We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the President of the Executive Council.

Contributions 108–241 of 241. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The advantages are that 16,000 vacancies annually have been filled over the past six years from the people who notified themselves to the Exchanges. That is, at least, an incentive to register. If a man is unemployed and will not take the trouble to get a scrap of paper and, without even the cost of a postage stamp, send forward his name to the office, then I say the pressure of unemployment is not so severe on that person that he should really be considered here at all. What other system is there for getting these men to register if that is not good enough? Are we to have people going round and collecting names? Are we to send round inquirers, or are we to have a weekly or monthly statement furnished by the police as to conditions in their areas when all that is required is that an individual shall get a piece of paper, write his name upon it and send it to the office, without even putting a stamp on the envelope? If a man does not take that amount of trouble to register as unemployed, his case is hardly worth consideration.

Comment on this

Could the Minister give any figure which would indicate the number of vacancies filled other than through employment exchanges?

Comment on this

I have no record of that.

Comment on this

Would the number of new insurance cards issued serve for comparison purposes?

Comment on this

I might get a comparison of that sort made, but it has not been made. There are less than 20,000 people who take the trouble to get a scrap of paper and, without expense to themselves, drop it into a pillar-box for transmission to the office, notwithstanding that it has been bruited through the country for some years past that so many notified vacancies are filled each year through the medium of the exchanges. Is that a good system or is it not? Is it a system that will get recorded those upon whom unemployment really presses? And if it is not a system that will effect that, let us have some suggestion as to the system that will.

Comment on this

Is it not the case that most of the vacancies filled are those for skilled labourers, and that unskilled labourers derive very little advantage from registration?

Comment on this

That is not the fact. That is a simple answer to a simple question. If I am asked to do so, I will have a segregation of those figures made, but what the Deputy suggests is not the fact. That figure is, at any rate, some indication of the extent of the problem. I say no more of it than this: taking the limitations—I am cutting out of my calculations agriculturally-employed people who have never been in insurable occupation; that means people so completely tied up in agricultural occupations that they have never even worked on a road scheme in the last two or three years—so far as people ever were in insurable occupations, the register is substantially accurate in respect of those on whom unemployment presses to the point that they will take the trouble to get their names recorded in the way I suggested.

We have heard here Deputy Cooney and other Deputies talk about free trade. Where is there free trade in this country? When that phrase is used there is no sense of proportion. I have given a calculation over and over again, and I have given some of the details on which the calculation is founded. I know it is an arbitrary distinction in some ways. But the figures should be taken and argued about. I took the list of goods coming into this country in the year 1925. I divided those goods into two classes—goods that could be tariffed and goods that could not be tariffed. My calculation was that 50 per cent. of the tariffable imports had been tariffed. On my calculation 50 per cent. of the goods that could be tariffed were tariffed in two years. And yet we are a free trade country! Deputy Lemass said that he drove us to that. Deputy de Valera said, somewhere down the country during the weekend, that Fianna Fáil had driven us to this limited scheme of protection. These tariffs were imposed in 1924 and 1925 when Fianna Fáil were blathering in the wilderness about oaths. They did not know what was going on here with regard to economies. They were more concerned about the nonsense described in the two documents, (A) and (B), which were published recently on demand from the other side.

Comment on this

It seems to worry you.

Comment on this

They were more concerned as to whether the President of the Republic, being a barrister, could practise under what he called English law, and whether according to English law the Republic was existent or non-existent, and nonsense of that kind, than they were about economics. That is what Deputies were doing in 1924 and 1925. This House was then imposing tariffs on 50 per cent. of the tariffable imports.

Comment on this

Do not forget about the petrol tins.

Comment on this

What was the result of tariffing 50 per cent. of our imports? About 15,000 people put directly into employment. That 15,000 is really an illusory figure, because it is a 15,000 figure when one scales down part-time employment to conditions of full-time employment.

That 15,000 is a record of 15,000 people engaged full-time in occupations at the moment. There are probably 20,000 people brought into work through the tariffs, but sealing all that down, three-quarters time work and half-time work, to the sort of economic figure here, where the man is engaged full-time the whole year round, fifteen thousand people are put into occupations directly through tariffs. The figure of those indirectly concerned is a little bit more conjectural. In the beginning when factories were being built we had machinery and plant brought in and there was widespread subsidiary employment in the way of the building trades. Probably the indirect figure might rise to 5,000. At the moment put it as low as 3,000. There are 18,000 people on the unemployment list. Of the insurable occupations, that is, people who take the trouble to write their names on a sheet of paper and post it to the office, there are 20,000. There are 18,000 at the moment. You might say if the 50 per cent. tariffable imports had not been tariffed that figure would have been double what it is at the moment. Yet this is a free trade country and people talk in terms of free trade and what Fianna Fáil might have done in the years 1924 and 1925. I am going to leave out of my calculations in this debate altogether such things as the amalgamation of the railway system, a very big move that was beneficial to trade and industry in this country. I am going to leave out of my calculations at the moment the Shannon scheme and all the attendant benefits that scheme has brought and is going to bring, and all the bigger and more spectacular things, so that we can concentrate on employment that is being given to industries that once were alive and prosperous and how that employment is being increased and new employment is being given through the simple machinery of attending to the industries and making suggestions to those who are likely to introduce new industries into the country. Fianna Fáil wants—a useful way to avoid discussing things themselves— a big development commission and economic council.

Deputy O'Connell said there is nobody at the moment who is looking after industry in the country. Various speakers on the Fianna Fáil side said that nobody is looking at industries at present, and seeing how tariffs have resulted, and where changes in the tariffing might be beneficial to the country and the industries concerned. They are being looked after without the spectacular setting up of an economic council with all the benefits that economic council or anyone can think of can bring already there. I have around me in my Department all the industries in this country grouped into thirty-three committees. Some of these committees do not meet because when you write to them and ask them things that are troubling them, and things in which intervention might be useful to them, their answer is that they are going along steadily, and that they do not require meetings. Sometimes we get them to come to discuss matters. We have thirty-three groups representing industries in this country. We have the best brains industry in this country has been able to produce in these committees. We get the best evidence of what is being done, and what changes they think are required to bring an improvement in the situation. We get them in to discuss, one committee with the other, and with trade representatives of our own and other people, with a view to securing markets here and elsewhere. Yet we are told there is no attention being paid to industry in the country.

I quoted here a remark which was made on one occasion by one of those committees representing the best brains that particular industry had in this country, and Deputy de Valera, who left this country a second-class honours man in the University, and came back to find himself a scholar of European repute, characterises this statement as imbecile. Anyone who knows anything about industrialists will say to the industrialists that that remark is imbecility. We get information from them. We get consultations when they are required, and we follow up the progress of the tariffs in the industry. I hold certain of the tariffs are at this moment putting an extra cost on the consumer. I hold that most of them, in the beginning, put an extra cost upon the consumer. I hold that the biggest groups, as far as articles go, are imposing no cost upon the consumer at the moment, but certain groups, and, unfortunately, the groups, although few in numbers, are the groups that contain most articles imported into the country, do impose a certain cost upon the consumer.

I think of the groups that were attended to in 1924 and 1925 that the consumer in the Free State, if he is not minded to buy a luxury article, if his mind does not run that way, can get himself articles of equal quality at at least as good a price as the English consumer of English-manufactured articles in the following things: tobacco, soap and candles, margarine and blankets and oatmeal, metallic bedsteads, jam and sugar confectionery and cocoa preparations. I include the last two although there is still a big import shown—the import is of a luxury type—because of the reservation I made that if a man is looking for good value he can get Irish stuff as good in those as the Englishman is getting from his English-manufactured things. In that group there are two or three points to be challenged. There is an import still shown under the heading of jam. That includes other things than jam, and there is an import shown under the heading of sugar confectionery and oatmeal preparations. Under the import of oatmeal there is a certain breakfast preparation which people are brought to buy because of long-continued advertising. They are continuing to buy it, and something approaching prohibition of that import would be required to stop the purchase of it. If such prohibition is recommended that brings us to the question of sumptuary laws and of preventing people from eating things they want to eat. To that I shall come later on. In the matter of jam there is an import of about £36,000 shown, but that includes fruit jellies, and it is mainly in that particular item that the import is shown. As far as sugar confectionery and cocoa are concerned I have indicated that there are still higher grades of sweets and chocolates coming in from the other side and being bought, but if the consumer is not looking for the luxury article he can cut himself free from any extra cost now after four or five years. In most of these articles there was an increase at the beginning. I do not think that any of the manufacturers would deny that in the beginning there was an increase in most of these articles.

Comment on this

Why does the Minister exclude bus bodies? Does he hold that there is an increase in price there?

Comment on this

Let me go on. I mentioned certain things. With regard to these I held that the consumer at the moment is not paying anything more, need not pay anything more, than the consumer in England of English manufactured goods of equal quality.

There are certain items in which the consumer, I think, is still paying more—boots and shoes, clothing, hosiery, furniture and glass bottles. I am going to leave two of these out of my calculations. They do not amount to much, glass bottles and hosiery. Hosiery is a peculiar business. In so far as it is concerned, the figures of 1926, in the census production of that year, show that £250,000 worth were produced. The import for the same year was about £1,000,000. There was a total consumption here of one and a quarter million pounds. We believe that in regard to articles made in the country in the line of hosiery the consumer is not paying anything extra, but that he or she is paying for what is brought in from outside. Why is there anything brought in from outside? Mainly because certain poorer people want to buy a particular type of cotton goods and certain other people want to buy artificial silk goods. If you are going to block that you get again into the region of sumptuary laws and the prevention of purchases.

Furniture is of less importance than the boots and shoes or the clothing either. Again taking the census of production figures of 1926 there was produced in this country, £400,000 worth of furniture. There was imported £100,000, a total consumption of half a million. We believe, and I have got the figure agreed by certain people in the industry, that the consumer of Irish furniture is paying 10 per cent. more than the man buying the same type of furniture in England, produced in England. This could be said up to seven months ago. Those buying imported furniture were paying the full amount of the tariff in whatever was coming in. The two big items outstanding in this calculation are boots and shoes and clothing. The census of production figures of 1926 show that there was a production in this country of £340,000 worth and a total import of £1,800,000, total consumption being £2,140,000. Let us separate the imported article and the home manufactured article. The best evidence that can be got with regard to the imported article is that the full tariff is being charged. On the home manufactured article, it is very hard to get a proper figure. I would not go to the point of saying that the full 15 per cent. is being charged to the buyer of the Irish boot or shoe, but there is some percentage being paid extra, something about 7 per cent. I do not agree with the foolish statement Deputy Cooney made that the foreign boot of equal quality can be bought far cheaper than the home manufactured article. I think that is nonsense, but I do think that the consumer, to the difference between £340,000 and £2,140,000 has yet to rely on the imports and that the consumer of these imported articles is paying the full amount of the tariff. He is paying about 7 per cent. on the home manufactured article. Supposing he is paying nothing you must spread over the whole boot purchasing community the full amount of the tariff.

But the consuming population is paying something more by reason of that tariff. With regard to clothing, I have again to take the figures of the census of production, which are the most reliable I can get. For all classes of clothing except hosiery the total production in the Free State in 1926 was about £1,750,000, and in the same year the total import was 3¼ million pounds. There was a total consumption of about five million pounds. Of the £1,750,000 made in the Free State at least £1,000,000, probably something over that, was composed of shirts and men's and boys' clothing, and we are convinced, from all the examinations we can make, that in all shirting, and I think in all boy's clothing, and in most men's clothing, the consumer is not paying anything extra. Take £1,000,000 off the £5,000,000 consumption, and of the £4,000,000 worth remaining something extra is being paid by the consumer—a maximum of 15 per cent., and a minimum anywhere you like below that— except that one must take this into consideration, that the vast majority of the clothes represented in that £4,000,000 was ladies' clothing, of which very little is made in this country. That has to be spread over the purchasing community.

The consumer is being charged something extra on clothing and on boots and shoes, and that is after some of the tariffs have been in operation for six years and some for five years. If I had made a similar statement a couple of years after the tariffs were imposed it would look much worse. But, at any rate, for boots and shoes and clothing—I will leave furniture out of consideration, because it is not purchased very often, and when people do purchase it they do not bother much about the sum expended—the main items in respect of which some cost is imposed on the consumer by reason of our tariffs—we get 15,000 people directly into employment and, say, another 3,000 indirectly employed. I take that 15,000, which is an accurate return of the employment, actually found to exist, and I compare it with the employment that was claimed when applications were coming forward for tariffs on these items. I know that a great deal more employment was claimed as likely to result than that 15,000. I take all the other articles of the 50 per cent. tariffable, but not yet taxed, imports, in nearly all of which applications for tariffs at some time or other have been made, I scale down their claims by an amount proportionate to reach a figure corresponding to the 15,000 and I find that if we put on all the tariffs that were asked on the other 50 per cent. of tariffable imports we might get 10,000 people employed, and with a cost to the consumer, five years after, of nothing like what I have given here. There would be a greater cost to the consumer. We had to bear in mind that when tariffs were put on first there was no trained customs staff and that discrimination meant delay and expense, but we took the tariffs that showed themselves likely to give immediate employment, those where benefit was likely to be got almost immediately, and those which we postponed were those for which a case did not seem proveable at the time, and therefore those that were likely to impose a greater cost relatively than the ones we took.

Comment on this

Is not the Minister's case not against tariffs, but against inadequate tariffs?

Comment on this

I am coming to that. There have been 15,000 people given employment, and we might get another 10,000. The 15,000 cost something to the consumer in the way of increased cost of living, and the 10,000 that we would get from the rest of the tariffs if they were imposed would cost more. As to the Deputy's interjection with regard to the inadequacy of the tariffs, I refer again to my thirty-three advisory committees. There is no tariffed industry that I have not represented by a group. I consult them with regard to the adequacy or inadequacy of a tariff, and my Department gets considerable help from them. If any industry feels that a tariff at present imposed is badly placed, that it does not give discrimination as they think there should be discrimination, or that it is not high enough, we assist them, and we ask them to move forward with a case to the Tariff Commission. In the case of how many industries have the Tariff Commission themselves thought that the tariff is not adequate?

Comment on this

I could not say, but the Minister knows that in the case of very few applications was the full tariff asked for given. The estimate of employment made was generally based upon the full tariff.

Comment on this

And therefore would be higher than what is here. We come to the fact that tariffs have been imposed and that in only one case have we been able to get the advisory committee to proceed to the Tariff Commission to get a change made. I think that the judgment of these committees is the best. We do not agree with their judgments in everything, but I think these matters are hardly for outsiders. Unless they can show that they have a prima facie case, that they have a better knowledge of the facts, that the tariff is not adequate and that they must have a bigger one——

Comment on this

They asked for it.

Comment on this

They asked for it in the beginning. Naturally everyone puts his claim high. We are pressing them steadily with regard to employment and questioning them as to why more employment is not given, questioning them, say in the boot industry, as to why there is not an increase in the quantity of boots and shoes turned out. I will take boots as one instance. The manufacturers will not go to the Tariff Commission for an increase.

Comment on this

Is that not because there is a general fear amongst manufacturers that if higher tariffs were imposed there would be a big rush into the country of British and foreign capitalists?

Comment on this

There is no such fear current generally in industry, and that case could be met when it was put up. But there is the situation. The people who are best qualified to judge do not make any case about inadequate tariffs. Are we to set up some sort of economic committee to say to people: "The tariff is not enough for you, we are going to impose a bigger one?" Yet that is apparently what is being asked.

Comment on this

Has the Minister ever had an application from the boot factory in Waterford for an increase? I understood that they wanted one.

Comment on this

I deal here not with individual factories but with the boot factory committee, and the Waterford factory has a representative on that committee. I deal with the committee as a whole and they make representations to me. If one man in a particular business were to ask me for an increase which the committee did not back up, I would not go on with it.

Comment on this

Is it a fact that certain boot manufacturers did oppose an increase of the tariff?

Comment on this

Certainly, they did. The adequacy of a tariff should be raised through the advisory committee. But to complain that nothing has been done with regard either to new industries being tariffed or with regard to an improvement in the tariff in the case of industries which have already had its benefit is simply shutting one's eyes to the fact that these people are grouped together, that the best brains of all the industries in the country are in these advisory committees, that you have in them a combination of the best of them that no economic council could give. I can tell the House, from experience of these business men, that Irish business men on the whole in the present state of affairs are more inclined each to look after his own business than to go delving into general economic considerations, and in the present circumstances the best way that one can get effective work done is by insisting that each man delves deeply into the business which he knows well, of which he has experience, and in which his whole capital is. In that way we hope to get development, and not by a general economic committee that would do nothing. If there is any body to do an economic committee's work it is my Department, and I say that it is doing it. There is not an industry tariffed or not tariffed that we have not touch with through these groups.

There are industries that are not in the country at the moment whose representatives we do not meet, and yet we try to induce people to take them up. There is a great deal of information available with regard to industries not at the moment existent here, and any amount of information has been put before people who showed the slightest evidence that they were likely to embark in any one of these industries. All the information that is required is at hand. I would like to hear anybody make the case, and establish it by one example, that information was asked on anything upon which the Department might if it were an efficient Department be expected to have information and the applicant finding himself unable to get what he required. One example of that type would be worth all the floods of oratory that we have here about the absence of effort on the part of the Government to get industries going.

In addition to what I have said about the small number of people relatively that might be brought into employment if we tariffed everything, and the increased cost to the consumer that might result—I say no more than "might result"—there is another side to economic activities in this country. Deputy Byrne mentioned that we have Messrs. Ford's at present working in Cork, with 7,000 men employed at not a penny cost to the consumers in this country through their activities. We have Messrs. Jacobs giving employment in this city to the extent of 3,000 people. Divide those people on the basis of the amount of the firm's products consumed here and the amount exported and you will find that at least 2,500 have employment on account of the export trade and 500 on account of the home trade, and I doubt whether it would come to as much as 500. Estimate Messrs. Guinness in the same way. In so far as they have an export business it may be said that they do not cost the consumer in this country a penny. We must keep that side of things going. Whether people like it or not we are tied, and we will be tied for a long time, to the European community, and whether people like it or not, in the European community at the moment there is a very definite drive against tariffs. We will have to enter into trade relations with European countries with a view to keeping the 7,000 people employed in Messrs. Fords and the 2,500 employed in Messrs. Jacobs, and we will have to make trade treaties with European nations which are setting their faces against tariffs.

Comment on this

What European nations?

Comment on this

Almost any European nation. The one nation which could be said at Geneva last year to have as completely favourable an attitude on protection as ourselves was Yugo-Slavia.

Comment on this

But the trend of tariffs is upwards.

Comment on this

It is not. The position with regard to tariffs is that they are much higher elsewhere than here, but there is no trend upwards at all. If Deputies had to deal with these trade treaties they would realise that we have to keep certain a protectionist policy when we think it good, when we think we will get employment through it without any great cost to the consumer, but that we must also dovetail into the European system for the reason that we want to sell the products of the two firms I mentioned to those countries, and we must be caught to some extent in the drift of their whole economic policy. We have to make these trade treaties for the good of our industries.

Deputy Lemass sneered, in another connection, at the fixing of a modus vivendi with Turkey. I told him afterwards when he asked what crisis there was in our affairs that caused us to jump into that suddenly, that there was an actual crisis. There has hardly been a trade treaty that we have entered into—either an arrangement or a treaty or a modus vivendi—that we had not to start in at the behest of either of those two firms, and sometimes other firms, because we have exports from other firms besides those two. I am stressing those two firms because they are the biggest, if one is to measure from the point of view of employment. There are other productive industries that we must attend to, because some portion of their products are going abroad, and we have to pay attention to this side of things. It may come to this: that at some time this country will have to make its choice and have a ring around itself, try to be self-supporting and try to sell everything that is produced here to the people in the country and not bother about an export trade, because we may not be able to get an export trade. The best policy at the moment is to keep both ends going, to get another 15,000 employed here, to get others, such as the woollen manufacturers and other manufacturers, to make their way and give extra employment with small cost to the consumer. The best policy is to have some of the unemployed brought in by reason mainly of an export business.

If any industry thinks it can make a case for a tariff, it can go before the Tariff Commission. I cannot deal with any argument put forward in this House of the insinuating type that Deputy Cooney used with regard to the people on the Tariff Commission. There are people there who can be examined from any point of view—their past history, what is called their record, and their whole outlook nationally. It may be said that the Tariff Commission, judged in that way, have a very much more pronounced national bias than most of their critics. The Tariff Commission metes out justice. It was established because the officials of my Department and myself felt that we could not examine thoroughly the applications from various industries. We had to examine them thoroughly in order to get at the exact facts of the situation. There were certain industries that we did deal with. They were plain sailing, but there were others that were not. What is the position we have achieved by dealing with tariffs in that way? This is a very big thing: there is hardly anybody to be found in the country at the moment who is free trade. There is hardly anybody who has suspicions about the tariffs that were put on. It is notable—notorious—that in countries that go in more and more for whole-hog protection the element of corruption, of trying to get after people to secure votes, of lobbying— everything that can be summed up in that use of the word corruption, not in its criminal sense—comes to the top. Everything of that nature comes up as the country goes more and more deeply into the indiscriminate imposition of tariffs. We have achieved the position that at the moment there is no tariff put on that is not backed by the big majority of the people. The farming community —and the farmers are the most conservative class in any country— accepted these tariffs. Will they accept the imposition of every tariff —of tariffs as they are suggested for every article?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Let it be tried and see. Will they accept all these tariffs put on at the one go? We risked putting a pretty big burden on them in two years when we imposed that list of tariffs on them. Remember that in the early years my statement about these articles would have to be different from the statement I make now. Are we going now in one sweep to put tariffs on everything else? The essence of the complaint is that we are not going fast enough. The method of selection is the better one and it is one that Deputies on the other side at last seem to be coming to. Deputy de Valera, who used to talk about tariffs and about protection in its most extreme form, issued a statement on unemployment a year ago. His phrase was that "We stand for the protection of all articles that can economically be manufactured at home." I do not know any better definition of selective protection. Deputy Lemass said that we could get all our unemployed people at home employed within 10 years.

Comment on this

I said nothing of the sort. I said that a permanent solution through the development of industry could be got during that period.

Comment on this

To absorb 80,000 persons.

Comment on this

That is gradualness and selectivity.

Comment on this

You could find an immediate solution for unemployment to-morrow.

Comment on this

Am I being asked about the unemployment that is here and what is being done in regard to it? I am not answering on that. I am leaving out transport, the Shannon scheme, relief works and drainage. I am dealing mainly with the industrial present and the industrial future of this country as one item of this question of employment and unemployment. That is the situation as I see it from the angle of my own Department with regard to industries giving employment. We have done everything that any spectacular economic commission can do. We have got the best touch with industrialists—men interested in their own industries. We have solicited enquiries from abroad. We have brought people in this country not interested in a particular line of business into touch with the facts and we have given them data which they would be likely to find useful. There is a wealth of material collected by the Department.

Deputies say that nothing has been done, and that we should have an Economic Commission. What is the great secret of the Economic Commission? Is it that we are to call in experts from outside to examine into the state of this country, to suggest industries where they are not at present, to suggest how industries here might develop more speedily, and give better results, or is it that we are to collect businessmen, or are we to have the maligned civil servant brought into it? The civil servant is in it already, and the businessman is in it already; even the foreign experts are in it already, looking into different matters, getting data, and trying to formulate reports. What is required more than what has been done?

Deputy Lemass is always given to wild statements. Speaking on the 28th May on the Finance Bill he said that the problems of unemployment and emigration are very serious here. He pointed out that Deputies who read the news in the papers were aware how greatly the failure of the existing British Government to remedy the unemployment situation was perturbing the people of that country. He said: "Deputies who study the American and German newspapers in the library here know how greatly the unemployment problem is disturbing the people of those countries." Has the Deputy any appreciation of figures? The Deputy put the number of unemployed people here at 50,000. On that he bases the statement that we have an unemployment problem as big as there is in America, Germany and Britain. Does the Deputy stand over that?

Comment on this

If the Minister is prepared to take emigration as a part of the unemployment problem, yes.

Comment on this

What will we put for emigration per year?

Comment on this

About 30,000 a year.

Comment on this

Let the figure be 80,000, the biggest thing the Deputy has got to. If you take that as representing unemployment here—the 30,000 who emigrate, and add to that the 50,000 the Deputy has already mentioned—it makes a percentage of 2.6 in this country.

Comment on this

Of what?

Comment on this

The unemployment percentage to the population.

Comment on this

You must remember 30,000 every year.

Comment on this

Take it for a year.

Comment on this

Are you relating it to the insured population?

Comment on this

I will relate it to anything the Deputy likes. Now let us come to the number actually registered in Great Britain. I had it at a time when it was about 1,750,000, or about 3.8 per cent.

Comment on this

Of what?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy calculate? What figure would 1,750,000 represent 3.8 of? Will the Deputy do a little calculation?

Comment on this

Does the Minister not know?

Comment on this

Here is my comparison. Take the 50,000 which is the Deputy's calculation over and beyond the registered number, plus the 30,000 emigrants. That represents a percentage of 2.6. Is Britain better or worse off than Germany or America? Is Germany worse off or better off? America was recently worse off. Germany has fluctuated very much, but was recently worse off. To-day Deputy Lemass made the statement that we could solve this problem within ten years by setting up an Economic Council and by putting tariffs on everything that we have to tariff.

Comment on this

I did not suggest that.

Comment on this

The Deputy is never very willing to give concrete suggestions.

Comment on this

Provide employment, calculating on the census of production figures, for 82,000 workers by ensuring the production at home of the goods now imported but which are being sold in competition with similar goods actually being produced here at the moment, such as bacon, flour, wearing apparel, coach bodies and things of that kind.

Comment on this

That is to say, by a general tariff?

Comment on this

A tariff on all imports?

Comment on this

The Deputy read out the same figures as Deputy Derrig quoted. If I did not hear them from the Deputy I heard them from Deputy Derrig. The Deputy talked of woollen goods, slates, motor bodies, and wearing apparel. Deputy Derrig also talked of these things. Woollens are tariffed.

Comment on this

They are nearly all tariffed.

Comment on this

Nearly all tariffed.

Comment on this

And they are still coming in.

Comment on this

The Deputy's point is that within ten years the unemployed will be absorbed. It is not by increasing tariffs that the manufacturers do not want that you are going to prevent imports. The Deputy must realise that that makes a difference.

Comment on this

It is one way of doing it.

Comment on this

Prohibition of every import would mean that nothing would come in. Whether you are going to get a happy economic state of things hereafter that is another matter. Whether you are going to get anything at all that would make up for the loss of 10,000 employees as between Fords and Jacobs is an important consideration. What one has to do in a matter of this sort is to act with discretion and to act so that the people will not suffer.

The way to protection is the way we have chosen as the best. We have got people in harmony and agreement on it. We have come to the point that on the tariffs in force, with one exception, there is pretty definitely a good conscience in the country: a feeling that these tariffs were imposed because they were necessary; that there was no "hugger-mugger" about the imposition of them. There is one exception which I quoted before, that of margarine. That is suspect, and is suspect because of the way in which a certain applicant for that tariff behaved. I spoke of this before, and I have waited to hear a statement in defence made in the Seanad. I hope to get it in the Seanad; I am going to raise it when the Bill goes there.

Comment on this

Is that the industry the Tariff Commission said was inefficient? Is the Minister now in a position to contradict that?

Comment on this

I am talking about margarine. If the Deputy likes I shall go through it again. An application was put in based upon a free trade proposal.

Comment on this

Is that the particular firm which the Tariff Commission said was inefficient?

Comment on this

I did not say the Tariff Commission said anything with regard to that, because that particular group to which I refer withdrew their application.

Comment on this

Does the Minister withdraw the statement that that firm was inefficient?

Comment on this

They withdrew the application which had been made in May——

Comment on this

The statement is not accurate and has been contradicted.

Comment on this

No, it has been contradicted by one of the firm——

Comment on this

The member of the Seanad to whom the Minister referred.

Comment on this

Yes, and the statement made "My brother will be home from Germany in a few weeks and he will have much the same to say." He has not said it since. That case is the only one that is under suspicion of all the tariffs granted in this country simply because of the gyrations of that particular firm.

Comment on this

The Minister is now giving us a classic example of why industrialists in this country will not go to him for assistance because any of them who do not agree with him are attacked in public in this way.

Comment on this

He is one of a group of industrialists who sent in the first application to me.

Comment on this

It is not the first time the Minister has done it.

Comment on this

This firm was urged by me and eventually, at my request, went to the Tariff Commission on the document which they had previously given to me and the only time they were attacked was when public hostility was aroused over their action, which is unexplained up to this moment. They put in an application, they heard a statement made in the early summer and they took six months after that before they decided to withdraw. Having withdrawn, they made contradictory statements as to the reason why they did withdraw. A statement was made in the House of which that Senator was a member that the reason why six months' delay had occurred was because that gentleman was trying to get an allocation of output as between himself and another firm. That was never denied. If it is true, it is a bad state of affairs.

Comment on this

Political blackmail.

Comment on this

I do not see any political blackmail in challenging openly a particular statement and action and in waiting for a reply. Why has not a reply come?

Comment on this

It has come.

Comment on this

It has not. I quoted from a certain document here.

Comment on this

If he was not a political opponent of the Government the attack would not have been made.

Comment on this

I made a statement here, and I quoted the document. That document was communicated by one member of the firm and his position explained, but not his brother's. A statement was made in the Seanad by another Senator explaining the inconsistency of the firm's action, explaining that a particular manoeuvre had been going on. That has not been denied. That constitutes, to my mind, the only weak spot in the whole tariff situation.

Comment on this

The political opinions of this manufacturer.

Comment on this

Not at all. What have political opinions to say to this? First of all, this man, though a free trader, applies for a tariff. Then he refuses to go on in October because of a statement made to him somewhere about the month of May, and when challenged as to the real reason, namely, that he was manoeuvring for an allocation of output, he refuses, or at least refrains, from giving an explanation. That has nothing to do with political opinions.

Comment on this

An investigation into this particular industry which the Tariff Commission specially picked out to be inefficient showed that it was, in fact, thoroughly efficient. Is not the Minister now in a position, from his own investigation, to deny his own libel and slander of that particular firm? I say he is.

Comment on this

There is no libel.

Comment on this

It was a libel.

Comment on this

The Deputy is in the state of mind in which he was early to-day when he did not know whether we were imposing income tax or relieving from income tax.

Comment on this

You said "shut up."

Comment on this

The Deputy need not get annoyed over this.

Comment on this

I am not.

Comment on this

He is either concerned or he is not. I made no statement about the inefficiency of the firm.

Comment on this

You did.

Comment on this

I want the quotation.

Comment on this

I challenged you to prove it in any sum of money you liked to put up, and you ran away.

Comment on this

You put up a sum of money before, and we discovered where it came from.

Comment on this

It was my own money, anyway.

Comment on this

The Deputy is in this peculiar position, that he is the only man marked out in this Assembly in one way—his own statement about himself regarding a particular ——

Comment on this

You are attacking the Deputy in order not to reply to his question.

Comment on this

I will reply to it, but I am going to get the statement out here—the statement he made about himself that he was inefficient. Of course it was to save his skin that he made the statement. It was backed up by his father's own writing.

Comment on this

That I was inefficient? That is a lie.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

These interchanges must cease.

Comment on this

Will the Minister deal with the question?

Comment on this

Will the Minister come to the point?

Comment on this

I am coming to the point. I have been challenged about a firm. I made no statement about that firm being inefficient and the Tariff Commission made no such statement.

Comment on this

You did.

Comment on this

The Tariff Commission had not that particular firm's application before it when it reported.

Comment on this

It was efficient, and you know it.

Comment on this

How could it be reported upon if it was not before the Tariff Commission? It had withdrawn, and the reason for its withdrawal was stated to be something that it said it only heard in October, although sworn in evidence at a public sitting.

Comment on this

You said it was inefficient and you know it is not. You do not dare give the information.

Comment on this

The Deputy is still in the state of mind that he was in when he did not know whether we were imposing income tax or relieving certain people from income tax. If he will control himself and get less hysterical we can debate this.

Comment on this

More evasion.

Comment on this

There is no question of evasion or argument if the Deputy simply, in a mulish fashion, repeats a particular statement. That is not argument.

Comment on this

The Minister libelled this firm. He knows it is untrue.

Comment on this

The Deputy can get the particular statement I made and see if he can get a quotation about it. He does not do that. That is the tariff situation as we have it; that is the particular line of country that will be pursued with regard to certain tariffs, but one tariff threatened to cloud the whole tariff issue in this country. We have saved it from being clouded. We are getting the whole tariff situation cleared. We are getting tariffs accepted by the vast bulk of the country. The farming community accepts them.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Heffernan accept them?

Comment on this

Deputy Heffernan accepts them at the moment.

Comment on this

At the moment!

Comment on this

Deputy Heffernan will not accept the foolish tariffs which Deputy MacEntee would like to put on.

Comment on this

Because he will have no job.

Comment on this

The Deputy must always get back to the job. Again the Deputy is in a unique position. He is one of the few people who has been removed by his own friends from a job with which they at one time entrusted him—the so-called Minister was deposed.

Comment on this
A Deputy

There was no salary.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We must keep to the Estimate.

Comment on this

It was not his salary, but his credit which was at stake. He was dubbed inefficient and dismissed. He is in good company with Deputy Flinn. Deputy Heffernan accepts the tariffs which are imposed at present. I am glad to see that the point about the jobs is not being dragged in again.

Comment on this

It is too obvious.

Comment on this

It is too obvious to a certain type of mind. Deputy Heffernan represents the farming community and he accepts certain tariffs which have been tried out; he accepts them now that it is shown there is not such an increase in prices as was expected, and that, at any rate, if there was there are some benefits coming back and that the burden is easing. That does not mean that Deputy Heffernan or any group of farmers are going to be reconciled to the imposition at once of a mass of tariff which used to be the policy over there but which is no longer the policy. "Come along our path of imposing tariffs on goods where those goods can be economically manufactured at home." That is Deputy de Valera's latest pronouncement.

Comment on this

And first.

Comment on this

Not his first. Deputy de Valera and Deputy Lemass have now come to that point. It used to be: "We can cure unemployment right away." Now it is ten years. Hope is deferred for ten years.

Comment on this

This can all be read afterwards.

Comment on this

I have it here and I can read it.

Comment on this

We are asked for proofs of employment in this country. I have from time to time given proofs. I have quoted the Unemployment Insurance Fund and the way it has grown. I gave the returns from the sale of stamps. There is no test equal to that as a test of the growth of employment. If there are people in employment paying contribution to the Unemployment Insurance Fund that is tested by the stamps bought centrally. If the number of stamps purchased goes up, there are more people in employment. There are more people purchasing stamps because they are in employment and the fund has gone up. There are innumerable evidences of a similar type with regard to employment and there is the outstanding figure I quoted before of less than 20,000 who think it worth while to get a sheet of paper, write their names on it, without any trouble to themselves other than that of walking to the nearest pillar box, and without the expense of putting a stamp on it, and registering themselves as people who feel the burden of employment pressing upon them. That is the figure we have to deal with. We have reduced it to that. If it had not been for what we have done it would still be about 45,000 instead of 20,000. We claim that is a good record and a record that is not going to be equalled by any imposition of a whole heap of tariffs or any setting out of economic theories.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 55
·
Níl 59
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?