Emergency Imposition of Duties Bill, 1932 (From the Seanad) In Committee.
Contributions 1–183 of 498. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 23 of 1932 ›
Can we hear from the President the general intention with regard to all the amendments?
Comment on this
We propose not to agree to recommendations 1 and 2; but we accept recommendations 3, 4 and 5.
I move that the Committee do not agree with the Seanad on the following recommendations:
Section 1, sub-section (1). To delete paragraph (f).
Section 1, sub-section (1). To delete paragraph (g).
Comment on this
As 1 and 2 both deal with Stamp Duty I am deciding that they should be taken together and that one decision should cover both.
Comment on this
I presume, sir, having regard to the Bill which is before us, and the steps that were taken in this House on the occasion when it was last before us, that on the question of the amendments that have been made by the Seanad, the debate which is to take place on these amendments will be on somewhat more than what is contained in the particular amendment in question. For example, the Bill as it stands is one which has arisen out of a new situation, the new situation being that which was occasioned by the British Bill giving the British Cabinet power to make an order to impose up to 100 per cent. duty upon various articles coming into Great Britain from this State.
Comment on this
Before the debate proceeds further it might not be amiss to remind the House that the practice has been that when the House is summoned for a specific purpose, only the business set out in the Order Paper summoning the Dáil shall be transacted unless the House agrees that the debate should be of a wider nature.
Comment on this
I take it, sir, that Deputy Cosgrave is submitting that in the circumstances we should not be governed by the ordinary rule of procedure regarding ordinary amendments or recommendations sent from the Seanad, but that there should be liberty given for a wider debate than would be given in the case of an ordinary measure.
Comment on this
I do not think there is a precedent for such procedure except by consent of the House.
Comment on this
I am submitting that the House should consent, with the sanction of the Chair, that wider powers should be given than are allowed in an ordinary debate.
Comment on this
Never before when a recommendation has come back from the Seanad has it been suggested that we should discuss nothing else but the specific and particular recommendations made by that House. I do not see, in view of the debate which has taken place on this Bill both here and in the Seanad, that there is any necessity for having the discussion strictly limited to the matters on the Order Paper and to the recommendations made by the other House.
Comment on this
The proposals that have been made by the other House and the proposals dealing with the measure which was introduced in this House on Thursday last, one might say almost without notice, and which was guillotined on Friday, on which day, no opportunity was afforded, by reason of the guillotine motion, to amend or even to submit for the consideration of the House amendments to this measure. This measure arises out of another measure introduced in the British House of Commons, and it is the answer to that measure. I submit that we are entitled, on the consideration of these two amendments from the Seanad, to advert to the circumstances which have given rise to the business before us now. The deletion of the paragraph—
impose, whether with or without qualifications, limitations, allowances, exemptions, or preferential rates, a stamp duty on any particular description of document or transaction as from any specified day and, for the purpose of such duty, require a document or a particular form of document to be used in or in connection with any particular description of transaction.
in itself, apart altogether from the wider question, opens up a very big avenue of discussion. The very first question that one is disposed to ask in connection with the clauses in question, is "For what purpose?" The normal purpose which would occur to anybody's mind is that it is to raise money. That, I venture to think, was not the very first thing that was in the minds of the Ministry when they introduced the measure, although we got no information to the contrary. Taking it to be the counterpart of the other measure I have referred to, it would not, in the normal course of events, mean that more money was going to be raised here than was being raised by the other people, but that there was some equation about it. All this question, which was debated on the last day, arises from the circumstances, as I have said, in which we find ourselves; circumstances which, on the last day, were rather ably put by Deputy McGilligan in the course of his speech reported in columns 1168 and 1169 in the debates of 15th July, 1932.
Comment on this
Might I interrupt the Deputy on a point of order? Is the Deputy in order in reciting what Deputy McGilligan said when this Bill was last before the House? We are considering, I take it, Recommendation No. 1—
Comment on this
Recommendations 1 and 2 and I think that what the Deputy is saying at the moment is not relevant to that issue.
Comment on this
Until the Deputy quotes the paragraphs, the Chair is not in a position to say whether they are relevant or not. The particular quotations may refer to stamp duties and, if they do, they are in order, but, according to Standing Order 119, the business of this House is confined to the consideration of the recommendations sent down by the Seanad, unless there is agreement to enlarge the scope of the debate.
Comment on this
As I said when I began the discussion, this Bill is a Money Bill and the object of this Bill is to raise money. That, as I said, did not, to my mind, represent correctly what was in the mind of the Executive Council when they introduced the measure. I think the idea behind this measure was to make it the counterpart of the Bill which was introduced into the British House of Commons, giving power to the Cabinet there to impose certain duties on goods from this country into Great Britain. Arising out of that, stamp duties are one of the means by which it is proposed in this measure to give power to the Executive to collect certain moneys. The question arises at once, with great respect, as to whether, in all the circumstances, this is an advisable procedure and whether this is or is not a proposal which the Dáil ought to be asked to accept and whether it is not advisable for them to say whether there might not be a better way of dealing with this matter. Nobody in this country, or in Great Britain will assert that a Bill in one House to impose a tax on goods coming from another country and, the corollary to that in the other country, imposing taxes on goods or securities or anything of the sort, is the best method in all the circumstances for resolving a difficulty or a dispute which has arisen between the two countries. In that connection, I proposed to quote for the House a statement made by Deputy McGilligan on the last day.
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt the Deputy again, but, as I understand it, the ordinary procedure of dealing with a recommendation from the Seanad is to treat it as an amendment to the Bill, and, on the Committee Stage of a Bill, it is not permissible to discuss the principle of a Bill. The whole tenor of the Deputy's speech up to this has been as to whether the Bill in principle is justified or not, and I suggest that, for that reason, his remarks are out of order, and that he can only discuss the narrow issue here as to whether or not a stamp duty should be imposed and not the major issue, the principle on which the Bill is based, as to whether such a Bill should be introduced or not and such legislation passed or not. The House has already, on the Second Reading of the Bill, accepted the principle of the measure and I do not think that the debate can be enlarged now to cover ground already covered in the House.
Comment on this
Might I put it for your consideration, sir, and for the consideration of the Minister, that the Minister follows precedents when precedents suit, him and departs from precedents, as widely as he possibly can, when they do not suit him. To-day, we are discussing, at a specially summoned meeting, recommendations made in the Seanad to a Money Bill. There is no precedent at all for that. Secondly, we are discussing recommendations made by the Seanad to a Bill which was guillotined here on Friday last, under a motion which has no precedent in the annals of this House, and which made no provision for adequate discussion or any opportunity of dealing with it on Committee. That being the case, as we departed from precedent in the motion by which the Bill was guillotined, and in summoning a meeting specially to consider recommendations to a Money Bill made by the Seanad, we might, even at the expense of departing from precedent, have this particular kind of debate. I want to suggest also that, when the Minister says it is not permissible to discuss the principle of a Bill in Committee, he is stating a principle with which, I take it, sir, you do not agree.
Comment on this
Even on the question of the point of order put by the Minister, those two clauses, which the Seanad has recommended should be deleted from this measure, certainly do propose to collect some money. They certainly are intended to gather in some money and they are part and parcel of, if you like to put it so, the larger policy, but it could reasonably happen that those two clauses, which the Seanad recommends should be deleted, might be the major portion of this measure, might be by far the greater part of this measure, the much more potential instrument in the hands of the Executive either in collecting money or as their answer to the other Bill to which I have already referred. On the last day, I dealt, at some length, with those two clauses myself and I did not do so lightly and I do not do so now lightly. Any discussion in respect of the deletion or approval of these two clauses must inevitably be connected with the principle of this measure and is inseparable from it. These two clauses which as I said I referred to in this House on the last occasion, are the most revolutionary financial proposals ever put to any House. No administration in the world has ever put forward in a Bill proposals taking to themselves such authority and such financial potentialities as are involved in these two clauses. I presume I am entitled to continue on that basis.
Comment on this
The Deputy is again repeating the speech which he made on the Second Reading. I suggest, in reply to what has been said by Deputy Hayes, that even if new precedents were created on Friday they were precedents which were governed strictly by the Standing Orders.
Comment on this
If the Minister is in order in replying now, surely the whole discussion is in order?
Comment on this
Normally the principle of a Bill cannot be considered in a discussion of such recommendations, except in so far as the recommendations relate to that principle. Deputy Michael Hayes spoke of the hurried manner in which this measure was carried through the Dáil. This Bill was discussed in the Dáil and in the Seanad. It was discussed in the Dáil on a procedure sanctioned by a majority of the House. Deputy Cosgrave said the two clauses proposed to be deleted are vital clauses—that they contain revolutionary proposals. If so, surely they should afford sufficient subject matter for discussion without bringing in the question of tariffs and other extraneous matters?
Comment on this
Might I say, as a matter of personal explanation, that I did not use the word "hurried" as to the way in which the Bill was passed through the Dáil, but simply said that the guillotine motion, under which this Bill was put through the Dáil, had and has no precedent. That is all I want to say.
Comment on this
I want to suggest this: I think you have ruled that the discussion of principle on this stage can only be conducted by consent of the House. Bowing to that ruling, I suggest to the Government, as the President was not here when this Bill was being passed through the House in its earlier stages, that quite apart from all Party advantage, it is of vital urgency to this State that an opportunity should be given to discuss the principle of the Bill while the President is here, and that the President should be afforded an opportunity of stating fully to this House his views on the principle and the necessity of the principle of the Bill that he and his Government are sponsoring before us to-day. I ask the Government to consent to a wide discussion.
Comment on this
I entirely subscribe to Deputy Dillon's suggestion. I want to ask, bearing on the question of order here, because while it bears on the general question it also bears on the way in which we are transacting our business this evening, are we not in a difficulty, arising out of the fact that the matters we are asked to decide upon now are matters upon which neither the Minister for Finance nor the President has made any explanation good, bad or indifferent to this House? We have not been told in what way the power to impose stamp duties is going to be used. If the President for any reason does not find himself in a position to reply along Deputy Dillon's lines, can we have, either from the President or from the Minister for Finance, some explanation as to the lines upon which it is proposed, and the purpose for which it is proposed, to use these stamp duties?
Comment on this
Might I remind the House that this present discussion comes about solely as a result of the policy of the present Government in regard to the retention of the land annuities? It is now more than a month since we had from the President an undertaking solemnly given——
Comment on this
I am drawing attention to the fact that the President over a month ago assured this House that they would get an opportunity of discussing the policy of the Government as regards the land annuities, to the fact that they never got that opportunity, and that now they are discussing a matter that arises out of the policy of the Government which they never got an opportunity of discussing.
Comment on this
The second paragraph which it is proposed to delete says:
"vary, in any manner or respect whatsoever and as from any specified day, any stamp duty in force at the passing of this Act or imposed by any Act passed or order made after the passing of this Act, or any qualification, limitation, allowance, exemption, or preferential rate in force at the date of such order in relation to any such duty."
Comment on this
Before Deputy Cosgrave proceeds to deal with the recommendations of the Seanad, may we have a ruling on the point we have been discussing for the last twenty minutes, as to whether the discussion is going to be strictly confined to the recommendations from the Seanad, or whether we shall be allowed, on this special occasion, to deal with the principle of the Bill which, I agree with your ruling, is contained in the two recommendations?
Comment on this
Before you answer that, sir, may I direct your attention, and the attention of the House, to Standing Orders 119 and 120? Whatever was done on the last day was not in conflict with the Standing Orders. For ten years the procedure in this House has been governed by the Standing Orders. I submit that no good cause has been shown why the ordinary rules of procedure dealing with recommendations, not amendments, from the Seanad on a Money Bill, should be departed from now.
Comment on this
May I refresh your memory as to what exactly occurred on the last day we met here? If my recollection is correct, we disposed of all the Standing Orders in order to get through with a certain Bill in a particular time. We put them out of commission.
Comment on this
We practically said that we did everything in accordance with the Standing Orders while, at the same time, we went on in blinkers. There is no doubt that we put them out of commission and then went on with the work. That is the position that we are in now.
Comment on this
Before Deputy Cosgrave proceeds, do you, sir, rule that the principle of the Bill is a proper subject for discussion at this specially summoned meeting of the Dáil? I hope you will also make it clear that other matters which were introduced during the Second Reading Stage of this Bill, and which had nothing to do with the Bill, will be ruled out. I submit that during the Second Reading of the Bill a leading member, perhaps the leading member of the Opposition, discussed the policy of Fianna Fáil and Labour, the Oath Bill——
Comment on this
——the question of the advisability of the mission to Ottawa, the advisability, or otherwise, of wearing tall hats, the correspondence——
Comment on this
The Chair has not ruled that it is in order to discuss the principle of the Bill in considering these recommendations. The Chair has agreed to such a discussion if the House agrees, but not otherwise. There does not appear to be agreement, as there was on a certain motion a week or so ago, and the House——
Comment on this
The House has power to suspend Standing Orders. The motion referred to was agreed to by the House. Failing agreement now, the discussion must be confined to the matters on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
As a sort of an aside, may I suggest to Deputy Davin, through the Chair, that there are hats which are not of the silk variety but which are also tall and which certain people get in schools now and then? I hope Deputy Davin is not referring to these.
Comment on this
On the question which is before us, and which I have consistently kept to since I stood up, two points arise, one as to the necessity for getting the money in question and, two, as to whether this is the most advisable method in which to do it. I submit that in the absence of any explanation by the Ministry as to the purpose to which it is proposed to devote the money raised by reason of these two sections, the House ought to be very slow indeed to agree to the proposal of the Ministry that they should be kept in the measure. I understand some reference was made in the Seanad as to what was the purpose behind these two clauses. Surely these two clauses go far beyond anything which would be necessary to give the Ministry power to deal with what they have stated in the Seanad? While these two clauses remain there and while there is a feeling of apprehension, as there must be, in the country concerning this measure and concerning the circumstances which have given rise to it, they will be a very serious impediment to the transaction of business. A very serious dislocation inevitably is bound to occur as long as these two clauses remain part of an Act passed by the Oireachtas.
The portion of the recommendations from the Seanad which gives power to summon the Dáil on certain occasions at the desire of a majority of the members of the Dáil is practically valueless in comparison with the power that is placed in the hands of the Ministry by those two sections. As I have already said, we are entitled to consider whether or not we have yet examined in all its implications the possibility of getting a settlement of this question, of relieving the Ministry of the obligation of administering this Act and of relieving our neighbours across the water of the necessity of interrupting the business of this country by reason of their particular legislation. It is in that connection I propose to read for the House, for those members who were not here on the last occasion, what was said by Deputy McGilligan on 15th July last:—
There is a case for going to the Prime Minister of England, who has come back from Lausanne with a particular settlement and saying that in the new circumstances the 1925 settlement requires revision. But you can never get anything from these people if you are going to stand on legal rights—which are without substance or to equate these payments with war debts and reparations, which is untenable, and would not be put by any one with a grain of sense in his head. The circumstances of that time can be turned to account—circumstances in which there was the prospect of very heavy debts for war being saddled on the British, and of our having to share these and we got them all wiped out by saying:—"Remember we are paying these other very big sums." There is a case now for revision in the light of that, because of the phrase then used, a phrase which justified our case then and gave a secure hold to the Government of the moment. There is a case now to be made that that settlement requires revision, and a revision that ought to be in our favour. That, however, must be based on the equities of the situation and can only be made by people who are going to announce themselves as being honestly prepared to deal equitably with the other parties to the bargain, the British. A Government now could get some remission but it has to be a Government of a particular type. The time is ripe, the golden opportunity has arrived, but it requires a sacrifice which I doubt this Government is going to make. You have got to deal with the British in this case not on any nonsensical legal grounds but on the grounds of equity. Over and over again, as I said, they showed themselves prepared to deal in a generous way on an equitable case being put to them.
I venture to say that the number of people in this country and the number of people in Great Britain who want an economic war between the two countries is negligible. Nobody is concerned with them; they are altogether out of account. The vast majority of the people of the two countries want peace between the two countries. There is an opportunity now for exhausting every possible effort towards settlement that can be found, to see what negotiations can do and to see how possible it is for one side or the other to bring commonsense to bear on the problem that is only there to be solved. It must be solved if there is any good-will or statesmanship or Christianity amongst those who are charged with the responsibility of affairs in both countries.
Even at this moment I would suggest, with all the force at my command, and, I believe, backed by everybody in the country except that negligible element to which I have referred, that there is a case now for negotiation and that there ought to be some real attempt on the part of those interested in the vital needs of both countries to do something towards bringing about a settlement through negotiation. The conditions of 1925 or 1926 are different to the present time, economically very different to what they are now. Even last March circumstances were different to what they are now. It may be that in the peculiar circumstances of this period the British Government and the Government here have committed themselves to statements or actions which may render the possibility of negotiation difficult but not impossible. If real statesmanship exists in either country the force of public opinion, upon which Governments must depend either to fall or stay in power, must compel them to see the necessity that exists for finding accommodation on this question.
This is not a period in which the British Government can afford to ignore the value of the trade of this country. This is not a period in which we can afford to ignore the market which takes from 90 to 95 per cent. of our produce. It is idle for some people to say that we are all prepared to tighten our belts. That is the last thing anybody in any country wants to do. It would appear to me that they are tight enough already and serious damage might be done by endeavouring to make them any tighter. There should be a serious attempt made to bring about these negotiations and have this matter settled. I say in all sincerity, and with all the force at my command, that these negotiations ought to be resumed and that they ought to have the support of all parties in the State who are anxious and eager for the welfare of the State.
Comment on this
I believe I said that on the last occasion when this matter was discussed here. I have never uttered a single word at any time with any other object in view than that problems and difficulties between States had got to be settled.
Comment on this
Did Deputy Cosgrave repudiate the statement made by Deputy Blythe that if negotiations broke down the fault would be on the Irish side?
Comment on this
I would be much more inclined to stand over it than to controvert it—very much more. I do say that in these matters the most defenceless people we have in the State are the people who are going to suffer most. There will be no reduction in Ministers' salaries or in the payments made to members of the Dáil—none whatever. The business of the country will go on but the farming community will suffer great loss. Some farmers will suffer loss that in their life time they will be scarcely able to restore. Large numbers of people will be thrown out of employment. The railroads are already in a bad position but they will have a lesser amount of livestock to carry, they will have less traffic to deal with and the prospect for them is by no means bright. All the people of the country will feel this except, perhaps, those who are paid by the State.
Comment on this
As long as the Deputy's speech showed some indication that he was anxious to be helpful, I was not prepared to urge that the debate should be confined within narrow limits, but I do suggest that his last remarks are entirely out of order and go far beyond the consideration of the recommendations on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
I must differ entirely on that. If I am to consider who is to be hit by reason of the abolition of the two paragraphs in question, I am entitled to consider who is not going to be hit and to point the moral.
Comment on this
I am entitled to consider any institutions likely to be interfered with by reason of the policy involved by these two paragraphs.
Comment on this
The Deputy's speech is developing into a Second Reading speech, though a debate on stamp duties could be very wide indeed and still be in order.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, neither you nor I nor anybody else, with the possible exception of the Executive Council—perhaps not even they—knows how much of this measure depends on these two paragraphs. They may represent nine-tenths or nineteen-twentieths or they may represent only three-tenths. If no other opportunity is afforded, there is, at least, this opportunity afforded for saying that this is not the best way to solve this difficulty. Sooner or later, this Bill being passed and the other Bill being in operation, negotiations will have to take place. That has always happened. Countries cannot be perpetually at war. A settlement will be arrived at when it will be impossible to compensate a number of the people who suffered most during the conflict. Before the real damage is done, I put up that proposal again—that there should be negotiation and a settlement, that it is not the time for getting war measures ready, that it is not the time for interrupting business, as it is bound to be interrupted if these two clauses remain. Taking the whole measure as it stands, it has a life beyond that of anybody here. It is limited only by whatever changes may occur in Parliamentary representation. We are told that the measure is for a particular purpose but no such indication appears on its face or in these two clauses or any of the other clauses. I do not believe that even the British Government would have got from its Parliament powers so far-reaching as are proposed to be taken here without having those powers subject to Parliamentary control. The only Parliamentary control here lies in the possibility that the Government may be unable to get a vote of confidence at a particular time. Even if it were necessary to furnish the administration with weapons to combat the measure passed on the other side, I believe there is quite enough in this measure without these two clauses and that the elimination of them will not interfere with or mar in any way any negotiations that will have to take place in order to find a settlement of the problem with which we are faced at present.
Comment on this
I should like to approach this matter from a non-party point of view. Deputy Cosgrave has said that negotiations ought to be re-opened and that every man and every element in the State should be behind the Government in those negotiations. With that, I agree. The President and many of his Ministers and many public bodies throughout the country have called upon the representatives of the people in this House and in the Seanad and have called upon Irishmen both here and throughout the world to stand behind the Government. We have been told by the President that this is not a party matter, that it is a national matter. I agree. It is a matter that will affect not only those who voted Fianna Fáil but those who voted Cumann na nGaedheal, those who voted Labour and those who voted for the Independents. It is going to affect every man, woman and child in the Saorstát and, so far as I am concerned—I think I could say so far as every man in the House is concerned—we want to stand behind the Government. I put it to the President that if this is a national matter, as it is a national matter, if this is a great crisis, as it is a great crisis, we ought to have, not a party Government, but a national Government to handle it. I do not mind the smiles or the sneers on one side of the House or the other. I do not mind the sneers of Irishmen, but I am not going to stand for the sneers of men who are not Irish.
Comment on this
I can relate it quite easily, if you so desire, to stamp duties. Stamp duties are wide enough to be related to anything.
Comment on this
I suggest in all sincerity that if the President wants to rally the country and this House behind him he ought to let us know where he stands. He ought to act as if this were a national matter and not a party matter. I do not want, if I may say so without incurring your displeasure, a Chinn Comhairle, to enter into the merits or demerits of the Bill itself——
Comment on this
Might I again suggest that the only matter which it is proper for the House to discuss is whether the paragraphs which it is proposed to delete are necessary for the purposes of the Bill or not.
Comment on this
The Minister is right in his suggestion, but I have allowed a certain latitude to previous speakers. Nevertheless, I cannot allow this to become a Second Reading debate.
Comment on this
The interjection made by the Minister for Finance shows that he does not want a national Government to face a national issue.
Comment on this
There is not a national Government. The Minister for Finance has repudiated any suggestion that we should have a national Government and that the nation should be rallied 100 per cent. I expected nothing else from the Minister for Finance. I certainly expected better from the President.
Comment on this
No explanation has been given in this House or in the Seanad as to these stamp duties. Many of us can see that there are reasons for giving the Government power to meet the Act passed by the British Government and now being acted upon. What we are concerned about is how this Bill may be used against our own people and not against the British. That is the main point. In my opinion, there is more power given in this Bill to injure the Irish people than there is to injure the people of Great Britain. That is my main reason for objecting to it. My sole reason in standing up and, indeed, my sole reason for travelling to Dublin to-day, was to ask the President to give the lead so that we might have a united Oireachtas and a united Government to meet any onslaught upon us that was not justified.
Comment on this
With your permission, sir, I propose to speak on these recommendations in respect of this section on matters that have been reported as happening at Ottawa yesterday. I propose to relate what I propose to say to the question before the House in this way: This House, under a guillotine motion, passed a measure called the "Emergency Imposition of Duties Bill, 1932," and which in clause (f) gives them power to impose "whether with or without qualifications, limitations, allowances, exemptions or preferential rates, a stamp duty on any particular description of document or transaction as from any specified day and for the purpose of such duty, require a document or a particular form of document to be used in or in connection with any particular description of transaction."
The Seanad has asked and recommended that that clause should be deleted. The Minister refused to accept the Seanad's recommendation. The only phrase bearing upon this particular paragraph used in the Seanad, for none was used here, was that the paragraph was designed to give the Government all the control they wanted over insurance corporations. I want to test how far the Government are in line with what their delegates are doing at Ottawa, as shown in the report of the proceedings in this morning's newspapers, by asking whether or not they are prepared to drop that power with regard to insurance. Top hats have appeared at Ottawa. Some of these top hats will have to be insured on the way home. If there is to be an avoidance of civil strife and commotion, it will be necessary to go to an outside company to insure these top hats. A certain type of clothing has also appeared at Ottawa, clothing which will be regarded, presumably, as likely to cause civil strife and commotion here. At a recent ceremonial here, an almost sacred occasion in the history of the country, this clothing could not be used. Yet it was used yesterday in Ottawa. Is there to be any indication given by the Ministry as to how far they are in agreement with the attitude adopted in Ottawa? Are they going to stick to their demand for power to impose stamp duties on transactions of insurance companies which may be asked to insure the top hats and the type of clothing worn in Ottawa when it is being brought into this country? I think all these aspects of the situation in Ottawa come up for discussion on this Bill. We have seen a new policy adopted over there. Our delegates as they become irreproachable in dress appear to have become more approachable in manner. That they may continue to be so will be the fervent prayer of everybody here. If they continue in that manner there may be no necessity for an emergency measure of this sort.
Comment on this
I submit that while it may be in order to discuss a customs duty on top hats one is not entitled to discuss the attire or the policy of any party at Ottawa. What we have to decide here is the advisability of accepting or rejecting the recommendations.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I am discussing the necessity for giving the Government power to impose a stamp duty in regard to insurance transactions of a certain type on top hats. That is in order surely.
Comment on this
Except in so far as it can be brought within the scope of the top hat. The top hat at Ottawa may be very unhealthy as far as policy is concerned. I am taking it for instance that there has been a departure with regard to that. I am sure that if the selection of Ministers for Ottawa were made on the basis of those who could wear the top hat with dignity——
Comment on this
Surely this is in order, to call attention to the stamp duties which may be imposed on certain insurance transactions—insurance for instance on the top hats worn at Ottawa. We may find that such top hats cannot be insured at home. The discussion of such a stamp duty and the new policy observable at Ottawa——
Comment on this
The discussion of a stamp duty is in order but the policy adumbrated at Ottawa is not, nor is the question of whether top hats should be worn.
Comment on this
We are told the State must have control of insurance. Why are they so anxious about the insurance? One immediately turns one's eyes on reading the papers to the likelihood that they are afraid of a hostile demonstration against the wearers of the tall hats and the new departure at Ottawa when they come back. I submit it is permissible to argue that the policy at Ottawa appears to be inconsistent with the retention of this section. I think we should have some explanation from the Ministry as to why they want to hold on to the section. The only thing we are told about this is that they wanted to get control of insurance. I am approaching that question apropos of what happened at Ottawa, what I call the new departure and how far that new departure is going to affect the retention of these powers in regard to the stamp duty on insurance transactions and I am entitled to get an answer. It has been referred to as a small matter although it was made a big matter here. There has been another orientation of policy which is very welcome but which again might lead to the imposition——
Comment on this
I submit that the Deputy is not entitled even to state that there has been an orientation of policy.
Comment on this
I make the point that if there has been a change in policy it would affect the Bill and affect every clause in the Bill.
Comment on this
A reference to a change of policy (as it affects the Seanad recommendations) might be relevant, but a discussion on change of policy is not relevant.
Comment on this
May I suggest that the Minister for Finance has hardly even allowed a reference to policy, he is so anxious to cloak it?
Comment on this
I did not discuss the change of policy any further than to say it is welcome and to point out how far it has gone——
Comment on this
This is a matter in which I suggest the Deputy is out of order. Am I not entitled to call your attention to that, sir?
Comment on this
The Minister is entitled, as any other Deputy is entitled, to call the attention of the Chair to the fact that a Deputy is in his opinion out of order.
Comment on this
Is the Minister entitled to say persistently that a Deputy is out of order when he has not been ruled out of order?
Comment on this
That is the point I make. The Minister has said persiscently that the Deputy has been out of order although he has not been ruled out of order. I suggest that it is the Minister who is out of order.
Comment on this
The Ministry desires certain powers in certain circumstances, in the circumstances in which this economic war seems to be not merely inevitable but to be immediately upon us. There has been a change, I insist, and I want to show merely for the purpose of pointing out why this clause should be dropped that this is one of the ways in which they can show that they are affected by what has happened beyond the seas. I suggest that the powers which were given to them some days ago no longer appear to be necessary because of what has happened. For that purpose, I must refer to what has happened. The Conference opened as all Conferences open with a declaration. Although we have not got the text of that declaration we notice that it has been called by the descriptive writers a loyal address. We notice that what purports to be a quotation is given in one of the papers, that a message of goodwill and devotion has been sent by the representatives of the Governments of the British Commonwealth——
Comment on this
The Deputy has been told from the Chair that a discussion of the proceedings at Ottawa would be out of order.
Comment on this
I do not intend to go into the matter of attending the ceremonies. I only refer to the fact that certain things happened and to note that a certain resolution was passed and a certain message was received, and that it was a very good thing that that resolution was passed and that that message was received. It shows that people out there representing this Government have turned their backs on their own pledges——
Comment on this
Is the Deputy in order in even referring to the attitude of the delegation over there?
Comment on this
I had finished when the interruption of the Minister for Finance called me back again and all I wanted to say was that we have representatives there who assisted at certain things that were done yesterday and which when done on another occasion they described as hogwash. That is the last point. If the Minister has any other points to make I wish he would make them now, or make them all at once and let us get on.
Comment on this
There is a new situation and in that new situation the plea made by many people in this House last week is reinforced and has greater weight when made now. There was an appeal made many times by Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Morrissey that we should cast out the lawyers as far as this business is concerned, and get down to some sort of definite conference recalling the whole situation of 1925, relating that to the new circumstances and seeing what can be done. That plea has been made. Instead of answering that, what are Ministers doing? They are going to have this Bill as it stood, as if nothing had happened and as if there had been no change yesterday at Ottawa. They are going ahead with the demand that they must be allowed to attack foreign insurance companies. One of the biggest insurance companies doing business here is a company with its headquarters in Canada. Is that to be attacked? If it is attacked will it be attacked before our delegates can go further on their new path or until there is another long distance telephone message in Irish to say that there has been a new spirit here, and that the spirit is shown by those attacks on foreign insurance companies being dropped? Is there to be any sign that the Ministry has come to the conclusion that legally, and because of fraud, and because of what Deputy Morrissey said——
Comment on this
Once more on a point of order. Is the Deputy entitled, in discussing this amendment, to state that the Government's legal case is a fraud? The point is this: The Seanad has accepted the principle of the Bill. As the principle of the Bill has been accepted, the only thing the Deputy is entitled to discuss is whether the stamp duties are, or are not, necessary to carry out the policy of the Government?
Comment on this
Here is a sub-section that gives limitless power of taxation to the present Executive Council, and we are entitled to discuss every single bit of the policy of that Executive Council who are to decide. Those particular individuals who sit on the Executive Council at present are the persons into whose hands you are going to give limitless power of taxation, free from the control of the Oireachtas for eight months.
Comment on this
The Deputy is mistaken in maintaining that he is free to discuss every aspect of the policy of the Government in a debate on the particular recommendations sent down by the Seanad. I have given a certain amount of liberty to previous speakers. I am disposed to be equally liberal with other speakers, but we must get away from the question of our policy at Ottawa.
Comment on this
I may not have made myself clear. Here the Government are declaring that any transaction between any two individuals, in this State, must be carried out in a written document and that that is to be subject to a tax imposed by them to any amount they like. That is a power no Government ever asked for before. It is a limitless power of drawing upon the resources of the people of this State. Are we not entitled, when the Executive Council are asking for these unprecedented powers, to discuss what use the Executive Council is likely to make of these powers if they have them? How are you to know what use they are likely to make of these powers unless you consider their position?
Comment on this
I think the matter is now quite clear. I may have to repeat a little bit of what I said. The Government because they adopted a certain earlier line of policy decided that they must have a certain measure. I feel there has been a certain orientation of policy, in the last couple of days, and I want them to mark their appreciation of that by dropping one of the powers, which they thought necessary to have, when this Bill was being discussed previously. I ask them to drop the most drastic of these powers—the one that can be used in the most unfair way, the one that can lead to gross unfairness and partiality even as between individuals if it operates at all. So far as the other powers are concerned, that of customs duties and excise duties, these are likely to be applied to classes, to a particular main type that comes within named categories, but in regard to this, they may impose stamp duties on any particular document or transaction as therein specified. It gives unlimited control to the Ministry and a control which I think they ought not to possess.
I do not pretend to be able to interpret the meaning of this section. I should like if the Minister for Justice were here to give us his interpretation but he is always absent when legal documents are under consideration. I should like to have got his opinion as to whether or not we have the power to impose stamp duties on any particular transaction or licensing, and in fact powers to differentiate between individuals. There is no good in the Ministry telling us that they will not use that power. We are talking of the power the House is asked to give and the Minister for Justice should be here to interpret and determine this matter. He has been notorious throughout the session for his absence and his silence. He has become as close as an oyster. He has even the oyster's complexes. The oyster does not like months without the letter "R" in them. The Minister does not like associations without an R in them.
Comment on this
On a point of order, what has the absence or the presence of the Minister for Justice to do with the particular recommendation we are now considering?
Comment on this
They have neither discussed nor explained this in the House. It is time we heard from them, before this power is granted, what use is going to be made of it, and whether they are going to persist in the use of this clause. I said that the only expression of opinion given us by the Ministry was that it was for the purpose of controlling foreign insurance companies in the way of stamp duties, and certain insurance transactions. How is it going to be possible after it is passed and the damage is done to the insurance companies to withdraw from that position? That is the plea Deputy Morrissey has joined Deputy Cosgrave in making.
Before any foolish action is taken on these very wide powers, there should be another pause, in order that the Ministry would consider if it would not be well to get a real national issue on this, such as they have not at the moment; to drop these foolish Party lawyers. It is useless appealing to the Minister for Finance because he is a man who must argue for going forward with this bit of folly. Drop all the nonsense of equating war debts and reparations with commercial debts. Here you have a situation in which a commercial debt was accepted. If you point to changed circumstances and adopt ordinary methods of conciliation and consent the matter can be settled. A national cause can be made in this. It is not the one that has been made. There is a national approach. It is not the one being made. There is a national way of arguing it. It is not the one being adopted by the Ministry. There is even a national sign that might be made at the moment, by dropping some of the powers asked for, in appreciation of the fact that there has been some attempt to approach the situation at Ottawa. If these hopes are disappointed at this the last stage—and I do not suppose Ministers are asking for powers unless they intend to operate them—and if they get these powers in the mood that they have shown there is every fear that they will be operated. If they tackle a big thing like insurance, which was a problem that faced the people who were the Government for ten years, as the right way and the method for reprisal and retaliation, there is going to be enormous damage done to the people of this country, and the people who are going to be harmed are those who should least be harmed. Possibly they have unselfishly put aside the money, not for themselves but for their dependants. The Government may find by their hasty action that the securities of a very generous and unselfish type of people are imperilled, or ruined, if there is an attack on foreign insurance companies which have been allowed to practise in this country without any criticism. That is why there should be some response from the Ministry to the appeal made to-day, before we proceed to take the first step, from which there can be no withdrawal until this is fought to the bitter end.
Comment on this
It is all very well for Deputies opposite to laugh and to run away as they vanished the last day when we produced some letters. We had the usual statement from the Opposition to-day. Deputy Cosgrave said, "Kiss and be friends." That was the cry of Deputy Cosgrave to-day but, while the delay goes on, and while every effort is being made to delay proceedings both here and in the other Chamber our people are being crushed by Britain. I wonder the appeal was not made to Mr. Thomas, to take the 20 per cent. tariff off our cattle. It was made here where they are doing England's work by delaying and preventing any reprisal against Britain. That is their job— the legion of the rearguard. That is evidently portion of the job Deputies opposite have got from Mr. Thomas.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not charge any Deputy or party in this House, with taking orders from any outside source.
Comment on this
The Deputy withdrew a lot in his time. We were told about the problem before us and the losses that farmers have suffered. Farmers have far more patriotism than Deputies opposite. Farmers through their public representatives are supporting the Government in the fight they are making. I was present at a county council meeting yesterday, where my Party is in a small minority, and that council unanimously supported the action the Government are taking in this——
Comment on this
The Deputy would want to know a lot about them. What would have happened to the farming community if the Party opposite had been returned to office? Where would the farmers be now?
Comment on this
Where are the thousands of writs that were held up during the election period, to be let loose on the farmers immediately after the General Election? Where would the farmers be now with that sheaf of writs?
Comment on this
Having got sufficient latitude in his introductory remarks the Deputy might give his views on the stamp duties.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Deputy has made a statement in connection with the Department of Lands and Fisheries that writs were held up during the election period and launched immediately afterwards. As the Minister for Lands and Fisheries is the head of the Department, what has he to say to that?
Comment on this
I think anybody who saw the condition of affairs immediately after the General Election need have no doubt whatever——
Comment on this
Up to the present I have only dealt with the statements that are being made. I consider that the Ministry are entitled to the fullest powers necessary to deal with the situation before us. The Government should be given whatever powers they think necessary and I do not believe that these powers should be hampered in any way or held up in any way. Deputy McGilligan stated——
Comment on this
On a point of information. Would the Deputy tell us what powers the Government are getting under these two sub-sections?
Comment on this
I can assure the Deputy that it is long since a smoke screen was seen here. Deputy McGilligan said that these new duties would enable the Government to differentiate between individuals. That was for long the policy of the previous Executive Council here and I do not see why they should growl if the Government and the Deputies supporting the Government agree that there was to be differentiation between individuals. I do not believe there would be any differentiation but if there was I see no reason why Deputies opposite should growl about it. Under a previous Bill passed here if the ex-Minister for Justice did not like the colour of my tie he could deport me out of the country. The Executive Council who got those powers come up here now and complain because we are looking for the fullest powers we can get in order to deal with this crisis. That is their whole complaint. The whole cry here seems to be a cry for time and for delay. Delay for what? To delay the powers of the Irish Government to defend the Irish people. That is what Deputies opposite are actually doing—delaying the powers of the Government to defend the people. The Irish people are not behind the Deputies opposite in that action.
Comment on this
We know very well. There is a seat vacant, a seat that will soon be filled whenever the Deputies opposite have pluck enough to look for it. There is a seat vacant in my constituency for the past four months. The Opposition had a majority of 4,000 in that constituency at the general election and yet they have not the pluck to look for that seat. Still we have the cry of a general election. Deputy Gorey wanted an appeal to the people, while down in my constituency there is a vacant seat since the general election and the Deputies opposite have not the courage to fight it. When they sent down their organiser he came back with his tail behind his legs and he told them that the Irish people were not going to stand behind any renegades.
Comment on this
Very well, I will deal with the stamp duties now. I maintain that any powers that the Executive Council require should be given to them at once. There has been already far too much delay in this. It is close on a fortnight now since England took action and our farmers have been facing up to it since then. Thank God, the farmers have stood up to it and, as I stated here previously, the farmers will not be the first to squeal in this fight.
Comment on this
No fear. Deputy Bennett is squealing but Deputy Bennett is no farmer. The decentest thing for the Deputies opposite to do is to support this Bill, but I am afraid it is too late now to make an appeal to them. They have done the damage. The supporters of the Party opposite down the country have shown far more patriotism in this fight than they have. They have in open batches thrown their whole weight in this fight on the side of the Government. Deputy Cosgrave looked for negotiations. We have heard any amount of appeals for negotiations. We have offered arbitration in this matter. We are as much entitled to say whether we would get arbitration as the British Government are.
Comment on this
If the Deputy cannot get away from arbitration and the land annuities and get on to stamp duties he had better sit down.
Comment on this
As far as stamp duties are concerned, there is undoubtedly a large amount of money leaving the country and going over to Britain yearly and it is about time that people here who are so unpatriotic as to send their money to Britain should have some action taken against them by the Government so as to compel them to leave that money at home.
Comment on this
Deputy Bennett should not talk at all, the Deputy who said 9d. per week was enough for the support of a child.
Comment on this
I maintain it is our right to say that we are to keep enough money here to pay the farmers and that the farmers should get back at least whatever they lose under the new duties imposed by the British Government. We want this money to reimburse the farmers for what they may lose over the duties. That I take it is the principal object of the stamp duties. If it is, then more power to the stamp duties. I believe that is one of the principal ways in which we can get money.
Comment on this
Do I understand from the Deputy that when he says the stamp duties are for the purpose of recouping the farmers for whatever losses they incur under the duties imposed by Great Britain he is speaking for the Government—is that the Government policy?
Comment on this
Unfortunately I am like Deputy O'Neill; I cannot speak for anybody. As far as Deputy O'Neill is concerned, I do not believe that he can speak for the Opposition any more than Deputy Blythe did the other day. I am giving as my opinion that this is one of the reasons why the stamp duty should be imposed and it is one of the reasons why I am supporting it. It is necessary for us to take the money that is leaving this country every year. That money should be taxed and kept here. We are sick of the delaying actions of the Opposition as revealed here in the last fortnight. Undoubtedly the delaying action of the Deputies opposite is injuring our farmers. I am sure the Deputies on the opposite benches realise that. I am sure there is intelligence enough there, not in the Front Bench—but there is enough intelligence on the Back Benches opposite. There is intelligence enough there to realise that even at this late hour it is their duty to do what their comrades down the country have done and that is to throw in their support behind Ireland in this fight. I ask them to stop this stabbing in the back attitude. That attitude is nothing else but stabbing in the back. Any one of them who reads the Press weekly——
Comment on this
The Deputy will have to get away from the Press and get down to the stamp duties or sit down.
Comment on this
I know it is practically useless. I know I could not change the minds of men like Deputy Bennett because, unfortunately, he has no mind to change. There may be others there who have some glimmering of intelligence.
Comment on this
I must again ask the Deputy either to come to the stamp duties or to resume his seat.
Comment on this
I am giving my reasons as to why these stamp duties should remain portion of the Bill. I have put these reasons before the House and I am sure if the Deputies opposite consider them they will not continue fighting the delaying action here for the benefit of Britain.
Comment on this
The spirit behind the speech just delivered by Deputy Corry is in my opinion and may I say in the opinion of members of this small group, the kind of speech that is not likely to pave the way for national unity or for a peaceful settlement of the issues in dispute. I sincerely hope that that speech or the spirit behind it does not represent the general viewpoint of the Fianna Fáil Government or the Fianna Fáil Party on this matter. The members of this small group who have a very serious responsibility to shoulder in this matter have left nothing undone either privately or publicly to use their influence in order to try and bring about a friendly settlement of the issues in dispute. In doing that, we are not going to advise the Government to surrender on this issue. Deputy Cosgrave, in a speech seriously and sincerely delivered, pointed out the necessity for accommodation, and said that it was necessary to explore every possible channel for the purpose of endeavouring to arrive at a national viewpoint on the issues now in dispute. I accept that speech, as having been delivered in a friendly spirit, in the same spirit in which I, and the members of this Party, accept the greater portion of the speech delivered by Deputy McGilligan on Friday last. There is no necessity to call for a national Government in order to have a fair settlement in the interests of this nation. We are not asking for that, at any rate, and, personally, I see no necessity for it.
What would likely happen in any civilised country in the world to-day, if such a country, say, France or Germany, or any other European country, were faced with the position, with which this country is faced at present, is that the principal leaders of all the parties would come together, either behind the scenes, or publicly, for the purpose of endeavouring to put their best brains together in order to have the best possible settlement secured in the interests of the whole people of the country. Is the speech delivered by Deputy Cosgrave to-day and by Deputy McGilligan last Friday, any indication of the willingness of the Opposition to help in that direction? If it is, I and the members of this Party accept it and I am sure the nation as a whole will accept it.
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy Minch would reserve his sarcastic remarks concerning prominent members of the Labour Party until the time when he comes to deliver his speech, if he is capable of delivering one. Deputy Cosgrave, in that serious minded and very sincere speech, rightly pointed out the possible consequences of the passage of this measure, if the measure were used, as, I believe, it will not be used, for the purpose of inflicting punishment on our own people. I have sufficient knowledge of what is in the mind of President de Valera, and, perhaps, other members of his Ministry, to believe that it will not be used for that purpose. It is a defensive measure. I would like to have heard from Deputy Cosgrave or Deputy McGilligan, and I hope I will hear from Deputy Mulcahy when he comes to speak, what is the viewpoint of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party as to the action of the British Government in launching this economic war. Are they right or justified in the action they have taken in precipitating this economic war?
Comment on this
And might I ask Deputy Mulcahy, if he can speak on behalf of the whole of his Front Bench, to say whether they would agree, that, as a preliminary to the resumption of friendly negotiations, the British should be called on to withdraw that Act which they have put into operation and which is still in operation?
Comment on this
I will make my own speech and the Deputy can speak after me, if he likes. I realise that in an economic war—and every Labour man who has any kind of national or Labour outlook realises—the plain people are bound to suffer for the sins of the politicians, and I believe that it is not beyond the bounds of statesmanship, even at this stage, to have some kind of approach on behalf of the parties interested to prevent the terrible consequences of the carrying on of such an economic war, with the support of the different parties behind it. The only knowledge or experience that any of us, or our forefathers, could have of an economic war is the effect of the boycott carried on in the Land League days and this was not supported by Parliamentary action. Let us have at this stage of our career, at this special meeting of the Dáil, in this Eucharistic Congress year, some of the real Eucharistic Congress spirit. That is the viewpoint that those of us who sit on these benches are asking the two big Parties to take. Surely the bitterness of the past should be forgotten in a national issue of this kind, in an issue which may mean a great deal and which may mean millions of pounds, and, I believe, will mean millions of pounds, to the people of this country, if national unity can be secured and if we can have national unity in facing the whole issue as we now know it?
Comment on this
The Deputy has been allowed five minutes for his introductory remarks. He should now deal with the recommendations from the Seanad.