We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - Electricity (Supply) (Amendment) Bill, 1931—Second Stage.

Contributions 165–320 of 320. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electricity (Supply)(Amendment) Bill, 1931
Enacted

No. 31 of 1931 ›

Then the Minister does not need £850,000 for that purpose. Are we to take it that the interest has not been paid on these moneys to whoever holds the bonds, as in the case of the Dublin undertaking, and that only the interest will be paid? The Minister says that he wants £850,000 to discharge these liabilities, but when he is asked if he is going to pay them he says "No." Therefore the £1,150,000 is reduced by £850,000, so that all the Minister's requirements would be to pay off the immediate trade liabilities of the Board, and to give them sufficient to carry on development which should be in the neighbourhood of £300,000 to £400,000.

We do not know what the Shannon Board owe to the Minister. I think he hinted it was about £250,000. The Minister says we are not going to discharge these liabilities. Then what is the sense of asking for the money now? Why has not the Minister presented to the House the last accounts of the Board in view of the present demand? Why is he giving no information as to how far they have developed and what number of units they sell? We had grand reports on the last occasion with pictures of transformer stations, and we were told about the amount of current. What we want to know now is, apart from what we heard at the Rotary Club and street corner meetings during elections, how far has the scheme advanced, and what is the position to-day? I may not be in agreement with members of my own Party on this, or with the House, but when the Shannon scheme was started the development that I would like to have seen was the getting of customers for electricity who had not hitherto been using it. Instead of that they grabbed all they could in the shape of existing plant. They took over the Rathmines plant and the Pembroke plant, thus committing themselves immediately, in order that Shannon current would be used, to replacing every implement, every piece of machinery, every motor, every wireless apparatus, and even every vacuum cleaner. They had to replace all these for the users for the purpose of getting the customers in Rathmines and Pembroke. I consider that that was a silly thing to do.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think the Deputy ought to go into the question of local stations.

Comment on this

This is the first opportunity we have had of discussing the Shannon scheme since its inception, and I contend, and I ask your ruling on the matter one way or the other, that it is in order to discuss every single item of expenditure of the Shannon Board which has brought about this position. Do you rule that it is out of order? If I can prove that a policy was adopted which meant the extravagant use of money, almost amounting to wastage, and that that contributed, to a certain extent, to the present state of affairs in connection with the Board, do you rule that that is out of order?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think it would be much better——

Comment on this

I want a definite ruling.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I will give a definite ruling when it is required, but I suggest that it would be much better for the purpose of this discussion if the Deputy did not go into the question of every little plant in the country.

Comment on this

I am not going into the question of every little plant.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The point is that if the Deputy goes into the question of a particular plant every Deputy is entitled to do the same. I suggest that for the purposes of this discussion we ought not to go into details in that way. I am only suggesting that—I am not giving a ruling.

Comment on this

I am not going to deal with the 146 undertakings in the country.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There are 153 Deputies.

Comment on this

I think I am entitled as an illustration to refer to a particular plant and to particular transactions which took place. I say that whoever engineered the policy of taking over an existing plant which necessitated, in order to work the Shannon scheme, the complete wiping out of every implement formerly used with the electrical current, and the expending of capital sums of money to put the people owning these instruments back again on the basis of customers, was, to say the least of it, foolish. Certainly, the Minister who stood for that against public opposition has to take as much responsibility as anybody else. The Minister spoke about his agreement with a member or members of the Board. As far as we are concerned, any private undertakings given or agreements made between the Minister and the Board, outside the Act, or beyond the Act, do not concern us. We must judge this thing on the basis of the Act and on the debates which took place on the setting up of this scheme. If the Minister, when putting through the Shannon scheme, had at the back of his mind the over-riding of the House by having other agreements outside the purview of the House it was certainly wrong. The Minister admits that he led the Dáil to believe that a sum of two and a half million pounds would be sufficient for the Board and he wants the Dáil to support him in his present attitude because they believed him when he made that statement. I have no doubt that the Minister did believe it. I will go that far with him. I have no doubt that the Dáil hoped that the two and a half millions would be sufficient. But is there any reason why the Board should be blamed if the Minister and the Dáil miscalculated? As a matter of fact, the Minister took me to task several times because I said the scheme would cost £10,000,000. Now we have it that it has cost £12,100,000. The Minister took me to task in this House and poured all kinds of abuse and ridicule on me because I said that the scheme had cost at that time almost £10,000,000. Now the exact cost to the State, from what we know or from the figures admitted, is £12,100,000, not counting the value of the plant acquired by the Board without compensation to the districts concerned. If we include these we will find that the cost of the scheme is somewhere about £15,000,000. I am not one of those who wants to score because the scheme happens to be in difficulties, but we should face up to the facts. If the scheme requires the help of the nation to put it on its feet let us do it, but let us do it in a fair and open way and not by all kinds of political scoring such as the Minister has indulged in. I am almost tempted to say that the great publicity given to the Drumm battery is only beating the drum to take our attention off the Shannon scheme. That is what it appears to me. It is most unfair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy cannot deal with the Drumm battery now.

Comment on this

The Minister refuses to give the House facts and figures which he himself knows. He says he does not know them. I asked on the 12th June, 1929, the Minister for Industry and Commerce if he has received the report from the Electricity Supply Board of its proceedings for the first year's work as prescribed by Section 32 (1) of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1927. The Minister answered:

I will answer questions 9 and 10 together. The Electricity Supply Board was appointed in August, 1927, and its operations and expenditure in the financial year 1927-28 were, therefore, of a preliminary nature only. In view of the heavy pressure of work on the Board, I have arranged that its accounts and the auditor's report thereon, together with the annual report, should, in respect of the years 1927-28 and 1928-29 be furnished together. I expect to lay copies of these accounts and annual reports before each House at the commencement of next Session.

Then I asked a supplementary question: "Does the Minister feel that he has power to do that within the terms of the Act?" The Minister said: "Yes, certainly." Then I asked further: "So that the Act can be read one way for the Minister and one way for the people?" The Minister replied: "I would not take the Deputy's point of view on that." It appears to me that not only does the Minister want to read the Act in one way for himself and in another way for the Dáil, but he also wants to have a third way of reading it as far as the Board is concerned. Is the Minister in a position to give the House a true and accurate reflex of the capital position of the Board? He says he is not in a position to give a true record of its trading and revenue activities. Has the Minister made any effort to get from the Board separate accounts with regard to the sale of current, as distinct from the sale of fittings and plant and machinery and the installations in houses? The Minister must not forget that when the Shannon Board was set up it took away the livelihood of many men who were engaged on these plants and it also endangered the livelihood of those engaged in the electricity business.

The Shannon Board went out to undercut and to undersell in every shape and form of their activities the ordinary traders. Attention was drawn to that on several occasions, but the Minister refused to give any expression of opinion on the matter. I say it will be discovered at a future date when the accounts are properly examined, that the traders in regard to this and other parts of the scheme had to fight against unfair competition by the Shannon Board, and that the Minister will find that he has a great deal more to account for. Several firms in the electrical supply trade pointed out that wiring was done by the Shannon Board on a basis and at a price that it could not be done by ordinary firms, yet we were told that they were able to do it.

I want to know if they were able to wire houses and do it right, and what are the figures and what is the amount of loss, if any, due to the fact that the house-wiring operations of the Board were at fault. Another point I put to the Minister was that the Shannon Board were trading in competition with the ordinary ratepayers and taxpayers. No one knows whether their shops are on a paying basis. We should get separate accounts for these moneys. The Minister will not say to what he will devote this money or portion of it. He wants £2,000,000. As I pointed out, as the Minister is not going to pay out of that money immediately the amount required for the acquiring of local undertakings, he does not require that £850,000 at the moment. Deputy Lemass asked what he required the money for and to what extent he required it. The Minister should take the attitude of getting from this House a sufficient amount of money to enable him to carry out the activities of ordinary development. The House is not going to take up the position which the Minister did of holding up the Board for nine months, and then trying to put the responsibility for the extra loss which accrued on to the Board by the stopping of their operations. The House is agreeable to give what money is necessary to enable the Board to function in its normal way. But the House should be careful of giving this £850,000 to the Minister for a purpose for which he says he does not want it. He is not going to use it immediately; why, then raise the money and put the charge and the responsibility of having to pay the interest upon the Board?

I have gone through the Act section by section—Sections 71 to 79, deal with the activities of the Board in relation to local authorities. I do not know whether the Board ever advanced money to local authorities to develop the use of electricity. I do not know whether the Board has gone guarantor for local authorities to develop the use of electricity. The Board has all these powers under the Act, but we got no information on the subject from the Minister as to whether these liabilities are there. Let the Minister come here and put his cards on the table. As far as I am concerned I knew this was coming some years ago, and the Minister said that because I was descended from a nation of prophets I should not pretend to prophesy here.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy say I said that?

Comment on this

Yes. The Minister can look at the records.

Comment on this

Under what head?

Comment on this

I will send it to the Minister.

Comment on this

I deny I ever said that.

Comment on this

The Minister did say it, but perhaps he is ashamed of it now.

Comment on this

I never said it.

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny categorically that he referred to me as descended from prophets?

Comment on this

I do not believe I did. I would hesitate to say it now from what I have heard.

Comment on this

Probably the Minister has forgotten that as well as a lot of other things he said about the Shannon. I have two volumes of the Official Reports here with his statements.

Comment on this

Then pick out the quotation.

Comment on this

I can pick it out all right. The Minister gave the House no opportunity of criticising the Electricity Supply Board accounts. I wrote the Minister a personal letter asking would he ever give the House an opportunity of discussing the accounts presented, and the Minister's reply was that he would oppose it. The Minister has a majority and there is no sense putting down a motion when he would oppose it. Like his colleague, the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, if he is opposed to anything it must not be done. I wanted to know from the Minister if I would have an opportunity of criticising the accounts. I do not think we will have that opportunity, but I hope the Minister will bring the accounts into the House some time. I cannot find in the Act, or any discussion relating to the Act, any item that would give the Board the right, for instance, of capitalising any office expenditure.

You will find in the first year's business office expenditure put down as capital expenditure, notwithstanding that they took over concerns and plants which were producing revenue. Another thing I would ask the Minister is if he would give us some indication as to the actual generation cost of the current generated from the Shannon proper as distinct from current developed in plant taken over and generated under the Electricity Supply Board. Let us get an idea of what the generation costs are. I ask the Minister if the Board is in a position through him to tell the House if they have any idea of their distribution costs, if he can give us the cost to the Board per unit of the distribution of electricity. There is an item there for management expenses and overhead charges and we see a lot of property here. I ask the Minister if he can tell us what properties the Electricity Supply Board have acquired and where they are. As far as I can see, everywhere in Dublin you see offices of the Electricity Supply Board. Surely all these could be consolidated into one building and the cost attached to the keeping of so many buildings cut down? The Minister put the proposition that the Electricity Supply Board was outside the control of the House. It was nobody's business, and now it is everybody's business. I do not know whether the Board is functioning now as a Board under the Act or whether the resignation of Doctor MacLaughlin and the man who was Chairman and afterwards Director have taken effect, or whether the Board is still there or whether there exists as Deputy Johnson at the time pointed out there might exist, a state of chaos there. The state of chaos, if it existed, would not exist for many days, because before he would dismiss a man or call for any change he would have somebody in his mind to take over the running of the place. Is the Minister prepared to say that whatever money he gets from the House he is going to be responsible to the House for that money and that he is going to give a full, clear and detailed statement of the affairs of the Board as they are now and from time to time in the future? I am not going into all these figures here, because they can only be dealt with if accounts are presented. I only want to say that the Minister himself on the Second Reading of the Bill juggled between the independence of the Board and interference by the Dáil in the management of the affairs. First of all, when the late Deputy Cooper, Deputy Good, Deputy Hewat and a few others pointed out that they would feel better pleased if the accounts and the affairs of the Board would come under the control of the Comptroller and Auditor-General, the Minister pooh-poohed the idea of the Comptroller and Auditor-General, and pointed out that if he were to be given any look in at all the whole development of the scheme would be upset and retarded. And on the other hand he pointed out that civil servants could not be expected to run the service on a business basis, that running it as an ordinary Government Department would be quite as dangerous. "In saying that," he added, "I am passing no criticism on the Civil Service as we find it at the moment. The Civil Service was not recruited for the purpose of running business undertakings like this..." That is in Column 1907, 15th March, 1927, Volume 18 of the Official Debates.

Comment on this

That is from the book of words.

Comment on this

The book of proverbs. It is certainly, section by section, a peculiar item. Again, in Col. 2022 of the 16th March, on the Second Stage of the Bill, Mr. McGilligan, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, in answer to Deputy Myles on the same point, says: "But once this Board is set up I, personally, have nothing in the way of responsibility for it. I have no interest in it, and I wash my hands of it completely." That was on the Second Reading Stage of the Bill of 1927.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy might read on a quarter of a column farther.

Comment on this

Further on, on the same occasion, Deputy Davin asked: "Is it not a fact that under Section 4 a case could be made in certain circumstances for the removal of a member of the Board for certain stated reasons? Could not reasons be brought about by political pressure from the Executive Council for the removal of a member?"

Comment on this

I must ask the Deputy to read on further.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin seems to have had the present position weighed up pretty well.

Comment on this

Read on.

Comment on this

I have it here marked in red.

Comment on this

Have you marked in red "Saving always the power to dismiss"? I think you will find that there.

Comment on this

In Column 2023 the Minister said: "If it is suggested that an Executive Council wants to remove a member of the Board for political purposes, and is going to do so, whether these political purposes be good, bad or indifferent, as long as it has a majority of the elected representatives of the House behind it..." I do not see where that comes in at all except the Minister states about having created a political storm over the removal of a member. The Minister definitely states there that once the Board is set up he shifts all responsibilities and washes his hands out of it. But how has the Minister acted in the last few years? As far as I understand the Minister has changed his attitude in this House with regard to the Board. As far as I understand his attitude in this House was always that of giving the point of view of the Board, but his attitude to the Board was that he was speaking as the Oireachtas.

In view of the serious situation, he refers to letters and correspondence he had with the members of the Board. He points out that he spoke always as the Oireachtas, and if one reads the debates one will find that he always spoke as the Shannon Board here. Certainly, since September, 1927, since I came into this House the Minister has never been in any way helpful or anxious to allay any suspicions that were in the minds of the Deputies, or any doubts as to the success of the undertaking.

We have certainly got a lot of figures from the Minister, peak loads, units, and so on. I think Deputy Thrift, on a certain occasion here, asked for certain assurances that things were going right, and that the normal development of the undertaking was satisfactory. Is Deputy Thrift satisfied to-day? Is he satisfied that the Minister is entitled to get £2,000,000 without giving the House any information as to what he wants that money for? The state and finances of the Board are in such a way that he does not know where it is going to end or how much more they are liable for. Is Deputy Thrift going to take the attitude of saying "We will give you as much money as you require immediately so long as it will not stunt the normal development of your scheme, but we will give the Minister no money he needs until he comes to the Dáil with a definite statement of the affairs"? I would go almost as far as to say that Deputy Thrift's attitude would be, judging by the interest he took in the original setting up of the Board, and having regard to the ambiguous nature of the published accounts, and the manner in which the Minister has treated this House in his statement to the House with regard to the present position, that we should give no further money, except what is absolutely certified as being necessary for the economic development of the scheme until we have a definite statement from the Minister as to the exact position.

I think the Minister was disputing with Deputy Lemass the amount of money stated to be required for the Shannon works. The Minister stated at that time that the figure for the Shannon works would be £4,500,000 and £2,500,000 for the Board, plus £600,000 interest during the years up to the year 1932. The Minister all through his debate took the line of assuring the House that not one penny more would be required, that he was not trying to get £600,000 by a trick-of-the-loop, in other words. He took great care to show that he wanted so much money. Now we come to the stage where a whole lot more is required, and I say that as much care should be taken by the House now in voting £2,000,000 to make good the deficiencies of management as was taken by the House to grant 2½ million pounds before there was any Board, before there was any mismanagement, or any liabilities incurred. The House then took great care before they gave 2½ million pounds. I think they had no reason to refuse it then. They were then committed to it, having engaged themselves in a contract with Messrs. Siemens-Schuckert. We are in a much more difficult position to-day and we should be much more careful.

In discussing the question of the Comptroller and Auditor-General the Minister stated, amongst other items, that he wanted an outside auditor. He did not want the Comptroller and Auditor-General. He wanted a more impartial audit. "I would like to have the audit as impartial as can be achieved. In so far as it aims at greater publicity more accounts should be given to the public who are the shareholders. I am all for that."

That is in col. 646, 31st March, 1927. The Minister's attitude then was "We will have no Comptroller and Auditor-General, but I will have my own private accounting officer, and I will have him for the reason that I will have an impartial audit of the Shannon scheme, so as to insure that the public will have greater publicity and more accounts to be given to the public who are the shareholders." What is our experience of these accounts of the Shannon Board? We have had no publicity. Again in col. 649 we find this, for the 31st March, 1927:

"Professor Thrift: I desire to say that I voted against Deputy Cooper's amendment on the strength of two statements made by the Minister which seemed to me to be most important. I agree that it is desirable to keep the doings of this Board as far as possible from general discussion in the Dáil. I agree with the Minister also that it is desirable that as much publicity as possible should be given to the financial work of the Board."

I hope Deputy Thrift still subscribes to that attitude. I hope he will still stand for and support the demand for full publicity of the doings of the Board, particularly as regards the financial position. I am not going to go into all the figures the Minister gave us in regard to the units of electricity and so on and all the technical points but I must say that the Minister's statement to-day has been most disappointing. I think it is, to say the least of it, not manly for the Minister to try to shed himself of his own responsibilities and to throw the full responsibility on to the shoulders of one or two individuals. He has definitely made a cleavage as far as the Board is concerned, though the whole Board is responsible as far as we are concerned. Dr. MacLaughlin has been thrown to the wolves. Would I be correct in saying that the previous Chairman of the Board resigned from the Board whether at the request of the Minister or the President of the Executive Council? The President said it was not so when I asked a question. The fact remains that the Chairman resigned and went back as an ordinary member of the Board. What I want to ask the Minister is —did that Chairman get compensation to the amount of £500 when he resigned his chairmanship of the Board? Is there any foundation for the statement that the previous Chairman of the Board was given any compensation whatever when he resigned from the chairmanship?

Comment on this

I could answer that question simply by saying no, but that would be misleading. He did not get it on resignation, but he got it by way of extra remuneration on being re-appointed as a part-time member.

Comment on this

Could the Minister say what was the amount?

Comment on this

I have not it in my head.

Comment on this

Will the Minister promise to get the amount?

Comment on this

Certainly, quite soon.

Comment on this

If the Minister has come to the House now to give the ex-Managing Director £2,000 on his resignation on the grounds the Minister stated, I say the Minister had no power previously to give the previous Chairman any compensation by way of extra remuneration when he resigned from the chairmanship over differences on policy. That Chairman was brought back as an ordinary member of the Board. He has also gone out with Dr. MacLaughlin. I do not suppose he is getting compensation again this time.

Comment on this

Section 2 is where my power was to do whatever was done.

Comment on this

Why is not the late Managing Director given compensation under that section?

Comment on this

Because it does not apply.

Comment on this

What part of Section 2 gives the Minister power?

Comment on this

Sub-section (7).

Comment on this

"Every member of the Board shall be paid out of the funds at the disposal of the Board such remuneration and such allowances for expenses as the Executive Council shall when appointing him prescribe." Does that give the Minister any power to give a man remuneration when he resigns?

Comment on this

No; that is why this Bill is necessary. It can be done when a man is re-appointed.

Comment on this

Compensation was given to the Chairman when he was re-appointed.

Comment on this

There was remuneration given to the ex-Chairman when he was re-appointed.

Comment on this

Of course the Minister does not know the amount now?

Comment on this

I do not know the exact figure.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say later what brought about the resignation of that Chairman from that chairmanship? Surely the Minister cannot take up the attitude of saying "I do not know, he just resigned, we went after him and begged him to come back." There must have been some reason why he resigned.

Comment on this

There must have been with him.

Comment on this

The Minister does not know why he resigned?

Comment on this

He did not tell me.

Comment on this

Will the Minister deny that the ex-Chairman was called on to resign?

Comment on this

There were mixed circumstances, but I would not like to say that he was called on to resign.

Comment on this

What would the Minister say if I said that he told me he was called on by him to resign?

Comment on this

I would like to have the whole circumstances of the resignation.

Comment on this

Would the Minister deny that he was called on to resign by the Minister?

Comment on this

We will have to get down to details in this. I do not believe the Chairman of the Board was definitely called on to resign.

Comment on this

Not as such.

Comment on this

I can say this, that he told me that he was called on by the Minister to resign.

Comment on this

All I can say is that he was telling you wrong.

Comment on this

That he was not telling me the truth?

Comment on this

The truth depends on the way it is said.

Comment on this

I will leave it at that; I have his word for it.

Comment on this

I indicated a certain set of circumstances to him and he resigned.

Comment on this

The Minister obviously put up to him certain things with which he did not agree.

Comment on this

The fact remains that he resigned. A certain statement was made to me and it was denied in this House. I asked if the resignation of the Chairman was the result of a request that was made to him and the President said "No." The Minister's present attitude in reply to Deputy O'Kelly's questions is certainly not very impressive. The Minister knows more about that particular situation than he pretends to know or wants to give this House particulars of.

Comment on this

May I put this point with regard to that? If I had not the resignation at that particular time or thereabouts I think I would have come here to ask for his dismissal.

Comment on this

It is a great pity the Minister did not do so. He would have had much more sympathy in the House if he dismissed the man because he had come to the conclusion that he was not developing the scheme in the best interests of the country or of the finances of the State as a whole; but for the Minister to get it done in a way in which it is kept from the House I think is not fair or reasonable. I am not going to delay the House any further in going into a lot of information that I have here, but I want to know from the Minister if he is going to take this House into his full and open confidence and to give us an opportunity of satisfying ourselves as to the exact position of the scheme as regards its development from the technical point of view, and certainly as regards its financial aspect, so that the House can decide in what way further money may be given, and so that the House may find whether development on any great scale at the present time would be advisable or not, or whether it should go on for a certain number of years until certain things are wiped out and certain changes take place. On the other hand, the House may come to the conclusion that it would be far better to go on immediately with the further development of the scheme which the Minister stated he would give to the House. I hope the House will hold that what has been requested by Deputy Lemass is reasonable, that only such moneys will be given the Minister at the present time as will enable him to carry on for a particular period. That is distinctly different from the attitude of the Minister who left the concern high and dry—to carry on on the revenue from the sale of current and forced them, I imagine, to use certain revenues which should have been applied to other purposes than what they were used for. I hope the House will make the Minister come to his senses and realise that he is only going to get so much money that will enable him to carry on until such time as we know where we are in regard to the scheme.

Comment on this

How can the Deputy define the amount?

Comment on this

First the Minister said he wanted £2,000,000, and then he said that £1,150,000 of that sum is not required at the moment. He then said he wants £850,000, of which £600,000 is to pay the amount of liability incurred in taking over existing undertakings. He says he is not going to pay that £600,000 just now. Therefore all he requires according to himself for immediate disbursement is a sum of £650,000, which I contend he could get without this Act if he paid up the balance due to the Electricity Supply Board.

Comment on this

That is, I do not want any money.

Comment on this

If you handed the Board this £650,000 due to the Board I say you have £250,000 more than you require for your immediate wants. You are not going to pay off the bondholders of the electricity plant in Dublin. All you want is to pay the sinking fund and the interest. What is the sense of raising the money and paying interest on it?

Comment on this

You said whatever money he wants to develop this scheme. Can you define the amount?

Comment on this

The Minister says he requires £250,000 for that purpose.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

To pay debts.

Comment on this

And to carry on.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

He did not say that.

Comment on this

There are £546,000 still unpaid.

Comment on this

What is it then?

Comment on this

It depends on what the old Act is interpreted to mean.

Comment on this

Is the Minister going to state that the figures in the answer he gave to me the other day when I asked how much money is owing are wrong?

Comment on this

I think you asked how much has been advanced?

Comment on this

Yes. Therefore the amount that was still due was not advanced.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy say that the amount is not yet advanced or due?

Comment on this

If you were to give the Board £500,000 every half year for five years and if for six months you have given them nothing, I presume the balance is due. That is the Board's contention.

Comment on this

Their contention if you like.

Comment on this

The main disagreement between the Minister and the Board was this, that the Board felt that the liabilities of existing plants which they took over would not be a part of this two and a half millions. The Minister's contention was that it was to be included in that. Either one or the other is right. The fact is that this money is not immediately required. No one is asking for the liabilities to be paid at the moment. The Electricity Supply Board own the plants, and the plants, if they are any thing like the Dublin Electricity plants for which £300,000 was paid and which was worth £2,000,000, were very cheap. The only money the Minister wants is first of all an amount to pay the liabilities in the ordinary trading manner and, secondly, whatever money is required to carry on the transmission lines. I know as a result of the Minister's attitude for the last nine months that the Board were not able to bring the current to certain houses which had been wired and people have been issuing writs against the Board in the case of houses which were wired nine months ago. If the Minister had given the Board money to lay their cables or to take down cables which were overloaded and which could not take extra current he would be getting extra customers to consume his units of electricity. At the moment he need not get £2,000,000 or anything like it. He says he requires £250,000 for debts and another £250,000 for the Board to have in hands for ordinary developments for the next three months. I think he should get it but no more and then on the next occasion we should get a complete statement of accounts.

Comment on this

The Minister stated at the beginning of his speech that the Board actually owed £600,000 and stated further that they were honourably committed to a further £250,000 and I understand from the Minister that he has yet to discharge these debts.

Comment on this

The Minister stated that the £600,000 is due to people who were owed money by the undertakings which were taken over; in other words, capital borrowed for existing plants required by the E.S.B. Of that at least £300,000 is held by bondholders who subscribed to the flotation of the Dublin plant and all of whom will be very sorry when the amount is paid up.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

What is so?

Comment on this

That is a long story. I will have to detail it myself.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean that there is £600,000 in addition to the amount due by the various undertakings?

Comment on this

If you take all the liabilities that accrued and ought to have been paid last month, there was a sum of £700,000 definitely in that, and then commitments beyond that.

Comment on this

What commitments are beyond that?

Comment on this

About another couple of hundred thousand.

Comment on this

Is not that based on the assumption that the amount set aside to meet capital liabilities is already provided out of the two million pounds?

Comment on this

If the Deputies like to give the Board a present of the £250,000 in addition to the two and a half million pounds they need not take this sum, but why not vote it honestly rather than this way?

Mr. Flinn rose.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let the Deputy proceed by way of a speech.

Comment on this

If we have to make useful speeches we want accurate information, and we want to understand the information we get. The Minister has been brief, and we have not been all able to take down his figures. He says there is £700,000 of accrued liability. Does he hold against that the £546,000 which have not been advanced?

Comment on this

Not all of it.

Comment on this

Roughly speaking.

Comment on this

I said not all of it, about a half of it.

Comment on this

That is £500,000 of a net liability and another £250,000, making £750,000. That is included in the £3,350,000.

Comment on this

I do not know about that.

Comment on this

I am not cross-examining the Minister. I am asking for information.

Comment on this

I have a feeling that I am being cross-examined. Will the Deputy explain what the £3,350,000 is made up of?

Comment on this

I gave you that figure before.

Comment on this

It is made up of the two and a half million pounds which the Electricity Supply Board had first.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We will have to proceed by way of speeches.

Comment on this

I want to try to get Deputy Murphy into the same frame of mind as I am on this matter, because I believe that we may be perfectly sure that unless the gentlemen over there are going to stand up, and unless Deputy Thrift raises his finger and says "I am not going to support you," this Bill will be carried in its present form. That is why I am anxious to get Deputy Murphy to see the sense of our attitude. That is, that we are anxious to give the Minister sufficient to pay all existing liabilities. All he wants is enough to pay the trade liabilities and the running expenses. Let him state what is that figure, and the House will give it to him. The House does not want to see traders held up, and they do not want to see anything taking place under the Shannon Board that will restrict developments, or the leaving off of men engaged on constructive work that will be of benefit in future. If the Minister is prepared to say that £700,000 is the amount involved, as far as I am concerned, I would be prepared to give him that, but we should not give him more than that until we see something in the way of what Deputy Thrift requires, full publicity as far as the financial aspect of the Board is concerned.

Comment on this

How will you get that?

Comment on this

If we give the £2,000,000 we will not get it until the next time, but if we refuse to give it the Minister will be bound to come to the House and put on the Table a full statement of the activities of the Board. In that way, we will be prepared to give a sympathetic consideration to these figures as we see them.

Comment on this

I only wish to say that I am as much for publicity now as ever I was.

Comment on this

The only way of doing it is by refusing to give this money now.

Comment on this

I do not think that very many members will be disposed to follow the lead given by Deputy Murphy in passing judgment and passing sentence in this particular dispute without hearing the two sides of it. There is scarcely any doubt——

Comment on this

Might I intervene to say that I did not pass sentence? I said that if certain things, which I do not know, happened.

Comment on this

I think it is perfectly clear from Deputy Murphy's statement that he had made up his mind that the merits lay with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, and that the Shannon Board were hopelessly in the wrong, that they had made a mess of their business, and that they deserved whatever punishment it was in the power of the House to give, even to the withholding of sums of money which we are supposed to give them, even the sum proposed to be given to the Managing Director. That seemed to me, at any rate, to reveal an attitude of mind which I hope, and which, in fact, I feel certain, is not the attitude of the majority of members. There is a dispute, a dispute that involves very big issues, and it is our duty to insist on getting all the information that is necessary to enable us to form an impartial decision on the merits of the dispute. We want that information. What the Minister has given us does not supply us with anything like the information necessary to enable us to form a judgment on it, and even if he did give us full information it would be purely an ex parte statement. He is one of the principals in the dispute. The other principals are the Shannon Board. On account of the fact that two of the members of the Board have resigned a situation has developed in which there is discrimination between one set of members of the Board and the other. As far as we in this House are concerned, we ought not to discriminate between members of the Board until we have information which enables us to discriminate.

What is at issue, as far as I have been able to gather from the statement made by the Minister, is concerned with the question of accounts. It would appear that certain accounts which the Board was obliged to furnish have not been furnished. That is a fact, I take it, but further than that fact, what is the cause of the delay in furnishing these accounts? Is it, for example, interference by the Minister? I am only taking that as a possibility. What is responsible for the delay in furnishing these accounts? Was it possible for any Board to furnish these accounts in time? Was the rate of development so fast, for example, as to make it very difficult? I do not know, neither does any member of the House, what has transpired here in connection with these accounts. A year ago, in September, 1930, the then Chairman of the Board was, it appears to me, forced to resign. I think that was the conclusion that every member who was here at the time must have come to. He was forced to resign by the Minister. Was it on the question of the accounts? Each member of the Board was responsible for the accounts if there was a division of responsibility. Was the Chairman responsible for the accounts? If he were, and if there were a difficulty back in September, 1930, the Minister's new nominee was put in his place. Why, if the question were one of accounts, have not the accounts been furnished since September, 1930? Was not that time sufficient to make good? I do not know, neither does any other member in the House.

We have no information. All we know about this matter is that the Minister when he came here asking the House to set up this Board, made a show of the fact that this was to be an independent Board, acting independently without interference from him. He was to have no responsibility whatever for it. He washed his hands out of it and at the very same time or very soon afterwards, after he said that, he looked round in the Act and found there was a clause which completely negatived everything he said then. He said to himself: "I have power to dismiss these people. If I am going to exercise that I must have supervision over the work of the Board and I must know everything that happens." He then provided himself with a liaison officer.

The Minister himself was not apparently able to keep that contact with the Board that was necessary for supervision. What did he do? He handed over to somebody who is to report to him, who is to be the medium by which he is to get information. What does that mean? It means that the control simply passes from the Minister himself to one of the permanent departments. There was some one Civil Servant who had access to the Minister and was able to point out what was wrong. This liaison officer, who was really in control of the Board, was to be in a position in which he would bring about a situation in which the members of the Board and the Minister were going to be at loggerheads. I do not know anything about it further than what we see on the surface. That position was a fundamentally difficult one. You cannot have this half-measure of control. The Minister's idea of having a Board that would be free from Parliamentary control in the ordinary sense, capable of doing its work as a business Board was in my opinion a valuable idea and one that should be supported. I agree that it was an experiment of great sociological value. In fact, some of us believe there are certain developments necessary in the country and that they can only take place if pursued in that manner. I, for one, am anxious that no clash of personality which appears to be at issue here or that no question of pique should come in here to risk the possibility of this valuable experiment being a success. I am anxious about this experiment, this enterprise, in the success of which so much national money is involved. We do not want to see this experiment wrecked on any petty ground.

There is a difficulty undoubtedly. Is this House going to hand over to an independent Board full and complete powers, and is it going to keep no check? If it is going to keep a check, how is it to be made effective? I have no doubt that originally, when the House agreed with the Minister's proposal, it came to the conclusion that the check provided in the Act was the least that it could have if it were to feel that it had any control whatever. Again, that depended upon the person who was to exercise the powers given. Responsibility was placed upon the Minister to exercise those powers wisely and in such a way that this experiment would be given a decent chance to be a success. I do not think the Minister's speech to-night indicates that he has fulfilled this obvious duty in a satisfactory manner. This thing has been going on for two or three years. As regards the accounts, we have the same mess, apparently, under the new Chairman as we had under the old. What is the reason for that? The Minister had the whole country to pick from when he required a Chairman. Nobody interfered with his choice or with the choice of the Executive Council. They could select from the best men available. In appointing the first Chairman I take it they had good grounds for believing that he possessed the qualifications necessary to do the work in a successful way. I remember many years ago the President of the Executive Council talking to me in very eulogistic terms about the man who was later appointed Chairman of the Board, of his ability in matters of finance. Is the position now to be that this man, who was chosen for his ability in matters of finance, has not been able to deal with this particular work and, so to speak, has had to be fired? I find it hard to believe that if the Minister for Industry and Commerce really approached that question sympathetically, and did not want to insist too much on his own views being taken in detail, that the present situation would not have been reached. However, as I say, that is only an opinion. It would be as wrong for me to form a definite judgment on that opinion as it was for Deputy Murphy to form a definite judgment on the other matter. The members of the House have not got sufficient material to enable them to form a sound judgment on this, and therefore we ought not to vote this money until we get all the information that we require.

The only point of real importance that I want to make in connection with the accounts is that apparently the new Chairman, who is a civil servant, was not able to do any better than the old Chairman. The question naturally arises whether any of these men, not being experts on the question of electrical supply and its economics, was capable of doing this work satisfactorily.

The question of some agreement which was supposed to have been arrived at is, I think, the next point in dispute. The matter in dispute there apparently was whether or not certain liabilities of the acquired undertakings were to be met out of the two and a half millions. The Board apparently under the provisions of the Act was given the right to make requests for money and to get it on demand. The Minister was not empowered under the Act to dole out money in the way that he proposes. This doling out is clearly a violation of the principle embodied in the original Act. If the Minister were to be in a position to dole out money in that way he would be in a position to interfere from day to day in the policy of the Board, and that above all things was the thing to be avoided if the principle in the original proposal was to be followed out properly. Until the Minister gets such power as he is seeking now he is not in a position to interfere from day to day. The Board, having been told when they were set up that they were put in a position of independence, naturally proceeded to act independently and to say that they had a public responsibility for the scheme, to say to the Minister "You have washed your hands of that responsibility. Because we have that responsibility we are going to follow our judgment and not yours." They were perfectly entitled to do that. Who was to arbitrate between the Minister and the Board in a matter like this? I, like other members of the House, have looked up the debates that took place at the time, and I have certainly not come across anything to show where it was suggested by the Minister that the liabilities of these acquired undertakings were to be met out of the two and a half million pounds. The Minister has not shown us that they were to be so met. I am perfectly certain that if the Minister were able to show that to the Board, to show that he was in a legal position to compel the Board to do what he stated to-day, the Board would immediately have surrendered to his view and admitted that the position was as he says, but apparently the Board were within their rights—that the whole of the two and a half million pounds should be delivered to them as requested in accordance with whatever plans they, in the exercise of their own judgment, were to make. The Minister refused to give them that money.

Holding the view that they did, is it likely that the Board made this agreement which is referred to? Is the position this, that the agreement was made under some sort of compulsion, that self-same sort of compulsion that was used a few years ago to get the first Chairman of the Board to resign and to get the Managing Director to resign recently? Some sort of agreement, apparently, was come to, and the Minister now holds it was broken. It is the duty of the Minister to furnish the House with all the evidence, to enable Deputies to form a judgment upon that agreement. I hold that before the Minister asks for this money he ought to table the correspondence that took place at that particular time. Deputies are entitled to see that. We want to know in regard to this agreement where the merits lie.

The next point refers to the questions of major policy to which Deputy Lemass referred. What are they? What exactly is the policy that the Board was following, and what exactly is the policy that the Minister is following? As well as I remember the Minister gave some sort of explanation on these lines: that the Board proceeded to develop without concerning themselves with the question whether the revenues that would come from the ultimate development would be such as to warrant that development, whereas the Minister said "You must first of all calculate nicely what are to be the returns from a certain development, and when you have made these calculations then the development is to take place." I do not think that the Shannon scheme would ever have been started if these calculations were to be insisted upon. Certain estimates were made at the beginning, but the Minister has had to come to the House from time to time to look for increased sums. His estimate was based, as I take it, on certain rough calculations.

In my opinion the Board could not do more than was done as far as extra development was required. What has the Minister done? Apparently he has destroyed for some months past the whole credit of the Board. The letters appearing in the Press and the rumours current about the city make it clear that the Minister completely destroyed the credit of the Board. By withholding the sums that they were entitled to receive he put the Board in this position, that the further development which they had entered upon under their scheme could not be undertaken. It does not require one very well versed in questions of electrical supply to realise that it is the final step in all these cases that matters.

Suppose you have the mains laid in the streets and that they are ready to supply users with electricity, the possible revenue cannot come in until the final fitting up is done. Therefore, it is not sufficient to leave these things in the air, to bring the networks and the distribution up to a certain point. It is not fair, in my opinion, to judge the Board on its success or failure on the position that was largely the creation of the Minister himself. I think everyone must admit that if the Minister wanted to destroy any Board he could do it. Powers were left with him, and we have to judge him on the manner in which he exercised these powers; whether he exercised them wisely or whether, in fact, he exercised them in such a way as to make for a certainty that the Board would not be a success.

To summarise, the first point that we want information on is in regard to this whole question of the accounts. Why is it that, although a new Chairman was appointed, he has not been able to settle up the accounts since the time of his appointment in September, 1930? The House must remember also that there were direct representatives from the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Department of Finance on the Board. There must, therefore, over a long period, have been direct contact between the officials of these two Departments and the Board. The Minister cannot say that over a long period he was not in possession of intimate knowledge as to the position of the Board. If that is so, why did he wait so long, why did he allow things to get into the mess that we have now? Why did he bring about a situation in which the whole credit of this particular enterprise in which so many millions of money are sunk, as well as the credit of an experiment which he himself admits was one of great sociological value, has suffered over a long period without taking action to remedy it? As regards the agreement, we want to see all the information contained in the correspondence that took place. It is the duty of the Minister to put it before us. It seems to me that the Minister in elevating two of the matters at issue to a question of policy has done so without a great deal of justification. What is the policy as far as the Minister is concerned? Does he want to see as many consumers as possible for the power provided by the Shannon scheme or does he not? If he wants to see that must not any body that is going to undertake the development have certain wide powers to enable it to take the steps that it thinks necessary in order to make that development a success?

Is it fair to put upon the Board the restrictions that the Minister proposed to put upon them? If it is and if the Minister wants to see this thing out in detail then he should not talk of washing his hands of the Board because it simply means that he is going to exercise supervision from day to day over the Board. I do not believe that major matters of policy are involved. If they are, how are we to choose between the view of the Minister and the Board without some deciding body on whose opinion we can rely? What does the Minister know about these things? What does he know about the question of electrical supply and its economics? I do not believe that he knows anything about it. If we are to take the opinion of one man as against another on it would we not be on safer ground in taking the view that has been expressed in contradiction to that of the Minister, the view that has been expressed by the Managing Director who, the Minister admits, was the originator of the Shannon scheme in its present form? He, at any rate, can claim a certain amount of expert knowledge. What expert knowledge has the Minister to back up his opinion on the matter? If it is a question of the accounts simply then we must naturally ask what responsibility had the Managing Director for these accounts?

I think that at one time the Minister spoke about the Chairman of the Board being one who had enjoyed exceptional knowledge of public finance and of the care that should be exercised in dealing with such moneys. I take it that was one of the reasons why that particular Chairman was appointed, because he had that knowledge. He was accustomed to dealing with public moneys and had experience of the care with which they should be handled. He was a man who was eulogised greatly. I fail to understand why he should change so suddenly when he got control as Chairman of the Board and turn out to be a different type of man. I want to know what the expert opinion is that the Minister is backed by as against the admitted expert opinion of the Managing Director. These are questions that I want to have cleared up before I am asked to give judgment on this.

As regards looking for the sum of two million pounds, I think that is altogether unjustifiable. Can anybody imagine a Minister coming to the House and asking for £2,000,000 to have at his disposal to dole out, to compel subservience from a Board which he says is to be an independent Board? The Minister ought to give some indication of what he wants. Questions have been put from this side of the House, but we have not yet got any really definite set of figures such as a Minister looking for an appropriation of this size should produce. As regards the commitments that have to be met, £700,000 has been mentioned, but even the figures relating to that total sum we have not got accurately. Surely the accounts ought to be able to clear that up? As regards the future, why should the Minister want so much as two million pounds in excess of the sum that it was estimated in the past would be required? Is it that he may be in a position to put the new Board into the position that they will be able to say, "All is well, because we have not been hampered by any niggardliness as regards funds?"

The House would not be justified in giving the Minister a blank cheque for this two million pounds. He might be able to make a case for £300,000 or £400,000 to meet immediate requirements until this matter is straightened out, but surely when it is straightened out the House ought to get an opportunity of reviewing the situation. If at that time it is shown that any further moneys are needed, the House ought to have an opportunity of reviewing the whole situation and of determining whether the extra moneys are or are not to be given. In my opinion, the Minister has not treated the House fairly or candidly in this matter. If there is a question of difference of opinion on what have been called major questions of policy we ought to have an inquiry into the whole position Previously, before the House entered on large capital commitments in connection with the scheme, certain experts were called in, not representatives of the Department of Industry and Commerce, and not civil servants who cannot claim to have any real knowledge of the economics of this matter. Therefore, I say that we ought to have an inquiry by an independent expert group before we are asked to vote this further sum.

It is the duty of the House to see that. It is time for us now. This enterprise is an important one and it is in the balance. If we act unwisely, we may wreck the whole thing. It is our duty to the country and to ourselves as representatives here to see that whatever action is taken in this particular matter is only taken after the most careful inquiry, with all the information, technical and otherwise, that the House has a right to get. I suggest, therefore, that we should not precipitately deal with this matter and pass this money until we get the why and wherefore and information, if necessary, by setting up an expert Committee to examine into the whole situation. I think the situation is of sufficient magnitude to warrant a special inquiry, an inquiry, if you like, with members who will be all chosen so as to be impartial and members who will be able to give information worth something on the technical issues involved.

Comment on this

As one who had some criticism to offer as to the constitution of this Board when the matter was in the first instance before this House, I should like to say, what I said on several occasions then, that I was very doubtful from my experience of business matters of the success of the proposals of the Minister. I agree, however, with Deputy de Valera that as we have the scheme now it is the anxiety, or ought to be the anxiety, of all of us, not alone members of this House, but all those interested in this State, to make a success of this scheme. Whatever criticism one may have offered in the past, as far as I am personally concerned I am anxious to do everything now to further the scheme, as such a large sum of State money is invested in it. That is my attitude at present. But I am not satisfied that from the inception of this particular Board its business was carried on in a businesslike way. I have no information that would help me in coming to a conclusion as to the cause of the trouble. There may have been too much interference by the Minister's Department, or there may have been insufficient care on the part of the members of the Board.

I happen to know some of the members of that Board, including the past Chairman, and in view of one's knowledge of these particular men in the past I am not prepared to condemn them in the whole-hearted way that they have been condemned this afternoon in this House. Many of them are able business men who have discharged duties in the past in a most satisfactory manner. Then they were brought into this Board and now they have been censured without having been given an opportunity of making their case. As I say, we have these statements put before us and we are not able from the information we have at present to say whether the fault is that of the Board, on the one hand, or of the Executive Council or the Department of Industry and Commerce, on the other hand.

The House will agree that there is financial chaos in the affairs of that Board at the moment. That being so, what is the best method of dealing with that difficulty? Supposing any of us were on a Board of Directors who had to face such a situation, how would we deal with it? It appears to me that the first step such a Board would take would be to call in an independent firm of auditors of repute and get from them a financial statement of the existing position, showing, on the one hand, the liabilities and, on the other hand, the assets. In addition to that, we should get from these auditors a figure that would meet the commitments entered into by that Board. With these two figures we should have information as to what developments were necessary in the immediate future and an estimate of the cost of these developments. Before any further step is taken the House ought to have information before it on these three points.

There is a further difficulty in the matter. The services of the present Board, or portion of it, have been dispensed with. Further members of that Board are under a sort of sentence of suspension. In other words, they have only been reappointed for a period of six months. What the position of the balance of the Board is I do not know. The balance of the Board apparently is a minority of the Board and it is to continue. These are factors that would want to be cleared up.

I think, with all respect to the Minister and the Executive Council, that the House is not in a position at present to decide on this matter. I suggest that the whole consideration be adjourned, and that a firm of auditors be called in to give the figures which I have suggested should be before the House, just as they would be before any Board of Directors that is called upon to decide vital issues such as those the House is now called upon to decide, and that while that statement is being prepared the Executive Council should make up their minds as to the form of that Board for the future for the carrying on of this undertaking, and then come before the House and state: "That is the Board we recommend; that is the financial position; and we now come forward with an estimate of so-and-so to discharge the liabilities that will accrue if the House adopts this recommendation." If that course were adopted it would be a businesslike way of dealing with the problem, and it would do away with a lot of discussion that is not going to do the electricity undertaking any good, and is not going to help the reputation of this country for dealing with problems of this character. I suggest that the matter be adjourned, and that this information be obtained, and as soon as all this information is ready that the matter be brought before the House.

Comment on this

Could we now have some of the businessmen of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party to defend the attitude of the Minister?

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce introduced this discussion by a statement that he had never come to the House with more distaste and more embarrassment in relation to any task he had undertaken. I have never listened to the introduction of a discussion in this House of a serious matter with more distaste, and with more deep pain and regret, than the one we have heard to-day, because I am genuinely and deeply interested in the Shannon scheme. I want to see it a success. I think someone or other is responsible, that this discussion we are having is evidence that someone has been responsible, for very gravely risking the future success of this scheme and, in risking it, risking the reputation of this country as a business institution, and risking also, as Deputy de Valera has said, an experiment of very great, fundamental, psychological and political value. I am speaking now as one who has no use, ordinarily speaking, for Governmental interference in commercial affairs. Judging by the experience of the world up to the present—I am not saying there are not certain experiments going on that would change one's opinion in that matter—but up to the present we have been justified, as individuals, in saying that the further the State keeps away from business enterprises the more likely they are to be a success.

But we had in this a great State enterprise which was attempted to be carried on under State control and under which a very ingenious machinery—I am saying that sincerely —a very ingenious and well thought out machinery was put into the Act to enable a State enterprise to be carried on as nearly as possible with the advantages of a private enterprise, while having behind it the support and assistance of the State. It will be a tragedy not merely for the Electricity Supply Board, but a tragedy for a great many possible developments which might take place in this country if, as the result of what has happened here, we have to say that in this Free State, with the resources of men and their intelligence and decency which we have at our disposal, we are not able to set up successfully a board upon the lines of the Electricity Supply Board, and find it efficient to carry out a big enterprise in close connection with the State. It is for that reason that I would regard it as a very great tragedy indeed if we have to say that there has been a failure in this matter.

Now it is obvious that somebody has failed. Either the Electricity Supply Board has failed as a whole, or certain constituents of it have failed, or the Electricity Supply Board has broken down through interference and lack of sympathy of the Minister, or it has broken down through lack of efficiency and lack of sympathy and understanding of the purpose of the Electricity Supply Board by the permanent officials. As Deputy de Valera said, these are questions on which we ought to have evidence. I am not going to judge. I want to leave this question to-day an open question. If we were here in the position of giving evidence we could decide. I want to leave the thing to-night in the position in which this House, as a whole, without any division of political party, will insist that to us, individual members of the Dáil, shall be given that sufficient amount of exact and detailed evidence in relation to the history of this matter that will enable us to come to an honest judgment, as if we were jurors in a case trying the issue between those who say that the Electricity Supply Board have let down the Free State and those who say they have not. There is no evidence as yet on which any honest member of this House could, with a sense of responsibility as a juror, give a verdict.

We have had one witness in the box, and one witness only. And again I say it with regret, because I do chalk up to the Minister, to his credit, the great ingenuity and largeness of vision which was represented in the actual constitution of the Electricity Supply Board—we have had one witness in the box, and every member of this House is in a position to form an opinion as to whether or not that witness was there to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, in scorn of consequences and in disregard of interests of anything except the truth. I personally think that the Minister has not merely not been fair to this House, and not merely not been fair to the Board, but that he has been thoroughly unfair to himself by the exhibition of ill-timed reticence, of calculated suppression and suggestion which he has given us to-day.

Now we have unfortunately another witness who has not been before this House, a witness whose reputation the President of the Executive Council will stand over without hesitation, that is the late Treasurer and Town Clerk of the City of Dublin, who was Chairman of the Board. He was appointed Chairman of the Board with the enthusiastic consent of the President and of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. That gentleman has made statements in relation to the circumstances under which he resigned, which, if true, mean that every word of testimony which has been offered to us by the particular witness in this case must be regarded, to say the least of it, as doubtful. If the circumstances under which Mr. Murphy resigned from the Electricity Supply Board are the circumstances which Mr. Murphy stated they were to two members of this House, and not in confidence, then there has been interference with the Board, not merely of a financial kind but of the most grossly wrong and improper character. An attempt has been made, if these statements of Mr. Murphy are correct, to do with this Board that which would make it, as a successful runner of the Shannon scheme or anything else, impossible.

I personally am not prepared to say that Mr. Murphy has turned his back upon a lifelong association with the President; that he has turned his back deliberately upon the truth and has deliberately invented a story as to the circumstances of his resignation. Unless I am prepared to say that, I am to say that there are two witnesses now before you who definitely contradict one another in relation to the facts. Let us now take the Electricity Board as a whole. It consisted of the Treasurer and ex-Town Clerk of the City of Dublin; the ex-President of the Incorporated Chamber of Commerce and Shipping of Cork, and the ex-President of the Associated Chambers of Commerce of the Irish Free State; the Secretary of the Agricultural Organisation Society; two senior civil servants and now as Chairman an ex-principal officer of the Revenue Commissioners.

According to the statement which the House has received from the Minister—and I am not to judge that statement. I am only to tell you that it is a statement which, on the evidence, requires other examination than his mere statement—a Board so constituted has been as utterly inefficient, has been as criminally negligent, has been as recklessly reticent of the things which it ought to disclose to the Minister, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce has said. Do you believe that? Do you believe that the ex-Treasurer and Town Clerk of the City of Dublin has been as inefficient as that? What are the Associated Chambers of Commerce of the Free State going to say to their ex-President, who has held their honour and their reputation in his hands, when he has, according to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, so shamelessly neglected his duty? Do they accept that? Do they accept that they appointed as Chairman of that body a man as recklessly inefficient as the Minister has portrayed him? The whole co-operative industry of this country, co-operative marketing and co-operative manufacturing of butter, was under the control of the man who was put in as a member of this Board by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. Is he as inefficient, as reckless, as disregardful of his duties as the Minister for Industry and Commerce has said? There have been altogether, I think, four civil servants of one type or another upon that Board. Liaison officers is one of the terms. Did all those officers hold their tongues? Did all those officers see these things going on and say nothing, or were those officers so utterly inefficient that they did not see any of these things that the Minister for Industry and Commerce said were happening?

A principal officer of the Revenue Commissioners—Mr. Brown, I think, or Dr. Brown—was appointed. I do not know whether he would be called a business man, but he most certainly is a man who would be regarded as financially expert, as capable of going through accounts. Is it alleged that he, when appointed instead of Mr. Murphy as Chairman of the Board, so continued to neglect all these financial matters that they were allowed to remain in that condition? You have got to choose; you have got to say that everyone of those people are as inefficient as that. Does the House believe it? Does not the House believe that when Mr. McLaughlin said so, and their reputation stands against it, that there is a case for inquiry? That is all I am asking.

What is the main issue when you come to boil it down? I want to recall to the mind of the House the speeches we have heard and heard with great gratification and pleasure from the Minister in relation to the Shannon scheme. It was a huge success! They had done in two years what their programme required of them to do in four! Instead of 110,000,000 units they had produced 150,000,000 units! Instead of its being a doubtful proposition it was an outstanding and flagrant success and to the credit of this country. That is what was said in relation to that thing. Has any evidence been put before you that one single penny of all the money that was put into the possession of that Board has been misspent? Has evidence been put before you that one single penny has been spent by that Board before it should have been spent? Does not everyone who knows anything about the electrical position in the country know that these people have underspent, that at the very moment at which the money ought to have been available, the money which would produce 100 per cent. interest because it would make fruitful the dead capital that was lying behind it, that at that very moment this money has been cut off? There is no evidence at all at the present moment in relation to that Board, even on the speech of the Minister, except a neglect to provide him with accounts. That may be very serious but that does not involve the future of the Shannon. The Minister does not now even himself state—I read his speech as carefully as I could—that there is an agreement with the Board. The case which was made by the President in his statement most certainly is not being stood over in detail and in set terms by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. There is a change of front and we want to know why there is a change of front. If we have taken in our hands the reputation of the competent business men in this country and the reputation of the young engineers who we claim were bringing credit and honour to this country, and if we have chosen to smash them we have got to do it upon evidence. Where is the evidence? We have got to do it in a case which has not been altered in the middle of the statement of the case.

The Minister says that there is a sum of £600,000 or something of that kind—we had better get that clear. The amount which is involved is the amount of the undischarged liabilities of the undertakings which were taken over. That debt amounted to £835,000 when they took them over, and that is pushed down or reduced to a sum of £600,000 now. The Minister contends that that £600,000 has to be met out of the £2,500,000. The lawyers of the E.S.B. have advised them to the contrary. The Minister knows that they have advised them to the contrary. He knows that they would not have refused to come in line with him if they had not that advice, just in the same way as they refused to pay rates in Dublin until the law was changed, because they were advised by their lawyers. If they had used this £600,000 to pay these obligations in the way the Minister says they ought to be paid they will be using that £600,000 to pay money in a way in which their lawyers say it is illegal for them to use it. The Minister went to them, according to his own statement, and asked them to go behind the back of the Dáil, to contract out of the law with him. He had no contractual position of any kind. There is no agreement of any sort or kind which they could enter into with the Minister. The House had better get that clear. There is no agreement into which they could enter with the Minister, because the Minister does not exist in the matter. There is no agreement which they could make with the Minister which they are entitled to plead in law, and yet it is that agreement or a breach of that agreement to go behind and void the law, which is the sole gravamen of the charge which is brought against them. I have read the Act. I do not know any Act of this unfortunate Dáil which I have read with more care, and personally I have never seen any evidence whatsoever that they should pay that as a capital sum. They took over these undertakings. They took over their assets and they took over their liabilities as they were. They took over liabilities to pay interest and sinking fund on their debts, but they did not take over liability to extinguish those debts at once.

There is one difficulty in that and I want to be quite fair. When we come to investigate this matter it will have to be investigated that the only possible line of country on which they could possibly have an obligation to pay off these moneys as a capital charge, namely, that they themselves were unsound financially, or that that particular obligation of indebtedness being left upon the local authorities made them to that degree less financially sound. When the Shannon scheme was set up with the authority of the Dáil, and with the finance of this Dáil behind it, and with the enthusiastic support of every member of the Dáil to make the best of it, did anyone suggest that it was financially unsound? It can get now every penny that was required for it. If ever a man set himself out in fact to produce that very condition of insolvency, to produce that very condition in which creditors would foreclose and demand their money instead of interest and sinking fund, it is the men who have been behind whatever mess there is here. It is a fact that the E.S.B. have been asked to send cash for a £10 order. It is a fact that responsible firms have rung each other up and said: "We have an order from the E.S.B. for £40; are they good for the money?" It is a fact that letters have been written by firms saying that owing to the non-payment of debts by the E.S.B. that they must insist on arrangements of that kind before supplying goods.

And during the whole of that time what is the actual position? The actual position is that the Minister has been holding in his hands £546,000 which he had no right to hold, which he illegally held. He had the right to dismiss members of the Board; he had the right to come to the Dáil and say he made a mistake, and if he did he had the right to smash it up; he had the right to come to us, but he had no right under the Act either to make that agreement which he alleges, to void the Act, nor had he any right, nor had the Minister for Finance any right, to refuse to hand to those people money which the Act says that the Minister on demand "shall" hand to the Board.

Here is a great institution which with its acknowledged capital is somewhere like £12,000,000 and which upon its hidden capital is somewhere about £14,000,000, and it is like some miserable hard-run shopkeeper, with the bailiffs in on him, its credit destroyed by the neglectful and unbusiness methods of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, either in not giving them the money or not coming to the Dáil. Which was it? He could have come to the Dáil when he made the arrangement with them. He made an arrangement with them on consideration of his not telling the Dáil what he believed to be the truth. He said that himself. He came along here, and he was going to put in two amendments in the 1929 Act and he was going to tell the Dáil why he was going to put them in, and he said in consideration of my not doing that this Board was induced to enter into this agreement, which on the face of it is illegal, with a man who had no legal existence to make an agreement with them. That is the position. The only evidence I have produced here to-night is the evidence of Mr. Murphy, who had previous association with those who controlled the Board and interfered with it and the Minister's own speech. On these things alone there is manifest evidence that we have got to inquire into, who has tried to wreck the Shannon scheme?

The end of this may be the smashing of a Minister, the smashing of a Civil Service Department, the smashing of the personnel of the Board. The one thing which it must not mean is the smashing of the Shannon scheme. Let me be perfectly clear. Whoever goes down the Shannon scheme itself integrally is the same as if this thing never happened. Someone is going down, but our business is so to see that whatever accidental and incidental circumstances surround the scheme because of the large amount of human nature which has been shown in this matter, the scheme itself goes on.

My difficulty on the face of it is that the Ministry does not seem to have been concerned with the benefits of the scheme. That money should never have been held up. If the Minister felt that this Board was unfit then he should have come to the Dáil. He had no right to allow it to continue for one hour in existence while he was holding from it the money he was withholding, and so destroying the credit of that scheme and, in so far as he could do it, destroying the credit of the country as well. I think to many of us and for many more years than we have belonged to the Dáil the electrification of the Shannon and the big development which would come from it has been a dream which we are glad to see realised. I want in so doing to give every credit that I possibly can to the imagination and the courage of those who did decide under adverse circumstance, and possibly in the face of better economic advice, went on with it. The time now has come to show our real fealty to the Shannon scheme by coming together as a jury, determined to find out accurately and absolutely the whole facts, determined to deal out justice and not more and not less than justice to all those concerned in the matter.

It is in that spirit that I commend to the House this appeal. I want an investigation. I want to see the thing is fairly done. There is any amount of evidence available. I suppose I heard thousands of rumours of the things that have been done by the Shannon Board. I have investigated everything as far as an individual could. I know of nothing, at any rate of a practical character, which, at the present moment, stands to the discredit of the Shannon scheme, or those who operated in it, and I do not know if anybody else has. I only want to say one more word, and that is in relation to the Board as it at present exists. It consists, at the present moment, of three civil servants, who hold their position at the will and pleasure of the Executive Council. It consists of three people who, in the name of business representatives, have been put on under conditions in which in my opinion they cannot be of value. It consists, as far as I understand, of an inner and an outer cabinet. The three representatives of the business community have not, in fact, been attending; they have not been summoned. There have been statements of policy, and so on, issued by the Board and over the photographs, at any rate, of members of the Board, without consultation with the business element. Now, unless the business element on that Board can have that security of tenure and can have that freedom and independence of function which enables them to do some good work, they had better get out.

At present the reputation of the whole business community of the Irish Free State is involved if this thing is a failure. If, according to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, we cannot find, within the whole Free State, three business men who can render a better account of themselves than the Minister for Industry and Commerce says these men have rendered, then it is the duty of the business people of the Free State to see that such representatives are not upon that Board. I am absolutely in favour of an independent Board. The more independent is its function the greater is its authority in relation to its policy. The less interference by any Party or any Government, whatever it may consist of, the less interference the civil servants have with it, the more hope I have in the Shannon scheme. Unless we can have some machinery set up, a Board which will be an independent Board of responsible business men to run that thing, it is going to be a failure whatever we do in the matter.

Comment on this

Surely there are Deputies other than members of the Fianna Fáil Party who have a duty to discuss this in the House? With the exception of Deputy Good and Deputy Murphy the debate has been so far entirely confined to members of the Fianna Fáil Party. Business men in Cumann na nGaedheal have an equal responsibility, and are bound to inquire into all the circumstances and facts of this situation just as we are; some of them have a larger stake in the country than we have. Some of them would sneer at us because I suppose, not being in a position of affluence, we would venture to discuss and criticise the proposition to vote £2,000,000 of the public money, to give a blank cheque into the hands of the Minister who was responsible for concealing from the House the fact that since 1928 a serious difference of opinion has arisen between him and the Board which he created with regard to the expenditure of a sum of two and a half million pounds. There are very substantial business men with the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. There is Deputy Connolly, of Longford, and there is Deputy McDonogh, of Galway.

Comment on this

What has Deputy McDonogh of Galway to do with it? I know a good deal about the Shannon and its business and I saw mismanagement. I saw in the town of Galway— if you want to hear anything I can tell you——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think Deputy McDonogh must allow Deputy MacEntee to make his speech.

Comment on this

I do not mind any of these gentlemen either inside or outside the House.

Comment on this

I would gladly give way to Deputy McDonogh or any other member of his Party.

Comment on this

Do not be personal.

Comment on this

Let us be quite clear about it. Deputies have been discussing it. Every man jack of them has been discussing it, but in another place. It was discussed, as I happen to know, at the recent Convention of Cumann na nGaedheal, and why did not members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must either discuss this Bill now or conclude his speech. I thought he was coming to the Bill when he went on to talk of Deputy McDonogh.

Comment on this

He is more interested in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party.

Comment on this

Certainly. We hope soon to displace you, and then we will have less interest in you. We will have as little interest in you as the country has at present.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Still further away from the subject.

Comment on this

The proposal in this Bill is to place £2,000,000 under the control of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, to dole out as he wishes to a Board of his own selection and nomination. The whole of the Minister's speech, I would like to remind the House, was an indictment of the late Managing Director and the former Chairman of the Board. In the course of it he did not advance a single argument that would justify the grant of this £2,000,000. He said that he was without information which he should have in submitting such a proposal to the House. He told us that the Board had overspent to the extent of £600,000 and had incurred commitments to the extent of a further £250,000. He also told us that the total expenditure and commitments of the Board at present amounted to £3,350,000 approximately, which is computed as follows:—

There is approved expenditure, I have to call it approved expenditure, because the Minister has indicated that to the extent of £1,700,000 he is prepared to approve of the expenditure which this nominally independent Board has already undertaken. In addition to that there is an excess expenditure already incurred and in respect, I presume, of works already finished, amounting to £600,000. There were, he said, in addition to that, other commitments amounting to £250,000 and then, he said, there are the liabilities of the municipal undertakings transferred amounting to £800,000. Under the Electricity Supply Act of 1927 there was originally granted to the Board a sum of £2,500,000. It is in regard to the balance of £800,000 that the difference between the Board and the Minister is supposed to have occurred. That sum, according to the Minister, represents liabilities of the undertakings which were taken over by the Board from the local authorities. It is in regard to that sum that the differences between the Minister and the Board have arisen. It is common ground between the Minister and the Board that the Board eventually, whether out of the £2,500,000 or whether out of its profits and revenue from the operation of the undertaking, must provide for the liabilities of the transferred undertakings. There is no difference between the Minister and the Board as to that. I would like to make that quite clear. The Board accepts the responsibility for the liabilities of the transferred undertakings. The Minister states that they are bound to accept these responsibilities under Section 37 of the Electricity Supply Act. How then does the difference arise? It arises as to the manner in which that provision is to be made.

The Minister's attitude, so far as I can apprehend from his speech, was that out of the £2,500,000 provided by the House to enable the Board to equip itself with all the plant and the machinery required to distribute and sell locally 110,000,000 units per annum, the Board was bound to take one-third of the sum, £800,000, and immediately discharge the liabilities of the transferred undertakings. I would like to ask the Minister if that is a correct presentation of his position, that he desires that out of the £2,500,000 granted to the Board or authorised to be advanced to the Board under the Electricity Supply Act, he wishes the Board to take £800,000 and immediately to discharge the liabilities of the transferred undertakings?

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell us what he wants to do with that?

Comment on this

When I am replying.

Comment on this

Will he tell us now?

Comment on this

It is a long statement.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister could at this stage correct any misapprehension he left the House under as to how he wishes the liabilities of the transferred undertakings to be met?

Comment on this

As they fall due.

Comment on this

That is to say that the Minister wishes the Board to provide for interest and sinking fund as they fall due?

Comment on this

Is it out of income or capital?

Comment on this

Does it matter in the long run so long as we know what the yearly commitments are? Surely there are certain sums to be paid each year. Thus there may be £100,000 this year in repayment of sinking fund and interest in discharge of its liabilities. What I want to get at is what is the capital sum for which the Board is liable on all counts.

Comment on this

I gather from the Minister's statement that the estimate of the capital liabilities was £3,350,000.

Comment on this

He arrived at it in this way. There was £1,700,000 which had been legitimately spent. There was in addition to that a further capital sum of £800,000 which he stated should be set aside, earmarked, or in some way taken to discharge the liabilities of the undertakings transferred from the local authorities. Is that not the Minister's attitude according to his statement to us? He put it in this way. He said that £2,500,000 was placed at the disposal of the Board. He said we have to take away from that a sum of £800,000, representing the transferred liabilities of the undertakings taken over by the Board from the local authorities. That, he said, leaves us with a nett sum of £1,700,000, which the Board had at their disposal and could use to provide for the plant, new local distribution, and net-works which were required in order to enable them to sell 110,000,000 units of electricity. Is that not the case which the Minister has presented to the Dáil? The Minister is silent. I take it that is correct.

Comment on this

I cannot pay attention to all these questions because I am going to reply on my own case. The Deputy can make his case.

Comment on this

What is the use making a case to which quite obviously the Minister is not going to reply, because the Minister is not listening? We have got to establish some point of contact, at any rate, in respect of these figures. The Dáil has a right to get a correct presentation of the Minister's case. I do not want to say anything over which the Minister will not stand in his reply. I take it that what the Minister stated at the outset is correct. I am ready to admit that £800,000 had to be taken out of the capital sum of £2,500,000 and set aside to redeem the liabilities of the undertakings transferred from the local authorities. He said that when you do that you have £1,700,000 which the Board might legitimately expend on new capital works. That is the case which the Minister made to the Dáil, that and no other, and it is on that supposition, upon the supposition that that £800,000 is to be taken out of the £2,500,000 and set on one side, that he states now that the Board has over-spent to the extent of nearly £850,000. The exact words of the Minister were that "the Board had indicated, in fact, the position at the present moment is that the Board has over-spent to the sum of £600,000, and has committed itself to a further expenditure of £250,000."

If that means anything, it means, as I said, that £850,000 of the two and a half millions which was placed at the Board's disposal by the Dáil had to be used immediately to discharge the liabilities of the transferred undertakings. What would anyone think of that merely as a business proposition? Here is one-third of the total capital of the Board to be taken from the reproductive use of the Board, to be withdrawn from fruitful investment in plant, equipment and organisation, and used to redeem moneys advanced, in many cases at from three and a half to four per cent., when that fresh capital could not be raised in the market at less than five per cent.

That was the first consequence of the position which the Minister wished the Board to take up, and I put it to any business man in the House, that if he had £800,000, the major portion of which he got at four per cent., and had freedom to do otherwise, would he immediately withdraw that £800,000 of capital from his business and use it to pay off that money? Yet that is the position that the Minister endeavoured to manoeuvre the Board into. The Board quite rightfully said "No, we have £800,000, we have to pay interest on it at a rate to be determined by the Minister for Finance, a rate, as far as we can see, that will not be less than five per cent. Instead of using that to re-pay liabilities which mainly carry interest at four per cent. we are going to invest it in net works, plant, and use it to discharge the prime obligation imposed upon us by the Electricity Supply Act, to sell in this country one hundred and ten million units per annum." When it is remembered that inside two years the Electricity Supply Board—mismanaged and all as it has been according to the Minister—has succeeded in more than doubling the consumption of electricity in the Twenty-Six Counties, it can be seen that so far as excess expenditure, with which the Minister charges the Board with incurring, is concerned, that it has been a very fruitful investment.

What was the legal position of the Board in regard to the matter? The Board in refusing to accept the preposterous proposal, from the business point of view, that had been put up to them by the Minister, to withdraw this money from investment in the undertaking with whose management they were charged, in acting as they did, in over-spending to the extent of £600,000 which the Minister alleges, and in entering into further commitments of £250,000, in going to the very limit of the authority which the Dáil had granted to them to demand this money from the Minister for Finance, when they did demand it were acting strictly in accordance with the Act. They did not exceed by one iota their responsibilities under the Act. In his opening statement the Minister referred to Section 39 which relates to the liabilities of the transferred undertakings. Sub-section (6) of that section reads:

Whenever the former undertaker is a local authority the new undertaker shall as on and from the date of the vesting order become and be by virtue of this sub-section liable for and bound to indemnify and keep indemnified the former undertaker against all capital loans (including current bank overdraft) outstanding at the date of the vesting order and borrowed by the former undertaker for the purpose of the undertaking and all mortgages and charges on the undertaking or the assets thereof outstanding on the date of the vesting order... and also the interest on such loans, mortgages, and charges from the date of the vesting order.

Now, what obligation did that sub-section impose on the Board? Merely the obligation of taking over, becoming liable for and indemnifying the former undertaker—in this case the local authority—in respect to all capital charges that might arise because of moneys borrowed by the local authority to finance the electricity supply undertaking within its area. According to the concluding portion of this section all the Board was bound to do was to make provision for redeeming the loans in due course, in accordance, of course, with the terms on which the loans were originally raised, and to pay interest annually. That was the position which the Board took up, and it was the position which Deputy Flinn informed the House they were legally advised they were bound to take up. What was the position which the Minister wished to put them in? He wished to hamstring them to the tune of £800,000. If there was any justification at all for granting this Board the sum of two and a half million pounds in the first instance, it was because the Minister admitted that two and a half millions was necessary to put the Board on its feet, and to enable it to provide itself with the capital, plant and equipment required to dispose of one hundred and ten million units in the small towns and villages of this country each year. If the purpose of the Minister in asking the Dáil to grant that £2,500,000 was to ensure that the liabilities in respect of the local undertakings transferred to the Shannon Board should be immediately discharged, then the proper course for him to take was to have given the Board a certain sum which would provide for the new plant and equipment which was required, and to have asked the Dáil to authorise the Minister for Finance, in accordance with the Act, or within its terms, to discharge the liabilities of such undertakings immediately they were transferred to the Electricity Supply Board. I move the adjournment of the debate.

Comment on this