We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Butter Tariff—Financial Resolution.

Contributions 115–239 of 239. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

If the estimate be £415,000, then I take it that the levy which is proposed to be made will be 3d. per lb. on butter and that the export bounty will be 1½d.

Comment on this

No. 2d. and 4d.

Comment on this

I think the Minister will have to look up his figures again. The whole creamery production of butter is approximately 700,000 cwts. The export is approximately 320,000 cwts. Are these the figures which the Minister has got?

Comment on this

The production was 607,000 cwts. last year.

Comment on this

690,000 cwts. as a matter of fact is the correct figure.

Comment on this

That was the year before. The Deputy is referring to the year 1930.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan (Galway)

What about the factory and home-manufactured butter?

Comment on this

We are dealing with the creameries for the moment.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The question is, what the country is going to pay for.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is a question of the Deputy's speech.

Comment on this

I presume I will be allowed to ask the Minister a question?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am only trying to prevent interruptions.

Comment on this

The production is 690,000 cwts., as given on the third and fourth pages of the report. On that basis the levy of 2d. amounts to £644,000. The Minister said it will be £415,000. Will the Minister indicate to the House what segregation of sales for consumption in the country and for export is going to regulate the economy of each particular creamery? The levy will be collected or imposed, as the case may be. The next question for consideration in the creamery or in the combination of creameries is what is going to be exported? Obviously it would be to the interest of any creamery to export all the manufactured butter and not to sell any at home.

Comment on this

Why is that?

Comment on this

Because it is going to get the bounty. Is not that so? How is that going to be managed?

Comment on this

I explained that in my opening statement. For example, if the export price is 105/- and the bounty 37/-, that is 142/-. If the home buyer gives 142/-, naturally he will get it.

Comment on this

I am afraid I will have to agitate the Minister a little bit on that. Take a particular creamery. The manager wants to export two-thirds of the butter manufactured because he will get something extra on it over and above what he gets for the other one-third. Something will come back in respect of that two-thirds I have mentioned by way of bounty from the Department of Agriculture over and above his price. What regulation and what system will be inaugurated so that there will be a fair distribution in respect of the bounty that will come?

Comment on this

If the home buyer cannot get it at 142/- then the bounty goes down.

Comment on this

We will assume that the home buyer pays 142/- and he gets, as I have said, one-third of the butter. Two-thirds are ready for export, and a bounty is wanted on that. The bounty will be an advantage to him to deal with the export business.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

No advantage? What will be the regulation in respect of that particular thing with regard to the winter business? It is always an advantage to sell at once, I take it. There is cash in it and it will be sold at once. Are not we sending up our imports at the end of the year when we have no butter? Will there not be an increase in the imports, and will not that be against the dairying industry, unless some special steps are taken to improve winter dairying? That will not be done in a year.

Comment on this

I understand the point. Deputy Hogan made the same point: how to provide for the winter supply, that it would benefit naturally the creameries to export all through the year if they had the butter because they would have the bounty and there would be no benefit in storing for the winter. There will be power in the Bill to deal with that. First there will be power to vary the bounty if we see that the butter is going out too quickly in July or August or September, the months in which it ought to be stored for winter. The bounty can be lowered so as to encourage them to storage for the winter. And if the encouragement is not sufficient we will be looking for power in the Bill also to actually prohibit the export of butter at certain times.

Comment on this

In the first place the whole production in butter is represented on a fifty-fifty basis as between creameries and farmers. That is accepted. Now in respect of this levy it is on the creameries only it is to be imposed. I take it that the physical impossibility of doing the other thing will render it almost impossible.

Comment on this

The creameries and the factories.

Comment on this

So that the ordinary farmers' production escapes?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Obviously according to that it is not a fair arrangement. It does not appear to me to be a fair arrangement because one of the most important items in connection with our butter industry or in connection with any industry is the excellence of the product. There is no close inspection of the farmers' production. It may be good, but the fact is that it does not get the high prices that creamery butter does. Consequently there is almost an invitation, by reason of this particular levy, to farmers to start manufacturing butter on their own farms and the consequence would be a reduction of the quantity of milk going to the creameries. I have observed and I am sure the Minister has observed the extraordinary difference in the cost of the manufacture of butter in some creameries as against others. There are some creameries in which the cost is practically half what it is in others. The difference will be realised when I say that it amounts in some cases to 27/- a cwt. If the whole creamery industry is worthy of support one of the main considerations ought to be ensured, that is they ought to be made as efficient and economic as possible. This particular proposal endangers this economy by reason of the attraction there is to the farmers to manufacture in their own homes. Even if they send a certain proportion of their milk to the creamery and keep a certain proportion at home all the time the cost must be rather against whatever milk goes to the creamery and must tend to increase the cost of butter manufactured in that place. I suggest to the Minister that if a certain sum of money be required to support the creamery business and to subsidise the creamery industry in this country let him find out the amount necessary and come to the House for it in respect to taxation or something else. The point mentioned by Deputy Dillon is an important point. I do not know that there is any article of food in which the vitamins are so pronounced as in butter. There is no article so commonly used in the country, particularly by the young, and indeed by all classes and sections of the people.

Comment on this

Does not the same apply to tea?

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

What about the women?

Comment on this

For example I would have the temperament of Deputy Davin if I took to drinking tea. He is timorous, supercilious and provocative. I am none of these things.

Comment on this

You are a good advertisement for Oxo.

Comment on this

The other point I want to put is if the industry requires a particular sum of money let us be assured it is going to get it. We are not sure according to this. For example, it is on the cards that with this bounty butter may be sold at a lower price in England by means of the bounty than it would be normally. It is well known amongst business men that the more difficult it is to get money the keener people are to get it. Here there is some waiting and there is naturally a disposition to be careless, and a better system to my mind could be devised than this one. We are not placing the burden fairly upon all the people. Half the butter produced is going to escape the imposition; the other half is going to bear it, and I venture to say the industry is not in a position to maintain any other onslaughts or to deal with less milk than what it is dealing with, and any interference with the supply of milk to the creameries would be, I think the Minister will agree, one of real danger in connection with this proposal.

Last year we proposed to come to the relief of the rates to the extent of £750,000. The Party opposite wanted £1,000,000. The difference between £750,000 and £1,000,000 is £250,000 which is half the estimated cost of this proposal. Nobody will object to give what assistance is required to any industry of the importance and magnitude of the dairying industry in this country, if we are satisfied that it is a sound proposition. This to my mind is not a sound proposition. It fails in the first degree by taxing half the production and leaving the other half free. It fails in the second place in that the whole sum cannot be devoted towards industrial needs here, but may actually succeed in increasing the price of butter to our own people and cheapening it to the British. And I am sure as I stand here that if we brought in that proposal some months ago, Deputy Corry and Deputy Briscoe and all the back benchers at the other side of the House would be out at the cross-roads night, noon and morning, telling the people that we were taxing our own people and endeavouring to relieve the British people by this proposal.

Comment on this

All the speakers in this debate used the figure of 4d. per lb. as the amount of increase on the price of butter. If that is the correct figure, if that is to be the increase all-round in good seasons and in bad seasons, I am beginning to wonder what amount of butter, if any, will be used in the working-class districts of Dublin, and especially by the very poor. At the moment, and there is no use hiding it, the very poor of Dublin City are living on bread and margarine and tea three times a day. I think that is all they can afford out of the food tickets of ten or twelve shillings allowed to a man, his wife and three children in the city. The worker's delicate wife might try to get a half-pound of butter on her food ticket. I am glad to see that Deputy Sir James Craig is here, and I am sure from his medical experience he will tell us that there is nothing more essential for a delicate woman than butter. He will tell you why we have in the poorer districts of Dublin ill-nourished children. As Deputy Dillon and Deputy Cosgrave have stated, by this proposal you are putting beyond the reach of these people the possibility of securing even that small quantity of butter. I think the burden is not a fair one. We have a population of close on 500,000 people in the City of Dublin, and they will be bearing their share of this burden without the slightest advantage. I am very anxious to know what our Dublin Deputies will say to the people when their attention is drawn to the unfairness of the burden that they are going to be asked to bear. Is it right that the people of Dublin and of the towns and cities throughout the country should be asked to bear this when we all know that a large number of them are suffering serious hardships and undergoing grave injustices at the moment? I make an emphatic protest so far as this imposition on the people is concerned. I think it is unfair to the Dublin working classes and to the poor of Dublin.

I hope before the motion is put that some of the medical men in the House will explain the want of nourishment in margarine which our people are forced to buy. If this Bill is passed a larger number of people will be forced to buy it for their children. I was rather surprised that the only Minister who supported the Minister for Agriculture spoke only for three minutes. He commenced by saying that we import so much we have to export something. If that is his reason for supporting the motion surely exports, unless they are for the good of the country and at a profit, should not be indulged in. Export something that our own people have to bear the loss on. As Deputy Cosgrave put it, export something that may be sold cheaply in other countries as the result of the imposition here. It was good to hear Deputy Aiken, the Minister for Defence, admitting that we have a customer worth cultivating and that it was necessary to export something, but I earnestly hope that this type of export will not take place, that exports will not grow in this way and that in order to export to balance one side of your Budget you will put this imposition on your own people. If industries are to flourish in this country serious thought ought to be given to them. I heard the Minister say in introducing the motion that we must take care that in helping one industry or in building it up we do not knock down an existing one. I hope that when efforts are made to build up industries, consideration will be given to the industries which are existing at the present moment and which are giving reasonably good employment. There is a greater reason now than ever why our people should not be taxed further, especially through their foodstuffs. Every Deputy knows that within the past few weeks there has been a tightening up process somewhere that none of us can put our finger on at the moment, and that unemployment is growing. Our building trade is at a standstill, our people are approaching every day our Home Assistance Board and getting that small—I will not use the word miserable—food ticket of 10/- for a man, wife and two children out of which they have illegally to coax a grocer to give them a half-crown or so to pay their rent and avoid eviction. I would ask the Government that in helping one section of the community they should not put a burden on people who are least able to stand any further burden.

Comment on this

As one of the Dublin Deputies to whom Deputy Byrne has referred, I am quite satisfied with the proposition of the Minister for Agriculture. While Deputy Byrne and other members of the Opposition were speaking I looked back and asked myself was I dreaming or was I really facing facts as they were. Deputy Byrne is very solicitous now for the poor of Dublin, the poor who, he admits, have to buy margarine, but recently he went out in support of a Government that had taken from the very poor—the old age pensioners—a shilling a week. Deputy Byrne comes along now and is very concerned about the very poor and about what is going to happen to them arising out of a serious effort to save from absolute destruction what is admitted to be one of our most important industries. The fact that this industry is getting worse from year to year does not seem to concern the Deputy. What would happen if the industry ceased altogether and we had more very poor in the city? I do not really understand the Deputy. When he joined forces with Deputy Cosgrave in opposition to us he held out the horror that we might have conditions here such as had been witnessed in Spain. The Deputy forgot all he said and went to celebrate the first anniversary of the establishment of the Government he condemned when he was opposing us in the City of Dublin.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This has nothing to do with the butter bounty.

Comment on this

I made an interjection when Deputy McGilligan was speaking because I felt that this unreal contribution to the debate was deserving of some interjection. Deputy McGilligan not so long ago stated definitely that it was not the duty of the State to provide work for the unemployed people or to provide sustenance for them.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy quote Deputy McGilligan?

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy Mulcahy would look up some of the posters we issued and the advertisements in the Press which gave these quotations. Perhaps he would compare them with some of the literature he issued.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps we would get away from the Election and come down to the butter.

Comment on this

I merely want to say that I support this measure because I believe it is one really honest effort to save from extinction one of the most important industries we have in the State at the moment. In supporting it I also desire to cast back again to those Deputies who opposed it the unreal contribution which they made here, and by certain references I want to prove that some of these contributions to which we have listened are merely hot air and have nothing to do with considering the real situation. I am not one of those who, because I know of the existence of a certain situation in this city, hope to see a chronic state of poverty. I hope to see in the near future as a result of the efforts that will be made by this Government a revival of industry and a revival of employment in the country, and that you will not have people existing on 10s. per week outdoor relief, for whose sake we must not impose any subsidy or any protection for industry because the 10s. they receive does not permit them to pay any increased price for food. I hope to see very shortly a revival of industry, work and decent wages given to people so that they can help, by purchasing Irish produce, in keeping in employment people in other parts of the Free State.

Deputy Byrne seems to think that we are always going to have this state of chronic poverty, but I hope to see a different state of affairs. I hope to see, as a result of this effort by the Minister for Agriculture, a stoppage in the sale of cattle that has been going on because farmers found it was impossible for them to exist or to continue to deliver milk to the creameries at the price they were getting. What does this proposition intend to do? It intends to ensure that at least the riches we have in the State in the shape of cattle shall be preserved, and to bring about the production of butter by ensuring that farmers will not be discouraged by the continual decline that has been noticed in that industry for a number of years past.

Deputy Dillon referred to my interjection. I made that interjection because I realised that unless something of this nature is done, unless the Government sets about examining each industry on its own merits, protect those that are there and assure them of a continued existence, striving to create new ones or revive old ones that have gone out of existence, not only will we have a big portion of the community living in conditions of poverty and eating margarine, but you will have a considerably larger number living in the same conditions. It was only this week that the Board of Assistance in Dublin referred to the fact that former ratepayers were now seeking outdoor relief, and surely Deputy Dillon does not consider that we have any responsibility for that situation. We realise the seriousness of it, and we realise that by measures such as this, by trying to give some security to the industries we have, we will save them from extinction and save other people from falling back on outdoor relief for the means of their subsistence. It may be out of order to give illustrations to show that certain Deputies do not mean half of what they say. That is what I tried to prove by giving these illustrations. If the Opposition now want to see any improvement in the State or in the conditions of the people, and if they want to see any success so far as the country is concerned, they will understand that the methods they have tried have failed, as Deputy Dillon said, particularly in the creamery districts, miserably failed, and that this Government is going to try to do something to benefit from the failures of their predecessors. I hope that in a very short space of time the Minister for Agriculture will be able to show that he is quite satisfied and has quite justified himself in this Bill.

Comment on this

Nobody denies, I think, in the whole House, that the position of the farming industry is such that some provision must be made to bolster up the dairying industry if it is to continue in existence, and for that reason, I propose to support this motion, although I perceive various difficulties and dangers in the working of it. One danger I see in this proposal is that the Minister does not propose to make any levy on farmers' home butter outside the creameries. At least, I understood the Minister to say that.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

If he does not propose to make a levy on farmers' butter—I really think it would be rather difficult to impose such a levy—it will have the effect, mentioned in a few of the speeches on this side, of enticing farmers, particularly in those districts where there are new creameries, to manufacture their butter instead of sending milk to the creameries. It will have a very bad effect on creameries such as were recently established in counties like Carlow and Wexford and perhaps in Donegal, of which a Deputy spoke a few moments ago. There is another danger that I see, the possible danger that the import of butter into this country, which had nearly ceased as a result of the tariff of two years ago, will be revived as a consequence of this levy. The Minister said that he proposed to make what we might call a modification of the levy during the summer months, so that a quantity of butter would have to be held over for the winter months. I think he will find some difficulty in making such a provision. I was interested in something Deputy Dillon said which was repeated on the Opposition Benches, that the programme of the previous Minister for Agriculture practically resulted in the consequences which we now see, the difficulties in which agriculture finds itself. I do not think that in this House a more extravagant statement was ever made.

Anybody who knows anything about the dairying industry in this country knows that the legislation put into effect by the former Minister for Agriculture was successful in reorganising that industry and in putting it in such a position that the butter we export to-day is equal to, if not better in quality than the butter imported by England from the Danes and our trade opponents in other countries. Anybody with any conception of the industry in counties like Limerick and Tipperary must know that five or six years ago, there was a grave danger of the creamery business ceasing to exist if the Minister had not taken some steps to prevent that occurring. Speaking of this matter during the election recently, some of us were not afraid to face the issue and we told the farmers that the opposition offered to the late Minister's policy both in this House, and on platforms outside, was a false opposition.

The position that we see the agricultural and the dairying industry in to-day was not caused by any legislation passed by the last Government but is a consequence of world depression. It is only now that the Fianna Fáil Party recognise that. The onus now lies upon them to provide remedies for agricultural and other industries. When legislation was proposed for the reorganisation of the creamery industry the prices of butter and milk were much greater than they are now. I might answer Deputies Dillon and Corry, who are both absent just now, by repeating what I said during the elections. I said that if the price of milk which a few years ago was 7d. and which has dropped to-day to a little more than 4d., had remained at 7d. and if the world depression had not brought about a reduction in price, there would not have been one word of criticism of any legislation brought in by the late Minister for Agriculture.

The position of the farmer, the industrialist and the workman to-day is a consequence of the cycle of world depression which began in 1921 and which has continued up to the present time. The Fianna Fáil Party have up to now failed to recognise that. The onus of government is now placed upon them and they are beginning to realise the difficulties of legislation. I was rather surprised to-day when I did not hear from the Fianna Fáil Benches the slightest consideration for the consumer. If I remember rightly, when a tariff was introduced some two years ago and when the present Government occupied the benches we now occupy, we were almost deafened with cries of compassion for the unfortunate consumer who might possibly have to bear some portion if not all of the tariff then proposed. To-day, when the Minister for Agriculture submits a resolution putting into effect a similar tariff to what was then imposed—a tariff which many of us here believed would not be effective in protecting the butter industry during the summer—we do not hear one word about the imposition on the consumer. There was something said in a mild way from the Labour Benches, and a good deal from the Independent Benches, but even Labour Deputies did not put forward their usual considerations for the unfortunate consumers in the towns and villages.

If there is to be a great benefit conferred on the farmer by reason of this levy, I, for one, will not have any tears for the plight of any other members of the community. I always have had sympathy for the consumers, but, to my mind, the position of the agriculturist just now is worse than the position of any other section of the community. Any benefit that can be given to him, at whatever cost, will have my support, and I hope the support of all farmer Deputies in the House. I do not anticipate that the burden from this levy will be so serious and have such an effect as Labour and Independent Deputies have indicated. I do not believe that the addition of 4d. to the summer price of butter will raise the price to the consumer anything more than the price of butter during the last three or four years. If there was not some measure like this to bolster up the price, butter promised to sell this year at a figure unprecedented in the history of the industry. There is no grave danger that the price to the consumer this summer will be to any great extent above the average price of late years.

There are other dangers in this levy of which one might speak. We have, however, to wait until we see the Bill before we can enlarge upon them. I hope that there is no great danger of retaliation in the export market by reason of any legislation that may eventuate in this House. I hope that any difficulties that may face us will be composed in some manner that will not antagonise the English consumer of our products. As some Deputies pointed out, there is a danger of reaction to certain proposed legislation. There is possibly the danger that the enjoyment of the preference which we have over our foreign competitors may in conceivable circumstances lapse. I hope that no action on any side of the House will help to bring about such a state of affairs. I hope that any legislation that may be considered in this country will not have the effect of bringing conditions in other countries back to what they were in 1921. I remember a visit I paid to England in 1921. I walked down the streets of York and I was impressed by a notice on a butcher's stall "No Irish sold here." Further down in a retail butter store I saw a similar notice "No Irish sold here." There is a danger of a similar state of affairs occurring in the near future.

Comment on this

What has this to do with the matter under consideration?

Comment on this

The Deputy is obviously making suggestions to those across the water.

Comment on this

I hope that a similar state of affairs will not result because of any legislation that may be adopted by the Government of the Free State. I do hope that whatever benefit the farmer may get from this 4d. levy will not be off-set by the loss of the ten per cent. preference which would wipe out most of it. I do hope, too, that the benefit will not be off-set by the antagonism of the English consumers to our products. We will have more to say on this subject when the Bill is before us. I only say now that, so far as I am concerned, inasmuch as it proposes to benefit the farmers, I am supporting it.

Comment on this

I am in active sympathy with any effective proposal which will in any way alleviate the present unfortunate position of the dairying industry in this country. I think it is common property that the position of affairs is due to widespread over-production and to a decrease in the purchasing power of countries which are large consumers of dairy produce. The Minister for Agriculture told us that prices held until 1928. I want him to examine the position of affairs which resulted in the fall of prices then. Production was encouraged by Australia. This plan which is now proposed by the Minister for Agriculture was similar to the plan introduced by Mr. Patterson, the Minister for Markets and Migration in Australia, who imposed a similar levy on the home consumer and a bounty on exports from the country. The British market was a large consumer of that produce. Its purchasing power was high. It also consumed a very large portion of our products for which we got a very good price. But there is one danger in this. Is it proposed by the Minister for Agriculture to take off the tariff of 4d. on butter? If it is then there is danger that we will be exposed, owing to an increased price for butter in this country, to the imports from exporting countries other than our own. That is a consideration which the Minister must take into account.

I would probably have welcomed this proposal in 1925 or 1926 or up to the time that the price of butter fell in 1928. But that plan which raised the prices very materially in Australia from 1/3 to 1/6 may operate in the same way in this country. There was an increase of from £1,500,000 to £2,000,000 in the imports of butter into Australia. Have the benefits of that scheme continued to-day? If they have, then I certainly would be very glad to have it tried in this country, but under the altered conditions which exist internationally, and particularly in the country to which we send most of our butter produce, I am doubtful if the effect of that scheme would be such as outlined by the Minister for Agriculture.

There is a very serious danger that if it is not effective the only result will be to cheapen produce in the foreign country without giving any real benefit or advantage to the dairy farmers of this country. I would take very great exception to any act of ours which would in any way cheapen produce for another country and at the same time place impositions upon the people of this country. I do look with a certain amount of alarm to any increase in the cost of living. I would suggest to the Minister for Agriculture that there is another way. The ex-Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Patrick Hogan, has informed the House that the tariff that was imposed on butter was ineffective. In that case it was valuable as revenue. I would suggest that that tariff, if it is re-imposed, will be used as a means of helping the producers in this country and not raising the price to the consumer. In Australia the very fact that butter was raised, attracted immediately butter from New Zealand and so there were increased imports. Though the Patterson plan was welcomed in Australia there was immediately a strong agitation raised for the imposition of increased protective tariffs. That is what we must do to-day if we are to put this plan into operation. In Australia the plan was tried and operated at a time of great prosperity, and when production was not so good as it is to-day, and when the purchasing power of every country was very much larger. Whether that purchasing power was artificial or not, I feel, with the depression which exists in our own country and the depression which exists in the country that we have been accustomed to look on as our market, that very great caution will have to be observed in putting into force any plan of price fixing. We are contending with almost an international price fixing.

Some countries, such as Australia, export sugar at £9 a ton while imposing a very much higher price on their own consumers. They do this for the purpose of subsidising exports. What is the history of Australia to-day? What is the position? I do not think we could regard it as an enviable one. The people who are returning home from Australia, people who are regarded as assistants to production, do not regard it as an enviable one. There are other methods by which we can help the farmer. We can lower expenses. We can cheapen his overhead expenses. We can cheapen the cost of production by reducing the price that he must pay for his requirements on the land. I have endeavoured to do that myself with regard to such things as the co-operative movement, and I venture to say that I have succeeded in a good many cases.

I feel that it would be advisable for us to be very cautious as to what prices we fix and as to increases on the home consumer. There is just as much distress on people who are nonagricultural as there is amongst agriculturists; for this reason, that the latter are particularly depending on the agriculturists. I will be very cautious indeed in supporting any scheme which puts up the prices of food for the people. That is a danger that they will deeply resent. I feel that the Minister would be better advised in seeking some other way of subsidising exports from this country, because an attractive high price will undoubtedly defeat that very plan by increasing imports into this country, and at the same time defeat the means whereby the Minister hopes to receive revenue to subsidise exports.

Comment on this

I regret that Deputy Bennett is not speaking now after the speech to which we have just listened. Everybody in the House must have been disappointed with Deputy Bennett's speech. Considering that he has been a prominent farmer-Deputy here for the last five years, and that he represents the leading butter-producing county in Ireland, we expected to hear a great deal more about the subject under discussion than he told us. Deputy Bennett seems always to yield to the temptation of imagining what would have happened if history had taken a different course and if world depression had not set in. He likes to consider what effect that would have had on Fianna Fáil and on his own Party. This evening I heard him, for the third or fourth time, indulge in that useless sort of speculation. I thought that this was an occasion on which he would not waste time in that way.

I thought Deputy Bennett would have dealt with some of the questions put by the last speaker. I thought Deputy Bennett would have told us whether Limerick farmers have reached a position where their cost of production cannot be reduced, whether they are producing butter as economically as is possible, whether they are marketing their butter as economically as is possible, whether he feels they have reached rock-bottom, and that some such scheme as that which we are discussing is essential to the salvation of the important industry about which he knows so much. The discussion has been prejudiced by a number of speakers. It has been very much prejudiced, in my opinion, by the attempt to link it up with the misfortuness of the poor. The moment that question is brought into an economic discussion, the moment certain Deputies take upon themselves the mantle of protectors of the poor, the discussion, I hold, is at once seriously prejudiced. That is what happened this evening. When Deputy Dillon said that the Minister for Agriculture was snatching from the mouths of the poor the little bit of butter they had lately been able to get, he was, of course, making an appeal to which every one of us instinctively responded.

Comment on this

The Party Whip would not let you.

Comment on this

Was it fair, in dealing with an economic question—a question which ought to be discussed purely on economic grounds—to bring in matters of that sort? What was Deputy Dillon's real point? That the farmers should continue to supply butter at a price below the cost of production to meet the needs of the poor?

Comment on this

Is that practicable? I do not think that those who feel for the poor can be divided into parties. If there is any virtue in the House, we ought to be 100 per cent. in favour of the poor people having butter. But is not Deputy Dillon's proposal simply that the supply of butter to the poor should be subsidised? He does not deny that farmers are marketing butter at a loss at present. Deputy Dillon wants that to continue, and he wants the subsidy that is necessary to come from other sources. Therefore, he is in favour of the system of having butter marketed at a price that does not pay for production. Here the question immediately arises both for himself and for Deputy the Lord Mayor—Why should the subsidy not go to milk? They are both, I presume, thinking of the poor people of Dublin. Certainly Deputy the Lord Mayor is thinking of the poor people of Dublin. If a subsidy were given to any article of food for the poor, assuredly it would much more properly go to milk than to butter, because milk is more essential to children than is butter.

Comment on this

Milk at 4d. or milk at 1/- or 1/2?

Comment on this

That interruption is utterly irrelevant. I am afraid the Deputy was not listening to me at all.

Comment on this

Why should we listen to you when you speak in that way of milk in Dublin and milk in the country?

Comment on this

In my opinion there must be other ways of enabling the poor people to get good food at a price which they can afford to pay than this method of continuing the production of an article to be sold at a price below the cost of production. I do not think it will help the poor if you allow such a big industry as the dairy industry to continue in its present state, if you run the risk of the farmers—even an insignificant number of farmers—going out of production. If they go out of production, even to the extent of five per cent. or ten per cent, it is not going to help the poor in Dublin, Cork Limerick or anywhere else. Those who think they are serving the poor by opposing this scheme, while they mean well, are in my opinion, not acting wisely.

Comment on this

Would you permit me to say that the Deputy has wildly misrepresented what I said?

Comment on this

I beg the Deputy's pardon. I listened very carefully to him. Deputy Dillon held that there should be no interference with the price of butter, but that butter producers should be subsidised in another way than by a levy on the general public. Is that a fair interpretation of what the Deputy said?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Moore should address the Chair. We cannot have this cross-gangway discussion.

Comment on this

I think the report will show that I am correct. Other attempts were made to prejudice the scheme. We were told that this was another of the schemes that are in a class with tariffs and that tariffs are always paid by the consumer. We were told by an ex-Minister that industrial tariffs had been paid to the full 100 per cent by consumers.

Comment on this

You were told nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

There are more ex-Ministers than you.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We cannot have this interruption. If Deputy Hogan wants to make an explanation, he can do so.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

If Deputy Moore puts in the phrase "in respect of any article of which there was a shortage in home production" it will make all the difference in the world and he will be right.

Comment on this

If Deputy Hogan would look up the speech made by his colleague, Deputy McGilligan, on the 4th June, 1930, in which he described a scientific analysis which his Department had made of the result of the tariffs imposed here, he would find that he is in very strong disagreement with Deputy McGilligan. Deputy McGilligan divided the tariffs imposed into three or four different classes. In respect of some of them he implied—he did not state definitely—that there was actually a lowering of the price here and that people could buy the goods here at at least as low a price as British consumers could in their country. He mentioned other cases in which the tariff had not raised the price. He stated that in other cases there was a slight premium—that part of the tariff was being paid by the consumer. He mentioned other cases in which the full tariff was being paid. The classification does not correspond with Deputy Hogan's theory. It would not in any way correspond with the theory that when there is a shortage here the consumer necessarily pays the full tariff. As a matter of fact, Deputy McGilligan said, in respect of the most prominent of the tariffs, that those who chose to buy Irish boots and shoes paid only 7 per cent. of the tariff. Deputy Hogan and Deputy McGilligan should have a little chat on that subject because, on this question of tariffs, we would all like to be agreed. It is ridiculous that it should be argued in a Party way every time. The circumstances of the country now demand that we should discuss these questions free from prejudice. On the whole Deputy Hogan prejudiced this discussion this evening by unnecessarily bringing in the statement that I have quoted. It is too soon yet to decide in favour of the details of the Minister's scheme but so far we have not heard anything in the way of an alternative from any side of the House.

Comment on this

Yes, you have.

Comment on this

Until we do, we have to recognise that the Minister's scheme is the best one that the Department could put forward, and that it is essential that the position of such a great industry as dairying should be remedied at once. We have no alternative but to support the Minister's proposal.

Comment on this

With the general principle of the resolution the whole House will agree—that something should be done not only to enable Irish butter to meet competitors fairly on the export market, but to command its own position and value on that market. However, it is when we come to consider the machinery by which that support will be given to the industry that we begin to take different turns. I think the House will agree on the main point, and having done that it may be easy hereafter to devise ways and means of giving the necessary help. It seems to me that the resolution has been drafted in a rather hurried fashion and without any regard to the difficulties and cost of raising this levy. Above all, it would seems that the expense of the levy is going to fall heaviest on the home consumer. The Minister has not told us what the amount of the levy will be. I believe it will be anything from 2d. to 4d. Whatever it may be, there is one fact outstanding that practically two-thirds of all the butter in Ireland is home-manufactured butter. That butter is not produced in creameries. How is the Minister going to get after that butter? The levying of the tax is going to be a difficulty there. It will be necessary to send inspectors to the homes of people who have separators to stay there until the milk is taken off, or to follow the farmer who makes the butter into small shops or watch him at cross-roads. The resolution states that the tax will be payable by the manufacturer. Otherwise it would have to be raised from the person to whom the farmer sells the butter. Whatever way it is raised, it is quite evident from the resolution that the farmer is not going to get the benefit of the tax. The wholesaler, in the first instance, who afterwards becomes the retailer, pays the tax and passes it on to the consumer. Eventually the consumer of butter in Ireland will pay to the extent of £850,000, so that the English consumer of Irish butter will get it at 4d. per lb. cheaper. I agree with the general principle of the Bill, and when it comes before the House at a later stage, we may be able to get a way out of the difficulties that at present confront us. I would like if the Minister would state the amount of the levy and if he could give some idea of the machinery by which the levy will be collected. He should also state if the Resolution gives him authority to impose the levy immediately, and if it is the intention to put it into operation at once. The House might also be informed when the Report Stage of the Resolution will be taken so that reasoned amendments might be prepared.

Comment on this

As a representative of the farming community I welcome the introduction of this motion. It has been introduced for the purpose of relieving the dairying industry. The dairying industry needs this assistance. To-day, in another place I gave the Minister an example of the condition of that industry. I belong to County Limerick, which is one of the greatest dairying counties in this State. I could give unmistakable evidence that although in recent years we may have increased our supplies to the dairies, we have a very much decreased number of cows. In other words, the dairying industry is in grievous danger, and if something is not done for it there is a risk of its extinction. I would be surprised to hear a discordant note here, having regard to the fact that, although it may be said the motion only affects suppliers, it should be remembered that it affects every section of the community, because if the dairying industry disappears every section will suffer. Coming as the motion does from a new Government I very much appreciate its introduction, because it shows that the Government understands the needs of the people. This Government have the essential quality that makes for good Government. They know the condition of the people, and, as far as I can go, I will support the Government in the furtherance of this measure.

[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]

Comment on this

Coming from Tipperary, a county which produces a great deal of butter, I feel that I can claim to have some little knowledge of the state of the farming industry and of the dairying industry. I am not going to contend that that industry is not in need of assistance and that the farmers are not in a bad way. But I want to submit that we should have some regard for the consumers. At the risk of incurring the displeasure of Deputy Moore, and of being accused of trying to prejudice the issue, I want to say that it is the duty of those of us who primarily represent the poor, to see that in trying to assist the farmer an unbearable burden is not thrown on the poor.

I do not think it can be claimed, or will be suggested by any member of this House from any side, that this Dáil has not attempted to improve the position of the farmers of the country, and rightly so, but I suggest that it is unfair, it is not just, that an imposition of at least 4d. per lb. should be put upon butter in the hope that the farmers will get ¾d. per gallon more for their milk than they are getting to-day.

We are not absolutely certain that this measure is going to help, to any material extent, the dairying industry, but we are certain of this fact that it is going to place a very heavy burden on the consuming public and, in particular, on the poor of the country. The poor people in the towns, cities and villages and the working class people are, in the main, consumers of butter. They are the people who have to pay the highest price for Irish butter. I submit that in view of unemployment, and of the downward tendency of wages, the effect of this imposition will be to drive people from butter to margarine. That statement was made by some other speaker earlier in the debate and was pooh-poohed from certain parts of the House. I suggest to any Deputy who will try to look at this question in a reasonable way that if Irish butter is being retailed in Dublin City tomorrow, or in any town or village in the country, at, say, 1/2 per lb. the workman's wife will go and purchase it when margarine is at, say 1/- per lb., but if the price of Irish butter is increased from 1/2 to 1/6, that will make a very big difference in the weekly budget of, say, an agricultural labourer earning from 10/- to 15/- a week or a road worker earning 27/- a week, or an unemployed man who is fortunate enough to be drawing unemployment benefit to the extent of £1 a week for himself and his wife. This increase of 4d. a lb. in the price of butter will make all the difference in the world to such people.

I am speaking now as one of the representatives for one of the principal dairying counties in this country. I am sure I will not be thanked by many of my constituents, but I consider it my duty to protest against this system of robbing Peter to pay Paul, taking from the very poor, if you like, in order to help the poor. It is unquestionable that the farmers are in a bad way. Most people in this country, no matter what position they occupy, are in a bad way to-day, but there is no section of the community in as bad a way as the working classes. We must remember, also, that less than 12 months ago this House imposed taxation to the tune of £750,000 on what we may call the consumers, because it was provided that that amount of money was to be raised in such a way that it would affect, only to a small extent, the agricultural community.

We got some figures here this afternoon. Nearly every speaker had a different set of figures, telling us what it was going to cost. If we take an average figure I think we can safely say that between this imposition of 4d. a lb. and the 4d. a lb. that operates in the winter the cost will be at least £1,000,000 a year on the consumers of butter here. I submit that they are not able to bear that burden, and that it is too big a price to ask the consumers to pay for the very small improvement that it is intended to bring to the dairying industry,—an increase of ¾d. per gallon more for milk than is being paid to-day.

Comment on this
Dr. Thomas Hennessy Dr. Hennessy

While I would be very glad to see an obvious and honest subsidy given to the dairy farmers of Ireland, I must object to the camouflage of this subsidy proposed by the Minister for Agriculture. My objection is influenced by the fact that I am a city representative. I cannot understand why the unfortunate people of the Coombe, where they are leading a struggling existence, some on outdoor relief and others with moderate wages, should be taxed to find the bulk of this subsidy. The farmers throughout the country are consumers of butter to a very great extent. The consumption of butter by the members of their families and their work people is very great. Most of that butter is bought from the creameries so that this will mean a tax on the farmers themselves. It will mean that the farmers will have to contribute a very big proportion of this subsidy as arranged. I know the County Limerick pretty well. It is a grass county. Reflections are sometimes made upon grass counties, but still, it is an extraordinary thing that no industry I know of, gives more employment than dairy farming, and dairy farming is mainly supported by two-thirds of the grass county. The land there is used for raising beef. That serves a purpose also, but we must bear in mind that these principally grass counties, which are sneered at here by certain representatives, have the largest proportion of insured persons of any counties in Ireland. The persons insured are working on the farms so that the grass serves a very different purpose to that which we are sometimes asked to believe.

Now I understand that butter made by farmers in their own homes is exempt from this taxation. They are to be exempt from contributing to the subsidy. I do not think that is desirable, because this is an age of standardised food, and if you are exporting butter to the English market you must have it of the same colour, of the same flavour and containing a uniform amount of salt. The only way you can secure that is by encouraging farmers to send their milk to the creameries, where it will be manufactured into butter. We are told that the price of milk will be reduced as a compensation, say, to the poor people and to the rich people who use it. I do not see how that will compensate them very much. We may say that milk in the country is sold at 11d. per gallon to be sent to Dublin, but we forget the very great overhead charges that have to be met in Dublin in retailing the milk.

I do not believe in all this talk about profiteering in the case of milk, because the cost of its distribution here is a very big item. Quite a number of people are engaged in its distribution, and overhead charges, rents and rates have to be reckoned with. In view of that I do not think that any tribunal set up to investigate this will be in a position to reduce very much the price of milk for the poor or the rich people. I suggest that the best way to approach this would be by an open subsidy and to distribute the taxation on another incidence altogether. I believe that something must be done to save the dairying industry, that it is worth while spending money on saving it, but I think that the scheme proposed by the Minister for Agriculture will prove an illusion.

Comment on this

I am a dairy farmer myself and I am selfish enough to accept a subsidy, no matter how it comes. I make that confession here quite honestly, but I do object to the method. An article is good or bad, according to the workmanship and material put into it, and this subsidy is good or bad, according to the material and care and work we are going to put into it here. We do not want to make any political capital out of it, but I do believe that many farmers in the country would almost prefer not to get the subsidy at all than have a subsidy the brunt of which would be borne by the very poor. There is no doubt about that. We are all agreed that a subsidy is needed. Why not take it out of revenue? Why not agree to the democratic principle with regard to taxation? We are all agreed there should be income tax, but this is a reversal. It is taxing the poor people who cannot afford to pay taxes. Is this carrying out some of the programme of the elections, where you promised to give everything to everybody, at no cost to anybody? This is feeding the farmer largely on his own tail.

The farmer is one of the largest consumers of butter in the State, and he will have to pay the enhanced price, which does not mean half so much as you pretend it means. In addition, you are going to hang on a big costly machinery for collection, and all the rest. You are going to have, as Deputy Davin says, the danger of profiteering. You can avoid profiteering, machinery and all these expenses by a State subsidy. You will have a better Bill and remove the blemishes that are suggested here. I am glad that the discussion has taken place, because I hope that the Minister will be converted to a different method of raising the money from that which he suggests. The method of raising the money is the only difficulty, and I think that method is wrong. I merely rose in the hope that when the Bill was introduced it will be on the lines suggested from this side of the House.

Comment on this
James Ryan Minister for Agriculture (Dr. Ryan) Fianna Fáil

I do not think the question raised by Deputy Gorey had been raised before —that it was going to be a costly scheme to collect money from the farmers, most of which the farmers will have to pay by buying the butter back. First of all, it is not going to be a costly scheme. It will be run at very little cost—probably in or about £3,000 a year. The cost to the consumer was pointed out by some Deputies at £1,000,000—I think Deputy Morrissey reached the million figure. It started at £600,000, and somebody else put it up to £850,000, and by the time it came to Deputy Morrissey, it had reached £1,000,000. But Deputy Gorey says that the farmers themselves are going to eat all the butter—

Comment on this

Is there any necessity to be extravagant in your language?

Comment on this

You said most of the butter.

Comment on this

I said a considerable amount of it.

Comment on this

Deputy Hennessy said also that the farmers would pay most of this subsidy, so that nobody is going to suffer at all, except, if we are to judge from the speeches—

Comment on this

And nobody is going to benefit.

Comment on this

Except the people who live on 8/6 a week—people of whom the Lord Mayor of Dublin spoke—the family getting 10/- a week, and paying 2/6 for rent—they are going to pay 4d. extra on butter. These are the sort of estimates given of how this thing is going to be judged. I do not know how the figures were got. If we are to take the amount of butter consumed in this country contained in this "Agricultural Output of Saorstát Eireann" which is the latest we have, on the division of the output of butter into the amount consumed by the urban population, the rural population and the amount exported——

Comment on this

What is the latest date of that?

Comment on this

1926. That is the latest issue. The value of butter consumed by the urban population, otherwise than by the agricultural community, in that year was £1,778,000 and the price of butter in the same year was 1/8 a lb., so that if we increase the price of butter by 4d. a lb., which is the maximum we can do under this proposal, one-fifth of that sum is the most we can impose on the community buying butter in this country—that is, somewhere about £300,000 to £400,000, according to these figures. We can judge also from other figures the amount of butter produced by the creameries in 1929, and the amount produced by the factories; the amount consumed at home, out of the production of the factories, and what was produced on the farms, and the figure would work out again somewhere about £400,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Does that include the cost of factory butter as well?

Comment on this

Yes. I have not got the exact figures here that we worked out when drawing up the Bill, but I promise to produce them again at some other stage of the Bill. I do not believe that the cost of this scheme going through can be higher to the consumer than in or about £400,000, and that is on the assumption that we are going to put up butter by 4d. a lb. I mentioned already here to-day that for the last two years only on one occasion was the retail price of butter under 1/3, and if you take the difference between the price of butter this year and the price of 1/3 for the last two years, we are going to put it up 2d. a lb.

Deputy Davin asked me if I could give an undertaking about this price. I said in my opening statement that, as far as we could go, we would not allow the retail price of butter to go above 1/5. We can do this much. We can see that the creameries will not be enabled, through this artificial method, to charge more than 142/- per cwt. for their butter, and I said that we believed that that would mean that butter would be sold at 1/5 per lb. I have gone further than that, however, I have got an undertaking from the biggest distributor in Dublin that as long as the price of creamery remains at 142/-, the price of butter here in Dublin, so far as he is concerned, will not be more than 1/5. I have no other machinery than that. To go into price fixing would need an altogether different Bill from this, and I do not think I could meet Deputy Davin by putting in a clause for price fixing purposes. That would entail a Bill in itself. Another question raised by Deputy Hogan and other Deputies was the danger that there will be under this scheme to the new creameries; that we are going to collect the levy on the creamery butter and that we are going to give a bounty on the creamery butter exported. Naturally the price of the farmers' butter will go up in sympathy with the creamery butter and they will not have to pay the levy. That is quite true.

Comment on this

If the Deputy does not understand that I cannot explain it. He should not be here if he does not understand it. It is quite obvious that the price of the farmers' butter will go up in sympathy with the price of creamery. There is a danger that the new creameries may suffer and we intend to provide some protection for the new creameries that are in very strong opposition to the ordinary farm butter-making in their own area. There might be a grave danger of the people going back to make their own butter if they were getting more for it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan (Galway)

What are your lines?

Comment on this

Power will be taken to vary the levy in particular cases. Particular creameries will be named in the Bill. Deputy Hogan also said that he was afraid that wherever this sort of artificial method of marketing was adopted it did not give much incentive to the people to do the best form of marketing. He instanced the case of Australia, and also of Poland with regard to bacon. I think if the Deputy will examine the figures with regard to Australia he will have to admit that Australia improved her marketing considerably during the last three or four years. The price of Australian butter in the British market has gone down naturally like all other butter, but relatively to New Zealand I find it has come much closer to New Zealand butter last year than the year before. For the year before there was 11/- of a difference, and last year the difference was only 4/-. So that I think it cannot be disputed that Australia has done something towards the improvement of her marketing, even though the scheme was in operation for the last five or six years. I might also mention that the volume of exports from Australia has increased remarkably during the last three years under the scheme.

In the same way I think that we can hardly draw a conclusion from the case of Polish bacon, because Poland came into the British market and the market here as a new country supplying bacon against countries that were well-established like Denmark, the United States, England and Ireland, and there was a prejudice, I suppose, against the buying of Polish bacon which had to be worn down. In any case, I think that the thing that must be kept in mind is this—it was already stressed by the Minister for Defence—that we must keep in production. That is the thing that must be kept in our minds all the time. Practically every Deputy has admitted that something must be done for the dairying industry. A good many Deputies, who were probably anxious to see this scheme going through, felt it was rather up to them to make some objection and said that we were raising the money the wrong way; that we should raise the money by taxation rather than by putting it on the consumer.

Comment on this

Is not this taxation?

Comment on this

All right, it is taxation. That we should raise it in some other way, rather than by putting it on the consumption of butter. I am not averse to that scheme at all. I do not think any member of the Executive Council is averse to it. But we find that we are left in such a position that we have to look for some millions of pounds to balance the Budget this year and we have to tax different things. So that if I want to put a scheme like this through I have to look after it myself, without going to the Minister for Finance who has enough to do to make good the deficiency of the last couple of years.

Comment on this

It is better to look for it where it is than looking for it where it is not.

Comment on this

Deputy Good was mistaken in thinking that the price would be increased 4d. over the tariff price. That is not right. The tariff is 4d. During the winter of course there is no intention whatever of putting on a bounty in addition to the tariff. It would be impossible in the first place, because they work more or less parallel. The intention is to reduce the price to the consumer in the winter by keeping a level price all the year round, so that really there will be that advantage to the consumer, at any rate, that he will get butter at 1/5 in the winter as well as in the summer.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say what is the meaning of the words in the first paragraph of the resolution: "There shall be charged, levied, and paid in respect of all butter imported into or manufactured in Saorstát Eireann...?"

Comment on this

"With such, if any, exceptions as may be prescribed or authorised by statute."

Comment on this

There is an ambiguity. I have no doubt that the interpretation is as the Minister puts it, but it conveys quite a different interpretation.

Comment on this

I am not well up in these legal documents but anyway there is going to be no change as far as the tariff is concerned. Perhaps this is necessary to keep the tariff as it is, or something like that. The Bill will make the matter much plainer when it is introduced.

Comment on this

What will the increase in the price be in addition to the tariff? We will have a 4d. tariff in the winter, because there will be a shortage of home-made butter. What will the subsidy increase that 4d. by, or will it increase it at all?

Comment on this

Not at all. There will be no levy at all during the winter.

Comment on this

The Minister says that the maximum price in winter will be 1/5. If this bounty did not operate, what would the average price of butter be in the winter?

Comment on this

It went up to 1/7 towards the end of last winter. It was 1/4 at the beginning and 1/7 at the end.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Is not the real position that this will not interfere with the winter price, but leave it the same as with the tariff? Is that the intention?

Comment on this

The retail price will be lower under this scheme. It will be 1/5 all the time.

Comment on this

If the Minister suggests that if the bounty did not operate the price would go up to 1/7, is it not obvious that 1/7 per lb. would be better for the farmer than 1/5? What good is the bounty then?

Comment on this

It would if he got it. 1/2 or 1/2½ all the summer; 1/4 for most of the winter, and 1/7 for a month at the end, would not be as good as 1/5 all the year round. As a matter of fact, it has been contended by many Deputies that the consumer is going to pay much more under this scheme than he has paid. That is going to the farmer anyway, so that the farmer must be better off. There is nobody else to get it.

Comment on this

What will the increase in the summer price be?

Comment on this

A maximum of 4d. It cannot be more than 4d.; it may be less.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Am I right in stating that the intention is this: to put on the bounty and to retain the tariff but at the same time to see to it that the summer price shall be raised by no more than 4d. over the world price and the same in winter?

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

If the world price goes up to 1/3 in the winter it will be 1/3 plus 4d.?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Unless there is a price-fixing machinery.

Comment on this

It would not be price-fixing but we would always have a remedy. We can allow butter to come in.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Supposing the world price in summer goes up to 1/3, will not the summer price of butter here be 1/7?

Comment on this

No, as a matter of fact in that case I understand we come down to meet the price. Probably it would be 1/3 here also, because we meet it at 123/- per cwt.

Comment on this

If the tariff is effective the levy will not be productive. The levy will not be productive at the same time as the tariff is effective.

Comment on this

Yes. A lot of these questions will be made plain in the Bill. The Bill is much more detailed. In reply to Deputy Norton, we have of course considered very carefully the advantageous position that the farmers will be in in regard to the creameries and we are trying to provide against that as well as possible. The point was made by Deputy Hogan that there might be a tendency to export during the summer. If we say to the creameries we are not going to allow a charge of 142/- in the winter any more than in the summer there will be a tendency to export, and why should anyone cold store? We mean to vary the bounty in such a way as to lower it in August and September, when they should be storing it for the winter, and to give an incentive, whatever it should be, of a few shillings a cwt. or so to store for the winter. In that case also there will be provision made not to collect the levy until the butter is taken out of cold storage.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It will come up later on.

Comment on this

Yes. Deputy Blythe and Deputy McGilligan were very much afraid we might lose the ten per cent. preference. I do not know why that question should be raised now.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Why not?

Comment on this

We had not anticipated that this ten per cent. would be lost. If and when it is lost it will be time enough to face the question. Deputy McGilligan said that I had learned certain things. He put me a certain question. He said suppose we should lose the ten per cent. preference how are we going to make it up, and then he said Denmark, not being able to put butter into Germany, had to send it to England, so that you cannot annihilate trade by tariffs. That, I suppose, is the well-known axiom of the indestructibility of matter. Deputy McGilligan said you cannot annihilate butter by tariffs. How is Britain going to annihilate our butter if she takes away the ten per cent.? I asked Deputy McGilligan to solve that. If she takes off the ten per cent. and if Great Britain puts a tariff against us how is she going to annihilate our butter? Take this row we are accused of getting into with the British and suppose we get three million of land annuities and that they withdraw the preference, how much will that be worth? How much do we get for our butter and eggs in the British market? Our preferences amount to half a million pounds, so that Deputy Gorey or anybody else would take the three million pounds in that case. It would be a very good bargain if we could pull it off.

We are told further that the ten per cent. may be actually raised at Ottawa. But so far as we can learn from the statements of British statesmen and others there is just the possibility that the ten per cent. may be taken off altogether. We do not know what way it is going to go.

Deputy Anthony said if he thought this was going to guarantee employment to another 200 men he would support it. But as a Labour representative he is not a bit ashamed to say that he will not support any proposal to get the farmers out of the difficulty of producing milk at costs under the costs of production. As long as we made a farmer produce milk to be sold at a cost under the cost of production, Deputy Anthony, as a Labour man, will make them do so. He says we said nothing about tillage. Have we any guarantee, Deputy Anthony wants to know, that our export trade will continue, provided we do certain things with regard to the removal of certain other things. Have we any guarantee, he asks, that our export trade will continue if we do something for the dairy farmers and the keeping of cows. Have we any guarantee with regard to anything in regard to the import or export market? I cannot give a guarantee, but we are doing our best to provide for the continuance of our export trade as well as for the maintenance of our home market.

Deputy Dillon made a complaint that the money comes from the wrong source. He said that the slump brought butter within the reach of the very poor. I do not think it did. Deputy Dillon also spoke of the diseases, and in this he was seconded by Deputy Cosgrave, caused, he said, in Denmark by the want of vitamins, and because the people were not eating enough fresh meat and butter and eggs and other things; they were exporting these things to foreign markets and eating margarine themselves. We were warned that if we had this bounty on the export of our butter we may have the position that all our fresh butter might go to the British market and that we would have to live on margarine and suffer from the want of vitamins. I do not know which vitamin it is, and, therefore, cannot discuss it. It may be the vitamin which is in lettuce or cabbage and, therefore, we are all right. Deputy Dillon suggested a tax on tea, and Deputy Cosgrave said that butter was an important article of food and should not be taxed. Note the hypocrisy of a man who was leader of a Government for nine years and several times raised the tax on sugar, an essential article of food, and now declared that butter should not be taxed because it is an essential article of food. Deputy Bennett went back to 1921, and told us about the placards put up in England against this country saying "No Irish goods sold here." Yet I think if we go back to 1921 and find out what our trade with England was then and what our prices were like, we have to come to the conclusion that the placards put up in shop windows were not effective. They were not trying to sell goods to the bigots who tried to stop our goods. They were sold in England and got good prices. Deputy Brasier wants to know has this benefited Australia. I think it has. I think, from the quotations Deputy Brasier gave, he has a good knowledge of the conditions in Australia himself and can form a sound conclusion.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Is it still in existence in Australia?

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

Is it effective?

Comment on this

With regard to the question put by Deputy O'Neill, as to what is the machinery, the machinery is very well set out in the Bill. I think there would be really no use in going into the matter now. We hope that the Bill will be circulated in a few days. As I say, a lot of those points which are more or less going into detail will probably be explained more lucidly in the Bill. This financial resolution is more or less a synopsis of what we are putting in the Bill. I think many of the questions that Deputies have been asking and that have been agitating their minds will be clearly explained in the Bill. Really the only question now before the House is the question of whether the House should allow us to go on with this matter or not.

Comment on this