We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Charitable Hospitals (Amendment) Bill, 1931—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 107–225 of 225. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Public Charitable Hospitals (Amendment) Bill, 1931
Enacted

No. 16 of 1931 ›

As far as I can see, several Deputies who have spoken here, and particularly Deputy Sir James Craig, have very little knowledge of the condition of the county hospitals. They would seem to have absolutely none. Now up to the present the Dublin hospitals have got £852,000. That would take fifty years to collect voluntarily in Dublin or in the country. They have got far more than three times what they expected to get. They have got £852,000 in Dublin, compared with £364,000 to the rest of the country, that is, the other twenty-five counties. I know the conditions of the hospitals in Cork County. I am sure it would rather surprise Deputy Sir James Craig to know that in the best county hospital in Cork patients for operations have to be taken up two flights of stairs in blankets. That might surprise Deputy Sir James Craig, but it is the actual position in the Cork County Hospital at the present moment. Does Deputy Sir James Craig think there is any money wanted there?

Comment on this

I am not going to tell you what I think.

Comment on this

I know you will not. In Midleton, for the last 5 years the sum of £15,000 is wanted and it has not yet been found; nor can that money be found. I quite realise the position of Deputy Sir James Craig and those other Deputies here who see nothing outside Dublin and never want to see anything outside Dublin. Their whole idea is that patients who want to be operated on must be brought up to Dublin. Deputies in this House should be concerned for those unfortunate people who cannot afford to come to Dublin to pay for operations. They should be the concern of this House and they should be catered for by the sweepstakes. We have had too much of the other talk at the present time. I think that some of the voluntary hospitals in Dublin have got enough already and should be out of the sweeps for the future. That would be far nearer the mark. I am well aware of the situation in the country, where those representing the poor would not or could not, in justice, put a burden upon the ratepayers to provide proper hospital facilities or proper hospital accommodation. I am well aware of the situation. It exists for a number of years, but now there is an opportunity of remedying the situation and I think it should be remedied. If any amendment were brought in here it should be to cut out the City of Dublin hospitals from the sweeps. They have got more than their share as compared with the rest of the country, and that is what I am in favour of. I am in favour of this amendment, and I hope it will be carried and that those who represent country constituencies will support it. We have had too much talk that everything must come to Dublin. There is too much of that in the country at the present time. The unfortunate poor who cannot afford funds to get them to Dublin for operation are deserving at least of some facilities.

Comment on this

The Deputy is cutting out Cork City as well as Dublin.

Comment on this

I am not, but I am in favour of cutting out Cork City if we could get the money for the country hospitals in Cork which want it far more, and if we could get it for the Cork County Hospital, which wants it far more. That Cork County Hospital is supposed to be the best county hospital in the Twenty-Six Counties, and if that is so, considering its condition, the condition of the others must be very bad entirely.

Comment on this

I think I can clear the ground in one direction. The original Bill had its conception in the National Maternity Hospital, Holles Street, the walls of which were falling in. It had no money to build, and a statement was made to me that the hospital would have to close. The Holles Street people saw they could not promote the Bill themselves. They applied to other hospitals, also in great need, and the result was they brought together a small committee of the representatives of at least half a dozen hospitals and they promoted the Sweepstakes Bill. That Bill was brought to me, and I was asked if I would sponsor it. I sponsored it to some extent with the help of all sections in the House, and it went to the Seanad. I want to say this, that as far as the Act is concerned, after it passed the Seanad I had no hand or part in anything done under the Act. I refused to act as trustee, and I refused to go on the Hospitals' Committee.

The original Hospitals' Committee was enlarged by the inclusion of two representatives from each hospital that came into the sweep, and these were the people who had before them the needs and requirements of the hospitals that were brought in after it. I began by speaking about Holles Street, and I want to say this, it is an example of the state of affairs in a good many of the others and would be some answer to Deputy de Valera's remarks. Holles Street Hospital has received, I think, something like £80,000—I am not sure of the exact figures, but I think they received out of the three sweeps something like that figure. Am I correct?

Comment on this

More!

Comment on this

Somewhere in the neighbourhood of £80,000. At all events the point I make is that that hospital consisted of old tenement houses and was falling in. They could do nothing else, if they were to do any good work in the future, than pull down the entire structure. The result was they sent out proposals for rebuilding the hospital themselves. I am not sure of the figure, but I understand it came to something like £130,000. That means they still require a certain amount of money to erect their building. Are they going to set up a white elephant that they can never support after? It will require the capitalisation of at least £110,000 to secure an income of £4,500. The amount of money which came to Holles Street in voluntary subscriptions varied from £400 to £600. That was all they received from the public. Therefore, they are bound to make provision for the future. Their entire outlay was something like £6,000 or a little over it in a year. If in rebuilding their hospital they make more accommodation it will cost more and therefore they will have to look for the investment of a large sum of money. The least amount I would put that sum down at would be £110,000.

[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]

I do not think that they are likely to get in the future £10,000 out of each of the nine sweeps, that is to say that they are going to get £90,000 on the basis of the figures I have been using here. From that they will have to deduct what will equip the hospital after they build it, and then they will have to look for their income for the future. I could give figures with regard to other hospitals that would bring out the same idea namely, that it is no use for these hospitals to erect buildings and then make no provision for income in the future. With regard to the one hospital I have something to say to, although I am not on the Board, the first effect of getting the money was that they were able to raise their nurses' salaries to something like what you would pay your cook, to a decent wage, something that many of the Deputies here would not think a very large sum for a cook. The next was to pay the servants, who were getting only £18 a year or something like it, decent wages. The third was to provide the laundresses with wages they were never able to give before and about which they had been pestered. Increased pay to nurses, servants and laundresses means capital expenditure of £12,500 a year; that has to be earmarked at once. If we go on the assumption of what the Minister said, that at least half the voluntary subscriptions would disappear, that means that another £10,000 would have to be provided for which would take twenty-two and a half thousand pounds. The hospital was being run each year at a loss of £1,000 a year. The expenditure was £1,000 over the income. That means that provision would have to be made for that. There you have £40,000 with the £12,000 before anything has been done in the way of equipment. I have been listening to Deputies saying that the hospitals have been all equipped. Not a single thing has been done except putting aside money to meet the future expenditure of the hospitals. That shows that there is another side to the case I give than what is shown here that the hospitals were getting hold of money and throwing it about without any control.

I have no objection to the suggestion made here that there should be some committee which would have control over the expenditure of the hospitals. I remember making a speech here five years ago in which I stated that it was a great mistake that any one, on his own, should be able to start a hospital for his own sake or aggrandisement or anything else without any supervision from the Government. They started a little hospital in a small way and got the committee to come and begin to collect funds that should be going to the regular hospitals. After that they got grants for the hospital. There was no proper board. There was no control over the financing of the hospital which was only run by one person.

I would like to see the county hospitals provided with every convenience that would bring them up to date. There was no suggestion in my mind that the county hospital surgeons are not capable of doing excellent work. I would be very sorry that anything to the contrary went forth from this House, but when I hear people like Deputy Corry suggesting that the Dublin hospitals should be thrown out of this, why does not Deputy Corry bring in a Bill and get the whole of the money for the county hospitals when this Bill is passed? Any one of us would support that. He says that what was provided for the county hospitals should be divided with the others in equal shares. My opinion was that 25 per cent. was a very large amount, because if we are able to foresee things it is quite obvious that there is not going to be a falling away but an increase.

Some Deputies wanted to know what is meant by a voluntary hospital. A voluntary hospital means that physicians or surgeons connected with it give their work for nothing. I say that for over forty years I have given my services to the poor of Dublin without any fee or reward, and as far as the sweepstake is concerned I have not benefited by one sixpence. Voluntary hospitals are manned by people like myself who have given their time for years and years without getting a single fee, attending poor suffering patients. I think those hospitals should be considered.

As far as the voluntary part is concerned, reference was made about voluntary subscriptions. Fortunately some of the hospitals are well provided with voluntary subscriptions; others are not nearly so well provided. Some of the hospitals getting £5,000 or £6,000 a year can only count on getting half that at present. There were three or four in the last, and what is regarded as voluntary hospitals were those who were receiving a certain amount of voluntary subscriptions. I reiterate that there were 34 hospitals, of which 19 are included in the City and County of Dublin. As against that there were only 6 in Cork, 4 in Limerick, 3 in Waterford, in Louth 1, in Donegal 1, in Kildare 1, and in Wicklow 1. Therefore, it is quite absurd to be thrown in my teeth that I am only metropolitan and only take a metropolitan view. I am sorry that Deputy Tubridy went out, because some years ago I was sent to Galway to examine a hospital to see whether students should be allowed to go there to be taught their clinical surgery and medicine, so that I know something about conditions there. What surprises me is that Galway did not come in. Why Galway, which deserved it most undoubtedly, has not come in I do not understand.

Comment on this

It is maintained by rates.

Comment on this

So are the others.

Comment on this

Does it get no voluntary subscription at all? That excludes it from under the original Act. The original Act says that the hospitals must be getting some voluntary subscriptions and must be attending 25 per cent. of their patients free. As far as I am concerned, I would like to see Galway hospital, where there is any teaching done, equipped in the most up-to-date manner possible, and I would like to see every county hospital equipped and fitted throughout the country. I think the amount that is to come from this is quite sufficient to do all that. I may be wrong. I do not know.

Deputy Briscoe suggested on Friday that as I had pressed the Government to appoint county medical officers of health I should see that their salaries were provided for in this way. It is all nonsense to talk in that particular way.

I got a letter from a very excellent doctor in Mayo. He says that there should be a research hospital set up to inquire into the causes of the defective mental conditions of children down in Connemara. That is a most excellent thing. It is so good that I would like to have it extended to some adults. That is only in passing. The other suggestion that was made to me is that something should be done for the district nurses. I do not think there is any better work done in the country than the work done by the district nurses, and if it were possible to bring them back into this Bill I would be very glad to do it. I am sorry that Deputy O'Kelly did not accept the offer of the compromise made. I do not consider it is any compromise. He is going to vote as to whether he is to get 50 per cent., and then, if defeated on that, to vote as to whether he would get 33? per cent. I understood that the compromise was to have 33? per cent.

Deputy Flinn and Deputy Corry rose.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputies may speak more than once in Committee. Are we to start the debate again? One can be relevant for a long period on this topic.

Comment on this

I submit that these are very big issues, and that the issues are widening all the time we are discussing them.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is what I mean.

Comment on this

That is the difficulty. We have started one Bill. We have got a second one. The issues which we are driven to discuss in making any attempt to get to grips with the question are getting so big that we should be either prepared adequately to discuss them or to say simply that we will not discuss them. I have listened with great interest to what Deputy Sir James Craig said. I think Deputy Sir James Craig, like everyone else, is acting in good faith. That is the spirit. The first thing I suggest to Deputy Sir James Craig is that we should get rid of the word "compromise" altogether. That is not what we are here for. We are not here to make bargains. We are here to pursue what is the opinion of the House on this question. It is not a question of finding a compromise between two different people in relation to a figure. It is a question of finding out what proportion this House on a free vote— each person independently exercising his judgment—desires should be made in the matter. Such a question as compromise is not what we are here for, and I do not think it is what Deputy Sir James Craig intends. If you once use the word "compromise," you suggest interests. You suggest that there are two interests which have to compose their differences. That is not a suggestion I am prepared to make, and if it is to be made it must be made in set terms by someone. Therefore we cannot use the word "compromise." What we are here to find out is, what the figure should be. Like everyone else, I think the Minister was acting entirely in good faith, and when he formed the opinion that 25 per cent. was a fair figure for the county hospitals, as far as I understand it, that means that he must have formed the opinion that 75 per cent. was the figure required by a voluntary hospital.

I want the Minister to explain upon what basis he came to that opinion. A point was made—and I do not think it was intended to be a political point—that Deputy Corry, in relation to what he was saying about Dublin, was neglecting the City of Cork. I am a Cork representative, and I would not be expected, I suppose, to say something which is unpopular in Cork. I adopt quite freely the attitude of Deputy Corry, and I say that if it can be shown that any voluntary hospital in Cork would receive money from this proposal which it could not properly use then it ought to go out, and some other institution which has not sufficient money ought to come in. In exactly the same way we are faced by the fact that £850,000 has gone to the City of Dublin. A sum of £110,000 went to one place and £80,000 to another. Has the Minister satisfied himself that that is not adequate for the present and the immediately prospective needs of these hospitals in relation to other hospitals? If he is satisfied by making the basis 25 per cent., I take it that some attempt has been made to do that. If there is an hospital which, due to the fact that it got in on the ground floor when this thing was started, has already received an amount which relative to its necessities and the necessities of other hospitals seems fair, then it might drop out. Are we to take the line that those who got in on the ground floor have a vested interest to remain in, and simply that they have an obligation to use the money which is automatically going to flow in from this fairy fountain of gold? Is that line taken? Is the line taken that the hospitals which originally came in have a vested interest? Are they to get the money all the time this is going on?

Comment on this

A certain amount of it probably. I do not know. I have nothing to do with it.

Comment on this

That is clear. We are talking of 25 per cent. and 75 per cent. being fair. On what basis are they claiming part of the 75 per cent.? Is it on the ground of vested interests because they got in on the ground floor? You have to face that issue. Or are you going to say that whoever came in and whatever the amount of money they are going to get for their hospital is to be in proportion to the needs of that hospital and the work it is doing? I want to know from the Minister—and I am not putting this question in any controversial sense— on what basis he has calculated that six millions is required for these nominal voluntary hospitals as distinct from one and a half millions for the hospitals that are said to be non-voluntary. Deputy Sir James Craig told us that one hospital received £80,000. He also said that the subscriptions were from £400 to £600. If he cannot see the danger in that to the whole principle of voluntary hospitals——

Comment on this

I saw the danger of the hospitals falling.

Comment on this

If any other hospital happened to get in on the ground floor which received £400 or £600 in voluntary subscriptions, are you going to say that it should go on, develop and pull down buildings in order to absorb £80,000, £18,000, or whatever hundreds of thousands of pounds may automatically fall into its lap because it got in on the ground floor?

Comment on this

Certainly not.

Comment on this

I am glad. Here is the issue, and I suggest to the Minister that he has to find the basis of the 25 per cent. and the 75 per cent. or of the 50 per cent., or whatever figure is taken, based on one of two considerations, either the vested interest consideration or the consideration that he is convinced by examination of the question that that proportion of money can be better used than any other proportion distributed as between two people. I would ask the Minister to tell the House why he has come to the opinion that six millions, or we will take the figure of 75 per cent., are required by the voluntary hospitals relative to the one and a half millions required by non-voluntary hospitals?

Comment on this

In this amendment I think there is a great risk of the county hospitals suffering, from the very fact, as Deputy Davin put it, that we have 25 per cent. in the Bill, 50 per cent. in the amendment and, at the same time, 33? per cent. offered as a compromise. If, as An Leas-Cheann Comhairle declared in reply to Deputy Davin, the question be put that the 25 per cent.. stand part of the Bill, and if we pass it, it will embarrass the position of county hospitals very much because it would deprive them of accepting the offer of 33?. Every Deputy who spoke to-day represented a county hospital, a county home and the poor, sick, and infirm. It is his business and his interest to see that the best possible provision is made for the sick, poor and infirm in county hospitals. He has no personal greed or avarice regarding the money to be contributed and his only desire is to see that the greatest possible amount of luxury is provided for patients in the county hospitals in the county in which he lives. I am sure that every Deputy would regret very much if he sacrificed any benefits that would be coming to such hospitals provided for in the Bill. Deputy Sir James Craig has made a strong case for the city hospitals, and rightly so, and he deserves the greatest possible credit for making such a fight for them. It is questionable whether any doubt can be cast on the validity of his statement. He is trying to make provision for them in the future, and no one can find fault with that. He initiated this scheme and carried it through successfully, despite much opposition and heckling. I quite see his point of view, and I can see that he is right in looking to the future when the hospitals may again be embarrassed, but I think that the county hospitals, which are in a dilapidated condition, and whose equipment is of a very primitive character should also be assisted.

I am sure that if Deputy Sir James Craig had an opportunity of visiting the county hospitals in the midlands and the west he would be prepared to ask the Minister to grant the greatest possible share of this money for the equipment of those hospitals. I do not think that it is a matter of 25, 50 or 33? per cent. It should be a question of what the House can agree to give, the largest amount possible to relieve the position of such hospitals. It is a matter that will pass from the control of this House and we will not have to consider it again, but that is all the more reason why it is highly desirable, when we are dealing with it now, that we should decide it in the way that would be most beneficial to all concerned. I think that we should agree to accept the compromise. It can, after all, hardly be said that this is going to be a free vote. There is no such thing as freedom in this matter for the simple reason that you have a barrier, clear and distinct, as between 25 and 50 per cent. A Deputy representing a constituency in which there is a county or district hospital, would be required by the people he represents to vote for the 50 per cent. On the other hand if he voted for the 25 per cent. he would not have freedom either. I suggest that a compromise is essential. We should be unanimous. If each Deputy expresses his opinion I am quite certain that we would all agree to compromise on the matter.

Comment on this

I would like to correct the misapprehension which apparently exists in Deputy Connolly's mind. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle informed the House that if this amendment were defeated there would still be an opportunity of introducing, on the Report Stage, an amendment which might provide a compromise acceptable to all.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That there will be an opportunity.

Comment on this

Yes. Therefore, if Deputy Connolly feels that it is only fair that the county hospitals should get 50 per cent., he is at liberty to vote for the amendment and he will have an opportunity on the Report Stage of considering and supporting any compromise that is desired.

Comment on this

There could not be a compromise then at all.

Comment on this

There might be because there are, I believe, a considerable number of Deputies, a majority of Deputies, who, even if they are not going to support the 50 per cent. proposal, are prepared to support 37½ per cent., or some other amendment less than 50 per cent. but certainly much more than 25 per cent. If this amendment is defeated there will be another amendment fixing something more than 25 and less than 50 per cent., so that those in favour of this amendment should not allow themselves to be misled by believing that they are going to dispose of this question as to what is a fair allocation to the hospitals. I should like to go back to the speech of Deputy Sir James Craig, as he has referred to the circumstances under which the original Bill was introduced. When the Bill was introduced it met with considerable opposition from influential personages in this House. It would have met with considerably more opposition from this Party and, speaking for myself, from me certainly, were it not impressed upon us that the Bill was designed to relieve the pressing necessities of a few hospitals in Dublin which were faced with a situation that they would have either to close their doors or secure relief from sources other than public subscriptions. We felt that the Government were not prepared, at the time, to undertake the investigation which a considerable number of us felt was required into the whole position of the hospitals in Dublin. We were prepared to support the Bill as a temporary measure designed to deal with a very circumscribed situation. In allowing that Bill to go through those of us who spoke on Second Reading made it clear that we hoped when opportunity offered that this, or some succeeding Government, would institute an inves- tigation into the whole position of the Dublin hospitals.

A number of us had been informed, by those competent to speak on the matter, that the whole situation was unsatisfactory, that there was a number of redundant, inefficient hospitals which ought to be in the public interest closed down, and that there should be some amalgamation of certain of the hospitals. In the case of the original Bill we qualified our support of the measure by stating that at some future date some investigation should be set on foot as a result of which these hospitals would be put on a satisfactory basis. What were the speeches made here to-day? Deputy Sir James Craig heard the views which were then expressed, and I think he assented to them. In the speech to which we have just listened from him, there was a plea for permanently endowing the present unsatisfactory position of the hospitals in Dublin. He said that there were nineteen or twenty hospitals, a considerable number of which were in debt. A considerable number were going to have that debt cleared off, and, he said, when all that has been done, he hoped that they would set aside a proportion of the proceeds of the sweepstake in order to create an endowment which would perpetuate the present unsatisfactory condition of these hospitals. That is precisely what we do not want to see. We want to limit the endowment of the inefficiency of the Dublin hospitals. That is one of the reasons why I am in favour of the amendment rather than the proposals contained in the Bill, because I believe the more money that is allocated to the hospitals, the greater the difficulty any authority is going to have in dealing with the hospitals' problem and in reorganising the Dublin hospitals, if they have to be reorganised as a result of examination and investigation later on.

Deputy Sir James Craig, in the course of his speech, said he was against one-man hospitals instituted for the aggrandisement of single individuals. I do not know whether any county hospitals have been instituted for the aggrandisement of a single individual, but it seems to me that amongst the hospitals which it is proposed to benefit by this money in Dublin there are hospitals which are one-man shows instituted by single individuals, which grow up in that way and which do the same work as the other hospitals. It would seem to me that Deputy Sir James Craig's speech in this respect was in favour of the amendment and against the permanent endowment on the present lines of the voluntary hospitals in Dublin.

The main point which I would like to stress again was that the original Sweepstakes Bill was introduced to deal with a certain limited number of hospitals which were in a position of dire necessity. Now the proposition is brought forward here, and seriously advanced, that the proceeds in the sweepstakes are to become the perquisites of the voluntary hospitals alone. That was never contemplated when the Bill was originally before the House. That is the introduction of a new principle to the Bill. For that reason again, in order to preserve the right of public authorities and of the local authorities in the matter of a fair proportion of the proceeds of the sweepstakes, which though they are now run in the guise of being private sweepstakes are really, as Deputy Flinn stated, public lotteries, in order to be clear that the proceeds of the public lotteries will be under the control of a central authority, as they will be in the case of the county hospitals, where the expenditure will be under the supervision of the Minister for Local Government and the competent officials of his Department and where there will be no waste or unnecessary expenditure, the amendment ought to be supported rather than the proposals in the Minister's Bill.

Comment on this

In the year 1923 I reintroduced into Ireland after a great number of years a Hospital Sweepstakes Bill. The gods then were not propitious, and my Bill did not become law. I am glad to see that, as time rolled on, some of the members of the old Dáil who then bitterly opposed my little Bill became, in the years 1930 and 1931, enthusiastic supporters of sweepstakes for hospitals. I was informed when introducing the Bill, by my friends here in Dublin, that the metropolitan hospitals from a financial point of view were in a very bad way, and it was also intended under that Bill that the money obtained from sweepstakes would be allocated, not only to metropolitan hospitals, but to provincial hospitals. As the original introducer of the hospitals sweepstakes in 1923, I am more than delighted to see the extraordinary success with which sweepstakes in the Saorstát have met in the last year or two. I hope their success will go on growing until, perhaps, the present amount subscribed will be doubled.

There is no doubt that some of the county hospitals do require money. I am not prepared to say what percentage of the money from the sweeps should be allocated to the county hospitals, but I think that if an agreement could be arrived at 33? per cent., it would be a reasonable amount for the present. I do not subscribe to the doctrine that the Dublin hospitals should be cut out of the sweepstakes at all. We all know what the metropolitan hospitals have done and are doing, and what very important institutions they are in the life of the nation. If they have got £852,000, and if the provincial and county hospitals and county infirmaries have only so far obtained £364,000, I say good luck to Dublin, and I hope Dublin will get in the near future another £852,000. No doubt the county hospitals do require equipment. I must say that in the case of the county hospital to which I am attached, whenever I require any equipment, I have only to inform the Local Government Department or the county board of health, and I have no trouble in getting any equipment we require. Structural alterations are undoubtedly required in the Waterford county hospital. The scheme is on the tapis, and they are urgently required. I would ask the Opposition seriously to consider the question of 33? per cent., and perhaps we might have agreement on it.

Comment on this

Might I point out that this is not a matter for the Opposition? It is an open vote, and every Deputy has an open mind on this matter.

Comment on this

I feel that it is most regrettable that so much time has been taken up discussing the difference between 50 per cent. and the lesser percentage suggested by the Minister. So far I have heard no substantial grounds of objection raised to the 50 per cent. I think the whole discussion was most unseemly. The matter could easily have been referred to a Committee of the House at which it could be discussed possibly to the greater advantage of the hospitals and to a greater advantage of the country. Whilst I intend to vote in favour of Deputy O'Kelly's amendment, I would like to give some explanation, or at least to offer a reason or reasons why I intend voting that way. So far I have not heard any speaker opposed to the amendment suggest that the county hospitals are not doing good work. It is admitted on all hands that they are very useful adjuncts to the city and metropolitan hospitals. But there is a point which should get some consideration and which should weigh very considerably with the Minister and with anybody who has any doubt whatsoever with regard to the utility of these county institutions: Remember if these county hospitals will get 50 per cent. from the results of the forthcoming sweepstakes, that will largely relieve congestion in the metropolitan and city hospitals. As a city representative I feel that if I were to take an insular view of the matter, I would be all out in favour of the suggestion or compromise offered by the Minister. But I do feel that there are numbers of those county hospitals which, as I have already said, are doing very useful work and performing work which might otherwise have to be performed by the city hospitals and infirmaries.

I think Deputy Sir James Craig, Deputy White, and other medical Deputies will agree with me that there are occasions when it is absolutely essential that patients in the country districts should have at their command the best medical and surgical aid. When I say the best medical and surgical aid I want to include in those terms the best that can be done by way of operating theatres and so on. Those of us who have any connection with county hospitals are aware that in the majority of cases they are not provided with up-to-date apparatus. The consequence is that many of these patients who require the kind of treatment I have indicated have to be removed at considerable expense either to Dublin or Cork.

Surely that is a consideration that should commend itself to the Minister. It should also commend itself to Deputy Sir James Craig who, I feel, has taken a wonderful interest in the promotion of these sweepstakes. He has taken a very great interest indeed in seeing that all these hospitals are properly equipped. We all give him credit for his humane feelings in that matter. I cannot see where the objection to giving 50 per cent., as suggested in Deputy O'Kelly's amendment, can come in. But this is an aspect of the question which I think should be discussed in a Committee of the House. Some Deputies to-day have spoken as if these sweepstakes are to go on for ever. I hope that the attitude adopted by some of us on the sweepstakes is not going to be misconstrued in that direction.

I hope that this country will never be turned into a second Holland, and that we are not going to have only one reputation in the world as being the country which stands out pre-eminently for the promotion of sweepstakes. In saying that I do not want to throw any cold water on the forthcoming sweepstake or on the ones that may follow it. I would, however, like to correct the impression that might be in the minds of some Deputies, and to point out that we are not all in favour of continuing these sweepstakes ad infinitum. There must be an end to them some time, and I suggest that that end is very near. It has been stated by some Deputies that a very large amount of money has already been subscribed to the Dublin and Cork hospitals. All these institutions were in dire need of financial help at the time when the Act was introduced into the House. I can now see and appreciate the long-headedness of the President who, whilst he did not oppose the sweepstake, was not very active in support of the promotion of the original Bill. I felt then, and I feel now, that many of those institutions would have to close their doors were it not for the fact that these sweepstakes were promoted. Many of us felt that we had to choose the lesser of two evils. The money that had accrued as a result of the sweepstake was a God-send to these hospitals. I hope that as a result of these sweepstakes these hospitals will be so well financed that they will be able to invest the money which will accrue to them so that they will never have to ask for assistance in this way again.

I want to make this suggestion to those who are opposing the 50 per cent. division for the county hospitals. Let them bear in mind that by the granting of this 50 per cent. they will not alone be helping these county hospitals but they will in addition be helping the very hospitals they have already helped. I say that because giving the money to the county hospitals will relieve congestion in the city hospitals and relieve it in a way that will be reflected in the balance sheets of the metropolitan and city hospitals in the future. For that reason I support Deputy O'Kelly's amendment.

Comment on this

I was not present during the whole of the debate and am therefore speaking now at a slight disadvantage. I understand that the question is as to whether 50 per cent. or 25 per cent. is to be allocated to the county hospitals. Naturally I am very largely interested in the county hospitals and being a member of a board of health there are few who are more conversant with the record of the great and good work done in these hospitals, and also conversant with the very many things required in order to place these hospitals in a position to be able to give the most modern treatment for the innumerable diseases that they have to treat. I understand that the Minister has made a suggestion to compromise the matter by giving 33? per cent. What I would like to know is this: if Deputy O'Kelly's amendment is defeated will the Minister at a later stage be able to bring in an amendment to allow 33? to be given? Another thing which is most important is, what is the probable amount that will be received on the basis of an allocation of 33? to the county hospitals? If the sweepstakes develop as they are developing they will bring in three times as much as the enormously successful Derby Sweep. I assume that the county hospitals will get at least £20,000 a year during the next three years— that is £60,000 before the end of 1934. They will get this sum assuming that it is not going to increase beyond the limits of the Derby Sweep. Undoubtedly this would be a tremendous benefit to the county hospitals and naturally I am very strongly in favour of it. At the same time we could overdo it. One important note I would like to strike is that this matter here to-day should not really be made a controversial one. There should be no tinge of politics in it; that is a matter I would very much like to avoid. These sweeps have been such a gigantic success it would look very bad before the world if the Parliament of the nation were to be divided on any issues connected with them. Deputy Anthony suggested also that this matter should be referred to a Committee. I strongly object to any tinge of politics being brought into this. As one who is deeply interested in the county hospitals I realise the tremendously great work that the Dublin hospitals are doing, but at the same time the county hospitals are to receive a huge sum on the 33? per cent. basis.

Comment on this

Not enough. May I interrupt Deputy Shaw to tell him what the financial position is. Under the present proposal in the Bill 26 counties received 1½ million. That would be allocated amongst, I think, 25 county hospitals and 58 district hospitals. That 1½ million will be divided amongst these 83 hospitals, leaving out of consideration the mental and fever hospitals. As against 1½ million to 83 hospitals there will be 6¼ millions available for division amongst the 45 voluntary hospitals. That is the position. We ask that that money should be split on a 50-50 basis.

Comment on this

There would be three millions for the county hospitals.

Comment on this

Yes, and three millions for the voluntary hospitals.

Comment on this

The sum I have suggested would go to the county hospitals. I would like again if the Minister would say if on the Report Stage he could bring up an amendment to increase it to 33? if this amendment is now defeated.

Comment on this

The proposal now put forward of giving 33? is not a reasonable attempt to meet our point of view. It is ridiculous and does not go half way to it.

Comment on this

I do not want to continue the debate any further, but I would ask the Minister to go even a little further in the way of compromise. I repeat that it would look bad before the world, in view of the enormous success of the sweepstakes, to have the Parliament of the nation divided on a matter that we are all interested in, and not with a view of anyone wanting to score off the other person.

Comment on this

I do not think Deputy Shaw is right in suggesting that anyone wants to make this a political matter. Several Deputies on Deputy Shaw's side of the House have supported this amendment. There is no question of politics. I think the figure given by Deputy MacEntee should be conclusive, that under the amendment proposed by Deputy O'Kelly the county hospitals and the Dublin hospitals will get a fair share of the proceeds of the sweep. There is no doubt about that. The voluntary hospitals have got one and a quarter million, and if they are to get a further six and a half millions it will be unfair. There are well over a hundred country hospitals and sanatoria, and the sum would not amount to very much per hospital if they were only to get one and a quarter million.

I think the House is of the opinion that the country hospitals are entitled to more than twenty-five per cent. I am sure the Minister will see the logic of the arguments that have been put up, and that he will agree to this amendment. I would like to ask the Ceann Comhairle whether if this amendment were defeated another amendment can be brought in on the Report Stage.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think the Leas-Cheann Comhairle explained that. The question will be put that the words proposed to be deleted stand. If the words stand no amendment can be proposed on the Report Stage, which proposes to substitute for three-quarters one-half. It must be for less than half.

Comment on this

Can it be more than half?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

No, it must be less.

Comment on this

Would the Minister increase the amount and have a compromise on it?

Comment on this

It was not my intention to add anything further. I have already spoken twice upon this matter. I will just say that I think Deputy MacEntee's figures are very fantastic. The figures that I will put before the House will probably prove to be correct. The voluntary hospitals in getting three-quarters would probably get about three millions and the rate-aided hospitals would probably get one million. It should be borne in mind that in addition to the hospitals that have already participated and that still have needs, six new hospitals have been brought in and there are a great number of county infirmaries on a voluntary basis. In consequence you are not giving to what I call, strictly speaking, voluntary hospitals, hospitals whose main source of support is voluntary subscription, anything like half of the amount, because the hospitals which are entirely rate-aided will get one-half and the hospitals that are partly rate-aided will get one-third of the remainder, with the result that the voluntary hospitals will get a comparatively small proportion. By the voluntary hospitals I mean the hospitals that do charitable work and are maintained almost entirely, if not entirely, by voluntary subscriptions. It was because these voluntary subscriptions fell off that this hospital scheme was started at all and I think we should keep as close to that as possible.

Comment on this

Could the Minister tell us, on the fifty-fifty basis, how much actually would go to the voluntary hospitals?

Comment on this

It would be utterly impossible. There are hospitals like the North Infirmary, Cork; the South Infirmary, Cork; the Louth County Infirmary, and infirmaries of that kind which are receiving substantial proportions of this money already and their proportion will not come out of the rate-aided hospitals fifty per cent.; it will come out of the voluntary hospitals' fifty per cent. What percentage that would be it would be impossible for me to tell. The Committee of Reference will have to go into that and decide. It seems to me to be more than one-third and the purely voluntary hospitals that it was the intention of the House to benefit when this scheme was first brought in will get really about two-thirds of the half. I personally quite agree with what Deputy Shaw said. I think it a pity that there should be a division of the House and I ask Deputies to consider again the substitution of one-third.

Comment on this

I hope the House understands my position. I have tried to make it clear that I would personally favour accepting the amendment offered but that I was joined in this amendment by at least half-a-dozen of my colleagues. It was agreed that the amendment should go down in my name. They repudiated my acceptance and they insist on a division. I tried to get them to accept the further suggestion I made of thirty-seven-and-one-half per cent. and even that they are not willing to accept. Perhaps if the Minister would see his way to accept that we might get agreement of the House upon it. I would rather that there was agreement in the House.

Comment on this

Make it forty per cent.

Comment on this

I do not think we can start bargaining across the House. I think it is most undignified. I do not see any way except by taking a vote on it.

Comment on this

As the city hospitals have got a good deal of money already, I would ask the Minister to agree to the 50 per cent. and give the county hospitals a chance.

Comment on this

The Minister said that under the present system the whole of the county infirmaries can benefit to a certain extent.

Comment on this

As voluntary hospitals, yes.

Comment on this

Under this Bill, when passed, would they not be segregated and placed with the rate-aided hospitals?

Comment on this

They will not be, as a matter of fact, because they are entitled to participate. The only way in which they could be segregated would be if I refused to sanction a scheme in which they appeared as voluntary hospitals. Then they would be put in with the others. If I administered the Act in that way this amendment would really have very small effect.

Comment on this

I take it that every county infirmary can come under the term "voluntary hospital"?

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Not except they are mainly voluntary, which none of them is.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey is completely wrong.

Comment on this

What I was going to say is that the amount of money given to county infirmaries at present is a very small fraction of the total, and it does not affect this argument. As 50 per cent. of the money would go to voluntary hospitals, that 50 per cent. will not be affected by one per cent., or by the fact that Louth——

Comment on this

The Deputy is quite wrong. The hospitals which receive substantial rate-aid would receive something like one-third of the proceeds. That is my recollection.

Mr. Kennedy rose.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is not the Deputy debating the question again?

Comment on this

I am trying to make a case for agreement.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think that all that can be done to get agreement has been done.

Comment on this

I would be prepared to accept the suggestion of Deputy Reynolds that they should get 40 per cent.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to agree to 40 per cent. It will not look very well to the outside world if we are divided on this issue of what is to be done with the money received from the sweepstakes.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The question will be put that the words "three-fourths" stand. If that is carried these words will stand and on the next Stage another amendment may be moved, but it must be for less than one-half. If the words "three-fourths" are deleted, the question put will be: "That the words `one-half' be there inserted." If that is carried that settles the question for this particular Stage. If that figure is not inserted, another figure, less than one-half, can be moved immediately and the question put without debate.

Comment on this

Can that be done after this is decided?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

It can be done at once.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words `three-fourths' stand."

Tá 63
·
Níl 53
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Is it now in order to propose a lesser amount than 50 per cent.?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Not at this stage. The Committee has decided that the words "three-fourths" stand part. At a later stage an amendment would be in order, but not at this stage.

Comment on this

I think that division covers the next amendment, No. 9.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Yes, that disposes of amendment 9.

Comment on this

I move amendments No. 10 and 11:

In sub-section (4) (a), page 4, line 33, after the word "bodies," to insert the words "or such one or more of them exclusive of the other or others and".

In sub-section (4) (b), page 4, line 38, before the word "report" to insert the words "and after consultation with the Committee managing such sweepstake".

It was agreed that these amendments should be put into the Bill, and then Deputies opposite would reconsider the Bill when they see them in it. For the time being, and temporarily I understand, my amendments go in.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 15:

To delete all from and including the word "disposed," page 4, line 53, to the end of the section and substitute the words—

"applied by him in such manner as he shall think fit in or towards the provision, improvement, or equipment of institutions for the prevention, treatment, or cure of physical or mental diseases or injuries of human beings.

(2) The following provisions shall have effect where the Minister for Local Government and Public Health applies or proposes to apply any money under this section in or towards the provision, improvement, or equipment of an institution which is wholly or partly maintained by a local authority, that is to say:—

(a) such application may be made conditional upon the fulfilment by such local authority of such conditions as the said Minister shall think proper to impose.

(b) the money so applied shall be in addition to and not in substitution for the moneys expended by such local authority for or towards the ordinary maintenance of such institution and shall not be taken into consideration by such local authority when determining the amount to be so expended by them."

This amendment shows the powers the Minister for Local Government will have in the distribution of the proceeds.

Comment on this

With regard to the amendment, I think the Minister would agree on reading it again that the phraseology might with advantage be changed. Sub-section (2) (a), for instance, says "such application may be made conditional upon the fulfilment by such local authority of such conditions as the Minister shall think proper to impose." There is no suggestion at all there of consultation with the local authority. I think the Minister will agree that it will be necessary the local authority should be consulted or asked to put up a scheme, or have some say as to how the money should be spent. It should not, as the wording here would suggest, be in the power merely of the Minister to send down an order to the local authority and say this is my belief as to how the money could best be spent, and to impose certain conditions upon them without reference in any way to them as to what their wishes were.

Comment on this

If the Deputy likes I shall discuss the matter with the Minister for Local Government, but I do not think that there will be the slightest danger of the county boards and boards of public health and other similar bodies not making application for this money.

I think that there will be very great keenness on the part of every county body to get their proportion, and I do not think there will be any danger of the Minister for Local Government not receiving enough applications. I think his difficulty will be to decide between a large number.

Comment on this

The amendment says: "The fulfilment by such local authorities of such conditions as the said Minister shall think proper to impose." I think Deputy O'Kelly's point is that the Minister may impose any conditions he likes, and that if he has any particular hobby he can order that to be carried out without consulting the local authority at all. Certainly the local people are the best judges of what is most needed in the particular area.

Comment on this

I do not think that it will take away from the Minister's power to add "if after consultation with the local authority."

Comment on this

I will consult with the Minister for Local Government, and if it appears that such words would be helpful, we will insert them. If necessary, I will actually move them myself. I will bear the matter in mind.

Comment on this

With regard to clause (b) in the amendment, is it intended that this money will be used entirely for capital purposes? I think, as worded at present, that it is linked up with money for maintenance. "The money so applied shall be in addition to and not in substitution for the moneys expended by such local authority for or towards the ordinary maintenance of such institution."

Comment on this

"And not in substitution."

Comment on this

They can be used for maintenance purposes.

Comment on this

They can not.

Comment on this

I suggest, as it reads, that it can be construed as applying to maintenance. "The money so applied shall be in addition to and not in substitution for the moneys expended by such local authority for or towards the ordinary maintenance of such institution."

Comment on this

"In addition to." That is over and above the amount spent in maintenance. Everything spent in maintenance must be spent out of the rates, but this is to be different from maintenance. It is to be for improvement.

Comment on this

I submit it is not clear at all. I think as it stands it can be read to mean extraordinary maintenance. It is to be in addition to such moneys expended by such local authority for ordinary maintenance. Therefore it can be used for extraordinary maintenance. Then a further question arises. Is there not room for tremendous friction as to what is maintenance and what is improvement? The local body may very well contend that certain expenditure which the Minister would judge to be maintenance, would not be incurred in the ordinary course. They might say that what the Minister is demanding is improvements, new furniture, for instance, new beds, the addition of a porch, the addition of anything you like.

Comment on this

That would not come under the heading of "maintenance." That would be under the heading of "improvements."

Comment on this

I submit that it is very hard to draw the line between "maintenance" and "improvement." The ordinary householder regards these things as maintenance of his household. If a building has to be preserved and maintained a lot of these things have to be done.

Comment on this

Maintenance would mean the payment of all salaries and wages. The food of the patients and everything of that kind would be regarded as the cost of the maintenance of the hospital.

Comment on this

Ordinary repairs are maintenance.

Comment on this

If you get in new surgical instruments those would be regarded as ordinary maintenance. The distinction may be fine, but in practice it will be able to be drawn quite easily.

Comment on this

Would the salary of an extra medical officer be maintenance?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Therefore it can be used for that purpose.

Comment on this

There is nothing in this amendment to indicate to the Minister the lines on which he should apportion these moneys over the counties.

Comment on this

I am aware of that, and I thought myself that it would be better to have it on a population basis, but I have not been successful. I was very anxious that this should be a completely agreed measure. Therefore, I surrender that point to the Party opposite, and have left it now to the unfettered discretion of the Minister.

Comment on this

Not to the Party opposite. There is no Party vote on that.

Comment on this

To the Deputies on the benches opposite, particularly Deputy O'Dowd.

Comment on this

Under the amendment there is, I think, grave danger that ratepayers in a county who have hitherto done their duty by providing hospital accommodation will not get the same consideration as ratepayers in counties where absolutely nothing in that respect has been done. Considerable sums have been spent in County Cavan in the equipment and enlargement of a surgical hospital. They are so well equipped that unless there are safeguards possibly in the way of power given to the Minister where he has no guide that counties that have not done so well will make application, while counties like Cavan will get nothing. No hospital is so well equipped that it could not be improved. Some steps should be taken to ensure that counties that have done well will get a fair proportion of the money.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy will find that there will be more than enough money to go round.

Comment on this

It may go round but counties like Cavan might get the thin end. There is provision in the Bill under which a new hospital could be provided. There will be applications from counties to provide new hospitals where there are none at present and where the representatives of the ratepayers have been negligent. The consequence is that the money will be absorbed to make good what the ratepayers should have provided for the relief of the poor.

Comment on this

You must leave that to the discretion of the Minister.

[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair].

Comment on this

I prefer it as it was originally in the Bill. I think there should be some guide for the Minister in the administration of the money.

Comment on this

If the Minister likes he can take the population basis as one of the principles on which to act.

Comment on this

But he need not do so.

Comment on this

He will take a considerable number of things into account. The objection was that he would be too tied down.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Hanlon has raised a point which it was difficult to decide in connection with the original measure. Certain hospitals got a great deal of money to put them into a proper condition. They had to get that money. Other hospitals were so well off that they did not need to come under the Act at all. As far as Deputy O'Hanlon is concerned I am afraid he is not making a good case when he suggests that because a county has done well it should get as much money as counties that have not done well.

Unfortunately that is the situation and it arose in connection with the other Acts. I think it should be left to the discretion of the Minister to decide what the requirements are.

Comment on this

The original scheme dealt with voluntary hospitals which are different to hospitals maintained by the ratepayers.

Comment on this

I think Deputy O'Hanlon is wrong when he says that there are some counties without hospitals. Every county has one hospital and some have several hospitals. If the Deputy stated that some counties had not x-ray apparatus and had not proper operating theatres or sanatoria he would be nearer the point. I think it is only the poorer counties that have not hospitals. Most of the counties are fairly up to date in that respect. As regards the fear that any county would pay the salary of the assistant medical officer of health from this money I think the counties would be very glad to get the money and devote it to capital expenditure. No board would be so foolish as to pay £400 or £500 out of what they got to an assistant medical officer. No one need fear that any very fine distinction will be drawn between maintenance and expenditure of a capital nature. The boards of health and the county councils are composed of practical people and they know as well as anyone the difference between these items. The sums available from the sweeps between the present time and 1934 will not, to my mind, be nearly sufficient to meet the requirements of the various counties. There is no fear of a reduction of a penny in the pound on the rates as a consequence of any money the hospitals get from the sweeps. When that occurs Deputies can make provision to meet it. I hope it will arise, but I cannot see the possibility of it doing so.

Comment on this

May I congratulate Deputy Kennedy on his change of heart with regard to the Minister for Local Government. Up to the present we have had nothing but complaints from Deputy Kennedy as to how impossible the Minister was when he laid down rules, and how he would not allow any departure, verbal or otherwise, from them. The Deputy is now satisfied that the Minister is going to be reasonable——

Comment on this

I said nothing about the Minister.

Comment on this

— and that the chairmen of boards of health and county councils will do nothing but embrace each other.

Comment on this

I must thank Deputy Moore for his misinterpretation of my speech.

Comment on this

I move:

In page 5, line 31, to delete the words "passing of this Act" and substitute the words and figures "30th day of April, 1931."

It has been arranged that this and the other amendments in my name will go through by consent for the time being.

Comment on this

I move:

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

(2) Where a scheme for a sweepstake has been sanctioned by the Minister under the Principal Act after the 30th day of April, 1931, and before the passing of this Act, this Act shall apply in relation to such scheme and any sweepstake held in pursuance thereof subject to the following provisions, that is to say:—

(a) the Minister may after the passing of this Act revise such a scheme in such manner as he may think desirable having regard to the provisions of this Act including this section;

(b) any hospital to which the Principal Act is applied by this Act may participate in such scheme and any sweepstake held in pursuance thereof;

(c) the committee of reference for such scheme shall be appointed when such scheme has been so revised by the Minister.

Comment on this

I move:—

"In page 5 to delete lines 47 and 48."

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 2, line 8, after the word "extend" to insert the words "and amend" and to delete all words from and including the word "to" line 9 to the end of line 21.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

When will the Report Stage be taken?

Comment on this

Before the Report Stage is taken there is an arrangement that the Bill will be recommitted.

Comment on this