Twenty-Seventh Report of the Committee of Selection. - Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill, 1931—Second Stage—(resumed).
Contributions 93–223 of 223. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 43 of 1931 ›
I think Deputy Everett stated that there would be a considerable amount of discontent in the country when it came to consider this Bill. I think there will, but it will have a touch of the divine discontent about it, and it will be helpful discontent. It will be the discontent of a man who is forced to exert himself, being rather reluctant to do it, but with the kind of idea in his mind, that he remembered exerting himself on a previous occasion, that when he got into his stride he rather enjoyed it, and that when he was over his exertion he had a very pleasant feeling about it all. There has been a lot of talk about making this a national question. Like every other question, it is a national question.
Deputy O'Kelly tells us that Governments are set up to overcome difficulties. If Deputies lead themselves into the belief that, by the electors of this country setting up a Government, they have done something which relieves them of all the effects of original sin, they are going to be disillusioned. The Government can help to organise things for the people so that the people can do their own work and solve their own problems. When we discussed here some time ago a Relief Bill for the city of Dublin, Deputies protested against the terrible amount of money that was going to fall on the city of Dublin because of it, and said that that money was going to be spent by the city of Dublin on country people. To-day we have Deputies protesting on behalf of Dublin, and in order to relieve Dublin of some of the financial responsibilities for housing, suggesting that this should be made a national matter—that is Dublin Deputies think that the country outside Dublin should be made to give financial assistance to Dublin towards the solution of its housing problems. We have rural Deputies demanding that this should be made a national problem in order that some of the financial responsibility for dealing with housing in rural areas will be put on the city of Dublin.
Comment on this
It cancels out in this particular way, that Dublin people get rid of their financial responsibility in their own mind, and people in the rural districts get rid of theirs, and they also say with Deputy Fahy: "hang the cost now." If the cost is hanged now, neither the Dublin people nor the rural people will get rid of their financial responsibilities. That is where we come back to local government for local problems, so that local problems as part of the general national problem will be faced responsibly in the first place, that they will be faced by people close down over the job in the second place, so that the work will be critically looked at, and will be as well done as it can be, as a result of that critical inspection, and that the cost will not be hanged. This is a matter of local government. The State has, up to the present, borne a considerable amount of the cost of housing. In the country there are 24 urban authorities making a profit out of housing for the working classes. That is, so far from raising anything in the rates they have a small income from houses for the working classes.
Deputies from the rural constituencies have criticised this Bill. I appreciate their attitude in the matter. Deputy Reynolds criticised it on behalf of Leitrim, and Deputy Allen criticised it on behalf of Wexford. What is the position of the housing of our rural population, the population that Deputies say bear the greater part of the financial burden of running this country? The housing conditions in Leitrim are comparable to the housing conditions in Rcscommon, Galway and Mayo. In some aspects there is an improvement in Leitrim in contrast with Galway and Mayo. These four counties account for 100,000 inhabited houses, and of these houses 70 per cent., or 70,000 houses, have less than four rooms. That is, they are three-roomed houses and under. The position of Wexford is that there are about 20,000 inhabited houses, and 18 per cent. of these have less than four rooms. They are three-roomed houses and under. Both have the same complaint. In Wexford the housing conditions are such that only 18 per cent. have three rooms and under; the same complaint in respect of this Bill is made by the Deputy from Leitrim, where 70 per cent. are in that condition. We are asked under these circumstances to solve the rural housing position. We are not told anything as to what are the things in the rural housing position that we are asked to solve. In every county in respect of which Deputies have spoken, the percentage of the population living in urban houses containing three rooms and under is much more localised, and there is, therefore, a different type of sanitary problem, and it is also greater in percentage than in the rural areas. It is an urgent and pressing problem. Nevertheless, even as regards that problem there is no facing of the facts, there is no facing of the responsibility for dealing with the matter. We are asked in these circumstances to spread our efforts to a consideration of bringing, first, the rural housing in Galway, Mayo, Roscommon and Leitrim to the position in which rural housing is in Wexford, and then improving rural housing in Wexford. It is all dealt with nice and airily, and lightly, and with great sweeping gestures. This is a great national problem, a problem of first importance that the Government must deal with. The Government is going to deal with it by bringing close up under the noses of the people generally, before the local authorities, who are part of the whole government system, the facts of the problem. The facts of the problem are that housing has to be improved, that it will take money to do it and that the money must come from the people.
Deputies mentioned agricultural labourers and said that they got 9/- weekly. I say that a country whose main industry is agriculture, which cannot pay its labourers more than 9/- a week cannot put them into decent houses. I do not accept that the agricultural industry is in the position that Deputies suggest. But it shows how completely people run away from facing this problem of housing.
What does this Bill propose to do? In the first place, in dealing with the clearance of insanitary areas in Dublin and in cities like Cork and, perhaps, Limerick and Waterford, it will be found necessary to put up apartment houses. Our experience is that a reasonably sized apartment costs more, as such, than if it were a single house put up on its own site. We considered that the limit to which any local authority should go in building an apartment house would be £450. We are giving annual grants towards principal and interest to the extent of a present worth £162, leaving the finance of a single apartment house in an apartment scheme in this way. The local authority will bear 36 per cent. of the capital cost, the State will bear 36 per cent. and the occupier will bear 28 per cent.
Comment on this
We are giving the local authorities grants under certain conditions. The details of the scheme will be a matter for discussion between the Department and the local authorities. It will be for them to agree as to how the local authority will allocate the financial burden between itself and the tenant—
Comment on this
Am I to understand that the Department will fix the maximum figure for rent and that the local authority will make up the difference between what the Government pays and the occupier pays?
Comment on this
Everything will depend on the details of the scheme. So far as the Dublin position is concerned, we are not so much out of touch with it as some of the Deputies suggest. I am pointing out what is going to happen in Dublin City, so far as we can see at the moment. There is the fullest possible co-operation and harmony in dealing with the housing situation in Dublin. That is not special to Dublin. We intend to stand over the development of the attack on the housing problem generally in urban and rural areas in the same close way that we do in Dublin.
Comment on this
Will the Minister answer the question: is it intended that in arranging the loans to the local authority the Department shall fix the rent to be charged for the flats provided?
Comment on this
That will all depend on the circumstances as we go along. We have stood over every scheme put up to us and considered it on its merits in relation to the particular locality to be dealt with. We considered very carefully the opinions and suggestions of local authorities. I do not want to bind myself here to saying that we will fix particular rents.
Comment on this
The Minister realises that he is talking about a housing scheme which is not the scheme contained in this Bill. He is talking about a scheme in which the local authority will put up £ for £ with the Government.
Comment on this
I am talking about our general housing policy, and I say that in respect to that particular type of building, in so far as we can talk in general terms, we contemplate that a local authority will bear approximately 36 per cent. of the capital cost, that we shall bear 36 per cent. and that the occupier will bear 28 per cent. If Deputies cannot take that as a clear statement of our intentions, I fear we could not make it clearer by going into details.
Comment on this
It is very hard to understand how the Minister arrives at 36 per cent. Does he contemplate that if a house costs a certain amount he will insist on a certain rent being charged? If the house costs the amount he has in mind, the 36 per cent. will work out all right; but if the house is built at a smaller price, would it still be necessary for the local authority to pay 36 per cent.?
Comment on this
I emphasised that these figures were referable to a cost of £450. Surely any reduction in costs would go to the relief of the State and the local authority.
Comment on this
If a house is built for £400 as against £450, the particular percentage of the loan charges payable by the State annually will be less than if the house cost £450.
Comment on this
The percentage of subsidy is stated in the Bill. Does the Minister say that he can give less than the amount fixed in the Bill?
Comment on this
We propose to give 40 per cent. for fifteen years, and 33? per cent. for twenty years.
Comment on this
It is fixed in the Bill, and it will mean the outlay of less money by the State if the cost is below £450.
Comment on this
If in a scheme of apartments the cost is £450 and in another scheme the cost is £400, and the local authority decide that they are going to charge the same rent for both schemes, the percentage paid by the occupier in respect of the second scheme will be bigger than 28. We cannot bring a blackboard in here to demonstrate the matter.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants to have it that way, he can. All I can hope to do is to try to give Deputies a general idea of our policy here.
Comment on this
If the local authority is in a position to suggest that the occupier is able to pay a bigger rent than what we suggest here, we will be very glad to examine that situation. We certainly are not tying ourselves up in the way of permitting falling building costs to reduce the rent to a figure to which rents should not be reduced.
Comment on this
I take it, it depends on the particular schemes and the particular areas. I hope that a certain number of Deputies at any rate do understand that what we propose in the Bill is to fix the contributions in respect of different classes of houses.
Comment on this
Are we dealing with the Second Reading of the Bill, and am I trying to reply in a Second Reading speech on a Second Reading debate, or am I under cross-examination?
Comment on this
Section 29 has nothing whatever to do with what I am talking about. Section 29 fixes the valuation for particular houses in respect of which we bind the lessors to keep them in proper condition. As I say, I am trying to reply in a general way to the criticisms of general policy that have been made here. As part of that reply I want to re-state the financial assistance we propose to give in the case of different houses. That financial assistance is a contribution towards the principal and the interest, based on the total cost of the houses. We have nothing else in the Bill beyond that that will prevent our examining every scheme put up to us, and seeing whether the local authority is bearing its fair share, taking into consideration the capacity of the occupier to pay the rent, and the general reasonable policy in respect of rents generally.
Comment on this
Yes. It includes the all-in cost of the house. There are cases in cities and in urban areas like Ennis or Wexford where a process will be undertaken of rehousing persons who are taken from insanitary houses which it is proposed to demolish or taken under a general scheme of clearance or improvements—cases in which houses will be destroyed or, at any rate, will no longer be used as habitations. Persons will be removed from these insanitary areas and rehoused in some way or another as a result of new houses being erected. In respect of every new house so erected it is proposed that the State will bear for fifteen years 30 per cent. of the loan charges and for a further fifteen years 20 per cent. of the loan charges, involving a contribution to the local authority as if they were getting a lump sum of £82.
Comment on this
The Minister visualises a position where it is necessary to clear an area and to knock down houses. Supposing there are isolated cases of houses here and there where there is overcrowding and where it may be necessary to remove the families without demolishing the houses. Am I to understand then that the contribution would be less than 30 per cent? What does "displacement" actually mean in this?
Comment on this
"Displacement" means taking persons from insanitary or unfit houses and putting them into new houses and demolishing the insanitary houses or utilising them for non-habitation purposes.
Comment on this
Supposing we take a person out of an insanitary house, or supposing we get a closing order against the house without wishing to have it demolished, and insist upon the owner putting it into a state of repair?
Comment on this
Surely these are points for the Committee Stage and not Second Reading points at all?
Comment on this
That suggests to me too thin a way to avoid the clearing up of insanitary areas that we have in mind.
Comment on this
There may later on arise cases of that particular kind, but there are too many cases to-day in which there are houses that should be destroyed and families taken out of these houses to warrant my agreeing too easily to a situation like that. Let us discuss the equivalent of the grant of £82 as against the removal of a family from an insanitary house, the demolition of that house, the levelling and the clearing of the site and the putting of the family either into a new house or into a better house as a result of transferring another person to a new house. The third way we propose in respect of houses not costing more than £400 all-in, for a member of the working classes, independent altogether of any clearance area, is to give what is the equivalent of a grant of £45. That £45 is in relation to an expenditure of £400, and if the all-in cost is less than £400 the grant will diminish. We propose in respect of houses that have been built by local authorities and by private persons between 1st April last and the coming into operation of this Bill to give local authorities grants towards interest and principal on these houses that will be equivalent to an immediate grant of £60.
Comment on this
Yes; that is, a house sanctioned since the 1st April last. To private persons building since 1st April last, when the 1930 Bill ceased to operate, we propose to give this grant of £45 to which they would have been entitled under the 1930 Act. I realise that Deputies consider that in many parts of the country labourers' cottages cannot be built, but there are many parts of the country in which local authorities are anxious to build. Hitherto we have given them a grant of £50, and they have had to find their own capital. Now we propose to open the Local Loans Fund on the same terms as we opened the Local Loans Fund to urban authorities. We propose to give them annual grants towards interest and principal that will be of the same value to the local authorities as if they were giving a present grant of £60.
Comment on this
I cannot make any statement as to the terms upon which money will be given. Some Deputies have suggested that I should make a statement promising better terms. Our policy is to give local authorities the best possible terms that we can give them based on the terms upon which the Government itself can borrow money.
Comment on this
Does not the Minister know the terms which the Government can give, and that criticism might be different if we knew the terms?
Comment on this
If the Government can borrow money on cheaper terms than that at which we are now borrowing it, you will get it cheaper and on better terms.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say whether it is going to be an annuity charge or interest on sinking fund?
Comment on this
The local authorities have been paying their loans on the annuity system. Under this Bill they will be paying them on the instalment system.
Comment on this
The payment will be heavier in the beginning and will taper out towards the end. The grants paid each year by the State will be heavier in the beginning and will taper towards the end, so that during the time when the heavy charge will be falling on the local authorities, they will be assisted by the heavier grant from the State.
Deputies have been worried about whether this Bill is going to assist urban housing. I think it was Deputy Hogan who said that it was framed by the metropolitan mind. Deputy Law has been talking about the bad conditions of housing, say in Ennis. Well, housing is bad in Ennis. We had to carry out in respect of urban areas an examination of the condition of housing in 1929, and at that time it was reported that there were in Ennis 200 houses that were unfit, and 100 houses that were below reasonable requirements. Our policy in respect of places like Ennis would be that the housing that would now be carried out there would be housing done in relation to the wiping out of these 200 unfit houses and rehousing the people that were in them; and we propose in respect of each house built for that purpose to give a grant of £82. The urban Deputies suggest that that should be a national charge, that is, that some one else should pay besides the urban area. We had reason to put a Commissioner into Ennis at a time when the town rates in Ennis were 16s., apart altogether from what was paid in poor rates. Inside six years the town rate has been reduced from 16s. to 9s.
Comment on this
I do not want to allow that to pass. It is not fair to the local body that was administering the affairs of Ennis to suggest that it was maladministration or inefficient administration on their part that put up the rates. The Minister ought to know that there were certain income tax and such charges as were withheld during the British occupation here that ran up the rates in that particular district. Although I do not want to say anything against the administration of a man who cannot defend himself here, I want to say that the rates were reduced by the simple expedient of raising the valuation and lowering the rates and sacking about 20 workmen.
Comment on this
Well, at any rate the ratepayers in Ennis have to pay 7s. less in their rates now. That meant a reduction in the amount of money taken from the ratepayers in Ennis in any one year of over £3,000. And if Ennis was able to pay £3,000 unnecessarily because it was not managed in a different way to the way in which it is managed, it ought to be able to make a contribution towards its housing.
Comment on this
Has the Minister considered that £3,000 in relation to the increase of valuation and seen how it would work out?
Comment on this
It was not a flat increase. In one case it was increased 10 per cent., in another 8 per cent., in another 20 per cent., and so on.
Comment on this
I am eliminating any increase in the valuation, and I am suggesting that the rates raised from Ennis in 1926 as distinguished from 1922 were not less than £3,000 and I am suggesting that Ennis, which was able to pay that, can afford to pay something towards its housing problem; and I do not see why any other part of the country should be asked to relieve Ennis from paying that amount of money that will, under this Bill, fall on it towards dealing with its housing problem. Deputy O'Connell says that the attitude of the Government in throwing responsibility on the local authority under this Bill is different from the attitude of the Government when it interferes in the matter of the typist who is going to be appointed in a local area.
In the first place I think that it comes very badly from the Leader of the Labour Party and from Deputy O'Connell in particular to suggest that it is unreasonable that the Department of Local Government should interfere with a local authority for refusing to appoint to a particular position the person best qualified for it. It may be wilful blindness and ignorance and all that, on my part, but I believe that I am helping the local authority and fitting them to bear their responsibility, if I see that they get for the positions which they have to fill the persons who are best able to do the work of these positions. And when the local bodies throughout the country are organised upon the lines upon which we are trying to organise them, the saving effected in Ennis is only indicative of the saving that will be made in local government generally. Our policy in the matter of housing and other things is to secure that some of the money that is now going to waste through bad organisation and bad administration may be saved, and that the rest of it may go into productive work and into the solving of the people's problems, rather than be fritted away in the manner in which the expenditure is being fritted away to-day. This is our view with regard to Ennis, Dublin, Limerick and Cork. So that we are not inconsistent when on the one hand we say that a local authority shall bear its burden in the matter of housing to the extent of 50 per cent. and bear its burden in other matters, and when at the same time we interfere with them to prevent them from appointing a person to a position who is not the person best qualified for that position. We are making the matter a national problem, realising that the national problem can only be dealt with by being satisfactorily dealt with in its own little bits here and there and by seeing that the machinery and all that reach the national standard that the people are looking for when they talk of national affairs.
Deputies have addressed themselves to the question of costs. We cannot, as I said before, using Deputy Fahy's mind on the matter, hang the costs. The costs matter materially. If it is a fact that we have to address ourselves to improving rural housing conditions in a radical way, after we have made people more reasonable in facing the problem of urban housing, then the costs matter materially. I do not know what Deputy Reynolds, Deputy Maguire, or Deputy Brodrick think is the amount of money required to be put into, say, Mayo, Leitrim, Galway and Roscommon, to make the housing conditions what they want them there. I have no conception of what amount of money will be necessary to bring the housing conditions there up to the standard that exists in Wexford, with which Deputy Allen is displeased, but it must be an enormous sum of money, and it can only come from the people. Costs cannot be transferred, as Deputy Little would transfer them, to headquarters here to review and examine them. From my point of view, I want local authorities, aided by their qualified engineering and other officers, to scrutinise the costs. I want them to do that in sympathy and in full co-operation with our technical officers in doing the same thing. We have not that now, because all local people want to put the responsibility on headquarters. We really do want to get a sound outlook on who is to bear the burden. We cannot simply turn round and say that all government should be financed centrally. It certainly is not unreasonable to raise money on the rates for local government problems. We should have a clear understanding that you cannot have government without local government, and that you cannot have government without those people who are taking on themselves the responsibility for local government shouldering their own responsibility; and as part of the general governing system we cannot sit down in a detached, unbiassed and critical way to examine these things which require thorough, careful, systematic and continuous examination if we are to remove the waste and inefficiency in them that ought to be removed, if we are to solve such problems as the housing problem. I say that we have not the critical examination of the details of building schemes in urban areas on the part of individual members of the urban councils in co-operation with their own technical officers that I think we are entitled to get. We are helping, in so far as a central office can, to solve problems that local people have, and if we could, standing over the ground that this Bill sets out, get local authorities to address themselves to the problem in the spirit that they were prepared, if only for a trial, to bear their share of this cost of housing, we could for the next few years create a very different position with regard to housing. We could get a more reasonable outlook on the standard of houses. I submit to Deputy Lemass that it is absurd to talk of five-roomed houses, and of taking nothing less than four-roomed houses, in the light of the conditions obtaining in Dublin. I suggest that no better housing board for Dublin could be got than the Dublin Corporation.
Comment on this
Provided they had any liberty to do what they wanted to do and no restrictions by the Minister. They cannot even use native materials.
Comment on this
——and are doing it in spite of the building costs; in spite of the conditions that Deputies O'Kelly and Lemass commented upon yesterday. As I say, whatever their restrictions may be you can get no more satisfactory housing board for Dublin City, to talk of no other place, than the Dublin Corporation. I suggest to Dublin Deputies, at any rate, that t'ey might give up talking of a National Housing Board and give the Dublin Corporation a five years' chance with the work that they have before them, before they talk again of a housing board.
Comment on this
Would the Minister give the Dublin Corporation absolute freedom in the matter of housing?
Comment on this
They are prevented from using native materials because they cannot be got as cheaply, in some cases, as foreign materials.
Comment on this
At any rate, whatever restrictions we put on the Dublin Corporation we will do it, and have done it, after thoroughly talking out the whole matter with them.
Comment on this
The Deputy was asking this morning to be told when we got a letter from the Dublin Corporation telling us what they thought of the assistance they ought to get towards housing. He does not know of such a letter.
Comment on this
I will do no such thing. I will tell the House, in reply to the Deputy, that the Finance SubCommittee of the Corporation, and that the Housing Committee of the Corporation, which is a Committee of the whole House, dealt with the matter.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not know that our inspectors, our technical officers, sat down with the representatives of the Dublin Corporation to discuss their recent Mary's Lane scheme. The Deputy is too far away from housing in Dublin, and he has shown it by his intervention here.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister to prove here that the Dublin Corporation only agreed to build houses provided the Government could give them a loan at 3 per cent.
Comment on this
The Deputy is ignorant of definite letters that passed between the Dublin Corporation and the Department on a very important matter.
Comment on this
Would the Minister be surprised to know that because of his statement I got into touch with the Corporation and was informed definitely by the City Manager on the 'phone that no such letter to his knowledge ever emanated from the Dublin Corporation.
Comment on this
The Deputy might look up the letter from the Dublin Corporation of the 15th August, 1931, in regard to the Housing Bill.
Comment on this
Quote the Dublin Corporation letter correctly and accurately or do not quote it at all.
Comment on this
The Deputy seeks to evade the discussion of problems proper to be discussed here by bringing in matters to the Dáil that are proper to be discussed in the Dublin Corporation.
Comment on this
We want understanding on the part of the representatives on the local body. They are the representatives of trade, industry and business drawn from the people who have to shoulder this burden. They have officials that are in most cases good officials and if they have not good officials it is their own fault. At any rate they have their officials trained technically. Surely it is very hard to suggest that any housing board here at the moment could do more effective work for this national problem than each individual local authority, together with their officials settling down to the problem, making their plans and subjecting them to the most through criticism of estimates and tenders for building houses put up to them.
The policy of this Bill if it does create discontent will be the preliminary discontent of putting than problem up to the local authorities and their officials and it will be very temporary. Once they sit down over it there will be no discontent, and there will be the realisation that it is placing the burden of housing fairly upon the people by placing it partly upon the ratepayers and partly upon the taxpayers in the way in which we propose to do it here.
On the question of rural housing Deputy Corry referred to the Land Improvements Acts. I appreciate the fact that reference is made to these Acts here. I did not know that money is being made available much more cheaply from the Board of Works under that Act at the present moment than under the Agricultural Credit Corporation scheme. I would like the rural authorities looking around them and seeing calmly and detachedly what is the general condition of housing in their counties, to give a somewhat clearer conception than we have been given here of what improvements are necessary. The facilities embodied in this Bill for rural areas are in the first place an increased grant from £50 up to the value of £60 and the opening of the Local Loans Fund on a 35 years period at the same rate as is available to the urban authorities; the opening of the Local Loans Fund through the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act, to give loans to private persons in rural areas to build houses and a grant of £20 as a lump sum to such persons provided that the local authority gives another £20. Deputies have asked how could anyone who knows anything about the county councils or the boards of health expect that they are going to give £20 to any private person to build a house in their area. I would take that as a commentary on the opinion of the locally elected representatives upon the housing conditions in their area and it would make me feel that they were not terribly worried about them.
Comment on this
At any rate they are elected by the people from among the people and they have a broad survey of the conditions and you cannot in justice to any problem in the country or in justice to the general well-being of the people themselves take the country's conscience and put it here. If this thing is a national problem surely there is a national mind upon the matter, and if there is no national mind upon the matter then there is no national problem. If the County Council of Cork or the County Council of Galway are so satisfied with the conditions of housing in their areas or are not satisfied to give £20 to assist the policy that the Government have been carrying on in special conditions for the purpose of assisting private persons to put up houses, I must say that I would be very calm for a while.
Comment on this
Would you take the view of the county councils in regard to the appointment of county medical officers of health?
Comment on this
I would not. All this talk there is about housing shows that someone thinks there is a problem, there is a terrible problem and a national problem. The county medical officers of health are the machinery that will help to get that problem defined systematically and thoroughly so that we will know precisely where we are.
Comment on this
They are part of the machinery which makes local government effective. There is no county council that has got a county medical officer of health that would let him go. I think I am quite justified in insisting in the gradual and reasonable way we are doing it—that county medical officers of health will be appointed in the counties. If we had our counties equipped with county medical officers of health qualified for the position; with the county engineers qualified for their position, and with managers, I would not be afraid of the housing problem in this country not being solved, or in any other problem, because we would have spread all over the country machinery for dealing with a national problem. If the national problem is dealt with in Carlow, in Monaghan, and in Mayo in their own separate little ways, it is being dealt with all over the country.
Comment on this
Then you will be a long time waiting if you depend on the county councils.
Comment on this
To a certain extent I have not been depending on the county councils or on the county medical officers of health. I do see a general appreciation of the situation on the part of the county councils— that we are proceeding in the right direction and that we are helping. It is not the loudest voice that is raised at the county council meeting that reflects the opinion of the county council as a whole.
Comment on this
That is the voice that will affect the giving of a grant in this case.
Comment on this
As I say, personally, I would wait very calmly for a while as regards rural housing if that was the attitude of the county councils.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware of this: that the Carlow County Board of Health would not strike a beggarly rate of 1/2d. in the £? They refused to appoint the county medical officer of health until the Minister compelled them.
Comment on this
If that is so, then a large percentage of the speeches that we heard to-day about rural housing being a terrible national problem is simply all talk.
Comment on this
Supposing we built houses in Leitrim costing the county council £20,000, perhaps, that would be, approximately, 3/4 in the £ on the rates. Where are we going to get that money, in Leitrim?
Comment on this
Deputy Brennan speaks of the reconstruction under the 1924 Act. The intention of the 1924 Act was that large houses in urban areas would be turned into an increased number of dwellings. The Act was not tightly drawn to cover that and grants were given for actual reconstruction, but the thing was stopped because it did not meet the intentions. If reconstruction is necessary in rural areas, then I do suggest the Land Improvement Act, or the Agricultural Credit Corporation is sufficient to meet it.
Comment on this
Then we are being dragged along in this way because in urban areas post-war conditions stagnated the building industry, and we had to turn and assist in the first place the building industry by bringing money into it. In the next place we assisted urban dwellers by putting money into houses. That was because we had to deal with that post-war problem; now we are getting away from that; we are putting money into the housing of the poor and the removal of insanitary areas. As we are getting to that we are going to be called upon to give assistance to people in rural areas, who ought to be able to improve their own houses or to build their own houses on borrowed money.
Comment on this
Not from the Agricultural Credit Corporation. The reason I raised the question at all was that the Agricultural Credit Corporation knows nothing whatever about the reconstruction of farm dwellings. You have only one office that knows anything about this question of the housing scheme and that is the present Local Government Department, and unless you leave the reconstruction of the farmers' houses to that Department there is no use in going to the Agricultural Credit Corporation for money.
Comment on this
Well then, with this kind of new responsibility, if you like, thrown on the local bodies they would turn definitely to the consideration of what they think requires to be done for rural housing in the country. Then we can get down to the consideration of it. But as I say that Deputies in areas like Wexford have definitely the same complaints with respect to rural housing as Deputies from Leitrim and Roscommon. The situation is not by any means clear, and I feel that words have been used here in respect of rural housing that have nothing but vague ideas behind them. We must get down to a thorough estimate of what the conditions are and what exactly requires to be done and what the conditions will be when that has been done. But with the general financial conditions of our people as they are and with all the terrible talk there is about the absolute bankruptcy and inability of the farmers to pay for anything, we cannot turn round and put down proposals for improving housing conditions and improving them to a point when we are not told what these conditions should be.
Comment on this
Quite a number of detailed matters have been raised here on the question of Irish manufacture. Again it is a question of getting down to every individual thing for every individual scheme and seeing what the effect of it is. I notice in these discussions here that a tile in Monaghan can be Irish manufacture, but a concrete wall in South Dublin is imported.
Comment on this
I drew attention to the fact that the present proposal put up from the South Dublin Rural District Council based on the desire to use Irish manufacture would have kept a number of people indefinitely out of being housed, and you have to relate the increased cost in house-building to keeping a number of people indefinitely out of being properly housed, and you have to relate what profit it is to the country through the giving of a particular amount of employment in the handling of Irish materials against the loss it is to the country to having a certain number of families for an unlimited period not properly housed. But so far as Irish materials and the use of Irish materials are concerned we have to sit down in case over case with the local authorities and argue out the pros and cons. There is a limit in increasing the cost beyond which we cannot be prepared to go in the use of Irish materials because of the fact that it keeps people out of being properly housed. Deputy O'Kelly raised some point with regard to the acquisition of sites and the cost of arbitration. I do not know if I got the Deputy quite correctly on the cost of arbitration. The costs of arbitration are not great. In the most recent award we had in Dublin in a case of £5,800 the total cost was less than £50. Now I come to the matter of acquiring sites. When acquiring sites you are taking their property compulsorily from the people. You are compensating them for it, but a certain amount of formula has to be gone through. An inquiry has to be made as to who are the owners and the sub-owners likely to be involved. Now in the proposition we put down here in this Bill for acquiring sites and entering on those sites we have made a contribution towards shortening the time. Under the old arrangement an appeal could be made to the Circuit Court against the action proposed to be taken on the merits.
Then you had legal costs. In connection with that you had appeals which might go to the High Court. We have cut that out and have given appeals to the court on the question of the validity of the order and we have introduced into the Bill an arrangement by which, when the order has been confirmed and before the consideration of the compensation, the local authority can, on very short notice, go in on the land and begin to carry out its work there, waiting for the assessment of the compensation. We have shortened it in so far as it can be reasonably shortened.
In conclusion I would say that there can be no thorough and satisfactory examination of our housing requirements and no satisfactory control of the actions that will be taken to provide the necessary houses and clear away the insanitary houses that exist except by thorough co-operation on the part of the local authority and their officials and we can promise them on our part the fullest assistance that is in our power.
Second Reading agreed to.
Comment on this
I am afraid Wednesday would not give us time to get in our amendments. There are a number of our Party who are anxious to give consideration to amendments. We will not meet again until next Thursday, and there would be no opportunity of submitting them or of having them discussed.
Comment on this
I realise that. I understood that there was a general consensus of opinion to take the Committee Stage on Wednesday and the Final Stages on Friday in order that the Bill might get to the Seanad and become law before Christmas.
Comment on this
There is that anxiety. There is certainly no anxiety on our part to put obstacles in the way of the Bill, but there is an anxiety among the members of our Party to get an opportunity of discussing amendments before putting them down.
Comment on this
I am prepared to enter into any conversations that may be necessary to shorten matters. I understand that recommendations are being made by the Dublin Corporation. I have not yet seen them except in so far as they were in the Press. There will be a thorough and sympathetic consideration of these matters between myself and the representatives of the Corporation. If it would assist Deputies to have the Committee Stage on Thursday, it being understood that we can take the final stages on Friday, perhaps that would be agreeable to them. If Deputies have any representations to make on the matter between this and then I would be very glad to meet them.
Comment on this
The amendments I had in mind were not amendments so much from the Dublin Corporation as from Deputies living in the rural areas. I imagine that amendments which might have to be submitted from the Corporation's point of view will probably be in in time, and can be discussed with the other amendments; but with regard to the other amendments I am afraid that it would be difficult to have them discussed and put down before Wednesday. They might on Thursday.
Comment on this
I do not really see what amendments rural Deputies could put down except looking for more money.
Comment on this
I must say that if any effect is going to be made on myself or the Minister for Finance in connection with that, that effect will have to be made while the discussion is taking place here. On that question I will not enter into any conversations or negotiations. For my own part I am terribly hardened until I see a lot more daylight as to how the local authority, generally, are going to consider the propositions that are in this Bill. However, if the Deputies wish to have the Committee Stage put down for Thursday, we might be able to get the Final Stages on Friday.
Comment on this
I recognise that it will not be possible to get in amendments to this Bill that will be effective, but I am wondering if the Minister would consider it desirable and feasible between now and the Committee Stage to circulate an explanatory statement as to the financial clauses. It would be very desirable and would shorten discussion.