Finance (Customs Duties) (No. 2) Bill, 1932—Second Stage.
Contributions 102–244 of 244. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1932 ›
I do not want to have them all centred in Dublin. I do not care what the opinion of the Mayor of Wexford may be. I stand as much for national development as the Mayor of Wexford. He has no practical experience of the matter. If he has anything to say on the subject, I challenge him to refute any of my statements.
Comment on this
It is easy enough to do that. For instance, the Deputy spoke about sixty firms being engaged in the manufacture of agricultural machinery. The Deputy knows nothing about it.
Comment on this
I obtained that information from publications issued by the Department of Statistics, a most reliable body, and I am prepared to stand by those figures. Suppose there were only twenty firms engaged in the manufacture, does the Deputy think that these twenty firms, split up, can ever produce economically? Can they buy raw material at a proper price or supply plant and machinery to enable farmers to produce their stuff economically and reduce overhead charges? We have heard practical farmers point out the faults there are in certain kinds of machinery supplied in connection with the agricultural industry. If you think that by stabilising twenty or thirty small units for the purpose of producing agricultural machinery you are going to increase employment, then I can say I never heard a more fallacious argument expounded by any Minister for Industry and Commerce.
What is the object of levying this tariff at all? I believe the only thing that lies behind the Minister's mind is not the industrialisation of this State but the building up of fragments of cottage industries that will be no national asset. If he wants to build up cottage industries, let him tell us so plainly. He should not tell us that by building up cottage industries he is going to solve the unemployment problem. If the Minister deals with this matter in a fair way we are ready to help. We are anxious to see unemployment relieved through the medium of tariffs. If the Minister introduces any tariffs in connection with which he can show a national gain we are ready to stand behind him. When the Minister introduces tariffs of a nature that will be more productive of unemployment than tending to cure unemployment it is our duty to tell the country what he is doing and to explain the repercussions that will follow. Did the Minister ever approach brush manufacturers in regard to this tariff? The Minister does not answer. Does he think he knows more about the industry than those engaged in it?
Comment on this
The late Government put a tariff on brushes by a mistake. Did they approach the brush manufacturers?
Comment on this
The tariff the late Government put on brushes has been approved by those engaged in the trade.
Comment on this
Did the Minister ever approach anybody engaged in the brush industry? I happen to have some knowledge about that industry. The biggest man engaged in the trade in this country informed me that he found himself totally unprepared for the imposition of a tariff; that he would need new machinery; that obtaining it would occupy a considerable space of time and until he was in a position to instal that machinery he saw no hope of coping with the increased trade Irish manufacturers would expect by reason of the tariff. Would it hurt the Minister to consult the industry? Is it the policy to impose tariffs whether those engaged in the industry want them or not? The men concerned with the industry know more about it than the Minister, who probably knew nothing at all about it until he took up office. Surely he is not better qualified to judge than people engaged in the industry? The Minister has made a very serious error if he has not approached these people.
Has he approached those engaged in the spade and shovel industry in order to see what effect the tariff will have? Has he asked them will it improve the industry or give increased employment? Is the Minister really a law unto himself? Does he consider that he has the superhuman intellect which is capable of dominating the intellects of those engaged in the trade? If the Minister acts in these matters regardless of the interests of the industry, I do not know how these seven Deputies opposite can continue to keep the present Government in office. I agree with Deputy Norton that numbers of these small industrial units scattered throughout the country would not be an asset to the State. If you are to set up industry, set it up on an economic basis or not at all. Has the Minister any hope of an export trade in agricultural machinery or in spades and shovels?
In the imposition of any tariffs there are two objects to be attained. I may say, in passing, that I am as unmoved by the cynical smile of the Minister as by his silence. I have referred to the two objects of a tariff. One is to give the home manufacturer the home market. With what object? With the object of building up an export trade. Then there is the tariff on margarine. It was imposed under a guarantee given by the margarine manufacturers that the price would not be increased and that margarine would be sold at the same price as in England. What has been the result? The result has been that where we used to have £100,000 worth coming in we now have only £2,000 worth and we are exporting annually several thousand pounds' worth of margarine. That is the ideal effect of a tariff. Can there be any such hope in regard to agricultural machinery or spades and shovels?
Until industry is organised, whether by State organisation or organisation undertaken by the workers and by employers, there can be no industrial progress. Where you have scattered units manufacturing agricultural machinery or spades and shovels, and these units cannot produce economically, how can you hope to have unemployment relieved? I have observed that those in the spade and shovel industry have not availed of the tariff. Those who own the principal factory in Dublin have, if Press reports be true, declined to restart the industry. In this connection I may say that a meeting was held in the Mansion House the other day and the Lord Mayor gave a cheque for £50 for the purpose of restarting that industry. Let me add that the leader of the industry is Mr. James Larkin. Does anybody think that the spade and shovel industry can prosper under the management of James Larkin?
Comment on this
He did know it. The Lord Mayor is quite capable of looking after his own affairs.
Comment on this
Deputy Jordan does not know much about this business.
Comment on this
He gave the £50 with the object of restarting that industry. From what I can gather, Mr. James Larkin, trade union organiser, has the job in hands and he is going to resurrect the spade and shovel industry.
Comment on this
If the Minister thinks he is going to have the Saorstát industrialised under such a tariff system as that, then all I say is God help the Saorstát. I had some little respect for the business acumen of the Minister before he took up office. I thought he was a trained business man. When a trained business man tackles a job like this he goes about it in a business-like way. He consults the interests concerned, ascertains how the industry could be improved and manages to find out what is required. I asked him if he approached these industries to find out whether they wanted a tariff, but he gave no answer to the House. As regards the spade and shovel industry, Mr. James Larkin may be a very good man; I have no doubt he is an excellent trade union organiser and I have no doubt that he did a great deal for the working people in the City of Dublin. When he comes to take over the control of a technical industry of this kind, I can only term it an industrial anachronism. I can see no hope whatever for it.
If a tariff is imposed, surely the Minister has greater ambitions, so far as industrial development is concerned, than to fill the small quantum of orders that come from this State? Is that the policy in Denmark, in Belgium, or in any other country in the world? Is there any hope of building up an export trade in the case of tariffed industries under existing conditions? I agree with Deputy Norton when he says that industry in this country must be organised. The Minister is not bothering his head whether it is organised or disorganised. "I will give you a tariff," he says, and then he advises the people to do the rest themselves. Apparently the Minister has that turn of mind that makes him think the mere imposition of a tariff will mean that industries will grow up like mushrooms in the night.
I am sorry I have found it necessary to criticise tariffs in the manner in which I have criticised them to-day, but in the circumstances one is forced to criticise. This is the most hopeless economic policy that any Minister for Industry and Commerce could stand over. Let me tell Deputies one thing they may not know. The moment this tariff was imposed, certain people engaged in the distribution of spades and shovels wrote to four different firms in the country asking for quotations and when they could obtain delivery. That was four weeks ago and they have not received a reply yet.
The Minister for Industry and Commerce, a born optimist, thinks that by means of these tariffs he has solved the unemployment problem and that he is going to create a new heaven and a new earth in this little country. I wonder how it was that the Danes, whose country is an agricultural country like ours, could, by the scientific imposition of tariffs, build up an industry that dealt with not alone the needs of the home market but with an export market. If the Minister would only deal with industrial problems on economic lines, on sound logical lines, he would not find the severe opposition to his plans that he finds in this House. When we are confronted with plans that can only be termed the height of insanity, it is our duty, as representing the constituents who sent us here in the national interests, to offer the most determined opposition to the passage of these tariffs. We do not offer this opposition purely for opposition motives, but in the national interests.
It has been pointed out already by Deputy McGilligan that we are starting on a policy that other countries have tried and have found to end in nothing but hopeless failure. Deputy McGilligan referred to Australia. Australia followed precisely the same lines that the Minister is following to-day. Everything was tariffed, the rate of wages went up and new industries sprang up everywhere, but none of them was economic and they could not endure. As Deputy Norton has properly remarked, when you set up industries on an uneconomic basis and under a tariff system you must always keep them tariffed or they will collapse. That is the position in France to-day. Does the Minister know that the French tariff system has become so strong that if the tariffs were removed the whole industrial organisation in France would crumble into pieces? We are not criticising these tariffs in any hostile or unfriendly spirit, but in an endeavour to turn them into some service so far as national upliftment and the industrialisation of the State are concerned.
I want to remind the Minister that when we handed over the reins of office to the new Government they had a country in apple-pie order; its institutions were thoroughly working; its credit was sound and its financial stability second to none in Europe. What is happening to-day? Do you think that if the present policy of indiscriminate tariffs is persisted in that the financial stability is going to be maintained? Do you think that this £1,000,000, that is going to be raised by tariffs, is going to improve the staple industry of this country? Do you think that the agriculturists of this country are in a condition to bear this extra £1,000,000 that this tariff will impose on them, because they will have to bear the bulk of it? Superphosphates, boots, agricultural machinery, spades and shovels, corrugated iron—there is scarcely a thing required by the farmer that the Minister has not placed a tariff upon, and we want to warn the Minister that exactly what happened in Australia will happen here. We have this interest in it that we handed over a thoroughly sound State, whose financial stability was above and beyond reproach, and we are just as anxious, although not in office, to have that financial stability maintained, as if we were responsible for guiding the destinies of this country, for which those on the opposite benches now have responsibility.
Is it the aim to bring this country to the position occupied by Australia? Australia has to pay in interest alone £35,000,000 per annum. The income of this State for one year is more than the whole national debt, and we want that financial stability maintained, and we want to impress on the Minister that the policy he is now embarking on can only end in unmitigated disaster, and we ask him, honestly and conscientiously, carefully to consider the effects of these tariffs he is now imposing. They cannot cure the problem of unemployment. If they could, the Opposition here would be very small indeed, and the Minister, instead of opposition, would have a party only too willing to go every way and any way they could to help him. If you impose tariffs wisely they can be productive of great national good, but if you impose tariffs unwisely, if you impose them indiscriminately as you are now imposing them, they can be productive of nothing but national disaster and national instability, and without financial stability in any country, you cannot have industrial progress. I want to say this, that in criticising these tariffs, we do so in no spirit of opposition, and from no desire to delay the business of the House, but from a clear wish to prevent anything being done that may injure the present financial stability we now enjoy, and that may injure the future industrialisation of this country, for which we are just as anxious as those who sit on the Government Benches.
Comment on this
It is somewhat difficult to know where it is best to begin to disentangle the web of misleading and frequently irrelevant arguments created by Deputies opposite during the course of the day's debate. Deputy McGilligan, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, Deputy O'Sullivan and others, compared the policy of the present Government, in the matter of tariffs, with the policy of the late administration, and Deputy McGilligan alleged that we had imposed all these tariffs without proper examination, whereas the late Government had always given every application for protection very lengthy consideration, and had only acceded to it after every possible repercussion had been foreseen.
I think it was Carlyle or Spenser or Deputy Hugo Flinn, or some other person of that kind, who once said that the greatest trouble in life was a theory killed by a fact, and I am afraid that quite a number of theories are going to be killed by facts in the next five minutes. This theory about the great care with which the late Government imposed tariffs, the lengthy examination and the careful estimation of possible consequences, will not stand five minutes' examination, in the light of our knowledge of what did actually happen. I will concede, at once, that they gave lengthy examination to every application. Deputies know that. In the year 1926, we had a more or less flourishing coachbuilding industry, employing from 600 to 700 skilled workers. It applied for a protective tariff, and a very lengthy examination was given to the application.
They examined it all through 1926 and all through the years 1927, 1928 and 1929, and, in 1930, they thought they could arrive at a decision. They arrived at a decision in that year, but the industry had since disappeared. In 1926, the readymade clothing manufacturers applied for protection, and, again, a very lengthy examination was given to the application, and every possible repercussion that was likely to follow from the imposition of a duty, was, we are told, carefully estimated and safeguarded against, and then, they put a duty on wearing apparel, and, as a result of that duty, they actually collected revenue on carnival caps imported in paper crackers, as wearing apparel. They collected revenue off a diver's suit on the ground that it was wearing apparel, and off boxing gloves and cricket pads on the ground that they were wearing apparel. After two years' examination, they could not possibly make a mistake, and so we must assume that these omnipotent and omniscient people on the opposite benches regarded divers' suits, carnival caps and boxing gloves as wearing apparel, to be brought under the general wearing apparel duty.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister a question on that? Is it not true that under that policy there was a gross output of £695,000, and that employment rose from something like 1,000 odd to 2,600?
Comment on this
I am not questioning the wisdom of taxing wearing apparel, but I am demonstrating to the Deputy that the two years' examination which the late Government, and its Tariff Commission, gave to the application in that respect, no more prevented them making minor mistakes of that kind than we have made in some of the duties we have imposed. Deputy McGilligan was very clever and very witty, an hour or so ago, when talking about further modifications that are to be made on the Committee Stage of the Bill. The modifications we are going to make, then, are designed to clear up the mess created by some of the tariffs imposed by the late Government, including the mess created by that tariff on wearing apparel to which I referred.
We have made mistakes. We have imposed over sixty duties in three months. It was not possible to give these precise and detailed examination, and foresee every possible consequence of each. It was not possible to get the draftsman to prepare a resolution for submission to the Dáil, and satisfy ourselves, in advance, that that resolution was only going to include in its scope exactly the things we wanted it to include. We have put on these duties. We had to proceed by a system of trial and error, if you like, but we have the duties there, and when people came to us and made representations for modifications of these duties, for their extension, or for the elimination of particular articles, we have made those modifications, those extensions and those eliminations, but we have a protective system created. We have told here before that we put these tariffs into operation without examination. My answer to that is that the late Government kept them off without examination, and, as a result of their keeping them off without examination, they left us the problem of 80,000 unemployed, and they put 300,000 of our people to America in ten years. I prefer to take the risk of making mistakes in proceeding in the way we are proceeding, rather than to take the risk——
Comment on this
——of producing the same results that the late Government produced by its inactivity. I was approached by the brush trade, and if the Deputy has any doubts as to the attitude of the trade to that duty, let him ask them if they want it.
Comment on this
Do they want it? We have been told also that the duties which were put on by Provisional Order should not have been put on by Provisional Order and that the Act passed by the late Government was never intended to be used to prevent dumping. Why was the Act passed? It was passed to give the Government power to deal with an abnormal situation, and an abnormal situation was created on the day that this Government came into office with an avowedly protectionist policy, and with three or four weeks to wait for the Budget. Every importer in the country endeavoured to forestall that Budget by bringing in abnormal quantities of various classes of goods. A number got away with it. Very abnormal importations did take place, and, as a result, there are people unemployed in this country to-day who need not be unemployed. There are stocks of boots, stocks of readymade clothing and woollen clothing, and stocks of every class of commodity here now, and it is not until these stocks are cleared, that the effects of these tariffs will be experienced by Irish industrialists and employment given to Irish workers in the manufacture of these goods.
If Deputy McGilligan or any other Deputy wants any proof that these abnormal importations took place the proof is available for him if he is not too lazy to look for it. We print and circulate to Deputies every month a copy of the Trade and Shipping Statistics, and Deputies will find in those statistics, for the first three months of this year, adequate proof that such abnormal importations were taking place. Deputy McGilligan alleged that we should have stopped the importation of these goods—that we should have ascertained in advance that abnormal importations were about to take place, and should have stopped the importations before they arrived. We could not do so. We had no power to stop the importation of goods, but we had power at any time to put an emergency duty into operation. We exercised that power, but even when we exercised that power it took at least three days from the decision to do so to the bringing of the duty into actual operation. The machinery to which Deputy McGilligan referred was utilised in full, but we put these duties on by emergency order to prevent abnormal importations. We were sometimes too late to achieve that purpose, but we did succeed in stopping some part of the abnormal influx of goods that was taking place prior to the introduction of the Budget.
We got a whole lot of half-baked economic theory from Deputy McGilligan to-day that I do not think worth dealing with. Prices, he told us, always go up by the full amount of a tariff and sometimes by a little more. If Deputy McGilligan, Deputy O'Sullivan, Deputy J.J. Byrne or any Deputy opposite would try to judge these matters in the light of his own experience and not in the light of some theory which he has dug up from the text books of English economists he will begin to understand things much better. In fact, did the price of any commodity which they subjected to a duty, while they held office, increase by the full amount of the tariff and a little more?
Comment on this
I know why he chose that. Certain duties are imposed to protect trade habits—to get for Irish industries a trade which, because of actions extending over a number of years, was going to English factories. Certain duties are imposed to prevent dumping, to deal with price-cutting and other trade devices of that kind. Let us be quite clear about this. Certain duties are imposed for no other reason than to put up prices, and the late Government imposed duties for that purpose. The duty upon butter was one and the duty on oats was another. I approve of them, I am not criticising them for having done so. I think they did right. My only criticism in respect of these duties is that they acted too late. But they succeeded in putting up the price available to the Irish farmer for his produce and that was a very good thing under the circumstances.
Comment on this
I stated specifically that the tariff on butter put up the price of butter to the full amount of the tariff. Am I right?
Comment on this
Did not the Minister state the exact opposite in his speech?
Comment on this
I did not. I did say this: that the argument put forward here, that the imposition of a tariff always results in prices being increased by the full amount of the tariff and a little more, does not hold water in the light of the experience of the late Government in respect of the tariffs they imposed. The tariffs on butter and oats, and other agricultural duties of that kind, where there is an export surplus and unusual conditions, were imposed for the express purpose of raising prices and would have failed in their purpose if they did not raise prices. I am talking about industrial tariffs now, the tariffs on boots, furniture, clothing, oatmeal, margarine, and any of the other tariffs. Did not prices go down instead of going up?
Comment on this
The Minister asked one question which I answered. May I ask another question of the Minister and ask for a definite answer? Am I right in stating that the reason the price of butter went up to the full amount of the tariff was because there was a shortage of butter produced in the country? Is that the reason? Answer, yes or no.
Comment on this
The price of butter did not go up to the full amount of the tariff except for a short period of the year.
Comment on this
I already told the Deputy that I criticised the action of the late Government on the ground that they put on the tariff too late.
Comment on this
I ask for a definite answer to my question, as I answered yours. I am talking of that short period. Am I right in stating that the reason the price of butter went up to the full amount of the tariff during that short period was that the production at home was not equal to the demand at home?
Comment on this
Does not that apply to practically every industrial tariff?
Comment on this
Does it not apply to boots, agricultural machinery, furniture, and to every tariff which you are imposing?
Comment on this
It does not. That is a fact. The Deputy is running his head against a fact and he will get hurt. It is a fact that it does not, an easily demonstrable fact. The Deputy can get a range of prices from any of the firms.
Comment on this
I am not on prices. Does not exactly the same consideration, if there is a shortage of home production, apply to practically all the goods which you are protecting under the tariff?
Comment on this
Some days ago we had these duties under discussion when the resolutions were before us, and Deputies will remember how Deputy Hogan, Deputy J.J. Byrne, Deputy Blythe and other Deputies, said that this duty on agricultural machinery was going to send up prices.
Comment on this
On the next day an advertisement appeared in the daily Press announcing a reduction of prices. Now we have Deputy McGilligan trying to explain that that reduction was due to a fall in the price of certain raw materials, and other causes not associated with the tariff. The fact is that the prices went down. We had Deputies telling us that if we put a duty on maize meal the price would go up. The price of maize meal has come down. Again we have had Deputies trying to explain that that was due to a fall in the price of maize, and other causes not associated with the tariff. As prophets they were proved to be duds. We put a duty on soap and the price has not gone up. The Blackrock Hosiery Company has issued a price list reducing the price of its regular lines of hosiery. The price of furniture has gone down. In respect of quite a number of industries subject to duties by this Bill and the Customs resolutions contained in the Budget, there has been a downward trend in prices.
Comment on this
It has happened. Again, the Deputy is taking the very foolish course of running his theories up against facts, and they cannot possibly survive.
Comment on this
I wish to refer to a tariff not put on by the present Government but the late Government. Is the Minister aware that the retail price of flaked meal in the City of Dublin is 3s. 4d. a stone while the English meal can be bought here for 3s.?
Comment on this
That is oatmeal. There is a special situation existing at present in relation to oatmeal, in so far as there is a temporary shortage of Irish oats, and oats have to be imported by the millers and a duty has to be paid on these oats which was imposed by the late administration. That is a purely temporary situation. In fact, the duty imposed on oatmeal by the late Government was so successful that for a number of years the oatmeal producers in this country were building up and maintaining a very substantial export trade.
Comment on this
I am only speaking of the effect on the consumers of oatmeal when they have to pay 4d. per stone more than for the English oatmeal.
Comment on this
Following the imposition of the duty, and for a number of years, they were paying less than the English, because of the fact that there was an export of oatmeal to Great Britain from Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
Why not wait for three months until we know whether prices have gone up or not?
Comment on this
I can assure the Deputy that it is not at my volition that this debate is still continuing at 8:10 p.m. We had Deputy McGilligan telling us that this country must be a paradise for dumpers, if the statements made from this side of the House were correct. It has been a paradise for dumpers. Not merely is that correct, but in relation to a number of commodities the prices prevailing here were lower than world prices. It has been a paradise for dumpers in the precise meaning of the words. There are a number of classes of goods in respect of which this was the only free market in the world, and the surplus products of European factories were sent here at any price they could fetch. It is true in relation to cement, paper, and quite a number of goods, that this was the only free market in Europe where surplus production could be disposed of.
Comment on this
Was there any case where there was a free market here where the article was preventing employment here? Take cement. Was it not entirely to the good?
Comment on this
I can see that, although it did create special difficulties in the way of getting a cement industry going here, difficulties which I think we have now succeeded in getting over. It did produce employment in relation to paper, and to other things, but there is no good going into details of these. The fact is that Deputy McGilligan and Deputy O'Sullivan, at meetings of the League of Nations and other conferences at Geneva, were in a position to boast that this country was much less protected than most other countries. Deputy McGilligan now contemplates with horror what he calls the unfavourable comments to be made about us in consequence of our decision to protect our industries. We shall risk that. I think we can afford to risk it, if we are going to get tangible results here from the imposition of these duties.
I do not want to spend any considerable length of time discussing general matters, but I want to deal with some specific points raised. I do not think I can pass over one statement made by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, who says that the number of unemployed is rapidly increasing. The Deputy, and other Deputies opposite, know quite well that the number of registered unemployed is no index of the extent of the unemployment problem. When the number of registered unemployed was 20,000 there was other evidence to show that the actual number of the workless was in or about 80,000. The late Government, whether by accident or design, kept down the number of registered unemployed until it had no significance. There are counties in the Free State in which there are only two labour exchanges, and for the great majority of our workers labour exchanges had no significance. They never went near them and they never got employment through them. Registration in the labour exchanges was of no benefit to them. It was a mere useless expenditure of energy. When employment was given out of public funds voted here for relief purposes, the workers were selected through the instrumentality of Cumann na nGaedheal members of county councils and the like. We have decided to end that. We have announced publicly that every man who is going to be employed in consequence of the relief expenditure decided upon is going to be employed through the labour exchanges. We have announced that the allocation of that money, as between one county and another, will depend on the number of registered unemployed. We have decided to give increased facilities for registration, and a person can now register through the local post office or civic guard station. We want to get the name of every unemployed person on to the books of the labour exchanges. It is because of these increased facilities, these announcements, and that policy, that the number of registered unemployed is going up. It has not yet gone up to the maximum. It is now 35,000. We think that the correct number must be in or about 70,000. Our design and hope is to make the number of registered unemployed a real index of the extent of the unemployment problem.
Comment on this
May I ask how soon the Minister expects he will have a system in force by which he can tell what he considers the true number of unemployed?
Comment on this
It is in force now. In the last week it came into force. Facilities for registration through the post office and civic guard barracks are now there and, in all the local papers of the country, that fact was advertised in recent weeks, and within the next week or so we hope that we will get on the books of the labour exchange the majority of those who are available for employment.
Comment on this
Do I understand that within the next few weeks the Minister expects to know what is the real amount of unemployment?
Comment on this
We are likely to get a figure which will be of very definite value, but it will include a number of small farmers who although available for employment might not be properly describable as unemployed. However. we will get, as a result of the increased facilities, the Press announcements and this policy which we have decided upon, a figure in relation to the registered unemployed which will have some significance. The present figure has no significance.
Comment on this
Might I ask a further question arising out of that? Is the Minister in principle prepared to regard his tariff policy as experimental to this extent, that if, in a year's time it shall be seen that it has not succeeded on the side of employment, he will be prepared to drop the whole thing?
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy considers by the word "succeeded." In a period like the present, a period of world depression, a period in which industries which were established for hundreds of years are going down in every country in the world, it might be considered success merely to hold our own. I am hoping for more than that, but in relation to some industries, in relation to railways, for instance, it will be a considerable success to save them from extinction much less to restore anything like the prosperity which they enjoyed in former days.
Comment on this
The Minister will at any rate say this, that he will maintain an open mind, that he does not wish to brush up against facts, that he will maintain an open mind to the extent that he is not bound to the economic theory of protection?
Comment on this
That is so. But you can take it that the disposition is in favour of protection. Where that protection is not producing the desired results or where a case is made for the modification or removal of a tariff, the tariff will be modified or removed but not until the case is made for it. In other words, we have reversed the policy of the late Government. The policy of the late Government was free trade unless they were coerced by public opinion to put on tariffs. In our case, protection is given unless facts coerce us to modify them in some particular way.
Comment on this
Might I ask does the Minister believe that as a result of the instructions recently issued he will be in a position in the near future to state definitely the number of unemployed in the country?
Comment on this
I should not like to answer in the affirmative. We are trying, as I said, to get on the register every person available for employment, but that will include people who might not be properly describable as unemployed, such as small farmers, in the West particularly, who are always available for relief work on roads and otherwise. We will have a figure which will be a very definite figure, and on the basis of that figure the allocation of grants will proceed.
Comment on this
I agree that it is almost impossible to get the true figure, but does the Minister believe that as a result of the instructions which he has issued, in which I hope the trade unions will co-operate, that it will be possible to get an approximate idea of the amount of unemployment?
Comment on this
It has got to take place fairly soon. In order to speed up the work we inserted advertisements in the local Press last week and have approached trade union officials to assist. We want to ensure that the relief money available will be fairly allocated in relation to the degree of unemployment in particular counties and the sooner we get the division of that money decided the better we will be pleased.
Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney made a reference to the discussion we had on the adjournment last Friday and he said in view of the extraordinary discrimination which the Government were displaying he could not see how anybody, particularly anybody not a native of this State, would invest his money in an Irish enterprise. I rather thought we would have such a statement made in consequence of an article which appeared in the "Independent" last Friday morning. I made a note of the approaches which were made to my Department between 2.30 last Friday and this morning. During that period twelve foreign firms, Northern Ireland, British or other firms, approached my Department to ensure that they would have approval in the establishment of factories here. Some of them got approval, some of them did not, but that fact alone knocks the bottom out of the very foolish contention which has been made here by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney.
I agree with those Deputies, including Deputy Norton, who said a tariff alone will not produce industrial development. Nobody ever argued that point of view on these benches, but the imposition of these tariffs, affording to our weak, infant industries protection from their long-established and more highly capitalised rivals, is only the first step. There must be behind that better industrialisation and a continuous drive. There must be available financial assistance and Government assistance of one kind or another. It is only by a combination of these things that we hope to achieve the position which we desire, namely the development of Irish industry, financed by Irish capital and under Irish control. We are not opposed to external companies operating external firms engaged in industrial enterprise in this country wherever there is room for them. What we are opposed to and the one thing we are determined to prevent, wherever we can, is the domination of a particular industry by a foreign combine or by external firms. That situation if it arose in relation to any industry here is bound to lead to disaster. Deputies have seen in the Press in the past few days an announcement that the price of soap has been reduced by 1d. per lb. There has been no fall in the raw material to justify that reduction.
Comment on this
It has been reduced because the combine operating in both countries is anxious to smash its trade rivals. In this drive it is trying to smash Irish firms as well.
Comment on this
No, that reduction in the price of soap was decided upon by trade jealousy in the soap industry, but the net consequence is likely to be the disappearance of a couple of Irish-owned factories. They have been disappearing and they are going to have a very hard struggle to carry on until the policy of the combine is changed. That situation in any industry is going to lead to uncertainty and the refusal of Irish industrialists to risk their money if they feel, that after putting their money into industry in this country, some foreign combine can come in and cut the market from under them. They prefer to keep their money and it would be much wiser to keep their money unless we can secure protection from the foreign combine at home. We intend to secure the development of Irish industry by Irish capital under Irish control.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton referred to the unwisdom of proceeding with a policy designed to create small and weak industries here and there. The terms "small" and "weak" are only relative terms. In view of the size of our market any industrial organisation which we have here must be relatively small and weak in comparison to the industrial organisations we have elsewhere, with a few outstanding exceptions. We can ensure, however, that these organisations can be intrinsically sound, and even though it may not be possible for them to hold their own when competing with highly capitalised competitors we can ensure that they can produce at an economic price and so tend to decentralise industry. We stand as Deputies have mentioned for the decentralisation of industry. We have not power to compel it. We do not propose to take power to compel it, but we do endeavour on every occasion, wherever it is feasible and practical, to get industries established in country towns or in any place where there are special facilities which make it a matter for consideration and where these special facilities offset other facilities that are available to industries starting in Dublin which, of course, is the centre of distribution for the country.
To get down to some of the specific points that have been raised, Deputy Blythe referred to the matter of farmers' carts crossing the Border. I have considerable sympathy with his proposal if it were feasible, but I am not at all convinced that it is feasible. There is, I understand, quite a considerable importation of these carts from Scotland. I will have the matter examined, but I think we could not deal with the question of the Border in the way he suggests. I will have the matter examined, and if my information is not correct or if the importation of carts is only to an insignificant extent we can meet the matter possibly in the way he suggests. In any circumstances the Border is and must always remain a curse. No amount of modification in protective duties can turn that curse into a blessing. The only way we can get rid of the Border is by abolishing the Border.
Comment on this
Many people believe that by making a slight modification in the Tariff Bill it will obviate a considerable amount of trouble to people on the Border without seriously affecting the tariff itself.
Comment on this
We shall see what can be done, but if there is any substantial importation of these articles the duty will have to be collected and the difficulties met by customs regulations of one kind or another. Deputy Dillon also referred to the duty we have imposed on agricultural machinery and drew attention to the list of exemptions mentioned in the Bill, and said that the Irish agricultural machinery manufacturers must be only assemblers of parts and not manufacturers. That is altogether incorrect. The list of exemptions in the majority of cases, and particularly the exemption of parts under 5/- in value, is designed to meet the difficulty created by the fact that there is a number of farmers in the country who are using foreign machinery and who require these parts for replacements for some years to come. Some of the exemptions were decided upon despite the fact that the agricultural machinery manufacturers would prefer that the exemptions were not there. Deputy Dillon talked about an Indian meal ring. I do not know of any part of the country, with one exception, where the price of maize meal is not reduced to the minimum by very intensive competition. That is certainly the case in Donegal. In any area where that competition does not prevail the price of maize meal is higher than it is elsewhere, as in the Limerick area, but I take it Deputy Dillon has not referred to that. In Donegal there is effective competition and that competition regulates prices.
Deputy Anthony mentioned the possible effects of the imposition of these duties upon commercial travellers. Undoubtedly, there are a number of people who are engaged in the distribution of imported goods who are going to have their particular livelihood taken from them. But goods are still going to be distributed and the importation of foreign goods will only diminish as the manufacture of Irish goods increases. In so far as goods must be distributed it is our hope and belief that these people will be absorbed by Irish firms. We are trying to facilitate that. We have a list of commercial travellers who represented outside firms and we will bring that to the notice of firms in the same lines with a view to getting a preference for these people in any additional employment of a similar kind that they may be undertaking. We are, generally, trying to ease the position for these people and to reduce to a minimum any hardships that may result from the change of policy. The Deputy referred, particularly, to duty on sugar confectionery and cocoa preparations. There has been, as regards the cheaper lines of these goods, not merely competition, but cutthroat competition in the past. The old duty of 4d. per lb. was, in fact, a prohibition as far as the cheaper lines were concerned, and the force of competition between concerns operating here brought down the price of sugar confectionery until there was no concern selling at a profit. I think that the Department of Industry and Commerce under the late administration stepped in to try to get an arrangement between the firms to increase their price by agreement so as to ensure that some economic return would be available. There is capacity in this country to produce confectionery for about the half of Europe. As regards the higher end of the business our people are only going into it now, but there is no reason why all the requirements of the country cannot be met. It is true that by very intensive and very effective advertising certain brands of confectionery have held the public taste, but, possibly, within a few months under the new conditions that will be broken and people will begin to realise that confectionery just as good and a lot cheaper is available from Irish factories.
Comment on this
Has the Minister received any representations from the firms to which I alluded regarding facilities for the erection of factories in this State?
Comment on this
Certain applications in that respect have been received, and are under examination. Deputy McGilligan referred to the duty on motor bodies and said it has been imposed despite the report of the Tariff Commission, which said that bodies for private motors could not be built here. Again a beautiful theory is knocked on the head by facts. Bodies are going to be built here. We are told that the duty on footwear was imposed despite the fact that lower grade ladies' shoes were not being, and probably would not be, produced here. They are going to be produced in this country. The increased duty on footwear has resulted in the establishment of two factories already at Drogheda, and two additional ones are about to be opened. One factory in Drogheda will be engaged entirely on the production of children's footwear and the two other factories will be engaged on cheap grade ladies' footwear.
Comment on this
I would like to know from the Minister whether under paragraph 4 of the Schedule, the preferential rate will be ten per cent.
Comment on this
There is possibly a printing error there. The intention was that the preferential rate should be fifteen per cent. I will have the matter looked into.
Comment on this
We have been told that certain classes of woollen cloth will not be made here. When the Resolution was under discussion I mentioned that I was about to discuss with the Association of Irish Woollen Manufacturers the extent to which they would be able to meet the requirements of the ready-made clothing trade this year. I met woollen manufacturers, and every mill in this country will be engaged this year, and will have available for the trade this autumn, cheap grade cloths from 1/10 per sq. yard—2/8 per trade yard. The bulk of what is required is, I think, about 3/6 per trade yard. All the requirements of the industry in respect of cloths will be procurable from Irish factories and, in addition, cloth down as far as 2/8 per trade yard will be available.
Comment on this
Yes. It will be woollen cloth and will not contain any cotton. It will be made in part, or to a considerable extent, from reclaimed wool. We went carefully into the question of cotton mixtures, and the woollen manufacturers are opposed to the idea—I must say that there is a great deal in their contention—that they should engage in the manufacture of cotton mixtures of any kind. All wool cloth will be available at 1/10½ per square yard, up to 2/6 and 2/8, suitable for the requirements of the ready-made clothing trade, and the resulting article will be much more satisfactory from the point of view of the purchaser. It is true that there are imported into this country much cheaper grades of cloth, sometimes at 1/- per yard or thereabouts. If it consists of cotton it is free of duty. If there is wool mixed with it it becomes subject to duty. The difference that the payment of duty would have on the price of a suit would be only about 4d. or 6d. There will be available for the ready-made clothing manufacturers' Irish cloths in adequate quantities and with a considerable variety of patterns at the prices that they have been accustomed to pay.
Comment on this
Yes. We have discussed with the woollen manufacturers the question of the manufacture of yarns, and I hope they will be able to get a considerable production of yarns here in the future. We are quite satisfied that the requirements of the ready-made clothing industry in this country in woollen and worsted cloths, cheap grade, middle grade and high grade, will be available.
Comment on this
Lest there might be a false impression created by the Minister's speech in the minds of Deputies that these yarns are not imported, I say that they are.
Comment on this
Certain yarns are imported and, under present circumstances, must be imported; but for a great number of range of cloths yarn is spun here and will continue to be spun.
Comment on this
That is so. I am sorry if the Deputy understood the contrary. I do not think that there are any other points that I need refer to at this stage. Presumably, we will have these duties under discussion again when the Bill is going through Committee. I merely want to say that, in respect of every duty contained in this Bill, my expectations have been more than exceeded, and I believe if any wrong impressions that may now exist relating to the future are removed—the impressions which some people may have that changes may take place or that modifications in the duty may arise—development will be all the more rapid. So long as it is clear in the minds of manufacturers, importers, merchants, and consumers that these duties are there to stay, if that feeling of security is engendered, we are going to get considerably more development than we are getting in relation to other industries affected by the duties imposed in this Bill. I confidently recommend this Bill to the Dáil as one that has already justified itself in every particular.
Comment on this
Could the Minister give any figure regarding the estimate of the cost of production of motor bodies in comparison with ordinary cost of those imported?
Comment on this
It is anticipated that bodies will be available, when the tax which formerly had to be paid is taken into account, at a lower price than that at which they were heretofore available.
Comment on this
As was anticipated the fact that we have drawn the attention of particular firms to the market here, and that we have taken this action with regard to motor bodies, may possibly lead to the assembly of the bodies and the chassis as well.
Comment on this
I would not like to say definitely that I have seen the actual costings in relation to each type of body likely to be made here, but I have discussed with people more competent to give an opinion than I am— people actually about to engage in the manufacture—and they are satisfied that the difference in the cost of production here will be offset by the fact that there will be no tax payable.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister how he reconciles two statements he has made? A few minutes ago he said in answer to a question of mine that if his tariff policy proves a failure, if it raised the cost of living and did nothing much on balance for unemployment, he was prepared to bow to facts and reverse it. Is that not so?
Comment on this
Subsequently he said that it was essential that persons and firms starting or enlarging industries under the protection of tariffs should be assured that those tariffs would be permanent. How does he reconcile that with his earlier statement?
Comment on this
I have no objection to putting my money on one horse when there is only one horse in the race.
Comment on this
I have received from various sides of the House and from every Party representations for and against alteration in the rate of duty on second-hand clothing. I am having the matter examined. My inclination is against any remission concerning it, but I realise the strength of some of the arguments used by Deputy Murphy to-day. I hope, however, we will be able to get the position clarified before the Committee Stage, in which case we will have the matter discussed again and a definite decision arrived at.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?