We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1932—Committee (Resumed.)

Contributions 1–126 of 236. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 11 of 1932 ›

When we were dealing with this on Friday I was speaking on amendment 46: "To delete sub-section (4)." I want to press for this amendment. There is an amendment down later which changes the form in which the sub-section stands, but only in small points—changes it by, in fact, befogging the issue to some extent, because it pretends to take the responsibility off the Minister, as it is mentioned here, and put it on the Commissioners, which, in fact, it does not do. The only argument in favour of this was that certain people were likely to come in and establish packing machinery and indulge in packing in the Free State in a variety of commodities. It is pointed out that that is only to take place whenever two Ministers are satisfied that a person bona fide intends to establish in Saorstát Eireann equipment and facilities for packing and that then a licence may be given. I have answered that first of all if people are going to come in to institute packing facilities, the sooner they come in the better, and it would put a little extra pressure on them to come in if we delete the clause. If we keep this clause as it stands we will not put pressure on them.

With regard to the subsidiary pleas advanced in connection either with the sub-section as it stands or the amendment that is later to be proposed—the points that certain people coming into the country might lose their market, that the people might get on to some other product or give up the use of their article altogether and take to some substitute, Deputy Blythe queried what were the substitutes. Were they Free State or were they from outside? Because clearly if they were Free State it would not be the same to give facilities for an article not produced here as for a Saorstát substitute easily available. The point subsidiary again to that was that if packing facilities were not granted and if there was no Saorstát substitute, people might abandon the hope of taking or using whatever the substance is and consequently there would be a loss of trade. The Minister for Finance in connection with this amendment did say—and in so saying countered some of the arguments he has been making in other sections—that it would be wrong to put on the consumer the extra cost which would have to be increased by reason of the package tax. That is rather contradictory and contrary to what has been hitherto said by both the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce—that British manufacturers are always willing to bear the cost, to meet any sort of tariff, particularly in a position to meet them where they are very small. Apparently the Minister falls back on this particular item—that if you do not allow for the giving of licences and if people show themselves ready to bring in machinery, and if the bringing in of that machinery is going to be delayed that in the meantime the consumer will have to pay the extra cost. Evidently, the consumer will have to bear the cost. He is going to pay it in particular where there is no home product in competition. He is going to pay it where the home product, if produced here at all, is only produced in such a small quantity or in such small numbers that there will be very little or practically no internal competition, and in particular the consumer will pay no matter what point home production has reached where for a fraction of a penny requirements which are the only check they have upon prices are removed, and the only check upon prices is the height of the tariff. The tariff is kept at a relatively low point. It always has to be kept at a relatively low point in consideration that the value of the article produced should not go beyond the limit which the tariff can give. If a tariff is very high the consumer is at the mercy of those bringing in the particular article. The tariff is merely an application from a manufacturer to be allowed to increase his price on the consumers. I have pointed out that the granting of a licence is for that purpose, and when a trade had no competition from outside or inside then your prices were going to soar to whatever height will be allowed by the height that the tariff amounts to. As it says here: "Twopence if the weight of the package does not exceed two pounds, and in any other case one penny on every pound or fraction of a pound of the weight of the package or, if the content of the package does not exceed two pints, twopence, and in any other case one penny on every pint or fraction of a pint of the contents of the package." If these things are taken in relation to a vast number of articles likely to fall for tax under them, the tariff is not small—it is extremely high. Consequently the other principle would come into practice— that is, that the prices will go to an extraordinary height. If people are going to come in here to manufacture, we should test out the bona fides of their statements that they are coming in here by saying to them to come in at once, and the best way to do that is to have no alleviation of the tax because through that you are going to get a definite agitation among the consumers of certain articles either that the tax will have to be modified or that the Minister will have to see that those who are coming in will come in and that they will come in without delay.

Fundamentally, I have an objection to the paragraph as it stands, and that is that it is allowing two Ministers jointly, on representations made to them that a person bona fide intends to establish equipment and facilities for packing, to grant licences. I think that that is a power that should not be given to any Minister—such discriminatory power between the Ministers. I suggest that the only safe line is that, if discrimination is to be accepted at all, it should be accepted in the simplest and easiest way, and that is by a tax. This, however, is a licensing system, and I have a fundamental objection to that licensing system, which is not removed by the amendment later to be moved. I do prefer to keep this, with its objectionable principle, rather than to have what is to come on afterwards. I do not like the principle, and hence I am pressing that the whole sub-section should disappear. If the sub-section disappears, it puts it beyond the discriminatory control or discriminating judgment of one or two Ministers to interfere in this matter. It is only a question thereafter of a situation being presented, the public mind having this agitation about them, and being agitated because prices have gone high, and being further agitated because they are told of the possibility of packing of a certain type being established here, in which all the pressure that then can come will come on the Minister not to exercise discrimination with regard to licences, but to say that, as soon as possible, certain people will be introduced into the State.

I cannot understand why there is a time limitation in the sub-section. The section, as it is at the moment, allows the Minister for Finance to authorise the Minister for Industry and Commerce to use his discretion as to the issue of a licence "to import at any time or times before such date (not being later than 12th day of November, 1932)." If there is any meaning in that, it means that the two Ministers are convinced that before 12th November this year any machinery or establishment of equipment and facilities for packing can be brought about. If that is so, I do not see any reason for giving this peculiarly vicious power of discrimination to any two Ministers for such a period, and I cannot think of it, in the circumstances that we find ourselves in at the moment, in which one of the Ministers mentioned is to depart from this country by the end of this week, and will not be here to exercise any sort of personal judgment on this matter for many weeks to come, unless my forebodings about the particular Conference he is going to attend happen to be correct, in which case he will come home earlier probably than he imagines himself, but the mere fact that the date is put in weakens entirely any argument that can be advanced for keeping the paragraph. I do not think that anybody, supposing that this year was the only time we were faced with what I call this vicious principle of discrimination —and we are faced with it simpliciter and only here in this country—would argue for it. It is such a bad thing, and the introduction of such a serious check on business ideas as they ordinarily prevail in a country that I do not think anybody could argue for a date limited by such an early point as 12th November. It has only been tolerated here at all, even with that date in it, because there are so many other vicious things which have been introduced in the course of this finance legislation and the accompanying legislation, and because this particular point of discrimination has been founded already, or has been limited, at any rate, by a point of time, with power to license being given to the discreation of a certain Minister within that period. I do not see any reason whatever in any of the arguments advanced for refusing to accept amendment 46 and have the entire section wiped out.

Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present—

[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]

Comment on this

In the course of the long, rambling statement we heard from the Deputy, he touched on this amendment in one or two sentences. The only point of substance made by him was that the insertion of a provision of this kind might lessen, to some extent, the compulsion created by the imposition of the duty on certain manufacturers to establish packing premises here. It is undoubtedly correct that there is substance in that argument. When a duty is imposed for the purpose of compelling manufacturers to undertake a certain part of their processes of manufacture here, it is desirable that those manufacturers should feel that there is no avoidance of the imposition. I do not think, however, that the licensing provision which is inserted here will weaken in any way the sense of compulsion which the manufacturers concerned must feel in relation to this duty. The Deputy can be satisfied that no licence will be issued except where it is clearly demonstrated that some period of time must elapse before the necessary machinery can be installed, and, also, where it is clear that existing concerns within the country cannot meet the requirements of the country in the articles concerned, or with articles which could be substituted for the articles concerned. The example was given of the case of certain meat essences and meat cubes. Well-known firms engaged in the marketing of these goods have decided to establish plants here for the purpose of supplying the Irish market. It will take a certain period of time for that plant to be established, and, in the meantime, there is no special reason, and, certainly, no special advantage, in the duty operating. The licence given in any one case will be for the shortest possible period, and the entire provision lapses within six months of the date of the introduction of the Budget. I do not think the Deputy made any case against it nor do I think that, if he were examining the question with an open mind, he would not be satisfied himself that a provision of this kind was desirable.

Comment on this

I am not disposed to agree at all with what the Minister says as to the arguments I advanced. The Minister told us that we could be quite certain that no licence will be given unless evidence was produced that people bona fide intend to establish. I want to put in a better test than that. We have had many examples while the Finance (Customs Duties) (No. 2) Bill was on, of the ready way in which the Minister swallowed all the assurances, no matter how absurd, that manufacturers looking for benefits from him, gave him on different occasions.

There is nothing more likely than that people will roll up to the Minister and assure him that bona fide they intend to establish in the Free State facilities for packing. Manufacturers are very human, and, when on the look-out for certain benefits that are going to be given them, they are not going to be reluctant in the way of promising, or shy about the guarantees they will give. We have not had any sound impression created as to the difficulties the Minister will put before them with regard to getting himself satisfied as to the credibility of their statements or their actual capacity to carry out their promises within a certain specified time. There is more evidence of the Minister's credulity in listening to the statements made to him by anyone who intends to benefit. I prefer to have the test of people coming in. That is going to be the test and it is sufficient for people. If there is a package tax, and if people say they are coming in, the best way to see whether they are or are not is to induce them by every means to come in. One of the best ways is to have a certain imposition on them until they come in. The Minister for Finance told us that if we remove the paragraph there is an inducement to come in, because manufacturers with trade at the moment have to be wary not to lose that trade. He pointed out two difficulties, that people might turn to substitute substances, or drop using a particular material altogether. That is the thing that will be more evident to the business mind and to people concerned than the offer of the Minister for Finance or the Minister for Industry and Commerce. That in itself is going to be the stimulus to people to come in. They are going to be the best judges, whether there is any likely substance to which people could turn; they are going to be the best judges whether people are going to drop using a particular material, and they are going to be forced by that in their choice. The strength and clarity of their judgment is going to be the greatest goal to get these people in.

The whole thing is very hopeless. We could pick out one defect in the section. We say that it is possible to give people, as soon as possible, facilities for establishing in the Free State equipment and facilities for packing. The best way is not to have any licence given. The Minister has not attempted to defend the licence. He said that from his angle it was there and that he sees no difficulty about it because it is his discretion which will be almost entirely brought to bear on the matter. He does not see any difficulty when people who say they are manufacturers will sometimes find themselves ruled out and sometimes accepted. The people who will be in an especial difficulty will be those in the country when they find prices rising by this relatively very high tax. If they find themselves harassed by this relatively high tax, they may proceed to get agitation, and through agitation have pressure brought on the Minister, in order to have the tax withdrawn, or modified, or an arrangement made at the discretion of the Minister to have these things taxed here.

The point that would fall for inquiry, we are told, is that where a case is made to the two Ministers a licence might be granted to certain persons to import at any time, not later than the 12th of November, 1932, without limit, or limited in certain ways. Is it intended that this shall be retrospective? If it is found hereafter, and is proved to the satisfaction of the Minister, that a concern is going to establish facilities for packing, after a licence is given, if the package tax has been already collected, will the amount already collected be refunded? Is it the ordinary theoretical case again for retrospective legislation, seeing that the Ministry are legislating retrospectively? That is a point on which an answer might be given. If it is intended to be retrospective, what is going to happen to retailers who sold packages at an enhanced price? There is the difficulty of satisfying customers who bought at that price while others bought at a lower price. This is one of the many disturbances that occur through lack of forethought throughout the Budget.

Comment on this

The only new point raised by the Deputy was a query with reference to the operation of the licensing provision. The licensing provision will operate either way, either retrospectively to the date of the tax, or to the date of the licence. Generally, it will operate from the date of the Budget.

Comment on this

That is to say it will be retrospective completely?

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill."

Tá 68
·
Níl 46
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 47.

In sub-section (4), page 17, lines 17 and 18, to delete the words "on representations made to him by" and substitute the words "after consultation with" and to delete all from the word "Minister" in line 21 to the word "Minister" in line 27, and substitute the words "Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such person, at any time or times before such date (not being later than the 12th day of November, 1932), and subject to compliance with such conditions as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper to specify in such licence, to import, without payment of the duty imposed by this section, packages containing such substance either, as the Revenue Commissioners."

The purpose of the amendment is to provide that the licences will be issued by the Revenue Commissioners, and not by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, as provided in the Bill. The amendment is designed to simplify the procedure.

Comment on this

To my mind, this is an objectionable amendment, because it clouds the viciousness of what was previously in the section, and which still remains there, notwithstanding the clouding effect of this amendment. The sub-section previously read

Whenever the Minister for Finance is satisfied on representations made to him by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that a person bona fide intends to establish in Saorstát Eireann equipment and facilities for packing...the Minister for Finance may by order authorise the Minister for Industry and Commerce to issue, at his discretion, to such person a licence to import...

The amendment proposes to delete the words "on representations made to him by" and substitute the words "after consultation with" and to delete all from the word "Minister" in line 21 to the word "Minister" in line 27, and substitute words authorising the Revenue Commissioners in these circumstances to issue the licence.

Leaving out the second part, wherever the Minister for Finance is satisfied via the Minister for Industry and Commerce that various things are about to happen, then instead of the Minister for Finance authorising the Minister for Industry and Commerce to do such a thing, the Revenue Commissioners are going by licence to authorise. It is clear, although not so clear as it was originally, that the whole thing is to turn upon agreement between two Ministers. Previously it was not merely the agreement of the two Ministers but one Minister was going to authorise the other to issue the licence. This is an absurd variation of a very absurd principle, and it should be left in all its absurdity. For that reason I am going to object to the amendment. If we are going to have the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance confabbing as to whether or not a certain man is going to establish certain facilities for various things in the Free State, then let it remain as it is put here in the Bill, that the Minister for Finance is satisfied on representations made to him by another Minister, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that a person intends bona fide to establish these packing facilities and let us keep it at that. It is far better put in that way, because it is more patently absurd.

It is a peculiar thing that the Minister should become shy about issuing licences when he is becoming a much greater issuer of licences under a more ridiculous Bill, the Control of Manufactures Bill. He can under that issue a licence for anything he pleases or refuse a licence for anything he pleases. Why, if he is going to do that he cannot shoulder the responsibility of issuing a licence under this Bill I cannot understand. Why should it be that there should be some sort of connection between the Revenue Commissioners and the two Ministers? If it were made quite clear that the Revenue Commissioners were recognised as the right people and that they were ordered to do certain things, if that were made quite clear by a further adaptation of the phrase in the Bill I would not mind so much, but here we have the two Ministers carrying on the same sort of confabulations as before and then you suddenly switch off to the statement that "the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such persons... and subject to compliance with such conditions as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper to specify in such licence to import." Previously it was clear that it was the Minister's view that was impressed upon the licence whether it was a licence to import generally or a licence to import under certain specific conditions. Here it is turned on to the Revenue Commissioners. It should be made apparent within the legislation itself that it is really the Ministers who are issuing the licences. It may perhaps cause certain complications if the two Ministers are left to do this instead of the Revenue Commissioners; the Revenue Commissioners may have certain power to do it under other legislation, but until a case has been made for giving the Revenue Commissioners this power I think we should leave the section as it stands. We are always told, when we come to move amendments, that the Bill has been carefully considered, that it is in proper form and that it is almost an insult to insinuate that there is any modification or change required. Now we find Ministers themselves modifying the Bill, and I think modification is being made in a manner that is not desirable.

Comment on this

I noticed that inclination on the part of the Deputy in the various legislative proposals which he introduced himself from time to time.

Comment on this

I shall be interested to hear from the Minister for Industry and Commerce that this Government amendment signifies that the Government accepts the principle, which was admitted here on more than one occasion, that it is an undesirable burden on Ministers of State to have to decide questions of this kind in view of the political pressure and pressure of other kinds which will be brought upon them and which they will be called upon to withstand.

Comment on this

The Minister will remember that on a previous occasion he waxed eloquent when this aspect of the case was put up to him, and said that there was no more exacting tribunal to call public servants to account than Dáil Eireann. I believe the Minister has admitted pressure of no kind other than of public interest in the decision of the question of issuing a permit under the Bill. I would like to remind the House that very shortly after that impassioned oration the Minister came here and said he had done the equivalent, in anticipation of powers then before the House, of refusing a licence to certain persons to conduct certain commercial activities in this State. I asked him there and then, in fulfilment of his previous pledge, to render an account of what he did under these powers to the Dáil. His answer was: "It is not in the public interest; it is not in the interests of the person whose application is refused." Does the Minister say that he does not make that answer?

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

Well, subject to the production of the Official Reports, which are not at present by my hand, I of course accept what the Minister has said, but I shall take the opportunity either to correct myself or to correct him when the Official Report is available.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy's question relate to the publication of my reasons?

Comment on this

I asked the Minister why he refused a licence, and the answer was that it was not in the public interest nor in the interest of the parties to whom the licence had been refused, to afford the information. If I am wrong in my recollection of the Minister's statement I shall be glad to withdraw, in deference to the Official Report, at a later stage. I perceive here that this case is not quite on all fours with the general powers that have been taken to refuse or grant a licence under another Bill, because this is a temporary provision to facilitate persons to maintain their market while building up an organisation to pack merchandise here. I do not share on the whole Deputy McGilligan's dislike of the amendment, quite apart from the general principle, which I detest, of control by licence. I do not know whether Deputy McGilligan dealt with the matter that the Revenue Commissioners are called in here with power to specify in such licence certain conditions that they will deem a safeguard. I think the less exclusive this jurisdiction of the Minister is the better. The further he is compelled to consult civil servants who are not open to the same pressure as he is inevitably open to, who have not got to resist the same kind of pressure that he will be called upon to resist, the greater will be the safeguard. I dislike the whole principle, but I think on the whole that it is better to bring the Revenue Commissioners in here than to leave the matter as it was heretofore, exclusively in the hands of the Minister for Finance and the hands of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The words changed in the early part of the sub-section are calculated to alter the relationship existing between the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

I do not think that it makes very much difference in the form of words. I am not surprised that Deputy McGilligan, to make it more practical, moved that "public interest" might be put in. I think there may be something said for bringing in this whole principle of Ministers granting licences off their own bat, but the more that matter is brought before the public the better. Here is a case where the full principle is not in issue because these are temporary licences given to a man to carry on his trade. There are sections in this Bill which involve the full principle. Is it right that the Minister should have exclusive power to give or refuse a person a licence to conduct a commercial transaction in this country? On that section the principle should be debated and public attention riveted on it. Here a safeguard is introduced; we have not got the full principle admitted. I am grateful for small mercies and I am glad to see the Revenue Commissioners brought in. This admission by a Minister shows that he is disposed to sympathise with our view, but he still proposes to retain the power to grant or refuse licences. I hope a more elaborate safeguard will be introduced elsewhere where it is proposed to place similar powers in the hands of the Minister.

Comment on this

In view of the obstructionist tactics adopted by the Opposition, would I be in order in moving that the order for the adjournment be discharged and that the House sit until 12 p.m. next Saturday?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

We are in Committee on the Finance Bill now.

Comment on this

The Government act first and inquire afterwards.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

The Minister has not told us what this means; what powers does it give the Revenue Commissioners?

Comment on this

The amendment enacts a licensing provision similar to that introduced some years ago by the late Government, and the Deputy on the right of Deputy Hayes (Deputy McGilligan) may be able to give him the information.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

It is the Minister who is supposed to give information and the Minister cannot substitute a Deputy as a fount of information. The position is that in the sub-section, as provided in the Bill, two Ministers have certain powers. Is there any power now transferred by the amendment to the Revenue Commissioners? Do the words in the amendment, "the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such persons at any time before such date," give the Revenue Commissioners any power to thwart the decision arrived at by the Minister for Finance in consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce; or are the Revenue Commissioners a body who are meant to act when agreement has been reached between the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce? Is it intended to give any discretion to the Revenue Commissioners with regard to the issuing of licences at all? Or is the position, as Deputy Dillon suggested, that the Revenue Commissioners, having been informed that the Minister for Finance is satisfied after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce that a licence is to issue, are then obliged, under the terms of the amendment, to issue the licence, and are they then in the position that they may impose such conditions as they think fit without reference to the Minister for Finance? I hope the Minister will not call me an obstructionist because I want to have these points cleared up.

Comment on this

I would not think of it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Seeing that the Minister has turned to the particular wording, would he tell us what is the meaning of it?

Comment on this

I would advise the Minister to keep his temper and, for the benefit of the House, as the Minister will not give the information, I will give it for him. What has happened here is that the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance went on with this Bill and the Revenue Commissioners like sensible men let them fire away. But having shown them the absurdity of their case they pointed out that if they were to be responsible in connection with imports that this particular amendment was to be altered so that the Minister for Industry and Commerce would make representations to the Revenue Commissioners and that the Revenue Commissioners would then exercise their office. That is the full reason for the amendment.

Comment on this

The Deputy's explanation is as lucid and incorrect as his explanations usually are.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Would the Minister tell us what powers are conferred on the Revenue Commissioners by his amendment?

Comment on this

Full powers.

Comment on this

The Revenue Commissioners issue licences on the authority of the Minister for Finance—

Comment on this

Where is the authority? Would the Minister read the section? The section now reads:—"Whenever the Minister for Finance is satisfied, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that a person bona fide intends to establish in Saorstát Eireann equipment and facilities for packing in Saorstát Eireann any substance to which this section applies, the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such person at any time or times before such date (not being later than the 12th of November, 1932), and subject to compliance with such conditions as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper to specify in such licence, to import, without payment of the duty imposed by this section, packages containing such substance either as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper without limit or limited in all or any of the following ways, that is to say,” and so on. The whole sum and substance is that they may be authorised. Notwithstanding what the Minister said, the fact is the Government have come to heel and it is about time.

Comment on this

Does not the Deputy accept the explanation given by Deputy Cosgrave?

Comment on this

The Minister has put himself in the position that he has lost his temper and a bad-tempered man is never seriously able to debate anything.

Comment on this

The Deputy is O.K. so.

Comment on this

I am O.K. with everything so far as Deputy Corry is concerned, and that is one of the most odious comparisons I have ever suffered myself to make about myself. We have here the amendment which has not been explained; we have been given two versions as to what that explanation is, but we must know, before we take any vote on this at all, what is the new situation. It is clear that the only person who has got to be satisfied about a certain item is the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce. He has got to be satisfied with what? "That a person bona fide intends to establish in Saorstát Eireann equipment and facilities for packing in Saorstát Eireann any substance to which this section applies.” Does the Minister leave it at that point that the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied, or does he move after that and name the person; do the Revenue Commissioners then take up the running and enter into this position, with full power to do what they please? If that is the position, it is a much more acceptable one than the previous position. But I wonder is that the position, because clearly the Revenue Commissioners can in fact nullify? They will presumably subject this matter to some examination on their side to see whether or not they should authorise by the powers given to them in the remnant of this amendment. They are given powers to specify conditions, either “without limit or limited in all or any of the following ways, that is to say, to a specified number of packages, to packages of a specified class, or to packages of a specified size.” The Revenue Commissioners are apparently going to decide, and they must decide whether or not they are going to impose conditions, or whether it is going to be a general licence and they will have to make some examination. Supposing on their examination they think the situation is not as clear as represented to them by the Minister, they can quite clearly have full powers given to them under the latter part of the amendment, and they can nullify the Minister. They can make up their minds that the only licence they will ever allow will be an unlimited licence.

This must introduce into the minds of the Revenue Commissioners the feeling that these people are not going to establish facilities for packing except on very small lines. If, on the other hand, the word "may," which is brought in after the words "Revenue Commissioners" in the second part of the amendment, means that they are being given certain powers, but that the discretionary use of the powers depends upon the satisfaction of the Minister, then the Revenue Commissioners are entirely out of it. The position then is that the Revenue Commissioners are merely being brought in as a blind. There might be some virtue in bringing in the Revenue Commissioners and releasing the Minister from responsibility, but it would appear that they are being brought in merely as a blind. Is the situation this: that the Minister must be satisfied not merely that people should have a right to establish facilities, but also as to how far the scope of the facilities is to extend? Is the Minister's satisfaction to run right through the whole business? Is he to be the arbiter as to whether a business is to be one to import or whether it is to be, as defined here, limited in various ways? We really ought to be given some information, and we should know whether we are to have the Minister in this or the Revenue Commissioners. Are we to invest the Revenue Commissioners or the Minister with full powers?

Comment on this

The Deputy was Minister for Industry and Commerce for a number of years. During that period precisely similar licensing provisions were in operation and therefore the Deputy must have some information as to how this works. He cannot possibly have been in a day dream all the time.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister as politely as I could for what I consider to be very vital information. The Minister indicated that if obstruction went on he would be inclined to ask leave to withdraw the President's motion and to move that we should sit until 12 o'clock on Saturday night. Having done that, and having informed Deputy McGilligan that he ought to know his own business, the Minister still leaves me without an answer to a question that was put to him in no spirit of obstruction and with no intention to embarrass. I simply put the question in order to find out if I could interpret the section clearly.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

May I protest against the insinuation contained in Deputy Dillon's statement that every other Deputy who has addressed questions to the Minister is not equally polite and civil?

Comment on this

I repudiate the suggestion made by the Deputy. I had no idea of insinuating anything of the kind.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

The difficulty about the Minister's proposal to sit until 12 o'clock on Saturday night is that he has passed the wrong motion for the purpose of getting the business done and he is only discovering it now.

Comment on this

I think the Minister should give the information that he is asked for. The fact that Deputy McGilligan was a Minister and is in possession of certain information, or should be in possession of it, cannot assist ordinary back-benchers like Deputy Dillon and myself to make up our minds on the matter. We should get all the information necessary, because this is a very important section. It is important to know where the authority is vested.

Comment on this

I would despair of explaining the matter to the Deputy.

Comment on this

If the Minister is capable of making an explanation, Deputies will understand it all right.

Comment on this

There have been many questions put to the Minister and all that has happened is that he has tried to be insulting to members of the House. He has tried, but he has not been successful.

Comment on this

I would have to be a Deputy McGilligan to be able to do that.

Comment on this

Or else the Minister might prefer to be like the vest pocket Minister for Finance he has beside him. If he were, he would find that he is as weak in insults as that Minister was on finance last Friday, and that is saying a great deal. On that occasion we investigated to some small degree the depths of the Minister for Finance's ignorance on financial matters.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We are not now discussing the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

I am discussing the insults the Minister for Industry and Commerce tries to hurl at the House. Then the Minister for Finance intervenes. Deputy Dillon asked a question and Deputy MacEoin asked a question. Neither Deputy was answered. Let me be the subject for all the insults the Minister thinks fit to produce in the House. I am beginning to believe that it is not that Deputy MacEoin or other Deputies are incapable of being taught, but rather that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is incapable of making an answer. The answer may insult members of the late Government. The members of that Government expect treatment of that sort from their successors. There is, however, an Independent Deputy, a new-comer, and then there is Deputy MacEoin. They both asked perfectly simple questions, questions that nobody could describe as other than reasonable, but yet no answer was given to them. I believe this discussion would stop immediately if an answer were given.

Comment on this

I will answer any question seriously put or seriously intended.

Comment on this

The insinuation is that Deputy Dillon, for instance, has not put a serious question.

Comment on this

I may say that I put my question quite seriously and without consultation with anyone. The Minister implies that I consulted some member of my Party. I did not. I asked the question sincerely, and it is unfair for the Minister to make those insinuations.

Comment on this

The licensing provision provided for here is precisely similar in effect to one that has been in operation for a number of years. The mode of operation is well known. The licences are issued by the Revenue authorities after certain consultations have taken place between the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Department of Finance. Reference has been made about the Minister coming in, and about political pressure. That is very wide of the mark, because, as a rule, matters of this kind do not come to the Minister. They are dealt with by the officials of the Department. That has been the practice in relation to the other licensing provisions in operation. In the particular case under discussion here undoubtedly the Minister concerned would have to be consulted and Ministerial opinion would have to be given because the issues at stake would be larger. The mode of operation would be the same. An application would be made to the Minister for Finance by some firm desiring to have the benefit of the licensing provisions. The Minister for Finance would consult with the Minister for Industry and Commerce. If they were satisfied the licence should be given, the Revenue Commissioners would be so informed. The actual details of the licensing arrangement would be made by the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

Will the conditions be entirely under the control of the Revenue Commissioners?

Comment on this

It is wonderful what can be done when we get an explanation.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy really want it?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment 48 is consequential.

Comment on this

I move amendment 49 on behalf of Deputy Blythe:

To delete sub-section (7) (d).

That is to say, that the scope of the whole package tax should be limited by the elimination from it of "medicinal preparations not excluded by the next following sub-section." In this connection, I should like to have information, which we have not previously got, as to what medicinal preparations it is thought there is any likelihood of the packing or the bottling of being done here. Quite a number of preparations will be caught, quite a number of proprietary medicines of one kind or another. Quite a number of them are proprietary medicines of a type, at least on the representations made to me, where it seems that the virtue of the advertisements used about them has been running out, and that by degrees, in the course of years, the proprietors have been forced to make many reductions of price, with the result that at present they say—I am not accepting what they say as gospel— they are up to the point where there is a very small amount of profit to be taken off each bottle, each pill-box, or each packet of these things. Some of the packing is a very simple matter, but representations have been made to me that some of the packing is a rather expert process. In some cases even climatic conditions enter into the whole business—climatic conditions, of course, which can to a certain extent be reproduced here by keeping rooms at a certain heat or lacking in certain degrees of heat. In some cases of this kind, where the profit-taking has been reduced to a small point indeed, and where the packing has to be done under peculiar conditions, it would entail such expenditure in the reproduction here that there will not possibly be an equipment established, so that either the market simply has to be given up, or the alternative which is most likely to be followed is that the people who buy these preparations will continue to buy them at the enhanced price.

Again, some of these preparations, have been made up in very small lots indeed in order to cater for the physical needs of a section of the population which has not a great deal of purchasing power at one moment under its control. The preparations which used to come in in rather large bottles or boxes have, under stress of economic circumstances in the world recently, come to be put up in very small packages indeed. If there is going to be anything like 2d. charged on each one of these we will have the absurd point reached that preparations which sell for 1d. will have a 2d. tax put on them, and that preparations which require two things to be amalgamated to get the proper mixture, the sale price being 1½d., will now have to be sold, and are at present being sold, at 5d. in chemists' shops, there being a twopenny tax on each ingredient because they are done up in separate containers. I am informed that there is not the slightest likelihood of having most of these medicines done up in this country, consequently that this is going to be a tax upon medicine which people in their wisdom or folly like to buy for themselves as either a preventive against disease or as a remedy once the disease has been established. Unless there can be pretty good evidence adduced that a lot of these preparations are likely to be made up here and that considerable employment is going to flow from the packing here consideration ought to be given to that point. It is a bad thing to interfere with what people actually buy for the good of their health. Some attention might be paid to that, unless a very good case can be made in the alternative that employment is really going to be given to considerable numbers through the establishment here of the facilities and the equipment required.

Various points might be raised on the question of foods and drinks. Cosmetics are a thing that nobody will worry about, because in the main that series of things will count as luxuries. Medicines, however, are of a different type and ought to be picked out in a category by themselves and get different treatment. We had no evidence given, either on the section itself, or when the matter was previously before the House as a Finance Resolution, or in the general discussion on the Budget, as to the amount of employment expected to flow from this. I should like to have that information segregated as far as it can be to the medicinal preparations to which this amendment refers.

Comment on this

This section applies to medicinal preparations not excluded by the next following sub-section, such as serums, vaccines, or preparations in ampoules. I must say frankly that I do not agree with Deputy McGilligan about that, because so far as many patent medicines are concerned, if the tax was 4d. or 1/- it would be so much the better. The less the people waste their money on such things as Hall's Wine, and other preparations like that, the better. I think the Minister's medical colleagues, however, could tell him that a practice has grown up within the last ten or fifteen years, particularly since the war, of doctors prescribing for safety sake the preparations of certain well-known wholesale chemists in England. I refer particularly to Burroughs & Wellcome; Parke Davis, and others. There is no doubt whatever that doctors are constantly prescribing preparations which are well recognised combinations of drugs made up by these people, because they have far greater dependence on these made-up combinations than the prescriptions as they would be made up perhaps in some small, unreliable chemist's shop. Doctors will not risk their reputation. They put on their prescription, "P.D." or "B.W.," placing the obligation on the chemist to use the particular preparation put up by the firm, which-ever it may be. These preparations largely come in—I think medical men will confirm what I say—in sealed packets, and the practice of the chemist is simply to scrape off the label and put on the instructions in the doctor's prescription. That means that you are going to add an unjustifiable tax to what is already a heavy expenditure on poor people when ill. Apart from that, it is very desirable to have these excellent preparations coming in because these firms have a reputation of putting up preparations which are, like Cæsar's wife, beyond suspicion. What I suggest is that this should be medicinal preparations which enjoy the benefit of the Patent Medicine Act. A good many of these things are protected by the Patent Medicine Act or have their formula protected by some Act which provides for patent medicines. I suggest to the Minister that at a later stage he might redraft the sub-section to deal with the patent medicines and to exclude drugs brought in for the proper compounding of physicians' prescriptions and the ordinary sale of legitimate drugs.

Comment on this

I should like to press Deputy Dillon's point on the Minister, because the particular point which Deputy Dillon has made was urged upon me by a number of my constituents, who are medical men. There is a type of patent medicine of which Deputy Dillon has spoken, which people buy to drug themselves. But there is also undoubtedly a number of preparations which medical men of repute prescribe for the reason Deputy Dillon has given and other reasons. I was anxious to be here for this amendment to make that point. I will not labour it now, as Deputy Dillon has made it excellently. He has made it exactly in the way put to me by more than one medical practitioner in Dublin, including people of high repute indeed. To tax the kind of preparation that doctors will prescribe for a patient is to add very considerably to a cost that is already very high, particularly upon those who pay their own doctor, and who buy their own medicine. I think the Minister should give consideration to them.

Comment on this

While I find myself in agreement with a lot said by the last two Deputies, I am rather slow to believe that reputable men in this country would hand a prescription to anybody to be made up unless to a registered and qualified chemist. We have ourselves the degree of L.P.S.I. and I think that that degree is not conferred upon any person unless a duly qualified person who should be able to make up a medicine.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy has misunderstood me. I should have added that some of these prescriptions contain minute quantities of enormously expensive drugs which a country chemist might not be called upon for once in ten years. The doctor will not use a prescription lest these minute drugs may not be available in the country chemists' shops.

Comment on this

I should like to hear Deputy O'Higgins, whom I regard as some authority, on this matter. The only drug that I know of to which the last speaker referred is undoubtedly a very dangerous drug, but in view of the improvements in locomotion at the present time it is quite easy for a country chemist, if he does not possess any particular commodity, to obtain it in a neighbouring town.

Comment on this

There is no criticism implied or intended in anything I said upon licensed chemists. But it is true, and any medical man will confirm it, that the ordinary preparation that a medical man prescribes would come within the ambit of this particular section of this Bill and would be taxed. It would add to the people's expenditure without giving any appreciable employment in the country.

Comment on this

There is no question about the fact that prescribing nowa-days is done very much in the direction of made-up complements of medicines. Certain patent medicines are nothing but official, standard pharmacopoeia preparations specially guaranteed and now sent right through the world in a mass in packets and in bottles. I do not think it would be wise to give an advertisement to any particular firm or any particular medicine used in tuberculous treatment that now comes into the country in small bottles. I ask the Minister to remember that medicines are influenced by temperature, light and moisture. A person cannot run a chemist's shop having stuff in bulk except with an enormous sale. The wholesale houses, on the other side, supply the Irish chemists with made-up bottles and packets. The Irish chemists' business could not be carried on by buying large quantities of stuff and putting it into packets and bottles and keeping it in that way. It would not pay. I have discussed this thing, quite apart from its political aspect, with friends in the business, and they said it would be quite impossible to carry on the ordinary chemist's establishment in face of this particular tax. They could give to the Minister a long list of things that they could not get to sell except as made up at the present moment.

If this tax is a revenue tax imposed to bring in revenue, I believe that it will bring in very big revenue; but if it is a tax imposed to give employment, I firmly believe that the amount of added employment that will be given by people putting up in boxes medicinal preparations that come into the country will be really negligible. It is a tax that will hit the very poorest of the people. Seidlitz powders or Beecham's pills, with a tax of 2d. per package, are sold in small quantities to the poor. I think the Minister should forget about the revenue to be derived, and what the recompense in the way of added employment would be, and if he approaches it in that light I am certain he will remit the tax.

Comment on this

Deputies opposite say that this will make it impossible for any chemist to carry on his business. How, then, do they account for the enthusiasm with which they have received it? They have been welcoming this phase of their business for a long time, and they have been passing resolutions approving of the action of the Government. There are quite a number of very reputable firms engaged in the business of making up medicines in packages, for retail and for wholesale, and there are other firms coming into the business. Some external firms are engaged in it, and we are anxious to limit the external firms. It is one of those classes of business which it is obviously desirable should be retained in the hands of our own people. There is always the possibility that some chemist here might invent and compound a medicine that will get a momentary sale all over the world. That sale will never take place from a branch factory established by an external firm. The great majority of the medicines that are sold in packages are being made up here now, and everyone of them covered and mentioned in sub-section (e) can be made up here. There is no duty upon medicine. The duty is only upon medicine imported in packages. Deputy O'Higgins does not deny that it is within the skill, and the competence, of the Irish people to wrap up Seidlitz powders in pieces of paper. The same applies to Beecham's pills although they are supposed to be worth a guinea a box. It is not necessary to pay on Beecham's pills unless they come in in boxes. Any goods coming in in bulk are not liable to duty. The object is that the packing must be done here. There are existing firms, engaged in the packing of medicines wholesale and retail, and they are extending their business, and some new firms are coming into the business. There is no process in relation to the packing of medicines which cannot be done here. There are firms with international reputations, keeping their connection here, and having their medicines packed here, by one of the reputable firms engaged in that business.

The only other matter that arises is in connection with the exclusions mentioned in paragraph (e) sub-section (8). It is intended to add to the list of articles to be excluded Insulin, which is not covered at the present time, so that Insulin, imported in packages, will be liable to the effect of the tax. I do not think Deputies need be concerned about these different heads. In my opinion they are likely to bring in very little revenue indeed. The great majority of the medicines here are packed here and a great amount of employment is given in consequence. In one concern, engaged in the packing of patent medicines, the number of people employed rose from well over 20 to 150 and that took place in a few weeks after the duty was mentioned. Other firms, well known in the country, have increased the number of their hands very considerably. The employment is not highly skilled. It is mostly female labour but it would absolutely disappear if this amendment were carried.

Comment on this

Did the Pharmaceutical Society ask for the tax?

Comment on this

No, they were not consulted about it.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider stating here medicinal preparations protected by the Patent Medicine Act? There is certain legislation protecting patent medicines with secret formulas and all other medicines are outside that. Would the Minister consider preparing a schedule of medicines which come under the heading of patent medicines? They are the ones whose formulas are protected by some process in the Patents Act. I suggest that the Minister should look into this and bring in those and exclude the others.

Comment on this

The Deputy misunderstands the purpose of the duty. It is not a duty on patent medicines. It is a duty on packets.

Comment on this

I quite see that.

Comment on this

It is a duty on packets and the purpose is to ensure that the packing would be done here. Consequently, the only exclusion would be in the case of an article that was not or could not be made here. In these cases, if it is not possible to get the article made here, there would be a case for exclusion, but where it is possible to have the article imported here in bulk and divided here and packed in packages or containers here, there is a case for a duty.

Comment on this

The Minister believes that substantially that will be done.

Comment on this

Yes. It is, in fact, being done.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Do articles in hermetically sealed packages come in free?

Comment on this

That is covered by what I have just said.

Comment on this

Do such things as sheep come under this heading?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

I have been very much intrigued by this statement about the firm somewhere in North Dublin who are now employing 150 hands where formerly 20 were employed. I should like to know what is the range of packing being done. I was wondering was there a difference or a rise in the methods of packing, because if the Minister ever went through many of the packing arrangements in conjunction with certain businesses he would realise that the thing that jumps to the eyes is how little human labour there is at all. In the main—certainly for proprietary medicines where there is a formula which has to be attended to and where there is a staff of expert chemists engaged on the work of seeing that the preparation agrees with the formula—the packing is only a matter of a machine. It is generally rather an expensive machine and in the main only one hand—and that a very experienced type of person—is engaged to work that machine. Sometimes there is a second type of person as a helper, with a very low type of labour involved—simply the ranging of bottles in grooves and taking them from the machine. In the main, however, the most conspicuous thing, particularly with the packing of medicines, is the lack of the human agency. It is simply a question of a machine—a rather expensive machine as I have said—in the main and just one hand employed. That is why I was anxious to find out if there was an establishment in this City engaged in packing in which the amount of employment had risen from 20 to 150, and to find out how many machines were brought in, because I understood that it would mean mainly machinery being brought in and also the granting at the beginning of permits to allow quite experienced people to come in. I know of certain people who said that, although they did not think that the trade being done in certain things here was sufficiently established to enable them to judge definitely that their trade here was worth the expense of the machine, but that if they did bring in the machine, they would also ask for a permit to introduce skilled and experienced hands into the country and that that was the beginning and end of it. I think that the equities of the case are definitely with the exclusion of all packet medicines and preparations as Deputy O'Higgins and Deputy Dillon said. Deputy Dillon advanced two arguments but I thought that the second argument he advanced was the better one. In his first argument he seemed to be getting on to the point made on Friday last. As to what we should do for certain people he advanced the point that really if a tax of this sort led to people refraining from spending their money on things like Hall's Wines it would be all to the good. It is not all to the good. He had that same point of view when he talked on the gramophone tax on Friday. He spoke of well-informed people but with all respect to the Deputy I suggest that he does not qualify, not that I would deny him the right, to be well-informed. Similarly in this, if he is speaking with medical advice—and possibly he is—when he says that there is a great variety of rubbish that comes in and which is being bought by the people, then there may be a case for some very powerful Government hereafter to set out deliberately on the course that certain things which are deleterious and harmful are coming in and that they should be excluded. I suggest, however, that there is a great deal of faith cure in everything and there is quite a number of people who, because they believe that certain substances do them good, do get benefit out of these substances unless the substances themselves are in their essence harmful.

The complete exclusion of the packet medicines from the operations of the tax, as Deputy O'Higgins has suggested, reinforces what has been said previously, that there is no revenue in the main to be derived from it, and I think the Minister withdrew his statement.

Comment on this

I did not withdraw it.

Comment on this

Well, the Minister's explanation or modification of his statement indicates that the amount of employment anticipated will not be given by it. Whatever employment will be given by packing will come out of the packing of food and drink. The inclusion of cosmetics is simply a bad-tempered gesture. I do not think he knows himself why cosmetics should be included.

Comment on this

I wished to leave the Deputy's beauty unadorned.

Comment on this

I cannot say the same for the Minister. I wish I could.

Comment on this

My standards in these matters are Epstein's.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I wish we could get on with this matter as quickly as possible.

Comment on this

I am sorry you will not allow the minor poet to talk on beauty. It would be an interesting discussion, even at 6 o'clock in the morning. I do suggest that whatever employment there is going to be given by the effect of the tax, will come under lettered sections (a) and (b) of Section 7. There is going to be a very little under (c) but let it pass; (d) is going to have bad effects and it affects people in their health. I do suggest again that, unless some better estimate can be given of actual employment to be attained under it, the whole business should be wiped out. Alternatively, I would press very earnestly, with Deputy Dillon, that better consideration should be given to it with a view to modifying it. We have already had one modification by way of exception which shows that debate in this House is not always obstruction, but does effect improvement at times.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

I discussed this matter with certain medical people who were interested in this particular paragraph, as I said, and the announcement by the Minister that he is going to include Insulin in the exceptions suggests to me that there must be similar things, drugs or medicinal preparations of great importance, but the sale of which is not sufficiently large here to warrant any factory being set up for packing. If the Minister would consider that, we could let Beecham's Pills and the other things go. There is, however, a genuine case for the kind of thing prescribed by doctors which is not very generally used, and of which there is perhaps not a very large sale here. I would press the Minister, apart from what Deputy Dillon asked him, to make further inquiries—he must have some source open to him— and say whether there ought not to be some other thing specified, either by way of finding a formula to include all, or to mention certain things, because there are certainly things besides Insulin which will not be packed here and the cost of which will go up and will make the sufficiently large expenses of people who pay their doctors and chemists larger still.

Comment on this

No such case has been made.

Comment on this

I would suggest that the Minister should look into this question in the light of the facts laid before him in this debate. He can simply look into it and seek expert advice from the medical or the chemists' profession between this and Report Stage. It is a matter that could easily be adjusted. I think he will find a lot of preparations which are very similar to Insulin, such as liver extract and other things of that kind, that are not and could not be made here because there is no demand here. Deputy McGilligan found fault with me for leaning towards what he thought was paternalism in government. I repudiate that suggestion. What I say is this: that you should not make inroads on revenue nor should you make inroads on possible sources of employment unless you have very good reason; and if you are not satisfied that there is very good reason for excluding something from the schedule, if you accept the principle of general covering section, you should not exclude that commodity. The other point was where I got my information about patent medicines. I would refer the Deputy and the Minister, if I might, to the report of the Royal Commission which sat in London on the whole question of patent medicines in 1914 and if he digests it he will digest it with great profit.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I will put amendment 49.

Comment on this

Is this not going to be considered at all?

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider the representations made?

Comment on this

If any case for further exclusion is made it will be considered. I submit that no case has been made here. It has been argued on the basis of Beecham's Pills and Seidlitz Powders.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

Any parties interested in this duty who made representations to the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Department of Finance had their representations fully considered, and the result of this consideration was that various exclusions were inserted and no case has been made then that was not worth consideration which was not made now.

Comment on this

If the Minister went into a chemist's shop and looked around for ten minutes he would not require any case to be put up by anybody

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

If he went and simply studied the cases of a certain firm, he would probably find in those cases one hundred small bottles. These small bottles would probably not be bought by any individual chemist to the extent of more than what one could count on the fingers of one hand at a time. They are only used occasionally and the chemist does not keep any large stock. It would not pay to make them except at fabulous prices, nor would it pay anybody to undertake the packing of them, but in order to catch a small number of cases——

Comment on this

Mention the article. There is no good in talking about a generality of bottles.

Comment on this

There is a number of articles of which I may give Aspirin as an example. I do not want to mention the name of the firm. The Minister will find cases of such like things in the stock of a certain firm which would probably contain one hundred small bottles. The Minister has in mind to catch the packing of a small number of things, which might possibly be done here and which would produce a small amount of employment, but, in order to catch that small number of articles, he brings in a net which will catch things by the hundred, and of which the only result will be the catching of the revenue from this package tax, and the affecting of the price of prescriptions wherever these are got by anybody, poor or otherwise. It must and will mean that. A chemist does not care, because it simply means that he will increase his price for making up prescriptions, but the probability is that for every one thing on which duty will be paid, and where some employment may be given, 100 will be caught by the package tax.

Comment on this

Quite the reverse.

Comment on this

The Minister has only to look at a chemist's shop to see it.

Comment on this

I will mention one category—pluriglandular preparations, of which there are dozens. I do not want to press the Minister because the thing is exceedingly complicated. All I ask is that he will enquire into the matter between now and the Report Stage. He will find legions of preparations of that kind which no chemist will attempt to prepare, and which he could not possibly bring in in bulk. I give the Minister that one category of pluri-glandular preparations.

Comment on this

What about aspirin?

Comment on this

I want to make this clear before the amendment is put that if a strong case is put up for any one of these preparations it will be considered, but, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce has already mentioned, no case has been put up on a specific ground for the exemption of anything other than those covered by general exemption in paragraph (e), sub-section (8), and this other in regard to insulin, and it seems to me that the members of the medical profession are not very serious in the matter or they would have made themselves more vocal. In regard to the point raised by Deputy Thrift, I think his speech proves the case for the package tax, if nothing else does. He talked of going into a chemist's shop and looking at one hundred small bottles, most of them in cases, and not one of them sealed hermetically.

Comment on this

On the contrary, they are probably all sealed.

Comment on this

Yes, with a little bit of cotton wool and a screw cap.

Comment on this

And wax.

Comment on this

Sometimes wax, but very often not.

Comment on this

But they are generally sealed.

Comment on this

Every one of these preparations could be put into the bottles here, and could a screw cap not be put on here?

Comment on this

Not unless you establish an agency here to buy in bulk from a particular maker and distribute it throughout the country. Who is going to do it? Nobody. I have in mind things that are made up, not only in England, but in Germany, especially. Nowadays, there are comparatively few doctors' prescriptions which will not have in them one of these specially made products, made according to formula and made in bulk at a comparatively cheap rate, which come in that manufactured form, generally in sealed bottles, in order to prevent deterioration by damp. All these will be caught by the tax and it will all lead to an increase in price to the consumer.

Comment on this

Another additional reason for consideration I submit to the Minister is that frequently rare drugs have to be wired for abroad and unless there is a covering exclusion for drugs other than those protected by the Patent Medicines Acts they must be held up by the customs authorities until they can be discharged. If there is an exclusion of drugs used for therapeutic medicine that commodity will pass immediately. Deputy O'Higgins, I am sure, could tell the House that in his practice he has to wire to London, and sometimes to Berlin, for some special drug required urgently for a special case. If it comes under this schedule, no matter how anxious the Revenue Commissioners may be to accommodate him, they must hold it, collect the duty and pass it on, and, although they do it as quickly as they possibly can, it will mean delay and sometimes possibly fatal delay. That is an extreme case, but I only ask the Minister to look into it between now and Report Stage.

[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the sub-section stand."

Tá 67
·
Níl 47
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 50: "In sub-section (8) (b), line 54, before the word "fruit," to insert the words "soup in liquid form." There is a small import of tinned soup. The canning of the soup is part of the process of manufacture. Consequently, it could not be imported in bulk and canned here. The total trade is so small that the process of manufacture could not be carried on here. On representations made, we agreed to the exclusion of liquid soup from the scope of the duty.

Comment on this

I move amendment 51:

In sub-section (8) (b), after the word "fruit," line 54, to insert the word "vegetables" and in line 55 after the word "or" where it occurs a second time to add the words "meat extract, soup, soup cubes or soup powders or."

The amendment proposed by the Minister is not wide enough. As the section is drawn, it is difficult to know what would be covered, but I want to make sure that certain things not made here, and not likely to be made here, will be exempt. I quote as an example meat extract. I do not know whether under the section as it stands an article like Bovril would be exempt or not. The section exempts meat paste in sealed bottles. Whether Bovril would be recognised as a meat paste, I do not know. Even if it were recognised, I do not know whether it would not be cut out by the phrase "sealed bottle." There is no prospect whatever of such goods being made in this country. This article is made in another part of the world where, I presume, meat in bulk can be obtained at a very much cheaper rate than it could be obtained or produced here. There are a great number of soup cubes and soup powders. Some of them might be produced here, but there is no prospect of their being produced in such variety as is required. These things are very valuable from the point of view of the housekeeper, and from the point of view of the general consumer. They have also their value from the health point of view. They make it possible, where the domestic resources are limited, to give variety to the dietary of the household. Everybody is aware that, from the health point of view, that is very important. I think all these items in the amendment have as good claim for exemption as anything that has already been exempted. They cannot be produced in any great variety here. You may have one or two flavours of a particular brand produced, but the market here is relatively small and production to meet the variety of the demand is impossible. The case exists here that exists in respect of a great many other articles— that the public demand is really for small quantities of large variety. The demand is not met if that variety is not obtainable, and it is impossible to meet that demand by production here. I do not know what was principally in the Minister's mind when the package tax was introduced. There would be no harm in taxing certain things when introduced in package from—things in respect of which the packing could be done here, and where very little inconvenience would result to the public. But the net is cast much more widely, and I think the exemptions ought to be extended in the manner suggested by this amendment.

Comment on this

The amendment is one which could not be accepted, nor do I think the Deputy will press it when he knows the circumstances. There is a considerable industry in the canning of vegetables here and that process has been extended considerably as a result of the package duty. Quite a number of firms which were importing canned peas have since made arrangements to have the peas canned here. Similarly, other firms are engaged in packing or canning vegetables here. That is a type of business we should endeavour to foster because it has considerable possibilities. There may be certain types of tinned or canned vegetables which at the moment are not being produced here, but they would be the least important both in relation to the quantity imported and the effect of the package duty on the price. So far as the great range of vegetables, including peas, is concerned, the importation of these things in packets has now stopped and the packing is being done here. Certain Irish firms have been considering the installation of machinery and a very considerable development of their business is contemplated in relation to the packing of vegetables in one form or another. As regards meat extract, Bovril is subject to duty. It is a meat extract and arrangements are being made, I understand, to have Bovril imported in bulk and put into bottles here. That is the purpose of the package duty and, so far as that is concerned, it is being effected. Machinery is being installed, I understand, for that purpose. The same applies to Oxo cubes and things of that sort. They will be packed here. The object of the Government is to secure that the packing will be done here. It has been successful in relation to these things. As regards soup powders, the same thing applies. It is quite feasible to have the packing done here and arrangements are being made to have it done so that there need be no stoppage of supplies of any of these articles and no increase in price.

A certain part of the process of manufacture will be carried out here and some employment will in consequence be given. The amount of employment to be given it is very hard to estimate because it will depend largely upon the nature of the machinery and the amount of machinery that is utilised in the various processes. At the same time quite a large number of girls—it is mostly girl labour which is utilised in this class of work—have been employed in various firms in the packing of peas and other processes, who would lose their employment if the amendment were carried. If there was any considerable difficulty or if there was any definite reason to believe that any of these goods would not be available except at a substantially increased price as a result of the duty, there would be a situation to be dealt with but that is not the case. Each of the firms will avoid the duty by having the goods imported in bulk and packed here.

Comment on this

Will the Minister assure the House that these goods will be imported in bulk and that they will be of the same quality as those sold elsewhere?

Comment on this

That is a matter for the firms concerned.

Comment on this

The Minister in referring to peas was dealing with dried peas.

Comment on this

Dried vegetables in packets.

Comment on this

Tinned peas.

Comment on this

Peas are not being tinned here.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, we are beginning to get a slight export trade of tinned vegetables of one kind or another. I think Deputy Bennett will inform the Deputy about that.

Comment on this

Until you destroyed it.

Comment on this

I heard that there was a tinned pea industry, but I was certainly not aware that the quantity that was being produced was anything like what would meet the market. No arrangements could certainly be made for this year, for instance. Whatever quantity was produced last year must more or less regulate what is going to be produced this year. The sowing season was practically over and it would not be possible to make any special arrangements for this year for anything that would very much exceed the supply of last year. Certainly, unless the Minister has very definite information, I would doubt that the quantities produced by these firms last year were such as to supply any great portion of the market.

Comment on this