We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Vote 56—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).

Contributions 201–403 of 403. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

In what way?

Comment on this

First of all you have in the Saorstát a civil aero club, the members of which are handicapped tremendously because they have been promised—I do not say by the Minister but by some means—that they will be given some kind of a subsidy.

Comment on this

There has been no subsidy for the year that is under consideration in this Estimate.

Comment on this

There was a subsidy given under different Votes. I am given to understand that the Minister's Department has had certain conferences with representatives of this aero club.

Comment on this

May I again ask for a ruling on a point of order. Can there be discussed on an Estimate what I may do in the future unless it is tied up with some particular power that I have, and by which my administration last year may be criticised?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is confined to something which arises under the Vote.

Comment on this

Surely, A Chinn Comhairle, you are not going to rule that transport, as an industry in the country which gives employment and in which money is invested, is not a matter that comes under the administration of the Minister?

Comment on this

Except in so far as it is imposed on me by statute, there is no obligation on me with regard to it.

Comment on this

Are we to take it that in this debate on the Minister's Estimate we can discuss nothing except what is set down under the various sub-heads, the same as we might do at a meeting of the Public Accounts Committee? Can there be no discussion of policy? Is the Minister not to give the House any idea of his policy in regard to any particular matter that arises under the head of industry and commerce? Is that what we are to take from your ruling?

Comment on this

The Deputy is asking me for a ruling, I think.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I could not rule in the terms that the Deputy suggests. The position is that we are here reviewing the action of the Minister within the last twelve months, and we can only discuss the things which the Minister has a statutory power to do. The rule which prevents us from advocating legislation is a sound rule. There would be no limit otherwise in a discussion on Estimates. The Minister is asking for a certain amount of money for the expenses of his office. Deputies are confined to criticism of his administration within the powers devolved upon him by statute. Of course, as the Deputy is aware, there is no comparison at all between what the Public Accounts Committee normally does and the discussion, which is in order, and what takes place on an Estimate. On Estimates questions of policy can be discussed.

Comment on this

That makes the position very difficult. The ruling now is that we can only criticise the Minister's administration on Estimates for the coming year.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The past year.

Comment on this

The Estimate before us is for the coming year.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are discussing the action taken administratively by the Minister during the past year.

Comment on this

Are we to discuss the past year on the Estimates for the coming year?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Yes—administrative action.

Comment on this

So that if an item appeared on last year's Estimate and does not appear on this year's Estimate, we are precluded from discussing it because it does not come under one of the sub-heads in this year's Estimate. I think that your ruling makes it absolutely impossible to get any reason——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is importing meanings into my ruling that are not there at all.

Comment on this

You stated definitely that we must criticise the Minister's administration during the past year. You realise that we have in our hands the Estimates for the coming year. The position is that we must not refer to them at all. I suggest that we should send for last year's Estimates and discuss them over again.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Ceann Comhairle did not say that the Deputy cannot criticise the Minister.

Comment on this

No, the Minister's Department.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Or the Minister's Department. The Ceann Comhairle does not suggest the matters which may be debated.

Comment on this

Would you please tell us what we may do? I was attempting to criticise, if you like, the lack of policy on the part of the Minister last year. For instance, he failed last year to give any help in the development of civil aviation. The Minister says there is no sub-head in the Vote dealing with that matter, and that therefore it cannot be discussed. I want to argue that civil aviation is something that will have to be tackled, and that it is a matter of policy. The Minister can say that we have no policy in the matter.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy may discuss the matter of civil aviation.

Comment on this

I thought the Minister was trying to rule me out. On the same basis that I have got your permission, if you like, to discuss the policy of civil aviation, surely we can discuss policy and everything else on the Vote for the Minister's Department.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy has got permission to discuss civil aviation and he wants to extend that permission indefinitely. We will discuss civil aviation now, and we will decide the other point when it arises.

Comment on this

With regard to civil aviation, the Minister has done absolutely nothing. I give him credit to this extent, that I understand that recently conferences have taken place between his Department and representatives of the Aero Club for the purpose of seeing what facilities could be accorded to them to develop a scheme. I would like the Minister to explain why it is that he has given the Club such limited facilities. I would like to know why it is that the Minister—not the Minister for Industry and Commerce but the Minister for Defence— is giving such limited facilities to this Aero Club for the use of a hangar and with regard to flying machines at Baldonnel.

Comment on this

Is Baldonnel under my Vote?

Comment on this

No, but the Minister knows very well that if he had any policy with regard to civil aviation he would have made some effort before now to acquire existing grounds as suitable landing places. If the Minister has any policy on this matter I would be glad if he would give us some indication of it, and what the lines are that he intends to develop on. I would like to know if any chance is to be given to people in this country who qualify as pilots to make a living in their own country, or whether we are going to continue the present position that people who have a leaning that way and qualify as pilots will have to go abroad to seek a living. I come back now to the Minister's functions with regard to electricity supplies in general. Will the Minister inform the House when he expects to be able to give us the information to which I referred a few minutes ago? He says that when the particular report comes to hand it will be discussed. Under the Act he is supposed to bring that report to us at certain stated intervals.

Comment on this

What are they?

Comment on this

Every twelve months.

Comment on this

What twelve months?

Comment on this

The Minister had all this out with me before. A couple of years ago I had down, practically every couple of weeks, the same set of questions asking the Minister when he was going to lay on the Table of the House certain reports and balance sheets which it is incumbent on him to lay on the Table of the House regarding the working of the Electricity Supply Board. At that time the Minister said that the first two years' reports would be discussed together, as the first year was the formation year. Subsequently, the two reports came separately. Now the time has elapsed when the two reports should come before the House.

Comment on this

What time? Would the Deputy quote the section of the Act under which he makes this contention.

Comment on this

I will not, because I have not got it all in my head. The Minister knows that, and he is quick enough to take advantage of a person to try to show he is not conversant with the Act.

Comment on this

Is there a stated time before which we must produce the report?

Comment on this

Once every twelve months.

Comment on this

When do the twelve months begin to run?

Comment on this

From the time the previous balance sheet was presented.

Comment on this

Is that in the Act?

Comment on this

Are we to take it that every single Act for which the Minister is responsible that goes through this House has a catch in every section and sub-section, and that the Act is not what it appears to be, or what it is described as, but is actually a Chinese puzzle? If that is the case, we might as well not discuss anything here. I say that there is a section in the Act which I think is Section 12 — the Ceann Comhairle will correct me if I am wrong, because he has the Act there.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

It is not Section 12.

Comment on this

The Ceann Comhairle has the Act there. If the Minister says I am not correct, I shall have to leave the matter at that, and look up the Act before he replies, to see if I am correct. The Act says that he must bring the balance-sheet to the House once every year — whether it is twelve months or nine months after the presentation of the last balance-sheet does not make much difference. The balance-sheet must be presented within twelve months after the last one has been presented. I wonder if the Minister disputes that point. I say that it is up to him to give us some information on that matter. I should like to hear from the Minister a more detailed statement regarding the policy he is to follow in the future regarding trade loans. He stated on a former occasion that his experience in this respect was so bad that he was considering the question of allowing the Act to lapse altogether. If the Minister considers that the present system is a bad one, will he state what other means he proposes to try to stimulate or help industry in this country. I should like to hear the Minister give us an outline with regard to his civil aviation policy, if he has any policy. I should also like to hear him deal with the matter raised by Deputy Hogan regarding the people who have been displaced from employment or whose livelihood has been interfered with in connection with the Shannon Scheme. I should like if he would state what can be done by himself in that matter, or if nothing can be done, if he would at least express sympathy and give an indication that some means will be taken to provide for these people.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan (Clare)

I desire to raise a point of order. I do not raise it in any irresponsible way. The Minister stated, when I was endeavouring to make a case for certain people who were disemployed in connection with the Shannon works, that he had no legislation under which he could com pensate these people. I do not say that the Minister is deliberately misrepresenting the position, but I put it to you, A Chinn Comhairle, that the position is this: the Minister states that he has no power under any existing legislation to pay certain compensation. With the limited resources available to me, I cannot bring the authorities here to show that he has. Does the duty devolve on the Chair to say whether there is or is not legislation under which compensation can be paid and to rule accordingly?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I do not gather what the Deputy wants me to decide. This point of order arose when the Leas-Cheann Comhairle was in the Chair, and I presume a ruling was given.

Comment on this

I do not think a ruling was given.

Comment on this

The Deputy stated himself that he was not in at the time.

Comment on this

When the point that Deputy Hogan is raising was being discussed, I was here.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

A ruling was given on a particular point. Does the Deputy desire me to rule now on the general question?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Yes.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

As to whether it is the function of the Chair to decide whether the Minister has or has not power under a statute to do a particular thing.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Yes.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Obviously, that would be impossible for the Chair.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Then I could now proceed to argue the case of the Killaloe fishermen?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think that would be impossible also.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Chair will then have to say that there is no legislation under which these people can be compensated. Otherwise, how can I be cut out? Either there is legislation or there is not. If there is, I am entitled to proceed. If there is not, some authority has to show that there is no legislation.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy was not allowed to proceed?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I do not know what the Deputy wants me to say.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I want to have the position clarified. When a Minister stands up and, for the purpose of avoiding discussion or otherwise, says that there is no legislation under which he can act, and the Deputy concerned says that there is, but has not, in the limited resources available to him, the opportunity of bringing his authorities here, is it the duty of the Chair to say that there is not, in fact, legislation under which a particular Minister — not necessarily the Minister for Industry and Commerce — can act?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Discussions on the Estimates and on all other matters are presumed to take place with bona fides between the parties concerned. If a Minister states that he has not authority under a statute to do a particular thing, that is prima facie evidence to the Chair, and to the House, that the position is so. If a Deputy desires to make the point that the Minister is mistaken, that he really has the power which he thinks he has not, it is open to the Deputy to demonstrate that to the Chair. It is open to the Deputy to cite the section of an Act which appears to him to give the Minister the necessary power in the particular case. If there is conflict between him and the Minister as to what the Act precisely means, the Chair is prepared to allow that discussion to proceed up to a certain point. It is not the function of the Chair to construe what the Minister's powers under a statute are, nor is it the function of the Chair to say that the Minister has the power which he takes the responsibility of stating he has not.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

If it is the function of a Deputy to show that there is legislation under which a Minister can act, surely it ought to be the function of the Minister to demonstrate that there is no authority under which he can act.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

It is not for the Minister to demonstrate the absence of something but for the Deputy to demonstrate the presence of something. That is the position.

Comment on this

I feel that while the Department of Industry and Commerce has, in many respects, been in advance of some of the other departments of State, and has to its credit a scheme which is a tribute to the imagination and ability of its official head, Deputy McGilligan, we should, from the very fact that the Minister has able and efficient assistants, have expected from this Department much more than mediocre and half-hearted measures. It is, therefore, with the object of stimulating the Minister and his Department to further sustained efforts in certain directions, for which the State has already provided the machinery, that I wish to offer some criticisms on the failure, in some respects, of this Department to satisfy the requirements of our people. I am not, for the moment at any rate, going to attempt to follow the involved and rather confused mentality of Deputy J.J. Byrne, because the more experience I have of this House the more confused I become in trying to follow his contributions to any debate here.

When we find that in the matter of home assistance alone we have something like 84,000 people in receipt of relief, that over half a million is being paid out in that respect, and further, when we have regard to the increase in unemployment, surely it cannot be said, having regard to the fact that the Minister has at his disposal the machinery to initiate reproductive work, that his Department has been the success which we would all like to see. The Minister, perhaps, may reply that it is not his function to create or give employment, but I submit that he should take the initiative in this matter of creating employment, and if he has not, as he may suggest, the machinery under his control to do so, he should seek for powers in the Dáil, and I believe that they would be readily granted to him.

We have on occasions suggested, and I repeat the suggestion now, that the authority and prestige of this State should be actively used in promoting new industries and in reorganising and expanding existing ones. We have suggested the national organisation of our essential industries. On the discussion on the proposed tariff on flour and on the discussion of the motion in my name in regard to the flour-milling industry, we suggested that it was the function of the State to see that that essentially national industry should not pass into foreign control, and, incidentally, we also suggested that the Minister should take appropriate action to see that this key industry was controlled by Irishmen and financed, as far as possible, by Irish capital.

Again, we have had the spectacle of a Food Commission being set up in 1926 to regulate prices and to prevent profiteering. So far as present indications go, and so far as present experiences show, no result whatever has accrued from that Commission. The prices paid to the farmer to-day do not bear a proper relation to those charged by the retailer to the consumer. We have suggested from time to time that that is one of the problems which the Department of Industry should take in hand and, if possible, control. We find, for instance, in the case of one commodity — eggs — that the farmer gets something like 6d. or 8d. a dozen, whereas the retailer charges the consumer from 1/- to 1/4. The same applies to butter and milk. The position in regard to the flour-milling industry is one which should engage the attention of the Department of Industry at the earliest possible moment. Very disquieting paragraphs have appeared in the newspapers recently indicating that it is the intention of those who control that industry at the moment to rationalise it.

In that bland and innocent way of his, Deputy Byrne suggests that rationalisation is a good thing for industry. He suggests, and no one will dispute the fact, that rationalisation aims at efficiency—efficiency, as translated by Deputy Byrne, at the expense of those engaged in the industry; efficiency which may, in the long run, be at the expense of the people of this country. I do not know one Deputy in this House, whether he comes from Cumann na nGaedheal or Fianna Fáil, who will go down to his constituents and make the type of speech which Deputy Byrne made in this House this evening. I have yet to find a Deputy, Fianna Fáil, Cumann na nGaedheal or Labour, who is willing to stand up at a public meeting and tell the people that it is a good thing for the country that one of our principal industries— in the sense that it is an important and key industry, not in the sense that it gives a great deal of employment — should be controlled by a foreign firm which is supposed to have such great concern for the industry that it will not reduce the number of persons engaged in it, and will see that it is maintained here as a national asset.

I cannot help repeating that Deputy Byrne and those who think with him must be very innocent and must not have regard to what occurred even on the other side of the Channel as a result of the combine in this industry. When the industry resolved itself into two or three great combines or trusts they agreed to divide the spoils between them; in other words, they said: "Let us rationalise." In the process of rationalisation one great flour mill in the City of York, employing over 1,000 persons was scrapped. Surely, neither Deputy Byrne nor the Minister will, or can, tell me that when an English combine has so little compunction in closing down an English mill to suit its own purposes, in other words, to pay better dividends, it is going to keep alive mills in this country. Surely we cannot expect this foreign combine which now controls the flour-milling industry here to have more regard for the mere Irish than it has for its own countrymen. Deputy Byrne was indeed very entertaining.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy has not yet mentioned what he wants the Minister to do.

Comment on this

I am just indicating where Deputy J. J. Byrne entertained us with some figures in which he paid a big tribute to the Minister for the increased employment, for instance, in the hosiery industry, the clothing industry, the boot and shoe industry, and the readymade clothing industry. I want to show the things that the Minister could have or might have done during the year under review. We find that the estimated annual requirements in the Saorstát for woollen and worsted tissues approximate to 6,200,000 square yards. The highest figure which the home sales ever reached was in 1918, during the war period, when the mills found a market at home of £1,684,000, equal to 3,100,000 square yards. We find a somewhat similar story in regard to the hosiery trade. For the year 1929 more than £1,000,000 worth of hosiery was imported, and in that year you had a tariff on imported hosiery. I am not an out-and-out believer in tariffs at all. I have raised my voice on occasions here against some tariffs which I considered unnecessary, but we have the tribute paid by Deputy J. J. Byrne to the Minister in regard to tariffs, not caring whether they were revenue producing or trade protecting. That is the kind of logical criticism we have so frequently from the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches, but more particularly from Deputy J. J. Byrne. He spoke about the clothing industry and congratulated the Minister on the fact that there were 3,500 persons extra engaged in the readymade clothing this year. What are the real facts and what are the powers of the Minister and the potentialities of this industry? We find that in the case of clothing, not including boots, shoes and hosiery, no less than £3,200,000 worth at wholesale prices, was brought into the Free State from Great Britain or Northern Ireland in the year 1929. Goods of half this value produced at home in 1926 provided employment for 6,600. So much for Deputy J.J. Byrne and his statistics. We have the same story in regard to boots and shoes, another tariffed industry, all going to show — and I feel that I will get this reply from the Minister — that these tariffs have not served the purpose for which they were applied.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are not discussing that now. I do not understand how the Deputy is connecting all this with the Estimate. We are not discussing tariffs, and I am not sure that it is relevant to give the Minister any credit at this particular stage for the tariffs imposed by the House.

Comment on this

I accept your ruling, but Deputy J. J. Byrne was congratulating the Minister, and I wanted to show his involved and confused mentality. It is not due to the Minister or to his Department that we have a steady increase under certain heads, and that we have certain decreases under other heads. I want at least to show that he undertook, when the flour position was under discussion some time ago, to keep his eye on the situation, or, as they say in Deputy Sheehy's county, to keep his eye on Russia like the "Skibbereen Eagle." I am wondering has the Minister anything to report to us on the present position of the flour industry, a position upon which he decided to concentrate his attention. I do know that in my own area, where there are some mills, a good deal of dissatisfaction is felt at the position created by recent developments. I must express my own disappointment that the position in the way of rationalisation was allowed to develop to the extent it has. I do hope that the Minister in his reply will indicate what the position is at the moment, and how far his Department has kept its eye on the situation.

Comment on this

I wish to draw the attention of the Minister to a matter concerning the Shannon Scheme. That is in regard to extending the Shannon power system to country towns throughout Ireland.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister is not responsible for that.

Comment on this

I presume he would have some function in the matter.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

He has not.

Comment on this

I presume he can supply the money, and that would be an essential factor in the matter. I might be permitted to ask whether he would assist us in that direction in the near future. I feel that the position, in general, in regard to the matter of tariffs and the Department of the Minister is satisfactory. I do not know if I could refer to the question of navigation on this Vote; that is in regard to the navigation of the Shannon. Is the Minister responsible in any way for the existing services carried on by the Shannon Navigation Company? It has been alleged, I do not know whether rightly or wrongly, in my part of the country, that to facilitate navigation the waters have to be kept at a very high level in some of the areas. As a result of having the waters maintained at these high levels for the navigation of deep draught boats, extensive flooding has been caused in these localities, particularly where the lands are low-lying. That system of navigation has been initiated lately for deep draught boats. I think some provision might be made by which boats of a lighter draught might give the necessary service to this part of the country.

If it were necessary to compel those companies to provide light draught boats it would do away with a great deal of the flooding. Something like five and a half feet of water is required in the lock.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

What has the Shannon navigation got to do with this — has the Minister any function in that matter?

Comment on this

Well, yes, in respect of trade and industry.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Would the Minister say whether he has any function?

Comment on this

Under one of the Shannon Navigation Acts I am given certain powers with regard to navigation, and I was told to build certain works in connection with navigation. It was said that these works were not carried out properly at the time. To a certain extent I have responsibility, but of a limited type.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Could the Minister change the type of boat?

Comment on this

He might change the type of lock.

Comment on this

If the Minister would make representations to these companies to provide light draught boats it might save a great deal of expense and loss caused to the farmers in the area at present. On the other hand, if it is not possible to do that I think that transport has now become so modern and up-to-date that, perhaps, this water system may be regarded as obsolete. If the country as a whole has to suffer extreme losses for the purpose of facilitating this particular company, it might be well to review the system of modern transport in the interests of people requiring transport. Those particular areas and small towns in the district could be served by modern transport. It is in the power of modern transport to deliver goods now almost as cheaply by lorry as by water. That is a thing that concerns us very much in the midlands. I do not think it is possible to overestimate the losses endured by the farmers in this particular area all along the Shannon, North Longford, South Leitrim and Roscommon, where the lands are suffering from incessant flooding.

I do not attribute this thing in any way to the initiation of the Shannon Scheme. This trouble has been there for years and years. Previous to the setting up of our own Government there were vested interests in connection with all those companies and the interests of the farmers or the other people in the area were ignored. Now that we have our own Parliament here and that we have people sufficiently interested to look after the interests of the landowners and the farmers, it is, I think, about due that the whole situation should be reviewed from the point of view of enabling the farmers to use their lands to their greatest possible capacity. There may be insinuations made that the Shannon Scheme caused the flooding. I have the opinion of a number of farmers who have given me to understand that since the electrification of the Shannon the flooding disappears very much faster than heretofore. The opinions I have obtained are to the effect that there is a difference of six inches in the flooding now as compared with the time prior to the setting up of the Shannon Scheme.

As to the question of giving farmers compensation for losses sustained in any one particular area or areas, my own opinion is that that would be impossible so far as any Government is concerned. The same situation would arise in a very short time again. There would be a renewal of compensation claims. There is one thing that would relieve the situation very much, and that would be if those firms using the Shannon for the transport of goods could be induced to put on boats with a three and a half feet draught instead of a four and a half feet draught. In my opinion that would give considerable relief to the farmers in the district.

I have heard Deputy Briscoe refer to civil aviation. The Deputy asked the Minister to supply ways and means for civil aviation. In my opinion this country has not yet reached the stage when so rapid a system of travel as aviation is required. Our methods of business have not been so developed as to require that any sums of money should be devoted by the Government to aviation. The country is sufficiently small for any member of the community to get into a Ford motor car at any time in the evening and arrive here in the metropolis four or five hours later. That is a thing we can do with for a considerable time to come. I cannot understand why there should be such stress laid on matters such as civil aviation that do not concern the welfare of the country so very intimately. There are things very much more important. There is just one thing that I want to press on the Minister, and that is that he would by direction or otherwise induce the Electricity Supply Board to facilitate the towns throughout the country in the matter of Shannon power——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy has made two points which were not within the bounds of order, and he ought to be satisfied.

Comment on this

There is one matter to which I would like to direct the Minister's attention. It is in connection with the imports of second-class harness into this country. I understand that as a result of the reorganisation of the British Army a considerable quantity of second-class harness has been thrown on the British market. The sale of this harness has been discouraged in England, and it is being dumped over here now. The coming of the motor car to a great extent has driven the Irish harness makers out of existence. The Irish harness maker is now depending for his livelihood on the making of cart harness. As a result of this importation of British Army second-class harness the existing harness makers in the country are being deprived of their livelihood. The Minister should take some steps to prevent the import of this harness. If the British people will not allow this harness to be sold in England, surely we should take steps to prevent its sale here to the detriment of our own harness makers. Harness makers in country towns fill a useful function, and it is too bad that there should be driven out of existence these very useful and necessary trades.

Comment on this

In the Minister's statement on Friday he gave pride of place to his statistical section. In that he was probably well advised, because in the opinion of many people it is the one bright spot in the Department of Industry and Commerce. Certainly everyone will bear testimony to the efficiency of its work. I want to ask him if his attention has been called to the way in which agricultural statistics are obtained, particularly in regard to the exportation of live stock. I have heard it asserted on very good authority that these statistics are quite unreliable. The information is obtained from drovers to whom the animals have been handed perhaps only half an hour previously. They are not concerned as to whether the animals are bulls, cows, heifers, calves, store cattle or any other description. They are simply asked a question by an official at the North Wall, who is responsible for furnishing the information to the Department of Industry and Commerce, or an official at some other port, and they reply, "They are so and so or mostly so and so"— information that as a rule is not at all accurate. It is taken from quite irresponsible people, and there is no appreciation on the part of the person giving the information of the importance of the information he is giving. I think it is worth while calling the Minister's attention to it, and to ask him if he is satisfied that what I am saying is not the case, as, of course, it would be a very serious matter if statistics that are made so much use of both in this House and throughout the country were so unreliable as my statement would indicate.

The Minister gave us very interesting information about the Geological Department and in another of his statements he mentioned that his representations had been a good influence with the Contracts Committee. He told us how much the Department has been able to do in getting the Contracts Committee to give preference to Irish goods wherever they are available. I propose to connect that fact with his statement referring to the work of the Geological Survey wherein he laid emphasis on the fact that they have recently been surveying the Connacht coalfield, preparing certain maps of minerals, and so on. Connecting these two matters I want to call his attention to a statement that was made here to-day by the Minister for Finance as to the respective quantities and cost of Saorstát coal and foreign coal purchased by the Board of Works during the financial year ended the 31st of March, 1931. His reply to my question was that the total quantity of coal purchased by the Board of Works during the financial year ended the 31st of March, 1931, was as follows: Saorstát coal, 2,120 tons; foreign coal, 11,370 tons. I may tell you that I have got the impression that the reply was a very guilty one. It bears the impress of guilt because there is only part of the information asked for given in it. "The foregoing figures," it states, "are exclusive of supplies for the army, prisons and for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs outside the Dublin district which, though purchased under contract made by the Commissioners of Public Works, are paid for out of the votes of the consuming Departments." He also excludes information regarding coal supplied to the Gárda Barracks throughout the country for which information I am referred to the Department of Justice. I think it is not a too farfetched inference to say that the reply indicates that the Minister did not like to give the full statistics as to the quantities of Saorstát coal and imported coal which are purchased by the Board of Works and supplied by it to the different Departments of State. It does seem curious, presuming representations from the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that the discrepancy between Saorstát coal and foreign coal should be so great, the Saorstát coal amounting to only about one-sixth of the foreign coal used. According to other information that I have been able to get it seems that in the Gárda Barracks throughout the country there is not one ounce of Irish fuel used. It is an extraordinary thing that if we have a geological survey which is doing excellent work, preparing statements as to the coal supplies available and all that sort of thing, and when we all know we have plenty of other fuel, that we cannot afford to allow such a big consumer as the Gárda Síochána to use Irish fuel. It seems to me that the Minister could very well look into that department of industrial activity and see whether everything is as right as right could be. It would be a great surprise if it were the case that the Government Departments must depend on imported coal for their fuel supplies.

There were two important omissions, I thought, from the Minister's statement as to the activities of the section of his Department that deals with trade and industry. He did not state that any new industry had been established, although he indicated that his Department was active in bringing those with money and skill together. He did not state that any new industry was established or about to be established. Three or four years ago he told us that cement and artificial silk were engaging the active attention of his Department. Apparently nothing has been achieved in either direction and, though I quite admit that it is not the function of the Government to establish new industries, it would be rather disconcerting to learn that, notwithstanding what the Department is able to do in the way of supplying information and other services, it is not able to induce people to start new industries. If we have reached the limit of our industrial activity, if the State cannot induce capitalists to start industries here, and if the State is not prepared itself to start new factories, that is a very big fact that we will have to reckon with. The economic position then, I think, would have to be reviewed in an altogether different light from that which has been the case up to the present. There is a further omission from the Minister's speech. He did not make any remark as to how far his Department interacts with the general public in obtaining support for Irish products. Is that altogether outside the function of the Minister's Department, or is the Minister satisfied that nothing can be done there? It is by far the most important opening that there is for encouraging industrial output in this country, and if the Minister can do nothing there, then it is rather unfortunate for his Department.

I would like if the Minister would tell us whether, in the case of hosiery, he is satisfied that that industry is getting on as well as might be expected in the present situation of the country. I think the imports of hosiery are something like £1,000,000 a year. That is an enormous sum to be going out for goods which obviously can be produced in this country as well as in any other country. Many people are concerned to know whether the present tariff on hosiery is sufficient to preserve or to encourage the development of that industry. Could the Minister tell us whether it is the case that supplies of foreign hosiery are being dumped in the Saorstát, thus making it quite impossible for any growth here of that important branch of manufacture? It would seem a line of activity which deserves very special attention on the part of the State, and I think the census return for 1929 does not show very much of an improvement on that for 1926.

We used to be told that peat offered a great opening for industrial development. Has the Minister considered whether there is anything in that statement or is it another of our illusions that must disappear? We believed at one time that there were by-products of peat that could be developed, and that under a sympathetic administration there could be a great deal done to exploit the peat deposits of the country. We might be told now whether the Minister's Department has considered that subject or not.

With regard to rationalisation, it is very interesting to hear from Deputy Byrne that rationalisation means increased employment and increased output. That was no ordinary chance statement. It was made in a very dogmatic fashion by one who asserted that he was an authority on the question, and that very few of those who talked about it knew anything like as much as he did. Except on the question of flour, the Minister has never stated what the attitude of his Department is to the question of rationalisation. Are we to understand that the State is acting as an organ for rationalisation of industry, that in the case of woollens, for instance, hosiery and other things, it is using its influence to develop rationalisation within these fields, or do the Government regard that question as outside their scope, except in regard to flour on which, of course, they have taken up a very pronounced attitude?

Comment on this

You, sir, have my sympathy in having to listen to the drivel spoken here. I wonder why Deputies do not try to know something about a subject before they talk about it. They talk about shipping cattle. Are they aware that every beast shipped out of this country is examined by a veterinary surgeon thoroughly and branded before it is shipped? They talk about coal. Irish mining is a beautiful myth. There is no such thing as a commercial mine in Ireland. If Deputies consumed some of the Irish coal they would know what it is like. All this drivel and waste of time should be put a stop to. It is an extraordinary thing that Deputies who do not employ any person should come along and lecture Deputies who do employ people as to what they should do. Why do not Deputies on the other side start some industry or do something except talk about Deputies over here and say that we do not know anything and do not do anything? It is about time that that sort of thing was stopped.

Comment on this

Is Deputy McDonogh such an ignoramus as to think that veterinary surgeons act as statistical officers? Really he ought to learn something before he stands up and makes such an idiotic speech.

Comment on this

I know what I am talking about, but you do not.

Comment on this

I am very much in line with Deputy McDonogh's last comment, particularly in relation to the Deputy who preceded him. Deputy Moore has spoken of how disconcerting it is to him to find that although industrialists, capitalists and people with information about industry are brought together, in the end there is no industry. That must certainly be disconcerting to a Deputy with the mentality which Deputy Moore revealed. Let me take one thing to which Deputy Moore referred. The most efficient part of my Ministry is the Statistics Branch. The Deputy went out of his way to praise it. Having done that he went on to state, in the good old phrase which came as a preamble, that he had heard on good authority that these agricultural statistics were most unreliable. Who is the good authority? I can counter that statement by saying that I have heard on better authority that they are very reliable and that will carry as much weight as the Deputy's statement. Who are those reliable authorities to whom the Deputy opens too willing an ear in order to get anything that will damage even what he described as the best section in this Department?

Comment on this

I am not at liberty to reveal it.

Comment on this

It is like another occasion on which I was told by a Deputy that somebody had put something to him. I asked for the name of the person and I was told that he was introduced as one of a group, and that the Deputy did not get the name. Those unnamed individuals can go round to cranks where they know that anything derogatory they say will be well received, and that is brought in here "on good authority."

Comment on this

You are wrong.

Comment on this

I will deal with the question of agricultural statistics any time it is raised specially, and when I hear what is the allegation that is made as to the unreliability and from whence that particular statement proceeds. I do not think that I should be asked because Deputy Moore heard from somebody whom he describes as a "good authority," something with regard to these things, to go into details as to how the statistics are produced, collected and compiled. Does he think that officials of the type which he knows to be in the Department of Statistics would allow a system to prevail which would enable figures to be got in the way he spoke of? The thing is ludicrous. Prima facie the case is against the Deputy, until he gives us some better statement than he has given.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say whether it is correct or not that drovers, having brought cattle to the North Wall, are asked to describe the cattle?

Comment on this

Drovers may be asked amongest others, but that the statistical returns are founded on the statements of drovers of the particular type referred to I deny entirely. It is impossible that such a system should have grown up. It is not possible under the particular officials who are engaged on statistical work, and who are probably amongst the most careful as well as the most acute-minded in the service.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister will admit that it is his duty to describe how these statements are checked or corrected? I have asserted, and he has not denied, that irresponsible men like drovers who have only half an hour previously been engaged to drive cattle to the North Wall are asked to describe the cattle. I have asserted that, and he does not deny it, and it is his duty to say how the statements are corrected or checked.

Comment on this

I neither accept the statement nor deny it. I say that if drovers are queried their statements are checked definitely. The Deputy might as well refer to certain other statistics collected, and a particular class of individuals could be mentioned on whom no great reliance could be placed. It is when the checks that are imposed upon these people are examined that the whole question as to how the statistical material eventually comes out is understood.

Comment on this

It is not good enough.

Comment on this

Is it good enough for the Deputy to come here and say "I heard it on good authority?"

Comment on this

On excellent authority.

Comment on this

Even on excellent authority. I want to know where it comes from.

Comment on this

I am not at liberty to tell you.

Comment on this

I leave the Deputy to it until I hear something better than any statement of that type which the Deputy simply brings in with a preamble of "the good authority." I do not recognise the Deputy's "good authority" until I have reason to know who they are. On the face of it, the statement is ludicrous.

Comment on this

Does the Minister know the method by which they are collected?

Comment on this

I have a fair idea.

Comment on this

I suggest to the Minister that he does not.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will the Minister be allowed to make his speech?

Comment on this

The Minister has conducted a conversation with most of the other Deputies who spoke.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

He did not.

Comment on this

With regard to rationalisation Deputy Moore wanted to know the Department's attitude to it. I think the Deputy has just the view that rationalisation is a big word to play about with, that it is a satisfactory mouthful in a debate. What is the meaning of it? Did he ever hear me describe the work of these Advisory Committees in the different industries, how we try to get the people together when we thought the unit too small, and when we tried to get different groups to concentrate on a particular type of fabric when there were seven or eight different types? Would all that come within the heading of rationalisation in the Deputy's vocabulary? Rationalisation means better output and better production in every way, and production in a more rational way. That is the full aim of the Department. We go in for rationalisation in every way in so far as we can induce members of the Advisory Committees to better their establishments, which again is rationalisation, and then we will bring all the pressure we can to bear upon them to achieve that end. The Deputy was disconcerted because industrialists will not start here, and then thought that possibly the State should start factories.

Comment on this

He said it was a big thing but it was not to be out of his mind—at least I was to be criticised if I put it out of my mind. We have started some things here. There was what could be called a disconcerting reception given to these. I shall take one that certainly was an aid to industry — the electrical scheme. It did not get very much of a reception from the Deputy's Party at the beginning or any other time. That was one thing we started on lines almost approaching State lines although the method we adopted tried to get away from the worst elements of State control. There is at any rate an atmosphere in this House in favour of the establishment of factories under State management or some type of State control. We have never had any indication given that the details have been thought out, that anybody was prepared to put up a scheme or to indicate in relation to particular industries the precise way in which they think Government factories might be instituted.

The Deputy has spoken of three industries — hosiery, cement and peat. With regard to hosiery I spoke at length on that in the autumn of last year. I described that as one of the best tariffed industries. I went into detail as to the amount of goods classed as hosiery that were still coming into the country and set that against the home production and gave details of the increased home production, as soon as the tariff was put on.

Comment on this

Not an increase all round. In the case of underwear anyway there has been a decrease.

Comment on this

I am talking of hosiery.

Comment on this

That is a class of hosiery.

Comment on this

I went into details on these things. I am referring to the fact that I did allude to them previously. I said that as far as what is ordinarily known as hosiery was concerned there was a biggish import of two types of goods, one a type of cotton wear which certain people want and will not be prevented from buying, and to prevent the purchase of which would certainly be imposing somewhat of a burden on the poorer classes of the community. In addition to that there is artificial silk hosiery coming in, and coming in against the tariff, and will continue, the manufacturers say, to come in against the tariff, not until a further tariff is put on, but until fashion changes. As far as the Advisory Committees are concerned, I have not heard any statement either that the tariff has not been effective or that it is not as effective as would be the case if there were a bigger tariff. I have heard some people say that we should set out to prohibit either artificial silk stockings coming in or the type of cotton stocking or sock that is brought in. Very few people hold by that, and nobody in this House has stood up to defend that.

Cement and peat are two things that have got greater consideration departmentally than possibly any other things. Cement stands out on its own as a thing that has been specially considered. There have been numerous applicants who have come along with views on the subject. People have got all the information that could be given, and very voluminous information can be given as to where the raw material is to be found, and the fullest costings have been made as to prices of establishments, the workers to be employed, the amount of electric current to be used and the resulting prices for the product made here. Up to date we have not been able to get anybody to engage in that industry. The Deputy says that it is one of the things as to which he has always been led to believe there is an abundance of raw material here. It is not so much a question of abundance as where it lies — where the different elements are situated, where they can be located together in one spot, and eventually what is going to be the price paid under the very best conditions of, say, a monopoly, as compared with the price at which the imported article can be sold here. Up to date we have not found anybody, native or foreigner, willing to embark upon the industry under the most favourable conditions, say, of a monopoly. That may disconcert the Deputy. So will a whole lot of other economic facts when he gets to know them.

Peat has been the subject of very considerable inquiries. Peat may have two or three uses — a use as a fuel, a use as by-products, and a use even as a fabric. All these have been examined. Again natives and foreigners have looked into it. The best decision I have been able to reach in the matter is that until there is an application of a very cheap supply of electricity to certain workings in connection with peat very little can be done, except to allow it to be used in the ordinary way for fuel purposes for the poor. But if anybody wants to make inquiries about peat or cement, particularly cement, I can promise all the information that would satisfy anybody. All the details of that particular matter are known and can be put at the disposal of anybody who seems likely to engage in that industry. I suppose in the end, when everybody else fails, the State ought to take it up. We will see how that will work out.

As to Deputy Goulding's point with reference to harness I have nothing to say on this Estimate. I do not know how the Deputy intends I should deal with it. He did not indicate any special way, and if he had indicated any way it would be outside the scope of the Estimate.

Comment on this

Stop the dumping.

Comment on this

I cannot stop dumping under my present powers of administration — the powers which can be discussed on the present Estimate.

The Shannon navigation has been adverted to. For that I have some slight responsibility, which I hope to shed very soon. But at present I do not know what can be done beyond the point of asking the company who utilise the Shannon navigation to use boats of a lighter draught. If the interests of navigation are to be adverted to and looked on precisely, and if the other navigation levels have rigidly to be kept, then there is going to be increased flooding in certain parts of the country. It seems to me that there is a possibility, however, that navigation in certain areas may prove not to have any great utility, and, there, examination may reveal that lower levels may be kept. In that event flooding will certainly be lessened. I should like definitely to confirm what Deputy Connolly stated with regard to the effect of the Shannon works on flooding in particular areas. So far from its having caused any further damage, testimony has been borne that in considerable areas of the country the old-time flooding caused through the waters of the Shannon has been lessened to a very considerable extent. As a matter of fact, the better regulation of the two upper loughs as well as these navigation levels led to a runoff being achieved at better periods of the year.

Comment on this

My statement with regard to the Shannon scheme was to improve things with respect to flooding.

Comment on this

I am confirming what the Deputy said. There are outstanding questions with regard to flooding around Lough Derg which is alleged to be due to the Shannon works and about which engineering inquiries are going on. Deputy Davin criticised the Trade Loans Act, and what he called the Department's policy of standing still in transport matters. In these two things and everything else considered vis-a-vis unemployment there has been certain activity. Certain employment has resulted. A wage fund of a certain big amount was created for a period in which the Act in its application to certain cases ran. In the end, this year the State has to pay the amount of £175,000 less whatever amount may be recovered by the sale of the assets in the hands of the State previously belonging to the companies which were guaranteed. I am asked what is likely to be the amount realised by these. I cannot answer that.

Comment on this

Will a return be given to the Dáil?

Comment on this

It can be asked for when a complete sale has been effected but it would be undesirable for me to state the best prices I expect to get on articles sold by me. I would either have to exaggerate, with a particular type of open bluff, or else state the true thing and diminish the actual return. There are six companies for whom moneys were guaranteed. In two of these cases, nearly the full amount of the loan had to be met by the State. In the first case on the list, Allihies Copper Mines, an instalment of £2,000 was paid and in the second case, a small instalment of a few hundred pounds was paid, but on the whole we have to meet pretty definitely the full amount of the money guaranteed and in addition the interest that had accrued. What I am expected to say with regard to these cases I do not know. Deputy Lemass gave his view of the reasons he had heard for the failure of some of the cases. In the case of the Allihies Copper Mines the reason was clearly and distinctly that the bottom dropped out of the copper market and Deputy Lemass's only complaint apparently in this matter was that we should have preserved the machinery in the hope that copper would again pick up and that the mines would be run. The best information we could get was that there was not the slightest possibility of the price of copper rising to a point which would make the working of these mines economic. If we did not sell we would have to pay so much per annum in keeping the machinery in order as well as so much per annum for rentals arising out of the leases. It was a well-worked concern. Nothing can be said by way of criticism of the management. It was simply that the market went and that the company went after it.

The second concern was a small one, but its trading results were never satisfactory. They were unfortunate right from the beginning. Here certain allegations of unsatisfactory conduct can be made against the management. We had the greatest trouble and found it almost impossible to get them to comply with the Department's requirements. Owing to the bad state of the company's finances and trouble between the management and ourselves we decided to see if we could save anything from the wreck. We may save something, but it will be very small.

In the matter of the Irish Freshmeat Company, Deputy Lemass said that he understood a loan was given contrary to the views of the Advisory Committee. I said that was not a correct statement. When the guarantee was first applied for the Advisory Committee asked for a special meeting with myself and the Minister for Finance, to which we afterwards brought the Minister for Agriculture. They told us they had considerable difficulty with the case because they said if they were to view it purely and entirely as a business concern they would have great hesitation about the first application. We inquired where the hesitation arose and they told us certain things. We interviewed the directors of the Company and got them to advance upon certain lines which we considered met some of the points raised by members of the Advisory Committee. The Advisory Committee, on their own, put to us that they understood there were certain other considerations which precluded them from judging this purely in the ordinary, rigid, businesslike way. For instance, they said, they knew there was considerable agitation with regard to the packing industry. There was considerable national feeling over the livestock trade, as opposed to the dead meat trade, and they asked us was that particular feeling to be weighed in their considerations or were they to rule it out. In the end, the particular point of view we expressed to them was that that second matter was a matter for us. Their business was to rule more or less on business lines and if they liked to send me a case which was line ball or even a case that they would not ordinarily recommend I would deal with it myself. In the end, I took responsibility for it because the Advisory Committee sent me the case simply saying that the interview had shown their mind. I, and the Minister for Finance, aided by the Minister for Agriculture, decided further to make representations to the company with regard to the management and particularly with regard to working capital if we were to guarantee this money.

The Deputy raised the point that he understood one of the causes of failure was the commission on the purchase of cattle given to people who were salaried directors. If that were a factor in the failure of the company it was a very small point. The big point on which this company broke was its marketing arrangements. They found themselves entirely in the hands of distributing firms on the other side with whom they thought at one time they had alliances of a particularly friendly nature. I cannot say if they persist in that view. It never became clear to us that these distributors had treated them in a particularly friendly fashion. At any rate, this company broke down pretty definitely on the marketing side.

The fourth company was not a company merely, as Deputy Lemass described, for the sale of milk through the city, although, even if it had been, the consideration which Deputy Lemass referred to it could not, I think, have fairly weighed with me in coming to a decision on that line. Under the Act I am not given any specific function with regard to deciding whether or not there are other concerns of the same type in a particular neighbourhood. I might have to take that into consideration if I thought the concern to which I was going to give money was likely to go down in the struggle. But if I got an application from a concern — there being numerous other ones in the district — and if I thought the concern I was going to give money to would win out, I could not conceive it my duty to refrain from giving the guarantee. At any rate, this company, setting itself out in a certain way, proposed to develop trade of a particular type of Grade A milk, and also a trade in sterilised milk delivered in bottles. At the time they put up the application one could not say that there was any other development of that particular type of trade in Dublin. The application was advised on by the Committee in the ordinary way, and finally the guarantee was given. The trading results from the start were uniformly unsatisfactory, and by the early part of 1929 there was not sufficient resources to enable it to repay the debentures which fell due for repayment. That we might have passed over if there was any prospect of the business succeeding, but by that time they had accumulated losses of a large amount, and were not able to meet the claims of various creditors, so there was nothing to be done but to close down this company.

Very little can be said about the fifth company, the Wicklow Ochre Grinding Co. It had good prospects. There seemed to be a ready sale, and even the economic geologist who was called in to advise stated that the ochre seemed to produce results of an excellent marketable quality, of a particular type, for which there was a demand. Nevertheless, although it started with rosy prospects, and under probably as good auspices as I have met in connection with any trade guarantee loan, the market did go against it almost from the start, and by April, 1929, it found it had not sufficient cash resources to meet the creditors' claims. We did not see any prospects of a reasonable life ahead of it, so we came in with our claim. In connection with that case I do not want to say anything more at this point, except to refer to the amazing view held by Deputy Lemass with regard to legal advice, that legal advice is wrong when judgment goes against you. The Deputy will have a long trail of disappointed lawyers at his door if he takes that as his motto in dealing with lawyers throughout his life.

The Glass Bottle Co. is probably one of the trade loans about which there has been most discussion. It can be stated of this company in some respects that it started with everything in its favour, and in certain other respects had dreadful handicaps to meet. In its favour was this, that it was in a tariffed business. When it really got going under new auspices it was the only concern of the type in the country. There is no doubt but there is a consuming population for the type of product it had, sufficient to give a good economic life to one bottle factory. In addition to that there was the effect of the standard bottle order upon the factory's products. It had a special advantage by reason that the marking of bottles could be done quickly and much more cheaply than it could be done on bottles from outside. These things were all in its favour — the tariff, the single concern, the fact that there was a unit of consumption, that is, sufficient consumption to make at least one economic unit in the country. Against it was the accumulated load of debt or capital liability. It struggled for a certain number of years before it had to go into the hands of a receiver. It had trouble with machinery. I am convinced that it had trouble of a serious type with the workers. There was friction between the management and the workers, and allegations of misconduct by one party against the other. In the end it was just a question whether it would peter out by reason of the strike or of certain machinery falling in. The strike won, but only in a very limited way. The strike took place, and when negotiations were going on with a view to the men going back to work, one of the tanks collapsed.

It is quite impossible, seeing all the money spent on this concern, to put any more money into it. Whether any new factory will ever arise in the locality I do not know. It is a locality which by reason of labour troubles has got a very bad name. It does not appeal as an area in which a bottle factory should be started by anyone coming into the industry, although the blame will have to be allocated hereafter in the proper way. With regard to this company in particular, I cannot say anything about the assets, because negotiations are still going on with regard to a sale, and also negotiations to see whether it is not possible to get some new company to take up the business.

Deputy Davin, in addition to alluding to this case, referred to the firm of Ailesbury. I am not going to say anything about that at the moment. As far as I am concerned, Ailesbury's is still in existence, and while in existence it would be wrong to say anything which might prejudice the firm. I do not think any discussion on the lines more or less pressed by the Deputy could be regarded as anything but unsatisfactory. While the firm lasts better let it last and leave it alone. If anything does happen it will appear in a further list.

Comment on this

Is there any foundation for the rumour that the Edenderry factory might close down?

Comment on this

What is the good of asking that question? Merely asking will only give further force to the rumour. I have nothing to do with the management. I only know if instalments of the loan are not being paid, or if the interest is not being paid. I know that there is a particular situation with regard to that matter in connection with Ailesbury's, and that no action has been taken against Ailesbury's. I do not want to be asked questions about that, because I do not want to answer them. Neither would I answer with regard to other loans outstanding, because bringing them into this House raises certain doubts about their future. Better leave them alone.

Comment on this

If it is closed down will Deputy Lemass be held responsible?

Comment on this

If it can be proved that the Deputy has anything to do with closing it down, certainly. Deputy Davin has grave suspicions of that.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass has not done his best to keep it open as he promised, I understand.

Comment on this
Joseph X. Murphy Mr. J.F.X. Murphy Independent

In connection with the Glass Bottle Co., will the Minister say if there are any negotiations going on to get other people to take over the bottle factory?

Comment on this

I can say that there were. Whether they are continuing at the moment I do not know. The situation changes rather rapidly with regard to that case.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

My reason for asking the question is that there is a tariff on black bottles. I think if this factory is going to cease to exist, the tariff on black bottles should be removed.

Comment on this

When it is clear that no black bottles will be manufactured the question of a tariff will have to be dealt with. I have been asked what is the policy with regard to this Act. It has been put to me that it is not going to be continued, and I have been asked what legislation I intend to produce to take its place. I am not so sure that it will not be continued. If it is continued it will be continued only in reference to certain applications before us. I do not want to enter into any new period of activity with regard to this Act. The operations under it convinced the Department two years ago that, in fact, this was not the proper way to meet whatever difficulties there are in the way of industrial revival in this country.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin may not "hear, hear" to this: It was started because it was understood the banks were not giving proper facilities to industry in this country. If the Act is dropped it will be dropped as an appreciation of the fact that the banks have not merely done all they could, but possibly they erred on the other side by doing more than was proper for industry in the country.

Comment on this

They certainly did for industry with a vengeance.

Comment on this

As to the question of any legislation being introduced to take the place of the Trade Loans (Guarantee) Act, I have not in mind any legislation which I would bring in to replace that Act. Taking into consideration all the cases that came before the Advisory Committee, and the cases put through my Department that never went before the Advisory Committee for various reasons, it is clear this particular type of legislation is too cumbrous. If there is certain industrial activity which has to be furthered by State aid, it had better be done by the special application of money to that particular industrial activity, just as was done in the case of sugar beet, and just as might have to be done in the case of cement, or any of the things that were spoken of in this debate.

It might be of interest if the figures with regard to applications made under the Trade Loans (Guarantee) Act during the years since 1924 were made known. There were, in all, 770 applications received. Of that number 623 were not considered by the Advisory Committee. The 623 cases can be sub-divided in this way: there were 206 determined to be completely outside the scope of the Act, and 408 were not proceeded with by the applicants when certain questions were asked of them with regard to their previous industrial history, their capacity to finance themselves, and when we sought other detailed information from them. A few applications were withdrawn, and one or two of the others are still under consideration with a view to seeing whether they can be brought within the terms of the Act.

There were 147 applications considered by the committee. The committee did not recommend — they positively failed to recommend — in 99 cases. They did recommend in 48 cases, and of these 48, 18 received a guarantee; 16 were not proceeded with again when inquiries were made. Certain applicants preferred to withdraw when they had revealed to them the particular conditions under which trade loans would be given. There were 9 applications withdrawn. There were only 3 cases in which the Advisory Committee sent recommendations to me with which I could not agree. As I have indicated, 9 were withdrawn, and a couple are still pending final decision. I have the feeling that the Act has not found the conditions which we thought were present when it was introduced. Even if there may be a few cases hereafter of the type to which the Act might be regarded as suitable for application, we can deal with them by a special vote or as individual cases. Deputy Davin, touching on the question of transport, asked me if railway amalgamation was a success.

Comment on this

A failure.

Comment on this

"Success" is the word I took down. Most assuredly I can say it has been a success. The Deputy gave me four tests. He asked me if I could say that amalgamation brought about better employment, more employment, better dividends, or if it lessened fares. It has brought about all of the first three things. It has brought better employment than there would have been if there had been no Railways Act; it has brought about more employment than there would have been if there had been no amalgamation; it has certainly brought better dividends than could have been obtained if there were no amalgamation. Has it lowered fares, the Deputy asked me. I do not know whether it can be said that the Railways Act has lowered fares. It set out to do that in the first instance, but the stress of competition has brought fares to a much lower standard than the Railways Act intended. Fares have been greatly reduced since prior to amalgamation. The amalgamation did not prevent any fall in rates or fares that would have been brought about in the ordinary course of events.

Comment on this

How can the Minister suggest that it gave more employment in view of the fact that the number of employees on the railways has been brought down from 17,000 to less than 14,000?

Comment on this

The number would possibly have dropped to 10,000 if there had not been amalgamation. How many branch lines would have survived the stress of competition at the present time if there had not been amalgamation?

Comment on this

They would probably all have survived if the long-promised Traffic Act had been introduced.

Comment on this

They would have been in the same position as the Deputy's pet subject, the Londonderry and Lough Swilly Railway, which is kept alive by a Government subsidy, and the employees of which are being paid wages to which the traffic does not entitle them.

Comment on this

The Minister appears to be proud of what has taken place in regard to the Londonderry and Lough Swilly Railway, due largely to his own action.

Comment on this

Whether I am proud or not of what has occurred there will be made clear at the proper time when that particular subject comes under the consideration of the House. What I am stating now is that in that area people are being paid wages which the traffic on the railway does not entitle them to get, and they are getting the wages out of a Government subsidy. I say that that would have been the case in connection with a great many of the railways of the country if there had not been amalgamation.

Comment on this

If there had been a Traffic Act at the proper time that would not be the position to-day.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin wanted to know if railway amalgamation has been a success, tested from the point of view of employment, more employment, dividends and lessened fares. The Deputy is himself in the railway world, and he knows the consternation there was in the railway world when the Railways Act was introduced. The Deputy's Party, although they did not accept it wholeheartedly, welcomed the Act as a step in the right direction. The directors have told us what economies they have found it possible to bring about by reason of amalgamation.

Comment on this

At whose expense?

Comment on this

Deputy Cassidy talks about a Traffic Act, and he stated that if a Traffic Act had been introduced all would now be well. If a Traffic Act were introduced it could have, in Deputy Cassidy's view, kept certain traffic on the railways. That traffic is not there. If that traffic is not there must the railways always keep the same number of employees as they had when there was plenty of traffic?

Comment on this

Does the Minister maintain that there is less passenger traffic now?

Comment on this

There are fewer passengers on the railways than there were last year, or in any year back to 1924. There has been a decrease year by year.

Comment on this

On the railways?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

That is due to bus traffic.

Comment on this

I was asked if railway amalgamation has been a success. Taking into consideration the conditions in which railway amalgamation was determined upon, and having in view the continuance of those conditions, railway amalgamation must be counted a success. A Deputy asked what was the next step that was referred to by the President in the course of a statement in 1924. The Deputy mentioned that the President referred to another step that might have to be taken if railway amalgamation did not prove to be the success that we thought it would be. I may say that the conditions have changed. Who, in 1924, when we were discussing the Railways Bill, envisaged or could have envisaged the present traffic conditions? To take what was said in 1924 in relation to certain circumstances then existing and to criticise that statement in the light of present-day conditions is not fair.

Comment on this

Who created the circumstances?

Comment on this

Take the railway situation in 1924 and the attempt made to deal with it by means of the Railways Act. Anybody who takes the then existing circumstances into consideration and who looks at what has resulted from the Railways Act — the economies achieved — must count it a success, and as big a success as the authors of that scheme ever dreamed it would be. Tribute in that connection has been paid by the directors, by everyone concerned or who knows anything about the railway world. What are the new circumstances about the growth of traffic on the roads? At one time I brought in legislation to allow the railways to run vehicles on the roads. What was the view of the House then? That it would be scandalous to give the railway companies full freedom to run on the roads in competition with the private individual, because it was then stated that these railways, huge financial concerns, could, with all their cash and bank reserves, crush out the private undertaker. We had to put limitations in the Road Vehicles Act on the railway companies, and it is those limitations that have prevented the railway companies from getting the full effects of the permission we gave them to run on the roads. That was the view of the House at the time the Road Vehicles Act was introduced. Deputy Cassidy wants us to drive back the traffic on to the railways. He complains that traffic has been allowed to go away from them.

Comment on this

I complained that you have allowed the transport system, as far as the roads are concerned, to get into a chaotic condition.

Comment on this

The word "chaotic" is nearly as big a blessing to Deputy Cassidy as the word "rationalisation" is to Deputy Moore.

Comment on this

Of course we are not all university professors.

Comment on this

It covers absence of thought on details. What does the Deputy mean by "chaotic conditions"? The public at the present day are getting transport at a rate that they never got it before in the history of this country.

Comment on this

Subsidised by the ratepayers?

Comment on this

And, as far as passenger traffic is concerned, they are getting it at less than cost.

Comment on this

Who is paying for the roads?

Comment on this

As to the roads, there was a particular scheme with regard to financing them that we accepted about 1926. We took the old money that was paid by the ratepayers for roads in 1914 and increased that by the difference between what the farmer got for his produce in 1914 and what he was getting in 1926, and said that in relation to his earnings the farmer-ratepayer was not paying more for roads, say, in 1926 than in 1914. If that calculation was a mistake then, to the extent of the mistake, we erred. But that was the principle of the calculation. Every other item of road expenditure had to be borne by the vehicles that plied on the roads. When we found that taxation was not sufficient to meet the Bill we raised the taxation. That is my answer as to who pays. As a matter of fact people are getting transported throughout this country now at an unbelievable rate, at unfair rates, rates not merely unfair to the railway companies but to competing transport services — unfair to bus traffic itself.

Comment on this

Uneconomic?

Comment on this

That is a thing that will have to be met, but as far as the public are concerned they are reaping the benefit of all this. I hold that the ratepayer is not losing but that the individual bus owners are losing and, to a certain extent, that the railway people are losing. It was not my intention that they should lose. When I introduced the Road Vehicles Act I intended to put them in a stronger position, but the House was not satisfied to do that.

Comment on this

Why are the bus owners content to lose money?

Comment on this

They are not content to lose money. They are very discontented at having to lose it.

Comment on this

I thought that these bus services were voluntary?

Comment on this

They are, and that is shown by the fact that quite a number of them go off the road and into bankruptcy.

Comment on this

They do not know whether they are making money or losing it.

Comment on this

Quite a number of them do not, but they come to that knowledge after a bit. I have been asked by Deputy Lemass to indicate transport policy in advance of legislation. His complaint is that, although I have Transport Bills in preparation, I will not tell the House — at least that I had not done so — what our transport policy is. He went on to say that he presumed I was not going to tell the House. I do not intend to tell the House that now. It would be most undesirable.

Comment on this

What do the Bills deal with?

Comment on this

That is indicating policy.

Comment on this

Does the Minister propose to introduce a Bill to give effect to any of the recommendations made by the tribunal that was established at the time of the lock-out on the Dublin Tramway system?

Comment on this

It would be indicating policy if I were to answer that question.

Comment on this

A decision to do something is policy on the part of the Government.

Comment on this

What is policy except to take a decision and to implement it? That is the difference between the Deputy indicating his Party's policy and my indicating policy. When I indicate policy people have the feeling that it is going to be carried out. When the Deputy indicates any policy they know that it is nothing more than another jaunt at the crossroads.

Comment on this

The tribunal established by the Minister to inquire into the transport problem in Dublin made a number of recommendations. Is the Minister going to introduce any Bill arising out of the report made by that tribunal, or does he consider a mere decision to do nothing is something which can be described as policy?

Comment on this

Again the Deputy is asking me to declare policy in advance of a Bill. I will not do that. The Deputy will get that policy when the Bill comes along. If the Deputy had any sense of responsibility he would realise that on such a matter as transport you simply cannot declare policy before you bring in legislation.

Comment on this

The Minister could declare that he was going to consider the report of the tribunal which he set up.

Comment on this

On that, if I were to give the Deputy an answer that had any satisfaction in it, it would be a declaration of policy. I ask the Deputy to consider quietly when he goes home to-night, would it be wise to indicate policy before legislation is introduced on such a matter as transport where you have certain financial interests involved.

Comment on this

The Minister, in his original speech, said either too much or too little. He said he was considering a Bill to preserve the railway system, and then changed his mind. What does he mean?

Comment on this

I apparently said too little for the Deputy to satisfy him and too much for him to understand. I do not see what he is after.

Comment on this

Members of Cumann na nGaedheal, with their superior intelligence, can understand that. To me it does not make sense.

Comment on this

I do not see what the Deputy is after. Would he quote my words?

Comment on this

What the Minister said is in the Official Report.

Comment on this

I asked the Deputy before to read the particular extract and he read an extract which did not prove that he was accurate in his quotation. He is quite inaccurate again. I said that previously I had considered certain legislation and that I was advancing along certain lines up to a certain date last year; that I then went along another line of policy, after consultation with the railway people. I stated that clearly and distinctly, to stated with. If it is necessary to get it home to the Deputy, I reiterate it now. I said it was part of my duty to preserve the railway systems of the country. I say that again. Is that either too much or too little for the Deputy? At any rate, it is as much as he is going to get.

Comment on this

The Minister has changed that policy.

Comment on this

How has he changed it?

Comment on this

That is what you said.

Comment on this

No. Let the Deputy take two things—X and Y. X is my policy before Christmas of last year. My present policy is Y. I said that after I had considered certain things and after I had had discussions with the railway people, I made up my mind as regards certain matters, and that I was now advancing along Y. I have already referred to the legislation I have in hands and intend to introduce, and I am not going into any further detail in regard to it. Deputy Hogan asked me about landowner cases. He made the remark that they have never received any unemployment insurance benefit. I have countered that statement over and over again, and I repeat that the only way to tackle the question is to take a precise case. If a precise case is raised we can have all the details and all the merits in connection with it brought forward, and we can discuss it. The Deputy also brought in civil bill officers. It is the first time I have heard of these gentlemen in this connection. I should like to get particulars of any case of a civil bill officer who has contributed to the unemployment insurance fund and who has been refused benefit when, in the Deputy's opinion, he should have got it. Then we can have it all out. As regards the submerged lands, these are matters that have been under consideration for a long time. I gave a lengthy answer to a Deputy on this particular matter three days ago, and discussed with him the details of certain arrangements that have been projected in connection with the prevention of flooding rather than paying compensation for flooding that had occurred.

Deputy Briscoe raised a point about the electricity accounts. He also pretended to quote from the Act. His knowledge of the Electricity Supply Act of 1927 is that I must produce within a year certain accounts. That is not accurate. The Board have to produce to me certain accounts within a certain period, and I am "as soon as may be" to produce them to the House. Is that correct?

Comment on this

That is quite right, but would the Minister give his interpretation of that?

Comment on this

Suppose I appointed the last day in the year as the day on which the Board were to produce the accounts to me — that I gave them the widest latitude possible — and that by that date the Board had not given me the accounts, what should I do?

Comment on this

Is it a fact that they have not done so.

Comment on this

If the Minister is asking me how he should enforce the law, I reply that I do not know. However, the Act distinctly says that the Board "shall" do as directed. I leave the House to judge whether that is not the law as laid down by this House. If the Board refuse to carry out the law, I presume the Minister has power to compel them.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows the power I have. If the Board make a reasonable case to me that for a particular year they could not produce the accounts before the particular date, does the Deputy say I should dismiss them?

Comment on this

No, but the Minister should have told the House that the Board had put up that case and that he could not get the accounts within the year.

Comment on this

If the Deputy had not interrupted me, I would have told him that. The Board have made the case that with regard to the accounts of last year they have had considerable difficulty. Notwithstanding that, I am not specially satisfied with the particular reasons they have given, but all that can be discussed when the accounts are laid before the House. I have had many promises as to when the accounts are going to appear. The last promise I got was that these accounts would be in hand, if not this week, then certainly next week. That does not mean that they will reach this House, because I have certain consideration to give them. Undoubtedly, there has been delay. It will remain to see how far the delay is excusable.

Deputy Davin asked for determination from me yesterday as to how far there ought to be a national policy with regard to industry — whatever that phrase means. What is the Labour policy with regard to industry? I read an interesting correspondence during the year between members of the Labour Party and the Fianna Fáil Party as to which of the Parties had failed to insist that some of the new profits of tariffed industries should be passed on to the workers. Is that the attitude of Fianna Fáil and Labour with regard to tariffed industries? In the case of all industries which have been tariffed, the tariff has been imposed mainly because the industries are in an infant state and need protection. We imposed tariffs which, in the main, without exception, in the beginning, imposed an extra cost on the consumer, by the very fact that they gave less profits originally to the manufacturer. In those circumstances, Labour is determined not merely to ask for its full pound of flesh but to have something else passed on to it, without regard to the fact that it is an infant industry which is concerned. Is that the best that Labour can offer us as an industrial policy for the future?

Comment on this

What industry is the Minister referring to?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Gas.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Has the Minister abandoned the live-register figures?

Comment on this

The live register figures are no index to unemployment. They are an index to unemployment in the insurable trades. That is the beginning and end of everything I ever claimed for them. They are substantially accurate in so far as the business to which they refer is concerned. For any other purpose, the books are useless. The Deputy himself stated the reason — that the books may indicate people in employment but who are not in insurable employment.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

A small percentage.

Comment on this

The Deputy says a small percentage but I say a big percentage. That is where we differ.

Comment on this
Division

Motion to refer back, put.

Tá 54
·
Níl 76
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?