but on the shoulders of the council.
I am not going to follow Deputy J.J. Byrne into the extremely philosophical and metaphysical distinction he tried to make between administrative and executive functions. I fail to see that there is any great distinction between one and the other, and the principle which was adopted in this Bill seems to be the proper principle of distribution, that the council has the power of the purse and the Manager has the power of action under the supervision of the council, which supervision is and can be exercised, by reason of the control of the purse vested in the council. My difficulty about all these problems—it is in many ways a personal difficulty, and I do not know that I will get very many people to see eye to eye with me—is that I am much more afraid that the council will not be a success than I am afraid the Manager will not be a success. I am much more afraid that the council set up by the measure will be a council that will concern itself first and foremost with an attempt to get control of patronage, and, secondly, will concern itself with political matters largely outside its sphere. It should be our aim, as far as we can achieve it in this Bill, to secure that such a council will be set up as will refrain from interfering in these matters, in matters such as the employment of labour or the giving of patronage, such a council as will confine itself to the business side of administration and to the general supervision of the finances of the city and the planning, in conjunction with the Manager, from the financial point of view, of the lines on which the municipality should progress in the future. There is plenty of scope in the Bill as it stands for a council that wishes to do that, and any council that attempts to do more will only wreek this Bill and will run the risk of retarding the progress in the municipal government of Dublin for many a long year.
Another matter which I must confess gives me a certain amount of concern, and in regard to which I am likely to get fewer people to agree than on the other matter, is the question of the institution of the Lord Mayor. I am inclined to think that this whole business would be much better settled by having one person to act as titular and actual head of the municipality. But conditions being what they are, I think that that person should not be elected by popular suffrage. That person should be appointed on merit. I would like to see, not only in Dublin but all over the country, a system of local government by which officers, chosen for proven merit, would be appointed to govern the various districts in the country, and would be given authority by the State to act as sole governors. I say that because I believe, from the experience we have had not only in Dublin but all over the country, that we have proved, and proved very successfully, that our system of popularly elected local councils is an unfit system for efficient and progressive administration in local government in this country. I know that in saying that I will not get very many to agree with me.
Comment on this
I must say that, in my opinion, this Bill would be a better Bill if, instead of having a Manager with a Lord Mayor beside him—a Lord Mayor paid probably a large salary for presiding over the meetings of the council and receiving distinguished strangers, because quite possibly that is all he will take on himself to do—you were to give the Manager not only the power but the glory as well. Let the Manager be the representative of the city. If he has to do the work of governing the city he should also have, I think, the credit of being its governor.
[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]
Comment on this
I do not see that you could not devise a system by which a Manager of that kind would co-exist with a representative council selected to advise him on the best method of conducting the business of the city.
Comment on this
You never could tell. You might be in the Viceregal Lodge yourself yet. I am afraid that what is likely to happen under this Bill is this: you will set up a Manager who will be concerned with the administration of the city, with the executive work of governing the city. Side by side with him you are going to set up an elected head of an elected body, who will be paid a large salary and will have a great deal of prestige—all the prestige that he can be given. That person will be likely, to some extent, to use his position to interfere with the work which the Manager is doing. In consequence of that, you will have the danger of constant friction between the titular head of the municipality and its actual executive working head. Personally, I would prefer to see a system by which you would have one governor—that he would do the work and get the credit for doing it.
The opposition that has been expressed against the proposal for a special commercial franchise has already, I think, been sufficiently answered. One would imagine that the council which it is proposed to set up was going to have all the work of governing the city on its own hands. It is not. Surely it is going to be an advisory council, a council whose function will be primarily that of financial control-one to advise the Manager. In addition to that there is the fact that our present franchise in the city is a property franchise: that at the present moment no person is given a vote in a municipal election purely because of his human existence, as Deputy O'Connell said. These two facts are, I think, a sufficient reason to justify the institution of some special franchise by means of which a very small number of people, who have special business and financial qualifications, will be sure of getting elected to the municipality. I think that, so far from such a proposal being reactionary, it is a progressive proposal. It is a proposal which, if carried out in the proper spirit, will result in the setting up of a more competent, a more experienced and generally a more efficient municipal body to advise the executive governor of the city. I fail to see that the ultra-democratic arguments we have heard have any force in this matter at all. The danger about these democratic arguments is that behind democracy there always lurks somewhere or other the doctrinaire, if you go far enough to look for him. I am afraid that in their zeal for red tape democracy the Labour Party are proving themselves to be more doctrinaire than democratic.
This Bill is the beginning of a big experiment in municipal government in Dublin. It is an experiment which, as I said, takes the place of two previous experiments, neither of which was completely satisfactory. There was one thing at least in Deputy O'Kelly's speech with which I agree. I am not saying anything, because I do not know very much, about the recent government of this municipality, but I agree that, a priori, autocratic government in a municipality is apt to neglect, to some extent, the interests of the poorer classes in the community and to concentrate more on the interests of the wealthy. For that reason, I believe that a great deal depends, from the point of view of the ordinary citizens of Dublin, on the successful working of the machine that is going to be set up under this Bill. I believe that it is going to be a very difficult thing to get twenty-five men, business men, professional men or working men, who more and more as the world progresses, are finding themselves engrossed in the work of their own daily lives, to take up this business of governing the City of Dublin, a business in which their only reward will be a sense of having done good to their fellow citizens—a business in which they have no particular reason to be more interested than anybody else. It will be very difficult, I say, to get twenty-five men who will do that work competently, men who will confine themselves to the very important business which is allotted to them under this Bill, men who will not try to destroy the machinery of this Bill by unduly or too hastily wishing to extend that work.
I have no doubt that the whole success of this Bill depends upon a loyal acceptance of co-operation by the municipal council with the Manager. If you get a council under this Bill which, for pseudo-democratic, political or any other reason, sets itself up from the beginning in opposition to the Manager, in criticising the work of the Manager in an undue way, in interfering with his work where under the Bill he is the sole authority—if you get a body like that, then the government of Dublin is going to be worse in the end than it was in the beginning, and you are going to have to do all this work over again in a couple of years. That will happen under this or any other Bill which sets up two parties like these to govern. As soon as you set up a single governor, and side by side with him an advisory council, under conditions as they are and with public opinion as it seems to be, there is always the danger that the whole machinery of that institution may be damaged by friction between these two bodies.
I think it is the duty of members of the Dáil, instead of indulging in cheap semi-political criticism of the measure which after all is a measure designed for the good of the citizens of Dublin, and introduced by the Minister when he might very well have left it to the citizens of Dublin to settle their own difficulties by means of private and costly legislation, in considering this measure to avoid, as far as possible, any controversy or any direction of discussion which would be likely to give rise in the future to that kind of friction between the Manager and the council. I wish that members of the Dáil could address themselves, in a spirit of impartial interest, to the welfare of Dublin and to the future progress of Dublin as a great capital city— that they could address themselves in that spirit to the framing of this Bill and accept the result of the long and difficult labours on the part of the Minister for Local Government in the loyal and dutiful spirit in which that result has been put before the House in this Bill.
Comment on this
The Deputy stressed more than once that the council has control of expenditure. I would like if he would point out where in the Bill that is provided for.
Comment on this
If the council has the power to fix rates and to arrange for the issue of loans, surely no council will fix rates without knowing what the rates are to be spent on, and surely the council has the power to refuse to fix rates.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy point out where there is anything which shows the council has control over the moneys collected from the rates once it has fixed the rate?
Comment on this
There are a great many things which are not pointed out in the Bill. As Deputy O'Higgins said a little while ago, it is not pointed out in the Bill that members of the corporation are to enter by the door instead of by the chimney.
Comment on this
We have listened to a number of speeches on the subject of this Bill during the last couple of days. It appears to me there are a couple of points that have not been touched on in any of these speeches. The Deputy who spoke a few moments ago possibly touched on one of these points when he asked what is the view of Dublin. In all the speeches we have listened to from members of the Executive Council and others, we have not heard, at least I have not, any expression as to the view of Dublin, and Dublin surely ought to be considered when bringing in a Bill that is going to make such drastic changes in its administration as this Bill proposes. One would imagine that one of the very first things any Deputy, particularly any Deputy on the Government Benches, would endeavour to get information about is the view of the various areas that will be affected by the Bill. Has any Deputy who has spoken dealt with that question? Since the publication of this Bill I have endeavoured, as far as one could, to get the views of Dublin men on it. Nowhere in the city amongst the people I have come in contact with have I found the least enthusiasm for this Bill. The view of Dublin men is that Dublin wants to be left alone. Dublin is tired of changes. We have had nothing but changes in all departments of administration for the last ten years, and we are getting heartily sick of changes.
Some of us on these benches listened last night to a very representative deputation from Rathmines. What I told the House about Dublin is true of Rathmines. It wants to be left alone. On Monday night I listened to the views of a great many of my co-representatives in Pembroke. They were unanimous in the view that they wanted to be left alone. Will the Minister who put forward this Bill tell me who wants it? I have been closely in touch with the city for some years past and I do not know of any expression of opinion from any section calling for this Bill. If nobody wants it why is it brought forward? We have in the city at the moment an administration with which we are quite satisfied. We have in Pembroke a council with which we are quite satisfied, and the same applies to Rathmines. As far as I know, in the coastal boroughs there is no enthusiasm for the Bill. Where, then, is the demand for it? What is the reason for bringing it in? Surely that is one of the first things we ought have had information about from the Minister. There is no use in telling me that the matter was brought forward by the old Dublin Corporation, and that the demand comes from the old Dublin Corporation. That Corporation has been buried, and I do not want to hold any post mortem on it. Deputy O'Kelly did his best last night to whitewash it. Why, all the water in the Liffey could not whitewash the old Dublin Corporation.
Comment on this
I will leave that to the Deputy. He knows these mixtures better than I do. The question that arises from the point of view of a businessman, is, what advantage is Dublin going to get out of this Bill? Not a single Deputy who has discussed this Bill during the last two days has dealt with the economic aspect of it. Surely that is one of the first questions we ought to consider—what advantage is this Bill from the economic point of view, going to be to the city? What advantage is it going to be to Pembroke, Rathmines and the other areas affected? Has a single Deputy devoted a speech or any of his thoughts to the subject? This policy of change during the last ten years has not been carried out without incurring considerable burdens which the ratepayers and taxpayers are trying to bear. In the Estimates we find under the item of superannuation and retiring allowances we are carrying a burden in the current year of £1,777,400. That is as a result of this policy of change. Add that to the other burdens we are carrying for pensions, £2,727,000 for old age pensions, £253,473 for Army pensions, and £66,903 for teachers' pensions, and we find we are carrying a total burden of £4,824,776. That burden represents something between twenty per cent. and twenty-five per cent. of our total taxation going in pensions.
Comment on this
This Bill proposes to abolish the Dublin Corporation, the Pembroke, Blackrock, Kingstown, Urban Districts of Rathmines, Killiney and Dalkey, and also the Rathmines and Pembroke Joint Hospital Board, the Rathmines and Pembroke Main Drainage Board, and a number of other authorities. What addition is that going to mean to our pensions list? Has any Deputy made a conjecture as to the number of officials that will be pensioned as a result of this change, and that will become a charge on the local authorities and inflate the burden we are paying for out of the other pocket as taxpayers? These are economic aspects of the Bill which I would like to see getting some attention from this House, but not a single Deputy has attempted to touch on them. I wonder would the Minister in his reply be able to tell us what the resulting burden on the ratepayers of this Bill is going to be? I am sure what he will tell us is that it would be impossible for him.
We had some experience here lately of trying to force the Minister for Local Government and Public Health to give us an estimate. That was when we had the Poor Relief Bill in connection with Dublin before us. He refused to give any estimate, and I am sure the reply he will give in this instance will be similar to the one he gave then— that is, it would be impossible to say what the burden on the local authorities will be as a result of the pensioning of those officials. That is why I ask that before we pass measures of this kind we should have some facts as to the burdens, and not have Deputies talking, like the last speaker, about ideals of local government. We are carrying burdens as the result of other changes that are pressing very heavily to-day on trade and commerce. We have burdens with regard to pensions that are quite heavy enough without adding to them. Before I, at any rate, vote for any such Bill as this I am going to know what burden it will entail. I would like any Deputies who may speak on this Bill, particularly Deputies on the Government Benches, to give us some information on these two points. I do not want to deal with a number of points dealt with by other Deputies, but those are two matters of primary importance that we ought to know about and have all the details in connection with before we proceed any further.
I do not want to take up time dealing with a number of other subjects that have already been dealt with very fully in connection with this Bill. There are, however, one or two items on which I would like to express an opinion. First of all, the Bill deals with the question of the coastal borough. If I could get any reason at all for the bringing in of this Bill I might be satisfied. The one reason that I got that seemed to have any substance in it was that all these local authorities would be brought under one rule. What is the first step the Bill takes? We were told that the reason for the Bill was to bring all local authorities under one authority. Now, when we get the Bill we find that instead of bringing those bodies under one authority it sets up two, if not more, authorities. It sets up a coastal borough with a mayor, four aldermen and fifteen councillors. And the mayor, aldermen and councillors are to deal with an area and with a population that is about the same size as Pembroke at the moment. The population of Pembroke and the population of the new coastal borough are as near to one another as it is possible to get.
We have the position that instead of doing away with small local authorities we are setting up for all time under this Bill the idea of small authorities against big authorities. What will be the effect of that with regard to this particular coastal area? We have heard ideals expressed with regard to this coastal area and what might be done with it. One penny in the £ in Pembroke produces £600. If you want to do anything in the way of a marine promenade in the coastal borough to attract visitors and to give some amusement to your own citizens £100,000 or £150,000 is not going to go very far with the project. Now, saddling a coastal borough of that sort with its income, and with the expenditure it would have normally, will kill it for all time. It will take the rest of your and my time to try to pay off that debt. That is the position. The Minister said to-day that that would be an expenditure for the local area and would not affect Dublin. He objects to Dublin coming to the assistance of the local area. Deputies will remember his interjection here to-day, and that was his answer to that point—that projects of that kind for the purpose of attracting visitors are going to be a whole charge on the local area. It will be a charge on the local area and Dublin and the whole country will benefit. The idea is absurd. If we want a coastal borough of that kind, or if we want that area to be put in the condition in which we would like to see it, these improvements cannot all be charged to the local area. It is only from its connection with a big city like Dublin that these functions can be carried out and that the resources of these areas can be made the success that we would all like to see.
There were two other points touched on, and to these I would like to refer briefly. One was the special representation given to the business men. I do not know whether any of the Deputies understand our system at the moment. I listened very carefully to what has been said on the Bill. Are Deputies aware that there is no provision made in this Bill for giving votes to limited liability companies? The Minister informed us that over 50 per cent. of the valuation of the city was made up of business premises. The larger number of these would be owned by limited liability companies. In other words, a moiety of your rates in the city is contributed by limited liability companies that get no vote whatever in return. I am as strong an admirer of democracy as any man. Is that fair or reasonable? Labour Deputies have taunted us that other countries have dealt with that problem, and that they have given representation to those people who were denied representation. A moiety of your taxation is contributed by limited liability companies that have no representation whatsoever given in return. I do not think that matter needs any further argument from me.
The other question on which I wish to touch is the question of the manager. I was glad to hear the Lord Mayor of Cork saying that he heartily approved of the principle of having a manager. That conforms exactly to my experience. Many Deputies who have experience on local authorities know the difficulty where no manager existed of getting the policy that they laid down carried out through the various departments. The council meets once a month. Do you think that you can get a policy carried out and co-ordinated through your various departments by a council meeting once a month? The thing is absurd. It is only through a manager it can be done and done efficiently. We may differ as to the powers and authority that ought to be given to that manager, but the question of appointing a manager, as far as I am concerned—and I speak after 25 years' experience of local government—is one with which I am heartily in accord.
That is all I have to say on the subject of this Bill. I just want to add that I wish to urge on the Government that this Bill might be withdrawn. As I have already said, nobody wants it. We will have much more experience, and we will be in a much better position, possibly some years hence, to deal with a problem of this kind than we are to-day. In urging that particular action I ask what injury can the withdrawal of the Bill do? From the information I have I am satisfied that if a plebiscite were taken of every area that is affected by this Bill we would get back a return showing a 90 per cent. majority in favour of letting us alone. If that is the position, and I submit it is, why force the Bill on us? There is no demand for it as far as I can see. Even in this House there is no unanimity with regard to it. Therefore, I would urge the Minister to withdraw it.
Comment on this
I am not going to delay the House by offering any lengthy views upon this Bill. I will just content myself with making a few general remarks. Every argument I heard used against this Bill to-night could be used, and actually is used, with equal force against the development of the City of Boston. Some years ago the State of New York adopted a Bill for the City of New York something like what is now proposed for Dublin. The result is that to-day New York is one of the greatest cities in the world. The City of Boston, which should be practically equal to the City of New York, is in a backward position. Why is it in that position? It has a Cambridge that equals Rathmines and it has an Everett the equivalent of Pembroke, yet Boston remains the fourth or fifth city in the State instead of being the second or third. If we pass the Second Reading of this Bill it will do something for the capital of our country, the city we are proud of. It will bring Dublin into the position in which we would like to see it.
The Bill has been attacked from various angles. I submit that no attack has been made upon it that could not be made on the Greater Boston Bill. If we wish Dublin to be the type of city that I am sure we all would wish it to be, we should pass the Second Reading of this Bill, and later we could amend it in Committee in such a way as would make it just as we would like it to be. I am, perhaps, the most junior member in the House in the matter of local government, but I suggest that in Committee the Government should grant a certain latitude to various members so that they may be able to carry out improvements in the Bill. I appeal to Deputies not to wreck the measure simply for the purpose of wrecking, but rather to be constructive in their attitude. We have people here saying that managing directors and managers under certain circumstances are all right. I suggest that a managing director, if he is vested with authority, is all right. I think Deputy Flinn agreed with me a moment ago that a managing director under certain circumstances could even be paid a big salary. I ask the House to pass the Second Reading and, in Committee, to amend the Bill as may be thought fit.
Comment on this
As a citizen of Dublin I am not going to let pass Deputy Good's remark about the whitewashing of the old Corporation. I would like to remind the Deputy that it was the condition of things under the Corporation that existed before the 1898 Act was passed that gave Dublin the name of dear, dirty Dublin. It took all the time of the democratically-elected body that was established in 1898 to remove that stigma. Deputy Good and people of his class, who are apparently about to be reinstated in their old position by one of the provisions of this Bill, are the very people who gave the City of Dublin the world-wide name it had for dirt. Anybody who has lived in Dublin for the last thirty years, since the popularly-elected Council got control, knows that almost from the very start they endeavoured to improve the city in every possible way. Deputy Tierney said that the old Corporation practically did nothing. He did not live in Dublin all these years or he would know whether or not that was true. If he did live through it he would know that the old Grand Jury and the crowd represented by Deputy Good in the Dáil ignored the wants of the people of the city. Every one of the services in their time were a disgrace.
The President and Deputy O'Kelly know that when they entered the City Corporation they had to take on the job of practically reconstructing the services of the city. At the period of the suppression of the Corporation they had the best main drainage in the world, a splendid waterworks and lighting second to none. Deputy Good and his people objected to the richer townships being added to the Dublin Corporation; but the bankrupt townships were handed over, and the Corporation had to undertake sewerage, roads, lighting and other works, and I think Deputy Good ought to admit that. I admit that his party were a small minority in the Corporation and could not have their way. Consequently, we now hear him saying there is no need for a change and they want to be left alone. They certainly do want to be left alone, because they have got what they want. They have got the President to surrender the policy he fought for for so many years. He took from the citizens of Dublin the control of their own affairs. Deputy Good and the party he represents have always been in conflict with the Dublin municipality. If we cared to do it we could point out in detail what has been done by the old Corporation. It is a gross scandal for any Deputy to make the remarks that Deputy Good has made except, of course, that when speaking of the old Dublin Corporation he had in mind the real old Corporation elected on the restricted franchise that is going to be again introduced.
It certainly should have some effect on the Minister when he finds members of his own Party, particularly two resident in his constituency, one of whom at least must be a better judge of public opinion than the Minister himself, speaking against the Bill. I believe that there is no man in the House less in touch with public opinion, or who cares less for it, than the Minister. Deputy Byrne gave the Minister a few matters to ponder about. He told us—and we know it is a fact— that he knows what the opinion amongst certain sections of the people in Dublin is. Even Deputy O'Higgins ran up the white flag and suggested that we can amend the Bill. He said that certain sections are objectionable, but he urged that it should be given a Second Reading and then be amended. Some people on this side of the House, including myself, voted for the Second Reading of the Cork Bill in the hope that it would be possible to amend it, and as an alternative to a continuation of the Commissioner system. We thought, foolishly enough, it would be better to have some sort of council than none at all. I think now that it would be much better to have carried on with the Commissioner, and not try to have a semblance of democratic control for what is really the Commissioner system. That has been done in Cork, and that is what is going to be done here. We also had Deputy McKeon joining in the chorus to let the Bill have a Second Reading, and that then things would be all right. The white flag is certainly up, and I think there is every chance, especially as the Independents are also against the Bill, that it will be withdrawn.
Deputy O'Higgins said another thing that appealed to me. He wanted to know if there were powers given the council why all the talk about the commercial register. If the Bill is to go through as it stands, I admit that it is not worth any candidate's while going up. But we have to debate the matter in the hope that the Bill will be thrown out. That is the only reason I am wasting five minutes on it. Certainly, after being told for two or three years that we were to get a great Bill this is the worst attempt I ever saw. We have been told that the Bill is the work of experts. Certainly it bears the stamp of being the work of experts—the permanent officials who simply do not want to be bothered with interference by the representatives of the people. It is an expert Bill from that point of view. There is no doubt about that. I like the way Deputy Tierney spoke. He was very honest, and I think he should vote against the Second Reading, if he is to be logical. Apparently he objects to having any elected person like a Lord Mayor at friction with the manager. In his opinion that will take away from the efficiency of the new system. His plea was that as the manager is going to make the Bill such a great success the glory should be his. I submit it is up to Deputy Tierney in view of such an opinion to vote for the continuance of the present system and against this Bill. The Deputy was honest enough to say: "Let us have the Commissioner system without any camouflage or talk about democratic control." I think in that way he has been the straightest of all who spoke in favour of the Bill.
Regarding the commercial register, it is proposed to give four seats to people with a certain valuation. I object to that on principle. I agree with Deputy O'Connell that if there was no objection to the principle, there is no reason whatever why there should be a limit, why it should begin at valuations up to £50 and stop at £250, or why, for instance, Messrs. Jacob or Messrs. Guinness should not elect the whole Corporation. If the principle is right there should be no limitation. In Cork we know, as a fact, that the business element have got one-third of the representation. We will assume the unlikely happening and that the twenty-five members mentioned in the Bill will be accepted. That would mean that you would have one-third of the people elected representing the business community which would amount to eight. There would then be four extra members, making in all twelve, so that the commercial community would have practically fifty per cent. of the representation. The principle of giving people the plural vote is a negation of what we call democracy. I am not a very strong upholder of democracy at all, but, as I said on the Cork Bill, when you are trying to get a democratic cover for this managerial system or Commissioner system, you ought to do it properly or leave it alone. Let it be one man one vote or absolute autocracy. The President will correct me if I am wrong, but when he was asked why the Government suppressed the Corporation I think he said that his Government had not done so. I believe they did, and they must have had a reason for doing so. I suggest the reason was that the Government would have faded away long ago if the Corporation had remained.
Comment on this
Because the capital city would have had some way of expressing its opinion on how things were going on through the elected representatives of the city. You would not have had the hand-picked crowd that you have now, who are not independent, who never were independent, and who are simply the playthings of the Minister and do what he says without question.
Coming to the manager's powers, I see there is one power he has not got. I looked to see if there was one power he had not and I found it. In Section 37 he has no power to appoint himself, and stranger still, he has no power to dismiss or remove himself. I suppose the implication is that he will find the job so nice he will not think of resigning, or is the strict interpretation that he will not be allowed to resign? That is one power the manager has not got. I do not know if there is any other. In the first clause of Section 49, the same power is given to the Council in Dublin as was given to the Council in Cork. They can raise the money and the manager will spend it. Deputy O'Higgins has told us that that is the power of the purse. I must say that if all I could do was to raise the money so that somebody else could spend it, I would not consider it a satisfactory power. I do not think anybody else would either. The spending of the money is the real power. The spending of the money in this case is going to be done by the manager. As Deputy Flinn pointed out, the only power, in this connection, that the council has is the power that the head of a family would have to withhold supplies from his family. In other words, the people elected by the city have the power to hold up the services of the city—a power which one may say they cannot possibly exercise. No man will starve his family and no representative of any borough, town or county is going to persist calmly in holding up supplies—a course which would mean practically death to the place they represent. There is really no power given there at all and it is only special pleading to say that there is power given. There is a lot of talk about those reserved powers—the Shop Hours Act and all the rest— which mean nothing. They are not worth talking about.
It is taken for granted that this council, when elected, will know nothing whatever about how the affairs of the municipality ought to be administered. One of the principal duties of the manager will be to tell them how to set about their work—especially if he is asked to do so. But whether he is asked or not, that is one of his duties. Deputy Byrne—I do not know what he will do when this question comes to a vote—spoke about the possibility of amending the Bill, particularly in one respect, which we considered important in connection with the Cork Bill. He said that his idea of proper administration would be a small executive of elected people such as the Government is in respect of this House. We tried to get that provision inserted in the Cork Bill. We put in an amendment to provide that there should be a small board or executive committee of the Corporation and that was turned down. We were beaten on that amendment, and I can tell Deputy Byrne that except he acts now it will be as futile to try to amend this Bill as it was to amend the Cork Bill. If the Minister had been honest when he said that Cork City Bill was only an experiment and that the experience of the Cork Bill would be used in the framing of this Bill, he would have learned a lesson from it. But we have in the Minister a man who is absolutely impervious to public opinion. He does not care whether the Bill works or not, with the result that we have here the same Bill as before, but with the addition of the reactionary clause providing for the commercial register.
There is no provision as to town-planning in this Bill. It is an outrageous thing that in the twentieth century a landlord can do what has been done in North Dublin. A thoroughfare which we understood some years ago was to extend to a certain district has been blocked up by a certain individual. No powers are taken in this Bill to deal with that sort of thing. Deputy O'Kelly told us about the great thoroughfare to which I have referred, along by Griffith Avenue. At a point there it abuts on the Malahide Road, where there was a large field; it has been blocked because an individual who could have built on any spot took occasion to build at the particular spot at the end of the road. As far as I hear, the Corporation has not power to stop him. In the twentieth century there should be some attempt in a Bill of this kind to deal with matters of that sort, but it has not been touched at all. The whole policy of the Corporation is to be decided by the manager, just as it has been decided in Cork.
Deputy Tierney said that the case for the City Manager was written broad in the streets of Dublin. That may be true about the principal streets, but I would like to draw the attention of the Minister to the fact—if he does not know it already—that since the Corporation departed from the system of direct labour on the roads, one new road of concrete laid down under the new scheme at Marino had to be pulled up in parts before three years had passed and re-laid by the Corporation by direct labour. The parts that have not already been pulled up will have to be pulled up very soon. I would like to know what redress the citizens have for that at present or what redress they will have for such occurrences under the manager system. At present, they have no redress. These things are done as they are done in Cork. They will be done by the manager in the future as they have been done by the Commissioners here in the past. Contracts will be given out; road and other work will be scamped and then the municipality will have to come along, pull up these roads and lay down new ones at the expense of the ratepayers. The Minister may say that some of these contract schemes are done on a maintenance basis. In those cases, they are probably safeguarded, but in the case I refer to no such provision was made, with the result that rubbishy roads were laid down. That would not have been possible if these matters could have been discussed by a council. So far as I see from this Bill, they are outside the province of the council altogether. The manager will be able to decide, just as the Commissioners have decided, what streets are to be cleaned and what streets are not to be cleaned. I defy anybody who goes round the back streets of Dublin to say they are even as well swept as they were in the old days. I make a point of going through those streets every day.
Comment on this
I do not know whether or not the Deputy was in the House at the time, but the Ceann Comhairle ruled that it was not in order on this Bill to discuss the administration of the Commissioners.
Comment on this
I was in the House when the question was raised, and, with all respect, I submit that the Ceann Comhairle, immediately after his decision, allowed Deputies to continue discussing the administration of the old Corporation and of the city at the present time.
Comment on this
I was not in the House at the time but I understand it was ruled by the Ceann Comhairle that it was not in order on this Bill to deal with the administration of the City Commissioners. I had occasion to call the attention of Deputy Byrne and other Deputies to that ruling. That being so, the Deputy cannot continue to refer to the City Commissioners.
Comment on this
I presume that in suggesting that under the managerial system a non-elected person— a person responsible to the central executive—will have the deciding of policy, I will be in order.
Comment on this
That will do me all right; that is just what I wanted. I think that nobody, with the exception of Deputy Tierney, will stand up and say that the individual poor man and poor woman have not as much right to take an interest in the affairs of their municipality as the richer classes, or that their streets should not be properly made properly cleaned and properly lighted.
Unless the representatives of these districts are allowed to express the opinion of those who elect them as they were when the city was under the old system of the Corporation, and which should be the case under any system which pretends to be democratic, you are going to have all sorts of ill-considered schemes and neglect of areas, including those which cannot call attention to themselves as the main streets can do. Conditions are obvious in the main streets. It is from their appearance that the whole city is judged by visitors or casual observers and by such people as the President brings round when he wants to show them the state of prosperity we are enjoying. Of course, naturally, these streets are sure to be attended to. The manager will not bother his head about the poor quarters, and unless you have the general policy of the council under the control of elected members the thing will be absolutely a farce. Deputy Good made an appeal to have the Bill withdrawn. I think that would be the best thing to do. We do not want it withdrawn in order that the matter may be left alone. Quite the contrary. We want the Minister to produce something else besides this.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture is the best man to ask me that question. I think abortion would be about the best thing to call it. There are several items in this Bill that would be referred to in Committee, only that I am living in the hope that it will not go to Committee, and consequently I want to refer to some of them now. I see there is a provision for public notices of what is about to be done, and that sort of thing. The idea of that was that public representatives should certainly have some respect for public opinion, and if they have not that they would be taught a lesson when the proper time comes. When these things would be published they would have a certain effect upon the elected representatives, but it is useless to put in such a provision in a Bill like this when the person you appoint is a man who cares nothing whatever what the people of Dublin care for, and when the main consideration would be what the people in the Custom House think about it. The Minister, who is undoubtedly out of touch with public opinion and always cares very little about it, would be very much in place in pre-war Russia. He would be an ideal junker. He cares nothing and knows nothing about his own constituency, which was made perfectly evident from the speeches delivered by members of his own party. He knows nothing about it, and cares less.
I think he ought to withdraw this Bill and have another go at it, and take into consultation somebody who knows something about what the people want. Let him simply tell his permanent officials that they have a certain job to do, and that is carry out the orders of the Oireachtas. Let him tell them: "It is my job to tell you what the people want, and it is your job to carry that out." If the Minister is not satisfied with the recommendations of the Greater Dublin Commission he can get a more suitable body, if it is possible to do so, to make recommendations. I doubt if it is possible. I do not suggest that he should take all the findings of the Greater Dublin Commission and adopt them. I myself would not do so. But he should pay more respect to them and less respect to those who carry on in the official way. I am not sure that it would be much good for me to join with Deputy Good in his appeal to have the Bill withdrawn, but if the Bill were withdrawn the Minister would be doing good for his own Party. Advice of that kind would not be taken from me, but I give him this advice in good faith. No doubt it will be very awkward for him, but we will be charitable. I think that one of the amendments Deputy O'Higgins suggested would be ruled out in Committee as being against the principle of the Bill. It would be too bad to put Deputy O'Higgins and Deputy Byrne in the position of voting in favour of the Bill after they had spoken against it, but it would not be the first time that the Minister withdrew something he had just put before the House.
Comment on this
I certainly would, but I would not trust Deputy Good to go that far.
Comment on this
I understood that there was no misapprehension on anybody's part so far as the necessity for introducing this measure was concerned. It would appear, however, from the speech of Deputy Good that some case should be made for changing the existing state of affairs and for introducing a Bill which extends the boundaries of the City of Dublin. If I might correct Deputies in a historical matter, I might say that the Commission reported more than three years ago. The date of the report is 29th November, 1926. The Commission, which had on it very competent persons who gave very careful consideration to this matter, at least two of them being of very high commercial standing, came to the conclusion that an extension of the city boundaries should be made, and accordingly made a series of suggestions, if I might again correct Deputy O'Kelly, consisting of 95 in one case and, I think, seven in the other. Their proposal was that the boundaries of the present city should be extended. It has been stated by many people that even if the Government were not to introduce this measure and were to leave things as they are, as soon as a council would be set up for the City of Dublin it would be inevitable that a Private Bill would be introduced on the part of the Corporation of Dublin for an extension of its boundaries; that an unanswerable case could be made for such an extension and for the inclusion within the area of the city of Rathmines, Rathgar and Pembroke. That procedure would be attended by very considerable expense. In such a case both parties would incur considerable expense. It is quite possible that, apart from the expenses so incurred, Rathmines and Pembroke would not get a better bargain than is given to them in this Bill. If my recollection of the terms of the report is correct, we were not led to infer that there was to be any stabilisation of the existing rates paid in those two districts. All the Commission did in that respect was to weight the representation in respect of Rathmines, Rathgar and Pembroke more effectually in so far as the representation of the whole of the extended area of the city would be concerned—a point which Deputy O'Kelly neglected to note, or perhaps overlooked in reading the report, and which I drew attention to last night. The representation in respect of the old city was to consist of 38 members out of a total of 65 If the representation had been based upon population it would have been 47. Other than that particular contribution towards the feelings of Rathmines, Rathgar and Pembroke, no other great consideration was given to the matter in the course of this report. It is for the people of Rathmines and Pembroke to make up their minds fairly rapidly as to whether or not inclusion in the area of the City of Dublin is not inevitable in any case, no matter what happens, no matter what Government is in power, no matter what Corporation is elected in the city, or whatever regulations are going to be prescribed in respect of the new government of the City of Dublin.
The Government proposals differ from the report in quite a number of respects, but running through the whole measure very careful consideration is shown towards the recommendations in the report. Practically every one of the provisions in the Bill is founded on some recommendation or other in the report. There has been variation. Unlike our friends opposite, we are not bound by expert opinion in respect of advice tendered to us from any source. We consider ourselves rather as judges than the advocates of a particular policy. I would have preferred in connection with the consideration of this Bill if the two leading lights of the Fianna Fáil Party had considered this matter from the point of view of representatives of the country rather than representatives of the City of Dublin. It would appear from the speeches of both Deputies that Dublin was being robbed of its territory, when it is actually being extended. To whatever would be taken from the county, whatever disturbance might result from the operations of the report to any or all of the local authorities in the county, they were absolutely indifferent. If the report had been adopted the valuation of the County Dublin would have been reduced from about £960,000 to a little under £300,000 and a very considerable impost would have been added to the burdens which the County Dublin has to bear. If there is one part of this country that has benefited more than another in respect of the events of the last fifteen or twenty years it is the City of Dublin. I am a Dublin citizen born and reared, although I live in the county, and I have much more valuable interests in the old city than I have in the county. In connection with the proposals which we put forward in this measure, we have had to take into account what the effect of the recommendations of the Commission would have been in respect of the other portions of the County Dublin if the report had been accepted and put into the form of a Bill.
Deputy Lemass last night expressed surprise that a coastal borough was being set up and that the city was not extended in that direction. He mentioned that there were various services common to both. Amongst the services he mentioned were water, drainage, registration of jurors, reformatory and industrial schools, food inspection, etc. I do not know how one could say that any one of these services is common. They might tap the water-pipes. I agree they could get water, because it comes from a place beyond the boundaries of the area of any of these particular local authorities. There are two separate drainage systems; in fact, one might almost say three separate drainage systems. The other services that he mentioned—registration of jurors, reformatory and industrial schools, food inspection, and so on, come within the function of the county council, and the proposed coastal borough is not getting these services. Deputy O'Connell fell into much the same mistake when he said that we were setting up vested interests. So far as the urban districts of Dun Laoghaire, Dalkey, Killiney and Blackrock are concerned, it is as if the four were made one. There is concentration in connection with their administration, and a saving in respect of the concentration that will take place, and there is kept within them the services which are common. They are a unit; they are capable of being amalgamated together; they serve their own purposes without any such disturbance as would occur if they were included in the City of Dublin.
Right through most of the criticism I have heard there has been an absence of study of the problem of local government; of the complexities of local government, and of the practice in respect of it. I was rather appalled to hear the discussion that took place in connection with the rates—that there was no power over the rates. However, I can deal with that later. The position then is that after due and careful consideration, and a balancing of the problem as it stands, not in respect to one local authority alone, but with due regard to economy of service and the efficiency which would result from combining those services, combining certain areas, the proposals in the Bill will stand any examination and the most careful analysis that any expert in local administration could possibly bring to bear upon them, and they will come out better than any other recommendations made. I think Deputy Lemass went on to say that even the recommendations in the Commission's report were not enough for him—that he would have gone further. I have often associated Deputies opposite with Imperialistic motives in another guise. It is quite possible that if this country contained a sufficient number of uncertified persons to put them into power they would forget all about their democracy, and all the rest, and seek to set up an Imperial concern for Western Europe, embracing Spain, France, Great Britain, etc., all to be under the sway of the Fianna Fáil Imperialists.
Comment on this
So much for the first part of the report. I now come to the new franchise which has been objected to by Deputies opposite. I could quite understand some of the criticism if this new franchise had been added to the other, and the representation in respect to the twenty-five members came out of an alteration in the franchise. That is not the case. Some time ago a number of advertisements appeared in this country with reference to a proposal to establish a new paper. It was to be controlled in respect to 51 per cent. of the property by an individual who was to be manager. Associated with him in that control were five other business men, all selected from the point of view of their business knowledge and so on. I went through the list very carefully and I found one Gael amongst the lot of them. From the benches opposite we have been continually told about the number of sons of foreigners who are friends of ours here.
Comment on this
I, as one member, protest against the policy of attacking business men who are not here to defend themselves. If we did the same thing we would soon hear all about it.
Comment on this
I honestly would not dream of doing such a thing. There is a party who has spoken to us for two days about democracy. Did they select seven democrats out of their own party to run the paper?
Comment on this
If they ever come into power it is from that party they will select the Government, a Government that will be good enough to run the country, but, by jove, not good enough to run a paper. Where their treasure is, there their hearts lie.
Comment on this
At least two members of that party are, to my knowledge, good business men. Deputy Lemass is a business man and Deputy Flinn is a business man—al though not up to the standard of the "Chief" for running the paper.
Comment on this
At least they are up to your standard as a business man. You have not got much to talk about in the business line.
Comment on this
I said Deputy Flinn I regarded as a business man, and Deputy Lemass I regarded as a business man, but, apparently, the Leader of that Party does not consider them up to his standard, because he did not put them on the board of his paper.
Comment on this
It is not the policy of this Party to provide jobs for its members; it may be of the Government Party.
Comment on this
That is not the point I was dealing with at all. I do not want the Deputy to misunderstand me. What I said was that in so far as running this country is concerned if Deputy de Valera requires to mobilise a Government it is from those benches he will do it, but when he comes up against a business proposition it is business men he puts on, his board. This proposal is to associate with the municipality of Dublin, on the council of the municipality, four business men. Why is it done?
Comment on this
What does the report say in connection with the matter? It makes two references to it in two separate paragraphs. Number one, it expresses the view that directors of companies might get the vote; in another place, it suggests that when the estimates are being prepared it will be open to representatives of the ratepayers to come in and discuss the estimates. Now we have gone one better than that. During long experience that I have had in connection with municipal administration we had very often deputations from the ratepayers. I think there was an association at one time brought into existence to express the views of the ratepayers and when the estimates were being prepared or the rates being struck they asked for a considerable sum to be taken off, explaining that the business of the city was being hampered by excessive rates and so forth. Our desire is to save all that time and get down to business and let business men be associated with the making up of the estimates.
Comment on this
The Deputies have not, along with this Bill, made up municipal finance.
Comment on this
The manager submits the estimate. How is the estimate prepared?
Comment on this
I was going to deal with that at another time. This Bill can be defeated if it is so desired. The Council need do nothing. It can come in, take no action, have no initiative, leave all to the manager meet once a year if it likes and leave all to the manager if it so wills.
Comment on this
This is the old story. Deputies do not believe that any member of the Majority Party in the House has a right to address the House. There ought to be some fair play as well as a little good manners.
Comment on this
It applies to both sides. There was hardly an interruption of any Deputy who spoke against the Bill, but it is a constant practice here to interrupt every Minister who speaks. Deputies must remember that there are other people besides themselves who have a right to speak.
Comment on this
The interruptions of Deputy O'Kelly were as child's play as compared with these interruptions.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass asked a question which was reasonable, namely, what section is that in? While Deputy Lemass was asking that question other members of his Party were shouting something quite different at the President.
Comment on this
We will take it for a moment that the new council is to be elected. I, unfortunately, am not entitled to be elected. We will assume that there was no such disqualification and that I became a member of the council, and I was satisfied in respect of, say, the paving of Westmoreland Street, that it should be done in wood blocks. I make representations to the manager to that effect. The manager says "No." I hand in notice of motion asking the manager to prepare an estimate in respect of Westmoreland Street and submit it to the council. Here is where the crux comes in. We have two streets—let us call one Lemass Street and the other O'Kelly Street——
Comment on this
The manager says O'Kelly Street is in need of repair. It is much older than Lemass Street. The council, on the other hand, says: "No, Lemass Street is a much more fashionable thoroughfare; it should be kept in perfect order and it should be renovated." The manager objects, and says Lemass Street is going to be opened up in respect of water mains, electric mains, perhaps in connection with main drainage within the next three years and it is a waste of money to do it. He backs O'Kelly Street, and O'Kelly Street is renovated.
Comment on this
Supposing there was going to be no main drainage in Lemass Street or electric main, then will you show where the council have power to compel the manager to proceed with Lemass Street?
Comment on this
I wish to raise a point of order. In calling upon Deputy Corish you said that Deputy Corish wished to make use of another kind of interruption.
Comment on this
I would like to know exactly what you meant by it. Deputy Corish had not spoken at the time, and I think it was an extraordinary anticipation on your part that Deputy Corish's interruption was going to be quite different to the ill-mannered ones from this side of the House.
Comment on this
The particular kind of dispute is the council disagrees with the manager. The council can then pass a resolution asking the manager to include that in his estimate. If they like, his estimate will not be passed unless it is included, and the matter is at an end. Deputy Lemass had some objection a moment or two ago.
Comment on this
I am still in the dark. The President was talking about the advisability of putting business men on the council so that they could give the benefit of their business experience in the framing of the estimates. I want to know what section gives the business members of the council power to frame the estimate.
Comment on this
At a rates meeting the council may amend or modify. What is the meaning of that?
Comment on this
Certainly. Surely it is not to be expected that the council should frame estimates. The council is not the executive body. The council is the directing body. They are on policy. It is for the manager to carry out this section of the Bill. If the council were to carry it out every member should carry it out. Should not the Lord Mayor do it then?
Comment on this
In that case, you have the case of the two streets I mentioned—O'Kelly Street and Lemass Street—and the direction from the council in respect to these. It so happens it ought not to be always the business of members of the council to put up these recommendations. They come in in the ordinary way from the engineer. The engineer should submit to the council each year a list of the streets which he thought should be renovated, reconstructed, rebuilt, or made, as the case may be.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, if the Deputy would allow me, blind alleys are not taken over by the Corporation unless in perfect order. I do not wish to be misunderstood in connection with the matter. Normally, the estimates come up from each Department. If the members of the council so desire to alter, amend, modify or anything else of the sort, there is their authority, and if there is a doubt in respect of the authority of the members in connection with that let us see how Deputies would resolve it, how they would recommend something additional to be put into the measure in order to insure that, because I accept completely what the Minister said in respect of the council, the executive and the manager. I hope that point is clear.
Comment on this
There was occasionally running through some of the speeches from the Deputies opposite a remarkable appreciation of their own capacity to pass judgment on other people and judgment was passed on those who were dead and gone long since. I do not think it is good taste. I do not think the circumstances warrant it. If we take Dublin City as an example of growth, with a municipal mind, a big mind, there is to the credit of those persons who are condemned by Deputy Boland great works. There have been no greater works than the Vartry Waterworks and they are constructed now for something like 65 or 70 years. It may be that it is forgotten, but the one individual more responsible than any other in respect of that I think was Sir John Gray. His son was afterwards a brilliant member of Parliament and Lord Mayor, that is to say at the time when the Corporation was elected on a poor law valuation basis.
Comment on this
The Deputy did not give them the credit for it. One would imagine that the Corporation started when Deputy O'Kelly and myself entered it. It did not.
Comment on this
It stopped shortly after we left it. Similarly with regard to main drainage. I remember reading many years ago about the inauguration of the main drainage system. As far back as 1868 the first proposals in that connection were before the Corporation, but unfortunately the Franco-Prussian war intervened, sending up prices. In the year 1873 the Corporation had permission to raise £350,000 in conjunction with Rathmines and Pembroke. They found that owing to the war, prices had gone up, and instead of an anticipated cost of £400,000 they got a tender for £700,000. At the time these two bodies were together, Rathmines and Pembroke, and so on. Rathmines left and to their credit it must be said that they inaugurated main drainage for Rathmines, previous to the City of Dublin.
Deputies may think I am irrelevant in introducing this matter, but I want to assure Deputy Good and other unbelievers in Pembroke, Rathmines and Rathgar that they are not being taken in but rather that the motherly cloak of the City of Dublin is going to be thrown around them.
Comment on this
It so happened that although that work was done at very considerable expense by Rathmines and Rathgar that it was not so well done as the main drainage of the city.
It will be interesting in view of some of the remarks passed yesterday by Deputy O'Kelly to see what marked improvement there has been in the health of the City of Dublin over a period of about 40 years. In the year 1879 the death rate was 37.5 per 1,000; in the year 1880 37.89. Now we come to the quinquennial periods. From:—
1881 to 1885 it was 30.3;
1886 to 1890 it was 28.7;
1891 to 1895 it was 29.2;
1896 to 1900 it was 30.3.
We will see the effect of the main drainage system. From 1901 to 1905 it was 24.8 and from 1906 to 1910 23.1. Now we will see the effect that Deputy O'Kelly and myself had upon the city. From 1911 to 1916 it was 22.3. From 1916-20 when Deputy O'Kelly was virtually absent from the country it was 21.6. Then since the happy blessings of the setting up of the Saorstát, 16.3, a marvellous improvement! It is into that healthy city that we are inviting Deputy Good.
Comment on this
Very few. Nearly all died at home. It is much more comfortable. The death rate is decreasing. May I occupy your attention just for a moment to deal with one particular item in the report which I think crept in unintentionally at the end of Section 79. The report goes on to say:
"According to the statistics of the Department of Justice, the alien influx through Cobh alone has increased during the past year from 6,302 in 1924-5 to 7,389. The City Manager should have power to frame regulations whereby the Gárda Síochána would demand from new arrivals in Dublin such particulars as are now demanded from strangers in all the towns of Western Europe; to reject undesirables; and to limit by licence the period in which other immigrants would be permitted conditionally to remain."
As a matter of fact what they have got out there, strangely enough, is a figure showing the effects of the tourist problem. Those are, I should say five-sixths of them, Americans, and the number is growing, I am glad to say, from 7,389 in 1925 up to 11,000 last year.
It is not an alien problem at all. I would like to correct that, because I am sure the Commission did not wish to mislead anybody. Mention was made last night of an enormous sum of money now owing by the City of Dublin, and it was stated that the dead-weight debt, or whatever one likes to call it, had gone up in the last five or six years to the extent of a sum of two million pounds. The facts are that for the year ended 31st March, 1924, the total indebtedness of the city was £2,832,773. That sum consisted of two items. One is called reproductive debt and the other unproductive debt. In the case of reproductive debt the amount was £1,932,904 7s. 3d., and in the case of the unproductive debt, £899,867, and a few odd shillings. The total capital invested on the 31st of March, 1929, was £4,452,725, consisting of a reproductive debt of £3,618,837 15s. 1d., and an unproductive debt of £833,887. It will be observed, therefore, that the total increase in indebtedness between the years 1924 and 1929 is £1,619,952. If my recollection is correct, Deputy O'Kelly mentioned £2,000,000.
Comment on this
The difference between the two is not very considerable.
Comment on this
Reproductive debt means debt incurred for undertakings which represent tangible assets and unproductive debt represents expenditure in respect of which no receipts are available other than rates imposed on the citizens for their maintenance. This sum that I have mentioned is further subdivided. There has been an increase in respect of indebtedness on housing of £1,497,826. Advances made under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act, which should be added to that, amounts to £138,152. There has been a slight increase in the capital indebtedness in regard to public health, namely, from £37,000 to £56,000, mainly due to the construction of an abattoir, and for waterworks in respect of the completion of the reservoir which was necessitated by housing schemes on the north side. The only thing I wish to bother you with now is——
Comment on this
The amount collected in respect of rates in 1920 was £1,920,971. That is what the ratepayers were paying in that year. Assuming that they paid at the same rate for five years they would be out of pocket to the extent of £888,361.
Comment on this
Would the President explain the alteration in the rateable valuation of the city which took place in the meantime.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wishes I will mention a figure off-hand, £100,000.
Comment on this
I am not very far off the mark and, if the Deputy wishes, I will have it examined and submitted to him. The point is that, however rhetorical these statements may sound which were made last night, they have a bad effect. They depress business, they depress industrialists and manufacturers, and they depress Pembroke, Rathmines and Rathgar, who will say that it is not worth while coming in. I want, however, to invite them in quite cordially. In respect of housing, somebody asked what rights the council would have in respect of schemes. Supposing the council met and wanted to make up its mind in regard to housing and, if the manager is engaged in preparing a scheme, the council can ask to see it. There is a direction by which the Lord Mayor can ask the manager to produce anything, but if that provision is not sufficiently strong we can strengthen it so that it will have all the characteristics of an ironclad, impervious to attack or assault of any kind. If they are dissatisfied, either in regard to the number or size of houses, they can say so, but for goodness' sake do not put us in the position, after the manager and everybody else have been engaged for months in preparing a scheme, when the scheme has been proposed, that somebody gets up with a footy objection and says, "We will not give the money."
Comment on this
The President said that the council could decide such a question of policy as whether the houses should be three-roomed, four-roomed or five-roomed.
Comment on this
I have mentioned Section 50. That is the section in which the Lord Mayor asks for something. I have given the section in respect of the raising of a loan. We listened to two or three cases in respect of Cork, but into their merits I am not going to go. We will accept the statement that there is a question regarding a stone bridge, and that the manager said that he was going to put up a concrete bridge. Now, mark this difference, as between putting down concrete in the estimates last year, allowing a sum of £1 for it, and putting down £20 as the cost of a stone bridge. The manager must insist on concrete, or allow the work to stand over for twelve months and put sufficient provision in the estimates which will cover the cost of the work being done in stone. Is that clear?
Comment on this
I told the Deputy in respect of borrowing money that the council had authority. I asked the Deputy to suppose that there is a meeting, that Deputy O'Kelly has been elected Lord Mayor, and that I say: "Lord Mayor, have you approached the City Manager in respect of any plans or schemes you have for housing?" He will say: "Yes, I saw him. He has a scheme consisting of 50 houses for Donnycarney, 100 for Crumlin and 500 for the Bull Wall." Deputy Lemass then says: "I want 300 at Crumlin," and the Lord Mayor says: "He is only putting up 100 there, as that is all the grant he got." Then Deputy Lemass says: "I will insist on getting more land acquired in order to provide 400 more." The manager, having got notice, then goes to provide the necessary money for the scheme, otherwise a complaint can be made against him by the council.
Comment on this
The council cannot decide these matters of policy. They can only do so on the advice of the manager.
Comment on this
Certainly. In connection with the other matter of spending money, supposing there was a sum of £5,000 allocated to the pulling down of gas lamps in Grafton Street—that is, supposing they were there—and replacing them by electric standards and it is provided in the estimates. If the manager does not do that duty within a certain time it is open to the Lord Mayor to draw attention to it and to bring that dereliction of duty before the council, and, if the council is dissatisfied—I do not mean to say that they should be dissatisfied on small things but on matters affecting major considerations—and if you get a two-third majority—I am sure you would, because I do not think that Deputy Good would stand for hanky-panky on the part of the manager—the manager will have to go.
Comment on this
He will if the council make a report to the Minister.
Comment on this
I take it that the council have two powers. They can either agree with the manager or ask the Minister to dismiss him.
Comment on this
Not at all. The council is absolutely responsible for policy, and if they do not carry out policy I expect the manager will do it.
Comment on this
It is in the Bill from the beginning. It is in that portion of the Bill that deals with the estimate. It is in that portion which makes him responsible to the Lord Mayor, who can ask him for any information in respect of schemes. I have just got the figures in respect of valuation regarding which I was queried by Deputy Lemass and I find that I made an excellent shot. The figure is £109,000.
Comment on this
If the President knew as much about the Bill as he does about the valuation of Dublin he would be much better.
Comment on this
I will stand an examination with any member of the Fianna Fáil Party in connection with this measure or with local government. Let us understand one thing. There was nothing but politics talked on the Bill since its introduction. Members wanted to know what subscriptions we were getting in connection with this Bill. I do not know whether any party will agree with it, but I do not think that any party can charge us with having pandered to popular feeling in the last seven or eight years. It is in that sense and with that sense of responsibility that we submit the Bill. We could easily have broken it up into two or three parts and get it through the House, but we have done the courageous thing and have introduced the measure in this form. The work that this new council can do, when it is established, the new orientation of areas which will occur, and the potentialities of the new organisation, will justify the policy of the Minister in introducing the Bill.
Comment on this
If there is one thing in which the President shines more than another it is in debating strategy. When he began his speech he devoted himself more or less to the proposals in the Bill. He dealt in a superficial and cursory way with the coastal borough, then he proceeded to defend the commercial register, and when he had led us down what Deputy Lemass described as Cosgrave's Blind Alley, he told us that business men were to be brought into the council in order to help in framing the estimate, but then he immediately skidaddled and endeavoured by picturing Dublin as a modern health resort to induce Deputy Good to forego his objections and to vote for the Bill. I would like, if I could, to bring the President back to the portion of the Bill which was immediately under discussion when he sat down, and I would like him, while I am on my feet, to refer me to a section which I can read to the House which will unmistakably and clearly give to members of the council the power of framing the estimate. The President referred us to Section 69 and I asked him to read that section, but he evaded doing so. I would like to read it now so that the President may know what the section prescribes. Section 69, sub-section (1) says: "The Manager shall cause to be prepared in each local financial year at the prescribed time and in the prescribed form an estimate."
Comment on this
May I interrupt for a moment? We will assume that I am wrong and that the Deputy is right. If the Deputy wishes to interpret my point of view into that clause what would he say?
Comment on this
I could not interpret the President's point of view into that clause unless I was going to read into the Bill something which is not there. It is a primary rule of legal interpretation that you should read the text in the ordinary sense.
Comment on this
We will suppose that the Deputy is perfectly correct and that he wants to give the council that right. What will he say in that section?
Comment on this
"The council shall cause to be prepared at the prescribed time and in the prescribed form an estimate." It is, however, the Manager who will prepare, or cause to be prepared, the estimate and not the council. It is the Manager who will give the estimate its first form and shape, whatever other powers the council have afterwards to modify or amend, and if they have powers to modify or amend the estimate they are definitely limited, not only by the circumstances and by the exigencies of local administration but by the Bill itself. The President wishes the House to understand that because of sub-section (6) the council has absolute control over the policy of the Manager. Take a case in point. Suppose the Manager decides that he is going to raise money for a housing scheme and that the houses are going to be of a particular type. He then goes to the council and says: "I want you to strike a rate of so much, to cover interest and sinking fund in connection with the scheme." The council say: "We will not strike that rate because we do not believe that these houses are of a proper type and are going to meet the requirements of the people in that district. Therefore we will not strike the rate." What is the position? The people want houses. The Manager says that he will build them houses of a particular type. The council will be put into a false position before the people when they will not vote the money to meet the service of the loan for this particular type of house which the Manager desires but which the council, as representing the people, do not think suitable.
What will be the position of the council in that dilemma? On the one hand, they have the Manager, who will be able to appeal over their heads to the people and say "At any rate, I am going to give you some sort of house." On the other hand, they have people wanting houses, and in that position what is left to the council but to surrender and to accept the policy dictated by the Manager and not laid down by them? You could multiply instances of that sort. Everybody knows that municipal services must be carried on, sanitary services must be carried on and, supposing the council are of opinion, at any time, that these services are not being carried out in a suitable manner and in a way best adapted to the requirements of the city, can the council refuse, no matter how strong it may be in that belief, to strike a rate for those sanitary services and consequently suspend them?
Why if they did that, immediately there would be an outcry. The health of the citizens, the Manager would say, is imperilled by the obstinacy of this council. The council, willy-nilly, no matter what it thought, no matter what the powers which the President, in order to mislead the Dáil, said they have over policy, would again be compelled to yield to the Manager. I admit that sub-section (6) does give them power to modify and amend certain estimates. But sub-section (7) of the Bill, unless I am wrong, virtually compels them to accept that estimate at a subsequent meeting which must be held within fourteen days after the meeting at which the original estimate is amended or rejected.
The President, in order to sustain the case which he made that the council has complete power over policy, referred the House to section 50 of the Bill. The fact that he referred to that section, and that obviously he was prompted to do so by some of his colleagues on the Government Bench proves that neither he nor they have read the Bill, with the possible exception of the Minister for Local Government, because that section deals entirely with the question of the appointment of the Manager and his powers. Sub-section (1) of section 50 states that "before the appointed day the appointment of a person to be a Manager shall be made by the Minister on the recommendation of the Local Appointments Commissioners," and so on. Sub-section (3) provides that the Manager shall hold office until he dies, resigns or is removed from office, and sub-section (7) provides "that the Manager may do all such matters and things, including the making of contracts for and on behalf of the Corporation and the affixing of the official seal of the Corporation to documents, as may be necessary for or incidental to the exercise or performance of any of the powers, functions and duties of the Corporation which are by this Act required to be exercised or performed by the Manager."
The President quoted that section in order to sustain his argument that the council would have control in matters of policy. He said that powers with regard to policy are reserved to the council, and that the function of administration is delegated to the Manager. He quoted this section in support of that argument. If there is one thing that is clear from the sub-section I have quoted it is that all the powers of the Corporation, except those expressly reserved to the council, are delegated to the Manager to be exercised, discharged and fulfilled by him. That is the effect of the sub-section which the President quoted in order to, as I have already said, sustain his argument that the council would have control over questions of policy. Under this sub-section the Manager can, without the consent of the council, enter into contracts which he considers are "necessary for or incidental to the exercise or performance of any of the powers, functions and duties of the Corporation which are by this Act required to be exercised or performed by the Manager." These powers to be exercised by the Manager include every possible power or function the Corporation had, with the following exceptions:
(a) the making of any rate or the borrowing of any moneys; (b) the making, amending or revoking of any bye-law; (c) the making of any order and the passing of any resolution by virtue of which any enactment is brought into operation in or made to apply to the city or the borough (as the case may be) and the revoking of any such order and the rescinding of any such resolution; (d) the application to be made to any authority in respect of the making or revoking of any such order as aforesaid; (c) the making or revoking of any order under section 5 of the Shops Act, 1913 (in that Act referred to as the Closing Order); (f) the powers conferred by section 5 of the Borough Funds (Ireland) Act, 1888, in relation to the promotion or the opposing of legislation, the prosecution and defence of legal proceedings, and the application for those purposes of the public funds and rates under the control of the Corporation; (g) the appointment or election of any person to be a member of any public body; (h) Parliamentary and local elections; (i) the admission of persons to the freedom of the city or the borough (as the case may be); (j) subject to the provisions of this Act, the appointment, suspension and removal of the Manager and the granting of an allowance or gratuity to the Manager on his ceasing to be the Manager; (k) the determination of the amount of the salary and remuneration of the Lord Mayor or Mayor (as the case may be); (1) applications to the Minister for a Provisional Order under this Act extending the boundary of the city or the borough (as the case may be).
With these exceptions the Manager, as I said before, can do everything that the Corporation under its charter or subsequent Acts of Parliament has the power to do, or is obliged to do. In doing that he can enter into a contract without a shadow of control or an iota of restriction being imposed on him or exercised over him by the City Council. In fact, though the council will have the responsibility for finding the money and facing the citizens when it strikes a rate to find the money, it will be powerless to interfere with the Manager when he enters into a contract for the building of houses, making roads, the extension of drainage schemes or provision of water supplies, or when he determines that the city shall be extended in one direction or another. The City Council, which will have the responsibility for facing the citizens and asking them to provide the money to defray the costs of these works, will not be able to intervene by advice, criticism or authority between the Manager and those with whom he enters into contracts in relation to these matters. It is quite obvious, therefore, no matter what the President may say, no matter what the Minister for Local Government may urge upon this House, that the council as such is going to have no real control over the Manager so far as matters of policy are concerned.
I move the adjournment of the debate.