We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Electricity (Supply) (Amendment) Bill, 1931—Money Resolution.

Contributions 128–255 of 255. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electricity (Supply)(Amendment) Bill, 1931
Enacted

No. 31 of 1931 ›

Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Could not all these questions be asked at the conclusion of the Minister's speech?

Comment on this

The Minister asked the question himself. Of course we know the rule of the Chair in this matter. We know the actions of the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Would the Deputy explain what he means?

Comment on this

It is always the practice of the Chair to prevent Deputies on this side interrupting Ministers, but not to prevent Ministers from interrupting Deputies.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is absolutely an uncalled-for statement.

Comment on this

Read the Official Debates.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not in accordance with the facts and the Deputy has no right to make the statement. Deputies know that quite well.

Comment on this

Sixty-six interruptions of Deputy Lemass by the Minister last week.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have read the debates and listened to Deputies. One point is clear as was put by the Ceann Comhairle. This House is entitled to hear the Minister and the House ought to be allowed to hear him and the people of the country are entitled to hear what the Minister's explanation is.

Comment on this

That is a perfectly good rule if it is applied to everybody.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Lemass knows better than any other Deputy in this House that it is.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe accuses me of a great number of omissions, mainly basing his accusation on the fact that accounts had not been insisted upon and that certain accounts that have been published are in a particular form. I wonder did he change his mind after listening to Deputy de Valera the other day? Deputy de Valera the other day was a little bit inclined to agree with me that these accounts were in arrears, but he now has made up his mind that that would be judging the Board too harshly. Is that Deputy Briscoe's view?

Comment on this

Have I the permission of the Chair to answer?

Comment on this

I wonder does Deputy de Valera agree?

Comment on this

If I have permission to answer I will answer the Minister.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

What I said was—I think it was clear to every Deputy— that I was inclined to give a hasty judgment on the last occasion when the accounts were mentioned and to side with the Minister in thinking that there had been unconscionable delay. But on thinking over it since and realising that the accounts of this House are not presented in full form for over a year, that the accounts of the Post Office are not presented in final form for a year and a half, and that these are long established so to speak, and running on routine lines, I asked myself have I not been guilty of a very hasty judgment when I judged as against the Board on that account, on the question of fact as to whether they were late or not and as to whether there was blame. I was inclined to attach blame to the Board for having them so late.

Comment on this

Deputy Briscoe I hope will take a lesson from that. I can leave this matter of the accounts aside without much more ado. The Deputy thinks that because I have power to prescribe accounts under Section 7 I have power to appoint myself almost an official of the Board. I can prescribe accounts and see that they are asked for, but that does not say that I will get them. I have prescribed a form of accounts and asked for information repeatedly, pressed about them and wrote letters about them. Deputy de Valera said the material was there but that unfortunately it could not be put together for the auditors. I have evidence that records were not there. The material was not there, and what these outsiders have been doing, and I am informed now that the number has gone up from 7 to 17, is not putting the material together but doing what the accounts side of that particular organisation should have been doing for about two years, collecting information that should have been in hands. Deputy de Valera is in a peculiar position over this. The other day he was inclined to pass what he thinks now would have been a harsh judgment upon the Board, because he thought the accounts might be in the arrear, "in a mess"—somebody used that phrase. He thinks it is unfortunate. He thinks we should not be too harsh on this new business. As far as the accounts are concerned he keeps in his usual state of philosophic doubt. At any rate, he is not going to pass judgment on the Board in the matter of the accounts. The Board is out of it as far as one of the three charges I made against it are concerned. He says that he understands the material is there and that it is only a matter of putting the material in order for the auditors. That I can assure him is not the case. People have been engaged on remaking records, getting receipts, looking for invoices, and so on. The whole system of records was disorganised. There was no material for the auditors, but the Deputy has his own view upon that. He says the Board is all right. At any rate, he will not pass judgment upon the Board.

As far as the agreement is concerned the Deputy again reserves judgment. Until the documents are published the Deputy will not say one thing or another. The third thing is the major item of policy. On that the Deputy's conclusion is that there must have been some system approaching a budgetary system. So on the three items which I really felt I was by implication charging against the Board, the Deputy said I am not in a position to pass judgment. Nevertheless he will not give them any money.

Comment on this

I am giving money for immediate needs.

Comment on this

Why restrict it to that? They are still a good Board as far as he is concerned.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

He has said that he will not pass judgment; he will not accept an ex parte statement of mine. That being so there is no case against them. His inner conscience tells him that there must have been something approaching a budgetary system. Then it was a good Board.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

The Deputy always objects to add two and two together and to make them four.

Comment on this

The Minister adds two and two together and makes them five.

Comment on this

There however is the situation. Yet the Deputy will not allow this Board to get money. The Deputy, as a matter of fact, is talking not really what he believes when he said what I have repeated. In fact he has a feeling in his heart that there is something wrong and he is quite right in refusing the money but he cannot refuse the money on the ground he has stated. The Deputy says I have found fault with the Board for not living within this two and a half million pounds. I do not know if that charge comes from any words of mine. I never said it. I said that when the Board guaranteed not to spend more than two and a half millions of money they should not have spent more. If they found that they could not keep within that sum it was their job to come to me and make the case for more money, so that I could make the case to this House. Even after I got word from them that they could not keep within the guarantee I wrote and said, "give me your view of a reasonable programme on which I can make a case to the Dáil, and guarantee the reasonableness of that programme." I never got satisfaction on that. That is the reason why there should be hesitation in this House in voting this money to-day, until something approaching a reasonable case is made and until a realisation is had of the circumstances in which we find ourselves. At that time I asked the Board to realise its circumstances and mine, and try and meet the conditions that ordinarily would attach to the granting of the money.

The Deputy said that I want this money for the indirect purpose of being able to insist on the Board working as I desire it should work and not as the Board desires. That raises the general question—we should know where we stand about this Board. Deputy Briscoe's implication on the question as to what I have cost the country by my attitude towards the Board is exactly the same as Deputy Lemass's explicit statement. Deputy Lemass explicitly stated that I am to be held responsible for all that has happened, on this special ground, apart from anything else, that I appointed the members of the Board. We have this position then with regard to an independent board, that if the Minister or the Executive Council appoints an independent board, and leaves them clearly to act as an independent board, they are nevertheless responsible at the end of the time for what that independent board has done. They are responsible in so far as they have appointed the men.

Comment on this

And re-appointed them.

Comment on this

That is a reservation which the Deputy can make later. The statement to which he nodded assent was that merely by appointing, the people appointing took responsibility for what happened. If that is to be the case, where shall we ever get an independent board? If that is going to be the situation, I want clearly and definitely to be put into the position of guardian, so that I shall be aware of my responsibility. If you are going to have an independent board, you cannot say that you are going to indict with everything that happens thereafter the people who appointed, simply because they did appoint. I do not see how the House is going to get out of that dilemma. It is Deputy de Valera's dilemma and Deputy Lemass'.

At the moment the position is that I am in the new Bill as the phrase is there about certifying reasonable expenditure, but without that phrase, it appears that as the person who appoints, I am going to be landed with the full responsibility for everything that happens. I wonder where is the great scheme of the independent board that everybody praised here the other night—an experiment so useful that "it might be applied to other matters affecting the economic life of the country." In any event, somebody must appoint unless we are to leave the appointment to the Dáil generally, which would be merely shirking responsibility. The Government by the mere fact of appointing is going to be held responsible afterwards for everything that happens. Under this present Bill, I must certify that moneys are reasonably and properly required before they are granted. If I am to be held responsible for everything done merely because I appoint, I am going to take very good care that I shall supervise every act the Board does. I do not think that the situation here is the proper situation. It is not the one I want to see hereafter, but there are circumstances at this moment which require a better guardianship than there has been. But I disclaim all responsibility for things the Board has done since the date of its appointment until this particular Bill is passed.

Deputy Lemass has several amendments down to this Bill. He wants to insert "for the purposes mentioned in sub-section (3)" in Section 3. He has made clear in his speech that he wants to prevent two things. In the first place, he wants to ensure that none of this money will be expended in meeting, say, extra charges made upon me in respect of the construction works. That is not possible under the Bill. He says, further, that he wants to prevent extra money being advanced for the provision of additional generation. I said that, under the Bill, I did not think that that was possible. I made a reservation on that. But the Deputy's amendment does not save the position at all, because anything that was possible in the way of additional generation work would occur under the particular sub-section to which he attaches his amendment. What that power is under that sub-section I do not clearly know, but I want to refer to one matter to show the doubts that may arise. Section 28 gives the Board power to "conduct such investigations, experiments and trials as the Board thinks fit for the improvement of the methods of transmission, distribution and supply of electricity or of the utilisation of fuel, water power or other means of generating electricity and may establish and maintain a testing laboratory for the testing and standardisation of electrical instruments." The Board may also "take such measures as in the opinion of the Board are calculated to advance the exploitation of water power in Saorstát Eireann." The section then goes on to deal with a special point about hydrometric survey work. There is one other section that has general provisions of that type. My intention is that if there was any proposition really for additional generating plant, that ought to come before the House on a clearly-stated proposal. But there may be some proposal which provides extra generation power incidentally. You can almost make a distinction by value. It is quite clear that nothing could be done by way of experiment or investigation or trial that would really amount to a considerable sum of money —say, £100,000. It is quite possible that the Board under that section might do certain things which, in fact, would give extra power — provide an extra peak load. That would be possible under the Act and it would be possible under the Deputy's amendment. My general proposition is this: So far as extra Shannon works on any scale are concerned, they are not in the Bill and they cannot be in the Bill. So far as money for extra generation is concerned, it is the State's business to look after the provision of extra generation. If there was any proposal for that, it would have to come before the House upon a particular scheme. But there may be things the Board will do by way of stand-by provision in particular places to which that would not apply. They might so increase stand-by provision as to allow, for instance, three turbines at Ardnacrusha to be used for ordinary purposes instead of two. That would be within the Board's powers under the Act and under the Bill, and it would be within the Deputy's amendment. I think it is quite right that that should be within their power. These being the two points, and making that reservation to which I referred, I think the Bill and the amendment are much on the same footing. But the amendment might prevent the money being used for other things which it is clearly right it should be used for.

Outside those points, there are two points to which I desire now to refer. One point which was raised dealt with the amount of money to be paid and the other point dealt with control by the Minister. Deputy Lemass advanced two proposals. One proposal was that we should set aside a sum of £600,000 for the undischarged liabilities of acquired undertakings. Nobody need bother now about undischarged liabilities. They are there and we know what is happening to them. They are being carried on in the way which we always intended they should be. We always intended that the two and a half million pounds should represent both new capital payments and the capitalised value of the liabilities that we took over. But nobody has ever advanced any absurd proposition as to paying off these liabilities at once.

Comment on this

Why did you want £600,000 docked off the Board's two and a half million pounds?

Comment on this

Nobody wanted that money for other special purposes. You might as well put the case that because I did not vote them three and a half million pounds I docked a million off them. The whole idea was to get a figure which would represent capital which the Board could remunerate. On a combination of a great many things, we agreed that that figure would be represented by two and a half million pounds. We knew that part of that would represent the capital liabilities of these undertakings taken over by the Board, but to say that I was stopping money from them because of that knowledge is equivalent to saying that because I did not give them an extra million, therefore I stopped an extra million from them. The picture we wanted to get was to consist of a figure which the Board could remunerate on the distribution side. The picture put up to me as the perfect picture was two and a half million pounds including the undischarged liabilities item. But there was no question of stopping money. In the course of my letter to the Board, I pointed out that that was the position, and I said later on in August, 1929, that I would make any change with regard to giving them extra money if they made a case to me. They have never made a case in a satisfactory way.

Comment on this

The Minister states that he was prepared to make a new arrangement with the Board. On one occasion, the Board wanted to be relieved in respect of a certain agreement because the situation was such that they could not allow that sum of £600,000 to be put aside. That representation was made to the Minister and it appears to me that the Minister said that his action on that was to tell them that he would bring the matter to the Dáil and tell the Dáil that this £600,000 was included in the original sum and that it should not go to them.

Comment on this

The Deputy is mixing up two things. At the time that I said I would go to the Dáil to make clear that the original sum included the £600,000 the Board made no good case that they wanted to be relieved of the agreement. The Board later made a statement to me that a reasonable programme could not be carried out within the limitation laid down. Our retort was: "What is a reasonable programme?" We pointed out that it must be shown that it was reasonable. Supposing I had not got that information, as I did not get it, and that I came to this House, what position would I have been in? The same position as I am in now or, perhaps, a much worse position, because I would have to say: "The Board tell me they cannot carry on on this particular sum of money. They ask for more. I asked them to make a case, to show me that this money could be remunerated and they cannot do so." Who would vote money under these circumstances?

The £600,000 is outside this. The Deputy, I suppose, wants to show that the agreement is not there. He says there is something like half a million available; add another half million or so and you have £1,100,000 and that ought to be sufficient. The Deputy put a further point: what is the control, if any? The Deputies opposite want an independent Board. The Board is to be independent, but still the point is made that people are to be held responsible for everything that happens. The suggestion has been made that the Board should draw the undischarged liability money without any check. What is going to happen to the £600,000 that is still on hands? The claim made from the opposite side is that it is to be drawn without any check.

Comment on this

Are there not any liabilities to be incurred?

Comment on this

The case put up is that the £600,000 is to go out without any check. It is to be paid on demand being made to the Minister for Finance. But while that is so, the £500,000 is to be put under control. If Deputy de Valera has the opinion of the Board that he states, why not give the Board the £1,100,000 without any control whatever?

Comment on this

The Minister does not seem to know my opinion.

Comment on this

People who want an independent Board are surely concerned at seeing that there is some check upon that half million. The Deputies opposite are not accepting the case I make. They are in further doubt as to whether there is a case at all. They are not clear why certain people resigned or whether their resignations ought to have been accepted. They are prepared to give them the benefit of the doubt. They want, nevertheless to have a check upon the Board by having the Minister to take control, but their position is that the £600,000 ought to go to the Board on demand. That seems to me a rather mixed situation.

I want to make my position clear with regard to control. I would ask the Dáil not to accept the position that the Party opposite is taking up with regard to the Board, that if it is appointed in an independent way with all the marks of independence upon it, merely because someone appoints the members of it, he is going to be held responsible.

Comment on this

Somebody has the power to dismiss.

Comment on this

No man is going to accept responsibility for a board unless he has some say in its movements. If he is going to be held responsible simply because he has the power to appoint and the power to dismiss, a power that has never been exercised, then the only decent step to take is to say, "We will be fully responsible, and we want that made clear." If we are to go back to an independent board, the case I would make is that if the man appointing has exercised proper judgment, and if the people appointed are men whose reputation is such that a good case could be made for their appointment, he should not be held responsible if they turn out badly in the course of operations.

If I were to consult my own wishes in this matter of freedom from responsibility and of not having to answer questions I would say take the Ministers out of it. But if I am to act with any sense of responsibility I would not advise the Dáil to vote one five pound note in the present circumstances without keeping the double check of the two Ministers. Remember there is more than one Minister. The Minister for Finance may advance if the Minister for Industry and Commerce certifies. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has to certify certain things, and after that it is not compulsory on the Minister for Finance to advance the money. There are two "mays" that have to be got over.

As far as this Vote is concerned, if there is not £2,000,000 granted in the circumstances that I am going to detail I personally will not accept willingly any responsibility for any part of this money. I do not know what the Minister for Finance may do, but I would recommend him not to accept responsibility for anything less than the £2,000,000. If that sum is not going to be voted, then take the Ministers out of it altogether. It must be admitted that I have certain inside information. If the House were to ask me to take responsibility for the running of the Board over a period of time I would not take responsibility for the Board's actions being properly carried out for a less sum than the £2,000,000.

With regard to the period of time we are told that we should get in experts. That is the phrase that has been used. I do not know what type these experts are going to be.

Comment on this

Let the Minister take the experts that he had before.

Comment on this

I do not know what sort of work they are going to do. If you were to bring experts here within the next week I do not know that we could give them an hour's good work so far as the affairs of the Board are concerned. There is nothing to put before an expert, nothing that you could ask an expert opinion on. There would be nothing to put before an expert until, at any rate, after the 1929-30 accounts have been produced, and to my mind until the 1930-31 accounts have been produced. There will be nothing for an expert to give an opinion on until the position revealed, whatever it may be, by the 1930-31 accounts has been examined, to see what, if any, financial readjustments in the whole scheme are necessary, to see whether any increased charges may be necessary to see whether a new charge system of a certain kind should be made, on the revelation that the present charges are too low or too high. To call in an expert at this moment would be to call in a man on false pretences. At the moment there is nothing to ask an expert opinion on. There will be no work that an expert could do until the accounts for the year ended March last have been produced, until after you have had auditors working on them, and until there has been an opportunity given for considering the auditors' report as well as possible readjustment arising out of it.

I do not know that even then it will be necessary to call in experts. But if it is necessary at any time that will be the time. When is that period likely to come? The accounts for the year 1929-30 are approaching final form. They are ready to be submitted to audit. The audit will take some time. After that I have the right to look into them to make certain proposals with regard to them. It may be that the accounts will have to go backward and forward between the firm of auditors and myself. All that will take time. After that they will be produced to the House with whatever reports are considered necessary to clarify them. It may take some time to get the reports necessary to clarify them. The earliest date that I would put on the accounts of 1929-30 being ready would be October or November of this year.

The accounts for the year ending the 31st March, 1931, must then be taken up. They will later have to go to the auditor. His report will have to be sent to me. Eventually, with whatever reports are considered necessary the accounts will be laid before the House. The earliest date, I think, at which the House can have these later accounts is February or March of next year, and if any real consideration is to be given to such readjustments as may be considered necessary arising out of them it may well be that they will not be available before Easter, 1932. Then there is the possibility that most people envisage, that there will have to be legislation brought in to deal with the readjustment of the Board. Take that as one thing. When is that legislation going to be drafted and ready for introduction? During all that time the Board must carry on. I do not see all that being done before, at the very earliest, this time next year.

I am asked what moneys will be required. I gave a certain figure as representing the debts that the Board had already incurred. I took the sum representing the accrued liabilities as being somewhere between £600,000 and £700,000. The latest figure that I have got dates back to the end of June. At that date the Board's accrued liabilities amounted to about £720,000. That means that if they had £720,000 in hands at the end of June they would not have had as much as one shilling on the 2nd or 3rd of July. That is the position with regard to the £720,000. It could have been paid out immediately; it could have been demanded at once.

They will require a certain amount of money for working capital. It is a very hard figure to judge. There is a very bad period in the Board's financial year when moneys are not coming in and when certain expenditure has to be made. That occurs about the end of July, or in August and September. Supposing you say that there would be a sum of not less than £53,000 or £54,000 required for that period. In my opinion it is not enough, but those figures have been put to me. I talked earlier of the Board's commitments. I talked of what I called their inextricable commitments at one time. I tried to get the figure of a quarter of a million then mentioned split up, one item estimated on the basis of work already engaged upon, material ordered, contracts placed, and a second amount referring to work of which it cannot be said that all those things have been actually done. For networks and substations being erected by outside firms of contractors; for networks and substations being erected by the Board's staff where the material was ordered by the staff, and for the reconstruction of networks, there is a sum of £115,000. That is a deduction, and a very big deduction, from the money I previously set against commitments. That is money that must be spent. When I go on to refer to what I am bulking as future requirements an amount of this second item is very nearly in the position of actual commitments. The amount actually committed will be nearly a quarter of a million, but I have sub-divided it into the £115,000 referred to and what I now go on to discuss.

I have here a statement with regard to certain sub-heads of expenditure, and I want to preface my remarks on these sub-heads by saying that these are not being put forward to the House in the same way as sub-heads in an ordinary estimate would be put forward. The statement is put forward with the definite understanding that any part of the money not spent on a particular sub-head can be removed and spent on some other sub-head. The thing is very provisional. It is the best that could be given in a very limited period of time, and it has to be taken subject to the reservation that the Board do not admit themselves as committed to the expenditure of all or any of the money under the sub-heads. They might spend more on some sub-heads than on others, or than is actually estimated. The Board say that the expenditure that is absolutely necessary to safeguard supply in Dublin, including Rathmines and Pembroke; in Cork and in Limerick, providing for the normal growth in load, would amount to £133,500.

Comment on this

Over what period?

Comment on this

I am going to speak about the period in a moment. This is the first statement giving block figures. The expenditure necessary to safeguard supply in all other areas in the country at present supplied, providing for the normal growth in load, is £77,300. The reconstruction and connection to the Shannon system of five named towns—named to me, but I do not propose to name them here— where economies will be effected by closing down fuel stations at present operated by the Board, will cost £45,000. Provision for a supply to completely new areas—this, to my mind, is a very small estimate— amounts to £37,000. For the cost of acquisition, reconstruction and connection to the Shannon system of towns which have existing undertakings there is a sum of £270,400. Provision for connecting new individual consumers to the Shannon system, including the cost of meters comes to £224,000. Public lighting, that is, the erection of both lamps and cables for public lighting, £27,000. The sum of about £133,000 is roughly divided up between alterations to the main transmission system, to improve supply, and to maintain the present supply in a satisfactory way; improvements at the Pigeon House for stand-by purposes; improvements at Fleet Street and elsewhere to safeguard supply, and improvements at the Pigeon House and Fleet Street to meet an increased load. For all those items there is a sum of from £133,000 to £135,000. There is a sum for contingencies amounting to about £100,000.

Comment on this

Are those figures which the Minister has read an addition to the first three items?

Comment on this

Certainly. Additional to the accrued liabilities, the working capital and the inextricable commitments. As regards the period, I do not know how this can be divided with regard to period at all. I am told with regard to certain items that they are absolutely necessary immediately. Part of them are so absolutely necessary that they are tied up in the £250,000 for which I have now substituted a figure of £115,000. The rest of the £250,000 is contained somewhere in the later list and, therefore, is not merely necessary somewhere in the immediate future, but is possibly contracted for in the peculiar conditions at the moment. There are certain items that could be picked out and one could say that they spread themselves over a couple of years. For instance, there is an item in connection with acquiring, reconstruction and connecting to the Shannon system towns that have an existing undertaking, and the amount in that respect is £270,000. Clearly, that amount will not be spent in the one year. Then there is provision for connecting new individual consumers to the system. The £224,000 there would not be spent in a twelve months period and quite clearly they do not propose to spend the £27,000 in the next twelve months for lamps and cables for public lighting.

With regard to the towns that have existing undertakings, at the moment the Board can only acquire by agreement. There may be a period when some fortunate circumstances may occur in a particular town which would make the Board seek to acquire in that particular town earlier than it normally would. There may be a town where the present undertaker might say: "I am bearing all the load I can. I have not put any money into reconstruction, and demands are being made by consumers to extend or give a better supply. If I am not going to be bought out at this period at a particular figure, I must be allowed to sink fresh capital." If he is not bought out then and there the day of his eventual acquisition will be indefinitely postponed. While one may say that certain sums must be expended in the next twelve months, one does not know when suitable circumstances may occur and when one may be called upon to expend the money. A further point on the time question arises. If this money is going to be under the control of a Minister or under the control of two Ministers and I ask the Dáil to vote this money deliberately knowing this—it means definitely a slowing up in the Board's operations. Let me assume that some of the money will be required for works that ought to be operating round about, say, the autumn of 1932. To get the works operating by the autumn of 1932 the order for the particular materials must be placed by a particular time in advance. Before that has been placed there must be an investigation of the circumstances as to whether they warrant the laying out of the money in that way. There must be added on to this some period also in which the Board will be able to convince the Minister that that expenditure is necessary. When you take all that, the sum of money, big as it looks, and the purpose for which it is required, and the added fact that there is going to be an additional period, a very long period probably, in which the Board must make its case to two Ministers for the expenditure of any of the money, I think that it is not too big in relation to the circumstances, and I ask that that two millions should be voted here and now for this purpose.

Comment on this

I should like to ask if the purchase of these existing undertakings in the five towns was contemplated when the original £2,500,000 was fixed?

Comment on this

The only plan put to me was that the money was supposed to cover either the taking over of existing undertakings or the erection of new undertakings in every town and village of 500 population and upwards.

Comment on this

I take it that all this expenditure was contemplated when the original £2,500,000 was fixed.

Comment on this

I think it was, certainly, and the answer to what is behind the question is that the calculation was completely wrong.

Comment on this

That is the original £2,500,000?

Comment on this

Yes, and the people who put it up simply have to suffer for the mistakes they made.

Comment on this

Before the period of the Board?

Comment on this

I may say that the person who estimated these sums of money went on the Board.

Comment on this

The whole contention of the Board is that they could not do it within that figure.

Comment on this

Not that they could not do that within the figure but that they could not do a reasonable programme within the particular figure. But, to get on, supposing that this new sum of two millions is spent. If all the Board has to deliver to consumers is the maximum output of the partial development of the Shannon scheme then that money cannot be remunerated? The Shannon scheme was established as far as the first Act was concerned as a bulk supply system. We then went on to the distribution side. There were two or three variables in the whole calculation. One was the amount of power which could be produced at Ardnacrusha. The second was the amount of power for which there were consumers in this country; and the third the prices at which consumers would buy and at which electricity would be offered to them. We know that at this moment we are up to the full delivery of all the power that Ardnacrusha can produce in a dry season. We must get a stand-by, and extra plant. Part of that money will be for certain stand-by arrangements at the Pigeon House, which will enable Ardnacrusha to produce at its extreme and the money may even go further than Ardnacrusha production. Certainly I would not contemplate the spending of that two millions unless I saw more units possible of delivery to consumers than what the Shannon partial development of itself in a dry year can deliver. If I am asked will this money be remunerated I say it most probably will and promise that it will not be spent unless an absolutely good case has been made that it is going to be remunerated. I want to make a reservation again. Debts have to be met and for these debts I take no responsibility. They are there and they will have to be paid. Once it is clear that the debts are there and that the people who are getting the money are the proper recipients of it there is not very much more to be done with that item. As to the new money certainly my attitude is going to be not to examine into every detail of the constructional work because there is 90 per cent. of it about which I know nothing but I will want a financial statement to be put up establishing with reasonable certainty that the money will be remunerated. I ask for the £2,000,000 under such a check. Deputy Lemass said that I put a proposal to the House which is merely guess-work. I described it myself as unsatisfactory. I have given more satisfaction now—I do not know how much.

Comment on this

The Minister confesses that his original estimate was farcically inadequate.

Comment on this

By no means. The two and a half millions would have done a certain amount of work and the two and a half millions applied to certain works undoubtedly would have been remunerated. Certain money was spent in other directions. I do not know definitely how well or how wisely it has been spent or how far it is going to be remunerated but nobody ever thought that the Board was going to operate on a particular scale, going to do everything in one gulp as it proceeded to do. I do not believe anyone would have put up two and a half millions for that. All the time, in this correspondence, the proposal was put to the Board: "You promised to limit your expenditure to a certain sum of money." When they stated that they had not done that I made a case against them on that point. I said I would not lightly give any new money to people who did not keep an undertaking. I wanted certain readjustments in their position. I did not make the case that that was the point to close down upon expenditure; I would even have gone on and relived them of the undertaking made with the Executive Council and come to the Dáil with regard to it. There are to my mind developments that can go on to another two million pounds in addition to what I now request from the Dáil.

Comment on this

The 2½ million pounds was to bring electricity to every town with 500 population and over and it did not succeed?

Comment on this

There was no necessity to buy out Cork and take over Dublin.

Comment on this

The purchase of Cork was contemplated?

Comment on this

If certain other things were not done. But there was no obligation on the Board to buy Cork.

Comment on this

The Minister said last year that the purchase of the Cork station was contemplated when the 2½ million pounds was fixed.

Comment on this

Certainly, but not in conjunction with everything else the Board did. Let me put it this way: If it is suggested to me that at one time I thought that the 2½ million pounds given to the Board was to be the last sum ever voted in this country for electricity distribution I can only reply that I never was so foolish as to conceive that. That is what the Deputy is trying to make out I did at one time believe.

Comment on this

What did they pay for the Dublin undertaking?

Comment on this

Whatever the undischarged liabilities were.

Comment on this

Nothing.

Comment on this

Say £600,000.

Comment on this

They have not paid it yet.

Comment on this

They are paying it off. I will now get back to what I started with. As to guesswork, there is less of guesswork now. I do not know how far it is satisfactory, but I want to make this clear: From the investigation I have been able to make and the contact I have had with people working very earnestly on the production of these figures I am not going again to be put in the position of having accusations made against me of starving a particularly good development, and I will not take responsibility for running this thing, in the way that it is in the Bill, for any figure less than the two million pounds provided. We will not quibble about £100,000 or £150,000 or £200,000. The round figure required is two million pounds, and it is to be given under the check of two Ministers, and these two Ministers are clearly going to be held responsible for the expenditure of that sum. I limit responsibility to that £2,000,000.

Deputy Lemass gives me an opportunity to refer to a previous quotation of his in a debate in 1929. The Deputy gave me a quotation the purpose of which, he will admit, was to show that I said the original estimate of £5,200,000 was fixed and binding. I denied that. He gave me a quotation earlier and purported to read it to-day. I asked him did he see any difference in the two quotations. He has not answered that. What he did in 1929 was to take two sentences of mine. He quoted the second sentence first, then he quoted the first sentence and stopped at the comma and left out half of it. Yet he does not realise the object apparently of the part omitted.

Comment on this

The meaning is the same in any case.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy read and compared the quotation with the original? Here is the point the Deputy left out. He read a broken sentence: "...but the only scheme that is under consideration at the moment is the scheme entailing a cost of £5,200,000. Nobody can question that is the amount which we are considering, because for that we have binding estimates, if we care to accept tenders here and now...." Full stop in the Deputy's quotation, but in the actual quotation, a comma, and then it continued, "with the exception of the item referred to by Deputy Thrift on page 80, limited to civil constructional costs." (Official Debates, Vol. 10, cols. 2019-2020).

Comment on this

Why does the Minister stop there?

Comment on this

I am going on: "The prices are absolutely fixed and binding. They are maximum prices from Siemens Schuckerts' point of view. They are not the minimum from our point of view. We have checks and controls," and so on. Does the Deputy still say that he thinks that that means that the £5,200,000 is binding? What does the Deputy think is in the phrase, "with the exception of the item referred to by Deputy Thrift, on page 80, limited to civil constructional costs"?

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell us what is in it?

Comment on this

The Deputy gave what purports to be an accurate quotation of how I represented the facts on a particular date. I am wondering is he still of the opinion that that makes no change?

Comment on this

I take it that that is the provision for the contingencies referred to.

Comment on this

The Deputy makes a quotation. He sees there "with the exception of the item referred to," and does not try to investigate what it refers to.

Comment on this

"The prices are absolutely fixed and binding. They are maximum prices from Siemens Schuckerts' point of view. They are not the minimum from our point of view." I do not know what meaning the Minister intended to convey, but to me it is obvious.

Comment on this

I stressed this because I have got used to the Deputy getting righteously indignant when somebody purports to show that he has not been honest in a quotation. I will have to get another phrase: it is that he does not understand English, that he does not care what it means, that he is reckless with regard to quotations. He will not verify what that particular item would cover. What is the item referred to on page 80? It is this: that these things were subject to an up or down, a plus or minus, ten per cent., and they are fixed and binding within that limit. That is what it comes to—fixed and binding within that limit.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

The Deputy will have to get the particular page 80 and look at what it means.

Comment on this

We have it here.

Comment on this

I say that if the Deputy takes that and gets the civil constructional costs——

Comment on this

I think the real point of the proviso was that Siemens Schuckert have made a provision of almost ten per cent. for what is known as a charge for building machinery.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy read the paragraph?

Comment on this

I will let the Minister make his own speech, as has been sometimes suggested.

Comment on this

At any rate, it is within the memory of everybody who was in the Dáil that discussed this business that never at any time did I say that the £5,200,000 or the £4,660,000 which is the figure in question was fixed and binding without always adding that there is a ten per cent. variation either way. If the Deputy goes back he will see that there was nothing dinned into people's heads more than that limitation was. If the Deputy will go back to the additional figure of the scheme he will find that the increased figure of the 1929 Act is not in excess of the variation allowed.

Comment on this

May I read the last sentence? "We have checks and controls by which, if we find a reputable firm in any other part of the world would do any part of this work at less than Messrs. Siemens Schuckert, then we can beat them down to that or give the contracts on those parts to other firms."

Comment on this

What does that mean?

Comment on this

That in no circumstances were the estimates to be exceeded.

Comment on this

Within the ten per cent. The Deputy is definitely incapable of understanding or else is deliberately misunderstanding if he cannot get down to that.

Comment on this

The Minister is always able to quibble out of every statement he makes. I am talking about the meaning conveyed to the Dáil.

Comment on this

The Deputy argues that I am quibbling when he himself has made a distorted quotation. He tore that from its context. He puts the second sentence first and cut out the last of the first sentence.

Comment on this

I read the whole sentence to-day.

Comment on this

Yes, to-day, when he knew he was going to be challenged. In 1929 he distorted what I said. He took the second sentence and put it first and cut out the remainder of the first sentence. Nothing in the scheme was more argued about or made so clear as that all these costs we are considering were, on the construction side, subject to 10 per cent. variation. Whatever the Deputy may say about it from time to time he must go back to these statements made and refer me to any increase over and beyond what I indicated there.

The Deputy says that we are voting money now to a Board of a particular type. He takes away from it the three part-time members because he considers they are not really on the Board. He says that the two full-timers were there when these excesses mounted up and when the accounts got into confusion. They were not. The material whose absence has delayed the production of the accounts had disappeared before these people went on the Board. These two people went on the Board on a definite statement from me that I could state nothing precisely as to the affairs at that time of that Board, but that I feared there was a bad situation with regard to the accounts, that if they went on the Board, undoubtedly their reputation was going to be blurred by people of an unfeeling type who would say: They are on the Board and the thing is not right yet and therefore they are to be condemned." I spoke earlier of my efforts in connection with the scheme. That is the Parliamentary formula a Minister has to adopt when he takes responsibility. But if I am to apportion credit I must say that the greatest part of the effort I had to make with regard to the Shannon scheme in keeping it right depended on the work of Mr. Fay, who has gone on the Board. Of Mr. Browne, I confine myself at this moment to the statement that no better choice could have been made in the circumstances I feared the Board was in to grip and right those circumstances. People who are ready to weaken statements from me by labelling them ex parte simply conclude that because two men who went on this Board not knowing whether a certain situation was good, bad, or indifferent, did not right matters in the interval we cannot have confidence in them. That is to judge them in as harsh a way as men were ever judged. They have put in an enormous amount of work to get the situation clear. Since they went on the Board we began to get letters which announced clearly that the Board had at last begun to realise where they were going. In June or July, 1930, they were able to tell me that they had got the Board to agree to the calling in of an outside firm of auditors—the first reassuring thing the Board had done—to try and get the position clear.

Comment on this

In June they also told you that they broke the agreement.

Comment on this

They did not make the agreement, and that ought to be noted.

Comment on this

In March they agreed that the agreement was not one that in any circumstances could be observed without deferring the financial success of the scheme.

Comment on this

Who agreed?

Comment on this

The Board.

Comment on this

In March, 1931?

Comment on this

Yes, and in March, 1931, on their representations, I would have been ready to advance to this House, and on their representations I am advancing to this House, but I certainly could not advance as long as I had on the Board people who had behaved in the particular way I described the last day; who had made no attempt at budgeting, who had allowed the accounts to get into the arrears they were in, and who did not keep an undertaking they had entered into.

Comment on this

Were the accounts presented to this Dáil over the name of his auditors for the year 1928-29 not correct?

Comment on this

Yes, subject to what the auditors said. The Deputy can read the auditors' report.

Comment on this

They were right up to that?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy read the auditors' report as saying that they were good accounts?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I think not, even for that limited period.

Comment on this

Who presented them?

Comment on this

I had to present them. The Deputy feels because I have power to prescribe accounts in a certain form that they must appear exactly in that form. I cannot impose on these people the necessity of keeping these records in a particular way. I can prescribe accounts in a particular form, and did so, but I am not responsible for how they produce them, and the best I can do is to offer the Dáil the best thing that came into my hands with the auditors' report upon it.

Comment on this

And no comment from yourself.

Comment on this

I am not supposed to make any comment. On the 1929 accounts I have no comment other than what the auditors made.

Comment on this

Where is their comment?

Comment on this

In their report at the end of the accounts. There is going to be reorganisation of the Board, we are told. I have not said all that has been inferred about that, I hope. I have said that the part-timers have got a certain limited term of appointment, that they would have a larger term only I wanted to have discussion with them on what they considered should be their effective power on the Board; what we should associate with that power in the way of complementary responsibility for the Board's affairs. My view is that there should be a business element of that kind associated with the Board in a part-time capacity. Procedure may have to be established whereby they would act in particular ways on particular subjects, but they should be there. I have no reason to lose faith in these three people. I would have recommended the Council to reappoint them if they had recently resigned. Not only did I not lose faith in the two appointed as full-time members in 1930—and I have no reason to lose faith in them—but the faith which I had in them has been increased by their attitude on the Board since they went there in 1930. If there is going to be reorganisation it would only be very limited with regard to personnel. There may have to be readjustment with regard to the effective power and responsibilities of the part-timers.

I put it to the Dáil with a sense of responsibility only, and not from any sense of liking power, that I would like to have for a particular period, two Ministers associated with the expenditure of this money, and that period will certainly, in my mind, not be less than this time next year. While these two Ministers have control two millions should be at their disposal for the Board along the lines stated. I am making this statement to the Dáil, that while I have responsibility, I am going to make it a condition that they will show the probability or certainty of remunerating any new money to be spent. For the debts I take no responsibility. For any less sum than two millions I will have to consider my position and to ask the Minister for Finance to consider whether he or I will take any responsibility for the action of the Board in the next twelve months.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

I have an amendment on the paper and I would like to have an opportunity of explaining it. When I spoke on the Second Reading of the Bill I think I made it clear that I was much more concerned about what was likely to happen in the future than with what had happened in the past. I complained that in his opening statement the Minister had not told us what steps were being taken to set right the state of affairs that had existed up to that time. I also indicated my unwillingness to sign what amounts to a blank cheque for two millions. I am quite ready to admit that in his closing speech on the Second Reading the Minister removed a good many of my doubts, especially in appointing a firm of auditors to examine the affairs of the Board over a period of six or seven months, and when he stated that steps were being taken to bring order into the affairs of the Board. That went a considerable distance to ease my objection in that respect. I will admit again that in making the case for the two millions in the speech which he has just delivered, the Minister has gone a certain distance to remove my objections, but he has not gone the whole way. The sum I have set out in my amendment taken in connection with the sum the Minister has in hands, approximately half a million, would be, I believe, quite sufficient to meet any demands that are likely to be made even within the period which the Minister says would be a reasonable period— twelve months. He has pointed out that the sums required in all would approximate to a little over two millions. He pointed out that in several instances the sums he mentioned are not likely to be expended within twelve months. The Minister has also pointed out that by bringing the Minister for Finance into the matter with himself it undoubtedly will mean a slowing up of the operations of the Board. I think the Minister would be the last to suggest that as between now and this time twelve months the sum of two millions would be expended.

In view of the statements that have been made that the Dáil would have an early opportunity for reviewing the whole situation, if the Minister comes back in twelve months time and gives a satisfactory account of what has taken place by bringing order into the affairs of the Board, and explaining the manner in which the money voted by the House has been spent, I would have no hesitation in voting another sum to be expended for the purposes of the Board. I think we should take care that within a reasonable time the Minister would come back to the House. It is clear that we have no guarantee that we can have the kind of discussion that we thought in 1927 we would have on the working of the Board and of its accounts. If the Minister had to come back here in twelve months time it would ensure discussion such as we have had during the present week of the affairs of the Board. I think we are entitled to have such a discussion from the Minister. Even taking into account what the Minister has stated the sum mentioned in my amendment would place at his disposal one million in addition to the £500,000 already available. I think that would be quite adequate to carry him on for twelve months, at least, even taking into account what the Minister said.

With regard to the control and the independence of the Board as I mentioned when the Bill was going through the Dáil in 1927, we had our doubts as to the wisdom of giving that complete measure of independence which the Minister was then so anxious to stress. I think our doubts have now become certainties. While I do not take the view-point of Deputy Lemass in this matter, I believe there ought to be responsibility in this House in some form and in a greater form than was given in 1927. I look at the matter in this way: The Minister says that he had power to reappoint and power to dismiss. The power of dismissal invested him with the right to make certain inquiries as to whether or not the Board set up was effectively discharging the duties for which it was set up by the Government. When the Minister proceeded to do that he found operating against him the position he took up when the Act was going through. Time and again he stressed the complete and absolute independence of the Board, independence of the Minister, independence of the Government and independence of the Executive Council. The Board was not long set up when it was realised that it was necessary for somebody to have some control over a body which had got a very large sum of public money, and to look to some extent into its operations. The Minister then found himself up against his own statements. I am quite sure the Board was not slow to quote very frequently the statements he made in 1927, so far as the independence of the Board was concerned.

I can quite understand a body being set up and having a very large measure of independence but certainly not so much as was claimed for this Board. I would hesitate very much indeed before ever giving a vote which would mean that we would revert in a year or two years' time to the position which was occupied by the Board since it was set up originally. Experience has shown that it cannot be successfully operated in that way. It is not the same as appointing a judge. When you appoint a judge he is absolutely independent to administer and interpret laws, but a board of this kind is not at all of that nature. It is getting very large sums of the taxpayers' money, and there must be a connecting link between the taxpayer and the Board. It would be intolerable simply to set up a body of men, five, six, or eight men, hand them over two and a half millions and simply say that there is no control of any kind over their activities or over the line they strike out for themselves and that until they have done something that is obviously wrong they cannot be interfered with and then all you can do is to dismiss them. I think that is an impossible position to take up. The Executive Council is elected by the House and the Minister is elected by the House. No matter what we think of them we must admit that they are elected by the members of the House who are representatives of the people. We would be very slow indeed to give the Executive Council or any Minister the measure of independence that is claimed by this Board or that is suggested for this Board. I do not see what great virtue there is in a board made up of individuals selected, no matter how carefully selected, that we should give them absolute independence. I think that there should be as I say a connecting link and I think the Minister should be responsible to the House, not again let me emphasise for small matters of detail or whether a particular person should be appointed to a particular post but for major questions of policy.

The Minister himself seems to visualise getting back to the present position, and it seems a rather strange position, that sometime he would claim, as he does claim and, I think, rightly claim, to intervene, to some extent at any rate, in the affairs of the Board and then shed himself of responsibility altogether to this House. That he would claim a certain amount of responsibility to interfere to a limited extent in the affairs of the Board, and that, on the other hand, he would say to the Dáil, "You have no right to question me as far as my interference is concerned." I think that is the position that cannot be maintained. As I say, I not only approve of the provision in this measure which gives the Minister certain rights to say whether or not the money should be available— to be satisfied at least that the expenditure is necessary in the national interests and that the money should be available—but also of the suggestion that it should be a permanent feature of legislation in that regard. That need not mean that questions would have to be answered continually upon small matters of administration.

Comment on this

How do you draw the line?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I think that is very well provided for. We have not been able to draw the line even now. We have not been able to draw the line in regard to our independent Board. The Minister has had to come in in spite of all his own protestations and his action has been approved by the House. Coming back to the amount of money again, I believe that by fixing on this sum of one million pounds, it will be the most effective way of affording us in this House an opportunity of having a full statement from the Minister as to what has been done in regard to the particular position that exists at the present time, and an opportunity of explaining the plans and the programme which he has in view for the future. For that reason I think the sum which I have set out is a reasonable sum to give the Minister on this occasion.

Comment on this

I am sorry to speak in the absence of the Minister, but I suppose that cannot be helped. The Minister started by telling us in what sum you could estimate the cost to the community of his interference with the Board. He went on to tell you his estimate of his value to the country. The two statements rest upon exactly the same authority as the indictment which he has made of absent men who are in the position—unless this Dáil does the honest and straight thing, to provide them with a fair trial by competent men—of not being able to answer that charge. The idea that this Dáil under the Party Whips and under the threat that the action of the Dáil will be regarded as a vote of censure on two Ministers, that it will involve the resignation of their normal functions by two Minister—the suggestion that it is a trial to which these people who are indicted in their absence can safely appeal for justice, is a ludicrous and dishonest proposal. I certainly had thought that the more intimate relations which had existed between the Front Bench and those concerned in this indictment would at least have left them with a claim to justice in their trial. What we are asked to do to-day is to accept the Minister's estimate of himself and his own value—yes, the Minister's estimate of his own infallibility, and we are asked to accept that under the test of the Party Whip.

The Minister went on to make certain allusions to myself. He said that on certain occasions—I only want to get these little things out of the way before we come to the larger matters with which we will have to deal—I had made certain statements at cross-roads which I had been asked here to justify. I have no recollection of any such occasion, except an occasion when absent and when I read in the paper that the Minister had said that I had with my usual discretion absented myself from a discussion on the Drumm Battery, on which I had made a vicious and vindictive attack in the country.

I answered that in another place and the Minister is perfectly well aware of it. At no time and under no circumstances, neither here nor elsewhere, had I ever made any attack, vindictive or otherwise, upon the Drumm Battery. That was purely a gratuituous falsehood. Why the Minister should drag that in here to-night I do not know, nor do I know of any other case in which that can be applied.

I have to clear up one other point. The other night I described Mr. J.C. Foley as being ex-chairman of the Incorporated Chamber of Commerce and Shipping of Cork. That was a mistake. Mr. Foley is ex-chairman of the Cork Chamber of Commerce and both Chambers concerned are entitled to that explanation.

The Minister said that he asked for information from this Board, this Board to which he will not give a trial before competent and impartial people, and he had been refused that information or he had failed to get any intelligible information. Mr. Browne was appointed to that Board in February, 1930. I am not saying one word against Mr. Browne. It was to Mr. Browne those inquiries went, and I ask the House whether they believe that over the whole intervening period Mr. Browne did not attempt, and did not, in fact, give very considerable and very useful information. It may not have been, and presumably was not, information right down to the last trouser button. They did not account in the way in which an auditor would probably account for absolute details but I have not personally the shadowiest doubt that Mr. Browne did give information which the Businessmen and the Independents on the Minister's own benches would, if it were given to them, say was useful information and was a useful basis of calculation. If that is not so then we ask that the whole of the correspondence which passed between the Minister and the Chairman of the Board, and the material which the Chairman of the Board sent to the Minister and which the Minister said is inadequate, shall be laid before us or before some other tribunal, some tribunal more impartial, so that such a tribunal will be in a position to decide as to whether the general impression gathered from the speeches of the Minister is correct and whether the indictment he has made can be founded upon those facts and the facts in these documents. Again we ask for a discovery of documents upon which this charge has been made. Again we say it is not fair nor right that one man who has possession of documents and who has this Dáil as his pulpit and the Press as his sounding board should be allowed to get out an ex parte statement on one side while the other people are not in the position to divulge any single document. Is Mr. Browne in the position to divulge a document at the present moment? Assuming that every statement made in the Dáil is false, is Mr. Browne in the position to produce documentary evidence assuming that documentary evidence exists? Is any one of them in a position to produce that evidence? Surely the Minister knows they are not. There is utter unrestraint in the misuse, in the misquotation, in the selective misquotation of documents because they know they are secured by the fact that the other people are in a fiduciary position in so far as they are in possession of documents and cannot produce them.

I do not agree that the Minister, merely because he appoints the personnel of a board, so long as he does it in good faith after proper examination of their qualifications, can be held responsible, except in so far as it can be shown that he is responsible for what they do within the function that is delegated to them by the Dáil. But what is the history in cases of this kind? You have one member of that Board, a man who was in a very responsible position in this State, a man very well thought of by the President, a man very well thought of by all responsible people in the City of Dublin, you have such a man as Chairman of that Board. Now he ceased to be Chairman of the Board by enforced resignation, by a resignation which, according to the statement of the Minister, if it had not been tendered would have been substituted by dismissal. He was the man who was told by the Minister that he had no grasp whatever of finance, and that he must be substituted by someone who had a competent knowledge and responsible function in relation to figures and finance. He was the man that the Minister told us here was, in his opinion, responsible for the sort of mess that was brought about, and yet he was being retained in that position in order that he might be held as possible evidence in relation to his mess. That man was reappointed to the Board as a part-time member. He was reappointed to the Board not merely at the salary of an ordinary part-time member, but he was reappointed with a bonus of £1,250 a year. That was the man whose resignation was being forced, whose resignation if it had not been given would have been substituted by dismissal, the man who had been declared by the Minister to be responsible for the mess. He has been declared in this House to be incompetent. Why was he given a bonus of £1,250 on reappointment, when the purpose of his reappointment was to hold him there responsible for the mess which he had created? He was reappointed for five years. Why was he reappointed for five years if that is correctly his record according to the Minister for Industry and Commerce?

Does the House believe that that was his record and that the Minister did so appoint him, believing that to be his record? Is anyone going to say that for any further default or defect by that man on that Board, for any further default or defect of that man due to the presence of that man and his voting power, that the Minister is not directly responsible for all the calculable consequences of his act in reappointing under these circumstances the man whom he has so described to himself and to us? The Minister is not responsible for any man whom he appoints in good faith, who performs his functions within the Act unless and in so far as it can be proved in this case that the Minister was responsible for knowingly, as I say, reappointing him as temporary officer for five years with a bonus equal to four years' salary, a man whom he had declared to be incompetent and to be unfit. The Minister is responsible for Mr. Murphy if Mr. Murphy was what the Minister said he was.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Would the Deputy connect this with the amendment?

Comment on this

I am dealing now, step by step, with the speech of the Minister. If I cannot do that I can do nothing. I have simply taken notes one after another of what he said and you will be amazed at what he did say on this motion.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must be relevant to the amendment.

Comment on this

Well, he was not, if I am not.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must connect this with the amendment in some way.

Comment on this

The Minister went on to tell us of the merits of particular men on the Board, how some of them were satisfactory and how some of them were not, why he was going to reappoint some, and under what conditions he was prepared to reappoint others. The Minister specifically dealt with what he euphemistically called part-timers. I hope the Chambers of Commerce who have appointed these men like that method of describing their representatives. What about the part-timers? What about the ex-President of the Associated Chambers of Commerce of the Irish Free State, Mr. J.C. Foley? What about the ex-member of the Dáil and I think the ex-Parliamentary Secretary of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, Mr. Patrick Egan, of Tullamore? What about Dr. Kennedy, Secretary to the I.A.O.S., appointed to look after the industry in which the Government puts most money, the creamery industry? What is the Minister's responsibility for them and for their acts and what is their responsibility as declared by themselves for anything in the nature of a mess which may in fact exist? These gentlemen were appointed for two years. They did act independently. I will go into the history of that to the same degree to which the Minister went into it. They were appointed for two years. At the end of that time they became ticket-of-leave men, reappointed from month to month and kept on in that state from month to month by month to month appointments, in which they were told, as they are now told, that it really was not necessary for them to attend until there was an agitation by the same Chambers of Commerce whose reputation is involved in their success. The Chambers of Commerce of Cork and Dublin and the Associated Chambers of the Free State demanded that they should be put permanently on the Board. They were put permanently upon the Board. They were appointed again I think for a period of a year, and at the end of that time they again became wandering luminaries and it was only when those same Chambers of Commerce again interfered to demand that there should be that representation of outside interests that these men were reappointed. What do those three men whom the Minister says should be reappointed say to this?

Comment on this

Where did you get all that stuff?

Comment on this

I know. Will the Deputy allow a Deputy upon this side of the House to make his own speech? Mind, I do not care a whole lot about any interruptions, but I would advise the Deputy not to interrupt. I can look after myself without the protection of the Chair. What is the record? What do those men whom the Minister says he would reappoint if he had the opportunity say to the mess which the Minister says exists? What do they say of this bad policy which the Minister says has caused £5,100,000 to be necessary for something which he previously estimated at £2,500,000? What they have said quite clearly and openly is this: That every question of major policy which was dealt with by that Board was submitted to us for examination. Every single act of policy of that Board was approved by us. We are, severally and collectively, responsible for everything that was done. There are men in this House—Deputy Connolly wants to know how I know. I know because they have told me— there are men upon the Front Bench of Cumann na nGaedheal who know that, because they told them.

Comment on this

That will not do.

Comment on this

Three men who declared themselves to be severally and collectively responsible, who say they will publicly take responsibility for the support they put behind the policy which they advocated in that Board, are reappointed in spite of the fact that the Minister says there has been a horrible mess made.

Again I say the Minister is not responsible if after consideration and proper examination he appoints men to do their function within the Act, but he is responsible if, knowing and believing they were not performing their functions within the Act, that they were unfit and unqualified, he reappoints them and leaves them there to do the job. It is all very well for the Minister in his usual way to say did you do this? Are you in favour of that? How did you get out of that? There is the oldest of all question of that kind. I will put it to Deputy Connolly: "Have you given up beating your wife?" Have you? Yes or no? Call the issue and at once. That is the method of the Minister. Give an answer at once. Yes or no? Have you or have you not? It is not any answer to say, I did not dare do it. It is not any answer to say I never did it. It is not any answer to say that only in circumstances of extraordinary provocation would I do it. Questions which the Minister throws over here in hundreds are expected to be met at once.

I move to report progress.

Comment on this