Local Government (Rates on Agricultural Land) Bill, 1931—Second Stage.
Contributions 1–139 of 270. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 32 of 1931 ›
I move:
To delete all words after the word "That" and substitute the words "the Dáil declines to give a Second Reading to a Bill providing for the additional relief of rates on agricultural land which does not provide for the total de-rating of agricultural holdings of £10 valuation and under, as well as relief of rates on £10 of the valuations of all other agricultural holdings."
The sum of £10 mentioned is the nearest I could estimate that the proposed grant of £750,000 would meet. I am not absolutely certain of that figure. I take it that the amendment will be interpreted as an objection to the principle on which the proposed allocation is based and that the House will wish to substitute another principle as to the allocation of the amount that is to be given. The Dáil has indicated already that it is willing to accept the Government proposal of £750,000, but we are not satisfied with that amount. The principle of allocation that I should like to see substituted for that proposed in the Bill is that the money should be used to relieve rates on as many pounds valuation as it will go. I have put in the figure of £10 because it is roughly approximate to the extent that the money will go and it makes clear in general phrasing what is intended. The effect of the amendment will be this: that the rates on holdings of less than £10 valuation—that is, assuming the money provided will be able to meet that—would be removed. That is, that no small holder whose valuation is less than £10 would have to pay anything in rates and that in the case of holdings of a higher valuation than £10 they would get relief to the extent of £10 of their valuation. The justification for that in the present case is this: there might be objection to it as a principle, although I think a good case could be made for it as a principle, independent of the method by which it is intended to raise the money. But when you take into account the method by which this £750,000 is to be raised and that the whole purpose of it is to relieve agriculture, I think that the particular principle which I should like to see substituted for that in the Bill is one which can hardly be disputed. The position is this: the House proposes to relieve agriculture by a grant of £750,000. The small holders of less than £10 valuation, instead of being relieved, will have an additional burden placed upon them by the proposal in the Bill as it stands.
I gave figures recently, which I can give to the Dáil again, in order broadly to make clear what is going to happen. Take the case in Kildare which we have been dealing with, and for which I happen to have the figures. In the case of Kildare, I estimate that the 2,918 occupiers of land with valuations of less than £4 will, on an average, be relieved by the Government proposal to the extent of a little over 2/6. If they are to bear their share of the sugar tax, supposing there is a family of five, as the President said, the amount that will be contributed on an average by each family of five will be 10/6 per year. We have disputed that figure, because, in our opinion, the yield of the tax will be higher than that estimated by the Minister, as indicated by the quantity of sugar consumed last year. Taking the President's figure of 10/6, it means that these 2,918 small farmers in Kildare will get relief of rates to the extent of 2/6.
Comment on this
It is made on the basis of the distribution, by finding out how much is to be allocated to County Kildare and estimating what relief in the rates it will give.
Comment on this
The basis of the calculation is the amount that is going to be given to the county as a whole. That is the average for those under £4 valuation. They are not all £4.
Comment on this
They will not be all £4 valuation, but it averages out at that. I have no reason to believe that any of these figures are wrong. It works out at about 2/6. In order to get that benefit of 2/6 these small farmers will have to pay 10/6. Therefore, instead of being relieved, there is clearly going to be an additional burden of, roughly, 8/- placed on them. Certainly that was not the intention of the Dáil. If we are going to relieve agriculture at all these small farmers are most deserving of relief. I am not saying that the larger occupiers of land who give a good deal of employment do not deserve relief also, but I say that they will not have an additional burden, as is clearly demonstrated here, placed upon them. Therefore, no matter what case may be made for occupiers of large holdings who give considerable employment, we have here the case of the small holder who is entitled to relief and instead of getting relief is going to have an additional burden placed upon him. I believe it was not the intention of any Deputy that instead of relief being given to him we should put a burden upon him. When you come to those between £4 and £7 valuation, the average relief there works out at about 3/3. Therefore, there will also be an additional burden placed on them.
Comment on this
The Deputy was dealing with those between £4 and £7.
Comment on this
The result will be that these also will be burdened. I will get the figures, as I have not the full details here. The Minister was very anxious to rush this Bill, and to prevent anybody having time to take up the figures and make certain. I am giving the figures, and until they are proved wrong I am going to stand by them.
Comment on this
If there is any interval I will be able to check up and make certain of them. I have never found these figures wrong yet. In the same way, I believe that in most counties, until the valuation goes up close to £10, the amount paid in sugar tax will more than balance any relief it is proposed to give. That was not the intention of the Dáil when they agreed to give relief to agriculture. Supposing the figures I am giving were found not to be accurate, it is clear that on general principles anyhow the small farmer is going to contribute in proportion to any relief he is getting, far more than will be contributed by the large farmer. I am not admitting the figures are not absolutely correct. I believe they can be shown to be correct.
Comment on this
They were given to the people of Kildare as correct.
Comment on this
Not at all. Is it because the President questions them? A man who turned the balance of trade from £17,000,000 on one side to £17,000,000 on another in a public speech is not a man whose word I am going to take on figures. At any rate, the general principles are unchanged. If the Minister was not in such a mighty hurry, if he was not in such a hurry as to prevent anybody from making a detailed case, then we would have got the figures not merely for Kildare but for a number of other counties as well. The Ministers here introduced two Bills on Wednesday to be forced through the House by their majority, thereby bringing about a situation in which anybody who wanted to propose a reasoned amendment had not an opportunity of drafting it and going through the statistics to prepare the case.
As I say, I believe these figures are correct, and I believe that we can go into it if you like and prove they are correct. It is only a question of getting the necessary statistics. But even if these figures should prove to be incorrect to the extent that a person with a valuation of £4 gets as much in return as he paid out in taxes, it is obvious to everybody that a small farmer of £5 valuation is going to contribute in the shape of the sugar tax proportionately more in regard to the relief he gets than a large holder. Anybody who cannot satisfy himself of that can scarcely be said to be able to reason at all. There is certainly a line to be drawn at some distance, £4, £5, or £10. I have drawn it at £10 because £10 in my opinion is the amount that the £750,000 will meet. If it does not meet £10 let it meet £8 then. The small farmer is entitled to relief in the first instance because he is going to contribute and anybody whose valuation is such as not to give him relief to the extent of 10/6 is going to lose. Such a man is going to lose if he does not get relief to the extent of 10/6, seeing that the average family is going to pay at least 10/6 in the year in sugar tax.
To prevent such a burden being placed on such a man and on such a family I say that the principle in this must be changed. The principle must be altered and the principle in my amendment must be adopted, namely, that you distribute the money so as to relieve some certain number of £'s valuation right through. That will relieve the small farmer to the extent at any rate that if he is not getting a benefit he will, at least, have no additional burden placed on him. If the House passes the Bill in its present form what it will do is to place an additional burden on the men least able to bear it or on the men most entitled to relief. We know that there is five times as much labour given on holdings of 15 to 30 acres as there is given on holdings of 200 acres and there are three and a half times as much labour given on farms of between 30 and 50 acres as on holdings over 200 acres. We know that there is more food produced on small holdings than on the large holdings and that the kinds of stock produced there are those that require the most labour.
Therefore, if agriculture is to be relieved at all it is the small farmer who deserves the first attention. It is certainly an extraordinary way to provide relief for agriculture when that particular section of the agricultural community that most requires relief is going to have an additional burden placed on it. Leaving the figure at 10/6, accepting that as the figure, it is obvious that every small farmer who does not receive relief in rates up to at least 10/6 in the year is going to be penalised. There are a number of small farmers whose total rates do not amount to 10/6. They, even if they were relieved of the whole rates, would, in fact, be getting no relief. If a man has to pay 8/- a year in rates, he is losing 2/6; if his total rates are 7/6, he is going to lose 3/-, and so on. The object of the amendment that I have introduced is to avoid that hardship and to see to it that if money is going to be distributed, money raised by the means of taxation, that the balance is not going to be against the small farmer. We have indicated by our votes here in this House and otherwise that we are against raising this money by a tax on essential articles of food, and especially raising it from the poorer sections of the community. We think it is a wrong way to raise money at all. If the Government is not prepared by economies and retrenchments to provide this money, but is to find it by increased taxation, we are prepared to say that the rest of the community should come to the relief of agriculture. But we think that that section of the community that should be asked to the relief of agriculture is not the poor man, whether he be in the city or town, but it ought to be those who are able to afford it. We would have preferred that this money would have been got by an increase in the income tax rather than that it should be raised by a tax on sugar. It is absolutely iniquitous to speak of relieving agriculture when you are, in fact, putting an additional burden on that section of the community which most deserves relief. It is not necessary for me to labour the point any further, and I ask the House not to take this particularly strange method of coming to the relief of agriculture.
Comment on this
I congratulate Deputy de Valera on having, within such a short space of time, turned such a somersault as he has turned and having come round to our amendment which he opposed here last March.
Comment on this
Might I remind Deputy Davin that I mentioned this particular way immediately the Report of the De-rating Commission was issued in which that suggestion was made, and I considered it an admirable suggestion?
Comment on this
I congratulate Deputy de Valera in having come completely round to our point of view since the 26th March last. This is the 3rd July, and on 26th March last Deputy de Valera rushed into the House in haste and in anticipation, as he thought at the time, of the De-rating Commission Report.
Comment on this
He proposed a motion then asking that a sum of £1,000,000 should be raised to de-rate agricultural land. In that motion, no matter what Deputy de Valera says now, or what he has said outside since, he cannot blot out the records of this House——
Comment on this
The meaning of that motion—much as Deputy Aiken may dislike it, and no matter what he has discovered now, or what Deputy de Valera has discovered—is that out of the £1,000,000 raised for de-rating agricultural land, one-third of the money proposed to be raised under the terms of the original resolution would have gone to the landlords, graziers and ranchers of the country— eight per cent. of the farming community.
Comment on this
He discovered the real meaning of it since. I heard somebody talk about the effect of that motion. The effect of it would be: In Kildare we have 7,105 occupiers of agricultural land, and under the terms of Deputy de Valera's motion as he now knows, £10,500 of the £32,000 which would have gone to that county would have gone to 247 graziers and ranchers, men of the type of poor Lord Cloncurry, people who are not sure whether they will have their breakfast, dinner or supper to-morrow. Deputy de Valera has discovered something in his tour of the Co. Kildare. That is the real meaning of the amendment we have here.
Comment on this
I have endeavoured to find the real meaning of Deputy de Valera's speech on the original motion.
Comment on this
I will wait until Deputy Briscoe has finished if he likes. Subsequent to the discussion on Deputy de Valera's motion, Deputy Lemass, speaking in Monasterevan——
Comment on this
—stated that the Fianna Fáil policy on de-rating was that they were prepared to relieve all those occupiers of holdings with a valuation of £15 and under from the payment of any further rates. In other words he accepted the dictum of the De-rating Report which was signed by Mr. Odlum and Mr. Cussen, a very handy way of taking over a policy signed by somebody else. Now we have the figure reduced to £10 in Deputy de Valera's amendment.
Comment on this
It is quite true that people occupying holdings of £10 or £15 valuation, or perhaps a little higher, represent the section of the farming community who carry the biggest section of the population on their backs. They give more employment, whether to members of their own families or to agricultural labourers, than any other section of the farming community. That is now recognised by Deputy de Valera in the amendment which he is moving to the Second Reading of this Bill. In the amendment which we moved to Deputy de Valera's motion on the 26th March last, we stated quite specifically that the money which would have to be raised for the derating of agricultural land, should not be raised by a tax on the necessaries of life. Deputy de Valera very cutely steered clear of stating in his motion how the money should be raised.
Comment on this
If anybody is being misrepresented a very simple way is to get up after such a person has spoken and expose these misrepresentations.
Comment on this
He should not misrepresent the facts. When Deputy de Valera made the speech, Davin was in the House.
Comment on this
The word "lie" was alleged to have been used here on Wednesday in a certain part of the House, and there was a great hullabaloo to have it withdrawn. Now we have it used by somebody else. The word should not be used and the simple way is to wait until Deputy Davin has finished and then by way of explanation expose the fallacies and misrepresentations that it is said have been made in the course of his speech.
Comment on this
For the information of Deputy Aiken, whose memory is so very short. I will read the motion moved by Deputy de Valera on that occasion. The motion was:
That the Dáil is of opinion that, in the present depressed condition of the agricultural industry, the Executive Council should, this year, provide a special Additional Grant of one million pounds for the relief of local rates on agricultural land, the sum allocated to each county to be in proportion to the average of the total assessments on such land in the county over the current and past two years.
That does not indicate, and all the speeches which were made in support of it did not indicate in what manner the million pounds should be raised.
Comment on this
Deputy Aiken has no right, at least it is not correct for him to deny the statement that Deputy de Valera had not indicated the manner in which that money was to be raised.
Comment on this
Comparing the motion moved by Deputy de Valera, and the speech made in support of that motion with the amendment moved by Deputy O'Connell and the speech made by Deputy O'Connell in favour of the amendment——
Comment on this
It may be that, as a result of the election and the lectures delivered during recent times to the Fianna Fáil Party, as a result of these people coming into contact with the small farmers, that Deputy de Valera and the other members of his Party have been brought round to the point of view expressed by Deputy O'Connell in this House on the 26th March last, namely, that preference in the allocation of any money which is to be raised at the expense of the taxpayers for the purpose of de-rating agricultural land, should be given to small farmers, the people who carry the main body of the population on their backs, and the people who are mostly in need of relief at the present time. For that reason we welcome the conversion of Deputy de Valera and the members of his Party to our point of view.
Comment on this
Since Wednesday last the members of the Labour Party have succeeded in dragging into the discussion on every subject that has taken place the matter of the bye-election which took place in Kildare. I am sure that you, a Chinn Comhairle, would agree that it is most desirable that something should be done to make it impossible for them to refer to the Kildare election in this Dáil ever again. I do not know what is the best way to go about that, but I have a statement here issued by Deputy Davin to the "Irish Times" on Friday last——
Comment on this
If that is Deputy Lemass's cure for references to the Kildare elections, it does not commend itself to the Ceann Comhairle. The Ceann Comhairle would like to see the amendment discussed de novo, beginning with Deputy de Valera's speech and going on with the speeches made in this debate. It does seem to be impossible to rule out quotations from the debate on the motion referred to by Deputy Davin, but the Ceann Comhairle is certainly going to set his face against any quotations from any speech made in the Kildare by-election or any statement made with particular reference to that by-election. I think Deputy Lemass has got out a certain amount, but I think it is better to have no further reference to statements made outside the House.
Comment on this
Let me come to the subject from another direction. Deputy Davin has just made various statements to the effect that the whole anxiety of Fianna Fáil has been in the past to protect the interests of the large farmers, and that we were indifferent to the welfare of the smaller farmers. Deputy Davin and members of Cumann na nGaedheal have been obviously recently in consultation on the best method of attacking Fianna Fáil. The similarity of the wording of their propaganda during the election would indicate that.
It is unfortunate that this particular subject does not appear to have arisen on that discussion, because if it had we would not have Deputy Davin making these statements to-day. Simultaneously with the statement made by Deputy Davin on Friday there appeared a statement issued by the Party opposite stating that Cumann na nGaedheal were going to win in Co. Kildare, and one of the reasons——
Comment on this
I want to get on to the amendment. The Deputy is quite clear, I am sure, that he is not going to convince me that something is relevant which was said in the Kildare election by reading it first. He could not get around my ruling in that way. I think the Deputy has got a fair show now and that he should come to the amendment.
Comment on this
I think, if you hear this particular sentence from this statement you will have to admit that it is relevant.
Comment on this
I may, but if I did I would have to admit the relevancy of other statements. My position is that I am not going to admit the relevancy of any document connected with the Kildare election. I think the note with which Deputy Lemass opened his speech would indicate that we ought to avoid statements made in or about the Kildare election.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin has been criticising Fianna Fáil on the ground that in the past it has endeavoured to provide benefits for large farmers as distinct from small farmers, and he is now pretending to believe that a change of policy has taken place in our Party.
Comment on this
On the other hand, we have his recent allies criticising Fianna Fáil on the ground that our whole concern is for the small farmers, that the large farmers will suffer severely at our hands if it should happen that a Fianna Fáil Government should come into office. What I am anxious to know is why this particular subject was not discussed between Deputy Davin and members of the other Party when planning their joint campaign against Fianna Fáil in the particular county of Kildare, because if they had discussed this matter and arrived at a joint plan of campaign in relation to it, as they do in relation to other matters, we would not have these contradictory statements made. Obviously both statements cannot be correct. Fianna Fáil cannot be here for the purpose of defending the interests of the small farmers and also for the purpose of depriving these farmers of their elementary right as Deputies on the Cumann na nGaedheal side say.
Comment on this
I rise to a point of order. My point is that both sides agreed to the sugar tax, and they went down to Kildare and denounced the Government there for doing what they were a party to here in the Dáil.
Comment on this
There is no use in asking me whether something is a fact. My mind is purposely a blank upon the facts.
Comment on this
Ask Deputy Lemass is it a fact that he, Deputy de Valera and members of the Fianna Fáil Party went into the Lobby with President Cosgrave in favour of the allocation of money for de-rating on a valuation basis?
Comment on this
No. We voted against an amendment by Deputy O'Connell, not because the principles embodied in that amendment, in so far as there were any principles, did not meet with our approval but because a particular method was suggested which if adopted by this House would have meant that no relief would have been given to any farmer in the Twenty-Six Counties this year.
Comment on this
That is a common practice with the Labour Party, when they see an amendment which is likely to put the Government in a hole to come along with an amendment carefully calculated to make it possible for the Government to do something to get out of it. On every occasion on which a motion was submitted in the Dáil by Fianna Fáil concerning which a direct vote for or against the Government would be particularly awkward for the Government we always had a Labour Party amendment, generally a foolish amendment but sufficient to let the Government Party out of its difficulties. The Government were for months talking of the million pounds relief they were going to give the farmers. During a by-election in Dublin Minister after Minister definitely promised that this was to be given immediately the by-election was over. The by-election took place. The Dáil met again and then adjourned and there was no sign of any member of the Government coming to the House to propose the giving of this million pounds. Months passed and still the million pounds was not available. In these circumstances we came here with a clear, definite, simple motion the main purpose of which was to make the Government redeem its promises. It was quite obvious to anyone with ordinary intelligence— I will try to make it clear even to Deputy Davin—that if the Government could get any opportunity in the way of wriggling out of that particular promise they were going to avail of it. We did not give them that opportunity. We did not want to complicate the motion by inserting conditions or reservations which would give them an opportunity of criticising them in detail and thus avoid a decision on the principle. We wanted to get a decision on the principle whether or not relief was to be given. The Government was sheltering itself behind the De-rating Commission. The De-rating Commission was meeting for well over a year and there was no sign of a report forthcoming. In these circumstances we came to the Dáil and asked the Dáil to vote a million pounds for relief this year. Deputy Davin tries to pretend that the proposal we submitted was a proposal for the permanent relief of agriculture. It was not submitted to the Dáil as anything of the kind but as a temporary measure designed to meet temporary circumstances pending the publication of the report of the De-rating Commission and the preparation of a permanent scheme of relief.
Comment on this
We wanted to vote against an amendment which, if passed, would have meant that no farmer would get relief this year and which would have meant the appointment of a new horde of officials. We voted against an amendment which was humbug. The fact was, however, that the Government succeeded, whether in consequence of the Labour trick or not, I will not say, to get out of its promise to provide one million pounds for relief.
Comment on this
On the contrary, in spite of our votes they succeeded in getting out of that promise. Deputy Davin should not talk about votes. There was very nearly an extra member here in consequence of the votes cast by the Labour Party. The Government ultimately came to the Dáil with the proposal to give a relief grant of £750,000. I do not believe they would have agreed to give that amount, if it were not that public opinion was aroused in consequence of the discussion which took place on Deputy de Valera's proposal. Deputy Davin knows quite well that it was the introduction of that motion, and the agitation of public opinion which followed that discussion, that forced the Government to redeem their original promise to the extent of £750,000.
Comment on this
The Deputy will find there is no element of doubt whatever concerning the correctness of what I am saying. Minister after Minister, from the President down, automatically talked about the relief they were going to give the farmers. The "Irish Independent" day after day came out with large headlines across the principal page, parading the statement that one million pounds was forthcoming as soon as the Government candidate had successfully negotiated the County Dublin by-election. Other Deputies with less responsibility than members on the front benches went beyond one million. I have produced quotations in the Dáil showing how members of Cumann na nGaedheal bid against one another as to the amount of relief they were going to provide. Deputy Connolly won the auction. He offered two million. Only £750,000 was ultimately provided, and that was provided because Fianna Fáil carried out its functions, the function of walking upon the heels of the Government, trying to make them go a little faster than they were prepared to go.
Comment on this
A sum of £750,000 was provided in a manner to which we took considerable objection. Deputy Sheehy says that we voted for the sugar tax.
Comment on this
Your Party agreed to it and did not take a division.
Comment on this
On every occasion on which the Finance Resolutions, the Finance Bill, or sections of it relating to the sugar tax, came before the House we divided the House. The last division took place less than 24 hours ago. Deputy Sheehy does not know what was being done. He comes to the House when the division bell rings and asks Deputy Duggan or Deputy Doyle, "What side am I on, Tá or Níl?" He does not know what decisions are being taken.
Comment on this
I am here for hours daily and the Deputy is not.
Comment on this
Only yesterday we voted against the sugar tax, while Deputy Sheehy voted for it, and apparently did not know what he was voting for. We objected to that particular method of raising money. Our main objection was that the sugar tax would result in a certain class of agricultural holder being compelled to pay more in taxation to the Central Government than it was being relieved of in rates charged by local authorities, and that on the majority of farmers we were increasing rather than decreasing the burden. The method of allocation proposed here means that we are taking more from those who need relief most, in combined rates and taxes, than we did before, and giving the benefit of the increased charge upon them to those who need relief least—that is, assuming that a person's need for relief decreases with the size of the holding.
We believe that the proposal submitted in the addendum of the majority report of the De-rating Commission by Mr. Cussen and Mr. Odlum was worthy of the consideration of the Government and of this House; that it contained the elements of a scheme of relief so obviously fair and capable of being made applicable to the existing situation here that we were very much surprised that the Executive Council decided to reject it. These two members of the Commission proposed that instead of giving relief on a flat rate to all farmers, or so much to each county on the basis of population, or on the basis of total valuation, the relief should be given so that all farmers under a definitely fixed valuation of, say, £15, would be entirely released from the obligation to pay rates and that all other farmers would be released from that obligation to the extent of the first £15 valuation. It might have been made the first £20 or the first £25 of the valuation. The extent to which we would give relief would be determined by the amount of money the Government proposed to give. We understand that if the Government give £1,000,000 we could give relief on the first £15 of the valuation. As the relief is limited to £750,000, we understand we could only give relief on the first £10. Deputy Davin attempted to represent Deputy de Valera's amendment as another change of policy on the part of Fianna Fáil. The Deputy does not understand, and I cannot make him understand the position. The original proposal of Fianna Fáil was that £1,000,000 be given. Because that has been reduced to £750,000 we cannot give relief on more than the first £10 valuation.
Comment on this
I am afraid I must. In our opinion the method of allocation proposed, although slightly better than the method in the existing agricultural grant, was such that the benefits of the amount which the Dáil is providing for agriculture will be greatly diminished. If the method of allocation was devised to help those who need help most, and to limit it in the case of those who least require it, we would get full value for the amount proposed to be taken in taxation from the people. The benefit of this grant will be considerably reduced, and in some cases it will be practically nil. That is why we are opposed to this particular method of allocation, and that is why we say, even at this late stage, that the allocation can be changed without legislative difficulties. I hope we will be able to get the Dáil to consider the principle embodied in the Bill, as compared with the principle embodied in the amendment, and get a decision on the merits regardless of any red herrings that the Labour Party may introduce into the discussion.
Comment on this
We came here to-day prepared to show that the Government by the method in which they have allocated the money were not doing what is best in the interests of agriculture. We expected we would get co-operation from all sides of the House when Deputy de Valera definitely proved that the farmers were going to be relieved under this scheme of less than 10/6 in rates, while they would have to pay more by way of a tax on sugar. We thought at least that every member who said that he was standing in the interests of the ordinary people would have assisted and supported Deputy de Valera's case. Time and again we have stated that £750,000 or £1,000,000 was not sufficient to take agriculture out of its present depressed state. We have pointed to the burdens that have been piled on to the agricultural community by the Government, year after year, while the income of that community was going down. We have pointed out that if we had control of the Government, instead of giving £750,000 we would give £2,000,000 for the relief of the agricultural community.
We could give much further relief by keeping more of our money at home. All this has been pointed out time and again by Deputy de Valera, who is the leader of the principal Opposition here in this country, and seeing that the Fianna Fáil Party are the alternative to the present administration and that they stand not for £750,000 relief to small and large farmers alike, but for two million pounds, and that if a smaller sum is to be given it will be given in a manner that will relieve those who are burdened most, surely to goodness anyone who had the good of the ordinary people at heart would have come in here to the Dáil and supported Deputy de Valera in his attack on the Government for their maladministration. Instead of that we have Deputy Davin coming in here and repeating misstatements which he has been making around the country and which were refuted here on 13th May last. I do not know what the reason of it is. I do not know whether Deputy Davin is going to get another token of appreciation or not.
Comment on this
What does the Deputy mean by that? I am not looking for appreciation from the Fianna Fáil Party or from the Government.
Comment on this
What does the Deputy mean by that statement? Let him tell the country what he means.
Comment on this
I will tell you; don't you fret. Deputy Davin is not going to get any appreciation from me, or anybody who prates about doing something for the ordinary people of this country and does his best to keep that gang in power.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy in order in referring to the Government Party as a "gang?" He knows a good deal about gangstering.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy is in order in referring to the Government which is the creation of the House as a "gang." There is no doubt about that.
Comment on this
I want the Deputy to be frank and tell the country what he means by the insinuation that I am looking for appreciation from the Government. If he can shoot straight let him talk straight.
Comment on this
I am not excited about getting that made clear at all. What I would like to make clear is that we are discussing how we are going to distribute £750,000 by way of rating relief. I want Deputies to keep to that.
Comment on this
Yes, we were discussing that and I was pointing out that an honest effort had been made here by the principal Opposition to bring the Government to their senses and to force them to do something for the ordinary people, particularly the farming community that are at the present time in most need of relief, and that we have also been trying to get the Government, if they are only to spend a smaller sum than the two millions which is necessary for full de-rating, to spend that money in giving relief to the people who are in most need of relief. Deputy Davin, instead of supporting our case, and instead of attacking the Government, as they should be attacked, never even mentioned the Government's policy once. I challenge those who were not in the House when he was making his speech to read it, and say whether there was one single word of condemnation of the Government's proposal to distribute the rates as they propose doing. Deputy Davin, as far as this House is concerned, is quite agreeable to the Government's present distribution.
Comment on this
He did not say a word against it. Anything he said was a misrepresentation of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
One of Deputy Davin's misrepresentations was this — one would think it was a Cumann na nGaedheal speech down the country. It was "Deputy de Valera,""Deputy de Valera,""Deputy de Valera," all the time.
Comment on this
Of course he deserves a token of appreciation from the Government for that. "Deputy de Valera," says Deputy Davin, "did not say how the money was to be raised when he introduced a million motion." Deputy de Valera said this on that occasion:
"We pointed out here in the last two or three days ways in which a sum equivalent to that mentioned in the motion can be found by economies. We pointed out the direction in which these economies can be effected, but the men who talk of economies, `at the bottom, in the middle and at the top' were not prepared to face these economies."
Again Deputy de Valera said:
"I am precluded from referring to the land annuities in connection with this motion. It is not that I am abandoning our case, but I did not want to have another red herring across the debate by the Deputies on the benches opposite."
Our leader, on that occasion, by his motion, indicated two ways of getting the million relief without adding any further burden to the community, either agricultural or the towns. The first was the retention of the land annuities of which Deputy Davin and the other members of his Party want to make a free present to John Bull every year. If Deputy Davin and the members of Cumann na nGaedheal had not enough backbone to stand up for their rights, we want them at least to effect economies amounting to one million in order to give farmers a million for that year. We all know the tactics in war of creating a diversion. If Deputy Davin were over on those benches he would not be so effective against us as he is when he is pretending to be a Labour man. When we introduced the motion asking the Government to give a million pounds towards de-rating, Deputy Davin and the rest of them came in and tried to create a diversion so that the Government might get away in the confusion. That is what he is trying to do to-day, but we want to pin the Government down to what they can do. When we introduced the million motion our leader gave his reason for the system of allocation.
He said: "This motion of mine is not intended to be a substitute for a considered scheme of de-rating. It is purely a temporary measure introduced to give timely assistance, because we are of opinion that immediate assistance is wanted. It does not indicate, as far as we are concerned, the lines on which we would propose a de-rating scheme, if the duty of proposing such a scheme devolves upon us." Deputy Davin has ears, he has eyes, and he is clever enough to take sense out of ordinary English when he wants to take sense out of it. Of course he is also cunning enough when for his own purposes he wants to, to twist ordinary English used by Deputy de Valera to the advantage of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. Clearly our leader showed there that the introduction of our million motion was to give immediate assistance, that it did not represent, or propose to represent, our system of permanent de-rating, and when the Budget was introduced we proposed that the first fifteen pounds valuation should be completely de-rated. We find that £750,000 will only completely de-rate the first £10 valuation, and we propose that the Government should use the money in order to de-rate completely all holdings under £10 valuation. Surely, when it has been proved that those under £10 valuation will pay more by way of additional tax on sugar than they receive in relief of rates, any ordinary person who wants to do his duty most effectively would support such a motion as ours. The Government have behaved scandalously towards the ordinary people during their term of office. They have every year and in every way so arranged the machinery of Government, so distributed taxes, as to make the rich richer and the poor poorer. In every Budget they have given enormous relief to the people who pay income tax. The year before last they reduced the tax on champagne but on nothing else. This year, when they wanted to raise additional taxes, instead of putting anything on champagne or on tall hats or black silk stockings for attending official functions, they put something on the sugar. Then you have the situation that, instead of being asked here definitely to stand over their policy, a diversion is created to confuse the issue. You have people like Deputy Davin coming in here and creating a diversion to cause confusion so that the Government may not be asked to account for their policy.
Comment on this
The Government, to raise this £750,000, have to increase taxation, and seeing that they are going to raise a large proportion of the money by the sugar tax, which will come off the small farmers, they should try and see, at least, that the small farmers will not be worse off this year than last year and take the burden of the rates completely from those under £10 valuation. I think it is a scandal that people getting less than 7/6 in relief in rates should be asked to pay more by the additional tax on sugar, and I hope that any of the members of the so-called Labour Party who get up to speak will ask the Government to justify this instead of telling lies and misrepresenting the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
He blacklegged on the occasion of anti-conscription. Find out the member of your Party who did it.
Comment on this
I wish the Deputies would keep to the allocation of the £750,000. That is what we are discussing. If they had a little sense of humour there would not be so much heat at all. If they look at the Government Front Bench I am sure there will be less excitement.
Comment on this
I would like to draw the attention of the House to the complete change of front by the Fianna Fáil Party in regard to the allocation of the money in relief of rates. I remember the time when the Fianna Fáil Party were out to give relief of rates to the tillage farmers simply because the tillage farmers employ four or five men. We do not hear now of relief for the tillage farmer or the dairy farmer employing four or five men. The Party has evidently discovered that the voting power of the tillage farmer and the dairy farmer is practically negligible as compared with the small farmers, hence the zeal we see displayed for the small farmers. I believe the Government allocation is a wise one, because they have taken into account the stress of the tillage farmer and of the dairy farmer, men who give large employment, and I am sure they will not accede to the wishes of the Fianna Fáil Party in the allocation of this money, a Party who are always guided by the results of the polling day.
[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]
Comment on this
I have a grievance in connection with the allocation. A small section of the agricultural community is entirely overlooked on this occasion. Under Section 48 of the Local Government Act, 1898, agricultural holdings situated in urban areas are excluded from the benefits of agricultural grants, and they are also excluded from any benefit under the present proposals, and I think it is unfair. I am putting up no plea for the wealthy shopkeepers in towns who may have land in urban areas, but there is a considerable section of people in the country whose land is situated in these areas, and they are subject to undue hardship. They are subject to urban rates. They get certain reliefs, but I am sure that, on the whole, their position is a hard one, and I ask the Minister if he can give them relief. The amount of money required is not very considerable, and it should not be hard to find a means of giving relief to these people. I do not want to take part in this controversy, but with reference to Deputy Dr. Hennessy's remark, the small farmers are all tillage farmers; the small farmer is, perforce, a tillage farmer. Therefore to say that we have purposely left out tillage farmers is perfectly absurd.