We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 26—General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–113 of 188. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

On Friday last I was dealing, sir, with the proposals of the Minister for Finance in connection with the imposition and relief of taxation. That, of course, follows almost immediately upon the figure which he decides as the necessary amount to get in taxation. The first big list of items which were selected with almost fiendish glee by the Minister for Finance, as evidenced in his speech, were impositions of income tax and impositions of sur-tax. Last October, when it was necessary to make some further assessment in order to produce a balanced Budget, which was eventuated, all the wishes, malicious and otherwise, of the present Ministry to the contrary notwithstanding, as I said on Friday last, this present Ministry, then in opposition, denounced any increase in income tax, or any other increase in taxation at all, as undesirable, as crushing industry, as interfering with progress, as hampering business, and generally as placing a burden upon the citizens of this State that they could not possibly bear.

This Budget follows very slavishly the British Budget. In fact, practically every item, with one possible exception, that appears in this Budget might have been borrowed from the British system. There is no indication whatever of originality in any of the proposals that are before us. And it does not require any expert examination of the effects of the crushing burdens in the shape of the heavy income tax on British industry to see where that is laid on the other side of the water, and it is idle to say that industry here can bear the same proportion of taxation as it can in England. But this Ministry of non-businessmen has gone a step further, very much further, while pretending to the people of this country that income tax and sur-tax is 2/- in the £ less than it is in England. I propose to be able to show that in respect of several institutions in this city the imposition is far higher than it is in Great Britain, and this industrial concern which we have got in this country and which is competing with British products of much the same type starts out before there is any deduction of income tax at all, unlike its competitors in England, with 2/- in the £ of an impost on its profits before it is in a position to land any of its goods at all. They have to compete with British manufactures, and the proposal to increase the corporation profits tax from 5 per cent. to 7½ per cent., and from 7½ per cent. to 10 per cent., can be designed for no other purpose than to injure the trade of that particular big industrial concern that I have mentioned and place it in the position of being almost unable to meet its, competitors in the British market. More may be said about that during the next twelve months in that portion of the City of Dublin where a very large number of the employees of that firm happen to live.

What is the position of a citizen in this country paying super-tax and income tax in respect of his property in that particular company? Five shillings income tax, 6/3 super-tax plus 2/- before he comes into possession of either one or the other, placing him in the same position as a man liable to super-tax and income tax in England in any of the ordinary sources of income that he would have over there. Take the case of a person living in England and who pays income tax in England and sur-tax from his investments in this particular firm that I have mentioned. Assume, if you like, that he has £100,000 a year, what is his contribution in England in respect of income tax and sur-tax? He pays 5/- in the £ income tax and a maximum of 8/3 sur-tax, that is 13/3. Before he gets possession of the one or the other he is charged 2/- in the £ here. So that his contribution for income tax, sur-tax and corporation profits tax here and in Great Britain amounts to 15/3. And what is the reason of it? The reason is that the stock of that particular concern is held largely in England as well as here. It is a very big concern. This time twelve months it had a market value of something like £40,000,000. What is its market value to-day? About £25,000,000, not even that much. The more of that stock that is sold from England and that comes here the more the depreciation in the price; and as our citizens hold that stock their balance sheets must be made up by a very considerable reduction in capital values, and the amounts of death duties, stamp duties and other sources of income in respect of various taxes will consequently be reduced. The stock that stood at £4 a couple of months ago is now selling at a little over £3. We go on to examine the proposal in connection with the £90,000 that it is proposed to get via the Currency Commission. Viewing the Budget in its proper perspective, and bearing in mind that there is an additional sum of £4,000,000 to be taken from the taxpayers' pockets, and seeing this onslaught in the currency percentage, one can draw no other conclusion than that this new Ministry is starting out on a policy of inflation. That which they have condemned in others they are apparently endeavouring to emulate. I should like to know whether or not the Currency Commission, the bankers or anybody qualified to give advice on the subject were consulted before these taxes were introduced. Take the position of the most important Bank we have got.

According to the proposal to impose a corporation profits tax, there is an imposition before any sums are paid in dividends of 1/6 in the £ by reason of that 7½ per cent. Then we look at this proposal to get £90,000 from note issue. The note issue of this particular bank amounts to £1,760,000, and that at 1½ per cent. amounts to £26,400. Add £26,400 to £37,500 and you get nearly £64,000. That is income tax, but they will not call it income tax. It is equivalent to income tax at 2/6 in the £. Any widow or charitable institution having money invested in that particular bank pays 2/6 in the £ and will not get it returned. This is a new Christian system of re-organising the social order in this country. I have advised quite a number of people to invest their money in such concerns. Take it that one of them draws, say, £105 a year. Under this new Budget he will have paid 2/6 in the £ and will not get it returned.

Take the sur-tax payer. There is not one in the country—but let us assume there is—drawing £100,000 out of that bank in dividends. That investor would pay 5/- in the £ income tax; 6/3 in sur-tax and 2/6 which is not called income tax but is the same to the individual as if it were. The whole thing amounts to 13/9 in the £. The Minister gets away with it by saying that he is charging 2/- in the £ income tax and sur-tax less than what is being charged in England. And this is in the interests of the business of the country! This is going to give confidence to people who have capital to invest! This is going to attract people who have money to invest it in this country! Not at all. They are not fools, and they will only invest their money where they see there is an appreciation of industry. The people will risk their money in countries where they are sure of stable government, sure of fair consideration for the money they invest in order to make profit. So much then for income tax and sur-tax.

I presume the Minister will give us information as to whether or not the Currency Commission was consulted in respect of that proposal. When for the last few years an imposition in respect of corporation profits tax was made by the late administration, the situation was entirely different. Up to a little over six months ago income tax amounted to only 3/- in the £ and sur-tax to 4/6. The total sum in respect of income tax and sur-tax for which a person was liable, under these two items, was 7/6. If you say an extra shilling or 1/6 in respect of corporation profits tax you have the whole. But, at any rate, we were never in the position in which we could get an offer from any big payer of income tax or sur-tax to take his property, give him the tax and keep the rest ourselves. Quite a number of people would in present circumstances be well paid if that offer were accepted.

During the last few years a considerable amount of capital has come into this country. The Revenue Commissioners can inform the Minister whether or not that is so. As a result of that we get in the revenue of this State income in respect of income tax and sur-tax that would not otherwise come in. It is useful money. If it goes now, our own citizens here, less well off than those who are going to go, will be taxed in some way or other in order to make up this sum. So much for income tax, sur-tax and corporation profits tax.

We come to this proposal to get £13,000 by a new method of assessing liability in respect of property. In my experience of the last eight or ten years, I would say that if one thing were more responsible than another for arresting building and the development of building it was the Rent Restrictions Act. There may be many views upon that subject, but the fact is that up to the time of the war building house property and all that sort of thing was a business in itself. Very many people thought it was an excellent means of getting interest on their money. The Rent Restrictions Act interfered to a very considerable extent with that development of house building. Anybody who had house property, and who could possibly sell it, sold it during that period. The ordinary public was driven towards a smaller number of providers of house property. I would like to know whether the Minister has carefully examined this proposal to see whether it is likely to mean another reduction in the number of persons who are inclined to provide houses or business premises or anything of that sort.

In my experience during the last 20 or 25 years dealing with public matters in connection with housing, in one very well managed company, in one very well managed estate in this country with which I came in contact through the various administrative offices I held, I found that they were in a position to deal with building and the control of estates in a much more satisfactory manner and in a much less expensive manner than local authorities could. If this new imposition is going to mean that a lesser number of people are going to be interested in the production of houses or business premises, then I say that is a bad tax and not an advisable tax at all.

Coming then to the proposal in connection with the increase in sur-tax, I find the Minister mentions that he expects to get £77,000 per annum from that. We have not many people in this country in possession of an income amounting to £100,000 a year—not many. But I think we possibly have two, and if those two were to leave this country during the coming financial year, the loss to the Exchequer here would be not £77,000 but approximately £30,000 or £40,000 more. And it is not impossible for them to go.

Perhaps the next item is open to much the same sort of criticism. That is the sum of £84,000 which it is proposed to secure from a tax on entertainments. "It is necessary, therefore," the Minister said, "to enlarge the scope of the tax to cover all forms of entertainment, including dances, for which an admission fee is charged. The duty will cover outdoor sports, horse racing and greyhound coursing, and it will bring in about £84,000 in the current year." So said the Minister. I expect the Minister will not avow any particular inside knowledge of either racing or greyhound coursing. Personally, I do not know much about greyhound racing, but I do know a little of the difficulties in connection with horse racing.

I know quite a number of owners of racing establishments in this country which provide a considerable amount of employment, circulate large sums of money, and bring in annually one way or another into the State considerable sums in respect of the export and sale of horses. I know that by reason of the world slump, the terrible depression that has taken place, the reduction of incomes, and so on, the number is not increasing. I know that it is decreasing, and that it is more and more difficult for trainers to maintain establishments. A gentleman who has been engaged in the work of training horses for something like 25 years informed me, within the last few days, that he will not be able to keep up his establishment. He pays in wages something like £2,000 or £2,500 per annum. He is, perhaps, better circumstanced financially than most of them. If, in consequence of this particular imposition, unemployment in that case is bound to result, the people who get employment in respect of this form of activity will not be suitable for drainage work, road work, house building or anything of that sort.

I advise the Minister, before he persists in imposing this tax, to inquire as to what the reactions will be. I presume, in connection with the £84,000, that the Minister includes tennis racquets, golf sticks, and so forth. It would appear that in his anxiety to tax every possible section of the community, even the unfortunate flapper has not escaped his attention. What harm the poor flapper has done to him, or to any other member of the Ministry, I do not know. Any form of tax on outdoor sports is not good business. The amount that will be brought into the revenue from this particular form of tax is negligible. Healthy occupations of that sort ought not to be subject to tax.

We will come now to the proposal to change the tax from sugar to tea. The Minister stated that the tax on sugar is a hard tax; it was proposed by a hard Government. The tax on tea is a soft tax; presumably it is imposed by a soft-headed Government. The sum and substance of it is that so far as the tax on sugar is concerned a considerable portion of it is paid by the better-off people. They eat sweets. After luncheons and after dinners they have chocolates and other such vile productions—sweets of one sort or another. But tea is used more extensively by all sections of the community than are sweets or other productions of sugar. Take the West of Ireland as an example. They buy the very best tea there. Take the poorer parts of the City of Dublin, or the County of Dublin. What is the price of tea there? The Minister says that a man who paid 2/8 a lb. for tea will be told by his grocer that he will be charged only 2/8 in future. That is not so with the smaller-priced teas. I do not know what the smallest price per lb. for tea is now. When I had some association with that business it was 1/4 a lb. I believe the amount is much smaller now, and I am told— and the Minister can correct me if he likes—that the very smallest-priced tea will bear the 6d. tax, and not the 4d. tax. That is an absolute injustice. If you are going to put on 6d. on the 1/- tea and 4d. on the 4/- tea, then obviously there is an injustice.

The disturbance of those taxes, bringing in the same amount of money, and imposed for no other reason than to make a change, is not good business. Certain people are in the sugar business. They have stocks in and the duties are paid. They know where they are. Certain people may, or may not, have had quantities of tea in stock. Nobody knows what is going to happen. Some friends of the Ministry may get a hint that there is a likelihood of a tax on tea, and the stocks will go up. I would invite the Ministry to take the public into their confidence in respect of the whole change in our fiscal policy during the last month or so. I would invite them to indicate how it was those taxes were started. The first tax was on flowers, and obviously that was not a serious tax. The second tax was on agricultural machinery. People throughout the country are inquiring whether or not it is a fact that one director of their newspaper was in their confidence when that particular tax was imposed. Personally, I would much prefer that those allegations were not made.

Comment on this

Why does the Deputy repeat them?

Comment on this

Did the Deputies opposite ever object to the allegation that Masonry dominated my Ministry?

Comment on this
Mr. Brady

Never.

Comment on this

That is a different thing.

Comment on this

They would not do it. They had not the moral courage or the honesty—neither one nor the other.

Comment on this
Mr. Brady

Have you not their letter—the appeal for funds?

Comment on this

I had not one of them in my Party, at any rate.

Comment on this

From whom did you get the £40,000?

Comment on this

As far as funds are concerned, it is just the same as the Minister in his business or the Deputy in his business. There is no notice on his door: "No Freemasons served here." I expect the Deputy is in business.

Comment on this

While the Deputy is on that point. I want him to state clearly whether he personally has any objection to Masons, and, if so, what is his objection.

Comment on this
Deputies

Order!

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Does Deputy Briscoe rise to a point of explanation?

Comment on this

I would like to have this thing settled once and for all——

Comment on this

I was dealing with the policy of the present Administration in respect of certain fiscal liabilities. I say that people in this country are speaking as to the origin and motive of the new taxes.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Briscoe is making a point of explanation.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave, when he suggested that he had not one Freemason in his Party, is following out the line of action adopted by his Party in the elections, when I personally was held up to the odium of the public because of my past connection with the Masonic Order. I will ask Deputy Cosgrave to state definitely and clearly what his views are in regard to that matter.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cosgrave is not bound to make any such statement.

Comment on this

I am merely a child in the matter; I know nothing about them.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows a great deal more than he cares to admit, and I know that he knows it.

Comment on this
Deputies

Order!

Comment on this

If Deputy Briscoe has any information which would convict or commit me, I am inviting him to produce it.

Comment on this

I will take advantage of the opportunity.

Comment on this

As to the imposition of new taxes, the public has observed —I have observed it myself—that the second tax was in respect of a commodity in which was interested a Director of the Company. I am inviting the Minister to give an explanation in that respect. I am prepared to support my arguments. I ask the Ministry to make a case. I put it to them to make a sound case and show clearly that it was unfair and wrong to make this allegation against a public man. Further, I will ask them to make a case in respect of another Director. I would like to know, in the case of the taking of the tax off sugar, whether that man had no more than the ordinary ingress to their councils in respect of that particular thing. I do not stand for these allegations against public men.

Comment on this

If the Deputy does not, why does he repeat them?

Comment on this

Why does the Deputy make them? It is all a damned lie.

Comment on this

I am putting it forward for the purpose of giving the Minister an opportunity of making an explanation.

Comment on this

Why should we make any explanation?

Comment on this

We are responsible to the Irish people.

Comment on this

Then you are responsible to me, because I am one of the Irish people.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Cosgrave anxious because the company from which his own private income is derived is going to suffer under this Budget?

Comment on this

Does the Minister know that?

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

It does not matter.

Comment on this

How does the Minister know that? Did the Minister get any information from private State documents?

Comment on this

No, he did not.

Comment on this

How does the Minister know it then?

Comment on this

What about the person who made the investments for the Deputy?

Comment on this

There is an allegation made which I am entitled to deal with. How has the Minister got that information?

Comment on this

The Minister is not going to give the Deputy that information, but the Deputy knows that what the Minister has said is true.

Comment on this

Will the Minister prove it? And supposing it were true, have I the right to make an explanation and the exposure that I have made of the Minister's incompetence in his capacity as Minister for Finance?

Comment on this

And your attack on business men in the City of Dublin.

Comment on this

The Minister will deal with that when he comes to reply.

Comment on this

I hope so.

Comment on this

And show how much Deputy Cosgrave's word was worth when he was President of the Executive Council.

Comment on this

I would invite the Minister—strongly invite him—to do it.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy any more allegations to make now?

Comment on this

I am inviting the Ministry to make its explanation.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy any more allegations to make?

Comment on this

I have made none. I am simply telling here in the Parliament of the people what is being said outside.

Comment on this

Who is saying it?

Comment on this

It was said here.

Comment on this

If nobody said it there are the two facts—

Comment on this

It was said in the Gresham yesterday.

Comment on this

—one a change in the sugar tax which was said to be a hard tax, and (2) a change to a tea tax which is a soft tax with £18,000 more into the revenue and all this disturbance of business with certain people getting off: 999 lbs. of tea in an establishment absolutely free of any tax, and 1,001 lbs. or 1,000½ lbs. all subject to tax. I happen now and then to read newspaper advertisements, and what do I find? One English company advertising that it has 800 cases of goods in respect of which no duty was paid, that it is in a position to sell those goods at a lower price than an ordinary Irish trader here who knew nothing about the possibility of an increase of the tax on boots. I say that the public ought to be taken into the confidence of the Ministry, and that we ought to have an explanation as to why each of these taxes was imposed; what was the reason for each, whether there was a recommendation from a Department of State or whether the door was opened to let people in one after the other according as the Minister was in a position to see them.

The next item I propose to deal with is the tobacco tax. Speaking from memory, the revenue from that tax last year was £13,000 less than it was the year before. Under the Budget it is proposed, with certain remissions, to get £350,000 in extra tax from tobacco this year. That is unlikely on the face of it. If there is one tax in respect of which we have reached saturation point it is surely this. So far as the ordinary working man is concerned, the ordinary farmer or anybody else who smokes pipe tobacco, goodness knows they have had to pay enough up to this for their tobacco. Therefore this penny an ounce extra, even if the proposed extra tax does not exceed that, is to my mind more than can be justified.

I now come to the remissions. I recollect, during the election campaign, Deputy Lemass, who is now the Minister for Industry and Commerce, making a speech in Dublin in which he said his was a pro-railway Party. It was pro-everything—pro-bus and pro-railway. So far as this Budget is concerned, nothing has been done in it for the railways. While on that, I come to another point. I want to know who it was that made representations to the Ministry for a reduction in the tax on seating accommodation in buses. If I am not very much mistaken, a secretary of one of their branches is secretary of one of these bus companies, and that one of the principal owners of one of the small bus companies wrote to the papers some time ago, saying that he was not a candidate for election for the Dublin Corporation—that he was supporting the Fianna Fáil candidates. That is one question that I am putting. This remission in duty amounts to £23,000. If there is a case for that, why not have it examined and an explanation of it; but so far as the remission is concerned it simply means that 10,000 men will be employed for one week out of the Road Fund. That is what it amounts to. The case made for the remission, as well as I can remember, was that the Government could not possibly see such a situation arising as would leave these companies in financial difficulties.

The railways are now in financial difficulties. There is very much more money invested in the Irish railways, the money of widows and orphans and of charitable institutions, than there is in bus companies, but this pro-railway Party that we have has done nothing for the railways since they came into office except to carry out the policy introduced by the ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce in closing down the Dublin and Blessington Steam Tramway Company.

Comment on this

What did the Deputy and his Party do for the railways?

Comment on this

A lot, a great deal. The Minister would take too long to understand it if I were to explain it to him. He would want to be very quick on the uptake to follow the great work that was done by the outgoing administration. I think I have dealt with most of the impositions proposed under the Budget. With regard to the remission in the beer duty, in the case of the smaller breweries, I think that is a good proposal. In fact, I think it is the only sensible proposal in the whole Budget.

I now come to this sum of £910,000, about which the Minister had so little information at his disposal the other day when we discussed it. We now have it in bulk form here. I find that there is a proposal in the Budget to make £150,000 available for the service of a loan in connection with housing. There is also provision for a tax, the estimated yield of which in respect of building amounts to £271,000 on one item, and £50,000 on another—that is to say, £320,000 is being placed upon an industry which has had to be subsidised here for the last 10 years. By reducing the charges for loans for housing, the Minister is making available a sum of £150,000. That does not appear to me to be very good business. I would like to have an explanation as to whether any examination has been made by the Ministry or by civil servants with regard to the possibility of having the goods mentioned in the Schedule manufactured in this country and, if so, why it is anticipated there will be such a large yield of £270,000 in one case and of £50,000 in the other? How can such a yield as that be expected at a time when the reports in connection with the building industry were never as bad as they are to-day? There were more plasterers idle, I believe, within the last month than there were 12 months ago when there was a strike on. Fewer houses are being sold now than were being sold twelve months ago. People who were inclined to buy are backing out, and so on. Surely, this is not the time to impose extra taxes in respect of the production of houses.

I have a few little questions here for the Minister. He mentioned in the course of his speech that £373,353 more is included for the service of debt than last year, and that he has included in that sum £150,000 for the cost of issue and capital charges on the new loan. The difference between these two figures amounts to £223,353, and he states, in the earlier parts of his speech, "that the increase in the balance remaining over what was provided last year was almost entirely due to the fact that we put £450,000 to the Savings Certificate Interest Equalisation Fund." The usual sum to that Fund was £150,000, and I presume that that £150,000 is included in this year's sum.

Comment on this

Where was it in last year's?

Comment on this

That is another question. Stop the stupidity just for a moment and I will deal with it later on. There was £150,000 included in last year's Estimate.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy go on with his speech now.

Comment on this

Will the Minister stop his stupid interjections? £150,000 deducted from £450,000 leaves £300,000, and then I gather that the Minister states that this £300,000 is almost entirely due to liquidating a debt of £223,000. Maybe there has been a misprint. Does the Minister follow that? In his speech there is a statement that the ex-Minister overlooked the fact that he had left £424,000 of accrued interest on Savings Certificates unprovided for; and, again, the Minister states that the total provision for the service of debt is £2,419,000 odd, or £373,352 more than last year. "Of this sum, £150,000 is to cover the cost of issue and capital charges in this year on the new loan. The increase in the balance remaining over what was provided last year is almost entirely due to the fact that we are putting £450,000 to the Savings Certificate Interest Equalisation Fund." What I am at a loss to know is, how £223,000 comes to be £450,000?

I want to ask whether the concession to give a 20 per cent. allowance, in respect of money invested in new companies, is to be afforded to persons who avail of the 75 per cent. liability for income tax, and whether the Minister will accept an amendment to that proposal, excluding members of the Oireachtas from participating in it. I want to know whether there is more than one year included in the proposal to increase the corporation profits tax, and I would like to know what proportion of the profits of the two Northern Ireland banking companies, and the two companies which have British branches, would be liable under the corporation profits tax. I have dealt, so far, with the proposal of the Minister to get very nearly £4,000,000 extra in this year's Budget than what was available from the impositions imposed last year. That, however, does not completely furnish a true picture of the balance sheet. A balance sheet is made up in two parts. There is, first of all, the ordinary Budgetary liabilities and the means of providing for them, and that total revenue is expected to amount to £26,260,250. There is a balance on the normal Budget of £12,000 to credit, and we go on, then, to what is called an Emergency Budget, where £600,000 is provided for employment, £100,000 for building by private persons, £350,000 for free grants to local authorities for housing, etc., and £150,000 special grants for relief, making in all a sum of £600,000. That is the total extra sum which is provided for employment in this Budget, over and above the Estimates left by the outgoing Administration. For that £600,000 taxation, as I have explained already, is going to be increased by nearly £4,000,000.

This £600,000 has all the appearance of new money, but what is it? Where does it come from? It comes in respect of a new impost on the hospitals of the State entitled to participate in the various sweepstakes. If I am not very much mistaken, these particular hospitals intended themselves to carry out various building extensions, improvements, developments or something of that sort. It is almost inevitable, it is practically certain, that they did intend to, and would have spent that money during the year. This administration comes in and says "we will relieve you of any popularity that may accrue to you or the Hospitals Trust or the people who invested or anybody else. We are going to get any popularity there is, for spending any money we can lay hands upon in this country," and so instead of spending it out of the right-hand pocket, it is being spent out of the left, but, so far as the people are concerned, they are getting no advantage. They are being taxed to the tune of £3,800,000 and all that the working people, the labouring men can boast of having got out of this great Budget, as it is called, is £600,000, which, in any case, would have been provided for the hospitals and spent by them. It is a legalised form of transporting from one source, expenditure which goes into another.

This particular sheet does not disclose by any means what our Budgetary position is this year. There should be added to the expenditure side that three-quarters of a million pounds which the Minister for Agriculture requires in connection with his butter bounty proposals. There should be added the £60,000 which the Minister for Industry and Commerce proposes to re-impose, and of which we relieved industry, in connection with unemployment insurance, and there should be added all the promises made in respect of widows' and orphans' pensions. These sums added together would amount to £810,000, plus, approximately, £500,000 for widows' and orphans' pensions, so that the Budget we are dealing with means an actual imposition on the taxpayers of this country of about £5,000,000, over and above what was received last year. What are they getting for it in return —£600,000, which is being taken from the hospitals, and which nobody is in a position to say the hospitals are themselves satisfied they can afford. This Budget is going to decrease employment in this country; it is going to spread distress and disquietude, and, very largely, feelings of despair, from one end of the country to the other. It is going to impede business and bring down our name as a country that requires a greater amount of taxation, and a country standing more taxation than the potentialities of the country can afford.

It is going to stop any possible expansion or improvement or the starting of any business in this country, and it is beyond the capacity of the people to bear it. Nobody with any experience of administration would think of imposing such a burden upon the people, having regard to what the Minister said.

Let me deal in conclusion with the earlier portion of the Minister's speech, in which he went into what he called contingent liabilities, where he reduced pounds into gold ounces and all that sort of nonsense that you hear of only in your early days in school when you get sums on the blackboard and have things reduced down to the last resort in certain cases. What is the position with regard to gold or with regard to quotations on the stock exchange or anything of that sort? They simply mean the fluctuations which occur in the market in respect of these things. Just imagine the people of this country this time twelve months saying: "There is going to be a new Minister in this country in twelve months time. All our investments must be sold and we will turn them into gold ounces." Things are not done in that way. It may be that it would be a very wise thing to do, but the fact is that the contingent liabilities of this State were put by the Minister at £115,000,000. Two sums are largely responsible for that figure, one of £24,000,000 in respect of the Land Act of 1923, and the other represents sums of money which have been mentioned, I believe, in the British Parliament in connection with Land Stock, principally in respect of the Land Acts of 1903 and 1909. Strangely enough, these were not reduced to gold ounces by the Minister— an oversight. The fact is that the £76,000,000 has its annual counterpart in sums given by the Minister: land annuities under Acts prior to 1923, £2,976,591; bonus stock annuity, £134,500. The total of these two sums is about £3,100,000. If there is any party in this State which has been reducing capital to its equivalent dividend, and dividends to their equivalent capital during the last five or six years, it is that Party over there. You got outgoings of any sort or kind over £100,000 a year capitalised at something like £2,000,000 at a shot. Every one of them is so accustomed to multiplying sums that they cannot get off the track of twenty to one. On their basis of a twenty-to-one chance, how much does twenty times £3,100,000 amount to? £62,000,000. What does the Minister estimate as our liability in respect of it? £76,000,000 in round numbers. All that is designed for one particular purpose. In respect of the service of that debt of £76,000,000 and the sinking fund, the British Government has undertaken a liability, under the secret document, of approximately £1,000,000 per annum. Was there any reason in the world why the people should not have been taken into the confidence of the Ministry in respect to that item? It is on the British estimates year after year. In bringing forward a most depressing and hard Budget, as the Minister described it, he might at least have given the people the consolation of knowing that the British Government bear £1,000,000 of that particular service year after year, and that we are only in for £134,500.

Within the last two or three weeks it was reported in the Press that there was something like £480,000 outstanding in rates in this country. I cannot remember at the moment whether that was in excess of last year's sum, but I do know, and I think everybody knows, that the collection of Land Commission annuities during the last three or four months has suffered considerable contraction. These are indications that business and commerce and prices have been suffering to a greater extent than before. This is a time when fitting the burden to the back should engage the attention of this Oireachtas. This Budget will hinder that development which it ought to be the first interest of Ministers to concern themselves with. Prices have fallen; fairs are no longer what they were. Whether we like it or not, the fact is that we are not popular, that our goods are not popular in the only market in which we can sell them, and that is largely attributable to the policy which is being pursued by the present administration.

Comment on this
Thomas Derrig Minister for Education (Mr. Derrig) Fianna Fáil

No.

Comment on this

If you take their own newspaper, there is scarcely a day that one does not find some criticism of the British Government, or British newspapers, or something of that sort. That is not the way to do business. The sooner they realise that we have to get the goodwill of that customer the better it will be for the finance and business of this State. Apart from that, we think that this Budget is beyond the capacity of the people to bear, and certainly I for one will register my vote against it.

Comment on this

Read the "Daily Express."

Comment on this

On a point of order. I should like to get a ruling from you, sir, on a matter of order in connection with an incident which happened in the course of the speech which has just concluded. In the course of that speech, the Minister for Finance made certain statements which indicated that he, at any rate, pretended to know the source of income of the last speaker. If he was revealing a confidential document, I think it would be a matter of disorder to do that, and I rise in order to find out from the Minister whether, in fact, he has made a wrong use of confidential information which we know is at his disposal through the avenue either of the Statistics Department or the Revenue Commissioners. I think that is a question which should be answered as a matter of order in the House.

Comment on this

If the Deputy's conscience with regard to confidential documents was as clear as mine, he would never make that insinuation against me across the floor of the House. We do know that Deputy McGilligan in another place used confidential documents to attack a member of the present Government. Deputies: "Order, order," and "Chair"). I have not done that, and I never will.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

As to the first point of order, the Chair has no means of deciding where the Minister got the information. Further, Deputy McGilligan should have raised the point of order immediately the Minister had made the statement.

Comment on this

No. With all respect, and in deep respect, I do not accept the second point you made, sir; that is, that it is only proper to raise such a point at the time. When the incident occurred, there was a certain heated atmosphere which I thought it was better to let pass, and have the Minister reduced to some more normal state of calm than we have seen him in for the last couple of days before one sought an explanation. On the first point, I put it to you that if the Minister was clearly and definitely quoting from a confidential document it would be a matter of disorder, and therefore a matter of order in this House to have attention called to it to see whether an explanation might be made by the person who made the statement. At the moment I put it to you that it is quite clear that, when any Minister, and particularly the Minister for Finance, has access to confidential information, that the standard of decency and good conduct in any country in the world would ensure that confidence is respected in regard to the information given in confidence. If there has been a breach of that confidence it is time the House was told it was so. If there has not been a breach of confidence it is time the House knew where the information came from. Otherwise the Minister must suffer hereafter from a particularly wounding imputation that he has no sense of honour, an imputation that, in fact, he has not lived up to the standards of decent conduct of Ministers in any respectable Government.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not making a point of order.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I must hear what Deputy McGilligan's point of order is.

Comment on this

Either he has not lived up to it and has consequently caused a severe shock to those people who do business in this country on the supposition that honourable standards will be observed, or else, alternatively, he has simply used something that he has heard, as a vague rumour or report, characterising that as information at his disposal.

Comment on this

Just as Deputy Cosgrave did.

Comment on this

I gave my facts.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair can only deal with matters that come within its knowledge. If this is a breach of privilege the Chair can deal with it. I have no proof where the Minister got the information he used.

Comment on this

On a point of order, will Deputy Cosgrave explain to the House the reason why he says that the statements he made in connection with the tariffs are facts? Will he give the House the information that is at his disposal to show that these insinuations there were facts?

Comment on this

They are on the records of the House. The second tax is on the records of the House, and the later one also. I am simply inviting a statement.

Comment on this

Is it a fact?

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

Are we to get no information from the Minister as to where he got his information?

Comment on this

No; beyond this——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot force the Minister to give information as to where he got it. I do not see that there has been any breach of privilege.

Comment on this

We can draw our own conclusions.

Comment on this

I think I am entitled to say that I have not divulged, and that I never in my capacity as a Minister divulged, any matter of information that came to me in a confidential way or from any official source. The only person——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That closes the incident.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave, according to the speech he delivered here, cannot possibly understand any Government imposing a tariff or doing anything else without getting some consideration in return. He went through the various tariffs imposed, and he racked his mind and tried to find out what connection had any member of this Government with anybody in the particular trade which we are protecting, to see what return we got in return for imposing the tariff. He took agricultural machinery and he took the remission on the tax on sugar, and he spoke of the bus tax. He gave us the relationship of the people who are to benefit by this remission of tariffs with certain members of the Government in order to show why it was done. That is a very nice mentality for the leader of the Government in this country for the last ten years. Is that the mentality that existed in the Government for the last ten years? That if there was a tariff to be imposed some Minister was asked if he was related to somebody in the trade, or if he was going to get something out of it, and if there was no benefit to some friend or relative of a Minister then the tariff should not be put on. If there was to be a remission of taxation Deputy Cosgrave asked his Ministers whether they were likely to have any friend that would benefit by the remission of this tax. That was the impression he gave to the House, and that is the impression he gave of the way business was carried on by the late Government for the last ten years. And with his small mean mind he accused us of acting in the same way. He takes every tax that we impose and tries to find out what benefit it will bring to any particular member of the Government. He wants to know did our friends come and put their claims before us, and how did we meet them or how were taxes put on. I tell Deputy Cosgrave this, that whatever was the method pursued by his Government, when in power, in relation to taxation, about remitting taxation or putting it on, that method, at any rate, is not adopted by this Government. I can assure Deputy Cosgrave, and the Party opposite, there was no approach from anybody in the sugar trade, whether these people were friends of Ministers or not, or anybody else, before the tax was taken off. I can assure Deputy Cosgrave that whatever his speech may imply as to what was done in the last ten years no friend of any Minister was told to go out and buy tea before the Budget was brought in this year. We can say we have clear consciences in this matter, and, what is more, we never attempted, in this House, to impute such things to Ministers who preceded us.

Deputy Cosgrave also spoke about the depressed prices the farmers were getting for their stock at the present time. He said our goods were not very popular in a certain market at the present time. That was an allegation that since the Fianna Fáil Party came into power we were getting worse prices for farm produce, relative to world prices, than were given before the Fianna Fáil Party came into power. There is nothing at all in that allegation. I defy any member of the House to say that we are getting worse prices for bacon—I leave butter out, because it is in a special category at the present moment—or eggs or any other things in which we compete with other countries in the British market. I defy anyone to show that we are getting worse prices, relatively to other countries, than were obtained under the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, so friendly to the British when it was in power. Things are not a bit worse in this respect, and I think if one examined the figures it would be found that we are selling things as well, and in one particular case something better than before this Government came into power. These are the wild accusations thrown out by Deputy Cosgrave and his Party. He was not so wild to-day as he was in the Gresham Hotel yesterday. In the Gresham Hotel he had people to talk to who were not likely to contradict him, and he could say anything, no matter how wild, there. He was a little more careful here to-day. Deputy Cosgrave, like everybody else who spoke against the Budget, tried to give the impression that the Fianna Fáil Party were putting four or five millions of extra taxation upon the country that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party would not have put on. I wonder how Deputy Cosgrave, who is so well up in figures, and who rolled off figures for an hour and ten minutes sometimes even without looking at his brief, can make such statements and expect people to believe what he is saying. Do we not all know the position? We know that the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, before it went out of office, prepared estimates for the coming year, and these estimates were there when we came into office.

We took these estimates as the basis to work upon. We said that it was possible to make certain economies on the estimates for the coming year but, in the meantime, we wanted to see what position we would be in with regard to expenditure required and the amount to be raised on that basis of taxation. What do we find? We found that on the Cumann na nGaedheal basis we were three and a half millions short. We came to the conclusion that if the Cumann na nGaedheal Party had been returned to power at the last election they would be coming before the Dáil with extra taxation amounting to three and a half millions. If that is not so, then the estimates prepared by that Party are wrong. Taking the Budget, we find that the normal revenue would amount to £23,310,000, and we propose to raise by extra taxation £2,950,000, in order to meet the estimated expenditure for the coming year. It is true that we have added two millions to the expenditure side to meet the requirements of a Bill that will be brought in dealing with Old Age Pensions, and an Army Bill. Against that we have made savings on the estimated expenditure handed over to us by the late Government that will be more than sufficient to deal with these two Bills. We are not so hard on the taxpayers as the normal budget of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government would have been if they had been returned to power. The former Government would have had to increase taxation by three and a half million pounds. We propose to increase taxation by only two millions.

Deputy Cosgrave endeavoured to give the House the impression that we were increasing taxation by £3,500,000, and later he stated by £5,500,000 more than Cumann na nGaedheal would have needed if they came back to power. I would like the House to realise that three and a half millions would have to be raised by Cumann na nGaedheal if they were to work on their own estimate. Members of that Party stated that they would have to save £2,000,000 if they had come back.

Comment on this

That is what Fianna Fáil said.

Comment on this

The Cumann na nGaedheal Party said that they were going to save £2,000,000. Some of their speakers have stated that we propose to save only a half a million. I believe the last Government was considering the question of savings. The then Minister for Finance told the House when he brought in the Supplementary Budget that they were considering savings on the public services. We never got any indication where the savings were to come from. If speakers on the Opposition Benches contend that they would not have to raise the additional three and a half millions that I have spoken of, I would like to have some indication where the money was to come from. We have had no such indication up to this. It is quite possible that that Party would examine old age pensions, which was a favourite source with them, when savings had to be made in the past. It is quite possible that they would cut down the money for relief schemes, housing grants—as was proposed in the estimates—and in other things that would give employment to the very poor. There has been no indication as to how a saving of two millions was to be made. This Government has been accused of saying that when they came into power they were going to make savings amounting to two million pounds. In our programme we stated we were going to do a good many things—to give pensions to the old and to widows and orphans, and to vote a considerable amount of money for the relief of the unemployed. We also proposed to do other things that are outlined in the Budget, such as relieving rates on agricultural land. I do not know if the £2,000,000 figure is right, but we said big savings could be made in the public services. We believe that. This Government has only been in office between two and three months, and, having gone hastily through the estimates for the different services, Ministers have made certain suggestions to the Minister for Finance as to where in their opinion savings could be made. As a result the Minister for Finance has set up a special committee to examine these suggestions and to see if large savings can be made. Before we came into office we said that savings could be made, and we still believe that. We are not "put out" when people accuse us of saying before we came into office that there could be a saving of two million pounds in the Estimates for public services. We hope to reach that figure some time, but not this side of Christmas.

Deputy Cosgrave was very polite in some parts of his statement and very scurrilous in other parts. When speaking in the Gresham Hotel yesterday surrounded by his own cronies, he accused us of taxing everybody except ourselves. Imagine the impudence of Deputy Cosgrave saying that we were taxing everybody and putting a burden upon everybody except ourselves. When Deputy Cosgrave was President of the Executive Council he was worth £2,500 a year. Would it not be a great joke if Deputy Cosgrave went to any commercial man in the city and told him that he wanted a job at a salary of £2,500 a year, plus £350 for a motor car.

Comment on this

He is well worth it. The Minister knows that his statement about £350 is wrong.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Gorey can make a speech and contradict the statement.

Comment on this

I saw it in the Estimates. That is all I know about it.

Comment on this

You know about it well enough.

Comment on this

When Deputy Gorey is a Minister we will give him more.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave, when he had his own followers in the Gresham Hotel, and wanted to make a small joke, told them that we were putting a burden upon everybody in the country except ourselves. He had £2,500, and his Ministers had £1,700 each, and they have been replaced by Ministers at a considerable reduction in salary. Even so, Deputy Cosgrave came forward and said that we were putting a burden upon everybody except ourselves. I believe the late Ministers did propose to cut their salaries before they went out of office. If they had been returned to office they had intended to cut their salaries by 10 per cent. It is a great pity that they did not get the chance to put their good resolutions into practice.

Deputy Cosgrave says the Budget is too heavy on income tax payers. He talked about income-tax, sur-tax, corporation profits tax, and practically every tax which bears on people with money. He almost shed tears when he spoke about widows who had money invested in the Bank of Ireland or in Guinness. He referred to the burden we are placing on these widows and said that, from that point of view, this was an un-Christian Budget. I should like Deputy Cosgrave and those who sympathise with him on this particular matter to realise that we are at present investigating the best means of giving a pension to every needy widow in this country—a thing that Deputy Cosgrave's Government, with their Christian ideas and Christian outlook, never thought of doing. If we take a little more income tax off the widow who has money invested in Guinness or the Bank of Ireland, we cannot help it. We cannot very well make an exception in the case of the widow who has these investments. We must collect income tax from all persons liable to tax, but we are going to see that the widow whom Deputy Cosgrave and his Ministry neglected for ten years is not going to starve any longer.

What is the real fact about income tax to which Deputy Cosgrave did not advert? It is quite evident that he studied the income tax proposals very closely. He gave us the tax which a man with an income of £100,000 would have to pay. There are very few persons of that type in this country, but the few there are are followers of Deputy Cosgrave, and probably his most valuable followers. Even so, he should have taken a better example than the man with a £100,000 a year. Take a man earning £600 a year with a wife and four children. That is not a very low salary. Under our Budget proposals, that man will be better off than he was under Deputy Blythe's Budget last year. It is quite evident that the man with a family and with a fairly low income is not by any means hurt by the Budget. The man who is hurt is the man with £100,000 income, as Deputy Cosgrave mentioned. We are not a bit ashamed of being hard on that man.

Other Deputies tell us that we are hard on the poor. A considerable part of Deputy Cosgrave's speech was devoted to the income tax payer and he ignored the resolution passed by his own organisation yesterday which referred to the impost on the poor and the small farmer. We have been accused of being too hard on the poor. The example taken in proof of this is the tax on tea. We are told that we should have left the tax on sugar and not transferred it to tea. This tax makes very little difference to the Exchequer. In our opinion, it was better to take the tax off sugar and put it on to tea. That was not because some Minister knew a man in the sugar trade, as Deputy Cosgrave said. It was for no other reason than that we thought that a tea tax was a more just tax than a sugar tax. I can tell Deputy Cosgrave that he is not right in saying that the 4d. tax on tea means an additional charge to the consumer of 6d. I know people who bought tea in shops in Dublin after the Budget and I am aware that the price has gone up only 4d. per lb. I do not know whether that is generally true, but I know that it is true of the larger shops in Dublin. Anything is good enough to throw at a Budget when you want to make little of it. I know from experience, when I was in medical practice, that sugar is absolutely essential to the children of the poor. Tea is not an essential. I defy any doctor in this House, if he has regard for his reputation, to say that he ever ordered tea to a person who was ill. Sugar must, of course, be prescribed in the diet of an infant, whether that infant be a member of a rich or a poor family. Sugar is a necessary and tea is not. We were quite justified in removing the tax from sugar and putting it on tea.

Reference has been made to the tobacco tax, and it has been said that we are putting up the cost of tobacco to the poor man. It is true that the price will go up somewhat, but half of the tax will be derived from the proceeds of cigarette sales. As far as I am aware, that will not be passed on to the consumer. The package tax has been mentioned. The package tax was considered a very good way of promoting employment in this country. We thought that since we were not able to produce tea or salt or some other things in this country, we should at least be able to import these commodities in chests or sacks and employ our own people in the packing of them. I think the package tax is a very just tax. Other people who do not care about the rich or poor tell us that the Budget is too heavy on the farmer. The farmer, apparently, is neither a rich man nor a poor man. Why is the Budget too heavy on the farmer? We are told that he must pay more for his agricultural machinery. As the agricultural machinery tax has been imposed, the Minister for Agriculture has power to issue a licence to import certain classes of machinery when there is a shortage, so that if the price of harvesting machines be raised by the manufacturer here the Minister for Agriculture has power to permit the importation of foreign machines, and he will do so. As regards parts, most people seem to be satisfied that the exemption up to 5/- wholesale will mean that there will be very little hardship on the farmer. The agricultural machinery tax is not going to bear too heavily on the farmer. Manures have been mentioned. We put a tax on certain phosphatic manures, but we allowed free imports from any country within the British Commonwealth. That ought to commend itself to our opponents, who have been attacking us very bitterly during the last two or three weeks on our hostility towards the British market. In the case of every tax, we give a preference to the British market, and, in this case, we actually allow in free imports from the British Commonwealth. Surely that ought to be sufficient guarantee to every farmer that he is not going to pay too much for phosphatic manures.

Comment on this

It is no such guarantee. It means that phosphatic manures will rise in price.

Comment on this

They may rise somewhat, but there cannot be a very big rise so long as that guarantee is there. Tariffs were also imposed on spades and shovels. I cannot see that the tariff on spades, shovels, wire and things of that sort will mean a very big item in the farmer's bill. They are estimated to produce something like £56,000, and against that £56,000 we propose to give £250,000 in direct relief of rates, which will be a bigger advantage. The small farmer was also mentioned. The small farmer will get the bigger share of benefit from this £250,000 when it comes to be distributed. He will also get the greater advantage from the votes for unemployment relief, drainage and the improvement of by-roads. These are the various classes on whom we are told we are too hard.

First of all it is said that we are too hard on the rich; secondly, that we are too hard on the poor; and thirdly, that we are too hard on the farmers. If we do not take a certain amount of taxation from the rich, from the poor or from the farmers, I would like to know where are we to get all this money? I would like to know where Cumann na nGaedheal would get the three and a half millions if they excluded all these classes. Deputies on the Cumann na nGaedheal side have attacked us by saying that we are taking from the rich, from the poor and from the farmers. If we are to take the advice of Cumann na nGaedheal we are not going to get a halfpenny from anybody. Even one Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy attacked us for cutting the salaries in the public service. They rule out everything. One Deputy attacks us on one matter and another Deputy on another matter. Deputy Shaw said that we should not take any money from horse-racing. Cumann na nGaedheal, assembled in the Gresham Hotel yesterday, said that we should not take it from outdoor games, and they are all against tariffs on imports. Deputy Cosgrave, speaking a few moments ago, said that we should not take it in excess profits tax or impose any bank note tax. Is there any single thing left in the Budget that has not been criticised? Is there any single source from which we could get income that would have the unanimous approval of Cumann na nGaedheal? They have condemned every source from which we could have got this revenue. Of course, they have not been unanimous, I know. If they held their Party meetings more frequently and spoke with one voice they would save a lot of time.

We are putting on tariffs, apart altogether from any revenue that may be derived from them, because we want to set new industries going here. Briefly speaking, for the last ten years, perhaps I should say for the last seventy or eighty years, we have had an agricultural community here trading with industrialists in another country. They were producing foodstuffs and selling them to industrialists in another country, buying back whatever they wanted from these industrialists. They were carrying on in spite of great depression, carrying the cost of the unemployed and of Government and other burdens. We want to change that. We want, if possible, to get our own industries going, to get our farmers to trade with our industrialists in our own towns, as far as possible, and in that way to cut out unemployment, to create a class in the town who will help the farmers to bear the burden of Government, unemployment, and so on. As well as that, we shall have a surplus for export and we shall have to buy certain things that we are not able to produce here. Deputy McGilligan asked if we are going to make all our worsteds and woollens under a tariff, how do we expect any foreigner to buy any worsteds or woollens from us when we are not importing any? If we were producing every single thing in this country that we want for ourselves and were not importing anything, of course we would not expect anybody to buy from us, because we would not want to export anything; but that is not going to be the position. We know quite well that we must import some things which we cannot produce here, and we shall expect to sell our exportable surplus to those from whom we buy those things.

Deputy Cosgrave, when he was doing the funny man in the Gresham Hotel yesterday, talked about Fianna Fáil fairs. He said the fairs down the country were Fianna Fáil fairs, when the farmers were not getting good prices. I have already said that we are getting as good prices, relatively to world prices, as when Cumann na nGaedheal were in office, and if Deputy Cosgrave wants to follow the example of the stage Irishman and tries to throw ridicule on his own countrymen for the benefit of his richer neighbour——

Comment on this

Were you not doing that long enough yourselves?

Comment on this

Perhaps we would take the Deputy as an example. I would like to get a little further with the Budget. I said that I would deal with matters other than the Budget at a later stage. In regard to what is called an Emergency Budget, we are accused again of going to the wrong sources for our Emergency Budget. Every source we have gone to is wrong. We are told that we should not take money from the Hospitals Sweepstakes. Deputy Cosgrave stated yesterday that if it were left to the hospitals it would go to the relief of unemployment. That is not true. It would not. There is a lot of that money going into investments in order that the proceeds will be there for the running expenses of the hospitals in years to come, and it would not, therefore, be there to give employment this year. Apart from that altogether, we, as anybody can see, had to examine various sources to get our money, and this was a source that presented possibilities. Various ways of getting money out of that source were suggested: profits tax, stamp duty or something else. This was the best way that could be suggested to get the money. I read a letter a few days ago in the newspapers from a certain doctor attacking us and saying that we were going to deprive his hospital of £25,000 this year. That means that their income from the Hospitals Sweepstakes this year would be £100,000, and that is not a very big hospital. I remember when Deputies introduced the Hospitals Sweepstakes Bill at first they had high hopes that they might get £100,000 altogether out of it.

Comment on this

Two hundred thousand pounds.

Comment on this

Two hundred thousand pounds. Here is one small hospital that is going to derive in one year this huge sum out of the Sweepstakes and we are blamed for taking a little bit out of that. Is prevention not better than cure? Is it not better to keep people out of hospital by giving them proper food and work? We are trying to keep people from going into the hospitals. We are raising the money to give employment, and the Hospitals Sweepstakes was one source we thought was a good mark.

Again, we have the matter of the arrears of income tax referred to. Deputy Cosgrave accused us several times of not taking the people of the country into our confidence. We have taken the people into our confidence on that at any rate, because every single year we were in opposition, we advised the then Minister for Finance to take courage in this matter, to declare an amnesty for all those people who had money hidden away, and ask them to declare what they had. We said that it would not only bring in arrears of income tax in that way, but that it would also bring in a certain amount of money in the future. We have adopted that method in this Budget, and we are going to take in £350,000 from that source this year.

There has not been any great attack as to the manner in which we spend the money under the Emergency Budget. There has been a certain amount of attack, but there is no Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy in this House who will go before his constituents and say: "I will vote against that expenditure." He will not go before his constituents and say: "I have voted against money being given for the relief of unemployment." There is no great attack on the way the money is being spent.

First of all we thought that the provision for housing was inadequate and we took powers to provide for housing. First we said that a free grant is necessary and we mean to increase the grant to the builders of private houses. We also wanted to get housing going on a more extensive scale by the local authorities, and there is a larger amount voted to the local authorities under that head. There is also the provision of milk for necessitous children. That was not referred to by Deputy Cosgrave. It must have been a great consolation to him last night when he was down in the Metropole to know that the very poor are going to get free milk. He did not refer in his speech to the £100,000 that we had to raise in order to give milk to the children of these poor people. When the Butter Bill was under discussion we were attacked very strongly here because we were putting up the cost of butter to such an extent that some people would not be able to buy butter in the future, and Deputy A. Byrne told us of the case of a man with 10/- a week and who had to pay 3/6 rent. That is the class of man that we want to benefit. He was a man who was not able to get butter either before the Butter Bill was introduced or after it was introduced. I have been in some of these houses and I have seen the children of those families and have seen how they are unable to get milk. If we are going to carry out the resolution of Cumann na nGaedheal in reference to the health of our future citizens, it is very important that we should look after this matter, even though the Cumann na nGaedheal Party did not.

Comment on this

I am not interested in what the Cumann na nGaedheal Party is doing or about to do, but I want to ask the Minister a question. Is it not the fact that necessitous school children have been supplied with milk under previous Budgets?

Comment on this

Not everywhere, I believe.

Comment on this

I know that in the City of Cork, which I represent, and in Dublin also, I am informed by Deputy Professor Alton, who represents the constituency of Dublin University, that milk is supplied to necessitous children. There is no use in the Minister taking credit for things done already.

Comment on this

It is supplied by the municipalities in some cases, but not all over the country.

Comment on this

With all due respect, we are doing it in Cork City by local effort, and there is no use in this Government taking credit for what we are doing for ourselves in Cork, and for what has been already done in Dublin.

Comment on this

Deputy Anthony has not informed the House that the state is recouping Cork for half the expenditure in respect of meals for school children. Therefore the State should get at least as much credit as Cork.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

What Deputy Anthony says is true about necessitous school children receiving milk while they are going to school, but it is not given to them during holiday time, and it is not given to infants. It is the infants whom we want to benefit in particular. Even though Deputy Anthony may not be altogether too favourably inclined towards giving us any little credit that is due to us, he will have to give us that credit anyhow.

Comment on this

Certainly. I should like to inform the Minister that already those infants are provided for in Cork City through the medium of the Child Welfare League.

Comment on this

That is true. The Child Welfare League is doing very good work in that connection, but they cannot cover the whole country. On this question of unemployment we have tried to provide a certain amount of money to relieve unemployment by giving work in house building, road making, drainage and so on—giving work to people in a temporary capacity while our tariffs will be bearing fruit in the way of getting factories started. We hope to succeed in getting a considerable number of factories started in the country, but while we are trying to get these factories going the Cumann na nGaedheal Party are warning those particular people who may come to start factories here that if they do they will be coming to a bankrupt country.

I have already said here that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party would not, of course, vote against us on the expenditure side of this Budget, because they would not like to go back to their constituents and say that they had voted against the making of roads, the building of houses, and so on. It is all very well for them, however, to vote against every increase in taxation. It is not a very nice position for them to be in, but it is not a bit surprising. I took up the proceedings of the 4th May, and I find that if you analyse the votes that were given on that occasion you will see that the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies come in for some things and go out for others. Take the case, for instance, of agricultural machinery. I find that my own colleagues, Deputy Esmonde and Deputy Keating, did not like to face the town of Wexford and say that they had voted against employment there, and so they did not vote at all. But when it came to a vote on the wearing apparel tariff, they came back. Deputy J.J. Byrne and Deputy Doherty and others interested walked out and did not vote. Deputy Anthony went over at that time with the majority. And when we had a vote later on on the Butter Bill we had all those Deputies who are interested in the creameries counties coming to our side. Deputy Cosgrave told us on the Second Reading that his Government had considered this Bill six months ago and had thrown it out. It was a rotten Bill six months ago, yet some of his own followers who represented the creameries counties voted for it, and Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Lynch, who represented a creamery county, did not like to vote with us, so they walked out. Deputy Hogan, who was Minister for Agriculture, also went out and did not vote at all, though he was very prominently identified in the rejection of this measure six months ago. Three ex-Ministers who helped Deputy Cosgrave six months ago to set this Bill aside had not the courage to face their constituents and say that they had voted against it. But when there was a vote taken on a clause of the Oath Bill they were united upon that. Deputy J.J. Byrne, Deputy O'Sullivan, Deputy Lynch, Deputy Hogan and all of them came back for that and voted against the Oath Bill. They were unanimous in voting to impose a test on the Irish people. That is all I have got to say on the Budget for the present. I quite realise that in the case of a measure like this we shall have the unanimous vote of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party against us.

They can all say different things. One will say that he is voting against it because the income tax is too high. Deputies representing places like Merrion Square, Rathmines, or places like that will put that argument forward. Another Deputy will say he is voting against it because it is too hard on the small farmer. Another will vote against the Budget because, like Deputy Shaw, he considers it is going to kill racing. They all have some excuse for voting against the Budget. An omnibus resolution like this is the best possible thing for Cumann na nGaedheal, because they will be united in voting against it. Where you have individual items such as agricultural machinery, wearing apparel, or something like that, we are likely enough to have some of them not inclined to vote against, and they will go out. Anyway, we will always get a good majority, but there are certainly some Deputies who will not vote against some proposals. It would save more time if the Cumann na nGaedheal Party would hold meetings frequently. Then they could come to some conclusion on matters like this; they could all be agreed on one thing, and we here would be in a better position to answer their arguments.

Comment on this