Private Deputies' Business. - Constitution (Removal of Oath) Bill, 1932—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 146–339 of 339. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 2 of 1932 ›
I would not ask him to withdraw, because anything he says is a compliment to decent people. There is one thing anyway, I have white hands, which he has not.
Comment on this
I think we should insist on the withdrawal of the statement. When a Deputy is assured that there is no proof for a charge he makes, he should withdraw it in common decency.
Comment on this
A charge against a certain Deputy that he mobilised a certain section to murder another Deputy. That is a statement that should not be made, particularly when it is expressly denied by the Deputy himself. I would ask Deputy Corry for the sake of the dignity of the House that he should withdraw the statement, and that he would not repeat such statements but confine himself to the terms of the Bill.
Comment on this
Is that not by implication a reiteration of the charge that has already been withdrawn?
Comment on this
Any Party is open to certain statements. Anybody can describe it as "a certain combination." Surely that is not a matter to which anybody can object.
Comment on this
I submit that by again repeating the words "this combination" of which he says one was a man who organised a body of men to assassinate another, he expressly repeats the allegation.
Comment on this
He is making no personal charge against any Deputy. When he made a personal charge against the Deputy I got Deputy Corry to withdraw it. A Party is fair game for such statements as Deputy Corry is making. Any Party is fair game for such a charge.
Comment on this
Another Party is, but what about the combination? This combination includes Deputy Shaw, who, he said, organised a body of men to assassinate another Deputy.
Comment on this
I do not know where I am. I understood that the Deputy who has spoken came into this Dáil four years ago. I saw him solemnly coming in here to vote for President de Valera as President of the Executive Council. Where is he to-day? I am sick of this kind of humbug.
We hear a lot about the economic viewpoint on this matter. We heard a lot of noise as to what John Bull is going to do. Deputy Roddy told us last night that we have already lost a farthing a lb. on our beef, while Deputy J. J. Byrne became quite eloquent about the unfortunate farmers who could not sell their milk, butter or eggs to John Bull. But look at the blessing that would be for the unfortunate people that Deputy Byrne talked about the other day when he said they were not able to buy a pound of butter. Look how cheap it would be for them. You cannot have it both ways. Then we had a speech from my colleague, Deputy Brasier, from East Cork. He was put out entirely about our losing our best customer and about all the trouble there would be. I know exactly where the shoe pinches the Deputy. I know he is highly troubled over the Oath business for fear the gentry who came over here recruiting in 1914 beating the big drum, and inviting young Irishmen to go out and fight for small nations, will no longer be sending over their cast-off clothes for the unfortunate maimed cripples who acted on their advice.
Comment on this
I have been trying to explain the different reasons Deputies have given for opposing this Bill. A number of Deputies to-day gave their reasons as to why Labour were voting with us. I think I am entitled to point out some of the reasons why Independent Deputies are going to vote with Cumann na nGaedheal to see that the Oath which nobody wants is kept in force here. Then we had Deputy Minch telling us about those who went out to fight for small nations. He forgot to tell us that when these unfortunate individuals came back they had to handle their rifles again—a lot of them—and fight for the freedom of this small nation.
I think I never listened to anything more ridiculous than the arguments which were put up here during the last few days. It was absolutely sickening. The whole cry from Deputies on the opposite side for the last two days has been that the Oath should remain. Deputy Minch and practically every Deputy who spoke on that side of the House admitted that we have the legal right to do what is proposed. If we have I do not see why we should go negotiating about it. I do not see John Bull coming over here to negotiate about anything.
Everyone knows that the people of this country are morally entitled to the land annuities. We had legal arguments put up from time to time as to why the land annuities should be paid over, and as long as the last Government were in power they insisted on observing that so-called legal right and paid over the annuities. I got up to say that I am glad Deputies will have plenty of time to discuss this until midnight to-morrow, and I hope they will take full advantage of it. They are not going to be limited as we were when the last murder Bill, or the Public Safety Bill, was being steam-rolled through all its stages in the Dáil in one day. We are giving them plenty of time and I hope they will take full advantage of it.
Comment on this
I hope it will be possible even at this late stage to get the House to come back to a serious consideration of the very important subject that is before us. The difficulty in addressing oneself to the consideration of a Bill which has ranged over such a wide field is the fact that some persons in this House seem to consider that all Irish history began in 1916. They seem to think that the State or the form of Government is a greater thing than the nation. The late Tom Kettle described the vagaries of some of our politicians. He once used the phrase that we were endeavouring to create an impossible future out of an imaginary past. We might paraphrase that epigram, as I may call it, and say that this House is going to create for this country an impossible future out of an imaginary mandate.
The word "mandate" has loomed largely in the discussions, but what we mean by a mandate has never been defined. I take it to be the unequivocal desire of a people or a nation towards some end. Judged by that, even the Fianna Fáil people have not got a mandate to form a Government. They have not a working majority in this House, and they can only get a majority by a coalition with the rump of what was once the Labour Party. The Labour Party has got no mandate whatever to take hand, act or part in any proceedings that are likely to jeopardise very seriously the security and the future good order of the country. If there was any doubt about that Deputy Norton their leader, in more than one pronouncement that he made since the election, laid it down definitely that he would be no party to tampering with such things as the Oath unless and until they could be re-arranged by negotiation. Furthermore he promised that these things would get no consideration from his Party while such an important economic subject as unemployment remained unsolved.
If there was any doubt whatever about the attitude of a single individual of that Party I can speak for the senior member for West Cork, Deputy T. J. Murphy. He gave an unmistakable pledge to the people of his constituency on more than one occasion that he stood by the Treaty, and it was on that promise and pledge that he was elected as senior member for that important constituency. Some short time ago the Labour Party dismissed from its ranks two men decause their consciences directed them to take a certain course that was not in consonance with the agreement they had with their Party. Now this same Party, which took such great account of a Party pledge, is going seriously and deliberately to break a solemn pledge they made to their constituents. We shall see that verified in a very short time. It is difficult for us on this side of the House to escape some of the taunts that have been levelled at us. It would seem from the speeches delivered from the other side that we are here holding a special brief for John Bull, and that we are taking up a very pro-English attitude on this.
I, personally, protest against that. I am sure that, if we were looked into, there would be found in us as much Fenian reaction as there is on the other side. It is no more pleasure to us to have to take this Oath than it is to many of the individuals on the opposite benches, and the only distinction is this, that we, by implication, feel bound in honour to take an Oath which was part and parcel of a solemn Treaty, entered into ten years ago, between this country of ours and England. Two things emerge from the very important speech of the Attorney-General, and these two points that stand out boldly are, first, that he acknowledged that there were two viewpoints. That is an important admission from a gentleman occupying his position. He also said that the speech he was delivering should be delivered, not against us, but rather against the supporters of the Oath in England. These two points are the very points that this Party, in the amendment it has put on the Paper, claim consideration for. We wish not to proceed, by deliberate action, to take this Oath out of the Treaty, or out of the Constitution, and thereby interfere with the Treaty, but to do it by consultation, and after due deliberation, and after consulting authorities on the subject, and also by addressing ourselves, or asking the Attorney-General to address himself, on our behalf and on behalf of the House, to England on the question. That is our case. We want negotiation on the matter, and it will be found better for this country, hereafter, if a little more discretion is exercised before this important matter was rushed through in this manner.
Ten years ago a very important mission set out from this country with a problem for solution. That problem was to find out how far Irish national aspirations could be reconciled with membership of the Commonwealth of Nations known as the British Empire. There was unity in Ireland then. That formula was arrived at to express what would be acceptable to this country, and it was after many vicissitudes, on the solution of that problem, that the Treaty was founded, and it was then, and there, and at that time, that the Republic was let down. Where we stand to-day, it is difficult to decide, as it is difficult to understand the political mentality of our friends, on the opposite side of the House. Up to a certain point, they call themselves Republicans, and then, they call themselves the Fianna Fáil Party, without any deliberate policy, and without any attitude towards this country, except the very negative one, of doing everything possible to destroy the Free State, and burst up the institutions, founded here in the last ten years. We have been told that we should read between the lines of Mr. Thomas's communication. There is an insinuation also that that communication of Mr. Thomas was sent from this side of the House. We were told deliberately that the matter of this Oath was one, purely and solely, for ourselves. We were told it was purely a domestic question and the first thing done, in regard to settling this domestic question, is to send a note across to Mr. Thomas to the British House of Commons.
Comment on this
I stand contradicted, if you wish, but the communication was received by Mr. Thomas and it came from the President.
Comment on this
At all events it was said to be a domestic question and it was taken out of the jurisdiction of this House and sent across to Mr. Thomas at his request.
Comment on this
Well, that is what gave rise to the further communications. We, here, quite agree that if this is a domestic question it should have been discussed here, and this House should have been consulted before any action was taken in the matter.
Comment on this
If the President has anything to say would he say it so that I can hear it. I am not a bit afraid to listen to it.
Comment on this
When the Deputy gets more accustomed to the practice of the House and the work an Executive has to do he will understand.
Comment on this
The opportunity was taken in this communication to speak not alone disrespectfully, but rather to traduce the memory of two men who died for the observance of their honour in regard to that Treaty. We were told in this correspondence that "the agreement divided the people of Ireland into two hostile camps—those who deemed it their duty to resist, facing the consequences, and those who deemed it prudent, in the national interest, temporarily, to submit, the latter being placed in the no less cruel position of having apparently to hold Ireland for England." I think that is a reflection on the honour of two of the greatest men of modern Ireland, who came from my constituency— Michael Collins and Seán Hales—and I protest, in the strongest manner, against their memory being traduced in the statement that they were men who were compelled to hold Ireland for England.
We were told that this Treaty was originally freedom to achieve freedom, and that statement was used sneeringly from the Government benches; but who, in any part of the House, will deny that Ireland is better off to-day, in its legislative institutions, than it was ten years ago? There is, in fact, nothing to stop President de Valera to-morrow from declaring definitely and openly that he will walk out of the British Commonwealth of Nations and set up a Republic for the Twenty-six Counties. You have freedom to achieve that, and I do not believe England will stir one hand, or fire one shot to prevent that beautiful consummation.
Partition has been brought into this question a good deal, but who created partition in this country? Partition, I suppose, was really created by the Government of Ireland (1920) Act, but when the Free State was set up, it was set up for all Ireland, and the Treaty was made for all Ireland, it being left to the North to opt out if they wished. There was a chance, a great chance, and a great opportunity, when the Treaty was passed, that the North might possibly come in. In fact, for a time, there was a little waiting space, during which it was hoped that some negotiations might be entered into that might bring about that result. The negotiations either did not take place, or had an abortive result, and the North, all this time, had not said a word about the passing of the Treaty, although the Free State applied to them, as well as to us. It was not until President de Valera raised the standard of revolt here that the standard of revolt was raised, at the same time, by Sir Edward Carson in Ulster. That is how partition was consolidated, and now the only chance you have is to keep firmly within the Commonwealth of Nations. There is, then, some common ground on which you can meet the North. Abolish your Oath; do away with your Treaty, and never again will the chance arise of coming to an agreement with the North.
The economic consequences that follow from this I do not propose to enter into. They may be too big and too serious to contemplate. But we cannot get over the fact that recently the firm of Messrs. Jacobs intimated in no uncertain way that if the Treaty is tampered with they certainly will have to create a lot of unemployment amongst their hands. A like situation may arise in the case of Guinness's stout. If you abolish Guinness's stout what are you going to substitute for it in the City of Dublin?
Comment on this
No. "Spanish ale will give you hope, my dark Rosaleen." Take care that Spanish ale may have a lot of froth on it, and it may contain some corrosive acid that will eat into the vitals of our country.
Comment on this
Our position is clear. All the rights you require and can exercise for the development of social order and national self-consciousness are given within the limits of the Treaty, and you can use them, but there is nothing to prevent you from becoming as Irish as you like and as anti-English as you like. There is nothing to prevent you from developing and making laws protecting your industries in any way you like. What more freedom will you get under a Republic or any other form of government that you do not derive at present from the position under the Treaty and from being within the Commonwealth of Nations? If we take this dispute, if you like to call it that, with regard to the Oath and the Treaty for consideration with the other parties to that Treaty. I am sure it will be capable of adjustment and rearrangement if necessary. I agree with the Attorney-General that countries advance and institutions develop and if we find it necessary now for any purpose, for the internal peace and good order and harmony of our country, to have certain changes made I am sure there would be no difficulty about having them made. But do not let us go take them like a bull at a gate. Let us take them with consideration. The matter is a delicate one. There may be strained relations that may have very serious consequences for the country. In connection with the negotiations, I have here before me a copy of a letter written by General Smuts to President de Valera about the time the settlement was made in 1921. General Smuts is a man something like our own Michael Collins who fought very hard against England and who fought to maintain the status of his own country once peace was made. Writing to President de Valera he said:
If, as I hope, you accept, you will become a sister Dominion in a great circle of equal States, who will stand beside you and shield you and protect your new rights as if these were their own rights; who will view an invasion of your rights or a violation of your status as if it was an invasion and a violation of their own, and who will thus give you the most effective guarantee possible against any possible arbitrary interference by the British Government with your rights and position. In fact, the British Government will have no further basis of interference with your affairs, as your relations with Great Britain will be a concern not of the British Government, but of the Imperial Conference of which Great Britain will be only one of seven members. Any questions in issue between you and the British Government will be for the Imperial Conference to decide. You will be a free member of a great League, of which most of the other members will be in the same position as yourself; and the Conference will be the forum for thrashing out any questions which may arise between members.
Comment on this
The Labour Party have been criticised for the action we have taken on this occasion. What is more natural for the Labour Party than to be with the Party which is prepared to advance along the road of complete freedom of this country? I have been criticised to-day by my colleagues from County Wicklow who asked me where I got a mandate for this. I got a mandate from the people who returned me for the past ten years to do everything possible in their interests and the interests of the Irish nation. I got a mandate to improve the conditions of the poor and to demand legislation for the widows and orphans. The Government have agreed to bring in proposals so that these poor people in future will have some hope, instead of depending on the charity of the public. I represent an ancient constituency that had the honour of returning a man to represent Wicklow and vote against the betrayal of Ireland by the Act of Union. That constituency also had the honour of producing a great leader of the Irish nation who always maintained in his fight for this country that no man had the right to put a limit to the onward march of the nation, and that was Charles Stewart Parnell. I say that we are now attempting to bring Ireland a step further. Deputies on these benches have not made any reference to men who may differ from us. I respect their opinion and I hold that they are probably as patriotic and as good Irishmen as men who are taking the other side to-night. We should be prepared to differ. We are all concerned as to what we should do for the advancement of the country. I belong to one of the largest trade unions in Ireland—the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union. One of the leaders of that Union in 1916, when he was bringing out his men to fight for the freedom of the country in the Citizen Army, unfurled a banner bearing the inscription, "We owe no allegiance to King or Kaiser, but to the people of Ireland." That was Jim Connolly. I am proud to maintain that doctrine and vote with the men who say that the people of Ireland are the only people who claim our allegiance. We are told that this will bring strife. We have been attacked by Deputy Gorey who said that we always had maintained that the removal of the Oath should be by negotiation. I admit that, but with whom are we going to negotiate? Is it with the Dominion Secretary who before he receives any communication from the Irish people or the representatives of this State said that he refused to allow any change or alteration in the Oath? Before any negotiations could be begun, before this Dáil got an opportunity of discussing the matter, Mr. Thomas closed the door of any hope of successful negotiation with him or his representatives. We are told that this will bring strife. God knows that the people I represent, the unemployed and the working classes, have suffered for ten years misery and hardship as the result of that Oath. If its removal will bring peace to this unfortunate country then, I say, it is our duty to take any risk to try and reunite the forces of the country, because, to my mind it is most important to have our countrymen, no matter how we may differ on other matters, united now which will bring peace and hope for the future, instead of having as we have had for the last ten years brother against brother, family against family, and misery and starvation for the purpose of maintaining what we consider is not worth fighting about and that is the Oath of Allegiance to a foreign monarch.
We have always maintained that this was not a final settlement. If the Irish people, by a majority, have given authority to the Fianna Fáil Party to remove this Oath, they have not been deceived. Cumann na nGaedheal had their Party machinery in my own constituency. They brought their paid organisers there, and ex - service officers went round amongst the people and tried to impress upon them that if the Fianna Fáil Government were returned the Oath would be removed and we would have war. The people did not heed their appeal because, in the last ten years, they heard similar appeals and because the working class people know that no matter what happened they could not be treated worse than they have been in the last ten years. They were prepared to take risks and to place their confidence in the Fianna Fáil Party that had adopted the Christian principle that it was the duty of the Government to do something on behalf of the poor and the unemployed people of the Saor-stát.
We have heard talk about honour— honour with a nation. Honour with what nation? With a nation that only recognises honour when it suits herself. As pointed out in the correspondence that has taken place, England does not know what honour is, that is, in her treatment of Ireland. I did not intend to intervene in this debate only I was challenged by my colleague. I have nothing personal against him. It is enough for England to put up her own case against the rights of Ireland. If we have coequal partnership and equal status, surely we have a right to do what the Irish people believe those rights permit them to do, and, if necessary, to change the Treaty. I would be prepared to change the Treaty if that meant bringing peace and happiness to this country. We are not to be dictated to by any foreign country.
Speeches have been made here, and arguments put up that would not even be put up by representatives of the British Government. Time enough if trouble comes, and if it does, let the Irish people get together and remember what we were able to do in the days of the Sinn Féin movement, when all parties were united. I believe that as a result of the removal of this formula men and women in the Irish-Ireland movement will leave certain associations and come together with the Fianna Fáil Party and the Labour Party to stand for Ireland against England. I am sure all parties in this House will be prepared to make a sacrifice, and in 1932 to put us in the position we were in in 1921, and then we will have the people of Ireland— labourers, shopkeepers and others— standing for Ireland, united against the common enemy in the interests of our unfortunate country.
Comment on this
I did not desire to intervene in this debate and only do so as a result of the speech of the last Deputy. He said that the people of Ireland had a right to govern their own destinies. They have, and we are meeting here to-night on the sixteenth anniversary of the occasion when, possibly, a small minority of persons did something which made it possible for us to meet here to-night and discuss this matter. They made it possible for the President and his Ministry and for the work of the last ten years to be carried on. I take it that is accepted, but when Deputy Everett says he was sent here to this House to speak on behalf of Labour, and that he had a mandate to destroy the instrument which enables us to meet here, I say he is making a statement that is not in accordance with facts. Neither Deputy Everett nor any other Labour Deputy got a mandate to come to this Dáil to vote for any measure that would be a violation of the Treaty of 1921. Never during that ten years did any member of the Labour Party suggest that they would do anything that would jeopardise the Treaty position, as they always described it. If Deputy Everett, or Deputy Curran, or any other Labour Deputy say they did not make such a statement, I am prepared to withdraw it. The President said a division on this important measure will be taken, and why should we talk about it; it will be decided by votes in the end. Why is it that people are present in this House to cast votes? They are here because they were elected by the votes of the people of Ireland. And I say here, without fear of contradiction even from Deputy Everett, that the votes that will really decide this issue were obtained under false pretences.
Never did Deputy Curran or Deputy Everett or any other Labour Deputy say that he or they would do anything that would interfere—I will use their own words which were "jeopardise the Treaty position." They were always very careful to say that. Deputy Everett said to-night that they stood for pensions for widows, for an extension of the Old Age Pensions Scheme, for pensions for orphans and so forth. That was a very plausible and a very proper scheme to put forward. But on every occasion wherever I heard any Deputy of the Labour Party speaking or wherever I read their reported speeches there was always this statement "we will do nothing which will jeopardise the Treaty position." If Deputy Everett desires to correct me I am prepared to withdraw but he does not.
Comment on this
It was not Deputy Everett said that. The leader of the Labour Party told this House that it was important that this measure should be passed. Why is it important that it should be passed? The leader of the Labour Party spoke at many meetings not only in his own constituency but throughout the country. At that time not as leader but as a responsible person in the Labour Party he stated the case for the Labour Party and why the people should support them. On no occasion did he say that his Party would do anything that would be a breach of the Treaty. He said, and he was always very careful to say it, that they were prepared to negotiate with Great Britain. His followers here can contradict me if that is not so. He said they would be prepared to negotiate with Great Britain for an alteration of the Treaty terms and of the terms of the ultimate financial settlement. The motion which we are discussing to-night is a motion that this Bill should not pass until what the Labour Party asked for is done— namely that there should be negotiations with the other Party to the Treaty and the ultimate financial settlement. That was what was promised by the Labour Party—what is left of them now and it is very small. I do not think it is necessary at this hour to ask why it is the Labour Party has changed its attitude.
Comment on this
I would like to ask, on a point of order, whether Deputy O'Sullivan is discussing the Labour Party or the motion before the House?
Comment on this
I have the right to discuss in this House the motion and to urge that the Bill before the House should not get a Second Reading until what the Labour Party promised the electors has been carried out. What I I am discussing is a matter about which the Labour Party should see. I am discussing the attitude of the Labour Party to this motion because I believe that the seven members of the Labour Party were returned to the House on a promise that they would not support a motion like this; because of a promise that they would not take any steps that would, as they themselves said, jeopardise the Treaty position. If Deputy Everett will say that is not so, I am prepared to withdraw.
Comment on this
The President said when introducing this Bill that there was no need for further speeches because it is the votes that will tell in the end.
Comment on this
"There is no need for further discussion on this matter," said the President in opening the case, "because," said he, "we will decide it by votes." I do not want to misquote the President. He is often misquoted. If that is not a fair interpretation of what he said, I am prepared to accept his interpretation of what he meant to say. There is no doubt about it the people of this country did give to the President and his Party a number of votes sufficient to make his the biggest Party in this House——
Comment on this
So am I. After his own argument there is certainly no reason why the President of the Executive Council elected because of the votes got from the people should come into this House and say flamboyantly if I may so describe it "I have got a mandate from the people of Ireland to remove this Oath." He said that. But did he ever say to the people of Ireland during the election campaign that it was quite possible that the removal of this Oath from the Constitution may be a breach of the Treaty? Because had he said so I submit that he would not have got even the increased votes that he got. President de Valera sits in the President's Chair to-night under false pretences.
Comment on this
If Deputy Flynn will translate into Irish what he said I will reply. The President sits here as President of the Executive Council and Chairman of the Fianna Fáil Party who are alleged to have behind them the support and the votes of the people of Ireland. I tell him that if he insists in pressing this measure to a conclusion he will be doing it and acting under false pretences. Deputy Everett has agreed with me that never did the Labour Party or any member of it say that they would in any way do anything in this House which would interfere with the Treaty position. It is quite possible that persons would say that they were not interfering with the Treaty position. I see no reason why the Irish people should not make a bargain with any other people, Great Britain, France, Portugal or America if their Government thought fit. I understand that the Fianna Fáil Party got several votes at the last election because of the Treaty made by the late Government with the French Government in connection with the reduction of taxation on French wine. I see no reason why we could not repudiate any such Treaty but let us say so openly. This measure does not do what President de Valera said to the people of Ireland he would do. He told the people that he would remove the Oath out of the Treaty without breaking the Treaty. He got his votes on the grounds that he was going to remove the Oath without breaking the Treaty, and by removing the Oath he would bring about peace. I say he was wrong. If he removes the Oath it will break the Treaty and it will not bring peace.
There was no attempt made by the President, or anybody speaking on the Government's behalf, to defend the measure. I may have misunderstood the President's words, but I think he did say something very like this: "What is the use of talking about it? This will be decided by votes in the end." I say that is fair enough, provided the votes have been got honestly. The seven Labour members who will decide this will march into the Division Lobbies in favour of this measure, but will the President feel that he has got those votes honestly?
There are times when people have to come down to hard tacks, and they should say what they really mean. I have challenged the Labour Party to say whether or not any individual member ever did seek votes on the ground that he would stand for the removal of the Oath, and so interfere with the Treaty position. No member of the Labour Party can say that he has adopted that attitude. It is not for me to explain why the Labour Party has taken up its present position. They got votes in the country under false pretences. I challenge Deputy Curran to say if, at any of his meetings, he ever declared he would support the President in any effort he would make to remove the Oath, whether or not that would be detrimental to the Treaty position.
Comment on this
I rise in order to contradict a statement. The people of County Dublin knew Curran's views since 1917, when he was instructed by Sinn Féin to pledge allegiance on all public boards with which he was connected, and Curran's name is recorded on several minute books throughout County Dublin.
Comment on this
It is very interesting to me to hear that Deputy Curran's views have been known since 1917. I am sure it is very interesting to Deputies who applaud, and also to those on the Gallery who join in the applause. But what does it mean to the people of the country what Deputy Curran thought in 1917, if, by his vote now, he is going to put them into a position which will be detrimental, not only to the interests of the people of County Dublin, but to the interests of the State from one end to the other? The Deputy has not answered the question I put him. I asked him if, during the course of his election campaign, he ever said he would do this. No, he did not. The seven Labour members who will vote, as they have got to vote for this measure to-night, will be really voting against the persons who returned them here. They were never sent here to vote against the Treaty.
It was declared here that this measure was not a breach of the Treaty. I believe we here form a sovereign Parliament. I understand that under one of the Articles of the Constitution, the State cannot be involved in warfare except with the consent of the Oireachtas. The President could declare war on any country in Europe, or the world, if you like. He laughs at that, but that is the unfortunate tragedy of it all. The President can declare war on France and get a resolution from this House on the grounds that he has already indicated, that it is the votes that will count in the end. It is not the reasoning or the common sense that will count; it is really the votes that will count in the last analysis. He would have his votes here to support his proposal.
The President and Deputy Norton, the leader of the Labour Party, have told us that this proposal will bring peace. There are numbers of persons in this country who think they are soldiers, and that they cannot be soldiers unless they are fighting the State. Is there anything in the Constitution to prevent the President from conscripting these persons and making them real soldiers? He could make me a soldier if he liked.
Comment on this
It was quite loud enough for you. I said it out in Rathfarnham, too.
Comment on this
There is sufficient power in the Constitution to enable the President to bring in a measure to do anything he wishes, provided, as he has mentioned, that the votes will count in the end and that the Labour Party will be there all the time. He could introduce a measure making it compulsory on every able-bodied youth of seventeen or eighteen, and upwards, to be a soldier. He could, at any time, mobilise all these youths and declare war on France, Russia or America, or even Northern Ireland—any place he likes. That is the freedom which we possess, but this measure is going to take that away. Why? It is going to take it away so that persons who do not believe that President de Valera sits in the Presidential Chair as head of the Executive Council and has the legal, moral and proper right to govern this country, may be facilitated. These people claim that the real Government is a Government outside this House. The seven members of the Labour Party who will follow the President into the Division Lobby will, by their action, show that they stand for that immoral principle. Deputy Curran did say something about the Oath, which appears in the Official Debates of the 22nd April. I am sure he will repudiate it now. He said:—
I hope the present Government will get to work immediately to remove unemployment. Deputy Byrne, as far as I can see, is more concerned with the Oath. I am not concerned at least with the Oath.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, on this day week we were speaking of unemployment, and the speech of Deputy J.J. Byrne was all about the Oath. I said at the time that I was not concerned with the Oath but with the unemployment question. To-day, we are dealing with the Oath, on which I am not going to say anything because I am only a new member of the House. That is my explanation of what I said on this day week. It was unemployment that we were dealing with then.
Comment on this
The explanation is excellent, and I think Deputy Curran and the Labour Party should go back to the people and say something like that to them. I ask Deputy Curran now what he has to say about the Oath. Did the people of Dublin send him here to remove the Oath and abrogate the Treaty? He has not replied to that question. As the President said, this measure will be passed and decided in the end by votes, but I want to have on record that I stated that President de Valera and his Party did not get a mandate to remove the Oath in this way. Never did he say that he would break the Treaty. Never did he say that he would do anything which would abrogate the Treaty. Yet, the Dáil will reject the amendment of Deputy Cosgrave that this matter should be dealt with in another way. The amendment will be rejected by the votes of seven Labour members—the remnant of what was once a Labour Party. On one occasion, two members of the Labour Party disagreed with their fellow-members. What did the people of their constituencies say when they went to them? They sent them back here.
Comment on this
Did they send anybody else here? Did Labour send anybody else from Cork or Tipperary?
Comment on this
The Deputy wants to draw me into a discussion about what he calls my own constituency. It is very far from Dublin.
Comment on this
If we met there, we could have a very interesting discussion.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Sullivan is, I think, doing a great deal of drawing himself. I suggest that interruptions should cease.
Comment on this
I did say that the remnant of what was the Labour Party will break the Treaty entered into solemnly ten years ago.
Comment on this
Who is speaking now? Whoever he is, I want to tell him that I was never a remnant of anything.
Comment on this
It has a lot to do with this Bill. Any possible excuse to show that the people of Ireland returned President de Valera with a mandate to break the Treaty is good enough. I was pointing out, when I was interrupted by many persons from the opposite side, that the two Labour members who are not the remnant of the Labour Party and who had the courage to say to their constituents that they would not break the Treaty and would not be associated with anything dishonourable or dishonest were returned by the big constituencies which returned them before. Deputy Anthony came back from Cork and Deputy Morrissey came back from Tipperary. If I am wrong in that, I am wrong in everything I say. Deputy Murphy said somebody else came back from Cork. I do not want to refer to Deputy Murphy because, though I am not ashamed of the fact that I came from West Cork, I desire not to be drawn into West Cork politics. Deputy Murphy came back to this House—I challenge him to deny it—because he gave to the electorate of West Cork a solemn pledge that he would do nothing that would jeopardise the Treaty position.
Comment on this
I was never asked for any pledge in West Cork and I am not afraid to repeat here anything I said in West Cork.
Comment on this
I put it to the Deputy that he said to the people of West Cork that he stood for the Labour programme, which was entirely nonpolitical and that it was in the economic side he was interested. On every occasion that the Oath question or the policy of the President of the Executive Council arose, Deputy Murphy—I almost said hedged —avoided the issue by saying he would do nothing to jeopardise the Treaty position. That is my only interference in West Cork politics. The President of the Executive Council never got a mandate to interfere with the Treaty. The Labour Party remnant came back here pledged not to jeopardise the Treaty position. I do not want to discuss the results of the passing of this measure. I do not desire to discuss the situation internationally. It has been said by Deputies on the opposite benches that anybody who spoke here spoke from the British point of view.
Comment on this
I accept the Deputy's statement. I was not sent here to represent the British point of view. I never took up the cudgels for the British.
Comment on this
I am speaking for the Irish people who sent me here. The persons who are so plucky and so heroic to-night were not so heroic some time ago. The Labour Party or the remnants of that Party will go down in history as the persons responsible for this betrayal of the trust that was given them, even as the remnants of what was supposed to be a Labour Party. Let it not be stated that they were not told publicly in this forum what their responsibility would be. Let them not apologise by saying: "We thought there would be peace." They never said that during the election. They never got a mandate to come here and vote for this measure. They are frightened about it now and they want to make excuses.
Comment on this
Deputy Curran cannot say that he ever stated in County Dublin, Deputy Everett cannot say that he stated in Wicklow, or Deputy Murphy that he stated in West Cork that they would support Deputy de Valera, as he then was, in a movement which would lead to a breach of the Treaty. There is a serious responsibility upon every person who votes for this measure. It is rather usual for those who are in opposition to talk wildly and to vote casually. I would say that on the President of the Executive Council there is a greater responsibility to-night. He is getting his Party in this House to vote for a measure for which they got no mandate. Greater than that is the responsibility on the remnant of the Labour Party, upon the Deputy Murphys, the Deputy Everetts, the Deputy Currans and others.
Comment on this
There is a rule in the Standing Orders governing reiteration of their speeches by Deputies. I heard the Deputy repeating himself three or four times, and I warn him that he will have to say something new if he is to proceed.
Comment on this
Could not Deputy Duggan supply him with a fresh point?
Comment on this
If you, sir, allow persons to interrupt me at the rate at which they are interrupting me and insult me to the extent of saying that Deputy Duggan supplied me with points, I cannot conclude. I would ask every member of this House to think seriously of what the consequences of a defeat of this amendment will be.
Comment on this
On a point of personal explanation. My name has been mentioned in the course of the debate; also the name of Deputy Morrissey, and I want to say in reply to Deputy Everett ——
Comment on this
I will not hear anything about any matter except it refers to the Deputy's own statement in the Dáil.
Comment on this
I know that I am not entitled to speak as I have already spoken on this stage of the Bill.
Comment on this
I cannot hear you on any matter concerning the private differences of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
The reflection was that I was not returned for Cork by Labour votes. I think it was Deputy Everett made that statement. If Deputy Everett says that such is not the case, I am satisfied. Might I suggest that I think this Scriptural quotation would fit in with the whole position: "The stone which was rejected by the builders has become the keystone of the arch."
Comment on this
I do not think I would be doing my duty to the people who sent me here without entering an emphatic protest against the introduction of this measure. We have had the opinion of many lawyers in this Dáil as to whether the Oath is mandatory in the Treaty or not. There is disagreement between the lawyers, and experience teaches us that it is very seldom agreement is found between lawyers, for the simple reason that if there were agreement and unanimity there would be no use for them. Consequently, I am not surprised that we have one opinion expressed by the Attorney-General and another expressed by Deputy Finlay as to whether the Oath is mandatory, and as to whether the Bill introduced by the President violates the Treaty. I am going to take the common sense view of the whole question. The President says that the Bill does not violate the Treaty. The Right Honourable Mr. Thomas, to give the Minister who represents Great Britain his proper title, says that it does. There you have a difference of opinion expressed by the parties to the agreement. I hold that the only common sense thing to do is to settle the matter either by negotiation or in the alternative, by arbitration. What I am going to say now applies in a special manner to the Labour Party. As one who has practical experience of what work is, as one who was a member of a trade union for the past 35 years, if there is one thing more than another upon which Labour depends to secure, maintain and defend the rights of the workers it is that in the event of a dispute between employers and employees, failing an agreement, it is to have recourse to arbitration or negotiation. Any employer who dared to lock out his men without first intimating to them the reason for his action and without giving them an opportunity to negotiate with a view to a settlement would, I am sure, have public opinion against him. Equally the employees, if, instead of submitting their grievances to negotiation and arbitration, they adopted what has brought untold misery upon this country and upon every other country, what is known as the lightning strikes, would have public opinion arrayed against them. So much importance have the Labour Party attached to the settling of disputes by negotiation or arbitration, failing agreement between the workers and employers, that as regards the greatest industry in the country, namely the railways, they had a judge of the High Court to act as the final umpire. I say to the President that he will not be lowering his dignity and I am one of the men who will support him, if he enters into negotiation with Great Britain on this question of the removal of the Oath. As far as I am personally concerned, I did not do very much to secure the signing of the Treaty between this country and Great Britain or this agreement with Great Britain, but I maintain that the agreement cannot be broken except by mutual consent of the parties to it. I am going to enter my emphatic objection and record my vote against the passing of this Bill from an angle totally different from many of the angles from which Deputies have spoken here to-night.
During the past three or four weeks the President, I think, gave as his reasons for the introduction of this Bill that it would have the effect of bringing peace to this country and unless I misjudge the President I think his remarks were in particular directed to that small section of the people of the Free State who have stated that they will not enter the Dáil until the Oath is removed from the Constitution. These people have declared from many platforms in this country that they will not even submit themselves as candidates for election to this Dáil unless the Oath is removed. The view I take of it is this, and I want to emphasise it. Am I to understand that Deputies like myself have got to go through the worry, the expense, the annoyance and the trouble of an election—the fact of the matter is that you have got to be a Jack Dempsey sometimes to defend yourself in fighting an election? Am I to understand that the 153 Deputies who at present occupy these benches have got to go through a campaign such as the last which, in some instances, undermined the health of Deputies and that a small section of this country can without any trouble determine the course that legislation should take in this Dáil? They say, pass such and such an Act, or else! Or else what? That is the question I am going to put. Are this small section going to have greater power than the vast majority of the citizens of this State? As a humble Deputy in this Dáil, elected to one of three seats in the smallest of the 26 counties that constitute this Free State, that is a position that I would not hold for five minutes. If you follow that policy to its logical conclusion, I am convinced at any rate that any other section of the people of the Free State can band themselves together and by threats and in secret can determine the course that legislation should take in this Dáil. Is that an honourable position for an Assembly such as this to adopt? That is really the position that is brought about by the introduction of this Bill that a minority will not condescend to come into this Dáil until the Oath is removed. President de Valera himself, mark you—I want to give him all credit for it took a certain amount of moral courage to do it and moral courage is badly wanted in the country at the present time—had the same objection to entering this House and to his eternal credit be it said he subordinated his own personal views and feelings to the interests of the people of the 26 counties. Has it done him any harm? In my opinion, if there is one thing more than another that has been responsible for President de Valera being in the position he now holds it is the step he took on that occasion, when he severed his connection with that small minority and took his place here in the Dáil. By his work here, supported by the members of his Party, he was enabled to have Acts passed here that were to the advantage of the vast majority of the people of Saorstát Eireann.
One might speak on this question for quite a long time, but I am not going to take up the time of the House very much longer, except that I would like to reply to some of the remarks that were made by certain Deputies during the course of this debate. It would seem, as one Deputy has already stated, that there were no Irishmen in this country until 1916. After all, there must have been some Irishmen before 1916 or there would have been none in 1916. Innuendoes have been thrown out that it is unpatriotic to oppose this Bill. We are not opposing the Bill. All we ask is that before the President proceeds with the passing of this Bill he should enter into negotiations with Great Britain. I would wish that a little better spirit of cooperation would exist between all parties in this House. I admit that I am perhaps one of the worst offenders myself at times, but I do say that it would be in the interests of the economic position of this country if there was a little more charity exhibited in the remarks that Deputies sometimes pass in regard to other Deputies. There is one thing that grates on my nerves, and it is that constant reference to what is known as Freemasonry. It seems to be the view of a great many people in the Free State that because a man is a Protestant he must be a Freemason.
Comment on this
I know that; but you will understand that these references have been made here, not alone during the course of this debate, but for the past three or four years.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy resume his seat. I think no reference whatever has been made in this Dáil to any religion of any kind, and I think it is ill-befitting anybody to make such reference in any discussion in this Dáil.
Comment on this
I am only suggesting that such references should not be made. That is all I say, and I resent it. We want to live in peace with all people in the Free State, irrespective of what their religion is. That has always been my principle. In conclusion, I feel that I have got a mandate from those who sent me here to vote against this Bill because in their and in my opinion, it will violate the Treaty. For that reason I do hope, in the interests of the good relations that have happily prevailed between Great Britain and this State for the past nine or ten years, that the present position will not be jeopardised. My appeal may be in vain, but I do appeal to President de Valera that the right policy—in fact, the only policy—for him to adopt at the moment, is to use a Latin expression, festina lente, hasten slowly.
Comment on this
I would like to say that I sincerely re-echo what was said by Deputy Norton at the opening of his statement in regard to this whole question. Like him, I have no illusions about the ultimate result of the passage of this Bill. So far as the obtaining of a livelihood for the people of this country goes, if I had my own choice in this matter and if the discussion had not taken a certain course in the statements that were made a few minutes ago, I would have much preferred to refrain from taking part in this discussion. An experience of almost ten years in this House has convinced me of one thing and that is that I have become heartily sick of this eternal question that is being discussed in the same old way, month after month, during that time. It is with very great personal reluctance that I intervene in a discussion of this kind this evening. I have been challenged in regard to where I stood in the recent election in my constituency. I have no hesitation in stating now, as I stated publicly then, where I stand. I did declare in the recent election that I was in favour of the maintenance of the Treaty in this country as long as the Parliament of this country functioned under that agreement, and I declare my attitude in that respect in exactly the same terms now. If Deputy Gearóid O'Sullivan had been here I could tell him that I can reconcile my vote in favour of this measure with support for the Treaty. I am sorry that he is not here because that is the attitude I take up and that is the declaration that I make.
As far as I can strip the discussions that have taken place here of the legal phrases and the vague language in which they were clothed, that view is not contested, and it appears to me that that issue only arises in connection with subsequent sections of the Bill. As I understand the attitude of the Government it is that the subsequent sections are consequential on the first provision. I cannot get behind the statement of the President made very definitely to-day that he is not prepared to exceed, during the lifetime of this Dáil, the mandate he obtained at the recent election for the removal of the Oath. If some of us are members of another Dáil that will come to deal with the whole Treaty question in another way in the future, it is quite possible that I may take a very different view, but until I see the President taking up a very different attitude to that which he has taken up to-day in respect of this measure, I am perfectly satisfied and perfectly convinced that I can reconcile my attitude, and that my constituents can reconcile my vote and action as supporting and giving adherence to the provisions of the Treaty.
Of course, I am not able to discuss this matter from the angle in which it was approached by Deputy Gearóid O'Sullivan. The flippant manner in which he treated the subject, and the circles he took in discussing it, make no appeal to me. I prefer to examine the question, and try to understand it, from the viewpoint of the plain person in the street. I want to deny emphatically that I or any member of our Party endeavoured in any way to run away from the position that was taken up during the recent election. I have no use for wrigglers, and be it said to the credit of the Party I belong to, that I know of none in that Party. I do know this, that there are people in this House who, I understand, earlier in the evening associated the action of some of us with wriggling out of our election promises. I know that some of these people are authorities on that subject. During the nine years that I have been a member of the House, I have endeavoured to direct my criticism of the legislation that came before us along constructive lines and to avoid taking the purely destructive line merely for the sake of taking it. I certainly would not like to be put in the position of having on election platforms and prior to the opening of my election campaign, accused members of the late Government of connivance in connection with the murders that took place in Cobh, and then come in here and say ditto to everything they said afterwards.
We are asked to decide this question along certain lines. On the one hand, it appears to me we have a very well defined attitude in the case of certain important organs of the Press in England. They take up a certain line, and as against that attitude we have the declaration of Mr. Thomas. Well, sir, there are some of us in this House who have heard a good deal about Mr. Thomas, and there are certain members of this Party who know quite a lot about him: who know that the attitude that Mr. Thomas would take up to-day would be as different as day is from night from the attitude he would take up to-morrow. It is very hard, in the case of a gentleman of so variable a character, with such a capacity for developing dramatic parts that apparently fit him best, to be very much influenced by his airy statements and the general line he takes up on some occasions. Personally, I am not very much impressed by the declarations of Mr. Thomas, either inside or outside the House of Commons.
I regret that it has fallen to me to delay the House at this late hour with my contribution to the debate. In saying that, I am reminded that on one other occasion on which we sat to a comparatively late hour, we were engaged discussing the action of certain gentlemen who were connected with the National Army. Somebody spoke about the members of the Labour Party being kicked out. Well, we may be kicked out by our constituents or out of the Labour Party, but I do not think our exit from our constituencies or from the Labour Party would be half as inglorious as the exit of certain gentlemen was from the National Army—gentleman who talk in a very cocksure manner about the stand they are taking on this question. It is true that we had a late sitting here on another occasion. I would remind Deputies that at that late sitting we were engaged discussing the conduct of Deputy Gearóid O'Sullivan——
Comment on this
I am trying to find out what this has got to do with the amendments to the Bill before the House.
Comment on this
My reason for referring to it is that some people in this House profess to speak with great authority on the will of the people. I submit that in taking up a certain attitude in this matter we are endeavouring to give effect, as we see it, to the will of the people. What I want to suggest is that people who are now so fervent in their protestations of reverence for the will of the people, if their own public records are to be an example of their faith on that, then it does not carry them very far. I am asked to decide my choice on this matter. On the one hand I have a declaration from the President of this State accepting the obligation to provide work for the unemployed people of this country— 80,000 in number. We have also had from the Government acceptance of the obligation to put into force a scheme providing pensions for widows and orphans, as well as acceptance of the principle of ending the tyranny which has been associated with the Department of Local Government and Public Health in their dealings with public authorities in this country. We have had an indication that a different outlook is to prevail, in regard to the administration of the central authority in this country. I do not say, that all the schemes and obligations I have referred to, can be honoured, 100 per cent., but I think I would be most unfair to the people I represent, and to myself, if I was not in favour of giving the fullest opportunity to the people, who have accepted obligations of that kind, to discharge them, and, on the other hand, I feel that the choice, as between persons who have accepted that responsibility, and people who have wilfully failed to discharge responsibilities of that kind, makes my decision very easy indeed. I accept that choice.
I do hope that, when the subsequent sections of this Bill come to be examined, we will have a very definite statement, that Sections 2 and 3 of the Bill are, following on the first section, necessary to give effect to that first section, and that so far as the life-time of this Dáil is concerned, we will hear no more of this issue of the Treaty. I do admit, of course, that if this was submitted to the country, and a definite decision sought as to the utility of retaining that instrument, the decision of the majority of the people must, and ought, to prevail, but until that is done, I regard this measure as one item which, having been dealt with, will enable the Executive to get to grips with the other questions I have referred to, to get to grips with remedying the social evils that exist in this country, and to justify, very definitely, as far as lies within them, the obligations they have accepted.
I have no reservations, whatever, about my vote on this question, and I feel that the people of this country, have no use for the fine distinctions that have been drawn here as between one particular section, or one particular interpretation of a section and another, that they have no use for that kind of phraseology. I prefer to regard this matter in a commonsense way, and, if for nothing else, than to get to the end of this unfortunate wrangle, and the subsequent discussions fruitless and futile, in my opinion, that have gone on for the last ten years If the passage of this Bill is going to end that state of affairs in this House, it will have done some good, and we can claim some credit for having supported it.
Comment on this
I will be very brief. I understand that during the many speeches that were made on this issue here, I was honoured by being quoted by many of the Deputies on the Opposition Benches, and amongst them by that notable Deputy, Deputy J.J. Byrne, who represents the North City. I want to make it quite clear that, in the recent General Election, I as a candidate standing for the Labour Party, said quite clearly and distinctly that I was not making the Oath a major issue in the election campaign. I stated from several platforms, in the presence of hundreds of my constituents, however, that if the Oath was raised in this Dáil, I would vote for its abolition, and I want that to be taken as a definite answer to Deputy J.J. Byrne and the others who have quoted statements made by me in this House in 1922, and I ask them to remember that this is 1932 and not 1922. I want, however, the President in his reply to answer a question. I want to ask him, in view of the fact that he has stated at the beginning of this debate, that the Oath is not required by the Treaty, does he still consider it essential to retain Sections 2 and 3 in this Bill, and if this Bill should secure a majority on Second Reading Stage, will he give the House an assurance that any proposal for the removal of the sections referred to will not be made an issue of confidence by the Government on Committee or subsequent stages?
Comment on this
I have given notice of that question to the President, and I hope that in his reply he will give a very clear and a very definite answer.
Comment on this
As I said when I opened the debate, I had hoped that it would be confined mainly to the question at issue, but that I expected that was likely to be a vain hope, and that, in a matter like this, the discussion would range over the whole region of controversy that has existed between those of us who refused to submit to the Treaty and those who accepted it. It was not germane at all to the present discussion. It does not arise in connection with the present discussion, except in so far as the historical background gives you a better understanding of the issues involved.
[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]
Now, I will take some of the points that were made here, in opposition to the Bill. It was stated by the Opposition that we had got no mandate for the removal of the Oath. I say there was scarcely ever an election held in which an issue was put so definitely to the people as that issue was put in the recent election. In order that there should be no doubt about it, several days before the election, I, myself, wrote that manifesto which was published in all the papers, and it was not published on the day of the poll, as in the case of the Free State Constitution. The people were given several days to consider it, and we could not, of course, disentangle it from another series of questions. Whose fault is that? I remember when we brought in here, in accordance with a former Article of the Constitution, a petition asking the Oireachtas to set up the machinery by which there could be initiation of legislation, one of the arguments I put forward for the action, according to that particular Article, was precisely, that there might be occasions in which it would be very important for the people to be able to separate one single issue, and to give their decision upon that issue, apart from any other issues, such as are always entangled more or less together in an election. What did the Opposition do when they were here in a majority? They came along, and because through this Constitution, which they boasted of as being one of the most democratic in the world, there was an opportunity presented to us of getting the decision of the people on a question of this kind, and they deprived us by a trick of the right we were entitled to exercise. Seventy-five thousand names were necessary in accordance with that Article to get the matter brought before the Oireachtas. We got over 100,000 and we brought them in here and were laughed at. To their eternal discredit be it said not merely did the Independent members of the House take part in that trick, but they initiated it. It was the first piece of disillusionment I must say that I got in this House as to the action of Independent members.
Comment on this
I am not going to say anything bitter against anybody. What I am doing at the present time is trying to secure the rights of those who are at present excluded by a conscience test, and when I am trying to do that for one section of the people, I am not going at any time to do anything which will be unfair to another section. I do say, however, that I shall never forget to my dying day the disillusionment I got on that occasion when the one group that might have been expected to stand for the rights of the Constitution became a party to ending the power that was there of having that question brought before the people. We cannot prove, as we could with the Referendum prove, that we have a majority of the people behind the removal of the Oath, but probably no Government in the world would be able to prove as definitely as we can that we have got a majority. Either you will have to give up elections as giving a mandate at all, or you will have to accept that we have a mandate here. We have certainly as good a mandate as the gentlemen on the opposite side had when they accepted this Treaty originally. Because we have got the people's mandate, having put it to them, to remove this Oath, we are going to remove it, or we will not continue to occupy these benches.
We are told that perhaps we got a mandate, but that we got it under false pretences. I deny that. In the most explicit way that I could I said to the people, "We can remove that Oath without violating the Treaty," and I say that no member of the Opposition has proved that we are violating the Treaty by removing the Oath. The legal luminaries on the other side did not prove it. I would say that our word is just as good as Mr. Thomas's word, and Mr. Thomas just saying, "We regard it as a violation of the Treaty" does not make it so, and he did not even say that. He is beginning to say it now when he thinks that the campaign which has been going on is likely to influence votes in this House and public opinion in this country. But I mistake the Irish people if he is going to succeed in it.
We deny that we are violating the Treaty. In order that there should be a greater degree of unanimity here I argued a case, not perhaps as I would argue it with the convictions that I have, but as the case might have been argued by the ex-Minister for External Affairs. We are told that it is a Treaty now. It is rather late in the day that the British are beginning to regard it as a Treaty in the proper sense of the term. When did they begin to regard it as a Treaty? Only when they think it will put shackles upon us. So long as it was a means of getting some advantage beyond the position that was occupied, in certain respects, by Canada, Australia, etc., they tried to deny it was a Treaty in the proper sense. But the moment they thought it would shackle us, hold us in an inferior position to the position occupied by Canada, Australia, etc., then we hear them talking about it as a Treaty.
I have heard people talking of honour. Deputy Cosgrave spoke about honour. I would have more regard for the Deputy's opinion of honour if he had used that argument when the Treaty was being discussed in Dáil Eireann ten years ago—much more regard for it. Who were the people who talked about the honour of the country being involved and the dangers we were running into in trying to proceed along from the Treaty to the freedom hoped to be got from it and who said we would be met with the cry that we were tearing up the Treaty and making of it a scrap of paper? It was not Deputy Cosgrave. It was not some of the gentlemen on the opposite benches. No, their argument then was "This is being imposed upon us by superior force. We can submit to it and we will have a moral right to get out of the position we are being forced into by any means at any time." It was they who were leading the young men along at that time to take this Treaty. I remember well some of them told us, "Get guns under this Treaty and when you have got the guns, then you can get the freedom to which you are entitled." It was because we were aware of these facts that members on this side of the House tried to warn the young men of the path they were being led into.
The ex-Minister for Agriculture quoted from a letter of mine that was written when a perfectly honest and fair statement made in Thurles was being twisted by an infamous Press and an equally infamous set of opponents at the time—twisted in order to pretend that I was setting brother against brother. That letter has been hidden away. Nobody has heard about it. In vain I said it was written and published a day or two after the original statement. It has been hidden away. What is it brought up to-day for? It is brought up because I said in it that the road the young men were being asked to travel was a road in which they would encounter very serious obstacles, and not the less serious of these obstacles, I pointed out, was the fact that the day they tried to act on the stepping-stone policy they would be met by that charge that we are being met with now by Deputy Cosgrave, that the honour of this nation is involved.
Yes, we are a people who have respect for honour; we are a nation that loves honour and likes to act straight. We have never been treated as such by the nation opposed to us. Appeals to honour and chivalry have always got a response from Irish hearts. It was such an appeal that took our young men out to the trenches and left their bones whitening in Suvla Bay and elsewhere. It was the appeal to their chivalry, sense of honour and the nobility of the Irish character that took our people out. These men on the opposite benches know, as the English never knew, how to appeal to that sense in our people, and they have abused it, abused it as shamefully as those who went out that time recruiting abused it, whether they did it knowingly or not. They abused it in the case of the land annuities when they told our people we were refusing to pay our lawful debts; when they told our farmers "these people are leading you along immoral paths," and when people in high authority, who ought to have known better and who ought to have examined into what they were saying, took part in the same campaign and tried to misrepresent us as people asking the farmers to break one of the Commandments. Now it is honour again, and they make a charge of dishonour against us without examining the question whether we are acting honourably or not.
I have no fear of negotiations with England, none whatever—not a bit. But when we do negotiate with Britain we will negotiate about the unity of Ireland, as far as I am concerned, and not before. There are no negotiations needed for this. None. We are acting perfectly honourably in the course we have taken. I do not care what view you take of the Treaty, whether you take the view and line of argument I took in the introduction of this Bill, or whether you take the British view, either that this Constitution under which we are working was a British creation, or there was some quasi-international settlement, no matter which side you take, the course we are taking to-day is in perfect accordance with any of the three views you take. We are dealing with England. If we are going to keep in contact with our minds at all, and to argue it out, we will have to try and get some common ground.
What is the common ground? It can only be a legal ground. We hear of gentlemen's agreements. If some new member of the Dáil spoke in that fashion, I could understand it. If the Deputy who spoke to-day and who did not understand the procedure, or what the Executive should do, spoke in that loose fashion, I could understand it. But between peoples, between nations, this sort of back-door agreements cannot be held. They would mean international anarchy. You must have something definite, and that is the meaning of law. We are here to deal with legal matters—legal matters pure and simple. We are entitled, being the weaker nation upon whom this Treaty was imposed, to get the last letter out of our legal rights, and we propose to get it—the very last letter.
Comment on this
Fan go fóill; we will see. Our legal rights entitle us to determine what conditions shall be imposed upon the representatives of the people entering into this Assembly. It is a domestic matter. I repeat it because there was some Deputy on the opposite benches who seemed to think that phrase should not be used. But the relation between the State and its citizens is a matter for ourselves alone—Sinn Féin. It is going to remain a matter for ourselves alone. And we are going to put it to the test now whether this co-equality which Britain says the States of the British Commonwealth have is a mere, empty, deceptive phrase or whether it has solid substance behind it.
We, the representatives of the people of the Twenty-Six Counties, have a right in the name of our people to determine what conditions shall be imposed upon representatives here. No outside people ought to have any interest in it; no outside people ought to be able to interfere if we are co-equal with that outside people. The very attempt at interference is an attempt at domination and there is no justification for it good, bad or indifferent in the Treaty.
In the opening of the debate I read a letter from Mr. Lloyd George written I think on the 10th or 13th December— it was just when the discussion was opening in Dáil Eireann on the Treaty. Mr. Lloyd George made it quite clear that there were certain Articles that referred to our status. He made it quite clear in that letter that the status of this country would advance step by step with any advance that would be made by the British Dominions; and, in so far as the Treaty does impose the Oath, it imposes it through Articles 1 and 2 and not through Article 4. And the reason is as I explained to-day, when I intervened during Deputy Thrift's speech. That the peculiar words "to be taken" appeared in Article 4 is easily explained by the fact that Articles 1 and 2 give Ireland the same status as Canada, and impose upon Ireland if you like the same relations between the Crown and the British Parliament as were imposed on Canada, and as an Oath was taken in the Canadian Parliament, there was, if you like, an implicit understanding that the same Oath should be taken here. The form was prescribed in Article 4, but the obligation of taking it was not prescribed in Article 4. It was contained, if at all, in Articles 1 and 2 by implication. I think Mr. Lloyd George's letter also referred to Articles 6, 7 and 8 as being more or less of an international character. The other articles were devoted to status. The status of the Free State having advanced step by step if it did not precede—I know it could be argued, in a sense it preceded—but, at any rate, taking the worst case, having advanced step by step with Canada, Australia and the other Dominions the position to-day is that, so far as these earlier Articles of the Treaty conferring status, are concerned, we are exactly in the same position as Canada, Australia and New Zealand; in other words, to use a legal phrase, these Articles are spent, so far as the Treaty is concerned. They have been given effect to in the recognition of co-equal status which has been fully recognised by the British Parliament in the Statute of Westminster. We are, therefore, to-day quite free to do anything here without any violation of the Treaty, anything that they can do in Canada, anything that they can do in Australia or New Zealand, anything that they can do in Britain as regards relations with the Crown.
I asked at the beginning was there any Deputy in this House who would stand up here and for a moment say Canada could not remove if they wanted to, the Oath in the Canadian Parliament. Is there one who doubts for a moment that they could do it? They talk about the Oath as the symbol of connection. It is nothing of the kind. The monarch is the symbol of connection. The Oath has nothing to do with it. There was a monarch in England and there was no Oath in the British Parliament for centuries. The Oath in the British Parliament is the result of the religious situation. The Oath is a comparatively new thing. Relations could subsist quite independent of the Oath. The Oath is a conscience test that I would not have in any democratic assembly. I did not like it when it was imposed.
Unlike Deputy Cosgrave, had I been there at the time I would probably have opposed the taking of the Oath on the grounds that that sort of coercion of conscience is wrong. It is no good. It is as bad as cast-iron Constitutions. They end in revolution and violent explosion, because the flexibility that is necessary is taken away. If we were here an independent Republic in the morning I would not stand for it if it was proposed that there should be an oath of fidelity to it imposed upon its members; I would be against it. I believe if you want to have a really representative, democratic assembly it must be possible for the people to send their representatives there without any shackling of their consciences.
There is nothing, I think, so mean as the attempt to impose upon a man something which his conscience revolts against and the conscience of Irishmen revolted from the start against this particular form of test. On December 3rd, 1921, when the Irish delegates who were sent to London came back to report and when they brought the latest British proposals to us, I remember there were three or four Articles before they came to the Oath. Then there was the Oath. It was not this form of Oath at all; it was the direct form of Oath that you have in Canada and Australia. Every one of the members of that Cabinet was against it—every single one of them. I took it up and criticised it to such an extent that, feeling that my criticism of it would be misrepresented, one of the members present asked me the question, in order that it might be put on record, was it only to that I objected and I said "Of course not."
I took up the Oath because to me it summarised in the neatest form, in the most explicit form, everything I objected to in the Treaty or in these proposals. This was simply a summary of the lot. I said I did not want to take Sections 1, 2 and 3. I had got them all succinctly there. "Everything I object to," I said, "is concentrated there." One of the delegates said, "But the British want to know it," and in my innocence I thought what they wanted the Oath for was that they were suspicious that we would not keep the Treaty we would make with them and, never being of the kind prepared to make agreements and not to keep them, I said "I, for one, am prepared to swear to keep any agreement I make."
And remember, here was the sort of agreement that we had proposed. It was not the Treaty. When Deputies and others accuse me and say "You were prepared to take such and such an Oath," they take mighty good care never to put it with the agreement that would go with it. The position would be different if I got the agreement that Oath was associated with—that agreement that would give us a united Ireland, that would have given to Ireland whatsoever advantages there were in the association, and that would have given to those who were Unionists in our midst North and South that concession to their feelings and their sentiments which would have been consistent with the rights of the majority of this people to enjoy the independent status that they wanted. The policy of the Republican cabinet in those days—and I do not mind confessing that I was the one to start it, and if there is any accusation ever to be made against me from the Republican point of view, let it be put to me honestly—was this that when it became a question of the negotiations I did a thing that it was my duty to do. I gave a lead and I said "There is a solution to this problem, a solution which will leave us and the State which has been declared by our people a Republic; will leave us that State and will bring to that State the loyalty of all sections of the people; the loyalty of the Unionists because they are not going to be completely cut off from Great Britain and that would give to our own people an opportunity of being loyal because they would have independence, they would have the Republic." The proposal made to us was that we should have this system of External Association. I was told that the British wanted an Oath. I said "Very well; I for one am prepared to take an Oath to keep any settlement I make. I am prepared to do that and to give my pledge on oath that any settlement which I make I will keep."
That was the origin of that Oath which is now imported into the Treaty settlement and said to be the Oath that I dictated for the Treaty. I did not dictate it. I was not even aware that my words had been taken down. I said offhand that I did not mind swearing allegiance to the Irish Constitution. I did not believe it was necessary. I believed that the very fact that you come along and take part in the Assembly is sufficient. I did not mind swearing that I would be faithful to any Treaty that we made provided we made it with our own free will and that it got the consent of the majority of the Irish people. This settlement would have been put before the Irish people to consent to or reject. We were prepared to recognise for the purpose of that association the British Crown. And I was prepared to swear that we would recognise the Crown for the purpose of association. I did it in my capacity as President of the Republic. Everything I did at that time I did it scrupulously. I did it with scrupulous regard to my obligations as such.
Comment on this
I am not quite sure that I heard the President aright. Did he say that he did it as President of the Republic?
Comment on this
I have had occasion recently to draw Deputies' attention to the fact that they are responsible for the conduct of their visitors in the Gallery. I hope there will be no necessity to do so again.
Comment on this
It is about time that visitors to the Gallery should learn to deport themselves in accordance with the dignity of the House.
Comment on this
It was recently the Deputy learned that. The Deputy learned that after the Treaty, not before.
Comment on this
On the contrary I was present at the first meeting of the Dáil at which that matter was discussed. I was also present at the meeting of the 16th or 17th August, 1921, when an amendment was proposed that the words "of the Republic" should be inserted in the Constitution. I was also present at the first meeting of the Cabinet when President de Valera returned from America when he explained that he had to use that title in America, a title which was illegal for him to use and he asked the Cabinet to justify that in a sort of post facto way, with retrospective effect.
Comment on this
That is quite untrue and a misrepresentation, and the Deputy is always misrepresenting me. It is always three-quarters of the truth with one-quarter of a lie thrown in.
Comment on this
It is untrue, and that can be proved by reference to the records of the Dáil debates.
Comment on this
Why? I will just put this point to you. "Untrue" is an objective word. It has no reference whatsoever so far as the Deputy's contentions are concerned. I must protest against having to withdraw the word "untrue." Things are true or untrue. If it is a lie, then I am accusing the Deputy of deliberately telling a falsehood. I simply stated that what he said is untrue, and I can prove it is untrue by reference to the Dáil debates.
Comment on this
In fairness to the President, I want to say clearly that I proposed President de Valera in the Assembly in August as President of the Republic.
Comment on this
On a point of personal explanation, I wish to say that the Dáil on the previous day had refused to have any such office.
Comment on this
I suppose we have plenty of time; at least I have. I can stay all night if others are not too tired. I will tell the truth, the whole truth, about that incident, and I can prove it from the records with reference to Deputy MacEoin's motion. In addition to that, I have seen the Trustee Deed of Dáil Eireann, which was signed when I was in America——signed by Acting-President Griffith, who was Acting-President of the Republic. The document is there, and, please God, it will be a State document one of these days.
Comment on this
The Deputy was contradicted from his own benches.
Comment on this
The fact is, there is no special minute that one could refer to. When I was in America and was presenting to the President of the United States a plea for the recognition of the Republic which was established here by the will of the Irish people— as democratically established as ever a State was—it was not, I will admit, internationally recognised, but when I was presenting that plea for the recognition of that Republic, I wanted to do it in a strictly legal way, and I tried to get a minute of the appointment with the words "as President" and the words were not there. Then when I came back, and when there was an opportunity of putting in expressly what had been implied all the time the question arose whether, if we did expressly put it in at that stage, there might not be an implication that it had not been there all the time.
Comment on this
And in order that that implication might not arise, the definite motion was not made to insert it as such in the Constitution and the way that Deputy MacEoin has referred to was resorted to, namely, that instead of having anything which might imply that it had not been there all the time, it was held that it would be a declaration of the fact that it would be, so to speak, an act declaratory of the true situation if Deputy MacEoin or others proposed me formally to the Dáil as President of the Republic. That was done and it is in the records.
Comment on this
I was at the point about the Oath. I state definitely that I did not dictate that Oath. I simply stated it as casually as I say it here. But next morning when the delegates went back to London some of them met and thought that it was their duty to present certain proposals. By the way, I have refreshed my mind on this matter since I came into office by looking up the old Cabinet minutes. My recollection, therefore, of the whole thing is freshened. The delegates went over to London and the understanding was that there would be no signing; there would not be a break-off and they would not take the responsibility for breaking-off. There would not be, as I say, any signing. The document would come home and would be presented to the Dáil as a proposition and it would be left to me and to the Dáil to reject it. When they went over the delegates met and some of them thought that it would be their duty to present to the British Government a set of counter-proposals which had been our policy. They sat down to compose those counter-proposals. They embodied some of the articles that were read out here to-day. They came to a certain point and they began to discuss the question of inserting certain matters in the counter-proposals which, I again want the Dáil to remember, were for a united Ireland.
I was in negotiation with Mr. Lloyd George. Somebody suggested in the debate that he never heard what happened. If he had been very interested in Irish history during the period I think he would know what happened. On 20th July Mr. Lloyd George handed me a set of proposals and I told Mr. Lloyd George that they were of such a character that I would not be seen taking them home to Ireland. Mr. Lloyd George made all sorts of threats, did what some of the Deputies over there are trying to do to-day—to saddle me with a certain responsibility—and I told Mr. Lloyd George what I tell the Deputies to-day, that there is no responsibility on my conscience at all, that what we are proposing to do we have a right to do, that if there are any consequences—which ought not to arise from a just act—the consequences are the responsibility of those who take an unjust action against us; we were not the aggressors; we were only doing a thing we had a perfect right to do.
Mr. Lloyd George failed in that. When the threats failed, he gave us time to discuss the proposals with the members of our Cabinet. Unanimously, on the 16th August, I think, Dáil Eireann supported me in turning down these proposals. The main reason I had for turning them down was that they involved the partition of our country. Deputy Dillon implied that we here—whichever side of the House we are on—had not a terrible lot to boast of, that we had not achieved very much more than the Irish Party would have achieved. Speaking for myself, I felt that if we were not able to achieve the unity of this country, we had not much to boast of beyond what the Irish Party might ultimately have achieved. It was, therefore, to secure the unity of this country that I fought when I was in negotiation with Mr. Lloyd George. No other proposal had any interest for me. We could have gone home, dumped our arms, or burned our arms, and, after a time, Home Rule in one form or another would have had to come, without a doubt. We might not have advanced as quickly to the stage we have advanced to to-day for the Twenty-Six Counties. That is true, but it is a futile thing to speculate as to the "might have beens." We can only say what "has been." The unity of the country was the thing I was struggling for. Because, in my opinion, the Treaty involved—I had experience of Mr. Lloyd George's mind and knew what he was aiming at—partition, I did not think I could propose it for acceptance here. I felt it my duty to those who had been comrades of mine and who died for the freedom of this country, that neither I nor anyone I could influence should be a party, directly or indirectly, to the partition of this country.
Mr. Lloyd George's tactics were these—it might be as well for Deputies to know, because this has reference to the land annuities as well as to the Oath. Mr. Lloyd George's Government had put through the 1920 Partition Act. He had got a Parliament working in the Six Counties. He took good care to present us with a fait accompli by having that Parliament working before he invited us to negotiate. He could not get the Parliament of Southern Ireland, as it was called, to work. It was made a laughing-stock. About four members turned up to its meeting. Mr. Lloyd George said “I must mend my hand and get a Parliament working in the South as well as in the North.” He set out to mend his hand by increasing his offer, by giving something more. In British law, the whole Treaty settlement is based and built upon the Partition Act. That is the position. He went out to give more. It would defeat his purpose if he took anything back. That is why there is nothing in British law that takes back the land annuities given under the 1920 Act. Anybody who had met Mr. Lloyd George for five minutes would know what he was after. I tried, time and again, to get him to discuss the question of Ireland as a unity. On each occasion, he would not. Then he said it was like a merry-go-round. When he tried to catch at me, he could not, and we were the same distance at the end. That was because Mr. Lloyd George did not want to come to business on the only basis on which business could properly be done. These things could have been done in such a way as would really establish friendly relations on a lasting basis between the peoples of these two countries. He may have had his difficulties.
We come to the Oath. The Oath is quoted out of its context. It is used to misrepresent the things I stood for. So far as I am concerned, the day that the British are prepared to negotiate on the basis of a united Ireland I am quite prepared to meet them and to go as far as any Irishman could go in the hope of getting anything like a final settlement. They do not propose to do that. We are told "Go and negotiate." What do the Deputies who tell us that hope to get from negotiations? If we are going to get our rights, we have them here and are entitled to them without negotiation. If we negotiate, will not the same threats be used privately in negotiations that are being used publicly now? If we are not going to give up our rights, we must be prepared to face these threats, publicly as well as privately. When a small nation comes to negotiate, the last word with a big nation is the big stick. In my opinion, it is as well to show that in public as to show it in private. If they are going to use the big stick, to use threats and all the rest, let them do it in the face of the world. We are not, in this Bill, seeking to go one step beyond what we are entitled to do. I asked Deputies could Canada, Australia and New Zealand Parliaments determine whether there was an Oath to be taken or not. Deputy McGilligan hedged in the most extraordinary fashion. I am sure he did not, for one moment, believe the argument he was putting forward when he read the Preamble to the Statute of Westminster. That has nothing to say to the question whether an oath should be taken by the members of the Parliaments to the Monarchy—nothing whatever, good, bad or indifferent to say to it, and he knows it. I cannot show the relationship better than to say again that this is a domestic question. What does it do? Is it any good to anybody? Why should England bother about it? We might as well be clear about it and tell the truth. I am here as President of the Executive Council and I have never taken an oath—never. No man who knows what an oath is will say I have. Not one of these Deputies here has taken an oath. There are members of the Seanad who have not taken an oath. If Article 17 of the Constitution was to be the oath, you violated it long ago and you connived at that. I came up when there was a crisis— when the Oath was being used as a machine to keep the Party yonder in power. When they wanted to exclude from this Assembly everyone except their own particular group and assure themselves of a continuance of power, they resorted to this. They brought in an Act saying that henceforth nobody could go up for election to represent the Irish people unless prepared to comply with Article 17 of the Constitution. They demanded that declaration. The moment that declaration was demanded it was quite clear that you could never, so long as they were in power except by force of arms—even if you had practically the whole people behind you—bring about a change. Deputies opposite could get the total number of members elected and they could say "Look around. We are unanimous. We have the whole people behind us," while they could have excluded by this means three-fourths of the people from representation.
It was an intolerable situation. My policy had been to try and get unity outside this House, to get the representatives of the people to meet elsewhere outside this House. I saw that there was no hope, with such an Act, of ever doing that. I would have been prepared to wait for another five or ten years to do it but they adopted a system by which they were going to secure perpetual power for themselves. I asked myself what was my duty in the matter. Anything that was not wrong in itself I was prepared to do but I was not prepared, and would not have felt justified, in committing perjury or anything equivalent to perjury.
What was the situation at the time? The situation was this. In order that the oath would not matter to the people they told them—and you all know it—all these years that there was no oath at all, that it was not an oath. Believing that "I swear" would mean an oath, I said, in my opinion, it was an oath. My view was that it was an oath. But the Deputies opposite had said quite differently. They said that it was not, that it was a mere formality —they used the words long before I used them—and had no binding significance whatever, that anyone could take it, and that it meant nothing. I asked myself whether in a crisis like that I would be justified in staying outside if it were, in fact, true that this thing was a mere formality. I could only find out in one way. In order that the people's attention should not be attracted to it, instead of taking the oath—as they would have done, if they dared to stand over it as a thing the Irish people would stand for—publicly, as in other Parliaments, they hid it away in a back room, hid it away out of sight, so that the public could not know what it was. I said that at least we were entitled to find out. We published a declaration and here is the original document, signed by every member, in which we stated our attitude. The attitude was in fact this: the majority party of that time held that this was no oath at all; we are going to put it to the test. In order that our coming in here might not be misrepresented we made a public declaration as to what our intentions were. When we came to take this so-called oath I presented this document to the officer in charge and told him that that was our attitude— there were witnesses present for every word—that this was our attitude; that we were net prepared to take an oath. I have here the original document written in pencil, and in Irish of the statement I made to the officer who was supposed to administer the oath. I said: "I am not prepared to take an oath. I am not going to take an oath. I am prepared to put my name down in this book in order to get permission to go into the Dáil, but it has no other significance." There was a Testament on the table and in order that there could be no misunderstanding I went and I took the Testament and put it over and said: "You must remember I am taking no oath." That has been done by every member of our Party and it has been said that it conformed with Article 17. Is it not time to get rid of this nonsense?
Comment on this
I signed it in the same way as I would sign an autograph in a newspaper. If you ask me whether I had an idea what was there, I say "yes." It was neither read to me nor was I asked to read it. I was told—perhaps this is only second-hand and I cannot vouch for it—that Deputies on the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches were so disgusted with the whole performance that they used to walk into the room and say "Sign that for me." This is the thing that all the threats are about. What is it? It is a humiliation for us, and it is no good for anybody. I say that I am acting more truly and more honourably than Deputies yonder who were parties to that. I say further that if I were the guardian of that Constitution, there would not be a single member allowed in under such conditions. I would either have the Article out or have it obeyed. It is time, I think, that we should have a little bit of light. It is time that we should end all this mummery and that we who have been accused of perjury and blasphemy should not be subjected to this humiliation and this semi-blasphemous performance carried on there. It is time to end it. We can, thank God, end it now.
Comment on this
Might I ask the President if he signed a declaration in the sheriff's office before his election?
Comment on this
Yes. I will make the point clear to the Deputy. I was allowed into the Dáil to my surprise. I heard the Clerk of the Dáil stand up and say—I forget the exact words—that we had conformed to Article 17 of the Constitution. It was as much as I could possibly do to resist standing up and saying, "That is an untruth." I will tell why I did not. I said that if that is their interpretation of Article 17 of the Constitution, as they are the guardians of it, it is not incumbent upon me to put a different interpretation upon it. They were interpreting it in that fashion. I will give them, if you like, all the credit in the world for it, from the point of view that if they want it they could have used it. I confess now that if I had been asked to subscribe to an oath, asked to take a solemn oath, I would not have taken it. I deserve no credit from anybody, because I was not prepared to do that violence to my conscience. We are here to end something which has been the cause of disaster in this country for the past ten years. I believe that it could have been removed at any time by the Deputies on the opposite benches. I may be wrong, but I believe it could have been. I believe that, having gone the distance they did, they used it as a political weapon. Again I may be wrong, but that is my honest opinion. We are in a position to remove it to-day, and I for one will not be occupying this position if it is not removed. If the British Government attempt to take any measures of reprisal for doing that, then I will say, as far as they are concerned, they have proved that this pretence of co-equality is all bosh.
We are either entitled to do this, or we are not. They tell us that we are going out of the British Commonwealth by doing this. What my own desires are on that question do not matter at the moment. I have taken certain obligations. I did not choose the course of events that has taken place for the past ten years. It would have been quite different if I had my own way. We find ourselves in a certain position since the Treaty was passed, and I have only one ambition and that is to defeat British policy in dividing our people here. I have restrained myself in public many a time when I felt impelled to say things that I believed were true, that I knew to be true in fact—I restrained myself when I said to myself: "Very well. To say such things would only help to perpetuate divisions which I do not want to see." In order to prevent division we had to get some rule by which we could have unity. I knew of no rule but one under the circumstances. When, immediately after the civil war was at an end and when it was clear to everybody that it would not be possible to maintain the Republic by force of arms, or to prevent its disestablishment, I put forward a proposal at that time, and that proposal was at that time accepted by all responsible Republicans in responsible positions. The proposal was that the people should be free to send their elected representatives to whatever place the majority were to meet, that they should meet there with their consciences free, and that they should come there pledged to nothing that would appear to violate their consciences and that majority rule should be accepted as the rule of order.
I defy anyone else to get a better plan. If they do I will give way as far as I am concerned. I do not know of any other way. It is unfair and unjust that we should try to impose a conscience test on people who will by such a test be excluded from accepting that rule of order. And if there was to be a three-fourths majority here in this House to-morrow and if they were to try to impose a minority test and if the minority was one that wanted this test opposed, I would oppose it. Deputy Thrift spoke here, and he spoke for the retention of this conscience test. I wonder does he realise the full implications of what he was asking for. He was asking that a conscience test should be imposed upon people whose aspirations undoubtedly —whatever their methods may be— correspond to the aspirations of the majority of our people.
Deputy Cosgrave says that he does not know what the aspirations of the Irish people are. I am sure that he does, quite sure that he does. He has no difficulty whatever, that I know of, in understanding what the general aspirations of the Irish people are. They want complete freedom to determine for themselves what form of government they should have, and what their relations with other States should be. They want complete freedom to do that. And the moment that freedom is given, as far as I am concerned, I would never bother to say a word, much less attempt to strike a blow against whatever form of government they choose to have. Perhaps Deputy Coburn is at one with me on that. As far as I am concerned, I say here that I do not care what form of government the Irish people choose as long as the Irish people as a whole are free to suggest that. I never had any special interest in forms of government as such. I have always believed, as far as I was concerned, in the rights of the Irish people completely to determine freely for themselves what they wanted. I opposed the imposition of an outside will upon them. If they were free and if they chose to have a Monarch instead of a President, I for one would not attempt to interfere. As far as I am concerned I do not care a thraneen. I have no particular interest in it. It never affected me. And I did not wait until I came here to say that. I said that in 1917, and as a result of saying it I was pointed at as not being a proper Republican. Deputy Hogan has frequently referred to that fact. I stand up here and make open confession of the fact that forms of government, as such, do not particularly interest me, because what I want to see and what I have striven for is that the Irish people should determine freely for themselves what their governmental institutions shall be.
To go back to this test, I wonder would Deputy Thrift like to have a conscience test imposed upon him. If there was here some particular form of conscience test would he like to have it imposed upon him? I do not think that he would. I do not propose that he should have any conscience test imposed upon him, but I do say that the liberty that we are prepared to give him, he ought to be prepared to give to others.
Comment on this
All I ask for is what the Irish people stood for in the only way in which they could speak when this Treaty was proposed and accepted. The Irish people accepted this Treaty in the only way in which they could speak, and as it was the decision of the Irish people we accepted it, and we claim that that kind of acceptance should not be asked for year by year. It should be given once and for all.
Comment on this
If there had been many Deputy Thrifts to ask for that in the old Dáil Eireann, I do not think you would have got a majority for it.
Comment on this
I do not think so. I think at that time there were probably not a half dozen members of Dáil Eireann who accepted that settlement in the sense that the Deputy says.
Comment on this
There were two or three probably. There may have been two or three who had that point of view.
Comment on this
We do not know where we are. We took it because we thought it was accepted by the Irish people.
Comment on this
As far as those whom Deputy Thrift represents are concerned, I have only to say that they will get from us the same protection and liberty that I want to see given to the men outside who are debarred by a conscience test from coming in here. They are entitled to that and they will never have to complain as far as we are concerned.
Comment on this
We are going to see that the section of our people who are entitled to be represented, are represented here. As I said what is all this pother about? It is not we who have raised this "rumpus." We want to get rid of this performance which was keeping our people apart. We want to get a rule of order, some stability here, some opportunity to develop here. Nobody will be hurt by it. But because we do that we are told by the British that all sorts of consequences are going to flow from it. Our attitude is this: If we are going to be threatened at every step we take then we might as well be in prison. If we are going to be threatened when we attempt to exercise our rights, that is the end of it.
I notice that General Smuts was referred to here. He wrote a very clever letter at the time—I remember it well —telling us how, if we stood for our rights in association with Canada, Australia and the other States they would stand by us against any interference by Britain. What does General Smuts do now? He writes in a case like this when he knows as well as I do that we are entitled to what we are proposing to do—this gentleman sends a telegram to Mr. Thomas telling him that he was glad he was taking a strong attitude in regard to us. That is his position—that he was glad Mr. Thomas was taking a strong attitude. We are not proposing to injure anybody. We are not proposing to violate any agreements that have been made. We are within our strict legal and moral rights in proposing what we are proposing to do; and because we are within our strict moral and legal rights we are asking the House to agree to it, and to stand up for those rights.
Deputy Davin has asked an important question. This Bill was framed with all the care and all the consideration that we could give it. Clause 2, removing the Oath section, was considered carefully and we came to the conclusion that it should go. It was not because we are afraid of the courts or anything of that kind. Our domestic courts ought to have no function in the matter. No country in the world would have it. And why? There is the very good reason that if a verdict was got in the courts against their own people even though it was a mistaken judgment—and judges are no more infallible than the rest of us; they make mistakes, they can be wrong—but if a domestic court in any country gave a judgment against its own people on an international issue, it finished it because the other party would say: "Your own courts have found against you." There would be something in putting it to the courts if their decision held both parties, but it would not hold on both parties, because if you got a judgment in your own courts in favour of your own country, the outside party would say: "Oh! that is only from your own courts." Therefore you have nothing to gain, and everything to lose, by submitting a question of that kind to the domestic courts and it should not be done. Deputies over there would not dream of doing it if they were in office. Take the case of the Privy Council. They were advised in exactly the same way as we are being advised that it was essential in the interests of the State— and any Executive is bound to safeguard the interests of the State when it has the responsibility for doing so— that it should be done. They proposed to do it and we propose to do it. Even if Deputy Davin or Deputy Dillon chooses to go into the Lobby against that Clause, then let them go. We have considered this Bill with extreme care. We take it as Government policy and we stand or fall by it. If the House are not going to support us in it they can get the alternative.
Comment on this
There will be a further Vote on the question whether this Bill is read a Second Time or not?
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
Question—"That the Bill be now read a Second Time"—put.
Do you agree with this result?
It is proposed to take the Committee Stage on Tuesday next. I move now, "That the Dáil do now adjourn until 3 p.m. on Tuesday." We propose to meet on Tuesday and Wednesday only of next week, as Thursday is a Holy-day and there would be no use bringing members back on Friday. We only propose that for next week.
Comment on this
We shall have to accept them up to Tuesday morning. The Committee Stage will, therefore, be fixed for Tuesday.