We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Vote on Account.—(In Committee on Finance).

Contributions 114–244 of 244. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I think my first duty should be to express appreciation of the manner in which this debate has been conducted this evening. Certainly it bears a striking contrast to some of the proceedings that took place here yesterday and on a previous occasion. As the Minister for Industry and Commerce stated, most of the remarks passed here this evening have been directed towards industry, the introduction of foreign capital into this country and what the Government should do by way of fostering our native industries. Let me say that as far as I am personally concerned I think, in relation to Government interference in industry, the best thing would be for the Government to keep its hands off industry. I believe that the men engaged in industry in this country are in a better position to carry on than the members of the Government, who are, after all, only birds of passage. That is a fact that should be recognised by every Deputy here. While of that opinion, I believe the Government can, by legislation of a wise and useful character, do much to help whatever existing industries we have, and perhaps also be in a position to help in the formation of new industries.

Speaking of industry in general, I would like the Minister to bear in mind the fact, especially in regard to the introduction of foreign capital into this country, that there has been a tendency on the part of foreign combines to get control of industries here, to work these industries for a few years and then to close them down and import the articles that had formerly been manufactured in this country. That applies in particular to one important industry that has been carried on for a long time in the chief town of the constituency which I represent. I refer now to the distilling industry, which afterwards was engaged in the manufacture of yeast. The foreign company, known as the Distillers' Company, got control of that distillery at a time when the local industry had a name renowned for the excellence of its product at that time, namely, yeast.

After working that yeast factory for a number of years, the Distillers' Company thought fit to close it down. At present the company is in the position to manufacture the yeast in a foreign country; it is part of Ireland, but yet it is a foreign country—Northern Ireland. If my information is correct, they have a monopoly of practically the whole trade of this State in that commodity. In order to be fair to the Distillers' Company, I should say that they were prepared, in the event of the Government giving them certain facilities, to continue here. But, since they have not restarted manufacturing operations in the local distillery, it is about time that the Government should examine the situation and see whether it would be possible to have established within the Free State—not necessarily in Dundalk, though I should like it to be there—a factory for the manufacture of yeast for the Twenty-six Counties. I might mention that when that industry was in full working order it gave constant employment to about 300 men directly, not to speak of the employment given in connection with the import of coal and in trades incidental to the working of the industry.

Reference has been made to the erection of tobacco factories within this State. So far as I am concerned, I more or less welcome foreign capital in this country. At the same time, I think the Government should be careful to see that, as far as possible, the firms that were already engaged here in the manufacture of tobacco should receive sympathetic consideration. Whilst Deputy Good may be right in saying that the erection of tobacco factories in Dublin was the means of giving employment to many hundreds of people who would otherwise be unemployed, yet the fact remains that simultaneously with the establishment of those foreign factories in Dublin a local factory closed down. While these foreign firms may give a certain amount of employment, there is no inducement to them to extend their trade to countries outside the Free State, unlike some of our local factories. For instance, the firm of Messrs. Carroll in Dundalk, which, I am glad to say, is in a very flourishing condition, not only manufactures tobacco for the Free State, but they also export to Great Britain, and even to America, which shows that the initiative is there in those captains of industry who have local ties and, what I might call, a national outlook. That is a matter which is worthy of consideration.

There is another question to which I would like to refer. It is a very delicate question, and one in which, I think, the Government will find it difficult to interfere, as it depends on the Irish people themselves. I refer to the extension of the deferred payment system. This system may be all right when the commodities bought through it are of home manufacture, but when it comes to buying foreign made articles, then it is a very serious matter for this country. It really means that large numbers of our working-class people are mortgaging part of their wages for a period extending from five to ten years, according to the length of the contract. That is a very dangerous principle to introduce into the country. It is a matter which is engaging the attention even of leading politicians in the United States of America. Deputy Flinn more or less dealt with that point when he said that this question of home industry depended to a large extent upon the Irish people themselves, a statement with which I agree. It does seem extraordinary, yet it is a fact, that since the establishment of our home Government here there seems to have been a regular mania through the country to buy nothing but foreign manufactured goods. It is very hard to explain, yet the fact remains. It is only fair to lay stress on the fact that the Government cannot be of much assistance unless they have the hearty, loyal and continuous co-operation of the people. Until the people throw off this apathy and indifference that exists there will be no hope for the contry, no matter what Government is in power. The people should be active and loyal to themselves and support Irish manufacture. Perhaps we have all been sinners in that respect in the past, but even now, if we stand shoulder to shoulder in this matter, there is a great possibility within a very short space of time of accomplishing something by way of reducing unemployment.

Reference has been made to house-building. There again I have the same complaint to make as regards this tendency to purchase foreign material. It is extraordinary that about eighty per cent. of the materials used in the construction of houses is imported. Whether our Irish architects are to blame or not, there seems to be a great tendency to stipulate for foreign materials in the building of most of our houses. I do not know why that should be. It may be that the cost of the native article is higher. I shall mention one or two specific articles which I think could be manufactured economically in this country with a little aid and assistance from this Government. One of them is bricks. As everybody knows, bricks are essential if we are to have good dry houses. In dealing with this point, I should like to venture the opinion that unless we are very careful as regards the materials used in the building of houses our efforts in combating the terrible scourge of tuberculosis will be of very little avail. If the type of houses that are being built here continue to be built, I am afraid they will be nothing more or less than French drains. It should be possible to have every brick necessary for the building of houses manufactured in the country. I should like the Minister for Industry and Commerce to enter into consultation with the Minister for Local Government, and between them it might be possible to devise ways and means whereby the quantity of foreign materials used in the construction of our houses could be considerably reduced.

There is one other matter I should like to refer to, that has already been dealt with by Deputy Corish, and that is the question of coast erosion. There is at present, I understand, a Committee sitting considering this very important matter. It has come to my knowledge within the past few weeks that a considerable tract of country adjacent to Greenore will, in the course of a very short space of time, unless something is done, be in the same condition as Greystones. The sea is beginning to make inroads there, and some 200 acres of land are threatened. It is an old saying that a stitch in time saves nine. If something were done immediately, as the erection of a wall to form a breakwater along that few hundred yards, it might be the means of preventing that tract of country from being inundated and make it possible to work it. I should like the Minister to give some attention to that matter.

I am glad that this debate is being carried on in an atmosphere that more or less reflects credit on the House. As I said in the beginning, no Government can do very much to solve our present difficulties, and they are many and great especially those connected with unemployment, unless the people as a whole forget their little differences, and work in the interests of the nation as a whole and not of a party. That can only be done by the people, in the first instance, recognising the fact that this is a poor country. There is no use making comparisons in regard to the standard of living that prevails in other countries. We must have here a standard of living suitable to the country. It is better to have our people working for a possible fifty out of the fifty-two weeks of the year than having them going round and only working twenty weeks in the year. That can only be done by co-operation and recognition of the elementary fact that Ireland is a poor country, that she is purely an agricultural country and can give a fairly decent standard of living to the majority of her people. It should not be a question of giving a high standard of living to the minority and a low standard of living to the majority of the people. I say that the time has arrived when all who have the welfare of the country at heart should stand behind whatever Government is in power, in its efforts to grapple with the great problems that confront us.

[Deputy Davin rose.]

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Before Deputy Davin speaks I should like to say that, as already suggested from the Chair, the debate on the particular question raised by Deputy Lemass—foreign capital—might be concluded first and other topics taken afterwards. I thought when Deputy MacEntee sat down and Deputy Corish rose that we were finished with the question of foreign capital. I understand it is Deputy Davin's desire to raise another matter altogether, and I would like if we could be assured that we were finished with the question of foreign capital now, so that we could go on to other matters. It has always been the suggestion from the Chair that one or two topics should be taken on the Vote on Account. The question of foreign capital has been dealt with and I think it should be concluded before we deal with other matters. What was Deputy Davin's intention?

Comment on this

I intended to follow the line taken by Deputy Corish.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

To deal with matters other than that of foreign capital?

Comment on this

I want to deal with the Estimates for social services.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Then I take it we are finished with foreign capital.

Comment on this

I would like a few minutes on that before we pass from it. First of all, I should like to say the House must be very grateful to Deputy Coburn for his patronage in complimenting us on our good behaviour. We shall try to be good in the future. When Deputies on the other side of the House are on the defensive they are always very good and we can be good in return. Deputy Coburn said that he more or less welcomed foreign capital into this country, and then he proceeded to use every possible argument that could be used against foreign capital. He pointed out the effects that follow from foreign capital coming into a country.

Comment on this

Under certain conditions.

Comment on this

Under the conditions under which it came in. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, when dealing with the flour question, said the reason the Government rejected the tariff on flour was because they believed the millers in this country were inefficient. He went on to outline what might occur if the present developments were allowed to proceed, and he said that certain of the flour mills would close down. They might be taken over either by Irish millers or British millers. Having developed his argument to the full he ended up by saying that the more Irish mills are replaced by English mills the nearer we are to a tariff. That puts in a nutshell the policy and outlook of the Executive Council. If you want efficiency bring in the English miller or tobacco manufacturer, or whatever is British, and you will get efficiency. But the Irish flour miller or tobacco manufacturer is inefficient when compared with the mills or factories in Great Britain. As long as we have that outlook in the Executive Council there is very little hope that our industries are going to succeed, and no hope that Irishmen are going to put their money into Irish industries. If the foreigner comes across here, whether he puts his money into sugar beet, tobacco or flour mills, or anything else, he has a chance of being protected and of being spoken of as an efficient industrialist, and will have a fair chance of getting a return for his money, but if he is an Irishman all sorts of questions are put as to his capacity, his efficiency, his management and everything else.

As Deputy MacEntee pointed out, if a tariff had been put on flour at least we would have given additional employment and the case could not be worse. Now what is going to happen? As Deputy MacEntee pointed out, the Irish millers who go down, have to be paid for out of this pool, which means out of the pockets of the consumers, and that can only be done by the price of bread going up. So that the price of bread will go up; we will lose our industries and we will have more unemployment and all because the Government could not see their way to grant this tariff. Speaking of foreign capital, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in criticising the remarks of Deputy Lemass as to the trend of money from this country, said it should be regarded that any money that went out of the country—the Minister went into details and spoke, for instance, of money that went out in the way of insurance—was a good investment. Even in the case of the very big insurance companies, they have cut down their expenses to a minimum. At least ten per cent. is paid out in head office expenses and in dividends. Every half-penny of that 10 per cent. is paid out to the staffs in the head offices in London, Liverpool, Manchester, as the case may be, instead of being paid out here, as it would be, if the Government nationalised insurance and compelled these companies to register here. At present they are registered in Great Britain.

Deputy Good asked what was the use of getting foreign investors to withdraw their capital from this country and of getting Irish investors to withdraw their capital from Britain, America or elsewhere and of investing it here to replace the foreign capital. He did not see that any good was going to result to the country if such a thing as that were done. A study of the arguments of Deputy Lemass, Deputy MacEntee and Deputy Coburn, with regard to the influence exercised by foreign capital here, will show what the disadvantages are of having our various industries run by foreign capital. We know what some of the disadvantages are.

Deputy Good spoke of the advantages that had accrued to this State by the setting up of the tobacco factories. We find when we examine this matter of the setting up of these tobacco factories, readymade clothing and some other factories, that they are simply employing a large proportion of young girls in them. They are not giving employment to men in this city who are supposed to earn a livelihood for their families. These tobacco factories are British controlled. The higher positions amongst the female staff are held by ladies from across the water. The higher positions amongst the male staff are filled by Englishmen. The Minister for Industry and Commerce asked if he could get an answer as to how this question was to be solved. I am not prepared here and now to say how a question of that magnitude can be solved. The Government, which has been in office for the last seven or eight years, has seen during that time our native industries being taken over by foreign companies. They have seen some of our native industries lose their foreign trade; they have seen more of them closed down. They have seen people employed in these native industries being, in many cases, dismissed, while people were brought over from England and other places and put in the higher positions. They have seen all that go on during the last seven or eight years. Surely they are not going to face the House and say they have failed to find a solution for this question—that they are looking across to this side, or to some other part of the House, for a solution of it. They must have examined the question, and if they are competent men they must have found a solution for it. If they have found a solution for it they have not given the House a sufficient reason as to why they did not put it into effect.

As a result of the taking over of a jam factory in this city a few weeks ago four employees who had been for a long number of years employed in that factory, one for over twenty years and another with twenty-nine years' service, were dismissed with a week's notice, while people from the other side were put into their places, as if we had not unemployment enough in the country without allowing these foreign companies to come over here and displace Irish people from positions they had held so long.

Comment on this

I want to say a few words about the outlook of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I suppose we may take it that what he said represents the view of the Government as a whole. What the Minister said was interesting in this way: He said that we can deal with this matter when it becomes bad enough. Therefore, I suppose we may take it that the Government are going to allow it to get worse. The majority of the people who live in this country, who work here to earn their bread and live here fairly comfortably, realise that things are getting bad here. They find that foreign companies are coming over here more and more every day, and are getting control of some of our most vital industries. The outlook of the Government seems to me to be like that of a doctor called in to examine a patient. Having made the examination, he diagnoses the case as one of cancer. He then says in regard to the patient: "He is not bad enough yet; we will let him go a bit further. We will let him get pretty bad and then operate."

What I would like to know from the Government is this: Do they think that this Irish nation will have resistance enough left if they allow the cancer that is attacking some of our most vital industries to gain a firmer grip and postpone the operation that, if performed in time, would save the Irish nation from dying from an industrial point of view? The Minister for Industry and Commerce said that when this thing becomes a menace they are going to step in. We believe that it has already become a menace, and I think the majority of the people in the country agree with us on that. During the last few days thirty per cent. of our milling capacity has gone under the control of foreigners.

A number of our soap factories are under the control of foreigners as well as a large number of our tobacco factories. Speaking of the tobacco industry, that was one in which we had a sufficient number of our own people fully and completely qualified to run it. We had several efficient tobacco factories here in Dublin and throughout the country. Before the English companies came over here, our own tobacco factories were so efficient that they were able to compete with them in their own markets. Now we have these English tobacco factories over here. These factories are controlled by the British. As has been pointed out by speakers from this side, the majority of their highly-trained staffs are English men and English women. A lot of their technical work as regards management and other matters is done in England. There might be a case for giving a licence to foreign companies to come over and operate industry here—industries that we never had in this country—but there is no case whatever for allowing foreign capitalists to come here and control industries that we had already proved we were competent to run ourselves.

If the Government had a really national outlook, if they were not always afraid of their own shadow, they would take such steps as they saw they could take to ensure that Irish industries are going to be controlled by Irishmen in the interests of the Irish people as a whole. Ministers have, as Deputy Derrig pointed out, made a fetish of efficiency. Deputy Good has also made it a fetish. It appears from the Minister's speech, and Deputy Good's speech to-night, that we ought to get down and worship as a god some efficiency machine. The only reason for the existence of any machinery is to do something for the comfort of mankind, and the only interest we have in wanting efficient machinery running in this country is not to see it working smoothly and beautifully, but producing something here which will add to our comfort and wellbeing. If there is any machine going to be operated in the country, no matter how efficient it is, whether that one machine will do the work three hundred men did formerly, we do not care how delicate and beautiful that machine may be or how smooth it works, we do not want it in this country if it is not going to add to our general comfort and wellbeing. The duty of the representatives of the people here is to get a decent standard of comfort for all our people.

The English people coming over here with their rationalised industries are doing business with the minimum number of employees. That means we are going to have less and less people here to buy the products of our industries. A great number of the Deputies this evening pointed out some of the dangers attending the influx of foreign companies. We have to make a stand against that now whilst there is some resistance left in the country. If we are going to put it off from day to day, perhaps in five years' time, when the majority of our industries are under the control of foreigners we will be then trying to do something which we will not have sufficient power to do. We are allowing the control of our industries to pass over to foreigners, and if that process is allowed to go further, we will not have enough resistance left to deal with it. Take the case of Mexico. The Mexicans, unfortunately for themselves, allowed the control of their industries to pass over to foreigners. Every year you have a revolution in Mexico, not that the Mexicans are more cantankerous than other people in the world but that you have two blocks of foreign capitalists striving for control in that country, and sometimes these opposing blocks come from the one country. It is an unfortunate thing from the national point of view to allow British or any foreign capitalists to get absolute control of our industries. I hope the Government, even at this late stage, will step in and do something to stem the tide. Deputy Lemass, in his opening statement, referred to the policy of Fianna Fáil which was agreed upon at the Fianna Fáil Ard-Fheis, to prevent Irish industries from going more and more under the control of foreigners. If the Government have no better scheme to put up themselves, let them put that scheme into operation and give it a trial.

Comment on this

Before this part of the debate is finished I would like to say that the general opinion of this side of the House as a result of the Minister's speech is that the flour-milling industry is going to be in a more unsettled condition than ever. His statement that economic forces are going to have their way and that no State action would be taken until a certain point is reached will obviously create the greatest possible unsettlement in the industry. Its effect on the miller must be to make his future entirely obscure. On the one hand, he is faced with the effect of this rationalisation process. He cannot see ahead for a day as to what the effect is going to be on him; and on the other hand, he is faced with State action here after that rationalisation has had a certain effect on the Free State mills, but he does not know what form that State action is to take. Can any industry progress under conditions such as that? Is it fair to leave the miller in the condition of uncertainty that he will be in when he reads what the Minister for Industry and Commerce has said with regard to the problem? In my opinion, the Minister will have to make another statement almost immediately, a statement more definite and re-assuring than the one he has made to-day.

In connection with the general problem, I think there should be some statement from the Government as to whether they are going to take any action to rouse the consciousness of the people as to their responsibility in face of the new conditions that are being caused by the revolution in industry all over the world. It is time, for instance, that the Government made some effort to secure a larger volume of voluntary support for Irish industry. They have the wireless and the schools and they have at hand the Post Office which is availed of in many countries for propaganda, and they have many other agencies. Are they satisfied the position is one in which they should not use these facilities? Are they satisfied that the support for Irish industry at present is substantial and promising enough for the future that they can remain indifferent to the position?

A few weeks ago a distinguished ex-member of the Executive Council addressed the civil servants in Dublin and made a strong appeal to them to give their best and strongest support to Irish agricultural and manufactured products. I think that the appeal was very badly needed in that same circle, if my knowledge of how the Civil Service spends its money be at all accurate. At any rate, it was a good beginning, and I think the ex-Minister is to be commended for his action. Is the Government not prepared to give more encouragement to appeals of that sort? Is it not prepared itself to take any part in such appeals or do anything that would rouse the people to give a greater support to the products of the country? I suggest no Minister can be satisfied at the condition of things in the Saorstát when he sees in every town and village into which he goes practically nothing but foreign goods for sale in the shops. I do not think he can be satisfied that that is very promising for the future of the country or that the country can continue to support its Government or its existing population if that state of affairs is not quickly changed. In my opinion, a lot of the discontent that is so often expressed with regard to high salaries and pensions and that sort of thing would be obviated if it were plain that the money which goes in that way was spent within the country. I think what makes the expense of Government so very serious to many people is the consciousness that a great deal of the expenditure is money that almost immediately goes out of the country. Even leaving Government expenditure aside for the moment, if you take the one million yearly that is spent in wages from Ford's factory, I have heard it estimated that probably £700,000 of that amount goes out of the country almost immediately.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is this a question of Government policy?

Comment on this

Yes. With regard to support for Irish products.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot see the connection between Ford's workers and the Government.

Comment on this

I am only taking that as an example. You have misunderstood me. I am just remarking that it is desirable that some effort should be made to have more of the money that is spent in the country respent in the country. The fact that so very big a proportion of the money spent by the Government and by large employers is leaving the country almost immediately is a very serious matter. I think that affects the general question. I was remarking that in regard to that million yearly I have heard it estimated that probably £700,000 of it almost immediately goes out of the country, that a great deal of the expenditure on food for the employees is on foreign food, that a vast amount is spent on foreign clothing, and practically all the other household requirements are articles of foreign manufacture.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not see how the Deputy can bring that into relation with the policy of the Government which we are discussing on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I thought I had made it clear. I am remarking on the necessity of the Government taking notice of the fact that there is not general support among the people for goods manufactured in the Saorstát. It is particularly important, I think, in connection with industries in which the Government has sunk a certain amount of money that there should be some determined support for their products. There are several concerns at present working on Government loans, and assuredly in justice to the people whose money is invested in them it is only right that the Government should see that their products are getting a fair support from the public. It would be only reasonable that the Government would put themselves about a little to see that the people are supporting the output of these manufacturers. Some two years ago the Minister told us that there were considerable prospects of cement manufactury in this country in the immediate future, and he also mentioned that he had under consideration the question of an artificial silk industry. It is rather remarkable that we have not heard anything about these two things to-day or at any time since, and if it would not be too late now perhaps the Minister who is to reply would tell us how much further the effort to get these things manufactured in this country has gone.

One thing that came out plain to-day from the Minister's statement was how regrettable it is that there is not required from the Department of Industry and Commerce an annual report. I think the report from that Department would be at least as important as a report from the Department of Local Government or some of the other departments which publish annual reports. We were told some time ago that there were several advisory committeees acting in connection with the different industries. We have got scraps of information like what I have quoted now from time to time, but we have no knowledge as to what line the Department of Industry and Commerce is going upon with a view to developing new industries. It is a very expensive Department, and, in my opinion, it is probably doing very good work. It is rather a pity the public are not allowed to have any information as to what it is doing. For instance, is the Department satisfied that the boot and shoe industry is going ahead sufficiently, or has it in contemplation anything that would tend to increase the output of boot and shoe manufacturers here and reduce imports? Has it anything in contemplation with regard to the huge import of woollen goods that would tend to reduce the enormous bill that the country meets for the imports of these articles? We find that leather manufactures are imported into the Saorstát to the extent of well over half a million pounds. How far has the Department interested itself in that question. Is it content that the output of leather here is sufficient in the conditions at present prevailing, or what is the programme with regard to it? I have no expectation that Government Departments can solve many of these questions themselves, but from hints the Minister has let fall from time to time it is evident that a great many of these items are being reviewed by his Department, and in some cases reviewed very thoroughly. It is rather a pity that we cannot get information as to what the Department's thinking is on these subjects, and I suggest now that it would be no harm if the Government reconsidered the question as to whether an annual report should not be published by the Department of Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

The members of the Labour Party are mainly concerned with that part of the Vote which is likely to affect the unemployment situation. We all agree that we are at a certain disadvantage in considering this Vote on Account because we have not before us the estimate giving details of the items that make up the various amounts in the total Vote. I am glad to notice that there is an increase of about £200,000 in the amount provided for the coming financial year under the head of Local Loans. May I appeal to the Minister and to the President to see that some of this money will be made available for boards of health in order to carry out housing schemes which they are waiting to proceed with when the money is made available on long term loans. It is hardly necessary to remind the President that he has on various occasions in this House and on platforms in the country promised that long term loans will be available for local authorities willing and anxious to carry out housing schemes where they are urgently needed.

I am glad to see that the boards of health in the two counties in the constituency which I represent have taken a good deal of trouble in getting their medical officers and engineers to prepare reports regarding the urgency for carrying out housing schemes. Communications have been passing from time to time between both boards of health and the Minister for Local Government in which requests have been made to the Minister to make money available for schemes that are urgent in the opinion of the county and local medical officers of health. I know of one small town in my constituency where the county medical officer of health has stated that in his opinion 38 of the houses are a danger to the people living in them, but they cannot get out of these houses until alternative accommodation is made available for them by the board of health, and the board cannot make this provision until money is made available by the Minister. I hope that the President will fulfil the promises which he has made on public platforms in connection with this matter.

I join with Deputy Coburn and other Deputies in impressing upon the Minister the necessity for carrying out housing schemes with bricks that are available in the country instead of continuing to import cement to the tune of £500,000 per annum. Anyone who travels round England, particularly in the south, whether by motor or by rail, cannot fail to notice the houses dotted all over the country, built of brick instead of cement, although cement is available in that part of England. Why should an Irish Government, or the housing authorities here, while they have brick available at home, import cement? If the brickyards could be opened up under some scheme which could be started or assisted by the Government they would give much more employment than the employment that is given here by the importation of cement. Deputy Coburn's opinion on this matter ought to be worth more than that of many Deputies who are not connected with the building trade, and he has stated, and I believe it is the opinion of medical officers, that a house built of brick is a much healthier house than a house built of cement.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear Deputy Good say "hear, hear." That is a matter on which I cannot express a sound personal opinion, but Deputy Good must be right sometimes, especially on housing matters. On the Vote for Public Works I want to say that in the opinion of the members of this Party the Government have not taken advantage, to the extent that they should and could, of the powers that have been provided for carrying out arterial drainage schemes. There is a considerable amount of unemployment in the rural areas as a result of the depression which we all know exists in the agricultural industry. I am one of those who hold the view that if this Act was properly, fairly, and impartially administered by the Government, with the co-operation of the local authorities, considerable unemployment could be relieved and useful work could be given in reclaiming flooded lands all over the country. I hope that the Government will be a little more active on that side in the coming financial year than they were in the past year, and that they will remove a number of these red tape regulations that have to be gone through in the Board of Works before schemes can be put into operation.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Green tape.

Comment on this

Red or green tape, it is all the same; the delay is there and the Board of Works are mainly responsible for that delay. Could we have any statement from the Minister for Local Government regarding his road policy? I cannot understand the road policy of the Government. During the present financial year I understand that the ratepayers of the whole Free State are being called upon to pay an increase of 16 per cent. for road maintenance charges compared with the last financial year. In one county in my constituency the estimate for the coming year shows an increase of a shilling in the £ compared with last year, and in the other county in the same constituency there is an increase of 10d. In both areas the increase is mainly due to the fact that additional sums had to be raised from rates for road maintenance purposes. Why should that be, at a time when we have considerably increased revenue to the Road Fund, and when the farmer ratepayers in these areas have less freedom on the roads than they had ten years ago? I believe that most farmers look upon it as a menace and a danger to do their daily work on the trunk roads in present circumstances. The revenue of the Road Fund has been considerably increased. Where is that money going to, or how is it being spent?

I suppose that this has a bearing on the popular de-rating proposal that we hear so much about, but I suggest that the trunk and main roads should be handed over to a central authority and control, instead of having the indirect control which we have to-day, which is the cause of considerable delay and confusion in the administration of the moneys that are made available. If we had that central authority and control, I believe that the people who have to provide the money, both ratepayers and taxpayers, would get a far better return for their money. You would have direct control, which would obviate delays, and from a purely labour point of view it should mean continuity of employment for a minimum number of road workers all the year round, instead of having the casual employment that there is to-day in most counties. It would also make roadmaking machinery available without having any boundary to the area where that machinery could be used from day to day, from week to week, or from month to month.

At any rate, I cannot understand why there should be increased charges on the rates every year for road maintenance, an increase of 16 per cent. this year over the year before, when we see that there is a continuous increase in the revenue derived from motors, motor buses and lorries. There should, therefore, be more money from the Road Fund and less to be provided from the ratepayers if the Road Fund money is properly administered. At any rate, I think it is the duty of the Minister to tell us whether he has any definite opinion on this very serious matter as a result of the consideration which he must have given to it since he became Minister. The de-rating proposal is a very plausible and a very popular matter for discussion in the country. I was dragged down recently to a meeting of the County Council in one of the counties in my constituency, where a gentleman who is an ex-member of this House put forward a scheme for consideration.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Surely the Deputy is not going to discuss de-rating on this motion?

Comment on this

I did not know that it was barred from the discussion.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy knows it now.

Comment on this

Well, I will say finally, that if you want to de-rate in partial and in a practical way, the way to do it is to take the main and the trunk roads off the ratepayers and put them under a centralised authority.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think that the Deputy can find another occasion for discussing that.

Comment on this

I have got it out now. There is one other matter that I want to refer to. I am in a difficulty in making up my mind about it, because we have no book of Estimates available for our information, and in this matter the book of Estimates would be very educative. I noticed that there was an increase in item 55— the Land Commission. It is £635,981 for the coming financial year as compared with £547,376 last year. I hope that the increase under that particular Vote is for the purpose of carrying out improvement works on the many estates which are waiting to be divided and for which schemes of division are in the Land Commission offices for the past twelve months. If the increase in that particular Vote is to be provided for that particular purpose, I hope that estates where the division schemes are drawn up will be divided in the early part of the financial year and that the necessary improvement works will be carried out without any undue delay. It is work of a useful nature and would give employment in many parts of the country where it is badly needed.

I rose on this particular discussion to try and get from the President, who takes a greater interest and knows more—I pay him that compliment—about the housing needs of the country and the financing of housing in general than any other member of the Ministry, an assurance before this discussion ends that the promises, made from public platforms throughout the country, that money will be made available for the boards of health who are ready to put these schemes into operation, will be carried out without any further unnecessary delay.

Comment on this

I wish to say a few words in the first place on the question of the taking over of Irish mills by those foreign combines. There were a few remarks of the Minister for Industry and Commerce with which I do not agree. In the first place he said that the reason for refusing a tariff was that it would only give employment to a few. I would be very anxious to hear some statement from the President, who is, after all, senior member for Cork City, as to whether the City Flour Mills are to be taken over by a foreign combine or not. In my constituency we have three flour mills working at present. One of them, Messrs. Callaghan's, is giving employment to 350 people. Those people are not supporters of ours; they paid £50 into the Cumann na na nGaedheal fund at the last election and expected something in return. I do not know what promises they got. I went into the question with those people; they pointed out that they were prepared to start a factory which is at present closed in Cork City if the tariff is put on. They propose to devote £18,000 for putting in new plant and machinery. They guarantee whole-time employment for the 350 hands they have at present, and, in addition, they will take on 80 hands. It might be a very small thing for the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who announced some time ago that if those people took their mills up to Dublin or some other place some consideration would be given to them. We, however, want them where they are. The employment of 350 or 400 families might be a very small thing to him, but it means a lot to a country town where there is no industry whatsoever except flour milling.

I have seen the Order Paper week after week covered with questions from Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies even in my own constituency asking what the Minister for Industry and Commerce is to do about the flour question this week, next month and the month after. With the utmost respect I say that those Deputies got their opportunity here on the tariff question and they did not take advantage of it. They voted against the tariff. Now they are looking to know how the cure is to apply. I say it is definitely up to the Government to find a remedy.

The Minister also alluded to the amount of money laid aside under the Trade Loans Act and said that when these proposals came to be examined by business men they were turned down. I would like to know who were the business men. If the proposal was for a jam factory were the business men already in the jam business to whom this new industry would be a rival or were they business people like the manager of the Cork Steam Packet Company interested in the cross-Channel trade? Were those the men, and therefore were the proposals turned down because of that? I would like to have a certain statement from the President as to whether he will allow this flour mill in his own constituency to be closed down or allow this foreign combine to take it over altogether.

I would like to hear something from the Minister for Local Government about those loans. We have repeatedly called attention in this House to the absolutely wrong policy adopted by the Minister for Local Government on the whole question generally. For instance, on these specialised roads he gives a certain refund. If the county councils expend £80,000 on specialised roads they will get back £40,000, but if the county council expends £80,000 on what in my county we call the farmers' roads which the ratepayers use they will get back nothing at all. In other words the policy that the Minister is trying to force on the local bodies is a policy of repairing roads on which the farmers cannot travel. The Estimate for the roads in my county at present has gone up by about £5,000 this year. It is climbing up every year owing to the policy of the Minister and at the same time the farmers of the whole county are complaining that they cannot travel on the roads. Anyone who has to travel from Midleton up to Cork can see the wheel tracks along the footpaths where the farmers have to drive in in order to carry their farm produce to the market.

I would like to hear some definite statement from the Minister as to when he is going to finish with this wrong policy of holding out an inducement of a refund from the road fund to the county councils for puting up roads that they do not want, and of giving no inducement as regards roads which are absolutely necessary to the farmers. The bye-roads of Cork county are in a worse condition now than they were in 1923 owing to the policy of the Local Government Department. I think the farmers who pay the rates should be the judges of what is required.

I would like to have some statement from the Minister for Local Government and Public Health as to whether his Department or the local bodies should be the judges of what salaries should be paid to officials.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the Deputy ought to keep to the general policy and not go into details.

Comment on this

It is on the policy of the Local Government Department that I am speaking.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will get another opportunity in going into details.

Comment on this

I do not know how I am going to box them together. I wish I could. I would be anxious to hear some statement from the Minister on that question. I would like to hear something as to the policy of the Government as a whole in regard to salaries. When a local body fixes a salary for an official the Minister comes along and says it must be three times what it has been fixed at, that instead of £150 it must be £450.

Then we have the Department of Justice. I take it that the actions of the Minister for Justice have the support of the Executive Council. I regret that the Minister is not here, but he might come in to-morrow and let us know something about it. I would like to know whether the Civic Guards are amenable to the ordinary law of the land or not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I would suggest to the Deputy that it would be much more suitable to raise that on the Vote for the Department of Justice when it comes up. The Deputy will have to follow the lines laid down by the speakers who preceded him.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, the speakers up to the present, with the exception of Deputy Davin, confined themselves to one special matter, namely, the matter of foreign combines.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Davin said he was going to deal with the question of the Government policy regarding the provision of employment in the country. Deputy Corry wants to deal with particular matters which are more or less details, and they can be much more profitably dealt with on the estimate for the particular Department.

Comment on this

If I make my subject the filling of the gaols and hospitals by the Civic Guards will I be in order? I will guarantee that I will stick solely to that subject. As regards this matter, it is time that we had some pronouncement—I will not say from the Minister for Justice, because I do not think there is any member in this House, even amongst his own Party, who treats his pronouncements with any shade of consideration at all. I would like to hear some pronouncement from the President as to whether he is in favour of the present state of affairs as regards the Civic Guards. For instance, if the ordinary civilian down the country is found in what they call the illegal possession of arms he will get six months in gaol, while the ordinary Civic Guard, who admits that he has no authority to hold arms can shoot a man and is not brought to trial for even the illegal possession of arms. I would like to hear some definite statement from the President as to whether the Civic Guards are amenable to the ordinary law of the land or not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest to the Deputy for the last time that he ought to leave that over for the Vote for the Department. We are now on the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I thought we had agreed that I would confine myself to that subject.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is wrong in that.

Comment on this

I only hope that the President will give us some pronouncement on that. We will have some bit of confidence in what he says. Since the debate is to be confined to the general policy of the Government, I do not see much use in speaking, for I have long ago realised the futility of bringing forward anything here. No matter what is brought forward here, it is going to be defeated by a certain number of votes. The general policy of the Government has been the same since 1922. It is a policy which is rapidly plunging this country into bankruptcy, the policy of going abroad every year and borrowing ten millions of money while not starting any new industries. If you are always taking out of the pot and never putting back, you will soon come to the bottom. If you are always borrowing and never paying back, you will come to the point when you will get no more. If, instead of spending the money they borrow on their political hacks all over the country, the Government started some industries in the country that would give employment, we might get a little relief. I would ask them at their next Executive meeting to go back along the road and see how they stood, for instance, in 1924 or 1925 and compare it with how they stand in 1930. Let them see how many new industries have been started in the country, how much they have borrowed, and what they have done with it. After all, they will have to encounter it some day. If they go on those lines, they will find very quickly that they are travelling the wrong road. They will find that with the exception of Ford's factory in Cork there has been no industry started. I do not think that we have to thank them even for Ford's factory because it was there before them and, I hope, will be there after them. I ask the Executive Council to go back over the road and see where their present policy is leading. We know that their policy in regard to land purchase is the policy of paying landlords ten times the value of their estates and trying to extract it from the unfortunate tenants. They should make up their minds to give these landlords only their just price and send throughout the country inspectors whose minds will be concentrated more on ascertaining the value of the estates than on the interests of the people who are to get them. I respectfully submit that the policy of the Executive Council in regard to land is to buy estates at excessive value and distribute them out in such a way as Deputy Hassett told us, that persons like a district justice can get 300 acres. There are other little things

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Because they are little things they should not be brought on this Vote, and I have already told the Deputy that.

Comment on this

I have dealt with their policy in regard to land and have given them a little advice which I hope they will take. They may succeed in getting away before they are caught, but if they are caught I would not like to be in their shoes.

Comment on this

In connection with Estimate No. 43—National Health Insurance—I may mention that when the Bill was going through the House, Deputies on these benches pointed out that the transfer to the boards of health in connection with the treatment of sanatorium cases would be relieving the Central Fund of its liability and placing the expense incurred in administration and the treatment of consumptive cases on the local ratepayers. That contention has been borne out by a letter which the Wicklow Board of Health received from the Minister's Department on 13th February.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest that that is a matter of detail which can be brought up on the Estimate.

Comment on this

It has to do with the general policy of the Local Government Department.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not a matter arising out of the Vote on Account.

Comment on this

I only want to know whether it is the future policy of the Department that all cases for domiciliary treatment must, in accordance with the terms of the Minister's letter, be treated at the expense of the ratepayers. Owing to the letter which we received——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Now!

Comment on this

Very well. All I want to know is whether it is going to be the policy of the Department that such cases are to be dealt with by the home assistance officer instead of by the medical officer of health. I desire to support Deputy Davin's plea in connection with the extension of the Local Loans Fund to rural authorities for the provision of houses for agricultural labourers. In my constituency, we have schemes ready and plots marked out for the erection of 250 cottages, but we are unable, owing to the fact that the bank will only give a loan for fifteen years, to build these cottages, which would, under those conditions, become an undue burden on the ratepayers. We appeal to the Executive Council to extend the Local Loans Fund to rural authorities and boards of health, to enable them to provide houses for such a deserving class as agricultural workers. Personally, I believe it would be much better to spend money on such houses than to provide pleasure for people by spending £48,000 on a new broadcasting station and giving £3,000 to a motor club in Dublin, while people in the country are deprived of such necessaries as food and houses.

I would also like to know from the President what is the policy, if any, of the Executive Council in connection with coast erosion. I know that there is a Commission sitting to deal with that matter, but I am honestly of opinion that that Commission, like many others, has only been appointed to delay matters and to try to keep the people's minds off important matters. I notice that there is nothing in the Supplementary Estimates for grants to local authorities for that purpose. In my constituency, coast erosion is a very serious matter, because property to the value of a couple of hundred thousand pounds is in danger of being destroyed, and no provision is being made to house the people whose dwellings have been washed away. The only advice which we get is the suggestion that the local authorities should provide for these people and spend £50,000 or £60,000 out of the rates in preventing inroads of the sea. I have come to the conclusion that it is not the Government's intention, no matter what recommendations may be made by the Commission, to deal seriously with the matter. I would like to have a statement on the subject from some member of the Executive Council in order that public bodies will know where they stand. Public bodies are expecting to receive some grants from the Government, but nothing has so far been done. The Government should display some real interest in the matter by giving grants towards the prevention of coast erosion, as public bodies, who already have to bear heavy responsibilities, are unable to deal with the problem, which is really a national one and which should be dealt with as such. I hope that it is not the policy of the Parliamentary Secretary for Posts and Telegraphs to give contracts without advertisements being duly published in the Press.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a matter for the Estimate. It is a minor matter.

Comment on this

I hope that it is not going to be the policy of the Department for Posts and Telegraphs——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy can ask that question when the Estimate comes up.

Comment on this

They have already given contracts for the carrying of mails.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not in order.

Comment on this

It is an important matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not questioning its importance, but it is not in order and therefore the Deputy cannot say anything more about it.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding the fact that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has a Supplementary Estimate in?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

No, it is not an Estimate.

Comment on this

It is a Vote on Account.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Yes.

Comment on this

It means payment to people who received contracts from the Parliamentary Secretary without the insertion of advertisements.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must accept my ruling. I have given the Deputy a good deal of liberty already.

Comment on this

Would An Leas-Cheann Comhairle tell us what we can discuss on a Vote such as this, as we want to know where we are?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy had been listening to some of his colleagues during the day he would have no necessity to ask me that question, because his colleagues would have demonstrated very well to him what he could discuss.

Comment on this

It was pointed out that one definite thing should be taken first and thrashed out, namely, the question of the combine in the flour industry. Until I stood up, so far as I could see, that was the only matter dealt with from those benches. Deputy Davin dealt with general policy, but he did not, of course, go into each item. He dealt with general policy as it affected unemployment. I would like to know what we can discuss on this Vote.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It may be no harm to say now that it has been urged before the Committee on Procedure and Privileges, which is constituted of representatives of different parties, that the only way in which any benefit could be got out of a debate on a Vote on Account would be to take one or two matters of general importance and discuss them. It would be obviously impossible, if you could take up each item and discuss it, to get any discussion or any reply, because the Minister for Finance, or whoever would be responsible for replying, could not reply to all the points raised. It was suggested to-day that a matter of general importance to the House should be taken up and discussed and, when the discussion on it was finished, that one other matter of general importance should be taken up and discussed. Deputies, however, cannot discuss every item which appears on this Vote.

Comment on this

I want to find out definitely what was the other matter of general importance which was decided upon.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It was not decided upon.

Comment on this

We may have different views as to what a matter of general importance would be. For instance, I think that the filling of jails and hospitals by Civic Guards is a matter of prime importance.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy mentioned that fact at several points in his own speech.

Comment on this

Am I to understand from the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs that there will be no departure——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has been told twice already that he is not allowed to make that point.

Comment on this

There has been a departure in making contracts, and I only want a guarantee from the Minister or the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have given my ruling. The Deputy will have to discontinue his speech Deputy Hogan.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. P. Hogan (An Clar) Labour Party

If the Minister for Local Government and Public Health is not going to conclude the debate, I will await his speech.

Comment on this

I am not concluding the debate.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Then I am prepared to await the Minister's speech.

Comment on this

On the question of the provision of greater financial assistance for the building of labourers' cottages——

Comment on this

I do not want to be caught out by the Minister for Local Government. He might follow the example of the Minister who sits on his right and we might have the discourtesy repeated of a Minister walking out of the House without answering questions. A number of questions have been asked from these and other benches and I want to be assured that the Minister is not now replying. Will he wait until some other questions are asked, because I want to ask a few other questions?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the Deputy may take it that asking questions would not be in order. The Minister for Local Government is now merely intervening in the debate to make his own speech. The Minister for Finance is responsible for the Vote on Account and he will reply.

Comment on this

I am only intervening at this stage at the invitation of one of Deputy Anthony's own colleagues.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. P. Hogan (An Clar) Labour Party

We are very anxious to hear you.

Comment on this

On the question of greater financial provisions for the building of labourers' cottages in the country, local bodies who build labourers' cottages can get at present a grant of £50 in respect of each cottage but they will have to make their financial arrangements with their own banks. In so far as the Local Loans Fund is open for the purposes of housing, it is open only to urban authorities and the size of the problem that exists in urban areas at the moment is such as to prevent the Government opening local loans at the present moment to other than urban authorities. We realise the difficulty in which rural bodies are placed in this matter at present but we have also to take the fact into account that two-thirds of the houses built by private persons with the aid of State grants under the Housing Acts, have been built in rural areas. One of the astounding facts is, if you take the year ended March, 1928—I had no opportunity of looking up the statistics in the Department but I take this from a return circulated in the Official Reports—is that whereas in Mayo 911 houses were built in rural areas with the assistance of Government grants, in Leix only 47 were built. It is very difficult to understand how private persons in Mayo can build 911 houses whereas in a much wealthier county like Leix only 47 have been built. The rural dwellers in Leix are apparently waiting for more Government assistance than the people in Mayo require to build houses.

If there is a real necessity for the erection of a larger number of labourers' cottages throughout the country, I would suggest that there are certain factors which would help the Government in coming to a decision to give improved financial assistance. The first of these is a realisation that the boards of health are going to collect the rents. A question was asked recently by a Deputy from Kerry as to the sum supposed to be outstanding to the British Government in respect of the rents of labourers' cottages. The amount outstanding in rents in respect of labourers' cottages in Kerry represents 2½ years' rental at present. If we could understand from boards of health that they were going to collect the rents, that would be something to help us. If we could understand from local authorities that their attitude to the collection of rents and rates was going to be that they would collect the rents as well as the rates, we would know where we were. In spite of the fact that the rents of these cottages are as low as 1/- and 1/3 per week in some cases, and the fact that the Rates on Small Dwellings Act was introduced to help poor people to pay their rates in weekly instalments with their rents, the very fact that these rates were added to the rents of labourers' cottages throughout the country was made in many cases an excuse for a strike against the rates and rents. The attitude taken up by many local bodies in the country in this regard was not the attitude that one would expect from them. People were practically encouraged by many members of local bodies to pay no rents or rates. Can we expect an assurance from the local bodies that they are going to collect these rents and rates?

Comment on this

Some of them are collecting them. They are collecting them in Carlow.

Comment on this

There are some counties certainly collecting them, but there are other counties which are the spearhead of the whole position and they have invited neighbouring counties to join in this movement against the payment of rents and rates, which could not be tolerated even in any one county. The position I speak of exists in more than one county. I think Deputies will understand. In the second case, we would like to have an assurance, which would help the Government in dealing with the matter, that local bodies would attend to the repair and upkeep of cottages that are their property.

There is another thing that I think would help us and that is a realisation that you cannot build at the rates for which money can at the present moment be got and let houses at the same rents that you could let them at when you got money for 68½ years at 3¼ per cent. which, with a reduction, practically amounted to 2.1 per cent. It is well that Deputies should be clear upon that matter. It would help us if people in rural districts, local bodies, realised that you cannot charge 6/6 for rent and rates in a town like Wexford and build the same sort of house or something like it and give a quarter of an acre of land with it and rent that house, which would be situated one and a half or two miles outside Wexford, for 1/3 a week. If the rent to be paid for labourers' cottages in the country was brought as close to the economic rent as the rent that is paid in an urban district for a workman's cottage, then we would be nearer the time when greater facilities could be given. Within the last six months there have been upwards of 100 labourers' cottages built in three parts of the country under the present Act. But our urban problem stands in the way immediately, and even if money were available there are certain aspects, such as the noncollection of rents, the non-repair of houses, and the non-acceptance of the fact that you cannot rent labourers' cottages to-day at the figure of 1/3 or the figure of 1/6.

Comment on this

Will the Minister inform us what he thinks would be an economic rent for a labourer earning nine shillings a week and having to support a wife and children?

Comment on this
Henry Broderick Mr. H. Broderick Labour Party

No rent.

Comment on this

The idea as to what the rent should be should come from below. There is no use in talking of labourers getting nine shillings a week. I do not know the county in which they get 9/- a week.

Comment on this

There are others who do know.

Comment on this

I am saying what I think it is right and useful to say in regard to this particular matter. I take it Deputies are prepared to accept that we are anxious to help in this matter. On the question of roads, and the policy with regard to roads raised by Deputy Davin, the Executive Council's policy at the present time, March 1930, is just what it was when the matter was discussed on any of the Estimates that I spoke on as Minister for Local Government. We are taking the Road Fund and dividing it amongst the local authorities, and we are letting the local authorities spend it. We are paying half the cost of maintenance of the trunk and link roads. We are utilising whatever can be then reasonably expended, out of what is left from the income of the Road Fund, on improvement work. We are spending it through the local bodies; but we are endeavouring, while spending it through the local bodies on improvement works, to see that it works out as the building up of a continuous scheme of good trunk and link roads throughout the country generally. There is no change in the policy that was expounded before. In so far as Deputies say that farmers have no use for the new roads, I think it was in Deputy Corry's own county a day or two ago it was explained that the work done on the roads in Cork had reduced the road traffic charges to the farmers by 50 per cent.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister where he got that statement?

Comment on this

The Cork Co. Council meeting.

Comment on this

I very much doubt it. I will make the Minister come down to look over those roads.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. Hogan (Clare) Labour Party

It should not be let pass unchallenged that there is any general attitude in the country against the payment of cottage rents. There is no organised attempt on the part of cottage holders or public bodies to withhold or obstruct the collection of cottage rents. What did happen in the matter of cottage rents is what happened in the matter of a great many other things. Take, for instance, the land annuities. During the years that have passed everybody knows what the effect was in the country. Certain amounts of money accrued that should have been paid and that were not paid. Certain farmers did not pay their annuities regularly. But the Minister for Finance does not suggest that you should withhold the agricultural grant from the farmers for the relief of rates because of that. You are giving them facilities to pay their rents easily, and that position is quite justifiable. The tenants of the labourers' cottages are just as willing and anxious to pay their rents as well as they can, consistent with their position and taking into account the amount of unemployment there is, and they are quite willing and anxious to clear off whatever debts are due to public bodies. I do not think the Minister for Local Government can put it forward as an argument that that is the reason why the money is held up and that long term loans are not given.

Comment on this

I did not give it as a reason.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am glad the Minister did not give it as a reason and therefore we need not dwell upon it.

Comment on this

The main thing is the amount of money required for urban districts. If there was an improvement in these other districts it would help us, with an easier conscience, to face the question of providing additional facilities for rural housing.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

In the county that I am concerned with, the county I have immediate experience of, I know that the cottiers are paying up as well as they are able to and they are not organised in any way to oppose the payment of rents. They have not been advised by any public representative not to pay their rents. They are anxious to pay them and they have repeatedly suggested there should be some facilities afforded them to clear off arrears. In the matter of roads I do not think the Minister was sufficiently explicit. I think what Deputy Davin wanted to know was about roads that are a national facility. His point was that there should be so much of them maintained as a local charge. We all know that there are roads which the Government consider national and not local facilities. They are not to a great extent local facilities. I know roads that should be maintained and I know it is very necessary for strangers coming into a county to have good roads. There are links between the larger centres and the smaller centres and I know that these links should be maintained in good order. But these roads are not the roads used generally by the farmers who contribute a good deal towards their upkeep. The roads used very often by the farmers are the roads that are getting very little assistance and that is what Deputy Davin wanted information about. He wanted to know if there was any intention on the part of the Government to take these roads under national control and make them a national charge, so that the county or district roads that the farmers use considerably could be maintained and kept in a proper condition for the farmer who would be bringing his turf, potatoes or oats over them.

The question of long term loans has been adequately dealt with, but the Minister has not told us very much about them. I think there was a good deal of reason for the getting of long term loans, but the Minister has not given us much information. Has he ever considered whether some of the money lying idle under the National Health Insurance Act could be utilised for the building of houses? Some £300,000 or £400,000 have been accumulated and invested. That could be converted into trustee stock just as well as into the stock in which it is now invested.

I do know that some of that stock was bought before the National Health Commissioners were under the direct supervision of the Minister for Local Government or the Minister for Finance, and I recognise that probably if he threw some of that stock into the market it would not realise as much as we would like. But I think there ought be some consideration given to the point that there are £300,000 or £400,000 in that fund and that half of that should be used for building houses, houses of the type of labourers' cottages and such things.

Nobody has said anything from the Ministerial Benches about coast erosion. I am anxious that something should be said by the Executive Council on this matter. I do know one district in the County Clare that is nearly wiped out altogether. It has been suggested seriously to us in the County Clare that we should shift one town altogether. I know the place thoroughly, and lately a man of 60 or 70 years of age told me that he remembers when the promenade at Lahinch was ten or twenty yards farther out than it is now. I do not know what Deputy Lemass finds funny in that statement. It is no fun for us in County Clare. The sea is eating in there, and at present it is easier to move Lahinch than to keep out the sea. Unless something is done at once the place will disappear and this whole health resort and attraction for tourists will be wiped out. I think that somebody ought to make an effort to tell us whether the Government has any policy on that matter of coast erosion. I do not think that the Coast Erosion Commission will give much satisfaction. I think that is a problem that is much too big for an inter-departmental Commission to deal with.

Comment on this

The advantage of this debate is that one can discuss the policy of the Government on it and get into two or three Departments at the same time and deal with a large subject. It was mentioned here that there was a difficulty in collecting the rents of labourers' cottages, although the rents are only 1/3 a week. Apparently the Minister was surprised, and he seemed to think that it was due to something else besides incapacity to pay those rents.

When he was faced with the wages paid to agricultural labourers in the country—sometimes 9/- a week—he could not state how much the man who was getting 9/- a week is able to pay as a weekly rent. That was because the Minister had in his mind what the cost of building was. Naturally there was a great gap between the two. Looking at this from the point of view of the larger policy, or the lack of policy, on the part of the Government, we see that what is really the matter is the fall in the purchasing power of the ordinary worker in Ireland. That is at the root of the trouble. Men would have no hesitation or difficulty in paying 1/3d. a week rent if they were in a position to pay it. But because wages they are paid are so low they find difficulty in paying this small weekly rent. I do not know if a wage of 9/- a week is typical of the whole country. Certainly in some parts of the country 12/- a week is about the average wage of the agricultural labourer. The reason he is paid so low a wage as 12/- is because the farmer who employs him cannot pay him any more.

That brings us up to the matter which is now very much in the minds of the people, and that is that there is a real neglect on the part of the Government in making an effort to raise the purchasing power of the people. I think it is fair to say that the attitude of the Ministry to-day is a passive attitude, one of watching but not an attitude where they are going to take any risks with new enterprises or doing anything to encourage new enterprises. Whether that is due to the fact that there is ill-will amongst a certain section of permanent officials and experts I cannot say. Without specifying individuals or going into charges against individuals, I feel that it is one's duty to mention in the House what one hears on all hands and that is that there is a deliberate effort on the part of certain people to prevent Irish enterprise from going ahead. A person cannot put his hand upon the influences but it is mystifying to find that when people are trying to push ahead with enterprise they seem to be met on all sides with an attitude which is so conservative as to be timid to the extent of paralysing the activities of the nation. Either that or on the other hand it is an attitude which is a sort of malicious complex. There is undoubtedly a very strong turning of the tide of opinion in the country. People feel that they are not being properly treated by the present Government. What they feel most is that the source of wealth in the country is being exhausted. This registers itself in the fact that there is a lowering of the purchasing power of the people. There was a time when shopkeepers and professional people did not feel that so much. But now no matter where shopkeepers buy their goods, either here or in England, they feel that their market is the most important thing and that that market is failing because the people cannot buy the goods which they have to sell. They rather blame the Government for their lack of initiative in helping forward enterprise in the country.

To come down to my own constituency of Waterford, I wish to say that some little time ago I suggested publicly that the businessmen of Waterford who had held a small exhibition there of Irish goods ought try to do something to build up industries in that city in order to give work to the unemployed. No reply came from those people. I had mentioned that they were opposed to us in their policy; that they were in favour of free trade and of conditions as they are, and that, therefore, it fell upon their shoulders and it was their duty to show that the present system was a good system—not by argument but by actually doing something for the relief of the unemployed by the building up of industries. The only reply I got to that was a pathetic retort that they were so occupied in trying to pay their employees' wages that they could not think of anything else. You have the business people on the one hand holding down to their old antiquated ideas of free trade and seeing the market slipping away from them and the purchasing power of the people dwindling. The consequence is that they are beginning to suffer, and yet they cannot do anything. On the other hand you have the Government taking up a purely passive attitude and doing nothing to encourage industry. Between them the country goes on drifting from bad to worse. Remedies have already been suggested. I am not going to repeat what has been said already, but there are plenty of examples to be followed in other countries. To these examples the Government might look if they wanted to see how the system could be changed, how good work could be done in a solid way, in a way in which the elements of risk would be reduced to a minimum and yet progress could be made in a fairly rapid way for the benefit of the people in particular. The Government might look into the method in which Germany a generation or two ago built itself up from being a poor country to becoming a rich country industrially.

Between the Government and those enterprising persons and the banks a system was established by which those industries were encouraged. We have a younger generation in this country of able and expert engineers and scientists coming along. They are at your command to make use of them if you wish. If they have not got experience, they have energy and hope. If the Government were to take a firm hand with these financial interests, so conservative, so stick-in-the-mud, and would learn from what is done in Germany and bring together the enterprise, energy and ability of these young men, together with the financial resources which are at the disposal of the banks, they could do something to end this decay which is going on in the country.

There is one matter I should like to ask the Minister about, and that is, how housing is progressing; whether there is a feeling that it is not moving forward rapidly enough and that more should be done for housing. I do not wish to indulge in criticism when the particular Minister concerned is absent, but I should like to draw the Government's attention, and the President's attention particularly, to the treatment of prisoners.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a matter that really must not be raised.

Comment on this

I do not propose to enter into criticism, but only to draw the President's attention to it to give him an opportunity of changing his policy.

Comment on this

I recognise that we shall have a later opportunity, on the consideration of the Estimates, to go into many of these matters in more detail. I believe that to address oneself to each of these items seriatim would be more in the nature of useless obstruction than an attempt to do any real business. I shall, therefore, confine myself to asking one or two questions and passing one or two comments.

I regret that the Government on the occasion in the Dáil this Session when an attempt was made by some of us, in view of the contemplated rationalisation of industries across the Channel—a policy that was well-advertised in the British Press—did not display a little more commonsense, not to say prudence, in supporting the resolution for a tariff on flour. I am concerned for the moment with my own constituency whilst at the same time being broadminded enough to have consideration for other places of relative, but perhaps of minor importance, such as the City of Dublin. I regret the want of sound economic policy on the part of the Government, having particular regard to the flour industry. I am personally acquainted with the affairs of two very important mills in Cork which would be affected by the rationalisation scheme which is contemplated. I think the scheme has gone something further in the realm of practical politics than the mere contemplation of such a step, because the Minister for Industry and Commerce, within the last couple of weeks, in answer to a question raised here, said that certain steps would be taken as a last resort if this key industry is very seriously threatened.

I shall have something to say at a later stage when the Estimates come up on the question of old age pensions, and also on the Civil Service Commission in connection with the mode of recruitment of certain civil servants, without having regard to some persons who have been engaged in certain branches of the Civil Service in a temporary capacity, notably the case of——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy said he was not going into details.

Comment on this

This is merely a summary.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the Deputy had better wait for the Estimates.

Comment on this

I have suggested that myself.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a very good suggestion, if the Deputy would only keep to it.

Comment on this

I shall confine myself to one or two items with a view to getting something in the nature of an outline of policy from the Ministers concerned. I have no objection, for instance, to a certain grant under the general heading of education, but I say that there is a want of proportion shown here, and certainly a lack of understanding or appreciation of the needs of the country. We have here a sum of £77,000 allocated in this Vote on Account to universities and colleges; we have a sum of only £40,000 for technical instruction. I submit that in a country which is mainly agricultural, and which requires so much industrial development, necessitating industrial or technical training, these figures should teach us a very important lesson. We might easily ask the question quo vadis? as far as this whole question of education is concerned. We should have some regard to maintaining a proper balance. I have due regard for education on cultural lines. I want to see the highest form of all branches of education developed, but I repeat that this Vote shows a want of balance and of understanding of the realities of the position in the country. We have our universities and colleges turning out many people who can find no employment in the country. We are subsidising these universities and I want to know for what. Many of those going through our universities to-day will not be able to find employment in this country. Instead of giving these young people, who will eventually find their way into other avenues of industry, a proper technical education, we are simply throwing money away by endowing universities. I have a concrete example to give. The city which I represent, and which the President shares with me the honour of representing, has one of the most wonderful industrial concerns in the world. From day to day application is made to that firm for employment by graduates from our universities. A course of Classics is very useful; a course in any branch of education, and particularly higher education, is very useful. I am not speaking against the further development of that kind of education. Rather is it my purpose to show that we are spending too much on the university side, and too little on the technical side.

I ask the House would it not be far better to develop along the lines I have suggested educationally rather than to be turning out B.A.s and M.A.s, and all the rest of it, who will have to emigrate, handicapped in many ways, and will have to take up teaching in other countries. Would it not be far better to educate them, as I suggest, by giving them technical training. I am not at all satisfied with the amount allotted for that purpose, and I do not anticipate that even in the Estimates there will be any great increase in the sum for technical education. There are a great many items in this Vote on Account with which I thoroughly agree and on which money will be very usefully spent. I cannot join in the suggestion that the amount provided in Vote 32 for the Gárda Síochána is anything but well spent money.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We are not going to debate that now.

Comment on this

I know. I want to touch on one or two items, but only one or two. Like Tennyson's brook, I should go on for ever if I were to deal with the whole list of Votes. As I said, we will have an opportunity of discussing these in detail later. With regard to one of these Votes, there is, at the moment, an inquiry proceeding whether a lot of gentlemen who, apparently, have a very soft and easy time, are going out under Clause 10 of the Treaty.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should not discuss that Estimate.

Comment on this

What I am anxious to get from the Minister is an indication of policy in that direction. How many of these gentlemen does the Ministry intend to turn adrift, and how long are they going to continue to acquiesce in this policy. I know there are certain statutory obligations on the Departments and the Government as a whole under that clause, and I think we should have some kind of declaration from the Minister for Finance, or other appropriate Minister, as to what the policy of the Government is with regard to those persons who find it fairly profitable, having enjoyed a Civil Service position for a number of years, to get out of the Service on the most favourable conditions possible, just because they think that this country and its institutions and its people are not as stable as other countries. I would like to have some indication of the Government's policy in this particular regard. Amongst the number of those people we find many of them with sufficient leisure, at any rate, to qualify for professions. It may be asked how can the country which, after all, is not a very poor country, afford to let loose a number of people under Clause 10 to swell the already swollen unemployed market while they are being subsidised by the State to enter into competition with unemployed people outside?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest the Deputy should not have raised this matter at all; but, having raised it, he should leave it there. The Deputy is aware there is a tribunal sitting, dealing with these cases, and I think it is very undesirable that any case that is before a tribunal should be dealt with in this House.

Comment on this

I submit to your ruling, sir. If I thought it was not correct to have raised this question, I would not have done so. I am only sorry that the tribunal has not concluded; if it had I should have had a great deal more to say. However, I want to say that, so far as this Vote on Account is concerned, on the whole it has a lot to commend it. I anticipate that in some Departments, particularly the Local Government Department, we will have increases in the Estimates under various heads, and, notably, under the heads of certain social services. I should like to see, when the Minister for Finance comes to issue the Estimates for the year, increases under the heads dealing with social services. I have little more to add at present on this Vote on Account, but I hope to be in a position to return to the matter on a future occasion.

Comment on this

I listened to the Minister for Local Government a while ago when he mentioned about the rents of labourers' cottages and the effect the non-payment of rents would have on the building of more cottages. I am a member of two boards of health in Cork, and the rents of the cottages under our control are paid up regularly. I believe that is because we keep these cottages in a good state of repair. For that reason, in our district at least where we manage affairs well, there is no rent owing. We have a new scheme of cottages on foot at the moment, and I hope we will get the necessary encouragement from the Minister for Local Government.

I heard it mentioned by Deputy Hogan that we have a big surplus in the Insurance Societies Fund— £300,000 or £400,000. It was the original intention that some of this money should be devoted to the building of labourers' cottages, especially for subscribers who were insured persons. Now there is to be an amalgamation of those Insurance Societies, and that is creating dissatisfaction throughout the country, inasmuch as a great number of domiciliary patients will have to go to the Home Assistance people for outdoor relief instead of getting domiciliary treatment which they got all along. It is well to get relief, any way, whether through the Relieving Officer or anyone else, because there is a lot of people in this country, nearly the whole of us, in want of outdoor relief at the moment. I suggest that as well as some of this money being devoted to the building of cottages some of it should be put to the benefit of the ratepayers and that certain grants necessary for domiciliary treatment should go to the insured persons entitled to it, instead of putting a burden on the ratepayers who are at present paying for it. They can take it and say to themselves afterwards "we are taking it because we have paid for it and we do not care a twopenny ticket from whom we get it." I would impress on the Government that a slice of this money should be taken out of the funds that are lying idle, invested in some way, and a certain amount of it handed over annually to the home assistance department. I hope that the Minister for Local Government will be able to do something in the way of sanctioning a scheme for the erection of cottages for those in need of them, that he will do that, even though some of the cottage tenants are stated to be bad payers. I hope that in giving his sanction to such schemes preference will be given to those districts where the present tenants are prompt in paying their rents. One of the reasons given against the erection of more cottages was that the present tenants do not pay their rent. The people in my district pay their rents and rates, and I hope that when the Minister comes forward with his scheme for the erection of more cottages no obstacle will be put in the way for carrying it into effect.

Comment on this

I did not hear the statement of the Minister on the question of cottages and the proposed new housing scheme. I hope, when the Minister starts his housing scheme, that he will be able to get money as cheaply for it as it was got for the erection of houses under some of the old schemes. If he is able to do that, then I hope it will be possible to fix the rents of the new cottages as low as the rents charged for the old ones. I take it that, on the Vote for the Department of Local Government, we can go into more detail on this question of rural housing.

There seems to be a great regret amongst certain Deputies with regard to the amalgamations that have been carried out amongst a number of insurance societies. From my knowledge of these societies the more quickly amalgamations are brought about the better. There is no term too strong to use about these people who are regular blood-suckers. They simply exist on the labouring man. The multiplicity of these societies and officials, who apparently tap Deputies in this House to cry about their interests and not the interests of the workers——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not know whether the Deputy was present or not when this matter was first referred to, but the only way in which the question of insurance societies came into the discussion was this: that the suggestion was made that the surplus funds of these societies, which are invested, should be used for the building of houses.

Comment on this

I see a sum here of £102,000 for National Health Insurance. I take it that deals with compensation arising out of amalgamation?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

No.

Comment on this

I take it that, on such a Vote as this, we can discuss each particular social service arising on the Vote?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Not on this.

Comment on this

I would like to know then, what we can discuss?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The general policy of the Government.

Comment on this

And part of the general policy of the Government is the amalgamation of insurance societies.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There is no question before the House of the amalgamation of insurance societies.

Comment on this

Was there not a Bill passed in the last session dealing with this particular subject?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

No.

Comment on this

I suppose, then, that I must submit to your ruling under protest. I heard the Minister for Industry and Commerce deal with the general question of insurance. One of the things he said, in answer to the arguments from these benches about the necessity for protecting Irish insurance, was that he was met by the demand from the existing Irish insurance societies that there should be a limitation on the number of Irish enterprises. I think it was quite a legitimate demand. We found, in the revival of Irish insurance, that there were too many insurance societies springing up here. Their doing so endangered the existence of one another, because with partition and a dwindling population the field of activity for insurance societies in this State is very limited. I think that, with a population of less than three million there should be a curtailment in the number of insurance societies, that is if Irish insurance societies are to be able to exist and to compete with the foreign insurance societies in the country.

As regards the efficiency of these insurance societies, the Minister for Finance, when issuing his last national loan, paid the greatest tribute that any Government could pay to them. What the Minister for Finance said on that occasion should help to remove from the mind of the Minister for Industry and Commerce any doubts that he may have as to the efficiency of these Irish insurance societies. Another striking tribute to their efficiency is the large assets they have been able to build up during the few years of their existence. Therefore, I say the question of their efficiency in the matter of protecting them does not arise at all. The fact that these Irish insurance societies were able to wallop such large corporations as the Prudential and the Pearl is certainly a great tribute to them and one of the reasons why an Irish Government should extend protection to them.

I notice, in the Vote on Account, that provision is being made for a sum of £40,000 for forestry. On this I desire to draw the attention of the Minister for Agriculture to the wholesale destruction of woods that is going on. I believe an order has been made with the object of putting the Forestry Act into force soon, but still it is no harm to stress this matter. I was at a meeting of the Westmeath County Council a few days ago, when a grant was made for tourist development.

[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]

On the same evening I saw employés of a North of Ireland firm going into woods at Lough Derravaragh and Lough Lene and cutting down the trees in them. There is not much use in giving money for tourist development purposes if the destruction of woods, which add to the scenic attractions of a district, is allowed to be carried on in that way. That destruction could not have gone on if the Department had asserted itself. The sooner the Minister does something to put a stop to the vandalism that is going on in that direction the better. The sooner, too, that he makes the Civic Guards enforce the powers given under the Act that was passed dealing with forestry the better. I remember that on the debates that we had on that Bill the Minister said he could not expect the Civic Guards to go out and watch every whin bush that might be cut down. On that I wish to say that I think the Civic Guards have a wide field for activity in stopping the wholesale destruction that is going on so far as the cutting down of trees in the Free State is concerned. The Forestry Act is one that should be strictly enforced.

As regards the question of housing, the census returns in the Free State show a very lamentable state of things, and the sooner it is remedied the better. The Ministry should endeavour to get, I repeat, the cheapest possible credit and the longest term credit for house building schemes. As to industrial enterprise, I would like to say that there can be no progress here until there is a proper national system of cheap credit. We should not continue to be the dearest country in Europe as far as credit is concerned. I notice by this evening's newspaper that the Bank of England rate is down to 4 per cent. It is a good sign that people are beginning to take an interest in the question of the bank rate, as it has a bearing on the economic life of the country. We have been told repeatedly that the English bank rate is for the very finest paper, and that the Irish bank rate is 1 per cent. higher. Business people who require an overdraft realise that the rate of interest charged by the banks is one and a half per cent. higher than the published Irish rate. That is a thing the Minister for Finance should look into. These institutions have in themselves the power of crippling all Irish enterprise. Taking the bank returns for the nine weeks ended on Saturday, we find that clearances for the period are down by £1,637,000 as compared with the corresponding nine weeks of last year, that is, the trade of the Free State is down by over £1,500,000 as compared with 1929, and by £3,000,000 as compared with 1928. If in nine weeks of this year things are one-third worse than last year, and last year was one of the worst years since the war, surely that is a matter for thought by any Ministry that wants to see progress in the Free State. The legislation we pass here and the sums we vote for improvement are rendered of no avail by these people curtailing the clearances, and the turnover of trade in the 26 counties. The bringing down of bank clearances is an effective weapon for paralysing trade, and it should be looked into by the Government if it has the interest of the Free State at heart.

Comment on this

I would like to support the Deputies who dealt with housing. In Carlow there is a scheme in progress for the building of 25 cottages, and the same difficulty is experienced there as in the rest of the country regarding a long term loan. Nobody in Carlow has advocated that the tenants of cottages should not pay rents or rates, and I believe that it can compare with any county in its up-to-dateness in the payment of rent and rates. In Carlow also houses are kept in a decent condition. There is one matter in particular to which I wish to draw attention, and that is the question of unemployment. From 1903 to 1927 we used to vote sums for the relief of distress. In my opinion, at no time in the history of the country was a vote of this sort more necessary than at the moment. We have thousands of people unemployed all over the country. Unemployment is due largely to the complete disarrangement of social conditions as a natural sequel to national waste. I have seen in this evening's paper that there has been an attempt to solve the unemployment problem with batons. If the country had the facilities for getting near to Leinster House, we should have thousands of them coming here. In my opinion we have been endeavouring to lock the door to progress in this country with the wrong key.

Speaking as a Deputy from a rural part of Ireland, I believe there never was a serious attempt to solve the unemployment problem. I believe most of the unemployment in the city of Dublin and in the towns is due to people flying from the rural parts into the urban centres. There is no employment in rural Ireland, because agricultural industry is being neglected to such an extent that it has become a source of weakness instead of strength to the nation. The neglect of agriculture leads to poverty and creates a pestilential mass of pauperism. We cannot have prosperity if we have not the people on the land, and we have only 160 people in the country to the square mile. Unless we develop highly and cultivate all the land capable of cultivation and produce the maximum of our requirements, not alone in quantity but in quality, this country will go down. Germany and other countries have seen that, although manufacturing industry is essential, agricultural industry is of even greater importance. These countries have developed their agricultural industry. Of course, the Minister for Agriculture will tell us that most of these countries are highly industrialised.

I move to report progress.

Comment on this