Electricity (Supply) (Amendment) Bill, 1931—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 171–367 of 367. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 31 of 1931 ›
We are all apparently proving one another right, which is very satisfactory, except that the accounts have not been audited and that I never said they have been.
Deputy O'Kelly has referred to the resignation of the ex-Chairman, and he said that I made inaccurate statements about that and he nailed me in regard to it. If the ex-Chairman of the Electricity Supply Board wants to have it that he was dismissed I will agree that he was. If he wants to have it, as he did at one time want to have it, that he resigned, he can have it in that way. If the Deputy wants to know the circumstances of that change I will tell him. I met Mr. Murphy at a particular time in 1930 and in some detail I explained the situation to him, and indicated to him at the first meeting that I thought he had not shown the financial grip in relation to the affairs of the Board that we thought he would have shown. I saw him a second time, and I told him that I thought it was incumbent on me to have somebody associated with that Board who would exercise proper financial control. I indicated to him that that person would have to have as much authority as I could give him, irrespective of the title that he was to have. I saw Mr. Murphy on the third occasion, and I did not get many words with him when he lifted his blotting-paper and produced me his letter of resignation and asked me was that what I wanted. I hope I showed as much tact as was necessary at that point, but I was glad to have that resignation.
Comment on this
Yes. The reason was because in my eyes he had been an accessory before the fact of a certain mix-up in the Board, and I was anxious to retain him as a paid servant until such time as that mess was cleared up. He made a certain appeal to me about his position and the emoluments he had lost, and explained the arrangements he had with the Dublin Commissioners, and I agreed to make certain payments to him.
Deputy O'Kelly is afraid of the credit of the Shannon scheme suffering by reason of the statements made here. I spoke in a very restrained way yesterday. I had to walk a very delicate line in the endeavour to indicate to the House that a serious situation had developed and at the same time avoid causing any great public uneasiness and disquiet. I think the debate has gone to the point when I am precluded from keeping silent on some matters any longer, and I think public credit will not suffer much by the revelation of things going wrong if the people see that the going wrong has been stopped and the damage checked; but it might suffer considerably if one cloaked matters and allowed the damage to go on until it reached a point when it could not be recovered.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Kelly has asked me two questions as to current being sold too cheaply. I do not know what the answer to that is. For three years I have been trying to get a statement from the E.S.B. as to whether, in their opinion, current was being sold to different types of users at such a rate as would remunerate all the money expended on the business. I could get no proper answer from them. I got estimates of expenditure and revenue by the dozen. The disquieting feature of these estimates was that on each occasion on which an examination of the financial position was attempted by me, and the expenses side shown to be higher than the figure represented to me, immediately the revenue return that was made to me jumped almost precisely to the exact amount necessary to meet the increased expenditure. I could have no confidence in the revenue estimate produced under these conditions. As to whether the Shannon prospects are bright, I can answer the limited question that the Deputy put to me. He asked whether the prospects of the Shannon scheme, if properly managed, were brighter than a year ago. I will answer considerably.
Comment on this
I am not sure if I have got Deputy Anthony's point correctly. I think his question was, has any portion of the money proposed to be set aside for undischarged liabilities been paid out as the purchase price for any of the municipal undertakings? As purchase price, nothing has been paid to municipalities. Municipal undertakings were taken over on the basis of the Board shouldering the liabilities properly incurred in connection with all these things. A certain amount of the liabilities so incurred has since been paid out of revenue.
Comment on this
Not less than a couple of hundred thousand pounds. Deputy Moore is concerned about the accounts.
Comment on this
Obviously if people have used money to pay undischarged liabilities and have consequently piled up further debts against themselves, they are not in a much better position. They might as well pay off their debt to the municipal authorities as pay off the traders. It is really only a matter of transfer from one shoulder to the other.
Comment on this
Nobody has made any point in that connection. The Deputy has been wrestling with himself on that particular point for a long period. Deputy Moore, as I have said, is rather concerned about the accounts. I am going to deal with them in some detail, and I will refer later to the point. The Deputy asked me just the same question as Deputy O'Kelly asked me about the reappointment of the first Chairman of the Electricity Supply Board, and I have answered on that. The Deputy finds it very hard to resist the inference that I had no confidence whatsoever in the Board, and that the Board had been forced upon me by influence. I do not know what is contained in the suggestion, or what hidden hand is being hinted at here.
Comment on this
I wonder is the Deputy the unnamed colleague of Deputy O'Kelly? Is that what we are now having revealed?
Comment on this
If it is that point, I will refer to it. Is the Deputy making the point about family influence?
Comment on this
Then Deputy Moore leaves Deputy O'Kelly in the lurch in regard to that. What influence, apart from the actual merits, could there be introduced into appointments to positions which, from the very beginning, I regarded as very onerous and about which, at the beginning, I actually despaired of getting people properly to fill them? If there was ever a case in which people were chosen completely and entirely on their merits, it was in this case. I chose them after consideration and comparison of different people who came before me and whose names were suggested by me to the Executive Council. In the end we came to the conclusion that the Board which was finally decided upon represented a good working team; that it represented most of the interests that we thought should be represented there; that it represented most of the points of view that we thought should be represented, and that it represented most of the particular types of judgment that we wanted to have brought to bear on the work of the Board, and that we felt should be properly associated with the Board. The Deputy wanted to know whether "these civil servants" are under the influence of the Minister. There is one civil servant on the Board—
Comment on this
There is one civil servant on the Board, and that civil servant, in the matter of the Board's affairs, is as free as any other member of the Board. I wanted to have the whole Board free, all the time remembering the power to dismiss and what that implied. As far as that civil servant is concerned, he is as free and independent in all his activities as any other member of the Board.
Comment on this
I do still as an expert, but not as a civil servant. The Deputy is confusing experts and civil servants.
Comment on this
It is quite legitimate to confuse them. The Minister has told us that the Chairman is a civil servant. Is Mr. Leydon no longer on the Board?
Comment on this
As an expert. Deputy MacEntee vigorously wrestled with two problems. I was never more reminded of the old comic turns of the artist on the music hall stage wrestling with himself as when Deputy MacEntee was speaking. He certainly knocked himself flat on the two points he was attempting to make. If anybody asked the Board to pay off immediately the undischarged liabilities of the transferred undertakings, it certainly was not myself. There was no question of paying off those undischarged liabilities at once. The Deputy talked as if I had refused the Board money which it demanded as of right. I did not. The real position in regard to that is that the Board agreed it would not need the money. The Board agreed further that it would make no demand for money beyond a certain amount until it could show to the Executive Council that that money was properly required.
The Deputy might refute the Scriptures and add cubits to his financial stature by taking thought if he had only listened to what I said at the opening. I made it precise and clear that we did not ask them to pay off undischarged liabilities. We could not have asked them to do it. The Act definitely states that the people who have to pay off liabilities in every case are the original borrowers. We made that point quite clear to them, and Deputy Geoghegan need not have gone to so much trouble in the rather henpecking sort of statement he made to me in order to satisfy me on two points with regard to the Act, about which I was quite clear. The Deputy did say that he assumed—why, I do not know, but possibly it was one of these rushes that the Deputy sometimes gets to his head—that the Board had budgeted on a two and a half million item. I may say that he was absurdly wrong in this case. In August, 1929, the Board said to me that they had decided that, until it was otherwise agreed by the Executive Council, their programme of operations was to be based on the assumption that the sum available under Section 12 (3) would be £2,500,000, less the amount of all outstanding liabilities on undertakings acquired or to be acquired by the Board. If they budgeted on two and a half millions free from the undischarged liabilities after writing that letter to me, they were then either trying to deceive me and through me, the House, or else they were acting in a wholly irresponsible manner.
Comment on this
They did not, because, in fact, there was never anything approaching budgetary calculations by the Board.
Comment on this
The Minister has stated that the Board approached him in June suggesting that they could not keep within the limit unless they closed down certain schemes abruptly, and they pointed out that a sudden stoppage might cause wastage.
Comment on this
If one is budgeting it means that one has a certain amount of money and one decides expenditure on a particular basis.
Comment on this
Did they not decide expenditure on the basis that they would have two and a half millions?
Comment on this
They decided in this way: they spent whenever they thought fit to spend and they had absolutely no idea from time to time of what their capital commitments were. The idea of saying that there was anything corresponding to budgetary arrangements in connection with the Board's finances is really ridiculous to those who know the circumstances.
Comment on this
When did the Minister discover the faulty nature of the Board's financial arrangements?
Comment on this
Through a letter which the Chairman wrote to me on the 6th of March this year. I will give the gist of that letter.
Comment on this
Deputy Geoghegan thought he had a cheap method of deciding this matter of the two and a half millions and he talked about going to a judge. His mind turned suddenly to law when he thought of cheap things. I may mention to the Deputy that there is a less expensive way and that is by coming to the House with a Bill. That was what I proposed to do in 1929. Deputy de Valera mentioned that I put some compulsion upon the members of the Board to make a certain agreement. The compulsion I used was this: I proposed to come to the Dáil in the full glare of publicity and I proposed to say here what I believed were the original intentions, and these were that the two and a half millions included the undischarged liabilities. I will add that the Board implored me not to come here, and they made the agreement so that I should not come here.
Comment on this
I am at a loss to understand that. Were they afraid of that Bill? What did it mean? It meant that I came in here and stated to the House that interpreting my own view, and as I thought interpreting the view of the House the two and a half million pounds was to be made include a particular sum. I would have asked the House to decide that.
Comment on this
It is the thing I regret most in my whole association with the Board. Looking at it now, I think it should have been done. Of course, all the wiseheads, if I may include Deputy Geoghegan in that term, think that they would then have thought that —that that Bill should have been brought before the House. But I had the idea that the Board once it made a promise would keep it, that it would at any rate make some arrangements to see that it was more or less kept. When they stated to me: "There is no necessity to come to the Dáil, we will accept that," I accepted that as good enough.
Comment on this
I cannot talk about the two Acts together. Let us get on. Deputy Geoghegan has talked of a cheap method of deciding. There was the other method I thought of, which got rid of counsel. We do not have to fee anybody.
Comment on this
If I asked the House to interpret the section, I think that the House would have said what its intentions were with regard to it.
Comment on this
No, that was my mistake. I relied on the promise of the Board that they would, until it was otherwise agreed upon by the Executive Council, base their programme of operations on the assumption that the sum available under Section 12 (3) was two and a half million pounds, less the amount of outstanding liabilities of undertakings acquired or to be acquired by them.
Comment on this
Does the Minister say "obligations," or what is the word?
Comment on this
May I be very precise in the presence of the learned counsel—outstanding liabilities of undertakings acquired or to be acquired.
Comment on this
In front of Deputy Geoghegan? I have humility, but not so much as that. Deputy Fahy started off by saying we are not in a position to apportion blame, that we have not the facts. I would like to associate myself with Deputy Thrift in that matter. Nobody has been asked to apportion blame. What is the blame? What is the situation as we have it at present? There is, to my mind, a certain amount of chaos in the accounts of the Board. There is a certain doubt with regard to some of the finances of the Board. Certain people have resigned from the Board, and these resignations have been accepted, and I am asking the House, on what I confess to be very insufficient and inadequate information, to grant a sum of money—we will leave the question of the amount over for the present. I do not see any question of apportioning blame. Apportioning blame about what? Certain people have resigned.
Comment on this
If people tell me they were compulsorily resigned I will deal with that, but the position, as I see it, is that two people resigned. If anyone tells me that he has been told——
Comment on this
If anyone tells me that there is any other suggestion made I will deal with it. The situation at present is that two people sent in their resignations.
Comment on this
If the Deputy thinks that let him see these people and find out what they think. Deputy Fahy wanted to know was any special duty allocated to the Chairman and the Managing Director. That I do not know. As far as I am concerned, the Board as an entity is primarily responsible for anything that goes wrong until I have reason given to me to show that the responsibility should be shifted to individuals. Two people proffered their resignations and I accepted them, and I think I was very wise to accept them. Certain other people did not put in their resignations and I did not call for them, and I was very wise not to call for them.
Comment on this
I said yesterday that if all the resignations came in I would have accepted them. To make the situation clear, I should have gone on to state that I would have reappointed to the Board the part-timers. I should most certainly have asked the people who had gone on at a late date and who were not involved in this mix up, to allow me to reappoint them.
Comment on this
As from the time in which they had the handling of it, and for the situation which developed from the period of their appointment.
Comment on this
Considering these circumstances, with the limitations I have spoken of, the part-timers fall for consideration. If the part-timers knew everything that was going on, if they were fully aware of the details of the organisation, and if they passed certain things with full knowledge of the circumstances, then they would definitely have to be regarded as being as much to blame for what has happened, if blame is going to be assigned, as the Managing Director or the Chairman. But with three members serving part-time on a Board like that, with the enormous amount of details that has to be attended to, attending at meetings once a fortnight or once a month, I cannot conceive that anybody, having in mind the consideration that their reputation is at stake, would say, without clear proof, that they are to be regarded as being as completely responsible as the other people for anything which has happened. They did not, at any rate, deem it their business to pass that judgment on themselves. They did not send in their resignations. I would not call for their resignations. If they had been received, I might have accepted them in order to get the situation cleared up, but I certainly would have asked them to accept an offer of reappointment.
Comment on this
Surely they cannot shirk responsibility on the two main issues that the Minister has raised, namely, the expenditure of the two and a half million pounds without regard to the undischarged liabilities, and the failure to send accounts for audit. Surely all the members of the Board were aware of the circumstances on these two issues.
Comment on this
All the members of the Board were aware of the promise made. How many members of the Board were aware of or were responsible for the circumstances that caused the agreement to be broken? That is the point.
Comment on this
I started off by stating that I made a division between the full-timers and the part-timers for the reason stated, but I do not believe it is possible for the part-timers to have anything like the grip of the details or the big problems as to have absolutely equal responsibility with the full-time people.
Comment on this
I think the Minister ought to be allowed to make his speech, not only from the point of view of the Minister's right to address the House, but from the point of view of the right of the House to hear the Minister who is responsible to it.
Comment on this
As to the two million pounds, Deputy Fahy asked if this was to be dealt with in detail. I propose to deal with it later on the Committee Stage. I am asking for two million pounds. This can be regarded as a figure to be discussed in Committee. It may be cut down or it may be enlarged, according as Deputies desire, and my responsibility with regard to the money may be removed entirely, and I would prefer it so. If Deputies so desire, we can discuss all this in Committee. Deputy Fahy also took the point that Deputy MacEntee was on, that the Board are entitled to two and a half million pounds under the Act and that they should get something more. The Board had to face up to the Act and their undertaking. The Board knew what the undertaking was, and the Board, in fact, made no attempt to assert what people on the other side would describe as their legal rights. They were bound by their own undertaking.
Comment on this
The Deputy probably does not understand the binding force of an undertaking given by four or five honourable men to the people who appointed them.
Comment on this
The Deputy would make a promise like that not to assert his rights under an Act of Parliament and then proceed to assert them on the basis of the Act. That is the Deputy's idea of proper conduct.
Comment on this
I shall yield to the Deputy if he wishes to explain. Deputy Fahy made a point about money being insufficient, and brought this out in connection with what was more or less a surmise that development had proceeded at such a rate. I do not know what his conclusion was. It was partly tied on to a statement that the money was insufficient. It was also tied on to a statement with regard to the accounts. Does the Deputy seriously suggest that in any development the rate of development can ever be so great that people cannot keep accounts about it or should not be able to keep accounts about it?
Comment on this
They should. That is the point I have always held. I do not think people should be so definitely engaged on spending that they cannot keep accounts of what they have spent. That is apparently what happened. Deputy O'Connell spoke of friction occurring early. No friction occurred early between myself and the Board. I asked for information and, on that, I said I got little satisfaction. I got no satisfaction on the particular questions I was asking. The questions I was asking were of this type: That I would be glad to learn the Board's opinion upon a particular matter—on this, whether the Board is of opinion, or is optimistic that distribution will be achieved within the limits of the money advanced for that purpose, and I asked to be supplied with the figures upon which that optimism was based. In answer to that very natural and proper query, when I say I got no satisfaction I mean simply this that I was told that they were not able to make a statement, and they asked me to postpone the matter for some time, and they told me, further, that any information that they could give me at the particular time would be so unreliable as to be of no practical use to me. We did get down to a very definite statement, but that was much later. What the Deputy describes as friction amounted only to this, that in the early stages I thought fit to address that type of question, and that only, to the Board, and could get from them only that sort of reply, "The information we have is of no great value to you; we cannot give you any information at present," and so on and so forth. The dissatisfaction was the absence of information, but not friction on any point.
I have referred to the question of the Chairman resigning. The Deputy has asked me that and I think I answered him in anticipation. He questioned also the differences prior to 1929 and queried why did I not come to the Dáil. I proposed to come to the Dáil with regard to these things but unfortunately allowed myself to be stayed in my progress because the Board gave me assurance that I thought was necessary in the interests of the scheme.
Apart from these smaller matters there are two or three big things that have come out of this debate. It is quite clear I think to everybody even without my saying a word that there must be something wrong when the accounts of that particular undertaking for the year ending 31st March, 1930, are not yet in our hands. There must be something wrong—let us put it no higher than that.
Comment on this
And they are still wrong. It is dissatisfying not to have not merely the accounts, because I think they are a small part of the whole business, but the sort of financial statement which we are entitled to have and which I tried to get under the section of the Act which gives me power to demand it. I say that I have not got a satisfactory statement of that and cannot produce it consequently to the House. Again I say that merely to state that is to argue that there is something wrong. I stated last night that in groping around, in certain ways, in putting all these financial enquiries to the Board I discovered, in fact I had it from themselves, that their policy was to look for revenue as quickly as possible. Deputy de Valera apparently took that as a sound point of view last night, when he asked was it my desire or not that the maximum number of consumers should be attached to the Shannon wires. It is not my desire. If that is the desire we can achieve it at once. Let us give current away and we can get the whole State connected up. It is my desire to get profitable consumers in the greatest possible number attached to the Shannon current as speedily as possible, but certainly not the greatest number irrespective of what they are going to pay. The people who had the policy of simply going ahead to get in revenue irrespective of what the revenue had to cover were making a complete mistake and to my mind were guilty, if that were their policy, of complete financial recklessness.
Comment on this
Their attitude was we will get revenue any way we can. Having that attitude I do not know how they fixed their scales of charges. Deputy de Valera conceives a managing director of a scheme like this who need have no touch with accounts—who is not responsible for accounts.
Comment on this
I should like to say that I did not have any such conception, but I can imagine in a case like the Board one expert from the engineering side being asked by the Board to pay particular attention to that, and another member who is a financial expert being asked to look after the finance. But as members of the Board as a whole they should be acquainted certainly.
Comment on this
If the accounts had gone wrong the Managing Director, as he was singled out by the Deputy, has some responsibility for that.
Comment on this
There are at any rate three things that emerge. Deputy de Valera lifted them to the rank of the three important points to be discussed here: the question of the agreement which, according to the Deputy, the Minister said was made and which the Minister said was broken; the question of the accounts and the whole question of financial policy. I will give the gist of the agreement. I got a letter, as I said, from the Board in March this year, and it contained certain statements. It contained an expression of regret from the Board for breaking the agreement with the Executive Council. It went on to state the reasons for that. It indicated that information was not available owing to imperfections in the Board's organisation to enable the Board to ascertain with even approximate accuracy what the real position was. The recording system had fallen into arrears to such a degree that figures could not be produced. That is March, 1931.
Comment on this
A letter stating that, more or less. It went on to indicate this, that from information now available it is clear that the agreement of August, 1929, was broken in December of that year, but up to June, 1930, the Board was not in a position to know what capital expenditure it had incurred. The records were in arrears and the figures were incomplete and unreliable. It is clear that they believed there was an agreement. It is also clear they believed they had broken their agreement. Further, it is clear that the records and their whole organisation of accountancy were completely broken up.
Comment on this
Yes. No one ever questioned anything about the agreement until it was questioned in this House. There has been no attempt to quibble regarding the law versus the agreement. The Board did not attempt to do it.
Comment on this
Are we to get back to the absurd point that Deputy Geoghegan made, that the Board, because they are entitled to ask for a certain amount of money, are bound to ask for it, and I suppose bound to spend it whether it is required or not?
Comment on this
What I did say was that if they felt the necessities of the undertaking required it they were bound to ask for it.
Comment on this
The explanation of the Deputy scarcely clears up what he did not very clearly say. His statement was that if they were entitled to the money they were bound to ask for it. They were not bound, and they did not ask as being entitled. The Board themselves knew their position. In two or three letters they admitted that they broke the agreement, but said it was not deliberately done. They went out of their way to make that point. They did not take up the attitude of Deputy Geoghegan, that they broke the agreement elevating the statute to a superior position over the agreement.
Comment on this
May I be allowed to say this. I stated that an agreement entered into under a misapprehension, and afterwards found to be in conflict with the statute, could not be relied on, and that it was the duty of everyone concerned to repudiate it, if it was in conflict with the statute.
Comment on this
I must say that after hearing that from the Deputy I would not like to appoint him to a responsible position in which he would have the duty of representing, if that is going to be his line of conduct, that he could make an agreement and then afterwards elevate the statute against it, and, saying that the agreement was inconsistent with it, break his agreement.
Comment on this
I have kept my temper, which is more than the Minister can say.
Comment on this
I must say that I feel with regard to the Deputy as if I had got a telling-off from a badly aggravated nanny, simulating real but genteel annoyance.
Comment on this
It is an overdose of mild bitters that the Deputy has served out.
I had certain correspondence with the Board on this question. Right through I aimed really at one point. I was trying to get from them an assurance that the voted moneys would be sufficient for the purposes of distribution, and that they would be enabled by whatever distribution networks they set up to get such sales at the experts' rates as would secure revenue to make the partial development financially successful. I stuck to that question—I may have varied the terminology of it —from October, 1928 until early in this year. That was the one assurance that I wanted and on that was the special bit of interference that I had with the Board. I was not at first disposed to look critically into various things that they put up. I wanted to have it on record that they had faced up to a particular question, and that they had backed their reputation on the answer. The answer was to be such as to assure me that they would be able to carry out their duties under the Act within the moneys voted, subject to the agreement afterwards, and that they would be enabled to get such sales as would remunerate the capital expenditure on the whole concern. That was the whole object of my endeavours over two and a half years, to get an assurance with regard to these points.
I asked about these matters and about the accounts. I got a letter in December which they said was sent to satisfy me that the Electricity Supply Act moneys would be sufficient for the purposes of the Board under the Act, but they warned me that the capital requirements which they put into the letter were an indication of the limits of the Board's possible capital requirements under any conditions. Of course when I related that letter to the circumstances of to-day I see that it was not a satisfactory statement or estimate of their capital requirements under present conditions. They said that to me in December, 1928, and at that point they revealed this item with regard to the undischarged liabilities. I took that up resolutely with them because I had the feeling that the Oireachtas definitely meant that the two and a half million pounds was to be the limit of the Board's capital liabilities, however accruing to them. I said to the Board at one time—I wrote them a letter on the point—"If it is not clear that the moneys in Section 12 include the undischarged liabilities, I intend to use the amending Act to make it clear." I am asked by Deputy de Valera who was to arbitrate on this difference between the Board and myself, and he wants to know what compulsion I used to secure the agreement. The arbitration that Deputy de Valera asked about, and the compulsion that I put upon the Board, was the arbitration and the compulsion of this House. I said to them: "I intend to make this clear and I will go to the House and make my position clear on that. If the House votes that money to me with this limitation, then you are so bound." Their answer to me was not that they could not carry on under the straitened circumstances, or that they had budgeted in 1928, or early in 1929, for a programme many years ahead to such a point that the money was clearly insufficient, but they said: "No, we will base our expenditure on the assumption that the two and a half million pounds are to include the outstanding liabilities." That was the definite promise made.
After that I queried how the arrangement was being carried out. Early in April I got a statement from them to show that the Board had kept the agreement. I then queried a very definite point. I said that they had put up to me a particular programme in 1928, and that I had pointed out certain things in regard to it. I had said to them: "If you carry out that programme and add on the undischarged liabilities you would clearly be going outside the money voted." I asked them in April what modification of the earlier programme had they made, arising out of the agreement. Late in April, 1930, they sent me a letter to show how the programme had been modified by a sum of £363,000, and so to prove that they had kept the agreement. There was never a word about the agreement being obnoxious to them, or that they were trying to elevate the statute above the agreement. Their whole point was that they had kept the agreement. I got letters from them somewhat later in which they said they could not complete what they called a reasonable programme within the limitations imposed upon them.
That brings me to the 1930 Act. Deputy Lemass made quotations from that debate and, after he had done so, handed over his quotations to Deputy MacEntee. I asked Deputy MacEntee was there not something in between what he read, whether it was in his favour or not, but I did not get it. The paper I presume was not an exact copy.
Comment on this
It was merely an extract given, as the Minister has given extracts, by paraphrasing letters he has received from the Electricity Supply Board.
Comment on this
That amendment had been ruled out of order, and the matter was discussed on the section.
Comment on this
I started by saying "that I would speak on the section in the light of the amendment that had been ruled out of order." I went on: "The amendment would mean that the sum of two and a half million pounds originally voted for the Board would be increased by half a million pounds. There is no necessity for that. The Board is not straitened owing to the outgoings to date." Then comes the point that the Deputy left out.
Comment on this
I went on to say: "The Board certainly ought to show that the money that is handed over to it is going to be remunerative, and it has to make a case why it should get more money. To introduce this casually, simply because the Cork station has been bought out is not justified. The purchase of the Cork station was always before those who drew up the 1927 Act, and the purchase price was always considered to be included in the two and a half million pounds. The whole thing was looked to. I do not say that the exact price was definitely arrived at, but a sum for the purchase of the Cork and other undertakings, and for the purchase by agreement of certain small undertakings, was always in our minds when we were arranging for this two and a half million pounds, and there is no reason to believe that that two and a half million pounds will not be sufficient."
Comment on this
At that point I was interrupted by Deputy Fahy, who said: "I take it that the Minister assures us that the Electricity Supply Board will not be in any way hampered in having to meet the charge." I replied: "I would not like to say that, because I do not know enough about it, but they always had before them the fact that they had to buy the Cork undertaking, and they know that the two and a half million pounds granted to them contained a sum which we thought was sufficient for that and for the purchase of the other undertakings."
Comment on this
Would the Minister inform the House if he had no reason to believe that the two and a half million pounds would be insufficient why he had written to the Board twelve months before to the contrary?
Comment on this
Yes, I wrote about a suggested programme and I got an assurance that they would modify their programme.
Comment on this
I am talking about long after the agreement was made. The Minister said yesterday that in the early part of 1930 he issued a letter stating that, in his opinion, the Board had definitely gone beyond the sum which they agreed was at their disposal, and six months later he informed the Dáil to the contrary.
Comment on this
I got a reply on the 7th April in which it was stated: "This is to show that the Electricity Supply Board has kept the agreement." There was a further letter on the 25th April to show that they had modified their programme by £363,000.
Comment on this
The day after that debate they asked to be released from the agreement. I believe that appeal was founded on the amendment that was discussed here. They saw that people here were ready to give them money without any case being made for it, and they asked for release. A request had been made on their behalf for a sum of £500,000. On the 13th June the Board said that they could not complete a reasonable programme without breaking the agreement. They asked that they should be released from it and said that wastage might occur through a breach or stoppage at this stage. I asked what they called a reasonable development. To my mind the test of that was, was it going to remunerate the money spent at some time? I did not care particularly when. I have been waiting to get their statement of what reasonable development they had before them at that time, and I am waiting for it still. Under those conditions it is alleged that I misled the Seanad. I did not. Remember again the terms of the agreement: "Unless it is otherwise agreed by the Executive Council." I might easily have asked the Executive Council to agree. If I had done that I would have come to the House and said: "I believe that the Oireachtas intended that sum of money to cover a variety of things. It seems now as if a good programme is ahead which will entail bigger expenditure." I would have asked the House to vote the money. I have waited, and have not yet got a full statement, or adequate evidence upon which I could come to the House and ask for any money. That is the position I am in at the moment.
Comment on this
On the terms that I stated, a completely unsatisfactory situation. That is the position with regard to the Act.
Comment on this
Might I ask why the Minister did not make it clear in the Seanad when the Bill had gone there, in view of the new information which had come to his knowledge in the meantime?
Comment on this
That the Minister had good reason to believe that the money available for the Board would not be sufficient for its purposes.
Comment on this
I had not good reason to believe that. I had the Board's statement that what they considered a reasonable programme could not be completed without breaking the agreement. The position that I was in then is the position that I am in now. It meant, as far as I was concerned, that new money had to be voted. I held the view that the two and a half millions included the undischarged liabilities. If I had to come to the House to ask for money for a reasonable programme then I should have evidence to demonstrate the reasonableness of it. I got no indication from them as to what their reasonable programme was, or what programme there was that could not be carried out inside the sum of money which they had agreed in 1929 to base their requirements upon. I might have said in the Seanad that the Board, arising out of an amendment moved in the Dáil, had asked for more money. I would have said that they had reason to think that they were going to get that money from the Dáil, arising out of the casual amendment which Deputy Fahy had put down to give them £500,000, nobody else having asked for it. That certainly indicated a big laxity in regard to financial procedure.
Comment on this
The purpose of the amendment was to compel the Minister to make the disclosure almost twelve months ago that he has made now.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy mean that Deputy Fahy knew that the Board wanted the money? Hardly, because I think the Board should have informed me as to the moneys they required before they informed Deputy Fahy.
Comment on this
The purpose of the amendment. The Deputy might have said that an accidental result, if the amendment had been discussed, would be a disclosure of certain things by the Minister. The Deputy is full of parts of speech as well as full of English and should know the meaning of the word "purpose." There was no purpose in Deputy Fahy's amendment except casually and lightly to grant £500,000 to the Board, which the Board had not asked for at that time.
The accounts is the last matter. After that agreement I associated with the Board in a part-time capacity two people. These two people retired from the Board when their period came to an end in February, 1930. At that time I reorganised the Board with a view to getting some better arrangement of the whole scheme. The finances of the Board had at that time become disquieting. I will go no further than to say that. Accordingly Mr. Brown and Mr. Fay were appointed. Deputy de Valera and other Deputies have made a great point that we do not appear to be in a much better position since these two were appointed. But it is to be remembered that it is easy enough to cause a bit of a mess but it is a desperately difficult thing to clear it up. I indicated to these two people when going on the Board, that there was a very definite possibility that they would find things, as far as accounts and records were concerned, in a state, more or less, of chaos. I indicated that if that was so that they were undertaking a very difficult and very responsible task, because people would not stop, unless things were pointed out very accurately to them, to consider the point at which they went in, and the state of things they discovered when they got in. I pointed out to them there was a likelihood that they would be tarred with any pitch that was going, if an unsatisfactory situation was discovered there. These two went on the Board in February of that year on my assurance that I would later on make their position clear.
In July of that year I received an intimation from the Chairman that a particular action had been taken. He gave it to me as a matter of information and I felt relieved when I heard what he had done. He wrote to me afterwards putting the same thing before me in writing. He told me that in June, 1930, he had suggested, and the Board had approved of the suggestion, that the auditors—the auditors in question are the auditors whom I had appointed to investigate the first accounts—should supply staff to help in bringing the records up-to-date and the auditors' staff was got in. I can give no better description of the present situation than to say that since July, 1930, five representatives of that outside auditors' firm, and since September, seven have been continuously engaged in making up all the records that were in arrear and that should have been kept in order by the Board. Those auditors are still engaged in doing what the Board should have been doing—keeping their ordinary business records and if anybody can tell me that I am to criticise in any way the two new members for not being able to do what an outside firm of experienced auditors with five of a staff from July and seven of a staff from September have not yet been able to do, I think they are asking me to judge them very harshly. That is the situation with regard to the accounts. Bear in mind these accounts run from the 1st April, 1929, to the 31st March, 1930, and that outside firm of accountants with five of a staff from July and seven from September to date are, you may say, continuously engaged in trying to remake the records which should have been there from the beginning and were not.
What is the point of view with regard to these accounts? The accounts are not to be had. The accounts will be had some time. I am asking the House at this point for money to carry on the activities of a particular organisation, and I am going to pass on to all the members of the Board, and would probably pass it to two people who are not now on it if they were there, all that has been said in this debate, because no better criticism could be spoken of their activities than all the phrases that have been used in the course of this debate. I am being criticised because I have not certain information. The House adopts towards me the very line that I adopted towards the Board, and a proper line of conduct. They are criticising me for what I criticised the Board.
Comment on this
Has the Minister adopted to the House the same attitude that the Board adopted to him?
Comment on this
No. I am making explanations; the Board made none. I have not the material to make a proper statement: the Board should have had the material for me. We will get that when this outside firm have completed their task. I do not care what allegations with regard to destroying credit may be made against me afterwards. It is better to have it known, now that the situation is in hand, that the accounts of the whole recording organisation from different departments were, according to the letters that were sent to me by the Chairman of the Board, in a complete state of disorganisation, and that people have been got in from outside to try and remake them.
In that, I want to be clear that I am not passing one word of criticism, as Deputy Flinn seemed to imply last night, on the staff. I know nothing much about the activities of the staff. I know of certain people being in certain positions, but as far as the situation that has developed is concerned, the people who were responsible for it were people at the top and mainly the full-time members of that time. From what I know of the staff they are very good, energetic and capable people, but there was no direction at the top, and the situation has been allowed to develop to this point.
Deputy Murphy asked last night what were we to think of a business concern which could not produce at this point the accounts of sixteen months ago. He said that no business concern could succeed on those lines. Yet for what am I being criticised? For refusing to increase the overdraft that a business concern had with me, when it is in the position that Deputy Murphy described of not being able to produce the accounts of sixteen months ago. Deputy de Valera alleges that I am destroying the credit of the Board. If a trader who has an overdraft with a bank finds himself in difficulties and applies to the manager of the bank for an increase in his overdraft, and if the bank manager says: "Give me your accounts; let me look at them and I will consider the question of the overdraft," and if the trader will not or cannot produce the accounts, and the bank manager refuses an extension of his overdraft, who is responsible for the destruction of his credit? Is it the bank?
Comment on this
Honouring is a good word. Remember that the money to which the Board was entitled depended on an agreement. That agreement was honourably undertaken by these people and it should have been kept.
Comment on this
The Deputy will probably get them later. As far as I am concerned all the Deputies ought to get them later.
Comment on this
Three positions have been taken up on this measure. Deputy de Valera will vote the money once he knows what it is for. He demands a statement of the sub-heads under which the allocation of this money will be made. Deputy Good goes a bit further and says: "Let us get in an outside firm of auditors." They have already been called in and have been working for over a year. He does not ask the same thing as Deputy de Valera. He does not say "Let us find out what this money is required for." He says: "Ask that expert firm to make out a statement as to the Board's commitments, to give us some idea of the revenue and expenditure position." I think that should be got, but if you are going to wait until that is got, remember that the 1929-30 accounts are about ready for audit now, and will not be available for six or seven weeks. They will not come into this House until October. These are the accounts for the year ending 31st March, 1930. The auditors are working to try to re-make all the records that the Board should have kept. What are we going to ask these auditors to do? They have got to get the 1930-31 accounts, to get a general picture of the whole position of the Board, its commitments, its estimated revenue, and its expenditure. We will wait a long time before we get it, but we must get it sooner or later.
Deputy O'Connell thinks that we should know more than even this. I think he agreed with Deputy Good with regard to the outside firm of auditors, but added that we should get the firm to make suggestions as to how anything that is wrong could be rectified. I do not know that auditors are the proper people to do that. The auditors can get the accounts, they can get a statement of the commitments, of the various types of revenue and of the expenditure position, and they may give certain suggestions of a limited type but there may be other suggestions that would have to be made in relation to the sum of money that is now being asked for. The House may say that they will vote a sum of money simply to meet the ascertained liabilities of the Board, that they will vote a certain limited sum that will keep the Board going for a couple of months. They can vote a sum which the Board says is required for immediate extensions. They can say that they will confine the money to paying for work done but they have to make up their minds on this: Are they going to wait for that statement, for a report such as Deputy Good wants and the much more detailed report that Deputy O'Connell suggests? The House can vote whatever money it believes is required, and I honestly hope when the House is voting the money that it will take me clean out of the new Bill, that it will have its mind clear when it is voting that money to a particular organisation, that it is going to keep the Board independent of the Minister.
These are things the House will have to approach on Committee Stage. At the moment the main thing the House has before it is that certain moneys should be granted for the purposes of the Electricity Supply Board——
Comment on this
I did not bring myself into that Bill with any satisfaction. If the Deputy likes I will agree to put down an amendment to take myself out of the Bill. But the House should know what it is doing. It is going to give money to a Board for certain purposes. Is it going to have no check or control upon it? It is inevitable that it is going to have very little statement of a detailed type as to what that money is required for— nothing is now possible in the nature of the investigation in regard to the money previously voted. Nobody can certify that the money is properly due. I could not certify it. If I am to do anything hereafter, I am to certify that the money is properly and reasonably required before it is authorised. I could not take that burden on myself at the moment. I could not recommend that £2,000,000. I do not believe that I could recommend £1,500,000 was properly due to them at the moment, but there are certain sums of money that one can say they are likely to need, and that there is a great likelihood that they will need within a certain limited period, but the House will have to take either of two points of view. It can say that it will take full responsibility for so much money; that the Board can make its demand and the Minister for Finance must pay on demand. Or the House can say "No, we want some check in between, and we will have the check in the persons of the Ministers, whom we will hold responsible when the moneys are disbursed."
Deputy de Valera last night referred to the Shannon scheme. He used it twice for his own purposes. First, he said that a certain sum of money was voted, and that that sum was from time to time increased. That is quite wrong. It was once increased. The way it progressed, he believed, was on certain rough calculations that were made. A little later he asked, why do not we act in this case as we acted previously when large sums of money were involved and get the assistance of outside experts? But apparently the experts never produced anything except rough calculations. I do not know what we want experts for if that is the case. We want something more than rough calculations if money is to be voted free of any ministerial check.
I said before that this was an unsatisfactory situation. It is not a situation that I would like to have seen happen or develop. It is one I did my best to prevent. I have never put more effort into anything than in trying to get the whole Shannon business, in so far as it had any relation to me, on an even keel. If I have to confess there is a certain failure at this moment I do so in this atmosphere—that I am trying my best to renew the conditions under which success will be achieved.
Comment on this
Following on a remark made by the Minister, I should like to make our attitude clear. We were prepared, and are prepared, to vote the sum of money which is immediately necessary to cover the liabilities and the immediate needs, and to keep the enterprise going. We are prepared to do that and as the Minister has indicated that he is willing, on Committee Stage, to have that point of view examined in detail, we are not going to do what we purposed doing— to vote against this Bill.
Comment on this
On a point of privilege, the Minister has quoted from various documents and communications which passed between him and the Shannon Board. Is it not the practice, when a Minister quoted from such documents, that copies of them are placed on the Table for the information of members? Can we be informed whether the documents in question now will be tabled for the information of members before the next Stage of this Bill is taken?
Comment on this
The Minister has referred to a considerable number of letters and has paraphrased them. He has also referred to an agreement. I submit that that agreement, and the correspondence which took place between the Minister and the Board in relation to this matter, the correspondence which took place particularly between the period September, 1929, and the present day, should be tabled.
Comment on this
The Minister quoted textually from certain letters and he gave certain textual portions of the agreement.
Comment on this
Is there any good reason for refusing to table these documents in view of the fact that their purport has been given to the House?
Comment on this
In view of the use the Minister has made of this agreement, surely the House is entitled to see the text of the agreement and of the correspondence which led up to it? This agreement, which obviously the Executive Council forced on the Electricity Supply Board——
Comment on this
The Minister says it is in writing. It is not in the public interest that it should be withheld.
Comment on this
In relation to a grant of money by this Oireachtas, a secret agreement has been entered into between the Minister and the body authorised to spend that money.
Comment on this
The position as regards documents is that if documents are quoted by a Minister, the Minister may be asked to lay the documents before the House and make them available to members. If the Minister says that it is contrary to the public interest in his judgment to do that, it simply is not done at that particular point. There is no way of getting over that at the moment.