We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Supplementary and Additional Estimates - Vote No. 73—Emergency Fund Grant-in-Aid.

Contributions 132–294 of 294. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Collect the Party fund as soon as possible. Deputies in the Dáil are very apt to laugh at present conditions, but anybody who cares for this country and the people of this country, should realise that a situation is being created which means that many people are leaving the country, getting out of the country, being driven out of the country. They will feel that the country is getting into poverty and that that poverty is being used for creating immoral views. They will find that it is being taught that the country can break international agreements, endeavours to control American Governmental policy, and demand dictatorial powers. They ask for what the President called a vote of confidence in his Government from an impoverished country and they make secret agreements with the illegal organisations outside, condemned by the Church and all right-minded men. Here we have a Government which misleads the people assuring them that we can force the British to their knees. This Government which wants to muzzle everybody who gets up to speak the truth now asks for a vote of confidence to the extent of two millions. I know there are poor fools up and down the country—I met many of them last week—who believe that the President can find alternative markets. The Government now comes along and tells us there is a state of war, that England is trying to beat us with a big stick. The truth is England is only asserting a right which even we must insist she has as we have also. We insist that any sovereign State has a right to put on tariffs. The British tariffs are limited tariffs meant to raise £1,500,000 which used to be half-yearly paid over by this country. We have been told that we have been dealing with the British for the last ten years. We put on certain tariffs against Britain and the present Government put on certain tariffs. But the moment the British put on a tariff to produce £1,500,000 they are denounced. So far as I remember one of the lists of tariffs in the recent Budget was to bring in £1,000,000. But immediately that the British Government attempts to put on this tariff we are told by our Government that we are in a state of war, and that everyone who does not agree with President de Valera is a traitor and a blackguard, should not be allowed to speak and should be locked up in Mountjoy.

We are asked to give a vote of confidence to this Government. I am not going to give a vote of confidence to this Government, nor am I to be muzzled. Whether I am denounced as being pro-British, whether I am told I am a traitor or that I am anti-Irish or anti-patriotic, I am not going to be deterred from the right road. Up and down the country we find people who, because of this mad outcry, are afraid to get up and say what they know. They say instead: "We have the authority of the Government that everything will come right. We now recognise that President de Valera is going to solve everything and help everybody." The person who says that is not a rational creature. He is an irrational creature, a sub-human being. I shall do my best to let the people know the truth, even if it is not helpful. If I think the land annuities should be paid to England I shall say so, and I shall tell the people that they should be paid to England.

There is an attempt to misrepresent us in that. I am convinced myself that on the legal side the land annuities should be paid. It is asked why we did not take steps in connection with this matter when we were in office. But there is a new situation created now by world conditions and limitations. The President himself last Saturday or Sunday put forward one reason, and that was our inability to pay. What might have been reasonable in the eyes of Britain in 1925 may very easily now, with world limitations plus the advent of the Fianna Fáil Government, prove to be an intolerable burden. When we made our last financial agreement with the British it was done on the face of enormous war debts. We were relieved of any liability under Article 5 which committed us to an undefined proportion of the British war debt. We were relieved of that, which was a very large figure at the time. At present it is a very much smaller figure, and consequently it can be argued that, in present circumstances, a position more favourable to us might have come about. I am not saying that it is possible now to make an agreement with the British that will absolve us from our duty to pay the land annuities. I am not saying anything of that sort. I am saying what I believe President de Valera believes, and that is, that we might get something out of it. I do not think that you must negotiate to be absolved. You may negotiate, and you may still have to pay the land annuities, but it would be even better to pay the land annuities than to bring about the situation which has now been brought about by the non-payment of them, which has cost us much more than the payment of them would have cost us.

It might be thought by a good many people that President de Valera has the duty of carrying out his original mandate to the letter. That is by no means binding upon him. His duty is to do his best for the people, that is to do the best thing that can be done, and his policy should be to do the best that can be done. In order to see where we are, in this thing, we must try and see what is going to be the outcome of this emergency. Is it going to make way for improvement? Where are we to be in three months' time? Are the people of this country going to be able to sell under equally good conditions as before allowing for the fact that world prices have gone down all round? Who is now going to promote industries? The State we are told is going to start industries and we are told it will find new markets. Are they to be allowed to spend money without giving some indication as to the finding of new markets? Where are the new markets to be? Who is to buy and what are the prices that are to be paid by those who buy? These things we ought to know. Until we know them we must recognise that we must face up to these things fairly and squarely.

We must recognise that the Treaty of 1921 can only be broken with the assent of both parties. We must recognise that the justification for the discontinuance of a thing that has existed for ten years must come from the person who requires the discontinuance. The onus of proof is upon that side. We must recognise that, and the fact that we cannot afford to pay has a great deal to do with the question. If we cannot afford to pay as much money as we did to the British to pay the bondholders it merely means going into the matter and showing that this is a burden greater than our people can bear. Our experience for the last ten years was that we always felt we had the right to expect the British Government, at any rate to some extent, to advance to meet this country, and not necessarily to be always looking for their pound of flesh or the last drop of blood. We have a right to expect that from any country and particularly from a country which, with ourselves, is a member of the Commonwealth of Nations. The President will undertake to prove that a violation of the Oath is not breaking the Treaty and that the retention of the land annuities is not breaking the Treaty. I should like to hear how he justifies his general behaviour towards the Governor-General. Is the Governor-General implied by the Treaty or is he not? If the position of the Governor-General is implied by the Treaty, and if the President is not out to break the Treaty, why does he carry on in that way about the Governor-General? Why have we such things as the Army Band not being allowed to play and the Army Benevolent Fund Dance being prevented from functioning?

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that the Governor-General still signs all measures passed by this House?

Comment on this

Yes, he does. But is it not absolutely ridiculous that the poor men who were in the Army and who are in want now have to be left in want rather than allow the Army Benevolent Fund Dance because the Governor-General, who has always been a generous patron of the fund, cannot be excluded and permit the Ministers to be present? We are told that the British are the aggressors. As far as I can see, the aggression has been entirely on this side. I am out-raged and indignant to think that it has been preached by the Fianna Fáil Party up and down the country that the truth and the Irish cause are antagonistic. We are told that we must shut up and that we are helping the enemy when we say what we know to be true, and what the enemy also knows to be true. The whole implication is that honesty of speech and openness of speech are incompatible with nationalism. That is the great state of affairs brought about by this great Government that the country, we are told, was hungering for for the last ten years.

Comment on this

The lovely accent of Deputy Fitzgerald——

Comment on this

Perhaps you would prefer Deputy Corry's accent.

Comment on this

——would convince those not acquainted with his usual Parliamentary tactics that this was the first occasion on which a vote of this kind was presented to this House. Does the Deputy remember that when, about twelve months ago, the former Government asked for a blank cheque for the Electricity Supply Board, they were unable to tell the Dáil what the money was for, or to explain the mess that that particular body had got itself into? Does he forget that period in the life of the first Dáil, after the Treaty was accepted, when, with or without the sanction of this House, ten million pounds of the Irish people's money was squandered in one year? If he does not believe this or if he does not like to accept that statement from me, I would refer him to the subsequent report of the Comptroller and Auditor-General regarding the spending policy of the Government. There were other occasions which I need not mention, but these are at least two occasions when something of the same kind, or perhaps of a worse kind, was put before this House by the colleagues with whom Deputy Fitzgerald was associated at that time.

With regard to the attitude of the Labour Party, the Labour Party would certainly like a more detailed reply from the President regarding the manner in which this money is likely to be spent. It is stated in the memorandum issued by the Executive Council that some of the money will be set aside for the establishing of new industries. If some of the money is to be set aside for the purpose of establishing, or for the purpose of re-establishing industries, I should like that some of it should be made available for re-establishing industries in some of the provincial centres where these industries have had to close down as a result of the failure of the banks and of the failure of the late Government to provide money for that purpose. It is the view of the Labour Party, expressed by Deputy Norton and the Labour members of the previous Dáil, that tariffs alone will never set up or maintain industries in this country and that the failure is due to the fact that we have a financial and banking system here in this country which was never favourable to the development of industry. I hope, therefore, that some of the money will be set aside for that useful purpose.

It has been stated, and it has been stated correctly, that the section likely to suffer most severely as a result of the economic war started by England, is the farming or agricultural community. I noticed that the Government had decided to allow a limited moratorium so far as arrears of land annuities were concerned. I believe that there is a good case for the extension of that moratorium. I hope that from this source, or from some other similar fund, that principle will be extended and that the people who were unable to pay their annuities before this economic war was started, and who will still be unable to pay whether the war goes on for a long or a short period, will be given some consideration in that respect. I was down in a part of my own constituency last week, attending a local show, where I met a considerable number of farmers from my own area, and I was informed there and I understand that it applies to other areas of the same constituency—that the country was literally littered with six-day notices for the immediate payment of arrears of land annuities. Those of us who represent rural areas, and who know the conditions that existed before this economic war was started, will have to admit readily that there is a good case for an extension of the principle of giving a moratorium on the question of land annuities, and that from this fund or through some other channel some provision of that kind must be made, if not for an indefinite period, at any rate for a set period.

Deputy Cosgrave suggested that this was the price which President de Valera was going to pay for the support of the Labour Party. Deputy Cosgrave suggested that it was an extension of Socialism and of Communistic principles. Perhaps he can put a different meaning or construction upon the word Socialism to that put upon it by those on this side of the House. What is the kind of Socialism which he feared from the present Government and those who support it? Is it the policy that will result in abolishing the slums and that will build houses on a national scale and provide milk for the children of the needy and poor? Is it the policy that will provide for the fixing of the retail prices of the necessaries of life which Deputies, if they were honest with one another and honest towards this House, would admit is urgently necessary; for the guaranteeing of fair prices for the farmers, about which we have heard so much from the Opposition Benches? Is it the policy that makes for the provision of employment at fair rates of wages, which the late Government could not see their way to provide, and for the provision of maintenance for widows and orphans which the former Government refused to provide? If that is the policy which he fears, I feel proud to stand up here and back the Government which will make such provision for the people of this country. You can call that policy what you like— whether you call it Socialism or not— but the people will understand what it means and when the time comes they will approve of such a policy. We are told what has led up to the present situation, and what is the immediate cause of this economic war, by the Deputies from the opposite benches. They have been talking about this economic war for the past three weeks and trying to lead the country to believe that the economic war has been provoked by the Deputies on this side of the House and by the present Government when they know quite well, that in the midst of correspondence concerning the land annuities issue, Mr. Thomas, on behalf of the Conservative Cabinet of England, declared that economic war. He declared that economic war before the correspondence had concluded. I have read most of the speeches and listened to a good many others from leading members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party on this matter and I have not heard from anybody on the opposite benches anything like the truthful kind of statement made by Deputy MacEoin, in some part of his constituency last week, in which he had the courage, and was the only Deputy in the Party who had the courage, to condemn the people who started this war.

We are called the timekeepers, in office. We are branded as the people who are responsible for the present state of affairs, presumably because we put President de Valera into office. I believe that, in the natural course of events, we will be charged and held responsible for everything that is done wrong and that we will, whether we have responsibility for it or not, be given very little share of the credit for anything that may be done right. Our attitude to the Ultimate Financial Settlement, including the land annuities, has been put to the people of this country, in the plainest language, by all our candidates in the two election in 1927 and the last General Election, and those of us who are supporting the Government in looking for a favourable revision of all the disputed payments are carrying out the wishes of the people who sent us into this House. I do not, and colleagues of mine do not, agree with the whole of the procedure, the method of approach to this question, but we believe that this country has a good case, whether it be legal or otherwise, for a revision of the payments which Deputy Cosgrave, when he was President of this State, signed over to England. Deputy Mulcahy read out here last week portions of our published programme from a book which is called "The Nation Organised." He read out the portions which suited his speech and endeavoured, to the best of his ability, to misrepresent our attitude on that matter.

Comment on this

I would not be allowed to read out any more. I was stopped from reading out any more than the things I read out.

Comment on this

I was very glad that the Deputy had, quite unconsciously, put on the records of this House so much of our published programme, free of cost.

Comment on this

And I would like to do more.

Comment on this

I hope that the Deputy will take another opportunity of reading the other portions he omitted to read on that occasion.

Comment on this

The Deputy will, at least, give me credit for having advertised their programme on very many occasions.

Comment on this

Ever since we became aware of the meaning, to the people of this country, of what is known as the Ultimate Financial Settlement, we objected to it, both inside and outside this House, and said that the people who signed that settlement did it without the authority of the people or of their representatives and that we were quite entitled to look for a favourable revision of that settlement. I put it in every election address that I issued since I discovered the meaning of the settlement. Who told us for the first time what that settlement meant to this country? Mr. Baldwin, when Prime Minister of England, in answer to a question by Lord Danesport, that famous friend of the Irish Free State. Nine months after the settlement was signed, he gave the information for the first time, to certain Deputies then sitting in this House as to the real meaning of that settlement. The records of the British House will prove that and let any Deputy, who speaks from the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches in this debate after me, say whether or when, after that settlement was signed in 1926, it was afterwards submitted to this House, and whether or not the facts were not fully given to the British House nine months after it was signed and before it was disclosed to the people of this country or to their representatives. On this issue, let it be known—and I or anybody on these benches make no apology for it—that we are backing the policy that we put before the people of the country, and we will keep President de Valera in office in order to secure a favourable and early settlement of that whole financial problem.

I am not going to discuss the legal aspect of the Land Commission Annuities. I am not competent to do it and I know, as I believe was admitted by the Attorney-General, and, I believe, as would have to be admitted by every lawyer, that two lawyers could give two different viewpoints on every issue arising in a law case, even a trespass case.

Comment on this

With the exception of Deputy J.J. Byrne.

Comment on this

I had always great fears that an issue of this kind would be submitted to any tribunal composed of legal men because the decision to be given by such a tribunal would depend on the presentation of the facts. It might possibly be that you had a good case on the facts, but it might also be possible that you might employ a bad lawyer to present your case. I certainly would not employ Deputy J.J. Byrne to present the case.

Comment on this

Is that the Deputy's opinion of the present Attorney-General?

Comment on this

I said Deputy J.J. Byrne, who is not seen as often in the Law Library as the Attorney-General.

Comment on this

The Attorney-General, I presume, would put the country's case, if it were to come before a tribunal.

Comment on this

We will get the Deputy to put it.

Comment on this

I congratulate myself and the members of this Party on having helped, if you like, the Fianna Fáil Party to come forward on the right road from the policy they had put before this House in May, 1929. On the 2nd May, 1929, Deputy de Valera, as he was then, brought in a motion, which read as follows:

That the Dáil is of opinion that the land annuities now being paid into "The Purchase Annuities Fund" for transmission to Great Britain should henceforth be paid into the Central Fund, and that the Executive Council should immediately take the appropriate steps to that end.

Now, I took the responsibility, and a very serious political responsibility it was, on that occasion, of voting against that motion, because, rightly or wrongly, I believed that the language meant repudiation. Some of my colleagues differed from me on that and I can tell the House that, when, subsequently, I went to fight an election in the Leix-Offaly constituency, I discovered that, from every platform in that constituency, the leading and eloquent spokesmen of Fianna Fáil said that my attitude in voting against that motion was an attitude of agreeing to continue to send money to England, whether it was legally due or not. I honestly believed that I might have been beaten in that election but, notwithstanding the eloquence of some of the Fianna Fáil representatives, I succeeded in piling up a few extra hundred votes on my previous result. While I believed—I might be wrong— that the meaning of the language of that motion was repudiation, I am glad to see that President de Valera to-day stands for arbitration on the issue.

Comment on this

Is that so?

Comment on this

He is standing on the right road, so far as I am concerned, at any rate. On the question of arbitration or negotiation I would much prefer—and my colleagues agree, perhaps for some of the reasons I have stated—this issue to be approached, not from the point of view of endeavouring to get a court of legal gentlemen, either from inside or outside the Commonwealth, who would give a decision on legal facts, and only on the legal facts, of the land annuities question. I would much prefer, and I hope that eventually the Government will adopt the attitude of re-opening negotiations on all the disputed payments, and by every fair and friendly argument that can be put forward, no matter whether legal or otherwise, endeavour to get, for the people of this country, some remission of the moneys which under present circumstances they are unable to pay. Take the land annuities. If we are obliged, as Deputy Fitzgerald said when concluding his speech, to pay the land annuities. we are certainly not entitled to charge our taxpayers with the cost of collection. Is he aware that our State solicitors, our sheriffs, our Civic Guards and a large number of Land Commission officials are a charge upon the taxpayers of this State for the purpose of collecting that money? I say that the £250,000 or £300,000 which it costs us to collect these moneys and send them to England should rightly be a charge on the British taxpayer or somebody else other than the Irish taxpayer.

Does anybody seriously suggest that when President Cosgrave signed the Ultimate Financial Settlement he was acting for the people of this country, when, without their authority he agreed that the pensions of the Royal Irish Constabulary should be paid by the Irish taxpayers? The R.I.C. was the most effective machine the British had for maintaining their rule in this country. The old R.I.C. did more to maintain British rule here than hundreds of thousands of British soldiers. I believe it is unknown in European circles for the taxpayers of a country, whether that country won or lost a war, to pay the pensions of those who fought against them. I believe that question would stand a fair test before any decent body of men who might be called to arbitrate upon it. There is a fair argument there to put before people who will listen to reason, and there is a good case for telling England that, for the future, she would have to make provision for such payments.

What has led up to the present situation? In the correspondence which took place between President de Valera on behalf of the Government here and Mr. Thomas, on behalf of the British Government—and I express the view that Mr. Thomas is only carrying the passengers' luggage in this case, —I think President de Valera, in the limited experience he had in his dealings with the other side, was convinced that Lord Hailsham was a much more important individual in the negotiations. I know Mr. Thomas fairly well and I know that in this matter he is only carrying the passengers' luggage for the Conservative Cabinet in England. Arbitration was offered by the British and was accepted by President de Valera on behalf of the Government here. As far as I can understand it the issue at the moment is this, that Mr. Thomas has no right to challenge the Government of this country, or to limit the selections of nominees. I have been associated with many labour disputes, where arbitration was eventually accepted, and led to satisfactory settlements. Does any Deputy think that I, acting on behalf of any body of men, would allow the employers to say that so and so should not be a member of the tribunal acting for my side? That may be a narrow view to take on the issues involved here, but I suggest that if arbitration has been offered by England and accepted here, President de Valera has a perfect right to have a free choice of the nominees he will put on the board. It is surprising that a man like Mr. Thomas. who started his career as an engine driver, and who, for many years, represented a large number of British workers in disputes, should make a fool of himself by taking such a line of action on behalf of the Conservative Cabinet.

Comment on this

That is a nice reference to people you are going to arbitrate with. It is a credit to Labour.

Comment on this

I am saying what I believe, and I have a perfect right to say it. The emergency powers in the Act recently passed here certainly, from our point of view, give very extraordinary powers to any Government. I refer to that because I did not like the language Senator Connolly used when speaking in the Seanad yesterday, when he said that he welcomed this fight and hoped it would be a fight to a finish. I am speaking for myself in this matter, but if I am going to assist this Government to take part in a fight which is described in that way, I want to know— and I believe my colleagues are entitled to know—the road upon which we are going to travel towards that end. There is an end to a fight to a finish and from experience it is not a very satisfactory one. All wars, whether civil or international, have been settled around a conference table. It was so in the European War, after millions of people had been killed and their dependents deprived of a livelihood. I do not think the issues which divide Britain and the Irish Free State are worth having a fight to a finish about. I do not believe the view expressed by Senator Connolly represents the views of the majority of the members in this House. Perhaps Senator Connolly may have a different meaning to the one that is being put upon his statement. I do not want to misrepresent him, but I say to him, and to President de Valera, that if we are going to have a fight, and if we are going to have a fight which is to be regarded as a fight to a finish, we would have to have a look at the map of the road which we are to travel.

Comment on this

You will have to look for it.

Comment on this

Will the official interrupter for the Cumann na nGaedheal Party allow me to make my remarks? Some of us believe that the money provided in this Estimate is for the purpose of giving a fixed and a fair price to people for their produce. I congratulate the Government on having the wisdom to take from the creameries any butter left on their hands, and to give them a fair market price, so that it can be put into cold storage for the use of the people during the winter period. That is a good sound policy, and so long as the money provided is used for that purpose, the Government will certainly get our enthusiastic support.

Comment on this
Dr. Thomas Hennessy Dr. Hennessy

That is very little.

Comment on this

If steps of the same kind are taken in other directions for the protection of the people——

Comment on this
Dr. Thomas Hennessy Dr. Hennessy

Is any of it going to the railways?

Comment on this

I did not hear the Deputy's voice last night when that question was under discussion. Under the terms of the Emergency Duties Act I do not want to see any building-up done only to have the structure pulled down afterwards. As far as I know there is no authority under that measure to go beyond the declared policy of either the Fianna Fáil Party or the Labour Party as stated at the last general election. I would not willingly help to erect some kind of an edifice during the short period that I hope this dispute will last only to have it pulled down after the fight is over. That would not be a good way of spending the people's money. I sincerely hope that the policy will not be in that direction, and that no attempt will be made under an emergency estimate of this kind to do anything for which a mandate has not been received from the people.

I agree with Senator Connolly when he said that something would have to be done, either now or in the very near future, to reorganise, or to establish, on a proper foundation, credit facilities for the people. If there is going to be real Government there must be in the very near future, a rational reorganisation of the banking institutions of this country. As long as Senator Connolly and his colleagues proceed on constitutional lines to bring about that very desirable end it will certainly have my support. I did not like the language he used when he said that he welcomed this fight, and that he hoped it would be a fight to a finish. I would recommend the farmers to keep their heads cool and their feet warm, and to realise that any benefits that will come out of the fight—if it is to be called a fight—must in the long run come back to themselves.

I travelled to a certain extent around my own constituency during the last couple of weeks and I found to my surprise that certain leading local supporters of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party were strongly sympathising with and supporting the attitude of the present Government. Their attitude is that whether the procedure which led up to this dispute was right or wrong or whether the tactics were good, bad or indifferent we are in a fight, and if we unite for the purpose we all have in view we are bound to get a favourable revision of the financial settlement which will gain in the long run millions a year for the real producers in this country.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

This Estimate, Sir, is another step in the complete destruction of Parliamentary Government about which Deputy Davin and his colleagues talked so much in the last ten years. The Estimate is one which asks us to give a Grant-in-aid of an Emergency Fund of two millions to the Government. When we give these two millions to-night or to-morrow we shall have no more control over it, and anything in the Estimate about the Cotroller and Auditor-General which would appear to convey that in some way the Dáil would have control over this money is illusory and deceptive.

The Estimate gives certain information. "Emergency Fund Grant-in-aid. —Disbursements will be made from this fund, subject to terms and conditions to be approved by the Minister for Finance, to promote the continuance of trade, industry and business, to open new markets for agricultural and manufactured produce, to establish or assist in establishing new industries and generally for all expenses arising out of or in the course of the present emergency." The last few words are the most important. The Estimate hands over to the Minister for Finance two million pounds with which he can do anything at all that he pleases, subject only of course to the control of a Parliamentary majority to put him out at a particular moment. In the present temper of the Labour Party there seems to be no prospect that whatever the Minister does the Labour Party will put him out.

The two things which are most important, perhaps, in any Parliament are control over taxation and control over expenditure. In the Emergency Imposition of Duties Act, the Government has completely destroyed Parliamentary control over taxation. They have got power to themselves to impose not only Customs Duties, but Excise Duties, Stamp Duties, and licences. When that Act was passed I wondered in what form they were going to take power to deal with the money that they were to get. Some people said that they can get this money by taxation without coming to the Dáil, but that they could not appropriate it to a particular purpose without coming to the Dáil. Now they have solved that particular difficulty by this Estimate. They are going to get the money under the Emergency Imposition of Duties Act and under this Estimate they are going to spend the money. They are going to tax whom they like, after what manner they like, and having got the money they are to spend it as they please.

For the last ten years we heard a good deal about Parliamentary Control and we heard it particularly from the Labour Party. For ten years they voted against every closure or guillotine motion. For the last ten or twelve weeks they have missed no opportunity of voting in full strength in favour of every closure and in favour of a guillotine motion which has no precedent in the records of this House. They voted for the Imposition of Duties Act which hands away all the power of the Dáil to tax the citizens. To-day they are voting for handing away the power of the Dáil over expenditure.

Comment on this

Not correct. Tell the Labour Party what your real grievance is against them.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Deputy Davin has made a remark which is not of the most elevating character, but I have a right to sit in this House and to state my views, and I am going to exercise that right whatever kind of tactics Deputy Davin produces, and Deputy Davin can produce a great variety of tactics. Nobody has more experience than I have of Deputy Davin's tactics; but if Deputy Davin thinks he can put me off what I have to say he is making a great mistake. The Labour Party has during the last ten or twelve weeks since they allied themselves to this Government voted for every kind of closure and restriction of debates and for a Bill which gives the Government control over taxation. They are now going to vote for putting the Dáil out of control over expenditure. Nobody is more clearly aware of that than De puty Davin. Nobody in this House can shout louder, nobody is more inaccurate in what he says here than Deputy Davin but he did not say one word in regard to the position he took up here in the last ten years on the question of Parliamentary control.

Usually an Estimate contains sub-heads showing how the money will be expended, and the Minister for Finance cannot normally go outside these sub-heads. The Comptroller and Auditor-General must be satisfied that the money is expended within the directions given by the sub-heads. In this Estimate there are no sub-heads, but there is a footnote under the asterisk which reads: "The expenditure out of this Grant-in-aid will be accounted for in detail to the Comptroller and Auditor-General, and any balance not issued will be surrendered." I take it that that was put in order to convey to the House and the people the impression that there was in some way to be some control over the Minister for Finance in the expenditure of this money. But in fact there is none. The Comptroller and Auditor-General has no function to say what the objects are upon which this money may be expended. The important thing is that the disbursements are to be made on the certificate of the Minister for Finance. As soon as the Minister for Finance certifies that the purpose is any of the purposes mentioned here or arising out of or in the course of the present emergency, the Comptroller and Auditor-General has no function. The procedure is this: This money will be expended before 31st March, 1933; the Comptroller and Auditor-General will not get the accounts probably until November, 1933, and the Dáil will not hear anything about it until February or March, 1934. The power of the Comptroller and Auditor-General is strictly limited. The power entirely rests with the Minister for Finance to say on what the money is to be expended. So that we give £2,000,000 as a blank cheque to the Minister. The allusion to the Comptroller and Auditor-General is put in for the purpose of making the case that somebody else is to have some control. I would like to ask why in this note the word "issued" is used instead of "unexpended.""The expenditure out of this Grant-in-aid will be accounted for in detail to the Comptroller and Auditor-General, and any balance not issued will be surrendered." Why is it not "any balance unexpended will be surrendered"? Is there a particular idea in that? If the Minister has some doubts that he can spend that money before March 31st, he can open a fund and out of the Central Fund he can pay a million pounds into that fund. The money will thus be issued, and there will be no refund at all, so that the word "issued" is used specifically. Great care was used in drawing up this Estimate, and yet no information is given in it. Great care was used in drawing up the words when the Government wants something for their own purpose, but they are reckless in imposing tariffs and in rushing us into what they style economic war.

Therefore, the position is that the Government has every power from the point of view of imposing taxation and spending money. This, I take it—this two million pounds—is only the first step; we will be asked to give them more later on and, in the situation in which we now find ourselves, we probably will give them more eventually. The Government is, therefore, supreme over taxation and expenditure. They want, as the speeches made here and as the speeches made in the country would indicate, to go a step further. They want to cut out the Dáil. They want to prevent anyone in the Dáil who does not agree with them, from expressing his views. They want to prevent anybody in the country from expressing a view that does not coincide with theirs. They have a system of propaganda which endeavours to make out that this issue we are now in trouble about is a great national issue. The man who does not agree with the point of view taken by the Government is not an Irishman or a nationalist. There could not be a more absurd point of view. Not only have members here a right to express their views, but they have a definite duty and they would not be Irishmen or nationalists if, in this situation, they did not express their views.

I suggest, in all the circumstances, that we are not really fighting for an ideal. We are fighting for something very sordid indeed. The appeal made to the people in the course of the General Election was not an appeal for any Irish or national or spiritual ideal. It was an appeal to the most sordid instincts of the people. The appeal made at every crossroads in the country was to the effect that if the people put in Fianna Fáil they would not have anything to pay. The legal opinions that were given and the various things that were said in Dublin were translated into very plain language in the country, at the crossroads and in the market places. They were translated into very plain English in some places and into very plain Irish in Connemara and other places. What the people understood in English and in Irish was——

Comment on this

What they were told.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

What they understood was that they would not have anything to pay.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy quote from any newspaper any particular speech in support of that statement?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I heard it half a dozen times.

Comment on this

Will Deputy Hogan mention the names of Deputies, or the name of the Deputy, who made that speech?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Hayes should be allowed to continue without interruption.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

I did not hear Deputy Moore's question. I would love to satisfy the Deputy.

Comment on this

Will Deputy Hayes quote from any report of a speech in which that statement was made? We would like to know what Deputy he heard saying it or when it was reported in the Press?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Would you really like to know that?

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

There are two languages spoken in this country and I understand them both. I know a good deal about the ordinary people of this country and I meet them pretty constantly. Most emphatically in one area of which I have some knowledge, South Tipperary, the plea made to the people was this: Vote for Fianna Fáil and you will not have anything to pay.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That was said by every organiser.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

The statement was made everywhere and it was understood.

Comment on this

Did Deputy Hayes hear that?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Hayes is surely entitled to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

But not to state untruths.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

It is obviously part of the scheme that no one should be allowed to say anything unless he plays on a particular string on which the Government and their henchmen are for the moment playing.

Comment on this

Deputy Hayes was very courteous to allow me to intervene and perhaps he will now allow me to explain my position? What he is saying reflects on the character of every member on these benches.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Chuck it. Do you not know very well that everyone was saying it?

Comment on this

Deputy Hayes knows enough about procedure in the House to be aware that he should support any statement such as he has made by either a newspaper report or otherwise by naming the Deputy who made the statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Has he not my word for it?

Comment on this

The jury did not accept that on one occasion.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

I say definitely that the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party was translated into very plain English at the crossroads by their organisers and their canvassers——

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

And their Deputies.

Comment on this

Name.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

It was translated very definitely in this way: "If you vote for us you will not have anything to pay."

Comment on this

That is a deliberate untruth.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Is that remark in order?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not in order.

Comment on this

I protest that Deputy Hayes's statement is not in order unless he can produce a newspaper report of the statement or name the particular Deputy who made the statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Is Deputy Smith's remark in order?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not, and should be withdrawn.

Comment on this

If the Deputy's statement is supported by facts, I am prepared to withdraw my statement.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must not accuse another Deputy of deliberate untruth.

Comment on this

Deputy Hayes has made the statement that the Fianna Fáil Party said if they were elected the people would have to pay nothing. I never heard a Fianna Fáil Deputy saying that. I never made the statement myself.

Comment on this

The Deputy might at least observe the rules of the House.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has accused another Deputy of deliberate untruth. That must be withdrawn.

Comment on this

Then, of course, in deference to your ruling, I must withdraw.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It is too late to protest. You will not get away with that.

Comment on this

I challenge Deputy Hayes to name the Deputy who made the statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Did you never say it?

Comment on this

It is an untruth.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That will not do

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

In Connemara the very same thing was said: "Ní bheidh dada le n-íoc agaibh"—"There will not be anything to pay." It was made quite clear, and the appeal was definitely made to the most sordid instincts of the people. These promises that were made cannot be carried out, and because they cannot be carried out the people who made them, and the Labour Party who supported those people when they came into this House, now want to raise a great national banner and go out on a great national crusade. At the same time they want to stigmatise every one who does not agree with them in their difficulty as being neither an Irishman nor a nationalist.

They are going to go further. Their propaganda is going very far. We have had from Ministers, and from back-benchers, statements to the effect that the Opposition have no right to be pursuing the tactics that they are now pursuing. We have had very thinlyveiled threats against the representatives of the people. When we hear these threats and that kind of talk we must remember in what atmosphere, in what country, with what history and against what background these statements are made. These statements assume very great seriousness indeed in this country, with its history and its background and with all the forces that are at present playing in it, either encouraged or allowed by the Government and in some cases both encouraged and allowed.

I want to make this quite clear. You have had that by propaganda and by interruption at meetings—organised interruptions—and you have had it by statements in the House here, statements of various kinds. The President, if I remember aright, said the Opposition was going beyond the bounds. I think the President said that.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Surely—the double entendre.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

We have had generalities from the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. He talked about people playing the British game. The Minister for Defence has constantly used the same phrase. Deputy Jordan—I am quoting from the "Connacht Sentinel"—talked about the just chastisement which his Government is preventing the people from giving to the ex-Ministers.

Comment on this

It depends on your own interpretation of just chastisement.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

I am giving quotations now. I think the Chair had to call upon members of the Government Party to withdraw the word traitor as applied to members of this Party when we dared to express our views. What does the word traitor mean here and what is the just fate of a traitor here? If I understand it correctly, it is death. I want to know quite clearly whether the position is that those who want to express their views —and they include Irishmen who have done as much work for Ireland as anybody in this House, either on the Government Benches or on the Labour Benches—on this crisis are going to be dubbed as traitors by people who have at their disposal forces who could do these people to death. It is a very serious matter.

The Government not only wants to oust this House from any control over the imposition of taxation or the spending of money, but it wants also to get into a position where only the Government and the supporters of the Government can talk in the House or in the country. I suggest that the Government want to create a situation, an atmosphere, outside where free speech will not be allowed. Just as the Dáil will not be able to discuss the sub-heads under which the Government will spend this money, so also in the country, if one desires to speak on the present situation, one will not be allowed to do so.

The situation is that in Westmeath, for example, the Minister for Justice, if he wishes, can state the national case, but Deputy Seán MacEoin is to be silent. You have only to consider that case and similar cases to see how absurd the whole thing is. One could give many other examples. The situation is quite simple. This Government, which is asking for two millions this evening does not give us any information as to what it is to be spent on. It is to start new industries, perhaps. We are giving this two millions to-night, presumably, and there is no member of the Government who has any notion of what he wants to spend the money upon. There is not any well-thought-out economic policy anywhere in the Government. There is not only scheme. I want to suggest that the Government has no economic policy, but has a political policy. The difficulty we are in at present arises because the Government is subordinating economics to politics, and, more particularly, that the Labour Party, which went to the country on an economic policy, has subordinated that economic policy to the political policy of the present Government. That is the situation we are in and we are handing over enormous powers, dictatorial powers, to a Government which having ousted the Dáil from financial control also wants in the country to suppress free speech.

Comment on this

And put you out of the Chair.

Comment on this
Hugh Victor Flinn Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Flinn) Fianna Fáil

Deputy MacDermot to-night asked Deputy Fitzgerald what justification he could bring forward in favour of a statement which he had made three times except the fact that he had made it three times, and Deputy Fitzgerald remained silent. What Deputy MacDermot does not know, and what unfortunately we have had to learn by bitter experience, is that a statement made from the Front Bench opposite by any of the ex-Ministers becomes a fact because it is stated. It becomes a sort of super-fact if it is stated twice, and it becomes a sin against all possible standards of intelligence to doubt it if, by any chance, it is made a third time. Now what has happened in relation to Deputy Hayes, who very discreetly is removing himself——

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

Then I will stay.

Comment on this

I thought he would not dare go out. He has again made a whole series of statements. "What the people understood," that is all.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

What they were told.

Comment on this

"What the people understood." He knew. Inside their minds he got. Then he could not produce the evidence of one single member of the Party, or one single person responsible for its organisation, as an authority for any statement that he made, but yet was perfectly satisfied as to what the people understood.

Comment on this

Deputy Hogan——

Comment on this

Wait a moment. We will deal with Hogan.

Comment on this
Mr. Hayes

I think I may leave now, Sir, while the Parliamentary Secretary is dealing with Deputy Hogan.

Comment on this

Wait a bit longer. I thought he would get out.

Comment on this

Be good enough to address me as Deputy Hogan.

Comment on this

Most certainly. I think the country will prevent me from very long having that opportunity. Very shortly it will be again "Mr. Hogan."

Comment on this

I hope very shortly we will get a chance of going to the country.

Comment on this

When we get an election I take it I will be deprived of the privilege of calling him Deputy Hogan.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

You can make it either Deputy or Mr., but I want no familiarity from you or the like of you.

Comment on this

Well, then, we will call you Sir Patrick Hogan, K.C.B. We will give you any formal title you like —Lord-Lieutenant, Governor-General, as you might have been if there had not been a General Election in which the people were foolish enough to throw you out of the position of being addressed as Minister for Agriculture. Deputy Hogan heard it. Let Deputy Hogan name to this House the man whom he heard say it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Certainly.

Comment on this

Right. The whole Party is going to be committed to that statement merely because Deputy Hogan says it. Deputy Hogan has been in the witness box, where he has been cross-examined, and where the verdict did not go with him.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Does this Deputy suggest that I told a lie in the witness box?

Comment on this

I have said exactly what I meant, that Deputy Hogan has been in the witness box and has been cross-examined, and the verdict did not go with him.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

In other words——

Comment on this

That is exactly what I said, and I meant exactly what I said.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

In other words, you implied it, but you have not the pluck to say it.

Comment on this

I have said exactly what I meant.

Comment on this

Take it and do not be squealing.

Comment on this

The next thing Deputy Hayes said was that nobody knows what the Government are going to do with the money. Another statement— no proof of any kind. He says it two or three times and, therefore, it becomes a fact, as Deputy MacDermot will now recognise. The Government has no scheme—a mere statement, no suggestion of any kind of proof. In the same way, he went on in relation to practically everything he said. The Comptroller and Auditor-General, for instance, was to have no authority over this because it was issued on the flat of the Minister for Finance. Practically every estimate we have is issued on the fiat of the Minister for Finance. The control was going to be absolutely useless, because it went to the Comptroller and Auditor-General, and from the Comptroller and Auditor-General it went to the Committee of Public Accounts, and from the Committee of Public Accounts it came back to the House, and there was a lag of a couple of years between the two, and therefore there was no control. If that is true, the statement is true of every penny of money that has been voted by this House from the beginning. Every penny in the Estimates is going to be in exactly the same position. It is going to take the same amount of time. That is one of the defects of the system. It is going to take just the same amount of time to get back into the knowledge and purview of the Dáil as any other sum of money of any sort, kind or description which ever has been or, under the present procedure, ever will be borne by the Dáil. Then we were causing complete destruction of Parliamentary Government because we were handing over this money to the Executive Council. The Dáil is expressing its complete control over this money in taking the responsibility for the precise terms in which it hands it over. The Dáil is capable of exercising a trust in the Executive. In exercising that trust, it exercises its authority in exactly the same way as it would exercise its authority if it refused to give that trust into the hands of the Executive. Remember, we have come and asked for the money before we spent it.

We have come and told you in general terms what we are going to do with it, and we ask you, in the generality of that authority, to give us that direct and immutable authority over it. What did the financial purists opposite do? They raided the Contingency Fund, without any authority whatever, to use it for purposes which they knew to be illegal. Did not that happen? They took £247,000 and handed it out in gratuities to their friends without any authority of any sort, kind or description from the Dáil and they kept it secret because it would have been impolitic to disclose it. That is why they did not put in a Supplementary Estimate. That is why they said they did not put in a Supplementary Estimate, because it would not have been good politics to say that they were taking £247,000 without the authority of the Dáil and using it for purposes of which the Dáil had no knowledge whatever or never gave consent to, until afterwards by that precise party majority which, when it is exercised by somebody other than Cumann na nGaedheal, becomes such an atrocious outrage on the liberties and the freedom of the people.

Why on earth should Deputies opposite be worried because this is a complete destruction of Parliamentary Government?

"Such action of their creed does not bear lawful fruit

They should befriend a being who behaves so like a brute."

Did not Deputy McGilligan, Minister for Industry and Commerce in the last Government, get up here the other day and tell us that this Dáil composed of you and me—I mean not vague and indefinite people—composed of Deputy Fionan Lynch, Deputy O'Neill, Deputy Seán MacEoin and even Deputy Gorey, was incapable of forming an opinion upon the transport problem of this country? Utterly ridiculous, even to submit to it the consideration of what should be the solution of the transport problem! That is what they said on Wednesday of the institution into which they say we have now introduced a provision which is the complete destruction of Parliamentary Government. The complete destruction of Parliamentary Government by a Parliament which according to the gentlemen opposite is not fit even to consider a practical problem in relation to their economic life!

Comment on this

Would the Parliamentary Secretary quote from the speech of Deputy McGilligan, because that is not at all what I understood him to say?

Comment on this

I propose to read out that whole speech on a future occasion. I called his attention to it at the time and that meaning was not repudiated by him. I think that Deputy MacDermot will agree that a statement that is not contradicted in this House is deemed to be true.

Comment on this

May I ask the Parliamentary Secretary whether the Government propose to spend the £2,000,000 in the same way that Deputy Cosgrave spent the £250,000?

Comment on this

Oh, no!

Comment on this

We are anxious to know.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave went down to Cork on one occasion and he addressed a gathering of the representatives of those who are interested in the building of houses. He said: "We have spent £2,000,000 of State money upon houses and, now that it is spent, I cannot say that we have received value for one single penny of it." He said further: "We are not going to spend any more of the State money in the way in which we have already spent £2,000,000 on houses." No, Sir, we do not propose to spend any of the £2,000,000 in the way in which Deputy Cosgrave or President Cosgrave spent it!

Comment on this

I thought you were going to follow him.

Comment on this

We had exactly the same attitude—"I am Sir Oracle; when I speak let no dog bark"—when the previous ex-Minister was speaking, the really nice Minister, he said: "You know it is admitted even by Fianna Fáil that there is no legal case." Then he said again: "It is obvious to everybody in the House that there is no legal case." Then he said: "Our opponents admit that there is no legal case." Now imagine that being said in this House and it was said, and if Deputy MacDermot looks up the records of this House, to his amazement he will see that it was said and I am rather inclined to think he was here when it was said. We are dealing with these people now as witnesses, people who hear things. Some of them see things. What are we to think of them as witnesses when in face of this House, and in the knowledge of this House, they have the effrontery to get up and make a statement of this kind, that it is admitted on these benches that there is no legal case? They go on and repeat that.

I suggest that they are, on the facts, very bad advocates and very rotten witnesses. I put that forward and I am now speaking to the credit of the witnesses. Is there any man in this House who is prepared to treat as a credible witness a man who gets up on the Front Bench opposite and says that it is admitted by Fianna Fáil that there is no legal case for the retention of the annuities? If you are not prepared to regard a person of that kind as a credible witness, then you must wipe out the whole of the evidence of these people in relation to every statement they make that is supposed to be of their own knowledge. It is purely in a technical sense that we will be bound to accept it, because you will be accepting it in the knowledge either that they had the effrontery to make a statement of that kind of which they must be so utterly incapable of forming a judgement that they believe it, or that they must be so dishonest that, disbelieving it, they put it forward as a fact. So much for the witnesses, now for the prophets.

All the red ruin blood and fire that was to fall upon this country when this Government came in! They exhausted on that occasion all their superlatives, and they have been using them up ever since. Time and time again in relation to everything: "This is chaos"—"chassis" I believe it would be called. We are leading them down the path of economic and moral ruin. That is one of the things we are doing. Why? Because we have had the effrontery to disagree with people who get up there and say that it is admitted upon this side of the House that we have no legal case. "Humbug and dishonesty." One Deputy on the other side got up, a Deputy who had the effrontery to praise somebody for his good manners and courtesy in the debate—the Deputy has discreetly removed himself since—and said that the speech delivered by Senator Connolly was deliberately singling out Deputy Blythe for assassination.

The same witnesses have told you that there is no legal case within our knowledge. In the ordinary way of business the mere fact that some of them said they heard or saw something would not carry the faintest conviction to me in face of the fact that I, in this House, have heard them say things which no intelligent man could believe and no honest man could state. Our duty, Deputy Fitzgerald says, as a Government is to do what Desmond Fitzgerald thinks is the right thing for the country. There is that idea that they have some sort of special revelation. They have not. They are just very, very ordinary young men who are in a hurry to be famous, men who, dressed up in a little brief authority, have done things that have made the angels laugh, men who have gone long past themselves, men who think that when they listen to their own voice they are listening to the voice of God. They do honesty think that. You get people like that amateur theologian, Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald, who gets up and lays down moral theology with an effrontery and with an absolute certainty and security that he is right, beyond all possible belief, that the Pope of Rome would not use. He lays down the law on theological and on political matters and on everything else. Mere assertion and reassertion is supposed to be proof, and when Deputy Hogan—to give him the title which he now has—gets up, he will tell you the same thing—there is no legal case for the annuities; there is no legal case for the annuities; there is no legal case for the annuities. Having proved it in that way, you will have a whole series of assertions from the sea-green incorruptible, but they will not carry one inch past the hearing of his own ears unless they are backed by what they have not been backed with up to the present. What are we going to use this money for? We are going to use it for whatever may be required in the actual circumstances of the case—to meet emergencies as they arise and for the purpose of carrying on this fight to a successful issue.

Comment on this

For war.

Comment on this

It is in that sense that we are asking the Dáil for it. The Dáil should understand, in voting for it, that they are voting for it in that sense. They are taking the full, intimate, continuous responsibility for our use of the money for that purpose and let no man afterwards say that he did not know what he was doing—that the Auditor-General has not the fullest possible authority from this Dáil to pass as properly voted and properly used every penny which is used in that particular way. The next thing we are told is that we are going to be desperately poor under these conditions. Why should we be desperately poor under these conditions? The British say they are collecting the annuities. I want to be polite. I have great respect for the British, and I have never hesitated to express it.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I am prepared to take their word.

Comment on this
A Deputy

They are flattered.

Comment on this

They will not be when they hear it. They say they are collecting the annuities and we say we believe them. If they are collecting the annuities, then there is an absolutely definite legal right in this country to retain the equivalent of the money which they say they are collecting.

Comment on this

Where are you going to get it?

Comment on this

We will deal with the matter quitely. They say they are collecting the money. They have imposed a tax specifically for that purpose. Therefore one thing is perfectly certain—that as long as we believe their word, as long as, even for the purpose of argument between ourselves, we accept their word that they are collecting this money, they are not entitled to any money under that head from Ireland and we will be entitled, upon their own declaration, to use whatever money may now be in, or in the future may be put into the suspense account for the purposes of this country, as they say they have already been paid. I hope they are flattered now. I have never complained and do not complain for one moment about the British putting on a tariff. They are perfectly entitled to put on a tariff. But they are not entitled to put on a tariff as against Ireland specifically for the purpose of collecting a debt which we allege is not due. Is it or is it not an unfriendly act specifically to tax another country? A general tariff as against the world is a perfectly orderly and perfectly proper thing, but to put on a tariff specifically against a country in order to collect from that country money which they refuse to pay into court before the other contestant is prepared to sue for it—is that a friendly or an unfriendly act? That is the specific difference. I believe they are going to pay it, just as I have told the House that we are going to pay anything we collect upon their goods except to the extent that we find a development of our own production to reduce their bargaining power in our market. Unless we can develop a productive power in this country in relation to the goods which they import to the extent to which we still import goods from them, we will be collecting our indemnities from ourselves in the same way as they are going to collect the annuities from their own people.

Comment on this

It is as plain as the nose on your face now.

Comment on this

Thank God, my nose is not as plain as some noses. The next thing we are asked is why we do not tell everybody what we are going to do. We would like to tell everybody in this House that. We have told a good deal of what we are going to do to members upon the opposite benches who have been prepared to co-operate in the work. We are asking for an opportunity to tell them. We are asking for an opportunity to tell men who are going to co-operate.

Comment on this

Tell it.

Comment on this

We are asking for an opportunity to tell them under conditions in which we will not be telling it to our enemies as well. If there is any man upon the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches, any man with Cumann na nGaedheal affiliations, any man outside our ranks at all who has knowledge of business, who has experience that ought to be used in this business fight, who is prepared to come in, not as a Fianna Fáil person—there is no reason in the wide world why he should change any political alliances—and to say: "In relation to my trade, this particular method might be adopted; what are you proposing to do; to the extent to which I can help you, we will co-operate;" to every man in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and to every man who is prepared to help on the work, we are prepared to give all the information we can and to take from him all the help and co-operation which he is prepared to give and which he is entitled to give without changing his political allegiance in any way whatever.

A speech of very considerable value was delivered last week by Deputy Seán MacEoin. He said: "You are asking us to come to the help of the Government; you are asking us to come in to Fianna Fáil and join the Government." There are many things on which many of you in this House are entitled to disagree with us. You may disagree with any point of our policy, but to the extent to which you are prepared to co-operate, to give us the advantage of your knowledge and experience, your position in industry and in commerce, or anything else such as your influence with your fellow men in making this fight better and more effective—to that extent we invite your co-operation. To that extent we will unhesitatingly put you in possession of what we think it is necessary to put you in possession of to do this work side by side with us in this common struggle.

Comment on this

I am not going to go into details of the law with regard to the annuities and I am not going into the question of the Treaty. I am going into this question as it affects the people from whom I come. The President has left. In introducing this Estimate the President said it was to be directed in part to the establishment of new markets or to finding alternative markets. Last week he said "when we considered the possibility of getting outside markets for our surplus products we may have to bargain. We may have to indicate to these other countries which may absorb a certain amount of our agricultural produce that we are prepared to give a certain preference here for the goods which we may want and which they are prepared to give us in return."

The week before that he said "the people from whom we will buy things will be glad to take our produce in return." The President has changed his ground. He does not appear so sure of himself now as he was three weeks or a fortnight ago. If the President is able to discover an alternative market he is doing a good deal more than Columbus did when he discovered America. Anyhow America was there for Columbus to discover; the alternative market is not there for President de Valera or anybody else to discover. People talk of alternative markets much the same as if they were in the nursery. People talk about developing markets to meet the present situation as if they were babies.

Deputy Corry said earlier this evening that there were three Deputies in this House who had committed an act of treachery to the country, and I was one of them. He said I was one of them because I mentioned a fortnight ago that half a million cattle had to leave the country between June and the 1st November. In addition to the half million cattle that have to leave the country another half a million will have to change hands within the country. Deputy Corry thinks that we should shut our mouths about that, and that if we did not give away the secret the English would not know about it. If they did not know that half a million cattle must leave the country then the English people are a lot of fools. I think the time for that kind of attitude on this matter, especially amongst Deputies and Ministers who represent the country, ought to stop. Let us not begin with the idea, when we are doing something, that the other fellows are fools. The English people are not fools and, especially, English statesmen are not fools. The statesmen of any country are not fools. It is a wrong foundation to start your argument upon: the assumption that the other people are fools. Everybody knows that we have to get rid of these cattle. Everyone in England knew it. They have their statistics and they can read them and their statistics are as good as ours. When people talk glibly of alternative markets they are not humbugging the English people. They are humbugging nobody outside this State. I say that the attitude to the people is an attitude of deliberate insult. It is an insult to their intelligence. You hope to fool nobody when you talk about alternative markets; if the people within this country believe that the word of the President goes for something, they base that belief on their knowledge of the President who went before him, because his word went for something.

I do not see much of the festive, joyous, holiday, picnic spirit that we saw on Friday week and on the Friday before that. Anybody could tell, on Friday week, that there was to be no settlement, judging from the festive attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party, except on the basis of England surrendering. I want to get an answer to a plain question from the President. Will he let me have it? Is there going to be any settlement except on the basis of a British surrender? We have only three months to get out our half-million of cattle if the rest of the cattle are to live. We must take protective measures. Our cattle here are in the same position as a garrison in a city that is hemmed in. They have only rations for a certain period. We have only rations enough to go round for a certain period. The other half-million must live.

Comment on this

Why can they not live?

Comment on this

Because there is no food there to give them. If the half-million of cattle that should go have to be kept, one million, or a million and a half, will die. There are enough thin cattle in this country already. We have enough skeletons in the country and we have enough ill-health without adding to it. No one who knows anything about farming or about agriculture, or cares anything about them, would ask why. This blessing in disguise was talked about yesterday in the Seanad. Senator Connolly welcomed this crisis—this blessing in disguise. All I can say about the disguise is that it is most perfect: a most complete disguise. So perfect and complete is the disguise that one cannot get a glimmer of the blessing. If there is a blessing it is hidden behind the clouds and no one can see it. Judging from the speeches that have been made one would think it was a crime that cattle should be reared in this country and that sheep and pigs should be produced in this country.

One would think that the people who engaged in agriculture did something wrong in catering for the only market which they had and the only thing that was paying them. The fact is that they have done it and that a certain amount of their money is capitalised there. Is it the idea that the cattle should be scrapped and the cattle trade rendered valueless? That is what the policy of the Executive Council is aiming at. That is the policy they are deliberately aiming at Well, then, let us do it. Let us get back to corn and destroy the only wealth we have. If it is not, then do not destroy our cattle and try to keep them in the country, as Deputy Carney was suggesting, until you have only hides and skeletons, and bury the lot. When the President talked of the possibility of securing alternative markets, it is very necessary that we should know now what are the prospects of securing those alternative markets. I think that the President and the Executive Council are not quite right in keeping whatever they have in their minds absolutely to themselves. The public must know now, or they must know in the very near future, how they are going to dispose of half a million of their cattle. They must know what is the position, or are they going to be stopped from selling their cattle and bearing the loss, except the Government come to their aid and subsidise them to the amount of loss they are going to suffer? Are the Government going to do that? The President says:

"The first thing we have got to do is to try to dispose of our surplus of agricultural produce in the best way we can and to try to make it possible for our people to consume as much of it as they can. Of course, they are not able to consume it all, and, therefore, what we have got to do is to get the best outside market that we can for the surplus portion over and above the amount which they can consume."

We have got to get the best market we can. What has been done in the last fortnight to get us that outside market? That is the answer that he gives—"that we must get the best outside market which we can get. What that best is remains to be seen." Most people who know anything at all about the subject know what the best is. It does not remain to be seen what it is going to be. I asked the President here on last Friday week, I think, if he could give us a guarantee that any of the outside markets would take even ten per cent. of our surplus produce, and we have not got an answer. Germany has put up a barrier, and Denmark would not take our surplus. Why? Because she wanted to be self-contained. The Germans do not want our stuff or anybody else's stuff. The stuff will go to any port in which they can get a market. They have not gone to Denmark, and it would be ridiculous to go to France or Belgium.

Yesterday you voted for a tariff on Belgian phosphates and you fought for it very bitterly. Now you want in their cement. Do you expect to get a market in Belgium or in France? The man who would be able to get an alternative market for the surplus produce of his country, when no other country has been able to do it, would deserve more credit than Columbus got for discovering America. How far has the President advanced in doing the best he can to develop that outside market? July has gone. We are getting into August. Nothing evidently can be done in a few days. We will be in the middle of August before anything can be done, and from the middle of August to the middle of October is only two months. What is being done? The President said that the policy would be to put our stuff on the markets in the smallest quantity so as to get the best price. What does he mean by that? I would be glad to help the President because it is a matter of life and death to me and to people like me. The normal flow of cattle should go on now, no matter what the price is and perhaps let this £2,000,000 compensate the people who have to sell at a loss. The President shakes his head. It is evidently not for them. If the cattle are kept back till the 1st September you will then have only six weeks and the market will get crushed by its own weight irrespective altogether of the 20 per cent. With the 20 per cent. added, it will mean utter ruin.

I suggest that it is up to the President and the Government to take the public into their confidence as to what they intend to do. There is no time to be lost. There are a half a million cattle that must go. They must go of necessity before 1st September. We have no choice in the matter. I say that it is nothing short of criminal for a man in the President's position to indulge in dangling the bait of an alternative market. This is a matter about which there should be no play and about which we should be honest. You are gambling with the whole resources of the country and we cannot afford to waste the money that is involved in this half-million of our cattle. There ought to be no equivocation about this matter at all. The facts should be disclosed, and if they are not able to deal with it they should be quite honest and say that they are not able to do anything for the people and that the people will have to do it for themselves and get themselves out of the muddle in which you have put them. There is no sense in holding back supplies or in trading at the end of the season and thereby crushing the market by the weight of your own supplies. It is very hard to deal with an Executive Council or with a Party who seem to know so little or to care so little about the affairs of the country as the party opposite seems to know or care. We had an extraordinary speech here, to-day I think, from Deputy Ryan of Limerick, dealing with the question of phosphates. He said that the farmers of Limerick were prepared to make sacrifices on the question of phosphates. That was not a sacrifice of the people to this State. It was a sacrifice not to the revenues of the State. It was a sacrifice to the manufacturers of phosphates in this State and it means £200,000 to the manufacturers of this State. Even their shares stand high in the market quotation and though you read that it is one of the best investments you can make, a gilt-edged security, Deputy Ryan is prepared to make sacrifices. Well then, the condition of the farmers of Limerick must be the envy of us all.

How can you hope for a reasonable consideration of any matter affecting agriculture, or anything else, from a Party who seem to view things in that light? Has the President consulted people in the cattle trade with regard to that trade, even in the last six months, since the controversy was started in March? I said, on the last day on which we were discussing this, that you were going to lose whatever preference you had, and I said that, in addition to that, you are going to lose whatever goodwill you had. Good will means a lot in a market, and it meant a hell of a lot in the English market. I have asked, within the last three weeks, of people engaged in the shipping of cattle and lambs, what was the reason for the cheapness of Irish lamb, and they said it was the hostility of the English public to Irish produce created by this controversy over the annuities and the Oath. It was stated to me that Canterbury lamb was fetching 1½d. and 2d. a lb., most of the time, more than Irish lamb, and anybody who knows the quality of Canterbury and Irish lamb will know that that difference is not justified at all. Still, that preference was given to another part of the Commonwealth in preference to us. The same thing applies to cattle, but not to such a marked degree. Goodwill is of immense value and you have destroyed that goodwill and lost your preference. In addition, you have a 20 per cent. tariff and, on top of that, you want to hold back supplies at a time when they must be got rid of, and that is statesmanship.

Comment on this

On a point of information——

Comment on this

I am not going to give way to the Deputy on a point of information. If it is a point of order, I will sit down.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Gibbons can make a speech afterwards.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not want to answer.

Comment on this

Ask the question, then.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Gorey state in this House that there is a 20 per cent. difference in the price of lambs pre-tariff and now, taking the price of lambs this season, and, particularly, during the weeks immediately preceding the imposition of the tariff?

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy' does not know what I am talking about. When I talk of 20 per cent. I am talking of the 20 per cent. tariff that the British have imposed to recover the annuities. When I, talk of a preference of 2d. a lb., it is quite a different matter.

Comment on this

I wish to state definitely that the price of lambs has not altered since the tariff was imposed as compared with the price immediately preceding the tariff.

Comment on this

That is what I am talking about.

Comment on this

Lamb can be bought at Birkenhead for 7½d. and before this it was 8½d.

Comment on this

This is going on since May. I have said that. Irish lamb is in competition with Canterbury lamb since last May and the English customer is showing a preference in favour of the Canterbury lamb.

Comment on this

The twenty per cent. tariff was not on in May.

Comment on this

I am not saying that. The Deputy does not understand what I mean.

Comment on this

The Deputy behind you did not understand, either.

Comment on this

The man behind knows what he is talking about, and he wants to know is the President in a position to tell us where our alternative markets are. Is our country going to be flung into bankruptcy——

Comment on this
An Leas Cheann Comhairle

The Deputy cannot make a speech now.

Comment on this

The President said, three weeks ago, that if we have to get things outside, those people who want to sell will be very glad to take our produce in return. That is a very important statement if there is any truth in it or any meaning in it. Has the President got any evidence now? I do not know, of course, what country the President was thinking about but has he got any evidence of that gladness and what has it been translated into and what quantity of our produce are these people prepared to take? Are they prepared to take even ten per cent. of our produce? It is time to let us know the facts. There is no use in the President trying to delude himself and the country on this question, if it is not true, and I would advise the President not to allow himself to be deluded by the kind of public opinion we are getting in the country. Down in Graiguenamanagh last week-end, when the Minister for Education was in Waterford, a man, Alderman Donovan, came up to hold a meeting—a peculiar coincidence—and I leave the House to draw its own inference. At the meeting, an individual called Foxy Foley, with his wife and two children, and two others, evidently had been paid for interrupting Deputy Fitzgerald and myself.

Comment on this

Good old Foxy Foley!

Comment on this

And they earned their money in the rain that day. They did well and they should get at least 10/-for the work they did.

Comment on this
Dr. Thomas Hennessy Dr. Hennessy

That was a foxy thing to do.

Comment on this

That would not be a trade union wage for two.

Comment on this

"It may be necessary," the President said, "to establish new industries." What does that mean? Does it mean the establishment of new industries now to consume our produce; that these industries will be manned by such a staff that they will consume our produce, or does it mean the establishment of new industries to deal with our surplus production by putting it in bottles or cans? If the President means the starting of new industries now to consume our surplus produce it is an utter impossibility. An extra beast will not be used in that way; but if he means by that the starting of new industries to deal with - our surplus produce by bottling or canning it, it is a different proposition and we would like to consider it, but do not be humbugging the people by saying that it is merely necessary to establish new industries in order to deal with the problem. The people are holding back their cattle in this country for one reason only, and that is the hope of a settlement. I asked here earlier if there was no hope of a settlement, if what the President said that a settlement on these lines was impossible was correct, if his position was irrevocable, and if Deputy Norton's idea was also impossible. If there is going to be no settlement except on the basis of a British surrender, the people had better be told that. They are holding back their cattle, not in the hope of securing an alternative market, or the starting of new industries here to consume production at home, but in the hope that there is going to be a settlement. Any other idea is false and the man who says otherwise is not telling the truth. If there is no hope of a settlement, except on the basis of a British surrender, let it be said. That is the honest way to do it.

Deputy Flinn said here, in dealing with a matter akin to this, that a statement I made was stupidly false. Deputy Flinn did not do me justice. It was not exactly stupidly false. I said that, in view of the present position brought about within the last few months, the farmers' capacity to buy fertilisers next year would not be anything like what it was last year, and you may take that as gospel. As a matter of fact, the bills are now due for the fertilisers of last spring, and all the shopkeepers and all the creamery societies in the country find that they are not able to get the money and that there is no possibility of getting the money to pay for them.

Of the people who bought fertilisers last spring five per cent. will not be in a position to pay for them in the coming year, at present prices. What is probably going to happen these, if the present war goes on, is that there will be no fertilisers used next spring. The President, we are told, is going to use this money to fight this question out. I suggest to the President that he could keep the money, and that by spending 3/- or 4/- on stamps and writing to the Trade Departments in other countries for information as to where there are alternative markets he would get it. What is the use of talking about alternative markets? What is the use of "codding" the people? Is it not dishonest, is it not unfair, and is it not tragic at a time when the country is faced with the fact that, between now and 1st November, a half-million stock will have to be sent out? Members of this Party associated with agriculture are prepared to give advice if Ministers think it worth while to ask for it. We know that this is a fight. We believe that the British will not depart from their position, and we believe that the Government here will not. I have made up my mind that there is to be no settlement. We can fight together, but only on the condition that we are going to have straight speaking. If our advice is sought it will be sought in public and given in public. If the attitude of the Party in power here and in Britain is no settlement, and I believe neither side can withdraw from the position they are in, then let the people know the position and let them make up their minds. I see that the President agrees with me in that. That clears the air a good deal. There is then no necessity for saying any more in that respect in view of the President's assent.

The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs talked about potential markets for 17 millions. When are we to get the potential markets? When will they be developed? How much of the potential markets will be available between now and November? What is to be the position of those with cattle, who have the wealth and the working capital of the country in their hands between now and November? On this side we have been called traitors by Deputies and by people who ought to know better, because we say things that other people are thinking; because we point to the obvious, and because we recommend other people to do what we are doing. If Deputies want to know what other people are likely to do they should ask themselves what they would do in the same circumstances. They know as much about the cattle trade and about the position as we do. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs talked about the significance of what the British did and what we said. Why did he use that expression? He did so in order to put a label on people here that they were traitors, people who had no interest in their country, although they own more of it than people on the other side.

Comment on this

Question.

Comment on this

When the sacrifices will be made 90 per cent. of them will be made by the people we represent. The only significance of what the British did and what we said is this: that the British had brains; they knew the obvious thing, and they knew how to think.

Comment on this

Great minds think alike.

Comment on this

And the other way about. The only thing is this, I think the British have a little common sense and can see the obvious. The President talked about English coal. How much English coal does Germany buy? Could the President tell us that? Germany must buy a certain amount of English coal for industries for which her coal is not suitable. Is the President prepared to state how much English coal Germany buys despite her own coalfields? Muck is going to be brought to this country. Good coal must be got for certain purposes. Germany is taking more English coal than we are taking. Speeches made in this House to-night had nothing to do with this question. It is very poor comfort for me and men like me to hear speeches like those made by Deputy Flinn and by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. These speeches did not deal with the subject and with the immediate dangers to the agricultural community. This is a question of life and death for the agricultural community and the sooner the President realises that the better for the country and for everyone.

Comment on this

I think it was Deputy Fitzgerald told us that we were in for a very bad time. Of course the Deputy meant that the farmers were in for a bad time, and after the farmers, everyone else. I do not know when these bad times started. They may have been intensified during the last three weeks. As far as I know these bad times started nine or ten years ago, because for that period money has been lost in agricultural production. I think I am not wrong when I make the statement that a couple of millions a year has been lost on agricultural production for the British market. Our produce was also being replaced in the British market by foreign competitors, and during that period of nine years we were constantly told from the opposite benches, the members of which then formed the Government, that every year we were rapidly turning the corner. Hundreds of thousands of pounds were spent reorganising the creamery and butter industry. The project failed. I wonder did the same reasons apply in England. Prices fell, according to Deputy Gorey, since we came into power. What is the mystery about the whole thing? The steps taken in 1923 are almost entirely responsible for the position that arises here. As farmers we were unable to compete. Our cost of production at all times was more than we could meet on the British market. An effort is being made now, and I believe we have a legal right to make it, to reduce the cost of production by, at least, five million pounds a year. I say we have a legal right to do so, and, if there is a legal right, there is a moral right. As far as Mr. Thomas is concerned he states that this question arose out of a certain form of agreement, a secret agreement of a sort, that was signed in 1923.

I think the farmers of Ireland are very greatly concerned with that agreement. The marketing of our agricultural products on the British market is a matter that is closely concerned with that agreement. That agreement did more than raise the cost of production by certain references that were made to these five million land annuities and local loans. It also, to my mind, did a much more vital thing. The vital thing that it did was this, that the British Government through that agreement got complete control over your Land Act of 1923 which followed that agreement. As well as I remember in that agreement appeared the word "agreed," that the British Government had to agree in any land scheme that was to be promoted in this country. That was the first item. Not alone did they state that, but they did another thing which definitely placed them in a position to say exactly what you are to pay for the land. So that as far as the 1923 Land Act was concerned—and we were caught in the old one—the position was this that the whole scheme had to be agreed to by the British Government.

The price the land was going to cost the farmer here was regulated by certain processes which were definitely stated in that agreement. In other words, it insured that the landlord was to get the full price for his land and that as far as possible it would be the 1923 price. The produce of that land is to be sold in the British market and it is to be sold at the price they cared to pay for it. That is the position as I see it and except the British Government are extremely philanthropically inclined towards us I do not myself see the slightest hope under those conditions of our being able to maintain our place in the British market. What is the cause of this trouble? Some people call it a crisis. It is undoubtedly a big crisis. There is a big question involved.

Who is to blame for this crisis? Who is to blame for the bad times that Deputy Fitzgerald speaks of as coming on immediately or here now? Who should have taken steps to obviate that? Who are the defaulting statesmen? Why should the position which I have described and which is an accurate description, be allowed to arise? After that had arisen and after it was consolidated the British Government was in a position to receive from us a sum of something over five million pounds. On previous occasions by her own law she agreed this money was to go to us because she said we could not continue in this country if she did not agree to it. Why was not that position then dealt with?

That was an impossible position for the people of this country. It should have been foreseen. We adverted to that position, but the then Government passed not the slightest remark but continued on. What did they tell our farmers? They told our farmers at times that they were dishonest. There is hardly a doubt about that. They told them that they had the money to pay their taxes and the other calls they had to meet and that they would make them pay. Then they started to help the farmers. They knew that the position for the farmers was clearly impossible.

Then this Agricultural Credit Corporation was introduced in order to help the farmers. What class of farmers? The farmers who did not need any help, or the farmers who could get that help from the banks, or farmers who knew that if they got help from the Agricultural Credit Corporation that the banks would get the benefit of that help? Was there any need for the setting up of the Agricultural Credit Corporation? Was the agricultural position at that time a position that should demand or accept any credit? I hold it was not. The result is that the credit of that industry has been gradually falling away. Until before the late election it had no credit. Because of that fact, and the need for the conservation of the agricultural industry and the hopeless outlook that then prevailed, we were returned to power. That was the reason.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The people knew that the Government that presided over them for ten years was bankrupt in statemanship.

Comment on this
Dr. Thomas Hennessy Dr. Hennessy

They were not bankrupt in honesty; they maintained the country's reputation for honesty.

Comment on this

I do not think there is any use in shelving any of these questions. We are faced with a great crisis to-day, a crisis brought on by the late Government and by their actions. I am not going to ask them to help us out. That is for their own judgement. If they care to help us, well and good. If not, we will help ourselves. We have the nation behind us to-day, 90 per cent. of the nation.

Who are our opponents? The only opponents we have in this country now in the farming line are men who have just as much as would half stock their land next year, and they hope that by the misery of the rest of the people they will get rich again. That is the position. We must be perfectly honest. At least 90 per cent. of the farmers of this country are down and out. Their industry is destroyed. There is no use in shelving this question. That industry can be revived, but not by the talk that went on to-day. It can be revived in this country by co-operation and by understanding exactly what competition is in foreign countries and how we are to meet that competition.

I believe that we cannot meet competition in any way except in two:—First, by raising the quality of our produce and, secondly, by the lowering of the cost of production. Was there any step taken during the last ten years by the late Government to do that one thing? It is all right for Deputy Blythe to get the excuse that at that particular period money was inflated and that values were completely distorted. It was quite apparent that even after Winston Churchill adopted the gold standard the Government held aloof.

Chambers of Commerce told us that because the volume of exports was all right we had turned the corner. We had so far as we had created credit sufficient for them to purchase the goods which they sold. The great motor car people had been talking in the same way. Anyone who views at this particular period the City of Dublin and the country roads will see what has occurred. There are thousands of magnificient motor cars passing through this country.

To-day Deputy Byrne told us how that was done. He said he could get £4,000 credit to-morrow morning. A lot of these motor cars are got on credit. I believe that most of the farmers who own these cars have not yet paid for them. A lot of these cars will become fowlhouses before they are paid for. I think the time has arrived when we should face up to the position. We are talking about markets, and the British market, and talking about holding our own there. I know Englishmen well. I know what sentiment they have. They are business people, really good business people.

There is not an ounce of friendship in their business. They will buy from the men who can sell them the best article at the cheapest price. They will always do that. What are your competitors? There is not much use in talking about Canada. As a meat exporter, Canada's interference is very small. The Argentine is on a different basis. That country to-day is selling beef at 2½d. That is all because of mass production. What is our position? Our cattle have fallen completely away. It might not be unwise, even at the present time, if all the female cattle were held here for some time until the land could be restocked. Deputy Gorey said that cattle would starve here. So far as Meath, Kildare and Westmeath are concerned, the cattle will not starve.

Comment on this

What about the other counties?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

There are hundreds of acres derelict, through the effects of one particular system or another. At one time it is our own rotten laws that prevent the land from being used; at another time it is some corrupt financial system. During all that time who is suffering most? Up to this it certainly has not been the big farmer. The smaller farmers have suffered to a degree, but I must candidly admit that for the last nine years the people who suffered most in the country were the labourers, the workers. They are the people we must have sympathy for and we must contrive, in some way, to maintain them.

What a crying disgrace it is to this country to say that we have not 3,000,000 people here! We have not sufficient people to start even an ordinary industry. What was the position hitherto? The position definitely was that we exported fat cattle and people; these were our principal exports. We were deprived of every industry, with one or two exceptions. We had no means of keeping people here, and they had to get out. I do not believe that what we are doing will be in any way injurious or will be likely to have bad results. I believe it will have good results, because we will succeed in proving one thing very definitely. Do the English take our cattle because they love us overmuch?

Comment on this

Starve them out.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

Are they taking our cattle because they want them? I think the answer is they are taking our cattle because they want them. The moment we start any industrial effort along the line of meat production, the moment we make any attempt to standardise that industry and endeavour to keep the offals in the country, then we have every evidence of the British attitude. Let us take, as an example, the Drogheda Meat Packing Company. When it made an endeavour in that direction down it went. Who put it down? Possibly the Drogheda Meat Packing Company itself had some little thing to do with it, but how was its establishment viewed in Birkenhead, Liverpool, Glasgow and the London market? What sort of reception did the butchers there give it? They put it on a par, not with the best chilled but with common frozen, and the industry was killed. Why did they do that? They did it because they had vested interests. The butchers in Manchester, Liverpool, Birkenhead and Glasgow have a definite vested interest in the cattle trade of this country. They are not quite happy to-day. They would be very glad, to my own personal knowledge, if they knew exactly what the result of all this is going to be. They are losing something. The number of people engaged in England on the handling of the agricultural production of this country is as great as the number of people engaged in the industry here.

I think that aspect of the question ought to be examined in a different way and from a different angle altogether. We have a legal right here. Whether we have a legal right or not, this thing cannot go on. We must change our system if we are to maintain our people. We cannot pay our land annuities because the United States have failed us in this respect: there is no contribution coming to the farmers from their sons and daughters in order to help them to pay the land annuities. A price was paid for the land in this country exactly three times what it ought to be. We left no margin for the unfortunate farmer and his wife to support themselves. The farmer must pay all; he has to work extraordinarily hard and even then he will be owing a bit at the end all the time. I hope sincerely what is now happening will tend to open up the whole question of the land position, the agricultural position, in this country. I hope that a system will be, as it can be, devised that will ensure that the land of the country will be peopled again and that at least 95 per cent. of it—at the moment there is a little over 50 per cent. of it—will be worked in the interests of the nation.

Deputy Gorey talks about the cattle that must be got away. I wonder must they? Are we all quite sure that they must be got away and that they could not be kept on to eat the meadows that will be growing here? I may tell you there are farmers who cannot afford to pay to get their meadows cut. If the farmer puts it into hay the rate collector will be at the gate to take it away from him. The position here is simply intolerable. It was brought about largely because the men on the opposite benches had not even wisdom enough to realise the true situation. They did not give it even thought enough to see where we were going. Instead of warning the people, instead of nothing the people's position—and they had every opportunity to do so—instead of taking stock of that position, they kept on bellowing: "Keep on; you are around the corner." There is no Deputy listening to me who does not realise that that is the fact. Farmer Deputies on the opposite benches know that is a fact.

I am not saying that in order to entice them to come and help us in this situation. They can remain where they are, but we will go on. Nationally it would look extremely well if they joined us and people in other countries would think a lot more of them if, in a situation of this nature they joined forces with us. At least if they do not join with us, these bitter debates that have occurred, these bitter expressions, would be better left over for some other occasion. There has been a lot of nonsense talked. In the markets you meet certain classes of farmers and graziers and they talk a lot of nonsense about the existing situation. "What are we going to do?" they ask, and all the time they are quite glad that this has cropped up, because they are prepared to say, as Deputy Gorey said, "Oh, it is this that brought us down." That is a nice excuse, a nice soft way of falling down; but it is not the case because they were down long ago.

Comment on this