We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Vote 52—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 164–326 of 326. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Why should we produce butter if we can buy it more cheaply? Does not the same argument apply here as in the case of wheat?

Comment on this

No. I will answer that. I said that the only reason why butter is being produced in this country is because it is a side-line to cattle-raising, pig-raising, and other industries. We cannot have cattle without milk, we cannot have pigs without milk, and we turn our surplus milk into butter.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy say why we should produce pigs at all if we can buy them more cheaply?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Can we buy them more cheaply?

Comment on this

I am speaking about butter.

Comment on this

Does not the same argument apply here as in the case of wheat?

Comment on this

I was at a show yesterday where you could buy pigs twelve weeks old for £1. I do not see how we can buy pigs from other countries as cheaply as we can rear them.

Comment on this

Ask Deputy Gorey.

Comment on this

I do not desire to go into all these intricacies now. I am speaking on behalf of the butter industry and making the plea that the House should face the question and deal with it, either by the strong arm of legislation or by financial assistance, so that the industry would be put on a proper basis and our produce exported and sold in the right way. I have had something to do with the creamery industry and I say it is utterly futile for a small creamery to think that it can sell butter in the British market economically. We must have a proper selling organisation like other countries and put our butter on the market in the best condition and get the very best price for it.

Comment on this

Deputy Haslett was the only member of Cumann na nGaedheal who really made any effort to defend the agricultural policy of the Minister.

Comment on this

I am not a member of Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy deserves a token of appreciation from the Minister for making the best case that could be made for the Minister's policy. He comes out boldly with the statement that the only reason we should do anything in this country in the line of agriculture is as a side line to help us to produce cattle and pigs. He thinks that the policy of this country should be aimed at the production of cattle and pigs. That is the old, traditional policy of the country and it is the policy which the Minister has adopted, but he has not adopted the argument quite as successfully as Deputy Haslett, who said that we should not produce what is a drug on the market and what can be bought at half the cost of production. Deputy Haslett and the Minister for Agriculture should look into the future and try and judge the future by what has happened in the past. They should see that we have been driven out of one farm crop and product after another simply because other countries grew so much of these products that they became a drug on the market and could be dumped into this country and England at half the cost of production.

We have been driven out of the tobacco market, though at one time we produced enough tobacco to supply eight millions of our people, and then had enough to export. We were driven out of wheat production though we produced sufficient wheat for 8,000,000 people, and had some to export. Anyone with an eye in his head can see that if the policy of foreign countries is to continue to produce butter, and dump it on the British and Irish markets, the farmers in England, Ireland, and other countries similarly situated are going to be driven out of production. Deputy Dr. Ryan gave us figures showing the decrease in the growing of oats and barley in this country. He also gave figures showing the increase in the imports of oats and barley into the Free State during the last three months, as compared with a similar period in 1930. He showed that the importation of barley had jumped by a hundred per cent. and that oats had gone up also to a great extent. Recent information I have got is to the effect that there are many ships on the sea at present carrying oats in here from Russia and Germany, and this produce will be dumped into our mills, and turned out as Irish oatmeal. If Russia or Germany, or any other country, for whatever reasons of policy seem best to it, continues to dump oats in here under the cost of production, where will we be? We will be driven out of the production of oats also, just as we were in the case of the production of wheat and tobacco. If Australia, and if all the southern European countries, as well as Russia continue to dump butter under subsidy into the English market, and even over here, what are we to do?

I want to put these questions first to Deputies, so that they may see the difficulties ahead, and see what the solution should be. We must not throw up our hands and say that nothing is to be done, and that, as Deputy Haslett says, we should not grow what is a drug on the market, and what can be imported at half the cost of production. As a result of the Government policy we are now faced with the situation that imported oats, barley, butter, bacon and eggs will be a drug on the Irish market.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy say whether we would not be better employed in growing what we can sell?

Comment on this

Would the Deputy say what form of produce we could produce at the moment at a profit? Is there an answer to that question?

Comment on this

Yes, there is; but I am asking you a question.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is an unsatisfactory system, as the Deputy will find.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Haslett will admit that producing butter and getting our farmers 3½d. or 4d. per gallon for milk is not going to be a paying proposition, nor is the production of eggs for sale at 6/8 per hundred on the Monaghan market going to be a paying proposition. The fact is that these are things we are producing for export. We are following the Minister's policy of producing more for the British market. Other countries are doing the same thing, and the result is that the more we produce, the less we find ourselves getting in that market. It seems to me hopeless, from the point of view of the farmers, to continue that policy, to continue it blindfold, shutting our eyes and opening our mouths waiting to see what will be sent to us. If we only consider what happened in the past we will see that we are going to be driven out of the production of butter, bacon and eggs, as we have been driven out of the production of wheat and tobacco. We are rapidly being driven out of the production of barley and oats; we will be driven out of the production of oats unless we take steps to save the situation.

Deputy Haslett stated that we should only go into dairying as a side-line to the production of cattle and pigs. That is to be the end-all and the be-all of our agricultural production—the production of cattle and pigs. In our opinion farming should be conducted in this country in order to produce a better livelihood for the people, both the people who are engaged in agriculture and the people generally who are living in the country. That is the point of view from which we approach the whole question of the difficulties in which the farming community find themselves. Looking to the future, we see no possibility of our competing on an economic basis with foreign farmers.

Deputy Gorey stated that bacon was produced under slave labour conditions in some other countries. I am not saying that that is true, but I think this is true: that unless we take steps to protect our farmers they will have to compete in the sale of their produce against countries that have the lowest possible cost of production, against countries in which producers live on the lowest standard of comfort on which human beings can exist and continue to produce. That is not our standard for our people. We believe that this country is capable of keeping the three million people we have here, or even three times that amount, on a much higher standard of comfort than that upon which we are existing at present. Our agricultural policy would be directed towards that end. A man must work to live, and there is no doubt that the production of tillage gives much more employment and distributes much more wages than the production of cattle. We could produce very efficient cattle ranches in this country by turning the whole country into five or six cattle ranches. Whether it was wet or dry the cattle could graze ahead. We could do that and produce more cattle than we are producing at present. If we were simply aiming at the production of cattle, that is what we should do, but if we are aiming at keeping the biggest possible number of people on the land, then our people should turn to the production that will keep the largest number here on the soil.

Members of Cumann na nGaedheal and Deputy Haslett sneer at our wheat proposition. Deputy Heffernan said a few words and then skipped off lest anybody might cross-examine him on what he said. Deputy Dr. Ryan, when speaking, pointed out that the Government turned down the tariff on flour and turned down the wheat proposition on the plea that it was going to add to the cost of bread to the consumers. He pointed out that by keeping bread at the present price level, and ensuring to the millers and the bakers the profits which the Food Prices Tribunal said were fair, we could produce all the wheat we need in this country at a cost or at a subsidy of half a million pounds. That was on the basis of giving the farmers 30/- per barrel for wheat. I think that if Deputy Haslett got the opportunity of producing wheat and had a guaranteed market at 25/- per barrel, he would have very little else on his farm. He would give up producing eggs at 6/8 per hundred and butter at 100/- per cwt. If Deputy Heffernan or anybody else says that on our wheat scheme it would cost three and a half millions to subsidise all the wheat we could produce, then the fact of the matter is that the consumers of the country are paying three millions too much for their bread at the present time. If they have as great a sympathy with the consumers as the people in Cumann na nGaedheal occasionally have, when they want to argue against some Fianna Fáil policy, they should see that the price of bread is reduced for the consumers by £3,000,000.

The average price of bread in 1930 was between 9½d. and 9¾d. per loaf. A fair price of flour on that basis, according to the report of the Food Prices Tribunal, would be 43/11 per sack. A fair price for wheat which the miller could afford to give the farmer on that basis, on the basis of 43/11 per sack, would be 30/- per barrel. If you deduct for moisture and milling 2/3, you have 27/9 which the miller could afford to give to the farmer. Therefore the subsidy the State would be called upon to pay would be, for four and a half million barrels of wheat, four and a half million times 2/3. That is roughly half a million pounds. These figures are given on the assumption—they cannot be contradicted—that all the wheat could be produced here and the bread made out of it sold here at the present price. It would only cost a half a million pounds to do it.

Supposing that it did cost £2,000,000 to do it, I believe myself that it would pay us well. We have no other crop to turn to in order to reduce our adverse trade balance. I think it was Deputy Flinn who once said that a nation is simply a larger family. If I went to some Cumann na nGaedheal T.D. to-day, or even to Deputy Haslett, the best Cumann na nGaedheal T.D. of all, and pointed out to him where, by giving £2 to some idle relative of his who was living with him, he could save himself buying £7 worth of goods in the shop, he would say it was a very good proposition for the spending of £2. That is the situation we have here. We have many thousands of idle hands and idle people whom we have to support by doles, rates and other ways in charity. We are keeping these people, and we believe that it would be good national policy to employ our idle people on the land by giving them the necessary £2,000,000 to produce the wheat we require in order to save ourselves from giving the foreigners £6,000,000 or £7,000,000 for the wheat we import. It is the same proposition as the farmer giving his son £2 to produce something for which the farmer would have to pay £7 in the shop. The spending of that £2,000,000—and we would be giving it to our own people— would save us from sending £6,000,000 or £7,000,000 to the foreigner for what we are able to produce ourselves.

However, I do not think that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party are going to adopt the wheat policy, and they will simply content themselves with refuting our arguments. I am sure there are several Cumann na nGaedheal farmers quite satisfied that our policy should get a trial, but I do not think they will support us in giving it a trial until the Cumann na nGaedheal Party is out of office.

The Minister, in his statement, said that we were spending £137,000 on education and research. I would like to ask him if he is satisfied that we are getting the best possible value for that money? It is a large sum to spend in addition to the four and a half millions already spent on education. Honestly, I do not think that education in the country is showing any great improvement as a result of a yearly expenditure of almost five million pounds. We are an agricultural people, and 75 per cent. of our people are depending for their livelihood on our agricultural production. Education should be directed as far as we can direct it to giving our people an interest in the land, and teaching them to become better farmers. Practically nothing has been done in the primary schools. We had that out on the Vote on Education. The Minister for Education himself does not seem to be interested enough in the matter to discuss it. The Minister for Agriculture must see that agricultural education is one of the first requirements of the country. The Dáil spent a lot of time last year passing legislation to compel farmers to do this thing and the other thing, to work their farms and to market their produce on the best possible lines, on lines which properly educated farmers would say that they should follow. This £137,000 is now being spent in addition to what we are spending on primary and secondary education. I think we are not getting the best possible value out of it.

The system the Department and the county committees of agriculture follow is to have itinerant instructors. A college or two is being kept up for the purpose of training these instructors. This instruction can hardly come to anything. A lot of the time of the instructors is wasted in collecting the classes. They get very poor results in most counties, even on the first few nights, and after the first few nights these classes melt away. Take the average county, on which we are spending £1,000 a year on these instructors, and I suggest that if we spent half of that thousand, and gave £50 each to ten farmers' sons between the ages of 17 and 18 years, to enable them to go to one of several colleges which might be established throughout the country, and keep them there for a year, the whole training being devoted to teaching them to be better farmers, and training them to go back to the land, and make a success of their own farms, we would get more value for our money in that way.

At the moment any agricultural education that is being given is directed towards turning out those itinerant instructors. Glasnevin is practically entirely devoted to that. They are making the best job they can of it, but, in my opinion, the system is not right. I think we are turning out good men if they had a proper opportunity of passing on the knowledge they have acquired. I think that the best system of passing on that knowledge that the professors and teachers have acquired is by the setting up of other colleges organised solely for the purpose of training farmers to go back and work on their own land. We are turning out plenty of teachers at the moment. But it is difficult for them to pass on the knowledge that they have acquired. The classes they organise are difficult to organise. This takes up a lot of their time, and the classes are very poorly attended. They cannot do much work in that way, particularly when the students they get have no preliminary training whatever. Itinerant instructors might as well be talking Greek to them as reading out to them a comparatively simple lecture on the up-to-date methods of agriculture. I think it would be a good thing to have this Vote referred back.

The Minister is not taking cognisance of what is going on in the world or what this country is going to be faced with in the future. He is creating a very nice machine. He is going to have very nice butter, very nice eggs and very nice bacon, and he has very nice machinery for producing these. Even if the Minister had nice butter, nice bacon and nice eggs the time is coming when it will be impossible for him to sell these commodities abroad at economic prices which will pay the farmers. We have the whole agricultural machinery dressed up but it will have nowhere to go. Deputy Dr. Ryan pointed out that the people in our towns and villages buy £10 per head of their agricultural produce from the farmers, as against 13/- per head that the English population buys from them.

It is fifteen times more worth our while to set Irishmen working somewhere in our own country than to set Englishmen working in England. It is better for the Irish farmers that one Irishman would get work in an Irish town or village than that fifteen Englishmen would get work in English towns or villages. That blows sky-high the argument of the Dublin Chamber of Commerce that the only hope for agriculture is that there should be some increase in prosperity in England. The hope for agriculture here is that we should have a Government that would devote its attention to creating a market that would be protected for the Irish farmer, a market in our own towns and villages. Instead of subsidising the export of butter and giving cheap butter to John Bull in order that we may create foreign credits so as to enable us to import wheat, it would be much better to subsidise our young people to produce the wheat and the other agricultural products which we are importing. If we only produced here the agricultural produce which we are importing we would not have a single idle man or woman who is willing to work.

Even if the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies have not the courage to go into the Lobby and express the disgust a great number of them must have at the whole outlook of the Government in regard to agriculture, I hope they will put the screw on within the Party and make the Government adopt a little more of the Fianna Fáil policy. The Government have already adopted a few ideas that they swore they never would adopt. A couple of years ago they said the land could not be vested for a great number of years. Suddenly they adopted the Fianna Fáil way, and they are now going to do the vesting within a period of two years. If Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies threaten the Government again as they did on the occasion of the last Budget I think they can get the Minister for Agriculture and others to adopt the Fianna Fáil method of dealing with agriculture. We will then be able to get decent prices for what we can produce, and we can give employment to our young people rather than to foreigners.

Comment on this

It would seem that the natural duty of an agricultural community, a community which is fully 70 per cent. agricultural, would be to produce all the food requirements of the country. It does not seem to me to be any argument that that food can be bought at a cheaper price from other countries. If we take the position of meat production, I think most Deputies will agree with me that owing to the economic depression on the other side the working population of England is being gradually forced to use what is known as cheap foreign meat. In other words, they have to use what is called frozen tack. It is cheaper than chilled meat, even. I have not the slightest doubt that chilled meat is really good meat, and few of us would be able to recognise any difference if we found it cooked. I want to point out that the industrial population of England will become accustomed to that meat because of the severe economic depression that exists there, and, as we know, when people once get into a certain habit it is very hard to eradicate it. Any Deputy may argue just as Deputy Haslett argued: Why should we produce meat here when we can buy it much cheaper from the Argentine? In fact, why should we produce anything if we can buy it cheaper elsewhere?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We should not.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

That argument would hold good if we were in this position: Suppose we were a balanced nation with a big industrial arm. It would be quite correct then; but we are not in that position, nor do we hope to be for some considerable time. The policy pursued by the Minister for Agriculture is nothing different from the policy pursued hitherto, although conditions are completely changed. I take it his policy is one of central control of agricultural production. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, if he has any policy on industrial production, has one of centralisation. Of course, the world has begun to find out already that that is not quite a correct policy. I daresay the Minister will come to the same conclusion ultimately.

The Minister for Agriculture started with the dairying industry. He found a number of creameries in the South of Ireland—in Limerick—which had created undoubtedly a great tradition in the English market. They had created a great respect for their products. Owing to the dislocation following upon the war, prices fell slightly. With the enthusiasm of youth the Minister started in to remodel the whole system. Some firm in England —I think they were known as Lovell and Christmas—were owners of those creameries. I do not know what the sum exactly was—it may have amounted to half a million—that the Minister offered for the creameries. Anyway, Lovell and Christmas accepted it. I do not know anything much about Lovell and Christmas, but I have heard once or twice that they are very large distributors in the creamery industry. Being in the position of distributors, there is hardly a doubt about it that they had something to do with the price paid for butter. It is very strange that the butter of reasonably good quality that we produce here should not alone fetch the lowest price of any other butter on the English market, but be actually losing its market.

I think that that is the position at present. It is all right to criticise, but in discussing such a serious problem as agriculture it is good, as far as possible, to be a little constructive. As far as the butter trade is concerned, it was not very much different from most other trades that we carried on in the English market. I am aware that the English people, especially those who buy our products, object to anything in the line of officialdom. I mean by that that there must have been a good deal of error in the marketing of our butter products in one way or another. It may have been that we took no steps to advertise and that we were up against a nation which is highly trained in that respect. The Danes recognised for a good many years the importance of advertising. That may have been the case. I have no knowledge of it. But I do know that the people in England who know that we produce butter are not very numerous. The knowledge is fairly restricted even up to the present day. We have, of course, certain areas around Lancashire and we may have a small market in London, but I think that that is the extent of our market. No great effort has been made to extend it. I was informed some time ago that butter ordered from certain creameries in the South of Ireland was actually supplied by Messrs. Lovell and Christmas. I do not know how that came about. They may have had the butter bought up and in storage here, but that was the case. But there may have been great danger that, although we bought from Messrs. Lovell and Christmas, we had not completely finished with perhaps the most vital part of the matter, namely, the selling part.

Deputy Bennett asked what would we do supposing prices had increased and that there were good prices for agricultural products. My reply is that we would still criticise with the object of getting better prices. That, I take it, would be the duty of any Party in opposition. I do not see why anybody should resent fair criticism, as long as there is an effort being made to be constructive. We must all have our opinions. There is one thing I am convinced of, and I take it a great many people in the country are convinced of it, and that is, that it is time we faced up to this whole question of agriculture and realised exactly our position. Our position is that we have begun here to housekeep for ourselves and we must make every effort to see that farmers who got land at a high price are going to be put in a position to be able to pay for the land by getting a reasonable price for the commodities they produce from it. The whole world, because of sheer poverty, owing to the aftermath of war, and the foolish questions of reparations and exchanges, is absolutely dumping goods into these countries in order to get money, and that position will continue for some time. As far as our own community here is concerned, we ought to make an effort to be independent of that sort of thing and encourage farmers to produce what we want here by restricting the market as far as foreigners are concerned.

We have heard a lot of talk about wheat. Deputy Haslett spoke of how hard wheat was on land. The county I come from has the name of having very rich land. Last week, in fact, some people described it as being the richest in Europe, and it is undoubtedly very good. I wonder how that is the case, considering that it was the greatest wheat-producing county not more than 60 or 70 years ago. If wheat is so definitely hard on land as the Deputy opposite thinks, I do not see how that could be the case. The world knows that we grew wheat largely some 60 or 70 years ago and, knowing that, the world will look down upon us if we call ourselves an agritural country with rich land, and we are unable, for one reason or another, to produce even our own daily bread. That seems to me the first step towards the organisation of an agricultural community, and where wheat is not grown and milled live stock cannot be raised. Anybody who was at the Dublin market this morning, or on any Thursday morning, will realise that at least 65 or 70 per cent. of our stock are ill-bred and ill-fed. Hundreds of cattle stand up there until 1 and 2 o'clock in the day waiting to be bought. They are a complete loss. That should not be the case. We have fantastic breeding schemes here. Anybody who goes to the R.D.S. Show will see cattle in the stalls there with premiums stuck on them. Farmers go there and have a look at bulls with premiums on them. It is the premiums they are looking at. They are really better judges of a bull than the man who passed the bull for the premium, but they take the bull because it has a premium. If you gave the premium after the farmer had finished judging him, we might get on better. We are constantly putting square pegs in round holes. It is better for us to realise the position, and the position is this, that as far as my experience goes, and I have some experience, our live stock have not improved. One of the reasons they have not improved is because we gave up the system where individual choice was put in practice and have resorted to a system of centralised selection. What I refer to is this: Anybody who was acquainted with the live stock of the country for many years past will recognise that in certain counties and districts you came across excellent cattle. There were buyers who resorted year after year to these particular districts. What was the reason? Because in these districts there were probably landlords who selected stock of the right description and gave their tenants the benefit free of their selection, with the result that you had a class of stock really suited to the districts. What is the case at present? Bulls are selected in the show yard and they get a premium. The men who select these bulls do not know a single thing about the cows in the area to which the bulls are going or the particular breed of bulls that would suit that area. The whole enticement is that the bull had a premium and down he goes. A few years ago, for one reason or another, whether it was the policy of the Department or not, we went in for popularising black polled Angus cattle. They are excellent, provided that you have good cows and that you can feed them well enough. But when they go down to a county like Leitrim, where the cows were not good, the results were really bad. The results can be seen in the Dublin market and at fairs in the country. That centralised system is not a good one. That the future of the cattle trade or beef production can be looked to with any great hopes, I do not believe. The only cattle that good prices can be obtained for at present are cattle that suit, not the English market, but the Dublin market, and the only hope of cattle producers and beef producers for the last year in the Dublin market was to meet a Dublin butcher. That would give some idea of how important the home market is, if it could be extended.

But so long as we have to keep supplying an industrial population which unfortunately has much unemployment at the present, and may continue for some time to have such unemployment, it may be possible that we are going to meet with disappointment after disappointment. We might as well at once face up to the position and realise that the land of Ireland is divided and has been given to the people of Ireland to a very large extent; but these people are not in a position to carry on the policy that was carried on in different circumstances; that things have changed now, and that the Irish farmers must get an opportunity of meeting heavy rates and extremely heavy rents. After all, in an agricultural community foreign prices make no difference internally. They would make a difference if we were an industrial country, but as we are not they make no difference whatever.

Another question that I would like to deal with is that of freights and railway transport as far as agricultural produce is concerned. One of the strangest features in the life of our agricultural community is this: that a farmer in Navan, in the County Meath, can get Indian corn, or the products of a farmer in the Argentine, in a much handier way and in a much better way and in quicker time than he could get the produce from a farmer in the County Wexford. I think we could not stand over that at all, yet it is the case. There is no effort made whatever to compel the railways to realise that they have duties to perform. It will have to be done sooner or later. The people are gradually doing it, because they are not using them. It is a pity to scrap them. We should make some use of them in the future. There is no effort being made at present to make the railways realise their duties. They were set up as a sort of military machine, and now they are a little out of range; they are not in the proper place. But we could make use of them, and I think the Minister for Agriculture should give serious attention to that matter.

I know a lot of people who last year and this year were anxious to get barley for feeding stuff, but they could not get in contact with any of the barley suppliers. There was surplus barley to be sold in Wexford and in other counties. I saw oats offered for sale in Oldcastle at 12/6 on a Monday, while on the Saturday before it was only worth 7/- or 8/- in Wexford. As long as that kind of thing goes on we could not claim to be an organised agricultural community at all. I am confident that it would pay the farmer and that it would pay the State a lot more if that particular question of railway transport was properly attended to. If we do export, and of course we do export, a large amount of cattle, the organisation of the railways is very important to us.

It is quite true that when our cattle leave Dublin in the boats, we have no chance of control over them, but I do not think it will be very long until we have some chance of getting control there. The shipping companies are controlling the railways now, and the cost of sea transport is far higher than land transport. I take it that there is no remedy for that at the present time. But, at the same time, if we are constantly going into a falling market, the only alternative is to reduce the cost of production. That is one way. Some system should be adopted, and some approach made to the railways, so that they could be made realise their duties, and made to take a larger interest in the agricultural community. They could be made to realise that they were making investments by their freightage, and that, in the near future, they would be multiplying the freightage they carry from one county to another, and that their duty ought to be to develop an inter-county trade. I think some attention should be given to that.

Another thing I would like to mention is this. For the last three or four years we have been gradually developing into a store cattle producing country. The meat trade is not followed up as it used to be. It seems not to have been a profitable trade, with the result that a great many people are going in for producing stores now. That is very hard on the land. The small farmer who got a new division of land, must perforce produce stores. Stores deteriorate the land rapidly, and there is no scheme for supplying any form of manure, artificial or otherwise. I think it would be well to consider some scheme, either by annuity payment or other means of payment for this manure, because the farmers are unable to buy it at the present time. If we adopt the policy of reducing the cost of production and at the same time of increasing production, which is the only way in a falling market, it would be wise to consider some scheme whereby we could supply farmers with artificial manure at a price to be payable over a period of years. It would give a great fillip to production, and it would give great assistance to the farmers to meet their land annuities, which, I take it, must be met. It is our duty to help them to meet them, and if we do not I suppose they will not be able to pay them. There is this last point I want to make, and I hope the Minister will tell us something about what he is going to do next year about it. It is not very important, but it is, no doubt, a little irritating.

He sends certain gentlemen round every year. They are necessary. I do not make any complaint about his sending them around. They are weed inspectors, but I do not know how he selects them. In the County Meath a good number of people were fined for not having their thistles cut. The cases did not come up until October or November, and one of these gentlemen who, it would appear, are selected from Kerry and Mayo, or other distant counties, comes back again to Meath to give evidence at very great expense.

The result, of course, was that the expenses were enormous. I think it would be a good job if the Minister could select some one near at hand to do that work, or that the prosecution should take place at once. It is hard lines on a man to be fined 5/- for not cutting his thistles, and then have to pay £3 or £4 expenses. That is one of the things I complain of. I think, too, that the Minister should do something to assist the fruit-growing industry in the County Meath. It is an important one. I refer to raspberry production in the Duleek area which is valued at something like £7,000 a year. The price last year was not as high as the year before, but the crop produces in or about £7,000 a year. That is an industry that could be very highly developed. I would be glad if the Minister would see that more attention was paid to it. There is also a district in the Co. Meath where young trees are raised. That particular work gets very little attention from the Department. I am told that most of the trees raised there are exported. Under the forestry scheme that is now in operation I think it would be a good thing if arrangements were made for the purchase of young trees in that area and have them planted in other parts of the country. I am sure that particular development has already been brought to the notice of the Minister.

What I want to draw particular attention to is the importance of developing fruit-growing in the area in which it has been carried on. I believe there is room for big development there, and that it should receive special attention from the Department. I do not know that any assistance is given to the fruit-growers. Some years ago a few people seemed to know of their existence. I think they ought to get encouragement. There are certain districts in the country suitable for the production of particular commodities, and I think the aim in our agricultural economy ought to be to encourage them as much as possible. The future of this country does not lie along the line of policy pursued up to the present. The political and economic changes that have taken place demand a complete change of policy. I believe our policy ought to be to develop along the lines of producing all our requirements as far as we can. If the growing of wheat is not made a national scheme at least we should give every encouragement to farmers to produce as much wheat as they need themselves for their own households.

Comment on this

The most amusing part of this debate has been the constant reference from the other side to the amateur farmers on this side. Apparently the sanctum around the Minister must be preserved—the yarn that he is It, that the lawyer-Minister is "It" in agriculture—ably assisted by Deputy Heffernan. Because Deputy Heffernan formed a political party and called it the Farmers' Party, therefore, everybody else who speaks on this subject is only a politician, notwithstanding the fact that eighty per cent. of the inhabitants of this State earn their livelihood from the land and that eighty per cent. of the representatives in this House are sprung from the soil and represent rural constituencies. The situation appears to be that anyone who speaks on this subject is only an amateur farmer unless he sits behind the Minister for Agriculture. Those who sit behind him sing their paeans and hymns of gratitude because he has carried on the policy of Plunkett House, the policy of grass, which he inherited from the British. Since the inception of this State he has seen the home market for bacon, butter and oats snatched from under his eyes and the Poles come in and capture the bacon market. He has seen the Germans come in and capture the oats market. We have all this praise for him and his policy, the policy carried on by Plunkett House. There is this difference between the Minister's policy and the policy of Plunkett House. Under the policy of Plunkett House the people disappeared and the number of cattle and sheep increased. Under the Minister's policy the people are disappearing and the number of cattle and sheep is decreasing. The statistics issued by the Minister's Department prove these facts.

We heard a masterly speech from Deputy Gorey about embarking on the growing of wheat because the world price for wheat had declined. Deputy Gorey apparently closes his eyes to the fact that the price of every other agricultural commodity—butter, eggs, oats and bacon—has decreased to the same extent as the price for wheat. If Deputy Gorey's argument is a sound one, that because the international price of wheat has decreased, we should not grow wheat, then equally we should not produce butter, bacon, eggs or poultry. Deputy Gorey seems to forget, when speaking about the international price of wheat, that at present there is an International Conference sitting in London dealing with that particular subject, with the suggestion of rationalisation and of curbing export. It is a world problem, just as the production of every other agricultural product is a world problem to-day. But, as Deputy Derrig indicated in the debate, our policy should not be guided by the particular circumstances of a particular year or couple of years. It should be directed to the production of essential food supplies for the community and of keeping the greatest population possible on the soil of Ireland. Certainly that is not the policy of the Minister for Agriculture.

Previous speakers have dealt with the amount of money spent on agricultural instructors. With the exception of the Land Commission, in my opinion the money spent on these agricultural instructors is the greatest waste that I know of. Every reasonable Deputy knows that you might as well not have these instructors in the counties they are operating in at present.

Tillage has declined, production of cereals has declined, and is declining every year. Has the fact that these agricultural instructors are in the counties made for the production of one extra acre of any crop? I know of no greater waste of money than the payment of these agricultural instructors, and it would be cheap if they were pensioned off for the rest of their lives. I suggested previously that one of these men should be put on an average sized farm and told to carry out his schemes there. Let him pay for his pet schemes out of revenue, and we will see how he will make it pay or how he will knock a living out of it. We had a lecture from Deputy Gorey about the privilege we enjoy from the English wholesaler and the English consumer. One would think that they were standing at Holyhead and at the Liverpool docks, crying out that they wanted nobody's products but Paddy's products. Dealing with that subject the Ministry as a whole have done nothing to break the shipping combine which transports practically all our agricultural products. Leaving aside the collapse of world prices, one of the factors tending to keep down prices for Irish bacon on the London market is the mishandling that goes on on the London, Midland and Scottish Railway. Boats due to leave Dublin at 12 midday with cargoes of bacon have not left at 12.30, 12.45 or 12.50. They have missed the connections on the other side, with the result that the bacon arrives late for the market. That affects quotations all round, and I have absolute proof that it has occurred more than once. It has occurred dozens of times, and the Minister has done nothing to tell that combine, which enjoys a privilege and a monopoly here of the transport of Irish produce, that they will have to render some account of themselves.

I notice that under sub-head G 3, for the improvement of live stock, a sum of £9,000 approximately is allocated for that purpose. If the Department of Agriculture is the greatest Department in Europe, we expect a very high standard from it, and we do not expect a happening like what I am going to relate to occur, which is a discredit to the officials concerned, and a discredit to the Department. Last May a constituent of mine endeavoured to buy a stallion in Ballymena and to license him in County Longford. He received a letter from the Department stating that they would not license the horse in the Free State and that they would not let him in on any account. That stallion is standing in County Galway this year, the Minister's own constituency. Another constituent of mine endeavoured to buy a horse in County Louth, and he got a letter from the Department stating that they would require to have the sire examined before deciding whether a licence could be granted. Notwithstanding that letter two of the Department's officials went to the man in County Louth and offered to buy the horse from him without any examination.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Any examination of the sire?

Comment on this

Apparently an examination was required according to the letter.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Read the letter.

Comment on this

"With regard to the question of a licence under the Horse Breeding Act the Department would require to have the sire examined before deciding whether a licence could be granted. If, therefore, you decide to purchase this stallion the Department would be prepared to have it examined when you advise this office of its arrival at your stables."

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

How do you know but the sire was examined?

Comment on this

I know from the man who owns the sire that he was not examined by the Department's officials, and that they went there to buy him. They may have had intimation as to his breeding. He had it examined in this case and certainly it was a very funny examination. The horse would not be allowed into the Free State then, yet he is standing in County Galway. Deputy Gorey referred to premiums for bulls and mentioned that good bulls were sold at a cheap price. That is easily understandable and I think Deputy O'Reilly has dealt very well with the point. People are going in for breeding good bulls now and the fact that a premuim is attached to a bull enhances its price.

Deputy Davin dealt with the question of credit for farmers. When is the Minister going to set about providing cheap credit facilities for farmers? The profits from agricultural production at present do not allow for the payment of large interest on money advanced. The conditions that obtained when a certain institution was set up in this State do not obtain now. Never was there greater necessity than now for the provision of cheap credit for farmers. One proof of that is this, that the estimated sum required for the Agricultural Credit Corporation has not been absorbed, and there is no likelihood of its being absorbed at the present rate of interest, because farmers realise that they could not carry on production and meet the interest which they would have to pay if they borrowed from the Agricultural Credit Corporation. Deputy Davin said something about the repudiation of liabilities or debts having a reflection on the amount of credit advanced to farmers. Deputy Davin knows very well that that has got nothing whatever to do with the policy of the joint stock banks. He knows that because of their inflationary advances they cannot get paid in inflation prices and that they are not advancing credit now. That is the reason they are not giving four months bills and that is the reason they co-operated in the setting up of the Agricultural Credit Corporation. The Minister is carrying on the old policy. Every undertaking, such as the beet industry and the creamery industry, has gone to pieces in his hands. Being an ardent free trader he has not done the obvious and the right thing to save these industries.

Consequently the result of his free trade is that all these industries are at the mercy of the international depression at present existing. A policy of agriculture should aim at keeping the greatest number of people on the land. It should aim at providing the necessary food for the people of the country, irrespective of taste and irrespective of the desires of the rich city man. If war arose, if an emergency arose, if a famine arose, the rich city man would be very glad to put up with wholesome food that would sustain life for him. The ordinary, average man in the country cannot choose and make a decision between this quality and that quality of bread. The quality of bread is a very minor consideration compared with the maintenance of the population of the country and its natural increase. The present policy is, as I have said, a continuation of the previous one and it means a decrease of population, big ranches, the wiping out of the small farmer, and the establishment of a new landed class on whose land nothing will roam but the proverbial herd and his dog.

Comment on this

I am not in a position to question the honesty of the speeches made in this debate, but if there is one Deputy more than another who should be praised for the honesty of his speech it is Deputy M. O'Reilly. He said that even if agriculture were prosperous it should be criticised for the sake of criticising it. Though he said many things that were really true we did not know exactly what he meant by other statements. He gave credit to many branches of agriculture, but he went on to say that he was criticising for the sake of criticising. That gives you some idea of the mentality of the Opposition. We have heard a great deal about wheat growing in this country seventy or eighty years ago. Wheat was undoubtedly grown all over the country then, but most of it was exported. Seventy-five per cent. of it was exported. It had to be exported, because while wheat in those days made anything up to 2s. 6d. a stone, labour was earning 10d. a day. How could a labourer or small farmer getting 10d. a day pay 2s. 6d. a stone for wheat? I think that should answer most of the criticism. The farm labourers and the people in the towns did not eat flour and bread, but potatoes. It used to be said in those days that the food of the farm labourer and small farmer was potatoes and point—he could point at the bacon hanging up from year to year.

I do not think that it would be possible now for us to feed eight million people and grow sufficient wheat, even with the subsidy as suggested by Deputy Dr. Ryan. Again, the Department is being criticised for the purchase of creameries, but no doubt every individual in the State at that time approved of the purchase. It was, however, unfortunate that the price of butter fell soon afterwards. Unfortunately, too, a small percentage of the people objected because they had to go a little distance extra to the creamery. About five or ten per cent. of the people have a grievance, but the 90 or 95 who got the advantages under the purchase scheme did not give the Department any praise for it. The Department should get credit, for, after all, the purchase of the creameries at that time saved the co-operative system. Were it not for the purchase of those creameries it is very doubtful whether they would be in existence to-day, because the proprietary creameries would reap the advantage. If the creameries had not been purchased, we would not have combined marketing. Deputy Davin spoke about compulsory marketing. That is all right, but I wonder would Deputy Davin and others like to make good the losses incurred by the creameries in Limerick owing to the fall in the price of butter. Undoubtedly they have lost during the last few years by combined marketing. I am sure that the Limerick creameries will not have compulsory marketing, and I am glad that when it was proposed a few years ago I advised the farmers not to have it. Though they criticised me at the time they are glad now that I did not agree to it.

We may have made mistakes in regard to marketing, but let us learn by them. The criticism directed at the Department for buying the creameries should be a sufficient warning to the Minister to keep his hands off compulsory marketing. There was a good deal of criticism about a month ago in regard to the purchase of a toffee factory from Messrs. Cleeve. My opinion is that the further the Government keep away from interfering in industry and commerce the better it will be for the Government, for the Department and for the people generally. The Livestock Breeding Act has also come in for a good deal of criticism. Deputy Dr. Ryan said that livestock had not improved. We had exactly the same sort of criticism a few days ago in connection with education, and we were told that the standard of education to-day is worse than it was thirty years ago. Deputy Dr. Ryan thinks that livestock to-day is inferior to that of thirty years ago. It is not, and that is proved by the fact that the British Government are copying our Act. The Act has been a success. It has not been 100 per cent. success, because it is very hard to get a standard animal all-round. I agree that it is difficult for the Department to try and get people to take that view, but we are prepared to help the Minister in that respect. I suggest to him that an inspector who examines bulls at a show should explain why he rejects some of them. There may, for instance, be thirty bulls at a show, and an inspector may pick out ten that should be rejected and ten that should be passed, but then there is the borderline between these two classes. I think that the inspector should explain why he accepted some and rejected others. I do not desire to criticise the inspectors, but I know that when one of them was asked recently to say why he rejected a particular bull he refused to give any information.

Deputy Gorey referred to the fact that there were bad two and three year old bulls coming from Limerick. I would like to point out that all these bulls are not bred in Limerick. One of the objections we have to the Livestock Breeding Act is that a good bull may be rejected in Limerick, certainly a better type of bull than the bull we have to buy in Kerry to replace him. A good number of the bulls in Limerick come from Kerry. If Deputy Gorey went down to Limerick and saw these bulls, he would not be so ready to suggest that the bad bulls come from Limerick. I must also say that the Act has improved very much the standard of bulls. I say that the Act is necessary, because 30 per cent. of the bulls accepted should not be accepted. For that reason alone the Act is necessary. Somebody suggested that the premium bull is not much better than another bull which might not be given a premium. The winner of the Derby may not be very much better than the second horse, but still there is a very big difference between the two horses. An individual who is successful in getting honours in an examination may certainly not be as good a person in general business as a person who merely passes. Still a premium is the best test one can have. He gets first place and he is therefore entitled to the premium.

Deputy Dr. Ryan frequently complains of a reduction in the livestock population. He has made that complaint year after year. That must mean that our young stores are getting dear. The natural scarcity that exists makes them dearer and the producer of the stores is getting the benefit of that. It is not very long ago since we were unable to export our stores. We had an unfortunate outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease in Wexford, and Deputy Dr. Ryan headed a deputation from Wexford to get the Department to use its influence to get the ban on Wexford cattle removed.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, I did not, and I was not asked to head the deputation. I might have if I were asked. That is the fourth misstatement that the Deputy has made, and I would not have interrupted him but I thought he made it in good faith.

Comment on this

I apologise to the Deputy, but nevertheless I think Deputy Dr. Ryan will admit that the people of Wexford and the country generally were very much upset by the embargo and were anxious to have it removed. There is no embargo now and the stores are going a good price because they are being sent across the water. The stores are going a good price, which is making up for some of the losses incurred by the fall in the price of butter. That is a matter for which we should be grateful instead of complaining that the price of store cattle is too high because they are being exported.

Some Deputy complained that we had not winter dairying. There is nothing to prevent anybody in any district going in for winter dairying if he wishes to do so. They have the advantage of the tariff on butter, and we will give them all the support possible. Somebody spoke about the lack of credit for farmers. It is one of the disadvantages of co-operation that the co-operative creameries are not giving the same facilities to their suppliers that the proprietary creameries gave facilities, they were certainly recompensed, because they lent money to farmers to buy cows, and that was an advantage to them. The co-operative creameries did not see their way to do that, but that is their own affair. It is in the power of any co-operative creamery, as the members wish, to lend money. There is no bank which would refuse a co-operative society a loan on the security of the suppliers. There is no doubt that they could not get a more gilt-edged security than that.

Comment on this

I would direct the attention of the Minister to the restrictions which he has imposed on the farmers in South Kerry in regard to bulls, and I again enter a protest on behalf of the people of this area. Of course, this protest is an annual event. The Livestock Breeding Act permits in this area only Kerry bulls, except in the case of three or four farmers, with the result that the cattle have deteriorated to a very large extent. Before the Act came into force the people in South Kerry were in the habit of introducing shorthorn bulls, bulls of a shorthorn strain. By that means they kept up the bone of the Kerry cows, so that we had a nice class of stores for the market and a nice class of cows for the dairy.

I wish to draw the attention of the Minister to the loss which has been sustained by the farmers in this area by the operation of the Act. There are approximately 6,500 farmers in South Kerry in the area affected. They hold lands capable of rearing about 35,000 cows. We will assume that there are 28,000 calves reared every year. Recently, owing to the cattle being of a very small type and badly shaped, the people are not able to sell most of their cattle as yearlings, and they have to keep them until they are two years old. We will take it that half of the 28,000 are sold as yearlings. I took the trouble of going round the constituency addressing meetings, and I asked people of various shades of opinion the loss they sustained per head by the operation of this Act owing to their being unable to sell the cattle when they were yearlings. They told me that it was at least £1 10s. per head, a good many said it was £2, and others told me that it was £3 in the case of two-year-olds.

I am sure that the deputations who waited on the Minister for Fisheries and the Minister for Education during their South Kerry tour this year— people of their own colour in politics— told them the same thing. If you sell 14,000 yearlings at a loss of £1 10s. each it will amount to £21,000. If you sell 14,000 two-year-olds at, we will say, a loss of £2 10s., it will mean a loss of £35,000. That would mean a loss of £56,000 a year to the people of South Kerry, or more than their annuities and rates combined. If the Minister went down to a fair in Cahirciveen or Kenmare and told the people that henceforth there would be no need for them to pay annuities or rates, what a welcome he would get! How the papers would boost the action of the good Minister for Agriculture. But does the Minister do this? No, he imposes a further tax, so to speak, on them of £56,000 a year. The Minister for Education and the Minister for Fisheries went through Kerry last summer. I know that in three places deputations, composed of Cumann na nGaedheal people, waited on them in regard to this particular Act and asked them to use their influence with the Minister for Agriculture to get those restrictions removed. South Kerry is the only part of the globe, I venture to say, where a man will be fined for having a good bull.

I will give you an instance to show you how unpopular this Act is. There is a gentleman named Mr. Randall living near Kenmare. He found that he had been losing considerably by keeping bulls of the new type, and he purchased a registered polled Angus bull. The agents of the Minister for Agriculture found this out and they told Mr. Randall that he should do away with the bull, but Mr. Randall and his neighbours, both Imperialists and Republicans, of all shades of opinion, combined and said, "We will not do away with the bull. He will go on the run and we will shield him while he is on the run." The bull did go on the run for many weary months. He had been on the run for eight months before the poor fellow was captured and brought to justice. It is the general opinion in Kenmare that it was a great shame that the Minister for Agriculture who imposed a tax, so to speak, of £56,000 a year should have been at large while the bull had been on the run, because it was considered that the Minister's activities had more to do with the depreciation in the quality of the Kerry cattle than had Mr. Randall's bull. I would like to ask the Minister for Agriculture was there any demand from South Kerry for these restrictions except, perhaps, from some of his friends who had been selling bulls at very remunerative prices and who boasted of it in the public Press.

I think that about £5,000 was set aside aside by the Land Commission this year for relief works in South Kerry. If £50,000 or £20,000 had been set aside instead of £5,000, how happy the people in South Kerry would feel? Still there is a sum of £50,000 taken out of their pockets every year, and all for nothing. I never heard before of one section of the people being robbed without some other section benefiting but in this case it is as if it were taken out of their pockets and thrown into the sea. There would be no use, I suppose, in appealing to the Minister at this eleventh hour to remove these restrictions. I would agree with the Minister that the bulls there should be true to type and of good shape, but the people themselves ought to know better than the Minister which class of bull would suit their requirements best. They should know their requirements in this respect as well as the people of North Kerry, East Kerry, West Kerry, or any other place. If it suited them they should be allowed to have a shorthorn, a polled Angus or any other sort they wished. I do not see why these farmers should be imposed upon like this by the Minister. I suppose there is no use in appealing to him, but I hope that he will change that regulation and I hope that I will not see him in Kerry if he does not.

Comment on this
Mr. T. Sheehy (West Cork)

It is exceedingly painful to any Irishman who has a love for the Free State and believes in its future prosperity to have to listen to the speeches that have been delivered from the Opposition during this debate. Never in the history of any assembly were there speeches delivered that were so wide of the mark. The only redeeming feature about it was Deputy Kennedy's speech, which proclaimed that there never would be success in this State until he was on these benches. That was the remedy he had for all the ills of the agricultural population. For the information of Deputy Kennedy, I wish to say that I have been associated with agriculture. Thirty-five years ago I was one of the guarantors who established the Carbery Agricultural Society. There is another agricultural society and a most successful one in Clonakilty. Within the next fortnight or three weeks those two societies will hold their annual Shows and I would ask those who are criticising the Minister and his policy to visit these Shows. There they will see unanswerable evidence of the great work that the Minister has accomplished for the farmers in the last seven or eight years. They will see there splendid horses, splendid cattle and splendid pigs, and they will see a contented and prosperous peasantry who are deeply grateful. They never complain or groan. They were satisfied and pleased the other day when their lands were vested and they got a 10 per cent. reduction. They realise that the Minister cannot do impossible things. The chief charge against the Minister for Agriculture is that he is not opening fresh markets. When he went across to England last year he was denounced. At the present time he is opening markets in Scotland, Wales and England for our good eggs and good butter, and not one of those on the opposite benches has the manliness to proclaim that he is doing his level best on the lines that they want. This is the first time that I heard the Opposition say that they wished to have anything to do with England or its markets. Now they would be very glad to have these markets. What those of us who accepted the Treaty honestly and honourably—the small farmers in particular—want is that the 45,000,000 people on the other side of the Channel would give us first preference for our butter, eggs, cattle and pigs. That is a very material question. That is what the small farmers who are toiling and moiling want, and it would be well for other people to take a leaf out of their book. If one of the Deputies on the opposite benches would take a little farm of 10 acres in my constituency and work as these people do he would be a healthy and prosperous man after a time.

I do not wish to take up the time of the House because we are all anxious to see the blow that the Minister will level at his critics. He will blow all their little points to the wind because there is nothing in them. They have over and over again put him in the pillory but he is admired and respected and he is received throughout the length and breadth of the Twenty-Six Counties with the cry, "Bravo, little Paddy Hogan."

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

In the welter, I suppose I had better pick out a few of the obvious misstatements made and deal with them first. For Deputy Ryan's information, I want to tell him that we have no regulation prohibiting the use of ripened cream. There is no such regulation in this State and, in fact, some of the creameries are using ripened cream. They are gradually abandoning it, but they are doing it voluntarily. The majority of the creameries of Denmark use ripened as against fresh cream, but there is an issue there as to whether ripened or fresh cream suits them better and they are inclined to get into fresh cream. Here, the creameries are quite free to use any cream they like and there is no regulation against their using ripened cream.

With regard to the sub-head providing for payment under the Bovine Tuberculosis Scheme, Deputy Ryan suggested that payment of 50 per cent. as compensation for animals slaughtered because of tuberculosis was not sufficient and that a greater inducement would be offered if the sum paid was not 50 per cent but 75 per cent. The position at present is that the sum paid on post mortem, when an animal is found free from tuberculosis, is the full value. When the animal is not in an advanced stage of tuberculosis, the amount paid is 75 per cent. of its value, so that the state of affairs which Deputy Ryan desires is already in existence. Deputy Ryan made another statement which surprised me. He stated, in effect, that the prohibition of the use of Clydesdale and 'Shire stallions will make it impossible to get good hunters in the country, and especially in Wexford, before very long. When he started to talk about heavy stallions I thought I could anticipate him. There is, of course, a certain agitation against the line the Department has taken prohibiting the use of Clydesdale and 'Shire stallions, but the opposition to the Department's line only comes from people who want heavy horses and who complain that the Department's policy tends to encourage the breeding of hunters. They say that the use of thoroughbred stock, even heavy thoroughbred stock, with good Irish mares will, undoubtedly, produce very good horses and very good hunters, but that it may not suit every area and that in particular it may not suit farmers who want particularly heavy horses for working purposes. Deputy Ryan was the first expert I heard advocating the use of 'Shires and Clydesdales as a method of improving hunters.

Comment on this

Was it Deputy Ryan urged that, or Deputy Gorey?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am quite sure that it was Deputy Ryan. When I want information from you, I will ask you for it.

Comment on this

Deputy Ryan mentioned neither Shires nor Clydesdales. He mentioned only heavy horses. They could be Irish draught horses.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Deputy is not as innocent as he appears. At the moment, there is a demand from Wexford and Wicklow for 'Shires and Clydesdales as heavy horses; and we are refusing it.

Comment on this

On a point of correction, Deputy Ryan did not say that he wanted Clydesdales and 'Shires into Wexford. I did not hear him mention those, but the Minister said he did.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

He referred to heavy horses.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Ryan is in the House and if he wishes to correct the Minister he can do so himself.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

When people who know anything about horses speak about heavy horses, they mean Clydesdales or 'Shires. When people who do not know anything about horses speak about heavy horses, I suppose they mean rocking horses.

Comment on this

I may know a little more about rocking horses than the Minister does, but if I mentioned 'Shires or Clydesdales, when I was referring to heavy horses, it was a mistake.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What did the Deputy intend to refer to?

Comment on this

There is a complaint made by horse dealers and others in connection with the mares that were called the old common breed——

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

The Irish draught.

Comment on this

He might be an Irish draught or he might not. They say that when the present mares go, three-fourths of the mares coming on will not be fit to breed hunters.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Deputy explains that when he referred to heavy horses he did not mean Clydesdales and 'Shires. The point is that there is in the Deputy's county (Wexford), and in County Wicklow a demand for 'Shires and Clydesdales, and there was an issue in the Deputy's county between the Department of Agriculture and certain people as to whether they should be forced to use Irish draughts and thoroughbreds other than 'Shires and Clydesdales. Deputy Ryan says he objects to our levying a contribution of £300 towards advertising bloodstock. There we have to agree to differ. I think it is far more important than wheat.

Comment on this

It was creameries I mentioned.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

My answer to that is that I will spend whatever sum is necessary on creameries, but I consider that £300 spent on advertising Irish bloodstock is money well spent. There is no use in trying to get away with the idea that I am in favour of the racing man, the rich man, or the millionaire. Irish bloodstock is of profit to every man who uses the stock afterwards. The horse trade is one of very considerable value to this country. Our bloodstock distinguished itself in the most extraordinary way during the last three or four years, and it would be losing a great opportunity, indeed, if we did not co-operate with the breeders' association in advertising our stock in England and America. I make no apology for this £300. With regard to this expert on beet and tobacco, we are not accustomed to divide a man into two. This particular expert concentrates on beet and has nothing to do with tobacco. My opinion as regards tobacco-growing is well known. I do not think that tobacco can be economically grown in this country. Deputy Clery also made an adventure into agriculture. He discovered that the premium bulls are bred by very few people. They are bred by 400 or 500 people— even those which come to the Dublin show. He also said that the average premium bull costs 400 guineas. That is nonsense. The average price at present of a Hereford premium bull is about 65 guineas. The average of an Angus is about 50 guineas. Shorthorns are around 45 guineas. The Deputy suggested that the judging for premiums should take place after the event—after they had been bought by the small farmers.

The first observation to make on that is that apparently he has no idea of what the scheme is. The small farmer is chosen for the premium by his county committee of agriculture, and he comes to the county committee for the premium. If the farmer buys a bull, and if the bull is not accepted afterwards by the Department, the man loses his premium. It is clear, therefore, that inspection must take place before the bull is sold, so that the purchaser may know where he is, and may know whether he will get paid or not. The second point made by the Deputy was that the people who breed live-stock, Herefords, Aberdeen-Angus, and Shorthorn cattle, should not get the benefit of their enterprise. There are hundreds and hundreds of these people all over the country, and they are as much entitled to encouragement from the State as any other class. They are performing an absolutely vital function in this country, and it is only cheap politics to make a distinction against them. Some of them are very small breeders and some of them even with a premium make very small profits. I make no apology whatever for encouraging them by giving them a fair share of the premiums. The only thing I am sorry for is that we have not more people going in for breeding good pedigree animals in the country.

Deputy Derrig took a most extraordinary line, but you never know where you are when dealing with members of the Fianna Fáil Party. The Deputy objects to sub-heads G2, G3, 1, and some other sub-heads. G2 is for the improvement of milk production and the Deputy specifically stated that he objects to that. He objects apparently to the expenditure of £12,000 towards cow-testing associations. At the moment, we are making a grant of 4s. and the farmer himself contributes 3s. per cow for cow-testing. Deputy Derrig objects to that expenditure. He went on to state that he objected strongly to G3. That is an item of £9,975 for the improvement of live-stock. It includes £2,000 for loss on the re-sale of stallions. We buy stallions, good heavy thoroughbreds. We have had considerable numbers of them. The average farmer could hardly afford to go in for the full price of such an animal and we sell them at less than the price at which we bought them. Deputy Derrig now announces that he objects to that. He told us so. He told us there is a loss made. He has in fact now become an economist and free trader almost. His policy as announced in fact by him was to sell them at the full price.

There is also a sub-head here which enables us to pay carriage on premium bulls and boars bought by the small farmer and brought back to his farm. That item for carriage is a considerable amount. Deputy Derrig objected to that also, if we are to take the English language to mean what is ordinarily meant by it. The Deputy objected to this money given to the county committees. He also objects to paying the bonus to agricultural instructors on what to him appears to be a considerable salary. The agricultural instructor has a minimum salary of £239, which includes bonus, and the maximum salary of £495 after twenty to twenty-five years' service. Deputy Derrig objects to that payment, and thinks, apparently, that the county instructors are paid at too high a rate.

Of course, he does not say that down the country. That is a good enough statement to make here, whereas down in Kilkenny, or in any part of the country where the agricultural instructors are thought well off and where every hard-working farmer knows their value, the Deputy will praise them. The Deputy went on to say that all these schemes should be made pay. What does Deputy Derrig mean by "pay"? That is to say we should have no premiums. We should never sell animals to the small farmers on reduced terms. That is an extraordinary point of view for the spokesman of the Party that professes to take a special interest in the small farmer. Where would the small farmer get live-stock unless we give him the animals at reduced terms?

But that is the sort of criticism put forward here by Deputy Derrig. Deputy Ryan complains that we are taking money from the producers of butter and eggs to pay for other things, and that complaint is immediately followed by Deputy Derrig making the opposite complaint. We have one spokesman of the Party speaking with one voice and another spokesman of the Party speaking with another voice. That has been the way here during the whole debate. I have the strongest objection to it. Any man who has done farming, who understands farming, and who knows that you have to have a certain knowledge of the technique of farming before you can apply statistics to agriculture, must, having listened to all the drivel that we have heard on this debate from the Fianna Fáil Benches and to the complete perversion of statistics, agree with me that statistics should be put into the same category as the books censored under the Censorship Act. Statistics should not be allowed into the hands of anybody until he has some experience of the world and until he has become adolescent. Statistics have done the Party opposite more real harm than seditious literature.

We are back again, apparently, to our friends' special subject, wheat and the prohibition of the imports of feeding stuffs. Somebody described the functions of a lawyer as explaining the obvious, illustrating the evident and expatiating on the commonplace.

Comment on this

And perverting the truth.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That is supposed to be the function of a lawyer. That seems to me to be the function of the unfortunate politician, especially if he happens to be a member of the Government. Just imagine at this hour of the day and at this stage of the world having to stand up to explain to grown-up men in this country the fallacy of wheat growing. Deputies from the Fianna Fáil Party stood up and talked about wheat growing and gave the old reasons for wheat growing all over again. I can hardly listen to this particular policy. It has been so blown about that it is a positive insult at this hour of the day to begin it all over again. Mark the case made this time. It was admitted by Deputy Ryan that under his scheme the subsidy would cost £3,000,000 in the first instance. That would be the cost to this country of growing wheat even if the farmers grew it at 30/- per barrel. Personally, I have no doubt whatever that the farmers would not grow one-quarter of the wheat requirements of this country at 30/- per barrel.

Comment on this

As it is now?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Yes, not the slightest chance that they would grow it. Equally I have no doubt whatever that a very little portion of any wheat that might be grown even under the most extravagant subsidy would be grown in Mayo where Deputy Clery, who was so very enthusiastic, comes from.

Comment on this

They would do it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Even assuming that you get it grown at 30s. the subsidy is £3,000,000.

Comment on this

Is the Minister clear that there would be only a quarter of the requirements grown?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

After all, if we make a mistake it is only a small one! That is a most futile policy! Let the Deputy take his policy and examine it to its logical conclusion. If his policy is right and if all the wheat required is grown, the subsidy would come to over £3,000,000. Any other point is futility. It is futility to say if you make a mistake it would be only a small one.

Comment on this

That is not my point at all, but if the Minister is talking about calculations and figures let him be accurate.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

They are accurate.

Comment on this

The point the Minister is trying to make out is this: He first admitted that only one-quarter of the amount would be grown and with the existing present conditions that would be only one-quarter of £3,000,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That is the point of view I protest against. I would not attempt to subsidise the growing of wheat. I am not examining my own policy but the Deputy's policy in its fullness, the policy put forward by Deputy Ryan.

Comment on this

The Minister is not.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What is the policy put forward? It is that about 4,400,000 barrels should be grown at a subsidy of 30/-, the total cost working out at something over three million pounds. There is no denying that statement. A month ago I bought the best Canadian wheat for 18/-; a fortnight ago I bought the best of wheat for 16/-, and I believe I could get the best of wheat for less now. Why, the difference would be nearer to 17/-, but, even taking it at 14/-, we would be encouraging wheat growing at a cost of something over £3,000,000. That is the one piece of constructive policy that has emerged from this debate to-day.

Comment on this

Is the Minister in a position to prophesy that the present price of wheat is going to continue? The evident conclusion from the Minister's remarks is that a subsidy given in this particular year would amount to about £700,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I do not know what the price of wheat will be during the coming year, nor does the Deputy. I rather suspect, however, that it is going to be low for a considerable time. I can only examine this matter in the light of present-day circumstances. In the year of grace 1931, during the consideration of this Estimate, we have an old policy repeated. Just in these circumstances Deputies opposite chose this as the occasion to reaffirm their allegiance to their wheat-growing policy. Even under present circumstances it is admitted that it will cost over £3,000,000 to encourage wheat growing; that is, if present prices remain, and, so far as we can see in regard to wheat, present prices are likely to remain.

[An Ceann Comhairle took the Chair.]

The Deputies opposite, however, have a constructive plan to save that money. The money is to be saved out of the price of bread. They are going to regulate prices; they will see that the consumers of bread are not paying an exorbitant price; they will see the retailers will charge a proper amount and will not be allowed to make exorbitant profits; they will see that the baker is also well looked after, and they will save a big part of the money.

Comment on this

At the moment a sum of 1½d. per loaf is being charged too much here.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We import something like £6,000,000 worth of wheat and flour. Not more than one-quarter of the flour of this country is turned into bakers' bread, as far as I know. That means that £1,500,000 worth of flour is turned into bakers' bread. Out of that bread Deputies opposite are going to save £3,000,000.

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That is really what it amounts to.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister ought to be a little more careful in his calculations.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister should be allowed to make one speech.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Deputies Aiken, Ryan, and MacEntee apparently did not take the trouble properly to understand what they were speaking about.

Comment on this

The Minister is asking the House to accept the proposition that the baker sells for the mere cost of the flour.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister should be permitted to contine his speech without interruption.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I do not intend deliberately to misrepresent Deputies. They stated, however, that they believed they were in a position to make a considerable saving in the price of flour and bread. That, at least, is what I understood was their attitude.

Comment on this

I think the Minister is trying to do it, all the same.

Comment on this

But he is not getting away with it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

There would be about £1,500,000 worth of flour in the form of bakers' bread sold in the country.

Comment on this

The Minister has already stated that that is only the price of the flour.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That is the price of the flour in the bread. Out of the bread that is made from the flour you are going to save £3,000,000. Are you going to save it out of shop flour? Shop flour is about 10s. a cwt. It is at pre-war price. Three-quarters of the bread of this country is made out of shop flour. According to the Deputies opposite, there is going to be a saving made there. What I would suggest to Deputies is that they should make the saving in the bread and give the wheat a rest. There will never be half the wheat requirements of this country grown in this country and you will never find the taxpayers of the country so utterly futile and so utterly ignorant of their own best interests as to agree to pay an enormous subsidy for a crop which can be produced in other countries much more readily and which, comparatively speaking, does not suit this country.

Comment on this

What about beet sugar?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We will have a field day on the question of beet sugar. Deputy Ryan made a great point to the effect that if we had carried out his advice some time ago with regard to a tariff on flour we would have bran and pollard very cheap now. Could we have them any cheaper than they are? I do not believe we could. I am able to buy wheat at 15s. a barrel, 6s. a cwt., and I can get bran and pollard and flour for that. Do you want it any cheaper?

Comment on this

The Minister can do it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Anyone can. There has been talk about the price of butter and bacon falling. You can get bran, pollard and flour for 6s. a cwt.

Comment on this

If the Minister looks into the imports of bran and pollard for last year he will find the average price paid at the port was 8s. a cwt.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I bought it at a cheaper rate. Bran and pollard were dear for some extraordinary reason.

Comment on this

What is the extraordinary reason?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

There is one Party in the House perfectly satisfied, apparently, that I am infallible—that I am, in fact, a heaven-sent Minister for Agriculture. I agree that bran and pollard are dear for some extraordinary commercial reasons which, I suppose, have something to do with the drop in the price of wheat. I have consulted millers and men who occupy a big position in the trade and they cannot understand it. Bran and pollard are dear, but it does not affect us because we can get wheat far cheaper than ever we thought we could get bran for. I was paying 6s. per cwt. for wheat and bran was the same price. As long as the wholesale price of maize is 4s. and as long as I can get it at that——

Comment on this

Will the Minister do that for the whole country?

Comment on this

Why do you not listen and learn?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Supposing we did put a tariff on flour, does the Deputy think that would make the slightest difference to the price?

Comment on this

It would.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Does not the Deputy know that there is no chance of getting milled in this country the total requirements of the country and that the deliberate policy of the mills is not to mill patent flour here? If you leave out patent flour the amount of offals would not be quite equal to the requirements of the country. I do not think now that there is anything in that point. Though a tax on imported flour would make flour dear, there would be some compensation in the way of cheap offals. That was what we were told. I say there would be no such compensation. Deputies opposite talk about cheap offals and yet they have been steadily advocating the policy of making them dearer.

Comment on this

I only suggested it as a good plank in the Minister's own programme.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Deputy has been always suggesting it as a good plank in my programme because he is at it for the last two or three years. Deputy Ryan told us our home market in crops and cereals is worth £55,000,000. These would include mangolds, turnips, oats, hay, turf and everything.

Comment on this

I think I excluded turf.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

All right. What happens those crops in so far as they are not used for human food? Fully 95 per cent. of them are utilised in the way of live-stock and live-stock products. Suppose we do not continue the production of live-stock or live-stock products, what will we do with the crops? Put them in a glass case?

Comment on this

Continue to feed live-stock.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What is the objection to my policy in regard to live-stock and live-stock products?

Comment on this

We want both.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Deputy wants to concentrate on the home market. He complains that the imports of maize, barley and oats are increasing. What is the point of that complaint? Am I to prohibit them? Am I to tax them? What is the point of the complaint which was made by numerous Deputies?

Comment on this

That they can be produced here.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Is the suggestion that I should tax them?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Is the suggestion that I should prohibit them?

Comment on this

Have you the quotation where we did suggest it?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

What about having this debate in the third person rather than by question and answer in the second person?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What is the suggestion? That we should prohibit these. If that was not the suggestion, what am I to do? Deputies deplore that more of these are coming in. What am I to do? There can be only one suggestion and that is that we should compel farmers in some way or another to produce these for themselves; to produce maize or a substitute for themselves; to produce cotton cake or a substitute; to produce wheat for themselves, because there is no substitute. That is not only a suggestion but a statement made time and time again. And when they do produce them for themselves what is going to be their inglorious end? They are going to be used as a raw material for live-stock and live-stock products which are going to be sold to a great extent, more than 50 per cent., in the English market, at the world price. Is there any doubt about that? We were told that our home market for live-stock and live-stock products was about £25,000,000. That is so. Remember we have got that and no one can take that from us.

Comment on this

We have not got it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We have the £25,000,000 market. That is the home market. What is the export market for live-stock and live-stock products? Over £30,000,000 steadily. When we have kept out this maize and got a substitute for it, and we have kept out cotton cake and got a substitute for it, we have to feed all these substitutes to the live-stock, and we have to use them as the raw material for the butter and eggs, which, as I say, will afterwards be sold on the British market and at the world price. Supposing these raw materials are dearer, will that increase our profits? If at present pigs hardly pay when Indian meal is 4/- per cwt. wholesale, is it likely to pay when we have to pay more for a substitute, or to do with a worse article? Remember all these young stock have to be fed at some period of their life, and the cows, with these imported feeding stuffs. If they are not paying, notwithstanding that these imported feeding stuffs are lower than ever they were before, are they likely to pay when they must be fed with substitutes which will cost more? Yet that is what passes for policy on the opposite side! As I say, we are back again to the position that was deserted yesterday, and will be deserted again to-morrow, but which has just been occupied for a certain purpose at the moment in view of certain contingencies which we all know of. We are back again to the old policy of wheat-growing, no matter what it costs, and the prohibition of the raw materials of agriculture, so that they may be produced in certain counties at home. I said last night that that was the constant policy of the Party opposite, and they denied it. I quoted Deputy de Valera, and I was asked to get some proof of it. It is hardly fair to ask a busy person to read all the speeches of Deputies opposite. In fact I did not, but I happened to turn up files, and I found proof of it in three papers. This is the "Irish Times" of January, 1929. Deputy de Valera, speaking in Dublin, tells us:—

"Fortunately their farmers had an alternative to the advice of the Minister for Agriculture. They had a great home market which, in addition to home produce, absorbed in 1927 by way of imports, live animals, food, drink, and tobacco to the value of £25,600,000...."

I looked up the statistics, and I found that that figure was correct. It represents the heading for food, drink and tobacco in our statistics, and includes not only food and drink in the ordinary way, but all imported cereals, including maize, wheat, flour and feeding stuffs:—

"...the value of exports under the same heads being £39,000,000.

"Most of these imports could be replaced by home products. In grain and grain products alone, the substitution of home produce for imports would increase the gross value of the agricultural output of the twenty-six counties by £11,000,000, and would bring a net gain of £6,000,000 a year to the community."

Again I take up that, and I find that the imports of grain and grain products amount to the figure which the Deputy mentioned, about £11,000,000. They include £6,000,000 for wheat and flour, about £3,000,000 for maize, and £1,000,000 for other feeding stuffs, so that that particular item refers to wheat, flour, maize and other feeding stuffs. We are told that:—

"The intention of Fianna Fáil was, by means of a combination of tariff protection, restriction of import by licence—and by means of a guaranteed price, in the case of wheat—to reserve a progressively increasing proportion, and ultimately the whole, of that great home market for the products of Irish agriculture."

So that, as far as wheat was concerned, there was to be a guaranteed price, and so far as these other products like maize was concerned, there was to be a system of tariffs and licences. Yet Deputies coolly deny that their policy ever was to increase the price of these articles.

Comment on this

We deny specifically that we advocated a tariff on maize.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Here it is.

Comment on this

Is not there a licence mentioned there?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The intention of Fianna Fáil was by means of a combination of tariff protection, restriction of imports by licence—a combination of both. That was to apply to maize. The other was a guaranteed price, and was to apply to flour and wheat. So that by a combination of these we were to have a market. Have it any way you like. Either of two things. The unfortunate farmer, according to Deputy de Valera, was either to be forced to pay more for his maize or go without it.

Comment on this

Or get it under licence?

Comment on this

Free of duty.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Get a portion of it and fail to get the other portion.

Comment on this

All of it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The same speech was repeated in specific terms in Limerick the week afterwards. Even Deputy Ryan himself in an article announced as follows:—

"Why should we waste our time, energy, money and patience in competing against Denmark, New Zealand and the rest of the world for the butter market of England...."

That is in an article in "The Nation" of April 12, 1930, which, even though it is not the official organ of Fianna Fáil, is a respectable newspaper, and would be from Deputy Ryan's point of view above suspicion. Would anyone dream when listening to Deputies to-day that they thought so little about the butter market in England after all the time they have spent telling me that I was not doing my duty by the butter market in England, that I should do more to encourage the creamery industry and the live-stock industry, and generally, that I should do more to hold our English markets?

Comment on this

I have a suspicion that there was more than that.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I shall read the whole of it:

"Why should we waste our time, energy, money and patience in competing against Denmark, New Zealand, and the rest of the world for the butter market of England, while we could by an Act of Parliament reserve our own market in wheat, feeding stuffs, bacon, butter and other agricultural produce for our own farmers?"

What is the Act of Parliament? Tariffs, licences? What is it? Are we going to reserve it at the same price? Was that the intention then? The present wholesale price of maize is 4/- per cwt. Will we reserve a market for barley at 8/- per cwt.? Barley is to be the substitute for maize. Is that the position? We cannot have it both ways. Is the barley market in this country as a substitute for maize to be reserved to the barley-growers at 8/- per cwt. wholesale? Make that proposal in Kildare. Is that the Deputy's proposal? If it is not, then his proposal is to increase the price of the raw materials, and there is no way out of that dilemma, and no quibbling will get him or Deputy de Valera, who is a past master in it, out of it. But, as far as I am concerned, I am not going— and neither would Deputies opposite if they were in any responsible position—to have anything to do with any policy of relieving agriculture at a time of extreme distress by increasing the price of the raw materials. It is amazing to me how a responsible Party, after three years' experience, should come forward and waste hours in the Dáil criticising me for not doing it and advocating it as a means of saving the country.

They speak of the home market for live-stock and live-stock products. What is the home market worth? We have about £25,000,000 of it—we have more I think. What is the home market that we have yet to obtain worth, because that is what counts? We need not bother too much about the home market which we have got. We always have a home market for beef. No one can displace us in that. We will always have the bulk of it for eggs, butter and bacon. These are the finished products of agriculture. These are 95 per cent. of our agriculture. What is the value of the home market we have yet to obtain? £3,000,000. Add £3,000,000 worth of beef, mutton, butter, bacon, eggs to our present home market, that is to say, supply the balance. We are supplying the home market at present with something like £25,000,000 worth of these products. If we keep at home £3,000,000 worth more, we will be supplying the total home market. That is the home market we hear all the talk about! If it is not that market, what is the talk about? Is it the home market in grain, maize and feeding stuffs? It must be either one or the other. As far as I am concerned, I have made my position clear about the home market in grain and feeding stuffs. We will not do anything to increase the price of these. Let us come to the other home market in finished products: cattle, sheep, beef, mutton, pigs, bacon, etc. What is it worth? £3,000,000. What is the value of the export market in the same products? £32,000,000 in 1929—the last figures I have. Yet we are to jeopardise the £32,000,000, and the possibility of a a very much larger market there, for the sake of what? For the sake of capturing a market which we have not yet got, and which is only worth at the maximum £3,000,000.

Comment on this

Why must you jeopardise the export market?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We must jeopardise it in order to play up to the silly theories of Deputies like Deputy de Valera and Deputy Ryan, who believe in monkeying around with our raw materials.

Comment on this

Why must you jeopardise the £30,000,000 for the £3,000,000?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Any attempt to interfere with the production of our raw materials, to increase the price, any action that will make the supplies less, anything like that would make it impossible for us to compete in the British market.

Comment on this

These raw materials are not included in the £3,000,000?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No.

Comment on this

Why must we jeopardise the £30,000,000 in order to get £3,000,000?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What is our present position in regard to butter? It was pointed out that our exports of butter have gone down. They have considerably gone down. Why? Because we were exporting none in a certain period and then, instead of sending out £5,000,000 worth to the English market we only sent a little less than £4,000,000 worth. As was pointed out, and as every Deputy knows, what is wrong with our butter in the English market is that we have not a winter trade and that we have not a large enough trade. Our butter is no good in the English market. Why does Danish butter, even at the end of last year, fetch a better price in the English market in spite of the depression? Danish butter fetches a better price because their supplies are so big and regular that they have created a goodwill in which they have had to buy even at the Danish price. If our exports fall seriously below £5,000,000 worth we would lose the little goodwill we have. Exactly the same applies to bacon. The Danes supply £27,000,000 of bacon and £20,000,000 of butter. I have it from important bacon exporters that the fact that they have split up their trade into different small markets in England so that the amount going into any one market is small, while it got them an increased price for a short time, it has seriously affected the goodwill of Irish bacon. It is generally admitted that the small supplies of Irish butter, as well as lack of winter dairying, are the reasons why we have not the goodwill we should have, and therefore the prices for our butter.

It is not only good business from the point of view of the consumer at home to buy cheap foreign butter and cheap bacon at certain times, but it is good business from the point of view of the producer who is exporting both butter and bacon that those exports should be kept up even though to do that it would be necessary to import small quantities of the same articles for home consumption. And of course every country in the world realises that. Even in Canada you have small imports of wheat and in countries that produce wool you have small imports of wool. All that is necessary in the interests of trade. What Deputies opposite have to realise is that trade and commerce is a complex thing and is not susceptible to the generalisations so dear to the hearts of politicians, especially those not in touch with everyday life and business.

Comment on this

The Minister is arguing in favour of the importation of foreign bacon and butter into this country.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No, I did not know it is relevant and I do not know that I should waste time on the argument put forward to-day to show that an increase in the home market could develop industrial tariffs and that that would immediately benefit the farmers. One enthusiastic Deputy went so far as to say that if there were more tariffs there would be less old age pensions. The argument seems to be that some old woman getting 10/- for her old age pension, from the moment we compelled her to pay more for her boots or her clothing she could do with 9/-.

There is no doubt about it that a tariff policy will develop an industrial market, but for a very long period our tariff policy will have not only to increase substantially the population of the towns but will have to double the population before the home market could consume all our production in beef, butter, bacon and eggs. In the meantime we in this generation must live and we cannot allow our duties and responsibilities towards the people of the next century to commit us to bankrupting the farmers who have to live to-day in a time of very great depression.

I was asked: Supposing butter did not pay, should we produce it? We should not. Mind you, the same applies to bacon. "I, Patrick Hogan, Minister for Agriculture, or Deputy Dr. Ryan, member of the Fianna Fáil Party"—we are not the producers. We are not the people who count. The people who count are the farmers of the country. It is not a question whether they should, or should not, produce bacon. If the time should come when it did not pay to produce bacon, butter or cattle they would get out of them. I do not see that time coming. There are always periods of acute depression. There are times when you have a slump in prices, times when cattle do not pay and times when they do. The same applies to butter and bacon. But the position is that over any certain long period their production always pays in this country, whereas wheat never pays, and never will pay without State assistance. Until such time as the production of cattle, sheep, pigs, eggs and butter ceases to pay permanently the Irish farmer, whatever we may think, will continue to produce them. When these items of agricultural production do cease to pay permanently they will get out of them, but should that ever come about the whole structure of the world will have changed so much that there will be other crops. Meantime, I am banking on losing less on cattle than on wheat. There was some reference to the purchase of creameries and I want to say a word on that.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

What about Deputy O'Reilly's bulls?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

On that I quite agree there was considerable criticism of the Department's action in making regulations confining certain areas to the Kerry bull. I am prepared to go so far as to admit that there were hardships in the beginning, but what I do claim is that these hardships are getting less. That is evident from the fact that less complaints are reaching the Department. The trouble about this particular issue is that it is extremely complex. What was the position before we came in in 1926? It was that, as a result of using Shorthorn and Angus bulls, the stock there was becoming almost entirely cross-bred. They were breeding from second and third crosses and the farmers were beginning to see if that process was continued the stock would be getting smaller and smaller.

Everyone knows that the first cross, and even the second produces a virile type of animal, but that you will ruin your cattle by constantly crossing. It is admitted that the first cross is excellent. Everyone knows that the Kerry breed was disappearing out of Kerry, and that if we had allowed the process of crossing to go on you would reach a time when you would have a mongrel breed. We stepped in and stopped that. Suppose we had let it go on what would have happened was that the milk supply of the area would have gone down. In the area we are dealing with the milk supply is of vital importance because there you have small farmers and poor land.

Comment on this

The Minister knows a lot about it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I do. I have admitted that there were certain hardships in the beginning. But as a result of the policy that we adopted we have brought back the Kerry breed into that area. As far as the reports which have reached me go they show that there is less and less objection to the regulations we were obliged to make. I am satisfied that if the policy we adopted is carried out over a certain period of time the net result of it will be a very big increase in the value of cattle in the Kerry area. The fact that our policy did cause some discontent in the beginning was seized upon by certain politicians for their own interest.

Comment on this

The Minister has stated that the complaints were becoming less and less. Is it any wonder that that should be so in view of the fact that the people have got tired making complaints over the last four years?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Deputy O'Reilly does not by any means speak for the men of Kerry. When I want information as to the state of affairs in a district. I need not go to the Deputy for it. I know exactly how things are there. I know from the people in the trade, from people dealing in cattle, from the producers, the buyers and others, that their objection is becoming less and less. They are the people that I listen to.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

I would like to know who these people are. I asked for their names before and the Minister would not disclose them.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Coming to the point about redundant creameries. At one time the Deputies on the benches opposite seemed to be very concerned indeed about the state of the dairying industry. They asked what was I doing about it. The price of butter was low, milk was only 3d. and 4d. and so on. They said the creameries were in a bad way, that we seemed to have no policy and that we did not take proper steps to help the dairy farmers to tide over the bad times. I am glad they should take such an interest in the dairying industry and that they are at last coming to realise that dairying is the foundation of our agricultural system. They said that we should try to tide the people over the bad times. The very same people who wanted to know all about our policy for the dairying industry are so interested in it that they criticise me for it. That policy consistently carried out over the last three or four years consists in buying up all the proprietary creameries and handing them over to the farmers.

Deputy Ryan quoted the statement which was made at the meeting held in Limerick. I know all about that meeting. I want to say, first of all, that this was really a commercial transaction. It is very difficult for a politican to carry out a commercial transaction. When you are running a business, and it is admitted that this is a commercial transaction, you really have as your partners every member of the Dáil. This was really a big business. If I were running a big business that I had technical knowledge of myself I would choose, as my partners, people who wanted to make it a success and not people who wanted to obstruct the running of it. That is the real trouble that any Government —I do not make any exception of this Government—will have in trying to carry out a commercial transaction. The business of an Opposition is to oppose and not co-operate. A Government in trying to do that is, I admit, in a very vulnerable position in this respect that you cannot carry through a commercial transaction without, let us say, half the partners in the business thinking all the time of their political interests. But I think that I will carry it through in spite of them. As Deputy Nolan pointed out the experience that I have had in this matter will make me very careful about going into anything like it again.

Comment on this

But the Minister bought the creameries before 1926?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We bought the creameries. I am criticised now for doing so. I am running them since. I agree that it was easier then to carry it out successfully because there was a general realisation in the Dáil that this was a very big national scheme on which I got ordinary criticism. I am now criticised on a great many grounds. Will Deputies say was I right in buying the creameries? Where do Deputies stand? Is it their line that I should not have bought the creameries? I challenge any Deputy on the opposite side to say that. They will be very careful not to do so. There is no reply whatever from them about that. The general policy is sound. It has to be admitted that the idea of purchasing out all the proprietors and handing over the butter industry to the farmers and all the profits, if there are profits, was a sound policy. It is said that I bought them too dear. The first reply I have to make to Deputies who say that is that they do not know whether I did or not. They are not in a position to know. The second thing is that if I bought them for twice the price exactly the same thing would be said, and if I bought them for half the price, exactly the same thing would be said, I bought them. Could I have bought them cheaper? Not voluntarily. That is quite certain. They could only be bought cheaper in one other way and that was by introducing an Act of Parliament compulsorily to acquire the creameries and to fix the price at a definite value in the same way as the price of land was fixed. If they were got by arbitration in the ordinary way I would have to pay 50 per cent. more for them. That is quite certain. There are creameries still to be bought. I would like to buy them. I want to buy them voluntarily. I do not want, if I can help it, to have to take the very doubtful step of buying compulsorily what a man has legitimately acquired and built up. That is the last thing I would like to do, and if I had to do it I think I should have to pay a swingeing fine price. They could not be got cheaper unless they were compulsorily acquired by the Dáil. We bought the creameries and, roughly speaking, we closed half of them. It was said that we closed them haphazard. I do not regard that as serious criticism. As Deputy Nolan pointed out, it led to inconvenience. We had to close them, and everyone knows that if I had to consult every milk supplier about closing the creameries I would never close them. Everyone knows that would be impossible. Everyone realises the difficulty, and I had to go ahead and do what I thought right straight off. Is it suggested that we should have kept the creameries open?

To run an auxiliary costs £500 a year and to run a central creamery, I suppose, would cost £1,000 a year. We have closed well over sixty of them. That represents £60,000 a year to the farmers. Is not that good value for the farmers? What would it represent capitalised at 5 per cent?

We charged the farmers nothing for the creameries we closed. We charged them only for the milk supplies. We took advantage of the purchase of the proprietary creameries to reorganise the co-operative creameries in the area. What have we done? We have removed all competition. We have doubled or added considerably to the milk supplies of 70 per cent. of the creameries in the South of Ireland. We have abolished redundant creameries which must have been costing the farmers between £60,000 and £70,000 yearly. We have handed over the milk supplies at a price which up to then was regarded as the absolute minimum, £1 per gallon. Does anyone suggest that that was not good business for the farmers? They are there now financially and economically sound. Milk supplies have been doubled and quadrupled, there is no competition, there are regular areas, and half overhead expenses. What has all that cost up to the present? Deputy Derrig described it as a loss of £150,000. The loss is not so much. I put this question to Deputies who know the South and West: What condition would the creameries be in to-day if I had not bought, not only the property of the Condensed Milk Company, but all the proprietary creameries in Kerry and elsewhere? We did that three years ago, and now they are in a position to stand up to the depression they are going through. Before I bought these creameries I had deputation after deputation from co-operative creameries, and I had all sorts of promises as to the way they would co-operate. I was begged to buy them. I was told there would be no difficulty in getting them through. It was said that the State would never again have to intervene to save the dairying industry. Most of the promises made by the farmers were carried out. Is not that an extraordinary thing, even though it is the State bought them, and remember the State is always very vulnerable. I have put through the transfer of big properties—all the creameries of the Condensed Milk Company and practically every other proprietary creamery in the biggest districts in the South—with half a dozen quarrels.

Notwithstanding that the dairy farmers are going through extreme depression, the interest is being paid up to the present. It amounts to something like £15,000—which is one-eighth of the total amount advanced—and it is being paid on the nail, except in very few cases. I have not the slightest doubt that if these farmers were let alone, if politics were kept out of this, and if interested parties did not go around with the easy doctrine of repudiation of debts in bad times, this scheme would go through, with all its difficulties. I have nothing but admiration for the way in which the farmers have co-operated in the scheme up to the present. I intend to go ahead and to buy the remaining creameries, if I can. It will take time. I may say that easily the largest creameries I bought were the creameries of the Condensed Milk Co. We got these cheaper than any of the others, notwithstanding that they were the biggest. It is easier to value a small one than a big one. We gave a fair price, and I think when you buy voluntarily a business that a man has built up you should give a fair price. That fair price has not injured the dairy farmers because they were sold the milk supplies, and there was a subsidy paid in respect of redundant creameries. In addition, you have removed all competition and put them in a strong financial position. I intend to go ahead with that policy and to try to complete the process. I think that particular policy has enabled the dairying industry to stand up to the depression that it is going through at present.

Supposing it takes £200,000, £300,000 or £400,000 to put all the creameries into a sound financial and economic position, by giving milk supplies which are adequate to the overhead expenses, could the same results be achieved in any other way? When you compare that figure, say, with the cost of a tariff, or with the cost of the butter tariff for three months, when you realise that you have definitely placed the dairy farmers in a tremendously advantageous position, and made them economically and financially sound, anyone who knows anything about the matter will agree it was money well spent, and I make no excuse for spending it. I only wish the creameries in other parts of the country were in as good and as sound a financial state. They are not. There are creameries in the West and in the South that do not get the benefit of this particular scheme. At the moment they are not in a strong position, and possibly they are a problem which will have to be dealt with later. I have only one other point to deal with. I want to insist that this debate has, to my mind, continued on wrong lines.

Comment on this

Before the Minister leaves the creamery question, I would ask him to say what is his policy with regard to marketing of butter?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Deputy Davin made a strong point about marketing. I am not going to market the butter for them. It is quite impossible for the Department of Agriculture to market butter for anyone.

Comment on this

I did not suggest that.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That is what it comes to. Marketing is essentially a commercial transaction. Other countries have succeeded in improving the standard of production. We have done that. We have succeeded in seeing that they make butter, but when it comes to selling we cannot do it for them. They must do it themselves. The Deputy must know that if I made myself responsible for a marketing scheme I would either have to pay for it or do what he suggests, namely, compel everyone to come in and I would have no answer to the demands for compensation if any commercial miscalculation took place. If I forced everybody into a marketing scheme and was paying the expense of a marketing board and if the board cold-stored butter in the summer in the hope that the price would rise in the winter, but instead of that, there was a fall, what answer would I have to every demand made on me for compensation because, remember, I forced them in? How could civil servants run a marketing business. It could only be done on commercial grounds. There are some things which the creameries must do for themselves. They must market their own butter. They are doing it in Denmark and other countries. I agree that there will be big losses this year by reason of individual marketing. I set up a tribunal to inquire into the matter. They took evidence from all the creameries and they suggested a scheme of marketing but it was turned down, and the creameries went back deliberately to individual marketing. I do not think that we should interfere with them until they see the light eventually.

Comment on this

Did the tribunal publish a final report?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Yes, it was before the meeting of creameries.

Comment on this

Not the final report. It was only an interim report.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What is the final report to be? The interim report had the whole scheme.

Comment on this

They promised to issue a final report but it has not been published.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Exactly. The interim report had the scheme, but that scheme was rejected by the majority.

Comment on this

Did you get a final report?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No. There was no point in bringing in a final report when they rejected the scheme. Now about prices. It has been said that the price of agricultural produce has been consistently falling for the past five years. That is not so. The price of eggs has gone up, compared with the price of Danish, Dutch, or any other eggs, except English eggs on the English market. Equally the relative prices of butter have improved.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Before the Minister leaves that point——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister has only five minutes left to conclude his reply.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I just want to ask whether the failure to agree to the scheme is to be attributed to the committees or to the managers of creameries.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That does not matter. The manager is a servant of the committee, and if he does not do his duty the committee can deal with him.

Comment on this

Would the Minister bring in a scheme for combined marketing?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The creameries must understand that they must do the marketing themselves, and any advice that we can give them will be given through our inspectors. We cannot take the responsibility for marketing.

Comment on this

They must do it—must.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I have here a statement showing the average price per cwt. of Irish, Danish, Australian, New Zealand, and other butters for the period 1926-29. These figures are taken from the British Official agricultural statistics. I am taking the figures month by month for the four countries and I average them. The difference between the price of our butter and that of Danish in 1926 was 18/-; in 1927 it was 12/-; in 1928, 10/-; and in 1929, 10/-. The difference between the price of our butter and that of New Zealand in 1926 was 5/- in favour of New Zealand; in 1927, 3/-; in 1928, 1/-; in 1929, 1/-, and in 1930, 4d. In 1930 Danish butter went up to 15/- over all butters, as it always does when there there is a complete slump. The price of New Zealand butter came down, and New Zealand and Irish butter were the same in price. As I say, I am quoting the figures from the official statistics of the British Ministry of Agriculture taken from their own market reports. It is extremely difficult to get reliable figures. Irish butter has re-asserted itself gradually as against New Zealand butter. All the time it has been on the average over Australian.

Comment on this

According to the Tariff Commission it was 15/- below New Zealand butter.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am giving the figures month by month. It is clear that our eggs have consistently beaten all eggs except the English and those of Northern Ireland. Generally, I want to say that there is a point of view here, and it is a fatal point of view, that is, that what is really important is what the State does for agriculture. That is of no importance, comparatively speaking. No Department can do more than give a little help compared with what the farmers can do for themselves. I see that more and more every day. We have been consistently spending money on agricultural schemes in the last four years. What has been the result? It was desired to get co-operation. There is no doubt that there is a tendency among farmers to expect that if the State has done so much for production, even by going the length of giving them a tariff, it will go on and do the whole thing. You have an example of that in the suggestion that the State should market their butter. It was thought to be a very big thing some years ago to tone up production and, at the taxpayers' expense, to buy up the creameries and, further, to save the butter industry by a prohibition order. The tendency is more and more to rely on the State. I am not talking politics now. That tendency is fatal. We have our duty to do. We can do a lot generally by helping the farmers but unless they co-operate and perform the functions which an individual producer should perform we can do nothing. The party in power can do a lot to prevent the adoption of false theories, unsound, wild-cat and uneconomic schemes. We have done that during the last five years. We have stood up to any such unsound, though well-meant schemes, schemes which were essentially unsound, and we have carried out the correct policy of concentrating on the particular items which farmers are producing at present and which they are best fitted to produce. We refused to listen to any schemes directed to getting the farmer to go in for production which does not suit him and in which other countries can beat him. If we are to carry out that policy we must get the proper co-operation of farmers. With that co-operation we will maintain our present position, a position in which we are somewhat better off than most countries, despite the world depression.

Comment on this
Division

Question: "That the Estimate be referred back for reconsideration," put.

Tá 48
·
Níl 66
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?