We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Adjournment Debate: Unemployment.

Contributions 96–201 of 201. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Fifteen per cent. tariff does not satisfy them, and the fact that only 10 per cent. of the boot requirements of the country is supplied by the home manufacturers proves that.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

What is the reason for that—is it not the high cost of living here?

Comment on this

Has the cost of living been raised because of these tariffs? Will Deputy Gorey take hold of the "Irish Trade Journal" and look into the index figures? If he does he will find out whether the cost of living has gone up or down. Civil servants know that it has gone down.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

It actually went up last week.

Comment on this

This is sheer bunkum to say that the cost of living has been raised. The fact is that the cost of living has proportionately fallen more here since 1926 than in any other country in the world.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Does the Deputy know that it was raised within the last few months?

Comment on this

Deputy Morrissey says "Even Deputy Lemass does not pretend that the protectionist policy is going to abolish unemployment." It is. That is an outstanding factor that the figure of 80,000 unemployed represents the number that can be absorbed into employment if we give protection to our industries. That number of unemployed can have work found for them. There is coming into this country every year £18,000,000 worth of boots, clothing, apparel, furniture, bacon, flour and articles that can be produced here by our own people. It would take the labour of 80,000 men and women to produce these goods. At the present moment those 80,000 people are employed in factories in England, Germany, United States, and Japan making these goods to be sold here in competition with the products of our own factories. We are depriving that number of people of employment here. We could transfer all that employment here if we want to do it.

Comment on this

Have tariffs prevented unemployment in the U.S.A.?

Comment on this

The conditions in America are different to the conditions here. This is the only country in the world since 1922 that has a continuously falling population. It is the only country inhabited by white people that has a falling population. That fact, and that one fact alone, distinguishes the problem here from the problem in any other country. The population of Great Britain, the United States, Germany and these other countries is going up, and the unemployment in those countries is due, unfortunately, to some extent, to the fact that opportunities for work are not increasing in the same proportion as the population is increasing. That is why unemployment exists in those countries. Unemployment persists here and is getting worse despite the fact that so many people have emigrated since 1922.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy considered what has happened in Australia?

Comment on this

Let us consider the problem here. Deputy Law cannot quote Australia for me in order to ignore the fact that we are importing into this country goods that we can make for ourselves and goods which represent the labour of 80,000 people. That is a concrete fact that cannot be got over, and it is because this Government has ignored it and has allowed these things to continue that it deserves such severe condemnation, not only from the Dáil but from every responsible person in this country. The Minister for Local Government and Public Health tried to ride away upon the old canard that we were opposed to selling goods to England. That is sheer nonsense. We are prepared to sell goods to England.

We are prepared to sell every single thing that we produce and that we do not want for ourselves in England or anywhere else. But the one fact that we want to emphasise is that there is available at home a market for Irish products that has been neglected. We are not getting a fair deal from England. That has been pointed out not merely by the Fianna Fáil Deputies but by the Minister for Industry and Commerce himself and by the High Commissioner in England. The High Commissioner in England has repeatedly called attention to the fact that the English are not giving a fair deal and that they are not buying our produce to the extent that we are buying their produce. The three million people here are buying more British goods than any other country in the world, and that fact should not be forgotten when there is any question of negotiations for trade facilities as between ourselves and England. That is one fact that we should rely on to safeguard our position.

The Danes do not buy one-third as much from England as we buy, yet England buys from Denmark almost double the amount of goods she gets from us. We have a market here at home that this Government has persisted in ignoring because the eyes of the Government are on Britain all the time. We are not belittling the importance of the British market. We realise its importance, but we do not want you here to belittle the importance of the home market. The home market is more important for us. It is the only market in which we can conserve our position and regulate our prices so as to ensure a fair return to our producers. So much for the Minister for Local Government.

There is a personal note I want to introduce now. I was informed that the Minister for Agriculture, replying to the case made from these benches, made a personal attack upon myself and on two other members of the Fianna Fáil Party. He said I was a professional politician and was making a living out of politics. To a certain extent that is true. It is true to this extent that I am giving my whole time to the furtherance of the cause with which I am associated.

I have alternative means of earning a livelihood if I choose to avail of them. It is true to that extent, and true not merely to-day, but for a very long number of years, that since 1918 and during that period opportunities of improving my position, opportunities of adopting a profession, opportunities of feathering my nest were allowed to slip. I gave, as I said, the whole of my time to the furtherance of that cause, and I am still doing it. In my opinion I have nothing to apologise for in doing that, and I do not think the jibe of the Minister for Agriculture is going to carry any weight with people who know the situation. I can say that such conduct on my part must appear very foolish to a Minister with the mentality of the Minister for Agriculture. It is certainly true that never to my knowledge did he sacrifice a penny on behalf of any cause since he announced his conversion to the national movement by subscribing five shillings to the Dáil Loan in Loughrea. I can retort by saying that he is a professional politician, and can point to the fact that he is on the pay-roll of this nation to the tune of £1,700 a year; I could point to the fact that he is not the first nor the only one of his family to be on the pay-roll of this nation. He poses here as a farmer. Let Deputies on the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches inquire as to how exactly the farm came into the possession of his family. They will understand that in the West of Ireland the old slogan of "the land for the people" has been changed to the new one of "the land for the Hogans." I do not like dealing with this matter, but I feel that the jibe made here is one that may be made again. It was one inspired by the President of the Executive Council, who has repeatedly wagged his money-bags before us and told us he has not to depend on politics for a livelihood. Neither have I, nor any member of this Party. So long as the cause with which we are associated has not been victorious we are going to continue until we bring it to victory. I think members opposite should feel a sense of shame if they think that someone like the Minister for Agriculture, by a jibe of that kind, is going to help the political fortunes of their Party.

Comment on this

I am sorry that anything the Minister for Agriculture has said should hurt Deputy Lemass. I must say that I have a great deal of sympathy for politicians on any side of the House. I think it is the last life a man who is matured like me should tell any young man to select. At the same time, in repelling the charge for the Minister for Agriculture I am afraid the Deputy did not speak strictly to facts. The Hogans always had land, plenty of it, and they got it honourably. I will not say any more about Deputy Lemass in his references, because he was done more than justice by Deputy Fahy during the absence of the Ceann Comhairle.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I was here for that. What strikes the Ceann Comhairle is that the term "professional politician" ought not to be a term of reproach at all. I think the House is foolish not to take up the attitude that in fact the term "professional politician" is not a term of reproach.

Comment on this
A Deputy

It was meant to be.

Comment on this

I know that Deputy Fahy kept his tongue in his mouth when there were abominable charges made against Ministers on the Front Bench, when it was stated that they set up dumps on the eve of the Kildare election. I am not going to make any apologies for saying that. We have heard a great deal about protection. There has been a very considerable measure of protection in this country, and it does not seem to have had any great effect. We have protection on boots, and an energetic Cork firm took advantage of it. They have certainly done very well at it. Why are there not more factories of the Cork type throughout Ireland? Is there something wrong with the other people who have boot factories? If they had succeeded as well as the Cork factory we would not be in the position that we are in to-day of having to import such quantities of boots. It would be well to be candid about these things. We have tweeds and woollens on which there is a very stiff tariff. I have scarcely ever seen an advertisement by manufacturers of Irish-made goods— and splendidly made, I must say they are—as to where these Irish-made goods can be had in Dublin. When I was looking for a suit made with Irish materials I had to tramp half the city making inquiries where I would get it. While Deputies opposite were making all these speeches I was surprised that so little was said by way of telling the people why they should use Irish goods.

Deputies on the opposite benches must represent nearly 40 per cent. of the population and if that 40 per cent. supported Irish manufactures there need not be such weeping here to-day. We heard a lot about the price of Irish butter in England and that normally it is not bought there. Why? Before the Minister for Agriculture took up the question of the production of butter under the best conditions it was a very poor article in Ireland, and it left an unsavoury reputation in the chief markets that we had. The position is quite different now. If the Minister had never done anything else than placing Irish butter on the English market as it is placed there to-day he deserves well of the country. It is the same way with the breeding of cattle. When I visit a fair now and compare the cattle with what they were twenty years ago they are certainly 30 per cent. better bred to-day. The Minister was attacked about grass land. We heard about Meath, Limerick and Tipperary in support of that attack. Some of these counties, especially Limerick and Tipperary, are dairy counties. If you take up the list of insured people you will find that proportionately these counties have a larger number of insured persons than any other county in Ireland. That is rather instructive when we hear reference to grass land. It all depends upon what grass land is for. In Meath many of the people who fatten cattle in the summer, stall feed them in the winter and in that way give a good deal of employment. The Irish market, unfortunately, is not of very great importance for the simple reason that it is too small. We could never consume in this country all the beef and butter that we produce. We must find a foreign market. If the new conditions in England are what we believe they are to be, there will be a substantial improvement here within a few months. There is already a very great improvement in the price of wheat and oats. That is not due to the Irish market, but to the English market.

How does it affect the Irish farmer? He has to pay more for the feeding of his cattle, and whether fattening them or keeping them for stores when he exports them he gets no better price at present, so that the higher price of corn in England has done the farmer no service there. That was the policy of the Opposition all the time. If you increase the price of feeding stuffs you see what the result is.

Deputy Aiken referred to the gentlemen on the front benches and used the word "gentlemen" sarcastically. He told them that they should go to what he considered was their spiritual home—England—and to do the washing for the English people. Looking at Deputy Aiken physically, tegumentally, and pigmentally, he is the last man in this House that I would call an Irishman. I think that if we are going to be lectured someone with an Irish name should stand up and lecture us.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Somebody with Irish blood anyway.

Comment on this

I have spoken in this House on many occasions on unemployment, and I think it is rather a pity that there is a necessity to do so again. In view of the fact that there are, even according to the Government figures, approximately 75,000 people unemployed, there is a big necessity for Deputies on these benches to deal with it. To my mind the discussion this afternoon has been noticeable for three things. In the first place, it has been noticeable for the absence of speakers amongst the rank and file in Cumann na nGaedheal, with the possible exception of Deputy Hennessy. As far as Deputy Hennessy's contribution to the debate is concerned, I regret to say that his speech was an apology for a lack of policy on the part of the Government. I am sure the Deputy who represents Dublin City South would not deny that unemployment is rampant in his own constituency, either in Inchicore, the Coombe, or other districts. The second point for which the debate has been noticeable is that not one of the six so-called Farmer Deputies has taken part in it. That is understood, in view of the fact that the Farmers' Party has been swallowed up by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. It is well known that the Farmers' Party in this House does not speak on behalf of the small farmers. The third point for which the debate was noticeable was the speech of the Minister for Finance, in which he did not endeavour to outline a Government policy for the cure of unemployment. After hearing that speech, one naturally came to the conclusion that the Government have no policy with regard to this big problem. In the course of his remarks the Minister said that we must get down to actual facts as they exist here. One of the faults that I find with the present Government is that they do not look the facts as they exist in the face. They have survived for a number of years on a policy of make-belief, by endeavouring to persuade the people that the country is prosperous. We have been told that we have turned the corner. According to some Ministers we have turned the corner so often that we can hardly keep up with our own shadows. The Minister for Finance treated the House to a lecture on economics. In my opinion, that was quite in keeping with the Manchester Liberal School of Economics, from which, apparently, the Minister for Finance and the Government take their policy. He told the House that unemployment was a relatively small problem in the Saorstát, although according to the figures issued by the Department of Industry and Commerce there are about 75,000 people looking for work and unable to secure it.

The Minister for Finance apparently has taken his cue from the speech delivered here on the last occasion by Deputy Byrne when we were discussing this matter. Deputy Byrne seemed to think that we have something to console ourselves with in the fact that unemployment exists in other countries to a large extent. But, although it does exist in other countries, that is no reason why Deputies should not endeavour, in a sensible, businesslike way to cure this unemployment problem. One other statement made by the Minister for Finance, in my opinion, proves that the Government is bankrupt in policy when it is a matter of dealing with this question was this: he said, "We cannot cure conditions here in regard to unemployment." That statement that we cannot cure conditions here in regard to unemployment, in conjunction with the statement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce some time ago, in which he said it is not the duty of the Government to find work for the unemployed, is an admission of failure on behalf of the Government to cope with this problem. It proves that they have no policy with regard to unemployment.

Up to the present three Ministers have spoken. I presume another Minister will speak before the debate comes to an end, but no Minister who has spoken so far has endeavoured to outline the policy of the Government on this matter. They have no policy to cure this condition of unemployment and to find work for the unemployed. The Minister for Finance said they will not adopt any quack policy. What policy have they adopted or what policy do they intend to adopt for the future? We have not been told, either by the three Ministers or the one Deputy who spoke from the Government Benches. Deputy Hennessy, who represents Dublin City, pointed out that the Irish manufacturers, so far as his constituency is concerned, are not advertising as much as they should do. I quite agree with that. And in that respect I would draw Deputy Hennessy's attention to one matter. There is in this city a firm known as the Donegal Tweed Company. They have two branches, one in Henry Street and the other in George's Street. They have been registered in a Government Department here as the Donegal Tweed Company. They are not an Irish firm at all. They do not sell five per cent. of Irish stuff. They are a cross-Channel firm owned and controlled by cross-Channel people, nevertheless the Department of Industry and Commerce allows them to be registered as the Donegal Tweed Company, misleading the citizens of Dublin. So much for the question of advertising Irish tweeds raised by Deputy Hennessy. I am one of those who believe that one of the principal duties of the Government of any country is to legislate in the interest and the welfare of the people. I believe that any Government that allows 75,000 of the people to be unemployed has failed in one of its primary duties to the people.

It is no consolation to the people of Donegal, or to the people in Kildare, in Kerry or in Dublin to know that unemployment exists in other countries. The only apology put forward from the Government Benches for the unemployment that exists at the present time is that unemployment exists elsewhere. It has been pointed out that we import every year millions worth of clothing, hosiery and boots. Speaking quite recently, the Most Reverend Doctor Mageean, at the annual meeting of the St. Vincent de Paul Society, said it was deplorable, so far as this country was concerned, that there should be so much poverty in the midst of plenty.

There are, as I have said, seventy-five thousand people unemployed. There are in the City of Dublin alone seventy-eight thousand people living in one-room tenements. Housing scarcity is not peculiar to Dublin. In my own constituency in Donegal there are forty-two thousand people living in two-roomed houses. In Mayo the housing conditions are as bad. I mention this condition of housing to prove the fact that while there exist unemployment and lack of work there are people looking for houses, waiting for them to be built. If there was a proper policy in regard to housing in this country, both in the urban and in the rural areas, it would go a long way to absorb the unemployed.

Some speakers were more concerned with taunting each other in regard to what took place in the past than in an endeavour to solve this problem. I believe that a great lot of the time of the Dáil has been wasted in enacting legislation of comparatively little importance when contrasted with the big problem of unemployment, and now, when the Dáil is going to adjourn until the 10th February, we are curtailed in the number of hours that we are allowed to devote to this discussion. I believe that if the Dáil were to do its duty it would close the doors of this Chamber and lock in Deputies of all Parties until such time as they found a proper solution which would absorb the 75,000 people unemployed, and in addition to that found a solution that would help to improve the economic position of the small farmers and fishermen.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. Hogan (Clare) Labour Party

There would be a riot.

Comment on this

If things do not improve as far as the unemployment of small farmers and fishermen is concerned there is going to be more economic discontent in this country now than ever there was before. Emigration is cut off. We were told by the Minister for Finance that some of the people who emigrated did so from a desire for further opportunity. Quite rightly so! The majority of the people who emigrated from this country did so for one reason and that is because they were unable to find work at home. They were unable to eke out a livelihood and provide for their wives and families. If some of them did emigrate from a desire for further opportunity it was owing to the fact that our agricultural and other industries have been neglected to a large extent in the past.

While some Deputies maintain that this question of unemployment is not so big, it might come as a great surprise to some of them to know that so far as unemployment insurance benefits are concerned they are lower in the Saorstát than in England, Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland, and there is a large number of unemployed at the present time looking for work and unable to find work who are not getting any unemployment insurance benefit—not one half-penny. Contrast that with the fact that expenditure on the prison service, taking into consideration the officials and cost of maintenance, amounts to £2 per head. We are prepared to expend £2 per head as far as our prison service is concerned, but on an unemployed man with a family possibly in a state of semi-starvation, we are not prepared to expend anything in the way of unemployment insurance benefit. Surely such a system should not be in existence. I say this to the Government, and I say it very seriously: It is their duty to get on with the business of finding work for the unemployed and if they are not prepared to do that it is their duty to clear out and make room for an Executive Council who will be prepared to face up to the problem and find work for the unemployed.

Comment on this
Desmond FitzGerald Minister for Defence (Mr. Fitzgerald) Cumann na nGaedheal

I am rather loth to intervene in this debate, which has largely been what I might call a sort of electioneering talk by the Opposition. The sort of the thing we have had is Deputy Lemass saying how things have got steadily worse here since the figures of the last census return were published. These figures were published in 1926, and Deputy Lemass said that things were in a worse condition now, and to prove that he says that unemployment has increased since 1929. The fact is that there is less unemployment here now than in 1926. The Government's general economic policy has been to increase the productivity of this country. That can take the form of either increasing the amount of production, or increasing its relative value in relation to other commodities produced elsewhere. At the present moment, when there is this extraordinary world condition, which to some extent has been produced by this rather mad policy embarked on in many countries of high tariffs, when the value of practically all commodities is falling in this country, where our enormously outstanding industry is the agricultural industry, the value of which, in terms of exchange, has been diminishing, while in many cases costs of production and overhead charges remain more or less stationary, it is actually proposed that we should embark upon a system of wholesale tariffs to improve our economic position.

Boots have been quoted. There is a tariff of 15 per cent. on boots at the moment. That means that the Irish bootmaker has a margin of 15 per cent., and can charge 15 per cent. more before he meets, on equal ground, competition from imported boots. It may be that boots have not gone up 15 per cent. But it does seem pretty clear that if there is business initiative and ordinary efficiency amongst the workers 90 per cent. of the boots imported, having to fight against the 15 per cent. tariff wall, would be produced here, if tariffs were going to be such an enormous salvation to the economic life of this country. It is suggested that a 15 per cent. tariff on one commodity, which, generally speaking, works out at a 15 per cent. increased cost to the consumer, is not enough. But at the moment, when the real productive industry in this country, farming, is facing up to a condition that is universal from world conditions, it is proposed that the price to the consumer is to be increased in order to make life more difficult to people actually producing, and that 15 per cent. tariff is not sufficient.

We are told about clothing and about cloth. There is a tariff on both of them. Yet we are importing a great deal. We have to put a much higher tariff on, we are told, and in the meantime what is to be done for the real producer in the country? Deputy de Valera said that he had no objection to our exporting a certain amount of our surplus industrial produce to England. The only sound economic policy is for us to consider what we can produce most economically in this country. It is well known that, with the advent of dry farming and owing to certain developments, the wheat-growing area of the world has increased enormously. The cost of production, however, and of wages in the great wheat-growing countries is about one-fifth of what it would be in this country. Part of the Fianna Fáil policy is that we should expend in money or labour five times as much as it is necessary to expend elsewhere to produce a commodity that can be produced better elsewhere. That is the policy that is to be the economic salvation of this country. We talk sometimes about taking in one another's washing; that, roughly, is the proposal of Fianna Fáil. But in ordinary economics it is not a matter of taking in each other's washing. It is a matter of the natural resources of the country, plus the intelligence and labour of the people in producing wealth. Fianna Fáil says we are not producing boots and cloth, for example, and that we have 80,000 unemployed here. Of course, the figures are all wrong. We are told that if we manufactured all the things that we want here we could employ the 80,000 people at present unemployed. It is proposed that the farmer must pay more for his boots than at present, while he is to compete, so far as exports are concerned, in a world market, that he must pay more for his clothes, and the ordinary people must pay more for their bread, so that we can have Irish wheat instead of imported wheat. It is assumed that we could produce all these extra things, that we could produce 500,000 extra acres of wheat and still continue to produce exactly what we are producing at present. I would call the whole thing childish, except that we know that it is not honest. The Fianna Fáil Party have used this occasion, as they do every year, to appeal to the most stupid and ignorant people in the country, because they are likely to have more force with them; they assume a depth of ignorance and stupidity in the country as a whole that is rather over-estimated.

The Government have produced a state of affairs in this country whereby we have less unemployment at the moment than any time since the census was taken—considerably less unemployment, and we have that state of affairs at a time when practically every other country has seen unemployment increase by leaps and bounds. Deputy Lemass said it is no good comparing this country with America. The United States of America has the greatest resources of any country in the world, except possibly Russia and Canada. It is not over-populated. It has a population of 120,000,000, whereas if populated at the rate of Europe generally the population would be 500,000,000. The United States is under-populated; it has enormous capital, and it is, industrially, enormously efficient, with all the latest machinery. It is a country with enormous natural resources; it is a country that has overwhelming tariff protection, and yet it is a country with an enormous amount of unemployment. Deputy Lemass says we cannot compare ourselves with the United States. We are a country with fewer resources. Our resources are in no way comparable, even allowing for the great difference in size, with the United States. We are a country, as far as our industries are concerned, badly equipped; we are a country equivalently populated with the United States relatively, and we are told now we can do what the United States of America did, by putting up this enormously high tariff wall. The United States, with its enormous populous areas, has great economic units for all its great production in its own area. We have nothing of that sort. It can indulge, without any exports, in the most enormous mass production which cannot be carried out here if we are to depend upon the home market.

Yet Deputy Lemass says for the semi-illiterates presumably who read Deputy de Valera's paper "Do not compare us with America. Everyone can be employed, we can keep on our standard of living and rates of wages. We can improve the position of the farmers generally. Do not compare us with America, because we, with our natural resources, are more favourably placed than the United States. Do not compare us with Australia." Australia is a continent almost as big as Europe. It has twice as many people as the Free State; it has enormous resources and it has enormous wheat-growing areas. But Australia has also enormous unemployed. We should not be compared with Australia or the United States because we have not the natural resources and advantages that those countries have. The Party opposite try to play upon the misfortunes of the people of this country. They said in 1922: "The more unemployment the better it will suit our policy." That is what is happening now. They spent the whole afternoon preaching that there is the most dire and appalling situation in this country, exaggerating that side, and at the same time saying that the whole limitations placed upon humanity can be overcome, that everybody here can be employed and well-to-do, in spite of the world conditions, that we can supply everything people need in every commodity, and at the same time export to England our surplus commodities, which does not happen in any other country. What are the conditions in this country? Less unemployment now than three years ago, the only country practically in the world in that condition. Our conditions of labour are better practically than those of any other country in the world. Our rates of wages are better practically than any other European country. Our standard of living is really high, because, although our people may not live as well as other countries, the value of the consumption in the ordinary household is higher than in any other country, because we have in this country more waste than in any other European country.

What does the Government propose? The Government proposes to use every means in its power, as it has done in the past, to increase the value of our production. It may be that our butter and eggs are actually getting less than some time ago when world prices were higher. Relatively we get much higher prices for our butter now than we would be getting for our butter if we were producing under the same conditions as in 1922. We have never preached to our people a panacea or nostrum that is going to overcome all suffering in the world, because there is no such thing and the people who preach that doctrine are simply dishonest. We have told the people that there is to be no escape from hard work. In 1922 and 1923 Fianna Fáil were telling the people that they did away with unemployment by burning houses and carrying on the work of destruction. That idea is at the back of their heads all the time. As a Government we cannot, even if we wanted to, deceive the people as our friends opposite can.

We have improved the quality of agricultural production. We have selected certain tariffs and applied them where the conditions of the country indicated it would be possible to produce economically with them. We never proposed that we should grow our own tea in glass houses rather than import it from China or India. That is the sort of doctrine preached by Deputies opposite. They try to terrify them, as Deputy Lemass did, by a little dishonesty and by saying to them "there is more unemployment now and things are worse now than they were in 1926." He proves it by saying that things have disimproved since 1929. We are about the only country in the world, thanks to the sound policy due to the courage of this Government, and we are about the only country in the world in which there is less unemployment to-day than there was in 1926.

Comment on this

What about emigration contribution? You had not that in 1926.

Comment on this

We had emigration in 1926.

Comment on this

If you had not?

Comment on this

I am comparing the position now with that of 1926. If we take such countries as England, United States, Germany, with their big tariffs, and assume that every emigrant is back here and add these to the number of the unemployed here—we know that at this moment men are coming back from America to this country because they expect conditions to be better here than in America—taking all that into consideration I still say that our conditions have improved, and that these conditions are entirely dependent upon the Government and are a tribute to our Government. Deputies opposite pretend that the Government can do everything. It does not matter whether people work or are decent citizens, the Government can do everything and produce heaven on earth for all the people. On that basis, taking these things into consideration, it will be found that we have done better than an enormously wealthy country like the United States, better than Germany and better, practically, than any other European country. We have done that in face of particular difficulties because we have no great natural resources. A man in the United States may become a millionaire overnight by discovering some enormously valuable mineral deposit. That does not happen in this country nor is it likely to happen. Production here is largely agricultural. There is not going to be any sudden accession to wealth, there is only going to be the exploitation of the resources of the country by the hard work of the people. People who go about pitying others, telling them that they have to work too hard, that they ought to be far better off than they are, that there should be no unemployment and that they can indulge in any wild policy they like, and that everything can be made perfect by putting the people who give these assurances into power, are dishonest and are preaching a policy that would lead this country to disaster. We have no policy that will make this country enormously prosperous to-morrow or next month. Our policy is to improve the position of the country and to safeguard the well being of the people in a way that has not happened in any other country in the world.

By our financial policy we saved this country from disaster such as happened in Australia. We have not indulged in an enormous tariff policy; we had a sane tariff policy which to a certain extent has been successful. Our observation of it, and we are in a better position to judge than people who write only for propaganda, for the purpose of getting advantage out of it, but who have no real interest in the facts, is that it works well. They taunt us, and ask what have we to propose to the people. What we propose is this: The people have seen that in those years which have been a disastrous period in world history this country has held its own as no other country has. Has that been done because our wealth was more, and we had greater resources than other countries? Nothing of the sort. We had fewer resources than other countries. This country has held its position because things have been well managed so far as the Government of the State has gone. And it has been well managed in spite of every vilification and in spite of every attempt to undermine the authority of the Government, and despite the covert support of people who aim at the disintegration of the country. The Government have improved the position of the people in this country—a poor country—while the Governments of rich countries have seen their position disimprove. That is due to the fact that you have a Cumann na nGaedheal Government here and not a Government going round with their panaceas and nostrums without any care for the well-being of the people and only anxious to fool the people and to get their votes.

Comment on this

rose.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

When shall I be allowed to conclude the debate?

Comment on this

Does the President want an hour to conclude?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

If he were not interrupted he could do it in less than an hour.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Is it agreed that I start at 9.30?

Comment on this

We will give him a good hearing.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The position is that the debate must conclude to-night in the nature of the motion. There is nothing to prevent the President from intervening at any time.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I understood that there was agreement yesterday that the debate would conclude in two and a half hours. It was generally agreed that that would be quite enough. We have been four hours at it now, that is two hours beyond the time allotted yesterday. I should have thought that the time acceptable yesterday would have been acceptable to-day.

Comment on this

We are prepared to allow the President start at 9.30.

Comment on this

The Minister for Defence in that brilliant intellectual manner that characterises him, when he talks about ignorant people and semi-illiterates, has taunted the Fianna Fáil Party, as other Ministers have done in the past, with preaching panaceas and nostrums for the cure of our economic ills. It is a very unfortunate thing that there are ignorant people and illiterates in the country, but these ignorant people and illiterates, in my opinion, because they belong to the lower class of the unemployed and to the most poverty-stricken section of the population, deserve more consideration from Ministers than the wealthy people who, no matter what they have suffered in the recent financial crisis, nevertheless are able to carry on. They know that next year they will be able to carry on. At any rate, they know their families are not going to starve. The position of the unemployed is quite different and when the Minister tells us that we are saying things for the special benefit of the ignorant and the illiterate, I simply have to say that it is a fact that the Fianna Fáil Party has the support of a large section of the people whom he would characterise as ignorant and illiterate. It does not matter how ignorant or how illiterate they may be they are entitled to their rights under the Constitution and to their full rights as citizens. I submit that under the theory of government as it is now understood, not perhaps under the Minister's theory, but under the theory of government as now understood in every civilised community, you will have to pay attention to the plaints of these people whether you agree with them or not. If you continue to ignore them, particularly when these people are increasing in number, you will soon find yourself in the position that you will be compelled to do things that you have scorned to do previously. That is the position we are in in this country. As Deputy Morrissey has pointed out, up to the present we were in the position that we were exporting a large section of the population, but we are not doing that any longer.

When Deputy Dr. Hennessy comes along and tells us that we have a very valuable asset in the lands of Meath, Limerick, or Kildare, or some other county, in the agricultural economy of the country, my reply to that is to put against it the thousands of people who live in the bogs of the West of Ireland and ask further whether you are going to make a choice, as you will have to make a choice, as to whether you are going to persist in your present agricultural economy or whether you will make a determined effort to place these people on the land, give them some security on it, and show them that they can exist on the land. Where you are up against conditions of that kind you will have to make a choice, and I suggest the Government should have that point of view. I suggest that whatever Government may be in power they should not allow the situation to drift as it is drifting until these people are driven into methods as a result of which they will not be allowed to plead their case in a constitutional fashion. When they are outside the Dáil they are characterised as anarchists, criminals and bandits, and if the second largest Party in the State dares to assert that they have the same rights as the President and the Minister for Defence, monied men as they may be, we are told then that it is electioneering tactics and that this Party is making the utmost capital they can out of the question of unemployment. I think the Ministers must know that the question of unemployment is one for the community, and that no matter what Party is in office, and no matter what arrangement is sought to remedy the situation, there will always be people in the country who will cry out that the Government is not taking satisfactory steps or proper steps to deal with the situation. Whether the Fianna Fáil Party are dishonest or not they would certainly be lacking in intelligence, greatly lacking in intelligence, if they pretended to the country that this question of unemployment could be solved overnight. It cannot, but what they say is that you want a determined effort to solve it, and that the policy of drift that is at present imposed is leading nowhere, that unless you turn your ship round and sail in the opposite direction you are going to have confusion worse confounded and the present depression and state of affairs aggravated.

We hear a great deal of talk about the English markets. We have often heard it stated in the wilder moments of the Minister for Finance, if you can imagine the Minister for Finance having wilder moments—he is not a man who as a rule has wilder moments —that if you adopt a certain policy England is going to put a tax on Irish cattle going into that country. That is not the first time that that threat was used. It was used 100 years ago when the Irish people were fighting for the abolition of the tithes and fighting for a national government, when they were crushed by an ascendancy. They were told by the ascendancy and the agents of the British Government in this country that if they dared to assert their rights England would put a tariff on our cattle. One of the Catholic leaders of the day, Dr. Boyton, remarked: "Well, if the struggle comes, let it come, but I ask who is going to lose most in the contest. Is it we who are exporting food, the staff of life, who are going to lose, or is it the English who are exporting manufactured articles to us, because through their manufacturing ingenuity they are able to confer an immense value on articles of little intrinsic worth?" Is it they from whom we are purchasing 80 per cent. of our imports, is it they from whom, as Deputy Lemass pointed out, this country, with a population of only 3,000,000, is nevertheless purchasing more than any other country, is it they or we who are going to suffer most if a situation should at any time arise in which the British Government could say: "We will refuse to buy your food in future"? I submit that when this question comes to be settled, if it has to be settled, the men who represent this country need have no fear. No matter what happens here the Irish people are not going to suffer. England is feeling the pinch to-day more than ever she did.

The Minister for Defence made a number of statements comparing this country with other countries, and suggesting that our circumstances were infinitely better. Some of the statements he made in the burst of rhetoric that flowed from his lips are absolutely devoid of foundation. I do not care what statements have been made by the Fianna Fáil Party either here or down the country, they have a better foundation in fact than some of the statements made by the Minister here to-night. He has said that our rate of wages is higher than that of any other country in Europe. That cannot be substantiated. In fact, if the Minister for Defence goes through the report of the Tariff Commission on the tariff for oats he will find that agricultural wages in the Free State are lower than in any other country in Europe except one. If you add to that the fact that large numbers of our agricultural labourers unquestionably cannot get employment, that unquestionably large areas have gone out of cultivation, that unquestionably large numbers of farmers are unable to carry on or to give employment—so much for the position of the agricultural labourer. And if you tot up all the other factors in the agricultural situation in the Free State I do not know how you could possibly say that our agricultural conditions are comparable with those in other countries. Certainly, I think the Irish Free State farmer, in regard to the produce he is able to put into the English market or any other factor of importance, is not to be compared with the Danish farmer.

Let us turn to our position in the British market. We are not, as the Minister for Defence stated, getting a higher price in the English market than other countries. As I stated before, and as I repeat, we are being passed out on the English market not alone by Denmark and old competitors who had a great advantage over us at the start in that market, but we are being passed out by new countries like Finland, Esthonia, and Lithuania. The Minister has also stated that we have increased our productivity. Wherein have we increased our productivity? I grant that were it not for the measures taken by the present Government our farmers would possibly be in a very much worse position. Nevertheless the fact is that we are losing ground as compared with these competitors. Not alone are we losing ground, but we are not even exporting now in the total volume of our agricultural exports what we were exporting before the War. We are only exporting 45 per cent. of our bacon and 80 per cent. of our butter. How can the Minister conclude after nine years in office that we have increased our productivity when they have lost ground in the way I have indicated? Deputy Dr. Hennessy expressed the pious hope that conditions are improving in the English market. There may be some fluctuations. Temporary advantages may accrue to the Irish farmer, at Christmas time, for example, because of increased sales. But everyone knows that if conditions do improve it will be a long and tedious process. If the Government are prepared to concentrate on the Irish market they should know that the Irish farmer's cost of living has not been substantially decreased, although wholesale prices have fallen very considerably. How is the Government going under this policy of concentrating on the English market, to secure a larger income for the farmer either by securing increased prices as compared with the low prices he is getting at present or by getting a larger amount of Irish produce placed on the English market? If you are banking your hopes on the Empire free trade policy you must remember that we are selling 96 per cent. of our exports to Great Britain and under what quota system or system of Imperial free trade are you going to improve that position for the Irish farmer?

If the English people are going to make a bargain with the Irish Free State, let the Minister for Local Government, who seems to have changed his attitude very remarkably to that great institution, the British Empire—he is now so terribly anxious to have a spirit of co-operation I almost wonder is he the man who led the Irish Republican Army against them a few years ago—but let not the Minister for Local Government deceive himself into believing that it is in any spirit of goodwill only that this question will have to be discussed. It has got to be discussed on a business basis. On what basis do the present Executive, if they are returned to office, propose to discuss it? Are they going to discuss it on the basis which the Minister for Finance has mentioned, that the reduction of disastrous tariffs which have ruined Europe should be the aim of this Government? Is it contemplated that under a bargain with Great Britain we are going to reduce our tariffs? When the Minister for Defence emphasises to the House this argument about the increased cost of living, let me remind him that although the farmer has not yet got the full benefit of the fall in prices, and that the Government are not taking steps to see that he will get the benefit, they have not taken strong measures to keep down the cost of living or to see that the decrease in wholesale prices should be shown in retail prices, rents, and so on. Nevertheless there is undoubtedly a general reduction in the cost of living.

To come back to the question of Imperial free trade, how is this Government going to improve the situation of the Irish farmer in the British market? They have not taken any steps here to improve his position in ways that lay directly to their hands. They have not reduced taxation in conformity with present prices. Neither have they sought to bring down retail prices and the cost of living, generally, in conformity with the prices the farmer is getting. If the Government said, "We believe to such an extent in this policy of the free market that we are prepared to recommend to the country a cut all round that will not only apply to the general expenses of a Government, but to the cost of living," they would then, I submit, be taking some steps to bring the position down to bedrock, which is necessary if they mean to continue this policy and enable the Irish farmer to compete on fair terms with his rivals on the British market. They are not doing that.

There is this position also, that our imports represent many million pounds more than our exports, and even if you make allowance, as has been argued over and over again, for invisible trade items, I submit a good case can be made out to show that during the past seven years your adverse trade balance, even including the invisible trade items, is something like £60,000,000. Whatever it may be, on the visible trade balance there is a deficit in the last seven years of £120,000,000. When the Government say that there is no panacea for economic difficulties and for unemployment, my reply to that is that that is no excuse when there is a period of depression and the probability of a continuing depression for allowing the position to drift. That is no excuse for your failure to put forward an alternative policy to the policy Deputy de Valera has put forward here to-night. That is no excuse for the policy laid down by the Minister for Finance that a reduction of disastrous tariffs which have crippled Europe is the aim of the present Government. The present Government have such a high and mighty opinion of themselves, since they got mixed up with the British Imperial Conference and the British Cabinet, that they actually think, because the necessities of the British Empire demand it, that other countries on the Continent of Europe are going to abolish their tariffs to accommodate John Bull. At least if they are going to do it it will be in the belief that their own economic system has been sufficiently established and built up to enable them to weather the storm themselves. They are not going to allow Britain, or any other country, to flood their markets with foreign goods.

If there is something in the argument that our conditions must be different from big countries like the United States, and so on, there are other arguments which make it more necessary and imperative that you should have, on account of your peculiar circumstances here, and the smallness of your resources, a very strong protective policy. You are up against a powerful manufacturing country that has been crushed out of other markets. Her chief market lies here, and is it seriously contended that the little tariffs you put on are a serious obstacle to people in Northampton and Leicester if they wish to dump their goods here? We know that these people will not close their mills. Many of them have made a sacrifice in keeping their mills open at great losses to themselves. When they have collared their home market and secured it for themselves, what is to stop them from dumping their surplus manufactured goods into this country? Remember that under their new currency arrangement they will be able to export goods at an advantage. At the moment it will be to their advantage heavily to increase their exports and lower their prices to foreign countries. I believe it will be their policy here also, although you claim that your currency is the same as theirs.

The Minister for Finance goes even further. Not alone has he departed, as Deputy O'Kelly pointed out, from the policy of Griffith, but he has departed from the policy of every other Irish national leader who believed that the first duty of a National Government should be to build up our own industry and our own country, and to get away from the existing system forced upon us by the Imperial Parliament within the last century—a policy which involved the ruin and depopulation of our country. The Minister for Finance has not alone departed from Griffith's policy, I submit he has departed from any shred of national policy in the extraordinary cosmopolitan views he put forward to-night. He says that God gave the whole world to man in order to get the best general standard of living he could. If that statement came from Deputy Heffernan, who is cosmopolitan by nature, and who believes to the last extremity in buying in the cheapest market, I could understand it, but coming from the Minister for Finance, who claims, on the one hand, that he believes to a certain extent in tariffs, and that the Government have done a certain amount in tariffs, and that in a carefully examined, selective way it will perhaps do more in the way of tariffs, and in the same breath assures us that the tariffs in Europe are the obstacle to the economic construction, let us say, of the Continent of Europe, what are we to believe? Is that the policy that is being preached in your Free State Embassies in Europe? Are we taking it in advance that this policy of Imperial free trade is going to be such a wonderful thing for the Irish people that we are going out in advance to herald it abroad? I would be very glad to know, when the President is replying, how long this policy of "down with tariffs" is in operation. Is it the settled policy of the Government, and has it been communicated to other Governments with which our Government is in diplomatic communication? God gave the whole world to man; but He gave us the Irish Free State to make what we can out of it. God does not expect that we should leave everything to Him. The policy of the Government is that of laissez faire. Leave everything alone. Do not interfere with anything. The policy of Fianna Fáil is a hard one. The people will have to make sacrifices. Deputy Dr. Hennessy said that he could not find Irish suits. If he goes down to the biggest wholesale shop in Dublin they will ask him to buy nothing but Irish suits. I agree the Fianna Fáil Party could do a lot in urging people to buy Irish material. Could not President Cosgrave, the Minister for Defence and the other monied men in the Government Party, and the monied interests outside who wish to be allied with them, not come forward when they saw a crisis in England and saw that their investments were in danger of being lost and say: “The Irish Free State is our home. It is the place we are interested in. We should appeal to those people to bring their money home before they lose it abroad”? It would be nonsense on my part to pretend that the Government can do everything, but I say if the Fianna Fáil Party were in power and did very little indeed they would be doing far more than the Government have done in the last nine years to bring that money home to Ireland to be invested in Irish industry.

The policy of drift, of laissez faire, of depending on something which may not happen, of depending on something which will or will not happen at the Imperial Conference, and so on, is not going to get this country out of her difficulties. Her difficulties are not insuperable. We have a small population. The Ministers in our Government should hang up charts of the number of unemployed in the country in their offices when they take office after the next general election, so that they might look at that chart every week, and if the curve is not declining, and coming down to the base line, say to themselves, “We are not doing our duty.” As to the number of unemployed in this country, if we set about organising and have a proper plan and programme we may be able to absorb them. We may not be able to absorb them all in two, three or four years, but in five years we ought to have made a considerable advance in a policy of wholesale reconstruction, a policy in which all parties will be able to co-operate and to which every Irishman would naturally and sincerely be able to lend his support and be able to be enthusiastic about, a policy that, he felt, whatever small financial sacrifices it meant either in putting his own money into industry or being taxed to support it, would, in the long run, be worth the sacrifice, as these people would be definitely absorbed.

Your present policy is that you have a quarter million pounds being spent in the congested areas. It is being spent through the Land Commission. If I went on the same lines as the Minister for Defence, and if I were to assume that all the men on the Front Government Bench were villains and rogues, and that their only anxiety was to make whatever capital they could and to get back into office by whatever means were at their disposal, I could argue and I could make a very good case to show even from recent utterances of the people on the Government Benches that that £250,000 was being used for political purposes and that the Government themselves, even those on the Front Bench, were not above taking an advantage that would accrue to them out of the spending of that money. Therefore, if we are talking about crocodile tears and about people not being really sincere about unemployment, let us carefully examine our own house and let us remember that people in glass houses should not throw stones. The Minister for Local Government and Public Health, who is now in the House, stated with great emphasis, or, rather, pointed out and emphasised that Deputy de Valera did not refer to Russia when he was talking about people and countries who are sending their butter into the English market and ousting our butter from that market. The Deputy did mention Russia, as a matter of fact.

Comment on this

He did not.

Comment on this

I do not know what particular significance the Minister had in that. Is it suggested that Deputy de Valera had his eye on the Soviet as the "Anglo-Celt" had its eye on Mr. Stalin? Is it suggested that by the omission of Russia from his speech he was acting deliberately, or that if Deputy de Valera mentioned Russia he was somehow going to incur the displeasure of the Soviet Government? I do not think that the Soviet Government are going to worry very much about what Deputy de Valera or the Minister for Local Government says about them or what they do not say about them. They are going to carry on whether we agree or disagree with them. They are going to carry out their policy whatever points in their policy we agree or disagree with. Whatever points are in their policy that we cannot agree with and that we feel are not suited to the conditions in our country, we must admit that they are making a real effort to build up their country. They have taken a number of years and they have said that at the end of that number of years they expect to make their country self-supporting as far as their manufacturing industries are concerned, and they feel that they are certain to do that. We could do with a little more of that spirit in this country. We could do with a little more of their will-power and determination and a little more appreciation of the difficulties. The Church and everyone else have emphasised that unemployment is the greatest social evil now existing. The present Pope has given it as his instruction to every Government in Christendom that it must be their duty no longer to say that unemployment is not their business, or that it is not their business to provide work for the unemployed. The Pope has said that in the future every Government must recognise the fact that if they do not make a serious effort to get the people behind them in a wholehearted endeavour by planning and by organisation to secure work for the unemployed that the unemployed are going to rise up against them.

That is what is going to happen in this country. Let not the Ministers shirk their duty. Let us take the attitude that this question of unemployment is too serious a question to be bandied about in a political debate. It is a question that demands the most serious and sympathetic consideration. We want to see the wisest and the best minds in this country attempting to solve it. We want all Parties to co-operate in future in building up this country. I sincerely hope that the outcome of this debate may be to send us all back to our constituencies with a firm resolution that no matter what may happen in the future we are all going to do the best we can and bring the best will of the community into the efforts that ought to be made for dealing with this pressing problem.

Comment on this

A great deal of play has been made in this debate and in nearly every other debate regarding the general economic conditions in the country, and especially as they apply to the agricultural situation. In the first place, on the question of supplying the home market we have had it preached to us that the first duty of the farmer is to supply the home market, and that when the wants of the home market are supplied then the surplus produce could be exported. To my mind that policy, as put forward, must be dishonest, and any man who examines it impartially must come to the conclusion that it is also unsound and dangerous. To what position would such a policy lead our farmers? It would lead them into working on lines that unfortunately would not be to their advantage but would lead very definitely to their disadvantage.

It must be accepted by those Deputies who talk about the desirability of commanding the home market as an axiom of trading that so long as we have an exportable surplus the price to be obtained in the home market will always be governed by the price that can be obtained in the outside market. Now, we have an exportable surplus with regard to bacon, butter, beef, mutton, eggs and so on, and if by some manipulation of subsidies or the control in some way of prices, we secured for the farmers the home market and then exported the balance, how do we benefit the farmers? Surely that is not good sense or sound policy. The primary consideration with the farmer, in fact the only consideration of the farmer when producing his goods, and the consideration which must govern all producers, is the question of price. Unless we can, by concentrating on production for the home market, increase the price of the article which the farmer produces, we do not stimulate the farmer to produce in great quantities. The policy put forward by the Opposition Deputies is a policy that is dishonest and unsound as well. I agree that it would be desirable perhaps from the national point of view to see the Irish people consuming, to a large extent, the produce of the land of this country. We would prefer to see the farmers consuming Irish bacon to seeing them consuming American bacon, but the policy put forward is unsound in this way: Our main market, our principal market for agricultural produce must remain, if conditions are to remain as they are, an outside market. Anybody who has any knowledge of conditions in this country knows that our main market must be an outside market. One of the primary considerations for us if we are to maintain our place in that market is not only to improve but to increase and maintain the quality of the article we export, and as far as possible to see that the quantity we are exporting will be as large as possible and that there is continuity of supply.

It has been stated here that the position of the Irish butter in the outside market has been steadily lowered. It has been lower than the price of the Danish butter. The price of our butter has been higher than the price at which some other butters are sold in the English markets. Generally the price of our butter is around about the price that is paid for New Zealand butter. But in the opinion of experts and all authorities one of the reasons for that, indeed the main reason for the low price of our butter, is that we have not been able to maintain continuity of supply and we have not been able to send the quantity of butter necessary to make the English people realise that our butter is an important commodity in the English market. The consumer of our butter in the English market is not yet aware of the fact that Irish butter is coming into the market in any considerable quantities at all. Even our people in many of the important towns of England do not know that Irish butter is coming on the English market at all.

They know that Denmark is an exporting country; Danish butter can be had in the shops the whole year round. Anyone with experience of agricultural produce will acknowledge that Irish butter at present is as good as any butter in the world. I am absolutely confident that butter going from Irish creameries to the English market to-day is as good as any butter that goes there. The price is not as good. Why? Because we have not held the market and because people have not become accustomed to Irish butter and do not ask for it. What would be the effect if we restricted the supply of butter that we send to the English market as we did last year by a tariff? It would injure us on the English market. I maintain that the same argument applies to every article of agricultural produce that we export.

Comment on this

What has been done to remedy that position?

Comment on this

Everything has been done that could be done. We have taken steps to improve the quality of the butter, to improve the condition of the creameries, to improve the farming, but there is the question of continuity of supply.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I prefer to hear the Deputy on unemployment.

Comment on this

It seems to me that the lesson of this debate is that we are dealing with unrealities, that Deputies are dealing with matters that, so far as they are concerned, do not exist. With the possible exception of Deputy Derrig all the speakers on the opposite benches assumed that the Government has power to cure unemployment if they would only assume that power. Deputies who assume that the Government has that power are confusing the situation. They are confusing the powers of Government with the powers of Providence. They believe that the Government has only to say "let it be so," and it will be so. "Let us not have unemployment and we will not have unemployment." What remedies have been put forward for unemployment? The main remedy put forward was the old remedy which we have up and down the country, and which we will hear about during the next two or three months and between now and the general election. We will hear that the cure for unemployment and for economic conditions is a policy of tariffs. We are going to have a policy of general tariffs.

When listening to the debate I was struck by the unreality of it and the lack of appreciation on the part of Deputies opposite of the serious situation that exists not so much amongst the unemployed—serious as that may be—as amongst the agricultural community, where the people are partly employed but are getting an unremunerative return for their work. We are told that the remedy for that situation is tariffs. We were told by Deputy de Valera that if steps are taken to produce for our needs here all the articles which we can produce, and that if we give protection, we can give employment to 80,000 people at once. We were told that if steps were taken to deal with the production of wearing apparel, including boots and clothes, we could provide employment for 25,000 people. Surely it is accepted that if we took such steps there would be an increase in the price of wearing apparel, and an increase in the present protective tariffs. There is already a protective tariff on boots of 15 per cent. and on wearing apparel of 25 per cent. We have also tariffs on woollen materials. We are now told that these tariffs have not had the effect of securing the home market for Irish manufacturers. We are asked to take steps to secure that home market for our manufacturers. How? Evidently the only step we can take is to increase the prices.

Comment on this

I would not like to be misunderstood. I did not say these were the only steps at all. A number of other steps will have to be taken of a much more active kind.

Comment on this

At least one of the steps that must be taken is to increase the tariffs.

Comment on this

The abolition of the oath will do it.

Comment on this

And the seizure of the land annuities.

Comment on this

How are such steps going to improve the economic conditions of the agricultural community? The members of the agricultural community are carrying most of the financial burden of this country on their shoulders. Already, owing to tariffs, these people have to pay increased prices for what they buy. I think it is foolish and dishonest to deny that these articles are not higher in price here than they are in outside markets. They can be had cheaper outside this country. I acknowledge that tariffs may be imposed in certain situations for the purpose of developing industries. I acknowledge that industries have been developed, and that they can be developed to a greater extent by higher tariffs, but always at a cost. In my opinion that cost would be an increase in the price of the tariffed articles. Taking into account the dire condition of the agricultural community —and that condition is very nearly desperate at present—we have no means at our disposal for increasing the price of what it produces and exports. Farmers get the export price. There has been a great fall in export prices. On the debit side of the farmer's ledger the prices which he has to pay for goods have not fallen commensurately with the fall in the prices of what he sells. Taking that into account, surely the economic condition of 50 per cent. of the community cannot be remedied by increasing the price of the things which these people must buy if they are to live and to operate. Surely that is not the way to stimulate and improve economic conditions for that section of our people. While it might improve employment in particular industries, the effect certainly would be to increase unemployment amongst the agricultural community. We would simply drive many of the agricultural community out of production. It is quite clear that many amongst that section are on the margin line. They are producing almost at a loss. It only requires the last straw to break the camel's back and to put many farmers out of production. The remedy we are offered for that situation is to increase the cost on the farmer.

I took a note of Deputy de Valera's remarks, and while I am not sure if I have his exact words, his speech was an extraordinary example of his outlook on agriculture. The Deputy said that we should first cater for the home market, and having done that endeavour to sell at any price we could in the export market. To my mind, that is an extraordinary attitude for the Leader of the main Opposition Party—one who possibly has ambitions to be in control of the economic policy of this country—to say that we should be prepared to sell our surplus agricultural produce at any price we could get in an outside market. Surely it is not our policy to dump what is left and to take any price for that surplus.

Comment on this

What are you doing with it now?

Comment on this

As Deputy de Valera indicated, he is prepared to take steps which will have the effect of increasing the cost on the farmer, thereby worsening the position. He is prepared to offer a remedy. What is it? It is the old remedy which we have had repeated again and again, which I thought was dead and buried, if not forgotten. The remedy was to encourage Irish farmers to grow wheat. In what way? If we are to take the policy laid down by the Deputy's Party it is to be by means of a subsidy to the farmers.

Comment on this

The same as beet.

Comment on this

A subsidy which will depend on the price of the article on the outside market. Farmers here can only produce wheat economically at 30s. a barrel. The Government would be obliged to make up the difference between the price the Irish farmer would get for wheat and the price of the imported wheat. Let Deputies opposite who support that policy examine the position. Let them look at the prevailing price of imported wheat during this season, and they will find that it was cheaper than it has been in living memory. I have not the exact figures, but I think it would be necessary to subsidise home-grown wheat to the extent of 15s. a barrel. Taking into account the quantity that would be required to supply the home market, the cost of the subsidy would amount to about £3,000,000. Yet that is put forward as a serious panacea for the evils of farmers.

Comment on this

What was the world price of wheat when 30s. a barrel was put up?

Comment on this

The price of wheat was very much higher than it is at present. The cost of production to the Irish farmer is still the same. I think the Opposition will accept the statement that the Irish farmer will require to be paid something like 30s. a barrel before he could be induced to grow wheat. The cost to the taxpayer would be something about £3,000,000. A subsidy of that kind would be a tax on the farmers because ultimately they are the people from whom most of the taxation must come. We are going to help the Irish farmers out of the position in which they find themselves by asking them to pay their share of the £3,000,000 subsidy, in order to induce them to grow a crop that is least suited to this country, and which can be bought cheapest in the world market. If we force the farmers to grow wheat we will put them out of production in some other article of agricultural produce which they are at present producing and selling in the export market. If that is the easy solution of the farmer's troubles I do not agree with it. It is not a solution. It would definitely worsen the situation. I agree that the problem is not confined to this country. It is a world-wide problem. There is depression all over the world, but the effect is greater in other countries than it is here. Unemployment is greater in other countries than it is here, but of course, that does not in any sense lessen our responsibility. We are trying to find a way out. It is our duty to try to find a way out. This Government is not bringing forward any newly found panaceas. Its policy is known to the country, and while conditions are bad, and the depression very serious, they are not as serious as they are in many other countries.

Comment on this

I would like heartily to endorse the sentiments expressed in Deputy Derrig's speech when he stated that the solution of unemployment should be the work of all Parties. I have always held that it is not the duty of a Government to solve unemployment, though it may help in certain ways. Even if it could solve unemployment I do not think it would be wise to entrust the solution to any Government. In my opinion a Government can, by wise and useful legislation, give assistance to people who are engaged in industry so that more employment may be given. We are living in a small country and I think the mistake that was made is that we have always before our eyes the four unfortunate years of the great war. The world has been going on for 1931 years, but we take four unfortunate years and set them up as the basis of our comparison. Everyone knows that the produce of the fields, which, after all, is the foundation of the wealth of the State, is practically back to pre-war prices. Anyone who faces facts must admit that. How can we expect to do this, that and the other thing when revenue is decreasing day by day? For instance the Minister for Local Government stated that he is only providing so much money for housing this year. Do people realise that it would take £2,500,000 to build to-day as many houses as could be built for £1,000,000 in 1914? That is the position we have to face. What we want is a sacrifice on the part of everybody, in order to try to build up industry and in that way to give much needed employment. It has been suggested that one of the means for solving our unemployment problem would be by the provision of more houses. And the suggestion has been made that the best way of solving the housing problem would be to set up a housing board. Does any man of commonsense think that by the setting up of a housing board under Government control houses could be built more cheaply than they are built to-day? A house costing £300 to-day built by a builder or by a public authority by direct labour would, under the conditions advocated by certain Deputies if a housing board were set up, cost £500. I shudder to think what would be the cost of a house under a housing board.

I ask Deputies who advocate the setting up of a housing board to read the report of the scandal in connection with houses built in Belfast, the capital of Northern Ireland. We all know the history of that board which was set up by the Belfast Corporation—graft, corruption, thousands and thousands of pounds gone astray, bad materials put into houses which were badly built, and the superstructure rotten. We all know the sensation that that created. Yet we have Deputies here putting forward this means as a serious solution of the housing problem.

I say that if instead of talking about unemployment each of us did our part in our own respective districts much useful work could be done. I do not want to eulogise what has been done in my district, but during the past year a sum of £45,000, £25,000 of which was spent on wages, has been spent in Dundalk. Within the last three weeks the Urban Council without waiting for their share of the unemployment grant of £250,000 have spent night after night devising ways and means of giving work to the unemployed. As a result of their exertions about 170 men have been given a couple of weeks work before Christmas. In addition to that, anticipating the grant we have put up a scheme which will be reproductive and we have got a contribution out of the £250,000, and we hope as a result of the assistance we have received, backed by a contribution from the Council, that we shall be able to give employment to fifty or sixty men after Christmas. I hold that the Government cannot solve the unemployment problem on their own. It is only the people by their united efforts can solve it. Who built the City of Dublin? Was it not the citizens of Dublin? Who built up the principal industry in Dundalk, Carroll's tobacco factory? Was it not the members of the Carroll family, who by their business capacity have been the means of making that factory one of the foremost tobacco factories not only in the Free State but in Great Britain? They are giving far more employment now than they ever gave before. Does anyone imagine that were it not for the attention they pay to their business it would be in the flourishing condition in which it is to-day? They have done all that without Government aid and above all without Government interference. The less interference the Government have in industry the better. Look at what happened in England when a party belonging to the people, the Labour Party, dabbled in this question of unemployment. We know the results after two or three years. Three millions unemployed in England and conditions worse than ever. The result was that the workers themselves rose up and hurled the Labour Government out of office at the last election. I would impress on both Parties in this House that the only way to solve the unemployment problem here is to stop all this talk that is going on and do away with all the suspicion and distrust at present prevailing. We want to restore confidence in the country. Let us all work together for the uplifting of the Saorstát and if we do that the problem of unemployment will be well on the way to solution.

Comment on this

There are two matters I should like the President to say a few words about. The first is the question of a bacon tariff which is connected with unemployment, because if the President looks up the returns he will find that the imports of bacon into the country are increasing continously while our exports are decreasing. It is quite clear that the consumption of bacon here is not increasing, so that the output of bacon must be going down, thereby causing unemployment. I was speaking to four or five managers of bacon factories the other day at a certain meeting, and they all said that they were getting more breeding sows into their factories to be killed than they could deal with. That is a bad position to have, because it shows that the people are getting out of pigs. The prices quoted last Saturday for pigs were 28/- per cwt. live weight, and 24/-for heavy pigs. That is the lowest price reached in living memory. What Deputy Heffernan said is quite true, that the farmer has reached his lowest point and another straw would be likely to break his back altogether. I think that the President ought to give us some hope that the Executive Council will not allow the bacon industry to go altogether. The Executive Council have powers to apply an emergency tariff in this matter. The second matter which we would like the President to say something about is in regard to the prisoners.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is clearly away from the question of unemployment.

Comment on this

I did not think we were confined to one question.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think we are.

Comment on this

Deputy Fahy spoke about this.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Fahy introduced it by saying that he was debarred from speaking of it.

Comment on this

Are we confined to one question in this debate?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

On occasions like this when a general debate may be taken, it is better to choose a particular subject and the subject chosen to-day was unemployment. That subject was chosen not only by the main Opposition Party but by the Labour Party, and I think we are confined to it.

Comment on this

The Deputy just wishes to put a question.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I shall let the Deputy ask a question.

Comment on this

We are all aware, although the Executive Council took particular care that no information should get out, how the prisoners are being treated in Arbour Hill. The Government even went so far, I believe, as to make counsel and solicitors sign a declaration of secrecy when interviewing prisoners. We are aware, however, from a released prisoner, that the conditions are as bad as they could be in Arbour Hill, that there is no heating and that the cold is intense, that the windows are altogether too small and that sufficient exercise is not allowed. These conditions are not such as prisoners, no matter how the Executive Council may hate them or how they may have hunted them down, should be asked to live under.

Comment on this

I protest against the suggestion that the Executive Council hate or hunted them down.

Comment on this

What else have they done?

Comment on this

I protest, sir, against it. In the first place, it is stretching things a little bit too far to introduce the question of the prisoners into this debate, but when the introduction of the question is made the occasion of an attack on the mentality of the Executive Council in the operation of the recent Act, I must protest.

Comment on this

Show some mentality.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The question we are discussing is unemployment, but in view of the long adjournment I am prepared to let Deputy Ryan ask a question. I think he will see himself that the longer the time he gives the President to reply the more likely he is to get information on this or any other topic. I think he ought to ask the question without making the matter the subject of a speech or of attack, because the matter is not open to discussion. I shall show him all the leniency I can in the circumstances.

Comment on this

I would be finished now only for the interruptions. I only want to ask the President, who has the reputation of being a very pious man and having a conscience, if he is going to give the House an undertaking, or whatever way he likes to put it, that these men will be treated as ordinary human beings during the term of their imprisonment, whatever it may be.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Ordinary human beings and ordinary Irishmen are responsible for the administration of the Act passed by the Oireachtas some time ago to deal with a particular public matter. Ordinary Irishmen having a conscience are engaged in the administration of that Act. I am quite satisfied to rely on their word, rather than upon the word of propagandists, as to the treatment of the prisoners. I have had considerable experience of this propaganda about prisoners. I am quite satisfied that if there was more truth in the statements made in respect of them much more consideration would be given to any representations made. But it is an unscrupulous, an un-Irish, and an unpatriotic attitude to take up, that Irishmen charged with the administration of affairs would be guilty of what the Deputy has said.

Comment on this

You ill-treated prisoners before.

Comment on this

We had experience of it ourselves.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

From what I see of Deputies opposite they do not look much the worse for it.

Comment on this

Would you like to hear our experiences? We have personal experiences.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

You can tell them on the hustings.

Comment on this

I want to put one question.

Comment on this
Deputies

Order, order.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Let us hear the President. This debate has been going on since 4 o'clock. The President is entitled to make his speech.

Comment on this

Will he allow an inquiry?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

The position is that ordinary patriotic Irishmen are administering this Act, and I am not going to take the word of propagandists in respect of allegations against them. Better Irishmen are administering it than those who are attacking them—much better. As regards bacon, the matter is under consideration. My recollection is that the Minister for Agriculture put forward an application to the Tariff Commission which is under examination at present. This whole debate savours of a general election. Practically all the speeches I have listened to from Deputies opposite, and some of the speeches from the Labour Benches—there were some notable exceptions—evidenced a desire on the part of Deputies to make their first election speeches here. I do not comment on that further than to say that unemployment is too serious a problem to be made the sport of politics. The recommendation which came from their Lordships the Bishops a couple of months ago inviting or imploring men in public life to sink political differences for the moment and see how far it is possible to find some solution for this and other social problems has apparently been forgotten, if it were ever read, by Deputies opposite. We have heard for some time past about the coming out of a great national newspaper. A great case could be made in respect of certain people who have impeded progress in this State, interrupted its industry, interfered with its commerce, sapped the confidence of the people and of capitalists who might be inclined to invest money in it. We have heard of an invitation from them to have a conference in respect of a group such as that. We have had no suggestion of an invitation from that great so-called national newspaper that was going to have truth in the news. The "Irish Independent" a couple of days after the debate on the Bill providing £250,000 for unemployment took the right note when it drew attention to the fact that no advertence was made in connection with that Vote or in connection with the problem to the desire of their Lordships the Bishops to have the matter considered in the light of commonsense, free from Party politics, to have some effort made to get a sensible, sane, business-like contribution towards what is admitted by all classes to be something which would require the wisdom and help of all sections of the community to solve it. It is a remarkable thing that a relatively small group of people could draw tears almost from the Labour Party and the Fianna Fáil Party when a conference was mentioned before, but there was no invitation whatever in connection with this very serious, very important and vital issue, not alone for this country but for every country.

What is the problem to be solved? Without pretending to be an economic expert, I say that there are four or five important issues in connection with unemployment. There is the peace and good order of the State. How many times during the past ten years has the business of the State been held up in an endeavour to restore public order when attention might have been given to this or other economic problem of much greater moment to the country and to the reputation of the country? There is the question of the value of the goods which we produce and the sale of the goods produced. There is the question of industrial peace. For some years in the early stages of this Government we had not industrial peace. For a couple of years past there has been industrial peace. There could be still greater industrial peace. There is the question of the credit available. There is the question of State and municipal charges. Most of the economic experts we have listened to this evening excluded these matters entirely from consideration. They are important matters; they are, as a matter of fact, essentials.

The main industry in this country is agriculture. Efforts have been made during the last ten years to improve agriculture. Various Acts were passed with a view to improving our agricultural production—the Live Stock Breeding Act, Acts to improve the quality of butter and the reorganisation of the industry, the sale and marketing of eggs and, within the last couple of months, the Dead Meat Act. It is obvious that the Ministry responsible for Agriculture in this country was alive to the interests of that important industry and that it did its duty. How have these measures been received? From Fianna Fáil platforms all over the country we have had references made to the cost of reorganising the butter industry. We have had criticisms of the low price of cattle and so on. In addition to all these things we established the sugar beet industry at a cost to the State, as I stated in July last, of £1,562,000 up to that date. Deputies made great play with that figure. On that occasion I stated the actual sum which the factory had either paid out in dividends or had in reserve, and the total sum was £560,000. We have had the statement made from Fianna Fáil platforms that the factory did not pay for the beet it got, that on account of a subsidy the beet was practically delivered for nothing at the factory. The facts are that somebody got £1,000,000 in excess of what the factory has made out of the transaction during the five years of the existence of the industry. That money was circulated within the counties growing beet and outside them, in railway freights and in various other ways. It was a considerable help to agriculture. The bargain we made was a better bargain than was made by the British Government in connection with the beet industry.

We have spent huge sums on drainage and afforestation. In one particular case, the drainage of the Barrow, the Government's contribution was very close on quarter of a million pounds. As a result of that scheme a great improvement was made, not alone in respect to the lands drained, but in the health of the people in and around the area of the river. We inaugurated a great scheme on the Shannon and carried out the contract there for a very small percentage in excess of the estimated amount, generating current at a price not greater than was estimated. We have had all sorts of criticism about that. When Deputies indulge in criticism they should remember that it is not this Government that is suffering most by reason of these criticisms. It is the confidence of the people in the capacity of Irishmen to do the business of the country.

There are certain matters that are above and before politics, as I have often stated, but the incredulous people opposite do not believe them. They seek to put a political label on practically everything that is done in this country. Every act of Ministers has a political design. I read a letter in the Press the other day from a Fianna Fáil Deputy in connection with the Shannon scheme, and he mentioned that the Dublin electricity undertaking had contributed large sums towards the relief of the rates, and that contribution was no longer going towards the rates. The facts are that something like £52,000 was levied in rates in respect of the Dublin undertaking up to 1910 or 1911. The last payment made by the Electricity Department in relief of rates was made in 1928-29, and the exact sum which the rates had contributed from the initiation of the electricity undertaking in Dublin up to the date I have mentioned was repaid, so that there was no real contribution towards the rates. The next question is: What was the price? The price charged in Dublin, as furnished by the Corporation, was an average figure of 2.5d. It has transpired that the actual sum was 2.7d. The new rate is 2.3d.

Another service referred to in the course of the debate was housing. Deputy O'Kelly charged me practically with responsibility for housing conditions in Dublin. I have not been a member of the Corporation since 1922. I believe the last meeting I attended was in May, 1922. The Deputy was a member of the Dublin Corporation up to 1924, and he is a member of the Corporation now. Does he absolve himself from all responsibility in connection with this, or do I bear a larger share of the responsibility than he does? The help given by the State towards the construction of houses in Dublin was far in excess of the wildest anticipations of the wildest Fianna Fáil enthusiast in this House or outside. As I said on many occasions, over 6,000 houses were constructed with the aid of Government funds in Dublin City. One would imagine from all that has been published in connection with this matter that Dublin was a most unhealthy city. The death rate in 1880 in Dublin was 35.0; in 1890, 26.0; in 1900, 27.5; in 1910, 19.9; in 1920, 18.1; and in 1930, 15.0 per thousand, notwithstanding all the criticism in connection with housing conditions. The Minister for Defence, speaking about the standard of living here, mentioned that it was high. Those figures show, if there are serious housing conditions in Dublin, that the standard must be fairly high when the death rate is not higher than 15 per thousand.

Deputy O'Kelly read some extracts from the writings of the late President Griffith. I have one of them here:—

We must offer our producers protection where protection is necessary. Let it be clearly understood what protection is. Protection does not mean the exclusion of foreign competition. It means, rendering the native manufacturer equal to meeting foreign competition. It does not mean that we shall pay a higher profit to any Irish manufacturer, but that we must not stand by and see him crushed by mere weight of foreign capital. If an Irish manufacturer cannot produce an article as cheaply as an Englishman or other foreigner, only because his foreign competitor has larger resources at his disposal, then it is the first duty of the Irish nation to accord protection to that Irish manufacturer.

Deputies opposite have undoubtedly gone further than that—very much further.

Comment on this

You have not gone so far.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

We have gone much further than that, very much further. It only needs a very hasty reading of the Tariff Commission Act to realise how much further than that we have gone, and there is in the records of the enactments of the Oireachtas ample evidence of the fact that we have gone further. As I said, housing was referred to. The Minister for Local Government in introducing the Housing Bill, mentioned that the total subsidies paid by the State up to date amounted to £2,500,000, and the total cost of the dwellings constructed was £11,000,000. I direct the attention of the Dáil to these figures. Of the £11,000,000, practically 25 per cent. was contributed by the State. What was it? It was a subsidy. Tariffs are much the same as subsidies. They mean that somebody else has to contribute towards the cost of a particular article.

Here is something which was stated in the Seanad by a Labour Senator on 25th March, 1931, when speaking of the furniture industry:—

Before that industry can ever be developed, Irish furniture manufacturers will have to develop some sense of honesty and some sense of the fitness of things. I think the Senator will agree that there is a general complaint about furniture manufacturers in this country working fresh timber and selling furniture in that condition. I have Irish furniture in my own house and I would be ashamed to admit to any foreigner that it was a product of Ireland. It is cracked and split. I am living in that house only four years, and the Irish-made doors and windows are falling to pieces simply because they were constructed of fresh timber. That is not the fault of the workmen, but it is the fault of the manufacturers. The Irish manufacturer who sells furniture of the type I have described, and who has the advantage of a tariff of 33 1-3 per cent. which was given by the Government to Irish producers, is guilty of a gross act of dishonesty, and is guilty of sabotaging the Irish furniture industry.

Comment on this

Does the President agree with that?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I cannot bear that out myself. My furniture is well made and it is of Irish manufacture.

Comment on this

Why did you read it?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I read that as a statement which a Labour leader in the Seanad made last July.

Comment on this

But the President does not agree with it?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I say that has not been my experience.

Comment on this

You just read it to slander an Irish industry.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Certainly not. If the Deputy or anybody else, foreign or at home, wishes to see some good Irish furniture I will show it to him at any time, and I am glad to say it is paid for.

Comment on this

Most of us could do the same thing.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I mention that because it is the statement of a responsible Labour representative.

Comment on this

I question that.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

What is the point? The point is that we must get value for our money.

Comment on this

But it is not true.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I did not interrupt the Deputy. It is true, I am positively certain, if the Senator said it. It is just one of a number of instances that one does not get satisfaction everywhere and at all times. What I do say is that if we are going to make goods here they must be the best. We are in world competition. It is no longer a question of the village practically supplying its own needs. It is useless for us to try to hide our heads in the sand and say, "Anything will do." It will not do. Everybody engaged in industry in this country must turn out the best work, and this country can only hope to keep its position in commerce or in industry by doing its work well. I hold, and it is my deliberate opinion, no matter what the consequences may be, political or otherwise, we cannot afford to pay twenty-five per cent. over and above the cost of any article to Irish operatives, and the sooner they know that the better for this country. Agriculture cannot bear any further imposts, as Deputy Ryan has stated. The Deputy immediately thought that I was going to say something or other about tariffs. Nobody in this House knows better than Deputy Ryan that the farmers cannot afford to pay any further imposts of that kind or afford to pay any price for goods other than the lowest price.

If we get an acceptance of the fact that better work must be turned out we have done something, at any rate, in this debate. Deputy de Valera's statement was, "Have a whole pile of tariffs. There are so many million pounds' worth of goods which can be made here." It is very much like a teacher addressing a group of schoolboys, getting a blackboard and chalk, and saying, "There are £30,000,000! How many people would be employed by that?" The Deputy knows now, better than he did before he started his newspaper, that that is not the way to do it. The question is how to get your outgoings met by your incomings. He realises that now, and he realises that reporting speeches and writing leading articles do not make a newspaper. You must get something better than has been out yet, and the Deputy realises how hard it is to do that.

Deputies opposite object very much to having the exact facts of a situation disclosed. What are the facts in respect of employment, because employment after all is a more important subject than unemployment. The energies, the industry, the genius of this Government have been devoted during the last ten years to making sure that persons in employment would be kept there, and that the number of those employed would be added to, and we have succeeded. The number of people registered in insurable occupations in 1922 was 242,000, and this year the figure has risen to 295,000. How would richer countries compare with that. What is America's position with regard to 1931 and 1932? What is England's position with regard to it? Even now, with all its wealth, what is the position of France? We do not pretend to be greater than these people, but there is none of them that we are going to look up to. We are going to be on the level, whether inside or outside the British Commonwealth. We have, by a tariff policy, given employment to 30,000 people; approximately 5,000 others have been employed through the operation of various Acts. We have, however, to pay attention to the fact that agriculture cannot bear any impositions in respect of its economy beyond its capacity. We must pay attention to that factor. Our main source of wealth in this country is agriculture.

Comment on this

Reduce the cost of government.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I can give the Deputies the figures as to the cost of government. In 1922, when Deputies were not considering economic questions at all, the cost of the Government was £25,000,000, of which £1,000,000 was given to local authorities. The cost of government now is £21,700,000, of which £3,700,000 is going to local authorities; £24,000,000 for the State in 1922, and £18,000,000 for the State this year. That is one of our contributions to economic production and the economy of the State.

Comment on this

What about the farmers? How hard was it for them to pay £24,000,000 in 1922, and how hard is it for them to pay £18,000,000 now?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

These are times when we require, as I have often said, the co-operation, the assistance and the benefit of the combined wisdom and wealth of the nation. Recently the Leader of the Opposition has taken great pride and pleasure in publishing a list of gentlemen looking for subscriptions for the Cumann na nGaedheal Party.

Comment on this

On a circular printed on English-made paper.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

That was a pity. That was a great mistake. I would like to know what unemployed man there is who would refuse employment from any of the persons whose names are on that list. I would like to know which one of the signatories, if they offered to subscribe to the coffers of the Deputies beyond, would be refused, and whether the subscriptions would be sent back. Deputies make this mistake: when citizenship is exercisable and is given by the Constitution to all citizens in this State they think that there are some who are not to be permitted to exercise it. We do not stand for that. We never did, and we do not intend to. Deputies mentioned on platforms that something like £300,000,000 have been collected by us during the last ten years. If it has, it is all distributed to the people of this country, with the exception of £2,000,000 for pensions abroad.

Of the grants to local authorities in 1931-32 which helped to relieve rates and so relieve unemployment there was £1,058,762 in local taxation grants; then there was a supplementary agricultural grant of £599,011 and there was an additional supplementary agricultural grant of £750,000, making a total of £2,407,773 in relief of rates. The road fund grants allocated in 1931-32 were £900,000. The housing grants were, for local government £213,563, and for Gaeltacht housing £80,000. Under development of industries there were £53,550 in the Lands and Fisheries Vote for rural industries, and £66,786 for Marine Products Industries. We have made available guarantees under the Trade Loans (Guarantee) Acts amounting to £322,000, of which the State has already paid £175,424. That reminds me of Deputy Derrig, who said this evening in the course of his speech that they would insist upon people bringing their money back and investing it here. Is that not a good advertisement for them? There is, as you know, much expenditure in estimates which relieves unemployment. Take 1931-32, for example. For Local Loans you had £1,170,000, for Public Works and Buildings £791,962, for Property Losses Compensation £187,100, for Haulbowline Dockyard £5,800, for the Beet Sugar Subsidy £162,500, for the Land Commission Improvement of Estates £211,250, for Unemployment Insurance £296,474. Deputies opposite do not seem to realise that the Dáil has voted £425,000 for direct relief of unemployment this year alone. Relief schemes were estimated at £140,000 and there was a Supplementary Estimate of £35,000. The Unemployment Relief Act cost £250,000. This was on top of actual expenditure on relief schemes to the end of 1928-29 of £1,450,000. These are remarkable evidences of the Government's efforts for the relief of unemployment.

The depression here is admittedly due to international causes. Deputy de Valera says there is a national remedy. If there is, then, according to that, he tried to show that the part is greater than the whole. I do not think that even the Deputy will stand for that. Last year we introduced a measure here reducing the contribution of employers and employees to the insurance fund. It is a very remarkable thing that in a difficult time it was possible to do that, but throughout the whole sphere of Government activity for the last eight or ten years an attempt has been made to reduce the burden on industry, to remove, so far as it was possible, every possible impediment that there could be to the expansion of industry, to make every effort in connection with our administration to assure all persons in the State that there was peace, order and security for the investment of capital in the State. Unfortunately we did not get from people who called themselves patriots that co-operation which any sensible minded politicians should give. The sooner Deputies scrap that line of policy the better. This country is ours for the making. There is a big responsibility for making a contribution in peaceful times towards building up the State. We should remember that it needs the active co-operation of all citizens to make good our conditions of affairs here.

Deputy Lemass said in the course of his speech here that having heard General Mulcahy's advocacy of co-operation with Great Britain he was now in a better position to understand a statement attributed to me in the "Daily Express" that after nine years I had found out that we were not fitted for self-government. In the first place, I never made any such statement, nor did I say anything remotely approaching it. In the second place, while the Deputy and his colleagues may regard, or pretend to regard, anything like co-operation with Great Britain as unpatriotic and anti-national, we, on our part, having no complex of inferiority and conscious that we stand on a basis of complete equality with Great Britain, welcome such co-operation at any and every time that we think that co-operation is calculated to promote this country's interests. That is the only criterion by which we form our judgments. We are even content to suffer the ignominy of the attacks of Deputy Lemass if we feel satisfied that we are doing the right thing.

Comment on this

If that is the President's election speech he can bow himself out.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

If the Deputy likes to think so, he is welcome.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 64
·
Níl 43
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Before the House adjourns, I wish to say that there is a Message from the Seanad stating that the Seanad has agreed with the Message sent by the Dáil in regard to the amendments to the Town Tenants Bill. That means that the Bill has now passed both Houses.

The Dáil adjourned at 10.25 p.m., until 10th February, 1932, at 3 p.m.

Comment on this