Constitution (Amendment No. 17) Bill, 1931—Allocation of Time Motion.
Contributions 107–218 of 218. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 40 of 1931 ›
There is, and a very prominent gentleman was recently arrested for drilling there, Mr. McGuinness, connected with "Saor Eire."
Comment on this
I can assure the Deputy that Mr. McGuinness extended his operations all over the Deputy's constituency.
Comment on this
Since he was arrested drilling has gone off the constituency considerably. There is a certain amount still. Let us now consider what is happening. Drilling goes on in the country. A certain number of boys are collected, are brought out and drilled, and are told all that sort of wretched nonsense that we hear in this House. They are told that this State is not free. They are told we are still under Imperial rule. They are told that we cannot do as we like in this country. They are told all that nonsense, and they are told that they are going to drill and fight for Irish independence just as if this State now were not completely masters of their destiny. When they have been told that and have been got in for a few days' drilling in the I.R.A., down comes one of the Saor Eire plus I.R.A. for the personnel on top has a great deal in common, and these young men who have been drilling in the I.R.A. are induced to join this Saor Eire organisation. That is regularly happening over the State, and these men are brought in to begin with on the plea that they are doing patriotic work, and before they know where they are they are landed by their leaders into this Saor Eire organisation.
Let us consider what this Saor Eire is. It is: "To organise Committees of Action among the Industrial and Agricultural Workers, to lead the day-to-day struggle of the Working-Class and Working Farmers against exploitation, and to secure a revolutionary leadership for their common struggle." This means: "The mobilisation of the Irish people behind a Revolutionary Government, for the overthrow of British Imperialism and its allies in Ireland, and for the organisation of a Workers' State." There is no question about coming into the Dáil there. There is no question of Parliament there. There is no question that they are endeavouring to convert this Assembly into carrying out their views. It is clear that they are a revolutionary party and their aim is revolution. If they were a constitutional party and if they did not look to physical force and that physical force the I.R.A. they would put up their representatives to stand for this House. They do not do that and they will not do that. They have no intention of doing it. They are purely revolutionary in their means. What is the good of saying that they will cease to be revolutionary if you take away the Oath? There is not a word about taking away the Oath here. They do not want to substitute the President of a Republic for the Governor-General. They want quite a different class of republic. Listen to what they want. "To vest all political power within the Republic in the Working-Class and Working Farmers." What is that but a pure Soviet business? Deputy de Valera is not to be entitled to have a vote. Deputy Ruttledge, because he is a professional man and other members of the Party opposite, are to be completely disfranchised. All political power is to be vested in the working class and working farmers. They are to abolish, without compensation, landlordism in land, fisheries, and minerals. Of course, landlordism in land has ceased to be except so far as the tenant proprietors are the landlords of their holdings or except so far as there may be landlordism in the possession of houses in towns. Those are to be confiscated. Fisheries and minerals likewise. The next object is "To make the National wealth and credit available for the creation and fullest development of essential industries and mineral resources, through Industrial Workers' Co-operatives under State direction and management, the workers to regulate internal working conditions." In other words, the industrial workers, the co-operatives under State direction, are to take over all national wealth and all the national credit "to establish a State monopoly in Banking and Credits.""To create a State monopoly in Export and Import services, and to promote co-operative distribution."
I am asked what has Russia got to do with this Saor Eire. Surely Deputy Davin, reading this document, as possibly he has read it, or hearing it read, must see that it has emanated from Russian sources and it will not surprise, I suppose, Deputy Davin very much if I inform him that in 1930 Mr. David Fitzgerald, who is secretary of Saor Eire, spent a very considerable time in Russia. I am asked about the connection between the I.R.A. and Saor Eire. I will tell you. Let me take some of the principal men of Saor Eire lately elected. Mr. Sean McBride is Adjutant-General also of the I.R.A. Mr. Michael Price is another important gentleman in Saor Eire Mr. Michael Price is Director of Intelligence of the I.R.A. Peadar O'Donnell, also a member of Saor Eire, is a member of the Army Council of the I.R.A., and this Sean McGuinness that Deputy Davin is so interested in is a member of the Directorate of Saor Eire and is Officer Commanding the Battalion Staff of the Offaly Brigade. So here you have perfectly plain the connection between these two bodies. You have Saor Eire coming along and collecting all the discontented persons, the persons who do not want to pay land annuities and who do not want to pay their taxes, the gentlemen who will not pay their debts. They collect all these on the one hand and get them together, and on the other hand they are deluding a great number of decent, respectable country boys into joining first the I.R.A. and afterwards Saor Eire. They are working the same way, both joining up together. It is said that it has nothing to do with Russia and that proofs are wanted of it. Deputies opposite want no proof. They know that the I.R.A. was very closely associated with Russia. There is an interesting gentleman who was tried here recently in Dublin called Mr. Sean Russell. Mr. Sean Russell is at the present moment Quartermaster-General of the I.R.A. Mr. Sean Russell visited Russia in the year 1925 and he was accompanied by two gentlemen, one of whom is now a Deputy of this House. On September 30th, 1925, he, then being Quartermaster-General of the I.R.A., sent a very interesting communication to Deputy Lemass, who at the time was Minister for Defence. Of course, it was in code, but I have had it decoded. It runs as follows:—
"With a view to fixing up communications between M. and London, via Berlin, I was instructed on my return from M. on last July to call on Mr. X in Berlin and arrange the line between Berlin and London. I found Mr. X, and having no London address I gave him a Dublin covering address, to which letters could be addressed to me.
As Mr. X considered it unadvisable to go to Dublin he wrote last month asking me to meet him in London. On receipt of this letter I reported to the M.D., who instructed me to meet Mr. X and introduce him to O/C B (Britain) as the link between Dublin and Berlin. This I did.
I had an hour's conversation with Mr. X and O/C Britain when future meeting places, postal and hand communications were fixed up for both ends.
Mr. X required the following:—
1. Information re navy and aircraft.
2. Drawings from Patent Office of new optical instrument for directing aeroplanes.
3. Drawings of new aeroplane engines. Type specified.
4. Sample of new gas mask.
Mr. X agreed to defray all expenses in connection with above.
It was Mr. X's intention to remain in London for three or four weeks after the date on which I met him, so it is likely that his list of requirements increased in the meantime.
I am in receipt of a communication from O/C Britain dated 25th September, in which he states that Mr. X is still in London and that he has been successful in supplying all his requirements. He promises to send us a detailed report later.
For your own information we have instructed O/C Britain to file all information required by this man and secure samples of articles required by him."
And now comes the most significant thing of all:—
"It is quite possible that Mr. X is using O/C Britain as one of his agents (just an individual), and although he is willing to pay us for our services, it may not come under the notice of the people in Moscow that we as an organisation are rendering any assistance. I have no doubt that we are in a position to supply information which, to them, is of the utmost importance, and that if we continue to assist these people it should be made clear that our assistance is coming to them officially.
I hope to talk this matter over with you soon.—Q.M.G."
The Q.M.G. was Sean Russell. There is a statement that he was sent to Russia——
Comment on this
Deputy Davin asks for proof that any Russian money comes into this country or that anybody was receiving Russian money. That is a proof that he was receiving Russian money.
I suggest that in the year 1925, and I say as far back as this, money was being received. Deputy Lemass sent on this communication at the time to Deputy Aiken and the communication was accompanied by that letter. "The attached report from the Q.M.G. which I am inclined to agree with... We must be in terms of absolute equality or there can be no liaison as far as we are concerned...I will put this matter on the agenda for the next Army Council meeting." I do not suggest for one moment that Deputy Lemass is now connected with Russia or influenced in any way about these things.
Comment on this
There is one thing I want to say and that is that to my knowledge no rouble of Russian money ever came into this country.
Comment on this
To the Deputy's knowledge. But still when the Deputy gets that letter that he is "willing to pay us for our services," it is plain——
Comment on this
——it is plain that that agent is being paid for his services. There has been steady communication the whole time between these persons and Russia. In the year 1927 ten prominent Communists from this country went over to Russia. In 1928 a gentleman called Burke was found with revolvers concealed. On 17th March, 1928, Mr. Burke was arrested in London and found to be in possession of twenty revolvers and a sum of money which included two £10 Bank of England notes. As a result of inquiries made it was found that these notes emanated from the Russian Trading Bank in London; and here is this gentleman found with his nice little portmanteau filled with revolvers. In 1929 six gentlemen chosen by Mr. Peadar O'Donnell went to the Lenin College in Moscow to go through a course of the technique of revolution in that school and they remained there, and they took out there that course which is extremely interesting I am sure—that course in which lectures are given in the Lenin College in Moscow.
Comment on this
Therefore to say that an endeavour is not being made at this moment to impregnate this country with Russian ideas is absolutely absurd; and I myself do not see how it is possible for this country to endure as it endures now, I do not see how it is possible for this country to remain the Ireland that it is now or the Ireland that it was in the past, I do not see how it is possible for Ireland to remain in the future a really Catholic country if it is going to be permeated by force of arms with doctrines of that nature. "What is the necessity? What is the hurry?" say the Deputies. They heard the President reading out a category of crimes, every one of which took place in the year 1931. Deputy de Valera says that as far as the Clare crime was concerned one of the crimes was not political. I agree with Deputy de Valera that it was agrarian and not political. But that crime was not mentioned by the President at all. It is solely the crimes that were political that were mentioned by the President, and these are crimes that have taken place within the last few months.
Comment on this
What prompted me to make the statement was the reference to a special case which I had been written to about, and it was not of a political character.
Comment on this
There have been several shootings in Clare lately, unfortunately. Two of the shootings mentioned by the President were of a political nature. The other shooting was not of a political nature.
Comment on this
What is taking place? Human life is being endangered. Human life is being frequently taken in this State. Are we to sit down and acquiesce tamely in that? Are we to allow it to go on or to take the necessary powers which will prevent a return of crime? That is the choice before the House. We have been told to try the ordinary methods. The ordinary methods are not capable of coping with this abnormal situation. We have tried the ordinary methods. We have tried the ordinary law. We have tried it as long as we could, and Deputies must know that. In the year when the civil war ended the Government made a tremendous gesture towards peace. They gave a free pardon to everybody who had committeed any crime which was committed during the civil war in pursuance of the civil war. The jails were flung open. There were plenty of cases in which prosecutions were being brought and in which a nolle prosequi was entered.
The Government endeavoured to make a fresh and clean start. They said: "Let us have no violence and no more crime." But crime did not cease, it went on. Then we brought in the Public Safety Act. As a matter of fact, if anybody finds fault with us over the Public Safety Act, a fault might possibly be found with us for keeping it in force for too short a time, and for using it with too great leniency. We used it only once and kept it in force for only eighteen months. During the time it was in force, peace was preserved in this country. As soon as it was revoked disturbance broke out again. As soon as it was revoked you had jurymen shot at and witnesses murdered. We tried the Jury Act. We tried to hold on as long as we could with that. It worked for a time and guilty men were found guilty, but finally the time has come when we say that jurymen now are not willing to find verdicts—to find guilty men guilty or to take the risk which doing their duty entails on them.
We say now that the time has come when it is unfair for us to ask jurymen to take that risk. We think that clearly the court procedure has broken down. We are met with two things— we must bring in a new procedure or bow our heads to crime. The issue that is before the House now is: are we to bow our heads to crime or to adopt a new procedure in the courts? Deputy de Valera says that the Dáil is the only institution in the State which has a right to make laws. Is this institution going to bow its head to criminal associations and let them carry on with immunity? That is now the question the House has to decide. Everybody who votes against this measure is, whether he likes it or not, voting for the continuance of a state of crime in this country.
We are told we are tearing up the Constitution. I pointed out that we are not. We have found and other countries find that in abnormal situations when the State is threatened by force the ordinary law is not enough. We are not the only country in Europe at present that has got to take repressive measures. Far from it. Because the Deputies opposite are absolutely steeped in British tradition they think that a departure from the Constitution or the refusal of free speech at all times is a denial of liberty. In England when the liberties of the majority of people were threatened by a minority the people did not allow their Constitution or the principles of the Constitution to ride roughshod over their common sense.
Are Deputies aware that since the Habeas Corpus Act was passed in England it was suspended not less than eleven times; and we, in this present situation, are asked to carry on with the English law which we inherited, but which the English people themselves found incompetent to deal with serious emergency problems. That is what the House is asked to do. We are taking the best line. It is our first duty to this House, it is our first duty to the public, and it is the first duty of the Executive, whatever Executive is in power, to see that the liberties of the majority of the people of the country are preserved, and that every law-abiding man may be able to earn his daily bread without interference by criminals.
Comment on this
My excuse for intervening in this Debate is that for the first time since I entered this House nearly ten years ago I cannot agree with, and I do not agree with, the views put forward by the leader of the Labour Party or the Labour Party itself. I regret that very much, because I have always been a member of the Labour Party and will be a member of it so long as I possibly can. But we are faced with a position in this country to-day which, in my opinion, and from my knowledge of the conditions in my own county, is much more serious than any position or any situation which existed in this country since this State was started. This is the first time that I ever voted for what might be called a Public Safety Bill. I have, in common with the other members of this party, since 1923 onwards voted against every Bill which has been introduced into this House which could be called a Coercion Bill. I voted against it because I did not believe it would have the effect, in the circumstances then existing, which it was thought it would by those who introduced it. But we must remember that when a Public Safety Bill was introduced here in July, 1923, we had a different situation. We were dealing then with our own people. We were dealing with something which, even if we could not agree with it, we could understand. We were dealing with men, most, if not all, of whom had certain definite national ideals and national outlook. To-day we meet here to deal with a very different problem. We have to deal with forces in this country which are both anti-national and anti-Christian.
Comment on this
That is the explanation, if any explanation is required, for the vote I am to give on this Bill. I first read the Bill to-day. I have heard here a lot of talk about the liberty of the subject and about the sacredness of the Constitution, and about the rights of the people of this country. I think I have and ought to have as much respect for the Constitution as any man either inside or outside this House. But I would ask those who talk about the sheet-anchor of safety which lies in the constitution for the people of this country, of what use was the Constitution to Superintendent Curtin when murdered in Tipperary outside his own door or what use was the Constitution to the boy Ryan, the labouring man brought outside his own door, shot on the side of the road in Tipperary and flung there like a dog? I know conditions in my own county. I can understand Irishmen fighting for Irish national ideals. I can respect men who fight for an Irish Republic, but I cannot understand Irishmen or an Irish Parliament truckling to people who are neither Irish nor Christian. I do not want to say very much in this Debate. We have heard a lot of talk about the danger of giving a free hand to the Government. If I am faced with the choice of giving a free hand to the Government elected by the majority of the people of this State or a free hand to those who murdered Superintendent Curtin or the boy Ryan, then I will give it to the Government, and I submit that, stripped of all trimmings and of all pleadings, that is the position to-day. I want to advert to one other thing which, in my opinion, is even more serious than perhaps the murder of these two men whom I have mentioned. That is the attempt to intimidate the members of the Oireachtas.
I want to proclaim that I am supporting this measure for the reasons I have given and for one reason above all others, because I am a democrat and because an attempt to intimidate the members of the Oireachtas strikes at the root of democracy. I want to submit that this is not a matter for the Government. It is a matter for every member of the Oireachtas because the attack which has been made is not an attack upon the Government, but an attack upon the State. If we in the Labour Party were the Government of this country to-morrow and if a similar state of affairs existed as exists to-day, we would have to take somewhat similar measures to deal with it and if we did not we would not be fit to govern. The same thing applies to the Fianna Fáil Party.
It has been stated that Communism does not count in this country—that it is not active. I know that it is active in my county. I know that within the last couple of weeks branches have been started in Tipperary. I know that within the last fortnight we had an Indian gentleman, whom I had the pleasure of meeting here ten or twelve years ago, an ex-member of the British Parliament, Mr. Saklatvala, speaking down in Roscrea in my constituency with Mr. Peadar O'Donnell. I have no doubt whatever in my mind and I am sure none of you have that it was because of love of Ireland or because he wanted Ireland prosperous and free that he came across here.
Comment on this
The Deputy did not stand very fast by Ireland in 1917 when he tried to get over by the first train, but missed it. I am entitled as a member of this House to give expression to my opinions, and I am giving expression to them fearlessly.
Comment on this
They know him so well that they have returned him for the last ten years and will do it again. If there is a characteristic of Tipperary men, it is this, that they admire the man who stands to his guns and who will accept his responsibility and stand up to it. If it is any information for the Deputy personally, I may say that sooner than shirk my responsibility like he is doing I would resign from the Dáil to-morrow morning.
Comment on this
We have heard two very interesting speeches—one from the Minister for Justice and the last one from the Leas-Cheann Comhairle.
Comment on this
Well, Deputy Morrissey. For the moment we were inclined to confuse it, especially in view of the speech we have listened to. A good deal of complaint has been made on this side of the House about this matter being rushed through. I do not think there should be that amount of complaint on this side of the House or from anybody who knows the Government. Members on this side of the House, at any rate, should know the tactics which have been always adopted by the Government Party. This is an alteration of the Constitution. When a certain pact was made as to the introduction of the Constitution and that it would be before the electorate of the country to pronounce upon it, it was handed out to that electorate on the morning of the election. The Government in bringing in this Bill now and in closuring the time on it are living up to their tradition and the tricks and methods and tactics they have adopted in the past. I would be surprised if they could now get away from these dirty underhand tactics by which they have been always trying to trick and fool the people. They very often succeeded by trying little sharp practices and mean, dirty underhand methods such as they practised when they put the Constitution before the country on the morning of the election. That is what they are doing now. In the last month or so we have been promised by the advance agent the Minister for Justice, something in the way of a coercion measure. He has made vague long harangues down the country at meetings where he could not get a suitable chairman to preside—where he could not get any chairman to preside—and stated that this measure was necessary and that it would be introduced. He got the paid organiser, Mr. Hands, to preside at these meetings, but no self-respecting citizen in the locality would preside at them when they were convened for a purpose like that.
Very little reference was made in these speeches to the economic condition of the country. It was the economic condition of the country that the people in the area where the Minister made the speeches were anxious to hear the solution of, but the Minister offered them none. He only tried to frighten and terrorise them into the belief that a terrible state of chaos existed in the country, that a revolution was brewing, and that they would all be burned out in a few days, so that he would try and blind them to the true position. He was sent out as an advance agent to create the atmosphere to try and frighten the people first. These are the tactics. Now the Government think that the atmosphere is sufficiently well created. They think that the stage has been pretty well set. The Bill could not come into the hands of Deputies a week or a fortnight ago. Although the Minister for Justice had been able to discuss something about it down the country, and other Ministers had been able to refer to it. Deputies could not be trusted to get it into their hands. It was just mooted that secret meetings were being held by the Executive Council. A strained feeling was sought to be created throughout the country. The next thing we had was Guards being sent through the country to protect Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies and the feeling was created through the country that it was very necessary to have them — that shootings would take place. Then we saw these Guards coming up in the trains with these Deputies to attend a very important meeting, and we have had the reports in the papers vaguely hinting at what transpired at these meetings, and the very serious mood in which Deputies were, thinking nobody would see through the game. When you have a Press behind you in a game like that, you can really succeed in going a considerable distance. Then this morning when we were coming down to the House we had a number of Guards ornamenting the Shelbourne Hotel corner and also around the entrance gate. You had them all over the place to try and frighten the people into thinking that really there was a serious situation to be dealt with. Now we have had it from the Minister for Defence, and I think it was uttered with a certain amount of regret, that he does not think this Bill is going to help them in an election. Candidly I do not think it will, because although the game was pretty well played, it was too thinly-veiled for anybody not to be able to see through it.
The Government recognise that they have been a hopeless failure in dealing with the economic position, and they look to the one thing in which they have been a success—that is, waging war upon their fellow-countrymen. In that they succeeded in the past, and they are taking advantage of this opportunity in the hope that, by waging another war and forcing the position, they may be able to get back to office again. This is not a Public Safety Act; it is a Public Provocation Act. The Party opposite are trying to work up a position that will provoke people in this country and bring about a condition of affairs that will empower them to carry on a relentless warfare so that the economic position will be forgotten and the position of the people smothered under. If there was any real demand for such a measure as this, is it not wonderful that we would not get something more than the flimsy evidence we got from the President. The President quoted some interviews given by some gentlemen to the Press. A good many of them were given, as Deputy Lemass pointed out, six months ago. If they had, as they seemed to have in the view of the President, the effect of creating or bringing about a revolution, why did not the President at the time of these interviews and their publication take a serious view of them then, and ask for more powers from this House? He did not, of course. The Bill before the House is a game. If the President took any of these things seriously six months ago he would have dealt with them at the time, but he did not consider them serious. In the same way, during the few months that the Dail was adjourned, if the Government really believed that a situation was developing in the country that was a danger, would they not have summoned the Dail and asked it to pass a measure that would enable them to deal with them. But that would not have looked so well. You must create the atmosphere at any cost and make it look as serious as you can, and that might well gull and deceive certain people.
In other countries, arising out of the economic condition, and otherwise, you have a good deal of turmoil and trouble. These countries are able to deal with the situation under their ordinary law. Here in this country when one of these measures was brought in before, we were told that such measures were necessary for the purpose of dealing with the situation that existed, and that if they got these powers they would in fact be in a position to deal effectively with the situation. We had the Juries Bill with its extended powers which, it was stated, was very necessary. We find now that juries are going to be abolished. Of course juries may sometimes find verdicts in accordance with facts with which the Executive Council would not agree. If a jury would not agree with the exact point of view of the Executive Council, then perhaps the Executive Council would think it would be best to do away with juries. That is one of the reasons they are inclined to do away with them. They want to substitute a sort of star chamber and to appoint officers as judges. So far as I have glanced at this Bill I gather that you are giving by it absolute powers of life and death to five members of the Defence Forces. There is to be no appeal or anything else. True it is that under Section 12 I think the Executive Council can remit sentences. But the unfortunate people brought before the star chamber, from which the Press and public can be excluded, might be executed before it comes to the knowledge of the Executive Council. There is nothing to prevent that. In a state of actual war I challenge any member on the benches opposite to point to anything so draconian or anything going so far as we find under this Bill goes. We know that bad as temporary judges have been in this country, and must be in any country, much worse will be members of the Defence Forces paid by the Government. These members of the Defence Forces will regard themselves as servants of the Executive Council.
I referred to temporary judges, and I referred to them before. I said before that it is a bad precedent to create these temporary judges because temporary judges get the idea that they must serve the Executive Council in a certain way or they will not ensure permanent positions afterwards. The same position, but worse, will arise here in appointing a Tribunal with absolute powers of life and deat. There will be no public present to see what is happening—and no Press present to record what is happening, and what will result from all this, and what is intended to result from it—it may not result, and I hope it will no —but what is intended to result is that it will cause a revulsion in the country, and give a feeling against this measure and this Tribunal, and where certain people become victims of this Tribunal, they will consider they have no alternative but a certain course of action.
You had in the civil war people compelled to do things because they had no alternative to them. You did nothing worse then, after all, than you are trying to do in this. You got men then just as you will get a Tribunal now or the same as you will get members of the C.I.D. or of the Army or wherever they come from, I do not know or care, who will go out and do certain acts. For example you will get men to do things such as the taking out three Fianna Eireann boys of fifteen or sixteen years of age and shooting them on the roadside, or the taking out of men like Bondfield and Lemass and McEntee and Hogan and shooting them and leaving them in lanes. Or perhaps you will get four men shot without trial as happened on the 8th December, 1922, in jail. There was no semblance of trial there. You have done as bad in the past and we are not surpried that a similar or worse measure is tried to be passed through this House now.
You might at least make some attempt when you are bringing in a measure of this sort to give some concrete example, rather than vague indefinite vapourings about the condition of the country. One would imagine that the Minister for Justice at any rate would try to keep to some definite statements and some definite facts and that he would have something to put before the House in the way of definite evidence. Instead of that we have generalisations and vague statements. In the one area that he was asked about by Deputy O'Connell, his own area, the Minister said he was satisfied there was no drilling there. He did so simply because the people there, if he stated in the Dáil that he believed they were drilling, would ask him to point out where it took place in the area and they would say "We will judge your statements with regard to other areas by your truth with regard to this area." The Minister for Justice slips out by saying that there is practically no drilling in his area. The area of South Mayo was at all times very prominent in the National movement, and if there are any people, guided or misguided, whatever way he wants to put it, working in any kind of way like that, I am sure there would be such people in South Mayo as in other places. I have not heard of any drilling in my area. I have not seen any. I have been in other areas. I have asked about it but I have got no definite information as to any drilling. If there was any drilling going on, with the forces of C.I.D., military and Guards that are throughout the country, does any sensible or sane member of the House not know that its existence, as well as the names of those concerned, and all the data would be put before the House, considering that the whole thing has been planned and worked up by the Executive in order to try to justify this measure? Except for vague interviews taken from "An Phoblacht" and a few statements like that, there is nothing before the House to justify it in passing a measure of such an extreme type.
Does the Executive really think that the people of the country are fools? There is the possibility that they may. There is the possibility also that they think that coercion like this is going to get them a lease of office that they would not otherwise get As speakers on this side of the House have pointed out, coercion has failed in the past. Sometimes where a Government that considered itself the constituted authority and felt it was entitled to exercise coercion, it failed. Coercion in this matter, where there is no demand for it, and no real evidence or justification for it, must fail in the same way. It must recoil on this Executive, on the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and on the Government, that when introducing this Bill, except for the few documents referred to by the President in a general and vague way as to what he thought was going on, he put nothing concrete before the House. To use the words of the Minister for Justice, except in the case of a man named McGuinness who was arrested when found drilling, there was no definite instance that the Minister for Justice with all the forces behind him could give. I might point out what was happening in the Guards, and I might read a letter I have before me referring to what happened at a church in Co. Limerick, Ballyhahill, where the Guards went on to the roof of the sacristy and took the slates off it. Only that they were seen I suppose there would be nothing about that. I might refer to other scenes like that in a vague way. I ask the House if they want to pass a coercion measure or to pass a measure that they think is for the safety of the State, first of all to be convinced beyond all possible doubt and beyond all reasonable suspicion that a case has been made out for the measure. It is not on the prepared statement of the President the House should decide—a statement that was carefully prepared with publicity and propaganda objectives—and which did not give sufficient evidence on which any assembly might feel itself justified in passing such a measure, especially a measure which has as its objective the proclaiming of martial law practically and the setting up of Tribunals which will sit behind closed doors in the absence of the Press and the public, where no relatives of the unfortunate person being tried will have an opportunity of knowing what goes on—Tribunals that will have the absolute power of life and death. I say that before powers like that are going to be given we should be very slow about passing a measure of this kind.
Comment on this
I do not feel called upon to explain my vote upon the First Reading of this measure, because, like the Deputy who has just sat down, I think the First Reading should be given to every measure proposed in this House in order that we should be enabled to see its provisions. But as we have been listening to Second Reading speeches on a motion for Closure. I feel bound to contribute a few remarks on the Bill as a whole. The motion before the House is one for Closure, and everyone who has spoken has dealt with the situation generally and to some extent with the Bill in particular. I would like to make my position clear with regard to the Bill. I have voted for the First Reading, and I intend to vote for the remaining stages. Deputy Ruttledge has complained of the prepared statement of the President in, as he said, not making a sufficient case for the Bill. On the contrary, I think that statement, as Deputy Ruttledge stated carefully prepared, is unanswerable by any responsible Deputy. As one who in his humble way was an antagonist of the Public Safety Act of 1927, I would like to recall to the House my attitude on that measure. Speaking on the Second Stage of the Bill, I said at that time "that if the Government made a case for the extension of existing powers within the bounds of reason we shall support them." I went on to say that I did not consider they had made that case and therefore I did not support them. My second objection to that measure was that I considered it an abrogation of the Constitution, and in that I was supported by Deputy Johnson, the then leader of the Labour Party. I said it was an abrogation of the Constitution because of the means whereby the Public Safety Act was to be passed and the Constitution subverted. I said that if the Constitution was to be amended it should be amended directly and specifically by a Constitution Amending Bill, and not by legislation of the nature that we were then discussing. I am glad that when the Government did make up their minds that it was necessary to amend the Constitution they came forward openly and boldly with a Constitution Amendment Bill, and directly amended the Constitution in the respects which this measure proposes. When I say amending the Constitution, of course I do not agree with statements that have been made that the Constitution has been torn up. I am not going over the ground which was so fully explained by the Minister for Justice when he said that no law-abiding person had anything to fear from this proposed amendment of the Constitution, and that as far as they were concerned the Constitution remained unimpaired. My other principal objection to the Public Safety Act of 1927 was to the setting up of military courts and tribunals. Inherently every liberty-loving and law-abiding person must dislike military tribunals. On the occasion of the Third Reading of the Bill I said:—
"It is almost entirely upon the grounds that where no sufficient cause has been shown our Government thought fit to substitute military for civil courts, courts which will administer only, I admit, in certain contingencies, but which may administer in the case of all the offences under this Bill— it is because of that I have strenuously opposed the passage of this measure. If I could be convinced, if there could be any argument brought forward even now by the President or any other member of the Executive Council to show me what the civilian courts could not do that are expected to be done by these military courts, and how these military courts could effect the purpose of this Bill, the purpose of it being the detection and the prevention of crime— if I could be shown how these military courts could effect that purpose any better than civil courts, I do not care of what composition, I would mend my way."
I am of opinion to day that the civil courts in this country have broken down. Things are very different now from what they were in the year 1927. At that time we had not long emerged from the strife and the turmoil of civil war. I believed at that time that the people should be given a breathing space, but, unfortunately, I am sorry to say that certain misguided sections of our people seem to have taken advantage of that breathing space and I think the time has come now for all responsible people in this country to face the question as to whether they are going to tolerate in future, in this Free State of ours, the rule of the gun in substitution for the rule of the Oireachtas. Furthermore long lists have been cited by Deputy de Valera, Deputy Ruttledge and others of the various measures which have been brought in—Public Safety Acts, Protection of Jurors Acts and so forth—and we are told that they have failed. They have failed and that in my mind is the one unanswerable reason for the necessity for a measure such as this to-day.
What is the position of Deputy de Valera? Honestly, when he had concluded his speech I could not tell where he stood. He seemed to me to take, in the course of his speech, one foot forward and then the other foot back. He rightly, and I am sure sincerely, condemned the taking of life. He said no one had the right to take life in this country except, perhaps, those in authority in accordance with the law of the land. I may be wrong, but I interpreted the following statement that he made in my words to be this: That if he were on those benches, if he were in control of the Government of the country and if he found himself in similar circumstances he would be obliged to take, if not exactly similar measures, certainly extreme and drastic measures to put down the taking of life. Very well. With that of course no one can possibly complain. On the contrary everyone will be delighted to know that that would be his policy and his action, but on the other hand he said that instead of introducing an amendment to the Constitution or proposing something in the nature of a Public Safety Bill the right way to proceed is to end the necessity of all such organisations. Very well. How does he propose to end the necessity for such organisations? Does he mean seriously to say that if the Oath were abolished to-morrow these organisations would disappear? I think it is only fair we should ask him does he propose to end the necessity for Saor Eire and the various other Communistic organisations which have been cited here in this House to-day? From the very nature of their composition and their aims these organisations are not out for Irish national independence. They are out, not for an Irish Republic, but for a Soviet or Workers' Republic, and is he prepared, if ever he does get to the front bench of the Government, to bring in a Bill to propose a Workers' Republic for this country? I fail to see how otherwise he would do what he says should be done, that is, to end the necessity for such organisations.
We are all sick and tired of the rule of the gun. It is time that all decent-minded and law-abiding people should face the situation as it is to-day. The situation, as the President has said, is worse to-day than it was when the last Public Safety Bill was introduced. These organisations have sprung up mushroom-like all over the country. They are inter-allied and they work together for purposes which have been openly declared, and which are revealed in documents that have been now brought before us and published in this House. Expressions of disbelief have come from some Deputies as to the amount of drilling that that goes on in the country. Even if there was no drilling going on in the country, or even if drilling was a thing of the past, it cannot be denied that there is a large quantity of revolvers in the country. What are the revolvers for? Revolvers are useless instruments for purposes of pleasure or sport. Revolvers are for one thing only, and that is for the taking of human life. I say it is time that the revolver was removed from this country. We have no time for it. We want to get on to what Deputy de Valera describes as our economic and political problems. However, I feel that every responsible Deputy in this House, whether he has been intimidated or not, whether he is afraid of the consequences or not, should not take upon himself lightly the responsibilities of opposing and voting against this measure.
This measure as far as I understand it—I have not had much time to peruse it either—is a proposal to amend the Constitution by giving extra power to the Executive, but only in certain cases will they be called upon to exercise those powers and certainly only in regard to certain classes of the people of this country, and therefore any respectable, God-fearing, law-abiding person should have no fear whatsoever of the consequences of a proposal such as this. I think that the House irrespective of Party must have been struck by the straightforward and outspoken speech of Deputy Morrissey, the Labour member for Tipperary. Deputy Morrissey to my mind is only voicing the opinion of all law-abiding people in the country when he says that what they want is to have no more of this incitement to murder and murder itself, and that we must face up to it now and put it down once and for all. It is time, therefore, and I deplore the fact most profoundly that we have not been unanimous in this Dáil in passing such a measure as this. This is no question of Party. It is entirely a question of our country first, and though some Deputies may treat the matter in a light and flippant strain, I venture to say there will be some amongst them who, though they may not voice their feelings in that direction, or go into the Lobby in support of it, will in the innermost depths of their hearts, only be too pleased that this measure has been passed.
Comment on this
Members of the Dáil do not seem to realise that for the first time in nine years they are assisting at a very unique ceremony. We are, to my mind, in discussing this motion before the House, taking part in the first stages in the funeral of this Constitution and taking part also in the first stage of the manufacture of a revolution. This smoke screen that has been thrown around the alleged conspiracy that exists in the country by the President's statement will deceive nobody. What we have to try to find out in making up our minds in this matter is the basic reason for this hurried panic legislation and I think we have not far to seek that basic reason. If we go to the "Poblacht," which was much quoted here during the President's statement, the issue of Saturday, October 10th, 1931, it gives an answer, I think, clearly and lucidly to every allegation made by the President and other Ministerial speakers. The editorial says:—
The enemy wants a rising. Only thus can they behead the rising struggle and get a new lease of office. To achieve that end every lie that can serve, every tool that can be used, every influence that can be cajoled, is being collected.
We have here in this House to-day and in the country yesterday a combination of the two most significant elements, which brings our minds back to this period nine years ago when this country was going through its Calvary. We find in October, 1922, when it was to the interests of this Government to suppress opposition to the existing institutions, that a most significant meeting of the Catholic Hierarchy was held in Maynooth and two days after this execution Bill was passed by the Provisional Parliament to execute the bodies of those who stood out against it in arms, a similar execution Bill was passed by Maynooth to execute their souls. The significant position we find here to-day nine years after in the same month is that this Bill is to smash finally all opposition to the existing type of State at present in Ireland, and coincident with it there is an announcement in the Press that the Hierarchy intend to pronounce on Sunday on matters of social and other order. It is significant to those who remember the history of that time and that period to see the same forces used at that time to bring the opinion of the people of this country against the Republican movement—the same tools, instruments, and the same methods that were used at that time to prevent the people getting a clear conception of what we stood for are being utilised in order that this panic legislation will achieve the end for which the other legislation failed.
It is significant that whenever any rising storm of indignation on the part of the people of the country militates strongly against the prospects of the existing rulers that the question of religion is always dragged in and we find this Government of the Irish Free State, whose tradition at least should be semi-national—most of its leaders were National—adopting the very same methods and instruments as the British Government adopted in this country for nearly 300 years. We find that this Government, realising that all the sanctimonious hypocrisy exhibited in the President's statement and the statement of the Minister for Justice exhibiting this terrible concern for the moral welfare of the Irish people, this tremendous desire that the young people of this country should not be corrupted by Communist influence, whilst at the same time they are using the inherent Catholicity of the Irish people to maintain this Government in office to-day. They are dragging in the Catholic faith in all their speeches as a method by which they can arouse the people in a belief that not alone is the State menaced but that its faith is menaced also.
On what do they base this panic legislation which has created a storm of indignation from one end of the country to another? They base it mainly, according to the President, on an interview given to the "Daily Express," and secondly, on editorials in that paper from time to time. We expected when this Dáil met to-day, as a result of the legislation which is about to be introduced, and as a result also of the campaign of lies and slander that has been going on through the country, that the President would come to this House and give some excuse which could be based on sound logic or on fact for the introduction of this proposed Bill. We expected that he would proceed to give us some startling revelation of things of which we were not aware and that he would pro duce concrete evidence that the lives, the property and safety of the Deputies and of this House were menaced considering that Deputies were given a guard during the last few weeks. We expected he would be able to give us concrete evidence, to link these organisations mentioned with some subversive influences of faith, morals and social order. What do we find? We find that on the statement of two men given to the "Daily Express," and editorials in that paper, the President proposes to murder his own Constitution and sow the seed here to-night of a social revolution, because remember at least five of the organisations which he mentioned as being detrimental to the existence of the State have had their origin, their genesis and tradition in the social inequality which exists here to-day, in the bad housing, the unemployment, and in the quest for bread. The President through this Bill proposes to drive these organisations under ground, to deny them the right to expound their policy publicy and freely. When organisations are put into such a position we all know what happens. We know what has happened in other countries. It leads to the very position which, I am sure, the President, in spite of his statement, and his Government, too, would very much desire to see. With all their pretended love for peace and security and their pretended reverence for the Eucharistic Congress that is to be held in this country next year, I cannot understand why they should at this inopportune moment bring in this Bill and challenge the people in this country who believe in the Irish Republic to either fight or get out, because that is what this Bill means. It is a direct challenge to anybody who believes in the aims and objects of the organisation which they themselves were concerned with and in the proclamation which they themselves helped to promulgate to the people in 1916. It is a direct challenge to them to get under the ground once and for all, to abandon the ideal of an independent Ireland or get a gun and fight.
Let us take the President's statement. The law is inadequate to deal with the situation with about sixteen coercion Acts on the Statute Book, with armed detective forces operating throughout, with a secret service, the machinery of which we are not acquainted with, with an army and police force which, according to the Minister's information, must be pretty effective. The law is inadequate to deal with the present situation. That statement coming from the President of the Executive Council, is the greatest monument to the failure of this Government to preserve social order and respect for the institutions of the State that I have ever listened to. We were told in the next breath that it is a Bill to safeguard the rights of the people. It is a Bill to safeguard the rights of a certain section of the people of this country, to safeguard the rights of a small minority who intend to hold power here despite the will of the people. It is a Bill to safeguard the rights of a small group of monopolists who believe that they must stay in power if this country is to live. It is a Bill undoubtedly to safeguard the rights of that class, but it is a Bill to abrogate the rights of the vast majority of the plain citizens of this country.
The President went on to tell us that the rights of the people have been attacked even though they have full and untrammelled liberty under the Constitution. Where is the liberty? They made us on this side of the House come in here and take that Oath of Allegiance to the Free State Constitution against all our desires, against all our heart, against all that tradition told us. We had to take that Oath and bend the knee to his Majesty George V. before we could attend an Assembly of the elected representatives of the Irish people. That is the untrammelled liberty that people have under the Constitution. Where is the liberty that prevents a section of the people of this State from making their voices felt in the counsels of this Assembly? Bill by Bill, week by week since the conclusion of the civil strife in 1923 they have killed whatever good things were in the Constitution. If this Bill did nothing else it brands the Constitution for what it is—a fraud and a farce. It has done a good thing for Ireland and a good thing for those whom the Bill desires to suppress—those who believe in its ultimate independence.
We are told that Parliamentary institutions are menaced and that this kind of menace must be removed once and for all. You fools! Do you think you can do that by a coercion Bill of this type? Has the Government not learned any lesson from the experience of the super coercionists who ruled for Britain directly here for the last three hundred years? Have they not taken notice of the ultimate result of their policies? Have they not taken the lesson that the more coercion Bills that are introduced, the more attempts are made to kill the spirit of Irish liberty, the more determined that spirit will be, the stronger the backbone will become and the more dangerous that ideal of one Ireland and that free will become to the existing institution? Have not the Government taken any notice of that or do they think that they are such super-men that they can crush what 700 years of British rule failed to crush? You will never kill by secret courts the desire in the hearts of the young men of this country to achieve its freedom. As I said at the start, you are laying the seeds of revolution, you are challenging a section of the people here to walk into a trap which you are trying to lay. You desire a rising; you desire a revolution. I challenge the Executive Council to deny that that is the chief purpose of this Bill. They know that the rising tide of public opinion is against them. They know that day by day the people are becoming more hardened in their ideas with regard to this Government and its policy, and they realise that the only hope of clinging to office is to create a situation such as they hope to create by the passage of this Bill. They will not succeed.
We find the President adding that there was an organised conspiracy to overthrow the institutions of this State. The President or any Minister who has spoken has failed to produce any evidence to satisfy any independent body of men that there is any conspiracy to overthrow the existing institutions of this State. There is no secret conspiracy to overthrow existing institutions. Everybody in this House and everybody in the country knows just as well as the President and his Ministers that there is an organisation in this country whose object is to achieve the independence of Ireland through arms. It is not a secret organisation. It has never pretended to be. It has been an open organisation all along. To pretend otherwise at this hour of the day is trying to pull the wool over the eyes of the people. To try to get them to believe that the Irish Republican Army are a secret gang of murderers is the act of a fool and the President knows it. They know very well that the Irish Republican Army has been in existence here all along. Their agents knew it and the ordinary people of the country knew it, and to pretend that now there is a conspiracy which needs the abrogation of the Constitution is bunk.
We heard some denials of the fact that drilling was going on from the Fianna Fáil Benches and the Labour Benches. There is no doubt in the world that drilling has been going on in this country and drilling has been going on in many areas in this country, but that drilling has not all been on the side of those whom this Bill seeks to destroy. Some time ago, not very far from the City of Dublin, there was a review by a member of the British House of Lords of over 1,000 individuals, described as Boy Scouts, Boy Scouts, most of whose officers were ex-officers of the British Army who have seen service in France, Boy Scouts whose ultimate aim and object is to maintain the British connection in this country, to ensure that it would remain an appendage of the British Empire, and where their services could be so used to ensure that they would be used.
I refer now to the Boy Scouts which this Bill does not intend to ban. The Baden Powell Boy Scouts and the British Fascisti existing here are a much more dangerous influence to this State than the organisations which this Bill is to ban, but the Minister will not take any notice of these organisations. Why? We want an opportunity of closely examining the Bill. On the one side we say those whose one crime is that they have been fighting all their lives to achieve the independence of Ireland, have been driven into secret organisations because you have prevented them coming in here. On the other side you have those people whom you all know openly and above board have no interest in maintaining or securing the independence of Ireland, no interest whatsoever. Their only interest is to maintain the British connection. Yet you are going to allow these people to function here in their Boy Scouts, their Fascisti, their brigades and their legions. You will allow them to march through Dublin; you will allow them to hold commemoration services, and their officers to give military directions. You will not suppress these. What is the answer to that? One side seeks to maintain the British connection and the other to achieve the independence of Ireland.
Now we come to the "Daily Express" interview on which the President bases his assumption of an intention to overthrow the Free State. We find that, because mention was made in the "Daily Express" interview of Russian co-operation that there is Russian co-operation, and that something is being done to subvert the religion of the people, and that not only is the State to be subverted, but that the right of private property, and the very existence of the people is menaced. The Minister for Justice says:—"We are the spiritual and temporal guardians of the State and the liberty of the people." We find that, because mention was made in the "Daily Express" that help might be expected from the Soviet Union, that there is a conspiracy to establish in Ireland a Soviet Republic. There is no such thing. It only boils down to the fact, and the Minister and the Government, and every Deputy here knows it as well as I do, and it always was so, that the object is to achieve the independence of Ireland, that England's difficulty is Ireland's opportunity, and that any enemy of England is a friend of Ireland. That will be the position while England keeps this country in subjection. Russia, for the time being, being graded amongst the enemies of capitalism and Imperialism, is the friend of Ireland. If Russia will help Ireland to achieve her freedom, I say there is no conspiracy in that. That is a self-evident truth. That is the positive statement made in the "Daily Express."
Then we come to the question of organisation which the President mentioned as being responsible. We find here mentioned the Irish Republican Army, the Cumann na mBán, Fianna Eireann, the Communist Party of Ireland, the Labour Defence League, the Soviet Union, Saor Eire, and so on. I do not know where the President got his interesting information with regard to the objects of these organisations, or some of them. I happen to belong to four of them, and I know more about them than the President or any member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party opposite. I could tell them that the statement made in this week's "Phoblacht" is a direct statement of fact, and that there is no use in dragging in religion. The Minister states that the Irish freedom movement is being run by Soviet agents. I am a member of the movement. That movement is absolutely independent. There is no such thing as the Irish freedom movement or the Irish Republican movement being run by Soviet agents. There is, naturally, the thing of being friendly with the Soviet Union. If that is a conspiracy, then I believe that there are many in this House besides myself who are guilty of conspiracy.
Then we come to the point that has been overlooked completely by the Government. We find in the list of organisations supposed to be illegal and dangerous to the existence of the State, that six of them are organisations dealing with housing and with the maintenance of the unemployed and dealing with the attempt to improve the social conditions of the people—with the idea of providing work or maintenance for the people— with the idea that nobody should starve while there is food in the country. If there is anything wrong in any of these programmes, then there is something wrong with Catholic theology itself, and I am sure the Minister would not go so far as to say that. I find here that one of the proposed organisations which is declared to be subversive is the Fianna Eireann. I am aware that the Fianna Eireann is not one of those organisations that teach the use of arms. So far as my knowledge goes it is a movement which teaches Irish history and Scout craft. If there is anything wrong in that, why not ban those Scout movements, which teach very much more of what is subversive to the existence of the State than the Fianna Eireann? Their further object is not the further advance of this State. The serious and ultimate object of Fianna Eireann is the achievement of the independence of Ireland. If there is anything wrong in that, then every Minister on the front benches has, at one time or another, been guilty of treason. We are told about the importation of sweets. Foreign sweets came into this country. That matter was tackled by the Cumann na mBán. A canvass was made of the shopkeepers and they were asked not to sell them while Irish factories were operating here, producing as good an article. Is there anything illegal in that? If there is, then any Deputy who advises a member to smoke Sweet Afton cigarettes is guilty of treason and is guilty of the intimidation of a fellow-Deputy. I find that amongst the other items which the President has mentioned is that no person in the State can be permitted to establish the tyranny of dictating to the people the type of political or economic policy they are to follow. I agree with every word of that, but the President having said that, introduces a Bill which is going to establish the tyranny which he condemns. What the President says, in other words, is this: "I am good enough to do it, but nobody else in this State is to be allowed to do it." He is hoping in that way to drive the ordinary people of this country to do things which in their eyes are not at all desirable. The President in establishing this dictatorship of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party is creating a very dangerous precedent, and a precedent which has received more careful thought and all that the exigencies of the situation demand.
Then we find him winding up on a splendid note. He says we intend to abolish violence and the preaching of violence. I agree with that. But if he intends to abolish violence and the preaching of violence he will have to do something else than attempt the suppression of all aspirations for freedom, and that is what this Bill stands for. If he stands for the abolition of the preaching of violence, it would be much more effective if he turned the attention of this Government towards the solution of economic problems confronting this State than do what he is doing in devoting his energies towards the suppression of nationalism in the hearts of the people. The organisations which the President mentioned as being harmful and tending to the subversion of the State, included the Cumann na mBán, Saor Eire, the Revolutionary Workers' Group, The Communist Party of Ireland and the Friends of the Soviet Union. Each of the speakers who have spoken here, from all sides of the House, mentioned these. Do they realise what they are talking about in connection with these organisations? We will take one for example—the Friends of the Soviet Union. There also the object is not the subversion of this State through the creation of turmoil here, but the establishment of friendly relations with the Soviet Union. If there is anything wrong in that I would like to know why that organisation is allowed to exist? Why was its correspondence allowed to come to this House and why was no action taken against its public meetings throughout the city and country? If there is anything wrong in creating relations with friendly States why does not the Minister declare war on Russia and refuse passports to everybody to go to Russia? He refused passports to a number of people some time ago but they got the passports in spite of him. If there is anything wrong in that why was not action taken then? Then we come to a purely working class organisation—the Communist Party of Ireland. It does not exist. The Minister's information must be either very scraggy or he must not have the faintest idea of what the term "Communist Party" means. But there is to my knowledge no such thing in existence as the Communist Party of Ireland. There are groups of workers in the different towns described as the revolutionary workers' groups. Surely the Minister and the President should be better advised than to make statements proposing to ban an organisation that in fact has no existence.
Let us get down to these workers' revolutionary groups. What do we find? Their activities have been towards better conditions in the factories and coal mines. There is a group established in Kilkenny and that group has done certain social work there. They tackled the obtaining of better conditions. Is there anything wrong in that? If a man believes in the distribution of wealth, what is wrong in that? The first object of Saor Eire is to achieve the overthrow in Ireland of British Imperialism and its ally, Irish capitalism. Why should not a man advocate that? One of the signatories to the Declaration of 1916, of which we used hear so much talk from the Front Bench, and one of the men who was mainly responsible for bringing back the spirit of consciousness to the Irish working classes stood for the same thing as Saor Eire. Is there anything wrong in its objects? Is there anything wrong in saying that a minimum standard of living is to be guaranteed for every worker for whom work is not available? Is there anything subversive of democracy in this aim to secure adequate housing?
Is there any reason why anybody should not advocate these things and all the objects of Saor Eire, and is there any reason why groups of men and women in this country, if they so desire, should not advocate these things here in the Dáil? I think I advocated them here myself in 1929. I advocated something very similar to the programme of Saor Eire. Is there any reason why these should not be advocated and the Republic of Ireland advocated and the consolidation of the workers advocated? They advocate the nationalisation of production and distribution, the fostering of the Irish language, Irish culture and Irish games. Is there any reason why these should not be tolerated? If the Minister believes that by suppressing organisations that are trying to link up the Irish people in a movement to solve economic problems, he will do any good for this country he is mistaken. But by preventing these people from meeting and driving them off the street corners he is not going to kill these movements. Is he not taking a lesson in that matter from the British Government? We all know that where they arrested one man in the Sinn Féin days they made ten converts. Does the Minister intend to enforce this Bill as the British did? It is a sad state of affairs that we have to listen to the introduction of a measure of that kind. The saddest part of it is that so far the people who are ruling this State know their position is so weak that they cannot hang on and they must create an atmosphere.
This Bill is really a camouflage measure, like the foreign gold we used to hear about in other days. The Minister and the Government, in speeches made here and there, tried to prove that there is a connection between the Russian Soviets and the Irish Republican movement, and that the Irish Republican movement is depending on the Russian Soviets. When they say that, I tell them they are liars, and they know it. The greatest mistake they are making is that they think they can get away with this Bill, and that it will have no detrimental effect on the State. If they have so much love and respect for the State as they profess to have, this is not the way to benefit the State, and it is no way to bring peace and order into the country. This is not the way to insure that the citizens of this State, under this Constitution or any other Constitution, will be prepared to co-operate in face of the spirit shown by the Ministers. Consequently they will get no co-operation through this Bill from the people of the country. I doubt if the Ministers fought any seat in Ireland on this issue that they would get their candidate elected. But that is what they are doing. You are here to-night tearing up your Constitution to maintain which you fought a civil war. It was for this Constitution you drenched this country in blood, and you are tearing that Constitution and taking out of it the liberties that remained to the people of this country, the liberty to advocate by constitutional means the principles for which they stand. If you vote for this Bill you are manufacturing further revolutions. I appeal to you, though I suppose it will be of little use, to consider very carefully any comments I have made on this Bill. I do not want to consider the comments made against the Bill as the ravings of some lunatics, and I do not want to dismiss them as ill-considered and uncalled for. I am in intimate connection with some of these organisations and I can tell the Minister, and tell the Dáil straight out, that if you pass this Bill you will create a situation which does not exist at the moment. You are going to vanquish any possibility that there is in this country of peaceful progress. You are going to drive those who believe in the independence of Ireland to the use of that force about which you have heard so much to-day, and which the Hierarchy on Sunday next will, I presume, condemn.
I appeal to you not to pass this Bill to take your time, to reconsider you attitude, and to put some of the love of Ireland, of which you speak and which you doubt anybody else has, into practical effect. By doing that you will be doing a good thing for your State, you will be doing a good thing for the happiness of the people, but, above all, you will be refusing to walk into the same trap that you walked into in June, 1922—you will avoid that. If your interests are the interests of the people of Ireland you will do that, because no body wants this Bill. Even many Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies I believe, if they were not coerced into voting for it, would turn against you and vote against it. Give them the chance to be honest. Take a free vote of the House and see what they have to say about it. Above all things, remember that you have to-night a serious responsibility and, even though it is to create an election situation, you have no right to create a panic in this country and you have no right to attempt to use the power which, as the Minister for Defence said, was given to you by God, to destroy the idealism of these people. If you attempt to do that, just as the Church of Rome has stood against Atheism for 1,900 years, the ideal of an Irish Republic will outlive you, and those who believe in that Republic will outlast your political career.
Comment on this
So far from destroying the present Constitution, as Deputy Mullins would have us believe, and so far from substituting another Constitution for our present one, as Deputy O'Connell would have us believe, the measure before the House now is intended to secure and will secure to our people the rights that are enshrined in our present Constitution. It will do that on the one hand, and, on the other hand, it will do what we have not fully been able to do up to the present—it will put into our people's hands machinery under the Constitution that will enable them to nip in the bud the armed unlawful organisation that would plunge this country into civil war. The Constitution as it is at present was framed as an instrument to be worked by the ordinary law-abiding Irish people without any consideration of the violent and misguided elements that might arise in the country or that were in the country when the Constitution was framed. It takes no cognisance that we may have in this country a condition of affairs mid-way or intermediate between a state of perfect peace and a state of civil war. In spite of the pretended absence of information on the part of so many Deputies, we have in this country, and have had for some years, a state intermediate between a state of perfect peace and a state of civil war. We have had, and have at the present moment, a state of affairs in this country in which a minority of the people are arming themselves with a view to the destruction of this State by force of arms.
It is a pity, as Deputy Redmond suggests, that we are not able to put this House, in the eyes of the people, into the position that it would say: "We are all unanimous in giving this measure to the Executive set up by the people in order to preserve the liberties of the people." It is a pity that that is not so. It is a pity that we cannot have in connection with this matter full co-operation, as Deputy O'Connell wishes us to have, and suggests that we might have. He suggests that we might have an agreed measure to deal with the gunman, but he gives us no idea as to what the terms of that measure might be. Whom does he ask us to co-operate with? With people who show the mentality, say of Deputy O'Connell and Deputy Davin, and which their official organ shows in this matter? To co-operate with Deputies on the far side who boast of having amongst them Deputy Little and Deputy Fogarty from Tipperary! Deputy Morrissey says that if he has to give full powers for the punishment of offences into the hands of the Government of the country or into the hands of the people who killed Superintendent Curtin and John Ryan, he is going to give them into the hands of this Government. And Deputy Little back here from a meeting of An Rioghacht, an organisation that is going to secure and maintain in this country the Kingship of Christ shouts to Deputy Morrissey that he has these opinions because he is bought, because he has got his price. Deputy Fogarty at a meeting of the South Tipperary Council the other day, when the Council discussed the question that £6,000 was to be given as some kind of legal compensation to the widow of Superintendent Curtin, was appalled at the sum of money and he says that the giving of such a sum to this woman is an encouragement to these women to get their husbands killed.
Comment on this
I can hardly express my feeling at any Tipperary man, living within the area in which that murder was committed, knowing the circumstances of that wife and mother, who would get up and use the words Deputy Fogarty used at a representative, or supposed to be representative, meeting of Irishmen.
Comment on this
What about the men you put against the wall in 1922 and shot and what about all the others? They are nobodies, I suppose.
Comment on this
These are the people we are asked to get co-operation with. How can we co-operate with the blind and the halt, such as sit on the Labour Benches? Deputy Davin is astonished and flabbergasted to hear that all these things are going on. He asked the Minister for Justice what drilling has been going on in his area. In the month of June alone six drilling parties of from twenty to forty men were known to have taken place in Deputy Davin's area, and that at one of them at least there were rifles used for the instruction of these men. Deputy O'Connell does not know that there is any drilling going on in Mayo. The organ of his Party writes on the 3rd October last that a General Election is coming and that for that reason "bloody Balfourism" is being raised by the Executive Council again, that we can never get away from the mentality of "bloody Balfourism." The following week, seven days after a colleague of Deputy O'Connell's in Claremorris has had his house surrounded at night by sixty men to endeavour to threaten him into refusing to support the measure of order required by the Executive Council— seven days after his colleague in Mayo has had his house surrounded by sixty men at night to endeavour to intimidate him, and the Press from day to day has reported numerous attempts to intimidate Deputies, that organ comes out on the 10th October and there is not a word either about order in this country or the attempted intimidation of the members of the Oireachtas. We are asked to co-operate with the blind and the halt in dealing with matters of paramount importance to the people of the country. The co-operation of those who do not want to see and those who do not want to stiffen their backbone is no use.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin asks what Section 25 is for. That section is intended to meet a situation like this: If instead of simply being threatened, as Deputies were during the last week by organised parties of gunmen in different parts of the country, they had been kidnapped or shot, would we find ourselves here to-day and who would direct the policy in this House? The people who do not know what is going on in this country and the people such as Deputy Little and Deputy Fogarty? The responsibility for taking action for the protection of the people of the country would be in the hands of such people.
We are taking measures to secure that in a country where there is possibly what happened last week the Executive whoever are put in control of the Executive machinery by majority of people are going to have powers in their hands that will enable them to serve the people even though it should unfortunately happen that members of the Oireachtas were prevented by force from attending to their duties in this House. That is all. Deputy Davin does not stand for that. What would he expect the Executive to do if it found itself here to-day dealing with an important measure and without the true voice of the people expressed through the majority of the people's representatives here? We are happily in the position that we are not asked to-day to face a situation in which the majority voice of the House is prevented from expressing itself by reason of affairs outside. We are preparing for eventualities. Deputy Mullins says there is going to be civil war. I do not expect there is, but, if there is going to be civil war it is going to be at such time as the people's representatives themselves decide, and not going to be at the time selected by an unlawful armed organisation in this country.
Comment on this
We are preparing to prevent civil war. I do not think and I do not think the Deputy thinks there are many people with their experience of civil war in this country who are going to start another. But preparations are being taken and as the Minister for Defence says no Constitution whatever be its terms is of any use to a people except it provides for the framing of instruments and the putting of them into the hands of the people and that will enable them to serve themselves whether it be for their protection or for doing their own work.
Deputy O'Connell thinks that Deputy de Valera is now all right and that the authority of this House is no longer challenged by Deputy de Valera's voice in the country or by his party. I think the sooner Deputy de Valera gets out a true edition of his own speeches with any glosses that may be necessary——
Comment on this
I suggest that Deputy de Valera should supply his own glosses and put them down in black and white.
Comment on this
Or to put anything between us and the help of any man in this country. I suggest we ought to have an edition of his speeches and his glosses.
Comment on this
I do not know, and I do not think Deputy Redmond or anybody else in this House knows even after what Deputy de Valera said to-day how he stands in regard to this matter. What is this assembly to do in regard to people organising an unlawful armed association in this country to impose their will by unlawful force against the people? We do not know that. Deputy de Valera suggests that his difficulty and our difficulty in dealing with government in this country, by means of ordinary instruments, is that there are historical circumstances which are rather in the way and that there is something running right across any attempt to deal with the situation by such means as we have at present, and that most of the responsibility for the misguided people who are suffering from such historical circumstances lies at my door, and at my door particularly because of some conduct of mine in 1924. Well like his remarks as to what he thinks himself I would like to see him put down in black and white what he thinks my outlook and actions in 1924 were, because it is important that what they were should be made clear.
I have been associated with the Volunteer Movement from the day it was founded on the 26th November, 1913, and, at any rate, from about 1918 down to March 1924 I was Chief of Staff of the Volunteers or Assistant Minister for Defence or Minister for Defence, or Commander-in-Chief. My own reading of my actions, and I think the practical working out of my actions was that I tried to gather such military force as was necessary in this country and put it into the hands of those who civilly represented the people to do their will.
I had to protest to Deputy De Valera's pre-1922 Government that it would be disastrous if the people of this country got the impression that the Army was running the situation in the country; that it would be of the utmost importance to the civil government to show that it was the controlling authority here and therefore, as, then Minister for Defence, in matters affecting agriculture, local government and ordinary justice I insisted that those who were responsible for the civil side were not keeping up the prestige of the civil departments and I showed the lines upon which I thought they ought to do it. So much was that so that after the Truce in 1921 I said to a very senior officer: "for goodness sake go and make out a memorandum on the situation bringing out the points on which the civil side of the Government are letting themselves down and creating difficulties for themselves, for the people and for the Army." And I submitted that to the then Minister for Defence and I said: "I am submitting this not as the actual state of affairs, but I am submitting it as a statement that if it were the actual state of affairs it would require the very serious consideration of the Cabinet and action," and I got a brief note to the effect that the writer of the documents should prove his statements.
I do not think that this House could say that the military will was in any other way but subservient to this House in 1922 and 1923, and that in 1924 circumstances arose in which I was asked to get the resignation of the senior officers—men who served the country as Adjutant-General and Quartermaster-General and later as Chief of Staff in 1922 and 1923, men who had maintained the civil Government from the time it was formed in 1919 and held up the hands of the people in their struggle against outside and internal oppression. When I was asked to get their resignations I asked them to resign and with their resignations I tendered my own resignation, also, to the Executive Council. I could have turned round and said to the Executive Council and to the House "when you wanted a job done we did it." I did more than that, I got these men associated with me to do more than that. Deputies opposite may read history as superficially as they do other things and may read the events of 1924 superficially.
The main officers who made the volunteers and their work possible, who made the Army for this Dáil in 1922 and 1923, they went, when there was no necessity for them to do so, before a Committee of this House, representative I think of every class of this people, as it were, to answer for what they did. Do you think there was any necessity for these men to do that? They went simply to let this country and everyone in it know that the Army never regarded itself as anything but subservient to the elected representatives of its people. That lesson may be lost on those Deputies as it may be lost on other people, but at any rate—
Comment on this
Will Deputies on the far side, like the interpretation of Deputy de Valera's speeches, write down what they think about secret societies? The Army that this House was given was an Army that stood by it work, was an Army that stood by it from the time it was formed until to-day, and will again. It is not kept up for fun and certain classes of people are going to be handed over to military tribunals to be dealt with in matters of trial and punishment. What are we keeping our Army for? Is it to fight the Chinese or the Japanese, the English or any other people?
Comment on this
Our Army is maintained to defend the rights of the people and to secure the rights enshrined in their Constitution. What would we want an Army for if it were not for that?
Comment on this
Deputy de Valera tries to cover up his own tracks by suggesting that Deputies on these benches put ideas into the minds of the people, and that now they have organised irregular and unlawful forces throughout the country. What was he doing in 1924? What was he doing in 1925? The first Irishman to send a Commission to Russia was Deputy de Valera. We have been told by the Minister for Justice that the Quarter-master-General of Deputy de Valera's army was in Russia in 1925. Who sent him there? On March 10, 1925, when Deputy de Valera was the President of the Republic of Ireland with a Government, an Army Council, a Military Attaché, and Envoy in New York, his Minister for Defence then, now Deputy Lemass, got a communication to say that he was in touch with a person who was in touch with Russian authorities in New York, and that he had discussed with him the sending over of a military mission to Russia; that if he thought it ought to consist of eight people, four who would be good on the ordinary mechanical line and four good with aeroplanes; that of those that might go, two out of one section and two out of another, after they had got their training, might have to remain for two years to serve the Soviet Government, and that the others could come home with their training. Deputy Lemass said that no Russian money came to this country as far as he knew. I quite agree with him, because the envoy in New York suggested that the Government of the Republic here might have to pay for them while in Russia.
We heard mention to-day as high up in the Army forces here, high up in Saor Eire, the names of Seán MacBride and of Seán Russell. The military attache in New York suggested to Deputy Lemass that one person who ought to go to Russia was Seán MacBride, as he knew French and was highly educated. When Deputy Lemass got that communication he sent it to Deputy Aiken, who was Chief of Staff, saying, "you know more about these things than I do, as they began before I came in." As a result it was discussed by the Army Council of the time. After discussion by the Army Council, Deputy Lemass, on the 16th May, writes to the President, now Deputy de Valera:
1. In connection with the proposed delegation to Russia the Army Council suggests that the following officers should compose the delegation: the A.G., the Q.M.G., and the late Q.M.G. if available.
The Army Council did not think that Seán MacBride should go, but thought that Seán Russell should go.
2. I think the Q.M.G. would be more suitable in every way, and the Army Council were unanimous that he should be one. The difficulty in connection with the A.G. is the danger that the work of his Department would be neglected until he returned, but this difficulty is not insurmountable. Otherwise he would be a suitable member of the delegation. The late Q.M.G. may not be able to go. I am sending you this so that you can think over the matter before the next meeting of the Cabinet. Of course the Cabinet could add an additional member if they so desired.—Minister for Defence.
That was May 1925. The Minister for Justice has told the House that Seán Russell was in Russia, and he gave some interesting information about his communications of that time. What was the mentality of Deputy de Valera and his colleagues at that time? He now suggests that I put bad ideas into the minds of these people, that I put bad ideas into Seán Russell's mind and into Seán MacBride's mind. This was their mentality. This is the letter that was sent over the name of the Minister for Defence, now Deputy Lemass, and the Chief of Staff, now Deputy Aiken, to the envoy in America, Deputy O'Kelly on the 2nd July, 1925, at a time when, no doubt, a decision was taken to send the military mission to Russia. I do not know how many went. Some were to come back with training and others were to serve the Russian Government for a proposed period of two years.
To Sean T. O'Kelly:
Statement on Army Position for American Envoy.
We have been instructed by the President to furnish you with a statement covering:
(a) The present Army position./
(b) The means employed to maintain the Army as an effective military force.
(c) The allocation of government funds for army maintenance.
A. Discussion on the military situation can be classed under three headings, i.e., relating to (a) the Twenty-Six Counties; (b), the Six Counties; (c), Britain. Although as Republicans we regard Ireland as a national unit and the forces holding Ireland in subjection as British troops, no matter what they call themselves, yet considering the situation from the military viewpoint alone, the different groups of anti-Republican forces must be taken separately.
In the Twenty-Six Counties the "Free State" Government has approximately 18,000 soldiers partially trained, well armed and equipped; but they could increase this number in the event of hostilities to a very considerable extent. Against these we could put into field 15,000 partially trained men, but we could not supply one half of them with any sort of weapon. A military victory over the "Free State" will not become a practical possibility until the deficiency in armament has been made good. In the Six Counties there are about 30,000 armed special police, which constitutes the "Army" of the "Northern" Government, together with six battalions of British Regulars. There is little possibility of military victory in this area until the "Free State" Government has been overthrown in the South and a Republican Government has had time to collect and organise its forces on a regular basis. Should the British Government attempt to prevent by force the establishment of a Republican Government, whether established by constitutional means or otherwise, the activities of the Republican Army would be directed towards making any other government impossible and so compelling recognition.
B. We are endeavouring to maintain the Army as an effective force, capable of being brought into immediate action should the occasion arise that would justify or necessitate its use. It is not advisable to detail all the measures we have taken to ensure this. I enclose herewith four copies of a recruiting poster which we have issued. It is hoped to induce into the Army the young men who have grown to manhood since the termination of the civil war, and thus enable us to give an honourable discharge to those who have borne the brunt of the last three campaigns and whose time of utility in the active force is over.
Of the funds allocated by the Government for use by the Army the major portion is spent in the maintenance of the existing organisation. The balance is used in the purchase of armament and supplies. The Government has placed at the disposal of the Army a generous share of the available funds, and we have no grounds for complaint under this head. While we do not state that the amount received is adequate to meet all the needs of the Army, we do not expect, and shall not seek, any larger amount until the funds at the disposal of the Government have been correspondingly increased.
We trust that this statement will make the situation clear to our friends in the U.S.A.
Minister for Defence.
Chief of Staff.
That is from Deputy Lemass and Deputy Aiken to Deputy de Valera in 1925. And I spoiled the morale of the young men of this country in 1924! We are not dealing with 1924 or 1925; we are dealing with 1931. In 1931, in spite of the incredulity of Deputies, in spite of their blindness to the things that are going on around them, there is an armed force in this country preparing for the overthrow of the institutions of Government set up here, and preparing to enforce their will on the people. They are prepared to put down our institutions by force of arms. What they will have after that, we do not know. Deputy de Valera thinks it would be quite all right if the things which are his will were put in operation. Deputy Geoghegan thinks the same thing. In fact there is great difficulty in dealing with these people until such time as they are able to arrange matters according to Deputy de Valera's point of view. What the point of view of the people outside is I do not think either Deputy de Valera or Deputy Geoghegan could assure us. We have, in 1931, the "Oglach" calling itself the official organ of the Irish Republican Army, and declaring that "our chief weapons are the rifle, the revolver, the automatic pistol, and the hand grenade," and being in the position that they have to realise that high percentage of volunteers are only recruits, men of short service, the product of to-day, those that are to relieve the old guard, according to the people of 1925. Their outlook is that "hand in hand with military training must go national and political education. Not only must we train men to fight, but also teach them why and what they are to fight. Political consciousness and a sense of political values must be taught, not only that the nation is unfree, but why it is not free, and the root causes and means by which it is kept in subjection. Let us profit by the recent past. The Republic was overthrown in 1922, largely because the Volunteers did not understand, and were not taught the fundamental principles upon which it was based or the economic or social principles it enshrined."
We have that body to-day at a time of financial and economic depression and social unrest, at a time when the Deputies on the far side do not know what politically or economically they want, at a time when so little of the Deputies on the Labour Benches know what socially or economically they want, that they are almost slipping into borrowing words from the Constitution of Saor Eire. Because we have important social problems and important economic problems to attend to, it is important that we should have the situation clear of the gun and clear of all those people who want to dictate their opinions by means of force. That is what this Bill is intended to do and that is what this Bill will do, no matter how flabby be the expressions of Deputies who criticise it. It would have been quite good if Deputies from all sides of the House were able to come in here and say "For goodness' sake, take your Bill and clean up an ordered situation, and let us get ahead with our economic and social problems, and the finding of their solutions." But as long as we have the mentality that makes excuses for for the past, or makes excuses for those who are employing force in the present by saying that there are historical reasons why the poor fellows should try force and endeavour to put the blame on the other side but their own, Deputy de Valera can be no help to any section of the people in this country in solving their economic or social problems.
Comment on this
Can I get agreement that the division on this motion will take place before 10.30?
Comment on this
The motion contemplates that an opportunity should be given to the House to decide it to-night.
Comment on this
The motion contemplates that the Second Stage of the Bill should be set down as the first opposed Government business to-morrow. Should the House get no opportunity of deciding it to-night, to that extent the motion would have been defeated.
Comment on this
Can we get the motion discussed to-night? The Minister for Local Government did not say a word about it.
Comment on this
The attitude of the Chair, after giving some consideration to the matter and looking at this whole thing together, is that the less intervention from the Chair against anybody the better. That has been the case all round.
Comment on this
If I do not get agreement, I would have to ask you, sir, to accept a motion for the closure so that a division would be taken to-night. That will limit the time further.
Comment on this
We say that this Bill raises such highly important issues that any attempt to closure discussion should be resisted by anybody who has a sense of responsibility.
Comment on this
I will undertake to move now that the Question be now put, or alternatively, if there is an understanding, that the motion be put at twenty minutes past ten.
Comment on this
There is no agreement. I will take Deputy O'Hanlon and Deputy MacEntee and divide the time between them.
Comment on this
I hesitate to venture a few words on the motion before the House for the simple reason that 360 minutes have been occupied in dealing with all sorts of subjects— Russia and Ireland, Ireland and Russia, Chinese, Thompson guns and various other things—and not a word about the question of the closure, which is the motion with which we are dealing. When I came here this morning I felt rather strongly about this Closure Motion and I did intend at that time to protest against the closure for this reason that taking it for myself, not being a member of any Party, I have not now and will not have between now and Friday an opportunity of consulting one constituent of mine as to the Bill before the House. I do not want to be taken at this stage as being opposed to giving the power to the Government that they seek in this Bill, but I do hold that the Government are guilty of bad tactics and perhaps unconstitutional tactics in rushing through the Bill without giving the members of the House an opportunity of consulting their constituents. All I know about the Bill is what I read in the Press, and one of the things already in the Press is that this is going to be a test of confidence in the Government. In other words if the Government were beaten on this Bill they would go out of office. I am not going to vote against the Bill, but I hold that the best way to get the confidence of the people is to take them into your confidence and to let them know that the Bill is for their benefit. Three hundred and sixty minutes have been occupied in discussing everything but the motion before the House. This is a Closure Motion. If a closure had been put on the Closure Motion at twenty minutes past three a decision would have been arrived at, at twenty-five minutes past three. We would not have wasted the whole day on the Closure Motion as to whether we were to deal with it on Thursday or Friday or not. We can only deal with seven or eight items on that agenda to-day without wasting the time of the House and we can only deal with the Second Reading on Thursday, and thus members who have not had an opportunity of consulting their constituents on this Bill could have got a week to consult them and the Bill could have been finished in the closure on Wednesday. That would be the proper procedure.
I will not be out of order in discussing the Bill. I declare myself here and now that I will vote for it but I intend to vote now against the Closure Motion. We have taken the whole day discussing it in the Dáil and thus wasted the time that we should have given to discussing the Bill.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Hanlon after a statement that he had not read the Bill, that he would like to have an opportunity of discussing the Bill, and that he did not discuss with his constituents the Bill, has already pledged himself to supporting the Bill without consulting his constituents.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation I did not say that I had not read it. I said I had not an opportunity of consulting my constituents on the Bill.
Comment on this
Possibly I might help to clear the Deputy's difficulty. This Bill is a measure designed to secure the incubation of a new Napoleon and the Minister for Local Government, the self-professed and self-proclaimed man of iron, is apparently going to be the new Napoleon. He is the one gentleman who seems to have any information as to the real purposes behind the Bill. He is the gentleman who getting up here in this House has sneered at the people who are the victims of historical circumstances much as Judas might sneer at the Cross. He is a man who talks about murder, who challenges Deputy Fogarty. Are his own hands clean? What of the men with whom he sat in conference day after day? What of the men whom he encouraged to hold the Four Courts, or of the men who were his own comrades in arms and who were shot by him and by the members of the secret organisation existing within the Army on 8th December, 1922? Deputy Mulcahy is a good judge of glosses. He got up here and put his own gloss on the events of 1924. He told us how he had requested certain people to hand in their resignation as officers of the Army, but he did not tell us that a committee set up by this House had passed its verdict on General Mulcahy's administration of the Army, and he did not tell that Committee, and he has not told this House, why the I.R.B. organisation was reformed within the Army under his auspices and by the direct and active co-operation of Deputy Gearoid O'Sullivan.
General Mulcahy is good at making revelations. General Mulcahy told us that Deputy de Valera was the first man to send a mission to Russia. Was Deputy Mulcahy a member of the Provisional Government, was he associated with General Michael Collins, and will he deny that on the personal authority of Michael Collins, Mr. Dermot Fawcett and a member of the Trade Union Congress was sent to London to get in touch with the Russian representative there in 1922?
Comment on this
No matter for what purpose, he was sent there. The fact is that undoubtedly the Provisional Government were the first to send a delegation or an emissary to get in touch with the Russian representative in London in 1922.
Comment on this
I do not know. The Minister keeps his own secrets well locked in his breast. The Minister pursues his own policy, in cold and callous silence. We know the Minister is an ambitious man, we know the Minister has proclaimed himself a man of iron; we know the Minister has a Napoleonic mentality.
Let us get back to 1924, because 1924 has a good deal to do with 1931 and with the possible course of events after the passage of this Bill to incubate General Mulcahy as a new Napolean. Paragraph 14 of the Report of the Army Inquiry Committee is as follows:
"While we are completely satisfied that there would have been no mutiny but for the existence of this organisation, we are equally satisfied that its activities were intensified by the revival or reorganisation of the I.R.B., with the encouragement of certain members of the Army Council, the lack of confidence and want of intercourse between these two sections of Army officers, and the failure of both to appreciate their positions as servants of the State."
What was the purpose for which that secret organisation was formed within the Army; what had General Mulcahy in his mind when he encouraged Deputy Gearoid O'Sullivan, at that time the Adjutant-General, to reorganise the Irish Republican Brotherhood within the Army? The Army Inquiry Committee could not find what their objects were.
Comment on this
I want to make a point of order. The Deputy has mentioned my name. In no place in the Report from which he has quoted, does my name appear, and I would ask the Deputy to withdraw the statement he has made. It is not being made against me, but against General Mulcahy.
Comment on this
I am going to rely on the report of the Army Inquiry Committee set up by this House.
Comment on this
It is a point of order. I submit, sir, that no person should misquote in this House a document of this House. That particular Report was made to this House, and is a document of this House. In no way am I mentioned in it as having been incited or induced by General Mulcahy to do anything.
Comment on this
Yes. The Minister for Local Government—I am going to relate this to the Bill in a moment——
Comment on this
I have no personal interest in this matter except to say that there would appear to be read into the Report something which is not in it. In no way is my name mentioned in that Report. Provided the Deputy withdraws what he said, I have no objection to what his imputations or suggestions are.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy sit down? Deputy MacEntee is discussing a particular Report. I am not in a position to say what Deputy MacEntee said about Deputy O'Sullivan. I have given Deputy O'Sullivan an opportunity of making an explanation of his own personal position. I do not know that I can do any more. It is not for me to decide a question of fact.
Comment on this
Do I understand that Deputy Gearóid O'Sullivan said that he was not a member of this reorganised I.R.B.?
Comment on this
There is no use getting on to another point. What Deputy Gearóid O'Sullivan says is that he is not mentioned in the Report.
Comment on this
But he is mentioned in certain discussions that took place in this House. I am perfectly certain that if we had the evidence here that was laid in secret before that Committee of Inquiry that the revelations——
Comment on this
I am sure the Deputy did not intentionally misquote the Report. I take it he will now withdraw the suggestion he has made.
Comment on this
The Minister for Local Government came here with white-faced candour, opening his whole soul to the Dáil, telling us the splendid patriotic motives that moved him when he was compelled to resign in 1924, when he induced General Gearóid O'Sullivan and the late Quartermaster-General of the Defence Forces of Saorstát Eireann to resign. He did not tell us and I do not think he told, judging by this Report, the Army Inquiry Committee what were the objects he was seeking to achieve when he organised this secret society within the Army. We have heard a good deal about treason, but can any member of this House conceive any greater treason or any greater treachery than that? We have been told that they must have an unequivocal declaration from us that all power and all authority can only be rightfully exercised by this Dáil? Was the Minister for Defence when organising that secret society giving the Dáil loyal service? Was he even loyal to his own comrades?
Comment on this
I was a member of that Committee and the charge was never made that he organised that society.
Comment on this
General Mulcahy was never accused of organising a society within the Army. At any rate, we do know that officers in whom he had the greatest confidence with his knowledge, if not with his active co-operation, were organising that secret society within the Army, and we know from the Minister's own letter that not only was he prepared to acquiesce in the organisation of one secret society within the Army, but that he was prepared to enter into personal and private negotiations with a rival secret society within the Army as well. It might be well to reveal his letter to the public once again. General Mulcahy has done good in spilling the beans. Here is a bean that might as well go on the Table with the others.
"To Major-General Tom Cullen.
A Chara,
Following our discussion of the 23rd instant, and in reply to your communication of the 25th instant, which reached me to-day, this note will assure you that"—he has almost assumed the imperial style even in July, 1923—
"(1) I am quite prepared to deal directly at any time with any three representatives of those I have recently met for the consideration of any representations they may wish to make on ‘matters which are considered vital to the progress of the Army on national lines with a view to the complete independence of Ireland."—
I suppose at that time with his tongue in his cheek he was feeling that these were the victims of historical circumstances. Even then in his own heart he was sneering at his comrades of 1923 as he is sneering to-day at his old comrades of 1921—
"it being understood that this is of necessity a personal and private arrangement and not indicative of sectionalism of any kind in the Army.
(2) I am quite prepared to see any individual of those I have already met who may wish to make representations in this matter.
(3) And I am quite prepared, after the recent discussion, to accredit all concerned with having absolute honesty of purpose and ideals.
I have seen sufficient disaster brought about by isolation and misunderstanding to be determined not to leave anything undone that may be possible on my part, to prevent either one or the other coming between men whose co-operation has made the present position of the country possible.
Beir beannacht,
(Signed) R. Ua Maolchatha."
I said that this Bill was a Bill for the incubation of the new Napoleon. With all respect to those who have asked us to confine the discussion to the Closure Motion this is the only reasonable opportunity that we are going to have to discuss what is in this Bill. The tactics of the Government are better and sounder than their intentions. We have heard Deputies here supporting the Bill and I doubt if they have even read the Bill or even studied any of its implications.
What is in the Bill? Section 4 is a section which is going to establish a Committee of general security. Section 4 is a section which provides that a Tribunal shall be established consisting of five members all of whom shall be officers of the Defence Forces of Saorstát Eireann not below the rank of commandant and shall be appointed and be removable at will by the Governor-General acting on the advice of the Executive Council. Even in that section there is a lamentable omission. There is not one possible safeguard for the liberty of the people. Five officers are to be appointed and set up as a Tribunal by the Governor-General. How are they to be appointed? Are their names going to be published? Are they to be kept secret? Are they going to be changed from day to day until General Mulcahy gets five instruments that are going to be suitable to his end, that are going to help him to achieve the ambition that has been fostering in his mind ever since 1919 and 1920, when he thought he was the strong man of the Volunteer forces, when he thought it was he and not Cathal Brugha who was carrying on the fight for the independence of this country?
General Mulcahy is going to get his five secret instruments and nobody is going to know who they are or anything about them. One thing I will wager is that they will be five members of the I.R.B. That is not yet disbanded. The Minister reorganised it in 1923. That was the organisation which was going to secure control over the Defence Forces of the Saorstát in 1923.
Comment on this
What is this Tribunal going to do? According to Section 5 (2) it
"shall have full and absolute power to appoint the time and places of its sittings and full and absolute control of its own procedure in all respects and, in particular, in respect of the admission or exclusion of the public to or from its sittings, the enforcing the attendance of witnesses and the production of documents."
When the Committee can sit in secret and hear evidence in secret, when the public are not going to be admitted into the Arcana of secrecy, we are going to have the policy of the Government carried out, and the advancement of one gentleman to a paramount place in this nation. That is the purpose of this Tribunal, and that is why these things must be done in secret. General Mulcahy and the members of the Executive Council found their way into public life through the help of secret organisations. They have never yet outgrown the spirit of the conspiracy in which they were bred. They are seeking by Section 5 to carry out a policy which they themselves engaged in long ago.
What is going to be the jurisdiction of this Tribunal? Section 6 reads:—"The Tribunal shall have jurisdiction to try and to convict or acquit all persons charged with an offence mentioned in the Appendix to this Article and brought before the Tribunal under this Article, and also jurisdiction to sentence every person convicted by the Tribunal of any such offence."
What are the offences mentioned in this Appendix? Has any member of the Government Party who is going to vote for this Bill read this Appendix or read paragraph 7 of the Appendix? It states that:—
"Any offence whatsoever (whether committed before or after this Article was inserted in this Constitution or before or after Section 4 to 34 of this Article came into force) in respect of which an Executive Minister certifies in writing under his hand that to the best of his belief the act constituting such offence was done with the object of impairing or impeding the machinery of government or the administration of justice."
Listen to this precious indictment which is going to be put to the Tribunal, an indictment which any of you may have to answer to and defend yourself against. "Any offence... in respect of which an Executive Minister certifies in writing." The present Minister for Local Government and Public Health and the present acting Minister for Defence, General Mulcahy, will be the "Executive Minister." Now think of that. Not a single act that you do, the speech which I am making here to-night protesting against this Bill, and it is a speech made before this Bill becomes law, that speech can be declared by General Mulcahy to be "an offence which was done with the object of impairing or impeding the machinery of Government or the administration of justice."
I may be hauled before this special Tribunal and tried in secret and "General" Gorey, because he will be a General under this Act, when he goes coursing hares, when he gives a wrong name to a Sergeant of the Civic Guards, could be declared by General Mulcahy to have committed an act which was done with the object of impairing or impeding the machinery of the Government or the administration of justice, and he may be brought before this Tribunal and tried there in secret. But let not Deputy Gorey be too downhearted, because in Section 12 the Executive Council may, at their absolute discretion, at any time freely pardon any person convicted by the Tribunal. The Bill will fall with its full weight only on the opponents of the Government.
In fact, in Section 12 we are going to revert in this country to the unhappy position which prevailed here in 1923, before the late Kevin O'Higgins took control of the situation, which then prevailed in the Army. We are going to revert to the position which the Army Inquiry condemned when they said that "General Mulcahy accepted full responsibility for the decision to drop the Kenmare case. . . In our opinion, this was a grave error of judgment on his part. It did not contribute to the mutiny, but it did militate against discipline generally by encouraging suspicion in the minds of officers and others that the Army authorities were disposed to hush up charges against persons high in authority." And so we see that the General has made the full circle, and having made the full circle, if "General" Gorey does act with the object of impairing or impeding the machinery of Government or the administration of justice, that General Mulcahy will be in charge of the Army, and will act as he did in the Kenmare case, and will accept full responsibility for dropping the proceedings against "General" Gorey.
I have told you what the functions of this Tribunal may be. Supposing a member of the Executive Council does issue such a certificate or such a statement as will shock the even consciences of some Deputies who are going to vote for the Bill, so that they rise in the House to protest against the Tribunal, what then will be the position? Sub-section (3) of Section 5 says:—
The Tribunal shall have full and absolute power to punish in such manner as the Tribunal thinks proper all persons whom the Tribunal finds guilty of contempt of the Tribunal or any member thereof whether such contempt is or is not committed in the presence of the Tribunal.
You will not even have the immunity which every member of the House at present enjoys, because under this Bill Section 2 of Part I. provides that every Article of the Constitution shall be read and construed subject to the provisions of this Article. Under Article 18 of the present Constitution every member of the Dáil enjoys immunity against prosecution or against punishment for anything he may do or say within the precincts of the House in the discharge of his duty. Under Article 2 of this Bill this immunity is wiped out and any Deputy who after the passage of this Bill ventures to criticise or in any way oppose the actions of this Tribunal or the actions of the Executive Council will at once render himself liable to punishment by this Tribunal whether that is before or after the passage of this Bill. What are going to be the sentences of this Tribunal. Section 7 says:—
Whenever the Tribunal finds any person guilty of an offence mentioned in the Appendix to this Article the Tribunal may, in lieu of the punishment provided by law (other than this Article) for such offence, sentence such person to suffer any greater punishment (including the penalty of death) if in the opinion of the Tribunal such greater punishment is necessary or expedient.
That may be the sentence for a mere misdemeanour. Any member of this House can be hauled before this Tribunal and he can be punished with any punishment not even excepting death.
And then as a happy afterthought we have in sub-section (5) of Section 7:—
"No coroner's inquest shall be held in relation to a death occasioned by the execution of a sentence of death pronounced by the Tribunal."
Deputy Gorey must remember that at one time the penalty for stealing a sheep was death by hanging, and Deputy Gorey may console himself with this thought that even if he were executed as a result of his pursuit of the hare his relatives would have the consolation that there would be no inquest on him.
What is Section 8 of this Bill? "(1) No action, prosecution, or other proceeding, civil or criminal, shall lie against any member of the Tribunal in respect of any order made, conviction or sentence pronounced, or other thing done by the Tribunal or in respect of any thing done by such member in the course of the performance of his duties or the exercise of his powers as a member of the Tribunal or otherwise in his capacity as a member of the Tribunal, whether such thing was or was not necessary to the performance of such duties or the exercise of such powers.
(2) No action or other proceeding for defamation shall lie against any person in respect of anything written or said by him in giving evidence, whether written or oral, before the Tribunal or for use in proceedings before the Tribunal.
(3) No action, prosecution, or other proceeding, civil or criminal, shall lie against any registrar, clerk, or servant of the Tribunal in respect of anything done by him in the course of the performance of his duties as such registrar, clerk, or servant, whether such thing was or was not necessary to the performance of such duties."
We have heard a good deal about perjury. We have heard in the course of this debate the Minister for Justice getting up and stating that one of the most dastardly things which one could do would be to defame a person in his character or in his reputation, and he almost suggested that members of the Fianna Fáil Party were incapable and should be disqualified from acting as public representatives because they have ventured to impugn the good faith of members of the Gárda Síochána in relation to certain things they had done and certain crimes they had committed. But here you have Section 8, sub-section (2) of this Bill giving absolute indemnity to perjury, absolute indemnity for public or private defamation of a person's character. Because we are told here that no action, or other proceeding shall lie against any person in respect of anything written or said by him in giving evidence whether written or oral before the Tribunal. I leave to members themselves to read Part III. of the Act because I want to say one or two other things before I sit down. I suggest that you turn to Section 25. Section 25, is I think the touchstone that should be applied to the whole of this matter. Section 25 provides:
(1) Whenever the Executive Council is satisfied that a member of either House of the Oireachtas has died in consequence, directly or indirectly, of an unlawful act of another person or is prevented by physical incapacity arising directly, or indirectly from the unlawful act of another person or by unlawful imprisonment or by threats or in timidation from appearing at and taking part in the sittings of the House of the Oireachtas of which he is a member, the Governor-General on the advice of the Executive Council may do either or both of the following things, that is to say—
(a) by order appoint such person as the Governor-General on the advice aforesaid and having regard to the known opinions of the member so deceased or so prevented (as the case may be) shall think proper to name in such order to be a member of the said House of the Oireachtas in place of the said member.
(b) by order adjourn either or both Houses of the Oireachtas for such period not exceeding one month as the Governor-General on the advice aforesaid shall think proper to specify in such order.
If a member dies as a result directly or indirectly of an unlawful act which bears no relation whatever to the offences which the special tribunal may try, then the Governor-General may nominate a person to be his successor in this House. This would tend to make this House what the Seanad was originally intended to be—a nominated assembly. It is also provided by this section that a person appointed under it to be a member of the House shall not be entitled to take his seat until he has taken in accordance with Article 17 of the Constitution the oath mentioned in that Article.
We are going to abolish the courts. We are going to set up a revolutionary Tribunal, and by a Public Safety Bill we are going to appoint five persons to act as General Mulcahy's bloodhounds. They are going to operate in secret. We are going to deprive people of the right to elect representatives to this House. We are going virtually to wipe out the whole Constitution, so that there is only one Article which this Bill is designed to preserve and that is Article 17. Is that what General Mulcahy had in mind in July, 1923, when he wrote that: "I am quite prepared to deal directly at any time with any three representatives of those I have recently met, for the consideration of any representations they may wish to make ‘on matters which are considered vital to the progress of the Army on national lines with a view to the complete independence of Ireland.'"
Now he is setting up a Tribunal one of the principal provisions of which is to insure that no matter what other Articles of the Constitution may go Article 17 will remain. Is there any member in this House who was formerly a member of the national organisation, and I can see some of them here whose record is a brave and heroic one—would any of them in 1921 or 1922, when they were discussing the Treaty in the Dáil, tell us what was their attitude to that matter then? Would any one of them at that time for a moment admit to himself that he would go into the Lobby in support of a Bill which would wipe out every Article of the Constitution, except Article 17? Would any member here at that time have admitted it to himself that such would be possible? Yet, when this closure motion is put to-night that is what you are voting for, to enshrine permanently Article 17 as the only Article of the Constitution that is going to have any permanent validity.
I have endeavoured to put before the House one or two of the leading provisions in the Bill. Deputy Morrissey made a speech which I must say, having regard to Deputy Morrissey's attitude when the position of An Leas-Cheann Comhairle was before the Committee on Procedure and Privileges of this House, astonished me. I do not know how the Deputy can possibly reconcile the speech made to-night with the attitude he took up then. His colleague on the Labour Benches was compelled to resign his position as Leas-Cheann Comhairle because he claimed the right to speak on behalf of his constituents when a motion relating to the land annuities was before the House. He was compelled to resign because it was held to be incompatible with his position as Leas-Cheann Comhairle to take part in a debate of that nature. Yet Deputy Morrissey vacates the Chair and comes down here to make a speech, a speech which I think could not be made with any sincerity by any member of the Labour Party or by any man who ever professed to follow the teaching of James Connolly. What was Deputy Morrissey's thesis? Whether, he says, you are going to give full powers to the Government or whether you are going to give full powers to those who killed Superintendent Curtin. That is not the position. The point is whether you are going to give uncontrolled powers to the Executive Council. That is a thing that no democratic assembly and no national legislature can afford to do. All history is against it. The teaching and the results of history are against it. Never once has that been done without the members of the legislative assembly being swallowed up one by one by the monster which they themselves had brought into being. You cannot do this thing in safety and in the hope that this House is going to exist. Once these powers are handed over to the Executive Council you will have ambitious men in that Council outvieing one another in order to prove that they are the only sincere champions of the Constitution. We will have a lot of talk about safe guarding the rights of the people, but look at the history of every dictatorship that ever was established. They always appealed to the people when they were depriving the people of their liberties.
We have made our position quite clear. We have already indicated to members of the Labour Party—some of us at any rate—that we are prepared to meet anybody, to discuss the present situation, to see what the possibilities of disorder are, and to prevent that disorder by removing the cause of it. The chief cause of the disorder is Article 17 of the Constitution, which the Government will not remove. I do not believe there is any justification even at this moment for this Bill, but if that Article were removed there could be no possible justification for the course which the Government are now asking you to adopt in giving them the powers which they seek in the Bill. That is the kernel of the situation. Article 17 was brought into the Constitution, and while they are lopping off the other Articles of the Constitution that Article is going to remain for all time as the bedrock of this State. Remove Article 17, give these men a chance to come into the House, give them a chance to put their point of view before us, and I say that there will be no Communism, no unrest, but there will be that unity of effort and unity of purpose which will help us to re-establish the Irish nation.
The Minister for Defence and the Minister for Local Government both spoke on the same note. The correspondence between their speeches was rather remarkable. The Minister for Defence said that there are two well-defined stages. There is, first of all, the ordinary normal, peaceful stage, where occasionally a man commits a crime; and then you have the other stage, where there is civil war and martial law is proclaimed. But he said there is an awkward stage which comes in between. This is the awkward stage. This is designed to bring about the civil war and to lead up to the proclamation of martial law. Why? Because the men whose mandate is now expired, who must face the electorate within twelve months, dare not face it with the record of utter failure which is behind them. They are the men who, when people are starving in Ireland to-day, when we have 80,000 unemployed, squandered £14,000,000, as Deputy MacEoin said, on the Army They are the men responsible for the Shannon scheme which was to cost 5¼ millions, and has cost 14½ millions. They are the men who are responsible for the beet sugar fiasco; the men responsible for the present credit crisis. They are the men whose misguided counsels and leadership have landed us into a financial debacle from which we might have escaped if there had been better hands at the helm. In order to cover up all that, and before they face the electorate, they are prepared and are anxious to bring about that awkward stage which will inevitably lead to civil war and the proclamation of martial law.
When I hear the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Justice talking smug platitudes, when I hear them talking about murder, and when I know what is in their minds, that it is nothing but the wholesale murder of their own countrymen that they are contemplating, I remember the lines of Shelley:
I met Murder on the way,
He wore the mask of Castlereagh,
Very smooth he looked, yet grim;
Seven bloodhounds followed him:
And one by one, and two by two,
He tossed them one's heart to chew.
Only in this case we are not going to have seven bloodhounds—we are only going to have five—five officers of the secret tribunal; five officers to sentence to death political opponents for any act, even the most harmless and innocuous that a Minister of State, a member of the Executive Council may certify to be an act done with the object of impairing or impeding the machinery of government or the administration of justice.
That is the state of affairs you are bringing about. I ask men of substance on the Government Benches, men who are engaged in trade in this country if their own personal fortune and futures will permit them to bring about that state of affairs? Can you not see that the course you are embarking upon, even if in good faith, is one attended with unavoidable dangers; that this thing which they are asking you to do is a thing which I say will inevitably breed disorder? When one man is killed, it must lead to a desires for revenge and to the seeking of retribution and retaliation. Can you not see that? Weigh the future of inevitable disorder in the balance against Article 17, and ask yourselves whether the game is worth the candle; whether it would not be better to tear up the whole Constitution, tear up Article 17, and let every man elected by the Irish people, believing in the destinies of the Irish people, come into this House and legislate and deliberate for the benefit of the Irish people. Is not that the safe way out, the sure way out? Is not that the way which will restore that peace and order in our midst which we all desire and which we all, once the necessity is brought home to us, will do everything to safeguard and pre serve.
Comment on this
Main question put.
Do you agree with this result?