Acceptance of Closure Motion—Action of Ceann Comhairle.
Contributions 134–259 of 259. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The Deputy does not suggest that he is now going to mention all the points that he considers should have been discussed on the Second Reading of the Bill?
Comment on this
If the Deputy claims the right to mention certain things, other Deputies can claim a similar right, and then we shall have a discussion on what was not said on the Second Reading of the Bill, instead of having a discussion on this motion.
Comment on this
What means have we of proving then that the action of the Ceann Comhairle was partisan and contrary to the rights of the minority?
Comment on this
If you are going to limit us in any discussion on that point, which is certainly very relevant to the motion——
Comment on this
My difficulty is that I have no option but to keep Deputies to the motion on the Paper.
Comment on this
The motion on the Paper deals with the Ceann Comhairle's action in relation to the Greater Dublin Bill.
Comment on this
In connection with the point about allowing the fullest possible discussion, this House, whatever members of it may think, particularly members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, has not a reputation for taking too much time over the consideration of legislative measures. I think I am pretty safe in saying that the general opinion in the country is that legislation is very often rushed through, and, furthermore, that in the case of an important and a long Bill like this, consisting of nearly a hundred sections which cover the whole field of local government in one way or another, which had only been in the hands of Deputies for a fortnight, there is no reason why it should be rushed through after a few days' discussion, without giving the Minister an opportunity to answer the points that have been made for its amendment, or even for its withdrawal, and without allowing the different Parties to come to some arrangement with regard to how the Bill was to proceed. The Bill was left hanging in mid-air, but so long as the Government Party succeeded in their ruse, with the connivance of the Ceann Comhairle, to get it through its Second Reading. I suppose they think they are quite safe, and that any pinpricks that it will get in Committee will not change it; that it will issue forth from the House in the long run substantially the same as when it came into it.
One of the great advantages that the Ceann Comhairle has, and one of the reasons why I welcome this discussion, is that as a rule, when the Ceann Comhairle makes a ruling asking a speaker to withdraw from the House, or when making any other pronouncement, he gives no reason. I had expected when we put down this motion that he would at least have given reasons for his action last Friday. He has given no reasons, and I leave it to the people to draw their own conclusions. The Ceann Comhairle has stated that his action in this matter simply was that he decided that the House should be given an opportunity to come to a decision. If that is the Ceann Comhairle's summing up of the authority which he has and of the rights which he exercises under this Standing Order, I say that it shows an absolute contempt for the rights of the minority, that apparently the rights of the minority were to be left in the background, that they were not to be considered, that they would be brushed aside by the formal phrase: "I am not the person who is responsible. I simply permitted the House to make a decision." If that were carried to extremes, carried out logically in all the business of the House, then the Ceann Comhairle could simply on all possible occasions refer matters to a vote of the House for closure.
Some reason must be given. He says that the essence of the closure motion is that there must be no reasons that there must be no argument. Reasons and arguments have been given from this side of the House as to why the closure motion should not have been accepted. We do not expect the Government Party to answer them; they are here to down us by every means, and that is their policy. But we expect the Ceann Comhairle, who is stated in the Rules by which this House is governed to be our protector and guardian and to safeguard our rights, to say why he did not do so. Perhaps it is that, like Pontius Pilate, he washes his hands of the whole business. Perhaps it is that, having been so long in association with one particular Party, he finds it almost impossible—in spite of the fact that our Party has given him a pretty decent show and has played the game pretty fairly with him since it came into the House—to see or is constitutionally incapable of seeing our point of view, or any other point of view than that the Government Party is the only Party that the Government Party is the House, and that it is only the Government Party which must be protected and safeguarded. Perhaps it is that the Ceann Comhairle has become so much the slavish instrument of the Government Party in using this closure motion so frequently upon us on this side on very important measures, that he is incapable of asserting that impartiality and sense of fairmindedness, that courageous attitude towards the Government Party as well as towards the minority which is absolutely necessary in a Speaker and which, in my opinion, must be found, if not in this Speaker in some other Speaker, before we can hope to do business in the way we all want it to be done, with good heart and with a feeling that whatever our differences here may be, we can all feel that the man in the Chair is one to whom we can look up to with admiration and with esteem.
Comment on this
Deputy Derrig stated that there had been an arrangement with the Speaker that the closure would be taken. There was no such arrangement. I have moved the closure in this House, perhaps twenty or thirty times, and I have practically always sent word to the Speaker beforehand that I intended to ask leave to move the closure. I have done that because I regard it as fair that the Ceann Comhairle should have at least a few minutes to make up his mind as to what action he will take when leave is asked to move the closure. Sometimes the closure has been refused. Generally, it has been granted, because it was not asked for unless things had reached a point when it was not unreasonable to ask for it. What happened in this case was what happened in nearly every case that the closure was moved. I did not communicate with the Speaker myself on this occasion. I think it was the President who did it. What happened in this case was: the Ceann Comhairle was informed that it was intended to move the closure so that he might have the opportunity to make up his mind whether or not he would grant it, in order that he would have an opportunity of looking at the course of the debate and of satisfying himself that all parties had spoken, or satisfying himself on any other matters he desired.
It was a matter for the Ceann Comhairle himself to grant or refuse leave then, though I think if he had refused leave to move the closure at that point he would have been, in a measure, abusing his authority. I think if he had refused to accept the closure motion even on Thursday night, after the President had spoken, it would have been, in some measure, an abuse of his authority, because it must be clearly understood that it is not the business of the Ceann Comhairle to thwart the majority of the House, and it is not the business of the Ceann Comhairle to insist that debates continue until, in the words of Deputy Derrig, "the humblest back-bencher who would reiterate the feeblest arguments had concluded his reiteration." It is the duty of the Speaker, as Deputy Thrift has put it, to have regard to the efficiency with which the business of the House is carried on, and to enable the House to come to its decisions with full knowledge of what it is doing. I take it that the whole purpose of a debate in an assembly like this is not to allow everybody to get his chance of talking and of having his speech in the Official Debates. It is to see that the members of the House shall have, at any rate, the principal arguments for and against any proposal put before them so that they may come to a reasonable decision on the matter on which they vote.
The words in the Standing Orders in regard to the protection of the minority are put there not for this purpose of enabling minorities to talk as much as they like but fundamentally for the protection of the majority, fundamentally for the purpose of seeing that the majority, when it does come to its decision, comes to its decision after having heard the arguments. I think, therefore, the suggestion that there must and ought to be unlimited discussion and that the House ought not to be allowed to bring the discussion to an end and that, in fact, the Ceann Comhairle should prevent the House from bringing the discussion to an end is put forward without having any regard to the basis of the Standing Orders or the real functions of the Ceann Comhairle.
Before I go on, I would like to refer to one point that was made by Deputy O'Connell. I think he made the point without having fully considered it. He suggested that there had been something like a pledge that the Minister for Local Government would wind up the debate, and he suggested that the Ceann Comhairle had been guilty of an error of judgment in not drawing my attention to that statement. Now I would like to read to Deputies Deputy O'Kelly's question and Deputy Fahy's answer. Deputy Fahy was in the Chair at the time. After the Minister for Local Government had spoken, and after Deputy O'Connell had moved his amendment, Deputy O'Kelly said (column 968, 26th February): "I would like to know what exactly is the position now with regard to the motion and the amendment," and the Acting-Chairman (Deputy Fahy) said: "Both the Bill and the amendment are before the House and open for discussion. The Minister will conclude the debate generally, and the question to be put is ‘that the words proposed to be deleted stand.'"
Now, I think that that was merely stating what the procedure was. He was merely intimating that there was not going to be two debates, one on the amendment and the second, thereafter, on the motion. He was intimating also that the Minister was not going to be allowed to speak on the amendment and afterwards wind up on the motion, but that the Minister, having introduced the Bill, would speak once again and then the matter would be put before the House. I think it will be perfectly clear to Deputies who will consider it, and to Deputy O'Connell himself, that a casual statement with regard to the normal procedure made in that way by Deputy Fahy could by no means, be held to preclude the possibility of moving the closure, because if we were to take the view that Deputy O'Connell indicated, it would mean that there could be no closure thereafter, because if the Minister for Local Government was allowed to rise for the purpose of concluding there would be no need for the closure. The Minister for Local Government could conclude in a few minutes if he liked.
I think it is perfectly obvious that those remarks between Deputy O'Kelly and Deputy Fahy could not preclude the moving of the closure. I think it would have been out of place for the Ceann Comhairle, when I asked for leave to move the closure, to have expostulated at all. It is clearly contemplated in the Standing Orders that there shall not be amendment or debate, that the matter shall be decided forthwith, that the Ceann Comhairle shall either accept the motion for the closure or refuse the motion for the closure, and it has been his practice neither to explain why he accepted, except by quoting the Standing Order nor to explain why he refused when he refused. I hold therefore, when Deputy O'Connell suggests that the Ceann Comhairle was guilty of an error of judgment in not expostulating with me when I rose to move the closure, that Deputy O'Connell has not given this matter the fullest consideration. There was a suggestion that the Ceann Comhairle had ruled wrongly with reference to this point of whether or not, when the amendment had been disposed of, the debate on the motion for the Second Reading should be continued. There has been a suggestion that in not allowing a second debate on the motion after the amendment had been disposed of, the Ceann Comhairle was wrong in some way. I have already pointed out to the House that Deputy Fahy, when in the Chair, indicated that there was only going to be one debate and that the motion would be put after the conclusion of the one debate. Deputy Fahy's statement was an indication of the normal procedure in these cases where the amendment is a direct negative, that after the amendment is disposed of there is no second debate.
Some question has been made of a ruling by the Ceann Comhairle on the Juries Protection Bill, 1929. I would like to point out that on that occasion, when he refused to allow the closure to be put on the motion immediately after the amendment had been defeated, the case was entirely different. The amendment that was then proposed was not a direct negative; it was merely an amendment to delete paragraphs 1 and 2 of the resolution. That amendment was closured and disposed of. I then asked leave to move that the motion as a whole be disposed of. The Ceann Comhairle refused to allow that. But that was an entirely different case from the case with which we are dealing, where the amendment was a direct negative and where it was clearly understood that there was to be one debate which would dispose of the amendment and the motion together. I think, although Deputy Lemass and some other Deputies have shown a disposition to fling charges about, that there has not been the slightest case made for the view that the action of the Ceann Comhairle was partisan or that it was an infringement of the rights of the minority. This Greater Dublin Bill, in my opinion, is a Bill of minor importance. It is a Bill which, I think, contains no novel principle.
Comment on this
There are local bodies in existence that were elected under that system of voting. The main principle of the Bill in regard to a system of city management is already enshrined in the Cork Bill. So far as altering the boundaries of local authorities by a Public Bill, that has been done before. Although there was considerable interest in it in Dublin, we had here really a Bill of somewhat minor importance and a Bill containing no novel principles. It occupied a whole parliamentary week of public time. Moreover the House indicated by its vote that it considered that it had been sufficiently discussed, and that is an important factor. In that week of discussion practically two-thirds of the time was taken up by Opposition speakers.
I cannot see how the Ceann Comhairle could possibly hold that he was entitled to regard it as an infringement of the rights of the minority and not allow a closure motion to be moved when a Bill of this sort, a minor Bill, although bulky, had been discussed for a full week and when two-thirds of the time had been taken up by those who oppose the Bill. I think those who suggest that there was an infringement of the rights of the minority have not a leg to stand on.
As regards partisanship, there has not been any attempt made to make a case there. Deputies seem to think that the Ceann Comhairle is a partisan if he does not favour them. Deputy Derrig seems to have the idea—he put it into words—that the Ceann Comhairle should be the guardian and protector of Fianna Fáil. His duty is to give fair play and to secure a fair hearing for all the members of the House. It is not an act of partisanship to say that Deputy Derrig shall be cut out, nor, on the other hand, is it an act of noble impartiality to say that the Minister for Local Government shall be cut out. There are Deputies on this side of the House who wished to speak, just as there were Deputies on the other side. I was cut out myself. I had intended to speak. I was hoping to speak in moving the closure, but I was afraid I could not do it.
I think the main argument in this matter has been put very well by Deputy Thrift. The House is entitled to regulate its business, the House is entitled to make Standing Orders; the House appoints, under the Constitution, its Chairman and prescribes his duties and remunerations; the House does all these things by majority and, consistent with securing for the House sufficient and reasonable opportunities of debate and with preventing, so far as he is able to prevent it, any gross ill-use of the minority, it is the duty of the Ceann Comhairle to have regard to the wishes of the majority of the House, and to give the majority in the House an opportunity of coming to any decision that they may like, in any matter that can be brought before it.
I think the Ceann Comhairle himself has very frequently stated that it is not his business to prevent the House doing something that it wants to do. When Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches have attempted to raise matters, and asked whether the Ceann Comhairle would allow them, I can remember the Ceann Comhairle saying that it was not his business to prevent the House discussing anything it wants to discuss. In the same way, it is not the business of the Ceann Comhairle to prevent the House from stopping a discussion of any matter that it wants to stop discussion on. If there are any Deputies who still think that the Ceann Comhairle was guilty of any partisanship, those Deputies have an impossible and impracticable idea of the duties and the position of the Ceann Comhairle. While the Ceann Comhairle has no right and no duty to try to make things specially easy for minorities it is, on the other hand, most valuable and necessary— I say this in reply to Deputy Lemass's suggestion—that the Ceann Comhairle should be impartial, and that every individual Deputy should realise and feel certain that he will get fair play from the Ceann Comhairle. I venture to say, and I do not think any Deputy will seriously contradict it, that all Deputies have got an equal chance. Although complaints come from the Fianna Fáil Benches, I want to say, without meaning to be offensive to Deputies on those benches, that one of the reasons why Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches are more frequently dissatisfied with rulings of the Ceann Comhairle than Deputies on these benches, is not that there is any partisanship or any partiality on the part of the Ceann Comhairle, but simply that the Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches have been a shorter time in the House.
I can remember when Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies were much more frequently dissatisfied with the rulings of the Ceann Comhairle because they had not realised exactly what his position was and what his duties were. I, and other Deputies, can remember occasions when Ministers were obliged to withdraw by the Ceann Comhairle statements they had made in this House. I remember myself being obliged by him to withdraw a statement. I remember a further occasion when a Minister declined, or showed reluctance, to withdraw a statement when asked to do so by the Ceann Comhairle and when the President had to inform the Minister that in his capacity as Leader of the House he would move his suspension if he did not withdraw. Many Deputies will remember that. The position is, I think, that members of the Fianna Fáil Party have not given sufficient consideration yet to the question as to how the Ceann Comhairle ought to behave and what is proper for him to do. They are dissatisfied, in my opinion, not because he is partisan but because he does not play into their hands or try to show his impartiality, as some people in the country do, by directly trying to hit the Government in some way.
Comment on this
The credibility and reasonableness of the speech of the Minister for Finance may be judged by one single word. He says that the principle of this Bill is enshrined in another Bill. The principle of that Bill is damned already to a hell too low for the conception of Dante. Every other statement which the Minister for Finance has made is about equally near the truth. Listen to this statement: "It is no business of the Chair to prevent the House— by that is meant the majority of the House—stopping a debate when it wants to." That is the statement of the Minister for Finance. It is specifically the business of the Chair to prevent the House stopping a debate when it wants to, if—there is a Standing Order, No. 52, in spite of the ignorance of the Minister for Finance—it shall appear that such a motion is an infringement of the rights of the minority. It is the specific business of the Chair in such event to prevent the majority stopping the debate.
If it is the opinion of the Ceann Comhairle that the question has not been adequately discussed, it is the specific business of the Chair to prevent the majority closuring the discussion. If, in the opinion of the Chair, the motion is otherwise an abuse of the Standing Orders it is the specific duty of the Chair to prevent the majority stopping the discussion. Does anybody who has read the rules deny that? Yet you have the statement, made by the same man who said that the principle of this Bill is enshrined in another Bill, that it is not the business of the Chair to prevent the majority closuring the discussion. His sole function, specifically laid down in the rules, is to see that the majority does not closure discussion when in so doing it interferes with the reasonable exercise of the right of any single member of this House, whether he be of the majority or of the minority. The Minister for Finance said that it is the business of the Chair to prevent the gross abuse of the rules of this House by the minority. Show me the power in these rules, show me the power in the practice of this House, by which the Ceann Comhairle can prevent the continuous gross abuse of these rules by the majority. There is no such power. He says that the House can make Standing Orders. It can make a Standing Order preventing the introduction of this motion, and I do not care if it does. I do not care what the rules are so long as I know the rules and so long as a partisan in the Chair cannot alter these rules as and when he likes to suit the Party to which he belongs. I do not care what rule you put in. We had this question up before us when the House sent to the Committee of Privileges the suggestion that they should try and strengthen the rules to deal with Deputies who disrespect the Chair.
Comment on this
Everybody is. I am giving examples showing that we can make Standing Orders, that this House can make Standing Orders.
Comment on this
The Deputy can reply to any statement which the Minister made, but he cannot discuss the whole question of Standing Orders and will have to keep to the motion on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
The Deputy is replying to statements made by the Minister for Finance. Surely that is in order?
Comment on this
The suggestion is that we should be bound by Standing Orders because they are made by the House. They are. We accept that, but we do not care twopence halfpenny what orders you make so long as they are not going to be varied, and so long as the Minister in possession of the majority is not allowed to get up and say to the Ceann Comhairle that it is no business of his under the rules to prevent the majority closuring a discussion when it likes. If that is to be the interpretation, if Ministers in possession of the majority are going to be allowed to say that to the Chair, we know that that rule is waste paper, that there are no "ifs," that the rules mean exactly what occurred, and that when the majority that controls the House gives an order to the Chair it shall be obeyed as literally as it was obeyed last Friday. We have drifted into the question—other people have been allowed to discuss it at considerable length; the President started it and Deputy Thrift followed the trail—whether or not we may discuss amendments, discuss the general body of a Bill after a particular amendment to that Bill has been rejected. That question arose with Deputy Morrissey in the Chair. It was a question to refer back an estimate, and an attempt was made to say that the decision on the referring back of the motion would decide the issue. I objected on the ground that the referring back was a thing which the Government could accept——
Comment on this
On a point of order. Several precedents were quoted here in the course of the discussion showing that there was a distinction between the closure being taken on an amendment and on the main motion. It is following up that contention, which was admitted so far to be within the rules of the debate, that Deputy Flinn is giving a further precedent.
Comment on this
As I understand what happened, the matter was mentioned in connection with last Friday's motion to give a Second Reading to the Bill and the amendment to it. I think it was first mentioned by Deputy Lemass. That was replied to by the Minister for Finance. All that was in connection with the debate on last Friday, and even that, in my opinion, is not in order.
Comment on this
We will pass from it. What are the specific reasons why, under the Standing Orders, the Minister for Finance, in possession of the majority, dares to tell the Chair that it must not operate? What are the reasons which are laid down in that Standing Order by which the Chair shall not allow the majority to decide why the debate must be closured? The question had not been adequately discussed. What is adequacy of discussion? What were the complaints that were made against government of this country by another House? That they had not time to deal with the measures, that matters which were of prime importance to us were merely incidental to them, that a day here and there given to the Irish Estimates was all that could possibly efficiently be given in the British House of Commons to Irish affairs. What are we here for but to alter that, to find time in which we can discuss, and discuss adequately and fully measures which do concern us? I hope that the suggestion will be placarded all over Dublin, that it will be made known to every citizen and elector of Dublin, that it is a minor Bill, that it is of so little importance that it could be rushed through, that it is an outrage on common sense to say that we should spend a week in discussing it. It is an outrage on common sense, an outrage on decency, on the efficiency of the Government of this country! The question of the size of the capital city of the country, the question of the government of the capital city of the country, the question of the qualifications of those who shall vote for that government, is so small and so trivial that it is an outrage on decency and common sense that a week of our Parliamentary time should be devoted to it!
Comment on this
Oh, yes, sixteen hours. Was that adequate discussion? Ask the citizens of Dublin. Ask the citizens, you men from Clare, from Wicklow, from Wexford and from Leitrim who are to decide the government of Dublin, who are taking into your hands and moulding into a form to which they have to conform the government of their city. Ask them is it an outrage on common sense and decency, on efficient government to say that a week of parliamentary time in this House should be spent on it. Yet that is what the Ceann Comhairle said when he accepted the motion, which he had no right to accept unless the question had been adequately discussed.
Now, look at this placard. (Displayed.) There is where you discuss it. If it was adequately discussed here then why was that necessary? Was it adequately discussed in the Dáil, when the Minister, whose business it was to reply to that matter, had to go outside this Dáil, knowing that there was a question which had to be answered, a discussion which had to be completed—to go outside this Dáil where he could not be met by those whom he was attacking and answer specifically, word for word and point for point, the speech of the Lord Mayor of Cork, a Second Reading speech? Was it adequately discussed when that man had to find another arena in which to answer the Lord Mayor of Cork in relation to the efficiency and beauty of the principles that were enshrined in another Bill? What do you think of this? Surely, no one is going to suggest that the "Irish Independent" is your enemy, but surely an enemy hath done that. Another paper came out on Friday with "Big Fight; Sensational Developments," and the next one was: "Disorderly Scenes in the Dáil." How can any man have the face to get up and say that the discussion was adequate when the Minister himself declares in this straightforward, open, public manner that it was not adequately discussed, because he must at once answer somewhere else the speech which he could not answer face to face, made by the Lord Mayor of Cork in this Dáil. The Minister for Finance has told us that if the Ceann Comhairle had refused to accept this motion he would have been abusing his authority. If he had refused to accept this motion he would have been abused by his authority, effectively abused by his authority, and that is why he took in anticipation the order he has received tonight, that it is not the business of the Chair to prevent a majority of this House, under any conditions, ending a debate which a majority of this House thinks it is good, proper and profitable to have brought to an end even before the subject can be adequately discussed.
Complaint has been made and criticism has been offered of a statement by Deputy Lemass which, as near as I can paraphrase it, was that he was not here to censure or to say anything against the Ceann Comhairle. That proposition is supposed to require explanation and defence, and of course, as I adopt that statement, I am not here to say anything of censure of the Ceann Comhairle. The Ceann Comhairle is a man who does know the Rules. He is a man of ability and experience in the Chair. I personally have no reason to be prejudiced against him because at least twice a week some message of personal approval and admiration of myself comes from him to me. The last person to transmit that message was an archbishop, and two days before it was a London K.C. I personally have always sent back, along the same line as those messages came, and I hope they got there exactly, what I have said here, that in my opinion the Ceann Comhairle is the ablest, the most efficient, and the most effective Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy in this House. It is in that sense that I say I am not here to say one word in disapproval of the Ceann Comhairle.
I accept the statement made by Deputy Lemass. Deputy Lemass said in effect: "We have recognised as a fact, founded upon our long experience and brought to a head by this palpable and flagrant act of partisanship, that these are the facts, that we are being governed in this House and controlled from the Chair by the most effective and the most efficient Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy in the House, that he is doing his work well and earning every penny he gets." Let us recognise that fact. Every man who goes into the Division Lobby with us tonight is going into it to say deliberately of his own opinion that an effective and an efficient Cumann na nGaedheal tool is sitting in the Chair that should be the chair of a judge. We are prepared to recognise that; we are prepared to live under it, and work under it, and break it. You can come into the Lobby with us and you can say that, or you can go into the other Lobby and say that this farce and camouflage shall continued; that this pretence that we have a judge, when in fact we have a partisan, shall continue. Those are the two things which, in face of the facts, are the only things you can do.
The party opposite has voted a public and deliberate lie in this House before. They may do it again. But it will not alter the fact that the most efficient and the ablest Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy in this House is doing effectively and efficiently, more effectively and efficiently than any Cumann na nGaedheal Minister or back bencher, the work of the party to which he belongs under the guise and pretence of being an impartial chairman of this House. That is the issue quite clearly. As I said before, we are prepared that you shall make any rules, but we are not prepared to pretend to tolerate that these rules shall be doubtful in their meaning or in their interpretation. We are not prepared to pretend henceforth, except in so far as the power of the majority, exercised through its tool is effective, to regard the present occupant of the Chair as anything but a paid party hack.
Comment on this
I rise to a point of order. I think it is your duty to stop the use of language of that description towards one of the most impartial men not alone in the Dáil, but in all Ireland—the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
Before Deputy Flinn leaves the House I want to suggest to him that the last expression which he used "a paid party hack" is an expression which, in my opinion, should not be used in the House.
Comment on this
I simply submit that the word "partisan" is in this resolution. That is exactly what I meant by partisan. If that is a disorderly expression of opinion I withdraw it.
Comment on this
Deputy Flinn is a very fine rhetorician. I am going to ask the House to come back from rhetoric to the facts of last Friday. I am also going to ask the House to come back from the spirit of the concluding remark of Deputy Flinn, to the spirit shown earlier in the debate by Deputy Thrift in one of the finest appeals that I have listened to in this House, to the spirit of the House as a whole. I for one would not remain for one instance a member of any Chamber in which it was accepted, as Deputy Flinn apparently is prepared to accept it, that our representative in the Chair was, in his elegant phrase, "a paid party hack."
Deputy O'Connell, earlier in the debate, said that he thought Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies should welcome this motion. I, for one, do welcome the motion, though not perhaps altogether for the reason which Deputy O'Connell suggested. I welcome it in the same spirit which Deputy Thrift already welcomed it, namely, that perhaps now that Deputies generally realise that there is, as the Ceann Comhairle indicated on Friday, an appropriate way of calling attention to any complaint which anyone may have to make against the Chair they may hereafter refrain from these disorderly and insulting interruptions of which we had too many examples last Friday, and of which we have had examples on other occasions. When we are invited to judge the conduct of the Ceann Comhairle everyone of us is bound to ask himself how he would have acted had he found himself in the place of the Ceann Comhairle. That seems a particularly appropriate question to be asked by Deputy Fahy, who has on various occasions himself occupied the Chair, and occupied it. I may say, with great dignity, great fairness and with complete acceptance from all parties. It is quite true that the President has reminded us that neither Deputy Fahy nor anyone else is invested with the power which falls to the Ceann Comhairle in respect to the closure. Nevertheless, it would not be difficult to imagine that some day, perhaps before very long, Deputy Fahy may find himself in the position in which he may be invested with all the powers and duties of the Chair. When that happens he will have to consider, when, perhaps, faced with a similar situation, whether or not he should grant the closure on an occasion such as that.
I think he will probably find that he will have to be guided by two or three fairly simple principles. He will have to consider, in the first place, not as a final, but as an important consideration, what are the precedents in the matter. He will have to consider also the character of the Bill or motion actually under discussion. Finally, he will have to consider the nature and character and length of the discussion which preceded the claim to move the closure.
I want to say one or two words upon these three points. If Deputy Fahy looked up the precedents he would find that, taking, for example, the present session, the Ceann Comhairle had, in fact, withheld his assent to the closure on three occasions when it was moved by the Minister, and had granted it on four occasions. He would also find that on the only occasion on which it was moved by a Private Deputy, he granted it—on a motion of one of the Deputy's own colleagues. I am not pressing that at all, but to that extent I think he would come to the conclusion that that was not the action of a partisan. If Deputy Fahy proceeded a little further and looked up other precedents to see the length of time which had been adjudged as duly suffucuent for Bills of certain importance here, and also in other assemblies, he would find some interesting information. He would find, for example, that the Second Reading of the Juries Protection Bill occupied twelve hours of the Dáil's time. He would find that the Censorship Bill occupied seven hours and twenty minutes, and he would find that the Game Protection Bill of the present session, which, after listening to something that had been said by Deputy Lemass, one would think would have taken a longer time than the Dublin Bill, occupied, on Second Reading, four hours and forty-five minutes. He would also find another rather interesting thing. That whereas the Dublin Bill occupied practically fifteen hours, the Cork City Management Bill was disposed of in less than four hours, and he certainly would be a very daring person who in this assembly would suggest that Dublin was a more important city than Cork. He would find other things even more remarkable, and I think decidedly pertinent to this issue if he pursued his inquiries as to what period of time was allotted for some of the most important Irish measures in the House of Commons.
If he looked up the debate on the Second Reading of the Irish Land Act, 1903, he would find that the time actually occupied by the Second Reading debate was three Parliamentary days, almost exactly the same period as was allowed here for the Greater Dublin Bill. If it be said, as Deputy Flinn said, that that proved nothing, because, of course, our complaint always was that we did not get sufficient time for Irish Bills in the House of Commons, let me point out this: That this was a Bill of a very unique and peculiar character. It was a Bill which revolutionised the entire land tenure and pledged the credit of the taxpayer of the United Kingdom to an unlimited extent. Consequently it was not purely of Irish interest.
Now there were six hundred odd members of the House of Commons. There were 105 Irishmen, and the debate, as I said, occupied three days. It was suggested the other day, and it has been suggested here to-day again, that there exists a right in a member to be heard in a particular debate; at any rate in relation to the Dublin Bill that a special right to be heard attached to Dublin Deputies. Just conceive what that would mean in regard to the Irish Land Bill of 1903. There were 105 Irish members of the House of Commons. Imagine no English member taking part in the debate; there is no question whatever that every Irish member, Nationalist or Unionist, was vitally and immediately interested in the fate of the Bill. Imagine how many days it would have taken if every Irish member of the House of Commons on that occasion had insisted on his right to take part in the Second Reading debate of the Bill of 1903.
I take another case, and that is the Home Rule Bill of 1912, and that will illustrate another point that I think it worth while making. What period of time was occupied in the debate on the Second Reading of the Home Rule Bill? The Second Reading debate occupied seven days, not much more than twice as long as was occupied on this Greater Dublin Bill. Here we come to what I think is an important matter and which is the last point that I desire to make, and that is, the character of the Bill. In the Home Rule Bill, you had a Bill which is almost the exact opposite to a Local Government Dublin Bill. It was a long, complicated measure. If you had taken every single clause out of that Bill, except one, the objection on principle would have remained. Our Second Reading debates are essentially directed to matters of principle. You could have taken out all the clauses and you could have turned the financial clauses on their head; you could make any arrangement you pleased, but so long as there remained in that Bill one single provision, namely, that there should exist in any shape or form a parliament in this country with an executive responsible to it, so long would the objection of a powerful opposition be persisted in. Consequently, it was not a Bill which could really be dealt with on Second Reading, but the Second Reading of it was obviously a vital stage. Yet, when the closure was moved at the end of what was in effect a parliamentary week, I have no recollection—although at the moment the most bitter feeling existed between the two sides—there was ever a suggestion that in accepting the closure upon that Bill the Speaker of the day was acting in a spirit of partisanship.
[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]
Let us look for a moment at the nature of the Dublin Bill and consider it. I listened carefully, not to the whole of the debate, but certainly to the greater part of it, and I can only discover this. The principle of the Bill, it appears to me, is that you should substitute for commissioners a council and a manager. If that is accepted, all that remains, to all intents and purposes, are matters that can be only satisfactorily dealt with in Committee. So far as I heard, nobody has said that we do not want the Bill at all, same as was said with regard to the Home Rule Bill. I listened with great care to Deputy French, who made the most powerful speech, in my opinion, against the Bill, but my recollection is that he was very careful to say that he did not object to the principle of the Bill.
What many people objected to was the allocation of the powers and duties as between the Manager and the council. What other people objected to was the area to be taken in; others objected to the creation of a separate borough, and some others to the creation of a special commercial register. These are points that are clearly intended for the Committee Stage. Therefore, whether we look at the matter from the point of view of the length of time occupied or from the nature of the Bill itself; the character of the debate which preceded the Closure Motion, or from the nature of the opposition and the character of the opposition, I have come to the conclusion that no case has been here made out in condemnation, sir, of your action.
Comment on this
My interest in the Bill was originally that of a person who had a watching brief on behalf of a large city elsewhere, namely, Waterford. It brought home to me how inadequately the Bill had been discussed when I felt the importance of it in its application to large towns in Ireland. The Bill was of the very greatest possible importance from that point of view. It was important because of the enormous amount of money which was involved. I think there was something like £4,000,000 mentioned as being the amount of the loan to the Dublin Corporation which would be transferred under the Bill. From my point of view I was mainly concerned with the principles involved in the Bill, especially with reference to the Manager. After listening to a discussion on that Bill I felt that any of the towns in Ireland would be mainly interested in the question of the Manager. What was in my mind at the time the closure was moved was—where exactly is the line of principle to be drawn in this Bill and the powers given under it to be set right on amendment and how far is it a Bill which is incapable of amendment. I felt that I was in this position, that something was going to be put over on us where we would not be able to get what we wanted otherwise by amendment at all. In this House, on several occasions, we found that the amendments that we wished to move to particular Bills were not such as could be moved within the principle of these Bills. That was one of the matters that I wished to see cleared up in the course of the debate. The closure prevented that from being done.
I need not go over the points that have been already dealt with, but I would like to point out in answer to the Minister for Finance that if he considers the measure a minor measure which involved a Commission on the Greater Dublin Scheme which lasted a considerable time, which accumulated an enormous bulk of evidence taken before it, and which subsequently took the Government with all the machinery at their disposal a period of three years in which to draft a Bill, after which the public gets only a fortnight to consider it, then he must have a peculiar conception of what a minor measure is. A Bill that has taken all this time in its preparation is being rushed through this House after three sittings. Deputy Law has drawn analogies from the House of Commons in England. I certainly think that if at the time these very instances had been quoted to show how completely disarmed we were, how lacking we were in the matter of self-government, we could not have got better examples than in these examples that Deputy Law has given us. His examples were unfortunate because they will bring home to a number of people who heard his arguments or read them in print that we are on a similiar footing or on the same footing as if we were still under the rule of Westminster.
Deputy O'Connell's action is one which I find very difficult to understand. He pointed out that the Ceann Comhairle had been wrong in allowing the measure to be closured because the House understood that the Minister was going to reply. Apparently the Ceann Comhairle had had plenty of time to consider the matter. The Minister for Finance pointed out that when moving the closure he always let the Ceann Comhairle know beforehand and apparently the House knew beforehand that the closure was going to be moved. We must presume that the Ceann Comhairle also knew it. No plea has been put up that he was taken unawares. It must have occurred to the Ceann Comhairle, therefore, that the House was under the impression that the Minister for Local Government and Public Health was to reply. Our case is based entirely upon the terms of the Standing Orders. If the case made against our contention is correct, if Deputy Thrift is correct in his interpretation of the Standing Orders or as to what he believes is the proper conduct of the Chair, then Standing Order 52 should not be there.
Obviously the duty of the Ceann Comhairle is to protect the minority against a decision being rushed by the majority in the House. In carrying out that function he is not merely protecting the minority in the House but he is protecting the rights of the people outside the House. He is giving the people outside the House an opportunity of considering adequately a measure by seeing that it gets adequate discussion inside the House. It is with the people outside the House that I am most concerned. There is a very considerable change of opinion in the country and that change of opinion is due largely to the jackboot methods of the Government, to their methods of dealing with the ordinary citizen. We might wish or like to deal with this matter in a gentle way, but the general public outside would say that we were fooling in this House if having put down that motion we should withdraw it and not press it to a vote. I believe that the general public think as we do about this—that we are protecting the rights of the country itself in so far as we are trying to assert the rights of the minority in this House.
Comment on this
If the Ceann Comhairle held that the closure on the amendment was entirely a different action to the prevention of speeches upon the main issue of the Second Reading, then he condemns his own action in preventing these speeches being made, because, according to his own ruling, the closure did not affect the main issue.
Comment on this
I am referring to what you said to-day. I understood from your ruling to-day that you regarded the amendment and the episode which surrounded the amendment as being one completely distinct and separate from the subsequent ruling. Our contention was that the two should have been considered as one motion. Our contention was that we were entitled to discuss both these episodes as being ruled by the closure. If our contention was not correct, then you were not entitled to prevent discussion upon the main question after the vote had been taken on the amendment. That is my argument.
I do not wish to delay the House on this discussion. I will, however, say that there is a very big change in public opinion in Ireland about the Government. There are many Deputies opposite to us who want to see fair play in this House, and who do not want to see themselves put wrong with the public outside. I advise them when they come to vote to consider rather the outside public and their judgment upon the rushing of this Bill, and the parties who have been parties to the rushing of this Bill, than any of the niceties of the game as played in this House.
Comment on this
I would like to preface the few observations I wish to make on this motion by giving my experience of the conduct of the Ceann Comhairle since I came to the House. I have expressed the opinion to other Deputies, and possibly I have also expressed that same opinion to the Ceann Comhairle, that if I had a fault to find with him in the conduct of the business of the House it is that he, as a rule, allows too much latitude to the members. I think that if this motion does not do anything else except to draw attention to the necessity of keeping speakers to the subject-matter under discussion and enabling the Chairman of our Assembly to rule with, perhaps, a little more of the stern hand in the future, it will have done very much good.
I am one of the aggrieved parties of Friday last. I want to keep within the bounds of the motion, but I must candidly admit that I was astounded when I heard the Minister for Finance moving the closure. I must also admit frankly that I was rather surprised the motion was accepted. I felt annoyed and I went into the Lobby against the closure motion. I will say that it is the first time that, in my opinion, I have differed with the ruling of the Chair, but even though I did differ with that ruling, I certainly, for one, am not going to go into the Lobby to vote that the Chairman of this Assembly is a partisan. I possibly have said enough. I do not want to express my opinion about the tactics adopted by the Government, because that does not form part of this motion.
Comment on this
We probably will have another opportunity of discussing that later on; possibly when the Committee Stage is reached there will be something more to be said on that matter. I prefer to take the line adopted by Deputy O'Connell whose amendment was under discussion when the closure was moved. I think he took the proper and dignified course in dealing with the motion on the Paper. Suffice it to say that, in my opinion, the moving of the closure motion on Friday was not creditable to the Government. I will also say that the manner in which protests were made against that were certainly not edifying to the members of this House.
Comment on this
There was a reason why the protests against the closure motion may not have been, according to Deputy O'Hanlon, edifying. The people on these benches felt that they had a certain grievance which must be aired in some other manner than was available hitherto in this House. Since we have come into this House we have not been able at all times to see eye to eye with the Ceann Comhairle and, of course, the Ceann Comhairle has not been able to see eye to eye with us on certain matters, individually, not collectively. Speaking as one of those not aggrieved personally as regards the constituency I represent, I must say I sympathise with those people who may have been aggrieved as regards their Dublin County or City constituency. Every person who thought he had anything to say on this particular subject should have got an opportunity of saying it. This is the capital of the country and those who represent it would like to have the same opportunity for discussing the welfare of the city as I or any other Deputy would like to have in order to discuss the welfare of our own constituencies. What applies in this case to Dublin City might in the future apply to towns in any other constituency in the Saorstát. Those Deputies who wished to discuss this Bill felt they were aggrieved because they were not given an opportunity to discuss it at proper length.
The Closure Motion was moved by the Government. It was moved several times before and we strongly objected to it. There were many days and weeks when more work could be done in this House than was done in it. There were many holidays. Nobody could convince me that we are so short of time that we should confine ourselves to a few miserable hours in discussing a Bill that relates to the capital city of this country, to a measure that may be of vital interest in years to come to the inhabitants of this city. On a measure like that, discussion should not be confined to a few miserable hours. Deputies owe a duty not only to this capital city but to the country as a whole. The country as a whole owes a duty to its capital city.
Comment on this
I do not want to come to the Ceann Comhairle too personally. I have been talking about the motion. At all times and in all places you have made it your duty to see that we do not overstep the bounds. I give you credit for this, that you never let us overstep the bounds if you can possibly help it. I have never given you cause to pull me up. I will take particular, damn good care that you do not, because I will say what I want to say about my constituency.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy sit down for a moment? There is no necessity for the Deputy to indulge in strong language about his constituency, or even about the capital city. There is no necessity for him to be personal about the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
I quite agree, and I was not inviting the Deputy to be personal about the Ceann Comhairle. Perhaps the Deputy could say something about this motion if he addressed himself to it. The motion is directed to the Ceann Comhairle. Up to the time that I intervened, the Deputy had not said anything at all about the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
If the Ceann Comhairle had not interrupted me, I would have finished up what I had to say in two or three sentences. What I want to say is this: that I object strongly to the action of the Government and the action of the Ceann Comhairle. As far as this motion is concerned, I am with it heart and soul.
Comment on this
If the Deputies on the far side set out in their motion to prove that the Ceann Comhairle was partisan in his action on Friday last, the only evidence of that that they have brought forward up to the present is their reiterated belief that he was so. In passing away from that to Deputy Flinn, the Deputy, in very strong language, so strong that it had to be withdrawn, accused the Ceann Comhairle of not only being a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, but of acting as such in the Chair. The Deputy's words were to the effect that the most effective and efficient Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy was sitting in the Chair in which there should be a judge.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it permissible, even for a Minister within the House, to refer to words that have been withdrawn?
Comment on this
These words were not even near the crescendo. It is a pity that the Fianna Fáil Party arising, say, out of the grievance which they feel, out of their incompetence to realise what that grievance is, to know what happened exactly on Friday, their incompetence to set down a motion that would afford an opportunity for discussing their grievance, should start to look around for something to break. That is the line which speeches delivered on the opposite side have taken. Turning to the line pursued by Deputy O'Hanlon and, to a certain extent, by Deputy Carney, let us see what opportunity Deputies have for discussing Bills. Bills are discussed in this House on four different stages—Second Reading, Committee, Report and Fifth Stage. Deputies who follow that line of argument must show the House in regard to what class of Bill, which had been under discussion for three parliamentary days, it would be possible for the occupant of the Chair to refuse to accept a motion for the closure of debate on it. Let us see what class of Bill there is in which in common reason such a motion could or should be refused by the Chair, and whether the Bill under discussion on Friday last was of that particular class. That is the only way out for a discussion that will prove that the Ceann Comhairle acted in a partisan way.
With reference to the statement of Deputy Flinn, a statement of a very strong kind as I said before, that the occupant of the Chair has been acting, and that he will always consider that he is acting, as a Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy rather than anything else, I would like to recall to the House the position of the present occupant of the Chair since he came into the House. On the 19th September, 1922, a motion was made by Deputy Ernest Blythe that Deputy Michael Hayes be elected Ceann Comhairle. The question was put by the Clerk and agreed to. In September, 1923, the motion was made by the President: "Go dtoghfar Mícheál O hAodha mar Cheann Comhairle." The question was put by the Clerk and unanimously agreed to. The election of 1923 was the last election at which the present occupant of the Chair faced any constituency. He then went before the electors of the National University constituency as a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. Deputies may have an objection to anyone associating himself with the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, but there is that particular type of objection.
So detached had the occupant of the Chair to keep himself from political matters during his occupancy of the Chair that, in the spring of 1927, the Constitution Amendment (No. 2) Act was passed. It was passed on the 19th March, 1927. That change was made in the Constitution after full consideration of the matter by the House. The effect of that Act was that the occupant of the Chair, on the dissolution of one Dáil, automatically became a member of the next. That Act was passed because it was felt that his duties in the Chair divorced him completely from political work. The Dáil divided on the Second Reading, and it was passed by 46 votes to 21, the 46 votes including members of different Parties. The Fourth and Fifth Stages of that Bill were carried unopposed, so that the completed conviction of the House passed the Bill making the Ceann Comhairle, on the dissolution of one Dáil, automatically a member of the next. The new Dáil met on 23rd June, 1927, and the President moved that "Deputy Michael Hayes be elected and do now take the Chair of the Dáil as Ceann Comhairle." The question was put by the Clerk and agreed to unanimously, amongst those agreeing being the Deputies on the far side.
Comment on this
It was unanimously resolved then that Deputy Hayes be elected to take the Chair as Ceann Comhairle. We now come to the 11th October, 1927, when the Deputies opposite were here, and when the President moved that "Deputy Michael Hayes be elected and do now take the Chair as Ceann Comhairle." The question was put and was passed unanimously, so that the present occupant of the Chair, after some experience of him, was unanimously re-elected to the Chair, the Deputies on the far side joining in that unanimity. Not to stretch it further than it can be stretched, the summer of 1923 was the last time on which he had political connection with any party, and his severance was so complete that the general position of the occupant of the Chair was recognised by the House as completely divorced from Party politics and from Party. It is regrettable that Deputies on the far side, through their own incompetence, could not hit out at what they want to hit at at the present moment.
Comment on this
They would not be allowed inside the terms of the motion, but I suggest a motion could be framed so that they could hit at what they wanted to hit inside the terms of that motion.
Comment on this
The Government is the wicked genius in a lot of these things and the Deputies on the far side, instead of making arrangements to hit at what they want to hit at, are hitting in a vital place at an institution. Deputy Derrig confessed he had rather qualms of conscience about allowing a motion like this to go down on the Paper, for he understood it was not right, but unfortunately he allowed himself to look around for arguments and for odd words which were an acceptance rather than a disapproval of the motion. Deputies should not attempt to label the present occupant of the Chair with any particular Party label, for the evidence goes back to 1923 to show that he cannot be so labelled. If Deputies, failing to show that the Ceann Comhairle has been partisan, would take an interest in their own education they will attempt to show in regard to what class of Bill that had three parliamentary days' discussion, permission to move the closure could be refused by the Chairman.
Comment on this
The authority of this House to pass legislation in the interests of all the citizens of this State was challenged, and it was only formally and clearly established as a result of a lengthy and expensive civil war. It is, therefore, only right that the people of this State should expect that their elected representatives in this House should have the opportunity on all occasions and on all matters of national importance of voicing their views on matters that come up here from time to time. I am one of the Deputies in this House who on every occasion when the Chair concluded that its authority had been challenged, and when on other occasions it came to the conclusion that disorderly and insolent remarks had been made, consistently voted for the suspension of the Deputy or Deputies concerned.
I claim, therefore, having done these things, to have as much respect for the rights of the Chair as any other Deputy. The President, in defending the action of the Chair in accepting the Closure Motion credited the Opposition Party with Deputies whom they did not claim to be on their side in this matter. He has credited the Opposition Party with the speeches made by Deputy Murphy and Deputy Good, for instance, who occupied seven columns of the official journal in objecting to this Bill, and who subsequently went out into the Lobby and refrained from voting for it. The President contended, and also other Ministers who have spoken, that the matter had been adequately discussed, and they expressed the opinion that a number of obstructive speeches had been made during the course of the debate.
Was the President aware of, or was he in the House listening to, the speech of Deputy J.J. Byrne, who occupied fifteen columns in the Official Debates in his speech against the Bill, which he subsequently voted for. If there is anything one could term obstruction it is the speech of that Deputy who occupied fifteen columns of the Official Debates speaking against the Bill for which he voted. If that speech was not obstruction I do not know what it could be called. I cannot understand why he should waste the valuable time of this House and the patience of its members in carrying on in that way. I take the line in this matter that Deputy O'Connell has indicated. Although I agree that the rights of the minority were infringed by the action which you, sir, took at the instance of the Minister for Finance, still I cannot bring myself to say, for I have no way of proving it, that your action in doing so was partisan. The Minister for Finance stated that no new or novel principles were introduced in the measure which was under discussion for two and a half days. If the reintroduction into this country of the Grand Jury system of voting is not a new and novel principle I do not know what it is. I think Deputies would be well justified in taking up more time in showing why that system should not be introduced as part of the local government system in this country.
The Minister for Finance also stated that the Opposition—and presumably he included the members of the Labour Party—wanted power to carry on an unlimited discussion on the Second Reading of the Bill. As far as members of this Party are concerned, they had decided that only members who had experience of local government affairs should take part in the discussion. Only two of the twelve members of this Party that were present during the three days of the debate took part in it, and it was the intention of Deputy Corish, who has more experience of local government affairs than most of the Ministers, to take part.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy say that any members of the Labour Party offered themselves to the Chair except the two members who were called upon?
Comment on this
I was informed by a private Deputy that the Closure Motion was to be put to the House, and he expressed delight that such action was to be taken at or before two o'clock. As soon as I was made aware of that fact I thought it my duty to mobilise the small number of men that I am responsible for keeping present here, and I took the necessary action. I came to the House immediately, and learned from Deputy T. Murphy that he was going to take part in the discussion —not at my request.
Comment on this
What the Chair would like to know is, whether up to the time that the Chair was asked to accept the motion, "That the question be now put"—whether during the debate on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday up to 1.25 p.m. —any Labour Deputies, other than Deputy O'Connell and Deputy Anthony, offered themselves to the Chair?
Comment on this
I know of no practice hitherto followed in this House which would impose on some member of this Party the duty of conveying such intimation to the Chair.
Comment on this
What I meant by offering themselves to the Chair was rising in their places and thus intimating to the occupant of the Chair—as a matter of fact, the Ceann Comhairle, the Leas-Cheann Comhairle, Deputy Thrift or Deputy Fahy, all occupied it at various times during the debate—that they wished to speak. No member of the Labour Party, I understand, offered himself at any time except Deputy O'Connell and Deputy Anthony.
Comment on this
I cannot say that they did but I can state positively that it was the intention of Deputy T.J. Murphy, Deputy Padraig O Hogain (Clare) and Deputy Corish (Wexford), to take part in the debate. Had we been informed by any of the Whips that it was the intention to move the Closure on Friday last I would have endeavoured to persuade Deputy Corish, with your consent, to take part in the discussion. The action which was taken by you at the request of the Government— and the Government are responsible as far as I am concerned—was an action which was never taken in the same way in this House on any important discussion before. It was always conveyed through the representatives of the parties concerned to a member of the Committee of Procedure and Privileges or through the Whips, and an attempt was made to arrive at an understanding regarding the length of discussions on particularly contentious matters. I might refer to the attitude adopted and the arrangements made to which this Party has always consented, in connection with the length of discussion on the Estimates. If the action of the Minister for Finance on Friday last is intended to terminate the harmonious arrangements that have been carried out previously with the consent of the Whips, in connection with discussions of the various estimates, I promise the Minister that he will get a warm time from Deputies on these benches on the Estimates. I hope the chief Government Whip will tell the House where he stands before this discussion ends. I pay tribute to the chief Whip of the Government Party as the individual mainly responsible for inspiring the Minister for Finance in connection with what happened last Friday.
Comment on this
I submit that the matters I am referring to were discussed and referred to by Deputies who spoke before me. Deputy Flinn got a very wide range for his views during your absence from the Chair, and he said things which I desire to disassociate myself from. As I said, Deputy J.J. Byrne——
Comment on this
As to whether the rights of the minority were respected in the debate that took place previous to the motion moved by the Minister and accepted by you, the position was this: the division that took place as the result of the Closure Motion proved that there were 129 members in the House. Most of them, I take the liberty of saying, were in the vicinity of the House during the two and a half days' debate. Two members, Deputy J.X. Murphy and Deputy Good, who between them occupy nine columns of the Official Reports, went out to the Lobby and took no part in the vote. I mention that to show that there were 131 Deputies in and around the House last Friday out of an available 152. Do you suggest that twenty-one votes out of 131, taking all things into consideration—the seriousness of the measure, the number of sections in the Bill—is sufficient to make it clear that the rights of the minority have been properly and reasonably respected? I suggest that your acceptance of the motion moved by the Minister was, by inference at any rate, an agreement with that idea.
Speaking for myself, I agree with the line taken by Deputy O'Connell that your action in accepting the motion moved by the Minister for Finance was an error of judgment. You cannot say, sir, that I hold any view other than one of the greatest possible respect for you and for your position in the Chair, and in the future, as on previous occasions, whenever the Chair is challenged on any matter, whenever any disorderly remark is made by anybody, no matter from what party it may come, I will always stand for respect for the Chair, because if we have not respect for the Chair the proceedings of the House are turned into a farce.
We hear a good deal in the country from Ministers about the powers of the people to make their own laws. The powers of the people under the Constitution, democratic as it is, are limited if you, in your judgment, when the occasion offers deprive Deputies from taking part in the debates in the way in which they should. As I say, I agree with the line that Deputy O'Connell has taken, and I am personally of the opinion that you did not give due and proper consideration to the rights of the minority parties when you accepted the motion; but I certainly would not go so far as to say that your action was partisan, and in voting against this motion I want to make it quite clear that I dissociate myself entirely from the abusive and insolent remarks hurled at you on Friday, and from the remarks which were made to-day, particularly by Deputy Flinn.
Comment on this
Deputy Little remarked that if the Fianna Fáil Party were not to press this motion to a division people outside would say that they were fooling the country. Putting together the speech made by Deputy Lemass earlier in the evening and the speech made by Deputy Little, I can only come to the conclusion that if the Fianna Fáil Party are not fooling the country in pressing this motion to a division, they are fooling themselves. Deputy Lemass's chief point was that the Ceann Comhairle was the nominee of a party, that he was elected by a party majority, and that he was kept in office by a party majority. If the Fianna Fáil Party really believes that the Ceann Comhairle acts as a party nominee, and acted as a party nominee last Friday in accepting the closure, what point is there in appealing to the same party majority which keeps the Ceann Comhairle in office to pass a motion, which it is quite certain in advance will not be passed, condemning the action of the Ceann Comhairle? I suggest that when Deputy Little says that unless this motion is pressed to a vote of that party majority the country will consider that it is being fooled, that speech is turned into absolute nonsense by the speech which Deputy Lemass made before him, and that Deputy Lemass's speech is equally turned into nonsense by Deputy Little's. Deputy Davin put his finger on the real point of complaint in this issue. The real point of complaint was that there were 130 Deputies out of a total number of 153 here on Friday. The Fianna Fáil Party failed, for some reason or other, to have their full strength present.
Comment on this
I am not making any disgraceful suggestions, and I do not think what I said could be called an innuendo. Seven members of the Fianna Fáil Party were not present on that day, so that Fianna Fáil could not put up as good a fight against the Government as they might have done. Having come into the House to play the game according to certain rules, the Fianna Fáil Party played the game up to a certain point, and when the game was going against them they turned round and abused the referee. Their action was like that of very petulant children who are invited to play a game of football but tire in the middle of it and say that because they are not strong enough to beat their opponents there is something unfair about the whole thing.
What the Ceann Comhairle had really to decide on Friday was not whether the Bill had been sufficiently discussed, but the previous question, whether it was right that the House should have an opportunity to decide if the motion had been sufficiently discussed. When a pronouncement was made by the vote of the House that the motion had been sufficiently discussed, then if there was any infringement of the rights of the minority that infringement was made, not by the Ceann Comhairle, but by the majority of the House. The Ceann Comhairle's function was limited simply to deciding whether, in a certain set of circumstances, it was right that the House should be given an opportunity to vote. That decision is a decision the limits of which must have a very narrow range. The Ceann Comhairle can hardly be expected to go into the rights and wrongs of every debate, to discuss the character of every Bill, or to make up his mind whether or not a Dublin Bill is more important than a Cork Bill. He has to take a certain broad fixed line, which is the same for one Bill as for another; he has to make up his mind simply and solely whether the House may now decide to terminate the discussion or not, and in doing that I suggest that he must, by the very nature of the case, be bound by no other than the most limited and rigid considerations of fixed procedure. I suggest that in doing what he did on Friday the Ceann Comhairle was only carrying out what has been the tradition of the House all along. When a request is made that the House shall decide as to the continuance or not of a discussion, unless to grant the request would be a flagrant breach of the rights of the minority, the Ceann Comhairle normally cannot decide of his own volition to refuse to allow the House to vote, because if the Ceann Comhairle refuses to accept a closure motion what he does is to refuse to allow the House to vote.
Comment on this
I do not remember the exact circumstances but they were circumstances in which certain very narrow and limited considerations of procedure dictated his course of action to him. He was not influenced in his previous decisions by the character of the Bill, or by the speech of Deputy J.J. Byrne, or by any other considerations of that kind; he could only have been influenced by those narrow considerations which apply as much to one Bill as to another. In actual fact, when a complaint is made that the minority was deprived of its rights on last Friday, the same complaint could equally have been made by the majority. There were a number of Dublin Deputies on this side of the House who intended to make speeches on the Bill, and who were equally deprived of their rights in voting for the closure. But the point I want to make is this, that the deprivation, if it occurred, was the act, not of the Ceann Comhairle but of the majority by its vote, and the Ceann Comhairle had no option under the ordinary traditions of procedure but to allow the House to decide for itself whether it should go on with the debate or not. The real problem before the Opposition seems to me to be that they have not made up their minds to realise that they are a minority and that a minority has only certain limited powers of action in a House of Parliament. The minority cannot expect, when a vote is taken, that the Ceann Comhairle will do something to put them into a majority, and that seems to be very much the position of the minority in this House. When a vote is taken and they do not like the result, or are angry about something or other, they immediately proceed to denounce the Ceann Comhairle in all the moods and tenses. They do not realise that there is a certain limited sphere of action in which they can do work in this House, and very effective work, if they choose to do it. I believe that if certain members on this side of the House had been on the other side the Bill would have found much more difficulty in getting a second reading. But it passed largely because a certain number of the Fianna Fáil Party sat down, wrung their hands because they were not given an opportunity to speak, and blamed the Ceann Comhairle for it.
Comment on this
I say the Bill had a much easier passage than it would have had if the Fianna Fáil Party had not decided to sit down, wring their hands, and call the Ceann Comhairle names instead of doing something. The Fianna Fáil Party cannot get it out of their heads that they are the people of Ireland and that what they say goes, and they cannot get it out of their heads that here as well as outside they have to obey, like everybody else, the decisions of the majority. Until the Fianna Fáil Party get into their heads that in this House as well as outside it they must accept the majority rule, there is no use in sitting down, wringing their hands, and calling the Ceann Comhairle names.
Comment on this
As one of the County Dublin Deputies, I certainly do protest that I was not given an opportunity of speaking on this Bill, and I think that you will agree, sir, that my protest is reasonable, because you will realise that I am not one of those who take up a great deal of the time of the House, as the President said, in order to appear on the records as having made a speech.
Deputy Redmond said that the Dublin Deputies had no particular right to voice their opinions on this Bill more than any other Deputies. That is certainly not so, considering that we who are elected for the city and county of Dublin have been receiving deputations from various representative bodies, which protested as vigorously as any public bodies could protest against this Bill, urging upon us to vote against the Bill and to express our opinions as strongly as possible against it. On that particular question out of a total of 23 Deputies who were elected to represent the city and county of Dublin only seven spoke, notwithstanding the fact that we were petitioned from public bodies to use every effort to see that this Bill should not go through. It was stated by some speaker here to-night that 21 Deputies had spoken on this Bill. That is not so, because although 21 Deputies actually did speak, 21 did not speak on this particular Bill. If you remember, Deputy Myles Keogh, although he spoke, did not mention the Bill good, bad or indifferent. He merely got up to whitewash President Cosgrave and Deputy O'Kelly. He said they were great ornaments to the old Dublin Corporation. Deputy McKeon also spoke, but instead of speaking on the Greater Dublin Bill he entertained us to a speech on the Greater Boston Bill, so I do not think that those speakers should be counted amongst those who spoke on the Bill.
Comment on this
I think 21 spoke, exclusive of Deputy Myles Keogh. Deputy Myles Keogh made an intervention. The Deputy is right about Deputy Myles Keogh, but 21 others spoke, including Deputy McKeon, of course.
Comment on this
I was checking over the numbers and my numbers corresponded to 21. The Minister for Finance, speaking here to-night, told us that after all it was a reasonable thing that this debate should be concluded in a short time, because it was only a Bill of minor importance. That seems to me to be a most extraordinary statement from the Minister considering that the Commission to deal with this subject was set up in 1924. They went to the trouble of holding 40 meetings. They issued their report on 29th November, 1926, and exactly 12 months later, when the Minister was pressed as to when we would hear about the Greater Dublin Bill we were told that the Executive were still busy examining the Bill and that their examination was not yet complete.
I find it took the Government, those great supermen we always hear so much about, exactly 39 months to produce this Bill, and after all that and the work of the Commission the Minister for Finance announces to the country that it is only a Bill of minor importance, and we, who only have ordinary intelligence, are expected to deal with this Bill in the space of what is called a Governmental week. I merely want formally to lodge my protest. I consider that those of us who have been intimately connected with the City and the County of Dublin certainly could have given some information on this particular Bill which could not be expected from those who have no connection whatsoever with the city or the county. The Minister for Local Government, I think, knows personally that I have definite opinions about certain very serious things in the county which require immediate remedy. I think I should have been given an opportunity of expressing my views on the subject.
You, sir, asked Deputy Davin when he complained that a number of Labour Deputies were not given an opportunity of speaking, did they offer themselves to the Chair, and he was not sure whether they did or not. I may say that I sat here during the whole debate, with the exception of the time occupied by my meals, and receiving a deputation, and I did not get an opportunity of offering myself to the Chair. When the closure was moved, our leader, Deputy O'Kelly, informed you that three of us had not spoken and were anxious to speak. I merely say that in reply to your question as to whether we offered ourselves to the Chair or not.
With reference to Deputy Tierney's remarks, he said we came in here and that we did not yet realise that we were a minority, that we came in here to play a game, and that having played that game up to a certain point, and having seen that we were losing, we blamed the referee. I say if any team were playing—I certainly think it a comparison with last Friday's proceedings— and found that, as soon as their opponents scored a goal, the referee declared that it was too dark to continue the match, I certainly would not blame the team for lynching him.
President Cosgrave told us that the real purpose of the debates here was in order to put forward the pros and cons that we might come to a proper decision before voting. I may remind the President that his contribution to this particular debate, as has been remarked by many people who read the evening papers, was not a discussion on the Greater Dublin Bill. He occupied a great deal of our time telling us a whole lot about Mr. de Valera and the new paper he is about to start. What connection that had with the Greater Dublin Bill I fail to understand. I therefore formally protest against the action of the Chair in preventing those of us who were anxious to speak on Friday last from speaking.
Comment on this
When the President alternates between jocularity and jogging along the bye-ways we always know he has a bad case. He did it very much this afternoon. He indulged in casuistry whenever he referred to the motion before us, and as far as possible he kept to the bypaths. However, he threw out one sentence which I hope he carefully considered and which I do trust he realises the significance of, because it was repeated in other words by three other Deputies on Cumann na nGaedheal benches. I shall come to them in a moment. We had from Deputy Thrift a disquisition on procedure and order, very eloquent but, to my mind, somewhat irrelevant. We had from the Minister for Local Government, as from an expert I presume, a lecture on incompetency. He did not tell us what we should have done, though he evidently intended to do it. He forgot the business on hand. The duty of the Ceann Comhairle, the President said, is to keep order and see that the business is done. I do not think the President or anybody else will deny that in preposing this motion I said that the first duty of the Ceann Comhairle is to see that the business is done here and to protect the majority, but in this particular case there was no urgency in the matter and the majority did not require protection.
I wonder why there is an idea here that the Bill must be got through in two or three days. I do not like, of course, to compare this mighty Assembly with such an insignificant institution as the Parliament of the French nation, but a Deputy there recently took eight consecutive days and nobody moved that he should be closured. Of course, we cannot fritter away time in that fashion, being an important institution, having to deal with the mighty problems of three millions of people. The phrase used by the President was this: "The majority leave the Ceann Comhairle little option." It was repeated by Deputy Tierney and others in another form—that the House decides and not the Ceann Comhairle. I submit that is casuistry, that there is a dangerous doctrine there. Heaven forbid that there should ever be a majority here or a Government who would use a party majority to suppress its political opponents now or at any other time, but it is a possibility that may arise, that they would have a party who would vote as they were told irrespective of the merits of the case. Consider the position of the minority, if the majority leave the Ceann Comhairle very little option. Deputy Professor Tierney said that we should be cribbed, cabined and confined within very narrow and tight limits of procedure. That is a very dangerous doctrine. I submit that Section 52 is specially designed to meet such a case, and that it is the duty of the Ceann Comhairle, if the Government is inclined to use its party majority to prevent the fullest possible discussion, to step in and protect not the majority, who do not need it, but the minority who do.
Suppose even that seven or eight hours were taken by the Opposition in discussing the Greater Dublin Bill, was that an excessive amount of time? If it takes the Front Bench of the Government and its supermen and experts in the Local Government Department three and a half years to base, on the findings of the Commission, a Bill, do they think it is a great tribute to the ability of the Opposition if they take nine hours to digest, analyse, discuss and approve or disapprove of that three and a half years' work of the super-men of the Government Front Bench and the experts of the Local Government Department?
Deputy Hugh Law, I thought, was rather clever. He put the proposition that if I were in the Chair as Ceann Comhairle, which God forbid, for I have no ambition in that direction, and I cannot fancy myself in the position, what would I do? Well, I say candidly, if I were in that position, as far as I understood the matter and I had an opportunity to judge it impartially, I would not have allowed the Minister for Finance to move the closure on Friday last. I say definitely that I would not have acceded to his request. It may argue incompetency on my part for the position, which I do not ambition, but I certainly would not have accepted his motion for the closure. I hope that answer is straight enough for Deputy Hugh Law. There are many things to be weighed up and I admit that many considerations would enter into it, but, as far as I can see at present, that would have been my decision.
The Minister for Finance said there was nothing wrong in that, that the closure is part of the machinery. Quite so. But I would like him or the President to tell us why the procedure which was common and usual on such occasions of informing the Whips of this Party or of the Labour Party that the closure was to be moved, was not followed on Friday last. What was the urgency? Why not follow that procedure? The President spoke of his courtesy in the morning in merely hinting that certain things might happen. I would not like to take it in the literal sense, but "a man may smile and, smiling, be a villain." A courtesy may often cloak a little ambiguity, and the President is very astute. It is a minor Bill, we are told, and why not move the closure? There was nothing important in it. There were no new principles in it, only the principles that were enshrined—or more properly, I suppose, we should say entombed—in the Cork Bill. Sufficient reason and opportunity for debate were given. I submit they were not. It would be out of order perhaps to go more fully into it, but we certainly were not told how it had worked out in Cork. The Government did not tell us that, having tried experiments, they were going to follow the disastrous results or not follow them. We did not hear anything about that from the Minister responsible for the Bill. I do not know that there is any more that I can add except to say that I still believe that the action of the Ceann Comhairle on that occasion was partisan and an infringement of the rights of the minority.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
On a point of order, before the House proceeds to discuss the next business I desire to point out that there were two matters which I intended to raise after Questions to-day but I did not do so because I would be cutting in on the debate which has just concluded. The first refers to a serious error which in my opinion crept into the Official Report of last Friday, Column 1236, in which it is stated that the Committee Stage of the Dublin Bill was ordered for Wednesday, 12th March. I was present when the proceedings concluded on Friday last and my recollection of what happened is that immediately you declared the Second Reading of the Bill carried, you announced the Adjournment of the Dáil. I did not hear you call on the Minister to fix, or suggest a date to be fixed, for the Committee Stage of the Bill. I did not hear the Minister mention any date, neither did I hear you announce to the House that the Committee Stage was fixed for the 12th March. I think that there must have been some misapprehension with regard to the date and I think it is only right that attention should be called to the matter.
Comment on this
The procedure usually followed when it has been declared that a Bill has passed its Second Reading is for the Chair to ask the Minister or Deputy who moved the Second Reading when he desires to have the Committee Stage fixed. If no objection is taken, the Committee Stage is ordered for the date mentioned. In this case the Minister was asked when he desired the Committee Stage to be taken and he was understood to say "12th March." No objection was taken and the Committee Stage was ordered accordingly.
Comment on this
Did you ask that after you declared the Second Reading carried?
Comment on this
Do I understand that the Deputy has difficulty in taking the Committee Stage on the 12th March? I have gone into the matter, and I would be prepared to take it on the 26th March.
Comment on this
I take it that it is now agreed that the Dublin Bill will be taken in Committee on the 26th March.
Comment on this
The second point which I wish to raise concerns your action on Friday last in declaring that the motion for Second Reading was carried, because Tellers were not appointed for the Negative. I raise this now in order to have a definite ruling, because there does not appear to me to be anything in Standing Order 56 which would entitle the Chair to declare that a motion is carried because one party or another refuses to appoint Tellers for or against a measure, as the case may be. It seems to me that according to Standing Order 56 the duty of appointing Tellers rests with the Ceann Comhairle, and that, in fact, it is his duty to do so. It reads: "When the doors have been locked and when the Division Lobbies have been cleared, the Ceann Comhairle or Chairman shall order the Dáil to divide and shall appoint Tellers for each side...." It has been the custom and the practice here for parties to nominate Tellers and to give their names to the Ceann Comhairle, but it appears to me, according to the Standing Order, that that is merely a matter of practice or custom that has arisen here for the convenience of all parties and to facilitate matters. In my opinion, according to the Standing Orders, failing the nomination of Tellers, it would be your duty either to nominate them or to proceed to take a Division without Tellers, to get the Clerk of the House to record who is for and who is against a particular motion. Once the Division is called, it is the duty of the Chair to see that it is taken. In this particular case neither the Fianna Fáil Party nor the Labour Party were prepared to nominate Tellers, but there may have been other Parties in the House who were prepared to vote against the Bill and to nominate Tellers. Even if there were not, I think it could be done. as is done in other places, I understand, by nominating people to tell. I believe that there are provisions for taking action against people who refuse to act similarly when nominated. I raise the matter because I think something similar happened here before. A question was raised as to whether the Chair was justified in not proceeding with the Division because one Party refused to nominate Tellers. We would like to have your ruling on that matter now.
Comment on this
For the information of the House, can the Ceann Comhairle say whether, in fact, a division was called and challenged?
Comment on this
On a point of order, I understand that this Standing Order is mandatory upon you. You shall order a division, you shall order the House to divide, you shall appoint Tellers.
Comment on this
What happened on Friday was that the question, "That the Bill be now read a second time," was put from the Chair. That is to say, the Chair took the voices with a view to seeing what the decision on the motion was. Having heard the voices the Ceann Comhairle declared that, in his opinion, the motion was carried. A division was challenged, that is to say, that Deputies who thought that in fact the decision of the House would be different from the decision announced by the Ceann Comhairle after having heard the voices, challenged a division. That is in answer to Deputy Redmond's point. I distinctly heard the challenge, both in Irish and in English. The procedure is that a division is taken under the provisions of Standing Orders 55, 56 and 57. Under our Standing Orders and practice Tellers from the House are absolutely essential to the taking of divisions. If Deputies will consult Standing Order 57, they will note that it states:
"On the completion of the count the Tellers shall sign a division paper which shall be handed to the Ceann Comhairle or Chairman, who shall announce the numbers and declare the decision."
In other words, the Tellers have complete responsibility for the numbers. The Ceann Comhairle merely announces the numbers handed to him on the paper signed by the Tellers and has no responsibility for the accuracy of the numbers except that the Tellers have handed them to him. Therefore, taking one of Deputy O'Connell's points, it would not be possible, it appears to me, under our Standing Orders to take a division by means of the clerks at the table or by any other officers of the House. Some members of the House are necessary as Tellers. Standing Order 56 states:
When the doors have been locked and the division lobbies have been cleared, the Ceann Comhairle or Chairman shall order the Dáil to divide and shall appoint two Tellers for each side.
That is to say, the Ceann Comhairle has to appoint two Tellers for each side by, presumably, whatever process is open to him. The process usually adopted is to ask the parties who have challenged the opinion of the Chair to nominate Tellers. An endeavour is always made in accordance with a certain practice in the House to get Tellers from particular parties in the House when a division has to be taken. In this case that procedure was followed. Neither the Fianna Fáil Party nor the Labour Party were in a position to appoint Tellers on this occasion, which meant that they were not prepared to go to a division. That being the case the Ceann Comhairle declared that there being no Tellers against the motion, the motion was carried. I am not aware of any power in the Chair here to compel Deputies to act as Tellers, nor do I know of any provision by which action of any kind can be taken against Deputies who have refused to act as Tellers. There is a precedent. On the 30th May, 1929. Volume 30 of the Official Debates, column 666, in a discussion in Committee on the Juries Protection Bill, Deputy MacEntee claimed to move that the question be now put. That claim was accepted by the Chair. That question, namely: "That the question be now put," was accordingly put from the Chair, and the voices having been taken was declared carried. A division was challenged and the Official Report reads:
The question—"That the question be now put"—was put and declared carried.
A division was demanded, but there being no Deputies willing to act as Tellers in favour of the question, the question was declared negatived.
That would appear to afford a precedent.
Comment on this
Arising out of your ruling, I submit that even if there is a precedent, and even if the incident which you have referred to has created a precedent, that precedent cannot be allowed to over-ride the Standing Order. The Standing Order very definitely prescribes the procedure in relation to divisions. It lays down that the Ceann Comhairle shall appoint Tellers. You have stated that because the Party which sits on these benches or the Labour Party did not appoint Tellers——
Comment on this
I took a note of it and the word was "appoint." I think that if we have any privilege in the matter at all it is the privilege of suggesting to you or nominating Deputies who will act as Tellers. You may, if you wish, disregard the nominations, but the power of appointment and the obligation of appointing, under the Standing Order, is imposed upon the Chair. Apart altogether from that, the Standing Order goes further and prescribes a certain procedure which has to be followed before you can declare the motion carried once a division has been challenged. The Standing Order is as follows:—
When the doors have been locked and the division lobbies have been cleared, the Ceann Comhairle, or Chairman, shall order the Dáil to divide, and shall appoint two Tellers for each side: Provided that after the lapse of not less than three minutes, as provided in Standing Order 55, the Ceann Comhairle, or Chairman, may again put the question and declare afresh the result, in his opinion, of the putting of the question, and a division shall take place only if such fresh declaration is challenged.
The point, therefore, is that having been informed that the Party on these benches or the Labour Party, who were opposed to this measure, did not desire to nominate Tellers, I suggest it was incumbent on you to put the question afresh from the Chair, under the Standing Order, so that the House might be fully aware of what was taking place in the matter.
Comment on this
Might I reply to the President's interjection? As a matter of fact we were informed during the debate to-day that certain Deputies were not aware of what was being done during that period.
Comment on this
I understand that at that particular stage of the proceedings Deputy J.J. Byrne and Deputy Good were within the House. They opposed the Bill and I am sure, if you had called upon them, they would have acted as Tellers.
Comment on this
I was putting that point showing that it was incumbent upon you to put the question afresh if you had been informed that this Party did not desire to nominate Tellers.
Comment on this
It is not incumbent upon the Ceann Comhairle to put the question afresh from the Chair. It is incumbent upon him to appoint Tellers, but the Ceann Comhairle can only act within the ordinary limits of human action. He does his best to get Tellers, but if he fails to get Tellers, then it is not surely suggested that the refusal to appoint Tellers must hold up the transaction of the business of the House. Once the expression of opinion has been given by the Chair: "The motion is carried," and if that is challenged and if the challenge is not followed to its logical sequence to a division, nothing remains but for the decision given originally by the Chair to be affirmed and nothing in the Standing Order can be construed to mean that action by any Deputy in refusing to carry out the provisions of the Standing Order can bring the House to a standstill. The House ex hypothesi, by its very nature, cannot be brought to a standstill. If there were any Deputies who were not in a position to follow the proceedings then those Deputies of course have the sympathy of Deputy MacEntee and my sympathy as well.
Comment on this
Might I submit that it is not a question of bringing the proceedings of the House to a standstill but of conducting them, from the Chair, in accordance with the rules of order. In this connection we have got to take into consideration, also, Standing Order 55.
When a division is demanded the Ceann Comhairle, or Chairman, shall cause the division bells to be rung once, and the doors shall be locked so soon after the lapse of not less than three minutes as he shall direct.
After that has been done the question of appointing Tellers immediately arises. If no Tellers are appointed I still submit that under Standing Order 56 you must put the question afresh from the Chair, because there is absolutely no suggestion that you have any option in the matter if you desire to have the question decided without a division, or if from the facts as you are aware of them at that moment, you think the question can be decided without a division. If that is your opinion then I submit that it is incumbent upon you to put the question afresh from the Chair. The words are "Provided that after the lapse of not less than three minutes the Ceann Comhairle or Chairman may again put the question and declare afresh the result"; otherwise there must be a division.
Comment on this
We are creating a precedent in this matter, and I want to ask you whether, before finally deciding that there were no Tellers, or if, as you say, nobody is prepared to tell against the Bill, before the motion is carried or rejected, as the case may be, would it not be right that you should ask, from the Chair, whether there is anyone in the House prepared to tell for or against, as the case may be? It is conceivable that if the Fianna Fáil Party refused to nominate Tellers and the Labour Party also, there might be four or five or half a dozen Independent members who would be prepared to name Tellers against the Bill if they were asked. I put it to you that that would be a practical way of getting out of the difficulty.
Comment on this
With regard to Deputy MacEntee's point, I think he answered himself by reading the extract from the Standing Order—"provided that after the lapse of not less than three minutes the Ceann Comhairle or Chairman may again put the question." The proviso in Standing Order 56 gives the Ceann Comhairle or Chairman the option of putting the question instead of taking a division in certain circumstances. As to Deputy O'Connell's point, it is the Deputies who challenge the decision of the Chair, when given on the voices, who ought to supply the Tellers for the division, not those who have not challenged the division. It might be advisable—and nothing has been decided against it—that the Chair should ask whether there are any Tellers available in the House. It was obviously not possible to do that on Friday. It is a procedure which might reasonably be adopted, and the decision that is being given now, after consideration and affirming what was done on Friday, is merely this: that if there are no Tellers for a particular side, then the decision given by the Chair is taken as having been declared on a division.