We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Emergency Imposition of Duties Bill, 1932 (From the Seanad) In Committee.

Contributions 310–498 of 498. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Emergency Imposition of Duties Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 23 of 1932 ›

"Answer the arguments"—what were the arguments?

Comment on this

Who paid for England's case?

Comment on this

There were four "Yesses" and one "No" stated by certain people. That is not argument.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

There were four "Yesses" and a "No," but apparently the Attorney-General took them so seriously that it took him and his collaborators 65 pages to answer them.

Comment on this

But the Attorney-General must remember that the word "argument" was put up. They were statements of opinion, without any argument.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

Apparently, it took 65 pages of pretended argument to dispose of the four "Yesses" and the "No."

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Might I put one question to the Attorney-General? Deputy Hogan made a very striking statement in his speech. He said that if there was a legal case for retaining these annuities, which he denied, it could only arise out of the neglect of the late Government to implement an international agreement by making it legally watertight. Does the Attorney-General accept that statement?

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for Defence (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

Does Deputy MacDermot know——

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Let him answer.

Comment on this

——that Deputy Hogan's knowledge of the law is not worth twopence according to himself?

Comment on this

I suggest that the Attorney-General be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

Hear, hear! Keep Aiken quiet.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

On the last occasion when this question of the agreement was mentioned some Deputies seemed to treat the suggestion that England, when asked to make her legal case for the retention of the annuities, relied upon these two agreements of 1923 and 1926. It was suggested that it was not a legal question as to whether these agreements were binding or not. I do not know whether that is seriously argued or not, or whether it can be suggested that agreements which deal with the payment of money are binding whether there is Parliamentary ratification or not. On that matter, I shall just quote one passage from Halsbury's "Laws of England:"

Where a grant of the public funds is rendered necessary it is apprehended that the previous or subsequent consent of Parliament is in all cases required to render the treaty binding upon the subject and enforceable by the officers of the Crown.

For Deputy McGilligan's information I may say that that is from Vol. 6, page 441, of Halsbury's "Laws of England." So that the question as to whether this particular agreement is binding or not is a legal question and has been put up as one of the legal questions involved and put up by the British. It is rather striking that they put up, as obliging us to transmit these annuities to England, not alone the 1923 agreement but the 1926 agreement, although the previous Attorney-General and the others who advised stated that was an agreement which did not oblige us to make any payment at all, while Mr. Thomas is advised that it is an agreement which obliged us to pay.

I do not wish to deal any further with the legal side of the matter. There is only one other matter. It was suggested that some explanation was necessary of this section of the Bill. I do not know whether anybody takes seriously the attempt to criticise the wording of the Bill as conferring very wide powers. I had occasion recently to read the history of another Bill in which Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, when Minister for Justice, sought wide powers, not for matters of money or material matters, but wide powers over the liberty of the citizen in the Constitution (Amendment) Act (No. 17), which was guillotined through the House, and the Committee Stage of which went through without any discussion whatever—absolutely no discussion. The Opposition are so perturbed about what material injury may be done by the wide powers being conferred in this Bill on the Executive that they have raised their hands in horror at the unconstitutional things which are being done. The title of the Bill states that it is an Emergency Bill. It is an Emergency Bill introduced under what are admitted by all parties to be more or less war circumstances; circumstances in which drastic and wide powers are considered necessary by the Executive. I am quite sure that anybody who is genuinely anxious to enable us to deal with the situation which may arise cannot hesitate to give us the powers asked for in the Bill.

Comment on this

I move: "That the question be now put."

Comment on this

Before that question is put, may I ask a question? Deputy MacDermot put a question to the Attorney-General. Will he now answer that question?

Comment on this

Is Deputy MacDermot the legal adviser now?

Comment on this

I move: "That the question be now put."

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am accepting the motion, "That the question be now put."

Comment on this

Could I contradict the statement made by Deputy Kennedy that the farmers of Westmeath are behind the Government?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No. There can be no debate after the acceptance of a motion for the closure.

Comment on this

The farmers are in a panic.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the question be now put."

Tá 70
·
Níl 60
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Division

Question put: "That Recommendations 1 and 2 be rejected."

Tá 71
·
Níl 60
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move: That we accept the following recommendations from the Seanad:

3. Section 1, sub-section (3). After the word "sub-section" in lines 28-29 to insert the words "or which is revoked by an order made under this section."

4. Section 1, sub-section (3). After the word "cesser" in line 30, and within the bracket, to insert the words "or revocation."

Comment on this

I move: That recommendation 5 be accepted:

Section 1. To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

(4) If when an order under this section is made or at any time thereafter and before such order is confirmed by Act of the Oireachtas or is revoked under this section or ceases to have statutory effect Dáil Eireann stands adjourned for a period of more than ten days and if during such adjournment a majority of the members of Dáil Eireann by notice in writing given to the Ceann Comhairle of Dáil Eireann require Dáil Eireann to be summoned, the said Ceann Comhairle shall summon Dáil Eireann to meet on a day named by him not being more than twenty-one days after the receipt by the said Ceann Comhairle of such notice nor less than ten days after the issue of such summons.

Comment on this

The proposal in this recommendation suggests that the Dáil is going to be given power over the course of events in the immediate future.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy opening a debate on recommendation 5?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is entitled to speak.

Comment on this

I just wanted to know that.

Comment on this

It is suggested here that the Dáil is to have power to take action in connection with circumstances that may arise in the near future. If the spirit of the majority of the House is to be the spirit of the President and of the members of the Fianna Fáil Party who have spoken these powers will be no use. The Labour Party have emphasised on more than one occasion that they are an independent body, tied to the tail of no party. Some of the speakers on the Labour Benches to-day emphasised the fact that they stand for peace and that they want the powers that are enshrined in this measure to be used only for the benefit of the people and that as far as their powers go they are determined to see that the interests of the people will be protected in every possible way. It is only because of this advance from the Labour Benches that I think there is any usefulness in this particular section, because the House has had put before it a measure containing certain powers. I think no powers like them have been sought even in this country for hundreds of years. I think it was in 1721— whatever kind of Government there was here at the time—that the Parliament in Dublin had put before it a proposal that supplies should be voted for twenty-one years. That proposal was defeated by one vote. From the attitude of the Labour Party here for some time past if there had been a similar party in that Parliament supplies would have been voted by a majority of six for the twenty-one years. The powers in this Bill are such that the President's acceptance of this recommendation is very cynical. Both from the Labour Benches and the Fianna Fáil Benches it has been made clear that there are some people who realise the very critical nature of the present situation and the terrible dangers that may arise from a prolongation of it. Deputy Dillon thinks that the President realises it. The President always acts too late. He always sees common ground when the opportunity of taking part in a discussion on common ground has passed. On the other hand, Deputy Davin seems hopeful although he spoke perhaps with two voices.

Comment on this

At any rate hopefully because I would not be referring to the matter at all if it had not been for some sign of hope from the Labour Benches to-day. The Deputy has declared that the proper Government in this or in any other country especially, under the proportional representation system of election, is to have it always dependent on the existence of a strong and efficient Opposition Party. That is inscribed in the hearts of the people of Edenderry as one of his first political maxims.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy quoting from? Is it the "Irish Independent"?

Comment on this

I can give the Deputy the quotation. The Deputy has subscribed to that. He and his colleagues, for whatever particular reason, in the discussion of the details of this Bill have silenced all the strength and the effectiveness of the Opposition Party. This recommendation here indicates what the Labour Deputy admitted here to-day—that they have a very heavy responsibility. That is they have the responsibility of asking to have the Dáil called together should the circumstances from their point of view dictate that course is advisable between this and the normal date of assembly, the 19th October. I think we are really entitled to some indication from the Labour Party as to the particular circumstances that they think would warrant the calling together of the Dáil. At the present moment there are in Dublin 14,600 registered unemployed as against 7,200 this time last year. I know it is argued from the Government Benches that instructions are in existence at the present moment which tend to increase the number of registered unemployed beyond what it was when they came into office. That is they have invited people to register on the understanding that the distribution of relief grants and the institution of public works will be regulated according to the number of people registered as unemployed in each locality. As a matter of fact we have the extraordinary position——

Comment on this

On a point of order I do not know how this could arise out of the recommendation.

Comment on this

I suggest I am in order in asking on this particular amendment how much unemployment in Dublin must increase before, from the point of view of the Labour Party here, circumstances will have arisen that will warrant their having the Dáil called together.

Comment on this

That is a hypothetical question.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is in order in putting the question as to when they consider the powers given under this recommendation should be exercised but he is not in order in going into the details of unemployment. If he were, any other problem might be taken up in a similar way.

Comment on this

To-day on the eve of plunging into an economic war, the volume of unemployment is twice what it was this time last year. The tendency from the time the Fianna Fáil Party came into office has been this—that between the 14th March this year and 14th July there was an increase of 3,000 in the number of unemployed whereas there was a decrease of 1,000 in the same period last year. There is an increase of unemployment here in Dublin. As I say, that is on the eve of this economic war. The tendency is in the direction of increasing unemployment particularly in the City of Dublin. I want to ask the Labour Deputies again have they considered what further increase in unemployment in the City of Dublin under the conditions that may obtain after to-day will warrant their calling for the assembly of the Dáil? The Labour Party take a certain amount of pride, and they are entitled to it, in the fact that they have set down in black and white their political programme. They have pointed out in their political programme that they regard agriculture as the real foundation of wealth.

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy a question?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

With the Deputy's permission.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy opposing the motion to accept the recommendation of the Seanad?

Comment on this

I am not opposing the motion.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is not opposing the motion he is wasting the time of the House. Accordingly I move that the question be now put.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I shall hear the Deputy further.

Comment on this

One of the particular industries that will be injured will be our agricultural industry. And so important have the Labour Party, sitting down in full examination of the situation, considered the position of our exports of agricultural produce, that in dealing with the question of agriculture in about nine paragraphs of their booklet, "The Nation Organised," they say in one of the very first paragraphs as regards our produce, paragraph 45:—

We firmly support the policy of improving the quality of livestock and animal products generally so as to obtain the highest possible price in the markets of Great Britain. We also support every well considered attempt to improve marketing methods and strongly favour the proposals for organising the export trade, on cooperative lines, so as to eliminate unnecessary expenses between the farmer here and the consumer in Great Britain. We believe that a failure to improve the position of Free State produce in the British markets relative to that of competing countries, would mean rapid retrogression involving enormous loss and all possible efforts should be made to place our goods at the head of the market.

Comment on this

I submit the Deputy is altogether out of order.

Comment on this

I want to ask for the information of Deputies here, who realise, as Deputy Dillon suggested, the terrible distress that lies before us as the outcome of the policy the Government is pursuing at the present moment, and I want to ask the members of the Labour Party who are in a peculiar position a question——

Comment on this

On a point of explanation I think I made it very clear this day week what the position of the Labour Party is. I might inform Deputy Mulcahy and Deputy Morrissey that on that occasion I put the position of the Labour Party very clearly.

Comment on this

The Labour Party are credited with being the friends of the rural areas. I accepted Deputy Davin's statement here in the Dáil that they are acting as the representatives of the people. With regard to Deputy Curran I ask him as far as the County Dublin is concerned, and I ask Deputy Corish, as far as the County Wexford is concerned, how many months of economic war, stopping the export of our agricultural produce to Great Britain, is going to be tolerated by the labourers before they have to be called together and asked to discuss this matter. Are we likely to have them called together, or are we likely to have the Dáil called together; which by the way can only be done with the consent of the Labour Party, while this boycott and, perhaps, complete stoppage of our agricultural export produce, is going on without any opportunity being given to the Dáil to discuss the matter?

Comment on this

You are the man who prevented the Dáil meeting in 1922.

Comment on this

Yes, certainly. It has been pointed out that the farmers are very badly hit. The information to hand, in the recent statistical volumes published, shows that the volume of trade up to date, has been practically consistent. So that so far as distribution is concerned the number of people employed has been constant in the whole of the community.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of distribution, production or employment does not arise on this motion.

Comment on this

Nor the Labour Party either.

Comment on this

What does arise is how long with the authority of the Labour Pearty——

Comment on this

Is Deputy Mulcahy lecturing the Labour Party as to their responsibility or is he lecturing the House?

Comment on this

We have been told that the Labour Party recognise their responsibilities.

Comment on this

Are you lecturing them upon that?

Comment on this

I am trying to get information for this House and, therefore, for the people as to certain things. It was Deputy Norton who told us to-day that they were not going to accept peace at any price. We are entitled to know from Deputy Norton what price we are going to pay for the satisfaction of being engaged in an economic war and at what price we are going to stop rather than continue it. We here can deal with our own affairs quite effectively, but we ought to know something of the prospects before us.

Comment on this

You will know that when it happens.

Comment on this

We will know that when it happens, and then we will have the Fianna Fáil Party in the position they are in to-day looking back at the "might have been" for the last ten years.

Comment on this

We might have you in Arbour Hill.

Comment on this

And trying to find out what ground would be available to discuss national affairs.

Comment on this

Where are you on that?

Comment on this

I want to know where Deputy Davin is as to the extent to which he is going to pay the price for war that he would not be prepared to pay for peace. I would again suggest to the Labour Party that these are matters that require the very fullest concentration. Again we are told we are entering upon an economic war and the President sees no way out of it. If that is so there is then one very serious danger and that is that the Jingoism that we have here to-day will increase in volume. I ask the Labour Party again to look back over their programme and especially to page 46. There we find the statement:—

The Labour Party would insist upon securing for the Free State every advantage accruing from any international agreement to which the country is a party. But declarations of policy on issues between nations, particularly on questions relating to finance and debts ought not to be made in the language of challenge and defiance.

Comment on this

I submit, on a point of order, this is an entirely obstructional speech.

Comment on this

Obstructing what?

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy a question?

Comment on this
Deputies

No, no.

Comment on this

The Deputy can make a speech when I am done. Their programme continues:—

The Jingo politicians of small nations, as of great, are notorious for the disastrous consequences of their leadership, financial and political. The chances of a favourable revision of the financial agreements with Britain have been seriously injured by statements made in the course of party controversy.

Comment on this

By you and others.

Comment on this

I take it that Deputy Davin will be entitled to speak after me if he wishes. Are we to-day, seeing powers such as are given to the Executive Council, doing anything favourable to effect a favourable revision of the financial agreements with Britain?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order. To-day we have spent most of the seven hours which were supposed to be devoted to the question of agreement or disagreement with the recommendations, to the discussion of that very matter. On this particular question neither the financial arrangement, nor the land annuities are in order.

Comment on this

My reason for not intervening before was that I appreciated your difficulty, a Chinn Comhairle, in regard to questions of order and I felt that my remarks would be more appropriate on this particular question. I am simply pleading in this with the Labour Party, who are the only party in this House who can make this amendment, accepted by the President so cynically, effective to give the Dáil control over the circumstances that are going to follow the putting into operation of the matters now before us, if this measure is going to be put into operation for the protection of the people. But the protection of the people demand that they be guarded against an additional and excessive increase in unemployment that is promised here; that they be guarded against the destruction of our agricultural export industry in the circumstances that all farming Deputies are aware of here, and that have been pointed out by Deputy Gorey. If the whole position with regard to unemployment in certain sections of our transport and distributive trade is to be brought to any particularly great figure, that is going to bring about a position that cannot be remedied.

Comment on this

I am delighted to see, as Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney said down in Mayo last Sunday, that the ex-Ministers are beginning to feel the depression.

Comment on this

I said what?

Comment on this

That the ex-Ministers are beginning to feel the depression. That is what the Deputy said last Sunday.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon, that is not what I stated.

Comment on this

The Deputy said last Sunday that the ex-Ministers are beginning to see it.

Comment on this

I did not state that. I said that the people are beginning to see that the loss of the British markets was not a blessing in disguise.

Comment on this

Speaking for myself now I must say that I feel very much that the condition of affairs that has been brought about is going to be very bad for the industries of the country.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy feels very much the depression now. Has he felt that depression for the last ten years?

Comment on this

Has he felt it when 250,000 Irish people were driven out of the country because of unemployment here?

Comment on this

Has he felt it when 75,000 people were doomed to live in single roomed tenements in Dublin?

Comment on this

If he felt it why did he not do something about it?

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell us what is going to be the result of unemployment?

Comment on this

I am not giving way. If Deputy Mulcahy felt the depression in the last ten years why did he not do something about it?

Comment on this

We stopped the fall in population here.

Comment on this

The population after Cumann na nGaedheal came into office, fell below what is was. Since Cumann na nGaedheal came into office at least 250,000 of the finest of the young people were driven out of the country; more of them were driven into the slums and they were driven almost into revolution by the Government's neglect. The ex-Ministers did not then feel this depression. They did not feel it until it hit them in their own pockets. That was the first time they felt the depression. They now talk about an economic war. An economic war against this country is not any new thing. It has been going on for 750 years since the British first came into this country. It has been going on for seven centuries.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We have had seven hours on economics and on land annuities and we cannot have a repetition of all that now. Emigration to countries outside has nothing whatever to do with the question for which the Dáil has been summoned to-day.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy asks the Labour Party whether if unemployment went up they were going to use their powers under this Bill? Would they aid somebody else to summon the Dáil? The Deputy spoke very lightly about unemployment for the last ten years while the Dáil was sitting here. During that time the ex-Ministers denied the existence of unemployment. We want to know the extent of unemployment here in this country and we have asked in public advertisements that all the unemployed come forward and register so that we might know the extent of the problem. We did not want to shut our eyes to the fact. We wanted to know the facts.

Comment on this

Unemployment unfortunately is increasing every day since the Minister's Party came into office.

Comment on this

Unemployment was increasing under Cumann na nGaedheal rule. There was then no Emergency (Imposition of Duties) Bill taken by the Dáil to deal with it. We asked last year when the Housing Bill was before the Dáil that something decent should be done, but Deputy Mulcahy then refused to accept our amendments to deal adequately with the slum problem. If the Fianna Fáil policy had been in operation for the last ten years; if we were producing here the things that we required within the country—the necessities of life and all the other things that we should produce—we could snap our fingers at any country that said it would not take our goods. The only reason why we are forced to sell abroad such a large proportion of our produce is because we are importing so many of the things that we should produce at home and which the Cumann na nGaedheal Government refused here in this House to make provision to grow in this country.

We had been asking the Cumann na nGaedheal Government for a number of years to make provision for producing here the necessities of life. If this thing does nothing else but to bring the people of this country to realise that every measure that is at the command of the Government should be utilised in order to produce here the necessities of life for the people, then it will have done good. The present position might have come in a much more aggravated form at some other time when we would be less well prepared for it. We have a chance now to set our house in order. The Fianna Fáil Government will give the order to do it and the people are going to do it. The Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies who are preaching here to-night about unemployment should have the decency to keep their mouths shut and give the Fianna Fáil Government an opportunity of going on with the work.

Comment on this

The Labour Party have strongly recommended the acceptance of this amendment and will if a vote is challenged by Deputy Mulcahy vote for its acceptance. They recommend its acceptance in order to give this Parliament proper control over the Executive Council. They would do the same if Deputy Mulcahy and the Ministers of the late Government were in office. The Labour Party had recommended its acceptance in order that if necessary they should be able to give effect to it. I would point out to Deputy Mulcahy that the Labour Party alone is not in a position with its present numerical strength to summon the Dáil. I hope it will be possible, as it has not been possible in the past, for Deputy Mulcahy and his collegues if the situation justifies or warrants it to come together, and, if they find it necessary, to summon the Dáil for a particular purpose under the terms of this particular amendment. The Labour Party believe in the right of Parliament to control the Executive and that is why we strongly recommend the acceptance of this amendment.

Comment on this

I want to ask a few questions—first of all about this amendment. It is, as it stands, without any great sense and without any close application to the circumstances likely to arise. We are told that if certain things happen and if a majority of the members of the Dáil, by notice in writing given to the Ceann Comhairle of Dáil Eireann, requires Dáil Eireann to be summoned, then the said Ceann Comhairle shall do certain things and certain things must happen. I want to ask first what does "a majority of the members of Dáil Eireann" mean? I want to ask if the numerical strength of the House is laid down by electoral law: is it a majority of the members who are found at any time to be in existence? I want to ask this: suppose that that question has arisen and that a majority of the members sign a requisition, what does the rest of the amendment mean? "If when an order under this section is made or at any time thereafter and before such order is confirmed by acts of the Oireachtas or is revoked under this section or ceases to have statutory effect Dáil Eireann stands adjourned for a period of more than ten days and if, during such adjournment the majority of the members of Dáil Eireann by notice in writing given to the Ceann Comhairle ... the Ceann Comhairle shall summon Dáil Eireann to meet on a day named by him not being more than twenty-one days after the receipt by the said Ceann Comhairle ..." That requisition need not be based upon the order. The only action I take it that the amendment has is that the order just comes to a point of time. It is not to discuss the order. It is to discuss nothing. I welcome very much the statement that has been heard from Deputy Davin who has been trying to go a little far but not too far in the last couple of days.

Comment on this

I will not take directions from Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin as yet does not know how far he is to go.

Comment on this

I know it just as well as Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

I want to get a couple of barometers for this. Deputy Flinn was in the House and I am sorry he has left. Deputy Flinn queried, when a division was challenged here, the powers that were being given, and said that great powers were wanted. So far as he is concerned, such powers are wanted to make him worth consideration but one can only blame the Almighty for not having given them to him, and, that being so, we cannot criticise it but we certainly can correct matters. Deputy Flinn came to this country because of a threat of war——

Comment on this

Is the Deputy in order?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not in order in discussing Deputy Flinn or any other Deputy on this matter.

Comment on this

May I leave Deputy Flinn out of the argument, and say, that if one finds that there was a Deputy who came to this country under a threat of war, and, if he again leaves under a threat of economic war, is that going to be the time when the Labour Party will say that the moment has come for their seven members to throw their weight into the scale with the others who are standing by and will they call the House together to discuss the emergency? We have heard about depressed people. I look along that Front Bench and I see there one man, who is now here, but who has not been here for a long time, and who might stand as a representative of the depressed class in any community since he became a Minister. If his depression goes to the point that he gets more silent than he has been for months past, would that be an emergency which would cause the Labour Party to join with those others who want to get the Dáil summoned to discuss an emergency? The Labour Party, for the period until 19th October, hold this country in the hollow of their hands. Seven political lawyers have brought us where we are and seven Labour men can repair their mistakes.

Comment on this

And 77 executions— two sevens after each other.

Comment on this

Seven lawyers and Deputy Briscoe's native Irish heart beats for the 77 executions.

Comment on this

There were many other non-native Irishmen who died for Ireland. There were many Careys and Pigots.

Comment on this

There are going to be deputations from this country sent to all parts of the world to get our kith and kin to rally to us in that direction. Will we get Deputy Briscoe sent to where his kith and kin belong to rally them to our cause?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not in order in indulging in personalities on this or any other question.

Comment on this

If I could be saved from interruption, there would be no necessity for these personalities.

Comment on this
Mr. Brady

You are fighting England's battle well.

Comment on this

Did you ever hear of Pádraig Pearse?

Comment on this

I am not going to be deterred by any nonsensical jeers about fighting England's battles. I fight no English battle.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Nor Irish.

Comment on this

You are well briefed.

Comment on this

We are saying to the Labour Party in this House, through you, sir, that, until October next, seven men hold this country in the hollow of their hands.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

And there are people here and on the Independent Benches who will join with them at any time they want to call this Dáil together. The seven men do control, and what Deputy Mulcahy said here was quite correct, that we would like to have some indication of when they are going to be moved and when will that sufficient emergency have come which will make them call this House together? Suppose the railway staffs go out of existence, as some of them have gone, and supposing there is short time that will lead to no time——

Comment on this

You have put a few thousand of them out already.

Comment on this

Very good. There is a bad situation, then, but, supposing it gets worse, by reason of this Emergency (Imposition of Duties) Bill, and railwaymen find themselves deprived of their emoluments and pay, they ought to know that, if they get a little bit of stranglehold on Deputy Davin, and, possibly, get him to sway his colleagues, they can get this House called together to discuss that emergency. If racing goes bad in County Kildare, and bloodstock sales round about the Horse Show period go bad, and the people of that area are deprived of the particular moneys that should be flowing through the county and irrigating it, the people, at any rate, should know that, if they can get a stranglehold on Deputy Norton, and he can persuade his followers, the seven men, joining with us, can get this Dáil together to discuss an emergency. Wherever there are men put out of employment—and everybody knows that thousands will be put out—by reason of this nonsensical business, every single one of them should know that there are seven so-called Labour representatives, with the interests of the working classes mainly in their hearts, and that, if they get any pressure put on these people, they can get this House called together, at any moment between now and the middle of October, to discuss the emergency that has arisen. There are certain seaport towns that are represented here by Labour Deputies, and Deputy Davin himself has some touch with a seaport town. If carryings go, and, if men who are employed about the docks find that life has not for them even the little it used to give them, then, again, these people should know, one and all, that they have seven people on whom they can direct their censure and on whom they can direct their efforts to try to get this Dáil brought together to discuss the emergency that has then arisen.

Comment on this

And to do what you want for England.

Comment on this

The Minister for Defence has spoken in this House on a number of occasions, and all one can say about him, after his speeches, is that he was a proper instrument to choose to send to anybody's house to insult that person. This is a very serious moment and there should be none of this play back and forward across the House. Nothing is over at the moment, bar the shouting, and, mind you, a lot of people are thinking that the shouting is not over yet. It is only beginning. Nobody has sensed yet what are the depths of misery to which this country is going to be driven through this nonsensical business.

Comment on this

Such hypocrisy! The country has been in misery for the past ten years.

Comment on this

Nobody has yet sensed the extra misery through which this country is to go——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputies cannot restrain themselves they need not sit it out.

Comment on this

Might I finish your sentence, sir? They should betake themselves to their native heaths."

Comment on this

You will go to a hot spot if you go to your native heath.

Comment on this

Nobody has yet sensed the misery coming to this country through this nonsensical business, but, as the days go on, it is going to be realised more and more, and, as it is realised more and more, I believe there is going to be more and more of a definite attack on the seven members here who are supposed to represent Labour interests in the country, and who are supposed to represent the employees. It has been agreed by everybody that the people who are mainly going to suffer, when this thing comes to a head, are those who work for wages. That situation must develop because the Minister for Defence is surly and cannot bow his head. There have been appeals made in this House to drop this nonsense and to throw aside the foolish case that the lawyers have put up—and it is essentially foolish——

Comment on this

So say the British.

Comment on this

——to drop this nonsense the Minister for Finance is so fluent about—the equation of war debts and reparations with this purely commercial debt.

Comment on this

I am sorry to interrupt the Deputy, but, again, is he in order in talking about the equation of certain moneys to our debts?

Comment on this

We will give them an "all-night" now.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That discussion is not relevant to the question of summoning the House.

Comment on this

It can be summoned under this amendment to discuss anything.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

But not everything may be discussed on the question of summoning the House.

Comment on this

No, but those things which might be discussed under the Order, can be brought in as examples of things which the House might be called together to discuss, and these are without limit. There has been an appeal made here, for two or three days, that this Bill should be treated as a national question. Then there would be no necessity for this rather foolish provision, because, unless the Labour Party act, it is completely and entirely foolish and cynical. If that appeal had been made in any decent way, we might have what has been pleaded for, and pleaded for insincerely, a national situation. The national situation has been thrown aside and the national chance has been lost. There are seven people here who could have put their feet down and prevented that situation being brought about and they must bear the burden of criticism with the seven lawyers.

Comment on this

Again, is the Deputy in order in stating that certain people must bear the burden of criticism with seven lawyers because a national chance has been lost?

Comment on this

The chance has been lost and these people have only one alternative now. They may act under this which was no doubt accepted because the President believed that they were definitely under his thumb and their past conduct entitled him to hold that opinion about them. The only hope we have is the few words from Deputy Davin that he wanted to go a little bit but he did not want to go too far.

Comment on this

He will not go far with you.

Comment on this

The only hope the country has is that when people are thinking of the butter in cold storage and of the cattle being kept on the farms, of the eggs that cannot be sold and of the general unemployment that will creep and spread over the country, these seven men will have got to think at night over that and try and make up their minds as to when the emergency will occur that will make them call this House together to end unemployment.

Comment on this

Tell us a ghost story.

Comment on this

Seven ghosts.

Comment on this

Seven ghosts eventually. I said at one time that the position of a Labour leader in this House was not a happy one. The Labour Party voted for the guillotine motion this evening. The same instrument politically may fall on them very soon.

Comment on this

And you will be sorry.

Comment on this

And I will not be sorry. I will not be sorry if they have failed to do their duty.

Comment on this

The position of an ex-Minister is not a happy one.

Comment on this

Possibly not because there is a feeling of responsibility attached to it, but we have no power in this unless the seven people join with us.

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy a question? Is he annoyed now because the balance of power has gone to a body of Irishmen?

Comment on this

What is the object of this question?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy say something about the economic boycott of Belfast when Deputy Mulcahy had charge of it?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

The people with a national outlook have the balance of power.

Comment on this

These interruptions show that the Deputy is not happy although there was applause when he brought in his last vote.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I will bring in many more.

Comment on this

There is not an easy feeling in the Party. The depression of the Minister for Justice is spreading. It is no good having it spread to that Party. That is not the Party that matters.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

It is a better Party than the Party that kept you in power.

Comment on this

The thirteen reactionaries.

Comment on this

The Deputy left a particular university to join another.

Comment on this

I may come back again.

Comment on this

The Deputy may come back again.

Comment on this

You are trying to get back to one for some time.

Comment on this

The Deputy had to deny that he had been there and he had to admit it afterwards. The Deputy may find, although he is not a Labour member, that his educational course may be interrupted.

Comment on this

Can we keep the discussion to the amendment instead of having these personalities?

Comment on this

Control your Party.

Comment on this

On a point of order. When the President has made an appeal I think it is up to him to control the picnic, holiday spirit of his followers.

Comment on this

If my wishes were going to rule the House we would discuss this recommendation on its merits.

Comment on this

Has the President discussed it on its merits? Has he argued about it? We did not hear an explanation from him as to what it amounted to.

Comment on this

Because it was not necessary to explain. It was self-explanatory.

Comment on this

That might even have been said. There was no discussion on this Bill when it was in this House. What has happened is that the crisis is now on and the reason for it as I said last Friday is that we have got to try to justify a certain person's past. That is what has to be weighed in the balance against all the misery that is bound to come. The Labour Party have got to bear that in mind because the Labour Party have not merely a great control but a great responsibility.

Comment on this

This amendment which the Government has accepted secures a very valuable control over the enormous powers that they have secured in the Bill. It gives the majority of this House the power to summon the Dáil. I had hoped at an earlier stage in this debate that something might come from these parties who seemed to spend their time decrying one another and recalling one another's record at a moment when they should be thinking of the country and of coming together and doing something for it. I do not despair of that yet. It is my belief that if we cannot do that that terrible suffering must follow not only for this country but for the people in England too. It is a great opportunity for President de Valera and the responsibility rests on him of making some attempt to unite the forces of this country on a common ground and forget for the moment the prejudices that his own followers failed to forget for the moment and the prejudices that members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party feel and to remember that the country was never in greater danger than it is in to-day. He has got his chance and it is a difficult task, but he will get plenty of help from those who care for the country if he makes an effort at meeting his erstwhile political antagonists and invites all parties to attempt an amicable settlement of this business with the English people, he will lose nothing and he will gain everything. There are extremists on both sides. There are cheerful men who go careering with their flags flying and their bugles blowing and who usually are the first to run away, and there are people trying to forget the past which they may feel as bitterly but they do not romp in with recrimination and with joy, sometimes brilliant and witty but wholly unsuitable, when the whole existence of the country is at stake. It is great fun to score off one's opponents. Goodness knows, if I wanted to score points, I could score plenty of them, but to-night is no time to do it. We are ready to forget. There are men on these benches who have as much to forget as any Deputy on either side of the House, whether Cumann na nGaedheal or Fianna Fáil. We are ready to forget and to do anything that the President may ask provided it is morally justifiable to help him along to make a friendly and final settlement of the differences that are outstanding between our people and Britain. Let the leaders on that side say as much. Let the President take a chance and make an effort and this country may yet be saved from a terrible catastrophe and our people may be saved from an ordeal, the most terrifying that any leader could lead them into.

Comment on this

I want to ask Deputy McGilligan just one question. Deputy McGilligan on several occasions has alluded to the faith I profess. I do not know whether he wants me to apologise for the faith I possess.

Comment on this

I have never done it.

Comment on this

You did. Stand your ground.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan knows that I have a certain heritage. Does he want me to apologise for it or get up here and boast of the fact and say that I am proud of it, or what does he want? Does he want to make out that a man born in this country with the faith I hold has no right to participate in a national struggle which concerns the majority of the people?

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan has specifically stated that he never referred to Deputy Briscoe's faith. Neither did he. Deputy McGilligan has never referred to Deputy Briscoe's faith, and is it in order for Deputy Briscoe to answer a statement which was never made?

Comment on this

Would Deputy McGilligan explain these references? They have been made on several occasions.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When Deputy McGilligan states that he never made any such statement his word must be accepted.

Comment on this

I shall take it in a different way, then. Will he deny that he has stated definitely that my ancestry did not emanate from this soil? He will not deny that. I want further to ask this: Does he want to deny to any person born in this country the right to participate in a national struggle on the side of the people as against foreign invaders, or does he expect them to take the side which he is now taking as against their own people? I want an answer to that now. If Deputy McGilligan were to face an ordinary democratic election, were he to go before the ordinary population in any part of the Twenty-Six Counties to get elected to the Dáil and were he to put his record side by side with anybody else, I wonder would he secure election?

Deputy Mulcahy talked about unemployment. Two Deputies less entitled to speak on that subject I do not know in the House, because I noticed in all the debates on this particular legislation Deputy Mulcahy never once referred to his own constituency. He spoke of other constituencies, rural constituencies, but never once did he refer to the North side. I challenge Deputy Mulcahy to go into the North side and talk to the people there.

Comment on this

What have you done about Gallaher's?

Comment on this

It is still open.

Comment on this

Who kept it open?

Comment on this

Much to the regret of Deputy Mulcahy, Gallaher's is still there. I want to say that Deputy Mulcahy has no right to indulge in the remarks in which he indulged for the simple reason that he never raised a finger, whether for the old age pensioners or the people on outdoor relief. Even when this Government brought in legislation to supply milk to the children of destitute people, Deputy Mulcahy never got up. He now talks about the number of unemployed and tries to curtail the powers given here, but he did not give a single thought to them before. Deputy McGilligan tried to side-track the discussion to-night. He has no right to speak on that line. "People may have to die of starvation," was his outlook once.

Comment on this

It was not, that was denied.

Comment on this

The Deputy may quibble.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This matter has been twice discussed by the House. Perhaps the Deputy will now come to Recommendation No. 5 on the Order Paper.

Comment on this

As regards Recommendation No. 5, the Recommendation is that if a majority of this House feel that it is essential in the interests of the nation to bring this House together this part of the Emergency legislation provides means for doing so. I do not want to delay the House any longer in discussing this but I would say to Deputy McGilligan that he had better keep his remarks as regards myself until he comes outside in my constituency to make them in front of the people who sent me here. I challenge him to do that instead of going to the University for his election. He speaks for nobody in the sense of the population who may suffer as he says. I challenge Deputy McGilligan to come, between now and the time the Dáil meets again, into any part of my constituency.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On Recommendation No. 5?

Comment on this

Yes, on Recommendation No. 5 and advocate that the Dáil should be called together or try to get the people who elected me to ask me to join with him in bringing the Dáil together. I ask him to attack me in my constituency in the way he tries to attack me in this House. I further want to remind him that unfortunately for this country the history of the country is full of instances of Irishmen of 100 per cent. Irish blood who let this country down. There were Careys and there were Pigots. Then there were men who were not 100 per cent. of Irish blood such as Pearse and Liam Mellowes. I want Deputy McGilligan to think of these things before he casts a slur on one who, even although he lives in this country and may be as good an Irishman as anyone here, has not got 100 per cent. Irish blood flowing through his veins. I want to make these remarks because it seems that during the last five or six months this particular abuse was indulged in inside and outside. Deputy Mulcahy tried his hand at it during the last Election. I happen to be here again and I now challenge. Deputy Mulcahy to come into my constituency or to go into his own and I will face him on his own platform or on opposite platforms. I challenge him to be a man instead of being a hypocrite in this House.

Comment on this

I should like to say that when we introduce the question of unemployment in this debate, we are not wholly dependent on anything we may have said ourselves to support our statements. I shall quote a statement from one who had been a political opponent of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party on the question of what has been done by Cumann na nGaedheal in regard to unemployment for some years past. I shall quote a statement made by Senator Johnson in Belfast as reported in the "Irish Times” of 7th April, 1931. Senator Johnson said that conditions in the Free State from the point of view of unemployment were better than they were a year ago, or two or three years ago.

Comment on this