Tariff on Butter. - Financial Resolution—Report.
Contributions 100–208 of 208. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Deputy Nolan is sure of that. It shows curious gambling then on the part of certain creameries, because in the winter season of 1929-30 the very same thing happened as happened in last year, and if, following the experience of 1929-30, when the I.A.C. and a Warehousing Co. in Dublin lost considerable sums through having cold-stored butter in September and October, there were creameries that repeated the experiment in the following year, I do not think they deserve much pity, especially when the market was fluctuating to the extent it was last summer. Another rather curious statement was made by Deputy Morrissey. He started off by saying that a tariff was of no assistance whatever to the farming community. He went on to say that the tariff had raised the price of butter from 1/1 to 1/9 or 1/10 a lb.
Comment on this
There is another phase of this question with regard to the Labour Party. The Labour Party is constantly boasting of its national policy, and that it stands particularly for the farmer and the labourer. At the same time they assert that the tariff that has raised the price of butter from 1/1 to 1/9 has brought no benefit to the farming community. Does Deputy Davin assert that the 18,456 cows in Leix, owned by farmers who do not supply the creameries with milk, but sell much of it in the form of butter, have not brought a big benefit to a number of small farmers in his constituency?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy assert that in Offaly, where 15,000 cows are kept in similar circumstances, the small farmers have not gained very substantial benefits by the price of butter being raised?
Comment on this
I will only take Deputy Morrissey's figures, that the price has been raised from 1/1 to 1/9.
Comment on this
If the price of butter is being raised anywhere, surely it has to be raised everywhere. The butter that is being brought into Ballybrophy, Mountrath, or anywhere else surely goes up in price if speculators or anybody else raise the prices elsewhere. Does Deputy Davin still assert that the small farmers are getting no benefit from it?
Comment on this
How could I give you the figures for a thing like that? I doubt if Deputy Davin and Deputy Morrissey are serious in maintaining that the tariff in such circumstances has not been of great benefit to thousands of struggling farmers throughout the country. If Deputy Davin likes I will bring him to-morrow or the next day—it will not take two hours of his time—to a small farming community and let him question them on this, as to the price they get for the butter they are now selling.
Comment on this
It does not look then as if the Labour Party were too solicitous for the small farmers that in their speeches they profess to be catering for. The efforts that they are making now for the first time do not show that they are so careful of the interests of the small farmers as they were a while ago. Or is there some other reason for putting forward a case against the butter tariff. I wonder what would be the position if the tariff had not been imposed, supposing the dumping that was beginning here at the time the tariff was first imposed had continued. Suppose you had butter being sold at less than 1/- here, would it be of great benefit to the labourer, the small farmer or anybody else? If you had people so crippled that they could not meet their annuities, would that have helped the towns a great deal? Is it not the case that every time the farmer is in difficulties the shopkeeper is hit and the labourer goes out of employment? It is a curious thing to find Labour economists putting forward the plea that things would be a lot better if this tariff had not been imposed. If stock had been disposed of, if farmers' difficulties had been increased, if the present produce from the 684,684 cows in the Saorstát which is not supplied to the creameries was being sold at a greatly reduced price everybody would be better off. That is a proposal which nobody can take seriously. If a better case than that cannot be made against the tariff, I do not think that the Dáil will have any great difficulty in deciding how to vote.
Comment on this
So far as I can see, it is rather unfortunate that, of all agricultural produce, butter should be chosen by the Minister for Agriculture as the one article on which to place a tariff. We all know that the Minister is not very keen on tariffs as such. He has stated so in unmistakable language very often. I think that before very long he will be in a position to strengthen the statement he made as regards tariffs so far as the farmers are concerned. Much play has been made by Fianna Fáil Deputies as to the attitude of the Labour Party on this motion as compared with their attitude on the motion of the Minister in November last. I want to say quite openly that if it were found necessary to introduce such a motion next winter, the Labour Party would have no hesitation in supporting it if the circumstances were the same and if the same necessity arose, but that is an entirely different situation to that with which we are confronted now.
Deputy Moore made some very peculiar statements. One particular statement which he made will, I think, be read by farmers with amazement. He talked about the price of butter now, and he asked Deputy Davin whether it would benefit the small farmers and labourers if butter were less than 1/-a lb., and he asked us to imagine the plight of the farmer if that were the case. He asked would the farmer be able to pay his rates and annuities if butter were less than 1/- a lb. Are we to assume from that that the tariff of 4d. per lb. on butter is going to take the farmer out of all his difficulties and help him to pay the rates and annuities with which he is heavily burdened? Surely Deputy Moore does not mean that seriously. I think that we are entitled to infer that that is what he means from his statement. I think we are all anxious to help the farmer and, so far as I personally am concerned, I have supported every effort to do so, here, in the county council on the question of de-rating, and elsewhere. Everyone knows that the farming industry is depressed and that it will require very careful handling to save it. While we are concerned with the farmers, we are also concerned with the very poor, who are asked to bear a burden of 4d. per lb. extra on butter. In comparison with the amount of good which the tariff will do the farmers we believe that it imposes a burden which is too heavy for these people to bear.
We have been assured by Deputy Nolan and Deputy Bennett, who are, I think, large dairy farmers, that this tariff is not a bit of use. They did not state that definitely, but one could infer from their remarks that they did not consider that it is going to be of any help, good, bad or indifferent, to the dairying industry. According to Deputy Nolan the amount of benefit that would be derived from the tariff is about 7/- per cow per year. Everyone must agree that it will require a great deal more than that to put the farmer on his feet. If I had any hesitation as to whether I should support this tariff or not the indefinite statement of Deputy Dr. Ryan would make me, without question, vote against the tariff. Those who spoke from these benches asked the people in the farming industry what benefits they derived since January from the application of this tariff. Nobody seemed to be in a position to answer. Both Deputy Dr. Ryan and Deputy Kent said that the benefit would amount to about 1d. a gallon, but our retort to that is that during this period of the year milk is always raised by a penny and even more per gallon.
I think that owing to the fact that Danish butter has increased by from 40/- to 50/- per cwt. there should be a greater increase than 1d. per gallon if this tariff is going to be of any use to the farmer. The reason that we cannot support the tariff is that we cannot see that it is going to do any good to the farmer. Deputy Moore referred to the small farmer and labourer and put up certain hypothetical cases, at least to my mind they are hypothetical. The small farmer or labourer does not benefit one iota by the tariff. The large farmer may benefit to some extent, but not to the extent that would warrant this huge burden being put on the poor in our cities and towns, and even in our rural areas. In consequence of that we do not think that the tariff is justified. So far as any one can see—it was admitted during the debate in January—the only one to benefit by the tariff is the Minister for Finance. In my opinion, and in the opinion of this Party, the money derived from that tariff should be used in some manner to subsidise the dairying industry or some other part of our agricultural industry. Nobody denies that the farmer needs help. Nobody denies that agriculture is our staple industry and must be saved. We believe, however, that the imposition of this tariff is really only tinkering with the situation, and that much more needs to be done.
We believe that the Government should urge on those who are inquiring into the question of the de-rating of agricultural land the necessity of submitting their report as soon as possible in order that they might deal with that problem as quickly as possible rather than by tinkering with the situation by imposing a tariff on butter which does farming no good and puts an intolerable burden on the poor. These are our reasons for opposing the tariff. We do not want to have confusion in the mind of any one as to what our attitude is now and what it was in November. As I have said, we would be prepared in the same circumstances and conditions to take the same action now as we took in November. We gave a qualified support to the motion when introduced by the Minister for Agriculture in January, and that can be proved by the records through the medium of Deputy O'Connell's speech. Deputy de Valera to-day said that he was not convinced altogether as to whether this tariff was effective or not. Deputy Lemass was. That certainly shows a different line of thought in that particular Party. He stated that in his opinion a licence to import a certain amount of butter would perhaps be more beneficial to the farmer. That is the line that was suggested by Deputy O'Connell in January. We are prepared to examine the question from that point of view and to give any help necessary to improve agriculture without placing an intolerable burden on anyone.
Comment on this
Everyone here doubts the effects of the tariff, and no one made that more clear than Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches. If that is so, they might have told us that in the course of half an hour and not have taken four or five hours to do so. That was the only contribution made to the debate to-day, that they are very doubtful about the effects of this tariff. They might have listened to me in that respect for the last few years because I always told them that that was so. They might have been content with what I told them and not tell me now what I knew already. All Deputies, except those on the Labour Benches, say that they are going to support the tariff.
Comment on this
Deputies of all Parties— Fianna Fáil Deputies, some of the Independent Deputies who have spoken, Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies—all except Labour Deputies, are going to support the tariff. Very well, why waste four hours telling us that? It seems to me that the surest way to get a long debate is to introduce something of which everybody is in favour. You can be perfectly certain then that there will be a debate for four or five hours, during which everybody makes a set speech explaining something in which he does not believe. If Deputies on the opposite benches are in favour of what they describe as a very doubtful tariff, why did they oppose it when it came before the Dáil in the shape of a prohibition? What was the point of opposing it when we introduced the motion on the first occasion? We introduced this motion by the Minister for Finance, and in fact, though there was no division, Deputies on the opposite benches opposed it. Now they are in favour of it.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Minister is wrong in the statement that we opposed the tariff. We welcomed it in the first instance.
Comment on this
You welcomed the motion here, but still you took about three hours in criticising me for introducing it.
Comment on this
You did not vote because there was no division, but you criticised it for about three hours. I put it to the House, what is the cause of all these protestations from all the benches in regard to a tariff about which everybody is doubtful? Everybody is for and against it. Deputy O'Hanlon said that the Tariff Commission was doubtful about it. They said that a tariff might be recommended. That is the position really. They were doubtful, otherwise they would put it more clearly. I do not know whether Deputies are curious as to my attitude. I am doubtful also, but I am entitled to be doubtful. I was always doubtful, and I compliment the Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches in coming over to me in this matter and adopting my attitude.
Comment on this
I would like to deal with one or two points which were raised in the course of the debate. Labour Deputies made the point that they were opposing the tariff because it would increase the cost of living and because its disadvantages to the consumer who had to pay these rather high prices would not be counterbalanced by any possible advantages to the farmer. They asked what advantage the farmer had derived since the introduction of the tariff. The farmers did get certain advantages. Listening to the discussion one would come to the conclusion that there was no winter production in butter. That is not a fact. Half the butter required in this country during the months of December, January and February is produced in Ireland. Very much more than half is produced in the month of December. About one-third or onefourth is produced in January, and very much more than three-fourths is produced in March. Take the winter months, leaving out the month of November, over half the butter required during the months of December, January and February is produced in this country. The price of butter admittedly has gone up at least 4d. per lb., so that the farmers who are producing half the total requirements of the country during these months are getting the advantage of that 4d.
Comment on this
Yes, they must be, with this limitation that a very small proportion of the butter is produced by proprietary creameries, and the proprietors in that case get the advantage of part of the increase, but only of part of it. That refers only to a very small portion of the output of butter. So far as the co-operative creameries are concerned, the farmers are getting the whole of it. Therefore, the farmers are getting an increased price for half the total requirements of the country for these winter months.
Comment on this
I should say about 1½d. They are getting that, due, of course, to the rise in the international price of butter and because of the tariff.
Comment on this
Is that quite clear? The price of creamery butter, as I understand it, is 180/-. The price of Australian butter and New Zealand butter is 122/-. Adding the tariff to that, one gets a figure of 159/4. Taking the difference between that price and the price of creamery butter at 180/-, who is getting it?
Comment on this
I do not know that the Deputy's figures are quite correct.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy would allow me to explain it. I could not say whether the price at the moment is 170/- or 180/-. There is this to be said for Deputy Good's point, that the wholesaler has some slight profit and the retailers have also their profits, but they are very small. Whatever these profits are you can take it that the farmers are getting 4d. If there is any more profit—it cannot be very much—the retailer or the wholesaler is getting that.
Comment on this
I should say so, but he will pay something in any event. The retailer and the wholesaler would get a small profit even if there was no tariff. The farmer is getting at least 4d.; that is definite. He is getting that on a quantity of butter which represents half the total quantity consumed in the country. That is some benefit. Personally I do not think it is a lot, but it is some benefit. Remember also that so far as the production of home butter is concerned, there is some increase in price. In so far as the farmer is selling home butter he is getting that 4d. as well. The retailer and the wholesaler are getting some small profits, but the retail and wholesale profits in butter are not very much, not nearly as much as in other items. They would be making that profit in any event.
Comment on this
That may be, but why should we object to that? Why should there be a special objection of that sort in the case of butter?
Comment on this
The very same thing must in the nature of things apply in the case of boots.
Comment on this
That is the point I want to make clear. I want to know why this tariff should be singled out. Deputy Good is quite consistent in his objection, because he makes the same objection to other tariffs, but, as for other Deputies, why should this tariff be singled out? You have exactly the same case in boots. You have a stronger case than that in regard to boots.
Comment on this
We have to wear boots and the poor man has to buy boots and clothing for himself and his family just as he has to buy foodstuffs. One is as necessary as the other.
What is the position there? At no time of the year is the production of Irish boots more than one-third of the total consumption. For every month of the year two-thirds of the boots required by our consumers are imported. That has been going on notwithstanding the fact that for the last five or six years there has been a tariff of 3/- in the £ on imported boots. During all that time the home production has only been equal to about one-third of the total home consumption. The remaining two-thirds have been imported, carrying the full duty 3/- in the £. That is the position, and there can be no denying it. In the case of boots, for every month of the year and every day of every month you have these imports carrying the full tariff, with the home production also carrying the full amount of the tariff.
Comment on this
No, but I am making the point that the people who are enthusiastic about a tariff on boots, on clothing and on woollens, and would be enthusiastic for a tariff on motor cars, should be at least equally enthusiastic, if they are sincere in their desires as regards their agricultural policy, for a tariff on butter and should not in this particular case raise the argument about the consumer. During the winter months there is this parallel between the case of butter, boots and ready-made clothing. You have not sufficient produced in the country to meet the demands of the home market, with this difference that the shortage in the latter items is greater than in the case of butter, and consequently prices are increased to the full amount of the tariff. There is no denying that. What I want to draw the attention of the Labour Party to is that in the month of March our production will be practically equal to our consumption. In the month of May we will have an export surplus. In June we will have an export surplus equal to twice our production. In July we will have a big export surplus as well as in August, September, October, November and December. That export surplus will operate to prevent an increase in price or at all events will limit an increase in price. That is the big difference between this tariff and the other tariffs, but it has not been stressed at all by a number of those who have spoken in this debate.
The people who are against this tariff because it may increase prices should be out more against the other tariffs, for the reason that during eight or nine months of the year, so far as butter is concerned, you will have a big export surplus which will operate against an increase in price or will tend to limit an increase in price. I put it to Deputies that, while they may have their views as to the efficacy of this tariff, whether it is going to be of any service or not, and I have my own doubts about it, that nevertheless if their objection is that the consumer is going to be mulcted, then while that objection may be a sound one it is very much more valid in regard to the industrial tariffs that have already been imposed.
Comment on this
I do not want to go fully into the question of tariffs, but I would point this out to Deputy Good, that some part of the profits, some of the increase in prices due to any tariff will, of course, go to somebody other than the producer. While that is so, there is this to be said about butter, that more of the profits and more of the increase in price due to the tariff will go to the producer than would go to him in the case of a tariff on any other agricultural product. The reason for that is that the farmers of the country practically own all the raw material required for the production of butter. That is not so in the case of eggs. The eggs are not sold to a co-operative society owned by the farmer himself. They are sold to a dealer. The same is true, except to a small extent, in the case of bacon. In a great many cases the bacon is sold to a proprietary firm, but so far as butter is concerned it is produced by co-operative societies which the farmers themselves own. In that way, any increase in price or any increase in profits brought about in the case of butter by a tariff will, to a large extent, go to the producer, to a larger extent than in the case of any other tariff. So that there is that particular reason for choosing this tariff on butter.
I have already pointed out to Deputies that there are very definite and solid guarantees against any increase in the price of butter because of this tariff. Personally I do not care twopence for guarantees given by manufacturers that they will not increase prices. Except in very rare cases these guarantees are worthless, and every business man knows that. They are worthless for the reason that you cannot check them. In most cases, to do so you would have to take into account too many considerations—not alone price, but quality. The only real guarantee the consumer ever will have to prevent extravagant increases as a result of a tariff is the presence of an export surplus. That guarantee will be here the whole time in the case of butter. Deputy Davin asked me whether I was for or against the tariff. All that I am concerned to show is that so far as the consumer is concerned he is more effectually protected than he is in regard to any other tariff imposed by the Dáil.
Comment on this
Deputies were right in saying that the prohibition increased prices and left the consumer no protection whatever. I am not thinking of what happened over the last two or three months, but rather of the effects of a permanent tariff. The prohibition, of course, was put on without notice and at a time of shortage. It left the consumer completely, if you like, at the mercy of the producer, except to this extent, that fortunately the Department of Agriculture, during the period of the prohibition, was in a position to control prices. That was because they had control of certain stocks of butter which they kept on the market. But the Department did effectually control prices. Prices, of course, went up to a certain extent, but still they were controlled. I am thinking now of the effects of a permanent tariff, and I say that so far as this tariff is concerned there is a much stronger and a much more effective guarantee against an increase in prices than in the case of any tariff imposed up to the present.
What about the producer's side of it? At the moment the producer is getting a certain advantage. He is getting at least 4d. a lb. on a certain quantity of butter, whether it be big or small, which represents half the total consumption of the country. What will he get in future? That is the question. First of all, I take it that Deputy Lemass has dropped the foolish pretence that tariffs that do not increase prices are still useful. I take it that we have all grown up and realise that tariffs increase prices.
Comment on this
Does the Minister allege that all tariffs that have been imposed have increased prices?
Comment on this
I was asked a question about margarine and tobacco. Everybody knows that there are certain considerations which apply in the case of margarine and tobacco, both of which are owned by two huge monopolies, that do not apply here and now is not the time to go into that.
I take it that we will give up the foolish pretence that tariffs are imposed for the sake of doing so, that there is an inherent good in taxing imports, and that you can give an advantage to the producer without putting up the price to the consumer. That is a silly pretence, and I am glad it has been shown up. I tried to show what the position of the consumer will be. Now come to the producer, and it is when you come to examine that side that we are all doubtful. What effect will this have on the producer? Do not mind what happened during the last two or three months. These effects were foreseen. As Deputies in all Parties admitted, its effects were from the point of view of the creamery industry good. What effect will this tariff have next summer? In my opinion practically none. There will be a big export surplus. What effect will it have next winter? As Deputy de Valera, and also Deputy O'Connell, pointed out, that will depend on how much butter there is in the country. No one can be certain what is likely to happen. Possibly what will happen will be that a certain amount of butter will be cold-stored. Possibly what might happen is that too much butter would be cold-stored, and possibly next winter there would be a surplus of butter in cold-store. If there is there would be very little increase in prices and very little advantage to the farmer.
I am not in a position to say what will happen. I can only say that there is, to my mind, one grave danger in this tariff, and that is, that an excessive amount of butter will be cold-stored. I am afraid there will be. I can only do one thing. Under the Dairy Produce Act, I propose to take extra powers to get returns from all public cold stores. Of course, we have power at present to get returns from creamery cold stores. We can take extra powers to get returns from the others for the benefit of the trade. I can publish monthly the quantity of butter in cold storage, so that every creamery manager will know what supplies are there, and have data to make up his mind whether it is good or bad business to cold-store more butter. If butter is cold-stored to such an extent that there is going to be a surplus during the winter this tariff will be no good to the farmer, and in fact, might do harm.
This was an abnormal year. There was a steep fall in prices from summer to winter. As it was abnormal people should not harp on it too much. As a rule, prices in summer and winter are about equal and, as a rule, it is good business to cold store a certain amount of butter. Business is complex, and people have to cold-store for winter use, but there would be a real danger if too much were cold-stored. If that is so, the consumer is all right but this tariff would be of no advantage to the farmer and, above all, of no real advantage to the country. No tariff is any good that does not increase production. There is absolutely no use whatever in producing the same amount of butter, holding it over and selling it in winter. If a tariff is to be of any use it must increase production. The only way is by winter dairying. Will this tariff bring about winter dairying? I do not know. That is the question. It is doubtful, to say the least of it.
There is this to be said, however, that the Tariff Commission, to my mind, took the right line. The Tariff Commission had all the evidence, all the information which the trade itself could give them, and in addition, the Commission contained some persons who have forgotten more about the butter industry and its complexities than any of us ever learned. Possibly, it is because they knew all the difficulties of winter dairying that they were not dogmatic. There is this to be said, that if winter dairying is to be encouraged it certainly could not be encouraged by any lesser tariff than 4d. A tariff of 4d. will mean—if there was no cold storage, and if the butter was sold as Deputy O'Hanlon suggested, as it was made—an increase of something like a 1¾d., or something less than 2d. per gallon in the price of milk. I doubt very much if 2d. per gallon would bring about any considerable increase in winter dairying. I doubt if 2d. per gallon will pay most farmers for the difference in the cost of production in the winter and in the summer. I am perfectly certain that anything less than 2d. would be no good.
Of course, this again is an example of the costliness of endeavouring to encourage something which the country is not specially suited for. If we decide that a type of production is to be encouraged for which the country is not specially suited, then we must make up our minds that it is going to cost a tremendous amount of money. This country is not specially suitable for winter dairying. A good deal more winter dairying could be done than is being done, but it would take at least 2d. a gallon increase in the price of milk to pay for the extra cost of producing milk in winter, if it will not take more. Nobody can say at this stage whether this tariff will bring about any increase in winter production. I do not believe it will. For the first year the temptation to cold-store will be great. I hope I am wrong. I think the Tariff Commission were right in making the experiment, and I think when they decided to tariff at all they were right to resist the temptation of imposing a tariff of, say, 3d. They were right in going the whole distance and putting on the full tariff. A tariff less than 4d. would not have any result other than to encourage cold storage. Whether 4d. will encourage winter dairying can only be said definitely after the event. In my own opinion, it is somewhat doubtful.
I make no apology for making the experiment. I make no apology to the consumer—while I sympathise with him—because in this case he is well protected, far better protected than in the case of any other tariffs introduced in this House. Above all, I make no apology whatever to the people who have been advocating tariffs indiscriminately for the last four or five years. In the past year it was taken as a matter of course that tariffs were inherently sound, that there was no reason on earth—except, of course, the double dose of original sin from which every member of the Government suffers—why tariffs should not be imposed automatically, without any examination, without taking the trouble to find out the reactions and understand their implications.
There was supposed to be no reason whatever why tariffs that are in existence should not be increased from 22 to 30 and up to 40 per cent. I heard the suggestion made earlier, as if there was no such thing as a consumer, that the tariff on boots should be increased and that the tariff on woollens should be increased. To people of that kind, who have been trying to deceive the farmers recently with regard to tariffs, who really want tariffs for themselves, and who have been trying to humbug the farmer with the idea that tariffs can be equally suitable for him. I make no apology for making this experiment.
It was suggested here also that we should couple with these tariffs some system of control. I think some Deputies from the Labour Benches talked about licences. When one speaks of licences, I suppose one means prohibition with butter being allowed in only under licence. When people speak about control they mean, I suppose, the fixing of prices. We are not going to enter into that now. Why was it not necessary to control prices when other tariffs were imposed? There was then no necessity for control. We did not hear any demand for it. Why? At that time the consumer was definitely deceived. He was effectually deceived. There was not the same agitation, and then we did not hear a word about the control of prices.
Comment on this
We did not. Now when we come to the question of butter, when the consumer can see what is happening, we hear a great deal about control. Let us have it clear that when we come to agricultural produce we must not only have tariffs but control. I hope that the Deputies who are indiscriminately advocating agricultural tariffs throughout the country every Sunday will explain to their audiences that they not only want protection but control. If they do they will not have the same enthusiasm for agricultural tariffs. As far as we are concerned, we will have no control. Control means inefficiency, waste, and even corruption. The less interference there is with production in business, especially in agriculture, the better. We put on this tariff as an experiment. We are in the same state of dubiety on this matter as the Fianna Fáil Party, and I cannot put it better than that.
Comment on this
We propose to allow the tariff to operate; we propose to watch its operation, and we propose to learn what we can learn from its operation. We believe that the other Parties here —Fianna Fáil, Labour, and the rest— have already learned a good deal from it.
Comment on this
The Minister spoke about control. Would he say what effect control on butter had in 1921?
Comment on this
I want, in the first instance, to congratulate the Minister for Agriculture on his funeral oration over his dearly-beloved child, the I.A.C. In another portion of this great city to-day there has been a meeting. which I might call the wake of the I.A.C., and the Minister has dutifully delivered the funeral oration on that body here. I want to congratulate him also on the very clever manner with which he has opposed the tariff on butter. It reminds me of the action of a gentleman who, during the war years, was sentenced to a week's imprisonment. We had no jail to which we could send him, and he was handed over to my tender mercies for the few days. I sent him digging potatoes and——
Comment on this
The Deputy had better tell us nothing about that.
Comment on this
When we went to collect the potatoes that he had dug we could not find any of them. He had covered them all up.
Comment on this
The less we hear about what happened in Deputy Corry's farm——
Comment on this
The Minister has been forced into the position of imposing a tariff, but he is doing his best so far as he can to spoil it. That is the position the Minister occupies. I never heard anything more ridiculous than the arguments put up here to-day about a tariff on butter. We did not hear any of these arguments put up when other tariffs were introduced here. But the very moment that anything is brought in that would be of any benefit to the farming community we have an immediate uproar. I admit that Deputy Good is an authority on profiteering. I do not think there is any Deputy here who will doubt that statement. I hope when other branches will be considered here we will hear Deputy Good equally condemning profiteering.
We were told the farmers were going to have no benefit whatsoever from this tariff. It is admitted, even by Deputy Gorey, that the farmer has benefited to the extent of 1d. a gallon. What was the actual position at the time that the Minister for Agriculture was forced by public opinion throughout the country and by the sickly condition of his own dearly-beloved child in this matter of butter? I say that the condition of the I.A.C. was the principal reason why the Minister came forward with a tariff on butter. That was practically the sole reason why this tariff was imposed. The Minister came forward, like somebody who was being forced to do something against his will, and he administered medicine, but that medicine was too late to save the baby. The baby is gone. The I.A.C. has been dissolved, or it is being dissolved.
Last May I made an appeal to the Minister for Finance for this tariff. I was then told by the Minister that this tariff would be a distinct disadvantage to the country. I have seen his words in the Official Report. In November it was an advantage to the country because it was going to save the I.A.C. The farming community, from May until November, was producing milk at a dead loss. Nobody in his senses would say that 3½d. to 4d. was a fair price for milk. That was the price paid when this prohibition was put on. We see a terrible anxiety at the present moment to get rid of this tariff. Why? This tariff has not got anything like a fair trial yet. The farmers of the country had become hopeless in this matter; they had lost all hope that the Minister for Agriculture was going to take any steps to protect them. To their amazement, he did take this step, but they were not prepared for it. Last November, when the Minister brought in this proposal for a tariff on butter, a large number of the farmers had got rid of their cows. That is the reason why there was not the increased production of butter this winter that, in the ordinary course of events, would be likely to follow the tariff. If the farmers of the country were able to place any confidence in the Minister for Agriculture, they would have kept their cows last November instead of selling them off. This tariff will be of benefit undoubtedly in the next three or four months while the farmers will have the summer milk. There will be no occasion for importing foreign butter from 1st May onwards.
Comment on this
The returns can very plainly be seen. One penny a gallon on milk is a definite profit to the farmer; it will mean 2/- a week for every cow, and a farmer with ten cows has £1 a week out of the butter tariff. No one can doubt but that is a benefit. I do not agree with the Minister that you can produce winter milk at the same price as you can produce summer milk. I have been producing milk for the last eleven years for the market, both in the winter and in the summer, and I find I could not do what the Minister says. I do not think this tariff is going to be of enormous benefit to the farmers, but it will at least prevent them being hunted out of existence altogether. As far as milch cows are concerned they were being sold wholesale, because farmers found it would not pay them to feed the cows and sell milk to a creamery at 3½d. or 4d. a gallon. They were getting out of that business in spite of the Minister's inducements. The worst of it was that they had involved themselves practically hopelessly. In many counties they had taken over creameries and they were hopelessly in debt. In all probability it would have meant absolute bankruptey in several parishes unless something of this nature was done. Therefore, for that reason, this tariff is undoubtedly a benefit.
I do not see why the Labour Party should have any great opposition to the tariff. The Labour Party should be concerned with the agricultural labourers who would be thrown out of employment, and indeed there are enough of them idle to-day. The wages paid to those labourers make them very little better than white slaves. It is an unfortunate position of affairs which can only be remedied if we go the right way about it. The right way is not by jumping on top of the first tariff that has been introduced here to protect the farmers. You will not benefit if the farmers have to sell their cattle and let the land go into grass. I have no doubt that is what the Minister for Agriculture might like; everything tends in that direction. This tariff has a bearing on the Minister's own child and he is trying to protect it, but unfortunately he did not start in time. He went into this matter much against his will and used every lever here to-day in order to damp every tariff put on here by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party during the last five years. He attacked the tariffs on boots, on woollens, and indeed every single tariff put on here under the cloak of defending this particular tariff. His defence of this tariff was the most damning thing of all. His speech to-night against the tariff on butter was the strongest speech delivered by any Deputy from any quarter of the House.
Comment on this
I am voting because I know, as a farmer, and as one who associates with farmers, that this tariff is a direct benefit to the farming community. I sympathise with Deputy Haslett, especially when I consider that he and the Minister for Finance were joint sponsors in rend ing this country into two sections and in creating the very situation which caused all this trouble.
Comment on this
The Deputy must get back to the matter under discussion; he must talk about the resolution and nothing else.
Comment on this
The Deputy will be allowed to roam over the resolution before the House and over nothing else.
Comment on this
I have given my reasons for supporting the tariff. It is the first relief the farmer has got. It is a lesson to those who represent rural constituencies to observe the howl that has been raised about this tariff. We have supported industrial tariffs one after the other. I have supported every tariff introduced since I came here for the reason that I want to see employment given to the people of the country. I believe every tariff that gives employment is a benefit to the country because it increases the home market. I wish others would be as generous towards the farming community. This tariff has not got a fair trial. If this matter were discussed twelve months from now we would be in a better position to discuss it because we would have an opportunity of seeing the tariff in operation.
The farmer is not like the industrialist; he cannot increase his products within a week. It takes him some time to develop a particular side of agriculture. He cannot jump from dairy cows to bullocks in a day or two. This tariff is deserving of at least a twelve-months' trial. If the Labour Party were to oppose this tariff twelve months hence I would consider very seriously their grounds for objecting. An objection now is frivolous and unfair, and it is unworthy of the Party making it. I congratulate the Minister on his funeral oration over the grave of the I.A.C. I think it was a splendid production. If the Minister took the advice given him last May by our Party he would not be in his present difficult position and the I.A.C. would be in a different position. He was not prepared to take that advice, which showed him that the farmer was producing milk and was at the same time taking imported butter.
Comment on this
During the whole of last summer. Deputy Gorey cannot pay attention to too many things at the same time. If he gets mixed up in the dog business he must remain with the dogs, and he must not be trying to switch over to other things, because that will not work.
Comment on this
I do not wish to delay the House any further. I have given my reasons for supporting the tariff, and they are honest reasons. I hope that when this tariff is examined twelve months hence the Labour Party will be the most enthusiastic supporters of it.
Comment on this
I would not have risen were it not for some of the conclusions drawn from this, which, unintentionally perhaps, were misleading. References were made to the benefits to the small farmer. This tariff can only be of benefit to the farmer for a period of four months in the year. It cannot be of any benefit to him outside that period. The amount of money involved in connection with the butter coming into the country this winter is comparatively small. The small farmer has not many cows. Suppose he has six cows. He may have one of them calving during the winter. He needs the milk for his own family. The small farmer has no milk to send to the creamery during these four winter months. It is a joke to talk about ten cows making so much profit during a week, because if a man has ten or twenty cows only a very small proportion of them will be calving during the winter. One Deputy talked about 2/6 extra profit every week. He is going on the basis of the five-gallon cow in winter time. We have no such yield. If we have a three-gallon cow during the winter period we have an exceptionally good cow on the average.
Comment on this
Taking them on the average, our cows are not making six hundred gallons in the summer. What is the average cow making in the winter time? It is not making two gallons. If we work it out in that way we will have to go on a different basis altogether from the half-crown profit every week, on the basis of one penny per gallon. There was no such price as 3½d. per gallon for milk during the summer time. It was bad enough at 4½d. and 5d.
Comment on this
There was no such thing as 3d. or 3½d., because the summer price last year was infinitely better than the winter price. If it were not for the tariff, what would have been the price for the winter, when we consider the price to which butter dropped? If the price of butter during the summer was 140/- or 145/- and the price of milk was only 3½d., what would it be in the winter? About 2d. Deputies ought to have some sense of proportion and not be exaggerating and making a joke of a serious matter. For the last supply of milk we got 6d., and probably will get that also for the January supply. The farmers have got something out of the tariff. One penny per gallon of milk means 2½d. or perhaps more on a pound of butter. In addition to that the butter that was in cold storage was not the property of the I.A.C. but of the farmers. The creameries outside the I.A.C. held more butter than those in the I.A.C., as Deputy Corry knows if he was just about the matter. I do not suppose, however, that he wants to be just. He would rather have a sling at the Minister by saying that he fathered the I.A.C. The I.A.C. was the child of the creameries and of nobody else. If they made a mess of the matter it is their own fault. They were doing the business and nobody else. I say that those who have broken away from it will wish before the season is over that they had continued in it.
The principal reason I stood up was to refer to this question of winter dairying. There is no use living in a fool's paradise. Except the tendency of the last three years is altered it is only a joke to talk of winter dairying in this country. New Zealand and Australia have developed their summer dairying to a point at which during 1929, 1930 and 1931 they were able to sell butter at much less than our summer price. Would anybody tell me that it is good sense to advise people here to go in for winter production when New Zealand and Australia can sell butter, as the last three years have proved, at much less than our summer price? That may be abnormal, or it may be normal. Before we give such advice we ought to wait and see if that will continue. If it does continue, and they can sell their butter as cheap as we can in summer time, it is foolish to advise our producers to try and produce butter in winter. If they can sell it less, it is worse than foolish to give that advice.
My advice to milk producers is not to attempt to enter into winter production of milk with the object of producing butter. If it is done with the object of producing milk for sale, it is quite good business. But even that can be overdone if a large number enter into competition with each other for a limited market. Winter dairying, even for milk production, is only good to a limited extent. If Australia and New Zealand are able to maintain their present rate of supply, winter dairying in this country is a thing of the past. What might be a good thing ten years ago is certainly not good to-day, and the events of the last three years have proved it. This discussion has done one thing if it has done nothing else— it has removed the fog from the brains of any farmers who thought tariffs, and especially indiscriminate tariffs, were going to be of any benefit to them.
I am rather amazed at this cry of the increased cost to the consumer of this particular article. The cost will only be increased for three or four months, and only to a limited number of thousands of pounds, while other tariffs have increased the cost by millions on the consumer. I am rather amazed to see the distinction made between this and other tariffs. This is only the crumb of a crust that has been offered to the farmers. They are not even getting a bit of the loaf, or even the crust. They are only getting a crumb of the crust.
[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]
Comment on this
I am sorry the turn this debate has taken this evening. I thought on the last occasion we were discussing this question, and when the tariff on imported butter coming into the country was passed without a division, that the farmers could expect something. Now it seems that the somersault has occurred and a lot of lip sympathy was offered to the farmers of the country and to the unfortunate agricultural workers—the worst paid section of the community. I speak on behalf of the agricultural workers, and I speak as an Irish farmer in contact with them daily, and as one who knows their sufferings and sympathises with them, and I say that we should all join together to improve the conditions in which they live and to lift them out of the unfortunate position in which they are.
A lot of questions have been asked as to how this tariff benefits the farmer. How many extra men have been employed, and a thousand and one other silly questions. How on earth can a tariff imposed two months ago and hardly yet in operation affect the position? Besides it must be remembered that the creamery industry of the country has gone through the worst phase of its existence during the last year. It takes a little time even if there were extra profits coming to the farmer in co-operation with the creameries to straighten out their difficulties with the creameries without talking at all of extra profits. The farmers who are trying to co-operate with the creameries are quite satisfied if that was the only benefit that accrued. I am giving my personal opinion, and I can speak for 400 or 500 dairy farmers in the Midlands—I have been in discussion with them on every phase of the question from A to Z— and we are quite satisfied if all the benefits of this tariff this winter only affect the creameries in so far as it may put them on their feet and enable them to get out of their financial difficulties, and enable them to start with renewed confidence in 1931—if that is the result a good day's work would be done by the action of the Dáil and the Executive Council in putting on this tariff. I know what I am talking about, for I was one of those who helped to put forward this application.
Our creameries as new creameries are feeling the effect of the situation by which foreign-produced butter is dumped here at 10d. a lb. from New Zealand and everywhere else. I ask the Irish men to turn a little of their attention to their own country, and not like Deputy Gorey to be defending the policy of bringing in New Zealand butter and leaving Irish farmers sitting down in idleness in winter instead of taking part in the production of the necessaries of life for their fellow-countrymen.
This tariff has definitely benefited the creamery situation. It has given the farmers a new hope. Cows ready for sale were retained and springers coming into milk now were retained simply because the farmer said the Government have given us a new hope and this is a chance of supplying home needs and we can look forward with confidence to other steps being taken by the Government to help us. On the question of the money that came from this tariff and the benefit it brought to the Exchequer, I earnestly suggest to the Minister for Finance that he could not do a better thing with that money collected from this tariff than to make it available for the Department of Agriculture to help the creameries, whether in Limerick or elsewhere, that are in financial difficulties, and that money should be spent for the benefit of industry worth £12,000,000 a year, and no public representatives need have any qualms about doing the right thing in allowing it to go in that direction.
We had a lot of talk about the consumer. I ask any fair-minded person to consider how much worsened the position of the consumer is this year as compared with last year. We know that economic depression set in during the last year. In no sphere of industry has acute depression been felt so much as among the farmers and the agricultural workers. Surely if we are sympathetic and if we are not offering merely lip sympathy to the farmers we should think before we rush this thing and not alter a right experiment before it has well started. I think the attitude taken up with regard to control is wrong. I agree with those who think that a claim can be put forward for control. At the same time I ask is control to be exercised in connection with other necessaries of life? Is there to be control when bacon prices jump from 2d. to 4d. per lb.?
Comment on this
I am glad that those who have spoken in favour of this tariff have realised that there is necessity for control as regards the amount of butter to be put into cold storage next winter. I am glad to hear that the Minister for Agriculture and the Department have power and intend to seek for extra power to control that situation. Otherwise it would nullify the good effect of the tariff in the coming winter. As regards the effect of this tariff on the creamery industry, it would want to get three or four years' trial before you can decide what the real effects will be. You cannot decide in one year or in two or three months. It will take two or three years and longer for a normal situation to come round as regards butter when we consider that New Zealand and Australia and other countries have increased their production in the last 18 months by 100 per cent. No apology need be made for shutting out the foreign article when Irish farmers, whether in the creameries of the country or in the homesteads, are willing and anxious to produce butter if the people will agree to pay the cost of production price for that article. The farmer is not asking for any abnormal profits. Anyone who knows anything about farming knows well that they are satisfied if they can keep the ordinary circle of farming going round and do not find themselves in debt. Unfortunately a very large number of them are in debt, and any little amelioration of their condition that we can bring about we ought to effect without making such a fuss about it.
I have been talking to several consumers in my constituency and elsewhere, and whilst they agree that in some cases the shopkeepers have taken an unfair advantage of the people, the situation is not as bad as it is painted. Deputy Nolan and Deputy Bennett, from County Limerick, are entitled to their opinions as regards dairying conditions in Limerick. But I speak for a mixed tillage district where, if anywhere in the country, the work of winter production of butter can be taken up. I am perfectly satisfied that experiment can be gone on with in the Midlands and made a success. I am convinced that the work done in our area—and I am speaking for five or six creameries connected with Roscrea, Donaghmore and Tullamore—is such as is going to be successful in the end.
Deputy Nolan thought it a pity that the Agricultural Credit Corporation did not do something for the farmer. As far as it affects this debate alone I think it fair to say that in our creamery we took advantage of the scheme for the distribution of funds for dairy farmers. The Midland creameries, with their three auxiliaries, distributed £6,000, repayable in seven years. That money is repayable from the milk cheques in the five best months of the year. That may be information for some of those who possibly could take advantage of a similar scheme, whether in Limerick or elsewhere. I would point that out to Deputy Nolan for the benefit of districts in Limerick which are hard hit for finance. In Limerick, there are, I understand, lots of farmers who go in for seasonal production of milk. They buy cows at the beginning of the season and sell them at the end, and such a scheme could be taken more advantage of than in our area. The Deputy should look into the matter to see whether any money could be got from that source for the benefit of the dairy farmers who may be in need of funds. That may be irrelevant to this question, but I wish to mention it to bring to light the true facts of the case. I am really sorry on this question of the sale of our butter that there is a difficulty in getting the dairy farmers of the country and the creamery managers to find a basis of agreement as to how to co-operate in the selling of their butter.
I believe it is essential, for the proper development of the dairying industry and the proper exploitation of the British market, for the selling of butter and the proper exploitation of the home market as between the butter for sale and the consumer, to have proper combination that could control the situation and the amount of butter that could go into cold storage. If such a co-operative development could be got together, and please God I hope it will, the farmers and the creamery managers who are pulling against each other now, and developing petty personal points instead of looking to the industry of the country should sink these differences and hammer out a common co-operative policy to control the situation. I say farmers have benefited by this, and I am quite prepared to defend that statement. I say the agricultural labouring people of the country have benefited because many farmers have been enabled to hold on to men who otherwise might have to go. At present, it is unfortunate, and I say with all sincerity, we ought to open up our minds and sympathies towards the situation. Many farmers are keeping men because they have them for several years, and it is not the farmers' fault that they only pay them 8/-, 10/- or 12/- a week. There are black sheep among farmers as you have black sheep among employees in relation to how they work for the farmer. We can cry quits on this question.
I say as far as the benefit of the 4d. tariff is concerned the major portion has been passed on directly or indirectly to the farmers, because who owns the creameries? As a matter of fact, when you talk about the I.A.C., who owns it? Who owns the butter in the cold storage? It is the farmers in co-operation. If certain profits went over to creameries, I.A.C. or anybody else was it not better that it went to them than that it should go to some wholesalers or anyone else? But even if wholesalers in the country happen to be lucky enough to benefit from this tariff what about it? It will do somebody good, and some of the butter factors and others had a bad time of it all last year. If they were put on their feet it would redound to their good and help them in the coming season to renew their efforts. It will encourage the farmer to make home butter and sell it to the factor. Deputy O'Hanlon quoted certain figures with regard to the I.A.C. and other figures of the sort. I think it is very dangerous to be quoting figures at present, and it is not fair to be asking anyone to state whether he is paying say 2d. or 3d. when the experiment has hardly started yet. I am whole-heartedly in support of this tariff. I hope it will be permanent, and that this time twelve months those persons in opposition to it now will make up their minds and say that it is a good thing that it was imposed.
Comment on this
Having listened to a lot of oratorical breezes from the hills of Ireland, it is time an ordinary representative from one of the cities would say something in relation to the unfortunate consumer about whom we heard a good deal this evening. The Minister for Agriculture was speaking with his tongue in his cheek most of the time when making his speech in support of that tariff, because, though he declared he was in favour of this tariff on butter, his speech was one which would convince any person here that he was inclined to waver as between a tariff or no tariff. My mind has been made up for a very long time, and I think, with the single exception of Deputy Coburn, I was the only Deputy in this House who spoke against the imposition of this tariff at the beginning.
I said then, and I repeat now, that there may have been at that period a particular reason why a tariff should be placed on butter, but what was true in November is no longer true. As a matter of fact, it is well known that some creameries are at the moment purchasing butter, putting it in cartons and wrappers in the majority of cases having the names of these creameries on the cartons or wrappers, and the butter is being sold over the country at a huge profit to certain retailers. Now we have had from the Minister for Agriculture that the imposition of this tariff was in the nature of an experiment. I want to suggest to the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Finance, who is responsible for this tariff, that it is a very dangerous thing to make any experiment so far as the food of the people of this country is concerned. When on one occasion in another country there was what one might describe as a tariff ramp, the slogan which was mainly responsible for putting a Government out of office was "A free breakfast table for the people." I suggest to the present Government that the sooner they put an end to these tactics of taxing the food of the people the better it will be for themselves and for the country as a whole.
An attempt has been made to suggest that there is an analogy between a tariff on boots and a tariff on butter. There is no analogy whatsoever between the two. In one case, it has been suggested by some of the farmer Deputies who profess to have a great amount of sympathy for the poor labouring man in the country that this tariff of 4d. per lb. on butter, which on the evidence submitted by the farmer Deputies does not mean 1d. or 2d. to the farmers in butter production, that that penny or twopence is to go in relief of the working-class people who work for the farmers of the country. I want to suggest to the farmer Deputies who speak like that, and the last Deputy who spoke is one of them, is it not true that the farm labourer will have to pay more for his butter? Is it not true that some of the farmers of this House are buying their butter now?
Comment on this
It may be more shame to them. It has been stated here by farmer Deputies, and by no less an authority than the Minister for Agriculture, that it is questionable whether under the climatic conditions that prevail in this country winter dairying could be made a paying proposition. Deputy Gorey admits that because of certain conditions operating in Australia and New Zealand they can produce and market butter in this country at the present time at less than the cost of producing it in this country, that it would not be an economic proposition to establish winter dairying in the Free State. Having regard to all these facts and to the extraordinary difference of opinion that exists between farmer Deputies and the dubiety that exists in the mind of the Minister for Agriculture himself, is it any wonder that the poor consumer from the cities and towns of the country is asking his representatives in no circumstances to vote for any future tariffs on butter, or on any other article of food that is consumed in this country
Some questions have been asked as to the effect of this tariff. Some Deputies who have spoken in favour of this tariff appear to doubt that it has increased the price of the commodity. I think it was Deputy Corry who suggested that it had not increased the price of butter in the towns and cities. I want to say that in the City of Cork, before the imposition of this tariff—I can bring Press paragraphs and market prices to prove it—the price of butter per lb. was 1/3 while to-day it is 1/9 and 1/10. Is that profiteering or is it protecting the consumer? No voice has been raised in protest by the farmer Deputies against this extortion and this profiteering and, I am reminded, not by Fianna Fáil either. Some people say, and it is the argument of the Minister for Agriculture, not the argument of the Minister for Finance, that those who advocated tariffs on boots, woollens, etc., have advanced a very specious argument in their favour. The Minister for Agriculture suggests that there should be no whining and no expression of disapproval because another section of the community, namely the agricultural community, desires or asks for a tariff on one of their products, namely butter. I have a slight suspicion, knowing something about the pranks of the Minister for Agriculture, that this tariff was introduced purposely and designedly for the breaking up, if you like, of this ramp for tariffs all over the country. I think the Minister for Agriculture is ingenious enough to be able to experiment in that way, so that this boomerang may react on people who think that the only panacea for all the economic ills in this country should be found in the imposition of tariffs and still more tariffs. I hold there is good and valid reason for the imposition of tariffs on certain commodities, but I see no reason whatsoever, and I stated so last November, why this tariff should be imposed on the food of the common people of this country, all the time remembering that this tariff will fall upon the people who are least able to bear it. The well-to-do person, the ordinary middle class person, will not mind paying an additional threepence or fourpence per pound for his butter. but, relatively and proportionately, it means a tremendous burden to the poor people of the lanes and the alleys of the city. I have had submitted to me during the last few weeks budgets of ordinary working-class households, showing an increase since this tariff was introduced, of from 1/9 to 2/3 per week, according to the size of the family, and according to the amount of butter consumed.
Something has been said about the agricultural labourer and his wages. In my view, this means a reduction in the wages of the agricultural labourer, a reduction in the wages of every consumer in the Free State, a reduction represented by the amount he pays over and above that which he should pay on a necessary article of food. Objection is taken to reducing wages. By all means it is the correct attitude to adopt, especially at this period when more spending is necessary. I look upon this tariff as I have looked upon it since last November as tantamount to a reduction in the wages and salaries paid to the wage-earners of this country. I understand there has been a great rapprochement in this country between certain members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and certain members of Fianna Fáil. It is certainly a very good thing to have such Deputies as Deputy Heffernan on the one side and Deputy Lemass on the other, entering into a combination to raise the price of this particular article of food. It is undoubtedly a happy consummation of the dreams of the profiteers in this country and a negation of all that Arthur Griffith stood for in the old Sinn Féin movement. The Minister for Agriculture said, or implied, in the course of his speech, if I did not mistake him, that he could give us no definite assurance that the imposition of this tariff would encourage winter dairying. Neither did he give us any assurance that there would be anything in the nature of protection for the consumer. He said that to an extent they could control prices at the source. He told us of the steps he proposed to take. He would get a census from the various creameries of all the butter they held in cold storage from time to time at certain periods, and at the same time he told us that once it passed from them he could not prevent profiteering, or control prices during a certain period. What the Labour Party has always stood for, and will continue to stand for, is control up to a certain point. I will go farther and ask for some price-fixing tribunal, but in this matter we had no attempt made to control. If we had we would not have the prices I mentioned a while ago operating in Cork City and, I understand, operating in certain parts of Dublin City.
Deputy O'Connell suggested that we would be prepared to support any measure that would be taken effectively to help the small farmer. We look upon the small farmer as a worker and a producer. We are prepared at all times to advocate anything that will better his position, but we feel in this matter that the small farmer is not being helped at all. I have made it my business to get into contact with a number of small farmers quite recently. I asked them what was the reaction of the butter tariff on their industry, and they assured me, as far as they were concerned, that it did not benefit them one brown copper. That is the position. Conditions, of course, may differ from one county to another, but I am giving you exactly the conditions as I have found them, and that within a radius of a couple of miles of where I live. I understand that one of the reasons advanced for winter dairying is that it would result in the continuity of supplies. That again has been turned down, so far, at any rate, as the Minister for Agriculture is concerned, and I take it that he is an authority. He has told us, in fact, that he is very doubtful that the effects of the tariff would result in that particular way, in the direction of continuity of supplies for the home market and for the British market. One point I think has been missed, at least by Deputies whose speeches I have heard, and that is that under any set of circumstances, so far as the production of butter is concerned, and, indeed, for the matter of that, any agricultural product, particularly for live stock, the price must always bear some relation to the international price of such commodity. The prices of such commodities as butter, bacon and eggs are usually governed by international prices or by those obtaining in the London market. The Minister will correct me if I am making a mistake, but that has been my impression.
Comment on this
There are several reasons, but it is not appropriate to go into them now. While generally concerned with the prosperity of the farmer, especially the small farmer, I am immediately more concerned—because I am more frequently brought into contact with them—with the consumers in the cities and towns who are footing the bill for this tariff. If the Minister for Agriculture or the Minister for Finance can assure this House that the revenue so derived would be placed to the credit of agriculture in some way—for instance, by helping the farmer to produce more milk in winter, though the Minister for Agriculture says that he does not believe it is possible—and if that money were directed into some productive channel, I think that the townspeople would be only too happy to make some sacrifice to put the industry on its feet. As I said in the beginning, however, this tariff is a very dangerous experiment, and I hope that it will come to an end very soon. It is a dangerous experiment to deal in this way with the food of the people, and for these reasons I intend to vote against the tariff.
Comment on this
One of the objections raised by the Labour Party on this question is the fear that it is resulting, and will continue to result, in increasing the cost of living. They stress very much the great hardship inflicted by an increase in the cost of butter to the poor labourer's family and the fact that it will limit the amount of butter which such family will be able to purchase, but they leave out of consideration altogether the family of the labourer who is out of work and who has not been able to purchase butter for a considerable period. They also ask for certain guarantees about the imposition of this tariff and want to know whether the benefits are going to the farmer. That has been fairly well answered by farmers here with experience, and they state that they are getting the benefit of it. If that answer is not satisfactory then I am afraid that they will have to set up some machinery to investigate the whole procedure in regard to this tariff and to see whether the farmer is really getting the benefit. Again, they raise doubts as to whether the tariff will result in an improvement in the case of the farm labourers, but the Labour Party know very well that they themselves ran away from the farm labourer for a number of years and failed to secure for him the economic conditions which apply to labourers in cities and towns. Why did they run away from him? Simply because the farmers were not able to pay the rate of wages which the trade unions laid down as necessary for farm labourers.
When a proposal is now put forward to improve conditions for the employers of the farm labourer the very Party who should support it— the Labour Party—are the first to fly in opposition to it, thereby inflicting a perpetual imposition on the farm labourer that is intolerable. It has been mentioned in the course of this debate by farmers that the rate of wages for a farm labourer is between eight and ten shillings a week, but we heard no strong condemnation from the Labour Party on that rate of wages, and we have not heard of them going down to organise the labourers in that part of the country. The whole point of view of the Labour Party seems to be that the amount of the tariff is so small it is of no consequence to the farmers. I can tell them, however, that the income of the farmer is so small, that even a small sum of money is eagerly sought by him, and regarded as worth looking after, no matter how small it may appear in the eyes of Labour Deputies.
The Minister for Agriculture made an extraordinary statement on this question. He seemed to wrap himself up in complete enjoyment over the fact that there was some opposition raised in this House towards the imposition of this tariff, and he seemed to think that this debate justified his whole attitude on the question of tariffs for a number of years past. One of the points which he laboured most was that he was very doubtful after two months' experience as to whether the tariff would result in any improvement in the winter supply of milk or an improvement in dairying in any way whatever. The Minister for Agriculture must know perfectly well that the dairying industry needs assistance, and that unless he is prepared to give the necessary assistance to keep it on its feet that industry will inevitably disappear. The Minister advocated in this House some years back a general policy of the spread of creameries, and secured from this House a substantial sum of public money in order to consolidate a certain group of creameries in a certain part of the country. He went round the country advising business people to invest their money in the starting of new creameries as they offered wonderful possibilities and provided the only solution that lay before the farmers of the country. Having done all that, having invested public funds in the development of that industry, and having encouraged private individuals to put their money into it, he now comes along with a sort of delightful feeling of accomplishment when he finds that the tariff is not likely to result in putting that industry on a successful basis. The only alternative, of course, is the ruination of that industry. Will he justify himself as the Minister who is responsible more than anybody else for the increase of creameries, and for the introduction of money into that industry? Will he justify it as a good and sound business proposition that they are a failure, that tariffs are hopeless to save them, although he himself is the man responsible for the establishment of that industry to an extent on its present basis?
The Minister must face the reality that if 4d. per gallon is not sufficient to establish the industry on a sound basis, then he must call on the country to provide the necessary contribution to make that industry a sound one. This is the position we should face, that dairying is an essential part of the existence of the State, and that any assistance that is necessary from the State must be forthcoming to safeguard that most essential end of industry. There is no use in saying that it is going to increase the cost of living. Other tariffs imposed by the Government have meant an increase in the cost of living, but in no single instance and in no single industry, in which public assistance has been given, was there such necessity for it as there is in the case of dairying.
Deputy O'Hanlon, on the other hand, found a solution which is ingenious and very simple. It consists of advertising the fact to the English people that we make butter in this country, and the moment the English people learn from these advertisements that we make butter they will offer us a higher price for our butter than they offer to any other country. I wonder if Deputy O'Hanlon is aware that the English people and the English consumers are aware that we produce eggs in this country and export them to England, and that on the shell of each egg is stamped the name of the place from which it was exported, namely, the Irish Free State? Therefore, the English consumer is well aware of the fact that we send eggs over to his market, but he does not come rushing along offering us the highest price he pays for eggs. Eggs exported from Northern Ireland bear no stamp, but by some form of Freemasonry the fact is known that these eggs are somehow a home product, and the exporters receive on the average from 2d. to 4d. a dozen more than we get from the consumer in England for our eggs. Very often eggs sent from the North of Ireland and sold to the English consumer as the produce of Northern Ireland are the produce of the Free State. They are taken across the Border and sold in shops there, and are afterwards exported to the English consumer. Will Deputy O'Hanlon tell us by what extraordinary process he is going to change the English mind towards Irish butter, seeing the English mind towards Irish eggs?
Some people suggest that Deputy O'Hanlon is a newspaper owner, and that that probably explains his anxiety for advertising. I would like Deputy O'Hanlon some day to come down to the country when the farmers are being paid from their creameries. The farmer there would be looking over a return something like this. This would be the month's return for a farmer who had three cows. He would have to his credit 100 gallons of milk at 3d. per gallon. When I mentioned that price Deputy Gorey contradicted me. He said he could not understand it, that the lowest would be 4d., or at least 3½d., but what I state is a fact. If Deputy Gorey or any other Deputy doubts my word I will show him a number of returns from creameries for last year. It may not be so low as 3d. per gallon now. The farmer looking at that return will see that he receives 3d. per gallon for 100 gallons, representing a total sum of £1 5s. 0d. As against that there would be the cost of cartage, a penny per gallon, a total of 8/4. There would also be the deduction for his shares on three cows at 2/6 each, a total of 7/6. This deduction would not occur on every pay-day, but it may be the pay-day on which Deputy O'Hanlon would go down. Then there would be a further deduction of 2/- for can-hire. That will represent a total deduction of 17/10, leaving the farmer a sum of 7/2 to take home with him. Deputy O'Hanlon can tell that man, who has such a large sum of money in his pocket, that we should advertise the fact that we make butter in this country. The Labour Party may tell that man that any improvement in the way of tariffs would be more than counterbalanced by the loss which would be entailed to the poor labourer, who would have to pay something additional for his butter. Let Deputy O'Hanlon and the Labour Deputies deliver that message to those farmers, and if they meet them in any numbers I can fairly guarantee that Deputy O'Hanlon and the Labour Deputies will get all the advertising they will be able to carry about with them for a few weeks afterwards.
There should be no question whatever about giving this tariff the support it deserves. It should at least get the assistance and the sympathy of the Dáil for such a period as is reasonably required to see whether it may prove a practical solution or not. If the Minister for Agriculture would take into consideration this problem as it should be handled or as it is his duty to handle it, he would not limit to 4d. the tax on butter, but he would tackle the situation on the basis that he would make this industry a paying proposition for those who are engaged in it. Until some person tackles the problem on these lines we cannot hope for any substantial improvement. There is one very vital question involved, and that is that creameries at present are heavily handicapped by overhead charges. These new creameries that have been established have to pay the initial cost of erecting the creameries and installing new plant. That has been made possible by loans made by the Department of Finance to the Minister for Agriculture. These loans are pressing heavily on the borrowers at the present time. Creameries newly started which hit a bad stroke of luck at the beginning of their career should be catered for specially as regards getting an extended period for repayment. It is a vital question for them. I say that until this question is tackled by some authority on the understanding that this is an essential industry and that whatever assistance the State may have to give in order to make it sound and prosperous, it will remain as it is, a staggering and a decaying one. I believe the solution lies in offering the farmer a price for his products that will enable him to continue in production and show some little margin of profit. I am old-fashioned enough to believe that the farmer, once assured of a decent return for his labour, will continue to produce, and that his products will find a market according to their merits. I prefer that line of reasoning and outlook to the one suggested by Deputy O'Hanlon. His only solution was that we should advertise.
Comment on this
One would imagine from the remarks made by some Deputies that the Labour Party was opposed to anything that aimed at the development of industry in this country. Deputy Lemass talked of the Labour Party always being shifty. One feels inclined to think that the Deputy is just preaching the doctrine that he himself is now following. He said that the Labour Party had changed concerning tariffs. I deny that. We have always contended that as regards industries which get the benefit of tariffs, the consuming public and the people engaged in them should get a fair show. I make no apology for being a member of the Labour Party. I was sent here by the working classes in Carlow-Kilkenny, not to support private profit seekers, whether they belong to the Fianna Fáil Party or to the Cumann na nGaedheal Party.
Those whom I represent are trying to exist on a miserable pittance of nine or ten shillings a week. They are being fleeced by these private profit seekers. I have worked as an agricultural labourer myself. I know what it is to try and live on ten or twelve shillings a week. My friends here on the left have only book knowledge on that. Think of the position of these agricultural labourers with large families trying to live on ten shillings a week and with the price of butter now increased by 5d. per lb. in order to increase the income of these private profit seekers. I will never stand for a policy of that kind. Deputy Lemass talked about Labour changing. The Deputy himself is the greatest authority in this House or outside of it as regards twisting. Five years ago he was in the wilderness, and asked the people to follow him there. He comes here now and says the Labour Party are wrong. The Labour Party have been here all the time endeavouring to secure that this country would be set up on a proper foundation so that our people could live in comfort and under decent conditions.
I am not in favour of this policy of increasing the price of butter on the working classes by 5d. per lb. If the private profit seekers have made a mess of things, that is no reason why the working classes, on their miserable wage, should be expected to make sacrifices in order to bolster up the inefficiency and blundering that has led to the present position. I intend to vote against the resolution.
Comment on this
We have now from Deputy Doyle the reason why the Labour Party is opposing this resolution. The reason is because it is not popular in the country. If it were popular the Labour Party would be in favour of it.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture said he doubted very much if the amount of the tariff would be sufficient to encourage winter dairying. I wonder if it occurred to him whether it would be sufficient to encourage even summer dairying? Are we coming to the point when the Minister may have to encourage summer dairying as well as winter dairying otherwise than by a tariff? Our Party is supporting the motion because they believe that it is of advantage to the farming community themselves to produce milk in the winter. The reason the tariff was introduced was not, as the Minister said, to try out an experiment, but rather because the dairying industry had reached a point when it needed some help. That help had to be given by means of a tariff, a subsidy or otherwise. It is possible that some better way of helping winter dairying could be found than by means of a tariff. I do not know. What I do know is that the tariff put on in November did help the people who were producing milk in the winter. I can speak on this with personal experience. I know that in many cases the increase in the price of milk was far more than 2d. a gallon. I have not heard any member of the Labour Party deny that.
If the price of milk had not been increased you would have very little milk being produced now. You would have all the butter needed coming in at 4d. a lb. less than the price it is to-day, but you would have none of that butter produced here. You would have the position referred to by many Deputies, of farmers going out of dairy production and selling off their milch cows. What would be the result of that? It would mean that the live-stock industry of the country would be threatened, because, as Deputies know, the dairy industry is its foundation. Some of us may hold different views with regard to the live-stock industry, tillage and other matters, but we all agree that if the dairy industry were to be killed by subsidised butter coming from Australia and other countries it would mean the end of our live-stock industry.
Deputy Anthony said that the price of butter in this country should never rule above the international price. I wonder if that opinion is held by all the members of the Deputy's Party? If that is their view, I would like to hear them explain the support they gave in the case of other tariffs introduced here. We all know that clothes and boots which are tariffed in this country can be bought on the international market far more cheaply than they can here.
Comment on this
I am aware of that. I think the case for this tariff has been sufficiently made. It is absolutely necessary if a filip is to be given to winter dairying. It is quite possible that a position will be reached when something similar will have to be done for summer dairying. The tariff will be useless after another month. The position may arise before the summer is over, when the Minister for Finance may have to come here and ask for a vote of money to help the dairy farmers. I wonder what will Deputy Anthony have to say if a vote has to be introduced to help the farmers to produce milk and butter? The opposition of the Labour Party to this tariff is mainly because it is unpopular in the country. If it were popular they would not be opposed to it.
Comment on this
So much has been said about this question that I only want to say that I was always opposed to the tariff on butter. I was opposed to the prohibition order, and also to the tax of. 4d. My chief objection to the tariff is that if people engaged in the dairying industry cannot meet competition when the raw materials are there in abundance, how in the name of common sense can we ever hope to establish other industries the raw materials for which have to be imported? We have the raw materials here in the form of land with which to manufacture butter and produce milk, and yet we are not able to compete. Surely that means that we are not able to stand up against outside competition. The cry some years ago was: "Get John Bull out of the country and we will have a land flowing with milk and honey." Now it seems that was a delusion, and that we want nothing but tariffs in order to hide behind them. This tariff, as has been pointed out by the Tariff Commission, will be of no advantage whatever to the dairying industry. My objection to the tariff of 4d. is that it is of no advantage to farmers generally. When Deputies are speaking about farmers I want them to think about farmers in the Twenty-Six Counties, and not to select a section of the farming community. There are farmers in my constituency who had to be content with five shillings per ton for potatoes three or four years ago. I am glad to say that there has been a change in that situation, and that they are now receiving from £3 to £3 10s. a ton. On the other hand, the dairying industry has only met one unfavourable year. Those in it immediately began to cry, and they expect the poor people in the towns and cities of the Twenty-Six Counties to pay for their losses.
It is well known that the chief factor for the introduction of the prohibition order and for the tax of 4d. a lb. was the fact that large quantities of butter were in cold storage in certain creameries throughout the Free State. That butter was being held over in the hope that the price would increase during the winter. These people made a mistake, and in order to compensate them for their losses prohibition was almost unanimously rushed through this House. I absolutely object to any section of the people, no matter in what industry they are engaged, having sufficient influence to compel whatever Government is in power to introduce for their particular benefit a special Money Resolution. I do not think such procedure would make for pure administration as far as this House is concerned. I absolutely protest against the manner in which this tariff is being introduced, and against the indecent haste with which it is being pressed. Deputies sought to draw certain analogies between the tariff on butter and the tariff on boots. In my opinion there is no analogy, for the simple reason that, as far as the butter industry is concerned, all the raw materials are here, while for boots the raw materials have, to a large extent, to be imported. In addition, the boot industry is an infant industry here, while the dairying industry has been carried on here since the beginning of the world, and, in my opinion, requires no incentive. The people engaged in it may not have employed the means that the people of other nations similarly engaged are employing. Deputy O'Hanlon ably demonstrated that point of view, and told the House the difference that exists between the price paid for Danish butter on the London markets and the price paid there for Free State butter.
I think it is about time we should get away from the idea that our only salvation lies in the imposition of tariffs. That outlook is the very negation of the principle for which the majority of the people of this country stood some years ago, self-reliance. I think the one thing necessary for all industries here is that the people should face up to the situation as it exists. As the Minister for Agriculture pointed out recently, there must be economies and sacrifices all round, because we are attempting to keep up here, more or less, a standard of living which the revenue of the country does not afford. Until people are prepared to make certain sacrifices which will have the effect of bringing relief to the farming community, I see no hope for the establishment of new industries, not to talk of preserving the existing ones. For that reason I am going to vote against this resolution.
I am glad that I will not be alone in my opposition on this occasion. I notice that the members of the Labour Party have—wisely, in my opinion— changed their opinions since the question first came before the House. I think that it indicates moral courage in any Party, where the members may have expressed certain opinions a few months ago, to admit that as time went on further pursuance of that policy is wrong. I think it displays a certain amount of moral courage amongst the members of that Party to get up and say they were wrong. I congratulate the members of the Labour Party on the stand they have taken on this occasion in opposing a tariff of 4d. per lb. on butter, as it is going to impose a very great hardship on a considerable section that is least able to bear it.
Comment on this
Question—"That the Dáil agree with the Committee in this Resolution"— put.
Do you agree with this result?